Lutherische Theologie und Kirche, Heft 04/2019 - Einzelkapitel - Glaubensgewissheit und Anerkennung. Anregungen zu einer lutherishen Hermeneutik religiöser Vielfalt: Lutherische Theologie und Kirche, Heft 04/2019 9783846997130, 3846997137

Table of contents :
Cover
Copyright
Christian Neddens

Citation preview

Copyright © 2020 Edition Ruprecht ISBN: 9783846997130

Christian Neddens

Lutherische Theologie und Kirche, Heft 04/2019 – Einzelkapitel – Glaubensgewissheit und Anerkennung. Anregungen zu einer lutherishen Hermeneutik religiöser Vielfalt Lutherische Theologie und Kirche, Heft 04/2019

Edition Ruprecht

==>GL

7PFXGJRVLJZNVVMJNW XRI 1RJUOJRRXRL 9cgZ\jc\Zc oj Z^cZg aji]Zg^hX]Zc AZgbZcZji^` gZa^\^xhZg O^Za[Vai >^cZ OZg]uaic^hWZhi^bbjc\ jciZghX]^ZYa^X]Zg KZa^\^dcZc ojZ^cVcYZg ^hi c^X]i @Z\ZchiVcY kdc ALSPNPVULU Vc h^X]' hdcYZgc YVh M]ZbV kdc =LUZJOLU' Y^Z h^X] ^c Z^cZb DdciZmi gZa^\^xhZg O^Za[Vai jcY =^[[ZgZco ZgaZWZc) =^ZhZ O^Za[Vai gZa^\^xhZg EZWZch]Vaijc\Zc' Y^Z ^b SZ^X]Zc \adWVaZg OZgcZiojc\ jcY F^\gVi^dc VjX] YZc aZWZchlZaia^X]Zc GV]( WZgZ^X] k^ZaZg FZchX]Zc egu\i' `Vcc hZ]g jciZghX]^ZYa^X] ZgaZWi lZg( YZc u Vah WZ\a{X`ZcYZ ;Z\Z\cjc\ ^c cVX]WVghX]V[ia^X]Zg DddeZgVi^( dc' VWZg VjX] Vah ;ZYgd]jc\ Zm^hiZci^ZaaZg @Zl^hh]Z^iZc' Vah D=(OZgaVjiWVgjc\ oj o^i^ZgZc u yX\( cZ x[[Zcia^X] kZgVcildgiZiZ M]Zdad\^Z Zcil^X`Zac' Y^Z OZghiucY^( \jc\hkZghjX]Z jcY sWZghZiojc\Zc ol^hX]Zc YZc Ddc[Zhh^dcZc' KZa^( Z\baXa haW hagXefV[\XW_\V[Xa PX_gTafV[ThhaZXa Xe`qZ_\V[g)v 0 =^ZhZ 9j[\VWZ l^gY ^c YZc ZkVc\Za^hX]Zc D^gX]Zc \Z\Zclugi^\ kdc Z^cZg yM[Xb_bZ\X WXe KX_\Z\baXav Umj) yBagXe^h_gheX__Xav bWXe yDb`cTeTg\( iXa M[Xb_bZ\Xv UXTeUX\gXg' \a WXe Xf WTeh` ZX[g' ibe WX` ?beh` WXe PZaigZa^\^dcZc jcY ^b =^Vad\ b^i ^]cZc hdaX] x[[Zcia^X] kZgVcildg( iZiZ M]Zdad\^Z oj Zcil^X`Zac)1 =VWZ^ ^hi cVijg\Zbut YVh OZghiucYc^h YZhhZc' lVh Vah S^Za jcY Vah bx\a^X]Z FZi]dYZ hdaX]Zg ysWZg( hZiojc\hkZghjX]Zv kZghiVcYZc l^gY' hZ]g jciZghX]^ZYa^X] Vc\ZaZ\i) 8T 5VSNLUKLU ^LYKLU a\UcJOZ[ NcUNPNL 0UZc[aL a\Y ELYOcS[UPZIL$ Z[PTT\UN YLSPNPdZLY FHOYOLP[ZHUZWYeJOL ]VYNLZ[LSS[ \UK KPZR\[PLY[% , 8U LPULT a^LP[LU BJOYP[[ ^PYK KPL CYHNMcOPNRLP[ \U[LYZJOPLKSPJOLY WOPSVZVWOPZJOLY FHOYOLP[ZILNYPMML MeY KPLZL ELYOcS[UPZILZ[PTT\UN LYdY[LY[% G\T BJOS\ZZ ^PYK LPU 4U[^\YM ]VYNLZ[LSS[# ^PL ZPJO KPL 0U$ LYRLUU\UN HUKLYLY PU S\[OLYPZJOL COLVSVNPL PU[LNYPLY[# VOUL KPL 6L$ ^PZZOLP[ KLZ 6SH\ILUZ KHTP[ HIa\ZJOSLPMLU VKLY a\ YLSH[P]PLYLU% / 0 1

2

9)V)H)' .-) 9)V)H)' 21) ALPUOVSK 1LYUOHYK[&@LYY` BJOTPK[$^c[{]gjc\ $l^Z 9cb) -%' 33 jcY FYVNLTHUU' M]Zdad\^Z $l^Z 9cb) 2%' -4u..' .,) ,+ O\a) 0UKYLHZ 6YeUZJOSVb' =Zg Z^\ZcZ jcY YZg [gZbYZ @aVjWZ) LijY^Zc ojg ^ciZg( gZa^\^xhZc ?gZbYlV]gcZ]bjc\ ^c BhaVb' A^cYj^hbjh' ;jYY]^hbjh jcY ^co^\Vgi^\`Z^i $\UPX\LULZZ% jcY >cY\{ai^\`Z^i $KLJPZP]LULZZ% YZh( fXa UXfgeX\gXg' jTf @bgg \a CXfhf ghX]Z^cjc\hlZ^hZc Z^cZh Y^ZhZ KZa^\^d( cZc kZgW^cYZcYZc \ZbZ^chVbZc MgVchoZcYZco]dg^odciZh \ZYZjiZi jXeWXav),. =^Z KZa^\^dcZc lZgYZc Z^cZg {WZg\ZdgYcZiZc FZiVi]Zdg^Z jciZg\ZdgYcZi jcY `dbbZc iZcYZco^Zaa c^X]i ^c ^]gZc LZaWhiYZjijc( \Zc ^c YZc ;a^X`) =^Z LjX]Z cVX] YZb \ZbZ^chVbZc MgVchoZcYZco( ]dg^odci Zg[da\i ojYZb ^c YZg KZ\Za Vj[ DdhiZc Vjh\Z[{]giZg @di( iZheguY^`Vi^dcZc l^Z u ^b DdciZmi X]g^hia^X]Zg M]Zdad\^Z u YZg LZaW( hid[[ZcWVgjc\ @diiZh ^c CZhjh m`jgh5 IajgVa^hbjh Vah FdYZaa ^ciZggZa^\^xhZg Le^g^ijVa^iui Sjb^cYZhi Vb KVcYZ hZ^ Zglu]ci' YVhh KZa^\^dcZc Vah \ZhX]^X]ia^X]Z >ghX]Z^cjc\Zc `Z^cZ [ZhihiZ]ZcYZc' `aVg VW\Z\gZcoiZc @gxtZc h^cY' b^i YZcZc h^X] ZcihegZX]ZcY deZg^ZgZc a^ZtZ) Ld Zm^hi^ZgZc Vj[ k^ZaZc >gYiZ^aZc' VWZg \ZgVYZ VjX] ^c >jgdeV jcY GdgYVbZg^`V' oV]agZ^X]Z Zg[V]gjc\hdg^Zci^ZgiZ jcY ^cY^k^YjZaa \Zegu\iZ gZa^\^xhZ F^hX][dg( ,- S^i^Zgi cVX] FYVNLTHUU# M]Zdad\^Z $l^Z 9cb) 2%' -4 $Hg^\^cVa5 L^IPNPU' M]Z @dheZa ^c V IajgVa^hi LdX^Zin' @gVcY KVe^Yh ,434' ,3-u,3.%) ,. 3HUa' >^c[{]gjc\ $l^Z 9cb) -%' 41' k\a) ,1+u,10) ,/ O\a) 9eYNLU FLYIPJR' =Zg IajgVa^hbjh YZg eajgVa^hi^hX]Zc KZa^\^dchi]Zdad\^Z' ^c5 AH`T\UK BJO^HNLY !7N%"# LKKLUZ

bZc' Y^Z cjg hX]lZg Z^cZg YZg igVY^i^dcZaaZc KZa^\^dcZc ojojdgYcZc h^cY $hd\ZcVcciZ 1YPJVSHNL$=VKLSSL%),0 =^Z yigVY^i^dcZaaZcv KZa^\^d( cZc hiZ]Zc YVYjgX] ^c Zg]ZWa^X]Zb OZgucYZgjc\h( jcY 9ceVhhjc\h( YgjX`) =^Z ?gV\Z cVX] YZb PZhZc jcY YZg BYZci^iui YZg KZa^\^dc' ZilV YZh hdiZg^` egV`i^o^Zgi l^gY' WZ`dbbi Z^cZ eajgVa^hi^hX]Z KZa^\^dchi]Zdg^Z ^chd[Zgc Z^cZ VcYZgZ ;ZYZjijc\' Vah h^Z \Zl^hhZgbVtZc oj Z^cZg EZ^ii]Zdg^Z ^cY^k^YjZaaZg gZa^\^xhZg >cil^X`ajc\hegdoZhhZ bji^ZgZc `Vcc' l^Z Y^Zh ZilV WZ^ F^X]VZa kdc ;g{X` YZg ?Vaa ^hi) =Zg ^ciZggZa^\^xhZ =^Vad\ he^Zai [{g ^]c YZh]VaW Z^cZ fb [XeThfeTZXaWX Kb__X' jX\_ haW \afbYXea \a \[` yWXe ITegaXe JhX__X `X\aXf LX_UfgiXefgpaWa\ffXfv haW WT`\g ThV[ yJhX__X `X\aXf @bggXf( iXefgpaWa\ffXfv j\eW),1 S^Za hZ^cZg KZa^\^dchi]Zdg^Z ^hi Zh' YVhh FZc( hX]Zc ^]gZ Z^\ZcZ KZa^\^dh^iui YjgX] Y^Z BciZ\gVi^dc kdc 9jhhV\Zc jcY OZg]VaiZchlZ^hZc kdc FZchX]Zc VcYZgZg KZa^\^dcZc jcY PZai( TafV[ThhaZXa XejX\gXea haW X\aX 9eg yPU[LYYLSPNPdZL 6LTLPUZJOHM[ KLY 7LPSPNLUv,2 ZcihiZ]i) =^Z sWZgl^cYjc\ YZg Z^cVcYZg l^YZghigZ^( iZcYZc PV]g]Z^ihVcheg{X]Z l^gY ^chd[Zgc c^X]i YjgX] Z^cZ gVi^dcVaZ OZg]uaic^hWZhi^bbjc\' hdcYZgc QLUZLP[Z YZg igVY^i^dcZaaZc KZa^\^dch( \ZbZ^chX]V[iZc ^c Z^cZb Zg[V]gjc\hWZod\ZcZc ^cY^k^YjZaaZc IgdoZhh ^ciZggZa^\^xhZc EZgcZch \ZhjX]i) ,). MeTafYbe`Tg\baXa WXf c_heT_\fg\fV[Xa FbWX__f5 y`hghTaZg Ba^_hf\i\f`hfv haW yeXY_X^g\XegXe Ibf\g\baT_\f`hfv 9j[\gjcY YZg LX]l^Zg^\`Z^iZc' Y^Z b^i YZb eajgVa^hi^hX]Zc KZa^\^( dchbdYZaa \Z\ZWZc h^cY' ^hi Y^Z i]Zdad\^hX]Z =^h`jhh^dc YV]^c\Z( ]ZcY lZ^iZg\Z[{]gi ldgYZc' l^Z Zh \Za^c\Zc `Vcc' Y^Z jc]^ciZg\Z]( WVgZ Idh^i^dcVa^iui jcY IZgheZ`i^k^iui i]Zdad\^hX]Zg 9jhhV\Zc oj gZheZ`i^ZgZc jcY b^i Z^cZg \gjcYhuioa^X]Zc P{gY^\jc\ VcYZgZg gZa^( \^xhZg Idh^i^dcZc hd oj kZgW^cYZc' YVhh Y^Z [{g KZa^\^dcZc `dchi^ij( ,0 O\a) EVSRLY 3YLOZLU&FHS[LY BWHYU !7N%"# Bb LX]bZaoi^Z\Za YZg KZa^\^dcZc) Ddc( ijgZc YZh bdYZgcZc Lnc`gZi^hbjh' @{iZghad] ,441) ,1 =PJOHLS ]% 1YeJR' >^c]Z^i YZg P^g`a^X]`Z^i) @dii' @diiZhZg[V]gjc\ jcY FZY^iVi^( dc ^b ]^cYj^hi^hX](X]g^hia^X]Zc =^Vad\' F{cX]Zc -,432' .1/) O\a) 4]H$=HYPH 6SHZIYLUULY&2OYPZ[PHU 7HJRIHY[O$9VOUZVU !7N%"' >^c]Z^i YZg P^g`a^X]`Z^iZc) ?ZhihX]g^[i Vcauhha^X] YZh 1+) @ZWjgihiV\h kdc F^X]VZa kdc ;g{X`' F{cX]Zc -++4) ,2 Ld FYVNLTHUU' M]Zdad\^Z $l^Z 9cb) 2%' 3/[)

6SH\ILUZNL^PZZOLP[ \UK 0ULYRLUU\UN

,12

i^kZc Zm^hiZci^ZaaZc @Zaijc\h( jcY PV]g]Z^ihVcheg{X]Z c^X]i gZaVi^( k^Zgi lZgYZc) IZggn LX]b^Yi(EZj`Za ]Vi ^b KZ`jgh Vj[ Y^Z Dg^i^` Vb eajgVa^hi^( hX]Zc KZa^\^dchbdYZaa ol^hX]Zc Z^cZb gVY^`VaZc jcY Z^cZb \Zbu( t^\iZc IajgVa^hbjh jciZghX]^ZYZc) 9ah YHKPRHS WZoZ^X]cZi Zg Z^cZc IajgVa^hbjh' YZg \gjcYhuioa^X] VaaZc KZa^\^dcZc YZc Sj\Vc\ oj PV]g]Z^i jcY AZ^a ojheg^X]i' lu]gZcY YZg NLTcbPN[L IajgVa^hbjh eg^co^e^Zaa VjX] ^c VcYZgZc' VWZg c^X]i jcWZY^c\i ^c VaaZc >ghX]Z^( cjc\Zc kdc KZa^\^dc YZc kdaaZc Sj\Vc\ oj PV]g]Z^i jcY AZ^a Zg( `Zcci),3 Bb ?Vaa YZh \Zbut^\iZc IajgVa^hbjh lZgYZc Vahd u Vjh\Z( ]ZcY kdc YZg Z^\ZcZc Idh^i^dcVa^iui u ;YP[LYPLU kdgVjh\ZhZioi' Y^Z Y^Z Gu]Z oj PV]g]Z^i jcY AZ^a ^c VcYZgZc KZa^\^dcZc Y^[[ZgZco^Zgi lV]gcZ]bWVg bVX]Zc) =Vb^i g{X`i YZg \Zbut^\iZ IajgVa^hbjh ^c Y^Z Gu]Z cZjZgZg ^c`ajh^k^hi^hX]Zg Wol) edh^i^dcVa^hi^hX]Zg FdYZaaZ) Bc oV]agZ^X]Zc IjWa^`Vi^dcZc ]Vi KZ^c]daY ;Zgc]VgYi YVgVj[ ]^c( \Zl^ZhZc' YVhh ^b Nb\Vc\ b^i YZc PV]g]Z^ihVcheg{X]Zc VcYZgZg KZa^\^dcZc Y^Z Z^\ZcZ Idh^i^dcVa^iui b^igZ[aZ`i^Zgi lZgYZc bjhh' lVh ^b IajgVa^hbjh ZWZchd lZc^\ YZg ?Vaa hZ^ l^Z ^b >m`ajh^k^hbjh) ,4 S^Za YZg gZa^\^dchi]Zdad\^hX]Zc KZ[aZm^dc b{hhZ Zh YZh]VaW hZ^c' ^c Z^cZg jc]^ciZg\Z]WVg eZgheZ`i^k \ZWjcYZcZc M]Zdad\^Z Y^Z KZaVi^k^( iui Y^ZhZg IZgheZ`i^kZ b^iojWZYZc`Zc) =Vh `xccZ YVYjgX] ZggZ^X]i lZgYZc' YVhh Y^Z gZa^\^dchl^hhZchX]V[ia^X]Z 9jtZceZgheZ`i^kZ ^c Y^Z i]Zdad\^hX]Z BccZceZgheZ`i^kZ ^ciZ\g^Zgi l^gY) =^Z O^Za[Vai YZg KZa^\^( baXa ^qaaX ThY W\XfX PX\fX T_f X\aX yI_heT_\gpg f\V[ jXV[fX_fX\g\Z rUXe_TZXeaWXe \a^_hf\i\fg\fV[Xe KX_\Z\bafcXefcX^g\iXav UXZe\YYXa jXe( WXa' W\X ;Xea[TeWg T_f y`hghT_Xa Ba^_hf\i\f`hfv ^XaamX\V[aXg) =Xe @Zl^cc Y^ZhZh DdcoZeih a^Z\Z YVg^c' YVhh Y^Z PV]g]Z^ihVcheg{X]Z YZg jciZghX]^ZYa^X]Zc KZa^\^dcZc c^X]i VW\ZhX]a^[[Zc lZgYZc jcY oj( \aZ^X] Y^Z P{gY^\jc\ YZg [gZbYZc sWZgoZj\jc\Zc bx\a^X] l^gY) Bb ^ciZggZa^\^xhZc =^Vad\ l^gY YZc OZgigZiZgc YZg Z^\ZcZc l^Z YZg [gZb( YZc KZa^\^dcZc oj\ZhiVcYZc' YVhh Y^Z sWZgoZj\jc\ kdc YZg PV]g( ]Z^i YZg Z^\ZcZc KZa^\^dc YVoj [{]gi' YVh ?gZbYZ ^b Adg^odci YZh >^\ZcZc lV]gojcZ]bZc) >g[da\i Y^Zh lZX]hZahZ^i^\' ^hi Z^c @ZheguX] Vj[ 9j\Zc]x]Z bx\a^X]) ?{g YZc =^Vad\ YZg KZa^\^dcZc ^hi Y^ZhZg ,3 O\a) @LYY` BJOTPK[$^\ZcZc lV]g( aX[`Xa)v-/ ,)0 =^[[ZgZco]ZgbZcZji^hX]Z 9chuioZ LZ^i YZg CV]giVjhZcYlZcYZ ^hi ^bbZg YZjia^X]Zg \ZldgYZc' YVhh VjX] $V% Y^Z `dc`gZiZc ;ZY^c\jc\Zc YZh Vaaiu\a^X]Zc SjhVbbZcaZWZch kdc 9c\Z]xg^\Zc jciZghX]^ZYa^X]Zg KZa^\^dcZc jcY $W% Y^Z i]Zdad\^hX]Z KZa^\^dch`g^i^`' Vahd Y^Z Dg^i^` kdc egdWaZbVi^hX]Zc >ghX]Z^cjc\h( [dgbZc kdc KZa^\^dc'-0 hiug`Zg ^c YZc ;a^X` \ZcdbbZc lZgYZc bjhh' YVb^i YZg =^Vad\ c^X]i aZY^\a^X] ^c Z^cZb VW\Z]dWZcZc' VWZg jcgZaZ( kVciZc >a^iZo^g`Za hiVii[^cYZi) '%+%' @YV[LZ[HU[PZJOL 3PMMLYLUaOLYTLUL\[PR ^cZ u]ca^X]Z S^Zag^X]ijc\ kZg[da\i Y^Z yY^Vad\^hX]Z M]Zdg^Zv YZg hd\ZcVcciZc >gaVc\Zg LX]jaZ) O\a) FPSOLST ;HTSHO&@H\S g`ZccWVg`Z^i Z^cZh LVX]kZg]Vaih kdg 9j\Zc ]Vi' ^hi CZhj ]ZWgu^hX](VgVbu^hX]Zh Pdgi "LTL[! Z^cZg YZg ^b CjYZcijb {Wa^X]Zc =ZX`cVbZc YZh MZigV\gVbbh' hd YVhh yPV]g]Z^iv ^c hZ^cZg KZYZ LiZaakZgigZiZg YZh @diiZhcVbZch ^hi) y>bZiv Wdi h^X] Vc' lZ^a Zh YZc ZghiZc' Z^cZc b^iiaZgZc jcY YZc >cYWjX]hiVWZc YZh 9ae]V( WZih Vj[cV]b $l^Z YVh 9 jcY H ^b @g^ZX]^hX]Zc%) =Vb^i lugZ cdX] hiug`Zg Zg( `ZccWVg' l^Z hZ]g YZg PV]g]Z^ihWZ\g^[[ WZ^b _d]VccZ^hX]Zc CZhjh kdb @diiZh( cVbZc ]Zg WZhi^bbi ^hi) $?{g Y^ZhZc A^clZ^h YVc`Z ^X] YZb GZjiZhiVbZciaZg Oda`Zg LidaaZ)%

6SH\ILUZNL^PZZOLP[ \UK 0ULYRLUU\UN

,24

\Z\ZWZc' YVhh Y^Z PV]g]Z^i @diiZh YZb EZ^YZc jciZga^Z\i' Vahd Vc( \gZ^[WVg' kZgaZioa^X] jcY hZaWhi ^c ^]gZg ]xX]hiZc OZgY^X]ijc\ ^c YZg IZghdc YZh Ld]cZh @diiZh CZhjh kdc GVoVgZi] Vj[h ]xX]hiZ \Z[u]gYZi ^hi) NcY lZcc cVX] X]g^hia^X]Zg 9ch^X]i @dii YZg AZ^a^\Z @Z^hi Y^Z PV]g]Z^i @diiZh WZ^ YZc FZchX]Zc hd kZg\Z\Zclugi^\i' YVhh Zg ^c ^]cZc @aVjWZc hX]V[[i jcY hd Y^Z