Begründen und Rechtfertigen: Eine Untersuchung zum Verhältnis zwischen rationalen Erfordernissen und prävalenten Handlungsgründen 9783110217131
534 53 2MB
German Pages 328 Year 2009
Polecaj historie
![Zwischen Tod und Lebensglück: Eine Untersuchung zur Anthropologie Kohelets [Reprint 2014 ed.]
3110166372, 9783110166378](https://dokumen.pub/img/200x200/zwischen-tod-und-lebensglck-eine-untersuchung-zur-anthropologie-kohelets-reprint-2014nbsped-3110166372-9783110166378.jpg)
![Die Finanzpolitik 1967–1976 im Spannungsfeld zwischen konjunkturpolitischen Erfordernissen und Haushaltskonsolidierung [1 ed.]
9783428470839, 9783428070831](https://dokumen.pub/img/200x200/die-finanzpolitik-19671976-im-spannungsfeld-zwischen-konjunkturpolitischen-erfordernissen-und-haushaltskonsolidierung-1nbsped-9783428470839-9783428070831.jpg)
Citation preview
Konstantin Pollok Begründen und Rechtfertigen
≥ Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
Quellen und Studien zur Philosophie Herausgegeben von Jens Halfwassen, Dominik Perler, Michael Quante
Band 92
Walter de Gruyter · Berlin · New York
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
Begründen und Rechtfertigen Eine Untersuchung zum Verhältnis zwischen rationalen Erfordernissen und prävalenten Handlungsgründen von
Konstantin Pollok
Walter de Gruyter · Berlin · New York
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
Gedruckt mit Hilfe der Geschwister Boehringer Ingelheim Stiftung für Geisteswissenschaften in Ingelheim am Rhein und des College of Arts and Sciences der University of South Carolina, Columbia (USA)
앝 Gedruckt auf säurefreiem Papier, 앪 das die US-ANSI-Norm über Haltbarkeit erfüllt.
ISBN 978-3-11-021713-1 ISSN 0344-8142 Bibliografische Information der Deutschen Nationalbibliothek Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek verzeichnet diese Publikation in der Deutschen Nationalbibliografie; detaillierte bibliografische Daten sind im Internet über http://dnb.d-nb.de abrufbar. 쑔 Copyright 2009 by Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, D-10785 Berlin Dieses Werk einschließlich aller seiner Teile ist urheberrechtlich geschützt. Jede Verwertung außerhalb der engen Grenzen des Urheberrechtsgesetzes ist ohne Zustimmung des Verlages unzulässig und strafbar. Das gilt insbesondere für Vervielfältigungen, Übersetzungen, Mikroverfilmungen und die Einspeicherung und Verarbeitung in elektronischen Systemen. Printed in Germany Einbandgestaltung: Christopher Schneider, Laufen Druck und buchbinderische Verarbeitung: Hubert & Co., Göttingen
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
'HP$QGHQNHQPHLQHV9DWHUV .DUO+HLQ]3ROORN
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
Å(LQ MHGHV 'LQJ GHU 1DWXU ZLUNW QDFK *HVHW]HQ 1XU HLQ YHUQQIWLJHV :HVHQKDWGDV9HUP|JHQQDFKGHU9RUVWHOOXQJGHU*HVHW]HGLQDFK3ULQ FLSLHQ ]X KDQGHOQ >«@´ ,PPDQXHO .DQW *UXQGOHJXQJ ]XU 0HWDSK\VLN GHU 6LWWHQ Å$VFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHRWKHUDQLPDOVPDQOLYHVQRWPHUHO\LQDEURDGHU UHDOLW\ KHOLYHVVRWRVSHDNLQDQHZGLPHQVLRQRIUHDOLW\7KHUHLVDQXQ PLVWDNDEOH GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ RUJDQLF UHDFWLRQV DQG KXPDQ UHVSRQVHV´ (UQVW&DVVLUHU$Q(VVD\RQ0DQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
9RUZRUW
'LHYRUOLHJHQGH8QWHUVXFKXQJZXUGHLP2NWREHUYRP)DFKEHUHLFK *HVHOOVFKDIWVZLVVHQVFKDIWHQ XQG 3KLORVRSKLH GHU 3KLOLSSV8QLYHUVLWlW 0DUEXUJDOV+DELOLWDWLRQVVFKULIWDQJHQRPPHQ (LQHIUKHUH9HUVLRQGHVHUVWHQ.DSLWHOVLVWXQWHUGHP7LWHOÅÄ:HQQ 9HUQXQIW YROOH *HZDOW EHU GDV %HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQ KlWWH¶ ² hEHU GLH JHPHLQVDPH :XU]HO GHU .DQWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH´ LQ .DQW6WXGLHQ HUVFKLHQHQ(LQHIUKHUH9HUVLRQGHVIQIWHQ.DSLWHOVZXUGH XQWHU GHP 7LWHO Å.DQW XQG +DEHUPDV EHU GDV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV PRUDOLVFKHU+DQGOXQJHQ´LQ0RUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQKJY+).OHPPH0 .XHKQ ' 6FK|QHFNHU +DPEXUJ )HOL[ 0HLQHU9HUODJ YHU|IIHQWOLFKW )U LKUH *XWDFKWHQ XQG DGPLQLVWUDWLYH 8QWHUVWW]XQJ LP +DELOLWDWL RQVYHUIDKUHQP|FKWHLFK3HWHU-DQLFK$QGUHD(VVHU0DQIUHG.KQXQG :LQIULHG 6FKU|GHU GDQNHQ 'LH IROJHQGHQ 3HUVRQHQ KDEHQ PLU ZlKUHQG GHU(QWVWHKXQJGLHVHV%XFKVLQPQGOLFKHQRGHUVFKULIWOLFKHQ.RPPHQ WDUHQ'LVNXVVLRQHQXQG.ULWLNHQJXWH*UQGHJHOLHIHUWPHLQH$XIIDVVXQJ YRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQQRFKHLQPDO]XEHUGHQNHQ 5/DQLHU$QGHUVRQ 5REHUW %UDQGRP 0LFKDHO %UDWPDQ -RKQ %URRPH 0LFKDHO )ULHGPDQ 'LHWHU+HQULFK1DGHHP+XVVDLQ0DQIUHG.KQ$OEHUW0XHV0DQIUHG 6DJD'LHWHU6FK|QHFNHU5-D\:DOODFHXQG$OOHQ:RRG$XFKZHQQVLH GHP YRUOLHJHQGHQ (QGSURGXNW QLFKW RGHU QLFKW LQ DOOHQ 6WFNHQ ]XVWLP PHQ P|JHQ VR ELQ LFK LKQHQ GRFK ]X JURHP 'DQN YHUSIOLFKWHW )U YHUEOLHEHQH8QNODUKHLWHQXQG'HQNIHKOHUELQVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKLFKDOOHLQH YHUDQWZRUWOLFK 'HU =(,76WLIWXQJ (EHOLQ XQG *HUG %XFHULXV GHU $OH[DQGHU YRQ +XPEROGW6WLIWXQJVRZLHGHP6WDQIRUG+XPDQLWLHV&HQWHUGDQNHLFKIU LKUHJUR]JLJH)LQDQ]LHUXQJPHLQHU)RUVFKXQJVDXIHQWKDOWHDQGHU6WDQ IRUG8QLYHUVLW\LQGHQ-DKUHQVRZLH $QQH3ROORNIKUWPLUMHGHQ7DJYRU$XJHQGDGDV)HOGGHU+DQG OXQJVJUQGHQLFKWDOOHLQGHQ1XW]HQPD[LPLHUHUQJHK|UW IULKUH1lKHLQ XQGDXHUKDOEGHU3KLORVRSKLHELQLFK]XWLHIVWGDQNEDU &ROXPELD6&LP$SULO .RQVWDQWLQ3ROORN
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
,QKDOW 9RUZRUWYLL (LQOHLWXQJ ,)UDJHQ ,,1RUPDWLYLWlWXQG(UNOlUXQJ ,,,$UWHQGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLW ,93UDNWLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJVJUQGH 97HUPLQRORJLVFKH$EJUHQ]XQJHQ 9,9RUEOLFN
.DSLWHO .DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
(LQOHLWXQJ %HGLQJWHV6ROOHQXQGGHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH(LQIOXGHU 9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQ +HWHURQRPLHXQG$XWRQRPLH 8QEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQXQGGLH%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ 3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQGGHUPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLV
(LQOHLWXQJ .RKlUHQWLVPXV (UNOlUXQJVZHUWXQG8QVFKlUIH +DQGOXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJVJUQGH 6FDQORQVQLFKWUHGXNWLRQLVWLVFKHV.RQ]HSW YRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ 6WUXNWXUHOOH5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG0D[LPHQ ,QWHUWHPSRUDOLWlW 6WUXNWXUHOOH,QWHQWLRQDOLWlW .RRSHUDWLRQXQGGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU .RKlUHQ] .ODVVHQJHEXQGHQH$PRUDOLVWHQ7ULWWEUHWWIDKUHUXQG GDV3UREOHPGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVNULWHULHQ
.DSLWHO +DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
[
,QKDOW
.DSLWHO 'DVGHRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJVPRGHOOXQG GLH'LIIHUHQ]HQSUDNWLVFKHU,QIHUHQ]HQ
(LQOHLWXQJ %UDQGRPV.DQWLDQLVPXV ,QIHUHQWLHOOH6HPDQWLNXQGQRUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLN 1RUPDWLYH6WDWXVXQGQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ 3UDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG,UUDWLRQDOLWlW 1RUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLNXQGGLH9HUELQGOLFKNHLW HLQHVXQEHGLQJWHQ6ROOHQV 0DWHULDOH,QIHUHQ]HQEHUHFKWLJHQGHXQGIHVWOHJHQGH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH *UQGH6ROOHQXQGQRUPDWLYH(UIRUGHUQLVVH *LEWHVHLQHQhEHUJDQJ]ZLVFKHQ(UIRUGHUQLVXQG 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ"
(LQOHLWXQJ (UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ 3UDNWLVFKH5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG9HUQQIWLJNHLW 3IOLFKWXQG(UODXEQLVLP.RQWH[W %HJUQGXQJVXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV 6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWLRQGHV:KDW:H2ZHWR(DFK2WKHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGHJHPlDOOJHPHLQHQ3ULQ]LSLHQ 6WDQGSXQNWHP|JOLFKHU=XUFNZHLVXQJYRQ +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ $OOJHPHLQH*UQGH 3HUV|QOLFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ 9HUQQIWLJNHLWXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV 5HFKWIHUWLJHQXQG%HJUQGHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVXQG5HDOLVPXV²*OWLJNHLW XQG*HOWXQJ
(LQOHLWXQJ Ä7UDQV]HQGHQWDOHbVWKHWLN·LQSUDNWLVFKHU+LQVLFKW² $FKWXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU +DEHUPDV·.RQ]HSWHLQHUSRVWNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ (QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHPRUDOLVFKHU0RWLYDWLRQ
.DSLWHO 3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
.DSLWHO 3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH 0RWLYDWLRQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
,QKDOW
[L
([NXUV .DQWV0RUDOSlGDJRJLN 'LH([SOL]LHUXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQXQGGDVHPRWLYH )XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW
%LEOLRJUDSKLH 3HUVRQHQUHJLVWHU 6DFKUHJLVWHU
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ ,)UDJHQ
:HQQ ZLU YRQ %HJUQGHQ XQG 5HFKWIHUWLJHQ YRQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW 9HUQQI WLJNHLW RGHU 9HUQXQIW VSUHFKHQ GDQQ JHKW HV LPPHU DXFK XP XQV RGHU GRFK ]XPLQGHVW XP XQVHU 9HUKlOWQLV ]X HWZDV XP XQVHUH 3HUVSHNWLYH DXI HWZDV Å)UGLH7LHUHGHV:DOGHVJLEWHVNHLQH9HUQXQIW:LUVLQGGLHMHQL JHQIUGLH*UQGHELQGHQGVLQGGLHGHUHLJHQWPOLFKHQ.UDIWGHVEHVVH UHQ *UXQGHV XQWHUOLHJHQ´ $EHU ZHU RGHU ZDV ZLUG KLHU ZRGXUFK EH VWLPPW" 6LQG GLH :HVHQ IU ZHOFKH *UQGH ELQGHQG VLQG GDGXUFK JHNHQQ]HLFKQHW GD HV VLFK EHL LKQHQ QLFKW XP GLH Ä7LHUH GHV :DOGHV¶ KDQGHOW" 2GHU VLQG XPJHNHKUW :HVHQ GLH 9HUQXQIW EHVLW]HQ GDGXUFK FKDUDNWHULVLHUW GDVLHVLFKGLHVHU HLJHQWPOLFKHQ .UDIW EHVVHUHU*UQGH XQWHUZHUIHQ N|QQHQ" 'LH HUVWH GLHVHU EHLGHQ (UNOlUXQJVVWUDWHJLHQ IKUW ]LHPOLFKGLUHNW]XUFNLQGHQ:DOGGHQQQXQPVVHQHUVWGLH7LHUHXQG LKU8QWHUVFKLHG]XXQVZHLWHUEHVWLPPWZHUGHQEHYRUGLH9HUELQGOLFKNHLW YRQ*UQGHQHLQJHVHKHQZHUGHQNDQQ$EHUZRULQXQWHUVFKHLGHQZLUXQV YRQ GHQ 7LHUHQ VLQG ZLUNOLFK DOOH 7LHUH DXHU XQV YHUQXQIWORV XQG ZLH VWHOOHQZLUGDVIHVW" $QVWDWW GLHVH 6WUDWHJLH ZHLWHU ]X YHUIROJHQ VROO LQ GHU YRUOLHJHQGHQ 8QWHUVXFKXQJ GLH hEHU]HXJXQJ ]XJUXQGH JHOHJW ZHUGHQ GD GLH 6SKlUH GHV9HUQQIWLJHQQLFKWYRQDXHQEHWUHWHQZHUGHQNDQQ ZLUILQGHQQLFKW LQ GHU 1DWXU HLQHQ ORJLVFKHQ 5DXP GHU *UQGH GHU GDGXUFK JHNHQQ ]HLFKQHWZlUHGDHUQXUYRQXQVGHQDQLPDOHVUDWLRQDOHVEHZRKQWZUGH :LUILQGHQYLHOPHKUXPJHNHKUWDOOHVZDVZLULQGHU1DWXUILQGHQLQGLH VHP ÅORJLVFKHQ 5DXP GHU *UQGH´ (LQHP VROFKHQ .DQWLDQLVPXV HQW VSUHFKHQG NDQQ QLFKW GLH 1DWXU GHV 0HQVFKHQ EHVFKULHEHQ ZHUGHQ XP GDUDXIKLQ HLQH P|JOLFKH 7HLOQDKPH DP 6SLHO GHV )RUGHUQV XQG /LHIHUQV YRQ *UQGHQ ]X HUNOlUHQ VRQGHUQ XPJHNHKUW WUlJW P|JOLFKHUZHLVH HLQH (UNOlUXQJGHVVHQZDVHVKHLWHLQ*UXQG]XVHLQ]XXQVHUHP6HOEVWYHU VWlQGQLVEHL'LH(LQO|VXQJGLHVHVOHW]WHUHQ$QVSUXFKVZLUGLQGHQYRUOLH
_____________ %UDQGRPD 6HOODUV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
JHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQMHGRFKNHLQH5ROOHVSLHOHQXQVHU6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLV JHK|UWQLFKW]XGHQKLHUYHUIROJWHQ(UNOlUXQJV]LHOHQ $EHUZDVNDQQHLQ*UXQGZRIUXQGIUZHQVHLQ"*UQGHODVVHQVLFK XQWHU DQGHUHP GDKLQJHKHQG GLIIHUHQ]LHUHQ GD VLH VLFK HQWZHGHU DXI hEHU]HXJXQJHQRGHUDXI+DQGOXQJHQEH]LHKHQLQGHPVLHGLHVHHUNOlUHQ ,P )ROJHQGHQ VROO HV QXU XP GLH 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW RGHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQJHKHQZRUDXVMHGRFKQLFKWIROJWGDDXVVFKOLHOLFKYRQ +DQGOXQJHQ GLH 5HGH VHLQ ZLUG GHQQ ]XU %HJUQGXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ ZHUGHQ VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK DXFK hEHU]HXJXQJHQ DQJHIKUW 8PJHNHKUW GLHQHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHDXFKQLFKWLPPHUGD]X+DQGOXQJHQ]XEHJUQ GHQ VRQGHUQ ZHUGHQ ELVZHLOHQ YRUJHEUDFKW XP DOOHLQ +DQGOXQJVDEVLFK WHQ ]X EHJUQGHQ 8QG XP GLH NODUH 'LFKRWRPLH YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ XQG hEHU]HXJXQJHQ ² YRQ 3UD[LV XQG 7KHRULH ² QRFK ZHLWHU HLQ]XWUEHQ QDWUOLFKZHUGHQKlXILJ]XU%HJUQGXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJHQHQWVSUHFKHQGH +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ JHlXHUW ZREHL NHLQHVZHJV NODU LVW RE $EVLFKWHQ HLQH)RUPYRQhEHU]HXJXQJHQVLQG +DQGOXQJVJUQGH EH]LHKHQ VLFK DOVR RIIHQVLFKWOLFK QLFKW QXU DXI +DQGOXQJHQ'RFKVROOHVKLHURKQHKLQQLFKWRGHUPLQGHVWHQVQLFKWYRU UDQJLJXP+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGHUHQ9HUKlOWQLV]X+DQGOXQJHQJHKHQ ,P 0LWWHOSXQNW PHLQHV ,QWHUHVVHV OLHJHQ YLHOPHKU GLH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH VHOEVWXQG]ZDUZLHGHUXPQLFKWKLQVLFKWOLFKLKUHUPDWHULDOHQ9LHOIDOWDOVR ZDV DOV +DQGOXQJVJUXQG ZLUNOLFK DQJHIKUW ZHUGHQ NDQQ VRQGHUQ KLQ VLFKWOLFK LKUHU P|JOLFKHQ )RUPHQ JHQDXHU LKUHU XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ %LQ GXQJVNUDIW RGHU 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW WHFKQLVFKHU LKUHU XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ GH RQWLVFKHQ 5HLFKZHLWH :LH YHUELQGOLFK LVW HLQ HLQVFKOlJLJHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQG ZRULQ XQWHUVFKHLGHQ VLFK GLH 9HUELQGOLFKNHLWHQ HLQHU SHUV|QOLFKHQ (PSIHKOXQJ HLQHU JHQHUHOOHQ (UODXEQLV HLQHU VXEMHNWLYHQ 3UlIHUHQ] HLQHU XQLYHUVDOHQ 3IOLFKW" *LEW HV +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GLH IU MHGH3HUVRQLQHLQHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ6LWXDWLRQHLQVFKOlJLJVLQG"8QGZHQQ MDZLHHLQVFKOl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|QQWHQ HLQH SRVLWLYH $QWZRUW YRUDXVJHVHW]WGLHVH6WDQGDUGVLKUHUVHLWVEHJUQGHWZHUGHQ"
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
,,1RUPDWLYLWlWXQG(UNOlUXQJ
,,1RUPDWLYLWlWXQG(UNOlUXQJ
'LH)RUPHQSUDNWLVFKHU1RUPDWLYLWlWVROOHQLP)ROJHQGHQGHWDLOOLHUWFKD UDNWHULVLHUWZHUGHQMHGRFKQLFKWLP6LQQHHLQHU%HVFKUHLEXQJGHUQRUPD WLYHQ 'LIIHUHQ]HQ ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHP :XQVFK HLQHU %LWWH HLQHP $QWUDJ HLQHU$XIIRUGHUXQJHLQHP$XIUXIHLQHU9HURUGQXQJHLQHP%HIHKOHLQHU 3IOLFKW HLQHU 1|WLJXQJ HLQHP 9HUERW HLQHU %LOOLJXQJ HLQHU *HQHKPL JXQJ HLQHU 'XOGXQJ HWF 9LHOPHKU VROO HV XP7\SHQ GHRQWLVFKHU5HLFK ZHLWHQJHKHQGHUHQMHZHLOLJH:HLWHUTXDOLIL]LHUXQJVFKOLHOLFKDXFK]XGHQ HEHQJHQDQQWHQXQGYLHOHQDQGHUHQ)RUPHQYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQIK UHQNDQQ (LQ DOOJHPHLQHU %HJULII SUDNWLVFKHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW XPIDW GDPLW ZLH VRZRKO 7KRPDV 6FDQORQ DOV DXFK -RQDWKDQ 'DQF\ IHVWKDOWHQ GLH YHU VFKLHGHQHQ9HUELQGOLFKNHLWHQDOOHVGHVVHQZDVIURGHUJHJHQEHVWLPPWH +DQGOXQJHQ VSUHFKHQ NDQQ XQG JHQDX GLHV VROO LP )ROJHQGHQ GHQ IXQ GDPHQWDOHQ%HJULIIGHV+DQGOXQJVJUXQGHVDXVPDFKHQ ,Q HLQHU +LQVLFKW KDW QXQ MHGRFK -RKQ %URRPH YROONRPPHQ UHFKW ZHQQHUGLH3ULPLWLYLWlWGLHVHV%HJULIIVGHV+DQGOXQJVJUXQGHVDQ]ZHLIHOW Å&RXQWLQJ LQ IDYRXU RI LV VRPHWLPHV WKRXJKW WR EH WKH EDVLF QRUPDWLYH QRWLRQ %XW LW FDQQRW EH EHFDXVH LW LV FRPSOH[ ,W LQFRUSRUDWHV WKH WZR HOHPHQWVRIQRUPDWLYLW\DQGH[SODQDWLRQ7KHQRWLRQRIDUHDVRQKDVWKH VDPH FRPSOH[LW\´ 'HPHQWVSUHFKHQG VROO HV LP )ROJHQGHQ QLFKW XP +DQGOXQJVJUQGHSHUVHVRQGHUQQXUXPHLQHQGHUEHLGHQYRQ%URRPH JHQDQQWHQ $VSHNWH JHKHQ QLFKW GLH HUNOlUHQGH VRQGHUQ GLH QRUPDWLYH 'LPHQVLRQYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQXQGGHUGDULQHQWKDOWHQHQSULQ]LSLHO OHQ 'LIIHUHQ]HQ ZLUG KLHU HLQH 5ROOH VSLHOHQ 6WHSKHQ 'DUZDOO KDW PLW %OLFNDXIHLQH$EJUHQ]XQJ]XU(UNOlUXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJHQGLH%HGHXWXQJ GLHVHUQRUPDWLYHQ'LPHQVLRQYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQIROJHQGHUPDHQKHU YRUJHKREHQ Å:LWKRXW WKH QRUPDWLYH DVSHFW RI UHDVRQV WKHUH ZRXOG EH QRWKLQJWRGLVWLQJXLVKUHDVRQVIRUVRPHRQHWRGRVRPHWKLQJIURPUHDVRQV ZK\ KH GLG RU ZLOO GR LW UHDVRQV WKDW MXVWLI\ RU UHFRPPHQG DFWLRQ IURP
_____________ 9JO GD]X 6FDQORQ Å, ZLOO WDNH WKH LGHD RI D UHDVRQ DV SULPLWLYH $Q\ DW WHPSWWRH[SODLQZKDWLWLVWREHDUHDVRQIRUVRPHWKLQJVHHPVWRPHWROHDGEDFNWR WKHVDPHLGHD DFRQVLGHUDWLRQWKDWFRXQWVLQIDYRURILWÄ&RXQWVLQIDYRUKRZ"·RQH PLJKWDVN Ä%\SURYLGLQJDUHDVRQIRULW· VHHPVWREHWKHRQO\DQVZHU´%HL'DQF\ IKHLWHV Å>«@ZHVKRXOGZHDNHQRXUFRQFHSWLRQRIWKHQRUPDWLYHVRDV WRLQFOXGHDOOIRUPVRIWKHIDYRXULQJUHODWLRQWKHQRQSHUHPSWRU\DVZHOODVWKHSHU HPSWRU\%HLQJQRUPDWLYHLQWKLVZHDNHUVHQVHZLOOWXUQRXWWRKDYHQRWKLQJHVSH FLDOO\WRGRZLWKQRUPV²DWOHDVWQRWLQWKHZD\WKDWZHXVXDOO\WKLQNRIQRUPV´9JO GD]XDXFKXQWHQ %URRPH YJOGD]XDXFK5D]
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
WKRVH WKDW H[SODLQ LWµ 'LHVHU 8QWHUVFKLHG LVW MHGRFK YRQ JUXQGOHJHQGHU PHWKRGLVFKHU%HGHXWXQJIUGDV$QOLHJHQGDVPDQPLWGHP%HJULIIGHU *UQGH DOV H[SODQDQV YHUIROJW HU WUHQQW SUlVNULSWLYH YRQ GHVNULSWLYHQ $QVlW]HQ²,QWHUHVVDQWHUZHLVHZDUHV,PPDQXHO.DQWPLWGHVVHQ3KLOR VRSKLHVLFKDQVRQVWHQHKHUGLH9RUVWHOOXQJYRQ'XDOLVPHQYHUELQGHW $Q VFKDXXQJ XQG %HJULII 1HLJXQJ XQG 3IOLFKW 6FK|QKHLW XQG (UKDEHQHV HWF GHUGLHVHEHLGHQ'LPHQVLRQHQYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQVHKUHQJ²LQ .DSVROOVFKOLHOLFKJHIUDJWZHUGHQRE]XHQJ²DXIHLQDQGHUEH]RJHQ KDWZHQQHUGLHPRUDOLVFKH4XDOLWlWHLQHU+DQGOXQJLQ5HODWLRQ]XUHQW VSUHFKHQGHQ 7ULHEIHGHU RGHU 0RWLYDWLRQ VHW]W 'LHVH PRWLYDWLRQDOH RGHU HUNOlUHQGH 'LPHQVLRQ GHV %HJULIIV GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGHV LVW MHGRFK ]X QlFKVW ]X XQWHUVFKHLGHQ YRQ GHU QRUPDWLYHQ 'LPHQVLRQ GHU *OWLJNHLW RGHU7ULIWLJNHLWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ
,,,$UWHQGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLW
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lQNXQJ PLW %OLFNDXIGHQ6SUDFKJHEUDXFKGHV6ROOHQVVWDWW(VVROOKLHUDXVVFKOLHOLFK XP HLQ QRUPDWLYHV 6ROOHQ JHKHQ 'LH 5HGHZHLVH GD MHPDQG DP $EHQG HUVFK|SIW VHLQ VROOWH ZHLO HU RGHU VLH JHUDGH HLQH DQVWUHQJHQGH %HUJWRXU KLQWHUVLFKKDWLVWHUNOlUHQGXQGLQGLHVHP6LQQHQLFKWSUlVNULSWLY]XYHU VWHKHQ 9RQ HLQHP VROFKHQ 6ROOHQ LP 5DKPHQ NDXVDOHU (UNOlUXQJHQ GHU (UZDUWEDUNHLWYRQ(UHLJQLVVHQLVWKLHUQLFKWGLH5HGH :LOOPDQGLHVHEHLGHQ%HJULIIHGHV*UXQGHVXQGGHV6ROOHQVPLW%OLFN DXIGHQDOOJHPHLQHQ%HJULIIGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHLQ%H]LHKXQJVHW]HQVR OlWVLFKIHVWKDOWHQGD)HVWOHJXQJHQDXI+DQGOXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJVDE VLFKWHQ KlXILJ ]XJOHLFK HLQH %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]X GLHVHQ +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ GDUVWHOOHQ ZRKLQJHJHQ %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ HEHQ QLFKW DXI HQWVSUHFKHQGH +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ IHVWOHJHQ :HU
_____________ 'DUZDOO
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
,,,$UWHQGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLW
HLQH+DQGOXQJDXVIKUHQVROOKDWHLQHQ HYHQWXHOOVRJDUJXWHQ *UXQG]X GLHVHU +DQGOXQJ DEHU ZHU HLQHQ HYHQWXHOO VRJDU JXWHQ *UXQG IU HLQH +DQGOXQJKDWXQWHUOLHJWNHLQHUOHLHQWVSUHFKHQGHP6ROOHQ %HUHLWV KLHU EHJHJQHW PDQ QXQ GHP 3UREOHP GHU XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ GHRQWLVFKHQ5HLFKZHLWHYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQGHQQHVNDQQXQWHU8P VWlQGHQ PLW JXWHQ *UQGHQ EHVWULWWHQ ZHUGHQ GD ZLU *UQGH ]X HLQHU +DQGOXQJE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWKDEHQDXIGLHZLUJOHLFKZRKOIHVWJHOHJW VLQG:HUUHFKW]HLWLJ]XHLQHU9HUDQVWDOWXQJNRPPHQZLOOLVWGDPLWXQWHU 8PVWlQGHQ GDUDXI IHVWJHOHJW PLW EHUK|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Å'LH5DWKJHEXQJHQWKlOW ]ZDU1RWKZHQGLJNHLWGLHDEHUEORXQWHUVXEMHFWLYHU]XIlOOLJHU%HGLQJXQJRE GLHVHURGHUMHQHU0HQVFKGLHVHVRGHUMHQHV]XVHLQHU*OFNVHOLJNHLW]lKOH JHOWHQ NDQQ GDJHJHQ GHU NDWHJRULVFKH ,PSHUDWLY GXUFK NHLQH %HGLQJXQJ HLQJHVFKUlQNW ZLUG XQG DOV DEVROXW REJOHLFK SUDNWLVFKQRWKZHQGLJ JDQ] HLJHQWOLFKHLQ*HERWKHLHQNDQQ´0LWGLHVHU$EVWXIXQJLQGHU1RWZHQ GLJNHLW HLQHU +DQGOXQJVIRUGHUXQJ LVW VFKOLHOLFK .DQWV 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ SUDNWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH LQ K\SRWKHWLVFKH XQG GHQ NDWHJRULVFKHQ YHUEXQ GHQ Å:HQQQXQGLH+DQGOXQJEORZR]XDQGHUVDOV0LWWHOJXWVHLQZU GH VR LVW GHU ,PSHUDWLY K\SRWKHWLVFK ZLUG VLH DOV DQ VLFK JXW YRUJHVWHOOW PLWKLQDOVQRWKZHQGLJLQHLQHPDQVLFKGHU9HUQXQIWJHPlHQ:LOOHQDOV 3ULQFLSGHVVHOEHQVRLVWHUNDWHJRULVFK´'DHLQH+DQGOXQJDQVLFKJXW LVW KHLW IU .DQW GD GHU *UXQG IU VLH LQ GHU $OOJHPHLQJOWLJNHLW GHV *HVHW]HV OLHJW GDV VLH JHELHWHW ,P *HJHQVDW] ]X ÅIXQNWLRQDOHQ *UQ
_____________ :HQQPLW%OLFNDXI+DQGOXQJVJUQGHYRQÄSULPDIDFLH·GLH5HGHLVWVRZLUGQRUPD OHUZHLVHGHUHSLVWHPLVFKH$VSHNWDQJHVSURFKHQ GLHYRUOlXILJH(LQVLFKWLJNHLW LP*H JHQVDW]GD]XULFKWHWVLFKGLH5HGHYRQÄSURWDQWR·QRUPDOHUZHLVHDXIGHQPHWDSK\VL VFKHQ $VSHNW GDV YRUOlXILJH %HVWHKHQ E]Z GDV UHODWLYH *HZLFKW GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV YJOGD]X'DYLGVRQ IXQG%URRPH²)UNOlUHQGH 'LVNXVVLRQHQ ]X GLHVHP .RQ]HSW GHU ÄSULPD IDFLH· +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GDQNH LFK 0L FKDHO%UDWPDQ .DQW,9 +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 .DQW,9 +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
GHQ´ GLHHLQH+DQGOXQJIUHLQH3HUVRQDOV]ZHFNGLHQOLFKNOXJXQGGD PLW VXEMHNWLY QRWZHQGLJ HUVFKHLQHQ ODVVHQ RULHQWLHUHQ VLFK ÅQLFKW IXQNWLRQDOH 3ULQ]LSLHQJUQGH´ DQ GHU LQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ RGHU ² ZLH .DQW VDJW ² ÅREMHFWLYYRUJHVWHOOWH>Q@ 1RWKZHQGLJNHLW´ GHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ +DQGOXQJ ,Q KLVWRULVFKHU +LQVLFKW JHKWHV PLU LP )ROJHQGHQXP HLQ 9HUVWlQGQLV GHVÄHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ(LQIOXVVHVGHU9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQ¶GHQ .DQWJHOWHQGPDFKWXPGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWVRZRKOGHUK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH DOV DXFK GHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV ]X FKDUDNWHULVLHUHQ 'HU%HJULIIGHUVLQQOLFKHQ1HLJXQJXQGGLHÅEHUVLQQOLFKH,GHHGHVVLWW OLFK*XWHQ´VROOHQEHLGLHVHUNDQWLDQLVFKHQ5HNRQVWUXNWLRQXQWHUVFKLHG OLFKHU 9HUELQGOLFKNHLWHQ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ GLH VFKOLHOLFK QHEHQ GHQ EHLGHQ )RUGHUXQJVUHODWLRQHQ RGHU ,PSHUDWLYHQ DXFK SULPD IDFLH *UQGH XPIDVVHQ PX HEHQVR ZHQLJ LQ $QVSUXFK JHQRPPHQ ZHUGHQ ZLHHLQHRQWRORJLVFKH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ]ZLVFKHQHLQHPPXQGXVVHQVLELOLV XQGHLQHPPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLV ,QV\VWHPDWLVFKHU+LQVLFKWJHKWHVLP)ROJHQGHQXP6WDQGDUGVGHU.R KlUHQ] P|JOLFKHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH 'HU =LHOSXQNW GHU $UJXPHQWDWLRQ EHWULIIWGDEHLHUVWHQVGLH.RKlUHQ]]ZLVFKHQSUDNWLVFKHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQGLHVLFKHLQH3HUVRQVHOEVW]XZHLVW]ZHLWHQVGLH.RKlUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQSUDNWLVFKHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQGLHHLQHU3HUVRQ YRQDQGHUHQ3HUVRQHQ]XJHZLHVHQZHUGHQXQGGULWWHQVGLH.RKlUHQ]]ZL VFKHQ HUVWHUHQ XQG OHW]WHUHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ G K 6WDQGDUGVGHUEHUHFKWLJWHUZHLVHHLQJHJDQJHQHQXQG]XJHZLHVHQHQ)HVWOHJXQ JHQDXIXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]XEHVWLPPWHQ+DQGOXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJV DEVLFKWHQ
,93UDNWLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJVJUQGH
:DV KLHU DOV HLQH+DQGOXQJ XQG ZDV DOV HLQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQG EH]HLFKQHW ZHUGHQVROOPXQDFKIROJHQGLPHLQ]HOQHQHU|UWHUWZHUGHQGRFKYRUDE NDQQ EHUHLWV DQQlKHUXQJVZHLVH IHVWJHKDOWHQ ZHUGHQ GD +DQGOXQJHQ DOV VROFKH PHQVFKOLFKHQ 9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQGHILQLHUWVLQGIUGLHZLU*UQGH IRUGHUQ XQG OLHIHUQ N|QQHQ (LQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQG ZLHGHUXP NDQQ DOOJH
_____________
.|KO (EG .DQW,9 9JO.DQW,9XQGXQWHQ .DQW9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
,93UDNWLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJVJUQGH
PHLQ DOOHV DXVPDFKHQ ZDV IU RGHU JHJHQ HLQH EHVWLPPWH +DQGOXQJ VSULFKW RGHU XP DXI GLH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ (UNOlUXQJ XQG 1RU PDWLYLWlW ]XUFN]XNRPPHQ DOOHV ZDV HLQH +DQGOXQJ ]XP HLQHQ HUNOlUW XQG]XPDQGHUHQHUIRUGHUOLFKRGHUDN]HSWDEHOHUVFKHLQHQOlW'DEHLVROO GHU DOOJHPHLQH %HJULII GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGHV LP )ROJHQGHQ EHLEHKDOWHQ ZHUGHQDQVWDWWLKQGHQ8PVWlQGHQHQWVSUHFKHQGGXUFKGLH%HJULIIHGHU 3IOLFKWGHV9HUERWVRGHUGHU(UODXEQLV]XHUVHW]HQ YJO 'HQQGLH VHU %HJULII GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGHV HUODXEW VR GLH KLHU ]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGH +HXULVWLN HLQH WUDQVSDUHQWHUH 4XDOLIL]LHUXQJ VHLQHU P|JOLFKHQ 9HUELQG OLFKNHLWVIRUPHQ 'RFK ZDV ]HLFKQHW QXQ HLQHQ VWlUNHUHQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQG JHJHQEHU HLQHPVFKZlFKHUHQDXV"8QG ZHOFKHQ6LQQNDQQGLHPHFKDQLVWLVFKH0H WDSKRULNYRQGHUQRUPDWLYHQRGHU%LQGXQJV.UDIWGHU*UQGHLKUHUMHZHL OLJHQ6WlUNHXQGLKUHPhEHUZLHJHQKDEHQVRIHUQVLHEHUKDXSWDQJHPHVVHQ LVW" :RGXUFK ]HLFKQHQ VLFK SUlYDOHQWH RGHU GRPLQLHUHQGH +DQGOXQJV JUQGHDXVXQG]ZDUMHQVHLWVGHUEORIRUPDOHQ%HVWLPPXQJDOVQRWZHQ GLJXQGKLQUHLFKHQGXPHLQH+DQGOXQJ]XHUNOlUHQ]XHUIRUGHUQXQG]X DN]HSWLHUHQ" +DQGOXQJVJUQGHKDEHQDOOJHPHLQZLHREHQEHUHLWVEHPHUNWGLH)RUP YRQ%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]XSUDNWLVFKHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQGDOVVROFKHVLQGVLHNULWL VLHUEDUGKDQIHFKWEDUDXVGHU3HUVSHNWLYHDOWHUQDWLYHUSUDNWLVFKHU)HVW OHJXQJHQ RGHU%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ 'RPLQLHUHQGVLQG+DQGOXQJVJUQGH DOVR QXU VRODQJH VLH QLFKW YRQ DQJHPHVVHQHUHQ EHVVHUHQ VWlUNHUHQ +DQG OXQJVJUQGHQDEJHO|VWRGHUEHUVWLPPWZHUGHQ'LHVHP|JOLFKH$QIHFK WXQJ JHVFKLHKW DXIJUXQG SUDNWLVFKHU hEHUOHJXQJHQ GLH GHQ XUVSUQJOL FKHQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQG LP /LFKWH DQGHUHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH ]HLJHQ $P (QGH HLQHV VROFKHQ hEHUOHJXQJVSUR]HVVHV HUODQJW HLQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQG P|JOLFKHUZHLVH+DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlW(UIKUWDOVREHUGLH%LOGXQJHLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ $EVLFKW G K GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ )HVWOHJXQJ ]X HLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ +DQGOXQJ ² 'DPLW VROO NHLQHVZHJV JHVDJW VHLQ GD SUDNWLVFKH hEHUOHJXQJHQ VWHWV ]XU $XVELOGXQJ YRQ HQW VSUHFKHQGHQ$EVLFKWHQXQGVFKRQJDUQLFKW]XHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ+DQGOXQ JHQIKUHQ =XHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ$EVLFKWHQIKUHQVLHQLFKWQRWZHQGLJ LP 6LQQH YRQ UDWLRQDO HUIRUGHUOLFK LQVRIHUQ ZLU SUDNWLVFKH hEHUOHJXQJHQ UDWLRQDOHUZHLVH GXUFKIKUHQ N|QQHQ XQG KlXILJ DXFK GXUFKIKUHQ RKQH VFKOLHOLFK KDQGHOQ ]X ZROOHQ ]X HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ +DQGOXQJHQ IKUHQ SUDNWLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQ EHLJHJHEHQHQ$EVLFKWHQ QLFKWQRWZHQGLJ LP 6LQQH YRQ DOOJHPHLQ LQVRIHUQ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU $EVLFKW XQG GHU +DQGOXQJ GDV 3KlQRPHQ GHU :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH DXIWUHWHQ NDQQ $XI GLH *WH GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGHV PX GLHV MHGRFK NHLQHUOHL 5FNZLUNXQJ KDEHQ *DQ] JOHLFKREPLWRGHURKQH+DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlW+DQGOXQJVJUQGHVWHOOHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
GLH VWHWV NULWLVLHUEDUH %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]X HLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ )HVWOHJXQJRGHU$EVLFKWGDU 3UDNWLVFKH hEHUOHJXQJHQ KDEHQ GDPLW GLH SULPlUH $XIJDEH GLH $Q JHPHVVHQKHLW YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ DE]XZlJHQ XP KHUDXV]XILQGHQ ZHOFKHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQG LQ JHJHEHQHU 6LWXDWLRQ HLQVFKOlJLJ LVW 6R LVW PHLQ:XQVFKHLQHQ.DIIHH]XWULQNHQHLQ*UXQGGDIU.DIIHH]XPDK OHQXQGHLQH7DVVHXQWHUGHQ%UKNRSI]XVWHOOHQ'RFKZHQQJOHLFKPHLQ :XQVFKPLFK]XGLHVHQ+DQGOXQJHQEHUHFKWLJWVROHJWHUPLFKGHQQRFK QLFKW DXI GLHVH +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z GLH $XVELOGXQJ HLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ $EVLFKW IHVW LFKN|QQWHPLFKHEHQVRJXWGDIUHQWVFKHLGHQLQHLQ&DIp ]XJHKHQ'RFKVWHOOWHLQHVROFKHhEHUOHJXQJQXULQVHNXQGlUHU+LQVLFKW HLQHSUDNWLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJGDULQVRIHUQHVKLHUOHGLJOLFKXPGDVÄWHFKQL VFKH¶3UREOHPGHVEHVWHQ:HJV]XU(UIOOXQJGHVEHVWHKHQGHQ:XQVFKHV JHKW9RQHLQHUSUDNWLVFKHQhEHUOHJXQJLPHQJHUHQ6LQQHLVWLQDOOHU5HJHO GDQQGLH5HGHZHQQGHU+DQGOXQJVJUXQGVHOEVWHURGHUDEJHZRJHQZLUG ZHQQDOVRZLHHVJHZ|KQOLFKGHU)DOOLVWQHEHQGLHVHP+DQGOXQJVJUXQG DQGHUHNRQNXUULHUHQGH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHH[LVWLHUHQ%HLVSLHOVZHLVHPXGHU :XQVFKHLQHQ.DIIHH]XWULQNHQHYHQWXHOOQLFKWDEJHZRJHQZHUGHQJH JHQEHU GHP :XQVFK HLQ 6WFN .XFKHQ ]X HVVHQ ZHQQJOHLFK GLHVHU ]XVlW]OLFKH:XQVFKHLQJXWHU*UXQGGDIUVHLQNDQQLQV&DIp]XIDKUHQ ZHQQZLU]X+DXVHNHLQHQ.XFKHQKDEHQ 'RFKNDQQGLHVHULQJHJHEH QHU 6LWXDWLRQ GRPLQLHUHQGH DJJORPHUDWLYH +DQGOXQJVJUXQG GHU :XQVFK QDFK.DIIHHXQG.XFKHQ P|JOLFKHUZHLVHYRQHLQHPDQGHUHQ+DQGOXQJV JUXQG ÄEHGURKW¶ ZHUGHQ %HL JHQDXHUHU hEHUOHJXQJ N|QQWH LFK QlPOLFK EHPHUNHQGDGHU:XQVFKQDFKGHP%HVXFKHLQHVVFKDWWLJHQ%LHUJDUWHQV PRPHQWDQ QRFK VWlUNHU LVW DOV GHU :XQVFK QDFK .DIIHH XQG .XFKHQ ZHQQJOHLFK HU GHQ OHW]WHUHQ QLFKW DXIKHEW DOOHUGLQJV KDEH LFK YLHOOHLFKW VFKRQ GLH (UIDKUXQJ JHPDFKW GD VLFK GHU :XQVFK QDFK .DIIHH XQG .XFKHQOHJWVREDOGLFKLQGLHVHP%LHUJDUWHQVLW]H 3UDNWLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJ IKUW GDQQ GD]X GD GHU ]ZHLWH +DQGOXQJVJUXQG GHQ HUVWHQ EHUZLHJW XQGLFKVFKOLHOLFKHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH$EVLFKWELOGH'RFKZlKUHQGLFK GLH 'HWDLOV GLHVHU $EVLFKW UHIOHNWLHUH GUlQJW P|JOLFKHUZHLVH HLQ ZHLWHUHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQG LQ PHLQH hEHUOHJXQJHQ 0LU ZLUG QlPOLFK NODU GD HV WURW]GHUELVKHULJHQhEHUOHJXQJHQEHVVHULVWVRZRKODXI.DIIHHXQG.X FKHQ DOV DXFK DXI GDV %LHU XQG GLH QHEHQEHL JHVXFKWH $EOHQNXQJ YRQ PHLQHU$UEHLW ]XYHU]LFKWHQXQGVWDWWGHVVHQGRFKGHQ9RUVWHOOXQJVYRU WUDJ HLQHV )UHXQGHV ZHLWHU]XOHVHQ GHVVHQ .RPPHQWLHUXQJ LFK LKP IU KHXWH DEHQG YHUVSURFKHQ KDEH 3UDNWLVFKH hEHUOHJXQJ NDQQ QXQ GD]X IKUHQLQGLHVHP9HUVSUHFKHQHLQHQLQJHJHEHQHU6LWXDWLRQGRPLQLHUHQ GHQ*UXQG]XVHKHQGHUPLFKGD]XEHUHFKWLJWDP6FKUHLEWLVFKVLW]HQ]X EOHLEHQ XQG ZHLWHU]XOHVHQ :HOFKH )RUP KDW QXQ HLQ *UXQG ZLH GLHVHU ZHQQ HU JHJHQEHU GHQ :QVFKHQ LQV &DIp RGHU LQ GHQ %LHUJDUWHQ ]X
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
,93UDNWLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJVJUQGH
JHKHQ GRPLQLHUW" :LHVR EHWUDFKWHQ ZLU GHQ HLQHQ *UXQG GDV JHJHEHQH 9HUVSUHFKHQYLHOOHLFKWVRJDUDOVHLQH1RUPGHUPDQIROJHQVROOXQGGLH DQGHUHQ*UQGHDOVSHUV|QOLFKH:QVFKHRGHU:HUWHGHQHQPDQIROJHQ NDQQ" (LQ GRPLQLHUHQGHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQG VHL GDPLW LQ HUVWHU $QQlKHUXQJ HLQVROFKHU*UXQGGHUHLQH+DQGOXQJLQ%H]XJDXIHLQHEHVWLPPWH6LWXD WLRQKLQUHLFKHQGOHJLWLPLHUHQNDQQXQGGDEHLYRQNHLQHPDQGHUHQ*UXQG EHUVWLPPW ZLUG 'RFK LVW GDPLW QRFK NHLQHVZHJV DXVJHPDFKW RE GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGH3HUVRQDXFKGLHVHP*UXQGHQWVSUHFKHQGKDQGHOQVROOXQG IUGHQ)DOOGDVLHVRKDQGHOQVROOWHDXVZHOFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHGLHVHV6RO OHQIRUPXOLHUWZHUGHQN|QQWH,VWGLH3HUVRQDXIJUXQGHLJHQHU(LQVWHOOXQ JHQ DOVR DXV GHU (UVWH3HUVRQ3HUVSHNWLYH ]X HLQHP HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ +DQGHOQ EHUHFKWLJW RGHU JDU DXI HLQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHV +DQGHOQ IHVWJHOHJW RGHU LVW VLH GLHV DXV GHU =ZHLWH3HUVRQ3HUVSHNWLYH DOVR LQ GHQ $XJHQ DQGHUHU3HUVRQHQ" =XP=ZHFNWHUPLQRORJLVFKHU.ODUKHLWVROOHQGDKHULQ]ZHLWHU$QQl KHUXQJDOVGRPLQLHUHQGH*UQGHQXUVROFKHEH]HLFKQHWZHUGHQGLHYRQ GHU 3HUVRQ ZHOFKH GLHVH *UQGH EHVLW]W HLQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHV +DQGHOQ IRUGHUQ 'RFK DXFK PLW GLHVHU %HVWLPPXQJ EOHLEW RIIHQ RE GLH 3HUVRQ DXIJUXQGHLJHQHU)HVWOHJXQJHQGLHVHU)RUGHUXQJXQWHUOLHJWRGHUREDQGH UH3HUVRQHQGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGH+DQGOXQJYRQLKUIRUGHUQ.OlUXQJVEHGDUI EHVWHKW GDQHEHQ ZHLWHUKLQEH]JOLFK GHU )UDJH ZLH GLHVH *UQGH ]X LK UHPGRPLQLHUHQGHQ&KDUDNWHUJHODQJHQ:DVEHGHXWHWRGHUZHUGHILQLHUW ZLH LKUH 1RWZHQGLJNHLW LKUH =XOlQJOLFKNHLW" :LH HUODQJHQ VLH EHUKDXSW LKUHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWXQGZRULQEHVWHKWGLHVH"*LEWHVHLQHLQ]LJHVXPIDV VHQGHV.ULWHULXPLKUHU9DOLGLWlW²XQGLPSRVLWLYHQ)DOOZRULQEHVWHKWHV LPQHJDWLYHQZRULQEHVWHKHQP|JOLFKH.ULWHULHQXQGZLHVLQGVLHYRQHLQ DQGHUXQWHUVFKLHGHQXQGDXIHLQDQGHUEH]RJHQ"$XIGLHVH)UDJHQYHUVXFKW GLHYRUOLHJHQGH$EKDQGOXQJ$QWZRUWHQ]XOLHIHUQ ,Q HLQHU GULWWHQ $QQlKHUXQJ DQ GDV =HQWUXP PHLQHV ,QWHUHVVHV XQG GLHQDFKIROJHQGH$UJXPHQWDWLRQVROOHQZLHGHUXP]XQlFKVWLP6LQQHHLQHU 1RPLQDOGHILQLWLRQ QXU VROFKH *UQGH DOV GRPLQLHUHQGH RGHU ZHQLJHU PHFKDQLVWLVFKSUlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHEH]HLFKQHWZHUGHQGLHHQWVSUH
_____________ 'DV ÄNDQQ· EH]LHKW VLFK KLHU QLFKW DXI HLQH )lKLJNHLW GHU KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ G K QLFKWDXIGLHP|JOLFKH(UJUHLIXQJKLQUHLFKHQGHU0LWWHO]XU5HDOLVLHUXQJGHUHQWVSUH FKHQGHQ$EVLFKWVRQGHUQDXIGLH%HUHFKWLJXQJGD]X ,PGHXWVFKHQ6SUDFKJHEUDXFKILQGHWVLFKGLH9HUZHQGXQJGHV$XVGUXFNVÄGRPLQLH UHQG·LQ9HUELQGXQJPLWGHPGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHYRUDOOHPLQGHVNULSWLYHQ LQVEH VRQGHUH|NRQRPLVFKHQ =XVDPPHQKlQJHQLP6LQQHYRQÄTXDQWLWDWLYYRUKHUUVFKHQG· 'LHVHU6LQQLVWKLHUDXVGUFNOLFKQLFKWJHPHLQW(VJHKWQLFKWXPGLHIDNWLVFKH$QHU NHQQXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ VRQGHUQ DXVVFKOLHOLFK XP GHUHQ SUREOHPDWLVFKH $QHUNHQQXQJVZUGLJNHLW 'HU %HJULII GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGHV VROO KLHU DOV HLQ ÄGXUFK
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
FKHQGH+DQGOXQJHQLGHDOHUZHLVHLQGHQ$XJHQDOOHUEHWURIIHQHQ3HUVRQHQ YHUODQJHQ ZRKLQJHJHQ *UQGH GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGH +DQGOXQJHQ QXU LQ GHQ$XJHQGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQYHUODQJHQDOVUDWLRQDOH(UIRUGHUQLVVHEH ]HLFKQHWZHUGHQVROOHQ
97HUPLQRORJLVFKH$EJUHQ]XQJHQ
(EHQIDOOV LQ %HJULIIHQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU $UWHQ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ XQG QLFKW XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU $UWHQ GHU 3IOLFKW E]Z GHU (UODXEQLV ZXUGH LQ MQJHUHU9HUJDQJHQKHLWEHU'LIIHUHQ]HQLQGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLWYRQ)HVW OHJXQJHQ DXI +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ VRZLH HQWVSUHFKHQ GHQ %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X VROFKHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ GLVNXWLHUW ,Q )UDJH VWDQG XQGVWHKWGDEHLQDFKZLHYRUGLHP|JOLFKH3UlYDOHQ]YRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQ GHQ 8P QLFKWLQWHQGLHUWH $VVLPLODWLRQHQ ]X YHUPHLGHQ VHL KLHU GHVKDOE IHVWJHKDOWHQGDSUlYDOHQWH*UQGHLP]XOHW]WHUOlXWHUWHQ6LQQHQLFKWPLW GHP LGHQWLIL]LHUW ZHUGHQ VROOWHQ ZDV -RVHSK 5D] DOV ÅH[FOXVLRQDU\ UHD VRQV´ XQG VFKOLHOLFK ÅSURWHFWHG UHDVRQV´ DQVSULFKW 0LW GLHVHP %HJULII KDW 5D] *UQGH QDPKDIW JHPDFKW GLH DOV *UQGH ]ZHLWHU 2UGQXQJ EH VWLPPWH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH HUVWHU 2UGQXQJ HQWZHUWHQ VROOHQ QLFKW ZHLO GLHVHNHLQH*OWLJNHLWEHVlHQVRQGHUQZHLOGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQVLWXDWL RQVVSH]LILVFK QLFKW DXI LKU HLJHQHV 8UWHLO YHUWUDXW 5D] QHQQW GDEHL 0 GLJNHLW DOV HLQ SURPLQHQWHV %HLVSLHO LQ ZHOFKHP GLH 5DWLRQDOLWlW GHUDUW HLQJHVFKUlQNW VHLQ NDQQ GD EHVWLPPWH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH ÄDXVJHVHW]W¶ ZHUGHQ Å$VHFRQGRUGHUUHDVRQLVDQ\UHDVRQWRDFWIRUDUHDVRQRUWRUHIUDLQ IURPDFWLQJIRUDUHDVRQ$QH[FOXVLRQDU\UHDVRQLVDVHFRQGRUGHUUHDVRQWR UHIUDLQIURPDFWLQJIRUVRPHUHDVRQ´=XP9HUVWlQGQLVGLHVHV.RQ]HSWV XQG GHU 5HODWLRQHQ GLHVHU XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ *UQGH ]XHLQDQGHU VROOWHQ ZLUQDFK5D]]XU.HQQWQLV]XQHKPHQÅ>«@WKDWFRQIOLFWVEHWZHHQILUVW RUGHUUHDVRQVDUHUHVROYHGE\WKHUHODWLYHVWUHQJWKRIWKHFRQIOLFWLQJUHD VRQVEXWWKDWWKLVLVQRWWUXHRIFRQIOLFWVEHWZHHQILUVWRUGHUDQGVHFRQG RUGHUUHDVRQV´,QHLQHP3RVWVFULSWKDW5D]VFKOLHOLFKGHQ%HJULIIGHU ÅH[FOXVLRQDU\ UHDVRQV´ GXUFK GHQ GHU ÅSURWHFWHG UHDVRQV´ ]X HUOlXWHUQ YHUVXFKWXPIROJHQGHV'LOHPPD]XO|VHQ Å,IDUXOHLVMXVWLILHGE\FHUWDLQ
_____________ XQGGXUFK·QRUPDWLYHU%HJULIIDXIJHIDWZHUGHQ²'HP$XVGUXFNSUlYDOHQWHQWVSULFKW GHULQHQJOLVFKVSUDFKLJHQ'HEDWWHQJlQJLJH$XVGUXFNRYHUULGLQJ OHW]WHUHUEHVLW]W]ZDU HEHQIDOOV PHFKDQLVWLVFKH 8QWHUW|QH GRFK ZLUG HU IDNWLVFK LP 6LQQH PHLQHV SUlYDOHQW YHUZHQGHW 5D] 5D]
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
97HUPLQRORJLVFKH$EJUHQ]XQJHQ
UHDVRQVWKHQHLWKHUWKHDFWLRQLWUHTXLUHVLVLQYDULDEO\WKHDFWLRQUHTXLUHG E\WKHXQGHUO\LQJUHDVRQVLQZKLFKFDVHRQHPLJKWMXVWDVZHOOUHO\RQWKH UHDVRQ UDWKHU WKDQ WKH UXOH RU HOVH WKH DFWLRQ WKH UXOH UHTXLUHV GHYLDWHV IURPWKDWMXVWLILHGE\WKHXQGHUO\LQJUHDVRQVLQZKLFKFDVHIROORZLQJWKH UXOHLVXQMXVWLILHG+HQFHUXOHVDUHHLWKHUUHGXQGDQWRUXQMXVWLILHG´8P GLHV]XYHUPHLGHQNDQQPDQQDFK5D]VLWXDWLRQVUHODWLYEHVWLPPWH5HJHOQ JHJHQ HLQ P|JOLFKHV hEHUVWLPPWZHUGHQ GXUFK NRQNXUULHUHQGH *UQGH ÄVFKW]HQ¶ ,Q PHLQHP 9HUVWlQGQLV N|QQHQ LP *HJHQVDW] ]X GLHVHU 9RUVWHOOXQJ SUlYDOHQWH*UQGHGHQ6WDWXVYRQ5HJHOQEHVLW]HQDEHUVLHPVVHQGLHV QLFKW 6FKOLHOLFK NDQQ DXFK GLH .OlUXQJ GHV 3RVWVFULSWV QLFKWV DQ 5D]· GRFK EHWUlFKWOLFKHP 6FKZDQNHQ LQ GHU %HJULIIOLFKNHLW YRQ H[FOXVLRQDU\ UHDVRQVUXOHVXQGSURWHFWHGUHDVRQVlQGHUQZLHDXV)ROJHQGHPGHXWOLFKZLUG Å7KHUHDVRQQRWWRFRPSO\ZLWKDQRWKHUUHDVRQLVDQH[FOXVLRQDU\UHDVRQ 6LQFH UXOHV FDQ RQO\ IXQFWLRQ DV UXOHV LI RQH WDNHV WKHP DV UHDVRQV IRU DFWLRQ DQG DYRLGV WU\LQJ WRFRPSO\ ZLWK WKH XQGHUO\LQJ UHDVRQV DOO UXOHV DUHH[FOXVLRQDU\UHDVRQV´ .XU]]XYRUGHILQLHUW5D]MHGRFK Å5XOHVDQG FRPPLWPHQWVDUHZKDW,FDOOSURWHFWHGUHDVRQVLHDV\VWHPDWLFFRPELQD WLRQRIDUHDVRQWRSHUIRUPWKHDFWRQHKDVXQGHUWDNHQWRSHUIRUPRUWKH RQHUHTXLUHGE\WKHUXOHDQGDQH[FOXVLRQDU\UHDVRQQRWWRDFWIRUFHUWDLQ UHDVRQV IRU RU DJDLQVW WKDW DFW ´ :HQQ 5HJHOQ DEHU DOV ÅH[FOXVLRQDU\ UHDVRQV´GHILQLHUWZHUGHQGDQQN|QQHQVLHQLFKW]XJOHLFKDOVHWZDVGHIL QLHUW ZHUGHQ ÅSURWHFWHG UHDVRQV´ GHVVHQ 7HLOEHJULII ZLHGHUXP GXUFK ÅH[FOXVLRQDU\ UHDVRQV´ EH]HLFKQHW ZLUG 'RFK XQDEKlQJLJ GDYRQ HU VFKHLQW 5D]· .RQ]HSW GHU ÅH[FOXVLRQDU\ UHDVRQV´ DXFK QDFK GHP 3RVW VFULSW IUDJZUGLJ 'HQQ IDOOV GLH hEHUOHJXQJHQ GLH GXUFK ÅH[FOXVLRQDU\ UHDVRQV´DEJHZLHVHQZHUGHQVROOHQHLQVFKOlJLJVLQGVRLVWNDXPHLQ]XVH KHQZHVKDOEVLHQLFKWDXFKLQGLH$EZlJXQJGHU*UQGHPLWHLQEH]RJHQ ZHUGHQ VROOWHQ )DOOV VROFKH hEHUOHJXQJHQ DQGHUHUVHLWV QLFKW HLQVFKOlJLJ VLQGVRLVWNDXPHLQ]XVHKHQLQZLHIHUQVLHEHUKDXSWHUZlKQHQVZHUWVLQG XQG HLQHV $XVVFKOXVVHV EHGUIHQ ,P )ROJHQGHQ VROO GHPHQWVSUHFKHQG GHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH*UXQG]XHLQHU+DQGOXQJQLFKWGDGXUFKDXVJH]HLFKQHW
_____________
5D] SRVWVFULSW (EG (EG 9JO 5LFKDUGVRQ 5LFKDUGVRQV $XIVDW] ² ZLH EHUHLWV 5LFKDUGVRQ $EVFKQLWW²GLHQWGHU$UJXPHQWDWLRQJHJHQGLHÄEDODQFH·9RUVWHOOXQJYRQ*UQGHQ LQVJHVDPW*HJHQ5D]·KLHUDUFKLVFKH7UHQQXQJYRQ*UQGHQKDWEHUHLWV/XEDQ)RO JHQGHVJHOWHQGJHPDFKW Å2QFHWKH ILUVWRUGHU PRUDODVVHVVPHQWLVLQLWLVDOLWWOHWRR ODWH WR UHVW FRQWHQW ZLWK VHFRQGRUGHU UHDVRQV IRU LJQRULQJ LW´ /XEDQ 9JO ]X NULWLVFKHU 'LVNXVVLRQ YRQ 5D]· .RQ]HSWLRQ DXFK %UDWPDQ 6FDQORQVRZLH:DOODFH0V
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
ZHUGHQGDHUZHLWHUHHLQVFKOlJLJHhEHUOHJXQJHQVLVWLHUWVRQGHUQXPJH NHKUWVROOHQSUlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHHLQH4XDOLWlWEHVLW]HQGLHLKUHU VHLWVHUVWGD]XIKUHQNDQQNHLQHZHLWHUHQVLWXDWLRQVVSH]LILVFKHQhEHUOH JXQJHQ GXUFKIKUHQ ]X PVVHQ GRFK DXFK GDV VROO QLFKW EHGHXWHQ GD NHLQH ZHLWHUHQ VLWXDWLRQVVSH]LILVFKHQ hEHUOHJXQJHQ GXUFKJHIKUW ZHUGHQ N|QQWHQRGHUJDUVROOWHQ (LQH JHZLVVH $IILQLWlW KDW GDV KLHU YHUIROJWH .RQ]HSW SUlYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH PLW GHP ZDV :LOOLDP ' 5RVV DOV ÄDEVROXWH 3IOLFKWHQ¶ LP*HJHQVDW]]XÄSULPDIDFLH3IOLFKWHQ¶EH]HLFKQHW5RVVVLHKWGLHÅDFWXDO RUDEVROXWHGXW\WRGRRQHSDUWLFXODUDFWLQSDUWLFXODUFLUFXPVWDQFHV´DOV HLQH 3IOLFKW DQ GLH LQ HEHQ GLHVHU 6LWXDWLRQ GLH K|FKVWH 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW EHVLW]W0DQN|QQWHEHLGLHVHUDEVROXWHQ3IOLFKW²LQ$GDSWLRQGHU)UDQN IXUW·VFKHQ 7HUPLQRORJLH ² YLHOOHLFKW DXFK YRQ GHU MHZHLOV ÄKDQGOXQJVHI IHNWLYHQ 3IOLFKW¶ VSUHFKHQ 6R PDJ HV QDFK 5RVV HLQH SULPDIDFLH 3IOLFKW JHEHQ9HUVSUHFKHQ]XKDOWHQGRFKNDQQGLHVH3IOLFKWVLWXDWLYEHUVWLPPW ZHUGHQYRQGHU3IOLFKWEHVWHKHQGH1RW]XOLQGHUQLQGHPHLQ9HUVSUHFKHQ QLFKWJHKDOWHQZLUG'LHWDWVlFKOLFKHRGHUDEVROXWH3IOLFKWYHUODQJWGDKHU LQ GLHVHU 6LWXDWLRQ HLQH DQGHUH 3IOLFKW ]X YHUOHW]HQ RKQH GD GDPLW MH GRFK OHW]WHUH DQ *OWLJNHLW YHUOLHUW ² VLH ZLUG OHGLJOLFK EHUVWLPPW ZDV VLFKEHLVSLHOVZHLVHLQ*HZLVVHQVNUXSHOQlXHUQNDQQDXFKZHQQGHUWDW VlFKOLFKHQ3IOLFKW ÅGXW\SURSHU´ JHKRUFKWZXUGH$OVSULPDIDFLH3IOLFK WHQQHQQW5RVVÅGXWLHVRIILGHOLW\´ÅGXWLHVRIUHSDUDWLRQ´ÅGXWLHVRIJUDWL WXGH´ ÅGXWLHV RI MXVWLFH´ ÅGXWLHV RI EHQHILFHQFH´ ÅGXWLHV RI VHOI LPSURYHPHQW´ VRZLH GLH EHUDXV YHUELQGOLFKH ÅGXW\ RI QRQ PDOHILFHQFH´ $OOJHPHLQ YHUVWHKW 5RVV XQWHU HLQHU ÅÄSULPDIDFLH GXW\¶ RU ÄFRQGLWLRQDOGXW\¶>«@WKHFKDUDFWHULVWLF TXLWHGLVWLQFWIURPWKDWRIEHLQJ DGXW\SURSHU ZKLFKDQDFWKDVLQYLUWXHRIEHLQJRIDFHUWDLQNLQG HJ WKHNHHSLQJRIDSURPLVH RIEHLQJDQDFWZKLFKZRXOGEHDGXW\SURSHULI LWZHUHQRWDWWKHVDPHWLPHRIDQRWKHUNLQGZKLFKLVPRUDOO\VLJQLILFDQW :KHWKHUDQDFWLVDGXW\SURSHURUDFWXDOGXW\GHSHQGVRQDOOWKHPRUDOO\ VLJQLILFDQW NLQGV LW LV DQ LQVWDQFH RI´ 5RVV OLHJW QXQ QLFKW DQ HLQHU 3IOLFKWHQNDVXLVWLNYLHOPHKUVLHKWHUKLHUHLQH $ULVWRWHOLVFKH VLWXDWLRQVEH ]RJHQH hEHUOHJXQJ DOV XQKLQWHUJHKEDU HUIRUGHUOLFK DQ 'DPLW EOHLEW 5DXPJHQXJIUGHQMHZHLOVQRWZHQGLJHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVGLVNXUVKLQVLFKW OLFKGHUMHZHLOVDXVVFKODJJHEHQGHQ3IOLFKW'RFKLVW5RVV·6SUDFKJHEUDXFK
_____________
5RVV 9JOXQWHQ)Q 9JO5RVV I 5RVV I 9JO5RVV Å)RUWKHHVWLPDWLRQRIWKHFRPSDUDWLYHVWULQJHQF\RIWKHVHSULPD IDFLHREOLJDWLRQVQRJHQHUDOUXOHVFDQVRIDUDV,FDQVHHEHODLGGRZQ´
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
97HUPLQRORJLVFKH$EJUHQ]XQJHQ
]XPHLQHQQLFKWSUl]LVHJHQXJXPHQWVSUHFKHQGHPLWGHP.RQ]HSWYHU EXQGHQHLQKDOWOLFKH3UREOHPHO|VHQ]XN|QQHQ=XPDQGHUHQVFKHLQWPLU HLQH$QQlKHUXQJDQGLHVH3UREOHPHOHLFKWHUEHUGHQDOOJHPHLQHUHQ%HJ ULIIGHV+DQGOXQJVJUXQGHV]XVHLQ HLQH.HQQ]HLFKQXQJRGHU.ODVVLIL]LH UXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQKLQVLFKWOLFKLKUHU.DXVDOUHODWLRQ]X*HIKOHQ ZLH6FKDP5HXHRGHU*HZLVVHQVVNUXSHOZLH5RVVVLHPLWEH]XJDXISUL PDIDFLH 3IOLFKWHQ YRUQLPPW HUVFKHLQW DXV GLHVHU 3HUVSHNWLYH GDQQ DOV EHUIOVVLJ (LQH GHWDLOOLHUWH .ULWLN YRQ 5RVV· VFKZDQNHQGHP 6SUDFK JHEUDXFK ]ZLVFKHQ ÅGXW\ VDQV SKUDVH´ ÅGXW\ SURSHU´ ÅDFWXDO GXW\´ XQG ÅDEVROXWHGXW\´ILQGHWVLFKEHUHLWVEHL-RKQ6HDUOHGHU]XQlFKVWGHQQDFK 5RVV HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ 6WXIHQXQWHUVFKLHG UHIRUPXOLHUW XP VFKOLHOLFK DXI JUXQG GHV DV\PPHWULVFKHQ ,QNOXVLRQVYHUKlOWQLVVHV GHU 7HUPLQRORJLH YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ GHQ 9RU]XJ YRU GHUMHQLJHQ YRQ 3IOLFKWHQ ]X JHEHQ Å2EOLJDWLRQV DQG VLPLODUO\ ZLWK GXWLHV UHVSRQVLELOLWLHV FRPPLWPHQWV HWF SURYLGHUHDVRQVIRUDFWLQJ´ (LQH ZHLWHUH GHP 1DFKIROJHQGHQ DXI GHQ HUVWHQ %OLFN QDKHVWHKHQGH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ KDW 7KRPDV 1DJHO LP $XVJDQJ YRQ 'HUHN 3DUILW PLW %OLFN DXI GLH %H]LHKXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ *UQGHQ XQG KDQGHOQGHU 3HUVRQ YRUJHVFKODJHQ Å,I D UHDVRQ FDQ EH JLYHQ D JHQHUDO IRUPZLFKGRHVQRWLQFOXGHDQHVVHQWLDOUHIHUHQFHWRWKHSHUVRQZKRKDV LWLWLVDQDJHQWQHXWUDOUHDVRQ>@,IRQWKHRWKHUKDQGWKHJHQHUDOIRUPRI DUHDVRQGRHVLQFOXGHDQHVVHQWLDOUHIHUHQFHWRWKHSHUVRQZKRKDVLWLWLV
_____________ 9JO]XGHQJHQDQQWHQ*HIKOHQ5RVV VRZLH]XP%HJULIIGHU3IOLFKWXQWHQ 6HDUOH YJODXFKHEG Å5HODWLYHWRDJLYHQVLWXDWLRQDSULPDIDFLHREOLJD WLRQFDQEHFRPHDQDEVROXWHREOLJDWLRQLILWRYHUULGHVDOORWKHUREOLJDWLRQV´6HDUOHDU JXPHQWLHUWMHGRFKQLFKWQXUJHJHQGLH5RVV·VFKH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJYRQ3IOLFKWHQVRQ GHUQ DXFK JHJHQ HLQH HQWVSUHFKHQGH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ YRQ *UQGHQ LQ SULPDIDFLH *UQGH RWKHU WKLQJV EHLQJ HTXDO XQG DEJHZRJHQH *UQGH DOO WKLQJV FRQVLGHUHG ZLH VLH %DLHU II YRUJHQRPPHQKDW$XIGLHVH.ULWLN6HDUOHVEH]LHKWVLFKVFKOLH OLFK*QWKHU GHUVHLQHUVHLWV]ZLVFKHQJOWLJHQ1RUPHQXQG1RUPHQ GLH JOWLJ XQG ]XJOHLFK DXFK DQJHPHVVHQ VLQG XQWHUVFKHLGHW Å1XUGDQQ ZHQQ HLQH 1RUPK\SRWKHVH PLW DOOHQ DQGHUHQ QRUPDWLYHQ $VSHNWHQ GHU 6LWXDWLRQ YHUHLQEDU LVW OlWVLHVLFKDOVDQJHPHVVHQEH]HLFKQHQ´ (EG 6WDWWGHUÅDEVXUGHQ´'LIIHUHQ ]LHUXQJ]ZLVFKHQ]ZHLYHUVFKLHGHQHQ*HOWXQJVEHJULIIHQ²ÅHLQHSULPDIDFLH*HOWXQJ EHLGHUXQNODU EOHLEWLQZHOFKHP *UDGHVLHYHUSIOLFKWHWXQGHLQH DEVROXWH*HOWXQJ GLH QLFKW HLQJHVFKUlQNW ZHUGHQ GDUI´ HEG ² GLIIHUHQ]LHUW *QWKHU LQ :HLWHU IKUXQJ GHV 6HDUOH·VFKHQ $QVDW]HV GLH EHLGHQ )RUPHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU LQ VLH MHZHLOV HLQJHKHQGHQVLWXDWLRQVUHOHYDQWHQ,QIRUPDWLRQ'LH$QJHPHVVHQKHLWYRQ*UQGHQLQ HLQHUVSH]LILVFKHQ6LWXDWLRQVRZLHLKUHMHZHLOLJH9HUELQGOLFKNHLWZHUGHLFKLQGHQ.DS XQGQLFKWDOVHLQH)XQNWLRQMHZHLOV]XJlQJOLFKHU,QIRUPDWLRQ]XHUOlXWHUQYHUVX FKHQ VRQGHUQ DOV HLQH )XQNWLRQ GHRQWLVFKHU 6WDWXV GLH 3HUVRQHQ DXIJUXQG HQWVSUH FKHQGHU6HOEVWRGHU)UHPG=XVFKUHLEXQJHQEHVLW]HQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
DQ DJHQWUHODWLYH UHDVRQ´ 'DV .RQ]HSW SUlYDOHQWHU *UQGH VROO LP )RO JHQGHQ VR HQWZLFNHOW ZHUGHQ GD LKQHQ 1HXWUDOLWlW ]XNRPPW RKQH MH GRFK DXI 1DJHOV +LQWHUJUXQGPHWDSK\VLN IHVWJHOHJW ]X VHLQ GLH QHXWUDOH *UQGH PLW LPSHUVRQDOHQ :HUWHQ NRUUHOLHUW 'DUEHU KLQDXV LVW GDV .RQ]HSW GHU DJHQWUHODWLYH UHDVRQV DOV VROFKHV QRFK ]X XQJHQDX XP XQWHU VFKLHGOLFKH GHRQWLVFKH 5HLFKZHLWHQ EHVWLPPHQ ]X N|QQHQ 6R PDJ ]ZDU NODUVHLQGD3HUVRQHQGLHLP5HJHQVWHKHQHLQHQJXWHQ*UXQGKDEHQ VLFKXQWHUHLQH0DUNLVH]XVWHOOHQ$EHULVWGLHVH$NWRUUHODWLYLWlWGLHVHOEH ZLHEHL3HUVRQHQGLHGHU$XIIDVVXQJVLQGGDQXUGDVWlJOLFKH7UDLQLQJ DQGHU.OHWWHUZDQGVLH]XUEHDEVLFKWLJWHQ7RXUDQGHU1RUGZDQGYRQ+DOI 'RPH LP ]ZGHP:LOOHQXQGGHVVHQ2EMHNW .3@HVEHUXKHQXQDXIGHU1HLJXQJ RGHU DXI 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ GHU 9HUQXQIW OlW QXU K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLYHQ P|JOLFK ZHUGHQ LFKVROOHWZDVWKXQGDUXPZHLOLFKHWZDVDQGHUHVZLOO'DJHJHQVDJWGHUPRUDOL VFKHPLWKLQNDWHJRULVFKH,PSHUDWLY LFKVROOVRRGHUVRKDQGHOQRELFKJOHLFKQLFKWV DQGHUHVZROOWH=(MHQHUVDJW LFKVROOQLFKWOJHQZHQQLFKEHL(KUHQEOHLEHQZLOO GLHVHUDEHU LFKVROOQLFKWOJHQREHVPLUJOHLFKQLFKWGLHPLQGHVWH6FKDQGH]X]|JH´
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
SUDNWLVFKHU $EVLFKW QDFK 3ULQFLSLHQ D SULRUL XUWKHLOW >«@´ $EJHVHKHQ YRQGHU3UREOHPDWLNGHU3URWDVLVGLHZHLWHUXQWHQQRFK]XWKHPDWLVLHUHQ LVWVFKHLQWHVPLQGHVWHQVSULPDIDFLHIUDJOLFK]XVHLQGD.DQWGHQ$Q VSUXFKGHU$SRGRVLVGLH,GHQWLWlWWKHRUHWLVFKHU6SRQWDQHLWlWXQGSUDNWL VFKHU$XWRQRPLHDUJXPHQWDWLYHLQJHO|VWKDW'LHVH VFKRQYRQGHQIU KHVWHQ .DQW5H]LSLHQWHQ DXIJHZRUIHQH 3UREOHPDWLN HLQHV HLQKHLWOLFKHQ %HJULIIVGHU9HUQXQIWDOVRGLH(LQKHLWHSLVWHPLVFKHUXQGSUDNWLVFKHU1RUPD WLYLWlW VROO LP IROJHQGHQ MHGRFK DXVJHNODPPHUW EOHLEHQ 6WDWWGHVVHQ VROO GLH(LQKHLWDOOHLQGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWWKHPDWLVLHUWZHUGHQ,VWÅSUDN WLVFKH 9HUQXQIW´ JHPl GHU .DQWLVFKHQ .RQ]HSWLRQ HLQH *DWWXQJ GLH YHUVFKLHGHQH$UWHQXQWHUVLFKEHIDW":RULQEHVWHKHQGDQQ(LQKHLWXQG 'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQHLQHPEHGLQJWHQXQGHLQHPXQEHGLQJWHQ6ROOHQ" ,FK ZHUGH ]XQlFKVW DXI GLH KLHUIU HLQVFKOlJLJH 'LIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ.DQWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHQHLQJHKHQZREHLVLFKKHUDXVVWHOOHQZLUGGD K\SRWKHWLVFKH,PSHUDWLYHHLQHQOHLFKWHUHQ=XJDQJ]XP%HJULIISUDNWLVFKHU 9HUQXQIW HUP|JOLFKHQ DOV GHU NDWHJRULVFKH ,PSHUDWLY JOHLFKZRKO GLH 1RUPDWLYLWlWMHQHUPLWHUKHEOLFKHQ3UREOHPHQEHKDIWHWLVW0LWGHU(UOlX WHUXQJ XQG %HDQWZRUWXQJ GHU )UDJH QDFK GHU QRUPDWLYHQ .UDIW LQVWUX PHQWHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW ZLUG ]XJOHLFK GLH V\VWHPDWLVFKH 9HUNQSIXQJ GHU K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH PLW GHP NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY VLFKWEDU
_____________ .DQW9 9JO GD]X EHLVSLHOVZHLVH 5HLQKROGV )RUGHUXQJ QDFK HLQHU ÅJHPHLQVFKDIWOLFKHQ )XQ GDPHQWDOZLVVHQVFKDIW´ 5HLQKROG YJODXFKHEGIXQG (LQHLQ GLHVHU +LQVLFKW DWWUDNWLYH .DQW,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ XQG 9HUWHLGLJXQJ ILQGHW VLFK EHL 2·1HLOO GLHVLHIROJHQGHUPDHQUHVPLHUW Å5HDVRQ>«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«@.DQW·VVWUDWHJ\LVUDWKHUWRJLYHDFRQVWUXFWLYLVWDFFRXQWRIWKHDXWKRULW\RI UHDVRQ>«@´ 2·1HLOO 9RQ HLQHU 4XHOOH GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW VROOWH QXU LQ VHQVX VWULFWR DOV GHU %HGLQJXQJ GHU 0|JOLFKNHLWYHUVFKLHGHQHU)RUPHQYRQ1RUPDWLYLWlW %LWWH$XIUXI9RUVFKULIW1|WL JXQJHWF JHVSURFKHQZHUGHQ.RUVJDDUGKDQGHOW]XQlFKVWYRQ1RUPDWLYLWlWLP3OX UDO GHU LKUHP %XFK 7KH 6RXUFHV RI 1RUPDWLYLW\ GHQ 7LWHO JHJHEHQ KDW ZHQQ VLH YHU VFKLHGHQH'LPHQVLRQHQGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLWDXI]lKOW ÅREOLJDWLRQULJKWQHVVJRRGQHVV PHDQLQJNQRZOHGJHEHDXW\DQGYLUWXH>«@2EOLJDWLRQWKHPRVWREWUXVLYHO\QRUPD WLYH RI WKHVH FRQFHSWV VHHPV VWHUQO\ WR FRPPDQG ZKLOH EHDXW\ RQO\ WR DWWUDFW DQG PHDQLQJSHUKDSVWRVXJJHVWµ .RUVJDDUG E .RUVJDDUGLVWVFKOLHOLFKMH
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
'LH (QWGHFNXQJ GHU JHPHLQVDPHQ :XU]HO P|JOLFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH IKUW QHEHQEHL]XHLQHU1HXEHZHUWXQJGHU%HJULIIHYRQ+HWHURQRPLHXQG$X WRQRPLHEH]JOLFK LKUHU 5HOHYDQ] IU GLH.DQWLVFKH 9RUVWHOOXQJ YRQGHU %HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ0HLQH)UDJHLVWKLHUEHLMHGRFKQLFKWREEHL VSLHOVZHLVH 7LHUH RGHU +HLOLJH NOXJ RGHU JDU PRUDOLVFK KDQGHOQ N|QQHQ VRQGHUQYLHOPHKUZHOFKH9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQHUIOOWVHLQPVVHQGDPLWHLQH $XIIRUGHUXQJ]XNOXJHPRGHUJDUPRUDOLVFKHP+DQGHOQEHUKDXSWVLQQ YROO LVW :LU NHQQHQ ² VR .DQWV $QWZRUW ² DXHU GHP 0HQVFKHQ NHLQ :HVHQEHLGHPGLHV]XWUlIH
%HGLQJWHV6ROOHQXQGGHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH(LQIOXGHU 9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQ %HGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
'LHKHXWHJlQJLJHXQGLQGHU(LQOHLWXQJEHUHLWVDQJHVSURFKHQH'LIIHUHQ ]LHUXQJ YRQ LQVWUXPHQWHOOHU SUXGHQWLHOOHU XQG PRUDOLVFKHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW UHIOHNWLHUW PHKU RGHU ZHQLJHU JHQDX GLH .DQWLVFKH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ YRQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHQGHU*HVFKLFNOLFKNHLWXQGGHU.OXJKHLWVRZLHGHP NDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYGHU0RUDOLWlW $XIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNVFKHLQWGLH6ROO*HOWXQJGHVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSH UDWLYVPLWZHQLJHU3UREOHPHQEHKDIWHW]XVHLQDOVGLHGHUK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH 'HU NDWHJRULVFKH ,PSHUDWLY ² Å+DQGOH VR GD GLH 0D[LPH GHLQHV :LOOHQV MHGHU]HLW ]XJOHLFK DOV 3ULQFLS HLQHU DOOJHPHLQHQ *HVHW]JH EXQJ JHOWHQ N|QQH´ ² OlWDXIJUXQGVHLQHV )RUPDOLVPXV VHLQHU,QKDOWV OHHUH QLFKW QXU NHLQHQ 3ODW] IU $EZlJXQJHQ YRQ ,QWHUHVVHQ VHLHQ VLH HJRLVWLVFKHU RGHU DOWUXLVWLVFKHU $UW .DQW HQWELQGHW YLHOPHKU GXUFK GLH XQEHGLQJWH 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW GLHVHV ,PSHUDWLYV GLHMHQLJH 3HUVRQ GLH DXV $FKWXQJ YRU GHP 6LWWHQJHVHW] KDQGHOW YRQ MHGHU ZHLWHUHQ 3IOLFKW GLH
_____________ GRFK HQWJHJHQ GLHVHU 'LYHUVLILNDWLRQ YRQ 1RUPDWLYLWlW XQG GDPLW DXFK LQ JHZLVVHU +LQVLFKWGHP%XFKWLWHO]XZLGHU GHU$XIIDVVXQJGDHLQÅXQLILHGDFFRXQWRIQRUPD WLYLW\´ HEG P|JOLFKLVW DXI.RUVJDDUGV,QWHUSUHWDWLRQYRQ.DQWV1RUPDWLYLWlWVNRQ ]HSWLRQZHUGHLFKLQHWZDVJHQDXHUHLQJHKHQ :HQQ LP IROJHQGHQ YRP 0HQVFKHQ YRQ PHQVFKOLFKHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW RGHU 9HUQXQIW XQGGHUHQ1RUPDWLYLWlWGLH5HGHLVWVRZLUGGDPLWLP6LQQHYRQ.DQWV5HOLJLRQVVFKULIW HLQ %HJULII DQJHVSURFKHQ GHU GLH $QODJHQ ]XU 7LHUKHLW ]XU 0HQVFKKHLW XQG ]XU3HUV|QOLFKNHLWXPIDW YJO.DQW9,VRZLHGD]X.DLQ 7UDQV ]HQGHQWDOSKLORVRSKLVFKLVWPHQVFKOLFKH5DWLRQDOLWlWQDFK.DQWGXUFK6LQQOLFKNHLWXQG 9HUVWDQG9HUQXQIWGHILQLHUW YJO]%.U9$% .DQW9 9JO.DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
%HGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
HQWVSUHFKHQGH+DQGOXQJ]XUHFKWIHUWLJHQ :HULQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHV6LW WHQJHVHW]HVGKVRKDQGHOWGDGLH0D[LPHVHLQHU+DQGOXQJ DOVGHUHQ KLQUHLFKHQGH %HJUQGXQJ NRQIOLNWIUHL DXFK YRQ DOOHQ DQGHUHQ 3HUVRQHQ DOV+DQGOXQJVJUXQGDQHUNDQQWZHUGHQNDQQKDQGHOWULFKWLJE]ZVLWWOLFK 'DV6LWWHQJHVHW]ZLH.DQWHVIUHQGOLFKH:HVHQDOVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSH UDWLY IRUPXOLHUW KDW OlW NHLQHQ 5DXP VWUDWHJLVFKHU hEHUOHJXQJ HV LVW ZHGHU 'LVNXVVLRQVYRUVFKODJ QRFK 9HUKDQGOXQJVEDVLV XQG ² ]XPLQGHVW QDFK .DQW ² VHOEVW ÅIU GHQ JHPHLQVWHQ 9HUVWDQG JDQ] OHLFKW XQG RKQH %HGHQNHQ HLQ]XVHKHQ´ ZHLO HV LP *HJHQVDW] ]X 1DWXUJHVHW]HQ QLFKW HUVFKORVVHQ XQG HUNDQQW VRQGHUQ DQHUNDQQW RGHU PLDFKWHW ZLUG 'LH :LOOHQVQ|WLJXQJGHVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVNRPPWXQJHIUDJWXQGIUDJ ORVDXIXQV]XVLHWULIIWXQVDOVÅ)DFWXPGHUUHLQHQ9HUQXQIW´²REZLU ZROOHQRGHUQLFKW1XUVHLQH$QHUNHQQXQJUHVSHNWLYH0LDFKWXQJHUIRU GHUWHLQHQ$NWYHUQQIWLJHU)UHLKHLWGHQ.DQWDOV$XWRQRPLHEH]HLFKQHW $QGHUV YHUKlOW HVVLFK GDJHJHQ PLW GHQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYHQ 6LHÅ>«@VWHOOHQGLHSUDNWLVFKH1RWKZHQGLJNHLWHLQHUP|JOLFKHQ+DQGOXQJ
_____________ 'D.DQWLQGHU*UXQGOHJXQJGLH*OWLJNHLWGHVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVKLQVLFKWOLFK LQQHUHUlXHUHUVRZLHHQJHUHUZHLWHUHUE]ZYROONRPPHQHUXQYROONRPPHQHU3IOLFK WHQGLIIHUHQ]LHUW QLFKWOHW]WHUH DXVHUVWHUHPDEOHLWHW YJOGD]X.KQ0V WDQ JLHUW QLFKW GLH XQEHGLQJWH *OWLJNHLW GHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV VRQGHUQ EHWULIIW QXUGLHXPVWDQGVVSH]LILVFKHÅ(LQWHLOXQJGHU3IOLFKWHQ´ ,9 XQGGDPLWGLH$Q ZHQGXQJVNRQWH[WHGHVXQHLQJHVFKUlQNWJHOWHQGHQGKNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYV .DQW9 .DQW 9 $XI GDV Ä)DNWXP¶ XQG GHQ GDPLW YHUEXQGHQHQ %HJULII GHU $FKWXQJ ZHUGH LFK LQ .DS QRFK QlKHU HLQJHKHQ 1XU VRYLHO NDQQ EHUHLWV DQ GLHVHU 6WHOOH IHVWJHVWHOOWZHUGHQ)U.DQWLVWPLWGLHVHP%HZXWVHLQGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVGLHVHUVLWW OLFKHQ(LQVLFKWNHLQHVIDOOVHLQ,QWXLWLRQLVPXVLP6LQQH3ULFKDUGVYHUEXQGHQ3ULFKDUG ZHLVW MHJOLFKH 0|JOLFKNHLW ]XUFN PRUDOLVFKH $QVSUFKH DXV EHVWLPPWHQ hEHU]HX JXQJHQ XQG hEHUOHJXQJHQ DE]XOHLWHQ Å'DV *HIKO GHU 9HUSIOLFKWXQJ ]X HLQHU EH VWLPPWHQ+DQGOXQJRGHUGLH5LFKWLJNHLWGLHVHU+DQGOXQJLVWDEVROXWSULPlU GKYRQ QLFKWV DQGHUHPDEJHOHLWHW E]ZXQPLWWHOEDU>«*@HVHW]WGHQ)DOO GDZLUGXUFKHL QHQ3UR]HEHLGHPHVVLFKQDWUOLFKQXUXPHLQHQ3UR]HDOOJHPHLQHUXQGQLFKWPR UDOLVFKHUhEHUOHJXQJHQKDQGHOW]XGHU(UNHQQWQLVJHODQJHQGDZLUPLWGHUJHSODQ WHQ +DQGOXQJ GDV (UJHEQLV $ LQ HLQHU %H]LHKXQJ % KHUEHLIKUHQ ZHUGHQ GDQQ HUNHQQHQZLUGLH9HUSIOLFKWXQJXQPLWWHOEDURGHUGLUHNWZREHLGLHVH(UNHQQWQLVHLQH 7lWLJNHLWGHVPRUDOLVFKHQ'HQNHQVLVW´ 3ULFKDUG ,QVRIHUQ0D[LPHQLP6LQQH .DQWVPRUDOLVFKHhEHU]HXJXQJHQGDUVWHOOHQXQGLQVRIHUQGHUNDWHJRULVFKH,PSHUDWLY HLQ*UXQGVDW]LVWVSLHOHQIU.DQWLP*HJHQVDW]]X3ULFKDUGJHQXLQPRUDOLVFKHhEHU OHJXQJHQHLQHHQWVFKHLGHQGH5ROOHEHLGHU(UPLWWOXQJGHU5LFKWLJNHLWHLQHU+DQGOXQJ .DQWV .RJQLWLYLVPXV EHVWHKW LQ VFKDUIHP .RQWUDVW ]XP ,QWXLWLRQLVPXV GDULQ GD PRUDOLVFKH 6lW]H HLQHQ SURSRVLWLRQDOHQ *HKDOW EHVLW]HQ GHU ]XVWLPPXQJVIlKLJ XQG EHVWUHLWEDU LVW JOHLFKZRKO VWHKW DXFK IU .DQW GDV %HZXWVHLQ GHU *OWLJNHLW GLHVHU JHQXLQPRUDOLVFKHQ8UWHLOHLQNHLQHPGHGXNWLYHQ9HUKlOWQLV]XDQGHUHQDXHUPRUDOL VFKHQ 8UWHLOHQ DXFK QLFKW VROFKHQ EHU GLH )UHLKHLW GHV 0HQVFKHQ =XPLQGHVW JLOW GLHVIUGHQ.DQWGHU.ULWLNGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW YJOGD]XXQWHQ)Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
DOV 0LWWHO ]X HWZDV DQGHUHP ZDV PDQ ZLOO RGHU GRFK P|JOLFK LVW GD PDQHVZROOH ]XJHODQJHQYRU´'LHVH,PSHUDWLYHVLQGLQVRIHUQK\SR WKHWLVFK DOV GLH LQ LKQHQ DXVJHGUFNWH 1RWZHQGLJNHLW HLQHU +DQGOXQJ EHGLQJWLVWGXUFKGLH9RUJDEHHLQHVEHVWLPPWHQ=ZHFNV=ZDUYHUIROJW DXFK GHU LP HQJHUHQ 6LQQH PRUDOLVFK KDQGHOQGH 0HQVFK HLQHQ =ZHFN ZHVHQWOLFK ]ZHFN RGHU DEVLFKWVORVHV 9HUKDOWHQ ZlUH DXFK IU .DQW HLQ EOR QDWXUDOHV *HVFKHKHQ 'RFK KlQJW EHL LKP GLH SUDNWLVFKH 1RWZHQ GLJNHLWGHU+DQGOXQJJHUDGHQLFKWYRQGLHVHP=ZHFNDE:lKUHQGGDV *HERW .ODYLHU ]X EHQ QXU IU GLHMHQLJH 3HUVRQ JLOW GLH GLH )lKLJNHLW HUODQJHQ ZLOO .ODYLHU ]X VSLHOHQ JLOW EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GDV/JHQYHUERW XQG PLWLKPDOOHLPHQJHUHQ6LQQHPRUDOLVFKUHOHYDQWHQ*HERWHXQG9HUERWH ]ZHFNLQYDULDQW ]XPLQGHVWEHVDJWGLHVGLH.DQWLVFKH.RQ]HSWLRQ ,P*HJHQVDW]]XPNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYJLEW.DQWYRQGHQK\SR WKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYHQ NHLQH DOOJHPHLQJOWLJH )RUPHO DQ 'LHWHU 6FK|Q HFNHU XQG $OOHQ :RRG KDEHQ MHGRFK DXV GHQ .DQWLVFKHQ %HLVSLHOHQ GLH IROJHQGH LQ PHLQHQ $XJHQVHKU KLOIUHLFKH )RUPHO H[WUDKLHUW Å:HQQ >@ L ]ZLVFKHQ GHP =ZHFN S XQG GHP 0LWWHO T HLQ 9HUKlOWQLV GHU $UW EH VWHKWGDQXUGLH(UJUHLIXQJYRQTGLH5HDOLVDWLRQYRQSHUP|JOLFKW LL PDQTHUJUHLIHQNDQQXQG LLL PDQSZLOOVRVROOPDQTHUJUHLIHQ´8Q
_____________ .DQW,9 1DFK 3DW]LJ OHQNW DXFK &UDPHU LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ GLH $XI PHUNVDPNHLW YRQ GHU VSUDFKOLFKHQ )RUP DXI PDWHULDOH hEHUOHJXQJHQ Å6R KlQJW GLH (QWVFKHLGXQJ GDUEHU RE HLQ ÄNDWHJRULVFK¶ RGHU ÄK\SRWKHWLVFK¶ IRUPXOLHUWHU ,PSHUDWLY ÄNDWHJRULVFK¶RGHUK\SRWKHWLVFK¶ÄXQEHGLQJW¶RGHUÄEHGLQJW¶JHELHWHWQLFKWYRQVSUDFKOL FKHQ(UZlJXQJHQVRQGHUQYRQVDFKOLFKHQ8QWHUVFKHLGXQJHQXQGGHUHQ%HJUQGEDU NHLWDE,PSHUDWLYHZLHÄ9HUVSULFKQLFKWOJHQKDIW¶LP8QWHUVFKLHG]XÄ=LHKGLFKZDUP DQ¶XQGÄ:HQQGXGLFKQLFKWXPGHLQHQ.UHGLWEULQJHQZLOOVWVRKDOWHGHLQH9HUVSUH FKHQ¶LP8QWHUVFKLHG]XÄ:HQQGXHLQ9HUVSUHFKHQDEJHJHEHQKDVWVRKDOWHHV¶PD FKHQ KLHUDXI DXIPHUNVDP´ &UDPHU 9JO GD]X DXFK /XGZLJ 9JO.DQW9 ,Q GHU *UXQGOHJXQJ ,9 KHLW HV ODSLGDU ÅPRUDOLVFK G L NDWHJRULVFK´ ² 'LH =ZHFNLQYDULDQ]GHU*OWLJNHLWYRQGHUKLHUGLH5HGHLVWZLGHUVSULFKWQLFKWGHUREHQ HUZlKQWHQXPVWDQGVVSH]LILVFKHQÅ(LQWHLOXQJGHU3IOLFKWHQ´ YJO)Q XQGLVWGDKHU QLFKW]XYHUZHFKVHOQPLWHLQHU6LWXDWLRQVLQYDULDQ] LP%HLVSLHO GDV/JHQYHUERWEH VLW]WXQEHGLQJWH*OWLJNHLWGKXQDEKlQJLJYRP=ZHFNGHU/JHDEHUHVNRPPWQD WUOLFKQXULQEHVWLPPWHQLQWHUSHUVRQDOHQXQGVSH]LILVFKLOORNXWLRQVVHQVLEOHQ.RQWH[ WHQ]XU*HOWXQJ 6FK|QHFNHU:RRG YJO EHUHLWV :RRG [[LL VRZLH PHLQHQ 9HUZHLV DXI%URRPH0VLQ)Q:ROOWHPDQGLHVHQ6DW]JUDPPDWLNDOLVFKLQHLQHLP SHUDWLYH )RUP EULQJHQ KlWWH HU HWZD IROJHQGH )RUP ÅZHQQ GX GHQ =ZHFN S ZLOOVW XQGGDVGD]XQRWZHQGLJH0LWWHOTHUJUHLIHQNDQQVWVRHUJUHLIHT´²'DGLHVLWXDWL RQVEHGLQJWH(LQVHW]XQJIUTXQGSHLQH.RQWLQJHQ]DXIGLHVHQK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,P SHUDWLYEHUWUlJWVWHOOWPHLQHV(UDFKWHQVNHLQ+LQGHUQLVIUHLQHDEVWUDNWH)RUPXOLH
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
%HGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
WHUGHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQDOVRGDPDQHUVWHQVHLQHQEHVWLPPWHQ=ZHFN YHUIROJWXQG]ZHLWHQVGLH]XGHVVHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJQ|WLJHQ0LWWHOHUJUHLIHQ NDQQVROOPDQGLHVH0LWWHOHUJUHLIHQ²'LHVHVVROOLVWGDVMHQLJHZDVLP )ROJHQGHQDXIGHP6SLHOVWHKW .DQW XQWHUVFKHLGHW ]ZDU LQQHUKDOE GHU K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH QRFK DVVHUWRULVFKSUDJPDWLVFKH GHU .OXJKHLW YRQ SUREOHPDWLVFK WHFKQLVFKHQGHU*HVFKLFNOLFKNHLW 'RFKLVWGLHVH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJIUGHQ JHJHQZlUWLJHQ .RQWH[W QLFKW ]HQWUDO XQG VHL GHVKDOE KLHU QXU IOFKWLJ UHVPLHUW:lKUHQGEHL,PSHUDWLYHQGHU.OXJKHLWGHU=ZHFNDOVYRQGHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ1DWXUYRUJHJHEHQDQJHQRPPHQZLUG²DOOH0HQVFKHQKD EHQ GDV =LHO GHU HLJHQHQ *OFNVHOLJNHLW ² LVW EHL ,PSHUDWLYHQ GHU *H VFKLFNOLFKNHLWGHU=ZHFNVHOEVWQLFKWVFKRQYRUJHJHEHQVRQGHUQEHLXQ WHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 0HQVFKHQ LQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ YHUVFKLHGHQ 'LHVH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJLQQHUKDOEGHUK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHLVWMHGRFK PLW JURHQ H[HJHWLVFKHQ 6FKZLHULJNHLWHQ EHKDIWHW .DQW OHJW VLFK EHL VSLHOVZHLVH QLFKW HLQGHXWLJ IHVW ZHOFKHQ GHVNULSWLYHQ RGHU QRUPDWLYHQ 6WDWXVGLH*OFNVHOLJNHLWDOV=ZHFNVRZLHGHVVHQNOXJH9HUIROJXQJEHVLW ]HQ 0DQ PX LQ GHQ HLQVFKOlJLJHQ 3DVVDJHQ OHW]WOLFK HLQ JHZLVVHV 6FKZDQNHQNRQVWDWLHUHQREQlPOLFKGDV6WUHEHQQDFKHLJHQHU*OFNVHOLJ NHLWHLQH LQGLUHNWH 3IOLFKWVHLRGHUHLQHÅ$EVLFKWGLHPDQVLFKHUXQGD SULRULEHLMHGHP0HQVFKHQYRUDXVVHW]HQNDQQZHLOVLH]XVHLQHP:HVHQ JHK|UW´'HVZHLWHUHQOlWVLFKQDFK.DQWQLFKWDOOJHPHLQJOWLJDQJHEHQ ZRULQ GLHVHU *OFNVEHJULII EHVWHKW XQG GLHVH 8QEHVWLPPWKHLW GHV *OFNVEHJULIIV ]LHKW HLQH ZHLWHUH 8QEHVWLPPWKHLW GHU 0LWWHO QDFK VLFK .DQW VWHOOW VFKOLHOLFK IHVW ÅGD GLH $XIJDEH VLFKHU XQG DOOJHPHLQ ]X EHVWLPPHQ ZHOFKH +DQGOXQJ GLH *OFNVHOLJNHLW HLQHV YHUQQIWLJHQ :H
_____________
UXQJ PLW 9DULDEOHQ GDU YJO ,9 'LH 6FK|QHFNHU:RRG)RUPHO XQWHUVFKHLGHW VLFKLQJHZLVVHU+LQVLFKWYRQGHUMHQLJHQ+LOOV Å,IDSHUVRQZLOOVDQHQGDQGFHUWDLQ PHDQVDUHQHFHVVDU\WRDFKLHYHWKDWHQGDQGDUHZLWKLQKLVSRZHUWKHQKHRXJKWWRZLOO WKRVHPHDQV´ +LOO 'LHYRQPLUYRUJHQRPPHQH+HUYRUKHEXQJLQGLHVHP =LWDW]HLJWGLH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGLHVHU$EVWUDNWLRQXQGGHUYRUVWHKHQGHQGLHYRQ .DQW YJO,9 VHOEVWQDKHJHOHJWZLUG9RQGHU8QP|JOLFKNHLWHLQHUDOOJHPHLQHQ )RUPHOK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHJHKWGDJHJHQ/XGZLJ DXVREZRKOVLFK DXFKQDFK/XGZLJV$XVIKUXQJHQHLQHDOOJHPHLQH)RUPHOQDKHOHJW Å:HUKDQGHOWLVW JHQ|WLJWVLFK]ZLVFKHQ(LQVDW]GHVDOVQRWZHQGLJHUNDQQWHQ0LWWHOV>0@XQG9HU]LFKW DXIGLH5HDOLVLHUXQJGHV=ZHFNV>=@]XHQWVFKHLGHQ´ /XGZLJ $QP 9JO.DQW,9 9JO.DQW,9 9JO.DQW,9 9JO.DQW,9 9JO.DQW,9 .DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
VHQVEHI|UGHUQZHUGHY|OOLJXQDXIO|VOLFKPLWKLQNHLQ,PSHUDWLYLQ$QVH KXQJGHUVHOEHQP|JOLFKVHL>@´ )UGLHJHJHQZlUWLJH7KHPDWLNLVWVWDWWGLHVHU'LIIHUHQ]HLQH*HPHLQ VDPNHLW]ZLVFKHQGHQEHLGHQP|JOLFKHQ)RUPHQK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUD WLYHEHGHXWVDP LP*HJHQVDW]]XPNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYGHUHLQÅV\Q WKHWLVFKSUDNWLVFKHU 6DW] D SULRUL´ LVW EH]HLFKQHW .DQW VRZRKO GLH DVVHUWRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHGHU.OXJKHLWDOVDXFKGLHSUREOHPDWLVFKHQ,P SHUDWLYHGHU*HVFKLFNOLFKNHLWDOVÅDQDO\WLVFKSUDNWLVFKH´6lW]H3UDNWLVFK VLQG GLHVH 6lW]H LQVRIHUQ VLH GLH 9RUVFKULIW HLQHU +DQGOXQJ EHLQKDOWHQ DQDO\WLVFK VLQG VLH LQVRIHUQ VLH EOR GLH QRWZHQGLJHQ 0LWWHO ]X HLQHP YRUDXVJHVHW]WHQ=ZHFNEHWUHIIHQ'LHJHIRUGHUWH+DQGOXQJLVWDOVRDXVGHP =ZHFN DEOHLWEDU 'LHV VFKHLQW HLQH NODUH %HVWLPPXQJ ]X VHLQ XQG .DQW VWHOOW PLW %H]XJ DXI K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLYH XQG LQ $EVHW]XQJ YRP NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY ODSLGDU IHVW Å(V LVW DOVR LQ $QVHKXQJ GHU 0|J OLFKNHLW HLQHV VROFKHQ >VF K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ .3@ ,PSHUDWLYV DXFK NHLQH 6FKZLHULJNHLW´'RFKVFKHLQWGLHVQRFKNHLQHVZHJVDXVJHPDFKWZLHPDQ EHLQlKHUHU%HWUDFKWXQJGHU%HJUQGXQJIHVWVWHOOHQPX 'LH6FKZLHULJNHLWÅLQ$QVHKXQJGHU0|JOLFKNHLWHLQHVVROFKHQ,PSH UDWLYV´ ULFKWHW VLFK ]ZDU QLFKW DXI GDV SUDNWLVFKDQDO\WLVFKH 9HUKlOWQLV ]ZLVFKHQ GHP =ZHFN XQG GHQ QRWZHQGLJHQ 0LWWHOQ ² ZHU HLQHQ =ZHFN ZLOO PX GLH ]X GHVVHQ (UUHLFKHQ QRWZHQGLJHQ 0LWWHO HUJUHLIHQ VRQVW HUUHLFKWHUVHLQHQ=ZHFNHEHQQLFKW$EHUPLWGHU&KDUDNWHULVLHUXQJHLQHV 6DW]HV DOV DQDO\WLVFK VFKHLQW VHLQH LPSHUDWLYH )RUP XQYHUHLQEDU ]X VHLQ 8QGGLHVHLPSHUDWLYH)RUPLVW²MHQVHLWVUHLQIRUPDOVSUDFKOLFKHUhEHUOH JXQJHQ²GDVMHQLJHZDVGLH)UDJHQDFKGHU0|JOLFKNHLWMHJOLFKHU,PSHUDWLYH DXVPDFKW .DQW EHWRQW QlPOLFK Å'LHVH )UDJH YHUODQJW QLFKW ]X ZLVVHQ ZLHGLH9ROO]LHKXQJGHU+DQGOXQJZHOFKHGHU,PSHUDWLYJHELHWHWVRQGHUQ ZLH EOR GLH 1|WKLJXQJ GHV:LOOHQV GLH GHU ,PSHUDWLY LQ GHU $XIJDEH DXV GUFNW JHGDFKW ZHUGHQ N|QQH´ (U VWHOOW GLHVH )UDJH QXQ QLFKW ² ZLH
_____________ .DQW,9 .DQW,9 9JO.DQW,9 .DQW,9 .DQWKDQGHOWDQGLHVHU6WHOOHHLJHQWOLFKQXUYRPSUXGHQWLHOOHQ,PSHUD WLYVHW]WGLHVHQDEHUJOHLFK]HLWLJDXIGLHVHOEH6WXIHZLHGHQLQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ6WHLJOHGHU DUEHLWHWLQHLQHULQVWUXNWLYHQXQGWH[WQDKHQ$QDO\VHHLQHP|JOLFKH5HOD WLRQ ]ZLVFKHQ ÅWHFKQLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYHQ´ XQG Å5DWVFKOlJHQ GHU .OXJKHLW´ KHUDXV ZREHLHUGHUHQK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ SUREOHPDWLVFKHQ UHVSHNWLYHDVVHUWRULVFKHQ&KDUDNWHU DOV HQWVFKHLGHQGH ,QWHUSUHWDPHQWH EHKDQGHOW 9JO ]X 6WHLJOHGHUV $UJXPHQWDWLRQ ]X K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHQLP6LQQHHLQHU5DWLRQDOLWlWVIRUGHUXQJHEGII ,9 +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
%HGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
PDQ YLHOOHLFKW HUZDUWHQ N|QQWH ² QXU IU GHQ NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY VRQGHUQ HEHQ H[SOL]LW DXFK IU GLH K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH (U IUDJW QDFKGHU0|JOLFKNHLWGHU:LOOHQVQ|WLJXQJGXUFKHLQHQVROFKHQK\SRWKHWL VFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY 'RFK VHLQH $QWZRUW VFKHLQW DXI GHQ HUVWHQ %OLFN YHU EOIIHQGGHQQHUJLEWDOV%HJUQGXQJGHV6ROOHQVHLQHQGHVNULSWLYHQ6DW] DQGHQHUVHOEVWZLHGHUXPDOVDQDO\WLVFKFKDUDNWHULVLHUW Å:HUGHQ=ZHFN ZLOO ZLOO VR IHUQ GLH 9HUQXQIW DXI VHLQH +DQGOXQJHQ HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOXKDW DXFKGDVGD]XXQHQWEHKUOLFKQRWKZHQGLJH0LWWHOGDVLQVHL QHU*HZDOWLVW'LHVHU6DW]LVWZDVGDV:ROOHQEHWULIIWDQDO\WLVFK GHQQLQ GHP:ROOHQHLQHV2EMHFWVDOVPHLQHU:LUNXQJZLUGVFKRQPHLQH&DXVDOL WlWDOVKDQGHOQGH8UVDFKHGLGHU*HEUDXFKGHU0LWWHOJHGDFKWXQGGHU ,PSHUDWLY]LHKWGHQ%HJULIIQRWKZHQGLJHU+DQGOXQJHQ]XGLHVHP=ZHFNH VFKRQ DXV GHP %HJULII HLQHV :ROOHQV GLHVHV =ZHFNV KHUDXV >@´ 'LH
_____________ 9JOGD]XLQGHU*UXQGOHJXQJ,9 GLH9RUDUEHLW]XGHQ3UROHJRPHQD6FKHIIQHU 1DFKOD ;;,,, VRZLH PHLQH (LQOHLWXQJ ]XU 1HX(GLWLRQ YRQ .DQWV 3UROHJRPHQD +DPEXUJ 0HLQHU [LI 'DPDQKLHUDXFKLQ.DQWV6LQQHYRQHLQHP6DW]QLFKWQXUYRQHLQHP8UWHLOVSUH FKHQNDQQEHVWlWLJHQ$XVVDJHQGLHLQGHU-lVFKH/RJLNGRNXPHQWLHUWVLQG Å,P8UWKHL OHZLUGGDV9HUKlOWQLYHUVFKLHGHQHU9RUVWHOOXQJHQ]XU(LQKHLWGHV%HZXWVHLQVEOR DOVSUREOHPDWLVFKJHGDFKWLQHLQHP6DW]HKLQJHJHQDOVDVVHUWRULVFK(LQSUREOHPDWL VFKHU 6DW] LVW HLQH FRQWUDGLFWLR LQ DGMHFWR (KH LFK HLQHQ 6DW] KDEH PX LFK GRFK HUVW XUWKHLOHQ XQGLFKXUWKHLOHEHUYLHOHVZDVLFKQLFKWDXVPDFKHZHOFKHVLFKDEHUWKXQ PXVREDOGLFKHLQ8UWKHLODOV6DW]EHVWLPPH´ .DQW,; .DQW,9²'HUOHW]WH6DW]GLHVHV=LWDWVJLOWPXWDWLVPXWDQGLVDXFKIUGDV6LW WHQJHVHW] $XFK GDV 6LWWHQJHVHW] LVW HLQ DQDO\WLVFKHU 6DW] ² DOOHUGLQJV QXU IU HLQHQ SUREOHPDWLVFKHQ ÅKHLOLJHQ :LOOHQ´ LFK ZHUGH GDUDXI LQ ]XUFNNRPPHQ ² %URRPHKDWKLQVLFKWOLFKGHU5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHOLPHUVWHQ6DW]GHVRELJHQ=LWDWVGDU DXIDXIPHUNVDPJHPDFKWGDGLH0LWWHOHUVWHQVDXIVROFKHUHVWULQJLHUWVLQGGLHYRQ GHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQDOVQRWZHQGLJJHZXWVLQGXQGGDGLH0LWWHO]ZHLWHQVQRUPD OHUZHLVH QLFKW ÄXQHQWEHKUOLFK QRWZHQGLJ¶ ]XU 5HDOLVLHUXQJ GHV =ZHFNHV VHLQ PVVHQ Å5DWLRQDOLW\UHTXLUHVRI1WKDWLI1LQWHQGVWKDWHDQGLI1EHOLHYHVWKDWHZLOOQRWEH VRXQOHVVPLVVRDQGLI1EHOLHYHVPZLOOQRWEHVRXQOHVVVKHLQWHQGVWKDWPWKHQ1 LQWHQGVWKDWP>«@7KLVLVDZLGHSULQFLSOHRILQVWUXPHQWDOUDWLRQDOLW\,WLQFRUSRUDWHV DUHQGHULQJRI.DQW·VUHPDUN :KRZLOOVWKHHQGZLOOV VRIDUDVUHDVRQKDVDGHFLVLYH LQIOXHQFHRQKLVDFWLRQV DOVRWKHPHDQVZKLFKDUHLQGLVSHQVDEO\QHFHVVDU\DQGLQKLV SRZHU>«@.DQWPDGHDVOLJKWHUURU KHVKRXOGKDYHVDLGÄ«WKHPHDQVKHEHOLHYHVWR EHLQGLVSHQVDEO\QHFHVVDU\«¶DQGWKDWLVFRUUHFWHGLQP\IRUPXOD0RUHLPSRUWDQWO\ P\IRUPXODGRHVQRWDSSO\RQO\WRPHDQV\RXEHOLHYHDUHLQGLVSHQVDEO\QHFHVVDU\,ILW GLG LW ZRXOG UDUHO\ KDYH PXFK DSSOLFDWLRQ @´ $XFK K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLYHÄJHELHWHQ¶DOVR
_____________ PLON XQOHVV \RX EX\ LW IURP D VKRS 7KHUHIRUH P\ IRUPXOD SUREDEO\ GRHV DSSO\ WR \RX>@%HFDXVH.DQWLPSRVHGWKHFRQGLWLRQWKDW \RXEHOLHYH²KHVKRXOGKDYHVDLG WKHPHDQVVKRXOGEHLQ\RXUSRZHUKHFRXOGKDYHGLVSHQVHGZLWKWKHFRQGLWLRQWKDW \RXEHOLHYH²KHVKRXOGKDYHVDLG LWLVLQGLVSHQVDEO\QHFHVVDU\7KDWLVZKDW,KDYH GRQH´ %URRPH 0V .DS Å5HTXLUHPHQWV RI UDWLRQDOLW\´ $XI GLH 1RWZHQ GLJNHLWGHU(UJUHLIXQJEHVWLPPWHU0LWWHOZHUGHLFKLPIROJHQGHQQLFKWZHLWHUHLQJHKHQ GLH(UNHQQWQLVDGlTXDWHU0LWWHOVSLHOWIUPHLQH'LVNXVVLRQNHLQH]HQWUDOH5ROOH:LFK WLJLVWIUPLFKDOOHLQGDGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQYRQGHU1RWZHQGLJNHLWHLQHVJHZLVVHQ 0LWWHOHLQVDW]HV]XU(UUHLFKXQJHLQHVJHVHW]WHQ=ZHFNHVZHLHJDOZLHYLHOHOHLVWXQJV lTXLYDOHQWH0LWWHOQXQ]XU$XVZDKOVWHKHQXQGZHOFKHV0LWWHOOHW]WOLFK]XP(LQVDW] NRPPW 9JOGD]XEHUHLWV&UDPHU =ZHL ZHLWHUH )RUPXOLHUXQJHQ ILQGHQ VLFK QXU ZHQLJH =HLOHQ QDFK GHU EHUHLWV DQJH IKUWHQ LQ HEHQ GLHVHP Å=ZHLWHQ $EVFKQLWW´ GHU *UXQGOHJXQJ ,9 YJO GD]X DXFK6FK|QHFNHU:RRG .DQW,9 YJODXFK,9XQGLQGHU.S9 Å'LH,PSHUDWLYHQVHOEHUDEHUZHQQ VLH EHGLQJW VLQG G L QLFKW GHQ :LOOHQ VFKOHFKWKLQ DOV :LOOHQ VRQGHUQ QXU LQ $QVH KXQJHLQHUEHJHKUWHQ:LUNXQJEHVWLPPHQGLK\SRWKHWLVFKH,PSHUDWLYHQVLQGVLQG >@ SUDNWLVFKH 9RUVFKULIWHQ >@´ .DQW 9 +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 9JO GD]X DXFK 0RUDOSKLORVRSKLH&ROOLQV;;9,,VRZLH0RUDO0URQJRYLXV;;9,, ,P $QVFKOX DQ &UDPHU KDW 6WDHJH GDUDXI KLQJHZLHVHQ GD GDV =ZHFN 0LWWHO3ULQ]LS XQG PLW LKP GHU K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLY VWHWV LQ GHU HUVWHQ 3HUVRQ 6LQJXODUIRUPXOLHUEDUVHLQPVVHQ Å'DGHUPLWHLQHP7RNHQGHV6DW]HVÄ'XZLOOVW=¶ $QJHUHGHWH GHQ 6LQQ GLHVHV 6DW]HV GXUFK HLQ 7RNHQ GHV 6DW]HV Ä,FK ZLOO =¶ DXIIDVVW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
%HGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
'DV ,QWHUHVVH DQ GHU QRUPDWLYHQ .UDIW DQDO\WLVFKSUDNWLVFKHU 6lW]H XQGGDPLWDQGHU8PZDQGOXQJGHV=ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LSVLQHLQHQK\SR WKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYOlWVLFKGDPLWZHLWHUVSH]LIL]LHUHQ:DVLVWGLH'LI IHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ GHP DQDO\WLVFKHQ 8UWHLO Å:HU GHQ =ZHFN ZLOO ZLOO VR IHUQGLH9HUQXQIWDXIVHLQH+DQGOXQJHQHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ(LQIOXKDW DXFK GDV GD]X XQHQWEHKUOLFK QRWKZHQGLJH 0LWWHO GDV LQ VHLQHU *HZDOW LVW´ DXIGHUHLQHQ6HLWHXQGGHPK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLY LQHLQHUDOOJHPHL QHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJ DXIGHUDQGHUHQ ÅZHQQGXGHQ=ZHFNSZLOOVWXQGGDV GD]XQRWZHQGLJH0LWWHOTHUJUHLIHQNDQQVWVRHUJUHLIHT´" 'LH HQWVFKHLGHQGH 'LIIHUHQ] EH]LHKW VLFK DXI GLH 5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHO LQQHUKDOE GHV =ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LSV 'LHVH 5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHO GHU .ODPPHUDXVGUXFN LQ GHP DQDO\WLVFKHQ =ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LS LVW YHUDQW ZRUWOLFKIUGLH8PZDQGOXQJGHVDQDO\WLVFKHQ8UWHLOVLQHLQHQ,PSHUDWLY'HU .ODPPHUDXVGUXFNÅ VRIHUQGLH9HUQXQIWDXIVHLQH+DQGOXQJHQHQWVFKHL GHQGHQ (LQIOX KDW ´ LVW GDVMHQLJH ZDV VLFK DOOHLQ LP =ZHFN0LWWHO 3ULQ]LS XQG QLFKW LP K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY ILQGHW 'LH DQGHUHQ %H VWLPPXQJHQGHV=ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LSV²GLHEHLGHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQGHV JHJHEHQHQ =ZHFNV XQG GHU %HKHUUVFKXQJ HUIRUGHUOLFKHU 0LWWHO ² JHKHQ XQYHUlQGHUW LQ GLH LPSHUDWLYH )RUPXOLHUXQJ HLQ 'LH 5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHO HQWKlOW VRPLW GHQ *UXQG IU GHQ hEHUJDQJ YRP DQDO\WLVFKHQ =ZHFN 0LWWHO3ULQ]LS ]X GHU 1|WLJXQJ GHV :LOOHQV DQJHVLFKWV HLQHV JHJHEHQHQ =ZHFNVGLHIUGHVVHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJHUIRUGHUOLFKHQ0LWWHO]XHUJUHLIHQ,Q GLHVHU5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHOEHILQGHWVLFKGHPQDFKGLH4XHOOHGHU1RUPDWL YLWlWK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYH,KU$XIJHKHQLP,PSHUDWLYOlWVLFKSUl VNULSWLYXQGDOOJHPHLQVRXPIRUPXOLHUHQ ÅJHVWDWWHGHU9HUQXQIWHQWVFKHL GHQGHQ (LQIOX DXI GHLQH +DQGOXQJ´ 'LHVH $XIIRUGHUXQJ OLHJW V\VWHPDWLVFK HLQH (EHQH XQWHU GHQK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHQ (UVW GLH 9HUNQSIXQJ GLHVHU $XIIRUGHUXQJ PLW GHU =ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQ QXQ RKQH GLH 5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHO HUJLEW HLQHQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY G K HLQH $XIIRUGHUXQJ GDV =ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LS ]X UHDOLVLHUHQ 'LH HQWVSUH FKHQGH5HIRUPXOLHUXQJGHVK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVODXWHWDOVR DXVGHU 3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHUGULWWHQ3HUVRQ (LQH3HUVRQGLH L LPVWDQGHLVW=ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQHQ]XHUNHQQHQ LL HLQ*HERWHUODVVHQXQG LLL GLHVHVDXFKVHOEVWEHIROJHQNDQQ
_____________ ZLUGGHUPLWHLQHPK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLY$QJHUHGHWH]XP$GUHVVDWHQGHV,PSH UDWLYV ZHQQ HU GHQ 6DW] Ä,FK ZLOO =¶ EHKDXSWHW 'HU ,PSHUDWLY ULFKWHW VLFK QLFKW DQ GHQ GHU = ZLOO VRQGHUQ DQ GHQ GHU VLFK GDV 3UlGLNDW ÄZLOO =¶ ]XVFKUHLEW´ 6WDHJH .DQWV7H[WHIRUGHUQGLHVHUHVWULNWLYH/HVDUW]ZDUQLFKWH[SOL]LWVWHKHQLKU DEHUZLHGLHHEHQ]LWLHUWH3DVVDJHLQ.DQW,9]HLJWDXFKQLFKWLP:HJ .DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
JHELHWHWVLFKZHQQVLHVLFKHLQHQ=ZHFNJHVHW]WKDWLSVRIDFWRGHQ(LQ VDW]YRQ0LWWHOQGLHVLHIU]ZHFNGLHQOLFKKlOW,QGHU.DQWLVFKHQ)RU PXOLHUXQJGHV=ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LSV]LHOWGLH5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHODXIGLH 5HDOLVLHUXQJRGHU8PVHW]XQJYRQ L LL XQG LLL -HDQ+DPSWRQKDWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJ]X5HFKWGDUDXIKLQJH ZLHVHQ GD GLH 1RUPDWLYLWlW K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH QLFKW DXI GLH LQ GHP =ZHFN RGHU =LHO HQWKDOWHQHQ 3UlIHUHQ]HQ UHGX]LHUW ZHUGHQ NDQQ Å>«@DFDUHIXOORRNDWKLVDFFRXQWRIWKHIRUFHRIK\SRWKHWLFDOLPSHUDWLYHV VKRZVKH>VF.DQW .3@EHOLHYHVWKDWZHDUHPRWLYDWHGWRIROORZWKHP QRWE\WKHGHVLUHVDVVXPHGE\VXFKLPSHUDWLYHVEXWE\UHDVRQ²WKDWLVE\ WKH LQVWUXPHQWDO DQG QRW WKH PRUDO FRPSRQHQW RI UHDVRQµ 8QG KLQ VLFKWOLFK GHV &KDUDNWHUV GLHVHU $XWRULWlW GHU 9HUQXQIW IlKUW VLH IRUW Å$ K\SRWKHWLFDOLPSHUDWLYHLVDQRUPWKDWJHQHUDWHVDUHDVRQIRUDQDJHQWWR SXUVXH DQ LQVWUXPHQWDOO\ HIILFDFLRXV DFWLRQ ZKRVH DXWKRULW\ RYHU WKH DJHQWLVREMHFWLYH VKHPXVWIROORZWKLVGLUHFWLYHRUHOVHEHFRQGHPQHGDV LUUDWLRQDO :KHQDUDWLRQDODJHQWDFWVRQDK\SRWKHWLFDOLPSHUDWLYHVKHLV QRWPRWLYDWHGWRGRVRE\WKHGHVLUHDVVXPHGLQWKHLPSHUDWLYHEXWE\WKH DXWKRULW\ RI WKH LPSHUDWLYH >«@ VR WKDW WKH LPSHUDWLYH LV PRWLYDWLRQDOO\ HIILFDFLRXVE\YLUWXHRILWVDXWKRULW\µ1LFKWGHU=ZHFNQ|WLJWGLHKDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ ]XU (UJUHLIXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQGHU 0LWWHO 9LHOPHKU EH]LHKW VLFK GLH 1RUPDWLYLWlW K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH DXI GLH .RKlUHQ] GHU =ZHFN 0LWWHO5HODWLRQ LQVJHVDPW ZHOFKH GDGXUFK HLQJHO|VW ZHUGHQ NDQQ GD HQWZHGHUGLH0LWWHOHUJULIIHQZHUGHQRGHUGHU=ZHFNIDOOHQJHODVVHQZLUG
_____________ 9JOREHQ)Q]XU'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGLHVHUXQGGHU.DQWLVFKHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJ +DPSWRQ +DPSWRQ I+DPSWRQV6LFKWZHLVHNDQQDOVHLQH7UDQVIRUPDWLRQYRQ+HQU\ $OOLVRQV VRJHQDQQWHU ¶LQFRUSRUDWLRQ WKHVLV· YRP %HUHLFK GHU 0RUDO ]X GHP GHV LQ VWUXPHQWHOOHQ+DQGHOQVDXIJHIDWZHUGHQ YJOGD]X$OOLVRQ VRZLH+LOO XQG5HDWK /HW]WHUHUKDQGHOWHEHQIDOOVYRQHL QHP GHUDUWLJHQ hEHUJDQJ VWHKW GDEHL MHGRFK LQ GHU *HIDKU HLQHU $VVLPLOLHUXQJ GHU EHLGHQ .DQWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY)RUPHQ GLHVH VROO LP )ROJHQGHQ XPJDQJHQ ZHUGHQ (LQHlKQOLFKH6LFKWZHLVHZLH+DPSWRQVFKHLQWDXFK'DUZDOO]XKDEHQZHQQHUIHVW VWHOOW Å7KHLGHDEHKLQGWKHK\SRWKHWLFDOLPSHUDWLYHLV>@WKDWWKHIRUFHRIUHDVRQVLV DVLWZHUHWUDQVIHUUHGEDFNDQGIRUWKDORQJWKHOLQHFRQQHFWLQJDQHQGDQGLWVQHFHV VDU\PHDQV>@,IWKHUHDUHQRUHDVRQVWRLQWHQGWRGR$WKHQWKHUHLVQRWKLQJWREH WUDQVIHUUHGWRWKHLQWHQWLRQWRWDNHWKHQHFHVVDU\PHDQVWR$µ 'DUZDOO I 9JO]XPKLHUDXIWUHWHQGHQ3UREOHPGHVÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶DXFK)QVRZLHGHQGD]X JHK|ULJHQ $EVDW] ,P /LFKWH %URRPHV 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ *UQGHQ XQG QRU PDWLYHQ (UIRUGHUQLVVHQ HUVFKHLQW 'DUZDOOV %HVFKUHLEXQJ MHGRFK ZHVHQWOLFK XQWHU NRPSOH[ YJOXQWHQ .DQWVHOEVWKlOWEHUHLWVIHVWGDÅ>«@ZDVEOR]XU(UUHLFKXQJHLQHUEHOLHELJHQ$E VLFKW ]X WKXQ QRWKZHQGLJ LVW DQ VLFK DOV ]XIlOOLJ EHWUDFKWHW ZHUGHQ NDQQ >XQG@ ZLU YRQGHU9RUVFKULIWMHGHU]HLWORVVHLQN|QQHQZHQQZLUGLH$EVLFKWDXIJHEHQ´ .DQW ,9 9JO ]X HLQHU QRUPDWLYHQ ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ GHV QLFKWPRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGHOQV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
%HGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
'LHVHV9HUKlOWQLVYRQ1RUPDWLYLWlWXQG9HUQXQIWLVWYRQIXQGDPHQWDOHU %HGHXWXQJ GHQQ ZLH +DPSWRQ KHUDXVJHVWULFKHQ KDW ZRKQW QDFK .DQW 1HLJXQJHQ DOV VROFKHQ NHLQH ² DXFK QLFKW LQVWUXPHQWHOOH ² 1RUPDWLYLWlW LQQH 'HU ÄHQWVFKHLGHQGH (LQIOX GHU 9HUQXQIW¶ JHKWGDUDXI GHP SUDNWL VFKHQ .RQGLWLRQDO LQVJHVDPW JHUHFKW ]X ZHUGHQ 2GHU HWZDV IRUPDOHU DXVJHGUFNW GLH .RQNOXVLRQ GHV SUDNWLVFKHQ .RQGLWLRQDOV NDQQ QLFKW PLWWHOVPRGXVSRQHQVDEJHWUHQQWZHUGHQHLQH%HVWLPPXQJDXIGLHLFKLQ QRFKHLQPDO]XUFNNRPPHQZHUGH .DQW ]HLJW VLFK GDPLW² LP*HJHQVDW] ]X +XPH GHUGDYRQ DXVJHKW GD GLH QRUPDWLYH $XWRULWlW GLH =ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQHQ HQWIDOWHQ N|Q QHQ OHGLJOLFK GHQ EHWHLOLJWHQ :QVFKHQ XQG QLFKW GHU 9HUQXQIW HQW VWDPPW ² HLQHV 3UREOHPV EHZXW GDV 0LFKDHO %UDWPDQ PLW GHP $XV GUXFNÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶EH]HLFKQHWKDW (VEHVWHKWLQHLQHP0LYHUVWlQGQLV GHU ORJLVFKHQ 5HLFKZHLWH GHV 6ROOHQV GDV EHL JHJHEHQHP =ZHFN GLH (U JUHLIXQJGHUHUIRUGHUOLFKHQ0LWWHOJHELHWHW'DV$XVELOGHQHLQHVEHVWLPP WHQ +DQGOXQJV]ZHFNV DOV VROFKHV YHUOHLKW GHU (UJUHLIXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQG HIIHNWLYHU0LWWHOQLFKWSHUVHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWVRQVWN|QQWHEHUGLH$Q JHPHVVHQKHLWHLQHUVROFKHQ0LWWHOHUJUHLIXQJQLFKWPHKUVLQQYROOGLVNXWLHUW ZHUGHQMHGHUIDNWLVFKH=ZHFNVFKIHGDQQHLQHQXUGXUFKQRFKÄVWlUNHUH¶ :QVFKH DQWDVWEDUH 1RUPDWLYLWlW XQG JHQDX GDULQ EHVWQGH GDV ÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶ ,Q HLQHP %HLVSLHO GLH YRQ HLQHU 3HUVRQ DOV ZHUWYROO EH WUDFKWHWH+DQGOXQJMHPDQGHQ]XW|WHQZUGHDXWRPDWLVFKDXFKGDV.DX IHQHLQHU:DIIH]XHLQHUZHUWYROOHQ+DQGOXQJPDFKHQ'LHVLVWDEHURI IHQNXQGLJ QLFKW SHU VH GHU )DOO PDQ NDQQ GXUFKDXV XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU $QVLFKWEHUGHQ:HUWHLQHVVROFKHQ.DXIHVVHLQ'LHVHVÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶ GDV $XVVWDWWHQ EHOLHELJHU +DQGOXQJHQ PLW HLQHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW NDQQ QXQ HEHQGXUFKHLQH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ]ZLVFKHQHLQHPÄHQJHQ6ROOHQ¶GDVVLFK DXIGLH(UJUHLIXQJ]ZHFNEHGLQJWHU0LWWHOEH]LHKWXQGHLQHPÄZHLWHQ6RO OHQ¶GDVVLFKDXIGLH=ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQDOVJDQ]HEH]LHKWYHUKLQGHUW ZHUGHQ $XV GHU 3HUVSHNWLYH HLQHU GULWWHQ 3HUVRQ OlW VLFK GDKHU VDJHQ :HGHU VROO GLHVH 3HUVRQ RGHU DQGHUH 3HUVRQHQ GLH GHQVHOEHQ :XQVFK YHUVSUHQ GLH:DIIHNDXIHQQRFKKDWGLHVH3HUVRQ RGHUDQGHUH3HUVR QHQ GLH GHQVHOEHQ :XQVFK YHUVSUHQ HLQHQ *UXQG GLH :DIIH ]X NDX IHQ:DVYLHOPHKUJLOWLVWGDGLH3HUVRQDXIJUXQGLKUHU)HVWOHJXQJDXI GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGH (LQVWHOOXQJ DXFK DXI GLH (UJUHLIXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQGHU 0LWWHOIHVWJHOHJWLVWGDV6ROOHQVHOEVWDOVRHLQNRQGLWLRQDOHVXQGGHU,PSH
_____________ QDFK.DQWDXFK5HDWKGRFKXQWHUVFKHLGHWHUQLFKW]ZLVFKHQGHQZHVHQW OLFKYHUVFKLHGHQHQ)RUPHQYRQ%HJUQGXQJ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ MXVWLILFDWLRQ LPK\SRWKH WLVFKHQE]ZLPPRUDOLVFKHQ.RQWH[W 9JOGD]XEHUHLWV:DWVRQ 9JOXQWHQ]XU8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQ6ROOHQXQG*UQGHUHODWLRQHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
UDWLY HLQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHU LVW (LQH VROFKH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ ÄHQ JHP¶XQGÄZHLWHP6ROOHQ¶LVWXQWHUGHUDOOHLQLJHQ$XWRULWlWYRQ%HGUIQLV VHQ :QVFKHQ RGHU 1HLJXQJHQ QLFKW ]X HUIDVVHQ OHW]WHUH VLQG OHGLJOLFK LQVWDQWDQH$QWULHEH]XP+DQGHOQ 0LW GHP *HERW GHU (UJUHLIXQJ GHU IU GHQ DQJHVWUHEWHQ =ZHFN DOV QRWZHQGLJ HUNDQQWHQ 0LWWHO LVW QDWUOLFK HLQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHV +DQGHOQ
_____________ 9JO]XU(UOlXWHUXQJGHVÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶%UDWPDQ ZREHL%UDWPDQ RIIHQOlW ZHVKDOE GLH XUVSUQJOLFKH $EVLFKW LUUDWLRQDO LVW G K NHLQH $XVVDJH ]XU 'RPLQDQ] EHLVSLHOVZHLVH PRUDOLVFKHU hEHUOHJXQJHQ PDFKW ,Q VHLQHP %HLVSLHO HQW VFKHLGHW VLFK GHU 3UlVLGHQWVFKDIWVNDQGLGDW 0RQGDOH LQ HLQHU :DKONDPSIGHEDWWH PLW VHLQHP.RQWUDKHQWHQ5HDJDQIUGLHLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJVLQQYROOVWHYRQGUHL )UDJHQ ]XP 5DNHWHQDEZHKUV\VWHP 6', DQ 5HDJDQ REZRKO HU ]XYRU GLH SROLWLVFKH 8QNOXJKHLWGLHVHV7KHPDEHUKDXSWDQ]XVFKQHLGHQEHUHLWV HLQJHVHKHQKDW)ROJHQ GH GHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlWVUDKPHQ HUZHLWHUQGH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ QLPPW %UDWPDQ GDEHL VFKOLHOLFKYRU Å:HPD\SXWWKHSRLQWLQWHUPVRIDGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQWZRNLQGVRI RXJKWMXGJPHQWV,QKLVGHOLEHUDWLRQ0RQGDOHDLPVDWUHDFKLQJDMXGJPHQWRIZKDWKH RXJKWRQEDODQFHWRGR²ZKHUHWKLVRXJKWMXGJPHQWLVWREHPDGHIURPWKHLQWHUQDO SODQFRQVWUDLQHG SHUVSHFWLYH RI KLV GHOLEHUDWLRQ &DOO WKLV DQ LQWHUQDORXJKW MXGJPHQW )URP WKH H[WHUQDO SRLQW RI YLHZ RI QRQSODQFRQVWUDLQHG UDWLRQDOLW\ ZH VHHN DQ RQ EDODQFH H[WHUQDORXJKW MXGJPHQW $OWKRXJK ERWK RXJKW MXGJPHQWV DUH UHODWLYL]HG WR 0RQGDOH·V DWWLWXGHV 0RQGDOH·V SULRU LQWHQWLRQV DQG SODQV SOD\ D GLUHFW UROH ZLWK UH VSHFWWRWKHIRUPHUEXWQRWWKHODWWHU:HVKRXOGQRWVXSSRVHWKDWHLWKHURXJKWMXGJ PHQWLVPRUHREMHFWLYHWKDQWKHRWKHU%RWKFRQFHUQDUHODWLRQEHWZHHQDW\SHRIDF WLRQ DQG FHUWDLQ DWWLWXGHV RI WKH DJHQW·V 1RU VKRXOG ZH VXSSRVH WKDW RQH JHQHUDOO\ WDNHV SUHFHGHQFH RYHU WKH RWKHU 5DWKHU HDFK KDV LWV GLVWLQFWLYH UROH WR SOD\ LQ RXU FRPSOH[ SUDFWLFHV RI GHOLEHUDWLRQ DQG UDWLRQDO DVVHVVPHQW ,QWHUQDORXJKWMXGJPHQWV ZLOOEHFHQWUDOWRGHOLEHUDWLRQ ZKLOHWKHDYDLODELOLW\RIH[WHUQDORXJKWMXGJPHQWVLVRQH SDUWRIRXUVROXWLRQWRSUREOHPVDERXWERRWVWUDSSLQJ´ (EG %UDWPDQV'LIIHUHQ ]LHUXQJ QRUPDWLYHU $VSHNWH LQ LQWHUQH XQG H[WHUQH 5DWLRQDOLWlWVQRUPHQ RGHU VWDQ GDUGV VFKDIIW HLQHQ %H]XJVUDKPHQ LQQHUKDOE GHVVHQ GDV SKLORVRSKLVFK LQDN]HSWDEOH 3UREOHPGHVÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶YHUPLHGHQZHUGHQNDQQ LQDN]HSWDEHOGHVKDOEZHLOMHGH (QWVFKHLGXQJ DOV UDWLRQDO DXVJHZLHVHQ RGHU ZHQLJVWHQV QLFKW DOV LUUDWLRQDO NULWLVLHUW ZHUGHQNDQQZHQQHLQHIUKHUHLUUDWLRQDOH(QWVFKHLGXQJ*UQGHGDIUOLHIHUQNDQQ HLQH VSlWHUH (QWVFKHLGXQJ LP /LFKW GHU IUKHUHQ DOV UDWLRQDO HUVFKHLQHQ ]X ODVVHQ 5D] I EHWRQW GLH QRWZHQGLJH *WH HLQHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV XP EHUKDXSW (OHPHQWHLQHUJOWLJHQSUDNWLVFKHQ,QIHUHQ]]XVHLQ Å&UXFLDOO\WKHZD\JRDOVDFTXLUH WKHLUQRUPDWLYHUHOHYDQFHLVE\EHLQJFRQGLWLRQVRQWKHDSSOLFDELOLW\RUVWULQJHQF\RI UHDVRQV7KHUHIRUHWKH\FDQKDYHWKDWHIIHFWRQO\LIWKHJRDOVDUHZRUWKSXUVXLQJLQ WKHILUVWSODFH>@,W>VFP\DFFRXQW@FRPELQHVWZRHOHPHQWV WKHQRUPDWLYHLPSDFW RIDSRWHQWLDOJRDOGHSHQGV D RQLWVEHLQJZRUWKZKLOHWKDWLVRQWKHUHEHLQJUHDVRQV WRDGRSWWKHJRDODQG E RQWKHFRQWLQJHQWIDFWWKDWLWLVDFWXDOO\WKHDJHQW·VJRDO,I HLWKHULVPLVVLQJWKHQWKHFRQGLWLRQDOUHDVRQGRHVQRWDSSO\´'LHYRUOLHJHQGH.RQ ]HSWLRQIROJWMHGRFKQLFKW5D]·5HDOLVPXVEH]JOLFK+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ YJOGD]XXQ WHQ 9JO ]XP 3UREOHP GHV ÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶ DXFK 6FDQORQ I %URRPH E XQG+ROWRQ VRZLHDXI.ULWLNHUUHDJLHUHQG%UDW PDQ 0V YJO%URRPHXQG0V]XPEHJULIIOLFKHQ*HJHQVDW]ÄHQ JHVZHLWHV6ROOHQ¶
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
%HGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
QRFKQLFKWJDUDQWLHUWGDV3KlQRPHQGHU:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHDOVRQLFKWDXV JHVFKORVVHQ'RFKVRZRKOGLH$QDO\WL]LWlWK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHGLH Ä$EOHLWEDUNHLW¶GHU0LWWHODXVGHP=ZHFNDOVDXFKGLH$XWRULWlWK\SRWKHWL VFKHU,PSHUDWLYHLKU5HNXUVDXIGLH+DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlWGHU9HUQXQIWLQ hEHUHLQVWLPPXQJ PLW XQVHUHQ NRQWLQJHQWHQ =ZHFNHQ VLQG GDPLW HU NOlUW (LQH $XIJDEH K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH LVW HV GHPQDFK ]X YHU KLQGHUQGDHLQDXIJUXQGHLQHVJHVHW]WHQ=ZHFNVEHVWHKHQGHU:LOOH]XP EORHQ :XQVFK GHJUDGLHUW ZLUG 'HQQ LP *HJHQVDW] ]X OHW]WHUHP KDW .DQW GLHVHQ :LOOHQ ÅDOV GLH $XIELHWXQJ DOOHU 0LWWHO´ FKDUDNWHULVLHUW ÅVR ZHLW VLH LQ XQVHUHU *HZDOW VLQG´ :LUG GLHVH $XIELHWXQJ HUIRUGHUOLFKHU 0LWWHOQLFKWJHOHLVWHWXQGJOHLFK]HLWLJDP=ZHFNIHVWJHKDOWHQVRKDQGHOWHV VLFKXPGDV3KlQRPHQGHU:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHJHJHQZHOFKHVLFKGLH$XWR ULWlWK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHJHUDGHZHQGHW
_____________ 9JOGD]X&UDPHU ÅÄ9HUQQIWLJNHLW¶GHVHPSLULVFKHQ:LOOHQVEHGHXWHWGD GLH 9RUVWHOOXQJ HLQHV 2EMHNWV XQG HLQHU HPSLULVFKHQ 5HJHO GLH HV DOV :LUNXQJ ]X EHVWLPPHQ HUODXEW ÄREMHNWLYHU %HVWLPPXQJVJUXQG¶ LVW´ 9JO LP 6LQQH GHU RELJHQ $QDO\VHDXFK6FK|QHFNHU:RRG Å(VJHK|UW>@]XU%HGHXWXQJGHV$NWHV VLFK HLQHQ =ZHFN ]X VHW]HQ GD PDQ VLFK GDPLW VHOEVW JHELHWHW DXFK GLH HQWVSUH FKHQGHQ0LWWHO]XZROOHQ'DVKHLWQLFKWGDPDQGLH0LWWHOZLOOZHQQPDQHLQHQ =ZHFNZLOO DEHUHVKHLWGDPDQGLH0LWWHOZROOHQVROO'HUK\SRWKHWLVFKH,PSHUD WLYLVWDOVRLQGHP6LQQHDQDO\WLVFKGDHLQQRUPDWLYHV3ULQ]LS²QlPOLFKGHUK\SR WKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLY VHOEVW ² PLW GHU $NWLYLWlW GHV =ZHFNHVHW]HQV YHUEXQGHQ LVW´ $XFK6FK|QHFNHU:RRGJHKHQDOVRGDYRQDXVGDQLFKWGLHLQGHQ=ZHFNHQHQWKDO WHQHQ3UlIHUHQ]HQVHOEVWVRQGHUQHLQHLJHQHVÄ*HELHWHQ¶GLH4XHOOHGHU1RUPDWLYLWlW GDUVWHOOW9JO]XUYRUVWHKHQGHQ,VRODWLRQGHVDXVGHU5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHOJHQHULHUWHQ QRUPDWLYHQ3ULQ]LSVDXFKGLH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ*HUKDUG6HHOVGHUPHLQHU%DVLVIRUPHO SUDNWLVFKHU 9RUVFKULIWHQ ÅJHVWDWWH GHU 9HUQXQIW HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOX DXI GHLQH +DQGOXQJ´ YHUJOHLFKEDU HLQ 3ULQ]LS Å6 ´ DXIVWHOOW Å(QGOLFKH YHUQQIWLJH :HVHQ VROOHQVLFKEHLLKUHU:LOOHQVELOGXQJYRQGHU9HUQXQIWEHVWLPPHQODVVHQ´ 6HHO (UIlKUWGD]XIRUW Å>@PLW+LOIHYRQ6OlWVLFKVRZRKOGHUNDWHJRULVFKHDOV DXFK GHU K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLY EHJUQGHQ 'LHV EHUHFKWLJW XQV ]X GHU $QQDKPH GD.DQWGLHVHV3ULQ]LSDN]HSWLHUWKlWWH>@hEHUGLH)UDJHZDUXP.DQWQLFKWVHOEVW DXIHLQVROFKHVREHUVWHV3ULQ]LSGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWYHUIDOOHQ LVWOlWVLFKQXU VSHNXOLHUHQ9HUPXWOLFKKlQJWGDVPLWGHUEHLLKPYRUKHUUVFKHQGHQ7HQGHQ]]XVDP PHQ GLH EHLGHQ %HUHLFKH GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW VFKDUI YRQ HLQDQGHU ]X WUHQQHQ XQGGLHWHFKQLVFKH9HUQXQIWJHJHQEHUGHUUHLQHQSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWDE]XZHUWHQ´ (EG $XI GLH GHU 5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHO LP =ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LS DQDORJH 3DUHQ WKHVHLP.RQWH[WGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVE]ZGHVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVXQGGDPLWGLH YRQ .DQW VHOEVW ZHQQJOHLFK HEHQ QXU SDUHQWKHWLVFK DQJHGHXWHWH 9HUNQSIXQJ GHU EHLGHQ,PSHUDWLYIRUPHQJHKW6HHOMHGRFKHEHQVRZHQLJHLQZLHDXIGLHLPIROJHQGHQ EHKDQGHOWHQ .RQVHTXHQ]HQ GLH GLHVH ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ IU GDV %HJULIIVYHUKlOWQLV YRQ +HWHURQRPLHXQG$XWRQRPLHKDW .DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
+HWHURQRPLHXQG$XWRQRPLH
*HPlGHUYRUVWHKHQGHQ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQYRQ.DQWV.RQ]HSWLRQK\SRWKH WLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH LVW GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW GHV 0HQVFKHQ XQYHUQQIWLJ ]X KDQGHOQLQGHPPDQGLH]XHLQHPVHOEVWJHVHW]WHQ=ZHFNEHGLQJWHQ0LWWHO QLFKWHUJUHLIWXQGGDPLWGHQ:LOOHQ]XPEORHQ:XQVFKGHJUDGLHUWPLW YHUDQWZRUWOLFKIUGLH0|JOLFKNHLWK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYH,QJHZLVVHU +LQVLFKW VWHKW GLHVH ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ GDPLW GHUMHQLJHQ +HUEHUW - 3DWRQV QDKHLQVRIHUQGLHVHULQGHU+HWHURQRPLHGHV0HQVFKHQGDVWKHRUHWLVFKH (UIRUGHUQLVK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHVLHKW $XFK 3DWRQ PDUJLQDOLVLHUW GLH DVVHUWRULVFKSUDJPDWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH GHU.OXJKHLWPLW%H]XJDXIGLH$QDO\WL]LWlWK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHXQG GLVNXWLHUW OHW]WHUH LP .RQWH[W SUREOHPDWLVFKWHFKQLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH GHU *HVFKLFNOLFKNHLW3DWRQV$XVJDQJVSXQNWLVWGHU6DW]ÅÄWRZLOOWKHHQGLVWR ZLOOWKHPHDQV¶´YRQGHPVRGDUIPDQLQWHUSROLHUHQNHLQ:HJ]XHLQHP ,PSHUDWLYZHOFKHPDXFKLPPHUIKUW.DQWHUZHLWHUWQDFK3DWRQGDKHU GLHVHQ 6DW] ]X GHP REHQ GLVNXWLHUWHQ =ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LS ÅÄ$Q\ UD WLRQDO DJHQW ZKR ZLOOV WKH HQG ZLOO QHFHVVDULO\ ² VR IDU DV UHDVRQ KDV D GHFLVLYH LQIOXHQFH RYHU KLV DFWLRQV ² ZLOO WKH PHDQV ZKLFK DUH LQ KLV SRZHU¶´ 'HU HQWVFKHLGHQGH 6FKULWW YRQ GLHVHP DQDO\WLVFKHQ 6DW] ]XP K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY EHVWHKW QXQ LQ GHU (UVHW]XQJ GHU 3DUHQWKHVH GXUFK GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGH $XIIRUGHUXQJVIRUPHO ÅÄ,I DQ\ UDWLRQDO DJHQW ZLOOVWKHHQGKHRXJKWWRZLOOWKHPHDQV¶´ 'HU *UXQG IU GDV 6ROOHQ GHU K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH OLHJW GHP QDFK LP P|JOLFKHQ $QWDJRQLVPXV ]ZLVFKHQ XQVHUHP UDWLRQDOHQ :ROOHQ XQG HLQHU GDYRQ DEZHLFKHQGHQ 1HLJXQJ ZHOFKH OHW]WHUH VLFK DOV KDQG OXQJVOHLWHQG GXUFKVHW]HQ NDQQ 3DWRQ IDW GLHV IROJHQGHUPDHQ ]XVDP PHQ Å3HUKDSV LW ZRXOG EH EHWWHU WR VD\ DW OHDVW ZKHUH WKH LQFOLQDWLRQ SUHYDLOVWKDWDUDWLRQDOYROLWLRQLVRYHUFRPHE\DOHVVUDWLRQDOYROLWLRQ,WLV WKH SRVVLELOLW\ RI VXFK GHIHDW WKDW JLYHV ULVH WR LPSHUDWLYHV DQG XQOHVV ERWKW\SHVRIYROLWLRQZHUHSUHVHQWLQXVRUDWOHDVWSRVVLEOHLQXVWKHUH ZRXOGEHQRLPSHUDWLYHV´
_____________
3DWRQ (EG (EG (EG &UDPHU I YHUIHKOW PHLQHV (UDFKWHQV EHL VHLQHU DXFK JHJHQ 3DWRQ JHULFKWHWHQ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGHUK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHGDV3KlQRPHQGHU:LOOHQV VFKZlFKHZHOFKHVYRUOLHJWZHQQHLQEHUHLWVJHVHW]WHU=ZHFNEHLEHKDOWHQZLUGRKQH MHGRFKGLHDOVQRWZHQGLJXQGP|JOLFKHUNDQQWHQ0LWWHO]XGHVVHQ(UUHLFKXQJ]XHU JUHLIHQ :LUN|QQHQ²VR]XVDJHQ ZLGHUEHVVHUHV :ROOHQ²HLQHPNRQVWDQWHQ=ZHFN ]XZLGHUKDQGHOQ V LP IROJHQGHQ .RUVJDDUGV %HLVSLHO GHU Ä3UXGHQFH¶ (LQH ZLOOHQV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
+HWHURQRPLHXQG$XWRQRPLH
'LH %HGURKXQJ XQVHUHV UDWLRQDOHQ :ROOHQV GXUFK GLH ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW YRQ 1HLJXQJHQ GLH VLFK GHP UDWLRQDOHQ :ROOHQ XQG GDPLW GHU +DQG OXQJVDEVLFKW JHPl GHU QDFK ZLH YRU DOV ULFKWLJ HLQJHVHKHQHQ =ZHFN 0LWWHO5HODWLRQ HQWJHJHQVWHOOHQN|QQHQLVWGHU*UXQGIUGLH:LOOHQVQ| WLJXQJLP.RQWH[WLQVWUXPHQWHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlW 'DGDPLWMHGRFKGLH$NWHQGHULQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ5DWLRQDOLWlWQLFKWEH UHLWVJHVFKORVVHQVLQGHUNHQQWPDQQXUZHQQPDQLP*HJHQVDW]]X3D WRQQLFKWGHU$XIIDVVXQJLVWGDGLHK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHLP.RQ WH[W SUDNWLVFKHU 3KLORVRSKLH OHW]WOLFK EHGHXWXQJVORV VLQG Å$OO KH >VF .DQW@LVGRLQJLVWRFOHDUWKHPRXWRIWKHZD\DQGVRJHWRQWRWKHPRUDO SUREOHP´ 3DWRQ NDQQ VLFK PLW GLHVHU %HPHUNXQJ ]ZDU DXI GLH VSlWHUH (QWZLFNOXQJ.DQWVEHUXIHQMDPDQNDQQJHJHQEHUHLQHUV\VWHPDWLVFKHQ $XIZHUWXQJ K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH VRJDU JHOWHQG PDFKHQ GD .DQW VLFKQXULQGHU*UXQGOHJXQJDXVIKUOLFKPLWLKQHQEHVFKlIWLJWKDW 'RFK .DQWJHKWQDFKZLHYRUGDYRQDXVGD=ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LSLHQQRUPDWL
_____________ VFKZDFKH3HUVRQGHUHQ0|JOLFKNHLW.DQWPLWGHU$XIVWHOOXQJK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSH UDWLYHXQWHUVWHOOWZLUGHEHQJHUDGHQLFKWDOVHLQHGLHLKUH=ZHFNHlQGHUWDGlTXDWEH VFKULHEHQ 8QWHU JHZLVVHQ 8PVWlQGHQ GD QlPOLFK GLH ULFKWLJHQ 0LWWHO ]XU =ZHFN UHDOLVLHUXQJ HUNDQQW ZXUGHQ XQG DXFK LQ GHU *HZDOW GHU EHWURIIHQHQ 3HUVRQ VLQG NDQQGDV$QVLQQHQÅ>@DXVGHP=XVWDQGGHV:QVFKHQVLQGHQGHV:ROOHQVEHU ]XJHKHQ´E]ZLQ%H]XJDXIGDV3KlQRPHQ:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHHKHUDXVGHP=XVWDQG GHV:ROOHQVQLFKWLQGHQGHVEORHQ:QVFKHQVEHU]XJHKHQVHKUZRKOGLHÅ)XQNWL RQHLQHVK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYV´ &UDPHU VHLQ 3DWRQ ,QGHU.ULWLNGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWKDW.DQWGLHDP$XIEDXGHU.ULWLNGHUUHLQHQ9HU QXQIW RULHQWLHUWH ZHQQJOHLFK GDYRQ DXFK VLJQLILNDQW DEZHLFKHQGH PRUDOSKLORVRSKL VFKH *HVDPWNRQ]HSWLRQ LP $XJH XQG NRQ]HQWULHUW VLFK GHPHQWVSUHFKHQG QLFKW DXI K\SRWKHWLVFKH,PSHUDWLYHVRQGHUQHUVWHQVDXIGDVHLQHÅ*UXQGJHVHW]GHUUHLQHQSUDN WLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW´ 9 ]ZHLWHQVDXIGHQÅ%HJULII>@ HLQHV*HJHQVWDQGHVGHUUHL QHQSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW´ 9 GHQ%HJULIIGHV*XWHQDOVRXQGGULWWHQVDXIGLH Å7ULHEIHGHUQGHUUHLQHQSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW´ 9 GHQ%HJULIIGHU$FKWXQJYRU GHP*HVHW]8QGVFKOLHOLFKLVWHULQGHU.ULWLNGHU8UWHLOVNUDIWGHU$XIIDVVXQJGDDOOH ÅWHFKQLVFKSUDNWLVFKH5HJHOQ>@]XUWKHRUHWLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHJH]lKOWZHUGHQ´PV VHQ .DQW9 YJODXFK(UVWH(LQOHLWXQJLQGLH.ULWLNGHU8UWHLOVNUDIW;; LQVEHVGLH$QP]X .DQWNHKUWGDPLWLQGLHVHU+LQVLFKW]XVHLQHUYRUNULWLVFKHQ $XIIDVVXQJ]XUFNYJO.DQW,, VRZLHGD]X6FKZDLJHU 'LHK\SR WKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHKDEHQDOVRGDVJHQXLQH,QWHUHVVH.DQWVYHUORUHQZHLOVLHVHLQHU QHXHQ$QVLFKWQDFKQLFKW]XP.HUQEHVWDQGGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHJHK|UHQLQ VRIHUQVLHGLH5LFKWLJNHLWGHU+DQGOXQJGKGLH.OXJKHLWRGHU*HVFKLFNOLFKNHLWQXU DQ HSLVWHPLVFKHQ 6WDQGDUGV JHPHVVHQ EHWUHIIHQ 9JO GD]X DXFK 6WDQJH GHUGHU$XIIDVVXQJLVW.DQWKDEHGLHK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHLP/DXIVHLQHU (QWZLFNOXQJ ]X 5HFKW DXV GHU 3UDNWLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLH LQ GLH 7KHRUHWLVFKH 3KLORVR SKLH YHUVFKREHQ VRZLH LP *HJHQ]XJ &UDPHU Å(V LVW HLQ WULYLDO ]X QHQ QHQGHU 6DFKYHUKDOW GD>@ HLQH WHFKQLVFKH RGHU SUDJPDWLVFKH 9RUVFKULIW EH]JOLFK GHVVHQZDVVLHYRUVFKUHLEWDOVWKHRUHWLVFKH$XVVDJHDXIJHIDWZHUGHQPX'LHVEH GHXWHWDEHUQRFKQLFKWGDVLHQLFKWDOV9RUVFKULIWRGHU*HERWDXIWUHWHQNDQQ´
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
YH.UDIWEHVLW]HQZHQQHULQGHU.ULWLNGHU8UWHLOVNUDIWWHFKQLVFKSUDNWLVFKH 5HJHOQ YRQ HLJHQWOLFKHQ 1DWXUJHVHW]HQ DEJUHQ]W Å'RFK KHLHQ GHUJOHL FKHQ SUDNWLVFKH 5HJHOQ QLFKW *HVHW]H HWZD VR ZLH SK\VLVFKH VRQGHUQ QXU 9RUVFKULIWHQ XQG ]ZDU GDUXP ZHLO GHU :LOOH QLFKW EOR XQWHU GHP 1DWXUEHJULIIHVRQGHUQDXFKXQWHUGHP)UHLKHLWVEHJULIIHVWHKW>@´6R EDOG ZLU 9RUVFKULIWHQ IU P|JOLFK XQG VLQQYROO KDOWHQ KDEHQ ZLU GHQ %HUHLFKGHU1DWXUEHUHLWVKLQWHUXQVJHODVVHQ 'LH)UDJHLVWDOVRLQZLHIHUQK\SRWKHWLVFKH,PSHUDWLYHDXFKLP.RQ WH[W SUDNWLVFKHU 3KLORVRSKLH HLQH 5HOHYDQ] EHVLW]HQ GLH EHU HLQH EOR WHFKQLVFKHXQGGDPLWWKHRUHWLVFKH'LVNXVVLRQKLQDXVJHKW'D]XHPSILHKOW HVVLFKHLQHZHLWHUHSURPLQHQWH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGLHVHV.DQWLVFKHQ7KHRULH VWFNVKHUDQ]X]LHKHQ,P*HJHQ]XJ]X3DWRQVDXVVFKOLHOLFKDQ+HWHUR QRPLHRULHQWLHUWHU,QWHUSUHWDWLRQK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHVLHKW&KULVWL QH 0 .RUVJDDUG LQ GLHVHQ EHUHLWV GHQ .RQWDNW ]XU HLJHQWOLFKHQ .DQWLVFKHQ 0RUDOSKLORVRSKLH XQG GHUHQ =HQWUXP GHP NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY .RUVJDDUG QlKHUW VLFK GHU QRUPDWLYHQ 4XHOOH LQVWUXPHQWHOOHU 5DWLR QDOLWlW EHU HLQH 'LVNXVVLRQ YRQ SUDNWLVFKHU ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW E]Z :LO OHQVVFKZlFKH Å7LPLG3UXGHQFHVD\VVKHKDVUHVROYHGWROHDGDPRUHDG YHQWXURXVOLIHEXWZKHQWKHRSSRUWXQLW\IRUDGYHQWXUHNQRFNV3UXGHQFH DOZD\VVD\VÄWRPRUURZ¶´ 'UHLP|JOLFKH(UNOlUXQJHQIU3UXGHQFH·9HUKDOWHQVLQGQDFK.RUV JDDUGQXQGHQNEDU L 3UXGHQFH ZLOO HLJHQWOLFK JDU QLFKW XQWHUQHKPXQJVOXVWLJHU ZHUGHQ PLW LKUHU =ZHFN$XVVDJH XQWHUOLHJW VLH HQWZHGHU HLQHU 6HOEVWWlXVFKXQJ RGHU VLH EHOJW LKUH0LWPHQVFKHQ YRQ :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH ZUGHQ ZLU LQ HLQHP VROFKHQ)DOOQLFKWVSUHFKHQ LL 3UXGHQFH ZLOO ]ZDU ]XQlFKVW XQWHUQHKPXQJVOXVWLJHU ZHUGHQ JHKW MH GRFKYRQGLHVHP=LHODEDOVVLHEHPHUNWZHOFKH0LWWHOVLHGD]XHUJUHLIHQ PWH LQNOXVLYHVROFKHUGLHVLHHYHQWXHOOLQV*HIlQJQLVEHI|UGHUQN|QQ WHQ DXFKLQGLHVHP)DOOZUGHQZLUQLFKWYRQ:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHVSUHFKHQ HV OLHJW KLHU YLHOPHKU HLQH P|JOLFKHUZHLVH YROONRPPHQ UDWLRQDOH $EZl JXQJYRUZRIU%UDWPDQIROJHQGHWUHIIHQGH&KDUDNWHULVLHUXQJJHIXQGHQ KDW Å2QHSHUVRQ·VPRGXVSRQHQVLVDQRWKHU·VPRGXVWROOHQV´
_____________ .DQW9 +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 .RUVJDDUG %UDWPDQ 1HEHQGLHVHQEHLGHQ$EZHLFKXQJHQYRQGHUJHlXHUWHQ+DQG OXQJVDEVLFKWGLHVLFKDXIGHQ=ZHFNEH]LHKHQN|QQWHPDQVLFKDXFKHLQHVROFKHYRU VWHOOHQ GLH VLFK YRUUDQJLJ DXI GLH 0LWWHO JHQDXHU GHUHQ )HKOHLQVFKlW]XQJ EH]LHKW 'RFKNDQQGDPLWHEHQIDOOVQLFKWGDV3KlQRPHQGHU:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHJHNOlUWZHUGHQ ZLH 6WDHJH GLHV QDKHOHJW Å'LH 8QYHUQQIWLJNHLW GHV :LOOHQV GLH GLH 6RIHUQ.ODXVHO YHUVWlQGOLFKPDFKHQZUGHN|QQWHDOOHQIDOOVGDULQJHVXFKWZHUGHQGDVVGDVDOVQRW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
+HWHURQRPLHXQG$XWRQRPLH
LLL 3UXGHQFH EOHLEW EHL LKUHP 9RUVDW] DXFK XQWHU .HQQWQLVQDKPH GHU Q|WLJHQ 0LWWHO GRFK VREDOG VLFK GLH *HOHJHQKHLW HLQHV :DJQLVVHV ELHWHW ZLUGVLHYRQ)XUFKWVDPNHLW7UlJKHLWRGHU'HSUHVVLRQEHUZlOWLJWVRGD VLH GDV =LHO ]ZDU ZHLWHUKLQ IU HUVWUHEHQVZHUW HUDFKWHW VLFK MHGRFK VFKOLFKWDXHUVWDQGHVLHKWHQWVSUHFKHQG]XKDQGHOQ HUVWLQGLHVHP6]HQD ULR]HLJW3UXGHQFH:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHLQGHPVLHQLFKWVRKDQGHOWZLHVLHHV VHOEVWLQGLHVHU6LWXDWLRQIUGDV%HVWHKlOWXQGYHUOHW]WGDPLWGDV=ZHFN 0LWWHO3ULQ]LS 'LHVHV)DOOEHLVSLHOJLEW.RUVJDDUGQXQGLH0|JOLFKNHLWGLH.DQWLVFKH 3RVLWLRQ PLWKLOIH SUDNWLVFKHU 6\OORJLVPHQ ]X UHNRQVWUXLHUHQ Å:KRHYHU ZLOOVWKHHQGZLOOVWKHPHDQV,ZLOOWKHHQG→,ZLOOWKHPHDQV´'LH RIIHQNXQGLJH )HKOHUKDIWLJNHLW GLHVHV 6\OORJLVPXV EHUXKW DXI GHU ² ZLH 3UXGHQFH· 9HUKDOWHQ JH]HLJW KDW ² IlOVFKOLFK DQJHQRPPHQHQ 0DLRU XQG IKUW.DQWVR.RUVJDDUGV,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ]XP(LQVFKDOWHQGHU5DWLRQDOL WlWVNODXVHO Å:KRHYHU ZLOOV WKH HQG ZLOOV WKH PHDQV LQ VR IDU DV KH LV UDWLRQDO , ZLOO WKH HQG → 7KHUHIRUH , ZLOO WKH PHDQV LQ VR IDU DV , DP UDWLRQDO→7KHUHIRUH,RXJKWWRZLOOWKHPHDQVµ
_____________ ZHQGLJYRUJHVWHOOWH0LWWHOQLFKWLGHQWLVFKLVWPLWGHP WDWVlFKOLFK QRWZHQGLJHQ0LW WHOGHU:LOOHVHLQHQ=ZHFNDOVRLUUWPOLFKXQWHU(LQVDW]HLQHV]ZHFNZLGULJHQ0LWWHOV YHUIROJW´ 6WDHJH)Q (LQGHIL]LWlUHU:LOOH DQGHQVLFKHLQ,PSHUDWLY ULFKWHQ NDQQ XQWHUVFKHLGHW VLFK DEHU ZHVHQWOLFK YRQ HLQHU GHIL]LWlUHQ (UNHQQWQLV .RUVJDDUGJHKWLKUHUVHLWVDXIGHQ)DOOGHV,UUWXPVQLFKWHLQIRUGHUWIULKUH9HUKDO WHQVGLVMXQNWLRQDEHUDXFKNHLQH9ROOVWlQGLJNHLW .RUVJDDUG 9JOGD]XEHUHLWV&UDPHU Å'DGLHLQGHUÄ6RIHUQ¶.ODXVHOJHQDQQWH%HGLQ JXQJ GHUHQ (UIOOXQJ HLQ GHUDUWLJHV *HERW DQDO\WLVFK DXVVFKOLHW HEHQ QLFKW LPPHU HUIOOW LVW PX MHPDQGHP DXI GHVVHQ +DQGOXQJHQ 9HUQXQIW >]X HUJlQ]HQ ÅP|JOL FKHUZHLVH´ .3@NHLQHQHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ(LQIOXKDWGDV(UJUHLIHQGHV0LWWHOVJHER WHQZHUGHQGDVLQVHLQHU*HZDOWLVW'LHVKlWWHQXUGDQQNHLQHQ6LQQZHQQGHUGHQ :LOOHQQLFKWQlKHUTXDOLIL]LHUHQGH6DW] Ä:HUGHQ=ZHFNZLOOZLOODXFKGDVXQHQWEHKU OLFKH0LWWHOGDVLQVHLQHU*HZDOWLVW¶HLQDQDO\WLVFKHU6DW]ZlUH'RFKLVWGLHVHU6DW] VRVFKHLQWHVQXQQLFKWQXUNHLQDQDO\WLVFKHUVRQGHUQQLFKWHLQPDOHLQZDKUHU6DW] >@'LH=XVDW]EHGLQJXQJGLHLQGLH3URWDVLVHLQ]XIKUHQLVWXPGHQ*HERWVFKDUDNWHU GHU$SRGRVLVXQGGDPLWGLH1|WLJXQJGHV:LOOHQVYHUVWlQGOLFK]XPDFKHQLVWHLQJH IKUWZHQQGLHLQGHUÄ6RIHUQ¶.ODXVHOGHU5HJHOJHQDQQWH%HGLQJXQJQLFKWHUIOOWLVW 8QGIUGLHVH0|JOLFKNHLWVFKHLQWGLHHUIDKUXQJVPlLJQXU]XRIWNRQVWDWLHUEDUH'H IL]LHQ]GHU9HUQXQIWLQ$QVHKXQJGHV(LQVDW]HVUDWLRQDOHLQVLFKWLJHU0LWWHOIU=ZH FNH GLH PDQ ZLOO LQ GHU 7DW HLQ]XVWHKHQ´ 9JO ]XU $QDO\WL]LWlW GHV =ZHFN0LWWHO 3ULQ]LSVDXFK.RUVJDDUG Å7KHRQO\SURSRVLWLRQZKLFK.DQWFDQFODLPLVDQDQDO\WLF WUXWKLVWKHRQHZLWKWKHFDYHDWLQLW´ .RUVJDDUG (EG ².RUVJDDUGVZHLWHUUHLFKHQGH.ULWLNGLHVHV6\OORJLVPXVEH]LHKWVLFKDXIGLH VFKHLQEDUEORGHQKLVWRULVFKHQ8PVWlQGHQJHVFKXOGHWH+LQWHUJUXQGPHWDSK\VLNGLH .DQW GD]X EHZHJW KDEH GLHVHV 6ROOHQ YRP VWHWV UDWLRQDOHQ :ROOHQ HLQHV J|WWOLFKHQ RGHU KHLOLJHQ :LOOHQV DE]XOHLWHQ Å*RG GRHV VRDQGVR RU D SHUIHFWO\ UDWLRQDO EHLQJ GRHVVRDQGVR DQGWKHUHIRUH,RXJKWWRGRVRDQGVR´ (EG .DQWVHW]W]ZDUQLFKW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
.RUVJDDUGV]HQWUDOH7KHVHLQGLHVHP.RQWH[W²ÅWKDWWKHUHFDQEHQR LQVWUXPHQWDOQRUPVXQOHVVWKHUHDUHDOVRXQFRQGLWLRQDOQRUPV´²UFNW QXQ K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLYH ]ZDU LQ HLQH VFKHLQEDU JHIlKUOLFKH 1lKH ]XP NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY (V VFKHLQW GLH DXV .DQWLVFKHU 3HUVSHNWLYH ]X YHUKLQGHUQGH $VVLPLODWLRQ GHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV DQ GLH K\SR WKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYH]XGURKHQ'RFK]XPHLQHQOlWVLFKGLHVH*HIDKU DXVVFKOLHHQ GD GLH SKLORVRSKLVFKH %HGHXWXQJ GHV %HVWLPPXQJVJUXQGV ]X HLQHU+DQGOXQJGDYRQXQEHUKUWEOHLEW .RUVJDDUGJHKWGDUDXIVRZHLWLFK VHKH QLFKW HLQ =XP DQGHUHQ ZHLVW GLHVH 6WUDWHJLH HLQHQ LQWHUHVVDQWHQ :HJ]XGHUHLQ]LJHQ4XHOOHSUDNWLVFKHU1RUPDWLYLWlW 'LHHQWVFKHLGHQGH)UDJHEH]LHKWVLFKGDUDXIZLHZLUGHQ]LHOJHULFKWH WHQ:LOOHQNRQ]LSLHUHQN|QQHQGHUZHGHUSHUVHGLHHUIRUGHUOLFKHQ0LWWHO HUJUHLIWQRFKXQDEKlQJLJYRQGHU2ULHQWLHUXQJDXIGLH0LWWHOYHUVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQNDQQ Å7KHDQVZHULVWKDWZLOOLQJDQHQGMXVWLVFRPPLWWLQJ\RXUVHOI WRUHDOL]LQJWKHHQG>@7RZLOODQHQGLVWRJLYHRQHVHOIDODZKHQFHWR JRYHUQRQHVHOI7KDWODZLVQRWWKHLQVWUXPHQWDOSULQFLSOH LWLVVRPHODZ RIWKHIRUP 5HDOL]HWKLVHQG´.RUVJDDUGPDFKWGDUDQDQVFKOLHHQGNODU LQZLHIHUQ K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLYH WDWVlFKOLFK LQ GLH SUDNWLVFKH 3KLORVR SKLH JHK|UHQ XQG VHOEVW LQVWUXPHQWHOOH 5DWLRQDOLWlW QXU LQ QRUPDWLYHQ 7HUPLQLDXVEXFKVWDELHUWZHUGHQNDQQ Å,WPHDQVWKDW\RXUZLOOLQJWKHHQG JLYHV LW D QRUPDWLYH VWDWXV IRU \RX WKDW \RXU ZLOOLQJ WKH HQG LQ D VHQVH PDNHV LW JRRG 7KH LQVWUXPHQWDO SULQFLSOH FDQ RQO\ EH QRUPDWLYH LI ZH WDNH RXUVHOYHV WR EH FDSDEOH RI JLYLQJ ODZV WR RXUVHOYHV ² RU LQ .DQW·V RZQSKUDVHLIZHWDNHRXURZQZLOOVWREHOHJLVODWLYH>@:KRPDNHVDODZ IRUZKRP"7KHDQVZHULQWKHFDVHRIWKHLQVWUXPHQWDOSULQFLSOHLVWKDW, PDNH D ODZ IRU PH >VF ZLWKRXW XQLYHUVDOL]LQJ LW .3@ $QG WKLV LV D ODZ ZKLFK,DPFDSDEOHRIREH\LQJRUGLVREH\LQJ´ :LH LFK LP )ROJHQGHQ DUJXPHQWLHUHQ ZHUGH LVW ]ZDU QDFK .DQW GLH 8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJ QLFKW GLH HQWVFKHLGHQGH 'LIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ GHP )HOG
_____________ *RWWRGHUHLQYROONRPPHQHV:HVHQDOV5HFKWVJUXQGGHVPHQVFKOLFKHQ6ROOHQVYRUDXV VFKOLHOLFKEHWRQWHUKlXILJGD 5HOLJLRQ DXI0RUDOIROJHQQLHPDOVDEHUGLHVHUYR UDXVJHKHQNDQQ YJO] %9I EHLPÅKHLOLJHQ:LOOHQ´ ,9 KDQGHOWHVVLFK GHPHQWVSUHFKHQGXPHLQH1RPLQDOEHVWLPPXQJGHUHQREMHNWLYH5HDOLWlWLQGHU(WKLN NHLQDUJXPHQWDWLYHV*HZLFKWWUlJW*OHLFKZRKOJLOWLKP²XQGQLFKWQXULKP²GLHRQ WRORJLVFKH3UlYDOHQ]GHV,QWHOOLJLEOHQDOVXQXPVW|OLFK,QEH]XJDXIGHQ%HJULIIGHU 1RUPDWLYLWlWPDFKWGLHVH3UlYDOHQ]GLHLQGHU'HGXNWLRQGHVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUD WLYV LQQHUKDOE GHU *UXQGOHJXQJ VRJDU GHVVHQ 5HFKWVJUXQG EH]HLFKQHW MHGRFK QXU GDV HLQHGHVVHQEHLGHU .RQVWLWXHQWLHQDXV'LH DQGHUH6HLWHGHU0HGDLOOHLVWGLH+HWHUR QRPLH .RUVJDDUG )Q (EG (EG
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
8QEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQXQGGLH%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ
PRUDOLVFKHUXQGGHP)HOGWHFKQLVFKHUE]ZSUDJPDWLVFKHU+DQGOXQJVPD [LPHQ GHQQ GHU DOOJHPHLQHQ *HVHW]HVKDIWLJNHLW GHU 0RUDO 6LWWHQJHVHW] HQWVSULFKW GLH DOOJHPHLQH *HVHW]HVKDIWLJNHLW LQVWUXPHQWHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW =ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQ GLH HQWVFKHLGHQGH 'LIIHUHQ] OLHJW IU .DQW YLHO PHKU LQ GHQ ZHVHQWOLFK XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ %HVWLPPXQJVJUQGHQ ]X HLQHU +DQGOXQJ 'DUEHUKLQDXVKlOW.RUVJDDUGGDV0HWDSULQ]LSÅ5HDOL]HWKLV HQG´IUYHUDQWZRUWOLFKIUGHQhEHUJDQJYRQGHU=ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQ ]XP K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY 'RFK KLOIW XQV GLHVHV 0HWDSULQ]LS ]XP 9HUVWlQGQLVLQVWUXPHQWHOOHU1RUPDWLYLWlWQLFKWZHLWHUGDZLU²SHUK\SR WKHVLV²GHQ=ZHFNEHUHLWVLQWHQGLHUHQ HULVWXQVHUIUHLJHZlKOWHU=ZHFN :LUEHQ|WLJHQGDKHUGDVREHQHLQJHIKUWHXQGMHQVHLWVDOOHUIUHLJHZlKOWHQ =ZHFNH OLHJHQGH 0HWDSULQ]LS ÅJHVWDWWH GHU 9HUQXQIW HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOX DXI GHLQH +DQGOXQJ´ XP GLH P|JOLFKH 'HJUDGLHUXQJ GHV :LO OHQV ]XP EORHQ :XQVFK ]X YHUKLQGHUQ XQG GLH GHVNULSWLYH =ZHFN 0LWWHO5HODWLRQLQHLQHQ,PSHUDWLY]XEHUIKUHQ $EHU.RUVJDDUGV9HUGLHQVWLVWHVGLHK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHKLQ VLFKWOLFKLKUHUQRUPDWLYHQ.UDIWDQGHQ%HJULIIGHU$XWRQRPLHZLH.DQW LKQ LP .RQWH[W GHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV GLVNXWLHUW KHUDQJHIKUW ]X KDEHQ 2E MHGRFK GLH 9HUQDFKOlVVLJXQJ HLQHU LUUDWLRQDOHQ $QIHFKWXQJ EHLGHU)UDJHQDFKGHUQRUPDWLYHQ.UDIWK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHHLQ&KD UDNWHULVWLNXP GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 7KHRULH VHOEVW RGHU HLQH V\VWHPDWLVFKH .RPSOHWWLHUXQJ GXUFK .RUVJDDUGV HQWVSUHFKHQGHV HLJHQHV 7KHRUHPVHLQ VROO ZLUG DXV LKUHQ $XVIKUXQJHQ QLFKW JDQ] GHXWOLFK :LFKWLJ VFKHLQW PLUGDKHUQHEHQ.RUVJDDUGV%HWRQXQJGHU$XWRQRPLHLP.RQWH[WK\SR WKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHDXFKGLH:UGLJXQJYRQ3DWRQV+HUDXVDUEHLWHQGHU 6LQQOLFKNHLW DOV %HGLQJXQJ GHUHQ $XWRULWlW XQG ]ZDU LP 6LQQH GHU 8UVDFKH HLQHU GURKHQGHQ 1LHGHUODJH GHU 9HUQXQIW 3DWRQV XQG .RUVJDDUGV 3HU VSHNWLYHQDXIGLHK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHEH]HLFKQHQGLHEHLGHQ6HLWHQ SUDNWLVFKHU5DWLRQDOLWlW +HWHURQRPLHXQG$XWRQRPLHNHQQ]HLFKQHQQDFK .DQW GHQ VSH]LILVFK JHERWVRIIHQHQ :LOOHQ GHV 0HQVFKHQ ZLH LFK QXQ QlKHUHUOlXWHUQZHUGH
8QEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQXQGGLH%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ
,FKKDEHGLH$QDO\VHYRQ.DQWV.RQ]HSWSUDNWLVFKHU1RUPDWLYLWlWELVODQJ DQKDQG GHU K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH GXUFKJHIKUW GHU HQWVFKHLGHQGH
_____________ 9JOGD]XLQGHU.ULWLNGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW 9JO GD]X DEHU DXFK EHUHLWV 2·1HLOO $OOLVRQ XQG +LOO 9JOLQVEHV.RUVJDDUG )Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
=XVDW]GHUDSSHOODWLYH5HNXUVDXIGLH9HUQXQIWGHV0HQVFKHQGHULQ9HU ELQGXQJ PLW GHP DQDO\WLVFKHQ =ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LS ]X HLQHP ,PSHUDWLY ZLUGLVWKLHUVHKUGHXWOLFK]XHUNHQQHQ (V LVW QDWUOLFK NHLQ =XIDOO GD .DQW GHQ VRHEHQ DXV GHU =ZHFN 0LWWHO5DWLRQDOLWlW KHUDXVJHVFKlOWHQ .HUQ SUDNWLVFKHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW DQ XQVHUHYHUQQIWLJH LP*HJHQVDW]]XUEORVLQQOLFKHQ 9HUIDWKHLWNQSIW 'RFKZLUGGLHVQRFKJUHLIEDUHUZHQQPDQVLFKGLH0HGDLOOHGHU:LOOHQV EHVWLPPXQJ YRQ GHU DQGHUHQ 6HLWH GHP NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY KHU DQVLHKW 1DFKGHP LFK GHQ NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY DOVR ]XQlFKVW DXVJH NODPPHUW KDEH ZHLO $EZlJXQJ XQG GDPLW LQVWUXPHQWHOOH 5DWLRQDOLWlW LQ LKP NHLQH 5ROOH VSLHOHQ ]HLJW VLFK QXQ GD VHLQH %HUFNVLFKWLJXQJ LQ GLHVHP.RQWH[WJHQDXGDQQORKQWZHQQPDQJHVHKHQKDWGDVLFKVHOEVW KLQWHUGHP.RQ]HSWLQVWUXPHQWHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlWEHL.DQWHLQHLUUHGX]LEHO QRUPDWLYH'LPHQVLRQHU|IIQHW,PIROJHQGHQP|FKWHLFKGDKHUVWDWWGHU +DXSWGLIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ P|JOLFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYHQ LKUH JHPHLQVDPH :XU]HO EHKDQGHOQ 7KHVHQDUWLJ OlW VLFK PHLQH ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ IROJHQGHUPDHQ ]XVDPPHQIDVVHQ (UVWHQVGDDXVGHP=ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LSHLQH1|WLJXQJGHV:LOOHQV ZLUG HUIRUGHUW ZLH LP YRUVWHKHQGHQ DXVJHIKUW HLQHQ 5HNXUV DXI GHQ (LQIOXGHU9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJ=ZHLWHQVGDDXVGHP6LWWHQ JHVHW]GDVIUGHQJHVDPWHQPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLVDOVRIUDOOHYHUQQIWL JHQ:HVHQJLOWHLQNDWHJRULVFKHU,PSHUDWLYXQGGDPLWHEHQIDOOVHLQH1| WLJXQJ GHV :LOOHQV ZLUG HUIRUGHUW HLQHQ QHJDWLYHQ 5HNXUV DXI XQVHUH (QGOLFKNHLW E]Z 6LQQOLFKNHLW 'ULWWHQVGLH 4XHOOH GHU1RUPDWLYLWlW OLHJW DOOHLQLQXQVHUHUVSH]LILVFKHQGOLFKHQ9HUQXQIWGLHYRQGHU6HLWHK\SR WKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHDXVEHWUDFKWHWHLQHhEHUVWHLJXQJEORHQ9HUKDOWHQV KLQ]XHLQHPDEVLFKWVYROOHQXQGEHJUQGHWHQ+DQGHOQXQGYRQGHU6HLWH GHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV DXV EHWUDFKWHW HLQ 8QWHUODXIHQ DEVROXWHU 6LWWOLFKNHLWGXUFKVLQQOLFKH$IIHNWLRQHUP|JOLFKW 3UDNWLVFKH1RUPDWLYLWlWEOHLEWEHL.DQWQLFKWDXIK\SRWKHWLVFKH,PSH UDWLYHEHVFKUlQNW'LHGRUWJHIXQGHQH5DWLRQDOLWlWVNODXVHOGLHVLFKIUGHQ LPSHUDWLYHQ&KDUDNWHUGHUK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHYHUDQWZRUWOLFK]HLJ WHILQGHWVLFKPXWDWLVPXWDQGLVDXFKDPNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYZLHGHU 'DVEHGHXWHWRGHUEHJUQGHWQLFKWGDHLQHGHUEHLGHQ,PSHUDWLYIRUPHQ² ZLH DXFK LPPHU ² DXI GLH DQGHUH UHGX]LHUEDU RGHU DXV GLHVHU DE]XOHLWHQ ZlUH HLQHVROFKH7KHVHYHUWUHWHLFKDXVGUFNOLFKQLFKW:RKOJLEWHVGHQ 8QWHUVFKLHG]ZLVFKHQLQVWUXPHQWHOOHUSUXGHQWLHOOHUXQGPRUDOLVFKHU5DWL RQDOLWlW'RFKGLH7DWVDFKHGD.DQWDXFKGLHHUVWHQEHLGHQDOVRLQVWUX PHQWHOOH XQG SUXGHQWLHOOH 5DWLRQDOLWlW LQ QRUPDWLYHQ 7HUPLQL EHKDQGHOW XQG LQVRIHUQ YRQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYHQ VSULFKW UFNW DXFK GLHVH
_____________ 9JO]XGLHVHP%HJULIIREHQ)Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
8QEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQXQGGLH%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ
)RUPHQGHU5DWLRQDOLWlWDXVGHP%HUHLFKSV\FKRORJLVFKHU'HVNULSWLRQLQ HLQH QRUPDWLYH 6SKlUH ,QQHUKDOE GLHVHU 6SKlUH ZHUGHQ ,PSHUDWLYH VFKOLHOLFKQXUQRFKGDKLQJHKHQGXQWHUVFKLHGHQGDVLHHQWZHGHUPDWHULDO EHVWLPPWVLQGGKGDGHU%HVWLPPXQJVJUXQG]XHLQHU+DQGOXQJLP(UUHL FKHQHLQHV=ZHFNVGXUFKGLH(UJUHLIXQJDOVDGlTXDWHUNDQQWHU0LWWHOOLHJW RGHUGDVLHIRUPDOEHVWLPPWVLQGGKGDGHU%HVWLPPXQJVJUXQG]XHLQHU +DQGOXQJ LQ GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ VLWWOLFKHU *HVHW]PlLJNHLW OLHJW *HQDX GLHVH 9DULDQ] GHU %HVWLPPXQJVJUQGH P|JOLFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ PDUNLHUW GLHGLIIHUHQWLDVSHFLILFD]ZLVFKHQGHQEHLGHQ,PSHUDWLYIRUPHQ .DQW JHKW VRZRKO LQ GHU *UXQGOHJXQJ DOV DXFK LQ GHU .ULWLN GHU SUDNWL VFKHQ9HUQXQIWGDYRQDXVGD:HVHQGLHLKUH1HLJXQJHQXQWHUVWlQGLJHU UDWLRQDOHU.RQWUROOHKlWWHQVWHWVVLWWOLFKKDQGHOQZUGHQ(UIKUWLQGLH VHP.RQWH[WQRPLQDODOV.RQWUDVW]XPPHQVFKOLFKHQ:LOOHQGHQ%HJULII GHV ÅKHLOLJHQ :LOOHQ>V@´ HLQ ÅG L HLQHQ VROFKHQ GHU NHLQHU GHP PRUDOL VFKHQ*HVHW]HZLGHUVWUHLWHQGHQ0D[LPHQIlKLJZlUH´$QDORJ]XPDWH ULHOOHQ.|USHUQGLHDXVQDKPVORV1DWXUJHVHW]HQIROJHQJHKRUFKWHQGLHVH UHLQ JHLVWLJHQ 9HUQXQIWZHVHQ VWHWV GHP *HVHW] GHU VLWWOLFKHQ :HOW ,P 6LQQH.DQWVGDUIGDV3ULQ]LSÅLQPXQGRQRQGDWXUFDVXV´YRQGHUVHQVLEOHQ DXI GLH LQWHOOLJLEOH :HOW EHUWUDJHQ ZHUGHQ GHQQ GLH $OOJHPHLQKHLW XQG 1RWZHQGLJNHLWGLHVHU*HVHW]HGXOGHQNHLQH$XVQDKPHQ:HVHQGLHOHGLJ OLFK%UJHUGLHVHULQWHOOLJLEOHQ:HOWVLQGKDQGHOQRKQH$XVQDKPHVLWWHQ JHVHW]OLFK)U:HVHQPLWHLQHPVROFKHQDEVROXWJXWHQ:LOOHQIlOOWGDKHU GDV REMHNWLYH PLW GHP VXEMHNWLYHQ 3ULQ]LS GHV :ROOHQV ]XVDPPHQ ÅGDV REMHFWLYH3ULQFLS>VFGHV:ROOHQV .3@ GLGDVMHQLJHZDVDOOHQYHUQQI WLJHQ :HVHQ DXFK VXEMHFWLY ]XP SUDNWLVFKHQ 3ULQFLS GLHQHQ ZUGH ZHQQ 9HUQXQIWYROOH*HZDOWEHUGDV%HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQKlWWH LVWGDVSUDNWLVFKH*H VHW]´ $XI GLH YRQ PLU KHUYRUJHKREHQH .DXWHO ZHUGH LFK VRJOHLFK JHQDXHU HLQJHKHQ ² (LQ ,PSHUDWLY DOVR HLQH $XIIRUGHUXQJ GLHVHP *HVHW] ]X JHKRUFKHQZlUHMHGHQIDOOVEHLVRNRQVWUXLHUWHQ+HLOLJHQEHUIOVVLJHEHQ GHVZHJHQZHLOHLQDOWHUQDWLYHVGKJHVHW]ZLGULJHV9HUKDOWHQGLHVHQ:H VHQ DXIJUXQG GHU DEVROXWUDWLRQDOHQ %HKHUUVFKXQJ LKUHU 6LQQOLFKNHLW JDU QLFKW]XU'LVSRVLWLRQVWQGH EH]RJHQDXILKU:ROOHQQLFKWDXILKU.|Q QHQ 'DMHGRFKHLQ,PSHUDWLYEHL+HLOLJHQZHUWORVZlUHEHGHXWHWQLFKW
_____________ .DQW9 YJO]XPKHLOLJHQ:LOOHQEHUHLWVGLH*UXQGOHJXQJ ,9 ZR .DQW HLQHUVHLWV ]ZLVFKHQ GHP DEVROXW JXWHQ XQG GHP KHLOLJHQ :LOOHQ XQWHUVFKHLGHW LQVRIHUQHLQ,PSHUDWLYDXIGHQHUVWHUHQQLFKWDEHUDXIOHW]WHUHQDQZHQGEDUVHLQVROO DQGHUHUVHLWV LGHQWLIL]LHUW HU GLH EHLGHQ MHGRFK DXFK PLWHLQDQGHU ² )U GHQ +LQZHLV DXIGLHVHVH[HJHWLVFKH3UREOHPGDQNHLFK$OOHQ:RRG .DQW.U9% .DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
GD GDV 6LWWHQJHVHW] IU VLH GHVNULSWLYHQ &KDUDNWHU KlWWH 6R]XVDJHQ YRQ DXHQ EHWUDFKWHW PDJ GLHV ]ZDU VR DXVVHKHQ GRFK EHVLW]W HV IU GLHVH SUREOHPDWLVFKHQ DXWRQRPHQ :HVHQ SUlVNULSWLYHQ &KDUDNWHU XQG PX GDPLWYRP1DWXUJHVHW]XQWHUVFKLHGHQZHUGHQ,P*HJHQVDW]]XPIDOOHQ GHQ 6WHLQ IROJWHQ DXFK +HLOLJH ² ZLH DOOH YHUQQIWLJHQ :HVHQ ² HLQHP *HVHW]QXUZHLOVLHGLHVHVDQHUNHQQHQ 'HU 0HQVFK NDQQ ]X PRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJHQ DXIJHIRUGHUW ZHUGHQ ZHLOHUVLFKQRWZHQGLJDOVHLQ:HVHQEHJUHLIWGDVXQWHULQWHOOLJLEOHQ*H VHW]HQ QXU VWHKW LQVRIHUQ HV GLHVH DQHUNHQQW ]XJOHLFK ÄPX¶ HU LP *H JHQVDW] ]X GHQ +HLOLJHQ ]X PRUDOLVFKHP +DQGHOQ DXIJHIRUGHUW ZHUGHQ ZHLOHUQLFKWSHUVHPRUDOLVFKKDQGHOW.DQWEHQHQQWGHXWOLFKGLH%HGLQ JXQJXQWHUZHOFKHUHLQNDWHJRULVFKHU,PSHUDWLYEHUIOVVLJZlUHZHQQHU ]ZLVFKHQREMHNWLYHPXQGVXEMHNWLYHP3ULQ]LSGHV:ROOHQVXQWHUVFKHLGHW :lKUHQGEHLPÄKHLOLJHQ:LOOHQ¶GLHEHLGHQ3ULQ]LSLHQEHUHLQVWLPPHQLVW EHLP PHQVFKOLFKHQ :LOOHQ HLQH $EZHLFKXQJ QLFKW DXV]XVFKOLHHQ Å(LQ YROONRPPHQJXWHU:LOOHZUGHDOVRHEHQVRZRKOXQWHUREMHFWLYHQ*HVHW ]HQ GHV *XWHQ VWHKHQ DEHU QLFKW GDGXUFK DOV ]X JHVHW]PlLJHQ +DQG OXQJHQJHQ|WKLJWYRUJHVWHOOWZHUGHQN|QQHQZHLOHUYRQVHOEVWQDFKVHLQHU VXEMHFWLYHQ%HVFKDIIHQKHLWQXUGXUFKGLH9RUVWHOOXQJGHV*XWHQEHVWLPPW ZHUGHQNDQQ'DKHUJHOWHQIUGHQJ|WWOLFKHQXQGEHUKDXSWIUHLQHQKHLOL JHQ :LOOHQ NHLQH ,PSHUDWLYHQ GDV 6ROOHQ LVW KLHU DP XQUHFKWHQ 2UWH ZHLO GDV :ROOHQ VFKRQ YRQVHOEVW PLW GHP *HVHW] QRWKZHQGLJ HLQVWLPPLJ LVW 'DKHU VLQG ,PSHUDWLYHQ QXU )RUPHOQ GDV 9HUKlOWQL REMHFWLYHU *HVHW]H GHV:ROOHQVEHUKDXSW]XGHUVXEMHFWLYHQ8QYROONRPPHQKHLWGHV:LOOHQV GLHVHV RGHU MHQHV YHUQQIWLJHQ :HVHQV ] % GHV PHQVFKOLFKHQ :LOOHQV DXV]XGUFNHQ´ %HL 9HUQXQIWZHVHQ GLH QLFKW DXVVFKOLHOLFK VLFK VHOEVW EHVWLPPHQ VRQGHUQ DXFK YRQ 1HLJXQJHQ EHVWLPPW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ DOVR EHLVSLHOV ZHLVH GHP 0HQVFKHQ DOV HLQHP YRQ Å%HGUIQLVVHQ XQG VLQQOLFKHQ %H ZHJXUVDFKHQDIILFLUWH>Q@:HVHQ´YHUKlOWVLFKGLH6DFKHKLQJHJHQDQGHUV DOV EHLUHLQHQ 9HUQXQIWZHVHQ Å,VW HV >GDVSUDNWLVFKH *HVHW] .3@ QLFKW ]XJOHLFK VXEMHFWLY LPPHU NUlIWLJ JQXJ ]XU +DQGOXQJ>@ VR KHLW GLH 1RWKZHQGLJNHLW 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW>@ GLH +DQGOXQJ VHOEVW 3IOLFKW XQG GLH
_____________ 9JOGD]X.DQW9 Å'LHVHV3ULQFLSGHU6LWWOLFKNHLWQXQ>«@HUNOlUWGLH9HUQXQIW ]XJOHLFK ]X HLQHP *HVHW]H IU DOOH YHUQQIWLJH :HVHQ VR IHUQ VLH EHUKDXSW HLQHQ :LOOHQ G L HLQ 9HUP|JHQ KDEHQ LKUH &DXVDOLWlW GXUFK GLH 9RUVWHOOXQJ YRQ 5HJHOQ ]X EHVWLPPHQ >«@´ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 9JO GD]X DXFK :RRG XQG VRZLH$QGHUVRQ .DQW,9 .DQW9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
8QEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQXQGGLH%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ
)RUPHOHLQDEVROXWHVVROOHQ´ :LUN|QQHQGHP6LWWHQJHVHW]JHPlKDQ GHOQDEHUZLUN|QQHQDXFKLKP]XZLGHUKDQGHOQ:LUN|QQHQXQVLQXQ VHUHQ +DQGOXQJHQ YRP $QVSUXFK GHU 0RUDOLWlW EHVWLPPHQ ODVVHQ ZLU N|QQHQXQVGLHVHP$QVSUXFKDEHUDXFKYHUVFKOLHHQ'DZLUQLFKWSHUVH VLWWOLFKKDQGHOQQLPPWGDV6LWWHQJHVHW]²DOVRÅQXUGDVMHQLJH]XZlKOHQ ZDVGLH9HUQXQIWXQDEKlQJLJYRQGHU1HLJXQJDOVSUDNWLVFKQRWKZHQGLJ >@ HUNHQQW´ ² IU XQV%UJHU ]ZHLHU :HOWHQ GLH Å)RUP HLQHV ,PSHUD WLYV´DQ1XUIUHQGOLFKH:HVHQZLHXQV0HQVFKHQLVWGHUÅ%HJULIIGHU 3IOLFKW´UHOHYDQWÅGHUGHQHLQHVJXWHQ:LOOHQVRE]ZDUXQWHUJHZLVVHQVXEMHFWL YHQ(LQVFKUlQNXQJHQXQG+LQGHUQLVVHQHQWKlOW´:LU0HQVFKHQPVVHQXQV DOVYRQ+HWHURQRPLHXPODJHUWH$XWRQRPLHYHUVWHKHQZHLOZLUHLQHUVHLWV YRQ1HLJXQJHQGKQLFKWYHUQQIWLJHQ%HZHJJUQGHQDIIL]LHUWZHUGHQ XQVDEHUDQGHUHUVHLWVGLHVHQJHJHQEHUYHUQQIWLJYHUKDOWHQN|QQHQGK ZLUN|QQHQGLHVLWWOLFKH)RUGHUXQJJHJHQEHUVLQQOLFKHQ1HLJXQJHQYRU ]LHKHQ RKQH GD GDGXUFK DOOHUGLQJV XQVHUH 6LQQOLFKNHLW DOV VROFKH YHU VFKZLQGHQZUGH 'HUNDWHJRULVFKH,PSHUDWLYULFKWHWVLFKGHPQDFKDQGHQMHQLJHQ:LOOHQ GHVVHQ VXEMHNWLYHU %HVWLPPXQJVJUXQG GDV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV P|JOL FKHUZHLVHYRPREMHNWLYHQGKVLWWOLFKHQ%HVWLPPXQJVJUXQGGHPSULQFL SLXP GLMXGLFDWLRQLV DEZHLFKW DXV GHU 3HUVSHNWLYH DOOJHPHLQHU PRUDOLVFKHU *HVHW]PlLJNHLW GHU +DQGOXQJHQ VROOHQ GLHVH EHLGHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ LQ .RQ NRUGDQ] JHEUDFKW ZHUGHQ 'DV IU XQV JHOWHQGH PRUDOLVFKH 6ROOHQ KlQJW GDPLWZHVHQWOLFKGDYRQDEGDEHLHQGOLFKHQ:HVHQGLH9HUQXQIWP|JOL FKHUZHLVHQLFKWGLHÄYROOH*HZDOWEHUGDV%HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQ¶KDW,Q GLHVHP6LQQHEHVWLPPW.DQWGHQNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYZLHREHQEH UHLWV DQJHPHUNW DOV HLQHQ ÅV\QWKHWLVFKSUDNWLVFKH>Q@ 6DW] D SULRUL´ ZHLO GXUFKLKQGDV:ROOHQHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ+DQGOXQJÅPLWGHP%HJULIIHGHV :LOOHQVHLQHVYHUQQIWLJHQ:HVHQVXQPLWWHOEDUDOVHWZDVGDVLQLKPQLFKW
_____________
.DQW;;,,, .DQW,9 .DQW9 .DQW ,9 +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 YJO DXFK ,9 XQG ,9 ]XU ZHLWHUHQ %HJULIIVNOlUXQJYRQ3IOLFKWXQG9HUELQGOLFKNHLWEH]JOLFKGHU1RPLQDOGLIIHUHQ]YRQ KHLOLJHPXQGQLFKWKHLOLJHP:LOOHQ9RQGHUQLFKWZHQLJHUGHXWOLFKHQ'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ LQ,9EHWRQW.RUVJDDUG]X5HFKWGD.DQWVLHYRUGHUZHLWHUHQ'LIIHUHQ]LH UXQJGHU,PSHUDWLYHLQK\SRWKHWLVFKHXQGGHQNDWHJRULVFKHQYRUQLPPW Å>@LPSHUD WLYHVDUHDGGUHVVHGWREHLQJVZKRPD\IROORZWKHPRUQRW$QGWKLVLVWUXHRIWKHLQ VWUXPHQWDO SULQFLSOH DV ZHOO DV RI WKH RWKHUV´ .RUVJDDUG 8QPLYHUVWlQGOLFKKHLWHVDXFKLQGHUHWZDSDUDOOHO]XU*UXQGOHJXQJHQVWDQGHQHQ0R UDO 0URQJRYLXV ,, Å'LH ,PSHUDWLYH VLQG DXV HLQHU ,GHH HLQHV YROONRPPHQHQ :LOOHQV KHUJHQRPPHQXQGJHOWHQDOV5HJHOQIUPHLQHQXQYROONRPPHQHQ:LOOHQ 3IOLFKWLVW HLQH,GHHHLQHVYROONRPPHQHQDOVHLQHQRUPHLQHVXQYROONRPPHQHQ:LOOHQV´ .DQW ;;,;
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
HQWKDOWHQ LVW YHUNQSIW´ ZLUG *HUDGH GLHVH 6\QWKHWL]LWlW GHV NDWHJRUL VFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVGKGHUEHLHQGOLFKHQ:HVHQZLHGHP0HQVFKHQP|J OLFKH .RQIOLNW ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHU 0D[LPH XQG GHP 6LWWHQJHVHW] LVW IU GHQ LPSHUDWLYHQ&KDUDNWHUGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVIUHQGOLFKH:HVHQYHUDQWZRUWOLFK 'HUNDWHJRULVFKH,PSHUDWLYGKGHU$XIUXI]XU6XEVXPWLRQVXEMHNWL YHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQGVlW]H XQWHU GDV 6LWWHQJHVHW] IRUGHUW GDPLW GLH :LO OHQVEHVWLPPXQJGXUFKGDVDOOJHPHLQH*HVHW]²MHGRFKQLFKWXQPLWWHOEDU VRQGHUQ LP Å6WUHLW>@ GHQ MHW]W GLH PRUDOLVFKH *HVLQQXQJ PLW GHQ 1HL JXQJHQ]XIKUHQKDW´:lKUHQGHLQKHLOLJHU:LOOHEHUHLWVDOVVROFKHUGLH 9HUNQSIXQJGHV:LOOHQVPLWGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ+DQGOXQJYROO]LHKHQZU GHXQWHUODVVHQZLU0HQVFKHQGLHVHP|JOLFKHUZHLVHDXIJUXQGXQVHUHUVXE MHNWLYVLQQOLFKHQ Ä%HIDQJHQKHLW¶ Å,FK YHUNQSIH PLW GHP :LOOHQ RKQH YRUDXVJHVHW]WH %HGLQJXQJ DXV LUJHQG HLQHU 1HLJXQJ GLH 7KDW D SULRUL PLWKLQQRWKZHQGLJ REJOHLFKQXU REMHFWLY G L XQWHU GHU ,GHH HLQHU9HUQXQIW GLH EHUDOOHVXEMHFWLYH%HZHJXUVDFKHQY|OOLJH*HZDOWKlWWH ´'LHKLHUSDUHQWKHWLVFK IRUPXOLHUWH (LQVFKUlQNXQJ EH]JOLFK GHU Å,GHH HLQHU 9HUQXQIW GLH EHU DOOH VXEMHFWLYH %HZHJXUVDFKHQ Y|OOLJH *HZDOW KlWWH´ EH]HLFKQHW GDVVHOEH ZLH GLH EH UHLWV DQJHIKUWH .ODXVHO LQ .DQWV 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ VXEMHNWLYHP XQGREMHNWLYHP3ULQ]LSGHV:ROOHQV ÅZHQQ9HUQXQIWYROOH*HZDOWEHU GDV%HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQKlWWH´ $XIIlOOLJ LVW QXQ KLHUEHL GD GLHVHU 9RUEHKDOW DQDORJ GHPMHQLJHQ ]X YHUVWHKHQLVWGHUVLFKLP.RQWH[WGHUK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYHLQGHQ %HVWLPPXQJHQ GHU =ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQ HEHQIDOOV DOV 3DUHQWKHVH IDQG +LHUZLHGRUWVWDPPWGLHQ|WLJHQGH.UDIWDXVGHUHLQJHVFKREHQHQ.ODX VHOGLHYHUDQWZRUWOLFKLVWIUGLH8PZDQGOXQJYRQSUDNWLVFKHQ*HVHW]HQ RGHU JHVHW]DUWLJHQ $XVVDJHQ LQ ,PSHUDWLYH 0LW HLQHU *HJHQEHUVWHOOXQJ GHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ 9RUEHKDOWH OlW VLFK GLHVH ([SOLNDWLRQ GHV 1RUPDWL YHQGXUFKGHQ$SSHOODQXQVHUHVSH]LILVFKHQGOLFKH5DWLRQDOLWlWYHUGHXWOL FKHQ :DUGHUhEHUJDQJYRPDQDO\WLVFKHQ=ZHFN0LWWHO3ULQ]LS]XPK\SR WKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY LQ MHQHP =XVDW] ]X ORNDOLVLHUHQ ÅVR IHUQ GLH 9HU QXQIWDXIVHLQH+DQGOXQJHQHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ(LQIOXKDW´VRILQGHWVLFK GHU hEHUJDQJ YRP 6LWWHQJHVHW] ]XP NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY LQ GLHVHP
_____________ .DQW,9 .DQW9 .DQW ,9 $QP +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 .DQW VSULFKW LQ GLHVHU $QPHUNXQJ YRP NDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYXQGGHP6LWWHQJHVHW]SURPLVFXHZDVOHGLJOLFKDOVVSUDFKOLFKH 8QJHQDXLJNHLWJHZHUWHWZHUGHQNDQQGDHULPDQJHIKUWHQ.RQWH[WHLQHVJ|WWOLFKHQ E]ZKHLOLJHQ:LOOHQVHEHQGLHVH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJHLQIKUW .DQW,9 .DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
8QEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQXQGGLH%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ
ÅZHQQ 9HUQXQIW YROOH *HZDOW EHU GDV %HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQ KlWWH´ 'DVLQGLHVHQEHLGHQ.ODXVHOQEHQDQQWH'HVLGHUDWVWHKWGDPLWKLQWHUGHQ EHLGHQP|JOLFKHQ,PSHUDWLYIRUPHQ:DVVLFKLP)DOOK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,P SHUDWLYH DOV :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH LQ EH]XJ DXI GHQ DOV ULFKWLJ HUNDQQWHQ0LW WHOHLQVDW]]XHLQHPVHOEVWJHVHW]WHQ=ZHFNlXHUQNDQQNDQQVLFKLP)DOO GHVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVDOV:LOOHQVVFKZlFKH LQEH]XJDXIHLQHDOV VLWWOLFKHUDFKWHWH+DQGOXQJlXHUQ 'LH'LIIHUHQ]GHU,PSHUDWLYHEH]LHKWVLFKZLHEHUHLWVEHPHUNWDXIGLH XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ %HVWLPPXQJVJUQGH ]X HLQHU +DQGOXQJ ZlKUHQG GLH 1RUPDWLYLWlWK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHDQGLHDOVJOWLJXQWHUVWHOOWHNRQ NUHWH =ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQ VRZLH HLQHQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ ZLOONUOLFK JH VHW]WHQ =ZHFN JHEXQGHQ LVW OLHJW GHU %HVWLPPXQJVJUXQG PRUDOLVFKHU +DQGOXQJHQLQGHUÅ$FKWXQJIUVPRUDOLVFKH*HVHW]´HLQHU6HOEVWDFK WXQJGHU9HUQXQIWGHUÅ$FKWXQJIUVHLQHLJHQHV:HVHQ´GKGLH9HU QXQIWGHUHLJHQHQXQGGHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQHQ 'LHJHPHLQVDPH:XU]HODOOHU,PSHUDWLYHGLH%HGLQJXQJGHU0|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
_____________ .DQW,9 9JO ]X .DQWV 6NDOD P|JOLFKHU :LOOHQVVFKZlFKHQ *HEUHFKOLFKNHLW 8QODXWHUNHLW %|VDUWLJNHLW XQWHQ .DQW9 YJODXFK,9 .DQW9, 5DLOWRQEHUVLHKWLQVHLQHU$QDO\VH XQGLQJHZLVVHU+LQVLFKW$VVLPLOLH UXQJ GHU.RQ]HSWHQRUPDWLYHU.UDIWEHL+XPHXQG.DQWGDIU.DQWÅ$FKWXQJ´ ]ZDU GHU %HVWLPPXQJVJUXQG PRUDOLVFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ QLFKW DEHU GHU *UXQG SUDNWL VFKHU5DWLRQDOLWlWLVWXQGVHLQNDQQGHQQ$FKWXQJLVWOHGLJOLFKGLHÄ$QWZRUW¶DXIGDV IUHL EHVWLPPWH G K VHOEVWJHVHW]WH 6ROOHQ GHU 0RUDOLWlW :HQQ ZLH .DQW VFKUHLEW ÅGDV PRUDOLVFKH *HVHW] $FKWXQJ DXIHUOHJW´ .DQW 9 GDQQ EHGHXWHW GLHV DXFK GDZLULP%HZXWVHLQGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVGLHVHP]XZLGHUKDQGHOQN|QQHQ$FKWXQJ NDQQIU.DQWQLFKWDOVÅDNLQGRIGLUHFWOLNLQJDNLQWRWKHH[SHULHQFHRIWKHVXEOLPH´ 5DLOWRQ GHQ*UXQGPRUDOLVFKHU*HVHW]HDXVPDFKHQ .DQWEHWRQWGLHVPLW DOOHU ZQVFKHQVZHUWHQ 'HXWOLFKNHLW Å'LHVHV *HIKO XQWHU GHP 1DPHQ GHV PRUDOL VFKHQ LVW DOVR OHGLJOLFK GXUFK 9HUQXQIW EHZLUNW (V GLHQW QLFKW ]X %HXUWKHLOXQJ GHU +DQGOXQJHQRGHUZRKOJDU]XU*UQGXQJGHVREMHFWLYHQ6LWWHQJHVHW]HVVHOEVWVRQ GHUQ EORV ]XU 7ULHEIHGHU XP GLHVHV LQ VLFK ]XU 0D[LPH ]X PDFKHQ´ .DQW 9 9JO]XU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW.DQWV$FKWXQJVNRQ]HSWXQWHQ.DS
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
UDWLYVGLH%HJUQGXQJLQHLQHUP|JOLFKHQDOOJHPHLQHQ*HVHW]JHEXQJGK GLH9HUQQIWLJNHLWGHU+DQGOXQJHQEHVWHKWLQGHPYRQ.DQWIHVWJHVHW]WHQ :HUWGHV,QWHOOLJLEOHQ(LQHZHLWHUH)UDJHÅZR]X"´ZlUHIU.DQWLQGLH VHP .RQWH[W DEZHJLJ ² ODSLGDU KHLW HV EHUHLWV LQ GHU *UXQGOHJXQJ ÅGLH YHUQQIWLJH 1DWXU H[LVWLUW DOV =ZHFN DQ VLFK VHOEVW´ 8QG LP =XVDP PHQKDQJ GHU Å'HGXFWLRQ GHV REHUVWHQ 3ULQFLSV GHU 0RUDOLWlW´ HUNOlUW .DQW Å:HLO DEHU GLH 9HUVWDQGHVZHOW GHQ *UXQG GHU 6LQQHQZHOW PLWKLQ DXFK GHU *HVHW]HGHUVHOEHQHQWKlOW>@VRZHUGHLFKPLFKDOV,QWHOOLJHQ]REJOHLFKDQ GHUHUVHLWVZLHHLQ]XU6LQQHQZHOWJHK|ULJHV:HVHQGHQQRFKGHP*HVHW]H GHU HUVWHUHQ G L GHU 9HUQXQIW GLH LQ GHU ,GHH GHU )UHLKHLW GDV *HVHW] GHUVHOEHQ HQWKlOW XQG DOVR GHU $XWRQRPLH GHV :LOOHQV XQWHUZRUIHQ HU NHQQHQ>@´ 'HU,QGLNDWLYGHVQXQPHKUIDFKJHQDQQWHQ.ODPPHUDXVGUXFNVLPLQ VWUXPHQWHOOHQ.RQWH[W ÅVRIHUQGLH9HUQXQIWDXIVHLQH+DQGOXQJHQHQW VFKHLGHQGHQ(LQIOXKDW´ HUKHEWXQVDOVRDXVGHU6SKlUHEORLQVWLQNWL YHQ9HUKDOWHQVLQGLH6SKlUHSUDNWLVFKHU1RUPDWLYLWlWXQGVFKDIIWGDPLW HLQHQhEHUJDQJYRPQDWXUDOHQ*HVFKHKHQ]XU9HUELQGOLFKNHLWUDWLRQDOHU .RQVHTXHQ] GHU .RQMXQNWLY GHV .ODPPHUDXVGUXFNV LP PRUDOLVFKHQ .RQWH[W ÅZHQQ 9HUQXQIW YROOH *HZDOW EHU GDV %HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQ KlWWH´ KLQJHJHQEH]HLFKQHWJHUDGHGLHREHUH*UHQ]HGLHVHU6SKlUHGLH ]XYHUODVVHQXQVHQGOLFKHQ:HVHQHEHQXQP|JOLFKLVW'HQQGLH7DWVDFKH GD ZLU NHLQHQ DEVROXWJXWHQ :LOOHQ EHVLW]HQ REMHNWLYHV XQGVXEMHNWLYHV 3ULQ]LSGHV:ROOHQVEHLXQVDOVRQLFKWSHUVHLGHQWLVFKVLQGPDUNLHUWKLHU GHQhEHUJDQJYRP3UDNWLVFKHQ*HVHW]]XP.DWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLY'LH 6SKlUH SUDNWLVFKHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW LVW GDPLW HLQHUVHLWV EHJUHQ]W YRQ YHU QXQIWORVHP9HUKDOWHQXQGDQGHUHUVHLWVYRQGHUÅSUDNWLVFKH>Q@,GHH´HLQHU
_____________ .DQW,9 .DQW,9 .DQW,9I YJOXQWHQ)Q VRZLHGHQGD]XJHK|ULJHQ$EVDW]]XU3UREOHPDWLN GLHVHU'HGXNWLRQ .DQW,9 ,P6LQQHHLQHVVROFKHQhEHUJDQJVVSULFKW.DQWYRP0HQVFKHQDXFKYRQHLQHP7LHU ÅZHOFKHV 'LVFLSOLQ Q|WKLJ KDW´ $QWKURSRORJLH3DURZ YRQ ;;9 YJO DXFK5HIOH[LRQ;9 9JODXFK.DQWV'HILQLWLRQHLQHVYRUEHJULIIOLFKHQ%H JHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQV LQ GHQ 9RUDUEHLWHQ ]XU 7XJHQGOHKUH Å1DWXUWULHE LQVWLQFW LVW HLQ %HVWLPXQJVJUXQG GHV %HJHKUHQV YRQ HWZDV YRU DOOHU .HQQWQLV GHV *HJHQVWDQGHV 'XUVW+XQJHU*HVFKOHFKWVWULHE ´ .DQW;;,,, VRZLHLP*HJHQVDW]]XP,Q VWLQNW.DQWV'HILQLWLRQGHV:LOOHQVDOVHLQHVÅ%HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQ>V@VRIHUQHVQXU GXUFK%HJULIIHGLGHU9RUVWHOOXQJHLQHV=ZHFNVJHPl]XKDQGHOQEHVWLPPEDULVW´ .DQW9 YJODXFK9 VRZLH9, .DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
8QEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQXQGGLH%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ
Å+HLOLJNHLW GHV :LOOHQV´ ([DNW ]ZLVFKHQ GLHVHQ EHLGHQ *UHQ]HQ ]XP EOR9HJHWDWLYHQXQG$QLPDOLVFKHQHLQHUVHLWVXQG]XP*|WWOLFKHQDQGH UHUVHLWVEHILQGHWVLFKGLH6SKlUHPHQVFKOLFKHU9HUQXQIWGLH.DQWLP.RQWH[W SUDNWLVFKHU 3KLORVRSKLH GXUFK GDV DXVVFKOLHOLFK KLHU ]X ILQGHQGH 6ROOHQ NHQQ]HLFKQHW
_____________ .DQW9 =XU :HLWHUEHVWLPPXQJ GLHVHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW PWH PDQ LP 6LQQH .DQWV VHOEVWYHU VWlQGOLFK GLH Å.DWHJRULHQ GHU )UHLKHLW´ .DQW 9 EHUFNVLFKWLJHQ (LQH 9HUELQ GXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHUMHZHLOLJHQQRUPDWLYHQ.UDIWP|JOLFKHU,PSHUDWLYHXQGGLHVHQ.D WHJRULHQ GHU )UHLKHLW VWHOOW %RE]LHQ KHU Å:LH GXUFK GLH .DWHJRULHQ GHU 1DWXU GDV 0DQQLJIDOWLJH GHU VLQQOLFKHQ $QVFKDXXQJHQ XQWHU GLH (LQKHLW GHV DSULRULVFKHQ %H ZXWVHLQVÄLFKGHQNH¶JHEUDFKWZLUGVRZLUG>@GXUFKGLH.DWHJRULHQGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIWGDV0DQQLJIDOWLJHGHU%HJHKUXQJHQXQWHUGLH (LQKHLWGHV DSULRULVFKHQ%H ZXWVHLQV ÄLFK VROO WXQ ¶ E]Z ÄLFK ZLOO DOV YHUQQIWLJ WXQ ¶ JHEUDFKW ZREHL GLHVHV %HZXWVHLQLQGHUHUVWHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJXQWHUGHP$VSHNWÄHLQHULPPRUDOLVFKHQ*H VHW]HJHELHWHQGHQ9HUQXQIW¶LQGHU]ZHLWHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJXQWHUGHP$VSHNWÄHLQHVUHL QHQ:LOOHQVDSULRUL¶ 9 JHVHKHQZLUG´ %RE]LHQ $OOHDEVLFKWV YROOHQ+DQGOXQJHQDOVRDOOGDVMHQLJHZDVHQWZHGHU*HJHQVWDQGHLQHVK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ RGHUGHVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVVHLQNDQQNDQQDXVGHU3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHV6ROOHQV E]ZHLQHVYHUQQIWLJHQ:ROOHQVEHWUDFKWHWZHUGHQ%RE]LHQLVWQXQGHU$XIIDVVXQJ GDQDFK.DQWIUPRUDOLVFKH+DQGOXQJHQLPHQJHUHQ6LQQHDXFK0RGDOLWlWVNDWHJR ULHQHUIRUGHUWZHUGHQZlKUHQGIU*HJHQVWlQGHGHULQVWUXPHQWHOOHQE]ZSUXGHQWLHO OHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW GLH HUVWHQ GUHL .DWHJRULHQWLWHO GHU 4XDQWLWlW 4XDOLWlW XQG 5HODWLRQ DXVUHLFKHQ Å,QGLHVHP)DOOHEOHLEWGHQ.DWHJRULHQGHU*UXSSHQELVGLH)XQNWLRQ +DQGOXQJHQDOV:LUNXQJHQYRQ=ZHFNVHW]XQJHQ]XHUNOlUHQ'DVKHLWGLH.DWHJRULHQ GLHQHQLQGLHVHP)DOOHQLFKWGD]XHLQH+DQGOXQJDOVSUDNWLVFKHJHOWXQJVGLIIHUHQW]X EHVWLPPHQVRQGHUQGD]XHLQH$QWZRUWDXIGLH WKHRUHWLVFKH )UDJH]XHUP|JOLFKHQ ZDUXP KDW GLHVHV RGHU MHQHV Ä1DWXUHUHLJQLV¶ +DQGOXQJ VWDWWJHIXQGHQ" +LHU]X OLHIHUQ GLH.DWHJRULHQGHQ%HJULIIGHV:RKOV>@VRZLHGHQ%HJULIIGHV1W]OLFKHQ>@´ (EG 'RFK%RE]LHQV$XIWHLOXQJGHU.DWHJRULHQJUXSSHQXQGGDPLWLKUH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ GHUSUDNWLVFKHQ.DWHJRULHQLQVJHVDPWIKUHQLQHLQH6FKZLHULJNHLWKLQVLFKWOLFKGHURE MHNWLYHQ 5HDOLWlW LQVWUXPHQWHOOHU 9HUQXQIW Å'HU YRQ .DQW LP .DWHJRULHQDEVFKQLWW GXUFKZHJEHWRQWH %H]XJGHU.DWHJRULHQGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWDXIGLHIUHLH :LOO NU ZLH DXFK VFKRQ GLH %HQHQQXQJ GLHVHU .DWHJRULHQ DOV Ä.DWHJRULHQ GHU )UHLKHLW¶ ]HLJHQGD.DQWKLHUQXUGLH PRUDOLVFK SUDNWLVFKH)XQNWLRQGHU.DWHJRULHQEHKDQ GHOW ²XQG DXFK QXU IU GLHVH )XQNWLRQ GHU .DWHJRULHQ ZXUGH GLHREMHNWLYH 5HDOLWlW EHZLHVHQ$QGUHUVHLWVPXHLQHWKHRUHWLVFKH(UNOlUXQJGHU+DQGOXQJHQDOV(UVFKHL QXQJHQVWHWVSULQ]LSLHOODXFKP|JOLFKVHLQGDPLWGHU.DXVDO]XVDPPHQKDQJLQQHUKDOE GHUÄ(UVFKHLQXQJVZHOW¶QLFKWGXUFKEURFKHQZLUG´ (EG 'LH.RQVHTXHQ]DXVGLHVHU ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQLVWDEHUGDGLHHUVWHQGUHL.DWHJRULHQJUXSSHQNHLQHREMHNWLYH5HDOLWlW KDEHQVRODQJHVLHQLFKWDXIPRUDOLVFKHGKJXWHE|VH+DQGOXQJHQDQJHZDQGWZHU GHQ 'DPLW KDEHQ VLH DEHU GLH YRQ %RE]LHQ YHUDQVFKODJWH Å1HEHQIXQNWLRQ >@ DOV WKHRUHWLVFKH RGHU WHFKQLVFKSUDNWLVFKH %HJULIIH´ HEG JHUDGH QLFKW GHQQ LKUH GLHV EH]JOLFKH *HOWXQJ EHGUIWH HLQHU HLJHQHQ WUDQV]HQGHQWDOHQ 'HGXNWLRQ /HW]WHUHV ZLUG YRQ %RE]LHQ QLFKW LQ (UZlJXQJ JH]RJHQ +DQGOXQJHQ GHUHQ WHFKQLVFK SUDNWLVFKH %HWUDFKWXQJ QLFKW EOR HLQ 'XUFKJDQJVVWDGLXP ]XU PRUDOLVFK JHOWXQJVYDULDQWHQ%HWUDFKWXQJGDUVWHOOW ]%GDV6FKXKHELQGHQ N|QQWHQQDFK%RE
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
-HQVHLWVGHUIU.DQW]ZHLIHOORVJHZLFKWLJHQ'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQK\SR WKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYHQ XQG GHP NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY EH]JOLFK GHU PDWHULDOHQ E]Z IRUPDOHQ %HVWLPPXQJVJUQGH ]X HLQHU +DQGOXQJ JUQ GHQ EHLGH )RUPHQ LQ GHP .DQWLVFKHQ *UXQGVDW] GD GHU %HJULII GHV 6ROOHQVGHQ%HJULIIGHU9HUQXQIWYRUDXVVHW]W DXVGUFNOLFKQLFKWPLWGLH VHP LGHQWLVFK LVW ZLH .DQWV QRPLQDOH (LQIKUXQJ GHV KHLOLJHQ :LOOHQV ]HLJW 'LH ÅSUDNWLVFKH>«@ %HVWLPPXQJ GHV 0HQVFKHQ´ VHLQH $XV ]HLFKQXQJ JHJHQEHU DEVROXWHU 6LQQOLFKNHLW XQG DEVROXWHU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW VRZLHVHLQH$XIJDEHGHUÅ%HI|UGHUXQJGHVK|FKVWHQ*XWV´ EH]LHKWVLFK GDPLWZHVHQWOLFKDXIGHQ$SSHOODQVHLQHYHUQQIWLJH:LOOHQVEHVWLPPXQJ ²LP)DOOK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHGDV:ROOHQGHUDOVDGlTXDWHUNDQQWHQ 0LWWHO]XPKDQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYHQ:ROOHQ]XPDFKHQLP)DOOGHVNDWHJRUL VFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVGDVVXEMHNWLYH3ULQ]LSGHV:ROOHQVLQ(LQNODQJ]XEULQ JHQPLWGHPREMHNWLYHQ3ULQ]LSGHV:ROOHQV'LHVHU$SSHOOGHU9HUQXQIW GHQ HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOX DXI XQVHUH +DQGOXQJHQ ]X JHVWDWWHQ G K 9HUQXQIW]XUHDOLVLHUHQLVWP|JOLFKZHLOGHU0HQVFKVLFKNUDIWVHLQHU$XWR QRPLHEHUVHLQHVLQQOLFKHQ$IIHNWLRQHQKLQZHJVHW]HQNDQQXQGLQVRIHUQ HLQ*OLHGGHU9HUVWDQGHVZHOWLVW GLHVHU$SSHOOLVWDEHU]XJOHLFKDXFKQ|WLJ ZHLOGHU0HQVFKQLFKWQDWXUJHPlULFKWLJKDQGHOWVRQGHUQGXUFK+HWHUR QRPLHÄEHGURKW¶LVWXQGLQVRIHUQHLQ*OLHGGHU6LQQHQZHOWLVW 'HU0HQVFKLVW.DQW]XIROJH L HLQGHUhEHUOHJXQJIlKLJHVDOVRUDWL RQDOHV :HVHQ LL HLQ KHWHURQRPHV XQG LLL ]XJOHLFK DXWRQRPHV :HVHQ (UVW GLH V\QWKHWLVFKH (LQKHLW GHU OHW]WHQ EHLGHQ $VSHNWH ² +HWHURQRPLH XQG$XWRQRPLHYHUHLQW²HUJLEWGHQ%HJULIIGHV6ROOHQV
_____________
]LHQV,QWHUSUHWDWLRQQLFKWHLQPDOLPYROOHQ:RUWVLQQH+DQGOXQJHQVHLQZHLOGLHGD]X HUIRUGHUOLFKHREMHNWLYH5HDOLWlWGHU.DWHJRULHQJUXSSHQELVQLFKWJHVLFKHUWLVW $XV V\VWHPDUFKLWHNWRQLVFKHU 3HUVSHNWLYH VWHOOW IU .DQW GLH IU EHLGH ,PSHUDWLYIRU PHQNRQVWLWXWLYH+HWHURQRPLHGHQ*UXQGGDIUGDUGDGLH0RUDOSKLORVRSKLHQLFKW 7HLOGHU7UDQV]HQGHQWDOSKLORVRSKLHLVWÅ>@ZHLOVLHGLH%HJULIIHGHU/XVWXQG8QOXVW GHU%HJLHUGHQXQG1HLJXQJHQHWFGLHLQVJHVDPPWHPSLULVFKHQ8UVSUXQJVVLQG]ZDU VHOEVWQLFKW]XP*UXQGHLKUHU9RUVFKULIWHQOHJHQDEHUGRFKLP%HJULIIHGHU3IOLFKW DOV +LQGHUQL GDV EHUZXQGHQ RGHU DOV $QUHL] GHU QLFKW ]XP %HZHJXQJVJUXQGH JHPDFKWZHUGHQVROOQRWKZHQGLJLQGLH$EIDVVXQJGHV6\VWHPVGHUUHLQHQ6LWWOLFKNHLW PLWKLQHLQ]LHKHQPVVHQ´ .U9% YJODXFK$I ,QZLHIHUQDXFKGDVPRUDOL VFKH*HIKOGHU$FKWXQJQDFK.DQWQXUHPSLULVFKHUNDQQWZHUGHQNDQQREZRKOHV VHOEVW DOV :LUNXQJ GHU 9HUQXQIW YHUVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ VROO VROO LQ .DS XQWHUVXFKW ZHUGHQ .DQW9 .DQW9 'LHVH 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ HUP|JOLFKW XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU )UDJH QDFK GHP 6WDWXV GHU YHUVFKLHGHQHQ,PSHUDWLYHLQ.DQWV6SlWSKLORVRSKLH YJOREHQ)Q HLQH,GHQWLIL NDWLRQ VHLQHU NULWLVFKHQ 0RUDOSKLORVRSKLH PLW VSlWHUHQ $XVIKUXQJHQ LQVRIHUQ GLH GUHL HEHQ DQJHIKUWHQ (OHPHQWH +HWHURQRPLH 5DWLRQDOLWlW XQG $XWRQRPLH PLW GHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQGGHUPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLV
3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQGGHUPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLV
3UREOHPDWLVFK DQ .DQWV .RQ]HSWLRQ SUDNWLVFKHU 9HUQXQIW LVW ZLH GLH YHUJDQJHQHQ ]ZHLKXQGHUW -DKUH NULWLVFKHU $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ GDPLW JH ]HLJWKDEHQXQWHUDQGHUHPGHU6WDWXVGHV,QWHOOLJLEOHQDOVÅ*UXQGGHU6LQ QHQZHOWPLWKLQDXFKGHU*HVHW]HGHUVHOEHQ´ $XFKZHQQ.DQWLQGHU.ULWLNGHU SUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWQLFKWPHKUDQHLQHUÅ'HGXFWLRQGHVREHUVWHQ3ULQFLSV GHU 0RUDOLWlW´ IHVWKlOW GLH KLHU DQJHVSURFKHQH %HJUQGXQJVUHODWLRQ LVW
_____________ (OHPHQWHQGHU%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQNRUUHOLHUHQGLH.DQWLQGHU5HOLJLRQVVFKULIW DOVÅ7LHUKHLW´Å0HQVFKKHLW´XQGÅ3HUV|QOLFKNHLW´EH]HLFKQHW 9, YJOGD]XDXFK REHQ)Q2·1HLOO KDW]X5HFKWGDUDXIYHUZLHVHQGD.DQW XQG]ZDU PLW%OLFNDXI7KHRULHXQG3UD[LV GLH9HUQXQIWQLFKWDOVHLQHQ%HUHLFKDXIIDWLQGHQ XQWHUDQGHUHP GLH$XWRQRPLHIlOOW Å5HDVRQWKHGLVFLSOLQHRIDOOGLVFLSOLQHVFDQRQ O\EHDQGPXVWEHVHOIGLVFLSOLQHG 7KHVXERUGLQDWLRQRIWKLQNLQJRUSUDFWLFHWRRWKHU VXSSRVHG DXWKRULWLHV >«@ LV QRW UHDVRQ EXW WKH DEURJDWLRQ RI UHDVRQ 5HDVRQ·V GLV FLSOLQH FDQQRW EH DOLHQ LW PXVW EH DXWRQRPRXV >«@ +H DUJXHV QRW IURP UHDVRQ WR DXWRQRP\ EXW IURP DXWRQRP\ WR UHDVRQ 2QO\ DXWRQRPRXV VHOIGLVFLSOLQLQJ EHLQJV FDQ DFW RQ SULQFLSOHV WKDW ZH KDYH JURXQGV WR FDOO SULQFLSOHV RI UHDVRQ´ 2·1HLOO ²'DVEHJULIIOLFKH3UREOHP9HUQXQIW5DWLRQDOLWlWZLUGV\VWHPDWLVFKLQ.DS XQWHUVXFKWZHUGHQ=XNXU]JUHLIWMHGRFK6WHLQYRUWKVVFKHLQEDUHLQGHXWLJH,GHQWLIL NDWLRQGHU0RUDOPLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIWVFKOHFKWKLQ Å:HQQZLUPRUDOLVFKKDQGHOQ IROJHQZLUQXU3ULQ]LSLHQGHUDOOJHPHLQHQ5DWLRQDOLWlW'LH*UQGHIUPRUDOLVFKHV+DQ GHOQVLQG*UQGHIUGDV+DQGHOQEHUKDXSW´ 6WHLQYRUWK YJOHEG 'LH3UREOHPDWLNGHV(LQIOXVVHVGHU9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUHLQVWUXPHQWHOOHQhEHUOHJXQ JHQZLUGGDPLWXQWHUVFKODJHQ9JOGD]XDXFKXQWHQ)Q²,QGHU$QWKURSRORJLHLQ SUDJPDWLVFKHU +LQVLFKW YRQ VFKOLHOLFK HUZHLWHUW .DQW GLH %HVWLPPXQJ GHV 0HQ VFKHQQRFKXPGHQ$VSHNWGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWE]ZGHU*DWWXQJ YJO9,, 0DQ PX]ZDU]XU.HQQWQLVQHKPHQGDGLHVH(UZHLWHUXQJQLFKWEHGHXWHWGD6R]LDOLWlW KLQVLFKWOLFK GHV 0HQVFKHQ GDPLW EHJULIIVNRQVWLWXWLYHQ &KDUDNWHU JHZ|QQH V\VWHPDUFKL WHNWRQLVFK WULWW GLH Å$QWKURSRORJLH LQ SUDJPDWLVFKHU $EVLFKW´ 9,, GDV (UEH GHU SKLORVRSKLVFK LUUHOHYDQWHQ ÄSV\FKRORJLD HPSLULFD¶ DQ YJO DXFK ; 'RFK LVW GHP %HJULII YHUQQIWLJHU :HVHQ ² QLFKW GHP %HJULII GHV 0HQVFKHQ ² PLW %OLFN DXI HLQH P|JOLFKH DXWRQRPH *HVHW]JHEXQJ IU HLQ Ä5HLFK GHU =ZHFNH¶ VFKRQ YRQ GHU *UXQGOHJXQJ DQ HLQH ZHQQJOHLFK DEVWUDNWH LQWHUVXEMHNWLYH 'LPHQVLRQ HLQJHVFKULHEHQ YJOGD]X5HDWK .DQW,9 'LH HQWVSUHFKHQGH 'LIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ GHU *UXQGOHJXQJ XQG GHU .S9 EHVWHKW LQ IRO JHQGHP ZlKUHQG.DQWLQGHUHUVWHUHQHLQH'HGXNWLRQGHVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYV IUP|JOLFKKlOWXQGLPÅ'ULWWHQ$EVFKQLWW´VRJDUYRUOHJWVSULFKWHULQGHU.S9DQ GHU YHUJOHLFKEDUHQ V\VWHPDWLVFKHQ 6WHOOH YRP Å)DFWXP GHU UHLQHQ 9HUQXQIW GHVVHQ ZLUXQVDSULRULEHZXWVLQGXQGZHOFKHVDSRGLNWLVFKJHZLLVW´ .DQW9 8QG .DQWIlKUWKLHUIRUW Å$OVRNDQQGLHREMHFWLYH5HDOLWlWGHVPRUDOLVFKHQ*HVHW]HVGXUFK NHLQH 'HGXFWLRQ GXUFK DOOH $QVWUHQJXQJ GHU WKHRUHWLVFKHQ VSHFXODWLYHQ RGHU HPSLULVFK XQWHUVWW]WHQ9HUQXQIWEHZLHVHQ>@ZHUGHQXQGVWHKWGHQQRFKIUVLFKVHOEVWIHVW´ (EG +HUYRUKHEXQJHQ .3 %HPHUNEDU PDFKW VLFK GLHVHV )DNWXP QDFK .DQW LQ )RUPHLQHUÅ$FKWXQJIUV*HVHW]´GLHHUDXFKDOVÅGLH6LWWOLFKNHLWVHOEVWVXEMHNWLYDOV 7ULHEIHGHU EHWUDFKWHW´ EH]HLFKQHW 9 'LHVH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU $U
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
GDV*UXQGWKHRUHPVHLQHVWUDQV]HQGHQWDOHQ,GHDOLVPXVYRQGHPHUQDFK QLFKWZLHGHUDEJHUFNWLVW 'LHVHU :HUW GHV ,QWHOOLJLEOHQ OlW VLFK EHVVHU YHUVWHKHQ ZHQQ PDQ .DQWV JUXQGOHJHQGH 9RUVWHOOXQJ HLQHU $QDORJLH GHU 6LWWOLFKNHLW ]XU 1D WXUZLVVHQVFKDIW XQG LKUHQ *HVHW]HQ EHUFNVLFKWLJW (LQ HLQKHLWOLFK EH VFKUHLEEDUHV9HUKDOWHQYRQ.|USHUQLQHLQHPEHVWLPPWHQ6\VWHPLVWQXU XQWHUGHU%HGLQJXQJHLQHUDOOJHPHLQHQ*HVHW]PlLJNHLWP|JOLFK IU.DQW LVW HV SDUDGLJPDWLVFK GDV YRQ 1HZWRQLVFKHU *HVHW]PlLJNHLW UHJLHUWH 6RQQHQV\VWHP(LQHVROFKH*HVHW]PlLJNHLWZLHGHUXPLVWQXUGDQQP|J OLFK ZHQQ DOOH HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ .|USHU DOV GLHVHU *HVHW]PlLJNHLW XQWHU ZRUIHQYRUJHVWHOOWZHUGHQ0LWHLQHP%OLFNDXIGLHDQGHUH6HLWHGHU$QD ORJLH N|QQWH PDQ PHWDSKRULVFK GLH Ä$XIIRUGHUXQJ¶ DQ HLQHQ .|USHU VR IRUPXOLHUHQ Ä*HKRUFKH GHQ 1HZWRQLVFKHQ *HVHW]HQ %HZHJH 'LFK VR GDGLH.UDIW'HLQHU%HZHJXQJPLWGHQ JUDYLWDWLYHQ .UlIWHQDOOHUDQGH UHQ.|USHUQLP6\VWHP]XVDPPHQVWLPPHQ¶1XUXQWHU%HIROJXQJGLHVHU Ä$XIIRUGHUXQJ¶ LVW HLQ HLQKHLWOLFK EHVFKUHLEEDUHV 9HUKDOWHQ GHU .|USHU P|JOLFK
_____________ JXPHQWDWLRQGHU*UXQGOHJXQJXQGGHUMHQLJHQGHU.S9LVWIUPHLQH=LHOVHW]XQJMHGRFK QLFKW]HQWUDOGDGLHKLQWHUGHU'HGXNWLRQGHU*UXQGOHJXQJVWHKHQGHRQWRORJLVFKH3Ul YDOHQ]GHU9HUQXQIWYRUGHU6LQQOLFKNHLWHLQH.RQVWDQWHLP.DQWLVFKHQ*HVDPWZHUN DXVPDFKW:DV.DQWKLQWHUVLFKJHODVVHQKDWLVWOHGLJOLFKHLQJHZLVVHU,QWHOOHNWX DOLVPXVLQSUDNWLVFKHU+LQVLFKW ÅWKHRUHWLVFKH´RGHUÅVSHFXODWLYH´9HUQXQIWYRQGHU HULPHEHQDQJHIKUWHQ=LWDWVSULFKWZUGHGLH*UHQ]HQLKUHV7HUUDLQVEHUVFKUHLWHQ ZHQQVLHHLQSUDNWLVFKHV*HVHW]]XEHZHLVHQYHUVXFKWHGHVVHQ:HVHQHRLSVRQLFKW WKHRUHWLVFKLVW9JO]XGLHVHU'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHQ.DQWLVFKHQ:HUNHQYRQ XQGDXFK+HQULFK IXQG6FK|QHFNHU LQVEHV 'DV3HQGDQW]XUSUDNWLVFKHQ3UlYDOHQ]GHV,QWHOOLJLEOHQYRUGHP6HQVLEOHQLVWLQGHU WKHRUHWLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHGHU*UXQGVDW] ÅGHU9HUVWDQGVFK|SIWVHLQH*HVHW]H DSUL RUL QLFKWDXVGHU1DWXUVRQGHUQVFKUHLEWVLHGLHVHUYRU´ .DQW,9 'LHVHHSLV WHPRORJLVFKH 6LFKWZHLVH GHU 3DUDOOHOH ]ZLVFKHQ WKHRUHWLVFKHU XQG SUDNWLVFKHU 3KLOR VRSKLH LVW DXI GLH LQWHOOLJLEOH *HVHW]OLFKNHLW LP 6HQVLEOHQ IRNXVVLHUW 'LH DOWHUQDWLYH 6LFKWZHLVHEHWRQWGHQRQWRORJLVFKHQ%HJUQGXQJVVWDWXVGHULQWHOOLJLEOHQ:HOW 'LQJH DQVLFK PLW%OLFN DXIGLHVHQVLEOH:HOW (UVFKHLQXQJHQ +LQVLFKWOLFKGHUV\VWHPDWL VFKHQ$WWUDNWLYLWlWWHQGLHUHLFK]XUPHWDSK\VLVFKVSDUVDPHUHQHUVWHQ6LFKWZHLVHGK ]X $OOLVRQV Ä=ZHL$VSHNWH7KHRULH¶ XQG JHJHQ $GLFNHV· Ä7KHRULH GHU GRSSHOWHQ$IIHNWLRQ¶%HLGH6LFKWZHLVHQMHGRFKKDEHQVWDUNH7H[WDUJXPHQWHIUXQG JHJHQVLFKXQGLQVEHVRQGHUHPLW%OLFNDXIGLHSRVLWLYQRXPHQDOH*HVHW]JHEXQJGHU )UHLKHLWLP3UDNWLVFKHQEHVLW]WOHW]WHUH9RUWHLOHJHJHQEHUGHUHUVWHUHQ 9JOGD]X.DQW99,X|
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQGGHUPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLV
6LWWOLFKHV+DQGHOQDOVHLQHLQKHLWOLFKEHJHKUHQVZHUWHV 9HUKDOWHQLQ WHQWLRQDOHU6XEMHNWH²RGHU.DQWLVFK :LOOHQ LP3OXUDO ZREHLLKUH 8Q +HLOLJNHLWQRFKQLFKWDXVJHPDFKWLVW²LVWQXUXQWHUGHU%HGLQJXQJHLQHU DOOJHPHLQHQ *HVHW]PlLJNHLW P|JOLFK (LQH VROFKH *HVHW]PlLJNHLW ZLH GHUXPLVWQXUGDQQP|JOLFKZHQQDOOH:LOOHQDOVGLHVHUVLWWOLFKHQ*HVHW] PlLJNHLW XQWHUZRUIHQ YRUJHVWHOOW ZHUGHQ 'LH $XIIRUGHUXQJ DQ HLQHQ HQGOLFKHQ :LOOHQ ODXWHW GHPHQWVSUHFKHQG Ä*HKRUFKH GHP 6LWWHQJHVHW] +DQGOH VR GD GLH 0D[LPH 'HLQHU +DQGOXQJ PLW GHQ 0D[LPHQ DOOHU +DQGHOQGHQ ]XVDPPHQVWLPPHQ NDQQ¶ 1XU XQWHU %HIROJXQJ GLHVHU $XI IRUGHUXQJLVWHLQHLQKHLWOLFKEHJHKUHQVZHUWHV9HUKDOWHQGHU:LOOHQLQVJH VDPWP|JOLFK 'LH 'LIIHUHQ] GHU HEHQ GDUJHVWHOOWHQ $QDORJLH ]ZLVFKHQ QDWUOLFKHU XQGVLWWOLFKHU*HVHW]PlLJNHLWEH]LHKWVLFKGDUDXIGDLPHUVWHQ)DOOHLQH $XIIRUGHUXQJVLQQORVLVWZHLO.|USHUGHUSK\VLNDOLVFKHQ*HVHW]PlLJNHLW VFKOLFKWZHJ XQWHUZRUIHQ VLQG E]Z DOV VROFKH YRUJHVWHOOW ZHUGHQ ZlK UHQGLP]ZHLWHQ)DOOGLH$XIIRUGHUXQJVLQQYROOLVWZHLOGHU:LOOHVLWWOLFKHQ *HVHW]HQQXUGDGXUFKXQWHUOLHJWGDHUVLHDOV$XWRULWlWGHUHUHQWVSUH FKHQNDQQXQGVROODEHUQLFKWHQWVSUHFKHQPXDQHUNHQQW'LH'LIIHUHQ] EH]LHKWVLFKGDPLWDXIGLH%HVFKUHLEXQJHQGHVVHQZDVLVWHLQHUVHLWVXQG GHVVHQZDVVHLQVROODQGHUHUVHLWVZLH.DQWLP$UFKLWHNWRQLN.DSLWHOGHU .U9DXVJHIKUWKDW Å'LH*HVHW]JHEXQJGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ9HUQXQIW 3KL ORVRSKLH KDWQXQ]ZHL*HJHQVWlQGH1DWXUXQG)UHLKHLWXQGHQWKlOWDOVR VRZRKOGDV1DWXUJHVHW]DOVDXFKGDV6LWWHQJHVHW]DQIDQJVLQ]ZHLEHVRQ GHUHQ]XOHW]WDEHULQHLQHPHLQ]LJHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ6\VWHP'LH3KLOR VRSKLHGHU1DWXUJHKWDXIDOOHVZDVGDLVWGLHGHU6LWWHQQXUDXIGDVZDV GDVHLQVROO´ :HQQ DEHU GHU PHQVFKOLFKH :LOOH QXU LQVRIHUQ DQ GHU LQWHOOLJLEOHQ :HOW WHLOKDEHQ NDQQ DOV HU VLWWOLFK HQWVFKHLGHW RGHU YRUVLFKWLJHU DOV HU VLFKIURGHUJHJHQHLQHVLWWOLFKH+DQGOXQJHQWVFKHLGHW GDQQILQGHQDOOH DQGHUHQ :LOOHQVHQWVFKHLGXQJHQ DXVVFKOLHOLFK LQ GHU VHQVLEOHQ :HOW VWDWW 'DQQ KDQGHOW HV VLFK EHL GLHVHQ DEHU DXFK QLFKW PHKU XP :LOOHQVHQW VFKHLGXQJHQGHQQGHU:LOOHLQHUVWHU3HUVRQ6LQJXODUGKGHUDSSHU]HS
_____________ 'HU$XVGUXFNÄEHJHKUHQVZHUW¶ZLUGYRQ.DQWV6\VWHPDWLNVHOEVWQDKHJHOHJWZHQQHU GLH YHUVFKLHGHQHQ *HPWVYHUP|JHQ GLIIHUHQ]LHUW Å:LU N|QQHQ DOOH 9HUP|JHQ GHV PHQVFKOLFKHQ*HPWKVRKQH$XVQDKPHDXIGLHGUHL]XUFNIKUHQ GDV(UNHQQWQL YHUP|JHQ GDV *HIKO GHU /XVW XQG 8QOXVW XQG GDV %HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQ´ .DQW ;;I 'HU XQHQGOLFKH RGHU J|WWOLFKH RGHU KHLOLJH :LOOH KLQJHJHQ ULFKWHW VLFK XQWHU DOOHQ %HGLQJXQJHQDXIGDVJHVHW]PlLJH9HUKDOWHQ VHLQHÄ1DWXU¶ LP6LQQHYRQÄ:HVHQ¶ LVW VLWWOLFKRULHQWLHUW YJOREHQ .U9$% YJO]XU$QDORJLH]ZLVFKHQ1DWXUXQG6LWWHQJHVHW]DXFK%UDQGW IVRZLH)ULHGPDQ0V
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
WLYH :LOOH NDQQ .DQWV .RQ]HSWLRQ JHPl QLFKW DOV HLQ UHLQHPSLULVFKHV 3KlQRPHQ DXIJHIDW ZHUGHQ (V UHVXOWLHUHQ NHLQH +DQGOXQJHQ VRQGHUQ EORH9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQXQGGHUÄHQWVFKHLGHQGH(LQIOXGHU9HUQXQIWDXI XQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQ¶IUGHQ.DQWHEHQDXFKLP.RQWH[WK\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYHDUJXPHQWLHUWKDWGRUWNHLQHQ*HJHQVWDQGPHKU1DFK.DQWLVW DOOHLQÅGDVPRUDOLVFKH*HVHW]>«@GLHUDWLRFRJQRVFHQGLGHU)UHLKHLW´ 'RFKGLHVH5HVWULNWLRQGHU$XWRQRPLHGHV:LOOHQVDXI6LWWOLFKNHLWPDFKW HV PHWDHWKLVFK XQP|JOLFK PHQVFKOLFKHV +DQGHOQ HQWODQJ GHU =ZHFN 0LWWHO5DWLRQDOLWlWDGlTXDW]XEHVFKUHLEHQ 0LWGLHVHP3UREOHPYHUEXQGHQLVWHLQHZHLWHUH6FKZLHULJNHLWGLHPLW GHUYRUVWHKHQGHQ$QDO\VHYRQ.DQWV.RQ]HSWLRQSUDNWLVFKHU1RUPDWLYL WlW VLFKWEDU ZHUGHQ VROOWH :HQQ .DQW GHQ HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOX GHU 9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQVRZRKOLPK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ DVVHUWRULVFK SUDJPDWLVFKHQ E]Z SUREOHPDWLVFKWHFKQLVFKHQ DOV DXFK LP NDWHJRULVFK PRUDOLVFKHQ .RQWH[W IRUGHUW GDQQ OLHJW LQ GLHVHP %HJULII GHU 9HUQXQIW HLQH 0HKUGHXWLJNHLW 'HU 9HUVWDQG PDJ IU GLH $EZlJXQJ GHU 0LWWHO ]XU 9HUIROJXQJHLQHV=ZHFNVYHUDQWZRUWOLFKVHLQGRFK.DQWOHJW:HUWGDUDXI GD GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGH (UNHQQWQLV QLFKW QRWZHQGLJ ]XU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ +DQGOXQJ IKUW :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH XQG VSULFKW GDKHU YRP HQWVFKHLGHQ GHQ(LQIOXGHU9HUQXQIWQLFKWQXULP.RQWH[WGHVNDWHJRULVFKHQVRQGHUQ H[SOL]LWXQGDXVVFKOLHOLFKDXFKLP.RQWH[WGHUK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWL YH .DQWKDWGHQ%HJULIIGHU9HUQXQIWLP9HUODXIVHLQHU.ULWLVFKHQ3KLOR VRSKLH²XQGYRUKDWHUGLHVHP%HJULIINHLQV\VWHPDWLVFKHV*HZLFKW EHLJHOHJW²GHUDUWXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKYHUZHQGHWGDPDQHLQHQZHLWHQ:HJ EHJULIIOLFKHU $XVVFKOXYHUIDKUHQ JHKHQ PWH XP VFKOLHOLFK JHQDX GDV ]XEH]HLFKQHQZRYRQLQ%H]XJDXIGLHJHQDQQWHQ.RQWH[WHGLH5HGHLVW 6RVSULFKW.DQWLP$UFKLWHNWRQLN.DSLWHOGHU.U9Å>«@YRQGHP3XQNWH >«@ ZR VLFK GLH DOOJHPHLQH :XU]HO XQVHUHU (UNHQQWQLNUDIW WKHLOW XQG ]ZHL 6WlPPH DXVZLUIW GHUHQ HLQHU 9HUQXQIW LVW ,FK YHUVWHKH KLHU DEHU XQWHU9HUQXQIWGDVJDQ]HREHUH(UNHQQWQLYHUP|JHQXQGVHW]HDOVRGDV
_____________ .DQW9 9JO]XGLHVHP3UREOHPDXFKGLH V\PSDWKHWLVFKHQ.DQW5HNRQVWUXNWLRQHQYRQ$OOL VRQ +LOO XQG2·1HLOO 'HU6FKZHUSXQNWGLHVHU ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQHQOLHJWMHGRFKDXIGHU9HUWHLGLJXQJ.DQWVJHJHQGHQ9RUZXUIGDNHL QHIUHLH+DQGOXQJPRUDOLVFKIDOVFKVHLQN|QQHZHLOHLQIUHLHU:LOOHXQGHLQ:LOOHXQ WHUPRUDOLVFKHQ*HVHW]HQQDFK.DQWHLQXQGGDVVHOEHVHL YJO.DQW,99 'LH%DVLVOLQLHGHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ9HUWHLGLJXQJEHVDJWGDHLQXQWHUPRUDOLVFKHQ*H VHW]HQ VWHKHQGHU :LOOH QLFKW lTXLYDOHQW PLW HLQHP PRUDOLVFK XQIHKOEDUHQ :LOOHQ LVW VRQGHUQOHGLJOLFKGDGLH+DQGOXQJHQHLQHVIUHLHQ:LOOHQHRLSVRDP6WDQGDUGPRUDOL VFKHU*HVHW]HJHPHVVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQGGHUPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLV
5DWLRQDOH GHP (PSLULVFKHQ HQWJHJHQ´ 9HUQXQIW RGHU GDV 5DWLRQDOH ZLUG KLHU DOVR GHU 6LQQOLFKNHLW JHJHQEHUJHVWHOOW ,Q GHU YRUDXVOLHJHQGHQ Å7UDQV]HQGHQWDOHQ $QDO\WLN´ KDWWH .DQW DEHU GLH 9HUQXQIW DOV 7HLO GHV ÅREHUHQ (UNHQQWQLYHUP|JHQ>V@´ GHQ EHLGHQ DQGHUHQ 9HUP|JHQ GHV 9HUVWDQGHV XQG GHU 8UWHLOVNUDIW EHLJHRUGQHW 'DUEHU KLQDXV XQWHUVFKHLGHW HU HLQH WKHRUHWLVFKH E]Z VSHNXODWLYH 9HUQXQIW YRQ HLQHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HU QXQIWLQQHUKDOEGHUOHW]WHUHQGLH9HUQXQIWYRQGHU1HLJXQJXQGLGHQ WLIL]LHUWVFKOLHOLFK XQWHU HEHQ GLHVHP%HJULII GHU 9HUQXQIW GDV Å9HUP| JHQ QDFK *UXQGVlW]HQ ]X XUWKHLOHQ XQG LQ SUDNWLVFKHU 5FNVLFKW ]X KDQGHOQ´ (V VFKHLQW PLU DQJHVLFKWV GLHVHU NRPSOL]LHUWHQ XQG G\QDPLVFKHQ 9HUP|JHQVNRQ]HSWLRQ .DQWV QLFKW JHUDWHQ GLH 0HKUGHXWLJNHLW GHV 9HU QXQIWEHJULIIVLQQHUKDOE.DQWV.RQ]HSWLRQSUDNWLVFKHU1RUPDWLYLWlWGXUFK GDV%HJULIIVSDDU9HUQXQIW NDWHJRULVFKHU,PSHUDWLY XQG9HUVWDQG K\SR WKHWLVFKH,PSHUDWLYH DXI]XO|VHQGDHEHQ]XYLHOHXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH'HQR WDWLRQHQ XQG .RQQRWDWLRQHQ GLHVHU %HJULIIH YRUOLHJHQ GDUEHU KLQDXV OHJWH HLQH VROFKH ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ HLQH VDFKOLFK YHUIHKOWH $VVLPLODWLRQ YRQ .DQWVNULWLVFKHU0RUDOSKLORVRSKLHDQVHLQHYRUNULWLVFKHQDKH=X5HFKW NRQVWDWLHUW &UDPHU GHVKDOE Å'LH Ä9HUQQIWLJNHLW¶ GHV :HVHQV GDV HLQHQ :LOOHQ KDW NDQQ >@ QLFKW PLW ÄUHLQHU SUDNWLVFKHU 9HUQXQIW¶ LGHQWLIL]LHUW ZHUGHQ $XFK GHU :LOOH GHU QLFKW GXUFK UHLQH SUDNWLVFKH 9HUQXQIW EH VWLPPWZLUGLVWLQVRIHUQÄQLFKWVDQGHUHVDOVSUDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIW¶DOVDXFK
_____________ .DQW.U9$ .DQW.U9$ YJODXFK9 9JO.DQW9I 9JO.DQW9I .DQW 9,, GHQ 9HUQXQIWEHJULII E]Z GLH )XQNWLRQHQ GLH JHPl GHU .ULWLN GHU UHLQHQ9HUQXQIWLP9HUQXQIWEHJULIIYHUHLQLJWZHUGHQKDW.DQWHUVWLP/DXIGHUHU -DKUH HQWZLFNHOW %DXP UHNRQVWUXLHUW GLHVH (QWZLFNOXQJ DOV .DQWV VHOEVWNULWL VFKHQ:HJYRPÅGRJPDWLVFKHQ5DWLRQDOLVPXV´GHU'LVVHUWDWLRQYRQ]XPÅNULWL VFKHQ 5DWLRQDOLVPXV´ GHU HUVWHQ .ULWLN )U GLH =HLW QDFK GHU HUVWHQ .ULWLN PDFKW %UDQGW I LPZHVHQWOLFKHQYLHU)XQNWLRQHQDP9HUQXQIWEHJULIIDXV L GDV 9HUP|JHQGHV6FKOLHHQVGDVGHQ9HUVWDQGXQGGLH8UWHLOVNUDIWDOVGLH9HUP|JHQGHU %HJULIIH XQG GHU 6XEVXPWLRQ GHV %HVRQGHUHQ XQWHU GDV $OOJHPHLQH XQWHU VLFK EH JUHLIW LL GDV 9HUP|JHQ GHU (UNHQQWQLVSULQ]LSLHQ ZHOFKHV GHQ 9HUVWDQG EHL VHLQHU (UNHQQWQLV OHLWHQ VROO LLL GHQ 8UVSUXQJ GHV =ZHFNEHJULIIV XQG ]ZDU VRZRKO PLW %OLFNDXIGLH1DWXUDOVDXFKDXIGDVPHQVFKOLFKH+DQGHOQXQG LY GDVLQGHU1DWXU OLHJHQGH 9HUP|JHQ GDV GHQ 0HQVFKHQ DOV 9HUQXQIWZHVHQ HUVW HUP|JOLFKW XQG HLQH 6LQQKDIWLJNHLWGHU0HQVFKKHLWVJHVFKLFKWHVWLIWHW 9JO]XGHQKLHUHLQVFKOlJLJHQKLVWRULVFKHQ'LIIHUHQ]HQ+HQULFK VRZLH GLH GHWDLOOLHUWH 8QWHUVXFKXQJ YRQ 6FKZDLJHU GHU LQVEHVRQGHUH GHQ (LQIOX %DXPJDUWHQVDXI.DQWV(WKLN(QWZLFNOXQJLQHLQGHXWOLFKHV/LFKWUFNW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DS².DQWXQGGLH(LQKHLWSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW
HU VHLQH +DQGOXQJHQ YRQ *HVHW]HQ DEOHLWHW´ 'LH 0HKUGHXWLJNHLW OLHJW GHPHQWVSUHFKHQG LQ .DQWV %HJULII HLQHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW DOV $GUHVVDW LQKDOWOLFK VHKU XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU )RUGHUXQJHQ ZLH DXFK +DPSWRQV )RU PXOLHUXQJ ² ÅWKH LQVWUXPHQWDO DQG QRW WKH PRUDO FRPSRQHQW RI UHD VRQµ²YHUGHXWOLFKW:DVJHQDXKDWPDQVLFKDEHUXQWHU.RPSRQHQWHQGHU 9HUQXQIW YRU]XVWHOOHQ" 'D VLFK ,PSHUDWLYH DXI GHQ (LQIOX SUDNWLVFKHU 9HUQXQIWLPHLQHQ)DOOXQGUHLQSUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIWLPDQGHUHQEH]LHKHQ VFKHLQW .DQWV 3UREOHP HKHU ]X EHQHQQHQ DOV ]X O|VHQ 8QG .DQW VHOEVW VLHKW HLQH VROFKH $EVWXIXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHP ÄUHLQHQ :LOOHQ¶ E]Z ÄUHLQ SUDNWLVFKHU 9HUQXQIW¶ XQG HLQHP ÄQLFKWUHLQHQ :LOOHQ¶ E]Z HLQHU ÄQLFKW UHLQSUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW¶ KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ PRUDOLVFKHP XQG LQVWUXPHQWHOOHP .RQWH[W DXVGUFNOLFK DXFK QLFKW YRU 'HQQ ZHQQ LP LQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ .RQWH[W GHU 9HUQXQIW DQVWDWW GHU 6LQQ OLFKNHLW GHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH(LQIOXJHVWDWWHWZLUGVRZLUGNOXJJHKDQGHOW ZRKLQJHJHQ GLH P|JOLFKH (LQVFKUlQNXQJ GLHVHV (LQIOXVVHV HEHQ JHUDGH QLFKW GHQ LQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ .RQWH[W FKDUDNWHULVLHUW VRQGHUQ GHQ 0HQ VFKHQ 'LH.OXIW]ZLVFKHQGHU=ZHFN0LWWHO5DWLRQDOLWlWXQGGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ 9HUQQIWLJNHLW EH]LHKW VLFK GDPLW QLFKW QXU QLFKW DXI GLH 'LIIHUHQ] ]ZL
_____________ &UDPHU I YJOGD]X.DQW,9 +DPSWRQ 9JO .DQW ,9 I Å%HVWLPPW DEHU GLH 9HUQXQIW IU VLFK DOOHLQ GHQ :LOOHQ QLFKW KLQOlQJOLFK LVW GLHVHU QRFK VXEMHFWLYHQ %HGLQJXQJHQ JHZLVVHQ 7ULHEIHGHUQ XQWHU ZRUIHQGLHQLFKWLPPHUPLWGHQREMHFWLYHQEHUHLQVWLPPHQ PLWHLQHP:RUWHLVWGHU :LOOHQLFKWDQVLFKY|OOLJGHU9HUQXQIWJHPl ZLHHVEHL0HQVFKHQZLUNOLFKLVW VRVLQG GLH+DQGOXQJHQGLHREMHFWLYDOVQRWKZHQGLJHUNDQQWZHUGHQVXEMHFWLY]XIlOOLJ>«@´ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 (LQH VROFKH $EVWXIXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHU ÄUHLQSUDNWLVFKHQ 9HU QXQIW¶ XQG HLQHU ÄQLFKWUHLQSUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW¶ KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQPRUDOLVFKHPXQGLQVWUXPHQWHOOHP.RQWH[WOHJW+DEHUPDVQDKH 9RQ GLHVHU .ULWLN DQ VHLQHU .DQW,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ EOHLEW VHLQH V\VWHPDWLVFKH 5HNRQ VWUXNWLRQGHU'LIIHUHQ]HQLP%HJULIIGHUÅSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW´VRZLHLPÅ.RQ]HSW GHV:LOOHQV´XQEHUKUW YJO+DEHUPDV 0HLQHV(UDFKWHQVNDQQDXFKGLH 9RUVWHOOXQJHLQHU6WHLJHUXQJGHUÄIUHLHQ:LOONU¶DOV([HNXWLRQVLQVWDQ]K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH]XHLQHUQRFKK|KHUHQ)RUPGHUÄIUHLHQ:LOONU¶DOV([HNXWLRQVLQVWDQ]GHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV GDV 3UREOHP QLFKW NOlUHQ ZLH 6WHLJOHGHU QDKH]XOHJHQ VFKHLQW ÅÄ)UHLH:LOONU¶NDQQEHL.DQW]ZHLHUOHLPHLQHQQlPOLFK HLQGXUFKSUDN WLVFKH P|JOLFKHUZHLVHDEHU QLFKW GXUFKUHLQHSUDNWLVFKH 9HUQXQIWEHVWLPPWHVE]Z EHVWLPPEDUHV%HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQ GDV%HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQHLQHV:HVHQVGDV UHLQH SUDNWLVFKH 9HUQXQIW EHVLW]W XQG VHLQH :LOONU HQWVSUHFKHQG EHVWLPPHQ NDQQ 'HU8QWHUVFKLHGEHVWHKWLQGHP6LQQLQGHPGLHDOVIUHLEH]HLFKQHWH:LOONUÄIUHL¶LVW ,PHUVWHQ)DOOLVWGLHÄ)UHLKHLW¶GHUÄIUHLHQ:LOONU¶HLQH P|JOLFKHUZHLVHEOR UHODWLYH >«@,P]ZHLWHQ)DOOPHLQWGLHÄ)UHLKHLW¶GHUÄIUHLHQ:LOONU¶GLH)UHLKHLWHLQHVYHUQQI WLJHQ 6LQQHQZHVHQV GDV GHU )UHLKHLW LP VWUHQJVWHQ XQG HLJHQWOLFKHQ 6LQQH IlKLJ LVW VHOEVWZHQQHVGLHVH)UHLKHLWQLFKWUHDOLVLHUW´ 6WHLJOHGHU
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQGGHUPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLV
VFKHQ9HUVWDQGXQG9HUQXQIWVRQGHUQDXFKQLFKWDXIGLH'LIIHUHQ]]ZL VFKHQ GHQ 9HUP|JHQ GHU 6LQQOLFKNHLW XQG GHU 9HUQXQIW E]Z GLH 'LIIH UHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ 1HLJXQJHQ XQG SUDNWLVFKHQ ,GHHQ 'HQQ ZLH GLH YRUVWH KHQGH $QDO\VH JH]HLJW KDW JHZLQQW GDV 3ULQ]LS GHU =ZHFN0LWWHO 5DWLRQDOLWlWVHLQH $XWRULWlW JHUDGH QLFKW DXV GHQ 1HLJXQJHQ VRQGHUQ DXV GHU9HUQXQIW GDVQRUPDWLYH3UREOHPLVWQLFKWGLH(UNHQQWQLVJHHLJQHWHU 0LWWHO ]XU5HDOLVLHUXQJ HLQHV JHJHEHQHQ =ZHFNV GDV QRUPDWLYH3UREOHP EHVWHKWYLHOPHKULQGHU+DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlWGLHVHU(UNHQQWQLVHEHQGHP ÄHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ(LQIOXGHU9HUQXQIW¶DXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQ8QGGLH VHU(LQIOXLVWHVDXFKGHUGLH:LOOHQVEHVWLPPXQJLPPRUDOLVFKHQ.RQ WH[W OHLWHQ VROO ZR .DQW GHP LQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ .RQWH[W DQDORJ YRQ GHU ÄYROOHQ*HZDOWGHU9HUQXQIWEHUGDV%HJHKUXQJVYHUP|JHQ¶VSULFKW 8P .DQWV 3RVWXODW GHU (LQKHLW GHU 9HUQXQIW DXIUHFKW]XHUKDOWHQ XQG GDPLW HLQH Ä6FKL]RSKUHQLH¶GHU 9HUQXQIW PLW EH]XJ DXI HLQHUVHLWVPRUDOL VFKHXQGDQGHUHUVHLWVDOOHDQGHUHQ+DQGOXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ ]X YHUKLQGHUQ VFKHLQW HV PLU JHUDWHQ $XWRQRPLH DOV QRWZHQGLJH %HGLQ JXQJGHU$QHUNHQQXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ²VHLHQGLHVHQXQ:QVFKH 1HLJXQJHQ RGHU DXFK PRUDOLVFKH 1RUPHQ ² DXI]XIDVVHQ .DQWV %HJULII GHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWYHUVWDQGHQDOVGHU*HVDPWXPIDQJPRUDOLVFKHU XQG QLFKWPRUDOLVFKHU :LOOHQVEHVWLPPXQJHQ VROOWH PLWKLOIH GHV %HJULIIV GHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHVRZLHGHUHQ5HODWLRQHQXQWHUHLQDQGHURSHUDWLRQDOL VLHUW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ LQGHP PDQ GLH QRUPDWLYH .UDIW YRQ +DQGOXQJV JUQGHQ JHQDXHU GHUHQ GHRQWLVFKH 5HLFKZHLWH EHVFKUHLEW $XI .DQWV PHWDSK\VLVFKH XQG SV\FKRORJLVFKH $QQDKPHQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU 6HHOHQ YHUP|JHQ VRZLH GHUHQ LPPHU VXEWLOHUH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJHQ GLH MHZHLOV HLQHQ =XJULII DXI XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH :HOWHQ EHVLW]HQ N|QQWH GHPHQWVSUH FKHQGYHU]LFKWHWZHUGHQ
_____________ 9JO.DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:38 PM
.DSLWHO +DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
(LQOHLWXQJ
%HL .DQW IXQJLHUWH GDV 3ULQ]LS ÅJHVWDWWH GHU 9HUQXQIW HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOX DXI GHLQH+DQGOXQJ´ QLFKW DOV NDWHJRULVFKHU,PSHUDWLY VRQGHUQ DOV%UFNHQSULQ]LS]ZLVFKHQGHPÅSUDNWLVFKH>Q@*HVHW]´DOVGHPÅREMHF WLYH>Q@ 3ULQFLS´ GHU 0RUDO XQG GHP NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY HLQHUVHLWV VRZLH DOV %UFNHQSULQ]LS ]ZLVFKHQ GHU =ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQ XQG GHP K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYDQGHUHUVHLWV :DVVLFKEHL.DQWDOVGHU.HUQSUDNWLVFKHU1RUPDWLYLWlWJH]HLJWKDW VFKHLQWQXQDXFKLP+LQWHUJUXQGHLQHUNRKlUHQWLVWLVFKRULHQWLHUWHQ+DQG OXQJVWKHRULH VWHKHQ ]X N|QQHQ =ZDU IRUPXOLHUHQ .RKlUHQWLVWHQ GLHVHV 3ULQ]LS QLFKW ² HEHQVR ZHQLJ ZLH .DQW GLHV JHWDQ KDW ² DOV HLQH %DVLV QRUPDXVZHOFKHUNRQNUHWH1RUPHQ ZHOFKHDXFKLPPHU DEJHOHLWHWZHU GHQN|QQWHQ'RFKVWHOOWDXFKIUGHQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVGHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH (LQIOXGHU9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQHLQH%HGLQJXQJGDUGLHIU GHQJHIRUGHUWHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQHUIOOWVHLQPX :HQQGDKHU6FDQORQGHULP*HJHQVDW]]XRUWKRGR[HQ.DQWLDQHUQQDFK HLQHP ÄUHIOH[LYHQ *OHLFKJHZLFKW¶ ]ZLVFKHQ K|KHUVWXILJHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ XQG NRQNUHWHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQVXFKWGLHEXFKVWlEOLFKH$XIIRUGHUXQJÅ%H UHDVRQDEOH´ VRZRKO LQ WKHRUHWLVFKHU DOV DXFK LQ SUDNWLVFKHU +LQVLFKW ² XQG KLHU ZLHGHUXP LQVWUXPHQWHOO XQG PRUDOLVFK ² DOV HLQH $XIIRUGHUXQJ LQWHUSUHWLHUW GLH VLFK HQWZHGHU D DXI GLH $UW ZLH HLQH 3HUVRQ GXUFK hEHUOHJXQJ ÅIURP D VKDUHG ERG\ RI LQIRUPDWLRQ DQG FRQFHSWLRQ RI WKH UHOHYDQWFRQVLGHUDWLRQV´]XHLQHUhEHU]HXJXQJRGHU$EVLFKWJHODQJWEH ]LHKWRGHUDEHU E GDV'UlQJHQEHLQKDOWHWÅWRWDNHLQWRDFFRXQWIDFWVRU UHDVRQVWKDWKHLVSUHVHQWO\LJQRULQJ´GDQQEHQHQQWHUGDPLWGHQ.HUQ SXQNWVHLQHV.RQ]HSWVHLQHUVWUXNWXUHOOHQ5DWLRQDOLWlW Å:KDWZHDUHFODL PLQJLVWKDWWKHUHLVUHDVRQWRWDNHWKHVH>VFRWKHUSHRSOH·V .3@LQWHUHVWV LQWR DFFRXQW JLYHQ WKH VXSSRVHG DLP RI UHDFKLQJ DJUHHPHQW RU ILQGLQJ D FRXUVHRIDFWLRQWKDWHYHU\RQHZLOOEHKDSS\ZLWK,WLVLQWKLVVHQVHWKDW, DPXVLQJWKHWHUP>VFUHDVRQDEOHQHVV .3@ZKHQ,VD\WKDWDQDFWLRQLV ZURQJ LI LW ZRXOG EH H[FOXGHG E\ DQ\ SULQFLSOHV WKDW QR RQH FRXOG UHD
_____________ .DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
VRQDEO\ UHMHFW JLYHQ WKH DLP RI ILQGLQJ SULQFLSOHV WKDW RWKHUV VLPLODUO\ PRWLYDWHGFRXOGDOVRDFFHSWµ$XI6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWGHVÄ:KDW:H2ZH WR(DFK2WKHU¶ZHUGHLFKQRFKQlKHUHLQJHKHQ KLHULVW]XQlFKVWQXUGHU 6WDWXV GHV 3ULQ]LSV GHU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW VHOEVW DOV GHV %DVLVSULQ]LSV HLQHU VROFKHQNRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHQ.RQ]HSWLRQZHVHQWOLFK ,QZLHIHUQ NDQQ QXQ HLQ SUDNWLVFKHU .RKlUHQWLVPXV DOV +HUDXVIRUGH UXQJ DQ .DQWV .RQ]HSWLRQ SUDNWLVFKHU 9HUQXQIW DXIJHIDW ZHUGHQ" $OO JHPHLQ VROOWH YRQ HLQHU VROFKHQ 7KHRULHQNRQVWHOODWLRQ JHOWHQ GD GLH KHUDXVIRUGHUQGH7KHRULHHLQH6FKQLWWPHQJHGHU3UREOHPHEHKDQGHOWGLH DXFK GLH KHUDXVJHIRUGHUWH ]XP *HJHQVWDQG KDW HV PX HLQ 0LQLPXP JHWHLOWHU7KHRUHPHJHEHQEHLGHPVVHQVR]XVDJHQDXIGHPVHOEHQ%RGHQ LQGLHVHP)DOOGHPGHV.RJQLWLYLVPXVVWHKHQ'LHKHUDXVIRUGHUQGH7KHR ULHPXDXHUGHPVROFKH3UREOHPHO|VHQE]Z3KlQRPHQHHUNOlUHQN|Q QHQGLHDXFKYRQGHUÄDOWHQ¶7KHRULHEHZlOWLJWZXUGHQXQGGDUEHUKLQ DXV VROFKH GLH YRQ MHQHU QLFKW EHZlOWLJW ZXUGHQ 'DEHL GDUI GLH 6XFKH QLFKWQXULQ5LFKWXQJXQJHO|VWHU3UREOHPHJHKHQGLHYRQGHUÄDOWHQ¶7KH RULH DOV VROFKH ZDKUJHQRPPHQ ZXUGHQ RGHU ZHUGHQ NRQQWHQ 9LHOPHKU NDQQ VLFK GLH +HUDXVIRUGHUXQJ DXFK DXI SUREOHPDWLVFKH +LQWHUJUXQGDQ QDKPHQEH]LHKHQGLHVLFKPHKURGHUZHQLJHUH[SOL]LWLQMHQHUILQGHQ (LQHVROFKHDQ7KRPDV6.XKQRULHQWLHUWH%HVFKUHLEXQJLVW]ZDU]X DOOJHPHLQXQGYDJHXPNRQNUHWH$QKDOWVSXQNWHIUGLH6XFKHQDFKHLQHU $OWHUQDWLYH ]X RGHU DXFK HLQHP $QVFKOX DQ .DQW ]X ILQGHQ 'RFK LQ HUVWHU KHXULVWLVFKHU $QQlKHUXQJ OlW VLFK GDV )ROJHQGH IHVWVWHOOHQ 'HU PHWDSK\VLVFKH 3UHLV GHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV LQQHUKDOE GHU .DQWL VFKHQ .RQ]HSWLRQ LVW KRFK GLH (LQZlQGH GLH VHLW GHU 3XEOLNDWLRQ YRQ .DQWV *UXQGOHJXQJ JHJHQ GLHVH 0RUDONRQ]HSWLRQ HUKREHQ ZXUGHQ VLQG QLFKWPHKU]XEHUEOLFNHQ VLHUHLFKHQYRQ'HWDLONULWLNELV]XUJlQ]OLFKHQ 9HUZHUIXQJHLQHUQRUPDWLYHQ(WKLN1XQOlWVLFK]ZDUGLH6FKZLHULJNHLW PLW GHP NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY EHUHLWV UHGX]LHUHQ ZHQQ PDQ LP *H JHQVDW] ]XP ,QWXLWLRQLVPXV QLFKW YRQ HLQHU 7RWDODEOHKQXQJ UDWLRQDOHU %HJUQGEDUNHLW SUDNWLVFKHU 6lW]H DXVJHKW 'HQQRFK VFKHLQHQ PLU DXFK GDQQ QRFK QHEHQ GHU LQ JHQDQQWHQ .ULWLN YRU DOOHP GLH IROJHQGHQ 3XQNWHYRQ]HQWUDOHU%HGHXWXQJ]XVHLQ =XP HUVWHQ NDQQ PDQ GHQ .DQWLVFKHQ 0HQWDOLVPXV RGHU JDU ,QWURVSHNWLRQLVPXVPLW%OLFNDXIGLH(LQVLFKWLQGDV6LWWHQJHVHW]LQ)UDJH
_____________ 6FDQORQ 9JOQHEHQ.XKQ DXFKGLHV\VWHPDWLVFKH:HLWHUHQWZLFNOXQJYRQ.XKQV7KHR ULHEHL)ULHGPDQ 9JOGD]XREHQ.DS)QXQGXQWHQ.DS)Q 9JO GD]X DXFK GLH DXVJHZRJHQH 'LVNXVVLRQ ZHLWHUHU (LQZlQGH JHJHQ ]HQWUDOH (OH PHQWHGHU.DQWLVFKHQ0RUDOSKLORVRSKLHEHL%DURQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
VWHOOHQ.DQWVHLJHQHU$QVDW]LQGHU]ZHLWHQ.ULWLNKDW]ZDUGHQDXIHLQH 'HGXNWLRQDE]LHOHQGHQ,QWHOOHNWXDOLVPXVGHU*UXQGOHJXQJKLQWHUVLFKJHODV VHQGRFKDXFKHUHUODXEWQXUGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGH)UDJHQLFKWPHKUKLQJH JHQHLQHEHIULHGLJHQGH$QWZRUW Å:LHQXQGLHVHV%HZXWVHLQGHUPRUDOL VFKHQ*HVHW]HRGHUZHOFKHVHLQHUOHLLVWGDVGHU)UHLKHLWP|JOLFKVHLOlW VLFKQLFKWZHLWHUHUNOlUHQ>«@´(LQH$OWHUQDWLYWKHRULHPWHQXQZHGHU GLHVHV %HZXWVHLQ HUNOlUHQ QRFK GHQ %HZXWVHLQVEHJULII DEOHKQHQ 6LH PWH YLHOPHKU GLH DUJXPHQWDWLYH /DVW GLH HU LQ .DQWV .RQ]HSWLRQ ]X WUDJHQKDWYRQLKPQHKPHQ (LQZHLWHUHV3UREOHPGDVHEHQIDOOVHQJPLW.DQWV.RQ]HSWGHUÄ$FK WXQJYRUGHP*HVHW]¶YHUNQSIWLVWVWHOOWGLH$EVWUDNWKHLWGHU.DQWLVFKHQ (WKLNGDU.DQWKDQGHOWLQGHU7XJHQGOHKUH]ZDUYRQNRQNUHWHQÅ7XJHQG SIOLFKWHQ´ GHUHQ &KDUDNWHULVWLNXP GHU Å6HOEVW]ZDQJ´ LVW LP *HJHQVDW] ]XP MXULVWLVFKHQ lXHUHQ =ZDQJ 'RFK HUVHW]W GLHVH 7XJHQGOHKUH NHLQHQ ÄSUDNWLVFKHQ6FKHPDWLVPXV¶GHU]XNOlUHQKlWWHZLHGDVZDVLQIRURLQ WHUQRDXVJHPDFKWZXUGH$QZHQGXQJDXINRQNUHWH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJHQ ]ZLVFKHQ3HUVRQHQILQGHQNDQQ 0LW GLHVHU $EVWUDNWKHLW XQG *HVHOOVFKDIWVIHUQH ZLHGHUXP YHUEXQGHQ EHVWHKWLQQHUKDOE.DQWV0RUDOSKLORVRSKLHGDV3UREOHPGHU,UUHOHYDQ]YRQ +DQGOXQJVNRQVHTXHQ]HQ IU GLH %HXUWHLOXQJ HLQHU +DQGOXQJ DOV PRUD OLVFK .DQWV SURPLQHQWHVWHV %HLVSLHO LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ LVW GLH :DKUKDIWLJNHLW LP PHQVFKOLFKHQ 8PJDQJ Å1XQ LVW HV GRFK HWZDV JDQ] DQGHUHVDXV3IOLFKWZDKUKDIW]XVHLQDOVDXV%HVRUJQLGHUQDFKWKHLOLJHQ )ROJHQ LQGHP LP HUVWHQ )DOOH GHU %HJULII GHU +DQGOXQJ DQ VLFK VHOEVW VFKRQ HLQ *HVHW] IU PLFK HQWKlOW LP ]ZHLWHQ LFK PLFK DOOHUHUVW DQGHU ZlUWVKHUXPVHKHQPXZHOFKH:LUNXQJHQIUPLFKZRKOGDPLWYHUEXQ GHQ VHLQ P|FKWHQ´ 0DQ ZLUG QXQ ]ZHLIHOORV ]XJHVWHKHQ GD GLH ]XU
_____________ ,QJHZLVVHU+LQVLFKWOlWVLFKQLFKW]XOHW]WYRUGHP+LQWHUJUXQGYRQ+HQULFKV$QD O\VHQ]XPMXULVWLVFKHQ8PIHOGGHV'HGXNWLRQVEHJULIIVEHL.DQW YJO+HQULFK DXFK LQ GHU .S9 YRQ HLQHU 'HGXNWLRQ VSUHFKHQ QXU ZLUG KLHU VR]XVDJHQ GHU :HJ YRP XUVSUQJOLFKHQ )DNWXP ]XU REMHNWLYHQ 5HDOLWlW GHV PRUDOLVFKHQ *HVHW]HV VWDUN YHUNU]W :lKUHQG LQ GHU *UXQGOHJXQJ GDV Ä)DNWXP¶ XP LQ GLHVHU 7HUPLQRORJLH ]X EOHLEHQGDULQEHVWHKWGDZLU%UJHUGHULQWHOOLJLEOHQ:HOWVLQGEHVWHKWGDVÅ)DFWXP GHUUHLQHQ9HUQXQIW´LQGHU.S9VFKOLFKWZHJLPÅ%HZXWVHLQGLHVHV*UXQGJHVHW]HV´ .DQW9 .DQW9 ,Q.DSZHUGHLFKQlKHUDXIGLHVHV3UREOHPGHV+DQGHOQVDXV(LQVLFKWLQGDV6LW WHQJHVHW]HLQJHKHQ 9JO.DQW9, .DQW,9 9JOGD]XDXFK.DQWV$XIVDW]ÅhEHUHLQYHUPHLQWHV5HFKWDXV0HQ VFKHQOLHEH]XOJHQ´ .DQW9,,, VRZLHLQ.DQWV$QWKURSRORJLH Å:DKUKDIWLJ NHLWLP,QQHUHQGHV*HVWlQGQLVVHVYRUVLFKVHOEVWXQG]XJOHLFKLP%HWUDJHQJHJHQMH
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.RKlUHQWLVPXV (UNOlUXQJVZHUWXQG8QVFKlUIH
)ROJHQDEVFKlW]XQJHLQHU+DQGOXQJHUIRUGHUWH.OXJKHLWKlXILJDQLKU(Q GHNRPPWEHYRUGLH+DQGOXQJVIROJHQNODUEHVWLPPWVLQGXQG:DKUKDI WLJNHLWLPNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ8PJDQJGHU0HQVFKHQHLQHK|KHUHGHQQEOR NRQVHTXHQWLDOLVWLVFKH 'LJQLWlW EHVLW]W VFKOLHOLFK LVW LKUH %HIROJXQJ HLQH QRWZHQGLJH %HGLQJXQJ YRQ .RPPXQLNDWLRQ 'RFK NDQQ HV XQWHUKDOE GLHVHU(EHQHVLWXDWLRQVYDULDQWHEHQDXFKPRUDOLVFKJHERWHQVHLQNRQWH[W VHQVLEHO XQZDKUKDIWLJ JHJHQEHU EHVWLPPWHQ 3HUVRQHQ ]X VSUHFKHQ XQG ]XKDQGHOQZLHNRQWURYHUVH)lOOHYRQbXHUXQJHQJHJHQEHU7HUURULVWHQ RGHU bXHUXQJHQ HLQHV $U]WHV JHJHQEHU HLQHP XQKHLOEDUHQ 3DWLHQWHQ EHOHJHQ $OOJHPHLQ OlW VLFK GDIU DUJXPHQWLHUHQ GD GLH Y|OOLJH (QW ZHUWXQJGHU+DQGOXQJVIROJHQ]XJXQVWHQGHU5HLQKHLWGHU:LOOHQVEHVWLP PXQJ DXIJUXQG GHU GDPLW DXVJHVFKORVVHQHQ $EZlJXQJ ]X PRUDOLVFKHQ 'LOHPPDWD IKUHQ NDQQ GLH DXV .DQWV 3HUVSHNWLYH XQO|VEDU HUVFKHLQHQ ZHQQQlPOLFKGLHYRP+DQGHOQGHQDEVHKEDUHQ)ROJHQHLQHUDXV$FKWXQJ YRUGHP6LWWHQJHVHW]JHVFKHKHQHQ+DQGOXQJPLWGHP6LWWHQJHVHW]NRQIOL JLHUHQ
.RKlUHQWLVPXV (UNOlUXQJVZHUWXQG8QVFKlUIH
'LHHLQJDQJVYRUJHQRPPHQH4XDOLIL]LHUXQJGHVLPIROJHQGHQUHOHYDQWHQ %HJULIIV GHV .RKlUHQWLVPXV PX QXQ QRFK ZHLWHU DXVJHIKUW ZHUGHQ GHQQHULVWELVKLHUKHULQWHQVLRQDO]XHQJXQGH[WHQVLRQDO]XZHLWXP]X VXEVWDQWLHOOHQ (UNOlUXQJHQ KHUDQJH]RJHQ ZHUGHQ ]X N|QQHQ :DV DOVR VROO LP )ROJHQGHQ XQWHU .RKlUHQWLVPXV YHUVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ" :HQQ PDQ QLFKW YRQ HLQHU 5HVWULNWLRQ GHV .RKlUHQWLVPXV DXI hEHU]HXJXQJHQ DXV JHKWVRQGHUQVWDWWGHVVHQDXFKSUDNWLVFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQZLH:HUWH1RU PHQ:QVFKHVRZLH+DQGOXQJVSOlQHXQGHQWVFKHLGXQJHQPLWHLQEH]LHKW RGHUXPJHNHKUWGHQ%HJULIIGHUhEHU]HXJXQJVRZHLWIDWGDGDUXQWHU DOOHVIDOOHQNDQQZDVHLQHU%HJUQGXQJIlKLJLVWVRNDQQ/DXUHQFH%RQ -RXUV'HILQLWLRQDOVHUVWH2ULHQWLHUXQJIUGDV1DFKIROJHQGHGLHQHQ Å>@ FRKHUHQFHLVDPDWWHURIKRZZHOODERG\RIEHOLHIÄKDQJVWRJHWKHU¶ KRZ ZHOOLWVFRPSRQHQWEHOLHIVILWWRJHWKHUDJUHHRUGRYHWDLOZLWKHDFKRWKHU VRDVWRSURGXFHDQRUJDQL]HGWLJKWO\VWUXFWXUHGV\VWHPRIEHOLHIVUDWKHU WKDQHLWKHUDKHOWHUVNHOWHUFROOHFWLRQRUDVHWRIFRQIOLFWLQJVXEV\VWHPV,W LV UHDVRQDEO\ FOHDU WKDW WKLV ÄKDQJLQJ WRJHWKHU¶ GHSHQGV RQ WKH YDULRXV
_____________ GHQ$QGHUHQVLFK]XUREHUVWHQ0D[LPHJHPDFKWLVWGHUHLQ]LJH%HZHLVGHV%HZXW VHLQVHLQHV0HQVFKHQGDHUHLQHQ&KDUDNWHUKDW´ .DQW9,, 9JO]XHLQHUV\VWHPDWLVFKHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLWGHP%HJULIIGHU:DKUKDIWLJNHLW 3ROORN 9JOGD]X0LOOJUDP
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
VRUWV RI LQIHUHQWLDO HYLGHQWLDO DQG H[SODQDWRU\ UHODWLRQV ZKLFK REWDLQ DPRQJWKHYDULRXVPHPEHUVRIDV\VWHPRIEHOLHIVDQGHVSHFLDOO\RQWKH PRUH KROLVWLF DQG V\VWHPDWLF RI WKHVHµ ,Q +DQGOXQJV]XVDPPHQKlQJHQ ZLUG GHPJHPl HLQ KRKHV0D DQ :LGHUVSUXFKVIUHLKHLW ]ZLVFKHQ KDQG OXQJVUHOHYDQWHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ VRZLH GLH (LQELQGXQJ GLHVHU UHOHYDQWHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQLQHLQ1HW]LQIHUHQWLHOOHU5HODWLRQHQHLQ1HW]YRQHLQVHLWL JHQRGHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ$EKlQJLJNHLWHQDQJHVWUHEW,P)ROJHQGHQVROOHV QXQQLFKWXPGHQ0D[LPLHUXQJVDVSHNWGHU.RKlUHQ]DOVVROFKHQJHKHQ VRQGHUQXPGDV.ULWHULXPRGHUGLH.ULWHULHQGLHHUIOOWVHLQPVVHQXP HLQH .RKlUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ KDQGOXQJVUHOHYDQWHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]X HU]LHOHQ 'DV ,QWHUHVVH ULFKWHW VLFK QLFKW DXI GLH $Q]DKO XQG GLH %LQGXQJVNUDIW LQIHUHQWLHOOHU5HODWLRQHQ²EHUHFKWLJXQJVXQGIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIH UHQ]HQ²VRZLHGLHGDJHJHQDE]XZlJHQGHQ,QNRPSDWLELOLWlWHQLQHLQHP LQWUD RGHU LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ 6\VWHP KDQGOXQJVUHOHYDQWHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ VRQGHUQDXIHLQ9HUVWlQGQLVGHU)RUGHUXQJQDFKGHUDUWLJHU.RKlUHQ] (LQH JHZLVVH (UZDUWXQJ DQ HLQH NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKH 7KHRULH VROOWH PDQ MHGRFK JDU QLFKW HUVW HQWZLFNHOQ ]XPLQGHVW ZLUG VLH LQ GHU 5HDOLWlW YHU PXWOLFK VWHWV HQWWlXVFKW ZHUGHQ ([DNWKHLW 'HQQ ZHGHU GLH $Q]DKO GHU DE]XZlJHQGHQ(OHPHQWHQRFK²XQGGLHVLVWLQPHLQHQ$XJHQLQSUDNWL VFKHU +LQVLFKW QRFK HQWVFKHLGHQGHU ² GDV Ä*HZLFKW¶ GLHVHU MHZHLOLJHQ (OHPHQWH N|QQHQ H[DNW NDONXOLHUW ZHUGHQ +LODU\ 3XWQDP GHU KROLVWLVFK DUJXPHQWLHUWXQGGDEHLQRUPDWLYH(OHPHQWHQLFKWQXULQ:HUWHDXVVDJHQ VRQGHUQLQMHGHU7DWVDFKHQDXVVDJHIHVWPDFKWVFKUHLEWLQGLHVHPSUDJPD WLVFKHUHQ6LQQH Å>«@ÄFRKHUHQFH¶LVQRWVRPHWKLQJWKDWZHKDYHDQDOJR ULWKP IRU EXW VRPHWKLQJ WKDW ZH XOWLPDWHO\ MXGJH E\ ÄVHDW RI WKH SDQWV¶ IHHO´'LHVH+HUDEVWLPPXQJGHU(UZDUWXQJVFKHLQWPLUZLFKWLJ]XVHLQ
_____________ %RQ-RXU YJODXFK%DUWHOERUWK IUHLQH$XIVWHOOXQJYRQ%HGLQ JXQJHQHLQHU.RKlUHQ]WKHRULHGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJYRQhEHU]HXJXQJHQ'LHYRQLKP VRJHQDQQWH6WDELOLWlWVEHGLQJXQJ G EH]LHKWVLFKGDEHLDXIGLHDXFKLP3UDNWLVFKHQ ZLFKWLJH'LDFKURQLHXQGYHUODQJWYRQHLQHPhEHU]HXJXQJVV\VWHP;Å>@GDHVEHU OlQJHUH=HLWKLQZHJVWDELONRKlUHQWJHEOLHEHQLVWGKGDHVLQGLHVHU=HLWWURW]P|JOLFKVW ]DKOUHLFKHQ ,QSXWV NHLQH UHYROXWLRQlUHQ bQGHUXQJHQ HUIDKUHQ KDW´ %DUWHOERUWK 8QWHUDQGHUHPZLUGGDPLW²HUNHQQWQLVWKHRUHWLVFKUHOHYDQW²DXFKGHU(U OHEQLVEHULFKWYRP0lUFKHQXQWHUVFKHLGEDU 'LHVHU 9RUJULII DXI %UDQGRPV 9RNDEXODU %UDQGRP D I ZLUG LQ .DS HLQJHO|VWZHUGHQ 3XWQDP I$XI3XWQDPVÄLQWHUQHQ5HDOLVPXV¶LQQHUKDOEGHVVHQGHP.RKl UHQ]EHJULIIHLQH]HQWUDOHWKHRUHWLVFKH5ROOHEH]JOLFKHLQHU.RQ]HSWLRQYRQ:DKUKHLW ]XNRPPW RKQHHLQHQ5HODWLYLVPXV]XSURSDJLHUHQ PXKLHUQLFKWZHLWHUHLQJHJDQ JHQZHUGHQ(QWVFKHLGHQGLVWDQGLHVHU6WHOOHOHGLJOLFKGD.RKlUHQ]HLQ0HKURGHU :HQLJHU QLFKW QXU HUODXEW VRQGHUQ LQ GHU 5HDOLWlW VWHWV GDUVWHOOW 3XWQDP VSULFKW LQ GLHVHP6LQQHYRQ5DWLRQDOLWlWDOVHLQHPÅ*UHQ]EHJULII´ 3XWQDP
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.RKlUHQWLVPXV (UNOlUXQJVZHUWXQG8QVFKlUIH
ZHLOVRQVWGHUÅUHDOLW\FKHFNµDXIMHGHQ)DOOQHJDWLYDXVIlOOWGHQQ+DQG OXQJVJUQGH VWUHQJ TXDQWLIL]LHUHQ ]X ZROOHQ LVW VFKOLFKW DEVXUG +HX ULVWLVFK ZHJZHLVHQG VFKHLQW PLU LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ 0LOOJUDPV 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ GHU EHLGHQ%HUHLFKH GHU +DQGOXQJVSOlQH XQG GHU 0RUDO ]XVHLQGHUHQ9HUVWlQGQLVVR0LOOJUDPZHVHQWOLFKDXINRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHU %HJULIIOLFKNHLW EHUXKW Å3UHVHQWHG ZLWK D KRGJHSRGJH RI JRDOV SRVVLEOH DFWLRQVUHOHYDQWEHOLHIV DERXWZKDWFRQGXFHVWRZKDWDQGDERXWZKDWLV LQFRPSDWLEOHZLWKZKDW DQGPD\EHRWKHUWKLQJV,FDQWUHDWWKHSUREOHP RI ILJXULQJ RXW ZKDW WR GR DV WKH SUREOHP RI VRUWLQJ DV PXFK RI WKH KRGJHSRGJH DV , FDQ LQWR WKH PRVW FRKHUHQW SRVVLEOH SODQ >«@ )LUVW PRUH FRKHUHQW SODQV ZLOO WHQG WR KDYH SDUWV WKDW ZRUN WRJHWKHU UDWKHU WKDQDWFURVVSXUSRVHVDQGWKLVPDNHVWKHSODQDVDZKROHPRUHOLNHO\WR ZRUN6HFRQGXQOLNHWKHVFLHQWLILFWKHRULHV>«@ZLWKWKHLU]HURWROHUDQFH IRU LQFRQVLVWHQF\ DJHQWV WKDW H[HFXWH SODQV DUH QRUPDOO\ DEOH WR DEVRUE DQGFRPSHQVDWHIRUDFHUWDLQUHVLGXDODPRXQWRILQFRKHUHQFHLQDSODQµ :DVQHEHQGLHVHP%HUHLFKGHU+DQGOXQJVSOlQHGHQPRUDOLVFKHQ%HUHLFK EHWULIIW VR XQWHUVFKHLGHW 0LOOJUDP ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHP 5HDOLVPXV XQG HKHU SUDJPDWLVFK RULHQWLHUWHQ 7KHRULHQ Å,I >«@ \RX WKLQN WKDW ZKDW \RX DUH WU\LQJ WR GR LV WR FRPH XS ZLWK WKH WUXH WKH UHDOO\ WUXH PRUDO WKHRU\ ² WKHQ XVLQJ FRKHUHQFH WR GHFLGH RQ \RXU WKHRU\ GRHV QRW PDNH D ORW RI VHQVH2QWKHRWKHUKDQGLI\RXWKLQNRIHWKLFVDVDZD\ZHVROYHDFRP SOLFDWHG VRFLDO FRRUGLQDWLRQ SUREOHP DQG WKDW VXFFHVVLQ FRRUGLQDWLRQ LV DOOZHFDQUHDOO\GHPDQGRIDQHWKLFDOSUDFWLFH>«@WKHQHWKLFVLVDORWOLNH SODQQLQJ ZKDW\RXZDQWLVIRUWKHFRRUGLQDWLRQVFKHPHWRZRUNDQGFR KHUHQFHPDNHVLWPRUHOLNHO\WKDWLWZLOO>«@µ'RFKLVWPLWGLHVHQ%H
_____________ 0LOOJUDP 0LOOJUDP LQ HLQHU )XQRWH EHPHUNW 0LOOJUDP GD]X Å7KLV IHDWXUH RI SODQ H[HFXWLRQKHOSVXVVHHKRZWZRFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRISODQVGLVFXVVHGE\0LFKDHO%UDWPDQ PHVK WKDWSODQVDUHVWDEOHDQGWKDWWKH\DUHILOOHGLQDV\RXJR´ (EG (LQH]HQWUDOH %HVWLPPXQJYRQ%UDWPDQV+DQGOXQJVWKHRULHEHVWHKWGDULQGDGLH(QWVFKHLGXQJIU HLQHQ +DQGOXQJVSODQ HLQH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI 9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQ EHGHXWHW GLH GLH LQWUD XQG LQWHUSHUVRQHOOH .RRUGLQDWLRQ XQG 2UJDQLVDWLRQ XQVHUHU JHPHLQVDPHQ 3UD[LV QLFKWQXUHUOHLFKWHUWVRQGHUQLQYLHOHU+LQVLFKWHUVWHUP|JOLFKW9JOGD]XDXFKXQWHQ )Q 0LOOJUDP QHEHQ 5DZOV XQG GHVVHQ .RQ]HSW GHV ÅhEHUOHJXQJVJOHLFKJH ZLFKWV´ GDVDOV6WDQGDUGEHLVSLHOHLQHVHWKLVFKHQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVJHO WHQNDQQHUZlKQW0LOOJUDPLQGLHVHP.RQWH[WDXFKGLH7KHRULHGHVÅ:KDW:H2ZH WR (DFK 2WKHU´ GHV 5DZOV6FKOHUV 6FDQORQ DXI GLH LFK LQ .DS QRFK HLQJHKHQ ZHUGH9JO]X5DZOV·.RQ]HSWGHVhEHUOHJXQJVJOHLFKJHZLFKWV'DQLHOV 3DUW, Å7KHNH\LGHDXQGHUO\LQJWKHPHWKRGRIUHIOHFWLYHHTXLOLELUXPLVWKDWZHÄWHVW¶ YDULRXVSDUWVRIRXUV\VWHPRIPRUDOEHOLHIVDJDLQVWRWKHUEHOLHIVZHKROGVHHNLQJFR KHUHQFHDPRQJWKHZLGHVWVHWRIPRUDODQGQRQPRUDOEHOLHIVE\UHYLVLQJDQGUHILQLQJ WKHPDWDOOOHYHOV´(EG (LQHQSUDNWLVFKHQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVYHUWULWWLP$QVFKOXDQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
VWLPPXQJHQQRFKNHLQHUOHL/|VXQJEH]JOLFKGHU)UDJHQDFKGHP(LQIOX GHU 9HUQXQIW DXI XQVHUH +DQGOXQJHQ VNL]]LHUW HV KDQGHOW VLFK KLHU HKHU XPGLH)RUPXOLHUXQJYRQ3UREOHPHQ :DV XQWHUVFKHLGHW HLQHQ KDQGOXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV YRQ HLQHPHWKLVFKHQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVXQGLQZHOFKHP9HUKlOWQLVN|QQHQEHLGH ]XHLQDQGHU VWHKHQ" (LQH HUVWH $QQlKHUXQJ DQ HLQH %HDQWZRUWXQJ GLHVHU )UDJH OLHIHUW GLH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ XQG LQWHUSHU VRQHOOHQ.RRUGLQDWLRQHQGRFKPXGDEHLLP$XJHEHKDOWHQZHUGHQGD DXFK GLH +DQGOXQJVSOlQH HLQHV ,QGLYLGXXPV GHUHQ .RRUGLQDWLRQ PLW +DQGOXQJVSOlQHQ DQGHUHU ,QGLYLGXHQ HUIRUGHUQ 0DQ ZLUG VLFK DOVR DXI HLQHOlQJHUH*HVFKLFKWHHLQVWHOOHQPVVHQDQGHUHQ(QGHDXFKGHUPRUD OLVFKH 5HDOLVPXV QLFKW PLW HLQHP HLQIDFKHQ +DQGVWUHLFK IU LUUHOHYDQW HUNOlUWZHUGHQNDQQ
+DQGOXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJVJUQGH
,QVRIHUQGHUSUDNWLVFKH.RKlUHQWLVPXVDXIDOOHKDQGOXQJVUHOHYDQWHQJHLV WLJHQ=XVWlQGHDE]LHOWIUGLHPDQ9HUDQWZRUWXQJEHUQHKPHQNDQQWULWW HUVWHWVDOVHLQH)RUPGHV.RJQLWLYLVPXVDXI6ROFKHSHUV|QOLFKHQ(LQVWHO OXQJHQLQ*HVWDOWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQVLQGGHP.RJQLWLYLVPXV]XIROJH JHUDGH GDVMHQLJH ZDV +DQGOXQJHQ YRQ EORHP 9HUKDOWHQ XQWHUVFKHLGHW =ZDULVWGDPLWQRFKNHLQH$XVVDJHGDUEHUJHWURIIHQZDVDOVHLQ+DQG OXQJVJUXQGIXQJLHUHQNDQQGRFKLVWGDPLWEHUHLWVDP%HJLQQSUDNWLVFKHU hEHUOHJXQJHQGLH$QVLFKWDEJHZLHVHQGDLP6LQQH+XPHV'LNWXPYRQ GHU9HUQXQIWDOVGHU6NODYLQGHU/HLGHQVFKDIWHQGLHHLQ]LJH5ROOHGHU9HU QXQIWGDULQEHVWHKH]XNRRUGLQLHUHQZDVYRQGHQ1HLJXQJHQ:QVFKHQ /HLGHQVFKDIWHQYRUJHJHEHQZHUGH9LHOPHKULPSOL]LHUWGLH%HVWLPPXQJYRQ HWZDVGDVHUVWUHEWZLUGEHUHLWVHLQUDWLRQDOHYDOXDWLYHV0RPHQW'HUKLHU YHUIROJWH $QVDW] HUVWUHFNW VLFK GDKHU QLFKW QXU DXI GLH LQWUDSHUVRQHOOH =ZHFN0LWWHO.RKlUHQ] VRQGHUQ DXFK DXI HLQH ZLH PDQ VLH QHQQHQ N|QQWH LQWUD XQG LQWHUSHUVRQHOOH =ZHFN=ZHFN.RKlUHQ] ZDV DXV GHU 6LFKWGHUYRQGHQ+DQGOXQJHQEHWURIIHQHQ3HUVRQHQVXEVWDQWLHOOH8UWHLOH EHU+DQGOXQJV]LHOHRGHU]ZHFNHHUIRUGHUW
_____________ 5DZOV DXFK %ULQN %ULQN YHUIROJW MHGRFK HLQH ZHVHQWOLFK QLFKW NRQVWUXNWLYLVWLVFKHVRQGHUQUHDOLVWLVFKH7KHRULH YJOHEG PRUDOLVFKH:DKUKHL WHQEH]LHKHQVLFKQDFK%ULQNDXI*WHUPHQVFKOLFKHU:RKOIDKUWVRZLHGHUHQ%HGLQ JXQJHQZHVKDOEHUDXFKYRQHLQHPÅREMHNWLYHQ8WLOLWDULVPXVµ HEG VSULFKW 9JO+XPH %RRN,,3DUW6HFW Å5HDVRQLVDQGRXJKWRQO\WREHWKHVODYH RI WKH SDVVLRQV DQG FDQ QHYHU SUHWHQG WR DQ\ RWKHU RIILFH WKDQ WR VHUYH DQG REH\ WKHP´ (LQHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV GHU PLW VHLQHU H[SOL]LWHQ %HWRQXQJ GHU $XWRQRPLH MHQHQKXPHDQLVFKHQ'HIHNWDXVJOHLFKWYHUWULWW(NVWURP Å$SUHIHUHQFHWKDWLVDXWKRU
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DQGOXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJVJUQGH
,Q HUVWHU $QQlKHUXQJ PDUNLHUW 1LGD5PHOLQ GLH KLHU YHUWUHWHQH NRJQLWLYLVWLVFKH3RVLWLRQGHUHQ*UXQGEHJULIIGHUGHV+DQGOXQJVJUXQGVLVW IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å(VLVWDQDO\WLVFKZDKUGDVVZLUIU+DQGOXQJHQ*UQGH DQJHEHQ N|QQHQ :HQQ ZLU IU HLQ EHVWLPPWHV 9HUKDOWHQ NHLQH *UQGH VRQGHUQK|FKVWHQV8UVDFKHQ DQJHEHQN|QQHQGDQQLVWGLHVHV9HUKDOWHQ QLFKW DOV HLQH +DQGOXQJ ]X FKDUDNWHULVLHUHQ´ $P GHXWOLFKVWHQ WULWW GLH 6WlUNHGHV.RJQLWLYLVPXVLQ)lOOHQYRQLQWUDRGHULQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ.RQ IOLNWHQ]ZLVFKHQYHUVFKLHGHQHQ:QVFKHQKHUYRU6LHN|QQWHQXQWHU9HU ]LFKWDXI%HJUQGXQJVYRNDEXODUQLFKWDXVJHWUDJHQZHUGHQVRQGHUQEOR YRQVWDWWHQ JHKHQ 1LGD5PHOLQ NULWLVLHUW LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ GDV KLQWHU GHP1RQ.RJQLWLYLVPXVVWHKHQGH0RGHOO HLQHUÅ3K\VLN GHV :RO OHQVXQG+DQGHOQV´GDVYRQHLQHU$QDORJLHYRQSK\VLNDOLVFKHU$WWUDNWLRQ XQG 5HSXOVLRQ HLQHUVHLWV XQG /LHEH XQG +D DQGHUHUVHLWV DXVJHKW XQG PHWDSKRULVFK IHKOJHOHLWHW HLQH IU +DQGOXQJHQ HUIRUGHUOLFKH ÅSV\FKLVFKH (QHUJLH´YRUDXVVHW]W'RFKEUDXFKHQZLUOHW]WHUHHEHQVRZHQLJZLHZLU EHL GHU 5HYLVLRQ HLQHU PDWKHPDWLVFKHQ hEHU]HXJXQJ HLQHQ $XIZDQG HUEULQJHQXQGHLQEHUGLHQHXHhEHU]HXJXQJKLQDXVUHLFKHQGHV0RWLY]XU 5HYLVLRQ EHQ|WLJHQ 'HQQ VHOEVW 1HLJXQJHQ XQG :QVFKH GLH XQVHUH ÄEHVVHUHQ (LQVLFKWHQ¶ KlXILJ ÄEHGURKHQ¶ RGHU GRPLQLHUHQ XQG LQ GLHVHP .RQWH[WVWHWVDOV*HJHQDUJXPHQWHDQJHIKUWZHUGHQKDEHQ+DQGOXQJVUH OHYDQ]OHGLJOLFKDOV+DQGOXQJVJUQGH'LH8QIlKLJNHLW]XUÅYHUEDOHQ:LH GHUJDEH GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGHV´ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH EHL XQIDOOEHGLQJWHU $SKDVLHDEHUDXFKEHL.LQGHUQGDUIGDEHLQLFKWEHUHLWVPLWGHP)HKOHQ HLQHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV LGHQWLIL]LHUW ZHUGHQ DXI GDV HQWVSUHFKHQGH 9HU KlOWQLV]ZLVFKHQGHP,PSOL]LWHQXQGGHP([SOL]LWHQZHUGHLFKQRFKQl KHUHLQJHKHQ YJO :DV GDV EHJULIIOLFKH 9HUKlOWQLV ]ZLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJHQ XQG *UQGHQ IU +DQGOXQJHQ EHWULIIW VR NDQQ PDQ QDFK ZLH YRU 'RQDOG 'DYLGVRQV 7KHRULH DOV GDV 6WDQGDUGPRGHOO EHWUDFKWHQ ZRQDFK MHQVHLWV GHU UHLQHQ
_____________ L]HGIRUPHFRXQWV DVWUXO\PLQHDVRQHWKDW,UHDOO\ZDQWWR KDYHVLQFHLWFRKHUHV ZLWKWKHRWKHUWKLQJVWKDW,SUHIHUDQGDFFHSW´ (NVWURP 8QGPLW%OLFN DXI GHQ %HJULII GHU 3HUVRQ UHVPLHUW VLH VFKOLHOLFK JHJHQ GDV KLHUDUFKLVFKH :Q VFKHXQG)UHLKHLWVPRGHOO)UDQNIXUWV Å:KHQ,DFWRQDQDXWKRUL]HGSUHIHUHQFH,DFW LQDZD\WKDWLVDXWRQRPRXVEHFDXVH,FDQJLYHPDQ\UHDVRQVIRUP\DFWUHDVRQVWKDW VXSSRUWHDFKRWKHULQDFRKHUHQWVWUXFWXUH7KHVHDUHWKHUHDVRQVRIP\VHOI+HQFH LQDFWLQJRQWKHVHUHDVRQV,DPVHOIJRYHUQHG,QDFWLQJDXWRQRPRXVO\,DFWLQDZD\ WKDWLVFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIPH² DZD\WKDWFRKHUHVDQGLVQRWDWRGGV ZLWKWKHZD\V, VKRXOGEHKDYHJLYHQZKDW,SUHIHUDQGDFFHSW´ (EGI 1LGD5PHOLQI 9JO1LGD5PHOLQ ZRHUVLFKH[HPSODULVFKJHJHQ:LOOLDPV HLQHQ SURPLQHQWHQ PRGHUQHQ 9HUWUHWHU GLHVHV QRQNRJQLWLYLVWLVFKHQ 0RGHOOV ZHQGHW YJO DXFK1LGD5PHOLQ 1LGD5PHOLQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
Ä,PSHWXVWKHRULH¶ :HUWXUWHLOH HLQ HQWVFKHLGHQGHV 0RPHQW DXVPDFKHQ Å:HQQMHPDQGGHU'HXWVFKNDQQDXIULFKWLJVDJW Ä6FKQHHLVWZHL¶GDQQ JODXEWHUGD6FKQHHZHLLVW,VWPHLQH7KHVHULFKWLJVRKDWMHPDQGGHU DXIULFKWLJVDJW Ä(VLVWZQVFKHQVZHUWGDLFKGDV5DXFKHQDXIJHEH¶HLQH 3URHLQVWHOOXQJ ]XP $XIJHEHQ GHV 5DXFKHQV (U YHUVSUW HLQH JHZLVVH 1HLJXQJGD]X MDHUZLUGHVWXQZHQQGHPQLFKWVLP:HJHVWHKWZHQQHU ZHL ZLH HV ]XPDFKHQ LVW XQG ZHQQ HU NHLQH HQWJHJHQJHVHW]WHQ :HUWH RGHU:QVFKHKDW8QWHUGLHVHU9RUDXVVHW]XQJLVWHVYHUQQIWLJIROJHQGH 9HUDOOJHPHLQHUXQJDXV]XVSUHFKHQ 6RIHUQH[SOL]LWH:HUWXUWHLOH3URHLQVWHO OXQJHQ ZLHGHUJHEHQ N|QQHQ DOOH 3URHLQVWHOOXQJHQ GXUFK :HUWXUWHLOH GLH ZHQLJVWHQV LPSOL]LW VLQG ]XP $XVGUXFN JHEUDFKW ZHUGHQ´ $XVJDQJV SXQNW KDQGOXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHU hEHUOHJXQJHQ VLQG QDFK 'DYLGVRQ 3URHLQVWHOOXQJHQ G K VlPWOLFKH Å:QVFKH %HJHKUHQ ,PSXOVH 5HL]H XQG HLQH JURH 9LHOIDOW YRQ PRUDOLVFKHQ $QVLFKWHQ lVWKHWLVFKHQ *UXQGVlW]HQ |NRQRPLVFKHQ 9RUXUWHLOHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ .RQYHQWLR QHQYRQ|IIHQWOLFKHQXQGSULYDWHQ=LHOHQXQG:HUWHQ>@LQVRZHLWGLHVH DOV DXI +DQGOXQJHQ HLQHU EHVWLPPWHQ $UW EH]RJHQH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ HLQHV +DQGHOQGHQJHGHXWHWZHUGHQN|QQHQ´(LQ SULPlUHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQG EHVWHKW 'DYLGVRQ ]XIROJH DXV HLQHU VROFKHQ 3URHLQVWHOOXQJ VRZLH HLQHU EHVWLPPWHQhEHU]HXJXQJ GDPDQHWZDVÅJODXEW>@ZHLZDKUQLPPW PHUNWVLFKHULQQHUW´ XQGNDQQIROJHQGHUPDHQGHILQLHUWZHUGHQ Å*LVW QXUGDQQHLQSULPlUHU*UXQGZHVKDOEHLQHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQGLH+DQG OXQJ + XQWHU GHU %HVFKUHLEXQJ E DXVIKUW ZHQQ VLFK * ]XVDPPHQVHW]W DXV HLQHU 3URHLQVWHOOXQJ GHV +DQGHOQGHQ ]X +DQGOXQJHQ PLW HLQHU EH VWLPPWHQ (LJHQVFKDIW VRZLH GHU hEHU]HXJXQJ GHV +DQGHOQGHQ GD + XQWHUGHU%HVFKUHLEXQJEGLHVH(LJHQVFKDIWKDW´ 'LHVHV0RGHOOLVWDXIZHLWUHLFKHQGH.ULWLNJHVWRHQYRQGHULFKIU GDV )ROJHQGH UHOHYDQW OHGLJOLFK ]ZHL 3XQNWH HUOlXWHUQ P|FKWH 'DYLG 9HOOHPDQKDWJHJHQGLH8QWHUNRPSOH[LWlWGHUVLFKDXVGHP6WDQGDUGPR GHOOHUJHEHQGHQ'LFKRWRPLH]ZLVFKHQ+DQGOXQJHQXQGEORHP9HUKDOWHQ HLQJHZDQGW GD GDV 6WDQGDUGPRGHOO +DQGOXQJHQ LP 9ROOVLQQH JHUDGH QLFKWHUNOlUHQNDQQZLHHUDQHLQHP%HLVSLHO)UHXG·VFKHU)HKOOHLVWXQJHQ GHPRQVWULHUW Å%HFDXVHWKHUHZDVDSXUSRVH>VFWRGHVWUR\WKHLQNVWDQGVR DVWRPDNHZD\IRUKLVVLVWHUWRSUHVHQWKLPDQLFHURQHRQWKHQH[WIHVWLYH RFFDVLRQ .3@IRUZKLFKWKHDJHQWEUXVKHGWKHLQNVWDQG·VFRYHURQWRWKH IORRUKLVGRLQJVRFDQQRWEHFODVVLILHGDVVRPHWKLQJWKDWPHUHO\KDSSHQHG
_____________ 'DYLGVRQ I HQJO 'DYLGVRQ HQJO 'DYLGVRQ HQJO YJODXFK'DYLGVRQ HQJO DOOH NRPSOH[HQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH N|QQHQ QDFK 'DYLGVRQ DXI GHUDUWLJH SULPlUH +DQG OXQJVJUQGHUHGX]LHUWZHUGHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DQGOXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJVJUQGH
WRKLP´$XV%HLVSLHOHQGLHVHU$UWOlWVLFKQDFK9HOOHPDQGDV%HGUIQLV HLQHU 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ ÄEHKDYLRU¶ ÄDFWLYLW\¶ XQG ÄDFWLRQ¶ DEOHLWHQ Å6XFKFDVHVUHTXLUHXVWRGHILQHDFDWHJRU\RIXQJRYHUQHGDFWLYLWLHVGLV WLQFW IURP PHUH KDSSHQLQJV RQ WKH RQH KDQG DQG IURP DXWRQRPRXV DFWLRQV RQ WKH RWKHU 7KLV FDWHJRU\ FRQWDLQV WKH WKLQJV WKDW RQH GRHV UDWKHU WKDQPHUHO\ XQGHUJRHV EXW WKDWRQH VRPHKRZ IDLOV WR UHJXODWH LQ WKHPDQQHUWKDWVHSDUDWHVDXWRQRPRXVKXPDQDFWLRQIURPPHUHO\PRWL YDWHGDFWLYLW\7KHSKLORVRSK\RIDFWLRQPXVWWKHUHIRUHDFFRXQWIRUWKUHH FDWHJRULHV RI SKHQRPHQD PHUH KDSSHQLQJV PHUH DFWLYLWLHV DQG DF WLRQVµ(QWVSUHFKHQGGLHVHU'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJJHKWHVLP)ROJHQGHQOHGLJ OLFKXPPRWLYLHUWH$NWLYLWlWHQXQG+DQGOXQJHQ9HOOHPDQVÄPRWLYDWHGDFWLYL WLHV¶XQGÄDFWLRQV¶ZREHLDXVVFKOLHOLFKOHW]WHUH9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQVLQGGLH HLQHU $XIIRUGHUXQJ ² ZHOFKHU GHRQWLVFKHQ 5HLFKZHLWH DXFK LPPHU ² EHUKDXSW XQWHUOLHJHQ N|QQHQ 9HOOHPDQV 3RLQWH GLHVHU 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ LVW ZRKOJHPHUNW QLFKW GD GDV 6WDQGDUGPRGHOO GHQ %HJULII GHV +DQG OXQJVJUXQGV Y|OOLJ YHUIHKOW ,QVRIHUQ EHVWLPPWH 3URHLQVWHOOXQJHQ XQG hEHU]HXJXQJHQ DQJHIKUW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ QLFKW QXU XP HLQH +DQGOXQJ ]XHUNOlUHQVRQGHUQDXFKXPVLH]XUHFKWIHUWLJHQNDQQ'DYLGVRQV7KHR ULHGXUFKDXV]ZLVFKHQ8UVDFKHQXQG*UQGHQXQWHUVFKHLGHQ0LW%OLFN DXIGLH)UHXG·VFKH)HKOOHLVWXQJHUNHQQWPDQMHGRFKGLHEHJUHQ]WH(UNOl UXQJVNUDIWGLHVHV0RGHOOVGHQQREZRKOGDV9HUKDOWHQGHU3HUVRQGLHGHQ 'HFNHOGHV7LQWHQIDVVHV]HUVW|UWGXUFKHWZDVYHUXUVDFKWVHLQPDJGDVLQ GHU7DWDOVHLQ*UXQGGLHVHV9HUKDOWHQVDQJHVHKHQZHUGHQNDQQVRZXUGH HV GHQQRFK QLFKW DXV GLHVHP *UXQG KHUDXV JHWDQ 9HOOHPDQ UHVPLHUW GDKHU Å>«@ WKH PRGHO KDV QRW OLYHG XS WR LWV RZQ DVSLUDWLRQV LW KDVQ·W VSHFLILHG WKH SURFHVVHV LQ YLUWXH RI ZKLFK EHKDYLRU LV EDVHG RQ UHDVRQV >«@+HQFHWKHVWDQGDUGPRGHOLVVXIILFLHQWIRUPRWLYDWHGDFWLYLW\EXWQRW IRU DXWRQRPRXV DFWLRQµ +DQGOXQJHQ DFWLRQV EHGUIHQ GHPQDFK HLQHU DQGHUHQ(UNOlUXQJDOVGHUGHV6WDQGDUGPRGHOOVXPYRQ9HOOHPDQVÄPRWL YLHUWHQ$NWLYLWlWHQ¶XQWHUVFKLHGHQZHUGHQ]XN|QQHQ
_____________
9HOOHPDQ 9HOOHPDQ 9JO9HOOHPDQ 9HOOHPDQ I YJODXFKHEG Å6RDOWKRXJKKLVEHKDYLRUKDVEHHQFDXVHGE\ VRPHWKLQJWKDWPD\LQIDFWEHDUHDVRQLWKDVQRWEHHQFDXVHGLQWKHULJKWZD\WRKDYH EHHQGRQHIRUWKDWUHDVRQµ 9HOOHPDQ (QWVFKHLGHQGIUPLFKLVWDQGLHVHU 6WHOOH OHGLJOLFK GLH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ 9HUKDOWHQ $NWLYLWlW XQG GHP VSH]LIL VFKHQ %HJULII YRQ +DQGOXQJ XQG ]ZDU XQDEKlQJLJ GDYRQ XQWHU ZHOFKHU %HVFKUHL EXQJ+DQGOXQJHQ DFWLRQV DOVYHUXUVDFKWEH]HLFKQHWZHUGHQN|QQHQ'LH1lKHGLHVHV +DQGOXQJVEHJULIIV ]XP %HJULII GHU $XIIRUGHUXQJ VWHOOW EHUHLWV +DKQ II KHUDXV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
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Å:HU S XQG QLFKW T ZQVFKW RGHU YRU]LHKW ] % OLHEHU %LUQHQ DQVWDWW 3ILUVLFKH HVVHQP|FKWH YHUOHLKWGDPLWSHLQHQK|KHUHQ:HUWDOVTEHWUDFKWHWSLP 9HUJOHLFK]XTDOVYRU]JOLFKHUDOVZQVFKHQVZHUWHU´1HLJXQJHQ:Q VFKH HWF ZHUGHQ GDPLW DXVGUFNOLFK QLFKW JHOHXJQHW (QWVFKHLGHQG LVW MHGRFKGDVLHXQDEKlQJLJYRQLKUHU%HZHUWXQJY|OOLJRSDNXQGGDVEH GHXWHW KDQGOXQJVLUUHOHYDQW EOHLEHQ PVVHQ 6FKRODVWLVFKSRLQWLHUW OlW VLFK GDPLW VDJHQ GD %UDQGRPV 3HUVSHNWLYHQZHFKVHO JHJHQEHU 'DYLGVRQ GDULQEHVWHKWGD:HUWXUWHLOH²ZLHLPSOL]LWDXFKLPPHU²GLHUDWLRFRJQRV FHQGL XQVHUHU 1HLJXQJHQ :QVFKH HWF VLQG $QNQSIHQG DQ .DS LVW GDPLW ]XJOHLFK HLQH ZHVHQWOLFKH 3UlPLVVH ]XU .DQWLVFKHQ 'LVNXVVLRQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH EHQDQQW GHUHQ HLQHV (UJHEQLV GDULQ EHVWDQG GDGLH$XWRULWlWK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHQLFKWDXVGHQEHWHLOLJWHQ1HL JXQJHQ :QVFKHQ HWF VRQGHUQ DXV GHP HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOX GHU 9HUQXQIWLQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHU=ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQVWDPPW'LHVH $XWRULWlW NDQQ VLFK VR JLOW HV KLHU IHVW]XKDOWHQ QXU DXI HWZDV EH]LHKHQ GDVVHLQHUVHLWVEHUHLWVLQQRUPDWLYHP/LFKWHUVFKHLQWGKDOVZQVFKHQV ZHUWEHWUDFKWHWZLUG
6FDQORQVQLFKWUHGXNWLRQLVWLVFKHV.RQ]HSWYRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ
,QH[SOL]LWHU$EVHW]XQJYRQGHU6WDQGDUGDQDO\VHGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHLQ :QVFKH XQG hEHU]HXJXQJHQ IDW 6FDQORQ LQ VHLQHU QLFKW UHGXNWLRQLVWLVFKHQ NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHQ .RQ]HSWLRQ GHQ %HJULII GHV +DQG
_____________ %UDQGRPD +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 LPGHRQWLVFKHQ9RNDEXODUGHU)HVWOHJXQ JHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQ YJOGD]XXQWHQ EHVFKUHLEW%UDQGRP DOVGDV(QWVFKHLGHQGHDQ3URHLQVWHOOXQJHQLP$OOJHPHLQHQGLH7DWVDFKHGDVLHGLH 6]HQH PHQVFKOLFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ HUVW GDGXUFK EHWUHWHQ GD VLH DOV %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]X RGHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH +DQGOXQJ ]XJHVFKULHEHQ ZHUGHQ ² GHU HLJHQHQ RGHU HLQHU DQGHUHQ3HUVRQYJO%UDQGRPDIVRZLH%UDQGRP 9JOREHQLQVEHV)QVRZLHGHQGD]XJHK|ULJHQ$EVDW]
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6FDQORQVQLFKWUHGXNWLRQLVWLVFKHV.RQ]HSWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ
OXQJVJUXQGVDOVHLQHQHLQIDFKHQ%HJULIIDXIGHVVHQ%HGHXWXQJJUXQGOHJHQG GDULQEHVWHKW]XJXQVWHQHLQHU+DQGOXQJ]XVSUHFKHQ (UEHVFKUHLEW]XQlFKVW+DOWXQJHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQRGHUZLHHUVLHVSH ]LILVFKHU QHQQW ÅMXGJPHQWVHQVLWLYH DWWLWXGHV´ GLH HU DOV $QWZRUW DXI IROJHQGH)UDJHDQVLHKW Å:KDWLVWKHUDQJHRIWKLQJVIRUZKLFKUHDVRQVLQ WKHVWDQGDUGQRUPDWLYHVHQVHFDQEHDVNHGIRURURIIHUHG">«@6WDWHVRU RFFXUUHQFHV WKDW DUH LQGHSHQGHQW RI DQ\ FRQVFLRXV DJHQW DUH FOHDUO\ H[ FOXGHG0RVWSHUKDSVHYHQDOORIWKHWKLQJVWKDWDUHLQFOXGHGDUHDWWLWXGHV RI UDWLRQDO DJHQWV VXFK DV EHOLHIV LQWHQWLRQV KRSHV IHDUV DQG DWWLWXGHV VXFKDVDGPLUDWLRQUHVSHFWFRQWHPSWDQGLQGLJQDWLRQµ6FDQORQVSULFKW LQ GLHVHP .RQWH[W YRQ ÅUHDVRQV LQ WKH VWDQGDUG QRUPDWLYH VHQVH´ XP GLHVHQ6SUDFKJHEUDXFKYRQGHPZHLWHUHQGHUGHQ%HJULIIGHUHUNOlUHQGHQ 8UVDFKH HLQVFKOLHW DE]XJUHQ]HQ Å-XGJPHQWVHQVLWLYH DWWLWXGHV´ VLQG GDPLWQDFK6FDQORQDOV(LQVWHOOXQJHQ]XEHVWLPPHQÅ>«@WKDWDQLGHDOO\ UDWLRQDOSHUVRQZRXOGFRPHWRKDYHZKHQHYHUWKDWSHUVRQMXGJHGWKHUHWR EHVXIILFLHQWUHDVRQVIRUWKHPDQGWKDWZRXOGLQDQLGHDOO\UDWLRQDOSHU VRQ ÄH[WLQJXLVK¶ ZKHQ WKDW SHUVRQ MXGJHG WKHP QRW WR EH VXSSRUWHG E\ UHDVRQV RI WKH DSSURSULDWH NLQG´ =X GLHVHU $UW (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]lKOHQ +DQGOXQJHQVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKQLFKWGRFKLVWQDFK6FDQORQGDV(QWVFKHL GHQGHDP+DQGOXQJVEHJULIIZLHHUKLHULQ9HOOHPDQVREHQHLQJHIKUWHP 6LQQYRQDFWLRQV QLFKWEORHQDFWLYLWLHV YHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQVROOGDVLQWHQ WLRQDOH0RPHQW Å7KHFRQQHFWLRQZLWKDFWLRQZKLFKLVHVVHQWLDOWRLQWHQ WLRQVGHWHUPLQHVWKHNLQGVRIUHDVRQVWKDWDUHDSSURSULDWHIRUWKHPEXWLW LV WKH FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK MXGJPHQWVHQVLWLYH DWWLWXGHV WKDW PDNHV HYHQWV DFWLRQV DQG KHQFH WKH NLQG RI WKLQJV IRU ZKLFK UHDVRQV FDQ VHQVLEO\ EH DVNHGIRUDQGRIIHUHGDWDOOµ :QVFKHKDEHQLQ6FDQORQV+DQGOXQJVWKHRULH²DEJHVHKHQYRQLKUHU )XQNWLRQDOV*UQGH²NHLQH5HOHYDQ]IUGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJXQG(UNOl UXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ bKQOLFK ZLH %UDQGRP JHJHQ GDV YRQ 'DYLGVRQ YHUWUHWHQH6WDQGDUGPRGHOOGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHDUJXPHQWLHUWVWHOOW6FDQ ORQ VHLQH 7KHRULH LQ 2SSRVLWLRQ ]X )UDQNIXUW XQG HEHQIDOOV 'DYLGVRQ ZREHLHUZHLWDXVVSH]LILVFKHUDOV%UDQGRPDXIGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGHQWKHRUH WLVFKHQ'LYHUJHQ]HQHLQJHKW 'LH(LQ]HOKHLWHQGLHVHVYLHOOHLFKWDPZHLWHVWHQHODERULHUWHQQDWXUDOLVWL VFKHQ:XQVFKPRGHOOV+DUU\)UDQNIXUWVGHU]ZLVFKHQÅ:QVFKHQHUVWHU 2UGQXQJ´ XQG Å:QVFKHQ ]ZHLWHU 2UGQXQJ´ XQWHUVFKHLGHW ZUGHQ DQ GLHVHU6WHOOH]XZHLWIKUHQZHVKDOEKLHUQXUGDVIUGDV)ROJHQGH5HOH
_____________
6FDQORQ 9JO6FDQORQ 6FDQORQ 6FDQORQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
YDQWHGLHVHUWKHRUHWLVFKHQ:HLFKHQVWHOOXQJHUOlXWHUWZHUGHQVROO:lKUHQG :QVFKHHUVWHU2UGQXQJQDFK)UDQNIXUWGDVVFKOLFKWH%HVWUHEHQEHLQKDO WHQ HLQHQ EHVWLPPWHQ =XVWDQG KHUEHL]XIKUHQ EH]LHKHQ VLFK :QVFKH ]ZHLWHU2UGQXQJLKUHUVHLWVDXI:QVFKHHUVWHU2UGQXQJ:QVFKH]ZHL WHU2UGQXQJVLQGDOVR:QVFKH:QVFKHHUVWHU2UGQXQJ]XKDEHQRGHU QLFKW ]X KDEHQ E]Z :QVFKH HUVWHU 2UGQXQJ DOV KDQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYH :QVFKH ]X KDEHQ RGHU QLFKW ]X KDEHQ 6FDQORQ YHUWULWW GDJHJHQ GLH $XIIDVVXQJ GLH5HGH YRQ:QVFKHQ ]ZHLWHU 2UGQXQJ VHL EH]JOLFK GHV GDEHL HUIRUGHUOLFKHQ $EZlJXQJVSUR]HVVHV LUUHIKUHQG LQVRIHUQ LKU YHU PHLQWOLFKHU:XQVFKFKDUDNWHUHLQHUJHVRQGHUWHQ%HJUQGXQJLKUHUVSH]LIL VFKHQ $XWRULWlW EHGUIWH 'LH %HJUQGXQJ PWH LP :LGHUVSUXFK ]X )UDQNIXUWV:XQVFKKLHUDUFKLHDXIHWZDVUHNXUULHUHQGDVVHOEVWQLFKWZLH GHUXPHLQVFKOLFKWHUHPRWLRQDOHU,PSXOVVHLQNDQQ 0LW%OLFNDXIGLHVHKXPHDQLVFKDULVWRWHOLVFKH(UNOlUXQJVUHLKHQIROJH² YRQ:QVFKHQEHUÄ,GHQWLILNDWLRQHQ¶PLWGLHVHQ:QVFKHQ]X+DQGOXQ JHQ²NULWLVLHUW6FDQORQ]XHUVWGLHWKHRUHWLVFKH'RPLQDQ]GHU:QVFKHLP 0RWLYDWLRQV]XVDPPHQKDQJ XP GDUDQ DQVFKOLHHQG GLH 5ROOH GHU :Q VFKHLP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV]XVDPPHQKDQJ]XGLVNXWLHUHQ$XIGLH3UREOHPD WLN PRUDOLVFKHU 0RWLYDWLRQ ZHUGH LFK GHWDLOOLHUW HUVW LQ .DS HLQJHKHQ
_____________ 9JO)UDQNIXUW LQVEHV GW 9JO6FDQORQ %HUHLWV*DU\:DWVRQHLQIUKHU.ULWLNHUQLFKWQXU)UDQNIXUWV VRQGHUQ GHV GHVLUHEHOLHI 0RGHOOV LQVJHVDPW XQG %HIUZRUWHU GHU $QQDKPH YRQ 3URHLQVWHOOXQJHQGLHQLFKWDXI:QVFKHUHGX]LHUWZHUGHQN|QQHQKDWDUJXPHQWLHUW GD )UDQNIXUWV ÄVHFRQGRUGHU GHVLUHV¶ RKQH GLH %HUFNVLFKWLJXQJ HLQHV ZHVHQWOLFK QLFKWHPRWLYHQUHIOH[LYHQ0RPHQWVQLFKWDGlTXDWEHVFKULHEHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ Å%XW ZK\GRHVRQHQHFHVVDULO\FDUHDERXWRQH·VKLJKHURUGHUYROLWLRQV"6LQFHVHFRQGRUGHU YROLWLRQVDUHWKHPVHOYHVVLPSO\GHVLUHVWRDGGWKHPWRWKHFRQWH[WRIFRQIOLFWLVMXVW WRLQFUHDVHWKHQXPEHURIFRQWHQGHUV LWLVQRWWRJLYHDVSHFLDOSODFHWRDQ\RIWKRVH LQFRQWHQWLRQ´ :DWVRQ 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKVHLVLFK)UDQNIXUWVR:DWVRQ GHU3UREOHPDWLNGHVVWHWHQ9HUZHLVHVDXIK|KHUH2UGQXQJHQYRQ:QVFKHQEHZXW XQGEHKDXSWHGHVKDOEGLH0|JOLFKNHLWGLH.HWWHK|KHUHU2UGQXQJHQYRQ:QVFKHQ ]XEHVFKOLHHQGDGXUFKGDPDQVLFKÄHQWVFKORVVHQ¶ ÅGHFLVLYHO\´)UDQNIXUW GW PLWHLQHPGHU:QVFKHHUVWHU2UGQXQJLGHQWLIL]LHUH:DWVRQUHSOL]LHUW GDUDXIIROJHQGHUPDHQ Å:HZDQWHGWRNQRZZKDWSUHYHQWVZDQWRQQHVVZLWKUHJDUG WRRQH·VKLJKHURUGHUYROLWLRQV:KDWJLYHVWKHVHYROLWLRQVDQ\VSHFLDOUHODWLRQWRÄRQH VHOI¶" ,W LV XQKHOSIXO WR DQVZHU WKDW RQH PDNHV D ÄGHFLVLYH FRPPLWPHQW¶ ZKHUH WKLV MXVWPHDQVWKDWDQLQWHUPLQDEOHDVFHQWWRKLJKHURUGHUVLVQRWJRLQJWREHSHUPLWWHG 7KLVLVDUELWUDU\>«,@WLVXQFOHDUZK\WKHVHDFWVRILGHQWLILFDWLRQFDQQRWEHWKHPVHOYHV RI WKH ILUVW RUGHU ² WKDW LV LGHQWLILFDWLRQ ZLWK RU FRPPLWPHQW WR FRXUVHV RI DFWLRQ UDWKHUWKDQZLWKRUWRGHVLUHV ²LQZKLFKFDVHQRDVFHQWLVQHFHVVDU\DQGWKHQRWLRQ RIKLJKHURUGHUYROLWLRQVEHFRPHVVXSHUIOXRXV>«@´ :DWVRQ I 9JONUL WLVFK ]X )UDQNIXUW DXFK 4XLQQ VRZLH ]X ZHLWHUHQ .ULWLNHQ XQG )UDQNIXUWV :HLWHUHQWZLFNOXQJ VHLQHU .RQ]HSWLRQ %HW]OHU*XFNHV VRZLH .XV VHU9JO:DWNLQV GHUDXV.DQWLVFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHNULWLVFKDXI)UDQN IXUWVVSlWHUH0RGLILNDWLRQHQVHLQHUHLJHQHQ7KHRULHUHDJLHUW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6FDQORQVQLFKWUHGXNWLRQLVWLVFKHV.RQ]HSWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ
GRFK VROO 6FDQORQV DOOJHPHLQH $XIIDVVXQJ KLHU NXU] HUOlXWHUW ZHUGHQ GD GLH VR EHVWLPPWH (UNOlUXQJVUHLKHQIROJH DOV :HLFKHQVWHOOXQJ IU PHLQH QDFKIROJHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQJHOWHQNDQQ 6FDQORQZHQGHWVLFKQLFKWJHJHQGLH$XIIDVVXQJGDHVHLQHQ8QWHU VFKLHG ]ZLVFKHQ GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV GXUFK HLQH 3HUVRQXQGGHUWDWVlFKOLFKHQ$XVZLUNXQJGLHVHV+DQGOXQJVJUXQGVDXIGLH QDFKIROJHQGH+DQGOXQJGLHVHU3HUVRQJHEH(UZHQGHWVLFKOHGLJOLFKGD JHJHQGDGDVMHQLJHZDVGLHVHQ8QWHUVFKLHGEH]HLFKQHWHWZDVLVWGDVZLU EOLFKHUZHLVH DOV :XQVFK EH]HLFKQHQ 'HU 8QWHUVFKLHG EHVWHKW QDFK 6FDQORQYLHOPHKULQHLQHU$EZlJXQJGLHVHV*UXQGVJHJHQDQGHUH*UQGH ZREHLGLH$EZlJXQJPLWXQWHUZHLWGDYRQHQWIHUQWVHLQNDQQ]XHLQHP² LP /LFKWH JU|HUHU LQWUD RGHU LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU =XVDPPHQKlQJH ² JXWHQ *UXQG]XIKUHQ 1XQ LVW HV VR 6FDQORQ Å>«@ WULYLDOO\ WUXHWKDW ZKHQHYHU D SHUVRQ LV PRYHG WR DFW KH RU VKH KDV DQ ÄXUJH¶WR DFW LQWKDW ZD\ %XW WKH LGHD RI VXFKDQXUJHIDLOVWRFRUUHVSRQGWRWKHRUGLQDU\QRWLRQRIGHVLUHµ $P %HLVSLHOGHV'XUVWVEHQHQQW6FDQORQZDVZLULPSOL]LHUHQZHQQZLUGDYRQ DXVJHKHQ GD ZLU DXV 'XUVW JHWUXQNHQ KDEHQ ÅD SUHVHQW VHQVDWLRQ WKH GU\QHVVLQP\WKURDW WKHEHOLHIWKDWVRPHDFWLRQZRXOGOHDGWRDSOHDVDQW VWDWHLQWKHIXWXUHDQGP\WDNLQJWKLVIXWXUHJRRGWREHDUHDVRQIRUVRDFW LQJ´ 'D GLH PRWLYDWLRQDOH .UDIW GLH VFKOLHOLFK ]XU +DQGOXQJ IKUW QLFKW DXV GHP N|USHUOLFKHQ *HIKO GHV WURFNHQHQ +DOVHV HUNOlUW ZHUGHQ NDQQ OlW VLFK GDUDQ HUNHQQHQ GD ZLU LPVWDQGH VLQG XQG GLHV KlXILJ DXFKWXQ GHUDUWLJH*HIKOH]XEHUJHKHQLKUH%HGHXWXQJJHJHQEHUGHU %HGHXWXQJDQGHUHU*HIKOHDE]XZlJHQ]XUFN]XVWHOOHQHWF'LHPRWLYD WLRQDOH .UDIW HQWVSULQJW DOVR YLHOPHKU GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GHV LQ =XNXQIW JHO|VFKWHQ 'XUVWV DOV HLQHV JHJHQZlUWLJHQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV %HKDXSWHW ZHUGHQ VROO GHPQDFK QLFKW GD DOOH :QVFKH YRUDXVJHKHQGHQ 8UWHLOHQ HQWVSULQJHQVRQGHUQYLHOPHKUGDGDV+DEHQHLQHV:XQVFKHVEHGHXWHW HWZDV DOV HLQHQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQG DQ]XVHKHQ HJDO RE GLHVHU VFKOLHOLFK KDQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYZLUGRGHUQLFKW 'DQHEHQ GDUI LQ HLQHU VROFKHQ 7KHRULH MHGRFK QLFKW GDV WUHLEHQGH (OHPHQWYRQ*HIKOHQYHUORUHQJHKHQGHQQZLHVLFKDP'XUVWXQGQDWU OLFK DXFK DQ DQGHUHQ %HGUIQLVVHQ OHLFKW DEOHVHQ OlW EHVLW]HQ *HIKOH P|JOLFKHUZHLVHHLQH,QWHQVLWlWGLHHLQH3HUVRQVR]XVDJHQÄEOLQG¶IUDOOHV DQGHUH XP VLH KHUXP PDFKHQ NDQQ 6FDQORQ VSULFKW GHVKDOE YRQ HLQHP
_____________
9JOGD]X6FDQORQ I 6FDQORQ 6FDQORQ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 9JO 6FDQORQ ]X HLQHU IXQNWLRQDOLVWLVFKHQ .ULWLN DQ 6FDQORQ YJO &RSS6REHO
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
ÅGHVLUH LQ WKH GLUHFWHGDWWHQWLRQ VHQVH >«@ LI WKH SHUVRQ·V DWWHQWLRQ LV GLUHFWHGLQVLVWHQWO\WRZDUGFRQVLGHUDWLRQVWKDWSUHVHQWWKHPVHOYHVDVFRXQWLQJ LQ IDYRU RI3´ 'LHVH *HIKOH RGHU :QVFKH N|QQHQXQVEXFKVWlEOLFK EHUIDOOHQXQGVRODQJHQLFKWPHKUORVODVVHQELVVLHEHIULHGLJWVLQG'RFK JHKWGLHVHUÄ,PSHWXV¶²VROODXVLKPHLQH+DQGOXQJXQGQLFKWEORHV9HUKDO WHQUHVXOWLHUHQ²HEHQQLFKWGLUHNWLQHLQSK\VLVFKHV(UHLJQLVEHUVRQGHUQ GUlQJWVLFKLQQHUKDOEXQVHUHUhEHUOHJXQJHQRGHU*HGDQNHQGHUDUWLQGHQ 9RUGHUJUXQG ELV VFKOLHOLFK VFKHLQEDU QLFKWV PHKU JHJHQ GLH (UIOOXQJ GHVHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ:XQVFKHVVSULFKW$XFKLQGHUDUWLJHQ)lOOHQZHUGHQ :QVFKHKDQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYQXUGDGXUFKGDGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQVLHDOV DXVVFKODJJHEHQG DQHUNHQQW Å'HVLUH LQWKH GLUHFWHGDWWHQWLRQVHQVH FKDU DFWHUL]HV DQ LPSRUWDQW IRUP RI YDULDELOLW\ LQ WKH PRWLYDWLRQDO HIILFDF\ RI UHDVRQV EXW LW GRHV WKLV E\ GHVFULELQJ RQH ZD\ LQ ZKLFK WKH WKRXJKW RI VRPHWKLQJDVDUHDVRQFDQSUHVHQWLWVHOIUDWKHUWKDQE\LGHQWLI\LQJDPRWL YDWLQJIDFWRUWKDWLVLQGHSHQGHQWRIVXFKDWKRXJKWµ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²ZLH6WHIDQ*RVHSDWK]X5HFKWEH
_____________ 6FDQORQ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 ² 3 VWHKW IU GLH %HIULHGLJXQJ HLQHV :XQ VFKHV 6FDQORQ 9JO 6FDQORQ PRGHUQHU $XVJDQJVSXQNW GLHVHU .RQWURYHUVH LVW :LOOLDPV GHVVHQ YRQLKPVHOEVWVREH]HLFKQHWHU Å 6XE +XPHDQLVPXV´DOV.RQWUDVWIROLHDXFK LP +LQWHUJUXQG YRQ 6FDQORQV $XVIKUXQJHQ VWHKW :LOOLDPV DN]HSWLHUW +DQGOXQJV JUQGHDOVVROFKHQXULQVRIHUQVLHHLQH9HUELQGXQJ]XUÅVXEMHNWLYHQPRWLYDWLRQDOHQ 9HUIDVVXQJ´ :LOOLDPV GHV+DQGHOQGHQDXIZHLVHQ(LQH3RLQWHJHJHQEHU GHULQWHUQDOLVWLVFKHQ8UVSUXQJVWKHRULH+XPHV %RRN,,3DUW6HFWVXQG OLHIHUW6FDQORQLQHLQHU)XQRWH Å7KHLQVLVWHQWFKDUDFWHUWKDWPDUNVGHVLUHVLQWKH GLUHFWHGDWWHQWLRQVHQVHPD\DOVREHSDUWRIZKDW+XPHKDVLQPLQGLQVSHDNLQJRI ÄYLROHQW¶SDVVLRQV>«@,IVRWKHQP\WKHVLVLVLQLPSRUWDQWUHVSHFWVWKHUHYHUVHRIKLV +H VD\V SS WKDW ZKHUH WKLV FKDUDFWHU LV ODFNLQJ ² LQ WKH FDVH RI ZKDW KH FDOOVÄFDOP¶SDVVLRQV²ZHDUHDSWWRPLVWDNHSDVVLRQIRUWKHRSHUDWLRQRI5HDVRQ,DP DUJXLQJRQWKHFRQWUDU\WKDWZKHUHWKLVHOHPHQWLVSUHVHQWZHPD\PLVWDNHQO\EHOLHYH WKDWWKHPRWLYDWLRQDOIRUFHRIDVWDWHOLHVLQVRPHWKLQJRWKHUWKDQDWHQGHQF\WRVHH VRPHWKLQJDVDUHDVRQµ 6FDQORQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6FDQORQVQLFKWUHGXNWLRQLVWLVFKHV.RQ]HSWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ
PHUNW KDW² MHGRFK ÅHWZDVÄDXVJHOHLHUW¶ ZHLO VLH LQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ%H GHXWXQJHQ YRQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ $XWRUHQ YHUZHQGHW ZLUG´ 'LH DXI : 'DYLG)DON]XUFNJHKHQGH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJKDW]XYLHOHÄLVPHQ¶KHUYRU JHEUDFKWXPDOVVROFKHQRFKHLQHQQHQQHQVZHUWHQH[SODQDWRULVFKHQ:HUW ]XEHVLW]HQ,P)ROJHQGHQVROOPLW%H]XJDXI%HJUQGXQJHQXQG5HFKW IHUWLJXQJHQ YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ HLQ ([WHUQDOLVPXV LQ GHP VFKZDFKHQ 6LQQ YHUWUHWHQ ZHUGHQ ZRQDFK SUDNWLVFKH 9HUQXQIW QLFKW GDULQ DXIJHKW GLH ,PSOLNDWLRQHQ RGHU .RQVHTXHQ]HQ XQVHUHU :QVFKH ]X EHQHQQHQ VRQ GHUQGDUEHUKLQDXVLPVWDQGHLVW]XPHLQHQJHQXLQHYDOXDWLYHhEHUOHJXQ JHQ]X:QVFKHQDQ]XVWHOOHQXQG]XPDQGHUHQPLWGLHVHQhEHUOHJXQJHQ QHXDUWLJH0RWLYDWLRQVSHUVSHNWLYHQ]XDOOHUVW]XHU|IIQHQ 'HU 9HUVXFK MHJOLFKH :HUWVFKlW]XQJ ]% YRQ .XQVWZHUNHQ LQHL QHQ :XQVFK ]X WUDQVIRUPLHUHQ HEQHW QLFKW QXU UHDO EHVWHKHQGH 8QWHU VFKLHGH]ZLVFKHQEHVWLPPWHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQHLQYLHOPHKUIHKOWGHU 5HGXNWLRQYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQDXI:QVFKHLP%HJUQGXQJVNRQWH[W GDV IU GHQ %HJULII GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV (QWVFKHLGHQGH QlPOLFK GDV 0RPHQW GHU %HZHUWXQJ G K HLQ 8UWHLO GD GLH $XVIKUXQJ HLQHU EH VWLPPWHQ +DQGOXQJ HWZDV *XWHV EHLQKDOWHW VHL GLHVHV *XW QXQ HWZDV
_____________ *RVHSDWK YJO]XU'HEDWWHXP,QWHUQDOLVPXVXQG([WHUQDOLVPXVDXFKGLH hEHUVLFKWPLWZHLWHUIKUHQGHU/LWHUDWXULQ*RVHSDWK 9JO)DON VRZLHDXIGLHVHQUHNXUULHUHQG.RUVJDDUG D 1DFKZLHYRUHLQVFKOlJLJVFKHLQWPLUKLHU1DJHOV$EJUHQ]XQJGHV0RWLYDWLRQVLQWHUQD OLVPXVÅHLQHUJUXQGVlW]OLFKDQWLUDWLRQDOHQHWKLVFKHQ7KHRULHGLH HWZDVVFKOLFKW9RU JHJHEHQHV ]X LKUHP )XQGDPHQW KDW ZLH HLQ *HIKO HLQH ]ZLVFKHQPHQVFKOLFKH %LQ GXQJHLQH1HLJXQJRGHUHLQ%HJHKUHQ´²PDQN|QQWHKLHUDQGLH VSlWHUHQWVWDQGHQH 7KHRULH:LOOLDPVGHQNHQ²YRQ1DJHOVHLJHQHP GXUFK.DQWLQIRUPLHUWHQ 0RWLYDWL RQVLQWHUQDOLVPXV Å(LQ VWULNWHUHU ,QWHUQDOLVPXV PDFKW GLH 0RWLYDWLRQ KLQJHJHQ DP NRJQLWLYHQ *HKDOW HWKLVFKHU $QVSUFKH IHVW XQG SRVWXOLHUW 0RWLYDWLRQVNUlIWH GLH QLFKW PHKU DEZHLVHQ NDQQ ZHU VLFK LKUHU HLQPDO EHZXW ZLUG´ 1DJHO ZRUDXV QDWUOLFKNHLQHVZHJVIROJWGDPDQDXFKVWHWVHQWVSUHFKHQGKDQGHOW0LWGLHVHU3RVL WLRQ1DJHOVLVWDXFKLQNRPSDWLEHOZDVGHU0RUDOUHDOLVW$XGLXQWHUGHP%HJULIIÅUHD VRQV LQWHUQDOLVP´ DEOHKQW Å>«@ WKDW D QRUPDWLYH UHDVRQ IRU DFWLRQ PXVW EH JURXQGHGLQVRPHLQWHUQDOFRQDWLYHRUDWOHDVWQRQFRJQLWYHPRWLYDWLRQDOVWDWHRIWKH DJHQWIRULQVWDQFHDGHVLUHDVRSSRVHGWRGHULYLQJIURPDQH[WHUQDOUHTXLUHPHQWVXFK DV D FDWHJRULFDO LPSHUDWLYH >«@´ $XGL ,Q $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW GHQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ 3RVLWLRQHQ .DQWV XQG +DEHUPDV· ZLUG VLFK XQWHQ LQ .DS ]HLJHQ ZLH SUREOHPDWLVFK GLH ,QWHUQDOLVPXV([WHUQDOLVPXV'LVMXQNWLRQ LVW LQVRIHUQ +DEHU PDV ]ZDU GDV ÄSULQFLSLXP GLMXGLFDWLRQLV¶ YRP ÄSULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV¶ HQWNRSSHOW GHVZHJHQ DEHU ZRKO NDXP DOV 0RWLYDWLRQVH[WHUQDOLVW EH]HLFKQHW ZHUGHQ NDQQ GHQQ HLQHULFKWLJH+DQGOXQJJHVFKLHKWLKP]XIROJHÄDXV(LQVLFKW¶LQGLHUHOHYDQWHQ*UQGH ZHQQJOHLFKQLFKWHQWODQJGHUREMHNWLYLVWLVFKHQ9RUJDEHQ1DJHOV YJOGD]XDXFK6FD UDQRDI %HLVSLHOVZHLVH DXFK ]ZLVFKHQ GHU +LOIHOHLVWXQJ JHJHQEHU PHLQHP %UXGHU XQG GHU +LOIHOHLVWXQJJHJHQEHUHLQHUYRQPLUDXVGUFNOLFKYHUDEVFKHXWHQ3HUVRQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
$QJHQHKPHVHLQ9RUWHLORGHUVRQVWHWZDV:HUWYROOHV 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK KDEHQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH3HUVRQHQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHLQVR IHUQVLHXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH:QVFKHXQG9RUOLHEHQEHVLW]HQ6FKOLHOLFKKDW PHLQ+DQGOXQJVJUXQG]%HLQHJDQ]EHVWLPPWH&'PLW'RZODQGV/DX WHQPXVLNDQ]XK|UHQDXFKGDPLW]XWXQGDPLUGLHVH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQJH IlOOW ZDV DQGHUH 3HUVRQHQ IU LKUHQ *HVFKPDFN HYHQWXHOO YHKHPHQW DE OHKQHQZUGHQ'RFKDXFKLQGLHVHP)DOOEHGDUIHVGHU9RUVWHOOXQJHLQHV ]XNQIWLJHQ (UOHEQLVVHV GHVVHQ (LQEH]LHKXQJ LQ PHLQH JHJHQZlUWLJHQ $EZlJXQJHQXQGVHLQHU$QHUNHQQXQJDOV+DQGOXQJV]ZHFNXPVFKOLHOLFK GLH,QWHQWLRQDXV]XELOGHQGDV*HUlWWDWVlFKOLFKHLQ]XVFKDOWHQ :LHEHZXWXQGH[SOL]LWGLHVH$EZlJXQJHQQXQDXFKLPPHUGXUFKJH IKUW ZHUGHQ ]ZHLIHOORV LVW KLHU $XVIKUOLFKNHLW NHLQ =HLFKHQ XQVHUHU $OOWDJVHQWVFKHLGXQJHQ HLQHNRQNUHWH+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW]XKDEHQEHGHX WHW HLQHQ *UXQG ]X EHVLW]HQ GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGH +DQGOXQJ DXV]XIKUHQ XQG ² QRUPDOHUZHLVH ² NHLQHQ EHVVHUHQ *UXQG ]X VHKHQ GLHVH $EVLFKW ZHLWHU]XEHUGHQNHQ6FDQORQZHLVWLQGLHVHP.RQWH[WHUOlXWHUQGGDU DXIKLQGDGLHVH5HOHYDQ]YRQ*UQGHQLP*HJHQVDW]]X:QVFKHQDOV DIIHNWLYHQ ,PSXOVHQ QLFKW QXU IU ,QWHQWLRQHQ JLOW VRQGHUQ EHUHLWV IU hEHUOHJXQJHQ GLHMDQLFKWLPPHU]XHQWVSUHFKHQGHQSUDNWLVFKHQ)HVWOH JXQJHQ RGHU ,QWHQWLRQHQ IKUHQ PVVHQ Å/LNH WKH IRUPDWLRQ RI DQ LQ WHQWLRQ VXFK D ÄWDNLQJ¶ >D FRQVLGHUDWLRQ WR EH UHOHYDQW .3@ LV D PRYH ZLWKLQSUDFWLFDOWKLQNLQJUDWKHUWKDQDVGHVLUHVDUHFRPPRQO\VXSSRVHGWR EHDVWDWHZKLFKVLPSO\RFFXUVDQGLVWKHQDÄJLYHQ¶IRUVXEVHTXHQWGHOLEH UDWLRQ 7KLV LV VKRZQ E\ WKH IDFW WKDW LW FRQWLQXHV WR DIIHFW WKH UHDVRQV RQH KDV RQO\ LQ WKH DEVHQFH RI JURXQGV IRU UHFRQVLGHUDWLRQ µ 'DV IU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH (QWVFKHLGHQGH ZDV :QVFKH LP 6LQQH GLHVHU VHHOLVFK RGHU N|USHUOLFK DXIWUHWHQGHQ %HGUIQLVVH RGHU %HVWUHEXQJHQ QLFKW EHVLW ]HQ LVW LKU VSH]LILVFKHU %HZHUWXQJVLQGH[ LKUH $QHUNHQQXQJ DOV *UXQG 'LHVH$QHUNHQQXQJDOV*UXQGLVWZHGHULGHQWLVFKPLWQRFKUHGX]LEHODXI GDV hEHU]HXJXQJVPRPHQW ÄGD GLH +DQGOXQJ GHQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ
_____________ 9JOGD]X6FDQORQ 9JO ]XU 5HYLVLRQ YRQ NRPSOH[HQ ,QWHQWLRQHQ XQG 3OlQHQ %UDWPDQ ² 'DVEHGHXWHWVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKQRFKQLFKWGDPDQPLWJXWHQ*UQGHQKDQGHOW DXI GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ 8QWHUVFKLHGH ]ZLVFKHQ JXWHQ *UQGHQ XQG UDWLRQDOHQ (UIRU GHUQLVVHQJHKHLFKLPQlFKVWHQ.DSLWHOHLQ 6FDQORQ YJOHEG Å>«@ZKHQZHFRQVLGHUWKHYDULRXVVWDWHVWKDWPLJKWEH LGHQWLILHGDVGHVLUHVZHILQGQRQHWKDWFDQSOD\WKHJHQHUDOUROHLQMXVWLILFDWLRQFRP PRQO\DVVLJQHGWRGHVLUHV²WKDWRIVWDWHVZKLFKDUHLQGHSHQGHQWRIRXUSUDFWLFDOUHD VRQLQJDQGZKLFKZKHQWKH\RFFXUSURYLGHUHDVRQIRUGRLQJZKDWZLOOSURPRWHWKHLU IXOILOOPHQW0DQ\RIRXUUHDVRQVGRKDYHVXEMHFWLYHFRQGLWLRQVEXWWKHVHWXUQRXWRQ FORVHULQVSHFWLRQWREHUDWKHUPLVOHDGLQJO\GHVFULEHGE\WKHWHUPLQRORJ\RIGHVLUHDQG GHVLUHIXOILOOPHQWµ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6FDQORQVQLFKWUHGXNWLRQLVWLVFKHV.RQ]HSWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ
:XQVFK HUIOOHQ ZLUG¶ GDV LP GHVLUHEHOLHI0RGHOO GDV HLQ]LJ 5DWLRQDOH DXVPDFKWH YJO REHQ (LQ :XQVFK PX XP +DQGOXQJVUHOHYDQ] ]X HUODQJHQ HLQ *UXQG ZHUGHQ HU PX ² PLQGHVWHQV DXV HLQHU VXEMHNWLYHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH ² ÄYHUGLHQHQ¶ LQ (UZlJXQJ JH]RJHQ ]X ZHUGHQ XQG GDVEH GHXWHWHUPXDOVHWZDVEHWUDFKWHWZHUGHQGDV]XJXQVWHQHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ +DQGOXQJVSULFKW2KQHGLHVH%HZHUWXQJIKUHQ%HGUIQLVVHQXU]X9HU KDOWHQQLFKW]X+DQGOXQJHQ'DV]ZHLIHOORVLUUHGX]LEHOVXEMHNWLYH0R PHQW EHOLHELJHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH EHVWHKW GDULQ GD XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH 3HUVRQHQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH'LQJHXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKEHZHUWHQ8QVHUQRUPDWL YHU 8PJDQJ PLW XQVHUHQ VXEMHNWLYHQ 9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQ EHVWLPPW HUVW ZHOFKH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH ZLU KDEHQ 'LH QDWXUDOLVWLVFKH SV\FKROR JLVWLVFKHPHQWDOLVWLVFKH²RGHUDQZHOFKHQLVPHQDXFKLPPHURULHQWLHUWH ²$QDO\VHGHV%HJULIIVGHV+DQGOXQJVJUXQGVNDQQVRIROJHLFK6FDQORQV 9HUPXWXQJ LKU =LHO ZRKO QLH HUUHLFKHQ Å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´ ,P )ROJHQGHQ ZLUGVLFKMHGRFK]HLJHQGD6FDQORQV3HVVLPLVPXVEH]JOLFKGHUQRUPD WLYHQ %HVWLPPXQJ GHV %HJULIIV GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV ² HLQ +DQGOXQJV JUXQG VHL HLQH DEVWUDNW QLFKW ZHLWHU VSH]LIL]LHUEDUH hEHUOHJXQJ GLH IU HLQH+DQGOXQJVSULFKW²KLQVLFKWOLFKGHUORJLVFKHQ5HLFKZHLWHYRQ+DQG OXQJVJUQGHQHWZDVYHUIUKWLVW
_____________ 2E9HOOHPDQVDFWLYLWLHVLQGLHVHP6LQQHDOV9HUKDOWHQRGHUDOV+DQGOXQJ]XEH]HLFKQHQ VLQGKlQJWYRQGHUMHZHLOLJHQ 6HOEVW =XVFKUHLEXQJVSHUSHNWLYHDE YJOREHQ)Q VRZLHXQWHQ 6FDQORQ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 YJO GD]X DXFK 6FDQORQV HQWVSUHFKHQGHV 5HVPHH Å,WLVUDUHO\LIHYHUWKHFDVHWKDWVRPHRQHKDVDUHDVRQIRUDFWLRQEHFDXVHVR DFWLQJZRXOGVDWLVI\DGHVLUH:KDWZHQRUPDOO\FDOOÄKDYLQJDGHVLUHIRU[¶LVEHVWXQ GHUVWRRGDVWDNLQJVRPHFRQVLGHUDWLRQVXFKDVWKHIDFWWKDW[ZRXOGEHSOHDVDQWDVD UHDVRQWREULQJ[DERXWDQGLQVXFKDFDVHLWLVWKLVFRQVLGHUDWLRQLWVHOIUDWKHUWKDQ WKHDJHQW·VÄGHVLUH¶WKDWSURYLGHVWKHDJHQWZLWKDUHDVRQ'HVLUHVDUHQRWWKHQEDVLF VRXUFHVRIMXVWLILFDWLRQ1RUDUHWKH\QHFHVVDU\DVVRXUFHVRIPRWLYDWLRQ LI,WDNHWKH IDFWWKDWGRLQJ[ZRXOGEHSOHDVDQWRUZRXOGUHSD\DGHEWWREHDJRRGUHDVRQIRUDF WLRQWKLVFDQVXIILFHWRH[SODLQP\IRUPLQJWKHLQWHQWLRQWRGR[DQGGRLQJ[7KHUHLV QRQHHGWRSRVLWDIXUWKHUVWDWHRIGHVLULQJ[´ (EG
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
6WUXNWXUHOOH5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG0D[LPHQ
(LQNRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHV.RQ]HSWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQNDQQQXQDXIGHP YRUVWHKHQG EHVFKULHEHQHQ JHPHLQVDPHQ %RGHQ GHV .RJQLWLYLVPXV HLQH +HUDXVIRUGHUXQJDQGLH.DQWLVFKH3RVLWLRQGDUVWHOOHQZHQQHVZLHGLHVH HLQH$OWHUQDWLYH]XP.RQVHTXHQWLDOLVPXVELHWHWRKQHGLHSUREOHPDWLVFKH 3UlPLVVH.DQWV]XWHLOHQGDGLH%HUFNVLFKWLJXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVIROJHQ ZHGHU EHL GHU $XVELOGXQJ HLQHU PRUDOLVFKHQ $EVLFKW RGHU 0D[LPH QRFK EHL GHU %HXUWHLOXQJ HLQHU +DQGOXQJ DOV PRUDOLVFK UHOHYDQW VHL ,Q GLHVHP 6LQQH DQ 6FDQORQ DQNQSIHQG DUJXPHQWLHUW 1LGD5PHOLQ PLW VHLQHU .RQ]HSWLRQ ÅVWUXNWXUHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW´ QLFKW QXU PLW .DQW JHJHQ GLH VLFK DXI +XPH EHUXIHQGH Å,PSHWXVWKHRULH GHV +DQGHOQV´ VRQGHUQ LQ WHJULHUWQHEHQ1HLJXQJHQNXOWXUHOOHQ3UlJXQJHQXQGVR]LDOHQ5ROOHQDXFK ZLHGHUXP PLW .DQW ÅQRUPDWLYH *UXQGSULQ]LSLHQ´ XQG GHPHQWVSUH FKHQGJHQXLQPRUDOLVFKH*UQGHEHLVSLHOVZHLVHDXIJUXQGGHV*HERWVGHU 5FNVLFKWQDKPHLQGHQ7KHRULHUDKPHQP|JOLFKHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGH (U ZHQGHW VLFK MHGRFK KLQVLFKWOLFK GHV PRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGHOQV ² XQG GDV LVW GLH NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKH 3RLQWH GLH HV LP )ROJHQGHQ ]X TXDOLIL]LHUHQ JLOW ² JHUDGH JHJHQ .DQWV VFKDUIH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ .OXJKHLWV JUQGHQXQGPRUDOLVFKHQ*UQGHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHGLHP|JOLFKH.RQ VHTXHQ]HQ GHU +DQGOXQJ UHIOHNWLHUHQ VHLHQ QLFKW SHU VH DPRUDOLVFK HV EHVWHKH YLHOPHKU HLQ 6SHNWUXP DQ JXWHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ GDV QLFKW D SULRUL EHVWLPPW ZHUGHQ N|QQH Å'LH UDWLRQDOH +DQGOXQJ UHSUlVHQWLHUW DN]HSWLHUWHJXWH*UQGHPDQFKHEHUXKHQDXIHUIDKUHQHP:RKOZROOHQPDQ FKH DXI JHJHEHQHQ 9HUVSUHFKHQ DQGHUH DXI JHlXHUWHQ :QVFKHQ RGHU JHJHEHQHQ%HIHKOHQHLQLJHDXIHLJHQHQ,QWHUHVVHQRGHUDXIGHQYHUPXWH WHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ DQGHUHU YLHOH DXI 5HFKWHQ XQG 3IOLFKWHQ HLQLJH ZHQLJH GLUHNW DXI HWKLVFKHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ´ 2E XQG ZHQQ MD ZLH PRUDOLVFKH
_____________ 1LGD5PHOLQ 1LGD5PHOLQ EH]LHKW VLFK LP JHJHQZlUWLJHQ .RQWH[W ]ZDU QLFKWH[SOL]LWDXI6FDQORQHLQHSDXVFKDOHDIILUPDWLYH5HIHUHQ]DXI6FDQORQILQGHWVLFK DEHULQ1LGD5PHOLQ 1LGD5PHOLQ 1LGD5PHOLQ 1LGD5PHOLQ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 ,P6LQQHVROFKHUHWKLVFKHQ3ULQ]LSLHQ HLQHV VR]LDOHQ .RKlUHQ]UDKPHQV KDW *HUW ]ZHL 6HWV PRUDOLVFKHU 5HJHOQ YRUJHVFKOD JHQ GLH GDV 9HUERW YHUVFKLHGHQHU 6FKDGHQV]XIJXQJHQ HEHQVR HQWKDOWHQ ZLH YHU VFKLHGHQH :DKUKDIWLJNHLWVJHERWH YJO *HUW =XVDW] ]XU GW hEHUVHW]XQJ QLFKWLP2ULJLQDO YJO]XGLHVHQ5HJHOVHWVGLH.DSXQGLQ*HUW 'LH'LIIH UHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHQEHLGHQ5HJHOVHWVEHVWHKWGDULQGDGHQ]ZHLWHQIQI :DKUKDIWLJ NHLWV 5HJHOQQLFKWJHKRUFKWZHUGHQVROOZHQQGDPLWDQGHUHQ KlXILJ'ULWWHQ 6FKD GHQ ]XJHIJW ZLUG ZREHL VLFK GDV 5DWLRQDOLWlWVNULWHULXP VRZRKO DQ LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHU DOV DXFK DQ LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU .RKlUHQ] RULHQWLHUW Å,UUDWLRQDOLWlW LVW HLQ LFKEH]RJHQHU
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6WUXNWXUHOOH5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG0D[LPHQ
*UQGHDOVÄDN]HSWLHUWHJXWH*UQGH¶LQHLQHQ.RKlUHQ]UDKPHQP|JOLFKHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGHEHUKDXSWLQWHJULHUWZHUGHQN|QQHQVROOLQGHQEHLGHQ QlFKVWHQ.DSLWHOQPLWHLQHU'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJYRQ.RKlUHQ]NULWHULHQZHLWHU XQWHUVXFKW ZHUGHQ 'RFK XQDEKlQJLJ GDYRQ NDQQ PDQ 1LGD5PHOLQ GDULQ]XVWLPPHQGD5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHQYRQLQWHUVXEMHNWLYJOWLJHQ.RKl UHQ]NULWHULHQ QLFKW XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU JHQXLQ HQGOLFKHQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW G K DEVWUDNW RGHU D[LRPDWLVFK ]X KDEHQ VLQG Å%HJUQ GXQJVSIOLFKWHQ WUHWHQ LP *UXQGH QXU GRUW DXI ZR ,QNRKlUHQ]HQ YRUOLH JHQ ,QWHUQH ,QNRKlUHQ]HQ YHUODQJHQ QDFK %HJUQGXQJ JHJHQEHU GHU KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ VHOEVW H[WHUQH JHJHQEHU NULWLVFKHQ )UDJHQ DQGHUHU >«@(LQHXPIDVVHQGHVWUXNWXUHOOH(QWVFKHLGXQJEHZlKUWVLFKGDQQZHQQ ÄNOHLQHUH¶(QWVFKHLGXQJHQIUGLHVHOEVWZLHGHUXPJXWH*UQGHVSUHFKHQ VLFK LQ GLH JU|HUH VWUXNWXUHOOH (QWVFKHLGXQJ HLQEHWWHQ ODVVHQ $QGHUHU VHLWVJHZLQQHQGLHNOHLQHUHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJHQDQ*HZLFKWXQG3ODXVLELOLWlW ZHQQVLHVLFKLQHLQHQVWUXNWXUHOOHQ5DKPHQHLQEHWWHQODVVHQ´'HUÄHQW VFKHLGHQGH (LQIOX GHU 9HUQXQIW DXI XQVHUH +DQGOXQJHQ¶ ULFKWHW VLFK GHPHQWVSUHFKHQG DQ GHU P|JOLFKHQ (LQEHWWXQJ YRQ (LQ]HOHQWVFKHLGXQ JHQ LQ GLHVHQ VWUXNWXUHOOHQ 5DKPHQ DXV 'RFK NODU LVW DXFK GD GLHVHU VWUXNWXUHOOH5DKPHQQLFKWHLQIDFKEHVWHKWVRQGHUQGXUFK+DQGOXQJVSULQ ]LSLHQRGHU0D[LPHQYDULDEOHU$OOJHPHLQKHLWVHOEVWHUVWNRQVWLWXLHUWZLUG $OV VROFKH SUDNWLVFKUDWLRQDOHQ %HVWLPPXQJHQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKVWHU (LQVWHO
_____________ %HJULIIGDV KHLWGLHHLQ]LJHQLUUDWLRQDOHQ+DQGOXQJHQVLQGVROFKHGLHVLFKLQGHP 6LQQH JHJHQ PHLQ (LJHQLQWHUHVVH ULFKWHQ DOV VLH PLU RKQH KLQUHLFKHQGHQ *UXQG LU JHQGHLQHQ6FKDGHQ]XIJHQRGHU]XP9HUOXVWLUJHQGHLQHV*XWHVIKUHQ*UQGHVLQG MHGRFK QLFKW LFKEH]RJHQ XQG ZDQQ LPPHU ZLU MHPDQGHQ QLFKW QXU XQV VHOEVW YRU 6FKDGHQEHZDKUHQZDQQLPPHUZLU6FKDGHQYHUKWHQRGHUDXFKOLQGHUQN|QQHQLVW GDVHLQ*UXQGHLQHVRQVWLUUDWLRQDOH+DQGOXQJLQHLQHUDWLRQDOH]XYHUZDQGHOQ>«@ 'HU%HJULIIGHU5DWLRQDOLWlWLVWVRPLWHLQ0LVFKEHJULIIGHUGLH,FKEH]RJHQKHLWGHU,U UDWLRQDOLWlWHEHQVRXPIDWZLHGLH8QSDUWHLOLFKNHLWYRQ*UQGHQ´ *HUW =XVDW]]XUGWhEHUVHW]XQJQLFKWLP2ULJLQDO 'LHXQWHQLQGHQ.DSXQGPLW5H NXUVDXISUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQYHUVXFKWHQ%HVWLPPXQJHQGHVYRQ*HUWDQJHVSURFKH QHQ5DWLRQDOLWlWVEHJULIIVVRZLHGHVYRQLKPHEHQIDOOVDQJHVSURFKHQHQ%HJULIIVSUDNWL VFKHU *UQGH ZHUGHQ GLH 5HVWULNWLRQ DXI Ä(LJHQLQWHUHVVH¶ DXIKHEHQ XQG MHQHV Ä0LVFKYHUKlOWQLV¶DXIO|VHQ'LH3UREOHPHGLHPLW*HUWVRGHUYHUJOHLFKEDUHQ$QVlW]HQ YHUEXQGHQVLQGEHVWHKHQPHLQHV(UDFKWHQV]XPHLQHQGDULQGDGHU%HJULIIGHU5D WLRQDOLWlW LQ HLQHP XQWHUEHVWLPPWHQ 9HUKlOWQLV ]XP %HJULII GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV VWHKWXQG]XPDQGHUHQGDULQGDYRQGHU:DUWHGHV3KLORVRSKHQDXVHLQHDQWKURSR ORJLVFKH .RQVWDQWH EHVFKULHEHQ ZLUG ÄGHU 0HQVFK IOLHKW hEHO¶ GLH PLW QRUPDWLYHU .UDIWDXVJHVWDWWHWYRUJHVWHOOWZLUGXPDOV+DQGOXQJVE]Z%HXUWHLOXQJVNULWHULXP]X GLHQHQ0LUVFKHLQWGHPJHJHQEHUHLQH.RQ]HSWLRQ DXVVLFKWVUHLFKHU]XVHLQGLHGLH $UWLNXODWLRQSHUV|QOLFKHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQGHQ,QGLYLGXHQVHOEVWEHUOlWXQGVWDWWGHV VHQ HLQH EHVWLPPWH )RUP YRQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ DOV OHJLWLP DXVZHLVW 9JO NULWLVFK ]X *HUWV%HJULIIGHUXQSDUWHLOLFKHQ5DWLRQDOLWlWDXFK6LQQRWW$UPVWURQJ 1LGD5PHOLQI
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
OXQJHQQHKPHQGLHVH+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQHLQHQ]HQWUDOHQ3ODW]LQHLQHP NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHQ.RQ]HSWGHU+DQGOXQJVOHJLWLPDWLRQHLQ 6FDQORQ EHVWLPPW 0D[LPHQ LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH DOV 3ULQ]LSLHQ GLH GLH $QJHPHVVHQKHLW RGHU 8QDQJHPHVVHQKHLW JHZLVVHU hEHUOHJXQJHQ DOV *UQGH IU HLQH JHZLVVH +DOWXQJ MXGJPHQWVHQVLWLYH DWWLWXGH VSH]LIL]LHUHQ XQGVLHKWVLFKGDPLW]X5HFKWLQGHU.DQWLVFKHQ7UDGLWLRQ Å>«@IRU.DQW PD[LPVDUHQRWMXVWIHDWXUHVRIPRUDOUHDVRQLQJEXWFHQWUDOFRPSRQHQWV RI SUDFWLFDO UHDVRQLQJ PRUH JHQHUDOO\ DQG P\ SUHVHQW SRLQW LV WKDW WKLV VHHPVLQWXLWLYHO\WREHFRUUHFW0RUDOLW\DVLGHRXUSUDFWLFDOWKLQNLQJWDNHV SODFH ZLWKLQ D IUDPHZRUN RI PD[LPV DQG LV FRQFHUQHG ZLWK DGRSWLQJ LQWHUSUHWLQJ DQG PRGLI\LQJ WKHVH SULQFLSOHV DV ZHOO DV ZLWK GHFLGLQJ ZLWKLQWKHIUDPHZRUNWKH\SURYLGHZKHWKHUZHKDYHVXIILFLHQWUHDVRQIRU DFWLQJLQSDUWLFXODUZD\Vµ ,QVHLQHU*UXQGOHJXQJKDW.DQWGHQ%HJULIIGHU0D[LPHDOVÅSUDNWLVFKH 5HJHOGLHGLH9HUQXQIWGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGHV6XEMHFWVJHPl |IWHUVGHU 8QZLVVHQKHLWRGHUDXFKGHQ1HLJXQJHQGHVVHOEHQ EHVWLPPW´GHILQLHUW 'DEHLKDEHQZLUZLH.ODXV6WHLJOHGHUNRQVWDWLHUWÅ>@.DQW]XIROJHYRQ HLQHP *HIOHFKW RGHU 1HW] YRQ 0D[LPHQ DXV]XJHKHQ GDV VLFK DXV GHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ HLQHV ,QGLYLGXXPV HUJLEW XQG GDV hEHU XQG 8QWHURUG QXQJHQ YRQ Ä:LOOHQVEHVWLPPXQJHQ¶ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ $OOJHPHLQKHLWVJUDGHV XQGYHUVFKLHGHQHU$UWHQWKlOW'DV6SHNWUXPUHLFKWQDFK.DQWYRQHLQHU JUXQGOHJHQGHQ XQG REHUVWHQ 0D[LPH IU GLH :DKO DOOHU =ZHFNH EHU KDXSWELVKLQ]XGHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJHQNRQNUHWH+DQGOXQJHQDXV]XIKUHQ XPEHVWLPPWH=LHOH]XHUUHLFKHQ´:LUELOGHQVR.DQWLP/DXIHXQVH
_____________ 6FDQORQ .DQW,9I$QP 6WHLJOHGHUYJODXFKHEG HULQWHUSUHWLHUW.DQWV0D[LPHQDOVÅ8U WHLOHLQGHQHQVLFKHLQKDQGOXQJVIlKLJHV6XEMHNWHQWVFKOLHWNRQNUHWHRGHUEHUJUHL IHQGH=LHOVHW]XQJHQKDQGHOQG]XYHUIROJHQ´ HEG XQGEHWRQWGDEHL Å:DVGLH DQJHVSURFKHQHQ$UWHQYRQ0D[LPHQDQEHODQJWVRJLOWHV>«@]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ]ZL VFKHQGHU,QWHQWLRQ=ZHFNHKDQGHOQG]XHUUHLFKHQXQGGHU,QWHQWLRQ+DQGOXQJHQ DXV]XIKUHQ XP =ZHFNH KDQGHOQ ]X HUUHLFKHQ´ (EG I 9JO ]X .DQWV 0D[L PHQEHJULIIDXFK$OOLVRQ I GHU0D[LPHQPLW9HUZHLVDXI.DQW DXFKDOV,QWHQWLRQHQDQVSULFKW HLQVFKUlQNHQGGD]X 2·1HLOO VRZLH:LO ODVFKHN GHUYRQHLQHPÅ·KROLVWLVFKHQ¶=XJ´VSULFKWGHQ+DQGOXQJVEH JUQGXQJHQGXUFK0D[LPHQHUKDOWHQ Å(LQH+DQGOXQJOlWVLFKQLFKWLVROLHUWEHJUQ GHQ VRQGHUQ LPPHU QXU DOV 7HLO HLQHV =XVDPPHQKDQJV ]X GHP DXFK GLH EULJHQ ,QWHUHVVHQGHV+DQGHOQGHQJHK|UHQXQGGHUGDKHUXQWHUHLQHQXPIDVVHQGHQLGHDOHQ +DQGOXQJVSODQIlOOWGHQGHU+DQGHOQGHPLW%OLFNDXIGLHHLJHQHÄ*OFNVHOLJNHLW¶HQW ZLUIW´ (EG 7LPPHUPDQQ ZLHGHUXPXQWHUVFKHLGHWEHL.DQWGUHL 0D[LPHQEHJULIIH0D[LPHQDOVGLHÅ3ULQ]LSLHQHUVWHU6WXIHYRQ+DQGOXQJHQ´DOVÅ:LOOHQV DNWH>«@GLHVLFKLKUHUVHLWVDXI:LOOHQVDNWHQLHGHUHU6WXIHHUVWUHFNHQXQGQLFKWGLUHNW ]X+DQGOXQJHQIKUHQ´VRZLHDOVÅEHZXWDQJHQRPPHQHEHVRQGHUVNODUHFKDUDNWH ULVWLVFKH+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQHLQHU3HUVRQ´6RXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKGLHYRUJHQDQQWHQ,Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6WUXNWXUHOOH5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG0D[LPHQ
UHV (UZDFKVHQZHUGHQV G K PLW ]XQHKPHQGHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW SHUV|QOLFKH *UXQGVlW]HDXVGLHVFKOLHOLFKXQVHUHQ&KDUDNWHUNHQQ]HLFKQHQXQGVLFK GDUDQRULHQWLHUHQÅQXUGDVMHQLJH]XZlKOHQZDVGLH9HUQXQIWXQDEKlQJLJ YRQGHU1HLJXQJDOVSUDNWLVFKQRWKZHQGLJ>@HUNHQQW´0DQPXQXQ NHLQHQUREXVWHQ%HJULIIHLQHV HPSLULVFKHQRGHULQWHOOLJLEOHQ &KDUDNWHUV GHV 0HQVFKHQEHVLW]HQXP YRQ EHUJUHLIHQGHQ +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ ]X VSUHFKHQ VRQGHUQ NDQQ LQ OHW]WHUHQ VFKOLFKWZHJ YHULQQHUOLFKWH ZHQQ JOHLFKGXUFKGLH3HUVRQEHJUQGEDUH(QWVFKHLGXQJVPXVWHUVHKHQZHOFKH HLQHQ JOREDOHQ +DQGOXQJV]ZHLIHO SXQNWXHOO VLVWLHUHQ N|QQHQ XQG GDPLW EHUKDXSWHUVWGLH6WDELOLWlWYRQ²DXFKLQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ²+DQGOXQJVSOl QHQHUP|JOLFKHQ ,P)ROJHQGHQVROOHVQXQOHGLJOLFKXPKDQGOXQJVEH]RJHQH5DWLRQDOL WlWVVWUXNWXUHQ JHKHQ ZHQQJOHLFK EHUJUHLIHQGH 5DWLRQDOLWlWVVWUXNWXUHQ QLFKW DXI +DQGOXQJHQ EHVFKUlQNW VLQGVRQGHUQ YLHOPHKU DOOJHPHLQH 8U WHLOHGDUVWHOOHQGLHGLH$XVELOGXQJEHVWLPPWHUHSLVWHPLVFKHURGHUSUDNWL VFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU $QJHPHVVHQKHLW YRQ GHUHQ %HJUQ GXQJHQOHLWHQRGHUEHVFKUlQNHQ 'DVNRQVHTXHQWLDOLVWLVFKH*HJHQPRGHOO]XGLHVHPVWUXNWXUDOLVWLVFKHQ $QVDW]VWHOOW+DQGHOQGHDOVÄSXQNWXHOOH2SWLPLHUHU¶YRUXQGJHKWGHPHQW VSUHFKHQGGDYRQDXVGDHLQH+DQGOXQJGDQQEHJUQGHWLVWZHQQVLHGDV =LHO]XGHVVHQ(UUHLFKXQJVLHDOV0LWWHOHUNDQQWZXUGHWDWVlFKOLFK RGHU
_____________
WHUSUHWDWLRQVDQVlW]HDXFKVHLQP|JHQVRYHUZHLVHQVLHGRFKDOOHH[SOL]LWRGHULPSOL]LW DXI GDV KROLVWLVFKH 0RPHQW LQ .DQWV 0D[LPHQNRQ]HSWLRQ GDV .DQW 0D[LPHQ ]ZDU VFKZHUSXQNWPlLJLPPRUDOLVFKHQ.RQWH[WEHKDQGHOQKLHUMHGRFKVWHWVDXFKDXHU PRUDOLVFKH *HJHEHQKHLWHQ HLQEH]LHKHQ OlW =X HLQHU LQVWUXNWLYHQ GLVNXUVHWKLVFKHQ 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQGHV.DQWLVFKHQ0D[LPHQEHJULIIVYJO:HUQHU ,QHLQHU5HIOH[LRQDXVGHQHU-DKUHQKHLWHV Å*HJHQGDVVWH-DKUEHVWLPPWVLFK HUVWUHFKWGHU&KDUDFWHU J'HUJXWH&KDUDFWHUEHUXKWDXIGHPNDOWHQ.RSIXQGZDU PHQ+HU]HQ ´ .DQW;9 .DQW,9 .DQWVSULFKWYRPÅPRUDOLVFKH>Q@%HZHJXQJVJUXQG´GHUÅGHUHLQ]LJH LVWZHOFKHUHLQHQ&KDUDNWHU SUDNWLVFKHFRQVHTXHQWH'HQNXQJVDUWQDFKXQYHUlQGHUOL FKHQ0D[LPHQ JUQGHW>«@´ .DQW9 9JO]XU LQWHQVLYHQ 'HEDWWHLQQHUKDOE GHU .DQW)RUVFKXQJ EHU GHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ YRQ 0D[LPH &KDUDNWHU XQG 7XJHQG EHL.DQWGHQKLVWRULVFKGHWDLOOLHUWHQXQGSKLORVRSKLVFKVHKUDXIVFKOXUHLFKHQ$XIVDW] YRQ.KQ0V .DQWVGLHVEH]JOLFKHU6SUDFKJHEUDXFKLVWXQHLQKHLWOLFK:lKUHQGHUEHLVSLHOVZHLVHLQ GHU .U9 $ 1DWXU XQG )UHLKHLWVXUVDFKHQ PLW GLHVHP %HJULIIVSDDU XQWHU VFKHLGHQP|FKWH]LHOWGLH5HOLJLRQVVFKULIW YJO.DQW9, GDPLWDXIGLH8QWHUVFKHL GXQJ]ZLVFKHQ/HJDOLWlWXQG0RUDOLWlW 9JO%UDWPDQV$XVIKUXQJHQ]XLQGLYLGXHOOHQXQGNROOHNWLYHQ,QWHQWLRQHQXQG+DQG OXQJVSOlQHQLQ%UDWPDQ LQVEHV3DUW, 9JO6FDQORQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
K|FKVWZDKUVFKHLQOLFK HUUHLFKHQ OlW 'HU .RQVHTXHQWLDOLVPXV QLPPW GDPLW .DQWV .RQ]HSWLRQ SUREOHPDWLVFKWHFKQLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH GHU *H VFKLFNOLFKNHLW HLQH EHVRQGHUH )RUP K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH DXI XQG JHQHUDOLVLHUW GLHVH $XI GHQ $EZHLV HLQHU GHUDUWLJHQ 9HUHQJXQJ P|JOL FKHU +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ ZHUGH LFK QRFK ]XUFNNRPPHQ :LFKWLJ IU PHLQH QDFKIROJHQGH $UJXPHQWDWLRQ LVW ]XQlFKVW OHGLJOLFK HLQH $QDORJLH ]ZLVFKHQLQWUDSHUVRQHOOHUXQGLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU.RKlUHQ]SUDNWLVFKHU(LQ VWHOOXQJHQ ZR]X HLQH .OlUXQJ GHU 3UREOHPH GHU ,QWHUWHPSRUDOLWlWVRZLH GHUVWUXNWXUHOOHQ9HU]DKQXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQHUIRUGHUWZLUG
,QWHUWHPSRUDOLWlW
$XIEDXHQG DXI GLH $UEHLWHQ 1DJHOV 6FDQORQV XQG %UDWPDQV DUJXPHQ WLHUW1LGD5PHOLQGLHVEH]JOLFKIUHLQHVSH]LILVFKH5HYLVLRQGHUEHUHLWV HUZlKQWHQ KXPHDQLVFKHQ ÄGHVLUHEHOLHI¶7KHRULH $Q %HLVSLHOHQ ZLH GHP JHJHQZlUWLJHQ (LQNDXI YRQ 1DKUXQJVPLWWHOQ XP UDWLRQDO HUZDUWEDUH
_____________ 9RQ GHP .RQVHTXHQWLDOLVPXV ]X VSUHFKHQ LVW ZLH DOOH 5HGH YRQ LVPHQ QDWUOLFK ]X XQVFKDUI XP 3RVLWLRQHQ JHJHQHLQDQGHU SURILOLHUHQ ]X N|QQHQ HV EHGUIWH KLHU DOVR QRFKGHU=XVDW]TXDOLILNDWLRQGXUFKGDV.RQ]HSWGHUGLUHNWHQ0D[LPLHUXQJ:lKUHQG GDV0D[LPLHUXQJVSULQ]LSOHGLJOLFKEHVDJWGDGLHMHQLJH+DQGOXQJJHZlKOWZLUGZHO FKHGLH$XVVLFKWDXIGDV(UUHLFKHQHLQHVVXEMHNWLYHQ=LHOVPD[LPLHUWJHKHQVXEVWDQ WLHOOHUH)RUPHQGHV.RQVHTXHQWLDOLVPXVGDYRQDXVGD=LHOHDOVPHKURGHUZHQLJHU DOOJHPHLQH:HUWHEHVWLPPWZHUGHQPVVHQLQVRIHUQGLHVLWXDWLYHDGKRF=LHOEHVWLP PXQJQLFKWDXVUHLFKWXPDGlTXDWH0LWWHO]XU(UUHLFKXQJGHV=LHOVDXV]XPDFKHQ,Q VRIHUQGHU:HUWHLQHU+DQGOXQJVLFKDP:HUWGHV6DFKYHUKDOWVGHUGXUFKVLHKHUYRU JHUXIHQ ZLUG EHPHVVHQ ZLUG RULHQWLHUW VLFK SUDNWLVFKH 5DWLRQDOLWlW GLHVHQ VXEVWDQWLHOOHUHQ)RUPHQ YRQ1XW]HQPD[LPLHUXQJJHPlQLFKWQXU DQGHU0D[LPLH UXQJGHU:DKUVFKHLQOLFKNHLWGHU=LHOHUUHLFKXQJVRQGHUQDXFKDQGHU:QVFKEDUNHLW GHV =LHOV VHOEVW (V EHGDUI DOVR HLQHU LQKDOWOLFKHQ $EZlJXQJ XQG %HVWLPPXQJ YRQ =LHOHQ HJDOREGLHVGHU.DUULHUHHUIROJHLQHV,QGLYLGXXPVGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH1XW ]HQRGHUHWZDVDQGHUHVLVW XPGLHJHHLJQHWHQ0LWWHOEHUKDXSW]XVXFKHQ9JO]XU 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]DKOUHLFKHU )RUPHQ GHV .RQVHTXHQWLDOLVPXV EHLVSLHOVZHLVH 6HQ GHUVHOEVWHLQHVXEVWDQWLHOOH9HUVLRQGHV.RQVHTXHQWLDOLVPXVYHUWULWW 9JO.DQW,9VRZLHREHQ.DS 1LGD5PHOLQ LVW JHJHQZlUWLJ VRZHLW LFK VHKH GHU HLQ]LJH GHXWVFKVSUDFKLJH $XWRU GHULQVHLQHhEHUOHJXQJHQGLHJOHLFKRULHQWLHUWHQ$UEHLWHQGLHVHU$XWRUHQNRQVWUXNWLY HLQEH]LHKW9JO]X1DJHOV$UJXPHQWDWLRQÅ>«@GDXQVHUHHLJHQHQ]XNQIWLJHQ,QWH UHVVHQEHUHLWVIUVLFKJHQRPPHQ*UQGHJHEHQXQVHU+DQGHOQLQGHU*HJHQZDUWDQ LKQHQDXV]XULFKWHQXQGGDHLQH0RWLYDWLRQGLHVHU$UWHLQHU(UNOlUXQJGXUFKGD]ZL VFKHQJHVFKREHQH JHJHQZlUWLJH :QVFKH RGHU LUJHQGZHOFKH DQGHUHQ YHUPLWWHOQGHQ $QWULHEVTXHOOHQZHGHUIlKLJQRFKEHGUIWLJLVW´ 1DJHO I LQVEHVRQGHUH1D JHO .DS9JODXFK%UDWPDQ GD]XDXFKXQWHQ)Q 6FDQORQ LQVEHV3DUW,
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
,QWHUWHPSRUDOLWlW
]XNQIWLJH²QLFKWJHJHQZlUWLJH²%HGUIQLVVH]XEHIULHGLJHQZLUGGHXW OLFKGDHLQDOOHLQDXI1HLJXQJHQXQG%HGUIQLVVHUHNXUULHUHQGHV0RGHOO YRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQHLQHUDGlTXDWHQ%HVFKUHLEXQJXQVHUHU$OOWDJVSUD [LVQLFKWJHUHFKWZLUG8QGVHOEVWZHQQPDQGDV]XNQIWLJH%HGUIQLVDOV HLQ JHJHQZlUWLJHV %HGUIQLV LQWHUSUHWLHUW ZHOFKHV GDV ]XNQIWLJH DQWL]L SLHUWVWHOOWVLFKGDV3UREOHPGHU$EZlJXQJJHPlVROFKHQ.ULWHULHQGLH GLH *HJHQZDUWVSHUVSHNWLYH EHUHLWV EHUVFKUHLWHQ GHQQ GD GLH VWHWV DXI DNWXHOOH 1HLJXQJVLPSXOVH XQPLWWHOEDUH +DQGOXQJVUHDNWLRQ DXVUHLFKHQ N|QQWHXPPHQVFKOLFKHV+DQGHOQ]XYHUVWHKHQZUGHQZRKOVHOEVW9HU WUHWHU GHU ÄGHVLUHEHOLHI¶7KHRULH NDXP EHKDXSWHQ ZROOHQ 1LGD5PHOLQ VSULFKWGHVKDOEYRQHLQHUÅ'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQSXQNWXHOOHUXQGVWUXNWXUHO OHU5DWLRQDOLWlW´XQGIRUGHUW Å(LQHDQJHPHVVHQH7KHRULHSUDNWLVFKHU5D WLRQDOLWlW PXVV ]XODVVHQ GDVV VSH]LILVFKHUH ,QWHQWLRQHQ HUVW LP +LQEOLFN DXI DOOJHPHLQHUH DOV UDWLRQDO JHOWHQ´ (UVW HLQH UHIOH[LYH'LVWDQ]LHUXQJ YRQ DNWXHOO EHVWHKHQGHQ %HGUIQLVVHQ DXIJUXQG GHU UDWLRQDOHQ (UZDUWXQJ ]XNQIWLJHU%HGUIQLVVH²RGHUDXFKDXIJUXQGGHU(LQEH]LHKXQJEHVWLPP WHU:HUWHRGHU1RUPHQ²HUODXEWHLQUDWLRQDOHV+DQGHOQ ,QWUDSHUVRQHOOH.RKlUHQ]EHGHXWHWGDQDFKGDHLQH3HUVRQQLFKWDXV VFKOLHOLFKDNWXHOOHQ1HLJXQJVLPSXOVHQIROJWRGHUJHQDXHUGDHLQH3HU VRQGLHVROFKHQDNWXHOOHQ$IIHNWHQIROJWHLQ+DQGHOQJHPlHLQHPVRO FKHQ$IIHNWJHJHQEHU$OWHUQDWLYHQGKHLQHPQLFKWDIIHNWLYHQ+DQGHOQ DEJHZRJHQ KDW ZRGXUFK VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK GDV +DQGHOQ DXV UHLQHP $I IHNWDXIK|UWHLQVROFKHV]XVHLQ =HQWUDOIUGHQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVLVWGDEHL GD QLFKW HLQH MHGH HLQ]HOQH +DQGOXQJ HLQ $EZlJHQ YRQ XQ]lKOLJHQ $O WHUQDWLYHQ ² VFKOLHOLFK OlW VLFK ]ZLVFKHQ $OWHUQDWLYHQ HLQ .RQWLQXXP ZHLWHUHU$OWHUQDWLYHQGHQNHQ²YRUDXVVHW]WVRQGHUQGDZLUXQVDXIJUXQG XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU %HGUIQLVVH 1HLJXQJHQ VR]LDOHU (UIDKUXQJHQ :HUWH XQG 1RUPHQ GLH ZLU LP /DXI GHU =HLW DXVELOGHQ +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ RGHU 0D[LPHQ ]X HLJHQ PDFKHQ DQ GLH ZLU XQV VHOEVW ELQGHQ 'LHVH +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQZHUGHQHRLSVRLQWHUWHPSRUDODXVJHELOGHWGDSXQN WXHOOH %HGUIQLVVH 1HLJXQJHQ HWF QXU EHU ]HLWOLFKH (UIDKUXQJ KLQZHJ
_____________ 1LGD5PHOLQ 1LGD5PHOLQGHPRQVWULHUWGLHVDP%HLVSLHOGHUVFKWLJHQ3HUVRQGLHVLFKYRUQLPPW GLH6XFKW]XEHUZLQGHQXQGVFKOLHOLFKGDPLW(UIROJKDW Å(VZlUHEHUDXVNQVW OLFK GLHVH ODQJH )ROJH YRQ EHZXVVWHQ 8QWHUODVVXQJHQ VLFK HLQH =LJDUHWWH DQ]X]Q GHQ DOV(UJHEQLVHLQHV$EZlJXQJVSUR]HVVHVLPVLQJXOlUHQ)DOO]XLQWHUSUHWLHUHQ(V VLQG QLFKW GLH JHVXQGKHLWVVFKlGOLFKHQ $XVZLUNXQJHQ GHU QlFKVWHQ =LJDUHWWH GLH ]X UDXFKHQ PDQ XQWHUOlVVW GLH HLQHQ GDYRQ DEKDOWHQ GLHVH =LJDUHWWH DQ]X]QGHQ VRQ GHUQHVLVWGLH$EVLFKWPLWGHP5DXFKHQHLQIUDOOH0DODXI]XK|UHQ GKVLFKDQGLH EHWUHIIHQGH 5HJHO GLH GXUFK GLHVH )ROJH YRQ 8QWHUODVVXQJHQ EHIROJW ZLUG ]X KDO WHQ ´ 1LGD5PHOLQ $PGHWDLOOLHUWHVWHQDXVJHDUEHLWHWLVWGLHVHUKROLVWLVFKH =XJYRQ0D[LPHQJHJHQZlUWLJLQ%UDWPDQV3ODQXQJVWKHRULH YJOXQWHQ)Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
LQWHJULHUW+DQGOXQJVPXVWHUDXVPDFKHQN|QQHQ'LH6XPPHGLHVHU+DQG OXQJVVWUXNWXUHQGLHEHLVSLHOVZHLVH]XHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ:DKOSHUV|QOLFKHU )UHXQGHRGHUDXFKHLQHV%HUXIVIKUHQWUlJWHLQHYRQ3HUVRQ]X3HUVRQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH6LJQDWXU :HOFKH LQKDOWOLFKH 6WUXNWXU GLH 6XPPH GHU +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z +DQG OXQJVJUQGH HLQHU 3HUVRQ EHVLW]W LVW QLFKW DOOJHPHLQ ]X EHVWLPPHQ ZDV ]XPHLQHQDQGHQSHUV|QOLFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQXQGLQGLYLGXHOOHQ6WHOOXQJ QDKPHQXQG]XPDQGHUHQDQLKUHU]HLWOLFKRIIHQHQGKUHYLVLRQVIlKLJHQ )RUP OLHJW 'D GLHVH XQKLQWHUJHKEDUH 6XEMHNWDEKlQJLJNHLW P|JOLFKHU +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ GHQQRFK QLFKW QRWZHQGLJ LQ HLQHQ LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ ,QGLIIHUHQWLVPXV PQGHQ PX OLHJW DP EHUHLWV HUOlXWHUWHQ WKHRUHWLVFKHQ 3ULPDW GHU *UQGH YRU GHQ :QVFKHQ %HGUIQLVVHQ RGHU 1HLJXQJHQ GDDOVRGLHVHKDQGOXQJVUHOHYDQWQXULQ)RUPYRQ*UQGHQZHUGHQN|Q QHQ8PEHVWUHLWHQ]XN|QQHQGDHLQEHVWLPPWHV%HGUIQLVIUHLQHDQGH UH3HUVRQHLQHQDGlTXDWHQ+DQGOXQJVJUXQGGDUVWHOOWPXPDQVHOEVWGHU $XIIDVVXQJVHLQGDGHUDUWLJHVXEMHNWLYH$QOLHJHQEHUKDXSWLQWHUVXEMHN WLYWHLOEDUHXQGPLW$UJXPHQWHQDXV]XVWDWWHQGH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHGDUVWHO OHQN|QQHQ :HOFKHIRUPDOH6WUXNWXUGLH6XPPHGLHVHU+DQGOXQJHQEHVLW]WLVW]ZDU HEHQIDOOVQLFKWDOOJHPHLQ]XEHVWLPPHQGRFKOlWVLFKKLHU]XPLQGHVWHLQ .ULWHULXPEHQHQQHQGDVZLULP$OOWDJDXFKVWlQGLJDQZHQGHQ GLH5DWLR QDOLWlW HLQHU 3HUVRQ YHUKlOW VLFK GLUHNW SURSRUWLRQDO ]XU .RKlUHQ] GHU 6WUXNWXUYRQ(QWVFKHLGXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJHQGLHVHU3HUVRQ'HU)RNXV OLHJWKLHUVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKDXIGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ5DWLRQDOLWlWGLHVHU3HUVRQ G K LKUHU NRQDWLYHQ RGHU 3UR(LQVWHOOXQJHQ GRFK LQVRIHUQ GLH $XVELO GXQJYRQ3UR(LQVWHOOXQJHQZLHEHUHLWVHUZlKQWVWHWVDXFKHSLVWHPLVFKH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQ +\SRWKHVHQ 9HUPXWXQJHQ HWF HLQEH ]LHKWHUVFKHLQWGLH*UHQ]H]ZLVFKHQWKHRUHWLVFKHUXQGSUDNWLVFKHU5DWLR QDOLWlW]XPLQGHVWDXV6LFKWGHUOHW]WHUHQQLFKWWUHQQVFKDUIEHVWLPPEDU]X VHLQ
_____________ =XP ,QGLIIHUHQWLVPXV LQ GHU WKHRUHWLVFKHQ (UVFKHLQXQJ GHV 5HODWLYLVPXV EHPHUNW 1LGD5PHOLQ Å,QHLQHPDXIIDOOHQGHQ.RQWUDVW]XU3UD[LVQRUPDWLYHU$OOWDJVGLVNXUVH VWHKW GDV YHUEUHLWHWH VXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKH RGHU UHODWLYLVWLVFKH PHWDWKHRUHWLVFKH 8UWHLO LQ XQVHUHP.XOWXUNUHLV'LHJOHLFKHQ3HUVRQHQGLHHUQVWKDIWGDUEHUGLVNXWLHUHQREHL QHEHVWLPPWH+DQGOXQJULFKWLJZDUPHLQHQGDVVHVNHLQHREMHNWLYHQQRUPDWLYHQ.UL WHULHQ JlEH´ 1LGD5PHOLQ 9JO ]XP 5HODWLYLVPXV DOV JHQXLQ ZHVWOLFKHU (UVFKHLQXQJ DXFK +DEHUPDV LQVEHV Å$P UDGLNDOVWHQ YHUWUHWHQ ZHVWOLFKH,QWHOOHNWXHOOHVHOEVWGLH%HKDXSWXQJGDVLFKKLQWHUGHP$QVSUXFKDXIGLH XQLYHUVDOH *OWLJNHLW GHU 0HQVFKHQUHFKWH QXU HLQ SHUILGHU 0DFKWDQVSUXFK GHV :HV WHQVYHUELUJW´ $P QHJDWLYHQ ([WUHPIDOO YHUGHXWOLFKW 1LGD5PHOLQ GLHVHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ YRQ .RKlUHQ]XQG SUDNWLVFKHU 5DWLRQDOLWlWIROJHQGHUPDHQ Å(LQH3HUVRQRKQHHUNHQQ EDUH +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ ZUGH XQEHVWlQGLJ VSUXQJKDIW LQNRKlUHQW ZLUNHQ PDQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6WUXNWXUHOOH,QWHQWLRQDOLWlW
6WUXNWXUHOOH,QWHQWLRQDOLWlW
8PGDV$XVELOGHQXQG6WHXHUQYRQ+DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ]XHUNOlUHQKDW 1LGD5PHOLQ PLW %OLFN DXI GHUHQ LQWUDSHUVRQHOOH .RKlUHQ] GHQ %HJULII GHU VWUXNWXUHOOHQ ,QWHQWLRQDOLWlW HLQJHIKUW Å:LU QHQQHQ HLQH +DQGOXQJ ÄVWUXNWXULQWHQWLRQDO¶ ZHQQ VLH LP +LQEOLFN DXI LKUH 6WUXNWXUNRQIRUPLWlW JHZlKOWZXUGH 'LH3HUVRQP|FKWHHLQHEHVWLPPWHWHPSRUDOH+DQGOXQJV VWUXNWXUUHDOLVLHUHQXQGVLHZlKOWGHVZHJHQ VRPRWLYLHUW GLHVH+DQG OXQJ´ 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK N|QQHQ +DQGOXQJHQ DXFK QDFK SXQNWXHOOHQ
_____________ N|QQWHLKUNHLQHVLFKLQGHU=HLWGXUFKKDOWHQGHQ=LHOHXQG(LQVWHOOXQJHQ]XVFKUHLEHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHZUGHQIUHLQHVROFKH3HUVRQYRQHLQHP=HLWSXQNW]XPQlFKVWHQ LKUH %HGHXWXQJ YHUOLHUHQ DQGHUH 3HUVRQHQ ZlUHQ QLFKW LPVWDQGH LKU ]HLWOLFK KLQUHL FKHQG VWDELOH :HUWRULHQWLHUXQJHQ ]X]XVFKUHLEHQ >«@ NXU] (LQH VROFKH 3HUVRQ HU VFKLHQHXQVLQKRKHP0DHLUUDWLRQDO´ 1LGD5PHOLQ $P%HJULIIGHU:LO OHQVVFKZlFKH GHU EHUHLWV LP =XVDPPHQKDQJ YRQ .DQWV .RQ]HSW SUDNWLVFKHU 5DWLRQDOLWlWWKHPDWLVLHUWZXUGH YJO OlWVLFKGLH$IILQLWlWGHV.RKlUHQWLVPXV]X HLQHP.DQWLDQLVPXVYLHOOHLFKWDPGHXWOLFKVWHQDEOHVHQ,Q ZHUGHLFKQRFKHLQPDO DXI,UUDWLRQDOLWlWXQG:LOOHQVVFKZlFKH]XUFNNRPPHQ YJO]XHLQHPhEHUEOLFNEHU YHUVFKLHGHQH .RQ]HSWLRQHQYRQ :LOOHQVVFKZlFKHGLH7H[WHLQ6SLW]OH\VRZLH GLH(LQOHLWXQJHEG 1LGD5PHOLQ 1LGD5PHOLQ JHKW ]ZDU QLFKW HLJHQV DXI %UDWPDQV ÅSODQ QLQJWKHRU\µ %UDWPDQ HLQGRFKVWLPPHQEHLGH.RQ]HSWLRQHQKLQVLFKWOLFK GHV WKHRUHWLVFKHQ 6WHOOHQZHUWV YRQ +DQGOXQJVSOlQHQ E]Z VWUXNWXUHOOHQ ,QWHQWLRQHQ ZHLWJHKHQGEHUHLQ1DFK%UDWPDQN|QQHQDXIGLH=XNXQIWJHULFKWHWH3OlQHDOVSDUD GLJPDWLVFKIU,QWHQWLRQHQLQVJHVDPWDQJHVHKHQZHUGHQDOVRDXFKVROFKHGLHVLFKDXI GLH *HJHQZDUW RGHU GLH XQPLWWHOEDU EHYRUVWHKHQGH =XNXQIW ULFKWHQ 6ROFKH 3OlQH GLHQHQ ]XP HLQHQ GHU %HVWLPPXQJ GHV JHHLJQHWHQ +DQGOXQJV]HLWSXQNWV VRZLH GHV +DQGOXQJVDEODXIVLPYRUDXVXQG]XPDQGHUHQGHU.RRUGLQDWLRQXQVHUHUXQWHUVFKLHG OLFKHQ+DQGOXQJHQVRZLHGHU.RRUGLQDWLRQXQVHUHU+DQGOXQJHQPLWGHQ+DQGOXQJHQ $QGHUHU 'LHVH /HLVWXQJ ZLUG GDGXUFK HUP|JOLFKW GD 3OlQH ]XP HLQHQ ZLOOHQWOLFKH XQG]XPDQGHUHQDXI*UQGHEH]RJHQH)HVWOHJXQJHQVLQG Å3ODQVVRXQGHUVWRRGDUH LQWHQWLRQVZULWODUJH7KH\VKDUHWKHSURSHUWLHVRILQWHQWLRQVUHFHQWO\QRWHG WKH\UHVLVW UHFRQVLGHUDWLRQ DQG LQ WKDW VHQVH KDYH LQHUWLD WKH\ DUH FRQGXFW FRQWUROOHUV QRW PHUHO\SRWHQWLDOFRQGXFWLQIOXHQFHUV DQGWKH\SURYLGHFUXFLDOLQSXWVIRUIXUWKHUSUDF WLFDOUHDVRQLQJDQGSODQQLQJ´ (EG 'DQHEHQVLQG3OlQHQDFK%UDWPDQLQGHU5H JHOXQYROOVWlQGLJXQGEHVLW]HQHLQHKLHUDUFKLVFKH6WUXNWXU YJOHEG ,KUYROLWLYHU$V SHNW EHWULIIW GLH %HVWLPPXQJ XQVHUHV 9HUKDOWHQV G K GD ZLU SODQPlLJ KDQGHOQ VREDOGGHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH0RPHQWJHNRPPHQLVWXQGZLUXQVHUH$EVLFKWQLFKWJHlQ GHUWKDEHQ,KUEHJUQGXQJVEH]RJHQHU$VSHNWEHGHXWHWGD3OlQHGLH5LFKWXQJXQG GHQ6SLHOUDXPZHLWHUHUhEHUOHJXQJHQEHVWLPPHQ+LQVLFKWOLFKGHVOHW]WHUHQ$VSHNWV JLOWQDFK%UDWPDQGD3OlQHHUVWHQVHLQHQJHZLVVHQ*UDGGHU6WDELOLWlWHUODQJHQPV VHQ *UQGH GLHQHQ KLHU GD]X 3OlQH UHVLVWHQW JHJHQEHU EHVWLPPWHQ hEHUOHJXQJHQ ]X PDFKHQ ZHLO EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GLH 8UWHLOVNUDIW ]XP +DQGOXQJV]HLWSXQNW HLQJH VFKUlQNW VHLQ N|QQWH YJO GD]X +ROWRQ VRZLH %UDWPDQ 3OlQHEHGUIHQ]ZHLWHQVHLQHU0LWWHO=ZHFN.RKlUHQ]GKGLH0LWWHO]XLKUHU$XV IKUXQJ PVVHQ JHHLJQHW JHZlKOW ZRUGHQ VHLQ 8QG 3OlQH EHGUIHQ GULWWHQV HLQHU .RQVLVWHQ]PLWDQGHUHQ3OlQHQVRZLHPLWXQVHUHQhEHU]HXJXQJHQVRGDLKUH$XV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
*HVLFKWVSXQNWHQ EHDEVLFKWLJW XQG DXVJHIKUW ZHUGHQ RKQH DOV LUUDWLRQDO ]X JHOWHQ QXU PVVHQ DXFK LQ GLHVHP )DOO VHOEVWJHZlKOWH %LQGXQJHQ GXUFK +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ HLQH 5ROOH EHL GHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ JH VSLHOWKDEHQ 'LH NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKH $UJXPHQWDWLRQ YHUOlXIW GDEHL IROJHQGHUPDHQ YRQ GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV $EVLFKW ]X HLQHU +DQG OXQJ LQVRIHUQZLUGLH$EVLFKWEHVLW]HQHLQHEHVWLPPWH+DQGOXQJ]XYROO ]LHKHQ XQWHU8PVWlQGHQVRJDULQHLQHP5HVWDXUDQWHLQHQ7HOOHU6SDJKHWWL 0DULQDUD ]X HVVHQ ZDV ]XPLQGHVW HLQ EHOLHEWHV %HLVSLHO 1LGD5PHOLQV LVW XQGGLHhEHU]HXJXQJKDEHQGDGD]XDQGHUH+DQGOXQJHQ KLHU HLQHU %HGLHQXQJ GDV HQWVSUHFKHQGH *HULFKW DXV GHU 6SHLVHNDUWH ]X VDJHQ HWF HUIRUGHUOLFKVLQGVREHVLW]HQZLUGLHÅ*HVDPWDEVLFKW VWUXNWXUHOOH,QWHQWL RQ ´ GLH VlPWOLFKH +DQGOXQJHQ XPIDW ZHOFKH ]XU (UIOOXQJ GHU XU VSUQJOLFKHQ$EVLFKW GDV6SDJKHWWL(VVHQ HUIRUGHUOLFKVLQG)DOOVQXQHLQ .RQIOLNW DXIWULWW LQVRIHUQ ]ZHL JOHLFKZHUWLJH :HJH ]XU (UIOOXQJ GHUVHO EHQ$EVLFKW HVJLEWLQXQPLWWHOEDUHU1lKHHLQ5HVWDXUDQWPLWYHUJOHLFKED UHQ6SDJKHWWL0DULQDUD H[LVWLHUHQVREHVLW]HQZLUGHQQRFKHLQHQ*UXQG LQHLQHVGHUEHLGHQ5HVWDXUDQWV]XJHKHQZRKLQJHJHQGHUSXQNWXHOOH2S WLPLHUHU GHU YRQ +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ QLFKWV ZLVVHQ ZLOO VWUHQJ JHQRP PHQ ZLH GHU -RKDQQHV %XULGDQXV IlOVFKOLFKHUZHLVH ]XJHVFKULHEHQH (VHO ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ EHLGHQ +HXKDXIHQ ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ EHLGHQ 5HVWDXUDQWV YHU KXQJHUQPWH²HLQHZHQLJUHDOLVWLVFKH$QQDKPH,QKDOWGHUMHQVHLWVGHV .RQIOLNWV VWHKHQGHQ VWUXNWXUHOOHQ ,QWHQWLRQ RGHU *HVDPWDEVLFKW LVW HV
_____________ IKUXQJDQJHVLFKWVGLHVHUP|JOLFKLVW YJO%UDWPDQ 'LHVH(LJHQVFKDI WHQ XQWHUVFKHLGHQ XQVHUH 3OlQH VR %UDWPDQ YRQ XQVHUHQ :QVFKHQ GLH OHGLJOLFK DXIWDXFKHQXQGHLQHQJHZLVVHQ(LQIOXDXIXQVHU+DQGHOQEHVLW]HQMHGRFKDOVVROFKH QLFKW LQ GHU /DJH VLQG GHQ *DQJ XQVHUHU +DQGOXQJHQ VR ]X EHVWLPPHQ ZLH 3OlQH GLHVWXQ,QVRIHUQ3OlQH LP*HJHQVDW]]XhEHU]HXJXQJHQXQG:QVFKHQ LQGHU/D JHVLQGVRZRKOXQVHUHSUDNWLVFKHQhEHUOHJXQJHQPLWXQVHUHP9HUKDOWHQ]XNRRUGL QLHUHQXQGLQGLHVHP6LQQHXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQIHVW]XOHJHQVSULFKW%UDWPDQYRQLK QHQ DOV ,QWHQWLRQHQ ,QWHQWLRQHQ VLQG GLHVHU .RQ]HSWLRQ ]XIROJH HLJHQVWlQGLJH SURSRVLWLRQDOH(LQVWHOOXQJHQGLHZHGHUDXI:QVFKHQRFKDXIhEHU]HXJXQJHQUHGX ]LHUWZHUGHQN|QQHQ YJOHEG ,QGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJDUJXPHQWLHUWHUJH JHQ GHQ ÅVLPSOH YLHZ´ HEG II ZRQDFK IU MHGH (LQ]HOKDQGOXQJ HLQH HQWVSUH FKHQGH$EVLFKWYRUDXVJHVHW]WZHUGHQPX'LHÄ$EVLFKW[]XWXQ¶LVWQDFK%UDWPDQ NHLQH QRWZHQGLJH %HGLQJXQJ GDIU [ LQWHQWLRQDO ]X WXQ ZLU N|QQHQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH VSRQWDQLQWHQWLRQDOKDQGHOQRKQHHLQHH[SOL]LWH$EVLFKW]XELOGHQ ]%GHQ)XLQ GHQ%XVVHW]HQZHLOZLULQGLH6WDGWIDKUHQZROOHQ ,P5DKPHQVHLQHUÄSODQQLQJWKH RU\¶PDFKW%UDWPDQLP.RQWUDVW]XPÄVLPSOHYLHZ¶JHOWHQGGDHLQHEHUJHRUGQHWH $EVLFKW HLQ NRPSOH[HU +DQGOXQJVSODQ LQQHUKDOE GHVVHQ [ ZLVVHQWOLFK DXVJHIKUW ZLUGJHQJWXPGLH,QWHQWLRQDOLWlWGHU+DQGOXQJ[]XJDUDQWLHUHQ YJOHEG 9JO]X%UDWPDQV,QWHQWLRQVEHJULII9HOOHPDQ F VRZLHGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGH5HSOLN %UDWPDQV 0V 1LGD5PHOLQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6WUXNWXUHOOH,QWHQWLRQDOLWlW
JHUDGHHLQHQVROFKHQÄ(VHOV]XVWDQG¶]XYHUPHLGHQGKGLHVH*HVDPWDE VLFKWZLUGXQVDXVGHPÄ(VHOV]XVWDQG¶LQGHPXQVEORHNRQNXUULHUHQGH 7HLODEVLFKWHQKDOWHQZUGHQEHIUHLHQXQG]XHLQHU(QWVFKHLGXQJIKUHQ XQGVHLHVHLQH0Q]H]XZHUIHQ ,QGLHVHP6LQQHVHW]WGLH$XVELOGXQJ YRQ (LQ]HODEVLFKWHQ XQG GLH $XVIKUXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQGHU +DQGOXQJHQ HLQH5HIOH[LRQDXI*UQGHXQGGHUHQLQIHUHQWLHOOH5HODWLRQHQYRUDXVGLH GHQSXQNWXHOOHQ$IIHNWEHUVFKUHLWHQ 'HU .RKlUHQWLVPXV IRUGHUW GDPLW HLQHQ %H]XJVUDKPHQ SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK GHVVHQ HLQ 9HUKDOWHQ HUVW DOV +DQGOXQJ EH VFKULHEHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ (LQ]HOQH 9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQ ZHUGHQ GDGXUFK ]X 7HLOKDQGOXQJHQGDHVHLQHXPIDVVHQGH$EVLFKW]XHLQHU+DQGOXQJJLEW GLH MHQH 7HLOKDQGOXQJHQ LPSOL]LHUW 'LHVH $EVLFKW NDQQ GDPLW DOV +DQG OXQJVJUXQG DXFK IU GLH 7HLOKDQGOXQJHQ JHOWHQ 2E DOVR LQ 'DYLGVRQV EHNDQQWHP%HLVSLHO GDV $ODUPLHUHQ GHV (LQEUHFKHUV HLQH +DQGOXQJ LVW KlQJW GDYRQ DE ZRULQ GHU *UXQG IU GDV $QNQLSVHQ GHV 6FKDOWHUV GHV GDPLW YHUEXQGHQHQ (LQVFKDOWHQ GHV /LFKWV XQG GHV GDPLW YHUEXQGHQHQ %HOHXFKWHQGHV=LPPHUVEHVWHKW'RFKQLFKWGDVNDXVDOH9HUKlOWQLV]ZL VFKHQ (UHLJQLVVHQ N|USHUOLFKHQ 9ROO]JHQ RGHU 9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQ LQGLYL GXLHUWGLHVHDOV+DQGOXQJHQXQG7HLOKDQGOXQJHQVRQGHUQGHUHQUDWLRQDOH 5HODWLRQHQ ,Q GLHVHP 6LQQH VFKUHLEW %UDQGRP YRP +DQGOXQJVEHJULII ZHQQJOHLFK RKQH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJHQ XQG 7HLOKDQG OXQJHQ ÅHLQ $NW >LVW@ XQWHU HLQHU %HVFKUHLEXQJ LQWHQWLRQDO >«@ ZHQQ GLHVH %HVFKUHLEXQJ DOV .RQNOXVLRQ HLQHV 6WFNV SUDNWLVFKHQ %HJUQGHQV DXIWDXFKW GDV GLH *UQGH GHV $NWHXUV GLHVH 3HUIRUPDQ] KHUYRU]XEULQ JHQ RIIHQOHJW´ 'DV EHJUQGXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKH 9HUKlOWQLV ]ZLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJHQ XQG 7HLOKDQGOXQJHQ OlW VLFK VFKOLHOLFK PLW 1LGD5PHOLQ IROJHQGHUPDHQ EHVWLPPHQ Å:HQQ >HLQH +DQGOXQJ@ + GDGXUFK YROO]R JHQ ZLUG GDVV >GLH (LQ]HOKDQGOXQJHQ@ K K « KQ YROO]RJHQ ZHUGHQ GDQQ VLQG K K « KQ ]XJOHLFK PLW GHU %HJUQGXQJ YRQ + EHJUQGHW >«@ 0HLQH VWUXNWXUHOOH +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW EHJUQGHW PHLQH SXQNWXHOOHQ
_____________ $XFK%UDWPDQDUJXPHQWLHUWLPYRUVWHKHQGHQ6LQQHIUUDWLRQDOHLQWUDXQGLQWHUSHU VRQHOOH.RRUGLQDWLRQVWDWWIUSXQNWXHOOH2SWLPLHUXQJXQGPDFKWLP5DKPHQVHLQHU 3ODQXQJVWKHRULHJHOWHQGÅ>«@WKDWWKHQHHGIRUGHFLVLRQLQWKHIDFHRIHTXLGHVLUDELOL W\ZKHQWLHGWRRXUQHHGVIRUFRRUGLQDWLRQSURYLGHVLQGHSHQGHQWSUHVVXUHIRUEHLQJ DSODQQLQJDJHQW´ %UDWPDQ I ²:DVGHQ%XULGDQLVFKHQ(VHOEHWULIIWVRKDW 0LFKDHO QDFKJHZLHVHQGDGLH3UREOHPDWLNEHUHLWVLQGHU$QWLNHGLV NXWLHUWZLUGGDHVEHL%XULGDQQLFKWXPHLQHQ(VHOVRQGHUQXPHLQHQ+XQGJHKW XQGGDGLH9HUNQSIXQJ%XULGDQ(VHOHLQH6FK|SIXQJGHVIUKHQ-KLVW 'DYLGVRQ I>HQJO I@ EHUHLWVY:ULJKW >GW @KDW EHWRQWGDGDV9HUKDOWHQYRQ+DQGHOQGHQ XQWHUEHVWLPPWHQMHZHLOLJHQ%HVFKUHLEXQJHQLQ WHQWLRQDOLVW %UDQGRPDI
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ´ 'LH5DWLRQDOLWlWHLQHU+DQGOXQJ²XQGGLHVLVWLP JHJHQZlUWLJHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJYRQEHVRQGHUHU%HGHXWXQJ²KlQJWGDPLW ZHVHQWOLFK YRP %HJUQGXQJVUDKPHQ DE LQQHUKDOE GHVVHQ VLH EHUKDXSW HUVW ]X HLQHU +DQGOXQJ ZLUG 0LW %OLFN DXI GLH DXV GHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW YRQ +DQGOXQJHQUHVXOWLHUHQGH5DWLRQDOLWlWGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQNDQQ1LGD 5PHOLQGHVKDOE]X5HFKWUHVPLHUHQ Å(UVWZHQQGLHVWUXNWXUHOOH,QWHQ WLRQ VWDELO JHJHQEHU ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ ]XU :QVFKEDUNHLW SXQNWXHOOHU +DQGOXQJHQLVWGLHGLHVHVWUXNWXUHOOH,QWHQWLRQ SXQNWXHOO UHDOLVLHUHQKDW GLH3HUVRQNRKlUHQWH,QWHQWLRQHQXQGLVWLQGLHVHU+LQVLFKWUDWLRQDO´ $XIGHQ%HJULIIGHU3HUVRQNDQQLFKLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJQLFKW QlKHUHLQJHKHQVRQGHUQKDEHLKQEHLGHU5HGHYRQ+DQGOXQJHQ+DQG OXQJVDEVLFKWHQ XQG JUQGHQ VFKOLFKW YRUDXVJHVHW]W =XPLQGHVW HUZlKQW ZHUGHQ VROO MHGRFK HLQ 3UREOHP GDV DXV SHUVRQHQWKHRUHWLVFKHU QLFKW PRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHU 3HUVSHNWLYH'HUHN3DUILWJHJHQEHUGLHVHU7KHRULH LQWHUWHPSRUDOHU +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ DXIJHZRUIHQ KDW XQG GDV PLW GHQ ELV KLHUKHU HLQJHVHW]WHQ 0LWWHOQ GHV .RKlUHQWLVPXV DOOHLQ QLFKW ]X O|VHQ LVW'LH6WDELOLWlWYRQGHUHEHQGLH5HGHZDUVFKHLQWQlPOLFKEHLJHQDXH UHU$QVLFKWVFKZlFKHUEHJUQGHW]XVHLQDOV]XQlFKVWHUZDUWHW ZHQQGLH VWUXNWXUHOOH 3HUVSHNWLYH EHL GHU GLDFKURQHQ $EZlJXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ JH JHQZlUWLJHQXQGGHQ]XNQIWLJHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQHLQHU3HUVRQhEHUSDUWHL OLFKNHLWLP6LQQHHLQHVHYHQWXHOOHQ$EVHKHQVYRQJHJHQZlUWLJHQ3UlIHUHQ ]HQ YHUODQJW ZLHVR YHUODQJW GLHVHOEH hEHUSDUWHLOLFKNHLW QLFKW DXFK HLQH V\QFKURQH $VVLPLODWLRQ GHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ YRQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ 3HUVRQHQ" :DUXP VROOWHQ ZLU GHQ QXPHULVFKHQ 8QWHUVFKLHG ]ZLVFKHQ SHUVRQDOHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DXIUHFKWHUKDOWHQ ZHQQ ZLU GHQ WHPSRUDOHQ 8QWHUVFKLHG QLYHOOLHUHQ" (UVW EHU HLQH %HVWLPPXQJ GHU LUUHGX]LEOHQ GHRQWLVFKHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVH YRQ 6HOEVW =XZHLVXQJHQ XQG $QHUNHQQXQJHQ YRQ )HVWOH
_____________ 1LGD5PHOLQI 1LGD5PHOLQ 3DUILW LQVEHVVRZLH Å2QWKH5HGXFWLRQLVW9LHZZHDUH OHVVLPSUHVVHGE\WKLVWKUXWK>LHWKHXQLW\RIHDFKOLIH@:HUHJDUGWKHXQLW\RIHDFK OLIHDVLQLWVQDWXUHOHVVGHHSDQGDVDPDWWHURIGHJUHH:HPD\WKHUHIRUHWKLQNWKH ERXQGDULHVEHWZHHQOLYHVWREH OHVVOLNHWKRVHEHWZHHQVD\WKH VTXDUHVRQDFKHVV ERDUG ² GLYLGLQJ ZKDW LV DOO SXUH ZKLWH IURP ZKDW LV DOO MHW EODFN DQG PRUH OLNH WKH ERXQGDULHVEHWZHHQGLIIHUHQWFRXQWULHV7KH\PD\WKHQVHHPOHVVPRUDOO\LPSRUWDQW´ 3DUILW JHKW LQ $QOHKQXQJ DQ +XPHV ÄEXQGOH RI SHUFHSWLRQV¶ DOV %HVFKUHLEXQJ GHV 6HOEVWEHZXWVHLQV YRQ HLQHP VFKZDFKHQ 3HUVRQEHJULII DXV GHU OHGLJOLFK IXQNWLRQDO HLQH5HODWLRQ5]ZLVFKHQSV\FKLVFKHQ=XVWlQGHQJHPlHLQHUÄSV\FKRORJLFDOFRQWLQXL W\¶XQGHLQHUÄSV\FKRORJLFDOFRQQHFWHGQHVV¶SRVWXOLHUW ÄFRQWLQXLW\¶PHLQWEHUODSSHQGH (ULQQHUXQJVNHWWHQXQGÄFRQQHFWHGQHVV¶PHLQWGLUHNWH9HUELQGXQJYRQ(ULQQHUXQJHQ 'DGLHVHUUHGXFWLRQLVWYLHZGHPKLHUYHUIROJWHQ$QVDW]QLFKW]XJUXQGHOLHJWVROOWHDXV GHQELVKHULJHQ$XVIKUXQJHQEHUHLWVGHXWOLFKJHZRUGHQVHLQXQGVROOPLWGHPQlFKV WHQ.DSLWHOQRFKGHXWOLFKHUZHUGHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.RRSHUDWLRQXQGGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU.RKlUHQ]
JXQJHQ DXI EHVWLPPWH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X VROFKHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ ZLUGVLFKLQGHQEHLGHQQDFKIROJHQGHQ.DSLWHOQHLQ%HJULII GHU 3HUVRQ HUJHEHQ GHU HLQH (LQHEQXQJ GHV QXPHULVFKHQ 8QWHUVFKLHGV ]ZLVFKHQ3HUVRQHQDXVVFKOLHW (LQHZHLWHUH)UDJHEH]LHKWVLFKDXIGDV0RPHQWGHU,QWHUSHUVRQDOLWlW GHV KLHU VNL]]LHUWHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV JLEW HV LQ GLHVHU .RQ]HSWLRQ HLQHQ 3ODW]IUPRUDOLVFKH1RUPHQDOV+DQGOXQJVJUQGHGHUHQ$N]HSWDQ]VLFK QLFKWDXIGLHLQWUDSHUVRQHOOH.RKlUHQ]YRQ,QWHQWLRQHQXQG+DQGOXQJHQ VWW]HQ NDQQ VRQGHUQ GLHVHU ELVZHLOHQ ]XZLGHUOlXIW" :LH NDQQ P|JOL FKHUZHLVH MHPDQGHP GHU NRQVLVWHQW XQG NRKlUHQW UFNVLFKWVORV KDQGHOW XQGLQVRIHUQHLQHQVWDUNHQ&KDUDNWHUEHVLW]WEHJHJQHWZHUGHQ"
.RRSHUDWLRQXQGGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU .RKlUHQ]
'HU$XVJDQJVSXQNW]XU%HDQWZRUWXQJGHUEHLGHQ]XOHW]WDXIJHZRUIHQHQ )UDJHQEHVWHKWLQHLQHP]HQWUDOHQ$UJXPHQWGHVELVKLHUKHUYRUJHVWHOOWHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV DXIJUXQG GHU 8QP|JOLFKNHLW LQGLYLGXHOOH +DQGOXQJV VWUXNWXUHQ OHGLJOLFK LQ IRUR LQWHUQR VR]XVDJHQ LP SHUVRQHQ RGHU PHQ VFKHQOHHUHQ 5DXP DXV]XELOGHQ G K DXIJUXQG GHU 1RWZHQGLJNHLW HLQHU 9HUQHW]XQJXQVHUHU+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQXQGVFKOLHOLFK+DQGOXQJHQPLW GHQHQ DQGHUHU 3HUVRQHQ PVVHQ ZLU QLFKW QXU HLQ LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHV 1HW] YRQ $EVLFKWHQ XQG GHUHQ %HJUQGXQJHQ EHUFNVLFKWLJHQ VRQGHUQ DXFK HLQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHV LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHV 6HOEVW DXV LQGLYLGXHOOHU 3HUVSHNWLYH LVW HV XQHUOlOLFK GLH HLJHQHQ +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ NRPSOH[HQ +DQG OXQJVSOlQHVRZLH+DQGOXQJHQPLWGHQHQ$QGHUHU]XNRRUGLQLHUHQ
_____________ 9JOGD]X%UDWPDQ I Å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«@2XUFDSDFLWLHVDVSODQQHUVKHOSXVPHHWWKHVHQHHGV:HIDFLOLWDWH FRRUGLQDWLRQLQSDUWE\FRQVWUXFWLQJODUJHUSODQVIRUWKHIXWXUHSODQVWKDWKHOSFRRU GLQDWHERWKRXURZQDFWLYLWLHVRYHUWLPHDQGRXUDFWLYLWLHVZLWKWKHDFWLYLWLHVRIRWK HUVµ 9JO GD]X DXFK GLH QDFKIROJHQGH )XQRWH VRZLH %UDWPDQ :DV%UDWPDQKLHUDOVÅDFWLYLWLHV´DQVSULFKWLVWPLW%OLFNDXIGLH=XUHFKHQEDUNHLWLGHQ WLVFK PLW GHP REHQ YRQ 9HOOHPDQ EHUQRPPHQHQ %HJULII YRQ DFWLRQV ZRULQ VLFK %UDWPDQVDFWLYLWLHVXQG9HOOHPDQVDFWLRQVMHGRFKXQWHUVFKHLGHQLVWGLH.RQQRWDWLRQHL QHUXPIDVVHQGHUHQ3HUVSHNWLYH ZlKUHQGDFWLRQV(LQ]HOKDQGOXQJHQEHQHQQHQN|QQHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
'LHVJLOWIU+DQGOXQJHQGLHQXUJHPHLQVDPP|JOLFKVLQG]%LQHL QHP 2UFKHVWHU 2ERH ]X VSLHOHQ RGHU LQ HLQHP )XEDOOVSLHO GDV 7RU ]X KWHQRGHUDXIGHP0DUNW/HEHQVPLWWHO]XNDXIHQ'LHVJLOWGDQHEHQDEHU DXFKIU+DQGOXQJHQGLHDOOHLQHDXV]XIKUHQ]ZDUP|JOLFKLVW]XGHUHQ JHPHLQVDPHU$XVIKUXQJVLFKGLH%HWHLOLJWHQDEHUIUHLHQWVFKORVVHQKDEHQ] % GDV .OHWWHUQ HLQHU VFKZLHULJHQ %HUJURXWH ,Q DOOHQ +DQGOXQJHQ GLHVHU 7\SHQLVWHLQHHLQVHLWLJH9RUWHLOVQDKPHHLQHUEHWHLOLJWHQ3HUVRQ]XXQJXQV WHQ HLQHU HEHQIDOOV GDUDQ EHWHLOLJWHQ QLFKW XQHLQJHVFKUlQNW P|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
_____________ DFWLYLWLHV LQ%UDWPDQVQLFKWLQ9HOOHPDQV6LQQ DXFKNRPSOH[H+DQGOXQJHQXPIDVVHQ ]%(LQNDXIHQDOVDFWLYLW\bSIHOLQGHQ:DJHQOHJHQDOVDFWLRQ ²,FKGDQNH0LFKDHO %UDWPDQ IU *HVSUlFKH EHU GLHVH XQG LP )ROJHQGHQ WKHPDWLVLHUWH 3UREOHPH LQWHU SHUVRQDOHU+DQGOXQJVNRRUGLQDWLRQ %UDWPDQ NRPPHQWLHUW GLHVH GUHL .ULWHULHQ IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å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´ %UDWPDQ I 'D NRRSHUDWLYH 3HUVRQHQ ÅHLJHQH ,QWHUHVVHQ´ ]XUFNVWHOOHQ PVVHQÅXPVLFKHU]XJHKHQGDVVHWZDVHUUHLFKWZLUGZDVYRQEHLGHQJHZQVFKWLVW´ ZLH1LGD5PHOLQ QDKHOHJWLVWGDPLWQRFKQLFKWDXVJHPDFKW GLHVJLOWHUVW LP ,QWHUHVVHQNRQIOLNW ZR ² LP *HJHQVDW] EHLVSLHOVZHLVH ]XP 2UFKHVWHUVSLHO ² .R RSHUDWLRQPLW$EVWULFKHQEHLHLJHQHQ,QWHUHVVHQYHUEXQGHQLVW9JO]XGLHVHPNRP SOH[HQ +DQGOXQJVEHJULII DXFK -DQLFKV 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ Å%HWHLOLJXQJVKDQG OXQJHQ´ ZLH HLQHP :HWWODXI VLH ÅN|QQHQ QXU JHOLQJHQ G K ULFKWLJ YROO]RJHQ ZHUGHQZHQQVLFKHLQHDQGHUH3HUVRQEHWHLOLJW´ XQGÅJHPHLQVFKDIWOLFKHQ+DQGOXQ JHQGLHQXU(UIROJKDEHQN|QQHQZHQQ DQGHUHVLFKEHWHLOLJHQ(LQ%HLVSLHOKLHUIU ZlUHGDV+RFKKHEHQHLQHVVFKZHUHQ%DONHQV´ -DQLFK 'LHVHU%HJULIIGHU ÅJHPHLQVFKDIWOLFKHQ+DQGOXQJHQ´LVWGDPLWHLQHVSH]LHOOH)RUPYRQ%UDWPDQVÄJHWHLO WHQNRRSHUDWLYHQ+DQGOXQJHQ¶LQVRIHUQGHQOHW]WHUHQGLHYRQ-DQLFKDQJHIKUWH([ NOXVLYLWlWIHKOW LFKNDQQGLHVHVFKZLHULJH%HUJURXWHDXFKDOOHLQHEHZlOWLJHQDEHUZHQQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.RRSHUDWLRQXQGGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU.RKlUHQ]
3KLORVRSKLVFKVFKZLHULJHU]XIDVVHQVLQGMHGRFKGLHPRUDOLVFKUHOHYDQ WHQ )lOOH LQ ZHOFKHQ DXFK DXV GHU 6LFKW GHV (LQ]HOQHQ *UQGH IU PLW *UQGHQ JHJHQ .RRSHUDWLRQ NRQNXUULHUHQ 1LGD5PHOLQ VFKOlJW PLW %OLFN DXI GLH 5DWLRQDOLWlW GLHVHU )lOOH HLQH $QDORJLH ]ZLVFKHQ GHU +DQG OXQJVNRRUGLQDWLRQLPLQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQXQGGHU+DQGOXQJVNRRUGLQDWLRQLP LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJYRU:DVEH]JOLFKHLQHUHLQ]HOQHQ3HU VRQ VLQQYROO DQ]XQHKPHQ LVW GD GLHVH QlPOLFK UDWLRQDO LQ JHQDX GHP 6LQQHLVWGDVLHXPIDVVHQGH+DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQJHJHQEHUGHUSXQNWX HOOHQ2SWLPLHUXQJYRQ(LQ]HOEHGUIQLVVHQDEZlJWVROOWHGDQDFKDXIGHQ LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ)DOOEHUWUDJHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ Å:HQQIUHLQH*UXSSH YRQ13HUVRQHQJLOWGDVVMHGHGLHVHU13HUVRQHQHVEHIUZRUWHWGDVVDOOH DXVGLHVHU*UXSSHHLQH5HJHO5EHIROJHQGLHGLH%HUHLWVWHOOXQJHLQHVNRO OHNWLYHQ*XWHVHUP|JOLFKWVRLVWHVXQWHUGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQZHFKVHOVHLWL JHQ 9HUWUDXHQV² G K HLJHQHU .RRSHUDWLRQVEHUHLWVFKDIW XQG GHU (UZDU WXQJGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVEHUHLWVFKDIWGHUhEULJHQ²QLFKWQRWZHQGLJHUZHLVH LUUDWLRQDOGLHVH5HJHODXFKZHQQVLHQLFKWVDQNWLRQLHUWLVWHLQ]XKDOWHQ´ +LHU ZLH EHUHLWV LP 9RUDXVJHKHQGHQ XQWHUVFKHLGHW VLFK GLH 3RVLWLRQ GHV .RKlUHQWLVPXV ZHVHQWOLFK YRP .RQVHTXHQWLDOLVPXV GLUHNWHU 1XW ]HQPD[LPLHUXQJ GHQQ .RRSHUDWLRQ LQ .RQIOLNWIlOOHQ ZLUG HUVW GDGXUFK P|JOLFKGDGLH%HWHLOLJWHQJHJHEHQHQIDOOVGLHXQPLWWHOEDUH2SWLPLHUXQJ GHUMHZHLOVHLJHQHQ+DQGOXQJVHUJHEQLVVH]XUFNVWHOOHQXPHLQLQVJHVDPW EHIULHGLJHQGHUHV(UJHEQLV]XHUKDOWHQ Å)UGLH>«@VWUXNWXUHOOH.RQ]HS WLRQSUDNWLVFKHU5DWLRQDOLWlWLVW.RRSHUDWLRQGDJHJHQJHUDGH]XSDUDGLJPD WLVFKUDWLRQDO>«@:HUNRRSHUDWLYKDQGHOWZlKOWVHLQH+DQGOXQJVRGDVV VLH SRWHQWLHOO 7HLO HLQHU LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXU LVW GLH GLH KDQGHOQGH3HUVRQJHJHQEHUGHUMHQLJHQLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ+DQGOXQJVVWUXN WXU GLH DXV MH LQGLYLGXHOO RSWLPLHUHQGHP 9HUKDOWHQ UHVXOWLHUHQ ZUGH YRU]LHKW´'HU.RKlUHQWLVPXVIRUGHUWGDKHUHLQH$EZlJXQJLQWUDXQG LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU(LQ]HODEVLFKWHQJHJHQEHUXPIDVVHQGHQLQWUDXQGLQWHU SHUVRQHOOHQ+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQXQGOLHIHUWGDPLW%HJULIIHGHUVWUXNWXUHO OHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW VRZRKO HLQHU (LQ]HOSHUVRQ DOV DXFK HLQHU +DQGOXQJVJH PHLQVFKDIW ZHOFKH 5DWLRQDOLWlWHQ IU GHQ =XVDPPHQKDOW HLQHU
_____________ PHLQ6HLOSDUWQHUXQGLFKXQV]XUJHPHLQVDPHQ7RXUHQWVFKORVVHQKDEHQVLQGZLUQRW ZHQGLJHUZHLVHJHPHLQVDPIUGHUHQ*HOLQJHQYHUDQWZRUWOLFK 1LGD5PHOLQ LQVHLQHQ$XVIKUXQJHQJHKW1LGD5PHOLQGHQXPJHNHKU WHQ:HJYRQGHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ.RRSHUDWLRQ]XUÄ.RRSHUDWLRQ¶NRQDWLYHU(LQVWHO OXQJHQHLQHU(LQ]HOSHUVRQ9JOGD]XDXFKGLH$XVIKUXQJHQGHV.RRSHUDWLRQVWKHR UHWLNHUV*DXWKLHU DXIGHVVHQ0RUDOVE\$JUHHPHQWLFKLQQRFKNXU] HLQJHKHQZHUGH9JO]XU(QWVFKHLGXQJV6SLHOWKHRULHVRZLHGHPGDPLWYHUEXQGHQHQ 3DUDGLJPDUDWLRQDOHU :DKO1LGD5PHOLQ 7HLO VRZLH6FKPLGW PLWZHLWHUIKUHQGHU/LWHUDWXU 1LGD5PHOLQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
*HVHOOVFKDIWYRQ,QGLYLGXHQGLHLQLKUHP+DQGHOQDXIHLQDQGHUDQJHZLH VHQVLQGRIIHQNXQGLJXQHUOlOLFKVLQG 'HU .RKlUHQWLVPXV NDQQ GHVKDOE DXFK DOV HLQ 9HUVXFK DQJHVHKHQ ZHUGHQ GLH YRQ .DQW LP 6LWWHQJHVHW] DXVJHGUFNWH (LQKHLW GHV PXQGXV LQWHOOLJLELOLVLQHLQH.RKlUHQ]PHQVFKOLFKHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGH²DXIJUXQG GHUHQ.RPSDWLELOLWlWVXQG$EKlQJLJNHLWVVWUXNWXUHQ²]XWUDQVIRUPLHUHQ :DV.DQWDOVLQWHOOLJLEOH:HFKVHOZLUNXQJHLQ]HOQHU:LOOHQJHPlVLWWOLFKHU )UHLKHLWVJHVHW]H HUNOlUW KDW HUVFKHLQW KLHU DOV :HFKVHOZLUNXQJ SHUV|QOL FKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ JHPl HLQHU LQWUD XQG LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ VWUXNWXUHOOHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW 'RFK .DQW VSULFKW HEHQ QLFKW QXU YRP 6LWWHQJHVHW] VRQGHUQ DXFK GDYRQGDGLHVHVIUHQGOLFKH:HVHQZLHGHQ0HQVFKHQHLQHLPSHUDWLYH )RUPDQQHKPHQPX:DVGHPKLHUYRUJHVWHOOWHQ$QVDW]H[SODQDWRULVFK DOVRQRFKIHKOWLVWGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWGLHGLH.RKlUHQ]YRQ+DQGOXQJV JUQGHQ HQWIDOWHQ PX XP HLQ )XQNWLRQVlTXLYDOHQW ]XP NDWHJRULVFKHQ 6ROOHQ EHL .DQW ]X OLHIHUQ 'DV V\VWHPDWLVFK YRUHUVW OHW]WH :RUW GLHVHV .RKlUHQWLVPXV IRUPXOLHUW 1LGD5PHOLQ ZHQQ HU DXI PRUDOLVFKH 1RU PHQLPNRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHQ.RQWH[W]XVSUHFKHQNRPPW Å(LQH3HUVRQGLH ]XU %HJUQGXQJ LKUHU +DQGOXQJ DQIKUW VLH KDEH GDPLW DXI MHPDQGHQ 5FNVLFKW QHKPHQ ZROOHQ RGHU EHVVHU QXU GLHVH +DQGOXQJ HQWVSUHFKH GHP*HERWGHU5FNVLFKWQDKPHLVWGDGXUFKJHEXQGHQDXFKLQDQGHUHQ YHUJOHLFKEDUHQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ LKU +DQGHOQ HQWVSUHFKHQG UFNVLFKWVYROO ]X JHVWDOWHQ´(VEHVWHKWDOVRHLQH)HVWOHJXQJDXIE]ZHLQH9HUSIOLFKWXQJ ]XGHUUFNVLFKWVYROOHQ+DQGOXQJYRUDXVJHVHW]WGLH3HUVRQKDWVLFKDXI HLQH HQWVSUHFKHQGH +DQGOXQJVQRUPIHVWJHOHJW E]Z EHVWlWLJW GHUHQ 9HU ELQGOLFKNHLW'LH)UDJHLVWMHGRFKREXQWHU%HLEHKDOWXQJGHV7KHRULHUDK PHQV GKGHU$QQDKPHGDGLH%KQHPHQVFKOLFKHU+DQGOXQJHQQLFKW YRQ HLQHP QDWXUDOHQ ÄPX¶ EHKHUUVFKW ZLUG VRQGHUQ YRQ GHU $QHUNHQ QXQJYRQ*UQGHQGXUFKGLHKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQHQ HLQH(UNOlUXQJVP|J OLFKNHLW IU GLH 3UlYDOHQ] YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQEHVWHKW ZHOFKH JHJHEH
_____________ (LQH .DQW,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ GLH GHQ NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY NRKlUHQWLVWLVFK DXVOHJW ILQGHWVLFKEHL2·1HLOO Å7KH LQWHUHVWRI D .DQWLDQXQLYHUVDOLW\WHVWLVWKDWLWDLPVWR JURXQGDQHWKLFDOWKHRU\RQQRWLRQVRI FRQVLVWHQF\ DQGUDWLRQDOLW\UDWKHUWKDQXSRQ FRQVLGHUDWLRQV RIGHVLUH DQGSUHIHUHQFH .DQW·VXQLYHUVDOLW\WHVW>«@IRFXVHVRQIHD WXUHVRIDFWLRQWKDWDUHDSSURSULDWHFDQGLGDWHVIRUDVVHVVPHQWVRIFRKHUHQFHDQGLQ FRKHUHQFHQDPHO\WKHPD[LPVRUIXQGDPHQWDOLQWHQWLRQVWKDWDJHQWVPD\DGRSWDQG WKHZHERIPRUHVSHFLILFDQFLOODU\LQWHQWLRQVWKDWWKH\PXVWDGRSWLQDJLYHQFRQWH[WLI WKHLUFRPPLWPHQWWRDPD[LPLVJHQXLQH>«@6XFKDWHVWLVSULPDULO\RIXVHWRDJHQWV LQJXLGLQJWKHLURZQPRUDOGHOLEHUDWLRQVDQGFDQRQO\EHXVHGPRVWWHQWDWLYHO\LQDV VHVVLQJWKHPRUDOZRUWKRIRWKHUV·DFWLRQZKHUHZHDUHRIWHQVXUHRQO\DERXWVSHFLILF RXWZDUGDVSHFWVRIDFWLRQDQGQRWDERXWWKHPD[LP´ 2·1HLOO 1LGD5PHOLQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.RRSHUDWLRQXQGGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU.RKlUHQ]
QHQIDOOVGHQ²DXFKOlQJHUIULVWLJHQ²,QWHUHVVHQXQG6HOEVWELQGXQJHQGHV KDQGHOQGHQ,QGLYLGXXPV]XZLGHUODXIHQ 8P GLHVHP 3UREOHP ]X EHJHJQHQ HPSILHKOW VLFK GHU 5FNJULII DXI -HQV%DGXUDV'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ]ZLVFKHQHLQHPÅSUREOHPRULHQWLHUWHQ.RKlUHQ WLVPXV GHU HLQH 0HWKRGH ]XU DQZHQGXQJVRULHQWLHUWHQ 6SH]LIL]LHUXQJ DOV JOWLJ XQWHUVWHOOWHU DOOJHPHLQHU PRUDOLVFKHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ GDUVWHOOW´ XQG HL QHP ÅEHJUQGXQJVRULHQWLHUWH>Q@ .RKlUHQWLVPXV GHU PRUDOLVFKH 8UWHLOH XQG 3ULQ]LSLHQ GXUFK HLQ NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHV %HJUQGXQJVPRGHOO LQ *HOWXQJ VHW]HQ ZLOO´ :lKUHQG LQQHUKDOE GHV HUVWHUHQ GHU VHLQH VWlUNVWH (UNOl UXQJVNUDIWLQQHUKDOEGHUDQJHZDQGWHQRGHU%HUHLFKVHWKLNHQHQWIDOWHWGLH SULQ]LSLHOOH*OWLJNHLWPRUDOLVFKHU1RUPHQYRUDXVJHVHW]WXQGGLHVH1RU PHQ OHGLJOLFK VLWXDWLY NRQNUHWLVLHUW ZHUGHQ VXFKW OHW]WHUHU QDFK .RKl UHQ]SULQ]LSLHQGHU*OWLJNHLWPRUDOLVFKHU1RUPHQ %HL.DQWQLPPWZLHVLFKLQJH]HLJWKDWGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWGHV 6LWWHQJHVHW]HVHUVWGDGXUFKLPSHUDWLYH)RUPDQGDVLHPLWGHU0|JOLFKNHLW KHWHURQRPHQ +DQGHOQV QLFKWKHLOLJHU :HVHQ NRQIURQWLHUW ZLUG $QDORJ GD]X PVVHQ ² FHWHULV LPSDULEXV ² GLH *HVHW]H GHU .RKlUHQ] GLH EH VWLPPWH+DQGOXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQSUlIHUHQ]RULHQWLHUWHU:H VHQYRUVFKUHLEHQLKUHUVHLWVPLWHLQHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLWDXVJHVWDWWHWZHUGHQ XP GDV ]XU LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ .RKlUHQ] ELVZHLOHQ HUIRUGHUWH $EVWHKHQ YRQ GHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQDXFKOlQJHUIULVWLJHQ3UlIHUHQ]HQ]XEHJUQGHQ $XVNRQWUDNWXDOLVWLVFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHEHVFKUHLEW'DYLG*DXWKLHUGLHVH $XIJDEHIROJHQGHUPDHQ Å(VVWLPPW]ZDUGDQLFKWDOOH6LWXDWLRQHQLQ GHQHQ GLH $QWHLOQDKPH JHJHQ GLH HLJHQHQ %HODQJH VWUHLWHW 3UREOHPIlOOH GDUVWHOOHQDEHUGLH0RUDOZLHVLHQRUPDOHUZHLVHYHUVWDQGHQZLUGEHKDQ GHOWHEHQGLH3UREOHPIlOOHZlKUHQGLKU+XPHVFKHURGHUQDWXUDOLVWLVFKHU (UVDW]GLHVQLFKWWXW´ *DXWKLHUVNRQWUDNWXDOLVWLVFKHU4XDOLIL]LHUXQJGHU 0RUDO OLHJW HLQ 0RUDOEHJULII ]XJUXQGH GHVVHQ DOOJHPHLQH %HVWLPPXQJ DXFK LP )ROJHQGHQ GLVNXVVLRQVOHLWHQG VHLQ VROO Å'LH 0RUDO VWHOOW HLQH %HVFKUlQNXQJ GDU YRQ GHU PDQ ZLH .DQW HUNDQQW KDW QLFKW DQQHKPHQ GDUIVLHKlQJHQXUYRQXQVHUHQ*HIKOHQDE8QGGDKHUGUIHQZLUDXFK QLFKWDXI*HIKOH]XUFNJUHLIHQXPGLH)UDJHQDFKLKUHQ*UXQGODJHQ]X EHDQWZRUWHQ´ 8QWHU GLHVHU NRJQLWLYLVWLVFKHQ %HJUQGXQJVSHUVSHNWLYH VWHOOW VLFK GLH )UDJH RE LQQHUKDOE GHV NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHQ 5DKPHQV HLQH )RUPSUlYDOHQWHU*UQGH]XEHVWLPPHQLVW
_____________ %DGXUD 'LHVH $UEHLWVWHLOXQJ GDUI MHGRFK QLFKW GDUEHU KLQZHJWlXVFKHQ GD LQ EHLGHQ 9DULDQWHQ HLQH VFKDUIH 7UHQQXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHP $SRVWHULRUL GHU $Q ZHQGXQJXQGGHP$SULRULGHU%HJUQGXQJZHGHUHUIRUGHUOLFKQRFKYHUIJEDULVW GLH .RKlUHQ]EH]LHKWVLFKKLHUZLHGRUWDXIGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWYRQ*UQGHQ *DXWKLHU *DXWKLHU
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
'HUNU]HVWH:HJ]XHLQHU$QWZRUWDXIGLHVH)UDJHVFKHLQWGDULQ]X EHVWHKHQSUlYDOHQWH*UQGHVFKOLFKWDOVGLHMHQLJHQ*UQGH]XGHILQLHUHQ GLH HLQHUVHLWV GLH LQWUD XQG DQGHUHUVHLWV GLH LQWHUSHUVRQHOOH .RKlUHQ] JHZlKUOHLVWHQ(LQ+DQGOXQJVJUXQGLVWGDQQEHVVHURGHUVFKOHFKWHUUHODWLY ]XP *UDG GHU .RKlUHQ] GLH GXUFK LKQ HUP|JOLFKW ZLUG *HERWH GHU 5FNVLFKWQDKPH DQGHUHQ JHJHQEHU GRPLQLHUHQ LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH P|JOL FKHUZHLVH*HERWHGHU(LJHQOLHEHLQVRIHUQHUVWHUHZHVHQWOLFKHLQHIXQNWL RQLHUHQGH *HVHOOVFKDIW NRQVWLWXLHUHQ LQ ZHOFKHU MHGH HLQ]HOQH 3HUVRQ EHUKDXSWHUVWLKUHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ=LHOHYHUIROJHQNDQQVRODQJHHEHQGLHVH 9HUIROJXQJ GLH LQGLYLGXHOOHQ =LHOH GHU DQGHUHQ 3HUVRQHQ IU GLHVH QLFKW XQHUUHLFKEDU PDFKW (LQH VROFKH VHOEVWPlFKWLJH =HUVW|UXQJ YRQ +DQG OXQJV]LHOHQ DQGHUHU 3HUVRQHQ VHW]WH GHQ +DQGHOQGHQ JHZLVVHUPDHQ DX HUKDOE GHV +DQGOXQJV]XVDPPHQKDQJV GHU LKP VHOEVW DXIJUXQG GHVVHQ ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU 5FNVLFKWVVWUXNWXU GDV 9HUIROJHQ VHLQHU HLJHQHQ =LHOH HUVW HUP|JOLFKW 'LHVH(UNOlUXQJLVWMHGRFKWURW]LKUHV)XQNWLRQVLGHDOVQRFKXQEHIULH GLJHQG LKUHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWLVW]XVFKZDFKXPZLH1LHOVHQLKQQHQQW GHPÅNODVVHQJHEXQGHQHQ$PRUDOLVWHQ´ ZHQLJVWHQVHLQ$UJXPHQWDQELH WHQ]XN|QQHQ'LHVHUNODVVHQJHEXQGHQH$PRUDOLVW]HLFKQHWVLFKGDGXUFK DXVGDHUJHJHQEHUVHLQHVJOHLFKHQVDJHQZLUHLQHUPHKURGHUZHQLJHU ZRKOKDEHQGHQ 3HUVRQ GLH LQ HLQHP PHKU RGHU ZHQLJHU SURVSHULHUHQGHQ 6WDDWOHEWVHKUUFNVLFKWVYROOLVWQLFKWDEHUEHLVSLHOVZHLVHJHJHQEHUGHP $UEHLWHUDXIHLQHU7DEDNSODQWDJHLQ6LPEDEZH2EPDQGLHVH3HUVRQQXQ DOVNODVVHQJHEXQGHQHQ$PRUDOLVWHQEH]HLFKQHWRGHUDEHU²PHLQHV(UDFK WHQVHEHQVRSODXVLEHO²DOVNODVVHQJHEXQGHQHQ0RUDOLVWHQLVWWKHRUHWLVFK LUUHOHYDQW (QWVFKHLGHQG LVW YLHOPHKU GD DXFK GLHVHU NODVVHQJHEXQGHQH $PRUDOLVWDOV$UJXPHQWHQ]XJlQJOLFKYRUJHVWHOOWZHUGHQPX7ULIIWGLHV QLFKWPHKU]XVRKDQGHOWHVVLFKXPHLQ:HVHQEHLGHPZLH.XUW%D\ HUW] HV FKDUDNWHULVLHUW ÅVWDWW 3KLORVRSKLH >«@ 3V\FKRWKHUDSLH XQG JHJH EHQHQIDOOVGLH3ROL]HL YRQQ|WHQVHLQ´ GUIWH
_____________ 1LHOVHQFKDUDNWHULVLHUWLKQDOVÅ D HLQH3HUVRQGLH]XUKHUUVFKHQGHQ(OLWHHLQHUVRO FKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW>VF.ODVVHQJHVHOOVFKDIW .3@JHK|UW E HLQH3HUVRQGHUHQXQHL JHQQW]LJH 6RUJH VLFK OHGLJOLFK DXI LKUHVJOHLFKHQ XQG MHQH 8QWHUJHEHQHQ HUVWUHFNW 'LHQHU0lWUHVVHQXQGGHUJOHLFKHQ IUGLHVLHUHLQ]XIlOOLJ6RUJHWUlJW XQG F HLQH 3HUVRQGLHDOOHDQGHUHQGXUFKJHVFKLFNWH0DQLSXODWLRQEHHLQIOXWXQGGLH0RUDODOV PRUDOLVFKH,GHRORJLHHLQVHW]WXPGLHEHVWHKHQGH2UGQXQJ]XHUKDOWHQVRGDGLH,Q WHUHVVHQLKUHU.ODVVHXQGGDPLWLKUHHLJHQHQ,QWHUHVVHQJHI|UGHUWZHUGHQ=ZLVFKHQ GHP $PRUDOLVWHQ XQG VHLQHVJOHLFKHQ ² GHQ 0LWJOLHGHUQ MHQHU (OLWH ² EHVWHKHQ HFKWH PRUDOLVFKH%H]LHKXQJHQ´ 1LHOVHQ %D\HUW] YJODXFKGHUV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
'DV3UREOHPGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVNULWHULHQ
.ODVVHQJHEXQGHQH$PRUDOLVWHQ7ULWWEUHWWIDKUHUXQGGDV 3UREOHPGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVNULWHULHQ 'DV3UREOHPGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVNULWHULHQ
2KQH5HNXUVDXI*UQGHVROOWHHLQNDXVDOLWlWVJHEXQGHQHU$EODXIQDWXUD OHU =XVWlQGH JHJHEHQHQIDOOV DOV PHQVFKOLFKHV 9HUKDOWHQ QLFKW DEHU DOV +DQGOXQJ EH]HLFKQHW ZHUGHQ 'HU ÄHQWVFKHLGHQGH (LQIOX GHU 9HUQXQIW DXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQ¶GHUVLFKDXFKEHL.DQWMHQVHLWVGHU'LFKRWRPLVLH UXQJ YRQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ XQG NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYHQ JH]HLJW KDW HU ZHLVW VLFK LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH DOV HLQ JUXQGOHJHQGHV SUDNWLVFKHV 3ULQ]LS ,VW GLHVH $XVJDQJVEHVFKUHLEXQJ DN]HSWLHUW VR OHJW GLH0|JOLFKNHLW LQWHUWHP SRUDOHU $EZlJXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ DXI LQWUD ZLH DXFK DXI LQWHU SHUVRQHOOHU (EHQH HLQH .RQ]HSWLRQ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ QDKH GLH QLFKWDXIHLQH%HIULHGLJXQJE]Z5HDOLVLHUXQJDNWXHOOHUXQGDXFKQLFKWDXI HLQH%HIULHGLJXQJE]Z5HDOLVLHUXQJLQGLYLGXHOOHU3UR(LQVWHOOXQJHQUHVWULQ JLHUWEOHLEWVRQGHUQ*UQGHIUHLQHQDXIOlQJHUH6LFKWLQVJHVDPWEHVVHUHQ =XVWDQG GHU 3HUVRQ E]Z GHU *UXSSH YRQ 3HUVRQHQ LQWHJULHUHQ NDQQ *UQGHZHUGHQGHPQDFKDQLKUHP.RKlUHQ]EHLWUDJ]XLQGLYLGXHOOHQE]Z LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXUHQ EHPHVVHQ $Q EHVWHKHQGHQ :Q VFKHQ +DQGOXQJVVDQNWLRQHQ PRUDOLVFKHQ 1RUPHQ RGHU UHOLJL|VHQ 9RU VWHOOXQJHQ RULHQWLHUWH *UQGH VLQG GDQDFK QLFKW SHU VH JXWH +DQGOXQJV JUQGH RE VLH MHZHLOV JXWH *UQGH VLQG KlQJW YRQ LKUHU UDWLRQDOHQ (LQELQGXQJLQGLHXPIDVVHQGHLQWUDXQGLQWHUSHUVRQHOOH+DQGOXQJVVWUXN WXUDEGHUHQ7HLOVLHVLQG 'RFK GLH )UDJH GHU 3KLORVRSKLH EOHLEW ZHQQ GLH *WH YRQ +DQG OXQJVJUQGHQGDUDQJHPHVVHQZLUGLQZLHZHLWVLFKLQLKQHQGLHYRUDXVJHVHW] WH 6\VWHPUDWLRQDOLWlW PDQLIHVWLHUW VR PVVHQ GRFK GLH .ULWHULHQ GLHVHU 6\VWHPUDWLRQDOLWlWVHOEVWEHJUQGHWZHUGHQ*HJHQHLQHQSUDNWLVFKHQ.R KlUHQWLVPXV ZLH LFK LKQ ELV KLHUKHU YRUJHVWHOOW KDEH NDQQ GDKHU PLW 5HFKWHLQJHZDQGWZHUGHQGDHUNHLQH+DQGKDEHELHWH]ZLVFKHQXQWHU VFKLHGOLFKHQLQVLFKNRKlUHQWHQ6\VWHPHQYRQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQXQG*UQGHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHU *OWLJNHLW E]Z LKUHU UDWLRQDOHQ $N]HSWLHUEDUNHLW ]X HQWVFKHLGHQ
_____________ (LQHQ(LQZDQGGLHVHV7\SVKDWDXILQWUDSHUVRQHOOHU(EHQHEHUHLWV%UDQGW YRUJHEUDFKW Å>@LIZHDVVXPHWKDWQRUPDWLYHSULQFLSOHVKDYHLPSOLFDWLRQVIRUDFWLRQ LWZRXOGEHVHOIGHIHDWLQJWRHVSRXVHLQFRQVLVWHQWRQHV%XWWKLVUHTXLUHPHQWZLOOQRW WDNHXVIDU LWUHTXLUHVXVPHUHO\WRKROGDFRQVLVWHQWVHW>@RIMXGJHPHQWVDERXWW\SHV RIDFWLRQ,WGRHVQRWGLFWDWHDQ\SDUWLFXODUZD\RIDGMXGLFDWLQJFRQIOLFWVEHWZHHQVD\ KLJKHUOHYHODQGORZHUOHYHOQRUPDWLYHÄLQWXLWLRQV¶6RSURSRQHQWVRIWKHWKHRU\PXVW ILQGVRPHRWKHUMXVWLILFDWLRQIRUWKHSURFHGXUHVRIPD[LPL]LQJWKHVXPRILQLWLDOFUH GHQFHOHYHOVRURIJLYLQJSUHIHUHQFHWRWKHVHWRIQRUPDWLYHEHOLHIVZHILQGLWHDVLHUWR DFFHSW DVDZKROH >@7KHUHLVD SUREOHPKHUHTXLWHVLPLODUWRWKDWZKLFKIDFHVWKH WUDGLWLRQDO FRKHUHQFH WKHRU\ RI MXVWLILFDWLRQ RI EHOLHI WKDW WKH WKHRU\ FODLPV WKDW D
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
6FDQORQ VWUHLFKW ]ZDU KHUDXV GD GLHVH 8QVLFKHUKHLW KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU .RKlUHQ]NULWHULHQHLQHHKHUWKHRUHWLVFKHGHQQUHDOH0|JOLFKNHLWGDUVWHOOW Å7KH SRVVLELOLW\ LQ TXHVWLRQ LV WKDW GLVDJUHHPHQWV PLJKW SHUVLVW HYHQ WKRXJKERWKJURXSVKDGGRQHHYHU\WKLQJSRVVLEOHWRFKHFNWKHLUYLHZVIRU HUURUV UHQGHU WKHP FRKHUHQW DQG VR RQ , ZRXOG HPSKDVL]H KRZHYHU WKDW DOWKRXJK WKLV SRVVLELOLW\ PD\ EH WKHRUHWLFDOO\ LQWULJXLQJ LW LV RI QR SUDFWLFDO VLJQLILFDQFH VLQFH RXU YLHZV QHYHU PHHW WKLV LGHDO WHVW 6R LQ FDVHVRIDFWXDOGLVDJUHHPHQWWKHUHLVDOZD\VURRPIRUIXUWKHUDUJXPHQWE\ DSSHDO WR LQFRQVLVWHQFLHV DQG RWKHU LQDGHTXDFLHV LQ HDFK RWKHU·V SRVL WLRQVµ 'RFKVHOEVWGLHVXQGGDUEHUKLQDXV]XJHVWDQGHQGDHVDQDO\ WLVFKZDKULVWGDGDVNRKlUHQWHUH]ZHLHUSUDNWLVFKHU%HJUQGXQJVV\VWH PHEHVVHUJHUHFKWIHUWLJWLVWDOVGDVZHQLJHUNRKlUHQWHVREOHLEWGLH)UDJH QDFK GHP $XVZHLV GHU KLHUEHL EHUOHJHQHQ 6\VWHPUDWLRQDOLWlW GHQQRFK EH VWHKHQ 'LH)UDJHJHKWDOVRDXI:HJH]X.ULWHULHQLQWUDXQGLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU .RKlUHQ]DOV$OWHUQDWLYH]XUWKHRUHWLVFKHQ$QQDKPHRGHU9RUDXVVHW]XQJ HLQHUPRUDOLVFKLQWDNWHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWGHUHQ6\VWHPUDWLRQDOLWlWEHUHLWVGDV LQ )UDJH VWHKHQGH .RKlUHQ]NULWHULXP ELHWHQ ZUGH 'HU .RKlUHQWLVPXV PX GHPQDFK HQWZHGHU DXI PDWHULDOH :HUWH ZLH ,QWHUHVVHQDJJUHJDWLRQ $OOJHPHLQLQWHUHVVH $OOJHPHLQZRKO HWF UHNXUULHUHQ RGHU DEHU IRUPDOH .ULWHULHQLQWUDXQGLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU.RKlUHQ]DQJHEHQ $UJXPHQWDWLY EQGLJ DQ GLHVH )UDJH DQVFKOLHHQ ODVVHQ VLFK VRZRKO HLQSUlVNULSWLYHU5HJHO8WLOLWDULVPXVLP6LQQH5LFKDUG+DUHVDOVDXFKHLQ NRQWUDNWXDOLVWLVFKHV %HJUQGXQJVSURMHNW LP 6LQQH *DXWKLHUV %HJULII GHU DEZlJHQGHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ XQG GLHVHV LQVWLWXWLRQHQWKHRUHWLVFK ZHLWHU IKUHQGHLQ0RGHOOGHVhEHUOHJXQJVJOHLFKJHZLFKWVLP6LQQH-RKQ5DZOV·
_____________ PRUHFRKHUHQWV\VWHPRIEHOLHIVLVEHWWHUMXVWLILHGWKDQDOHVVFRKHUHQWRQHEXWWKHUH LVQRUHDVRQWRWKLQNWKLVFODLPLVWUXHXQOHVVVRPHRIWKHEHOLHIVDUHLQLWLDOO\FUHGLEOH² DQG QRW PHUHO\ LQLWLDOO\ EHOLHYHG ² IRU VRPH UHDVRQ RWKHU WKDQ WKHLU FRKHUHQFH VD\ EHFDXVHWKH\VWDWHIDFWVRIREVHUYDWLRQ´'LHVHU(LQZDQGOlWVLFK PXWDWLVPXWDQGLV YRQ GHU LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ DXI GLH LQWHUSHUVRQHOOH (EHQH EHUWUDJHQ 9JO GD]X DXFK 6FDQORQ IVRZLHXQWHQ.DS)Q 6FDQORQ *LEEDUG VSULFKW GLHVH $QVLFKW XQWHUVWW]HQG DXFK YRQHLQHPÄVRNUDWLVFKHQ(LQIOX¶GHULQHLQHP'LVNXUV]XU6LFKHUXQJGHU.RKlUHQ] SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DQJHZDQGW ZHUGHQ NDQQ Å+HDUHUV PD\ DFFHSW ZKDW D VSHDNHUVD\VQRWEHFDXVHWKHVSHDNHUDFFHSWVLWEXWRQWKHEDVLVRIWKLQJVWKH\ZHUH SURQHWRDFFHSW DQ\ZD\LIWKH\WKRXJKWDORQJFHUWDLQOLQHV/HFWXUHVLQPDWKHPDWLFV FDQSURFHHGWKLVZD\6RFUDWLFLQIOXHQFHWKHQFDQZRUNE\DVVHUWLRQVRORQJDVWKH DVVHUWLRQV SURGXFH FRQYLFWLRQ VROHO\ E\ SURGGLQJ OLVWHQHUV WR ZRUN WKLQJV RXW IRU WKHPVHOYHVRQWKHEDVLVRIZKDWWKH\DOUHDG\DFFHSW6RFUDWLFLQIOXHQFHLQVKRUWLVLQ IOXHQFHWKDWFRXOGEHH[HUFLVHGVLPSO\E\DVNLQJDSSURSULDWHTXHVWLRQVµ'RFKLQGHU 3UD[LV PRUDOLVFKHU $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ VFKHLQW GLH *UHQ]H ]ZLVFKHQ ÄVRNUDWLVFKHP (LQIOX¶XQGNOXJHU3URSDJDQGD]XXQVFKDUI]XVHLQXPDOOHLQDXIGLH*WHGHUDUWLJHU (LQIOXQDKPHYHUWUDXHQ]XZROOHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
'DV3UREOHPGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVNULWHULHQ
/HGLJOLFK H[HPSODULVFK XQG NXUVRULVFK VHL GHVKDOE DXI GLH IU PHLQ JH JHQZlUWLJHV ,QWHUHVVH HLQVFKOlJLJHQ $VSHNWH GLHVHU 3RVLWLRQHQ VRZLH GLH ]HQWUDOHQGDKLQWHUVWHKHQGHQ3UREOHPHYHUZLHVHQ (LQH HKHU LQGLYLGXHOOVWUXNWXUDOLVWLVFKH SUlVNULSWLYH 3HUVSHNWLYH QLPPW +DUH HLQ ZHQQ HU GLH /DJH EHWUDFKWHW Å>«@ LQ GHU ZLU ZlUHQ ZHQQ ZLU HLQ .LQG DXI]|JHQ XQG XQV QXU VHLQH ,QWHUHVVHQ DP +HU]HQ OlJHQ >«@ 0DQ N|QQWH PHLQHQ GD ZLU GHP .LQG HLQ UHLQ HJRLVWLVFKHV 3ULQ]LSHLQLPSIHQZUGHQGDVMHQLJHQlPOLFKEHLMHGHU*HOHJHQKHLWGDV]X WXQZDVVHLQ(LJHQLQWHUHVVHDPVWlUNVWHQ]XWXQIRUGHUW´ 'RFKHV]HLJW VLFKVR+DUHGDHLQHVROFKH(U]LHKXQJGHP.LQGVHOEVWVFKDGHQZUGH ZREHL GLH (U]LHKXQJVSHUVSHNWLYH KLHU QLFKW ZHVHQWOLFK LVW 9LHOPHKU NRPPW HV +DUH DXI GLH %HJUQGXQJ HLQHU 5DWLRQDOLWlWVIRUP DQ GLH VLFK DXI HLQ ,QGLYLGXXP XQG GHUHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ XQG +DQGOXQJHQ EH]LHKW ZHOFKH LKUHUVHLWV DEHU ZHVHQWOLFK LP VR]LDOHQ .RQWH[W JHVHKHQ ZHUGHQ PVVHQ$XFKHUZHQGHWVLFKGDKHUJHJHQGHQEHUHLWVHUZlKQWHQÄSXQNWX HOOHQ2SWLPLHUHU¶ Å(VZlUHJDQ]HLQIDFKLPSUDNWLNDEHOXQGVHOEVWZHQQ SUDNWLNDEHO IHKOJHOHLWHWGHU6WUDWHJLH]XIROJHQDQOlOLFKMHGHUSUXGHQWLHO OHQ (QWVFKHLGXQJ HLQH HLJHQQW]LJH RGHU HJRLVWLVFKH .RVWHQ1XW]HQ $QDO\VH GXUFK]XIKUHQ 'DIU UHLFKW GLH =HLW QLFKW XQG RIW ZUGHQ ZLU XQVHUH$QWZRUWHQ]XUHFKWVFKXVWHUQ>«@PLWGHP>(UJHEQLV@GDGDVZDV QXU GLH XQPLWWHOEDUVWHQ LQ GHP 0RPHQW YHUVSUWHQ %HGUIQLVVH YHUODQ JHQ DXFK VFKRQ GDV SUXGHQWLHOO %HVWH LVW )DVW LPPHU ZUGHQ ZLU GHQ *DQJ]XP=DKQDU]WYHUVFKLHEHQ8PGLHVHU7HQGHQ]HQWJHJHQ]XZLUNHQ EUDXFKHQ ZLU SUXGHQWLHOOH SULPDIDFLH3ULQ]LSLHQ HEHQVR GULQJHQG ZLH PRUDOLVFKHXQGPVVHQLKQHQJHJHQEHUHLQHJDQ]H5HLKHGHUVHOEHQ(LQ VWHOOXQJHQ HQWZLFNHOQ´ 0LW HLQHU 9HUELQGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU VR]LDO GHVNULSWLYHQ XQG GHU LQGLYLGXHOOSUlVNULSWLYHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH NRQNUHWLVLHUW +DUH GDUDXIKLQ VHLQH NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ Å'LH 0HQVFKKHLW KDW KHUDXVJHIXQGHQ GD PDQ GDV /HEHQ XP YLHOHV HUWUlJOLFKHU PDFKHQ NDQQLQGHPPDQHV]XZHJHEULQJWGDVLFKHLQHPRUDOLVFKH/HEHQVIK UXQJ LP JURHQ XQG JDQ]HQ EH]DKOW PDFKW )U IDVW DOOH YRQ XQV LVW HV EHVVHU ZHQQ PLW VR]LDO QW]OLFKHQ UHVSHNWLYH VFKlGOLFKHQ +DQGOXQJHQ VR]LDOH %HORKQXQJHQ UHVSHNWLYH %HVWUDIXQJHQ +DQG LQ +DQG JHKHQ >«@´ 'DPLW GUlQJW VLFK MHGRFK XQYHUPHLGOLFK GLH Ä7ULWWEUHWWIDKUHU¶ )UDJH DXI Å:DUXP GDV .LQG QLFKW GD]X HU]LHKHQ PHLVWHQV GHQ KHUU VFKHQGHQ6LWWHQ]XJHKRUFKHQDEHU]\QLVFKJHJHQVLH]XYHUVWRHQZHQQ HV YHUPHLGHQ NDQQ HUWDSSW RGHU EHVWUDIW ]X ZHUGHQ" (LQH 7HLODQWZRUW ODXWHW GD UHFKWVFKDIIHQ ]X VHLQ GLH EHL ZHLWHP HLQIDFKVWH 0HWKRGH LVW
_____________ +DUH +DUH I +DUH I
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
UHFKWVFKDIIHQ ]X HUVFKHLQHQ >«@ :HQQ ZLU XQV GDUDQ PDFKHQ XQVHU .LQG ]X GHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ ]X HU]LHKHQ GLH K|FKVWZDKUVFKHLQOLFK VHLQHP HLJHQHQ*OFNLQVJHVDPWDP]XWUlJOLFKVWHQVLQG>«@GDQQPVVHQZLUHV QLFKWQXU]XHLQHU6WUDWHJLHRGHU3UD[LVGHU%HIROJXQJGLHVHU3ULQ]LSLHQHU ]LHKHQVRQGHUQ]XIHVWHQFKDUDNWHUOLFKHQ'LVSRVLWLRQHQGLH>«@GLHJHJHQVHLWL JH =XVDPPHQDUEHLW XQG =XQHLJXQJ >HUP|JOLFKHQ@ RKQH GLH DOO XQVHUH %HPKXQJHQ IHKOVFKODJHQ XQG DOOH )UHXGH XQG :lUPH LP /HEHQ YHU VFKZLQGHQ ZUGHQ´ (LQ XPVLFKWLJHV 8WLOLWlWVNDONO VFKHLQW VLFK KLHU DOV PDWHULDOHVLQWUDXQGLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHV.RKlUHQ]NULWHULXPKLQVLFKWOLFKSHU V|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DQ]XELHWHQ 'D MHGRFK +DUHV 2SWLPLVPXV ZDV GLH 5HFKWVFKDIIHQKHLW XQG GHUHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH (UVFKHLQXQJ DQODQJW SULQ]LSLHOOSUREOHPDWLVFKLVW]HLJWGLHEHUHLWVHUZlKQWH)LJXUGHVNODVVHQ JHEXQGHQH$PRUDOLVWHQDXIGLHLFKVRJOHLFKQRFKHLQPDO]XUFNNRPPHQ ZHUGH DXV GHV OHW]WHUHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH HUVFKHLQW GLHVHV .DONO DOV HLQ RSHQ TXHVWLRQ DUJXPHQW RKQH GD GHU 8WLOLWDULVPXV GLHV DOV VROFKHV DQHUNHQQHQ ZUGH *DXWKLHU VNL]]LHUW VHLQ %HJUQGXQJVSURMHNW G K GLH Å0HUNPDOH GHU DEZlJHQGHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW >«@ GLH HV HUP|JOLFKHQ PD[LPLHUHQGH (QW VFKHLGXQJHQ]XEHVFKUlQNHQ´DXVHLQHUVWlUNHUDQ)UDJHQGHU.RRSHUDWL RQ XQG GDPLW DP .RQWUDNWXDOLVPXV RULHQWLHUWHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH Å'HU *UXQGJHGDQNH LVW GHU GDLQ YLHOHQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ GDV (UJHEQLV HLQHU (QW VFKHLGXQJ ZHQQ MHGHU VLFK IU GDV HQWVFKHLGHW ZDV LQ $QEHWUDFKW GHU (QWVFKHLGXQJHQGHUDQGHUHQGHQHLJHQHQHUZDUWHWHQ1XW]HQPD[LPLHUHQ ZUGHIUDOOH%HWHLOLJWHQQDFKWHLOLJLVWYHUJOLFKHQPLWHLQHU$OWHUQDWLYH² MHGHUN|QQWHHLQEHVVHUHV(UJHEQLVHU]LHOHQ>«@$QJHVLFKWVGHU7DWVDFKH GDVROFKH6LWXDWLRQHQDOOJHJHQZlUWLJVLQGNDQQMHGHUGHQ9RUWHLOHUNHQ QHQGHULKPSHUV|QOLFKHQWVWHKWZHQQDOOHHLQH3UD[LVYHUIROJHQGLHYHU ODQJWGDMHGHUDXIGHQ9HUVXFKYHU]LFKWHWVHLQHQHLJHQHQ1XW]HQXQPLW
_____________ +DUH I .DYNDIRUPXOLHUWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJGUHL'LPHQVLRQHQGHU 1W]OLFKNHLW PRUDOLVFKHU (U]LHKXQJ ZREHL IU LKQ ZLH VFKRQ IU +DUH GHU (U]LH KXQJVDVSHNWQLFKWGDV(QWVFKHLGHQGHLVWYLHOPHKUJHKWHVDXFKLKPXPGLH9HUV|K QXQJYRQ0RUDOXQG.OXJKHLW Å)UW\SLVFKH(OWHUQGLHVLFKLQEHVRQGHUHP0DHXP GDV :RKOHUJHKHQ LKUHU .LQGHU XQG VLFK HLQ ZHQLJ XP GDV :RKOHUJHKHQ DQGHUHU NPPHUQJLEWHVGUHLJHZLFKWLJH*UQGHLKUH.LQGHU]XPRUDOLVFKHQ0HQVFKHQ]X HU]LHKHQ $OOHU:DKUVFKHLQOLFKNHWQDFKZLUGGLHVGHQ.LQGHUQ]XJXWHNRPPHQ HQW VSUHFKHQGXQVHUHQIUKHUHQ$UJXPHQWHQGDHVVLFKIUJHZ|KQOLFKDXV]DKOWPRUD OLVFK]XVHLQ DOOHU:DKUVFKHLQOLFKNHLWQDFKZLUGHVDQGHUHQ]XJXWHNRPPHQGLHPLW GHQ .LQGHUQ LQ %HUKUXQJ NRPPHQ XQG HV ZLUG DOOHU :DKUVFKHLQOLFKNHLW QDFK GHQ (OWHUQVHOEVW]XJXWHNRPPHQ ZHLOVLHYRQLKUHQ.LQGHUQEHVVHUEHKDQGHOWZHUGHQ 8QGZHQQ.LQGHUDOVPRUDOLVFKH:HVHQKHUDQZDFKVHQPLWHLQHP*HZLVVHQXQGGHU )lKLJNHLWGLH*HIKOHPRUDOLVFKHU=XIULHGHQKHLW]XHPSILQGHQGDQQOLHJWHV>«@IDVW LPPHU LQ LKUHP ,QWHUHVVH GDPLW IRUW]XIDKUHQ HLQ PRUDOLVFKHV /HEHQ ]X IKUHQ´ .DYND
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
'DV3UREOHPGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVNULWHULHQ
WHOEDU]XPD[LPLHUHQZHQQHLQVROFKHUDOOVHLWLJHU9HU]LFKWIUDOOH%HWHL OLJWHQYRUWHLOKDIWLVW1DWUOLFKNDQQQLHPDQGHLQHQ*UXQGKDEHQLUJHQG HLQH HLQVHLWLJH %HVFKUlQNXQJ VHLQHV PD[LPLHUHQGHQ 9HUKDOWHQV KLQ]X QHKPHQ MHGHUSURILWLHUWQXUYRQGHU%HVFKUlQNXQJGLHDXFKYRQVHLQHQ 0LWPHQVFKHQ DN]HSWLHUW ZLUG :HQQ PDQ DEHU YRQ HLQHU GHQ DQGHUHQ DXIHUOHJWHQ %HVFKUlQNXQJ PHKU SURILWLHUW DOV PDQ YHUOLHUW ZHQQ PDQ VHOEVW HLQHU %HVFKUlQNXQJ XQWHUOLHJW GDQQ KDW PDQ XQWHU 8PVWlQGHQ *UXQG HLQH 3UD[LV ]X DN]HSWLHUHQ GLH YHUODQJW GD MHGHU DXFK PDQ VHOEVWHUNHQQHQOlWGDHUVLFKHLQHUVROFKHQ%HVFKUlQNXQJXQWHUZLUIW :LUN|QQHQGLHVDOVHLQH3UD[LVGDUVWHOOHQGLHEHLUDWLRQDOHQ3HUVRQHQGLH XQWHUVLFKGLH%HGLQJXQJHQDXVJHPDFKWKDEHQXQWHUGHQHQVLHPLWHLQDQ GHUYHUNHKUHQZROOHQHLQKHOOLJ=XVWLPPXQJILQGHQNDQQ8QGGLHVH=X VWLPPXQJ LVW GLH*UXQGODJH GHU 0RUDO´ 'HP QDKHOLHJHQGHQ (LQZDQG GHQEHUHLWV+REEHVGHPÅ7RUHQ´LQGHQ0XQGJHOHJWKDWXQGGHUDXFK YRQ+DUHDQJHGHXWHWZXUGHGDHVIUGHQ(LQ]HOQHQQlPOLFKQXUGDQQ UDWLRQDOLVWVLFKDQGLHVH$EPDFKXQJHQ]XKDOWHQXQGJHPlVHLQHU=X VWLPPXQJ]XKDQGHOQÅZHQQHUGDPLWXQPLWWHOEDU]XUPD[LPDOHQ%HIULH GLJXQJVHLQHU3UlIHUHQ]HQEHLWUlJW´HQWJHJQHW*DXWKLHULP6LQQHGHVLP 9RUVWHKHQGHQ VNL]]LHUWHQ .RQ]HSWV VWUXNXUHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW EH]JOLFK LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU.RKlUHQ] Å=XUFNKDOWHQGH0D[LPLHUHUN|QQHQ>«@HKHU PLWJQVWLJHQ*HOHJHQKHLWHQUHFKQHQDOVLKUH0LWVWUHLWHU2EZRKOVLHDXI HLQH JU|WP|JOLFKH 3UlIHUHQ]EHIULHGLJXQJ YHU]LFKWHQ LQGHP VLH LKUHQ 0LWPHQVFKHQ EHLVWHKHQ 9HUVSUHFKHQ KDOWHQ XQG YRUKDQGHQH PRUDOLVFKH 3UDNWLNHQEHIROJHQHU]LHOHQVLHGRFKDXIJUXQGLKUHUJU|HUHQ0|JOLFKNHL WHQ LQVJHVDPW JHVHKHQ HLQEHVVHUHV (UJHEQLV DOV MHQH GLH LPPHU GHQ HU ZDUWHWHQ1XW]HQPD[LPLHUHQ´
_____________ *DXWKLHUI YJOGD]XDXFK*DXWKLHU LQVEHV9RQGHU.RPSD WLELOLWlWGHV*DXWKLHU·VFKHQ.RQWUDNWXDOLVPXV]XPELVKLHUKHUYRUJHVWHOOWHQ.RKlUHQ WLVPXV DEJHVHKHQ WHLOH LFK *DXWKLHUV WKHRUHWLVFKH =XYHUVLFKW KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU PRUDO SKLORVRSKLVFKHQ 7UDJZHLWH VHLQHV HQJHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlWVEHJULIIV QLFKW *DXWKLHU IRUPXOLHUWGLHVIROJHQGHUPDHQ Å$FRQWUDFWDULDQWKHRU\RIPRUDOVGHYHORSHGDVSDUW RIWKHWKHRU\RIUDWLRQDOFKRLFH>«@HQDEOHVXVWRGHPRQVWUDWHWKHUDWLRQDOLW\RILP SDUWLDOFRQVWUDLQWVRQWKHSXUVXLWRILQGLYLGXDOLQWHUHVWWRSHUVRQVZKRPD\WDNHQRLQ WHUHVWLQRWKHUV·LQWHUHVW0RUDOLW\LVWKXVJLYHQDVXUHJURXQGLQJLQDZHDNDQGZLGHO\ DFFHSWHG FRQFHSWLRQ RI SUDFWLFDO UDWLRQDOLW\ 1R DOWHUQDWLYH DFFRXQW RI PRUDOLW\ DF FRPSOLVKHVWKLVµ *DXWKLHU 0DQNDQQGXUFKDXVGHPOHW]WHQ6DW]]XVWLP PHQRKQHDXFKGHQYRUOHW]WHQ6DW]GLHVHV=LWDWVXQWHUVFKUHLEHQ]XZROOHQ 9JO+REEHV I .DS III .DS *DXWKLHU 9JO ]X *DXWKLHUV .RQ]HSW DXFK 9HOOHPDQ GHU GLHV EH]JOLFK HLQ 3UREOHP VRZLH HLQH HQWVSUHFKHQGH /|VXQJ IRUPXOLHUW Å%XW ZKHQ WKH WLPHIRUIXOILOOLQJWKHDJUHHPHQWDUULYHV*DXWKLHU·VFRQFHSWLRQRISUDFWLFDOUHDVRQLQJ ZLOOQRORQJHUIXUWKHUWKHDJHQW·VJRDOVLQFHKLVJRDOZRXOGEHEHWWHUVHUYHGE\UHD VRQLQJ WKDW SHUPLWWHG KLP WR YLRODWH WKH DJUHHPHQW >«@ 7KH VROXWLRQ UHVWV RQ WKH
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
_____________
FODLP WKDW *DXWKLHU·V FRQFHSWLRQ XQOLNH VWUDLJKWIRUZDUG PD[LPL]DWLRQ LV VHOI VXSSRUWLQJµ (EG 6HOEVWXQWHUVWW]HQG LQ GHP 6LQQH GD ZHU VLFK HLQPDO GLH .RRSHUDWLRQ]XU0D[LPHJHPDFKWKDWGHUHQ*UQGHEHUGLHMHQLJHQIUGLH1XW]HQ 0D[LPLHUXQJ GRPLQLHUHQ HR LSVR QLFKW DXV GHU 0D[LPLHUXQJVSHUVSHNWLYH VRQGHUQ DXVGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVSHUVSHNWLYHXUWHLOW Å7KHDJHQW·VFXUUHQWFRQFHSWLRQRISUDFWLFDO UHDVRQLQJUHFRPPHQGVWKDWKHDQVZHUVXFKDTXHVWLRQLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKDFRPSDUL VRQEHWZHHQWKHFRQVHTXHQFHVRIPDNLQJDQGDELGLQJE\KLVFRPPLWPHQWRQWKHRQH KDQGDQGWKHFRQVHTXHQFHVRIQHYHUKDYLQJPDGHLWRQWKHRWKHUHDFKFRQVLGHUHGDV DSDFNDJHGHDO5HDVRQLQJLQWKLV PDQQHUWKHDJHQWZLOOILQGWKDWWKHDGYDQWDJHVRI EHLQJRIIHUHGDFRRSHUDWLYHDJUHHPHQWRXWZHLJKWKHGLVDGYDQWDJHVRIIXOILOOLQJLW DQG VRKHZLOOGHFLGHWRDELGHE\KLVFRPPLWPHQWDQGKHQFHUHWDLQ*DXWKLHU·VFRQFHSWLRQ RI SUDFWLFDO UHDVRQLQJµ (EG 9HOOHPDQ VHOEVW LVW MHGRFK EHU GLHVH V\PSDWKH WLVFKH 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ GHU 3RVLWLRQ *DXWKLHUV KLQDXV GHU $QVLFKW GD GLH 0D[LPLHUXQJVWHUPLQRORJLHDOOHLQQLFKWDXVUHLFKWXP+DQGOXQJVNULWHULHQ]XHUNOlUHQ VRQGHUQGD]XZHVHQWOLFKGLH+LQWHUJUXQGHLQVWHOOXQJHQGHV(QWVFKHLGXQJVWUlJHUVXQG +DQGHOQGHQHLQEH]RJHQZHUGHQPVVHQ Å,IDQDFWLRQZHUHWKHVRUWRIWKLQJZKRVH VXFFHVVRUIDLOXUHFRXOGEHMXGJHGVROHO\E\XWLOLW\PD[LPL]LQJFRQVLGHUDWLRQVWKHQLW ZRXOGQ·WEHWKHVRUWRIWKLQJWKDWZHFRXOGGHFLGHRQWRGD\LQDZD\WKDWZRXOGQHF HVVDULO\JLYHXVUHDVRQWRSHUIRUPLWWRPRUURZDQGVRLWZRXOGQ·WEHEHKDYLRURYHU ZKLFKUDWLRQDODJHQWVKDYHGLDFKURQLFDXWRQRP\%XWDFWLRQLVWKDWVRUWRIWKLQJ²LWLV EHKDYLRURYHUZKLFKUDWLRQDODJHQWVKDYHGLDFKURQLFDXWRQRP\²DQGVRLWFDQ·WEHWKH VRUWRIWKLQJZKRVHVXFFHVVRUIDLOXUHFDQEHMXGJHGVROHO\E\XWLOLW\PD[LPL]LQJFRQ VLGHUDWLRQVµ (EG 6WDWWGHVVHQ KlOW HU $XWRQRPLH LP 6LQQH HLQHV 6HOEVWYHU VWlQGQLVVHVRGHUHLQHU,FK,GHQWLILNDWLRQIUHLQVXEVWDQWLHOOHV+DQGOXQJV]LHOGHPDQ GHUH +DQGOXQJV]LHOH QLFKW ]XZLGHUODXIHQ GUIHQ RKQH GLH 3HUVRQ LUUDWLRQDO HUVFKHLQHQ ]X ODVVHQ Å:KDW VHWWOHV WKH LVVXH IRU PH LV WKDW VLPSO\ EHLQJ UDWLRQDO DJHQWVHQDEOHVXVWRH[HUFLVHDXWRQRP\RYHURXUIXWXUHVZLWKRXWLPSDLULQJRXUIXWXUH DXWRQRP\ ² VRPHWKLQJ WKDW ZH FRXOGQ·W GR XQOHVV SDVW FRPPLWPHQWV KDG UDWLRQDO ZHLJKWµ (EG YJO GD]X DXFK +LQFKPDQ +LQWHU GHP VFKZDQNHQGHQ 6SUDFKJHEUDXFK 9HOOHPDQV DXWRQRP\ VHOINQRZOHGJH YJO DXFK 9HOOHPDQ F VWHKWGLHVHKUSODXVLEOH$QVLFKWGD+DQGOXQJHQGHUHQ*UQGHQLFKWDXILUJHQGHLQH :HLVHPLWDQGHUHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQGLHVHU3HUVRQYHUEXQGHQVLQGGLHVHU3HUVRQVFKOLFKW XQYHUVWlQGOLFK EOHLEHQ PVVHQ ,Q GLHVHP 6LQQH ² DXVGUFNOLFK QLFKW LQ HLQHP YRQ 9HOOHPDQ LQWHQGLHUWHQ VXEVWDQWLHOOHQ $ULVWRWHOLVFKHQ YJO 9HOOHPDQ I ² XQWHUOLHJHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH XQG DEVLFKWHQ GHP 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLV RGHU GHU $XWR QRPLHGLHVHU3HUVRQ'DUDXVIROJWDEHUQLFKWZLH9HOOHPDQLQ)RUWIKUXQJYRQ$QV FRPEHV ,QWHQWLRQVEHJULIIV DOV ÅNQRZOHGJH ZLWKRXW REVHUYDWLRQ´ $QVFRPEH LPPHUZLHGHUEHWRQWGDGLHVH$XWRQRPLHRGHUGLHVHV6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVRGHU 6HOEVWZLVVHQGDVHLJHQWOLFKH+DQGOXQJV]LHODOOHUXQVHUHU+DQGOXQJHQGDUVWHOOW9JO]X HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ (LQZlQGHQ XD 0HOH +XVVDLQ %UDWPDQ 0V VRZLH 9HOOHPDQV (UZLGHUXQJHQ DXI GLHVH XQG DQGHUH (LQZlQGH LQ 9HOOHPDQ DEF3UDNWLVFKH)HVWOHJXQJHQKDEHQZLHGLHLQ.DSGLVNXWLHUWH3UREOHPDWLN ]HLJHQZLUGHLQHZHVHQWOLFKDQGHUH)XQNWLRQDOVHSLVWHPLVFKHZHQQJOHLFKVLHLQIROJH LKUHU LQIHUHQWLHOOHQ *OLHGHUXQJ QDWUOLFK PLW GHP 9HUVWlQGQLV GHV HLJHQHQ +DQGHOQV XQGGDPLWGHUHLJHQHQ3HUVRQ]XVDPPHQKlQJHQGRFKLVWGLHVHEHQZHVHQWOLFKZHQL JHUDOV9HOOHPDQDQQLPPWZHQQHUGDIUDUJXPHQWLHUWGDÅ>«@WKHZLOOHPHUJHVDV DE\SURGXFWRIFXULRVLW\SOXVVHOIDZDUHQHVV´ 9HOOHPDQF
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
'DV3UREOHPGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVNULWHULHQ
'LH 1lKH VHLQHV 0RGHOOV HLQHU ÅNRQWUDNWXDOLVWLVFKHQ 0RUDO´ ]XP Å5DZOVVFKHQ .RKlUHQ]WHVW´ GD QlPOLFK Å>«@ PRUDOLVFKH 3UDNWLNHQ GLHJHUHFKWIHUWLJWZHUGHQN|QQHQVROFKHVLQGGLHXQVHUH=XVWLPPXQJH[ DQWHILQGHQ>«@3UDNWLNHQGHQHQZLULQVRIHUQ]XJHVWLPPWKlWWHQDOVVLH GLH %HGLQJXQJHQ XQVHUHU ]XNQIWLJHQ ,QWHUDNWLRQ ELOGHQ ZlUHQ ZLU SHU LPSRVVLELOH LQ GHU /DJH GLHVH %HGLQJXQJHQ IHVW]XOHJHQ´ EHQHQQW *DXWKLHUEHUHLWVVHOEVW'DPLWYHUVXFKWHU²XQGGLHVLVWIUGDV,QWHUHVVH GHUYRUOLHJHQGHQ8QWHUVXFKXQJYRQ]HQWUDOHU%HGHXWXQJ²GHQhEHUJDQJ YRQ GHU LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ .RKlUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQ XQG 3UR (LQVWHOOXQJHQ]XULQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ.RKlUHQ]GHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ6WDEL OLWlWKHU]XVWHOOHQ Å>«@GLH0RUDOYHUODQJWGDPDQIlKLJLVW9HUSIOLFK WXQJHQ HLQ]XJHKHQ PLW DQGHUHQ HLQH hEHUHLQNXQIW ]X WUHIIHQ LQ GHP YROOHQ%HZXWVHLQGDPDQVHLQHQ%HLWUDJOHLVWHQNDQQXQGZLUGXQJH DFKWHWGHUYLHOHQEHUHFKWLJWHQ(UZlJXQJHQGLHQRUPDOHUZHLVHLQGLHHLJH QHQ ]XNQIWLJHQ hEHUOHJXQJHQ PLW HLQIOLHHQ 8QG GDV LVW PHKU DOV GLH )lKLJNHLWGLHHLJHQHQ:QVFKHXQG,QWHUHVVHQPLWVHLQHQhEHU]HXJXQJHQ ]XHLQHPHLQ]LJHQNRKlUHQWHQ*DQ]HQ]XVDPPHQ]XIJHQ´ :LH LQ *DXWKLHUV .RQ]HSWLRQ GHU 0RUDOV E\ $JUHHPHQW VR LVW DXFK LQ 5DZOV·7KHRU\RI-XVWLFHGLHH[DQWH4XDOLILNDWLRQPRUDOLVFKHU3UDNWLNHQGLH KLHU LQ *HVWDOW HLQHV Å6FKOHLHUV GHV1LFKWZLVVHQV´ LP Å8U]XVWDQG´ HLQ ]HQWUDOHV(OHPHQWDXVPDFKWGHUQHUYXVSUREDQGLGHU7KHRULH1XUGLHVH H[DQWH4XDOLILNDWLRQNDQQHLQHUVHLWVWKHRUHWLVFKYRUGHPNODVVHQJHEXQGH QHQ$PRUDOLVWHQEHZDKUHQGHQQGLH%LQGXQJDQ3ULQ]LSLHQJHVFKLHKWKLHU XQDEKlQJLJYRQGHU.HQQWQLVGHUHLJHQHQ VHLHVQXQSULYLOHJLHUWHQRGHU
_____________ *DXWKLHU (EG (EG'DV(UIRUGHUQLVHLQHV VROFKHQhEHUJDQJVEHQHQQWDXVXPJHNHKUWHU3HU VSHNWLYH YRQ GHU *HVHOOVFKDIW ]XP ,QGLYLGXXP DXFK 1LHOVHQ Å'D ZLU PRUDOLVFK VHLQ VROOWHQ ² GD ZLU DOV *HPHLQVFKDIW PRUDOLVFKHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ EHGUIHQ ² ]HLJW QLFKWZDUXPHLQ,QGLYLGXXPLQHLQHU*HVHOOVFKDIWPLWOHLGOLFKIXQNWLRQLHUHQGHQPR UDOLVFKHQ,QVWLWXWLRQHQVHOEVWMHPDQGPLWPRUDOLVFKHQ3ULQ]LSLHQVHLQVROOWH´ 1LHOVHQ (VEHGDUIGHPQDFKHLQHUÅ>«@8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHPJHJHQEHUGHU KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ QHXWUDOHQ 6WDQGSXQNW XQG GHP DXI GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ EH]RJHQHQ 6WDQG SXQNW>«@´ 1LHOVHQ 9JO]X1LHOVHQVHQWVSUHFKHQGHP3HVVLPLVPXVDXFK XQWHQ)Q 9JO 5DZOV 2EZRKO GLH YRUOLHJHQGH 8QWHUVXFKXQJ ZHGHU GHP 5DZOV·VFKHQ QRFK GHP *DXWKLHU·VFKHQ (UNOlUXQJVLQWHUHVVH IROJW VR VWHKW VLH GRFK GHPHUVWHUHQQlKHUDOVGHPOHW]WHUHQ ZlKUHQG5DZOVHLQH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQ ÄUDWLRQDO¶ XQG ÄUHDVRQDEOH¶ IU HUIRUGHUOLFK KlOW ZHLVW *DXWKLHU HLQH VROFKH ]XUFN Å>@ZHFODLPWRJHQHUDWHPRUDOLW\DV DVHWRIUDWLRQDOSULQFLSOHVIRUFKRLFH:HDUH FRPPLWWHG WR VKRZLQJ ZK\ DQ LQGLYLGXDO UHDVRQLQJ IURP QRQPRUDO SUHPLVVHV ZRXOGDFFHSWWKHFRQVWUDLQWVRIPRUDOLW\RQKLVFKRLFHV´ *DXWKLHU $XIGLH VH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJZHUGHLFKLQ.DS]XUFNNRPPHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGLKUH.RKlUHQ]
EHQDFKWHLOLJWHQ 3RVLWLRQ LQ GHU 5HDOLWlW $QGHUHUVHLWV VFKHLQW ZLH .RP PXQLWDULVWHQ JHJHQEHU GHP 5DZOV·VFKHQ /LEHUDOLVPXV EHWRQHQ HLQH $EVWUDNWLRQ YRQ WDWVlFKOLFKHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHQ PLW XQ EHUZLQGOLFKHQ6FKZLHULJNHLWHQYHUEXQGHQ]XVHLQ ZLUN|QQHQQLFKW XQG GHU NODVVHQJHEXQGHQH $PRUDOLVW NDQQ XQG ZLOO QLFKW YRQ GHQ UHDOHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHQDEVWUDKLHUHQ'RFKOlWVLFKJHJHQEHUGLHVHP9RUZXUI]X KRKHU$EVWUDNWLRQDXV5DZOV·VFKHU3HUVSHNWLYHGXUFKDXVJHOWHQGPDFKHQ GD HV ]XU %HXUWHLOXQJ XQG .ULWLN DQ GLHVHQ UHDOHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHQ HLQHV KLQWHU GHP 6FKOHLHU GHV 1LFKWZLVVHQV HUVWHOOWHQ *HUHFKWLJNHLWVVWDQGDUGV EHGDUI'HUDP.RQ]HSWGHVhEHUOHJXQJVJOHLFKJHZLFKWVRULHQWLHUWH.RKl UHQWLVPXV 5DZOV· LVW GHU 9HUVXFK KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHU *OWLJNHLW QLFKW HPSLULVFKH(OHPHQWHDOV.ULWHULHQVR]LDOHU.RKlUHQ]]XHQWZLFNHOQ 0HLQ (UNOlUXQJVLQWHUHVVH JHKW LP )ROJHQGHQ QXQ QLFKWDXI HLQH VLFK P|JOLFKHUZHLVH KLHU DQVFKOLHHQGH %HVFKUHLEXQJ VR]LDOHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ ZHOFKHKLQVLFKWOLFKHLQHVPDWHULDO]XEHVWLPPHQGHQ,GHDOVHLQHUJHUHFKWHQ *HVHOOVFKDIW XQG DXIJUXQGGHU HQWZHGHU KLQWHU GHP 6FKOHLHU GHV 1LFKW ZLVVHQV RGHU DXFK XQWHU %HGLQJXQJHQ PD[LPDOHU ,QIRUPLHUWKHLW JH WURIIHQHQ9HUHLQEDUXQJHQEHUZHFKVHOVHLWLJH3IOLFKWHQXQG5HFKWH/HJL WLPLWlW EHVLW]HQ %HL GHQ IROJHQGHQ hEHUOHJXQJHQ VROO HV YLHOPHKU XP P|JOLFKH )RUPHQ QRUPDWLYSUDJPDWLVFKHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXI +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQVRZLHGHU%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]XGLHVHQ)HVWOHJXQ JHQJHKHQXP9HUELQGOLFKNHLWVNULWHULHQSUDNWLVFKHU,QIHUHQ]HQH[SOL]LW]X PDFKHQ'LH'DUVWHOOXQJGHUZLHPDQVLHQHQQHQN|QQWHÄ)HLQPHFKDQLN¶ LQWUDXQGLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLWLVWGDV'HVLGHUDWHLQHVVROFKHQ SUDNWLVFKHQÅEHJUQGXQJVRULHQWLHUWH>Q@.RKlUHQWLVPXV´
_____________ 9JOGLHIUGLHVH$UJXPHQWDWLRQ]HQWUDOHQXQGDOOJHPHLQGLH'HEDWWH]ZLVFKHQ/LEH UDOLVPXV XQG .RPPXQLWDULVPXV EHOHEHQGHQ 7H[W YRQ 6DQGHO XQG :DO]HU 2KQH GDPLW EHU GHQ (UNOlUXQJVZHUW GHU 5DZOV·VFKHQ *HUHFKWLJNHLWVWKHRULH HQW VFKHLGHQ]XN|QQHQVFKHLQW]XPLQGHVWPLWWHOIULVWLJ²XQGGDPLWEHXQUXKLJHQGJHQXJ ² ]X JHOWHQ ZDV 1LHOVHQ EHU GLH /HEHQVIlKLJNHLW HLQHU *HVHOOVFKDIW PLW NODVVHQJH EXQGHQDPRUDOLVWLVFKHQ (LQZRKQHUQ XQG GHQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ 0RUDO2SWLPLVPXV VFKUHLEW Å'DHLQHVROFKH*HVHOOVFKDIWLQVWDELORGHUZHQLJHUVWDELOLVWDOVHLQH*HVHOO VFKDIW LQ ZHOFKHU GHU PRUDOLVFKH 6WDQGSXQNW YRUKHUUVFKW LVW QLFKW HUVLFKWOLFK >«@ 'LH 6NODYHQJHVHOOVFKDIWHQ KDEHQ VLFK EHU ODQJH =HLW HLQHU JHZLVVHQ 6WDELOLWlW HU IUHXW´ 1LHOVHQ $XVJHRSROLWLVFKHU6LFKWVSULFKWGHVNULSWLYDXFKJHJHQZlU WLJYLHOIUHLQHVWDELOH*HOWXQJGLHVHV0RGHOOV (LQHDQ5DZOVRULHQWLHUWHSROLWLVFKH7KHRULHGHU*HUHFKWLJNHLWLQZHOFKHUGHU6FKOHLHU GHV1LFKWZLVVHQV]XJXQVWHQPD[LPDOHU,QIRUPLHUWKHLWGHU%HWHLOLJWHQIlOOWILQGHWVLFK EHL%DUU\ HUJUHLIWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJDXFKDXI]HQWUDOH(OHPHQWHYRQ 6FDQORQV7KHRULH]XUFNGLHLP)ROJHQGHQQRFKGLVNXWLHUWZHUGHQVROOHQ YJOLQVEHV %DUU\ %DGXUD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
'DV3UREOHPGHU.RRSHUDWLRQVNULWHULHQ
.DQWVXPIDVVHQGHV.RQ]HSWGHU9HUQXQIWDOV.RKlUHQ]UDKPHQMHJOLFKHU DXWRQRPHU(LQIOXQDKPHDXIXQVHU+DQGHOQNDQQQDFKGLHVHU+HXULVWLN ÄGHWUDQV]HQGHQWDOLVLHUW¶ XQG VHLQH 0HKUGHXWLJNHLW KLQVLFKWOLFK GLHVHV (LQIOXVVHVGHU9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQLPLQVWUXPHQWHOOHQXQGLPPR UDOLVFKHQ .RQWH[W VFKOLHOLFK PLW %OLFN DXI HLQH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV RSHUDWLRQDOLVLHUWZHUGHQ%HOLHELJH(LQVWHOOXQJHQHSLVWHPLVFKHURGHUHYD OXDWLYHU$UWPVVHQGDEHLQRUPDWLYSUDJPDWLVFKDOV*UQGHIUDQGHUHGHUDU WLJH(LQVWHOOXQJHQJHIDWZHUGHQGHQQGDV6SLHOGHV9HUODQJHQVXQG/LH IHUQV YRQ *UQGHQ LVW ² ]XPLQGHVW SULQ]LSLHOO ² DOV HLQ VR]LDOHV6SLHO ]X EHJUHLIHQ
_____________ 9JO]XGLHVHP%HJULII+DEHUPDV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DSLWHO 'DVGHRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJVPRGHOOXQG GLH'LIIHUHQ]HQSUDNWLVFKHU,QIHUHQ]HQ
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
(LQOHLWXQJ
$XIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNVFKHLQWHVVRDOVZlUH%UDQGRPV,QIHUHQWLDOLVPXVIU GLH6XFKHQDFKLQWUDXQGLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ.RKlUHQ]NULWHULHQYRQ+DQG OXQJVJUQGHQLP$QVFKOXDQ.DQWQLFKWHLQVFKOlJLJ=ZDUJUHQ]W%UDQ GRPVHLQHQ$QVDW]YRQHLQHPÅ$WRPLVPXV´DEGRFKKDQGHOWHVVLFKEHL LKPXPHLQHQÅ%HJULIIV+ROLVPXV´EH]JOLFKGHVÅLQIHUHQWLHOOH>Q@%HJULII>V@ GHV VHPDQWLVFKHQ *HKDOWV´ ZRKLQJHJHQ LQ GHQ EHLGHQ YRUDXVOLHJHQGHQ .DSLWHOQLQVWUXPHQWHOOHVXQGPRUDOLVFKHV+DQGHOQVRZLH=XVDPPHQKDQJ XQG'LIIHUHQ]HQWVSUHFKHQGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHWKHPDWLVLHUWZXUGHQ:LH NDQQDOVR%UDQGRPVÄ%HJULIIVKROLVPXV¶HLQHGHWUDQV]HQGHQWDOLVLHUWH)RUW IKUXQJ GHU .DQWLVFKHQ ]ZLVFKHQ GHP PXQGXV LQWHOOLJLELOLV XQG GHP PXQGXVVHQVLELOLVYHUPLWWHOQGHQ.RQ]HSWLRQSUDNWLVFKHU*UQGHEHLQKDO WHQ" *HKW HV QLFKW EHL .DQWV SUDNWLVFKHQ *UXQGVlW]HQ ]HQWUDO XP HLQH 0RUDOSKLORVRSKLHZlKUHQG%UDQGRPDXI0RUDOQLFKWZHVHQWOLFK]XVSUH FKHQNRPPWXQGVWDWWGHVVHQHLQHVSUDFKSUDJPDWLVFKRULHQWLHUWH3KLORVR SKLHGHV*HLVWHVYRUOHJW" 6LFKHUOLFK%UDQGRPLQWHUHVVLHUWVLFKDXIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNZHGHUGDIU ]XZHOFKHQ+DQGOXQJHQ3HUVRQHQYHUSIOLFKWHWZHUGHQN|QQHQQRFKGD IUZHOFKH0D[LPHQ3HUVRQHQDXVELOGHQRGHUJDUDXVELOGHQVROOWHQ$XFK LVWLQ%UDQGRPV7KHRULHNHLQ3ODW]IU5HIOH[LRQHQDXIP|JOLFKHPRUDOUH OHYDQWH0RWLYDWLRQHQ'LH2SSRVLWLRQYRQ3IOLFKWXQG1HLJXQJLVWVHLQHP $QVDW] Y|OOLJIUHPG 8PJHNHKUW ZLUG PDQ LQ .DQWV EDURFNHU *HVDPWDU FKLWHNWRQLN XQG D IRUWLRUL LQ .DQWV +DQGOXQJV XQG 0RUDOSKLORVRSKLH YHUJHEOLFK QDFK GHP 2UW HLQHU 6HPDQWLN VXFKHQ 6HOEVW GRUW ZR .DQW
_____________ %UDQGRP %UDQGRPD %UDQGRPVDOOJHPHLQH&KDUDNWHULVLHUXQJGLHVHV.RQ]HSWVODXWHW IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å,QIHUHQ]HQ EHLQKDOWHQ 3UlPLVVHQ XQG .RQNOXVLRQHQ 'LH LQIHUHQ WLHOOH 5ROOH HLQHU 3UlPLVVH KlQJW ZHVHQWOLFK YRQ GHU GHU .RQNOXVLRQ DE XQG XPJH NHKUWhEHUGLHLQIHUHQWLHOOH5ROOHHLQHV*HKDOWVZHLPDQJDUQLFKWVRKQHZHQLJVWHQV HWZDVEHUGLHDQGHUHU*HKDOWH]XZLVVHQGLHDXVLKPJHIROJHUWZHUGHQN|QQHQRGHU DXVGHQHQHUJHIROJHUWZHUGHQNDQQ´ (EG
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
IRUPHOKDIW XQG 1XDQFHQ HKHU YHUGHFNHQG YRQ Å6LQQ XQG %HGHXWXQJ´ VSULFKW LVW QLFKW GLH VSUDFKOLFKH 'LPHQVLRQ GLHVHU 3UREOHPDWLN JHPHLQW VRQGHUQ GLH REMHNWLYH 5HDOLWlW YRQ %HJULIIHQ XQG ]XPHLVW DXFK QXU GLH YRQ %HJULIIHQ D SULRUL (V HUEULJW VLFK EHLQDKH ]X HUZlKQHQ GD DOV .RQVHTXHQ] DXV .DQWV WUDQV]HQGHQWDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHP $SULRULVPXV IU LKQ QHEHQ GHU 6HPDQWLN DXFK GLH IU %UDQGRP DXHURUGHQWOLFK ZLFKWLJH SUDJPDWLVFKH 'LPHQVLRQ GHU 6SUDFKH NHLQH 5HOHYDQ] EHVLW]W XQG VFKRQ JDUQLFKWXPGHP%HJULIIGHV*HLVWHVE]ZGHU9HUQXQIWDXIGLH6SXU]X NRPPHQ 'HQQRFKOlWVLFK%UDQGRPV3RVLWLRQ²VRGLH+HXULVWLNGLHVHV.DSL WHOV ² EH]JOLFK GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlWVSUREOHPDWLN DOV HLQH )RUP YRQ SUDNWL VFKHP.RKlUHQWLVPXVDXIIDVVHQGLHGLH.DQWLVFKHQ,QWXLWLRQHQKLQVLFKW OLFK GHV HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOXVVHV GHU 9HUQXQIW DXI XQVHUH +DQGOXQJHQ DXIQLPPW XQG VLH VSUDFKSKLORVRSKLVFK WUDQVSDUHQW ]X GLIIHUHQ]LHUHQ HU ODXEW,P5DKPHQGHVYRUVWHKHQGVNL]]LHUWHQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVLVW%UDQGRP LQVRIHUQLQWHUHVVDQWDOVHUHLQHQRUPDWLYH7HUPLQRORJLHEHUHLWVWHOOWGLHJHHLJ QHW VFKHLQW VLFK GHP 3UREOHP SUlYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH ]X QlKHUQ %UDQGRPKDWPLWHLQHPVHKUVSH]LILVFKHQ9RNDEXODUGHUÄ3URGXNWLRQXQG .RQVXPWLRQYRQ*UQGHQ¶GLHÅQRUPDWLYH)HLQVWUXNWXUGHU5DWLRQDOLWlW´ XQWHUVXFKWXQG]ZDULQHLQHPVRXPIDVVHQGHQ6LQQHGDGDUXQWHUDXFK GLH)RUPHQSUDNWLVFKHU5DWLRQDOLWlWIDOOHQ :LH GLH )RUPXOLHUXQJ GHU Ä3URGXNWLRQ XQG .RQVXPWLRQ YRQ *UQ GHQ¶ EHUHLWV DQ]HLJW KDQGHOW HV VLFK EHL %UDQGRPV 3RVLWLRQ XP HLQH LP ZHLWHUHQ9HUVWlQGQLVGHV$XVGUXFNVUDWLRQDOLVWLVFKH3RVLWLRQ'LHVIHVW]XKDO WHQLVWLQVRIHUQZLFKWLJDOVVRQVWVHLQH6HOEVW]XVFKUHLEXQJGHVÅ([SUHVVL YLVPXV´ PLW %OLFN DXI GLH SUDNWLVFKH 9HUQXQIW QDWXUDOLVWLVFK PLYHUVWDQ GHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQWH %UDQGRP JUHQ]W VHLQH 3HUVSHNWLYH ]ZDU YRQ HLQHP PLWGHP1DPHQ-RKDQQ*RWWIULHG+HUGHUVYHUEXQGHQHQÅWUDGLWLRQHOOH>Q@ URPDQWLVFKH>Q@ ([SUHVVLYLVPXV´ DE GHU Å>«@ GLH 5HODWLRQ ]ZLVFKHQ HL QHPLQQHUHQ*HIKOXQGGHVVHQ$XVGUXFNGXUFKHLQHlXHUH*HVWHDOVVHLQ 3DUDGLJPDEHJULII´ 'RFK PX GDQHEHQQRFK HLQH VSH]LILVFKH )RUP GHV ([SUHVVLYLVPXV LQQHUKDOEGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHYRQ%UDQGRPV3RVLWLRQDEJHJUHQ]W ZHUGHQ'LHVHP([SUHVVLYLVPXV]XIROJHZLHLKQEHLVSLHOVZHLVH*LEEDUG
_____________
.DQW,99,,,.U9% % IYJODXFK.DQW,9 %UDQGRP %UDQGRP 9JO*LEEDUG I Å·7RFDOOVRPHWKLQJUDWLRQDOLVWRH[SUHVVRQH·VDFFHSWDQFHRI QRUPVWKDWSHUPLWLW·>«@$FFHSWDQFHLVDVWDWHRIPLQGDQGDJRRGZD\WRLGHQWLI\ WKLVVWDWHRIPLQGPLJKWEHWRH[KLELWLWVSODFHLQDURXJKSV\FKRORJLFDOWKHRU\7KH FDSDFLW\WRDFFHSWQRUPV,SRUWUD\DVDKXPDQELRORJLFDODGDSWDWLRQ DFFHSWLQJQRUPV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
RGHU %ODFNEXUQ YHUWUHWHQ VLQG :HUWXUWHLOH RGHU KDQGOXQJVEH]RJHQH 1RUPHQ$XVGUFNHYRQ*HIKOHQXQG(LQVWHOOXQJHQGLHDOVVROFKH3HUVR QHQGLUHNW]X+DQGOXQJHQEHZHJHQ5HGXNWLYLVWGLHVHU([SUHVVLYLVPXVLQ GHP6LQQHGD:HUWH1RUPHQXQGHQWVSUHFKHQGH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHLQ GHU 7HUPLQRORJLH PHQWDOHU =XVWlQGH EHVFKULHEHQ ZHUGHQ GLH GDV PHQVFKOLFKH LQWHQWLRQDOH 9HUKDOWHQ QXU JUDGXHOO YRP 9HUKDOWHQ QLFKW UDWLRQDOHU:HVHQXQWHUVFKHLGHQOlW9HUKDOWHQZHOFKHU$UWDXFKLPPHU ZLUG DOV NDXVDOH )ROJH YRQ QLFKWNRJQLWLYHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ YHUVWDQGHQ ZHVKDOEGLHVHU([SUHVVLYLVPXVDOVHLQH9HUVLRQGHVPHWDSK\VLVFKHQRGHU GHV SV\FKRORJLVFKHQ 1DWXUDOLVPXV DQJHVHKHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ 9RQ HLQHP VROFKHQ([SUHVVLYLVPXVXQWHUVFKHLGHWVLFK%UDQGRPGDGXUFKGDJHPl VHLQHP ÅUDWLRQDOLVWLVFKH>Q@ ([SUHVVLYLVPXV >«@ GDV $XVGUFNHQ YRQ HWZDV GDUDXI KLQDXV>OlXIW@ HV ]X YHUEHJULIIOLFKHQ´ ,Q JHZLVVHU :HLVH LVW GLHVH 3RVLWLRQQLFKWQXUGHPHEHQVNL]]LHUWHQ([SUHVVLYLVPXVHQWJHJHQJHVHW]W VRQGHUQHLQHPUHGXNWLYHQ1DWXUDOLVPXVLQVJHVDPWZHQQGLHVHUIUJHQX LQ QRUPDWLYH hEHUOHJXQJHQ ZLH VLH VLFK LQ *UQGHQ ZHOFKHU $UW DXFK LPPHUDUWLNXOLHUHQNHLQHQJDUDQWLHUWHQ3ODW]DXIZHLVW%UDQGRPV([SUHV VLYLVPXVEH]LHKWVLFKVRZRKODXIGLH(EHQHGHU$OOWDJVVSUDFKHGLHHWZDV ÅLQ HLQHP EHKDXSWEDUHQ EHXUWHLOEDUHQ GHQNEDUHQ JODXEEDUHQ G K SURSRVLWLRQDOHQ *HKDOW H[SOL]LW´ PDFKW DOV DXFK DXI GLH )XQNWLRQ ORJL VFKHQ9RNDEXODUVÅ>«@HEHQMHQHLQIHUHQWLHOOHQ5HODWLRQHQLQEHKDXSWED UHU SDUDGLJPDWLVFKHUZHLVH NRQGLWLRQDOHU )RUP H[SOL]LW ]X PDFKHQ GLH GLH*HKDOWHJHZ|KQOLFKHUQLFKWORJLVFKHU%HJULIIHLPSOL]LWJOLHGHUQZHOFKH
_____________ ILJXUHVLQDSHFXOLDUO\KXPDQV\VWHPRIPRWLYDWLRQDQGFRQWUROWKDWGHSHQGVRQODQ JXDJH1RUPVPDNHIRUKXPDQZD\VRIOLYLQJDQGZHFDQXQGHUVWDQGRXUQRUPDWLYH OLIHDVSDUWRIWKHQDWXUDOZRUOG1RUPDWLYHWDONLVSDUWRIQDWXUHEXWLWGRHVQRWGH VFULEHQDWXUH,QSDUWLFXODUDSHUVRQZKRFDOOVVRPHWKLQJUDWLRQDORULUUDWLRQDOLVQRW GHVFULELQJ KLV RZQ VWDWH RI PLQG KH LV H[SUHVVLQJ LW´ 9JO NULWLVFK GD]X 6NRUXSVNL VRZLHHEHQIDOOVNULWLVFK]XP([SUHVVLYLVPXVXQGGHVVHQ9HUKlOWQLV]XU0RUDO HSLVWHPRORJLH6LQQRWW$UPVWURQJ 9JO %ODFNEXUQ I Å>«@ WKH VWDWH RI PLQG RI RQH ZKR YDOXHV VRPHWKLQJ LV GLVWLQFWLYHEXWQHYHUWKHOHVVLWLVLWVHOIDQDWXUDODQGQDWXUDOO\GHVFULEDEOHVWDWH2QFH ZHILQGHWKLFVKHUHZHXQGHUVWDQGWKHHVVHQWLDOSKHQRPHQRQZKLFKLVWKDWRISHRSOH YDOXLQJWKLQJV:KHQWKH\YDOXHWKLQJVWKH\H[SUHVVWKHPVHOYHVLQ WHUPVRIZKDWLV JRRGEDGREOLJDWRU\ULJKWMXVWLILDEOHDQGVRRQ>«@6RWKHH[SUHVVLYLVWWKLQNVZH FDQVD\LQWHUHVWLQJO\ZKDWLVLQYROYHGIRUDVXEMHFW6WRWKLQNWKDW;LVJRRG,WLVIRU6 WRYDOXHLWDQGWKLVFDQEHH[SODLQHGLQQDWXUDOWHUPV1DWXUHLWVHOIPD\EHKHDUWOHVV DQGIUHHRIGHVLUHVEXWDPRQJVWWKHFUHDWXUHVLWKDVWKURZQXSDUH VRPHZKLFKDUH QRW KHDUWOHVV DQG QRW IUHH RI GHVLUHV :H XQGHUVWDQG RXU YDOXHV E\ XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RXUVHOYHVDVYDOXLQJDQGWKLVZHFDQGR,I\RXJRRQWRDVNWKLVVWUDWHJLVWZKDWLWLV IRUVRPHWKLQJWREHJRRGWKHUHVSRQVHLVWKDWWKLVLVQRWWKHVXEMHFWRIWKLVWKHRUHWLFDO FRQFHUQ>«@7RDQVZHULWWKHQZRXOGEHWRJRLQVLGHWKHGRPDLQRIHWKLFVDQGVWDUW H[SUHVVLQJRXUVWDQGDUGV´ %UDQGRP +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
ZLUYHUZHQGHQZHQQZLU'LQJHLQGHPDXIGHUHUVWHQ6WXIHDQJHJHEHQHQ 6LQQH[SOL]LWPDFKHQ´ :lKUHQG.DQWZLHVLFKLQ.DSJH]HLJWKDWXQWHU,QDQVSUXFKQDKPH HLQHU GHU WUDGLWLRQHOOHQ 9HUP|JHQVSV\FKRORJLH JHVFKXOGHWHQ 'LIIHUHQ]LH UXQJYRQ6HHOHQYHUP|JHQHLQHUVHLWVXQGHLQHUSODWRQLVLHUHQGHQ'LIIHUHQ ]LHUXQJ]ZLVFKHQHLQHPPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLVXQGHLQHPPXQGXVVHQVLELOLV DQGHUHUVHLWVDUJXPHQWLHUWGDGLHP|JOLFKHQ)RUPHQSUDNWLVFKHU1RUPD WLYLWlWDXVGHU.RQIURQWDWLRQYRQ9HUQXQIWXQG1HLJXQJE]Z$XWRQRPLH XQG +HWHURQRPLH UHVXOWLHUHQ JHKW %UDQGRP GDYRQ DXV GD GHU %HJULII GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW QXU PLWWHOV GHVVHQ OLQJXLVWLVFKVR]LDOHU 2SHUDWLRQDOLVLH UXQJ EHVWLPPW ZHUGHQ NDQQ =LHO YRQ %UDQGRPV 3KLORVRSKLH LVW MHGRFK ZHGHUHLQHIXQNWLRQHOOHQRFKHLQH3UDJPDOLQJXLVWLN YLHOPHKUJHKWHVLKP OHW]WOLFK XP HLQH 7KHRULH GHV *HLVWHV XP GHQ 0HQVFKHQ DOV HLQHV YHU QQIWLJHQ :HVHQV GHVVHQ+DQGHOQ XQG 6SUHFKHQ ÅGXUFK XQG GXUFK ELV DXIGHQ*UXQG´QRUPDWLYYHUIDWLVW%UDQGRPVXFKWGLHÄ6R]LDOLVLHUXQJ¶ .DQWVGDEHLLQIROJHQGHU5LFKWXQJ Å.DQW·VRULJLQDOVXJJHVWLRQWKDWIUHH GRP FRQVLVWV LQ FRQVWUDLQW E\ QRUPV UDWKHU WKDQ VLPSO\ E\ FDXVHV WKH GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQEHLQJIUHHDQGQRWEHLQJIUHHEHFRPHVDVRFLDOUDWKHU WKDQDQREMHFWLYHGLIIHUHQFH7KHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHVHWZRÄUHDOPV¶LV QRWDQRQWRORJLFDORQH7KHUHDOGLVWLQFWLRQLQWKHYLFLQLW\LVEHWZHHQWZR ZD\VRIWUHDWLQJVRPHRQH·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´
_____________ %UDQGRP YJO]X%UDQGRPV([SUHVVLYLVPXVLQ9HUELQGXQJPLW.DQWDXFK 3ROORN0V 9JO%UDQGRPD %UDQGRP %UDQGRP PHUNW ]X GLHVHP )UHLKHLWVEHJULII QRFK NOlUHQG DQ Å7KRXJKRIFRXUVHRQWKLVDFFRXQWWKDWIUHHGRPLVQRWPHUHO\VXEMHFWLYHDQGLPDJL QDU\HLWKHU,WLVUDWKHUDVRFLDOPDWWHUDQGWKHFULWHULDOFODVVLILFDWLRQGLVWLQJXLVKHVWKH VRFLDOIURPERWKWKHVXEMHFWLYH ZKLFKLVZKDWHYHUVRPHLQGLYLGXDOWDNHVLWWREH DQG WKHREMHFWLYH ZKLFKLVZKDWLWLVUHJDUGOHVVRIKRZDQ\RQHWDNHVLWWREH ´ (EG
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
%UDQGRPV.DQWLDQLVPXV
'D LP =HQWUXP PHLQHU QDFKIROJHQGHQ hEHUOHJXQJHQ QLFKW %UDQGRPV GLUHNWH $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW .DQWV 7KHRULH GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW VWHKHQ ZLUGVHLKLHUOHGLJOLFKHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGHNXU]H6NL]]HGLHVHV9HUKlOWQLV VHVYHUVXFKWLQVRZHLWOHW]WHUHVIUHLQHQRUPDWLYSUDJPDWLVFKH([SOLNDWL RQGHVHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ(LQIOXVVHVGHU9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJUHOH YDQWLVW%UDQGRPPDFKWQLFKWGLHVSH]LILVFKH$IILQLWlWVHLQHU7KHRULH]XU .DQWLVFKHQ0RUDOSKLORVRSKLHQDPKDIW9LHOPHKUEHWUDFKWHWHU.DQWVSUDN WLVFKH XQG WKHRUHWLVFKH 3KLORVRSKLH XQWHU GHP HLQKHLWOLFKHQ $VSHNW GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW XQG JLEW GDPLW ]XJOHLFK GLH %DVLVOLQLH VHLQHU HLJHQHQ $UJX PHQWDWLRQDQ Å(LQHGHUJURDUWLJHQ(LQVLFKWHQGLHZLU.DQWYHUGDQNHQ EHVDJWGD8UWHLOHXQG+DQGOXQJHQDXIJUXQGGHU7DWVDFKHYRQGHQ5HDN WLRQHQEORQDWUOLFKHU:HVHQ]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQVLQGGDVLHDOV'LQJH IUGLHZLULQHLQHPEHVWLPPWHQ6LQQHYHUDQWZRUWOLFKVLQGHLQHQEHVRQ GHUHQ QRUPDWLYHQ 6WDWXV EHVLW]HQ .DQW YHUVWDQG %HJULIIH DOV 1RUPHQ GLH HEHQEHVWLPPHQIUZDVZLUXQVGXUFKHLQ]HOQH$NWHGHV8UWHLOHQVXQG +DQGHOQVYHUDQWZRUWOLFKJHPDFKWKDEHQZRUDXIZLUXQVGDGXUFKIHVWJH OHJW KDEHQ XQG ZDV XQV GD]X EHUHFKWLJHQ ZUGH´ (LQH VROFKH 5HNRQ VWUXNWLRQ .DQWV VFKHLQW QLFKW XQYHUWUlJOLFK PLW .DQWV 7KHRULH ]X VHLQ GRFKPWHVLHGLHIU.DQWZHVHQWOLFKH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ]ZLVFKHQWKHR UHWLVFKHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ XQG VFKOLHOLFK lVWKHWLVFKHQ 6WDQGDUGV XQG GDPLW XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ )RUPHQ YRQ 1RUPDWLYLWlW EHUFNVLFKWLJHQ 'LH .ULWH ULHQ REMHNWLY JOWLJHU (UNHQQWQLVXUWHLOH XQWHUVFKHLGHQ VLFK IU .DQW ZH VHQWOLFK YRQ GHQ .ULWHULHQ REMHNWLY JOWLJHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQGVlW]H RGHU DXFK VXEMHNWLYDOOJHPHLQHU *HVFKPDFNVXUWHLOH GHU IXQGDPHQWDOH 6WDWXV GHV %HJULIIV GHV 8UWHLOV OHJW VRJDU QDKH GLH YHUVFKLHGHQHQ %HUHLFKH GHU 3KLORVRSKLHHQWODQJGHUXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQQRUPDWLYHQ6WDQGDUGVHQWVSUH FKHQGHU 8UWHLOH GLHVHU 'LV]LSOLQHQ ]X GLIIHUHQ]LHUHQ ,Q GLHVHP 6LQQH LVW .DQWV 9HUQXQIWSKLORVRSKLH ZHLW HQWIHUQW YRQ HLQHP +ROLVPXV .DQW PDFKWPLWVHLQHQEHLGHQHUVWHQ.ULWLNHQYLHOPHKUXQPLYHUVWlQGOLFKNODU GDLKPGLH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQÅVSHNXODWLYHU9HUQXQIW´XQGÅSUDNWL VFKHU 9HUQXQIW´ VDNURVDQNW LVW $QGHUHUVHLWVIRUGHUW .DQW ZLH EHUHLWV LQ .DSGLVNXWLHUWHLQHQHLQKHLWOLFKHQ%HJULIIYRQ9HUQXQIW Å'LH*HVHW] JHEXQJ GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ 9HUQXQIW 3KLORVRSKLH KDW QXQ ]ZHL *HJHQV WlQGH 1DWXU XQG )UHLKHLW XQG HQWKlOW DOVR VRZRKO GDV 1DWXUJHVHW] DOV DXFKGDV6LWWHQJHVHW]DQIDQJVLQ]ZHLEHVRQGHUHQ]XOHW]WDEHULQHLQHP HLQ]LJHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ6\VWHP´6ROOYRQ9HUQXQIWLP3OXUDOGLH5HGH
_____________ %UDQGRPI .U9$
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%UDQGRPV.DQWLDQLVPXV
VHLQVRPXJHNOlUWZHUGHQLQZLHIHUQGLHVHXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQÄ/HJLVODWL YHQ¶HLQXQGGHQVHOEHQ1DPHQYHUGLHQHQ.DQWVSULFKWMHGRFKHKHUSUR JUDPPDWLVFKSURVSHNWLYYRQGHU(LQKHLWGHU9HUQXQIW Å$OOHLQZHQQUHLQH 9HUQXQIWIUVLFKSUDNWLVFKVHLQNDQQXQGHVZLUNOLFKLVWZLHGDV%HZXW VHLQGHVPRUDOLVFKHQ*HVHW]HVHVDXVZHLVHWVRLVWHVGRFKLPPHUQXUHLQH XQG GLHVHOEH 9HUQXQIW GLH HV VHL LQ WKHRUHWLVFKHU RGHU SUDNWLVFKHU $E VLFKWQDFK3ULQFLSLHQDSULRULXUWKHLOW>«@´'LHVHQ(LQKHLWVEHJULIIGDV ÅJHPHLQVFKDIWOLFKH 3ULQ]LS´ WKHRUHWLVFKHU XQG SUDNWLVFKHU 9HUQXQIWNULWLN KDW.DQW VHKU]XP%HGDXHUQEHUHLWVPDQFKHV=HLWJHQRVVHQEHLVSLHOVZHL VH&DUO/HRQKDUG5HLQKROGV QLUJHQGZRDQJHJHEHQ :HQQ %UDQGRP QXQ PLW HLQHU LQWHUSUHWDWRULVFKHQ )UHL]JLJNHLW GLH LP EULJHQ JDQ] JHJHQ VHLQ VRQVWLJHV V\VWHPDWLVFKHV %HVWUHEHQ HKHU ]X $VVLPLOLHUXQJ DOV ]X 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ QHLJW VFKUHLEW Å9HUQQIWLJ VHLQ ZLUGKLHU>VFEHL.DQW@DOOJHPHLQYHUVWDQGHQDOVIlKLJVHLQDP6SLHOGHV *HEHQVXQG9HUODQJHQVYRQ*UQGHQWHLO]XQHKPHQDOVRDQHLQHUVSH]L ILVFK VSUDFKOLFKHQ VR]LDOHQ 3UD[LV´ GDQQ LVW GDV %UDQGRP ² QLFKW .DQW 8QG GLHV QLFKW QXU ZHLO HV HUVWHQV GHQ PHWDSK\VLVFKHQ +LQWHUJUXQG HSLVWHPLVFKHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW GHQ .DQW IDUEHQUHLFK DXVJHVWDOWHW LJQRULHUW XQG ]ZHLWHQV LQ .DQWV .RQ]HSWLRQ GLH %HJULIIH GHU hEHU]HXJXQJV XQG GHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH NHLQHUOHL WKHRUHWLVFK WUDJHQGH )XQNWLRQ EHVLW]HQ VRQGHUQDXFKZHLO%UDQGRPVLFKKLHUDXIVSUDFKOLFKH3UD[HQEH]LHKWYRQ GHQHQ EHL .DQW LQ WUDQV]HQGHQWDOHP .RQWH[W NHLQH 5HGH LVW XQG VHLQ NDQQ.DQWXQWHUVFKHLGHW]ZDU6lW]HYRQ8UWHLOHQGRFKLQWHUHVVDQWHUZHLVH JHUDGH QLFKW KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHV 6SUDFKEH]XJV (U VLHKW6SUDFKH OHGLJOLFK
_____________ .DQW 9 EHUHLWV LQ GHU 9RUUHGH ]XU *UXQGOHJXQJ DOV VLFK DOVR GLH 1RWZHQGLJNHLW HLQHU]ZHLWHQ.ULWLNDE]HLFKQHWVFKUHLEW.DQW Å>«@LFK>VFHUIRUGHUH@]XU.ULWLNHLQHU UHLQHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW GD ZHQQ VLH YROOHQGHW VHLQ VROO LKUH (LQKHLW PLW GHU VSHFXODWLYHQ LQ HLQHP JHPHLQVFKDIWOLFKHQ 3ULQFLS ]XJOHLFK PVVH GDUJHVWHOOW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQZHLOHVGRFKDP(QGHQXUHLQHXQGGLHVHOEH9HUQXQIWVHLQNDQQGLHEORLQ GHU$QZHQGXQJXQWHUVFKLHGHQVHLQPX´ .DQW,9 'D.DQWVLFKVHOEVWQDFK VHLQHUGULWWHQ.ULWLNQRFKQLFKWLP6WDQGHVLHKWGLHVHVJHPHLQVFKDIWOLFKH3ULQ]LSDQ ]XJHEHQKDWLKPZLHHU EULHIOLFKJHJHQEHU*DUYHlXHUWHLQHQÅ7DQWDOLVFKH>Q@ 6FKPHUW]´ .DQW;,, EHUHLWHW Å'DV)XQGDPHQWGHU.ULWLNGHUU9LVW>@QLFKWDOOJHPHLQJHQXJ GHQQGLH.ULWLNGHU WKHRUHWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWEHJUQGHWQXU0HWDSK\VLNXQG]ZDUQXUGHUVLQQOLFKHQ1DWXUXQG GLH.ULWLNGHUSUDNWLVFKHQQXU0HWDSK\VLNGHU6LWWHQ´ 5HLQKROG 9JOXQWHQ)QVRZLHGHQGD]XJHK|ULJHQ$EVDW] %UDQGRPD Å$XI GHP 8QWHUVFKLHGH ]ZLVFKHQ SUREOHPDWLVFKHP XQG DVVHUWRULVFKHP 8UWKHLOHQ EHUXKWGHUZDKUH8QWHUVFKLHG]ZLVFKHQ8UWKHLOHQXQG6lW]HQGHQPDQVRQVWIlOVFK OLFK LQ GHQ EORHQ $XVGUXFN GXUFK :RUWH RKQH GLH PDQ MD EHUDOO QLFKW XUWKHLOHQ N|QQWH]XVHW]HQSIOHJW,P8UWKHLOHZLUGGDV9HUKlOWQLYHUVFKLHGHQHU9RUVWHOOXQJHQ ]XU(LQKHLWGHV%HZXWVHLQVEORDOVSUREOHPDWLVFKJHGDFKWLQHLQHP6DW]HKLQJHJHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
DOV HLQH P|JOLFKH )ROJH GHV 'HQNHQV DQ ZLH GLH 1DFKVFKULIWHQ VHLQHU 9RUOHVXQJHQ]XU0HWDSK\VLN 3|OLW] ]HLJHQZRQDFKHUHLQH$QDO\VHGHU.D WHJRULHQ DOV ÅWUDQVVFHQGHQWDOH *UDPPDWLN´ EH]HLFKQHW ÅGLH GHQ *UXQG GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ 6SUDFKH HQWKlOW ] % ZLH GDV SUDHVHQV SHUIHFWXP SOXV TXDPSHUIHFWXPLQXQVHUP9HUVWDQGHOLHJWZDVDGYHUELDVLQGXVZµ 'RFK PDQ VROOWH DXFK ]XU .HQQWQLV QHKPHQ GD .DQW GLH 9HUELQGXQJ ]ZL VFKHQ 7UDQV]HQGHQWDOSKLORVRSKLH XQG $OOWDJVVSUDFKH ZRKO EHZXW PDQ N|QQWH VRJDU VDJHQ VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK ZDU ZLH DXV GHQ 0HWDSK\VLN 9RUOHVXQJHQ 0URQJRYLXV GHXWOLFK ZLUG Å8QVUH JHPHLQH 6SUDFKH HQWKlOW VFKRQ DOOHV GDV ZDV GLH WUDQV]HQGHQWDOH 3KLORVRSKLH PLW 0KH KHUDXV ]LHKW'LHVH.DWHJRULHQVLQGVFKRQDOOHEHLXQVHQWKDOWHQGHQQRKQHVLH ZlUHNHLQH(UIDKUXQJP|JOLFK]% (VLVW6FKQHHJHIDOOHQ+LHULQOLHJW GD 6FKQHH LVW 6XEVWDQ] JHIDOOHQ EHGHXWHW HLQ $N]LGHQV DXI GLH (UGH EHGHXWHWHLQHQ(LQIOXGDVLVWDFWLRJHK|UWDOVR]XUFDXVD+HXWHEH]LHKW VLFKDXIGLH=HLWJHIDOOHQDXIGHQ5DXP´'RFKGLHVEHGHXWHWQXUGD XQVHUH $OOWDJVSUDFKH LP 6WDQGH LVW (UIDKUXQJVXUWHLOH ]X DUWLNXOLHUHQ (V EHGHXWHWQLFKWXQGNDQQQLFKWEHGHXWHQGDDXVLKUHPUHDOHQ*HEUDXFK HLQHWUDQV]HQGHQWDOH/RJLNDEVWUDKLHUWZHUGHQN|QQWHXQGVHOEVWKLQVLFKW OLFKHLQHV%HOHJVIUGLHREMHNWLYH5HDOLWlWGHUYRQLKPWKHPDWLVLHUWHQ%HJULI IH D SULRUL VWDQGHQ .DQW PLW 6LFKHUKHLW (XNOLGLVFKH 0DWKHPDWLN XQG 1HZWRQLVFKH 1DWXUZLVVHQVFKDIWQlKHUDOVGLH$OOWDJVVSUDFKH
_____________ DOVDVVHUWRULVFK´ .DQW,; 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKVLQG%UDQGRPWURW]VHLQHUYHUHLQ QDKPHQGHQ %HUXIXQJ DXI .DQW GLHVEH]JOLFK DXFK HLJHQWPOLFKH 'LIIHUHQ]HQ EH ZXW Å(U >VF .DQW@ YHUWULHE MHGRFK YLHOH VFKZLHULJH )UDJHQ EH]JOLFK GHV :HVHQV XQGGHV8UVSUXQJVGLHVHU1RUPDWLYLWlWEH]JOLFKGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLWYRQ%HJULIIHQ DXV GHP YHUWUDXWHQ SKlQRPHQDOHQ 5HLFK GHU (UIDKUXQJ XP VLH LP 5HLFK GHU 1RX PHQD DQ]XVLHGHOQ´ %UDQGRP I 8QWHU GHP 1DPHQ Å5HLFK GHU =ZHFNH´ EHVWLPPW .DQW LQ GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLH EHNDQQWOLFK 1RXPHQD SRVLWLY QLFKW ZLHLQGHUWKHRUHWLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHQXUQHJDWLYDOV*UHQ]EHJULIIH'LH6SUDFKIHUQH YRQ.DQWVWUDQV]HQGHQWDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHP$QVDW]VWHOOWVHLW(UVFKHLQHQGHUHUVWHQ.UL WLNHLQHQZHVHQWOLFKHQ$QJULIIVSXQNWGDUGHU]XHUVWYRQ-RKDQQ*HRUJ+DPDQQIRU PXOLHUW ZXUGH Å>@ VR EUDXFKW HV NHLQHU 'HGXFWLRQ GLH JHQHDORJLVFKH 3ULRULWlW GHU 6SUDFKHYRUGHQVLHEHQKHLOLJHQ)XQFWLRQHQORJLVFKHU6lW]HX6FKOHXQGLKUH+HUDOGLN ]XEHZHLVHQ1LFKWQXUGDVJDQ]H9HUP|JHQ]XGHQNHQEHUXKWDXIGHU6SUDFKH>@ VRQGHUQ6SUDFKHLVWDXFKGHU0LWWHOSXQFWGHV0LVYHUVWDQGHVGHU9HUQXQIWPLWLKUVHOEVW>@ /DXWHXQG%XFKVWDEHQVLQGDOVRUHLQH)RUPHQDSULRULLQGHQHQ1LFKWVZDV]XU(PS ILQGXQJRGHU]XP%HJULIIHLQHV*HJHQVWDQGHVJHK|UWDQJHWURIIHQZLUGXQGGLHZDK UHQ lVWKHWLVFKHQ (OHPHQWH DOOHU PHQVFKO (UNHQQWQLV X 9HUQXQIW´ +DPDQQ 0LW GLHVHU VSH]LILVFKHQ .ULWLN DQ .DQW VWLPPW %UDQGRP MHGRFK QLFKW EHUHLQ GHQQ LP *HJHQVDW] ]X HLQHP VROFKHQ OLQJXLVWLVFKHQ $WRPLVPXV JHKW %UDQGRP YRQ HLQHPVHPDQWLVFKHQ+ROLVPXVDXVGHVVHQ9RUUDQJDXIÅJDQ]HQGHNODUDWLYHQ6lW]HQ´ JHJHQEHUÅVXEVHQWHQWLDOHQ$XVGUFNHQ´ %UDQGRP OLHJW .DQW;;9,,, YJODXFK.DQW,9I .DQW;;,;
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%UDQGRPV.DQWLDQLVPXV
0DQN|QQWHQXQYHUVXFKHQ ZDV%UDQGRPMHGRFKQLFKWXQWHUQLPPW GLH1RUPDWLYLWlWPHQVFKOLFKHU5DWLRQDOLWlWIROJHQGHUPDHQDOVIXQGDPHQ WDOH 9HUELQGXQJ WKHRUHWLVFKHU XQG SUDNWLVFKHU 9HUQXQIW LP 6LQQH .DQWV ]X LQWHUSROLHUHQ .DQWV WUDQV]HQGHQWDOH /RJLN QLFKW PLYHUVWDQGHQ DOV 3V\FKRORJLH NRQVWDWLHUWQLFKWZLHGHU0HQVFK%HJULIIHELOGHWXUWHLOWXQG VFKOLHW %HUHLWV YRQ GHU /RJLN LP $OOJHPHLQHQ KHLW HV YLHOPHKU LQ GHU VRJHQDQQWHQ -lVFKH/RJLN Å'LH /RJLN LVW >«@ HLQH :LVVHQVFKDIW D SULRUL YRQ GHQ QRWKZHQGLJHQ *HVHW]HQ GHV 'HQNHQV DEHU QLFKW LQ $QVHKXQJ EHVRQGHUHU *HJHQVWlQGH VRQGHUQ DOOHU *HJHQVWlQGH EHUKDXSW ² DOVR HLQH :LVVHQVFKDIW GHV ULFKWLJHQ 9HUVWDQGHV XQG 9HUQXQIWJHEUDXFKV EHUKDXSWDEHUQLFKWVXEMHFWLYGKQLFKWQDFKHPSLULVFKHQ SV\FKRORJL VFKHQ 3ULQFLSLHQ ZLH GHU 9HUVWDQG GHQNW VRQGHUQ REMHFWLY G L QDFK 3ULQFLSLHQ D SULRUL ZLH HU GHQNHQ VROO´ 8QG VFKOLHOLFK JHKW HV LQ GHU ÅWUDQVVFHQGHQWDOHQ/RJLN´XP ÅGHQ 8UVSUXQJ GHQ 8PIDQJ XQGGLH RE MHFWLYH *OWLJNHLW´ HLQHV ÅUHLQHQ 9HUVWDQGHV XQG 9HUQXQIWHUNHQQWQLVVHV GDGXUFK ZLU *HJHQVWlQGH Y|OOLJ D SULRUL GHQNHQ´ :DQQ XQG ZLH DXFK LPPHU DOVR (UIDKUXQJ LP .DQWLVFKHQ 6LQQH YRQ %HJULIIHQ 8UWHLOHQ XQG 6FKOVVHQVWDWWILQGHWVLHPXGHUWUDQV]HQGHQWDOHQ/RJLNJHKRUFKHQGK TXDQWLWDWLYHVTXDOLWDWLYHVUHODWLRQDOHVXQGPRGDOHV%HJUHLIHQYRQJHJHQ VWlQGOLFKHQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQLVWGXUFK1RUPHQGHU9HUQXQIWEHVWLPPW 'HU0HQVFKLVWQXQQDFK.DQWQLFKWSHUVHYHUQQIWLJ².DQWVSULFKW YRP0HQVFKHQDOVHLQHVÅDQLPDOUDWLRQDELOH´GDVDXVVLFKHUVWHLQÅDQLPDO UDWLRQDOH´PDFKHQVROO'DGHU0HQVFKYHUQQIWLJVHLQVROOGDHUVLFK LQ%UDQGRPV7HUPLQRORJLHDXIGDV6SLHOGHV*HEHQVXQG)RUGHUQVYRQ *UQGHQHLQODVVHQVROOYHUZHLVWDXIHLQHZHVHQWOLFKSUDNWLVFKH'LPHQVLRQ LQGHU%HVWLPPXQJGHV0HQVFKHQGLHVLFKQXUHLQHU$QDO\VHYRQ.DQWV SUDNWLVFKHU3KLORVRSKLHHUVFKOLHW,QGHUYHUQQIWLJHQ(UNHQQWQLV]XGHU DXIJHIRUGHUWZLUGOLHJWDOVREHUHLWVHLQSUDNWLVFKHV0RPHQW 'DVEHGHXWHWQHEHQEHLDEHUDXFKGD.DQWVELVZHLOHQKHIWLJHU$IIHNW JHJHQEHU HLQHP 6NHSWL]LVPXV GHU MHJOLFKH :LVVHQVFKDIW IU XQP|JOLFK KlOWXQGVLFKPLWGHPÅ6FKHLQGHUhEHU]HXJXQJ´]XIULHGHQJLEWÅZHOFKHU DXIVXEMHFWLYHQ8UVDFKHQGHU$VVRFLDWLRQEHUXKW´LQGHPHUÅVXEMHFWLYH 1RWKZHQGLJNHLWGL*HZRKQKHLWIUHLQHREMHFWLYHDXV(LQVLFKWXQWHU VFKLHEW´QLFKWDOOHLQWKHRUHWLVFK]XHUNOlUHQLVW,Q(QWZUIHQ]XU$QWK URSRORJLH9RUOHVXQJKHLW HV GDKHU ODSLGDU Å'HU FXOWLYLUWH 0HQVFKVROWH GLH
_____________
.DQW,; +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 .DQW.U9$ 9JO.DQW9,, .DQW.U9$ .DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
=ZHFNH GHU 0HQVFKKHLW GXUFK 9HUQXQIW HUUHLFKHQ´ 'DV ,GHDO HLQHU 5HDOLVLHUXQJGHU9HUQXQIWLVWHLQH3IOLFKWGHU0HQVFKKHLWJHJHQEHUVLFK VHOEVW G K JHJHQEHU GHU 9HUQXQIW 1DWUOLFK LVW QLFKW MHGHU 0HQVFK GD]XLQGHU/DJHGHQÅVLFKHUHQ*DQJHLQHU:LVVHQVFKDIW´]XEHI|UGHUQ GRFK LVW HV QDFK .DQW DXFK IU HLQ ,QGLYLGXXP Å>«@ LQ $QVHKXQJ GHU ]XIlOOLJHQ YHUGLHQVWOLFKHQ 3IOLFKWJHJHQVLFKVHOEVW>@QLFKWJHQXJGD GLH+DQGOXQJQLFKWGHU0HQVFKKHLWLQXQVHUHU3HUVRQDOV=ZHFNDQVLFK VHOEVW ZLGHUVWUHLWH >VF ZLH EHLP 6HOEVWPRUG .3@ VLH PX DXFK GD]X ]XVDPPHQVWLPPHQ 1XQ VLQG LQ GHU 0HQVFKKHLW $QODJHQ ]X JU|HUHU 9ROONRPPHQKHLWGLH]XP=ZHFNHGHU1DWXULQ$QVHKXQJGHU0HQVFKKHLW LQ XQVHUHP 6XEMHFW JHK|UHQ GLHVH ]X YHUQDFKOlVVLJHQ ZUGH DOOHQIDOOV ZRKO PLW GHU (UKDOWXQJ GHU 0HQVFKKHLW DOV =ZHFNV DQ VLFK VHOEVW DEHU QLFKWGHU%HI|UGHUXQJGLHVHV=ZHFNVEHVWHKHQN|QQHQ´ 'LHVHQ=ZHFN]XEHI|UGHUQGLH3IOLFKW]XULQGLYLGXHOOHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJ GHU 9HUQXQIW PDFKW IU .DQW QHEHQ Ä=LYLOLVLHUXQJ¶ XQG Ä0RUDOLVLHUXQJ¶ HLQH ZHLWHUH 'LPHQVLRQ GHU 'LJQLWlW LQGLYLGXHOOYHUQQIWLJHU 6HOEVWYHU ZLUNOLFKXQJDXV 0LWGLHVHU$XIIRUGHUXQJ]XULQGLYLGXHOOHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJ GHU 9HUQXQIW ² QLFKW QXU LQ GHU REHQ GLVNXWLHUWHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ .DS VRQGHUQDXFKLQWKHRUHWLVFKHU+LQVLFKW²OlWVLFK.DQWV3KLORVRSKLHLQV JHVDPWDOVRXPIDVVHQGHUDOVGHUHQRKQHKLQJHQXLQQRUPDWLYHWKHRUHWLVFK XQG SUDNWLVFKUDWLRQDOH 7HLOH DOV HLQH *HVFKLFKWH FKDUDNWHULVLHUHQ ÅLQ GHUHVGXUFKXQGGXUFKELVDXIGHQ*UXQGXP1RUPHQJHKW´ZLH%UDQ GRP VHLQH HLJHQH 7KHRULH EHVFKUHLEW XQG OHW]WHUH GDPLW ZHQLJ EHUUD VFKHQGDXFKDOVÅHLQHNDQWLVFKH*HVFKLFKWH´EH]HLFKQHW²'LHLQ.DS DXVJHPDFKWH0HKUGHXWLJNHLWKLQVLFKWOLFK.DQWVSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWEHJ
_____________ .DQW;9 GLH(QWZUIHVWDPPHQDXVGHQHU-DKUHQ .DQW.U9%YLL[[[YLL .DQW,9 YJODXFK9,,I 9JO.DQW,9 GHQ%H]XJ]ZLVFKHQGHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJGHU9HUQXQIW XQGGHP:HUWGHV,QGLYLGXXPVILQGHWPDQHEHQIDOOVLQGHQ(QWZUIHQ]XU$QWKURSR ORJLH9RUOHVXQJDXVGHQHU-DKUHQ Å'HU0HQVFKÅ>«@NDQVHLQ7DOHQWFXOWLYLUHQ>«@ GHQ 0DQJHO GHVVHOEHQ GXUFK )OHLV XQG HUZRUEHQH *HVFKLNOLFKNHLW HUVHW]HQ >«@ XQG LVW8UKHEHUYRQVHLQHPHLJHQHQ:HUWK´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|JOLFKHQ (UNHQQWQLVEHUHLFKGLHVEH]JOLFKHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQHU|IIQHW %UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%UDQGRPV.DQWLDQLVPXV
ULIIVEOHLEWYRQGLHVHQhEHUOHJXQJHQXQGGHUYRQ.DQWDQJHGHXWHWHQ(LQ KHLWGHU9HUQXQIWMHGRFKXQEHUKUW 6WDWWXPGLH YHUPHLQWOLFKH $IILQLWlW]ZLVFKHQ%UDQGRPVXQG.DQWV 3KLORVRSKLHLQVJHVDPWVROOHVLP)ROJHQGHQMHGRFKQXUXPHLQHQ7HLODV SHNWJHKHQQlPOLFKGLH.RPSDWLELOLWlWYRQ%UDQGRPVXPIDVVHQGHU7KHR ULHGHU1RUPDWLYLWlWPLWGHQ$QVSUFKHQYRQ.DQWVSUDNWLVFKHU3KLORVR SKLH LVW HV P|JOLFK GLHVH .DQWLVFKHQ $QVSUFKH LQ %UDQGRPV 1RUPDWLYLWlWVWKHRULH GHUDUW ]X LQWHJULHUHQ GD 0RUDO NDWHJRULVFKHU ,P SHUDWLY XQG.OXJKHLW K\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLY YRQHLQDQGHUXQWHUVFKLH GHQXQGDXIHLQDQGHUEH]RJHQZHUGHQN|QQHQRKQHHLQHUVHLWVGLHHLQHLQ GLH DQGHUH RGHU XPJHNHKUW NROODELHUHQ ]X ODVVHQ XQG ]XJOHLFK RKQH DQGHUHUVHLWVDXIGLH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLVXQGPXQGXV VHQVLELOLV UHNXUULHUHQ ]X PVVHQ $P QlFKVWHQ VWHKW %UDQGRPV QRUPDWL YLVWLVFKHU $QVDW] ]ZHLIHOORV GHU .RQ]HSWLRQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH LQQHUKDOE GHU.DQWLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH GDV +DEHQ HLQHU $EVLFKW OHJW XQV DXIGLH(UJUHLIXQJHQWVSUHFKHQGHU0LWWHOIHVW'RFKVROOHQ]XQlFKVWYRU HLQHUGLUHNWHQ.RQIURQWDWLRQGLHVHUEHLGHQ7KHRULHQGLHIUHLQHQWVSUH FKHQGHV 9HUVWlQGQLV HUIRUGHUOLFKHQ *UXQGNRRUGLQDWHQ YRQ %UDQGRPV 7KHRULHGHV*HLVWHVLGHQWLIL]LHUWZHUGHQGLHHUDOVUDWLRQDOLVWLVFKHQSUDJ PDWLVWLVFKHQOLQJXLVWLVFKHQH[SUHVVLYLVWLVFKHQXQGKROLVWLVFKHQ,QIHUHQWLD OLVPXVFKDUDNWHULVLHUW 6RYLHOYRUDE :lKUHQG.DQWZLHLQ.DSDXVJHIKUWGHQ%HJULIIGHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW DQ GHQ %HJULII GHU 9HUQXQIW NQSIW GHU VHLQHUVHLWV LQ GHU PHWDSK\VLVFKHQ=ZHL:HOWHQ/HKUHJUQGHW NQSIW%UDQGRPXPJHNHKUW GLH9HUQXQIWDQGDV%HKHUUVFKHQGHVJHQXLQQRUPDWLYHQ6SLHOVGHV5HFKW IHUWLJHQV DOVR GHV 3URGX]LHUHQV XQG .RQVXPLHUHQV YRQ *UQGHQ 1RU PDWLYLWlWJUQGHWDOVRLPHUVWHQ)DOOLQ.DQWV6\QWKHVHYRQ+HWHURQRPLH XQG$XWRQRPLHLP]ZHLWHQ)DOOLQ%UDQGRPV.RQ]HSWLRQNRPPXQLNDWL YHU 3UD[LV 2E HLQH Å'HWUDQV]HQGHQWDOLVLHUXQJ´ YRQ .DQWV $QVDW] LP 6LQQH%UDQGRPVGLH6WlUNHQGHU.DQWLVFKHQ0RUDOSKLORVRSKLHLKUH7KH PDWLVLHUXQJ LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW EHZDKUHQ NDQQ NDQQ VLFK HUVW ]HLJHQ ZHQQ %UDQGRPV .RQ]HSW HLQHU QRUPDWLYHQ 3UDJPDWLN LQ *UXQG]JHQHLQVLFKWLJLVW
_____________ 9JOGD]XXQWHQ 9JOGD]XGLH(LQOHLWXQJ]X%UDQGRP ([SOL]LW EH]HLFKQHW QLFKW %UDQGRP VRQGHUQ +DEHUPDV HLQHV VHLQHU $QOLHJHQ PLWGLHVHP$XVGUXFN 9JOGD]X%UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
,QIHUHQWLHOOH6HPDQWLNXQGQRUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLN
=ZDU ILQGHQ VLFK LQ %UDQGRPV V\VWHPDWLVFKHP $QVDW] DXFK VSH]LILVFK ZDKUKHLWV HUNHQQWQLV XQG KDQGOXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKH 3HUVSHNWLYHQ XQG LQ GHU7DWPXPDQEHLLKPVWlUNHUQRFKDOVEHL.DQW XQGGDPLWYLHOOHLFKW HKHU GHP 'HQNHQ /HLEQL]· RGHU +HJHOV YHUJOHLFKEDU VWHWV GHQ JURHQ 5HVWPLWLP%OLFNKDEHQGHQQLQJHZLVVHU:HLVHKlQJWKLHUDOOHVPLWDOOHP ]XVDPPHQ 'RFK LQ HUVWHU 1lKHUXQJ NDQQ PDQ JHOWHQG PDFKHQ GD %UDQGRPV ,QWHUHVVH DQ HLQHU XPIDVVHQGHQ 7KHRULH GHV *HLVWHV GDUDXI DE]LHOWGDVLFKLQGHQbXHUXQJHQVSUDFKXQGKDQGOXQJVIlKLJHU6XEMHN WH GHUHQ 9HUQXQIW DUWLNXOLHUW GLHMHQLJH Ä)DNXOWlW¶ DOVR DQ ZHOFKH VLFK GLH .DQWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH ULFKWHQ 'LH $SRVWURSKLHUXQJ GHU )DNXOWlW VROO OHGLJOLFKGHQ9HUVXFKHLQHUhEHUVHW]XQJLQ.DQWLVFKH'LNWLRQDQGHXWHQ %UDQGRPKDQGHOWQLFKWZHVHQWOLFKYRP0HQVFKHQXQGGHVVHQ9HUP|JHQ XQGVFKRQJDUQLFKWYRQGHVVHQ=XJHK|ULJNHLW]XUVHQVLEOHQRGHULQWHOOL JLEOHQ:HOW'RFKGHU%HJULIIGHU1RUPDWLYLWlWOlWDXFKQDFK%UDQGRP YHUVWDQGHVIlKLJH YRQ EOR HPSILQGXQJVIlKLJHQ :HVHQ XQWHUVFKHLGHQ HV JHKW%UDQGRPVFKOLHOLFKXPVDSLHQFHVWDWWXPVHQWLHQFH$XIGLHVHP:HJH VROO DXFK HLQH $QWZRUW DXI GLH )UDJH ÄZLH N|QQHQ ZLU YHUSIOLFKWHQ XQG YHUSIOLFKWHWZHUGHQ"¶JHIXQGHQZHUGHQ 3UDNWLVFKH 6lW]H D SULRUL VSLHOHQ ZLH EHUHLWV HUZlKQW LQ %UDQGRPV 7KHRULH NHLQH 5ROOH MD LP *UXQGH JHQRPPHQ JHKW HV %UDQGRP EHU KDXSWQLFKWXP0RUDOSKLORVRSKLHZHOFKHDXFKLPPHU:RVLFK%UDQGRP ]XJHQXLQPRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UREOHPHQlXHUWJHKWHUEHU$QGHX WXQJHQGHVDXINOlUHULVFKHQ3RWHQWLDOVVHLQHUHLJHQHQ7KHRULHNDXPKLQDXV Å'LHREHUVWH5HJHOLP.DPSIGHU9HUQXQIWJHJHQHLQGXUFK9RUXUWHLOXQG 3URSDJDQGD YHU]HUUWHV 'HQNHQ ODXWHW GD SRWHQWLHOO VWULWWLJH PDWHULDO LQIHUHQWLHOOH)HVWOHJXQJHQDOV%HKDXSWXQJHQH[SOL]LWJHPDFKWZHUGHQVROO WHQ XP VLH DXI GLHVH :HLVH HLQHUVHLWV IUEHJUQGHWH$QIHFKWXQJHQ YHU OHW]OLFK]XPDFKHQXQGDQGHUHUVHLWVGHXWOLFK]XPDFKHQGDYHUQQIWLJH 6WUDWHJLHQ ]X LKUHU 9HUWHLGLJXQJ JHIUDJW VLQG (V GDUI QLFKW ]XJHODVVHQ ZHUGHQGDVLHVLFKLP,QQHUQYRQDXIJHODGHQHQ3KUDVHQZLHÄ)HLQGGHU 0HQVFKKHLW¶RGHUÄ5HFKWXQG2UGQXQJ¶DXI'DXHUHLQULFKWHQ´*HQHUHOO JLOWGDGHU)RNXVYRQ%UDQGRPV7KHRULHGLH0RUDOQLFKWDOVHLJHQVWlQ GLJHV 7KHPD XPIDW ,QVRIHUQ PDQ QXQ HLQH 5HIOH[LRQ DXI GHQ 6WDWXV GHU5HGHYRQGHPZDVÄQLFKW]XJHODVVHQZHUGHQGDUI¶EHL%UDQGRPYHU
_____________ 9JOGD]XDXFKGLH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQVSHUVSHNWLYH.QHOOV E GHULQ%UDQGRP EHUHLWVHLQHÅQRUPDWLYLVWLVFKH:HQGHGHUDQDO\WLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH´HQWGHFNW 9JO%UDQGRP %UDQGRP 9JO%UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
,QIHUHQWLHOOH6HPDQWLNXQGQRUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLN
PLVVHQ PDJ NDQQ VLFK GLH )UDJH VWHOOHQ RE GHU WUDGLWLRQHOOH 2UW HLQHU XQEHGLQJW JHELHWHQGHQ 0RUDO KLHU OHHU EOHLEW OHHU EOHLEHQ GDUI RGHU OHHU EOHLEHQ PX ,Q ZHOFKHV NULWLVFKKHUDXVIRUGHUQGHV RGHU DXFK DIILUPDWLY HUJlQ]HQGHV9HUKlOWQLVOlWVLFK%UDQGRPV.RKlUHQWLVPXV]XGHULQ.DS VNL]]LHUWHQ .DQWLVFKHQ 3RVLWLRQ VHW]HQ ZHQQ HU PRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKH 3UREOHPHJUXQGVlW]OLFKDXVNODPPHUW".DQWV%HJULIIGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ1RU PDWLYLWlW MHQVHLWV GLHVHU Z|UWOLFKHQ %H]HLFKQXQJ GLH HUVW VHLW GHP -DKUKXQGHUWJHEUlXFKOLFKLVW]HLJWHVLFKVFKOLHOLFKDP*UXQGVHLQHU0R UDOSKLORVRSKLH²DXWRQRPH:HVHQVLQGGXUFKHLQH6HOEVWYHUSIOLFKWXQJ]X YHUQQIWLJHP +DQGHOQ EHVWLPPW ² XQG GLH VSUDFKOLFKH 'LPHQVLRQ YRQ 9HUQXQIWXQG1RUPDWLYLWlWVWHOOWHIU.DQWNHLQSKLORVRSKLVFKHV3UREOHP GDU :lKUHQG .DQW JODXEWH VLFK GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ 9HUQXQIW XQG GHU LKU LQKlUHQWHQ 1RUPDWLYLWlW GLUHNW PHQWDO ]XZHQGHQ ]X N|QQHQ VHW]W %UDQ GRPDQGHUSKlQRPHQDOHQ%DVLVPHQVFKOLFKHU.RPPXQLNDWLRQDQ'DEHL JHKWHVLKPMHGRFKQLFKWXPGLHIDNWLVFKH6SUDFKIlKLJNHLWDOVHLQHUQDWXUD OHQ7DWVDFKHVRQGHUQXPGLHLQGHUZLH+DEHUPDVVLHQHQQWÅ,QIUDVWUXN WXU GHU $OOWDJVNRPPXQLNDWLRQ´ DOVR LP 6SUHFKHQ DOV VR]LDOHU 3UD[LV OLHJHQGH1RUPDWLYLWlW1RUPDWLYLWlWZLUGDOVHLQ:HVHQV]XJGHU9HUQXQIW XQGGDPLWGHV0HQVFKHQ HUVWLQGHUVSUDFKOLFKHQ([SOLNDWLRQEHJUHLIEDU 'LHV PDFKW HLQHQ $VSHNW GHVVHQ DXV ZDV %UDQGRP DOV ÅOLQJXLVWLVFKHQ 3UDJPDWLVPXV´EH]HLFKQHW 'HQ OHLFKWHVWHQ =XJDQJ ]X %UDQGRPV $XIIDVVXQJ HLQHU QRUPDWLYHQ 3UDJPDWLN ILQGHW PDQ GHVKDOE EHU HLQH (LQEH]LHKXQJ VHLQHV .RQ]HSWV HLQHU LQIHUHQWLHOOHQ 6HPDQWLN GDV HU ODSLGDU IROJHQGHUPDHQ YRQ HLQHP 5HSUlVHQWDWLRQDOLVPXVDEJUHQ]W Å7KHFRQFHSWRIPHDQLQJLVDQRUPDWLYH FRQFHSW´ (U VHOEVW GHPRQVWULHUW GLH *UXQG]JH VHLQHU7KHRULH DQ IRO JHQGHU H[HPSODULVFKHQ )UDJHVWHOOXQJ :DV LVW GHU 8QWHUVFKLHG ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHP 3DSDJHL GHU PLW %OLFN DXI HLQ URWHV 6WRIIPXVWHU GDV :RUW ÅURW´ NUlFK]W XQG HLQHP 0HQVFKHQ GHU LQ GHUVHOEHQ 6LWXDWLRQ GLH $XVVDJH Å'DV LVW URW´ WULIIW" +DW GDV :RUW ÅURW´ LQ EHLGHQ bXHUXQJHQ GLHVHOEH %HGHXWXQJ"+DWHVEHUKDXSWLQEHLGHQ)lOOHQHLQH%HGHXWXQJ"'HU9HU ZHLV DXI SK\VLRORJLVFKH RGHU ELRORJLVFKH 8QWHUVFKLHGH IKUW KLHU LQVRIHUQ QLFKW ZHLWHU DOV GLHVH QLFKW JDUDQWLHUHQ N|QQHQ GD GHU 3DSDJHL QLFKW
_____________ +DEHUPDV %UDQGRP YJO]XP)ROJHQGHQDXFK.QHOOV LQVEHV.DS,, LQVWUXNWL YH XQG NULWLVFKH 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ YRQ %UDQGRPV .RQWRIKUXQJVPRGHOO LP *HVDPW NRQWH[WYRQLQIHUHQWLHOOHU6HPDQWLNQRUPDWLYHU3UDJPDWLNXQGH[SUHVVLYLVWLVFKHU/R JLN %UDQGRP E
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
GLHVHOEH (UNHQQWQLV!EHVLW]WZLHGHU0HQVFK:LHVRVROOWHHLQZHQLJHU NRPSOH[HU 2UJDQLVPXV DOV GHU 0HQVFK QLFKW ZLH GLHVHU HLQH )DUEHUIDK UXQJ ZDV DXFK LPPHU GDV LVW KDEHQ N|QQHQ" 'LH )UDJH LVW DOVR :DV XQWHUVFKHLGHW GLH %HKDXSWXQJ GHV 3DSDJHLHQ YRQ GHU %HKDXSWXQJ GHV 0HQ VFKHQ"6LQGEHUKDXSWEHLGHV%HKDXSWXQJHQ" %UDQGRP VWHOOW LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ HLQ PHWKRGLVFKHV 3ULPDW WKHRUHWLVFKHU'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJYRUWKHRUHWLVFKHU$VVLPLOLHUXQJDXI'DPLW LVW )ROJHQGHV JHPHLQW XP HLQHQ %HJULII KLHU GHQ GHV YHUQQIWLJHQ :H VHQVJHQDXHU]XEHVWLPPHQLVWHVLQWHUHVVDQWHULQ9HUJOHLFKHQPLWDQGH UHQ :HVHQ GLH 8QWHUVFKLHGH ]ZLVFKHQ EHLGHQ KHUDXV]XDUEHLWHQ DQVWDWW GHUHQbKQOLFKNHLWHQRGHU,GHQWLWlWHQ,P%HLVSLHO PDQNDQQGLHPHQVFK OLFKH %HKDXSWXQJ DQJHVLFKWV GHV YRUJHKDOWHQHQ URWHQ 6WRIIPXVWHUV HYHQ WXHOO DXFK QDWXUDOLVWLVFK DOV 5HL]UHDNWLRQ EHVFKUHLEHQ GRFK JHKW LQ HLQHU VROFKHQ%HVFKUHLEXQJRIIHQNXQGLJJHQDXGDVYHUORUHQZDVGHQ0HQVFKHQ YRP3DSDJHLRGHUDXFKPXWDWLVPXWDQGLVYRQ7KHUPRVWDWHQRGHU/DQG PLQHQXQWHUVFKHLGHW*HJHQVWlQGHQDOVRGLHTXDOLIL]LHUHQGDXI5HL]HUHD JLHUHQ 'LH )UDJH OlW VLFK GDPLW VSH]LIL]LHUHQ ZRULQ XQWHUVFKHLGHW VLFK GLH bXHUXQJ GHV 0HQVFKHQ YRQ GHU GHV 3DSDJHLHQ" 'HU 6FKOVVHO ]XU %HDQWZRUWXQJGLHVHU)UDJHOLHJWQDFK%UDQGRPLPQRUPDWLYHQ%HJULIIGHU %HJUQGXQJGHP*HEHQXQG)RUGHUQYRQ*UQGHQ'LH9HUNQSIXQJ]XU %HJUQGXQJ EHQHQQW GLH GLIIHUHQWLD VSHFLILFD ]ZLVFKHQ bXHUXQJHQ GLH HYHQWXHOOPLW(UNOlUXQJVPXVWHUQYRQ5HL]HQXQG5HDNWLRQVGLVSRVLWLRQHQ KLQUHLFKHQG EHVWLPPW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ XQGVROFKHQ EHL GHQHQ GLHVQLFKW GHU )DOO LVW GHP $XIVWHOOHQ YRQ %HKDXSWXQJHQ GHP )RUPXOLHUHQ YRQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQXQG$EVLFKWHQ 'LH HUVWH SURPLQHQWH PRGHUQH $UWLNXODWLRQ HLQHU LQIHUHQWLHOOHQ 6H PDQWLN VWDPPW YRQ :LOIULG 6HOODUV GHU VLFK GDPLW YRQ 6LQQHVGDWHQWKHR ULHQNODVVLVFKHU3UlJXQJGLVWDQ]LHUW1LFKWGD6HOODUVGDPLWHLQH$EELOG WKHRULHGHU6XEMHNW3UlGLNDW6lW]HQHJLHUHQZUGH²JHJHQHLQHQVROFKHQ 5HSUlVHQWDWLRQDOLVPXV ZHQGHW VLFK HUVW %UDQGRP 'RFK ZlKUHQG 6HOODUV LQ (LQNODQJ PLW GHU 7UDGLWLRQ VHLW 'HVFDUWHV XQG /RFNH GHQ NDXVDOHQ (LQIOXH[WHUQSK\VLNDOLVFKHU*HJHQVWlQGHDIILUPLHUWZHQGHWHUVLFKGRFK JHJHQ HLQH HSLVWHPLVFKH 9HUPLWWOXQJ YRQ 6LQQHVHLQGUFNHQ Å'LH GLUHNWH :DKUQHKPXQJHLQHVSK\VLNDOLVFKHQ*HJHQVWDQGHVZLUGGXUFKGDV$XIWUH WHQ YRQ 6LQQHVHLQGUFNHQ YHUPLWWHOW /HW]WHUH VLQG YROONRPPHQ QLFKW
_____________ 9JO]XGHQGLVWDQ]LHUHQGHQ$QIKUXQJV]HLFKHQREHQ(LQOHLWXQJ)Q Å,P9RUGHUJUXQG>VFYRQ%UDQGRPV7KHRULH .3@VWHKHQ'LVNRQWLQXLWlWHQ]ZLVFKHQ GHP %HJULIIOLFKHQ XQG GHP 1LFKW RGHU 9RUEHJULIIOLFKHQ 'HQ $XVJDQJVSXQNW GHU 'LVNXVVLRQ ELOGHW GDEHL GLH %HVFKlIWLJXQJ PLW GHU )UDJH ZDV GDV %HVRQGHUH RGHU &KDUDNWHULVWLVFKHGHV%HJULIIOLFKHQDOVVROFKHQLVW´ %UDQGRP 9JO6HOODUV RULJ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
,QIHUHQWLHOOH6HPDQWLNXQGQRUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLN
NRJQLWLY>@>'@LHVH9HUPLWWOXQJLVWNDXVDOHUXQGQLFKWHSLVWHPLVFKHU$UW 6LQQHVHLQGUFNH YHUPLWWHOQ QLFKW GDGXUFK GD VLH JHZXW ZHUGHQ´ /HLEQL]· 0RQDGHQ KDEHQ EHL 6HOODUV )HQVWHU EHNRPPHQ DEHU GHU *HLVW VLW]WQLFKWGLUHNWGDKLQWHU'DPLWVSUDFKOLFKH$XVGUFNH%HGHXWXQJHUODQ JHQLVWHVQDFK6HOODUVQLFKWEHUHLWVDXVUHLFKHQGDOV6\PSWRPRGHU=HL FKHQ GHU *HJHQZDUW HLQHV EHLVSLHOVZHLVH URWHQ *HJHQVWDQGV XQWHU 6WDQ GDUGEHGLQJXQJHQ GHQ 6DW] Ä'LHV LVW URW¶ ]X lXHUQ (V EHGDUI YLHOPHKU EHUHLWVGHV:LVVHQVXPDOOJHPHLQH7DWVDFKHQGHU)RUPÅ;LVWHLQYHUOlOL FKHV6\PSWRPIU@´ (U VSULFKW LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJDXFKYRQHLQHPÅ0\WKRVGHV*HJHEHQHQ´XQGEHQHQQW VFKOLHOLFKPLWGHULQ]ZLVFKHQEHUKPWHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJGHVÄORJLFDOVSDFH RIUHDVRQV¶VHLQH$OWHUQDWLYH Å'HUVSULQJHQGH3XQNWOLHJWGDULQGDZLU NHLQH HPSLULVFKH %HVFKUHLEXQJ GLHVHU (SLVRGH RGHU GLHVHV =XVWDQGHV OLHIHUQZHQQZLUHLQH(SLVRGHRGHUHLQHQ=XVWDQGDOVHLQ:LVVHQEH]HLFK QHQ:LUVWHOOHQVLHYLHOPHKULQGHQORJLVFKHQ5DXPGHU*UQGHGHU5HFKWIHUWL JXQJXQGGHU)lKLJNHLW]XU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGHV*HVDJWHQ´ 'LHVHUORJLVFKH5DXP YRQ*UQGHQ²LP0RQLVPXV/HLEQL]·EHKHUEHUJWHHUVRZRKOGLH:HOWGHU 7DWVDFKHQ DOV DXFK GLH GHU $XVVDJHQ ² LVW GLH HLQ]LJH 6SKlUH LQ GHU ZLU =XJULII DXI GLH :HOW KDEHQ $XI GHU ZLVVHQVFKDIWVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ (EHQH VSULFKW6HOODUVVFKOLHOLFKQLFKWYRQÄLQGXNWLYHQ$UJXPHQWHQ¶]XU*HZLQ QXQJ YRQ *HVHW]HVDXVVDJHQ VRQGHUQ YRP Ä*HLVW GHU 6RNUDWLVFKHQ 0H WKRGH¶ GHPJHPl ZLU +\SRWKHVHQ PLW *UQGHQ XQWHUPDXHUQ E]Z PLW (LQZlQGHQNRQIURQWLHUHQ 'RFKHUVW%UDQGRPKDWGHQYRQ6HOODUVPHKUDQJHGHXWHWHQDOVDXVJH IKUWHQ ,QIHUHQWLDOLVPXV ]X HLQHU V\VWHPDWLVFKHQ 6HPDQWLN MD ]X HLQHU JDQ]HQ3KLORVRSKLHGHV*HLVWHVDXVJHDUEHLWHW Å'LH,GHHLVWJUREGLHGD GDV SDUDGLJPDWLVFKH UDWLRQDOH 9RUJHKHQ GDV 6HOODUV DOV 6RNUDWLVFKH 0H WKRGH EH]HLFKQHW DXI GHU 0|JOLFKNHLW EHUXKW LPSOL]LWH )HVWOHJXQJHQ DOV %HKDXSWXQJHQ H[SOL]LW ]X PDFKHQ :HQQ PDQ VLH DXI GLHVH :HLVH DXV GUFNWEULQJWPDQVLHLQGDV6SLHOGHV*HEHQVXQG9HUODQJHQVYRQ*UQ GHQHLQLQGHPVLHHLQHEHVRQGHUH5ROOHVSLHOHQNUDIWGHUHQHWZDVEHU
_____________
6HOODUV [[[L[ (EG (EG (EG +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
KDXSWHLQHQEHJULIIOLFKHQ*HKDOWKDW²HLQHLQIHUHQWLHOOH5ROOHQlPOLFKDOV 3UlPLVVHXQG.RQNOXVLRQYRQ,QIHUHQ]HQ´ 'HU&ORXYRQ%UDQGRPVVHKUNRPSOH[HU7KHRULHGHV*HLVWHVGHU5D WLRQDOLWlWRGHUGHU9HUQXQIWLVWDOVRGDHUGLHLQIHUHQWLHOOH6HPDQWLNPLW HLQHUQRUPDWLYHQ3UDJPDWLNXQGHLQHUH[SUHVVLYHQ/RJLNYHUNQSIW ÅhEHU %HJULIIH]XUHGHQKHLWEHU5ROOHQLQ%HJUQGXQJV]XVDPPHQKlQJHQ]X UHGHQ´ 0LW GHU DP 3DSDJHL9HUJOHLFK YRUJHIKUWHQ 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ bXHUXQJHQ GHUHQ (UNOlUXQJHQ PLW 0XVWHUQ YRQ 5HL]HQ XQG 5HDNWLRQVGLVSRVLWLRQHQDXVNRPPHQXQGVROFKHQEHLGHQHQGLHVQLFKWGHU )DOO LVW HUVFKOLHW VLFK EHUHLWV %UDQGRPV (QJIKUXQJ YRQ LQIHUHQWLHOOHU 6HPDQWLNXQGQRUPDWLYHU3UDJPDWLN REGLHbXHUXQJÅGLHVLVWURW´DQJH VLFKWV GHV 6WRIIPXVWHUV DOV :LVVHQVlXHUXQJ EHWUDFKWHW ZHUGHQ NDQQ RE GDV:RUWÅURW´LQGLHVHU9HUZHQGXQJDOVR%HGHXWXQJEHVLW]WULFKWHWVLFK VR%UDQGRPQDFKGHU)lKLJNHLWGHV6SUHFKHUVGLHVH%HKDXSWXQJDOV3Ul PLVVHIUZHLWHUH%HKDXSWXQJHQ]%ÅGLHVLVWQLFKWJUQ´RGHUDOV.RQ VHTXHQ]DXVDQGHUHQ%HKDXSWXQJHQ]%ÅGLHVLVWVFKDUODFKURW´EHKDQ GHOQ ]X N|QQHQ 8QG GLHVH )lKLJNHLW VFKUHLEHQ ZLU VR %UDQGRP GHP 6SUHFKHUQLFKWDXIJUXQGQDWXUDOHU.ULWHULHQ]%DOVVSUHFKHQGHP2UJD QLVPXV]X9LHOPHKUHUNHQQHQZLUGLHVH)lKLJNHLWDOVGDVLQGHQbXHUXQ JHQ ,PSOL]LHUWH GDV VLFK LP 1HW] VSUDFKOLFKHU ,QIHUHQ]HQ PDQLIHVWLHUHQ PX 'LH bXHUXQJ ÅURW´ EHVLW]W DOVR QXU GDQQ %HGHXWXQJ ZHQQ GHU 6SUHFKHULPVWDQGHLVWIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]HQEHUHFKWLJXQJVHU KDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]HQXQG,QNRPSDWLELOLWlWHQDOVVROFKH]XLGHQWLIL]LHUHQ 'LH%HGHXWXQJHLQHV$XVGUXFNVZLUGYRQ%UDQGRPGDPLWQLFKWDQ5HSUl VHQWDWLRQHQ GHV 6SUHFKHUV DOVR LQWURVSHNWLY ]XJlQJOLFKH PHQWDOH $NWH JHEXQGHQVRQGHUQDQGLHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYVDQNWLRQLHUWHLQIHUHQWLHOOVWUXNWX ULHUWH6SUDFKSUD[LV Å8PHLQHQEHJULIIOLFKHQ*HKDOW]XEHVLW]HQPXHLQH 5HDNWLRQ VFKOLFKW HLQH 5ROOH LQ GHP LQIHUHQWLHOOHQ 6SLHO GHV $XIVWHOOHQV YRQ %HKDXSWXQJHQ GHV *HEHQV XQG 9HUODQJHQV YRQ *UQGHQ VSLHOHQ
_____________ %UDQGRP D YJO ]XU 'LIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ 6HOODUV XQG %UDQGRP DXFK %HUW UDP/LSWRZ %UDQGRP *HQDXHUEHWUDFKWHWEH]LHKWVLFKGLHKLHUDQJHVSURFKHQH)lKLJNHLW²GLHVHU$XVGUXFN VROOWHQXULQHUVWHU1lKHUXQJYHUZHQGHWZHUGHQGDVHLQHYHUP|JHQVSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ .RQQRWDWLRQHQLQGLH,UUHIKUHQN|QQWHQ²DXIGLHQRUPDWLYHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQQlP OLFKGHRQWLVFKH6WDWXV )HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQ ]X]XZHL VHQE]ZDQ]XHUNHQQHQ'LHVHQRUPDWLYHQ6WDWXVIKUHQVR%UDQGRP]XÅGUHL9DUL DQWHQ LQIHUHQWLHOOHU 5HODWLRQHQ´ KLQVLFKWOLFK EHKDXSWEDUHU *HKDOWH YJO %UDQGRP I LFKZHUGHLQ.U]HVRZRKODXIGHQ%HJULIIGHU(LQVWHOOXQJDOVDXFKDXI GLHKLHUDQJHVSURFKHQHQLQIHUHQWLHOOHQ5HODWLRQHQ]XUFNNRPPHQ 9JO%UDQGRPD 9JO%UDQGRP.DSLQVEHV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
,QIHUHQWLHOOH6HPDQWLNXQGQRUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLN
(LQHQVROFKHQ%HJULII]XEHJUHLIHQRGHU]XYHUVWHKHQKHLWGLH,QIHUHQ ]HQ LQ GLH HU YHUZLFNHOW LVW SUDNWLVFK ]X EHKHUUVFKHQ ² ]X ZLVVHQ G K SUDNWLVFK XQWHUVFKHLGHQ ]XN|QQHQ XQG GDV LVW HLQ :LVVHQZLH ZDV DXV GHU$QZHQGEDUNHLWHLQHV%HJULIIVIROJWXQGZRUDXVGLHVH$QZHQGEDUNHLW LKUHUVHLWVIROJW´'HU:HOWEH]XJGHU6SUDFKHZLUGLQ%UDQGRPV7KHRULH GDGXUFK KHUJHVWHOOW GD EHJULIIOLFKHU ,QKDOW DOV GDV GHILQLHUW ZLUG ZDV GXUFKPDWHULDOULFKWLJH,QIHUHQ]HQEHZDKUWZLUG Å'LHOHLWHQGH,GHHODXWHW GD VLFK GDV ZDV SURSRVLWLRQDO JHKDOWYROO LVW ZHVHQWOLFK GDGXUFK DXV ]HLFKQHWGDHVVRZRKODOV3UlPLVVHDOVDXFKDOV.RQNOXVLRQLQ,QIHUHQ]HQ GLHQHQNDQQ,QGHPPDQHWZDVIUZDKUKlOWEHKDQGHOWPDQHVDOVSRWHQ WLHOOH 3UlPLVVH IU ,QIHUHQ]HQ´ 6WDWW GLH 5HIHUHQ] YRQ 3URSRVLWLRQHQ DOVR EHU GHUHQ UHSUlVHQWDWLRQDOHQ *HKDOW ]X GHILQLHUHQ EHVWLPPW VLH %UDQGRPEHUGLHLQIHUHQWLHOOH*OLHGHUXQJYRQ.RPPXQLNDWLRQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQPLWGHQHQZLUDXIGLH9RUJlQJHXPXQVKHUXPUHDJLH UHQXQWHUVFKHLGHQVLFKYRQ5HDNWLRQHQGLHQLFKWSURSRVLWLRQDOJHKDOWYROO VLQG GLHDOVRLQGLHVHP6LQQHQLFKWYHUVWHKEDUVLQG GDGXUFKGDVLHDOV *UQGH IXQJLHUHQ N|QQHQ DOV 3UlPLVVHQ DXV GHQHQ ZHLWHUH .RQNOXVLR QHQHUVFKORVVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ+DQGOXQJHQGLHDOV5HDNWLRQDXISURSRVL WLRQDO JHKDOWYROOH ,QWHQWLRQHQ GLH 9RUJlQJH XP XQV KHUXP YHUlQGHUQ XQWHUVFKHLGHQVLFKYRQ3HUIRUPDQ]HQGLHEORHV9HUKDOWHQVLQG GLHDOVR QLFKWDQKDQGDXVO|VHQGHUSURSRVLWLRQDOJHKDOWYROOHU$EVLFKWHQYHUVWHKEDU VLQG GDGXUFKGDIUVLH*UQGHJHJHEHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ VLHN|QQHQDOV .RQNOXVLRQHQSUDNWLVFKHU,QIHUHQ]HQDXIWUHWHQ 'DUDXV HUJLEW VLFK IROJHQGHV GHU UDWLR FRJQRVFHQGL HQWVSUHFKHQG YRP =HQWUXPQDFKDXHQ]XOHVHQGHVVHPDQWLVFKHV0RGHOO
_____________ %UDQGRP %UDQGRP YJO ]XU PDWHULDOHQ 5LFKWLJNHLW YRQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ DXFK %UDQGRP D 9JO%UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
ELL D FLL EL FL :DKUQHKPXQJ )UZDKU+DOWHQYRQ LQIHUHQWLHOO :DKU0DFKHQ +HUVWHOOXQJHLQHU HLQHUQLFKW %HKDXSWXQJHQDOV JHJOLHGHUWHU YRQ%HKDXSWXQ QLFKWVSUDFKOLFKHQ 'LVNXUV JHQDOVÅGLVNXUVL VSUDFKOLFKHQ ÅGLVNXUVLYH(LQJDQJV 6LWXDWLRQ 6LWXDWLRQ VFKZHOOH´ YH$XVJDQJV ZDKUQHKPXQJVJHVWW] VFKZHOOH´ WHQLFKWLQIHUHQWLHOOH $EVLFKWHQPLW %HREDFKWXQJVEHULFKWH .RQNOXVLRQV PLW3UlPLVVHQ )XQNWLRQLQ )XQNWLRQLQ,QIHUHQ]HQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ
:HOWEH]XJ
%UDQGRPV0RGHOOLQIHUHQWLHOOHU6HPDQWLN
'LHVH )RUP YRQ ,QIHUHQWLDOLVPXV VR %UDQGRP VFKOLHW GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW QLFKWLQIHUHQWLHOOHU8PVWlQGHXQG)ROJHQGHU%HJULIIVDQZHQGXQJDXVGUFN OLFK HLQ Å$XI GLHVH :HLVH >@ ZLUG GHU VSH]LILVFK HPSLULVFKH EHJULIIOLFKH *HKDOW GHQ %HJULIIH NUDIW 9HUELQGXQJ ]X 6SUDFKHLQJlQJHQ EHLP :DKU QHKPHQ DXIZHLVHQ XQG GHU VSH]LILVFK SUDNWLVFKH EHJULIIOLFKH *HKDOW GHQ %HJULIIH NUDIW 9HUELQGXQJ ]X 6SUDFKDXVJlQJHQ EHLP +DQGHOQ ]HLJHQ LQ GHQ LQIHUHQWLDOLVWLVFKHQ 5DKPHQ LQWHJULHUW´ 0DQ N|QQWH GLHV DXFK VR IRUPXOLHUHQ XQVHU NDXVDOHU =XJDQJ ]XU :HOW ILQGHW LQ FL XQG FLL VWDWW DEHU XQVHU UDWLRQDOHU =XJULII DXI GLH :HOW OlXIW QXU EHU D XQG E GK %UDQGRPOHXJQHWQLFKWGLH5HDOLWlWHLQHU:HOWGLHZLUDEHUQLFKWQXUZLU VRQGHUQDXFK$QGHUHVXQG$QGHUHVLQGHUEHKDXSWHWYLHOPHKUGDGLHVH :HOW XP XQVHUH :HOW ]X VHLQ GXUFK GDV LQIHUHQWLHOOH 1HW] XQVHUHU 'LV NXUVH VWUXNWXULHUW VHLQ PX 2GHU QRFKPDOV DQGHUV JHZHQGHW DOOHLQ FL XQG FLL EHWUHIIHQ GLH NDXVDOH 3HUVSHNWLYH DXI GLH SK\VLVFKH :HOW GHUHQ 7HLOGHU0HQVFKLVWZRKLQJHJHQ EL GLHHSLVWHPLVFKHXQG ELL GLHSUDNWL VFKH3HUVSHNWLYHGHV0HQVFKHQEHVFKUHLEHQ'LHVHPDQWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYH ZLHGHUXPEHWULIIWOHGLJOLFK D LQQRWZHQGLJHU9HUELQGXQJDOOHUGLQJVPLW GHQ GXUFK E YHUPLWWHOWHQ 'LPHQVLRQHQ GLH GXUFK F JHNHQQ]HLFKQHW VLQG 'LH Ä%HKDXSWXQJ¶ YHUVWHKW %UDQGRP GDEHL DOV ÅGDV (LQJHKHQ RGHU $QHUNHQQHQHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJGLHNUDIWLKUHULQIHUHQWLHOOHQ*OLHGHUXQJSURSR VLWLRQDOJHKDOWYROOLVW´'HU$XVGUXFN3HUVSHNWLYHLVWKLHULQVRIHUQVLQQ
_____________ 9JOGD]XDXFK%UDQGRPDVRZLH%UDQGRP %UDQGRPDI %UDQGRP %UDQGRPEHWRQWPHKUIDFKGHQ6WHOOHQZHUWGHU%HKDXSWXQJYJO EHLVSLHOVZHLVH%UDQGRP D Å7KHIXQGDPHQWDO VSHHFKDFW ²WKHRQHZKRVH
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
,QIHUHQWLHOOH6HPDQWLNXQGQRUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLN
YROODOVHUGDUDXIYHUZHLVWGDGLHVH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJHQZLOONUOLFKHWKHR UHWLVFKH $EVWUDNWLRQHQ NRPSOH[HU 3UR]HVVH VLQG GLH UHDOLWHU DOOH RGHU PLQGHVWHQV PHKUHUH GLHVHU 'LPHQVLRQHQ GLH GXUFK GLHVH 3HUVSHNWLYHQ EHVFKULHEHQZHUGHQXPIDVVHQ 'LH )UDJH ZHOFKH )RUP YRQ $EVLFKWHQ DOV GLVNXUVLYH $XVJDQJV VFKZHOOHEHWUDFKWHWZHUGHQVROOLVWQLFKWHLQIDFK]XEHDQWZRUWHQLQVRIHUQ QHEHQ GHU YRQ %UDQGRP LQ )RUWIKUXQJ YRQ -RKQ 6HDUOH HLQJHIKUWHQ 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ Ä+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ¶ XQG ÄYRUDXVJHKHQGHQ $EVLFKWHQ¶ HLQH ZHLWHUH )RUP YRQ +DQGOXQJ 9HOOHPDQV DFWLYLWLHV YJO REHQ XQGGHUHQEHJULIIOLFKHV9HUKlOWQLV]X$EVLFKWHQUHOHYDQW]XVHLQ VFKHLQW %UDQGRP EHVFKUHLEW GLH 6\PPHWULH GHV YRUVWHKHQG WDEHOODULVFK GDUJHVWHOOWHQ:HOWEH]XJV]XQlFKVWIROJHQGHUPDHQ Å'LH$XVJlQJHDXVGHU 6SUDFKHRGHUGHUGLVNXUVLYHQ.RQWRIKUXQJ LQWHQWLRQDOH+DQGOXQJHQ VLQG DQDORJ ]X GLHVHQ (LQJlQJHQ ZDKUQHKPXQJVJHVWW]WHQ %HREDFKWXQJHQ ]X YHUVWHKHQ%HLP+DQGHOQIXQJLHUHQbQGHUXQJHQGHUGHRQWLVFKHQ(LQVWHO OXQJ VSH]LHOO $QHUNHQQXQJHQ SUDNWLVFKHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ DOV 5HL]H GLH
_____________ SUHVHQFH LV QHFHVVDU\ DQG VXIILFLHQW IRU WKH SUDFWLFHV LQYROYHG WR TXDOLI\ DV OLQJXLVWLF SUDFWLFHV ² LV DVVHUWLRQ $VVHUWLRQ LV WKH VWDNLQJ RI FODLPV WKDW DUH LQIHUHQWLDOO\ DUWLFX ODWHGLQWKHEDVLFVHQVHRIERWKVWDQGLQJLQQHHGRIUHDVRQVDQGEHLQJILWWRVHUYHDV UHDVRQV´ 9JODXFK%UDQGRPD )UGLHKHUYRUJHKREHQH6WHOOXQJYRQ%H KDXSWXQJHQLVW%UDQGRPV5DWLRQDOLVPXVYHUDQWZRUWOLFKGHUGDV*HEHQXQG)RUGHUQ YRQ*UQGHQLQGHQ9RUGHUJUXQGGHU7KHRULHVWHOOW+DDJ6WXUPEHPHUNHQGDKHU]X %UDQGRPV.RQ]HQWUDWLRQDXIEHKDXSWHQGH6SUHFKDNWH Å%HKDXSWXQJHQVLQGGLHVSUDFK OLFKHQ3HUIRUPDQ]HQGLHSDUDGLJPDWLVFKHU:HLVHDOVULFKWLJRGHUXQULFKWLJNODVVLIL]LHUW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ 'DUDXV HUNOlUW VLFK GLH 6FKOVVHOUROOH GLH LKQHQ LP %UDQGRPVFKHQ 7KHRULHUDKPHQ ]XNRPPW 'HQQ ]XP HLQHQ LVW GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW HLQHU .ODVVLILNDWLRQ EHVWLPPWHUbXHUXQJHQDOV%HKDXSWXQJHQGDV.ULWHULXPIUGLH=XVFKUHLEXQJYRQRE MHNWLYHPUHSUlVHQWDWLRQDOHP*HKDOW=XPDQGHUHQVLQG%HKDXSWXQJHQVSUDFKOLFKH8UWHL OHXQGHUKHOOHQGDPLWLQEHVRQGHUHU:HLVHGDVZHVHQWOLFKH&KDUDNWHULVWLNXPGHUUHOD WLRQDOHQ$XIIDVVXQJYRQ,QWHQWLRQDOLWlWGLHZHFKVHOVHLWLJH$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQ'HQNHQ XQG6SUHFKHQ´ +DDJ6WXUPI /DIRQWXQWHUPDXHUWVFKOLHOLFKGLH6RQGHU VWHOOXQJGHV%HKDXSWHQVKLQVLFKWOLFKXQVHUHVNRJQLWLYHQ:HOWEH]XJVLP$QVFKOXDQ %UDQGRPIROJHQGHUPDHQ Å,P*HJHQVDW]]XDQGHUHQ6SUHFKDNWHQ ZLH)UDJHQRGHU %HIHKOHQ VLQG%HKDXSWXQJHQ7HLOHLQHV6SUDFKVSLHOVLQGHPHVGDUXPJHKW]XVDJHQ ZLH VLFK GLH 'LQJH LQ GHU :HOW YHUKDOWHQ 'DV LVW GLH 3RLQWH GHV $XIVWHOOHQV YRQ %H KDXSWXQJHQ´ /DIRQW E 'RFK VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK YHUZHLVHQ DXFK )UDJHQ XQGVlPWOLFKHLPSHUDWLYHQbXHUXQJHQLPSOL]LWDXIGDVEHKDXSWHQGHDUWLFXODWLQJUHDVRQV ² VR GHU HQJOLVFKVSUDFKLJH 2ULJLQDOWLWHO YRQ %UDQGRPV %HJUQGHQ XQG %HJUHLIHQ %UDQ GRP VSULFKW ]ZDU YRUQHKPOLFK YRQ Ä%HKDXSWHQ¶ GRFK VLQG HEHQ DXFK DOOH DQGHUHQ VLQQYROOHQ6SUHFKDNWHLQVRIHUQVLHDQEHVWLPPWHhEHU]HXJXQJHQJHNQSIWVLQGHLQ JHEXQGHQ LQ GDV 1HW] EHVWLPPWHU ,QIHUHQ]HQ 'D DOVR ] % GLH $XIIRUGHUXQJ Å6SHQGHQ 6LH IU XQVHUH $NWLRQ´ RGHU GLH )UDJH Å+DEHQ 6LH GLHVHV %XFK JHOHVHQ"´ VLQQYROOVLQGVHW]WYRUDXVGDEHVWLPPWHLQIHUHQWLHOOH5HODWLRQHQXQG,QNRPSDWLELOL WlWHQGHUYHUZHQGHWHWHQ%HJULIIHLQ6SUHFKKDQGOXQJHQEHKHUUVFKWZHUGHQ 9JOGD]X6HDUOH 7DEHOOH GW 7DEHOOH
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
QLFKWVSUDFKOLFKH3HUIRUPDQ]HQDXVO|VHQ>«@(LQNRPSHWHQWHU%HREDFK WHU XQWHU JHHLJQHWHQ 8PVWlQGHQ UHDJLHUW DXI GLH 6LFKWEDUNHLW HLQHU URWHQ .XJHOLQGHPHUGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLH%HKDXSWXQJDQHUNHQQWGDGDHLQH URWH .XJHO LVW >«@ (LQ NRPSHWHQWHU $NWHXU UHDJLHUW XQWHU JHHLJQHWHQ 8PVWlQGHQDXIGDV(LQJHKHQGHU)HVWOHJXQJGHQ/LFKWVFKDOWHU]XEHWlWL JHQ PLW GHP %HWlWLJHQ GHV /LFKWVFKDOWHUV >«@ 1XU HLQ HQWVSUHFKHQG DXVJHELOGHWHU3K\VLNHUNDQQGDV9RUKDQGHQVHLQHLQHVƬ0HVRQVQLFKWLQIH UHQWLHOOEHULFKWHQXQGGDVQXUPLW+LOIHHLQHU%ODVHQNDPPHU XQGQXUHLQ JXW DXVJHELOGHWHU 3LDQLVW NDQQ QLFKWLQIHUHQWLHOO GLH 0RQGVFKHLQVRQDWH VSLHOHQXQGGDVQXUPLW+LOIHHLQHV.ODYLHUV´'LH)UDJHGLHVLFKQXQ DXIGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ6HLWHVWHOOWEH]LHKWVLFKDXIGHQLQWHQWLRQDOHQ&KDUDN WHUGHU+DQGOXQJ8QGGDPLWLVWGLH)UDJHYHUEXQGHQREHVVLFKEHLGHQ 'LVNXUVDXVJlQJHQXP+DQGOXQJHQRGHU+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQKDQGHOQVROO :HQQ PDQ ZLH LQ .DS VNL]]LHUW +DQGOXQJHQ DOOJHPHLQ DOV HWZDV EH WUDFKWHWGDVHVDQJHPHVVHQHUVFKHLQHQOlWQDFKHLQHP*UXQG]XIUDJHQ VR NDQQ PDQ PLW%UDQGRP ]ZLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ XQG YRUJlQJL JHQ$EVLFKWHQXQWHUVFKHLGHQ,PHUVWHQ)DOOEHVWHKWGLH+DQGOXQJGDULQ GDÅ>«@GLH3HUIRUPDQ]GHUHLQ.RQWRIKUHUGLH6LJQLILNDQ]HLQHU$Q HUNHQQXQJ HLQHU SUDNWLVFKHQ )HVWOHJXQJ > $EVLFKW .3@ ]XZHLVW GLH +DQGOXQJ VHOEVW LVW´ ,P )DOO GHU YRUJlQJLJHQ $EVLFKWHQ EHVWHKW GLH +DQGOXQJLQHLQHU9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHGLHÅHLQHUYHUOlOLFKHQXQWHUVFKHLGHQ GHQ 5HDNWLRQVGLVSRVLWLRQ DXI HLQH VROFKH $QHUNHQQXQJ >VF HLQHU SUDNWL VFKHQ )HVWOHJXQJ@ HQWVSULQJW 8QWHU GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ )HVWOHJXQJNDQQPDQVLFKGLH$EVLFKWYRUVWHOOHQPLWGHUGHU$NWKHUYRU JHEUDFKWZLUG´'LHGLVNXUVLYH$XVJDQJVVFKZHOOHLVWDOVRDOV$EVLFKW]X EHWUDFKWHQ ZREHL VLH LP KLHU HUVWJHQDQQWHQ )DOO +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW LP *HJHQVDW]]XUYRUJlQJLJHQ$EVLFKW DOVLQGHU+DQGOXQJVHOEVWLPSOL]LHUW GHP+DQGHOQGHQ]XJHVFKULHEHQZLUG QXUGLHVH)RUPYRQLQ+DQGOXQJHQ LPSOL]LHUWHQ$EVLFKWHQNDQQUHLQEHJULIIOLFKJHVHKHQQLFKWXQHUIOOWEOHL EHQ ELL XQG FLL VLQGKLHUQRWZHQGLJPLWHLQDQGHUYHUEXQGHQ
_____________ %UDQGRPDI YJODOOJHPHLQ]X%UDQGRPVYRQ'DYLG/HZLV EHUQRPPHQHP XQG IRUWHQWZLFNHOWHQ 0RGHOO GHU ÅGHRQWLVFKHQ .RQWRIKUXQJ´ %UDQGRPD.DS %UDQGRPD %UDQGRPIKUWHLQ%HLVSLHO6HDUOHVDQXPGLHVH+DQGOXQJVDE VLFKWHQ]XYHUDQVFKDXOLFKHQ Å$QJHQRPPHQLFKVLW]HGDGHQNHEHUHLQSKLORVRSKL VFKHV 3UREOHP QDFK XQG SO|W]OLFK VWHKH LFK DXI XQG JHKH LP =LPPHU DXI XQG DE :HQQLFKDXIVWHKHXQGDXIXQGDEJHKHGDQQVLQGGDVJHZLDEVLFKWOLFKH+DQGOXQ JHQDEHU HVEHGDUINHLQHUYRUDXVJHKHQGHQ$EVLFKWVLH]XWXQ,FKPXLQNHLQHUOHL 6LQQSODQHQDXI]XVWHKHQXQGDXIXQGDE]XJHKHQ:LHVRYLHOHVZDVPDQWXWWXHLFK GLHVH+DQGOXQJHLQIDFK´ %UDQGRPD YJOGD]X6HDUOH GW %UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
,QIHUHQWLHOOH6HPDQWLNXQGQRUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLN
$XI HLQH )RUP XQEHZXWHU $EVLFKWHQ UHNXUULHUW %UDQGRP LQ VHLQHU &KDUDNWHULVLHUXQJ]ZDUQLFKWJOHLFKZRKONDQQHLQHVROFKH)RUPSUREOHP ORVLQGLHVHLQWHJULHUWZHUGHQLQVRIHUQGDVGHRQWLVFKH0RGHOO%UDQGRPV YRQ +DXV DXV VWDWW HLQHU LQWURVSHNWLRQLVWLVFKHQ GLH LQWHUSHUVRQDOH =X VFKUHLEXQJVSHUVSHNWLYHZlKOWDXVZHOFKHUGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQ)HVWOH JXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X GLHVHQ DWWHVWLHUW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ GLH GLH KDQGHOQGH3HUVRQVHOEVWQLFKWHLQJHKWGKGLHLKUQLFKWJHJHQZlUWLJVLQG 'DGDPLWDXVGHU+DQGOXQJQLFKWXQWHUGHU+DQGHLQEORHV9HUKDOWHQ ZLUGZLUGGDGXUFKYHUKLQGHUWGDGDVIUDJOLFKH9HUKDOWHQGXUFKZHJXQG NRQVWLWXWLY DOV HLQ VROFKHVEHWUDFKWHW ZLUGYRQ GHP HVJUXQGVlW]OLFK DQ JHPHVVHQ LVW DXI *UQGH KLQ EHIUDJW ]X ZHUGHQ ,QVRIHUQ DOVR DXFK IU GLHQDFK9HOOHPDQV'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ YJOREHQ EHVWHKHQGH=ZLVFKHQ IRUPGHUDFWLYLWLHV*UQGHDQJHJHEHQZHUGHQN|QQHQHUVFKHLQWHVVLQQYROO VLH QHEHQ DFWLRQV XQWHU GHQ KLHU LQ %UDQGRPV 0RGHOO DQJHVSURFKHQHQ +DQGOXQJVEHJULII]XVXEVXPLHUHQ 1XUGHU9ROOVWlQGLJNHLWKDOEHUVHLKLHUPLW%UDQGRPV9RNDEXODUQRFK HUJlQ]WGD²DQDORJGHPUHLQHQ3KDQWDVLHUHQ,PDJLQLHUHQ7UlXPHQDXI GHU Ä%HREDFKWXQJ¶6HLWH ² HV DXFK DXI GHU Ä+DQGOXQJ¶6HLWH GLVNXUVLYH $XVJDQJVVFKZHOOHQJHEHQNDQQGLHWDWVlFKOLFKXQHUIOOWEOHLEHQHLQHUVHLWV GXUFK GDV $XVEOHLEHQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHU 8PVWlQGH ZHQQ GHU %XV LQ GHQ LFKVWHLJHQZLOOQLFKWNRPPWOlXIWGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGH)HVWOHJXQJLQV/HH UH XQG DQGHUHUVHLWV GXUFK NRQNXUULHUHQGH $EVLFKWHQ GLH VLFK DXIJUXQG DQGHUHU *UQGH LQQHUKDOE GHU LQWHQWLRQDOHQ 6WUXNWXU GHV +DQGHOQGHQ GXUFKVHW]HQXQGGLHXUVSUQJOLFKH)HVWOHJXQJDQQXOOLHUHQ$XIGDVGDPLW YHUEXQGHQH3UREOHPGHU:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHZHUGHLFKQRFKLQ HLQJH KHQ ,P)ROJHQGHQJHKWHVPLUQXQZHQLJHUXPGLH&KDUDNWHULVLHUXQJGHV SURSRVLWLRQDOHQ*HKDOWVVRZLHGDVGDPLWYHUEXQGHQH3UREOHPGHU2EMHN WLYLWlW 1XU XP 0LYHUVWlQGQLVVHQ YRU]XEHXJHQ VHL KLHU DQJHPHUNW GD GLH2EMHNWLYLWlWGDVLQGLVSRQLEOH0RPHQWGHU(UNHQQWQLVQDFK%UDQGRP QLFKW LPQLFKWVSUDFKOLFKHQ%HUHLFK F ]X ILQGHQ LVWVRQGHUQ LP *HKDOW GHU 'LVNXUVQRUPHQ D GHU GDPLW LP *HJHQVDW] ]XU ELQGHQGHQ .UDIW GLHVHU 1RUPHQ QLFKW GHU $XWRULWlW GHU 6SUHFKHU XQWHUOLHJW ,P .RQWH[W VHLQHU +HJHO,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ YHUGHXWOLFKW %UDQGRP GLHV IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å>@WKHGHWHUPLQDF\RIWKHFRQWHQWRIZKDW\RXKDYHFRPPLWWHG\RXUVHOI WR²WKHSDUWWKDWLVQRWXSWR\RXLQWKHZD\WKDWZKHWKHU\RXFRPPLW\RXU VHOIWRLWLVXSWR\RX²LVVHFXUHGE\WKHDWWLWXGHVRIRWKHUVWRZKRPRQH KDV DW OHDVW LPSOLFLWO\ JUDQWHG WKDW DXWKRULW\ >@ +DYLQJ D FRPPLWPHQW ZLWKDGHILQLWHFRQWHQWLVLQWHOOLJLEOH>@RQO\LQWKHFRQWH[WRIDGLYLVLRQRI ODERXUEHWZHHQWKHRQHZKRXQGHUWDNHVWKHFRPPLWPHQWDQGWKRVHZKR
_____________ 9JOGD]X%UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
DWWULEXWHLWDQGKROGWKHXQGHUWDNHUWRLW,JHWWRGHFLGHZKLFKSLHFHLQWKH JDPH,ZLOOSOD\>@EXW,GRQRWWKHQJHWWRGHFLGHZKDW,KDYHFRPPLW WHG P\VHOI WR WKHUHE\ ZKDW IXUWKHU PRYHV DUH DSSURSULDWH RU REOLJDWRU\ IRURQHZKRKDVSOD\HGWKDWSLHFH0\DXWKRULW\LVUHDOEXWLWLVSDUWLDO´
_____________ %UDQGRP YJO ]X %UDQGRPV 3URMHNWLHUXQJ GHU LQIHUHQWLDOLVWLVFKHQ (UNOl UXQJYRQ5HSUlVHQWDWLRQHQDXFK%UDQGRP D VRZLH]XU'XUFKIKUXQJGLH VHV3URJUDPPVGDVHLQVFKOlJLJH.DSLWHOÅ'DV=XVFKUHLEHQSURSRVLWLRQDOHU(LQVWHO OXQJHQ 'HU VR]LDOH :HJ YRP %HJUQGHQ ]XP 5HSUlVHQWLHUHQ´ LQ %UDQGRP D :HQQLFKULFKWLJVHKHGDQQVLQGYRUDOOHPGLHLQIHUHQWLHOOH6HPDQWLNXQGGLHEHUGHQ :DKUKHLWVEHJULII GDPLW YHUEXQGHQH 7KHRULH GHU 2EMHNWLYLWlW =LHOH GHU .ULWLN DQ %UDQGRPV .RQ]HSW YJO XD 0DFEHWK 0F'RZHOO 5RVHQEHUJ 5RUW\ QRFKPDOV5RUW\ GHUIUGDV9HUVWlQGQLV%UDQGRPVHU KHOOHQGH 8QWHUVFKLHGH ]X 'DYLGVRQ HUOlXWHUW HLQHP *HZlKUVPDQQ %UDQGRPV GHU GHP %HJULII GHU 5HSUlVHQWDWLRQ HEHQIDOOV GDV WKHRUHWLVFKH (UNOlUXQJVJHZLFKW DE]X QHKPHQEHVWUHEWLVW YJO'DYLGVRQ VRGDQQHKHUDSRORJH WLVFK (VIHOG +DEHUPDV DXI GLHVHQ XQG %UDQGRP EH]XJQHKPHQG /D IRQW E ZHLWHUKLQ*OHU .QHOO D 5|GO 6FKHOOHQEHUJ :LQJHUW %HUWUDP/LSWRZ 5RVHQNUDQ] VRZLH7LHW] 9JO DXFK %UDQGRPV Å5HSOLHV´ E DXI HLQLJH GHU YRUJHQDQQWHQ .ULWLNHU VRZLH VHLQ Å5HSO\ WR +DEHUPDV´ E 0LW %OLFN DXI GLH 2EMHNWLYLWlW YRQ *UQGHQ ² DXFK +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ²EHPHUNW%UDQGRP)ROJHQGHV Å$OVHLQ*UXQGLVW]XQlFKVWHLQ PDOGDV]XYHUVWHKHQZDVHLQH*HPHLQVFKDIWLQGHU3UD[LVDOVVROFKHQ*UXQGEHKDQ GHOWXQGGDVJLOWIUGLHSUDNWLVFKH6HLWHGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHHEHQVRZLHIUGLHWKH RUHWLVFKH 6HLWH GHU *UQGH IU %HKDXSWXQJHQ ,Q NHLQHP GHU EHLGHQ )lOOH LVW GLHVHU =XJDQJ]XPQRUPDWLYHQ6WDWXV ZR]XPDQZLUNOLFKEHUHFKWLJWRGHUIHVWJHOHJWLVW EHU GLH QRUPDWLYH (LQVWHOOXQJ ZR]X PDQ DOV EHUHFKWLJW RGHU IHVWJHOHJW JLOW XQYHUHLQEDU GDPLWDP(QGHYRQREMHNWLYHQ1RUPHQVSUHFKHQ]XN|QQHQGLHGLH0|JOLFKNHLWVWW ]HQ GD GLH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DOOHU LKQHQ JHJHQEHU IDOVFK VHLQ N|QQHQ 'RFK ZDV PLW VROFKHQREMHNWLYHQ5LFKWLJNHLWHQJHPHLQWVHLQN|QQWH²ZDVZLUNOLFKHLQJXWHU*UXQG LVWXQGQLFKWEORDOVHLQVROFKHUEHKDQGHOWZLUG²ZLUGVLFKHUVWDP(QGHHUZHLVHQ´ %UDQGRPD 'LHVHV(QGH²EHL%UDQGRPLVWHVGDV(QGHVHLQHV%XFKHVHL QHUVHLWV XQG GLH 3HUVSHNWLYH GHV +HJHO·VFKHQ ÄDEVROXWHQ :LVVHQV¶ DQGHUHUVHLWV YJO %UDQGRPD VRZLH ²EHWULIIWHLQ,GHDO,FKZHUGH%UDQGRPV .RQ]HSW YRQ 2EMHNWLYLWlW KLHU ZHGHU GLVNXWLHUHQ QRFK ZHUGH LFK HV LPSOL]LW EHDQ VSUXFKHQ PWH LFK PLFK MHGRFK DXI HLQ .RQ]HSW WKHRUHWLVFKHU 2EMHNWLYLWlW XQG GDPLW YHUEXQGHQ HLQ :DKUKHLWVNRQ]HSW WKHRUHWLVFKHU hEHU]HXJXQJHQ IHVWOHJHQ VR WHQGLHUWH LFK ]X +DEHUPDV· ÅSUDJPDWLVWLVFKH>U@ $XIIDVVXQJ´ YRQ :DKUKHLW DOV ÅLGHDO JHUHFKWIHUWLJWH$N]HSWDELOLWlW´GLHVLFKDXIHLQHDOVXQYHUIJEDUXQGLGHQWLVFKXQWHU VWHOOWH:HOWEH]LHKW Å6SUDFKVSLHOHXQG3UDNWLNHQEHZlKUHQVLFKDPZHLWHUHQÄ)XQNWL RQLHUHQ¶ DOVR GXUFK GHQ JHOLQJHQGHQ 9ROO]XJ VHOEVW :HQQ VLH VFKHLWHUQ VSLHOW GLH :HOW QLFKW PHKU LQ GHU HUZDUWHWHQ :HLVH PLW $Q GLHVHP SUDNWLVFK HUIDKUHQHQ 'H PHQWLHLQHV0LHUIROJVPLWGHPGLH:HOWSHUIRUPDWLYLKUH%HUHLWVFKDIW]XP0LWVSLH OHQZLGHUUXIWELOGHWVLFKGHU%HJULIIGHU2EMHNWLYLWlW'LHVHUHUVWUHFNWVLFKHLQHUVHLWV DXIGLH5HVLVWHQ]HLQHUXQYHUIJEDUHQ:HOWGLHXQVHUHQ0DQLSXODWLRQHQLKUHQ(LJHQ VLQQ HQWJHJHQVHW]W DQGHUHUVHLWV DXI GLH ,GHQWLWlW HLQHU IU DOOH JHPHLQVDPHQ :HOW :HLOVLFKKDQGHOQGH6XEMHNWHLQLKUHU.RRSHUDWLRQJHJHQVHLWLJXQWHUVWHOOHQGDVLFK MHGHUDXVVHLQHU3HUSHNWLYHDXIGLHVHOEH:HOWEH]LHKWÄJLEWHV¶GLH:HOWQXULP6LQJX ODU´ +DEHUPDV Å8QYHUIJEDUNHLWXQG,GHQWLWlWGHU:HOWVLQGGLHEHLGHQ%H
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
1RUPDWLYH6WDWXVXQGQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
1RUPDWLYH6WDWXVXQGQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
6WDWWXPGLHVH3UREOHPDWLNGHU2EMHNWLYLWlWVROOHVQXQVSH]LILVFKHUXPGLH PLWGLHVHULQIHUHQWLHOOHQ6HPDQWLNYHUNQSIWHQRUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLNJHKHQ (LQ SURSRVLWLRQDOHU *HKDOW WULWW QLFKW LVROLHUW DOV VROFKHU DXI VRQGHUQ LVW VWHWVDQHLQHEHVWLPPWH3HUIRUPDQ]HLQHGLVNXUVLYH3UD[LVJHNQSIW0LW GLHVHU$XIIDVVXQJYHUELQGHW%UDQGRPHLQJHZLVVHV3ULPDWGHU3UDJPDWLN YRUGHU6HPDQWLNZHQQJOHLFKLQVHLQHU.RQ]HSWLRQEHLGHVHKUHQJPLWHLQ DQGHUYHUEXQGHQXQGDXIHLQDQGHUEH]RJHQVLQG Å0LW6lW]HQXQGDQGHUHQ VSUDFKOLFKHQ $XVGUFNHQ NDQQ PDQ YLHOHUOHL YHUELQGHQ (LQH VHPDQWLVFKH 9HUELQGXQJ OLHJW JHQDX GDQQ YRU ZHQQ PDQ PLW LKU GLH 5LFKWLJNHLWHQ HUNOlUHQ NDQQ GLH GHQ *HEUDXFK GLHVHU $XVGUFNH OHLWHQ >@ 2KQH HLQH 3UDJPDWLNGLHHUNOlUWZDVHVKHLWGDHLQ*HKDOWRGHUHLQH3URSRVLWLRQ DXVJHGUFNWZLUG>@NDQQGLH%HUHFKWLJXQJGHV7KHRUHWLNHUV]XGHU)HVW OHJXQJ GLH HU HLQJHKW ZHQQ HU GLHVH 9HUELQGXQJHQ DOV VHPDQWLVFKH EH KDQGHOW DQJHIRFKWHQ ZHUGHQ 'LH 6HPDQWLN PX VLFK DQ GHU 3UDJPDWLN RULHQWLHUHQXQGGLH*HKDOW]XVFKUHLEXQJDQ(UNOlUXQJHQGHV*HEUDXFKV´ ,FK ZHUGH LP IROJHQGHQ GLHVH 9HUNQSIXQJ VHPDQWLVFKHU XQG SUDJPDWL VFKHU $VSHNWH LP %HJULII GHV :LVVHQV NXU] VWUHLIHQ GD GHU QRUPDWLY SUDJPDWLVFKH$QVDW]%UDQGRPVJUXQGOHJHQGQLFKWQXUIUVHLQH3HUVSHN WLYHDXIHSLVWHPRORJLVFKHVRQGHUQDXFKDXISUDNWLVFKH)UDJHVWHOOXQJHQLVW XPGLHHVPLUHLJHQWOLFKJHKW 'HU :LW] YRQ %UDQGRPV .RQ]HSWLRQ LVW GDEHL GD HU VLFK GHU 6SUDFKSUDJPDWLN EHU HLQHQ SHUVRQDOHQ RGHU JHQDXHU VR]LDOHQ 8PZHJ QlKHUW HLQHU Ä(LQEH]LHKXQJ GHV $QGHUHQ¶ XP HLQH :HQGXQJ +DEHUPDV· ]XJHEUDXFKHQ6WDWWGLHSUDJPDWLVFKH'LPHQVLRQGHV6SUHFKDNWVGLUHNW]X XQWHUVXFKHQ IUDJW %UDQGRP Å:DV WXW PDQ ZHQQ PDQ GDYRQ DXVJHKW GD MHPDQG :LVVHQ EHVLW]W"´ 0LW GLHVHU LQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH HLQHUSUDJPDWLVFKHQXQGVR]LDOHQ2SHUDWLRQDOLVLHUXQJGHV:LVVHQVEHJULIIV JHOLQJWHV%UDQGRPMHQHQP\VWHUL|VHQ,QWURVSHNWLRQLVPXVGHQGHUVSlWH :LWWJHQVWHLQ]X5HFKWNULWLVLHUWKDW]XXPJHKHQRKQHGDEHL=XIOXFKWEHL HLQHU TXDVLREMHNWLYHQ 6FKLHGVULFKWHUSHUVSHNWLYH ]X VXFKHQ 1HEHQ GHU 6FKLHGVULFKWHUSHUVSHNWLYHLVWDXFKHLQH,FK:LU3HUVSHNWLYHPLWLKUHUÅP\ WKRORJLVFKHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJ YRQ *HPHLQVFKDIWHQ´ DXV]XVFKHLGHQ GLH GDV ,QGLYLGXXP GHQ LQ HLQHU *HVHOOVFKDIW IDNWLVFK JHOWHQGHQ 1RUPHQ RSSR
_____________
VWLPPXQJHQYRQÄ2EMHNWLYLWlW¶>«@µ (EG YJODXFKHEG $XIGLHVSH ]LILVFKSUDNWLVFKH)RUPYRQ8QYHUIJEDUNHLWZHUGHLFKLQ]XUFNNRPPHQ %UDQGRPD %UDQGRP +LHUDXIKDEHQEHUHLWV+DDJ6WXUP XQG KLQJHZLHVHQ %UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
QLHUW 6WDWWGHVVHQ EHKDUUW %UDQGRP DXI HLQHU ,FK'X3HUVSHNWLYH GHUHQ 3RLQWH JHUDGH QLFKW LQ HLQHU ZLH DXFK LPPHU DUWLNXOLHUWHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOL FKHQ1RUPVRQGHUQLQGHPVWHWVLQGLYLGXHOO]XDNWXDOLVLHUHQGHQÄ.RQWR VWDQG¶ QRUPDWLYHU 6WDWXV EHVWHKW %UDQGRP VSULFKW KLHUEHL YRQ HLQHP Å>@ 2ULHQWLHUXQJVIHKOHU >@ ,FKZLU%H]LHKXQJHQ VWDWW ,FKGX %H]LHKXQJHQDOVGLHJUXQGOHJHQGHVR]LDOH6WUXNWXU]XEHKDQGHOQ%HXUWHL OHQ%LOOLJHQXVZVLQGDOOHV'LQJHGLHZLU(LQ]HOQHWXQXQGHLQDQGHU]X HUNHQQHQ XQG ZRGXUFK HLQH *HPHLQVFKDIW HLQ Ä:LU¶ HQWVWHKW´ 0LW GLHVHPZHLWUHLFKHQGHQ,QGLYLGXDOLVPXVLVWQHEHQEHLHLQZHLWHUHU.RQYHU JHQ]SXQNW ]ZLVFKHQ .DQWV XQG %UDQGRPV 7KHRULHQ GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW DQ JHGHXWHW GHU LP HLQHQ )DOO DXI LQGLYLGXHOOH $XWRQRPLH LP DQGHUHQ )DOO DXILQGLYLGXHOOHGHRQWLVFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQEH]RJHQLVW'DOHW]WHUH%UDQ GRP QLFKW ]XJOHLFK DXI .DQWV 0RQRORJLVPXV IHVWOHJHQ VHOEVW ZHQQ VLH HLQHQ%HJULIIYRQ$XWRQRPLHLQVWDQ]LLHUHQZLUGDXVVHLQHUIXQGDPHQWDOHQ 'LVNXUVRULHQWLHUXQJGHXWOLFK ,Q GHU $QWZRUW DXI GLH )UDJH Å:DV WXW PDQ ZHQQ PDQ GDYRQ DXV JHKW GD MHPDQG :LVVHQ EHVLW]W"´ RULHQWLHUW VLFK %UDQGRP QXQ DQ GHU NODVVLVFKHQ*:h7KHRULHZRQDFK:LVVHQDOVJHUHFKWIHUWLJWHZDKUHhEHU ]HXJXQJYHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQNDQQXQGUHIRUPXOLHUWGLHVH7KHRULHLQGHRQ WLVFKHQ7HUPLQL ZHQQLFKGDYRQDXVJHKHGDHLQH3HUVRQ:LVVHQEHVLW]W ZHLVH LFK LKU HLQH hEHU]HXJXQJ ]X DOVR HLQH SURSRVLWLRQDO JHKDOWYROOH )HVWOHJXQJGLHVRZRKODOV3UlPLVVHDOVDXFKDOV.RQNOXVLRQYRQ,QIHUHQ]HQ GLHQHQNDQQ LFKZHLVHLKUGDUEHUKLQDXVHLQH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XGLHVHUhEHU ]HXJXQJ ]X XQG ELOOLJH DXHUGHP GLH %HKDXSWXQJ VHOEVW GK LFK VHOEVW JHKHGLHVHOEH)HVWOHJXQJDXFKHLQ 0LW GHQ %HJULIIHQ GHU )HVWOHJXQJ XQG GHU %HUHFKWLJXQJ VLQG EHUHLWV ]ZHL IU GLH 7KHRULH HQWVFKHLGHQGH GHRQWLVFKH7HUPLQL EHQDQQW XQG GLH HUNHQQWQLVWKHRUHWLVFKH 3HUVSHNWLYH XP HLQH VR]LDOH 'LPHQVLRQ HUZHLWHUW 8P GHQ PDJHEOLFKHQ 8QWHUVFKLHG ]X UHSUlVHQWDWLRQDOLVWLVFKHQ (SLVWH
_____________ 9JO GDJHJHQ +DEHUPDV XQG VRZLH %UDQGRPV Å5HSO\´ E %UDQGRP D +DEHUPDV· GLHVEH]JOLFKH 6NHSVLV JHJHQEHU %UDQGRPV Ä,FK 'X%H]LHKXQJHQ¶ ² Å>«@ WDWVlFKOLFK NRQVWUXLHUW HU GLHVH DEHU DOV %H]LHKXQJHQ ]ZL VFKHQHLQHUHUVWHQ3HUVRQGLHVLFKDXIGLH:DKUKHLWHLQHU$XVVDJHIHVWOHJWXQGHLQHU GULWWHQ3HUVRQGLHGHUDQGHUHQ²XQWHU9RUEHKDOWHLQHUHLJHQHQ%HXUWHLOXQJ²HLQHQ :DKUKHLWVDQVSUXFK ]XVFKUHLEW´ +DEHUPDV ² NDQQ LFK QLFKW WHLOHQ %UDQ GRPV%HJULIIGHU=XVFKUHLEXQJOlWVLFKPHLQHV(UDFKWHQVYHUOXVWORVHUVHW]HQGXUFK $XVGUFNH ZLH ÄbXHUXQJHQ DXIIDVVHQ DOV¶ Ä3HUVRQHQ YHUVWHKHQEHKDQGHOQ DOV¶ XQG GLHVH $XVGUFNH VLQG QXQ WDWVlFKOLFK ZHLW HQWIHUQW YRQ GHU EORHQ %HREDFKWHUSHU VSHNWLYHYLHOPHKUDUWLNXOLHUWVLFKLQLKQHQQHEHQGLHVHU%HREDFKWHUSHUVSHNWLYHLUUHGX ]LEHODXFKGLH7HLOQHKPHUSHUVSHNWLYH 9JOGD]X%UDQGRPD VRZLH%UDQGRP
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
1RUPDWLYH6WDWXVXQGQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
PRORJLHQ]XPDUNLHUHQEHGDUIHVDEHUGDUEHUKLQDXVHLQHUNXU]HQ(UOlX WHUXQJGHV%HJULIIVGHUQRUPDWLYHQ(LQVWHOOXQJÅ>@GLHZLUDQGHUHQJHJHQ EHULQHLQHU3UD[LVHLQQHKPHQLQGHPZLUVLHQlPOLFKDOVIHVWJHOHJWRGHU EHUHFKWLJW>@DXIIDVVHQEHKDQGHOQRGHUDXIVLHUHDJLHUHQ´:LVVHQZLUG GDQDFKQLFKWXQWHU5HNXUVDXISULPLWLYH9RUVWHOOXQJHQGLHLPÄ*HLVW¶HLQHU 3HUVRQ DQJHWURIIHQ XQG DXI EHVWLPPWHQ :HJHQ NRQ]HSWXDOLVLHUW XQG NRPPXQL]LHUWZHUGHQVRQGHUQXQWHU5HNXUVDXI=XVFKUHLEXQJHQHSLVWH PLVFKHU XQG DXFK SUDNWLVFKHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ YRQ3HUVRQHQ DQ 3HUVRQHQ HUNOlUW.RPPXQLNDWLRQXQGDOOJHPHLQVR]LDOH3UDNWLNHQN|QQHQDOV,Q WHUDNWLRQHQ DXIJHIDW ZHUGHQ Å>«@ LQ GHQHQ MHGHU 7HLOQHKPHU YHUVFKLH GHQH GHRQWLVFKH 6WDWXV KDW ² G K )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ² XQGMHGHSUDNWLVFKVLJQLILNDQWH3HUIRUPDQ]YHUlQGHUWLQLUJHQGHLQHU:HLVH GLHVH6WDWXV´'RFKVLQGGLHVH6WDWXVQLFKWHVVHQWLDOLVWLVFK]XYHUVWHKHQ DOVHWZDVZDVGLHVH3HUVRQHQVFKOHFKWKLQEHVLW]HQXQGVLHLQVRIHUQNHQQ ]HLFKQHW 9LHOPHKU KlQJHQ GLHVH 6WDWXV YRQ GHU MHZHLOLJHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH HLQHU3HUVRQ$DXIHLQH3HUVRQ%VRZLHYRQGHU3HUVSHNWLYHGLHVHU3HUVRQ %DXIGLH3HUVRQ$DE Å'LH3UDNWLNHUEHWUDFKWHQRGHUEHKDQGHOQVLFKXQG DQGHUHDOVLP%HVLW]YRQYHUVFKLHGHQHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ 6LHIKUHQ.RQWREHUGLHGHRQWLVFKHQ6WDWXVLQGHPVLHVLHDQGHUHQ]XZHL VHQ XQG VHOEVW HLQQHKPHQ 'LH 6LJQLILNDQ] HLQHV $NWHV EHVWHKW LQ GHP 8QWHUVFKLHGGHQHUIUGDVGHRQWLVFKH.RQWRPDFKW²GDVKHLWZLHHU GHQ 6WDQG GHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ YHUlQGHUW GLH VLFK GLH 3UDNWLNHU HLQVFKOLHOLFK GHV $JLHUHQGHQ JHJHQVHLWLJ ]XHUNHQQHQ XQG VHOEVWHUZHUEHQDQHUNHQQHQRGHUHLQJHKHQ´'HUQRUPDWLYH6WDWXVHLQHU )HVWOHJXQJGHU3HUVRQ$DXIGLHhEHU]HXJXQJVZLUGDOVRHUZRUEHQGXUFK GLHQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJGHV$QHUNHQQHQVE]Z(LQJHKHQVGLHVHU)HVWOHJXQJ DXIVGXUFKGLH3HUVRQ$VHOEVWVRZLHGXUFKGLHQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJGHV =XHUNHQQHQVE]Z=XZHLVHQVGLHVHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIVGXUFK PLQGHVWHQV HLQH 3HUVRQ%'HUQRUPDWLYH6WDWXVGHU%HUHFKWLJXQJGHU3HUVRQ$]XVZLUG HUZRUEHQGXUFKGLHQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJGHV$QHUNHQQHQVGLHVHU%HUHFK
_____________ %UDQGRPDI %UDQGRPD %UDQGRPD YJOHEG Å'DVQRUPDWLYH+DXVKDWYLHOH:RKQXQJHQ'LH KLHU LQWHUHVVLHUHQGHQ 1RUPHQ VLQG GLH GLVNXUVLYHQ QRUPDWLYHQ 6WDWXV MHQH )HVWOHJXQ JHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQGLHEHLP*HEUDXFKYRQ%HJULIIHQHLQH5ROOHVSLHOHQ'LHVH 1RUPHQVRZLUGEHKDXSWHWZHUGHQGXUFKVR]LDOH3UDNWLNHQHWDEOLHUW'LHVVLQG3UDN WLNHQ GLH GLH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ GHU VR]LDOHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH ]ZLVFKHQ ]ZHL $UWHQ SUDNWL VFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJ GLH PDQ JHJHQEHU HLQHU )HVWOHJXQJ HLQQHKPHQ NDQQ HQWKDOWHQ GHV 6HOEVW $QHUNHQQHQV XQG GHV (LQHPDQGHUHQ =XHUNHQQHV´ 9JO DXFK HEG
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
WLJXQJ]XVGXUFKGLH3HUVRQ$VHOEVWVRZLHGXUFKGLHQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHO OXQJGHV=XHUNHQQHQVE]Z=XZHLVHQVGLHVHU%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XVGXUFK PLQ GHVWHQV HLQH3HUVRQ% 'D HLQH QRUPDWLYH (LQVWHOOXQJ QLFKW H[SOL]LHUW ZHUGHQ PX DEHU H[SOL]LHUWZHUGHQNDQQLVWHLQ]HQWUDOHV0HUNPDOGHUDXI6SUDFKSUDJPDWLN NRQ]HQWULHUWHQ.RQ]HSWLRQ%UDQGRPV Å9RQ:LWWJHQVWHLQV3UDJPDWLVPXV PLW %OLFN DXI GDV 1RUPDWLYH OHUQHQ ]X ZROOHQ KHLW GDV %HXUWHLOHQ DOV HWZDV ZDV JHWDQ ZLUG YHUVWHKHQ ]X PVVHQ GLH QRUPDWLYH (LQVWHOOXQJ PXDOVHWZDVLQGHU3UD[LVGHV%HXUWHLOHQGHQLUJHQGZLHLPSOL]W(QWKDOWH QHVDXIJHIDWZHUGHQXQGQLFKWDOVGLHH[SOL]LWH%LOOLJXQJHLQHU3URSRVLWL RQ´:HQQZLUDOVRQDFK*UQGHQIUDJHQRGHUJHIUDJWZHUGHQVRNDQQ GLHVGLH)RUGHUXQJEHGHXWHQHWZDVH[SOL]LW]XPDFKHQZDVLPSOL]LWLQGHU LQWHUGHSHQGHQWHQ6WUXNWXUXQVHUHUhEHU]HXJXQJHQHQWKDOWHQLVW 'LHVR]LDOH2SHUDWLRQDOLVLHUXQJYRQ6HPDQWLNXQG3UDJPDWLNEHVWHKW KLHU GHPQDFK GDULQ GD HUVWHQV ]ZHL (OHPHQWH GHU *:h7KHRULH GHV :LVVHQV LP 0RGXV GHV =XZHLVHQV HLQHU )HVWOHJXQJ XQG HLQHU %HUHFKWL JXQJHLQHU3HUVRQ$GXUFKHLQH3HUVRQ%XQG]ZHLWHQVGDVGULWWH(OHPHQW LP0RGXVGHV(LQJHKHQVHLQHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJGXUFKGLH3HU VRQ%UHIRUPXOLHUWZHUGHQ 3HUVRQ%JHKWGDYRQDXVGD3HUVRQ$GHQ:LVVHQVJHKDOWVEHVLW]W ZHQQ L 3HUVRQ%GHU3HUVRQ$GLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLHhEHU]HXJXQJV]XZHLVW LL 3HUVRQ%GHU3HUVRQ$GLH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XGHUhEHU]HXJXQJV]XZHLVW LLL 3HUVRQ%VHOEVWGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLHhEHU]HXJXQJVHLQJHKW 1DFKGHP*:h6FKHPDGHV:LVVHQVEH]LHKWVLFK L DXIGLHhEHU]HXJXQJ LL DXIGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGLHVHUhEHU]HXJXQJXQG LLL DXIGLH:DKUKHLWGLHVHU hEHU]HXJXQJ :lKUHQG L GLH =XZHLVXQJ HLQHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH hEHU]HXJXQJDQJHVLFKWVHLQHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ 6SUHFK +DQGOXQJXQPLW WHOEDU YHUVWlQGOLFK HUVFKHLQW VROOWH ]X LL XQG LLL QRFK )ROJHQGHV EH PHUNWZHUGHQ =X LL %UDQGRPV ÅOLQJXLVWLVFKHU 5DWLRQDOLVPXV´ JHKW ZLH EHUHLWV DQJHGHXWHW QLFKW VRZHLW GD HU HLQH MHZHLOLJH H[SOL]LWH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ IRUGHUQZUGH,Q$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW.DQWVÅ5HJXOLVPXV´ Ä%HJULIIH DOV H[SOL]LWH 5HJHOQ¶ XQG GHP Å5HJXODULVPXV´ GHV VSlWHQ :LWWJHQVWHLQ GHU 9RUVWHOOXQJ YRQ JHEUDXFKVLPSOL]LWHQ QLFKWVWDWLVFKHQ 5HJHOQ Ä5H
_____________ 'LHVH$QHUNHQQXQJGHUHLJHQHQ%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XVPDFKWGDV(OHPHQWGHU:DKUKDI WLJNHLWDQHLQHU:LVVHQVlXHUXQJDXV YJOGD]X3ROORN %UDQGRP D YJO DXFK %UDQGRP D 9JO GD]X DXFK 3ROORN 0V 9JONULWLVFKGD]XGLHLQ)QJHQDQQWHQ$XWRUHQVRZLH/DQFH %UDQGRP
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
1RUPDWLYH6WDWXVXQGQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
JUHDUJXPHQW JHJHQ GDV 5HJHOIROJHQ¶ HQWZLFNHOW HU HLQH 7KHRULH GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ GLH DXI GLH VR]LDOH 3HUVSHNWLYH ² LQNOXVLYH EHXUWHLOHQGHU SRVLWLYHU RGHU QHJDWLYHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DOV 6DQNWLRQHQ ² DEKHEW VRZLH IUGLH)lOOHLQGHQHQHLQH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJQLFKWJHIRUGHUWXQGRGHUJHOLH IHUW ZLUG HLQH QLFKWQDWXUDOLVWLVFKH 9DULDQWH GHU 9HUOlOLFKNHLWVWKHRULH ZRQDFKGLH9HUOlOLFKNHLWHLQHUEHKDXSWHQGHQ3HUVRQXQWHU(LQEH]LHKXQJ GHUVLHDOVYHUOlOLFKEHKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQQRUPDWLYNRQ]LSLHUWZLUGNRQ NUHW GHP (LQJHKHQ GHUVHOEHQ %HKDXSWXQJ GXUFK GLH 3HUVRQ % GLH GHU 3HUVRQ$:LVVHQ]XVFKUHLEW =X LLL $Q %UDQGRPV :DKUKHLWVWKHRULH LVW LKUH PHWKRGLVFKH Ä3DV VXQJ¶DXIIlOOLJGHQQJHPlGHPYRQLKPKLQVLFKWOLFKGHUÅSUDJPDWLVFKHQ .UDIW´JHOWHQGJHPDFKWHQÅ9RUUDQJGHV3URSRVLWLRQDOHQ´YRUÅVXEVHQWHQ WLDOHQ $XVGUFNHQ´ HUJLEW VLFK HLQH 5HIHUHQ]WKHRULH VXEVHQWHQWLDOHU $XV GUFNHHLQH7KHRULHGHU2EMHNWLYLWlWHUVWDXVGHU:DKUKHLWVWKHRULHQLFKW XPJHNHKUW Å*HZ|KQOLFKH$XVVDJHQGDUEHUZDVZDKUXQGIDOVFKLVWXQG ZRUDXIVLFKHLQ$XVGUXFNEH]LHKWVLQGVRZLHVLHVLQGY|OOLJLQ2UGQXQJ GLHDQDSKRULVFKH$QDO\VHHUNOlUWZLHVLH]XYHUVWHKHQVLQG>«@(LQH%H KDXSWXQJ DOV ZDKU ]X EHWUDFKWHQ PX ]XDOOHUHUVW DOV GDV hEHUQHKPHQ HLQHUQRUPDWLYHQ(LQVWHOOXQJYHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQ²HLQH%HKDXSWXQJJXW ]XKHLHQXQGGDPLWHLQH)HVWOHJXQJDQ]XHUNHQQHQ'LHVHQRUPDWLYH(LQ VWHOOXQJ ZLUG YRUDXVJHVHW]W ZHQQ HLQH REMHNWLYH (LJHQVFKDIW ]XJHVFKULH EHQ ZHUGHQ VROO XQG LVW QLFKW HWZD DQKDQG YRQ GLHVHU ]X HUNOlUHQ >«@ 'LH H[SUHVVLYH .UDIW YRQ ÄZDKU¶ VRUJW GDIU GD HLQH %HKDXSWXQJ GLH HLQHP *HJHQVWDQG HLQH REMHNWLYH (LJHQVFKDIW ]XVFKUHLEW PLW 5HFKW DOV REMHNWLYZDKURGHUIDOVFKEH]HLFKQHWZHUGHQNDQQ´6HLQWRSGRZQ=X JDQJIKUW%UDQGRPDOVRYRP%HJULIIGHU:DKUKHLW]XGHPGHU5HIHUHQ] GLH YRP :DKUKHLWVEHJULII JHIRUGHUWH Å(LQVWHOOXQJV7UDQV]HQGHQ]´ YHU VXFKW%UDQGRPPLWWHOVGHUGHRQWLVFKHQ'LIIHUHQ]HQ]ZLVFKHQGHGLFWRXQG GHUH=XVFKUHLEXQJHQ E]Z ]ZLVFKHQ %HKDXSWEDUNHLWV XQG :DKUKHLWVEH GLQJXQJHQ ]X EHVFKUHLEHQ 'LH ZDKUKHLWVWKHRUHWLVFKH 'LPHQVLRQ YRQ %UDQGRPV 7KHRULH ZLUG ZLH EHUHLWV EHPHUNW NRQWURYHUV GLVNXWLHUW VLH VWHKW MHGRFK QLFKW LP =HQWUXP PHLQHU JHJHQZlUWLJHQ $XVHLQDQGHUVHW ]XQJ
_____________
9JO%UDQGRPD 9JOHEG 9JOHEG %UDQGRPI %UDQGRPD %UDQGRP 9JOGD]XGHQ]ZHLWHQ7HLOYRQ%UDQGRPDLQVEHVRQGHUH.DS 9JOGD]XGLHLQ)QDQJHJHEHQH/LWHUDWXU
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
$XFKN|QQHQLPIROJHQGHQGLHPLWGHP*:h6FKHPDYHUEXQGHQHQ .RQWURYHUVHQ ² HV JLEW QDWUOLFK VRZRKO ]X MHGHP GLHVHU %HJULIIH GHU hEHU]HXJXQJGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJXQGGHU:DKUKHLWDOVDXFK]XGHUGDUDXV UHVXOWLHUHQGHQ7KHRULHGHV:LVVHQVLQVJHVDPWHLQJDQ]HV%QGHOGLYHUJLH UHQGHU$OWHUQDWLYWKHRULHQ²XQEHUFNVLFKWLJWEOHLEHQLQVRIHUQKLHUQXUGDV ,QHLQDQGHUJUHLIHQ GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlWVEHVWLPPXQJHQ²)HVWOHJXQJXQG%H UHFKWLJXQJ²DOV0HWKRGLNIUGLH7KHPDWLNGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHIUXFKWEDU JHPDFKW ZHUGHQ VROO 'LH *OWLJNHLW GHV DXI 3ODWRQV 0HQRQ D II ]X UFNJHKHQGHQ*:h0RGHOOVGHV:LVVHQVZLUGDOVRIUGDV:HLWHUHQLFKW YRUDXVJHVHW]W )UPHLQJHJHQZlUWLJHV$QOLHJHQLVWOHGLJOLFKGLHVHQWVFKHLGHQG 1RU PDWLYLWlW NRPPW QDFK %UDQGRP QLFKW DN]LGHQWHOO ]X EHVWLPPWHQ PRUDOL VFKHQ )RUPHQ VR]LDOHU 3UD[LV KLQ]X VRQGHUQ EHVFKUHLEW GLH *UXQGODJH MHJOLFKHU.RPPXQLNDWLRQ'DV7RUGXUFKZHOFKHV1RUPDWLYLWlW(LQJDQJ ILQGHW LQ GLH PHQVFKOLFKH .RPPXQLNDWLRQ XQG GDPLW GLHVH EHUKDXSW HUVW DOVVROFKH NRQVWLWXLHUW VLQG GLH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GHV =XZHLVHQV XQG$QHU NHQQHQVYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQ1RUPDWLYH6WDWXV DOVR GLH LQWHUVXEMHNWLYUHODWLRQDOHQ Å.RQVWHOODWLRQHQ YRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ´ ELOGHQ GLH *UXQGODJH PHQVFKOLFKHQ 6SUHFKHQV :LVVHQVXQG+DQGHOQV²LPSOL]LWRGHUH[SOL]LW'DGLHVH6WDWXVGXUFKGLH GLVNXUVLYH 3UD[LV JHVWLIWHW ZHUGHQ NDQQ PDQ YRQ OHW]WHUHU LQ %UDQGRPV .RQ]HSWLRQ DOV GHU Ä4XHOOH GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW¶ XP .RUVJDDUGV $XVGUXFN VLQJXODULVFK]XYHUZHQGHQVSUHFKHQ=XJOHLFKPVVHQDEHUGDV=XZHLVHQ XQG $QHUNHQQHQ GHRQWLVFKHU 6WDWXV LQ GHU $OOWDJVNRPPXQLNDWLRQ QLFKW VWlQGLJH[SOL]LHUWZHUGHQ(VYHUKlOWVLFKYLHOPHKUVR²XQGGDULQOLHJWGLH 3RLQWH GHU WLWHOJHEHQGHQ )RUPHO PDNLQJ LW H[SOLFLW ² GD HUVW QRUPDWLYHV 9RNDEXODUGLH)XQNWLRQKDWGLHGHRQWLVFKHQ6WDWXVGLHMHJOLFKHUGLVNXUVL YHQ3UD[LVLQQHZRKQHQH[SOL]LWPDFKHQ]XN|QQHQXQG]XPDFKHQ (UZlKQHQVZHUWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJLVWQRFKGDGLHVH7KHRULH GHUQRUPDWLYHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQQLFKWLKUHUVHLWVHLQH PHQWDOLVWLVFKH 7KHRULH GHU,QWHQWLRQDOLWlWYRUDXVVHW]W9LHOPHKUHUJLEWVLFKGHU%HJULIIGHU,QWHQ WLRQDOLWlW ² KDW PDQ HLQPDO GDV 3ULPDW GHU 'LVNXUVLYLWlW KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU (UNOlUXQJVUHLKHQIROJH HSLVWHPLVFKHU DEHU HEHQ DXFK SUDNWLVFKHU *UXQG NDWHJRULHQDN]HSWLHUW²DXVGHQ5HVXOWDWHQGHUKLHUYRUJHVWHOOWHQQRUPDWL YHQ 3UDJPDWLN %UDQGRP XQWHUVFKHLGHW LP $QVFKOX DQ 'HQQHWW ]ZL
_____________ %UDQGRPD 9JO'HQQHWW DVRZLHGHUV E Å>@DSHUVRQPXVWEHDEOHWRUHFLS URFDWHWKHVWDQFHZKLFKVXJJHVWVWKDWDQLQWHQWLRQDOV\VWHPWKDWLWVHOIDGRSWHGWKHLQ WHQWLRQDOVWDQFHWRZDUGRWKHUREMHFWVZRXOGPHHWWKHWHVW/HWXVGHILQHDVHFRQGRUGHU LQWHQWLRQDOV\VWHPDVRQHWRZKLFKZHDVFULEHQRWRQO\VLPSOHEHOLHIVGHVLUHVDQGRWKHU LQWHQWLRQVEXWEHOLHIVGHVLUHVDQGRWKHULQWHQWLRQVDERXWEHOLHIVGHVLUHVDQGRWKHULQ WHQWLRQV´
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
1RUPDWLYH6WDWXVXQGQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
VFKHQGHUÅ,QWHQWLRQDOLWlWHUVWHUXQG]ZHLWHU.ODVVH²MHQHUEHUGLH,Q WHQWLRQDOLWlWV=XZHLVHUYHUIJHQXQGMHQHUGLHGLHMHQLJHQEHVLW]HQGHQHQ ,QWHQWLRQDOLWlW]XJHZLHVHQZLUG´ 'DPLWZLUGQDFK0DJDEHGHUQRUPD WLYHQ 3UDJPDWLN GHU %HJULII HLQIDFKHU LQWHQWLRQDOHU 6\VWHPH YRP %HJULII LQWHUSUHWLHUHQGHULQWHQWLRQDOHU6\VWHPHDEJHOHLWHW:lKUHQGGLHHUVWHDOVR GLH GHULYDWLYH ,QWHQWLRQDOLWlW HLQH 8QWHUVWHOOXQJ LVW GLH VLFK LP 'LVNXUV EHZlKUHQ NDQQ NDQQ GLH ]ZHLWH GLH XUVSUQJOLFKH ,QWHQWLRQDOLWlW GLH ]XJOHLFK HLQH DQ GLVNXUVLYH 3UD[HQ JHEXQGHQH QRUPDWLYH (LQVWHOOXQJ LVW LK UHUVHLWV]X8QWHUVWHOOXQJHQJHQXW]WZHUGHQ =ZDUNDQQÅ>@GLHQRUPD WLYH (LQVWHOOXQJ >@ DOV HWZDV LQ GHU 3UD[LV GHV %HXUWHLOHQGHQ LUJHQGZLH LPSOL]LW (QWKDOWHQHV DXIJHIDW ZHUGHQ XQG >PX@ QLFKW DOV GLH H[SOL]LWH %LOOLJXQJHLQHU3URSRVLWLRQ>DXIJHIDWZHUGHQ@´ GRFKLVWGLH,QWHOOLJLELOL WlWGLHVHU3UD[LVDQGLH'LVNXUVLYLWlWGHU.RQWRIKUHUJHEXQGHQ'DVEH GHXWHW JHPl %UDQGRPV 3UDJPDWLVPXV VHW]W ]ZDU HLQ :LVVHQGD HLQ :LVVHQZLHYRUDXVGHQQRFKLVWOHW]WHUHV%UDQGRPVÅQRUPDWLYHP3KlQRPH QDOLVPXV´ HQWVSUHFKHQGLQWHUVXEMHNWLYQXULP'LVNXUVDOVQRUPDWLYH(LQ VWHOOXQJ HUNHQQEDU XQG GDKHU NDQQ VRODQJH GDV :LVVHQZLH QLFKW H[SOL]LW JHPDFKW ZLUG YRQ :LVVHQ LP HLJHQWOLFKHQ 6LQQH DXFK NHLQH 5HGH VHLQ 'LHV LVW GHU *UXQG GDIU ZHVKDOE %UDQGRP VWHWV DXI GHU ÅFRQFHSWXDO SULRULW\EHWZHHQFRQFHSWXDOQRUPVDQGQRUPVJHQHUDOO\´EHKDUUW
_____________ %UDQGRPD %UDQGRPHUOlXWHUWGLHVIROJHQGHUPDHQ Å=ZLVFKHQHLQIDFKHQLQWHQWLRQDOHQ6\VWHPHQGLH OHGLJOLFKLQWHQWLRQDOLQWHUSUHWLHUEDUVLQGXQGLQWHUSUHWLHUHQGHQLQWHQWLRQDOHQ6\VWHPHQ]XXQ WHUVFKHLGHQ DOVR ]ZLVFKHQ 6\VWHPHQ JHJHQEHU GHQHQ GLH LQWHQWLRQDOH (LQVWHOOXQJ HLQJHQRPPHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ XQG 6\VWHPHQ GLH GLHVH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DQGHUHQ JHJHQ EHUHLQQHKPHQN|QQHQKHLW]ZLVFKHQLQVWLWXLHUHQGHUXQGLQVWLWXLHUWHU,QWHQWLRQDOL WlW]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ'LHHLQIDFKH,QWHQWLRQDOLWlWGLHKLHUQDFKLP$XJHGHV%HWUDFK WHUVOLHJWLVWDXVGLHVHP*UXQGDEKlQJLJXQGLQHLQHPZLFKWLJHQ6LQQDEJHOHLWHWYRQGHU ,QWHQWLRQDOLWlW GLH GHQ ,QWHUSUHWHQ ]XNRPPW´ %UDQGRP D 9JO DXFK %UDQGRP E %UDQGRP D I YJO LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH DXFK %UDQGRP D VRZLH %UDQ GRP E %UDQGRPD YJOGD]XDXFK5RVHQ %UDQGRP E .QHOO VRZLH 7HLO NULWLVLHUW DQ GHU *H VDPWVWUDWHJLHGHVÄ0DNLQJLW([SOLFLW¶GD%UDQGRPGLH.RQNUHWLRQVHLQHU7KHRULHLQ WDWVlFKOLFKHQ 6SUDFKSUDNWLNHQ QLFKW H[SOL]LHUW XQG QLFKW H[SOL]LHUHQ NDQQ ZREHL HU VLFK YRU DOOHP DXI %UDQGRPV 7KHVH GHU 6SUDFKNRPSHWHQ]DEKlQJLJNHLW LQWHQWLRQDOHU =XVWlQGHNRQ]HQWULHUW LQVEHVLQ.DSYRQ%UDQGRPD 9JO]XUH[SUHVVLYHQ 5ROOH ORJLVFKHQ 9RNDEXODUV GLH PHWKRGLVFK ]X XQWHUVFKHLGHQ LVW YRQ GHU KLHU DQJHVSURFKHQHQ 5ROOH EHJULIIOLFKHU 1RUPHQ ÅFRQFHSWXDO QRUPV´ LQ $QWZRUW DXI 0DFEHWK %UDQGRP D Å>@WKHH[SUHVVLYHUROHRIVXFKORJLFDOYRFDEX ODU\LVSUHFLVHO\WRHQDEOHXVWRPDNHH[SOLFLWLQWKHIRUPRIFODLPVEURDGO\LQIHUHQWLDO FRPPLWPHQWV WKDW FDQ DOUHDG\ LQWHOOLJLEO\ EH GLVFHUQHG DV JRYHUQLQJ WKH XVH RI
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
'DVELVKHU(UUHLFKWHOlWVLFKPLW%OLFNDXIGDV3DSDJHL%HLVSLHOIRO JHQGHUPDHQ NXU] ]XVDPPHQ]XIDVVHQ (LQ ZHVHQWOLFKHU 8QWHUVFKLHG ]ZLVFKHQ JHQXLQHP :LVVHQ HLQHUVHLWV XQG EORHU 5HL]UHDNWLRQ DQGHUHU VHLWVEHVWHKWGDULQGDGLH%HKDXSWXQJÅGDV6WRIIPXVWHULVWURW´QXULP HUVWHQ )DOO VR YHUVWDQGHQ ZLUG GD GDV EHKDXSWHQGH:HVHQ GLH LQIHUHQ WLHOOH9HUELQGOLFKNHLWGLHHVVLFKGDPLWÄDXIJHODGHQ¶KDWDQHUNHQQWXQGLKU LP6SUHFKHQXQG+DQGHOQJHUHFKWZLUG :HVHQGLH9HUQXQIWEHVLW]HQ]HLFKQHQVLFKGDGXUFKDXVGDVLH9HU ELQGOLFKNHLWHQQLFKWHLQIDFKIDNWLVFKXQWHUOLHJHQVRQGHUQGLHVHQ9HUELQG OLFKNHLWHQ QXU GDQQ XQWHUOLHJHQ ZHQQ VLH VLH DOV 9HUELQGOLFKNHLWHQ DQHU NHQQHQ 'LHVH $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU $XWRULWlW ZHOFKH XQVHUH HLJHQHQ bXHUXQJHQ DXI XQV DXVEHQ ]HLJHQ ZLU LQGHP ZLU GLH VLFK DXV GLHVHQ bXHUXQJHQHUJHEHQGHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQEHIROJHQ,P%HLVSLHO ZLUYHUKDO WHQXQVLQXQVHUHQ6SUDFKKDQGOXQJHQGDQQNRUUHNWZHQQZLUGLH%HKDXS WXQJ ÅGLHV LVW URW´ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH DOV LQNRPSDWLEHO PLW GHU %HKDXSWXQJ ÅGLHVLVWJHOE´RGHUDOV.RQVHTXHQ]DXVGHU%HKDXSWXQJÅGLHVLVWURVWURW´ YHUVWHKHQ XQG EHKDQGHOQ :LU HUKDOWHQ GDQQ LQ %UDQGRPV .RQWRIK UXQJVDQDORJLH.UHGLWIUZHLWHUH6SUDFKVSLHOH 'HU3DSDJHLPDJ VLFK! ]X GHU bXHUXQJ ÅGLHV LVW URW´ JHUHL]W IKOHQ! GRFK HU EHUQLPPW ZLH PDQ VHLQHP ZHLWHUHQ 6SUDFKYHUKDOWHQ! DEQHKPHQ NDQQ NHLQHUOHL HSLVWHPLVFKHRGHUSUDNWLVFKH9HUDQWZRUWXQJIUGLHVHbXHUXQJ(U]HLJW XQV LQ VHLQHP 9HUKDOWHQ GD HU GLH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI EHVWLPPWH ZHLWHUH %HKDXSWXQJHQQLFKWDQHUNHQQW :LH LP RELJHQ 'LDJUDPP 6 DQJHGHXWHW HUIDW %UDQGRP PLW VHLQHP LQIHUHQWLDOLVWLVFKHQ 0RGHOO MHGRFK QLFKW QXU GHQ WUDGLWLRQHOOHQ %HJULIIWKHRUHWLVFKHU9HUQXQIWLQVSUDFKSUR]HGXUDOHQ7HUPLQLVRQGHUQLP
_____________
QRQORJLFDO YRFDEXODU\ EHIRUH VXFK ORJLFDO YRFDEXODU\ LV LQWURGXFHG´ 9JO GD]X DXFK XQWHQ)Q :HVHQWOLFKÄSULYDWHV6SUHFKHQ¶LVWGDPLWNHLQHUHDOH0|JOLFKNHLWÄ3ULYDWHV+DQGHOQ¶LVW ]ZDU VXL JHQHULV QLFKW XQP|JOLFK 'RFK DXIJUXQG GHU$EKlQJLJNHLW GHU SRWHQWLHOOHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GLHGDVHQWVSUHFKHQGH9HUKDOWHQHUVW]XHLQHU$NWLYLWlWE]ZHLQHU +DQGOXQJ PDFKHQ YRQ YLHOHUOHL HSLVWHPLVFKHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ LVW ZHVHQWOLFK QLFKW VSUDFKOLFKHVSULYDWHV+DQGHOQDXFKNHLQHUHDOH0|JOLFKNHLWVRQGHUQOHGLJOLFKDOVHLQ GHULYDWLYHU0RGXVGHVSULQ]LSLHOOÄ|IIHQWOLFKHQ+DQGHOQV¶GHQNEDU 9JO GD]X %UDQGRP D Å1LFKW GLH 5HJHO RGHU 1RUP VHOEVW YHUDQODW XQVHU +DQGHOQVRQGHUQGLH7DWVDFKHGDZLUVLHDQHUNHQQHQ,QGHU5HODWLRQ]ZLVFKHQUHLQ QDWUOLFKHQ *HJHQVWlQGHQ XQG GHQ VLH EHKHUUVFKHQGHQ 5HJHOQ IHKOW HV DQ HLQHU VRO FKHQLQWHUYHQLHUHQGHQ(LQVWHOOXQJ´9JO]XUKLHUEHLLP+LQWHUJUXQGVWHKHQGHQ.DQ WLVFKHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJ GHV =XVDPPHQKDQJV YRQ 9HUQXQIW XQG :LOOH REHQ .DS )Q VRZLHGHQ$EVFKQLWW]XGHPGLHVH)XQRWHJHK|UW 9JOGD]XREHQ)Q 9JOREHQ(LQOHLWXQJ)Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
1RUPDWLYH6WDWXVXQGQRUPDWLYH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
=XVDPPHQKDQJYRQ'LVNXUVDXVJlQJHQDXFKHLQHQ%HJULIIGHVUDWLRQDOHQ :LOOHQV :HVHQGLHHLQHQUDWLRQDOHQ:LOOHQEHVLW]HQ]HLFKQHQVLFKGHPQDFKDOV VROFKHDXVGHUHQ$QHUNHQQXQJHQEHVWLPPWHU)HVWOHJXQJHQJDQ]VSH]LIL VFKH $XVZLUNXQJHQ GDUDXI KDEHQ ZLH VLH QDFKIROJHQG KDQGHOQ Å'DV +DEHQ HLQHV UDWLRQDOHQ :LOOHQV NDQQ GDQQ DOV GDV +DEHQ GHU )lKLJNHLW YHUVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ YHUOlOLFK DXI GLH HLJHQH $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU )HVWOH JXQJ HLQHU1RUPGLHHLQHQELQGHW ]XUHDJLHUHQLQGHPPDQXQWHUVFKHL GHQG3HUIRUPDQ]HQKHUYRUEULQJWGLHGHP*HKDOWGHUDQHUNDQQWHQ)HVWOH JXQJHQWVSUHFKHQ´ ,Q %UDQGRPV .RQ]HSW HLQHU QRUPDWLYHQ 3UDJPDWLN VLQG GLH .DQWL VFKHQ .RQ]HSWH YRQ 9HUQXQIW XQG :LOOHQ DXI GHU SKl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lW Å5DWLRQDOLW\ FRQVLVWV LQ ERWK EHLQJ VXEMHFW WR DVVHVVPHQWDFFRUGLQJWR FRQFHSWXDOQRUPVDQGEHLQJVHQVLWLYHWRWKHP² EHLQJERWKERXQGE\DQGDEOHWRIHHOWKHIRUFHRIWKHEHWWHUUHDVRQµ ,FKKDEHLQEHUHLWVDQJHGHXWHWGD%UDQGRPV$XVIRUPXOLHUXQJ YRQÅ.DQWV*UXQGVDW]GDZLUQLFKWQXUQDFK5HJHOQVRQGHUQQDFK5H JHOYRUVWHOOXQJHQ KDQGHOQ´ GD 0HQVFKHQ VLFK DOVR ÅGXUFK QRUPDWLYH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DXV]HLFKQHQ´ LQQHUKDOE GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLH DP QlFKVWHQGHU.RQ]HSWLRQK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYHNRPPWZLHVLHLQ YRUJHVWHOOW ZXUGH 'LH OHLWHQGH )UDJH ZHOFKH %UDQGRPV VSUDFKSUDJPDWL VFKHQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVPLWGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLH.DQWVNRQIURQWLH UHQ OlW NDQQ GDPLW ZHLWHU SUl]LVLHUW ZHUGHQ LVW 5DWLRQDOLWlW LP HEHQ HU ZlKQWHQ6LQQH%UDQGRPVQlPOLFKHLQHU%LQGXQJDQGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIW EHJULIIOLFKHU1RUPHQWKHRUHWLVFKJHHLJQHWGLH.DQWLVFKH0HKUGHXWLJNHLW LPÄHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ(LQIOXGHU9HUQXQIWDXIXQVHUH+DQGOXQJHQ¶]XH[SOL ]LHUHQ"
_____________ %UDQGRP %UDQGRP %UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
3UDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG,UUDWLRQDOLWlW
5DWLRQDOLWlW EHVLW]W ZLH VLFK EHUHLWV LP .DQWLVFKHQ .RQWH[W GHU =ZHFN 0LWWHO5DWLRQDOLWlW K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH HUJHEHQ KDW GLH .HKUVHLWH GHU ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW RGHU :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH 'RFK LVW ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW XQG :LO OHQVVFKZlFKHLGHQWLVFK",VWHVQLFKWVLQQYROOLQ$EVHW]XQJYRQGHU.DQWL VFKHQ$XVJDQJVWKHRULH]ZLVFKHQWKHRUHWLVFKHUXQGSUDNWLVFKHU,UUDWLRQDOL WlW ]X XQWHUVFKHLGHQ XQG LQQHUKDOE EHLGHU ZLHGHUXP ]ZLVFKHQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ*UDGHQ" )ROJHQGHQ ZHLWHQ *HEUDXFK GHV :RUWHV ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW LP 6LQQH MHJOL FKHU NRQDWLYHQ )HKOHUKDIWLJNHLW KDW 3DUILW YRUJHVFKODJHQ Å7KH FKDUJH ¶LUUDWLRQDO· LV DW RQH HQG RI D UDQJH RI FULWLFLVPV ,W LV OLNH WKH FKDUJH ¶ZLFNHG·:HPD\FODLPWKDWVRPHDFWWKRXJKQRWVREDGDVWREHZLFNHG LVVWLOORSHQWRPRUDOFULWLFLVP:HPD\VLPLODUO\FODLPWKDWVRPHGHVLUH WKRXJK QRW GHVHUYLQJ WKH H[WUHPH FKDUJH ¶LUUDWLRQDO· LV RSHQ WR UDWLRQDO FULWLFLVP 7RVDYH ZRUGV,VKDOO H[WHQG WKH RUGLQDU\ XVH RI ¶LUUDWLRQDO·, VKDOOXVHWKLVZRUGWRPHDQ¶RSHQWRUDWLRQDOFULWLFLVP·7KLVZLOODOORZ¶QRW LUUDWLRQDO·WRPHDQ¶QRWRSHQWRVXFKFULWLFLVP·µ'DJHJHQIKUW6FDQORQ MHGRFKGDV%HLVSLHOP|JOLFKHUhEHU]HXJWKHLWYRQHLQHPVHKUNRPSOL]LHU WHQDEHUIHKOHUKDIWHQPDWKHPDWLVFKHQ%HZHLVDQXPIUHLQHQHQJHUHQ %HJULIIYRQ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW]XSOlGLHUHQ Å7KLV>VF,VLPSO\IDLOWRVHHWKDWD FHUWDLQ PDWKHPDWLFDOSRVVLELOLW\ KDVEHHQ OHIW RXW .3@ ZRXOG EH D PLV WDNHRQP\SDUWEXWPRUHZRXOGEHUHTXLUHGWRVXSSRUWDFKDUJHRILUUD WLRQDOLW\ >«@ , EHOLHYH WKDW ZH QRUPDOO\ GUDZ D GLVWLQFWLRQ EHWZHHQ DQ DWWLWXGH·VEHLQJLUUDWLRQDODQGLWVEHLQJPLVWDNHQRUÄRSHQWRUDWLRQDOFULWL FLVP·:HQHHGQRWWDNHRUGLQDU\XVDJHDVDXWKRULWDWLYHRQWKLVSRLQWEXW, EHOLHYH WKDW LW LV KHOSIXO WR SUHVHUYH WKLV GLVWLQFWLRQ DQG WR PDUN LW FOHDUO\´,UUDWLRQDOLWlWRGHU:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHWULWWJHPl6FDQORQV.RQ ]HSWLRQ GDKHU HUVW DXI Å>«@ ZKHQ D SHUVRQ UHFRJQL]HV VRPHWKLQJ DV D UHDVRQEXWIDLOVWREHDIIHFWHGE\LWLQRQHRIWKHUHOHYDQWZD\V´'RFK JHKWHULP$QVFKOXDQ'DYLGVRQHLQHQ6FKULWWEHUGLHVHDOOJHPHLQH(U NOlUXQJ KLQDXV LQGHP HU DXFK YRQ HLQHU ÅDNUDVLD RI EHOLHI´ VSULFKW *H
_____________ 3DUILW 6FDQORQ I 6FDQORQ 0LW %OLFN DXI GHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ YRQ ,QWHQWLRQHQ XQG +DQG OXQJVJUQGHQ HUOlXWHUW 6FDQORQ GLHVH $QVLFKW IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å7R DGRSW DQ LQWHQ WLRQMXVWLVWRJLYHFHUWDLQFRQVLGHUDWLRQVDVSHFLDOSODFHLQRQH·VIXWXUHWKLQNLQJ6RWR DGRSWDQLQWHQWLRQDQGWKHQIDLOWRJLYHLWDSODFHLQVKDSLQJRQH·VUHDVRQVLVDFDVHRI LUUDWLRQDOLW\ LQ WKH QDUURZ VHQVH , GHILQHG DERYH´ 6FDQORQ 'DPLW LVW VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK QRFK QLFKW JHVDJW GD MHGH $EVLFKW EHUHLWV HLQ JXWHU +DQGOXQJV JUXQGLVWZLHGDVLQGLVNXWLHUWH3UREOHPGHVÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶]HLJW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3UDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG,UUDWLRQDOLWlW
PHLQW LVW GDPLW GDV 3KlQRPHQ GHV 1LFKWZDKUKDEHQ:ROOHQV ZLH 6FDQ ORQDP%HLVSLHOHLQHU3HUVRQGHPRQVWULHUWGLHGHUYRUJHWlXVFKWHQ/R\DOL WlWHLQHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQWUDXWREZRKOVLHHLJHQWOLFKJHQDXZHLZLHJXW GLHVHDQGHUH3HUVRQ/R\DOLWlWYRUWlXVFKHQNDQQ Å>«@WKHUHLVVRPHWKLQJ WKDW,WDNHWREHDUHDVRQIRUEHOLHYLQJLQKLVJHQXLQHQHVVQDPHO\KLVDS SHDUDQFH RI JHQXLQHQHVV *LYHQ DOO WKDW , NQRZ DERXW KLP RI FRXUVH , NQRZ WKDW WKLV LV QRW D JRRG UHDVRQ LQ WKLV FDVH EXW LW FDQ VHUYH DV P\ UHDVRQ QRQHWKHOHVVµ 'LH *HJHQDXIIDVVXQJ VR 6FDQORQ JHKW IlOVFKOL FKHUZHLVHGDYRQDXVGDGLH9HUELQGXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHUhEHU]HXJWKHLWYRQ GHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHLQHV8UWHLOVHLQHUVHLWVXQGGHUhEHU]HXJXQJYRQGHP 8UWHLOVHOEVWDQGHUHUVHLWV]XXQPLWWHOEDULVWXPÄ)HKOOHLVWXQJHQ¶5DXP]X ODVVHQ6FDQORQJHKWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJ]ZDUQLFKWDXI%UDQGRPV ,QIHUHQWLDOLVPXVXQGGHVVHQ%HWRQXQJGHU.ROODWHUDOIHVWOHJXQJHQHLQZLH VLHVLFKLQGHUYRUVWHKHQGHQ([SRVLWLRQYRQ%UDQGRPV6HPDQWLNJH]HLJW KDWGRFKHUOlXWHUWHUVHLQH3RVLWLRQLQ$EJUHQ]XQJYRQHLQHP%HJULIIV DWRPLVPXVJDQ]LQGLHVHP6LQQH HUFKDUDNWHULVLHUW]XQlFKVWGLH*HJHQSR VLWLRQ]XVHLQHUHLJHQHQ Å7RWDNH3WREHVXSSRUWHGE\WKHEHVWHYLGHQFH MXVWLVWREHOLHYHLW´8QGIlKUWGDQQIRUW Å%XWWKLVVHHPVWRPHDPLVWDNH %HOLHI LV QRW PHUHO\ D PDWWHU RI MXGJPHQW EXW RI WKH FRQQHFWLRQV RYHU WLPHEHWZHHQWKLVMXGJPHQWDQGGLVSRVLWLRQVWRIHHOFRQYLFWLRQWRUHFDOO DVUHOHYDQWWRHPSOR\DVDSUHPLVHLQIXUWKHUUHDVRQLQJDQGVRRQ,QVR IDUDVDNUDVLDLQYROYHVWKHIDLOXUHRIWKHVHFRQQHFWLRQVLWFDQRFFXULQWKH FDVHRIEHOLHIDVZHOODVLQWKDWRILQWHQWLRQDQGDFWLRQµ0LUVFKHLQWHLQH VROFKH.RQ]HSWXDOLVLHUXQJVLQQYROO]XVHLQLQGHPVLHHLQHUVHLWVGDVJHQXLQ 3UDNWLVFKHGHU,UUDWLRQDOLWlWLVROLHUEDUPDFKWDQGHUHUVHLWVGHQLP=XVDP PHQKDQJGHU:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHDPKlXILJVWHQGLVNXWLHUWHQ)DOOLQVWUXPHQ WHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlWLQHLQHQJU|HUHQ5DKPHQHLQEHWWHW $OV3Ul]LVLHUXQJYRQ6FDQORQV%HJULIIGHU,UUDWLRQDOLWlWGHU]ZDUVR ZRKODXIWKHRUHWLVFKHZLHDXFKDXISUDNWLVFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQKLQVLFKWOLFK GLHVHU DEHU DXI HLQH HQJ XPVFKULHEHQH 3KlQRPHQNODVVH EH]RJHQ LVW KDW 1LGD5PHOLQ GDUDXI DXIPHUNVDP JHPDFKW GD VHOEVW GLH SUDNWLVFK LUUDWLRQDOHGKZLOOHQVVFKZDFKH3HUVRQLQHLQHPPLQLPDOHQ6LQQUDWLRQDO VHLQPXGDPLWZLULKUH9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQEHUKDXSWQRFKDOV+DQGOXQ JHQ VHKHQ XQG GLH 3HUVRQ GDIU YHUDQWZRUWOLFK PDFKHQ N|QQHQ (V LVW Å>«@HLQHXQ]XUHLFKHQGH$QDO\VHGHP:LOOHQVVFKZDFKHQ]XXQWHUVWHOOHQ
_____________ 6FDQORQ YJO DXFK 'DYLGVRQ HQJO VRZLH ]X 'DYLGVRQV $XIIDVVXQJ YRQ :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH 6SLW]OH\ XQG %UDWPDQ 9JOGD]XDXFKXQWHQ.DS)Q 6FDQORQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
GDVVHUQLFKW*UQGHQVRQGHUQ1HLJXQJHQIROJH´ (USOlGLHUWGDEHLIU HLQHQJUDGXHOOHQ%HJULIIYRQ:LOOHQVVWlUNHUHVSHNWLYHVFKZlFKHGHUVLFK DQ GHU UHIOH[LYHQ (LQEH]LHKXQJ VWUXNWXUHOOUDWLRQDOHU *HVLFKWVSXQNWH EH PLW Å$XFKGLHZLOOHQVVFKZDFKH3HUVRQKDQGHOWDXIJUXQGHLQHU6WHOOXQJ QDKPHDOOHUGLQJVDXIJUXQGHLQHU6WHOOXQJQDKPHGLHPLWHLQHUDQGHUHQLQ .RQIOLNW VWHKW GLH HLQHQ VWUXNWXUHOOHQ &KDUDNWHU KDW >«@ 'LH :LOOHQV VFKZlFKHGUFNWVLFKGDULQDXVGDVVGLH3HUVRQHLQHXQDQJHPHVVHQH*H ZLFKWXQJ GHU $XJHQEOLFNVVLWXDWLRQ YRUQLPPW 'DV ZDV JHUDGH ]lKOW LVW GDV 1DKHOLHJHQGH REZRKO HV LKUHU EHVVHUHQ (LQVLFKW ]XZLGHUOlXIW´ (LQH GHUDUWLJH VWUXNWXUHOOH %HWUDFKWXQJ DXV GHU HUVWHQ 3HUVRQ 6LQJXODU YHUKLQGHUW DXFK HLQH YRUHLOLJH =XVFKUHLEXQJ YRQ ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW DXV GHU 3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHUGULWWHQ3HUVRQZLHVLH:LOOLDPVGHQ9HUWHLGLJHUQH[WHU QHU *UQGH XQWHUVWHOOW :LOOLDPV JHKW GDYRQ DXV GD GDV %HVWHKHQ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ VWHWV YRQ GHU ÅVXEMHNWLYHQ PRWLYDWLRQDOHQ 9HUIDV VXQJ´GHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQDEKlQJW RKQHHLQH9HUELQGXQJ]ZLVFKHQ GHU +DQGOXQJ [ HLQHU 3HUVRQ V XQG GHUHQ DNWXHOOHU +DQGOXQJVPRWLYDWLRQ ODVVH VLFK GLH %HKDXSWXQJ GLHVH 3HUVRQ KDEH *UQGH IU [ QLFKW DXI UHFKWHUKDOWHQ 'RFK ]HLJW GLH (LQEH]LHKXQJ VWUXNWXUHOOUDWLRQDOHU *H VLFKWVSXQNWHGD*UQGHQLFKWVROFKHGHUSXQNWXHOOHQ2SWLPLHUXQJVHLQ PVVHQ GDV )HKOHQ OHW]WHUHU *UQGH LQ HLQHU VSH]LHOOHQ 6LWXDWLRQ GHP
_____________ 1LGD5PHOLQ YJO]X6FDQORQV(UNOlUXQJGHVEHJULIIOLFKHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHV ]ZLVFKHQ*UQGHQXQG1HLJXQJHQE]Z:QVFKHQREHQ 1LGD5PHOLQ $P %HLVSLHO YRQ .OHLQNLQGHUQ GLH LQ GHU 3KDVH GHV 6SUDFKHUZHUEVEHJLQQHQPLW)LQJHU]HLJE]ZHLQIDFKHQVSUDFKOLFKHQbXHUXQJHQLK UH +DQGOXQJHQ ]X EHJUQGHQ PDFKW 1LGD5PHOLQ GLHVH *UDGXDOLWlW GHXWOLFK Å'LH YHUIROJWHQ $EVLFKWHQ VLQG ]XQlFKVW VHKU NXU]IULVWLJ XQG NOHLQH .LQGHU ODVVHQ VLFK UDVFKYRQLKUHQ=LHOHQDEEULQJHQLQGHPPDQLKUH$XIPHUNVDPNHLWDXIDQGHUHVOHQNW ,KU 9HUKDOWHQ HUJLEW VLFK DXV GHP $XJHQEOLFN VLH UHDJLHUHQ DXI lXHUH 9HUlQGHUXQ JHQLQGHPVLHLKUHYRUKHULJHQ=LHOHDXIJHEHQE]ZYHUJHVVHQVLHYHU]ZHLIHOQUDVFK ZHQQ VLH HWZDV QLFKW HUUHLFKHQ LKUH 6WLPPXQJHQ N|QQHQ VLFK VFKODJDUWLJ lQGHUQ .LQGOLFKHV 9HUKDOWHQ LVW ZLOOHQVVFKZDFK LKP IHKOW GLH 6WUXNWXULHUXQJ GXUFK +DQG OXQJVJUQGH EHU OlQJHUH =HLWUlXPH KLQZHJ´ 1LGD5PHOLQ (LQH LQWH UHVVDQWH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH XQG ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW LQQHUKDOE HLQHV VWUXNWXUWKHRUHWLVFKHQ 5DKPHQV ILQGHW VLFK EHL $XGL HU EH]HLFKQHW VHLQ ÅEDODQFH RI UHDVRQVPRGHO´VHOEVWDOVÅKROLVWLF´ $XGL $XGLIKUW%HLVSLHOHDQLQZHO FKHQGLH+DQGOXQJ]ZDUQLFKWGHUHLJHQHQWDWVlFKOLFKHQSUDNWLVFKHQ(UZlJXQJIROJW XQG LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH DOV ZLOOHQVVFKZDFK ]X EH]HLFKQHQ VHL LQ ZHOFKHQ MHGRFK HLQH ]X VlW]OLFKH5HIOH[LRQDXIÅRXURYHUDOOV\VWHPRIUHDVRQV´ÅRXUPRVWLPSRUWDQWEHOLHIV DQGZDQWVUHOHYDQWWRWKH DFWLRQ´ HEG GXUFKDXVGLH5DWLRQDOLWlWGHU+DQGOXQJ HUZHLVHQ NDQQ :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH XQG 5DWLRQDOLWlW VLQG GHP]XIROJH QLFKW YROOVWlQGLJ GLVMXQNW 'LH GD]X HUIRUGHUOLFKH 3HUVSHNWLYHQGLIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ XQG 3HUVRQ WKHPDWLVLHUW$XGLLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJMHGRFKQLFKW9JODXFK$XGL :LOOLDPV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3UDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG,UUDWLRQDOLWlW
QDFKQLFKWEHUHLWV,UUDWLRQDOLWlWEHGHXWHW XQGGDGHUDUWLJH6WUXNWXULQ WHQWLRQHQ+DQGOXQJVSOlQHRGHUJDU/HEHQVHQWZUIHQLFKWVGHVWRWURW]JXWH *UQGHGLHVHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQVHLQN|QQHQ ,Q %UDQGRPV GHRQWLVFKHU 7HUPLQRORJLH OlW VLFK QXQ GLH =ZHFN 0LWWHO5DWLRQDOLWl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lOOLJRGHUQRFKPDOVPLW%UDWPDQ Å2QHSHUVRQ·VPRGXVSRQHQVLV DQRWKHU·VPRGXVWROOHQV´ ZLUG DEJHVHKHQ YRQ GHU 4XDOLIL]LHUXQJ DOV SUREDW QLFKWV ,QKDOWOLFKHV EHU GLH 0LWWHO DXVJHVDJW G K HV EHVWHKW OHGLJOLFK HLQH %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]XU (UJUHLIXQJGLHVHVRGHUMHQHVSUREDWHQ0LWWHOV'HQQRFKEHVWHKWDEHUPLW GHUbXHUXQJHLQHU$EVLFKWGDUEHUKLQDXVHLQH)HVWOHJXQJGDUDXILUJHQG HLQHVGHUDOVSUREDWHUNDQQWHQ0LWWHO]XU5HDOLVLHUXQJGHV=ZHFNV]XHU JUHLIHQ²RGHUDEHUGLH$EVLFKWIDOOHQ]XODVVHQ VLHKHZLHGHUXP3XQNW ,Q%UDQGRPVHQWVSUHFKHQGHP%HLVSLHOZLUGGXUFKGLH3URHLQVWHOOXQJ Å,FK ZQVFKH ]LHKH HV YRU WURFNHQ ]X EOHLEHQ´ IROJHQGH ,QIHUHQ] JH VWW]W Å1XUZHQQLFKPHLQHQ6FKLUPDXIVSDQQHEOHLEHLFKWURFNHQDOVR ZHUG· LFK ZRKO PHLQHQ 6FKLUP DXIVSDQQHQ´ .DQWLVFK JHVSURFKHQ LVW KLHUGHU:LOOHE]ZHUQVWKDIWH:XQVFKWURFNHQ]XEOHLEHQHLQ=ZHFNXQG GDV $XIVSDQQHQ GHV 6FKLUPV HLQ GDPLW UDWLRQDO JHZROOWHV G K LPSOL]LW JHVROOWHV0LWWHO'DUDXVIROJWNHLQH3IOLFKWGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ0LWWHO]X
_____________ 9JOGD]XEHUHLWV1DJHO 9JOGD]XDXFKREHQ %UDWPDQ ,P6LQQHGHU8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ%URRPHV KDQGHOWHV VLFKKLHUDOVRXPHLQH(U IRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQYJOGD]XXQWHQ %UDQGRPD I YJO DXFK %UDQGRP'HU:XQVFKWURFNHQ]X EOHLEHQVWW]WZLH%UDQGRPDXVIKUWGDQHEHQQDWUOLFKQRFKHLQHJDQ]H5HLKHDQGH UHUSUDNWLVFKHU,QIHUHQ]HQEHLVSLHOVZHLVHÅ1XUZHQQLFKPLFKXQWHUGLH0DUNLVHVWHO OHEOHLEHLFKWURFNHQDOVRZHUG·LFKPLFKXQWHUGLH0DUNLVHVWHOOHQ´RGHUÅ1XUZHQQ LFK LP $XWR EOHLEH EOHLEH LFK WURFNHQ DOVR ZHUG· LFK LP $XWR EOHLEHQ´ %UDQGRP D 'DJHUDGHGDV$XIVSDQQHQGHV6FKLUPVGDVPLWGHPHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ:XQVFKUDWLR QDO JHZROOWH XQG LPSOL]LW JHVROOWH 0LWWHO LVW VHW]W QDWUOLFK YRUDXV GD GLHVHV 0LWWHO YRQ GHU KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ DOV SUREDW ]XU =ZHFNHUIOOXQJ HUNDQQW ZXUGH GDQHEHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
HUJUHLIHQ ZLH XQWHU GHP 6FKODJZRUW ÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶ LQ DXVJHIKUW ZXUGH'DUDXVIROJWDEHUDXFKQLFKWGDGLH3HUVRQGLH0LWWHOWDWVlFKOLFK HUJUHLIHQZLOOXQGVFKRQJDUQLFKWGDVLHGLH0LWWHOWDWVlFKOLFKHUJUHL IHQZLUG'RFKXPJHNHKUWJLOWGDZLUGHUDUWLJHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQHQWVSUH FKHQGKDQGHOQPVVHQXPDOVUDWLRQDO]XJHOWHQ %UDQGRPHUZlKQWLQGLHVHP.RQWH[WH[SOL]LWDXFKGDV3KlQRPHQGHU :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH GDV LQ VHLQHP 9RNDEXODU DXVJHGUFNW GDQQ DXIWULWW Å>@ ZHQQ 6HOEVW=XZHLVXQJHQ SUDNWLVFKHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ GLH GXUFK $XVVD JHQGHU)RUPÄ,FKVROOWH¶H[SOL]LWJHPDFKWZUGHQ QLFKWGLHNDXVDOH6LJ QLILNDQ] YRQ $QHUNHQQXQJHQ SUDNWLVFKHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ EHVLW]HQ GLH GXUFK $XVVDJHQ GHU )RUP Ä,FK ZHUG·¶ H[SOL]LW JHPDFKW ZUGHQ ´ 0LW GLHVHU )RUPXOLHUXQJZLUGGHPYRQ5D]JHOWHQGJHPDFKWHQ9RUZXUIHLQHUXQEH UHFKWLJWHQ 'RPLQDQ] LQVWUXPHQWHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW ]XYRUJHNRPPHQ LQVR IHUQGLHVH)RUPXOLHUXQJ:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHVRZRKOKLQVLFKWOLFKGHU(UJUHL IXQJQRWZHQGLJHU0LWWHO]XU(UUHLFKXQJHLQHVJHJHEHQHQ=ZHFNVDOVDXFK KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU $XVELOGXQJ HLQHV =ZHFNV EHJUHLIHQ OlW :UGH VLFK MHGRFK GLH 3HUVRQ LP LQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ .RQWH[W GLHVH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH (UJUHLIXQJ SUREDWHU 0LWWHO QLFKW HLQPDO ]XZHLVHQ VR PWHQ ZLU XQ WHUVWHOOHQGDVLHGLH5HODWLRQ]ZLVFKHQGHPYRQLKUJHVHW]WHQ=ZHFNXQG GHQ ]X GHVVHQ 5HDOLVLHUXQJ HUIRUGHUOLFKHQ 0LWWHOQ QLFKW HLQJHVHKHQ KDW XQGLKUHbXHUXQJRKQH%HGHXWXQJLVW 'LH %HGHXWXQJVORVLJNHLW HLQHU VROFKHQ bXHUXQJ EH]LHKW VLFK VHOEVW YHUVWlQGOLFK QXU DXI =ZHFNVHW]XQJHQ LP HQJHUHQ 6LQQH DOVR VROFKH GLH .DQW DXVVFKOLHOLFK GHP :LOOHQ ]XVFKUHLEW 'DV :XQVFKGHQNHQ HLQHU
_____________ N|QQWHPLWGHUVHOEHQ)HVWOHJXQJ WURFNHQ EOHLEHQ]XZROOHQ VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKDXFK MHGHVDQGHUH)XQNWLRQVlTXLYDOHQWDOV0LWWHOJHZlKOWZHUGHQ 'LHV ZLUG EHL %UDQGRP HUVW GXUFK GDV ÄZHUG·¶ GDV HQJOLVFKH VKDOO LQ GHU $SRGRVLV DQJHGHXWHW %UDQGRP YJODXFK%UDQGRPD 9JOGD]X5D] Å:HDNQHVVRIWKHZLOOFDQPDNHXVIDLOWRDGRSWHQGVWKDWZH NQRZ RUEHOLHYHZHGR WKDWZHVKRXOGDGRSW,I,EHOLHYHWKDW,RXJKWWRFDUHDERXW KRZZHOO,WHDFKP\VWXGHQWVEXW,GRQRW,GLVSOD\ZHDNQHVVLQDGRSWLQJHQGV´5D] VLHKWPLWGLHVHU)RUPYRQ:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHGDV.RQ]HSWLQVWUXPHQWHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlW LQVJHVDPWDOVZLGHUOHJWDQ Å,WDSSHDUVWKDWWKHUHLVQRVXFKWKLQJDVLQVWUXPHQWDOLUUD WLRQDOLW\7KDWLVWKHUHLVQRGLVWLQFWLYHVHWRIGHOLEHUDWLYHVWDQGDUGVWKDWDUHLQYROYHG LQJHWWLQJXVWRUHDVRQFRUUHFWO\IURPHQGVZHKDYHWRPHDQVDQGWKDWDUHGLIIHUHQW IURP WKRVH WKDW DUH LQYROYHG LQ UHDVRQLQJ DERXW ZKLFK HQGV WR KDYH´ (EG 'RFK VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK DQHUNHQQW DXFK 5D]GHQSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ.RPSOH[GHUGXUFKGLH =ZHFN0LWWHO5DWLRQDOLWlWEHVFKULHEHQZLUG(UZHQGHWVLFKOHGLJOLFKJHJHQHLQH$V VLPLODWLRQMHJOLFKHU5DWLRQDOLWlWDQGLHVHV0RGHOO0LWWHO]XU(UUHLFKXQJHLQHV=ZHFNV QHQQW HU GHVKDOE YRQ GHU 6WDQGDUGEH]HLFKQXQJ ÅLQVWUXPHQWDO UHDVRQV´ DEZHLFKHQG ÅIDFLOLWDWLYHUHDVRQV´ 9JO]X.DQWV8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQEORHP:XQVFKXQG:LOOHDXFKREHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3UDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG,UUDWLRQDOLWlW
3HUVRQGLHVLFKXPHLQH5HDOLVLHUXQJXQGGLHGD]XHUIRUGHUOLFKHQ0LWWHO QLFKWQXUQLFKWNPPHUWVRQGHUQQLFKWNPPHUQNDQQZHLOVLHDXHUKDOE LKUHU0DFKWVWHKHQEOHLEW RKQHGDGLHVHV:XQVFKGHQNHQVFKRQEHGHX WXQJVORV ZUGH LQGLIIHUHQWJHJHQEHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG GDPLW 9HUlQGHUXQJHQ GHV GHRQWLVFKHQ 6WDWXV GHU EHWUHIIHQGHQ 3HUVRQ :QVFKHQNDQQLFKEHLVSLHOVZHLVHHLQHXQPLWWHOEDUH%HVVHUXQJGHU:HOW HUQlKUXQJVVLWXDWLRQ MHGHU]HLW ZROOHQ LP .DQWLVFKHQ 6LQQH NDQQ LFK VLH QLFKWRKQHZHLWHUHVGHQQZHGHUVLQGGLHQ|WLJHQ0LWWHO]XU5HDOLVLHUXQJ GLHVHV:XQVFKHVLQPHLQHU*HZDOWQRFKEHVWHKWEHUKDXSW.ODUKHLWGDU EHUDXIZHOFKH0LWWHOHUJUHLIXQJLFKPLFKGDPLWIHVWJHOHJWKDEH $QDORJ ]X GLHVHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ EHGHXWXQJV YROOHQIHVWOHJHQGHQbXHUXQJHQXQGEHGHXWXQJVYROOHQbXHUXQJHQRKQH ZHLWHUUHLFKHQGH )HVWOHJXQJ OLHHQ VLFK PLW %UDQGRP LP 7KHRUHWLVFKHQ HLQ]HOQHhEHU]HXJXQJHQDQIKUHQÅ>@GLHNRQVHTXHQWLHOOWUlJHXQGLVR OLHUW YRQ LKUHVJOHLFKHQ VLQG Ä,FK JODXEH HLQIDFK GD .KH EHVFKHXHUW DXVVHKHQGDVLVWDOOHV1LFKWVIROJWGDUDXVXQGLFKELQQLFKWYHUSIOLFKWHW DXIJUXQG GLHVHU hEHU]HXJXQJ LQ LUJHQGHLQHU VSH]LHOOHQ :HLVH ]X KDQ GHOQ¶´ %H]RJHQ DXI GDV HUVWH *OLHG GHU $QDORJLH XQG VROFKH $XVQDK PHQJLOWMHGRFK HVZlUHQLFKWSODXVLEHOZHQQZLUGDYRQDXVJLQJHQGD DOOH XQVHUH LQWHQWLRQDOHQ bXHUXQJHQ GHUDUWLJHP UHLQHP :XQVFKGHQNHQ HQWVSUlQJHQ +\SRWKHWLVFKH,PSHUDWLYHEHVLW]HQLQGHPHEHQUHNRQVWUXLHUWHQ6LQQH QLFKW PHKU XQG QLFKW ZHQLJHU DOV GLH QRUPDWLYH .UDIW UDWLRQDOHU .RQVH TXHQ] (LQH HQWVSUHFKHQGH )RUPXOLHUXQJ %UDQGRPV ILQGHW VLFK GDKHU DXFK QLFKW LQ HLQHP VSH]LILVFK SUDNWLVFKHQ .RQWH[WVRQGHUQ LQ GHP DOO JHPHLQHUHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ YRQ %HKDXSWEDUNHLWVWKHRULHQ XQG GHU YRQ %UDQGRP H[SOL]LHUWHQ ÅQRUPDWLYHQ )HLQVWUXNWXU GHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW´ Å,Q GHPPDQGHQHLQHQ=XJPDFKWYHUSIOLFKWHWPDQVLFKDXIGLH%HUHLWVFKDIW GHQ DQGHUHQ JOHLFKIDOOV ]X PDFKHQ 'DPLW VROO QLFKW JHVDJW ZHUGHQ GD DOOH6SLHOHUWDWVlFKOLFKGLH'LVSRVLWLRQHQKDEHQGLHVLHKDEHQVROOWHQ(VNDQQ VFKRQVHLQGDPDQQLFKWVRKDQGHOWZLHPDQHLJHQWOLFKIHVWJHOHJWRGHU YHUSIOLFKWHW LVW ]X KDQGHOQ PDQ NDQQ ]XPLQGHVW LQ EHVRQGHUHQ )lOOHQ GLHVH$UWYRQ6SLHOUHJHOEUHFKHQRGHUDQLKUHU%HIROJXQJVFKHLWHUQRKQH GDGXUFK DXV GHU *HPHLQVFKDIW GHU 6SLHOHU GHV %HKDXSWXQJVVSLHOV DXVJH
_____________ 9JOGD]X.RUVJDDUG Å:KDWPDNHVZLOOLQJGLIIHUHQWIURPPHUHO\GHVLULQJRU ZLVKLQJRUWKLQNLQJLWZRXOGEHQLFHLILVWKDWWKHSHUVRQZKRZLOOVDQHQGGHWHUPLQHV KLPVHOIWREULQJWKHHQGDERXWWKDWLVWRFDXVHLW$QGWRGHWHUPLQH\RXUVHOIWREHWKH FDXVHRIDQHQGLVWRGHWHUPLQH\RXUVHOIWRVHWRIIDFKDLQRIFDXVHVWKDWZLOOOHDGWR WKHDFKLHYHPHQWRIWKHHQG´'LHVH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJLVWEHLPÄEORHQ:XQVFK¶JH UDGHQLFKWJHJHEHQ %UDQGRP %UDQGRP
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
VFKORVVHQ ]X ZHUGHQ 'HQQRFK >«@ PVVHQ %HKDXSWXQJVVSLHOH VROFKH 5HJHOQEHVLW]HQ 5HJHOQGHUNRQVHTXHQWLHOOHQ)HVWOHJXQJ´ 2KQHDXIK\SRWKHWLVFKH,PSHUDWLYH]XVSUHFKHQ]XNRPPHQNULWLVLHUW %UDQGRP ]ZDU GD .DQW GLH NRQVHTXHQWLHOOH )HVWOHJXQJ GHP PRUDOL VFKHQ 6ROOHQGHVNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVDVVLPLOLHUWKDEHZHQQHUYRQ HLQHU ÅSURNUXVWHVKDIWHQ (UNOlUXQJVRUGQXQJ´ VSULFKW Å'LH NDQWLVFKH .RQ]HSWLRQJOHLFKWDOOH*UQGHIUHLQH+DQGOXQJDQGDVGULWWH0XVWHU>VF XQEHGLQJWHVÄ6ROOHQ¶VWDWWJHQXLQLQVWUXPHQWHOOHPÄ6ROOHQ¶E]ZLQVWLWXWLR QHOOHP Ä6ROOHQ¶ .3@ DQ >'@HU .DQWLDQHU EHVWUHLWHW GD HLQ EORHU :XQVFK HLQHVLQQOLFKH1HLJXQJ HLQHQ+DQGOXQJVJUXQGOLHIHUQN|QQWHVR ODQJHHUQLFKWGXUFKGLH$QHUNHQQXQJHLQHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ9HUSIOLFKWXQJ RGHU)HVWOHJXQJEHJOHLWHWZLUG´'LHJHJHQZlUWLJHQ$XVIKUXQJHQVRO OHQ LP *HJHQVDW] ]X GLHVHU (LQVFKlW]XQJ MHGRFK XQWHU DQGHUHP ]HLJHQ GDLQVWUXPHQWHOOH9HUQXQIWLP6LQQH.DQWVVLFKLQ%UDQGRPV7HUPLQR ORJLHUHIRUPXOLHUHQOlWXQG]ZDURKQH$QJOHLFKXQJDOOHU*UQGHDQGDV 0XVWHUGHVPRUDOLVFKHQ6ROOHQV:LHVLFKLQ.DSJH]HLJWKDWJHKW.DQW ]ZDUGDYRQDXVGDVRZRKOLQVWUXPHQWHOOHZLHDXFKPRUDOLVFKH.RQWH[WH QXULQQRUPDWLYHQ7HUPLQLEHVFKULHEHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ GDV(QWVFKHLGHQ GHLVWGLH+DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlWXQVHUHU9HUQXQIW'RFKZlKUHQGGLH1RUPD WLYLWlWLPLQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ.RQWH[WDOVHLQH)XQNWLRQGHU:DKOHLQHV+DQG OXQJV]LHOV LQ 5HODWLRQ ]X GHQ DOV ]X GHVVHQ 5HDOLVLHUXQJ HUIRUGHUOLFKHQ 0LWWHOQEHVFKULHEHQZXUGHLVWQDFK.DQWGLH1RUPDWLYLWlWLPPRUDOLVFKHQ .RQWH[WDOVGDVZDVGLHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ3UlIHUHQ]HQWUDQV]HQGLHUWLQYDULDQW JHJHQEHU EHVWLPPWHQ +DQGOXQJV]LHOHQ ZHVKDOE .DQW DXFK LP HUVWHQ .RQWH[W YRQ DQDO\WLVFKHQ XQG LP ]ZHLWHQ YRQ V\QWKHWLVFKHQ 6lW]HQ VSULFKW2GHUDQGHUVIRUPXOLHUW ZlKUHQGGLH%HVWLPPXQJVJUQGH]XHLQHU ÄNOXJHQ¶RGHUÄJHVFKLFNWHQ¶+DQGOXQJLQGHQLQGLYLGXHOOHQ3UlIHUHQ]HQGHU MHZHLOLJHQ=ZHFNVHW]XQJ]XILQGHQVLQGN|QQHQ%HVWLPPXQJVJUQGH]X HLQHUPRUDOLVFKHQ+DQGOXQJQDFK.DQWQXULQGHUHQVLWWOLFKHU4XDOLWlWDOV VROFKHU JHIXQGHQ ZHUGHQ XQG GDV EHGHXWHW LQ GHU 8QDEKlQJLJNHLW YRQ LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 3UlIHUHQ]HQ RGHU SRVLWLY LQ GHU (LQVLFKW LQ XQVHUH LQWHOOL JLEOH%UJHUVFKDIWLP5HLFKGHU=ZHFNH:lKUHQGLP)DOOLQVWUXPHQWHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlWGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLH(UJUHLIXQJDOVSUREDWHUNDQQWHU0LWWHO DOVR JDQ]LP6LQQH%UDQGRPV LQGHP0RPHQWHUOLVFKWLQGHPGLHÄVLQQ
_____________ %UDQGRP GHQ $XVQDKPHQ DXI GLH %UDQGRP DQVSLHOW HQWVSUHFKHQ LP .DQWLVFKHQ0RGHOOGLHHUZlKQWHQEORHQ:QVFKHLP*HJHQVDW]]X:LOOHQVlXHUXQ JHQ LP HLJHQWOLFKHQ 6LQQH 'LHVH $XVQDKPHQ EHVWlWLJHQ EXFKVWlEOLFK GLH 5HJHO GLH 0|JOLFKNHLWYRQVROFKHQ$XVQDKPHQ².DQWLVFKJHVSURFKHQ ÄGDGLH9HUQXQIWNHLQHQ HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOX DXI XQVHUH +DQGOXQJHQ EHVLW]W¶ ² LVW DOVR GDIU PLWYHUDQW ZRUWOLFKGDEHL.DQWXQGEHL%UDQGRPYRQUDWLRQDOHU.RQVHTXHQ]DOVHLQHU0DQL IHVWDWLRQYRQ1RUPDWLYLWlWGLH5HGHLVW %UDQGRP
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3UDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG,UUDWLRQDOLWlW
OLFKH1HLJXQJ¶YHUVFKZLQGHWLVWGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIHLQHPRUDOLVFKH+DQG OXQJ QLFKW YRQ GHU HLJHQHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ %HJUQ GXQJDEKlQJLJ*HQDXGDULQEHVWHKWGHU.DQWLVFKH8QWHUVFKLHGGHUHLQH 0RUDOLVLHUXQJ SUXGHQWLHOOHU +DQGOXQJHQ DXVVFKOLHW 2GHU QRFKPDOV DQ GHUV DXFK .DQWV K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLYH JHKHQ QLFKW EHU %UDQGRPV Å5HJHOQGHUNRQVHTXHQWLHOOHQ)HVWOHJXQJ´KLQDXV 1LFKWVGHVWRWURW] VSULFKW .DQW YRQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYHQ XQG GDPLWLVWIROJHQGHV3UREOHPYHUEXQGHQGDVYHUPXWOLFK]XGHUYHUNU]WHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH%UDQGRPVDXIGLH.DQWLVFKH.RQ]HSWLRQJHIKUWKDW )UHLQH 3HUVRQ[GLHHLQHQ=ZHFNSKDWVFKHLQWGLH(UJUHLIXQJGHU]XU5HDOLVLH UXQJ YRQ S DOV QRWZHQGLJ HUNDQQWHQ 0LWWHO T HQWZHGHU HLQH )UDJH GHV GHVNULSWLYHQ :LVVHQV RGHU HLQH 7ULYLDOLWlW ]X VHLQ 'HU K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLYZHQGHWVLFKDEHUJHUDGHQLFKWDQGLHMHQLJH3HUVRQGLHQRFKLP XQNODUHQGDUEHULVWZHOFKH0LWWHO]XPJHZQVFKWHQ=ZHFNIKUHQZHU GHQ HU IRUGHUW QLFKW GD]X DXI GLH QRWZHQGLJHQ 0LWWHO]XVXFKHQ GLHV LVW .DQWLVFK JHVSURFKHQ GLH $XIJDEH GHV 9HUVWDQGHV HU IRUGHUW YLHOPHKU GD]X DXI GLHVH ]X HUJUHLIHQ 6LQG GLHVH 0LWWHO DEHU EHNDQQW GDQQ VFKHLQW LKUH(UJUHLIXQJHEHQHLQH6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKNHLW]XVHLQ0DQN|QQWHYHU VXFKWVHLQ]XVDJHQ ZHUGLHVH0LWWHOQLFKWHUJUHLIWZROOWHHLJHQWOLFKDXFK QLFKWGHQ=ZHFN1RUPDWLYLWlWNlPHGDPLWJDUQLFKW]XU6SUDFKH'RFK DXFK .DQW NDONXOLHUW ZLH VLFK LQ .DS JH]HLJW KDW GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW PHQVFKOLFKHU :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH HLQ XQG ULFKWHW K\SRWKHWLVFKH ,PSHUDWLYH GDKHU DQ HLQHQ :LOOHQ GHU XQWHU P|JOLFKHU $QIHFKWXQJ GXUFK SXQNWXHOO NRQNXUULHUHQGH 1HLJXQJHQ VWHKW 'LH GDEHL DXIWUHWHQGH 1RUPDWLYLWlW LVW NHLQH GHV XQEHGLQJWHQ 6ROOHQV VRQGHUQ HUJLEW ,PSHUDWLYH LP 6LQQH YRQ LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ.RKlUHQ]JHERWHQGHU9HUQXQIW 1RFKHLQH%HPHUNXQJVFKHLQWLP.RQWH[WK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYH XQG%UDQGRPVHQWVSUHFKHQGHU%H]XJQDKPHQDQJHEUDFKW(VLVW]ZDUZLH GLH YRUVWHKHQGH $UJXPHQWDWLRQ ]HLJHQ VROOWH RIIHQNXQGLJ QLFKW VR GD .DQW DOOH *UQGH GHP PRUDOLVFKHQ 6ROOHQ DVVLPLOLHUW 'HQQRFK VSLHOW LQWHUHVVDQWHUZHLVH :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH EHL .DQW HLQH H[SOL]LWH 5ROOH KDXSW VlFKOLFKLPPRUDOLVFKHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJ3UDNWLVFKH1RUPDWLYLWlWEH]LHKW VLFK QDFK .DQW JUXQGOHJHQG GDUDXI GHU 9HUQXQIW GHQ ÅHQWVFKHLGHQGHQ (LQIOX´ DXI XQVHUH +DQGOXQJ ]X YHUOHLKHQ LP )DOO GHU K\SRWKHWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYHGLHDOVYHUQQIWLJHLQJHVHKHQH=ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQ]XUHDOL VLHUHQXQGGDPLWGHQDQDO\WLVFKSUDNWLVFKHQ6DW]ÅLFKVROOHWZDVWXQGDU XP ZHLO LFK HWZDV DQGHUHVZLOO´ ]X UHDOLVLHUHQ LP )DOOGHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV GDJHJHQ EHZLUNW GHU ÅHQWVFKHLGHQGH (LQIOX´ GHU 9HUQXQIW GD GDV VXEMHNWLYH 3ULQ]LS GHV :ROOHQV PLW GHP REMHNWLYHQ 3ULQ]LS GHV :ROOHQVEHUHLQVWLPPWXQGDXVVFKOLHOLFKGLH$FKWXQJYRUGHP6LWWHQJH
_____________ %UDQGRP
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
VHW]XQV]XU+DQGOXQJEHVWLPPW$XIJUXQGGHUJHPHLQVDPHQ:XU]HOGHU .DQWLVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYH LQ GHU $XIIRUGHUXQJ GHU 9HUQXQIW GHQ HQWVFKHL GHQGHQ (LQIOX DXI XQVHUH +DQGOXQJHQ ]X JHVWDWWHQ VWHOOW VLFK QXQ GLH GLHVHP9HUQXQIWHLQIOXHQWJHJHQVWHKHQGH6FKZlFKHQLFKWDOVHLQ3KlQR PHQ GDU GDV DXI LQVWUXPHQWHOOH =XVDPPHQKlQJH UHVWULQJLHUW ZlUH ,P *HJHQWHLOHLQHUHLJHQVWlQGLJHQ$UJXPHQWDWLRQZHUWVLHKW.DQWGLHVH3Kl QRPHQH GHU Å*HEUHFKOLFKNHLW XQG 8QODXWHUNHLW´ ZLH HU %DXPJDUWHQV $XVGUXFN GHU ÅLQILUPLWDV KXPDQD´ NRPPHQWLHUW QXU LP PRUDO E]Z UHOLJLRQVSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ %HUHLFK DQ ZR HU DXFK EHU GLH Å%|VDUWLJNHLW GHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ1DWXU´GLHÅ9HUNHKUWKHLWGHV+HU]HQV´GLHHUDXFKHLQ ÅE|VHV+HU]´QHQQWVSULFKW9RQGHUHLJHQWOLFKHQ:LOOHQVVFKZlFKHDOVR GHU Ä*HEUHFKOLFKNHLW¶ XQWHUVFKHLGHW HU VRZRKO GLH Å%RVKHLW ZHQQ PDQ GLHVHV :RUW LQ VWUHQJHU %HGHXWXQJ QLPPW QlPOLFK DOV HLQH *HVLQQXQJ VXEMHFWLYHV 3ULQFLS GHU 0D[LPHQ GDV %|VH DOV %|VHV ]XU 7ULHEIHGHU LQ VHLQH 0D[LPH DXI]XQHKPHQ´ ZDV HU QLFKW DOV PHQVFKOLFK VRQGHUQ DOV ÅWHXIOLVFK´ EH]HLFKQHW DOV DXFK HLQH ÅJHZLVVH 7FNH GHV PHQVFKOLFKHQ +HU]HQV GROXVPDOXV ´GLHVLFKLQHLQHUÅYRUVlW]OLFKH>Q@6FKXOG GROXV ´ XQGGHPHQWVSUHFKHQGYRUVlW]OLFKE|VHQ+DQGOXQJHQlXHUW:LOOHQVVFKZl FKH KLQJHJHQ PX QDFK .DQW GHP +DQGHOQGHQ Å]XJHUHFKQHW´ ]XJOHLFK DEHUDXFKDOVÅXQYRUVlW]OLFK´JHNHQQ]HLFKQHWZHUGHQ 6LHÅ>«@NDQQPLW HLQHP LP $OOJHPHLQHQ JXWHQ :LOOHQ ]XVDPPHQ EHVWHKHQ XQG HQWVSULQJW DXV GHU *HEUHFKOLFKNHLW GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ 1DWXU ]X %HIROJXQJ VHLQHU JHQRPPHQHQ*UXQGVlW]HQLFKWVWDUNJHQXJ]XVHLQPLWGHU8QODXWHUNHLW YHUEXQGHQ GLH 7ULHEIHGHUQ VHOEVW JXW EHDEVLFKWLJWHU +DQGOXQJHQ QLFKW QDFK PRUDOLVFKHU 5LFKWVFKQXU YRQ HLQDQGHU DE]XVRQGHUQ XQG GDKHU ]X OHW]W ZHQQ HV KRFK NRPPW QXU DXI GLH *HPlKHLW GHUVHOEHQ PLW GHP *HVHW]XQGQLFKWDXIGLH$EOHLWXQJYRQGHPVHOEHQGLDXIGLHVHVDOVGLH DOOHLQLJH 7ULHEIHGHU ]X VHKHQ´ 'DV 3KlQRPHQ GHU :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH VROOLP)ROJHQGHQMHGRFKQLFKWZHLWHUDQDO\VLHUWZHUGHQ HVZXUGHKLHUQXU XQGZLUGLQGHU/LWHUDWXU]XPHLVW HUZlKQWZHLOHVLP6LQQHHLQHU.RQ WUDVWIROLHGLHIUGLHMHZHLOLJHQSUDNWLVFKHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQFKDUDNWHULVWLVFKH 1RUPDWLYLWlWJXWHUNHQQHQOlW 1DFK %UDQGRP EHVWHKW GLH VSH]LILVFKH bXHUXQJ GHU :LOOHQVVFKZl FKH LP PRUDOLVFKHQ .RQWH[W GDULQ GD ÅGLH LQ GHU GULWWHQ 3HUVRQ WKHRUH WLVFKDQHUNDQQWHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQ>@XQYHUHLQEDU>VLQG@PLWGHQLQGHUHUV
_____________ .DQW,9 .DQW;,; .DQW9,I
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
1RUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLNXQGXQEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
WHQ3HUVRQSUDNWLVFKDQHUNDQQWHQ´$XIGLHVHSHUVRQDOH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ KLQVLFKWOLFKGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHZHUGHLFKMHQVHLWVGHU3UREOHPDWLNGHU :LOOHQVVFKZlFKHQRFK]XUFNNRPPHQ
1RUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLNXQGGLH9HUELQGOLFKNHLWHLQHV XQEHGLQJWHQ6ROOHQV 1RUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLNXQGXQEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
1RUPDWLYLWlWZLUGDOVR²GDVVROOWHGHUYRUDXVJHKHQGH$EVFKQLWWGHXWOLFK JHPDFKWKDEHQ²LQ%UDQGRPV.RQ]HSWLRQQLFKWHUVWLQNRQDWLYHQ.RQ WH[WHQVLFKWEDUVHLHQGLHVHQXQLQVWUXPHQWHOOHUPRUDOLVFKHURGHUDQGHUHU $UW 6LH OLHJW YLHOPHKU MHGHP :HOWEH]XJ ² DXFK GHP HSLVWHPLVFKHQ ² ]XJUXQGH 9HUJHJHQZlUWLJHQZLUXQV]XUZHLWHUHQ.OlUXQJGHV=XVDPPHQKDQJV YRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQXQG1RUPDWLYLWlWPLW%OLFNDXIGLH$XVJDQJVWKH RLH .DQWV XQG GHQ KLHU ZHLWHUYHUIROJWHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV %UDQGRPV )RO JHQGHV VRZRKO.DQWDOVDXFK%UDQGRPVHKHQ1RUPDWLYLWlWXQG PHQVFK OLFKH 9HUQXQIW DOV DXIHLQDQGHUEH]RJHQH %HJULIIH DQ ² 9HUQXQIWEHWULIIW GLH $QHUNHQQXQJ YRQ $XWRULWlW HJDO RE OHW]WHUH VLFK QXQ DXI 1DWXU 'HQN6SUDFKRGHU+DQGOXQJVJHVHW]HEH]LHKWDXIPHLQHHLJHQH3HUVRQ RGHU DXI DQGHUH 3HUVRQHQ 'RFK ZlKUHQG .DQW HLQH VWULNWH 7UHQQXQJ YRUQLPPW ]ZLVFKHQ SUDNWLVFKHU XQG WKHRUHWLVFKHU 9HUQXQIW LVW LQ GHU .RQ ]HSWLRQ %UDQGRPV NHLQH VROFKH 7UHQQXQJ ]X ILQGHQ ZLH EHUHLWV +DEHU PDV NULWLVFK NRQVWDWLHUW Å$QGHUV DOV .DQW EULQJW %UDQGRP SUDNWLVFKH XQG WKHRUHWLVFKH 9HUQXQIW DXI GHQVHOEHQ 1HQQHU UDWLRQDOHQ 7XQV 'D QDFKVLQG8UWHLOHXQG0HLQXQJHQHEHQVRQRUPHQJHOHLWHWZLH+DQGOXQJV DEVLFKWHQ VR GD VLH VLFK QLFKW QDFK GHVNULSWLYHQ 7DWVDFKHQ XQG SUl VNULSWLYHQ +DQGOXQJVEH]JHQ GLIIHUHQ]LHUHQ´ +DEHUPDV EHWRQW PLW VHLQHU .ULWLN GLH 8QWHUVFKLHGH ]ZLVFKHQ WKHRUHWLVFKHU XQG SUDNWLVFKHU 9HU QXQIWZLH.DQWVLH]ZLVFKHQÄGHPZDVLVW¶XQGÄGHPZDVVHLQVROO¶JH]R JHQKDW+DEHUPDV·(LQVFKlW]XQJGHVÅHEHQVR´NDQQMHGRFK]XPLQGHVW PLW%OLFNDXIGDV3RWHQWLDOYRQ%UDQGRPVQRUPDWLYHU3UDJPDWLNKLQVLFKW OLFK GHU ÄSUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW¶ EH]ZHLIHOW ZHUGHQ =XQlFKVW QXU VRYLHO 1RUPHQJHOHLWHW LVW MHGH 5HIOH[LRQ LQVRIHUQ VLH PLW GHP %HXUWHLOHQ XQG $EZlJHQ YRQ *UQGHQ EHIDW LVW VHLHQ HV *UQGH IU hEHU]HXJXQJHQ
_____________ %UDQGRP D YJO HEG ]X %UDQGRPV 5HIRUPXOLHUXQJ GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ REMHNWLYHP XQG VXEMHNWLYHP 3ULQ]LS GHV :ROOHQV LQ LQIH UHQWLHOOHQ7HUPLQL +DEHUPDV 9JOGD]X.DQW.U9$VRZLHREHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
RGHU*UQGHIU+DQGOXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ'HQQRFKEHVWHKW KLQVLFKWOLFK 1RUPHQ GLH LQ 5HODWLRQ ]X :DKUQHKPXQJHQ VWHKHQ XQG 1RUPHQGLHLQ5HODWLRQ]X+DQGOXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQVWHKHQ HLQJUDYLHUHQGHU8QWHUVFKLHG %UDQGRPQHJLHUWQLFKWUXQGKHUDXVGLH0|JOLFKNHLWHLQHUJHQXLQSUDN WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLH YLHOPHKU LVW 3KLORVRSKLH IU LKQ LP YRUJHQDQQWHQ 6LQQHYRQ*UXQGDXIHLQH7KHRULHGHU1RUPDWLYLWlWPDJVLHVLFKLQLKUHP ZHLWHUHQ)RUWJDQJQXQPLWWKHRUHWLVFKHQRGHUPLWPRUDOLVFKHQ)UDJHQLP HQJHUHQ6LQQHDXVHLQDQGHUVHW]HQ%UDQGRPV%HJULIIYRQ1RUPDWLYLWlWOlW VLFK DOV HLQ LP ZHLWHUHQ 6LQQH GHV $XVGUXFNV WUDQV]HQGHQWDOHV $UJX PHQW YHUVWHKHQ 6SUDFKH 9HUQXQIW :LVVHQ XQG +DQGHOQ N|QQHQ QXU XQWHU GHU 9RUDXVVHW]XQJ HLQHU JOWLJHQ (UNOlUXQJ YRQ 1RUPDWLYLWlW YHU VWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ 'HRQWLVFKH 6WDWXV DOVR )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQ JHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQVLQGLQGLH*UXQGVWUXNWXUMHJOLFKHU5DWLRQDOLWlWHLQ JHZREHQ 'HU 9RU]XJ GLHVHU .RQ]HSWLRQ EHVWHKW ]ZHLIHOORV GDULQ GD YRQ1RUPDWLYLWlWJHKDQGHOWZLUGRKQHVWDUNPHWDSK\VLVFKH7KHVHQEHU GLH9HUQXQIWGLH1DWXURGHUGHQ0HQVFKHQEHJUQGHQ]XPVVHQ6WDWW GHVVHQ EOHLEW GLH 7KHRULH DXI GHP %RGHQ VSUDFKOLFKHU $XVGUFNH GHP %HUHLFK D LQ RELJHP 0RGHOO GHU LQIHUHQWLHOOHQ 6HPDQWLN 6 XQG OLHIHUW XPJHNHKUW HUVW DOV (UJHEQLV HLQ 0HQVFKHQELOG ,Q $QOHKQXQJ DQ .DQWLVFKHV 9RNDEXODU VFKUHLEW %UDQGRP GDKHU Å,QGHP VLH >VF GLH 3UR GXNWHVR]LDOHU,QWHUDNWLRQHQ@GHQLQLKQHQDXIDQJHPHVVHQH:HLVHHQWKDO WHQHQ 3HUIRUPDQ]HQ =XVWlQGHQ XQG $XVGUFNHQ EHJULIIOLFKHQ *HKDOW YHUOHLKHQ LQVWLWXLHUHQ GLHVH 3UDNWLNHQ HLQ 5HLFK GHU .XOWXU >@´ 0HQ VFKHQ YHUVWHKHQ VLFK GDQDFK QLFKW ZHVHQWOLFK DOV $JHQWHQ LQ 5HL] 5HDNWLRQVVFKHPDWDVRQGHUQDOVQRUPDWLYH:HVHQGHUHQ.RPPXQLNDWLRQ YRP=XZHLVHQXQG$QHUNHQQHQYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQDQ DQGHUHXQGVLFKVHOEVWJHVWHXHUWZLUG 'LHV NDQQ LQVRIHUQ DOV HLQH +HUDXVIRUGHUXQJ DQ GLH 7KHRULH .DQWV YHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQDOV%UDQGRPVLFKLP6LQQHYRQ2FNKDPVgNRQRPLH SULQ]LS DXI GLH 6SKlUH GHV VSUDFKOLFK DUWLNXOLHUEDUHQ VR]LDOHQ 6HOEVWYHU VWlQGQLVVHV EHVFKUlQNW GHVVHQ HLQH %HGLQJXQJ HEHQ GLH QRUPDWLY SUDJPDWLVFKH9HUQHW]XQJGXUFKGLH(LQVWHOOXQJHQGHU6SUHFKHULVW%UDQ GRP IKUW GHQ %HJULII GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW EHUHLWV DXI GHU VHPDQWLVFKHQ (EHQH HLQ GLH .DQW VFKOLFKWZHJ QLFKW EHUFNVLFKWLJW XQG GHVKDOE EHL
_____________ )U GLH JHJHQZlUWLJH 'LVNXVVLRQ VROO GLH IROJHQGH 'HILQLWLRQ 6WHUQV JHQJHQ Å2QH WKLQJ ; LVDQHFHVVDU\FRQGLWLRQIRUWKHSRVVLELOLW\RIVRPHWKLQJHOVH < VRWKDW>@ WKHODWWHUFDQQRWREWDLQZLWKRXWWKHIRUPHUµ 6WHUQÅ,QWURGXFWLRQ´ 9JO]XU 'HEDWWHGLHVHVDXI.DQWV3KLORVRSKLH]XUFNJHKHQGHQ%HJULIIVGLH%HLWUlJHLQ6WHUQ IU PHLQHQ =XJDQJ UHOHYDQW LQVEHV 'DYLG %HOO Å7UDQVFHQGHQWDO $UJXPHQWV DQG1RQ1DWXUDOLVWLF$QWL5HDOLVP´ %UDQGRP
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
1RUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLNXQGXQEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
VHLQHU(LQIKUXQJGHV%HJULIIVDXIVWlUNHUH=XVDW]SUlPLVVHQIHVWJHOHJWLVW .DQWV(UNOlUXQJGHU4XHOOHGHV6ROOHQVGHU,PSHUDWLYHVHLQ5FNJULIIDXI GLH6\QWKHVHYRQ$XWRQRPLHXQG+HWHURQRPLHLP%HJULIIGHVPHQVFKOL FKHQ :LOOHQV HUZHLVW VLFK DOV PLW DQVSUXFKVYROOHUHQ =XVDW]DQQDKPHQ YHUEXQGHQ DOV %UDQGRPV ([SOLNDWLRQ GHU ÅQRUPDWLYHQ )HLQVWUXNWXU GHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW´ 'RFKGDPLWJHZLQQWHLQH)UDJHDQ%HGHXWXQJGLHLQGHUYRUVWHKHQ GHQ 'LVNXVVLRQ LP +LQWHUJUXQG VLFKWEDU ZDU RKQH EHUHLWV H[SOL]LHUW ]X ZHUGHQ NDQQ %UDQGRPV XPIDVVHQGHU XQG JUXQGOHJHQG QRUPDWLY RULHQ WLHUWHU.RKlUHQWLVPXVHLQbTXLYDOHQW]XU/HLVWXQJGHU.DQWLVFKHQ7KHRULH GHU (UNOlUXQJ HLQHU EHU 0D[LPHQ YHUPLWWHOWHQ +DQGOXQJVGLUHNWLRQ GXUFKGHQ PHWDSK\VLVFKHQ %HJULIIGHU1RUPDWLYLWlWOLHIHUQ"3ULPDIDFLH VFKHLQWNHLQH0|JOLFKNHLWLQ6LFKW]XVHLQGLH.DQWLVFKH$XIIRUGHUXQJVLWW OLFKGKYHUQXQIWJHPl]XKDQGHOQLQ%UDQGRPV7HUPLQL]XUHIRUPXOLH UHQ ZHLO ZLU LP 6LQQH %UDQGRPV JDU QLFKW XQYHUQQIWLJ KDQGHOQ N|QQHQ HVVHLGHQQXPGHQWKHRUHWLVFKLQDN]HSWDEOHQ3UHLVGHV9HUOXVWVMHJOLFKHU 6HPDQWLN 6LQQOLFKH 1HLJXQJHQ XQG :QVFKH DOVR GDV ZDV .DQW DOV DPRUDOLVFKXQGXQYHUQQIWLJLQEHVWLPPWHQ)lOOHQVRJDUDOVXQPRUDOLVFK TXDOLIL]LHUW LVW IU %UDQGRP LP QRUPDWLYLQIHUHQWLHOOHQ 1HW] HEHQVR IHVW YHUDQNHUWZLHhEHU]HXJXQJHQ:HUWHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH(WLNHWWHQXQG$Q GHUHV *HQDXDQGLHVH7KHRULHQNRQVWHOODWLRQVFKOLHWVLFKQXQGLHEHUHLWVDQ JHGHXWHWH ZHQQJOHLFK LQ QRFK HUNOlUXQJVEHGUIWLJHU +LQVLFKW EHUUD VFKHQGH.ULWLN+DEHUPDV·DQ Å%UDQGRPPLYHUVWHKWVLFKJHZLVVHUPDHQ VHOEVW ZHLO HU HLQHQ EHULQNOXVLYHQ %HJULII YRQ 1RUPDWLYLWlW YHUZHQGHW XQG 5DWLRQDOLWlWVQRUPHQ LP ZHLWHVWHQ 6LQQH ² ORJLVFKH EHJULIIOLFKH VH PDQWLVFKH HEHQVR ZLH SUDJPDWLVFKH 5HJHOQ ² DQ +DQGOXQJVQRUPHQ DQ JOHLFKW >@ 'LH $IIHNWLRQ GXUFK *UQGH LVW DEHU HWZDV DQGHUHV DOV HLQH 9HUSIOLFKWXQJ GXUFK 1RUPHQ :lKUHQG +DQGOXQJVQRUPHQ GHQ :LOOHQ YRQ$NWRUHQELQGHQOHQNHQ5DWLRQDOLWlWVQRUPHQLKUHQ*HLVW´+DEHUPDV ZLUIW %UDQGRP HLQH XQJHUHFKWIHUWLJWH $VVLPLOLHUXQJ WKHRUHWLVFKHU XQG SUDNWLVFKHU .RQWH[WH YRU ZHQQ HU GLH $QVLFKW lXHUW %UDQGRP JOHLWH Å>«@ EHUGHQ VLJQLILNDQWHQ 8PVWDQG KLQZHJ GD GDV QRUPDWLYH 9RND EXODULQGHU$OOWDJVSUD[LVYRUDOOHPGHU+DQGOXQJVRULHQWLHUXQJXQGQLFKW NRJQLWLYHQ=ZHFNHQGHUORJLVFKHQ([SOLNDWLRQGLHQW(UVFKOlJWDOOHVZRU EHU ZLU LQ LUJHQGHLQHU HYDOXDWLYHQ RGHU SUlVNULSWLYHQ 6SUDFKH $XVVDJHQ PDFKHQGHP%HUHLFKQRUPDWLYHU7DWVDFKHQ]X´
_____________ %UDQGRP +DEHUPDV I +DEHUPDV %UDQGRPKDWGDUDXIIROJHQGHUPDHQUHDJLHUW Å,DJUHHWKDWWKLV >VFIDFWVYVQRUPV@LVDFUXFLDOGLVWLQFWLRQ WKRXJK>@,WKLQNWKHWHPSWDWLRQWROLQHLW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
,FK P|FKWH QXQ LP )ROJHQGHQ GDIU DUJXPHQWLHUHQ GD LQQHUKDOE %UDQGRPVHLJHQHU.RQ]HSWLRQWDWVlFKOLFKNHLQJHQXLQPRUDOLVFKHU6WDQG SXQNWLGHQWLIL]LHUWZLUGGDDEHUXQWHUEHVWLPPWHQEHJULIIOLFKHQ9RUHQW VFKHLGXQJHQ %UDQGRPV 9HUVLRQ HLQHV .RKlUHQWLVPXV GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW HLQHU 0RUDOSKLORVRSKLH .DQWLVFKHU $UW GHRQWRORJLVFK NRJQLWLYLVWLVFK IRUPDOLVWLVFKXQLYHUVDOLVWLVFK LPSOL]LHUWZlKUHQGXQWHUEHVWLPPWHQDQGH UHQ EHJULIIOLFKHQ 9RUHQWVFKHLGXQJHQ VLFK HLQ VROFKHU $QVFKOX DOV EHU IOVVLJHUZHLVW 0LW %UDQGRPV (UNOlUXQJ GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW DOV HLQHU %HGLQJXQJ GHU 0|JOLFKNHLWYRQ:HOWXQG3HUVRQHQEH]JHQVSUHFKKDQGHOQGHU:HVHQ² XQGGDUDXI]LHOW+DEHUPDV·.ULWLN²LVWHWZDV(QWVFKHLGHQGHVYHUEXQGHQ ZHQQZLUÄLPPHUVFKRQ¶VRKDQGHOQGDQQVFKHLQWHLQH3IOLFKWVRXQGQLFKW DQGHUV ]X KDQGHOQ PLW GHQ %RUGPLWWHOQ GLHVHU 7KHRULH GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW QLFKW PHKU EHVWLPPEDU ]X VHLQ $XV GHU ÅQRUPDWLYHQ )HLQVWUXNWXU GHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW´VFKHLQWNHLQH+DQGOXQJVQRUPXQGVFKRQJDUNHLQ.DQWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYDE]XOHLWHQ]XVHLQ:HUHWZDVYHUVWHKW]HLJWVLFKLSVRIDFWREHUHLWV DOVHLQYHUQQIWLJHV²XQGGDVKHLWQDFK%UDQGRP²QRUPDWLYHV:HVHQ 'DPLWVFKHLQHQGLH$NWHQGHU1RUPDWLYLWlWJHVFKORVVHQXQGHLQZHLWHUUHL FKHQGHV6ROOHQLQQHUKDOEGLHVHU.RQ]HSWLRQQLFKWIRUPXOLHUEDU]XVHLQ :lKUHQGVLFKREHQ]HLJWHZLHVLFK.DQWVK\SRWKHWLVFKH,PSHUDWLYHLQ %UDQGRPVPRUDOLQYDULDQWHP6LQQHDOVNRQVHTXHQWLHOOH)HVWOHJXQJHQHUIDV VHQOLHHQVFKHLQW.DQWV7KHRULHGHU0RUDOLWlWUHVLVWHQWJHJHQEHUHLQHU LQIHUHQWLDOLVWLVFKHQ7UDQVIRUPDWLRQ]XVHLQ'HQQGLH8QEHGLQJWKHLWHLQHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV EHQHQQW JHUDGH]X GLH 8QDEOHLWEDUNHLW HLQHU +DQG OXQJVGLUHNWLYHDXVHLQHPZLOONUOLFKJHZlKOWHQ=ZHFNJHPlGHPLQIHUHQ WLHOOHQ0XVWHU:HUEHLVSLHOVZHLVHDOV.DXIPDQQRGHU.DXIIUDXJXWH*H
_____________ XSZLWKWKHGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQWKHQRQFRQFHSWXDODQGWKHFRQFHSWXDOVKRXOGEHUH VLVWHG ,W ZRXOG LQGHHG EH D EDGWKLQJ LI LW JRHV PLVVLQJ EHFRPHV XQLQWHOOLJLEOH RU HYHQLVWUHDWHGDVRIPHUHO\VHFRQGDU\LPSRUWDQFHLQWKHDFFRXQWRIGLVFXUVLYHDFWLYLW\ >@%XW,GRQRWWKLQNWKDWLWGRHVDOWKRXJKWKDWIDFWFDQEHREVFXUHGE\WKHZD\VLQ ZKLFK,XVHÄIDFW¶DQGÄQRUP¶²ZKLFKDUHTXLWHGLIIHUHQWLQVRPHZD\VIURPVWDQGDUG XVDJHVLQFOXGLQJ+DEHUPDV·RZQ7KHGLIIHUHQFHLQTXHVWLRQVKRZVXSLQWKHV\VWHP DWLFDOO\ FHQWUDO GLVWLQFWLRQ EHWZHHQ QRQQRUPDWLYH IDFWV DQG QRUPDWLYH IDFWV 8VLQJ ÄIDFW¶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´ %UDQGRPD $EJHVHKHQGDYRQDOVRGDMHJOLFKHGLVNXUVLYH3UD[LV QRUPDWLYÄLPSUlJQLHUW¶LVWOlWVLFKMHQVHLWVGLHVHU.RQVWLWXWLRQVHEHQHZHLWHUKLQ]ZL VFKHQ6SUDFKVSLHOHQXQWHUVFKHLGHQGLHVLFKJHQXLQDXISK\VLNDOLVFKHPDWKHPDWLVFKH LQWHQWLRQDOHVHPDQWLVFKHRGHUQRUPDWLYH)DNWHQ²ÅDQGVRRQ´ HEG ²EH]LHKHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
1RUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLNXQGXQEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQ
VFKlIWH PDFKHQ ZLOO KDW VLFK QLFKW DOOHLQ GHVKDOE VFKRQ LPSOL]LW DXI (KU OLFKNHLWGHQ.XQGHQJHJHQEHUIHVWJHOHJW'DVÅPRUDOLVFKH6ROOHQ´PHLQW ZLHVHOEVW%UDQGRPIHVWKlOWPHKUDOVHLQÅ.OXJKHLWV6ROOHQ´ 'DPLWLVWEHUHLWVGLH5LFKWXQJGHUYRQ+DEHUPDVHLQJHNODJWHQ'LIIH UHQ]LHUXQJYRUJHJHEHQXQGGHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH6FKULWWKLQ]XHLQHUP|JOL FKHQ,QWHJUDWLRQHLQHVJHQXLQPRUDOLVFKHQ%HJULIIVGHU9HUSIOLFKWXQJRGHU 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW LQ HLQ NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHV .RQ]HSW PHQVFKOLFKHU 9HUQXQIW JHWDQ Å'LHÄ6ROOHQ¶GLHGLHKLHUDOV%HLVSLHOHJHZlKOWHQ6SH]LHVGHVSUDNWL VFKHQ%HJUQGHQVH[SOL]LWPDFKHQ²DOVRGDVLQVWUXPHQWHOOHÄ6ROOHQ¶GDV LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHÄ6ROOHQ¶XQGGDVXQEHGLQJWHÄ6ROOHQ¶²VWHOOHQVRPLWDOOHVDPW XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH$UWHQGHVUDWLRQDOHQÄ6ROOHQV¶GDU(VH[LVWLHUWNHLQDSULRUL *UXQG GHU GDIU VSUHFKHQ ZUGH DOOH MHQH Ä6ROOHQ¶ HLQHU HLQ]LJHQ )RUP HLQ]XYHUOHLEHQ ² EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GHP .OXJKHLWVVROOHQ GHP +XPHVFKHQ 7RWDOLWDULVPXV ZLH HV 7KHRUHWLNHU ZLH *DXWKLHU WXQ GLH 5DWLRQDOLWlW DOOHLQXQWHU0D[LPLHUXQJVJHVLFKWVSXQNWHQEHWUDFKWHQ´'HPNDQQPDQ MHGRFK]XVWLPPHQRKQHGDPLWEHUHLWVWKHRULHLPPDQHQWH0LWWHO]XEHVLW ]HQHLQPRUDOLVFKHV6ROOHQ]XEHJUHLIHQ'HQQLP*HJHQVDW]]XP]ZHFN GLHQOLFKHQ RGHU SUlIHULHUHQGHQ 6ROOHQ XQG DXFK LP *HJHQVDW] ]XP VR]LDOHQ RGHU LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ 6ROOHQ PWH GLH 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW HLQHV XQEHGLQJWHQ 6ROOHQV LQ ZHOFKHP %UDQGRP GHQ ÅDXVVLFKWVUHLFKVWHQ .DQ GLGDWHQ IU ÄPRUDOLVFKHV 6ROOHQ¶´ VLHKW RKQH 5FNVLFKW DXI :QVFKH 3UlIHUHQ]HQRGHUGHQVR]LDOHQ6WDWXVGHUEHWURIIHQHQ3HUVRQUHNRQVWUXLHUW ZHUGHQ'DVKHLWGDVLFKGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWGHVPRUDOLVFKHQ6ROOHQV DXVHLQHUDQGHUHQ4XHOOHVSHLVHQPX:RULQMHGRFKGLHVH4XHOOHEHVWHKW VFKHLQWHEHQLP*HJHQVDW]]XPLQVWUXPHQWHOOHQXQGLQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ6RO OHQQLFKWWKHRULHLPPDQHQWHUNOlUEDU]XVHLQ .RQNUHW DXIGLH)UDJHÄZLHVRVROOWHLFKGHQ6FKLUPDXIVSDQQHQ"¶ODX WHW GLH $QWZRUW ÄZHLO 'X GDQQ WURFNHQ EOHLEVW¶ D GLH 5DWLRQDOLWlW GHV HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ :XQVFKHV EHUHFKWLJW ]X HLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ +DQGOXQJV DEVLFKW $XI GLH)UDJH ÄZLHVR VROOWH LFK HLQH .UDZDWWHWUDJHQ"¶ ODXWHW GLH $QWZRUW ÄZHLO HV IU %DQNDQJHVWHOOWH HLQH .OHLGHURUGQXQJ JLEW XQG 'X
_____________ %UDQGRPD %UDQGRP YJODXFK%UDQGRPD Å5DWLRQDOLWlWLVWGLH*DWWXQJ]X GHUDOOHGLHVH6ROOHQVVSH]LHVJHK|UHQ´9JOGD]XNULWLVFKXQWHQ)QVRZLH6FDQ ORQ +LHU ODXWHW %UDQGRPV %HLVSLHO YJO %UDQGRP D ,FK P|FKWH WURFNHQ EOHLEHQ XQG GDV $XIVSDQQHQ PHLQHV 6FKLUPV LVW GLH HLQ]LJH 0|JOLFKNHLW WURFNHQ ]X EOHLEHQ DOVRZHUG·LFKZRKOGHQ6FKLUPDXIVSDQQHQ +LHUODXWHW%UDQGRPV%HLVSLHO YJO%UDQGRPD %DQNDQJHVWHOOWHPV VHQ HLQH.UDZDWWHWUDJHQXQGLFK ELQHLQ%DQNDQJHVWHOOWHUGHU]XU $UEHLWJHKW DOVR ZHUG·LFKZRKOHLQH.UDZDWWHWUDJHQ %UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
%DQNDQJHVWHOOWHUELVW¶ E KLHUEHUHFKWLJHQGHUHQWVSUHFKHQGH6WDWXVXQGGLH RIIL]LHOOH 8PJDQJVIRUP ]X GHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW 'LH PRUDOLVFKH 1RUP Å F -HPDQGHP JUXQGORV ]X VFKDGHQ LVW QLFKW LQ 2UG QXQJ PDQVROOWHHVQLFKW ´EHUHFKWLJWQXQ]ZDU]XHLQHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWDOV$QWZRUWDXIGLH)UDJHÄZLHVRVROOWHLFKNHLQHEOHQ *HUFKWHEHUMHPDQGHQYHUEUHLWHQ"¶'RFKLVWGLHVH%HUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDO WXQJRIIHQEDU]XVFKZDFKXPGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWPRUDOLVFKHU1RUPHQ H[SOL]LW]XPDFKHQ %UDQGRPEHWHXHUWQXQ]ZDUHVVHLÅ>@QLFKWGHU6LQQGLHVHU'LVNXV VLRQ HLQH 3RVLWLRQ EH]JOLFK GHU %HVWLPPXQJ VSH]LILVFK PRUDOLVFKHU 1RUPHQ]XEH]LHKHQ>@´GRFKVFKHLQWPLUPLQGHVWHQVHLQ$UJXPHQW GDIU ]X VSUHFKHQ GD HLQH :HLWHUEHVWLPPXQJ GHV PRUDOLVFKHQ 6ROOHQV LP 6LQQH HLQHV ÅXQEHGLQJWHQ 6ROOHQV´ GXUFK 7KHRUHPH JHVWW]W ZHUGHQ PWHGLHEHUGDVZDV%UDQGRPVHOEVWH[SOL]LWJHPDFKWKDWKLQDXVJH KHQ 'DV EHGHXWHW MHGRFK QLFKW GD GHU QlFKVWH 6FKULWW HLQH .DVXLVWLN HQWODQJ P|JOLFKHU 6SUHFKDNWH RGHU HLQH Å%HVWLPPXQJ VSH]LILVFK PRUDOL VFKHU 1RUPHQ´ VHLQ PX ZLH %UDQGRP DQGHXWHW ]XPLQGHVW LVW GLHV QLFKW GHU 6FKULWW GHU LP )ROJHQGHQ YHUVXFKW ZHUGHQ VROO 'LH )UDJH LVW ]XQlFKVWYLHOPHKUZRULQGLHQRUPDWLYH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHQ)lOOHQ D XQG E HLQHUVHLWVXQGGHP)DOO F DQGHUHUVHLWVEHVWHKW 0LWGHQEHLGHQ%HJULIIHQGHUEHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ,QIHUHQ]XQG GHUIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ,QIHUHQ]VROOKLHUHLQH,GHHIUXFKWEDUJHPDFKW ZHUGHQGLH%UDQGRPLPDOOJHPHLQHUHQVHPDQWLVFKHQ.RQWH[WHLQJHIKUW KDW XP GLH QRUPDWLYH 6WUXNWXU VLFKWEDU ]X PDFKHQ LQ GLH EHKDXSWEDUH *HKDOWHHLQJHEHWWHWVLQG Å'LHKLHUYHUIROJWH(UNOlUXQJVVWUDWHJLHJHKWYRQ 3UDNWLNHQ DXV GLH GHRQWLVFKH 6WDWXV GHU )HVWOHJXQJ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJ LQVWLWXLHUHQXQG]HLJWGDQQZLHGLHVH3UDNWLNHQGDGXUFKGHP%HKDXSWED UHQ VSH]LILVFK SURSRVLWLRQDOH EHJULIIOLFKH *HKDOWH EHUWUDJHQ ² GLH DOV VROFKHHUNHQQEDUVLQGDXIJUXQGGHUGHRQWLVFKHQ)ROJHUXQJVXQG8QYHU HLQEDUNHLWVEH]LHKXQJHQ LQ GHQHQ VLH VWHKHQ´ 'LH NRQWURYHUVH )UDJH REPLWGLHVHQGHRQWLVFKHQ)ROJHUXQJVXQG8QYHUHLQEDUNHLWVEH]LHKXQJHQ EHUHLWVZLH%UDQGRPDQQLPPWJHQJHQGWKHRUHWLVFKHV0DWHULDO]XU9HU IJXQJVWHKWXPHLQHEHKDXSWEDUNHLWV]HQWULHUWHVHPDQWLVFKH7KHRULHDXI ]XVWHOOHQ HLQH VROFKH DOVR GLH GLH %HGHXWXQJ YRQ $XVGUFNHQ DXV GHQ 5LFKWLJNHLWHQLKUHV*HEUDXFKV]XJHZLQQHQYHUVXFKWPXKLHUQLFKWZHL WHU YHUIROJW ZHUGHQ (V VROO KLHU LQQHUKDOE GHU QRUPDWLYHQ 3UDJPDWLN
_____________ %UDQGRPD %UDQGRPD (EG %UDQGRPD 9JOGD]XREHQ)Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
0DWHULDOH,QIHUHQ]HQEHUHFKWLJHQGHXQGIHVWOHJHQGH+DQGOXQJVJUQGH
OHGLJOLFKHLQ$QVDW]SXQNWIUGLH(UNOlUXQJJHQXLQSUDNWLVFKHQ5HIOHNWLH UHQVJHVXFKWZHUGHQZREHLGLHGUHLIROJHQGHQYRQ%UDQGRPDXVJHPDFK WHQ 6RUWHQ LQIHUHQWLHOOHU )ROJHUHODWLRQHQ UHOHYDQW VLQG Å:LU KDEHQ HV ]X WXQPLWIHVWOHJHQGHQ GKIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQHLQH.DWHJR ULHGLHGLHGHGXNWLYH,QIHUHQ]YHUDOOJHPHLQHUW HUPlFKWLJHQGHQ GKEHUHFK WLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQHLQH.DWHJRULHGLHGLHLQGXNWLYH,QIHUHQ] YHUDOOJHPHLQHUW XQGPLW,QNRPSDWLELOLWlWVIROJHQHLQH.DWHJRULHGLHGLHPR GDOH GDV .RQWUDIDNWLVFKH DEVWW]HQGH ,QIHUHQ] YHUDOOJHPHLQHUW´ 0LW GHU GULWWHQ .DWHJRULH GHU ,QNRPSDWLELOLWlW GHP PDWHULDOHQ .RUUHODW GHU IRUPDOHQ ,QNRQVLVWHQ] LVW PLW %OLFN DXI GLH 6HPDQWLN JHPHLQW GD GLH 8QYHUHLQEDUNHLW EHKDXSWEDUHU *HKDOWH DQKDQG YRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQHUNOlUWZHUGHQNDQQ Å=XVDJHQGD]ZHL%HKDXSWXQJHQ PDWHULDO LQNRPSDWLEOH*HKDOWHKDEHQKHLW]XVDJHQGDGLH)HVWOHJXQJ DXIGLHHLQHGLH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XGHUDQGHUHQDXVVFKOLHW´0LW%OLFNDXI GHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ .RQWH[W VLQG GLH EHLGHQ HUVWHQ .DWHJRULHQ MHGRFK HLQ VFKOlJLJHU LQVEHVRQGHUH ZDV GHQ %OLFN ÅVWURPDEZlUWV´ EHWULIIW GLH )UDJHDOVRDXIZHOFKH.RQVHTXHQ]HQZLUXQVGXUFKHLQHEHVWLPPWH3UR (LQVWHOOXQJ IHVWJHOHJW KDEHQ E]Z ]X ZHOFKHQ .RQVHTXHQ]HQ GLHVH XQV EHUHFKWLJW
0DWHULDOH,QIHUHQ]HQEHUHFKWLJHQGHXQGIHVWOHJHQGH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH
)U GLH QDFKVWHKHQGHQ $XVIKUXQJHQ LVW HV QLFKW JDQ] XQEHGHXWHQG LQ ZHOFKH )RUP %UDQGRP GLHVH ,QIHUHQ]HQ EULQJW :LHVR KDQGHOW HU QLFKW YRQGHGXNWLYHQE]ZLQGXNWLYHQ,QIHUHQ]HQ"'LH$QWZRUWDXIGLHVH)UDJH
_____________ %UDQGRP YJOGD]XDXFK%UDQGRP I Å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µ9JOGD]XDXFK.QHOO %UDQGRPD %UDQGRP
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
OLHJW LQ %UDQGRPV SUDJPDWLVFKH[SUHVVLYLVWLVFKHP =XJDQJ ]XU /RJLN 8P EHL GHQ %HLVSLHOHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ hEHUOHJHQV ]X EOHLEHQ N|QQWH PDQ GHU $XIIDVVXQJ VHLQ GD GHU 6FKOX Å'HQ 7UDWVFK ZHLWHU]XYHUEUHLWHQ ZUGHMHPDQGHPJUXQGORVVFKDGHQDOVRZHUG·LFKLKQZRKOQLFKWZHLWHU YHUEUHLWHQ´XQYROOVWlQGLJLVWGKHLQ(QWK\PHPGDUVWHOOWGDVGXUFKGLH +LQ]XIJXQJ HLQHU ZHLWHUHQ 3UlPLVVH ]X YHUYROOVWlQGLJHQ VHL 'LH ÄXQWHU GUFNWH¶ 3UlPLVVH N|QQWH LQ GLHVHP )DOO ODXWHQ Å-HPDQGHP JUXQGORV ]X VFKDGHQLVWQLFKWLQ2UGQXQJ PDQVROOWHHVXQWHUODVVHQ ´%UDQGRPSOl GLHUW QXQ GDIU 6FKOVVH ZLH GHQ JHQDQQWHQ DOV PDWHULDO ULFKWLJ RGHU IDOVFK]XEHWUDFKWHQMHQDFKGHPZRUDXIVLFKGLH3HUVRQGLHGHQ6FKOX lXHUW PLW DQGHUHQ bXHUXQJHQ IHVWJHOHJW KDW E]Z ZR]X VLH DXHUGHP EHUHFKWLJWLVW6lW]HXQGGHUHQ9HUNQSIXQJHQEHVLW]HQPDWHULDOH5LFKWLJ NHLWHQQRFKEHYRUORJLVFKHV9RNDEXODUH[SOL]LWHLQJHIKUWZLUG-D%UDQ GRP LVW VRJDU XPJHNHKUW GHU $QVLFKW ORJLVFKHV 9RNDEXODU ² SURPLQHQ WHUZHLVH GDV .RQGLWLRQDO ² KDEH OHGLJOLFK GLH $XIJDEH $XVVDJHQ GDUEHU ]X HUP|JOLFKHQ GD HV VLFK EHL GHQ IUDJOLFKHQ PDWHULDOHQ 6FKOVVHQ XP NRUUHNWHRGHULQNRUUHNWHKDQGHOW'RFKDXFKXQDEKlQJLJYRQGLHVHU%HV WlWLJXQJ N|QQHQ 6SUDFKKDQGHOQGH LKUH XQG GLH bXHUXQJHQ $QGHUHU DOV NRUUHNWH EHKDQGHOQ RKQH GD GDEHL GHU :HUW GHU ,QIHUHQ]HQ JHJHQEHU GHUHQ)RUPDOLVLHUXQJYHUlQGHUWZLUG0DQNDQQGLHVHU.RQ]HSWLRQ]XIRO JHDOVRGLH%H]LHKXQJ]ZLVFKHQPDWHULDOULFKWLJHQ6FKOVVHQHLQHUVHLWVXQG GHQVLHÄVWW]HQGHQ¶6lW]HQDQGHUHUVHLWVVRDXIIDVVHQGDGLH+LQ]XQDKPH GHUÄVWW]HQGHQ¶6lW]HDOV3UlPLVVHQGLHPDWHULDOULFKWLJHQ6FKOVVH]XIRU PDO ULFKWLJHQ PDFKW G K Å>«@ GLH VFKHLQEDU YHUNU]WHQ HQWK\PHPDWL VFKHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ LQ GLHVHU )RUP DOV RUGQXQJVJHPl]X EHWUDFKWHQ XQG GLH .RQGLWLRQDOH QLFKW DOV XQWHUGUFNWH 3UlPLVVHQ ]X EHKDQGHOQ VRQGHUQ DOV HLQ ([SOL]LWPDFKHQ LQ )RUP HLQHU %HKDXSWXQJ GHVVHQ ZDV LPSOL]LW LQ
_____________ hEHUGLHWKHRUHWLVFKH(UNOlUXQJVUHLKHQIROJHGLHGLH(LQIKUXQJIRUPDOHQ9RNDEXODUV QLFKW DQ GHQ $QIDQJ VRQGHUQ DQV (QGH GHU (UNOlUXQJ YRQ ,QIHUHQ]PXVWHUQ VWHOOW EHPHUNW %UDQGRP Å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´ %UDQGRP 'HQ$XVGUXFN ÅPDWHULDOLQIHUHQFH´EHUQLPPW%UDQGRP D LQGLHVHP.RQWH[WYRQ6HOODUV 'DYLGVRQ KDWWH LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH YRQ Ä9ROOVWlQGLJNHLW¶ HLQHQ ÅSULPlUHQ *UXQGµ HLQHU +DQGOXQJDOVHLQ3DDUDXV3URHLQVWHOOXQJXQGGLHVEH]JOLFKHUhEHU]HXJXQJEHVWLPPW YJOGD]X'DYLGVRQ >HQJO @
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
0DWHULDOH,QIHUHQ]HQEHUHFKWLJHQGHXQGIHVWOHJHQGH+DQGOXQJVJUQGH
GHU %LOOLJXQJ GHU ,QIHUHQ]HQ HQWKDOWHQ LVW´ $XI GHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ .RQ WH[WEH]RJHQIlKUW%UDQGRPVFKOLHOLFKIRUW Å'DVKlWWHGHQ9RUWHLOGD VLFKGLHH[SUHVVLYH5ROOHGHULQHLQHPZHLWHQ6LQQHZHUWHQGHQ:|UWHU ZLH ÄYRU]LHKHQ¶ ÄYHUSIOLFKWHW¶ ÄVROOWH¶ GLH GLHVH3URHLQVWHOOXQJHQ DXVGUFNHQ lKQOLFKZLHGLHGHU.RQGLWLRQDOHYHUVWHKHQOlW0DQNDQQGDQQ²REZRKO SUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ>VFZLHGLHHEHQJHQDQQWH .3@NHLQHU(UJlQ]XQJ EHGUIHQXPULFKWLJ]XVHLQ²LQHLQHU6SUDFKHPLWKLQUHLFKHQGH[SUHVVL YHQ 0LWWHOQ GLH LQIHUHQWLHOOHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ GLH LPSOL]LW LQ GHU %LOOLJXQJ VROFKHU,QIHUHQ]HQHQWKDOWHQVLQGDOV%HKDXSWXQJHQH[SOL]LWPDFKHQ´ $OV (UNOlUXQJVUHLKHQIROJH KDW GLH QLFKWIRUPDOLVWLVFKH $XVGUXFNVZHLVH GHQ HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ 9RUWHLO DOOWlJOLFKHV XQG GDPLW KlXILJ HQWK\PHPDWL VFKHV 6SUDFKKDQGHOQQLFKWDOVLQNRUUHNWRGHUZHQLJVWHQVZHVHQWOLFKGHIL ]LWlUTXDOLIL]LHUHQ]XPVVHQ )U GDV )ROJHQGH JUXQGOHJHQG LVW KLHUEHL GHU 8QWHUVFKLHG ]ZLVFKHQ EHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQXQGIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ,QIHUHQ]HQGHUPLW %UDQGRPV QRUPDWLYSUDJPDWLVFKHP 9RNDEXODU LQVRIHUQ OHLFKW ]X IDVVHQ LVWDOVPLWGHP([SOL]LHUHQGHU5LFKWLJNHLWHLQHUPDWHULDOHQ,QIHUHQ]GHU :HUWGHV]XGLHVHUMHZHLOLJHQ)HVWOHJXQJEHUHFKWLJHQGHQRGHUDEHUDXIVLH VRJDUIHVWOHJHQGHQ*UXQGHVGHXWOLFKVLFKWEDUZLUG 0LW EH]XJ DXI IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH *UQGH UHVPLHUW%UDQGRP GDV 9HUKlOWQLV ]ZLVFKHQ GHUHQ ,PSOL]LWVHLQ LQ JHZ|KQOLFKHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ XQG GHUHQ ([SOLNDWLRQ IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å:HQQ GLHVH )HVWOHJXQJHQ >GHU $UW F @ HUVW HLQPDO DOV %HKDXSWXQJHQ DXVJHGUFNW VLQG N|QQHQ VLH DQJH IRFKWHQ XQG JHUHFKWIHUWLJW VWDWW HLQIDFK QXU DQHUNDQQW RGHU DEJHOHKQW ZHUGHQ :HQQ ]ZHL .RPPXQLNDWLRQVSDUWQHU EHU GLH 5LFKWLJNHLW HLQHU ,QIHUHQ] ZLH ƣ XQHLQV VLQG N|QQHQ VLH MHW]W GLVNXWLHUHQ RE F ZDKU LVW GLH %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]X HLQHU VROFKHQ %HKDXSWXQJ LQ )UDJH VWHOOHQ XQG *HJHQEHKDXSWXQJHQDXIVWHOOHQ(VZLUGHLQQHXHV)RUXP]XU/|VXQJYRQ
_____________ %UDQGRP D YJO ]X %UDQGRPV ([SUHVVLYLVPXV .QHOO GHU GHVVHQ6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWJHJHQEHUDEHUDXFKGHQV\VWHPDWLVFKHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJPLW GHULQIHUHQWLHOOHQ6HPDQWLNXQGGHUQRUPDWLYHQ3UDJPDWLN%UDQGRPVKHUDXVDUEHLWHW ]XPHLQHQUXKWGHUORJLVFKH([SUHVVLYLVPXVDXIGHUNRQVWLWXWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ(UNOl UXQJEHJULIIOLFKHQ*HKDOWV]XPDQGHUHQNDQQOHW]WHUHVHOEVWVRZRKOLQLKUHULQIHUHQ WLHOOVHPDQWLVFKHQDOVDXFKLQLKUHUQRUPDWLYSUDJPDWLVFKHQ+LQVLFKWDOVH[SUHVVLYLVWL VFKHV3URMHNWYHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQ %UDQGRPD Å-HPDQGHPJUXQGORV]XVFKDGHQLVWQLFKWLQ2UGQXQJ PDQVROOWHHVQLFKW ´ $QP .3 Å'HQ7UDWVFKZHLWHU]XYHUEUHLWHQ ZUGHMHPDQGHPJUXQGORVVFKDGHQDOVRZHUG·LFK LKQZRKOQLFKWZHLWHUYHUEUHLWHQ´ $QP.3
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
0HLQXQJVYHUVFKLHGHQKHLWHQ GDUEHU HU|IIQHW ZDV ZRUDXV IROJW ZHOFKH %HKDXSWXQJHQZHOFKH+DQGOXQJHQUDWLRQDOLVLHUHQ´ 8QEHGLQJWLVWQXQVRPHLQHKLHUYHUIROJWH7KHVHGDV6ROOHQLQ)lOOHQ ZLH F QXUGDQQZHQQHVQLFKWQXUEHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGVRQGHUQDXFK IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGLVW GKZHQQHLQHU3HUVRQZHOFKHUGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXI GHQ LQ F JHQDQQWHQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQG ]XJHZLHVHQ ZLUG LSVR IDFWR DXFK GLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLH.RQNOXVLRQLQ ƣ ]XJHZLHVHQZLUG1XUGLHVH)HVWOH JXQJVHUKDOWXQJ JDUDQWLHUW GD F HLQ LQ GLHVHU 6LWXDWLRQ JHJHQEHU DOOHQ DQGHUHQP|JOLFKHQ*UQGHQSUlYDOHQWHU*UXQGLVW'RFKZRKHUVWDPPW GLH 3UlYDOHQ] GLHVHV *UXQGHV GLH GDIU YHUDQWZRUWOLFK LVW GD HLQH 3HU VRQLQGHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ6LWXDWLRQQLFKWQXUHLQHQSULPDIDFLHRGHUSUR WDQWR*UXQG]XGLHVHU+DQGOXQJEHVLW]WVRQGHUQGLHVH+DQGOXQJDXV IKUHQ VROO" ,P *HJHQVDW] ]XP LQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ RGHU LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQ 6RO OHQ ZR HLQ :XQVFK ZLH LP )DOO D RGHU HLQH (WLNHWWH ZLH LP )DOO E QLFKW RKQH ZHLWHUHV ]XU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGH $EVLFKW IKUW HV N|QQWHQ MD DXFK DQGHUH K|KHUZHUWLJH SULPD IDFLH*UQGH IU HLQH DOWHUQDWLYH+DQGOXQJDXIWUHWHQ VROOHLQHPRUDOLVFKH1RUPZLHLP)DOO F ]XU)HVWOHJXQJDXIHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH$EVLFKWIKUHQ)HVWOHJXQJVHUKDO WHQGH ,QIHUHQ]HQ KDQGHOQ ZLH EHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH ,QIHUHQ]HQ YRQ *UQGHQ QXU XQWHUVFKHLGHQ VLH VLFK YRQ GLHVHQ ZHVHQWOLFK KLQVLFKWOLFK GHVQRUPDWLYHQ6WDWXVGHU5HODWLRQ]ZLVFKHQ3UlPLVVHXQG.RQNOXVLRQ 5D] KDW LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ GDUDXI KLQJHZLHVHQ GD GLH (LQ IKUXQJGHV3IOLFKWEHJULIIVDOOHLQQLFKWGLHVSH]LILVFKH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQ GHP LQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ XQG GHP PRUDOLVFKHQ 6ROOHQ DXVPDFKW 9LHOPHKU IKUHQVR5D]·5HNRQVWUXNWLRQDXFK3IOLFKWHQQXU]XEHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDO WHQGHQ,QIHUHQ]HQVRODQJHNHLQVLWXDWLRQVXQGSHUVRQHQLQYDULDQWHU6DW]
_____________ %UDQGRPD %UDQGRP HUZlKQW GLHVH %HVWLPPXQJ ]ZDU YHUKlOW VLFK GD]X DEHU ZHGHU DIILUPDWLY QRFK NULWLVFK VRQGHUQ VFKHLGHW MHGH ZHLWHUH HQWVSUHFKHQGH hEHUOHJXQJ DOV EHGHX WXQJVORVIUVHLQ$QOLHJHQDXV YJO%UDQGRPD VRZLHXQWHQ 'DUDXV GDHLQXQEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQQXUGXUFKHLQHIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]H[SOL]LWJH PDFKWZHUGHQNDQQIROJWZLHVLFKQRFKKHUDXVVWHOOHQZLUGQLFKWXPJHNHKUWGDDOOH IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ,QIHUHQ]HQGXUFKHLQXQEHGLQJWHV6ROOHQJHVWW]WZHUGHQ 9JOGD]XREHQ(LQOHLWXQJ)Q $XVGUFNOLFK YHUZHLVW %UDQGRP GDUDXI GD VHLQH =XVDPPHQVWHOOXQJ YRQ 0XVWHUQ SUDNWLVFKHQ %HJUQGHQV GHQ JHQDQQWHQ )lOOHQ D E XQG F QLFKW DOV YROOVWlQGLJ VRQGHUQOHGLJOLFKDOVEHLVSLHOKDIW]XEHWUDFKWHQVHL YJO%UDQGRPD %UDQ GRP 9JOGD]X%UDQGRPDVRZLH ZR%UDQGRPEH]JOLFKIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDO WHQGHU ,QIHUHQ]HQ DXFK YRQ *UQGHQ VSULFKW GLH ÅDOV GRPLQLHUHQG RGHU YRUUDQJLJ EHKDQGHOW´ZHUGHQ'LHVH'RPLQDQ]PXMHGRFKZLHGLHQDFKIROJHQGHQhEHUOHJXQ JHQ ]HLJHQ VROOHQ QRFK KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHU GHRQWLVFKHQ 5HLFKZHLWH GLIIHUHQ]LHUW ZHU GHQGKREVLHOHGLJOLFKLQWUDRGHUDXFKLQWHUSHUVRQHOOJLOW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
0DWHULDOH,QIHUHQ]HQEHUHFKWLJHQGHXQGIHVWOHJHQGH+DQGOXQJVJUQGH
VRQGHUQOHGLJOLFKGLH:DKOGHU]XU(UIOOXQJIKUHQGHQ0LWWHOEHWUDFKWHW ZLUG Å, PD\ KDYH D GXW\ WR EH LQ 2[IRUG E\ QRRQ DQG EX\LQJ D WUDLQ WLFNHWZLOOIDFLOLWDWHJHWWLQJWKHUH%XWLWGRHVQRWIROORZIURPWKHVHIDFWV DORQHWKDW,KDYHDGXW\WREX\DWUDLQWLFNHWRQO\WKDW,KDYHDUHDVRQWR GRVR7KHIDFWWKDWWKHUHPD\EHDOWHUQDWLYHSODQVIDFLOLWDWLQJIXOILOPHQWRI P\GXW\WKDWRWKHUVPD\EHSUHIHUDEOHHWFPD\H[SODLQWKLVGLPLQXWLRQ LQVWULQJHQF\µ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lQ ]XQJ GHV QRUPDWLYHQ 9RNDEXODUV %UDQGRPV KHUDXVVWHOOHQ GD QLFKW QXU 3IOLFKWHQ XQG VFKRQ JDU QLFKW QXU PRUDOLVFKH 3IOLFKWHQ IHVWOHJHQGH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH DXVPDFKHQ N|QQHQ VRQGHUQ GD )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXI 3URHLQVWHOOXQJHQ MHJOLFKHU $UW IHVWOHJHQGH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GDUVWHOOHQ N|QQHQ ZHQQ GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ GLHVH )HVWOHJXQJ VHOEVW DQHUNHQQW ² GLHVH %HVWLPPXQJ EHUVLHKW 5D] ² XQG GLH 0LWWHO ]XU (UUHLFKXQJ GHV =ZHFNVDOWHUQDWLYORVVLQGE]ZJHQDXHUYRQGHU3HUVRQVHOEVWDOVVROFKH HLQJHVFKlW]W ZHUGHQ 1HEHQ GLHVHU VSH]LILVFKHQ )RUP UDWLRQDOHU .RQVH TXHQ]ZLUGGLHLQWHUHVVDQWH)UDJHVFKOLHOLFKVHLQREHVGHRQWLVFKH6lW]H XQEHGLQJWH 3IOLFKWHQ PRUDOLVFKH 1RUPHQ JLEW GLH XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU 6HOEVW]XZHLVXQJIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]HQVWW]HQN|QQHQ %UDQGRPV 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ *UQGHQ DOV %H UHFKWLJXQJHQ]XHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQ XQGHSLVWHPLVFKHQ*UQ GHQJHZLQQWGDPLWHLQHQHXH3HUVSHNWLYH Å,PGR[DVWLVFKHQ)DOOJLOWHLQH EHUHFKWLJHQGH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ IU MHGHUPDQQ DXHU EHL )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXI %HKDXSWXQJHQGLHPLWGHQ3UlPLVVHQRGHUGHU.RQNOXVLRQLQNRPSDWLEHO VLQG,PSUDNWLVFKHQ)DOOEUDXFKWHLQHEHUHFKWLJHQGH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJQLFKW DXI DOOH +DQGHOQGHQ EHUWUDJEDU ]X VHLQ´ (LQH VROFKH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ NDQQQXQKLHUZLHGRUWH[SOL]LWJHQDQQWRGHUDEHUYRQDQGHUHQ'LVNXUV WHLOQHKPHUQDXIJUXQGEHVWLPPWHUYRP+DQGHOQGHQEHUHLWVHLQJHJDQJHQHU )HVWOHJXQJHQDOVLQOHW]WHUHQLPSOL]LW]XJHZLHVHQZHUGHQ:DVLP)ROJHQ
_____________ 5D] %UDQGRPD'LHHQWVSUHFKHQGHQSUDNWLVFKHQ,QIHUHQ]PXVWHUN|QQHQQDFK %UDQGRPZHOFKHVHLQGLHGHU.RQWRIKUHUÅ>«@IUMHGHUPDQQIUULFKWLJKlOW XQEH GLQJWHV 6ROOHQ RGHU IU GHQ +DQGHOQGHQ DXI *UXQGODJH YRQ 6WDWXV LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHV 6ROOHQ RGHUQXUIULKQZRPLWHULKPLPSOL]LWLGLRV\QNUDWLVFKH:QVFKHRGHU3UlIH UHQ]HQXQWHUVWHOOW ]ZHFNGLHQOLFKHV6ROOHQ RGHUVRQVWZHOFKH´ (EG 9JODXFK GLHQDFKIROJHQGH)Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
GHQMHGRFKYRUDOOHPLQWHUHVVLHUWVLQGQLFKWEHUHFKWLJHQGHVRQGHUQSUDN WLVFKIHVWOHJHQGH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHQ XQG KLHUEHL LQVEHVRQGHUH GLH 3URE OHPDWLNREXQGZHQQMDXQWHUZHOFKHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGHUDUWLJHIHVWOHJHQGH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHQ ÅDXI DOOH +DQGHOQGHQ EHUWUDJEDU´ VLQG RGHU WHFKQL VFKHU IRUPXOLHUW LQZLHIHUQ LQ IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ PLWWHOV PRGXVSRQHQVGLH.RQNOXVLRQDEWUHQQEDULVW DXIGLHVHORJLVFKH6SH]LIL NDWLRQZHUGHLFKQRFK]XUFNNRPPHQ 'DEHLLVWZLFKWLJGDDOOHIHVWOH JXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ,QIHUHQ]HQDXFKEHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGVLQGQLFKWDEHU XPJHNHKUW
*UQGH6ROOHQXQGQRUPDWLYH(UIRUGHUQLVVH
$XIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNN|QQWHHVVRVFKHLQHQDOVZUGHGLH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ EHUHFKWLJXQJV XQG IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ HLQH 3D UDOOHOH]XGHUMHQLJHQ]ZLVFKHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQXQG+DQGOXQJVSIOLFKWHQ ELOGHQ'RFKGLH3UREOHPDWLNUHLFKWWLHIHUHVKDQGHOWVLFKQLFKWXPHLQH EORWHUPLQRORJLVFKH6FKZLHULJNHLW,QVRIHUQLQ,QIHUHQ]HQYRQ3UlPLVVHQ XQG.RQNOXVLRQHQGLH5HGHLVWEHGDUIHVLQKDOWOLFKHU%HVWLPPXQJHQGLH GLH HLQH )RUP YRQ *UQGHQ ² VLH VLQG EHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQG LQVRIHUQ LKUH =XVFKUHLEXQJ ]X HLQHUSUDNWLVFKHQ.RQNOXVLRQ EHUHFKWLJW ² YRQ HLQHU DQGHUHQ)RUPYRQ*UQGHQ²VLHVLQGIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGLQVRIHUQLKUH =XVFKUHLEXQJ DXI HLQH SUDNWLVFKH .RQNOXVLRQ IHVWOHJW ² LP SUDNWLVFKHQ .RQWH[WXQWHUVFKHLGHQOlW :HQQ %UDQGRP LP WKHRUHWLVFKHQ .RQWH[W IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHU ,QIHUHQ]HQ YRQ GHU Å9HUHUEXQJ HLQHU )HVWOHJXQJ GD PDQ DXI HLQH %H KDXSWXQJ DOV )ROJH GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH DQGHUH IHVWJHOHJW LVW ´ VSULFKWVRLVWGDPLWQRFKQLFKWLPDOOJHPHLQHQDXVJHPDFKWREGLH.RQ NOXVLRQ GLHVHU IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ] PLWWHOV PRGXV SRQHQV DEWUHQQEDULVWRGHUQLFKW =XGLHVHUHUIRUGHUOLFKHQLQKDOWOLFKHQ%HVWLPPXQJEHJULIIOLFKHU'LIIH UHQ]HQ ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ JHQDQQWHQ )RUPHQ YRQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ LP SUDNWLVFKHQ
_____________ :HQQEHUHFKWLJHQGH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHQLP7KHRUHWLVFKHQDXIJUXQGLKUHU:DKUKHLW EHL %UDQGRPGHP(LQJHKHQGHUUHFKWIHUWLJHQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJGXUFKGHQ=XZHLVHU EHUHLWV DXI DOOH DQGHUHQ 3HUVRQHQ EHUWUDJEDU VLQG VR VLQG HV D IRUWLRUL DXFK IHVWOHJHQGH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHQ 6R IKUW LP 7KHRUHWLVFKHQ GLH %HJUQGXQJ GHU $XVVDJH ÅGLHVHV 7LHULVWHLQ:LUEHOWLHU´GXUFKGLH$XVVDJHÅGLHVHV7LHULVWHLQ6lXJHWLHU´]XHLQHUIHVW OHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ] XQG LVW DXI DOOH DQGHUHQ 3HUVRQHQ GLH KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU %HGHXWXQJGHUYHUZHQGHWHQ$XVGUFNHEHUHLQNRPPHQ EHUWUDJEDU HUVWHUH$XVVDJH NDQQDXVGHU]ZHLWHQPDWHULDODEJHOHLWHWZHUGHQ 9JO%UDQGRP %UDQGRPD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
*UQGH6ROOHQXQGQRUPDWLYH(UIRUGHUQLVVH
.RQWH[WP|FKWHLFKDXIHLQH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJUHNXUULHUHQGLH-RKQ%URR PH LQ )RUWIKUXQJ HLQHV $QVDW]HV YRQ 5RGHULFN &KLVKROP HLQJHIKUW KDW %URRPH DQDO\VLHUW GLH YHUVFKLHGHQHQ ORJLVFKHQ ,PSOLNDWLRQHQ YRQ *UQGH 6ROOHQ (UIRUGHUQLV XQG (PSIHKOXQJVUHODWLRQHQ 0LW QRUPDWLYHQ (UIRUGHUQLVVHQ ÅQRUPDWLYHUHTXLUHPHQWV´ VROOIUGHQJHJHQZlUWLJHQ .RQWH[W HLQVFKOlJLJ GDVMHQLJH EH]HLFKQHW ZHUGHQ ZRUDXI PDQ DXIJUXQG HLJHQHU bXHUXQJHQ IHVWJHOHJW LVW %HL %UDQGRP KDWWH VLFK JH]HLJW GD GHP Å>«@ %HJULII GHU )HVWOHJXQJ >«@ GHU GHU %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]XU 6HLWH JHVWHOOW >ZHUGHQPX .3@=XWXQZRUDXIPDQIHVWJHOHJWLVWLVWLQHLQHP6LQQH DQJHEUDFKW XQG ]X WXQ ZR]X PDQ EHUHFKWLJW LVW LQ HLQHP DQGHUHQ´ 'LHVH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ HQWVSULFKW LQ HWZD %URRPHV 'LIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHUVHLWV(UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQUHODWLRQHQVRZLHDQGHUHUVHLWV*UQGHUH ODWLRQHQ'LHYRQ%URRPHDXVJHPDFKWH(PSIHKOXQJVUHODWLRQGHUHQQRU PDWLYH .UDIW QRFKVFKZlFKHU LVW DOV GLHMHQLJH GHU *UQGHUHODWLRQ LVW LP JHJHQZlUWLJHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ RKQH %HGHX WXQJ'RFKYRQZHOFKHP6ROOHQXQGZHOFKHQ*UQGHQLVWKLHUGLH5H GH"
_____________ 9JO&KLVKROP VRZLH6FDQORQGHULQ5HDNWLRQDXI$XGL YRQHLQHU7HQ GHQ]VSULFKWÅ>«@WROXPSWRJHWKHUDVÄUHTXLUHPHQWVRIUDWLRQDOLW\¶WZRNLQGVRIUH TXLUHPHQWV WKDW VKRXOG , EHOLHYH EH NHSW GLVWLQFW 5HTXLUHPHQWV RI WKH ILUVW NLQG VSHFLI\WKHIRUPWKDWRXUWKLQNLQJPXVWWDNHLIZHDUHWRDYRLGWKHFKDUJHRILUUDWLRQ DOLW\5HTXLUHPHQWVRIWKHVHFRQGNLQGVSHFLI\ZKDWZHKDYHPRVWUHDVRQWRGRKHQFH ZKDW ZH ZRXOG GR LI ZH ZHUH ¶LGHDOO\ UDWLRQDO·µ 6FDQORQ $XGLV I 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHPKDQGOXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ,QWHUQDOLVPXVXQGGHP HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ([WHUQDOLVPXVOlXIWDXIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNSDUDOOHO]XGHUYRUVWHKHQGHQ 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ 6FDQORQV ZREHL $XGL EHLP ([WHUQDOLVPXV GHQ $N]HQW MHGRFK DXI GHQWDWVlFKOLFKHQ+DQGOXQJVHUIROJOHJWXQGQLFKWZLH6FDQORQDXIGLHEORH5HIOH[LRQ YRQ *UQGHQ GLH JHJHEHQHQIDOOV DXFK ]X HLQHP )DOOHQODVVHQ GHV =ZHFNV IKUHQ NDQQ (UIRUGHUQLVVHGHUHUVWHQ$UW6FDQORQV ÄUHTXLUHPHQWVRIUDWLRQDOLW\¶ EHQHQQHQ KLQJHJHQH[DNWGDVZDV%URRPHDOVÄQRUPDWLYHUHTXLUHPHQWV¶EH]HLFKQHW,P*HJHQ VDW]]X6FDQORQYHUVXFKHLFKLP)ROJHQGHQMHGRFKGLHEHLGHQ$UWHQYRQ(UIRUGHUQLV VHQQLFKWJUDGXHOOVRQGHUQPLW%OLFNDXILKUHQSHUVRQHQUHODWLYHQ*HOWXQJVEHUHLFK]X XQWHUVFKHLGHQ,QHQJHP=XVDPPHQKDQJGHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ'LVNXVVLRQXPQRUPDWL YH (UIRUGHUQLVVH VWHKW GDEHL GDV SKLORVRSKLVFKH 3UREOHP GHV ÄERRWVWUDSSLQJ¶ YJO REHQ 6LHELOGHQGHQ+DXSWJHJHQVWDQGYRQ%URRPH %UDQGRPD 9JOGD]X%URRPHI %UDQGRPXQWHUVFKHLGHWMHGRFKPHLQHV(UDFKWHQVQLFKW KLQUHLFKHQG]ZLVFKHQGHPZDV%URRPH*UQGH5HODWLRQQHQQWXQGGHPZDVGLHVHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQQHQQWVRQGHUQEHWUDFKWHWEHLGHHLQHUVHLWVDOVDXVVFKOLHOLFKEH UHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQG XQG VSULFKW DQGHUHUVHLWV LQ EHLGHQ )lOOHQ XQG GDUEHU KLQDXV DXFK EHLP XQEHGLQJWHQ 6ROOHQ YRQ HLQHP ÄUDWLRQDOHQ 6ROOHQ¶ YJO %UDQGRP IVRZLHREHQ)QXQGGHQGD]XJHK|ULJHQ$EVDW]
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
%URRPHVWHOOWGHQ%HJULIIGHUÄQRUPDWLYHQ(UIRUGHUQLVVH¶LQHLQH2S SRVLWLRQ ]X GHQ %HJULIIHQ VRZRKO GHV 6ROOHQV DOV DXFK GHU *UQGH 'LH OHW]WHUHQ EHLGHQ %HJULIIH ÄRXJKW¶ ÄUHDVRQ¶ JUHQ]W %URRPH IROJHQGHUPD HQ YRQHLQDQGHU DE LQGHP HU GLH EHLGHQ3URSRVLWLRQHQ S XQG T LQ HLQH NRQGLWLRQDOH 5HODWLRQ ]XHLQDQGHU VHW]W Å6XSSRVH S LV WUXH EXW T LV QRW 7KHQLIWKHRXJKWVUHODWLRQ>SRXJKWVTPHDQLQJÄSPDNHVLWWKHFDVHWKDW \RXRXJKWWRT¶ .3@KROGV\RXDUHGHILQLWHO\IDLOLQJWRVHHWRVRPHWKLQJ \RX RXJKW WR VHH WR SUHDVRQVTPHDQLQJÄSLVDUHDVRQ IRU\RXWRT¶ .3@KROGV\RXPD\EHIDLOLQJWRVHHWRQRWKLQJ\RXRXJKW WRVHHWR@²XQJHDFKWHWGHU:QVFKHRGHU3UlIHUHQ]HQXQGXQJH DFKWHWGHVVR]LDOHQ6WDWXV´VFKHLQWQXQHLQH$XIJDEH]XVHLQ]XGHUHQ /|VXQJ GHU ,QIHUHQWLDOLVPXV %UDQGRPV NHLQH WKHRUHWLVFKHQ 5HVVRXUFHQ EHUHLWKlOW ZDV ZLHGHUXP GHQ YRQ +DEHUPDV HUKREHQHQ 9RUZXUI QDKH OHJW Å>@GLHSUDNWLVFKH9HUDQWZRUWXQJIUGDVZDVVLH>VFUDWLRQDOH:H VHQ@WXQVROOHQHUVFK|SIWVLFKQLFKWLQGHUHSLVWHPLVFKHQ9HUDQWZRUWXQJ IU GDV ZDV VLH EHKDXSWHQ GUIHQ´ 'RFK KlOW %UDQGRP GLH (QWVFKHLGXQJ EHU GLH .RPSDWLELOLWlW VHLQHU 7KHRULH XQG HLQHU JHQXLQHQ 0RUDOWKHRULH PLW IROJHQGHP +LQZHLV LQ GHU 6FKZHEH Å,W LV QRW FODLPHG WKDW ZH JHW DQ\ VSHFLDO HQOLJKWHQPHQW DERXW PRUDO QRUPV IURPWKLQNLQJ DERXWWKHPRUHIXQGDPHQWDOFODVVRIGLVFXUVLYHRQHVEXWLWLVQDWXUDOWR KRSH WKDW WKLV PLJKW HYHQWXDOO\ WXUQ RXW WR EH SRVVLEOH >@ $ TXHVWLRQ WKHQDULVHVDVWRZKHWKHURQFHRQHKDVXQGHUVWRRGWKHVHQVHLQZKLFKDOO
_____________ %UDQGRPD 9JOGD]X)RUVW EVRZLHXQWHQ %UDQGRPD +DEHUPDV 9JOGD]XDXFK%UDQGRPEVRZLHREHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
*LEWHVHLQHQhEHUJDQJ]ZLVFKHQ(UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ"
FRQFHSWXVHLVQRUPDWLYHWKHUHUHPDLQVDQ\WKLQJVSHFLDOWRVD\DERXWWKH QRUPDWLYLW\RIPRUDOFRQFHSWV´ 0HLQHV(UDFKWHQVHUJLEWVLFKKLHUPLWGLH0|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|QQWH VLH DXFK DOV HLQH +HUDXVIRUGHUXQJ%UDQGRPVDQ HLQHPHLQHV(UDFKWHQVIHKOJHOHLWHWH,QWHU SUHWDWLRQYRQ .DQWIROJHQGHUPDHQIRUPXOLHUHQ GDVÄXQEHGLQJWH6RO OHQ¶YRQGHPEHL.DQWGLH5HGHLVWNDQQ*HOWXQJQXULQ)RUPYRQ=X VFKUHLEXQJHQYRQ3HUVRQHQDQ3HUVRQHQHUODQJHQ6ROOGHU*HKDOWGLHVHU =XVFKUHLEXQJHQQXQQLFKWDUELWUlUVHLQVRNDQQHUQXUDOVHLQHUVHLWVDE KlQJLJYRQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQGHU9HUJDQJHQKHLWXQGDQGHUHUVHLWVYRQGHQ VDQNWLRQLHUHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJHQGHU=XNXQIWJHGDFKWZHUGHQ%UDQGRP GLVNXWLHUW GLHVH KLVWRULVFKH 'LPHQVLRQ ZLHGHUXP LP JU|HUHQ .RQWH[W EHJULIIOLFKHU1RUPHQEHUKDXSWLOOXVWULHUWVLHDEHUDPNRQNUHWHQ%HLVSLHO GHV)DOOUHFKWV FDVHODZ LP*HJHQVDW]]XPNRGLIL]LHUWHQRGHU*HVHW]HV UHFKW VWDWXWH ODZ Å3DVW DSSOLFDWLRQV RI FRQFHSWV GHFLVLRQV RI FDVHV H[HUFLVHDQDXWKRULW\RYHUIXWXUHRQHV)RUWKH\VXSSO\WKHSUHFHGHQWVWKDW FRQVWLWXWHWKHRQO\UDWLRQDOHVDYDLODEOHWRMXVWLI\IXWXUHGHFLVLRQV7KH\DUH WKH VRXUFH RI WKH FRQWHQW RI WKH FRQFHSWV ODWHU MXGJHV DUH FKDUJHG ZLWK DSSO\LQJ>@%XWUHFLSURFDOO\ODWHUDSSOLFDWLRQVRIFRQFHSWVE\WKHMXGJHV ZKR LQKHULWWKH WUDGLWLRQ H[HUFLVH DQ DXWKRULW\ RYHU WKH HDUOLHU RQHV)RU
_____________ %UDQGRPE 'LHVH6WUDWHJLHLVWQLFKW]XYHUZHFKVHOQPLWGHUMHQLJHQGLH%UDQGRPVHOEVWLQ*HJHQ EHUVWHOOXQJ]XU.DQW+DEHUPDV6WUDWHJLHDOVÅQDWXUDONLQGVNHSWLFLVPDERXWWKHPR UDO´VNL]]LHUW YJO%UDQGRPEI )HKOJHOHLWHWLVWGLHVH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQPHLQHU$QVLFKWZHLOLKUH[SODQDWRULVFKHV=HQWUXP LQ .DQWV 7KHRULH YROONRPPHQHU XQG XQYROONRPPHQHU 3IOLFKWHQ OLHJW ZHOFKH .DQW ]XIROJHMHGRFKOHGLJOLFKORNDOH*HOWXQJEHDQVSUXFKHQ Å1XQZROOHQZLUHLQLJH3IOLFK WHQ KHU]lKOHQ QDFK GHU JHZ|KQOLFKHQ (LQWKHLOXQJ GHUVHOEHQ LQ 3IOLFKWHQ JHJHQ XQV VHOEVWXQGJHJHQDQGHUH0HQVFKHQLQYROONRPPHQHXQGXQYROONRPPHQH3IOLFKWHQ´ .DQW ,9 ,Q GHU ]XJHK|ULJHQ $QPHUNXQJ VFKUHLEW .DQW GDUEHU KLQDXV GD GLHVHÅ>«@(LQWKHLOXQJGHU3IOLFKWHQ>«@KLHUDOVRQXUDOVEHOLHELJ XPPHLQH%HLVSLH OH ]X RUGQHQ GDVWHKH´ %HJUQGXQJVWKHRUHWLVFK JHKW HV PHLQHV (UDFKWHQV EHL .DQW MHGRFK JHUDGH QLFKW XP GLH EHU]HLWOLFKH *OWLJNHLW PDWHULDOHUPRUDOLVFKHU 1RUPHQ GLHDXVGHPNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYJDUÄDEJHOHLWHW¶ZHUGHQN|QQWHQVRQGHUQXPGLH JHVHW]OLFKH)RUPPRUDOLVFKHU1RUPHQ²ZHOFKHUPDWHULDOHQ)OOXQJDXFKLPPHU
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
WKH VLJQLILFDQFH RI WKH DXWKRULW\ RI WKH WUDGLWLRQ >@ LV GHFLGHG E\ WKH MXGJHV FXUUHQWO\ PDNLQJ GHFLVLRQV 7KH\ DGPLQLVWHU WKHQRUPV PDNH WKHP GHWHUPLQDWHO\ ELQGLQJ´ 'LH VLFK GDUDXV HUJHEHQGH 6WUDWHJLH LQ EH]XJ DXI GDV 3UREOHP GHV 9HUKlOWQLVVHV YRQ %UDQGRPV )XQGDPHQWDOEHJULII YRQ1RUPDWLYLWlWXQGHLQHPVSH]LILVFKPRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ%HJULIIYRQ 1RUPDWLYLWlWEHVWQGHVRPLWGDULQGLH.DQW+DEHUPDV.ULWLNGHU0RUDO EOLQGKHLWXP]XNHKUHQLQHLQH+HJHO%UDQGRP.ULWLNDQHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ )RUPYRQ.DQWLDQLVPXV(LQHVROFKH.ULWLNPDFKWH LQ$QDORJLH]X5HL FKHQEDFKVÄUHODWLYHP$SULRUL¶ JHOWHQGGDGHU.DQWLDQLVPXVGLH.RQ VWLWXWLRQVEHGLQJXQJHQNRQNUHWHUPRUDOLVFKHU1RUPHQEHUVHKH$XFKHLQ XQEHGLQJWHV6HOEVWPRUGYHUERWEHLVSLHOVZHLVH YHUGDQNWVLFKGLHVHU.UL WLNHQWVSUHFKHQGGHUJHKDOWYROOHQ=XVFKUHLEXQJYRQ3HUVRQHQDQ3HUVR QHQ ]X HLQHP EHVWLPPWHQ =HLWSXQNW %UDQGRP IlKUW GDKHU LP ZHLWHUHQ 6LQQHHLQHUVROFKHQ.ULWLNIRUW Å:KDWWKHQRUPUHDOO\LV>@LVWKHSURGXFW RI UHFRJQLWLYH QHJRWLDWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKHVH WZR SROHV RI UHFLSURFDO DXWKRULW\ ZKDWWKHFRQWHQWLVIRUWKHSDVWMXGJHVDQGZKDWLWLVIRUWKHSUHVHQWRQH >@6LQFHWKLVSURFHVVKDVQRHQGSRLQWLQSULQFLSOHQRILQDOO\DXWKRULWDWLYH DXWKRULW\ QRW GHSHQGHQW LQ WXUQ RQ LWV DFNQRZOHGJHPHQW RU UHFRJQLWLRQ WKHQRUPDWLYHVLWXDWLRQLVHQWLUHO\V\PPHWULFDO´ 'DV3UREOHPYRQPR UDOLVFKHQE]ZUHFKWOLFKHQÄ0LYHUVWlQGQLVVHQ¶RGHUÄ)HKOLQWHUSUHWDWLRQHQ¶ O|VWVLFKGLHVHP0RGHOOHQWVSUHFKHQGDXIODQJH6LFKWGXUFKGDV8UWHLOGHU =XNXQIW ,FK ZLOO DQ GLHVHU 6WHOOH QLFKW GLH $XVVLFKW GLHVHU 6WUDWHJLH DXI (UIROJ E]Z GHUHQ H[SODQDWRULVFKH $GlTXDWKHLW GLVNXWLHUHQ GHQQ GD]X PWH]XQlFKVWJHNOlUWZHUGHQZRULQJHQDXGLHVHUÄ.DQWLDQLVPXV¶.DQWV RGHU DQGHUHU 0RUDOSKLORVRSKHQ EHVWHKW XQG LQZLHIHUQVLFK GHU $SULRULV PXVVRZLHGHUGDPLWYHUEXQGHQH5LJRULVPXVDOV(LQZDQGJHJHQGLHMHZHL OLJH7KHRULH QLFKWGHUHQ.DULNDWXU HLJQHW %HPHUNHQVZHUWHUZHLVH HU|IIQHW MHGRFK %UDQGRPV 7KHRULH VHOEVW GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW HLQHU $OWHUQDWLYH ]XU KLVWRULVWLVFKHQ (LQHEQXQJ GHV .DQWL VFKHQ 8QLYHUVDOLVPXV XQG VHL HV DXFK HLQHU VROFKHQ (LQHEQXQJ GLH LQ .DQWV7KHRULHGHUYROONRPPHQHQXQGXQYROONRPPHQHQ3IOLFKWHQJHJHQ VLFKVHOEVWXQGDQGHUHHLQHQ$QVFKOX]XILQGHQJODXEW %HLGHUQlKHUHQ %HVWLPPXQJ GLHVHU $OWHUQDWLYH ZLUG HV PLU XP HLQH :HLWHUIKUXQJ YRQ
_____________ %UDQGRP IYJOGD]XDXFK(VIHOG 9JO5HLFKHQEDFK LQVEHVVRZLH 9JO]XGLHVHP%HLVSLHO.DQW,9I %UDQGRP +DEHUPDV KDW VRZRKO HLQH NOlUHQGH $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ $QVSUFKHQ .DQWVXQG+HJHOVDQHLQH0RUDOWKHRULHJHOLHIHUWDOVDXFKGDUEHUKLQDXVGLH'LVNXUV HWKLN ² .DQWNULWLVFK ² JHJHQ DQDORJH (LQZlQGH YHUWHLGLJW YJO EHLVSLHOVZHLVH +D EHUPDV VRZLH
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
*LEWHVHLQHQhEHUJDQJ]ZLVFKHQ(UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ"
%UDQGRPV.RQ]HSWGHUIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQLQIHUHQWLHOOHQ'LVNXUVJOLH GHUXQJ VRZLH %URRPHV 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW LQIHUHQWLHOOHU (LQVWHOOXQJVUHODWLRQHQ LP %HUHLFK PRUDOLVFKHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ JHKHQ ,P =XJH GHVVHQ HUODQJW 6FDQORQV .RQ]HSWLRQ GHU VLWXDWLRQVDEKlQJLJHQ XQG SHUVRQHQVSH]LILVFKHQ E]Z XQVSH]LILVFKHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH EHVRQGHUH 5HOHYDQ]ZRGXUFKGLHDSULRULVFKH7UHQQXQJGHU.DQWLVFKHQ0RUDOSKLOR VRSKLH]ZLVFKHQ3IOLFKWHQXQG1HLJXQJHQLPSOL]LWXQWHUODXIHQZLUG +LQVLFKWOLFK GHU 7KHRULHNRQVWHOODWLRQHQ GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW LP JHQXLQ PRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ.RQWH[WEHVWHKWZLHELVKLHUKHUGHXWOLFKJHZRUGHQ VHLQVROOWHGLHHQWVFKHLGHQGH)UDJHGDULQREVLFKGLHWUDJIlKLJHQ0RPHQ WH GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlWVNRQ]HSWH YRQ .DQW XQG %UDQGRP 8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJ RKQH PHWDSK\VLVFK RGHU DQWKURSRORJLVFK DQVSUXFKVYROOH =XVDW]SUlPLV VHQ DXI GHU HLQHQ 6HLWH XQG OLQJXLVWLVFKVR]LDOH 2SHUDWLRQDOLVLHUXQJ SUDNWL VFKHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW RKQH $VVLPLODWLRQ VlPWOLFKHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH DQ HSLVWHPLVFKH *UQGH DXI GHU DQGHUHQ 6HLWH ]X HLQHU VLQQYROOHQ SULQ]L SLHQXQG]XJOHLFKNRKlUHQ]RULHQWLHUWHQ$OOLDQ]YHUELQGHQODVVHQ %UDQGRP VHOEVW ² QLFKW +DEHUPDV GHU HLQH VROFKH .RPSDWLELOLWlW DXVZHLVOLFKVHLQHUKLHUDXIEH]RJHQHQ.ULWLNQLFKWIUP|JOLFKKlOW²GHXWHW HLQH 6WUDWHJLH ]XU )LQGXQJHLQHU 7KHRULHPRUDOLVFKHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLW DXI GHU*UXQGODJHHLQHUQRUPDWLYHQ3UDJPDWLNDQZHOFKHEHUHLQ*HERWGHU EORHQ .RQVLVWHQ] XQG .RKlUHQ] YRQ =ZHFN0LWWHO5HODWLRQHQ ZLH LP )DOOH.DQWLVFKHUK\SRWKHWLVFKHU,PSHUDWLYH KLQDXV]XJHKHQHUODXEW Å)RU RQH PLJKW >@ IROORZ .DQW DQG +DEHUPDV LQ SXUVXLQJ D WUDQVFHQGHQWDO PRUDOWKHRU\,QWKHLGLRPRI0DNLQJ,W([SOLFLWRQHZRXOGORRNWRJURXQG RQH·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² DQG VR DFW XSRQ WUHDW DV UHDVRQV WKDW DUH FDXVDOO\HIILFDFLRXVLQWKHDHWLRORJ\RISUDFWLFDOSHUIRUPDQFHV²WKRVHLP SOLFLWO\XQGHUWDNHQFRPPLWPHQWVµ ,PIROJHQGHQ.DSLWHOVROOQXQQLFKWHLQHXPIDVVHQGH7KHRULHJHPl GLHVHQ 9RUJDEHQ HQWZLFNHOW ZHUGHQ XQG HV VROO DXFK QLFKW GHU ZHQLJ DXVVLFKWVUHLFKH 9HUVXFKXQWHUQRPPHQZHUGHQDXVGHU7HLOQDKPHDQGHU
_____________ %UDQGRPE
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²'HRQWLVFKH.RQWRIKUXQJXQGSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQ
$UJXPHQWDWLRQVSUD[LV PDWHULDOH 1RUPHQ ZLH EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GDV /JHQ YHUERWDE]XOHLWHQ'LH)UDJHVWHOOXQJEHVFKUlQNWVLFKYLHOPHKUGDUDXIRE XQG LQZLHIHUQ VLFK GLH JHQDQQWH 3URJUDPPDWLN GDKLQJHKHQG UHDOLVLHUHQ OlWGDLQQHUKDOEGHVNRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHQ5DKPHQVGLH0|JOLFKNHLWHU|II QHWZLUGGLH)RUPEHVWLPPWHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHDOVSUlYDOHQWDXV]X]HLFK QHQ(VJHKWXPGDVÅ6SLHOGHV*HEHQVXQG9HUODQJHQVYRQ*UQGHQ´
_____________ %UDQGRPDX| YJOEHUHLWV%UDQGRP I
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DSLWHO 3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW .DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
(LQOHLWXQJ
%UDQGRPV QRUPDWLYH 3UDJPDWLN ]HLFKQHW VLFK ZLH GDV OHW]WH .DSLWHO JH ]HLJWKDEHQVROO]XPHLQHQGDGXUFKDXVGDVLHDXIJUXQGGHVGHRQWLVFKHQ 9RNDEXODUVGHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIE]ZGHU%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJ DXIhEHU]HXJXQJHQRGHU$EVLFKWHQHLQHQJPDVFKLJHV1HW]GHUPHQVFKOL FKHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW RGHU 9HUQXQIW DXIVSDQQW =XP DQGHUHQ JHKW HV LQQHU KDOE GLHVHU )RUP YRQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV YRQ $QIDQJ DQ XP GLH PDWHULDOH 5LFKWLJNHLWYRQ,QIHUHQ]HQ²YRQ$QIDQJDQLQVRIHUQDOVIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDO WHQGHRGHUEHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]HQJHUDGHDOVVROFKHEHWUDFK WHWZHUGHQGLHHLQHQ/HJLWLPDWLRQVJUXQGLPSOL]LHUHQGHUGXUFKORJLVFKHV 9RNDEXODU SURPLQHQWHUZHLVH GDV .RQGLWLRQDO OHGLJOLFK H[SOL]LW JHPDFKW ZHUGHQNDQQ
_____________ :DOODFHEHVFKUHLEWGLHVH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHP,PSOL]LWHQXQGGHP([SOL]LWHQPLW %OLFNDXIGLH0RUDOLWlWDXVGHU3HUVSHNWLYHGHV6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVVHVPRUDOLVFKHU$N WHXUHDOV]ZHL(EHQHQÅ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·VGRLQJVWR RWKHUVDSRVLWLRQIURPZKLFKRQHFDQMXVWLI\RQH·VDFWLRQVE\UHIHUHQFHWRFRPPRQ PRUDOSULQFLSOHV3HRSOHZKRDFKLHYHWKLVVWDWXVDUHWKHUHE\DEOHWRHQWHULQWRTXDOLWD WLYHO\VXSHULRUUHODWLRQVKLSVZLWKRWKHUSHRSOH7KH\KDYHQRQHHGWRIHDURUVKXQWKH JD]HRIWKHLUIHOORZVVLQFHWKH\DUHFDSDEOHRIMXVWLI\LQJWKHLUDFWLRQVLQPRUDOWHUPV WHUPVWKDWDOODFFRXQWDEOHDJHQWVVKRXOGHTXDOO\EHDEOHWRXQGHUVWDQGDQGWRDFFHSWµ :DOODFH :DOODFH IKUWGLHVH'LIIHUHQ]PLWGHP=LHOHLQGLHVHQ]ZHLWHQ 6WDWXVDOVHWZDV]XFKDUDNWHULVLHUHQGHPJHJHQEHUZLUXQVLQDOOHU5HJHOQLFKWLQGLI IHUHQW ]HLJHQ ZREHL HU DXFK $XVQDKPHQ GDYRQ GLVNXWLHUW )lOOH LQ GHQHQ DXIJUXQG QRFK PDQJHOQGHU6R]LDOLVDWLRQRGHUHLQHU3V\FKRSDWKLHHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH5HDNWLRQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
'LH$XIJDEHGLHDXVGHUYRUVWHKHQGHQ$UJXPHQWDWLRQUHVXOWLHUWEH VWHKW QXQPHKU GDULQ ]X ]HLJHQ ZHOFKHQ 2UW LQQHUKDOE GHV MHJOLFKHQ =XJULII DXI GLH :HOW EHVWLPPHQGHQ GHRQWLVFKHQ 1HW]HV YRQ =XZHLVXQ JHQXQG$QHUNHQQXQJHQYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]X)HVW OHJXQJHQDOOJHPHLQJOWLJH1RUPHQLQ)RUPYRQSUlYDOHQWHQ+DQGOXQJV JUQGHQ HLQQHKPHQ N|QQHQ %UDQGRP KDWWH GLH $XIJDEH VR IRUPXOLHUW GDPDQLQLKUPLQGHVWHQV]ZHL)UDJHVWHOOXQJHQYRQHLQDQGHUXQWHUVFKHL GHQNDQQ =XP HLQHQ VROO GLH IROJHQGH +\SRWKHVH XQWHUVXFKW ZHUGHQ Å,I DQG LQVRIDU DV SOD\LQJ WKH JDPH RI JLYLQJ DQG DVNLQJ IRU UHDVRQV FRXOG EH VKRZQ LPSOLFLWO\ WR LQYROYH XQGHUWDNLQJ FRPPLWPHQWV WR UHFRJQL]LQJ IHOORZSUDFWLWLRQHUVDQGWRWUHDWLQJWKHPLQVRPHZD\VUDWKHUWKDQRWKHUV WKHH[LVWHQFHRIWKRVHFRPPLWPHQWVZRXOGEHLQGHSHQGHQWRIWKHGLVSRVL WLRQV RI WKH SUDFWLWLRQHUV DFWXDOO\ WR DFNQRZOHGJH WKHPµ 'LH )UDJH LVW KLHU DOVR RE HV HLQH $UW YRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXI +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z +DQG OXQJVDEVLFKWHQ JHEHQ NDQQ GLH HLQHU 3HUVRQ EHUHFKWLJWHUZHLVH ]XJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQN|QQHQXQDEKlQJLJGDYRQREGLH3HUVRQGLHVH)HVWOHJXQJDXFK DQHUNHQQW RGHU QLFKW 1RPLQHOO XQG LP 9RUEOLFN OlW VLFK EHUHLWV VDJHQ GD HLQH )HVWOHJXQJ HLQHU 3HUVRQ DXI HLQH +DQGOXQJ E]Z HLQH +DQG OXQJVDEVLFKW XQDEKlQJLJ GDYRQ RE GLHVH 3HUVRQ GLHVH )HVWOHJXQJ DXFK DQHUNHQQW RGHU QLFKW QXU GDQQ EHUHFKWLJWHUZHLVH ]XJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ ZHQQ GLH %HUHFKWLJXQJ GD]X LKUHUVHLWV LQ HLQHU 3URHLQVWHOOXQJ EH VWHKWDXIGLHIHVWJHOHJW]XVHLQDXV6LFKWGLHVHU3HUVRQDQHUNHQQXQJVZU GLJ LVW :LFKWLJ LVW GDEHL GD KLHUPLW NHLQ 4XDVL$XWRPDWLVPXV YHUEXQ GHQ LVW GHUDUW GD VHOEVW LP )DOOH GHU WDWVlFKOLFKHQ H[SOL]LWHQ RGHU LPSOL]LWHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ GLHVHU YRUDXVJHKHQGHQ RGHU EHGLQJHQGHQ RGHU EHUHFKWLJHQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJGXUFKGLHEHWUHIIHQGH3HUVRQGLHVHEHUHLWVGLH GDUDXV DEJHOHLWHWH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGH +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW DQHUNDQQW KlWWH 9LHOPHKU NDQQ PDQ VLFK GXUFKDXV ZHLJHUQ GLH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH $EVLFKW GDV *HUFKW QLFKW ZHLWHU]XYHU EUHLWHQ DQ]XHUNHQQHQ REZRKO PDQ GLH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH (LQVWHOOXQJ GDGDV:HLWHUYHUEUHLWHQGLHVHV*HUFKWVHLQHU3HUVRQJUXQGORVVFKDGHQ ZUGHXQGPDQHVGHVKDOEQLFKWWXQVROOWHDQHUNDQQWKDW1XUUHVXOWLHUHQ
_____________ QLFKWHUIROJW'RFKLP1RUPDOIDOOVR:DOODFHKDEHQZLUHLQ,QWHUHVVHGDUDQGDGHU %OLFNDXIXQVDXFKJHUHFKWIHUWLJWLVWZR]XHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH$UWLNXODWLRQVIlKLJNHLW HUIRUGHUOLFKLVW0HLQJHJHQZlUWLJHV$QOLHJHQULFKWHWVLFKGHPJHJHQEHUZHQLJHUDXI XQVHU ,QWHUHVVH DP ([SOL]LWHQ VRQGHUQ PHKU DXI GLH NRQVWLWXWLYHQ %HGLQJXQJHQ GHU 2SHUDWLRQHQGHV([SOL]LHUHQVVHOEVW9JOGD]XDXFKREHQ.DS)QVRZLHGHQ $EVFKQLWW]XGHPGLHVH)XQRWHJHK|UW %UDQGRPE
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
GDUDXVHEHQSUDNWLVFKH3UREOHPHKLQVLFKWOLFKGHUGHRQWLVFKHQ.RQWRIK UXQJ 'LH ]ZHLWH )UDJHVWHOOXQJ EH]LHKW VLFK DXI GLH $UW HLQHU 9HUELQGOLFK NHLW GLH GLH YRQ %UDQGRP LQVLQXLHUWH ÅH[SUHVVLYH HWKLFDO WKHRU\µ ]XP $XVGUXFN EULQJHQ ZUGH Å,WV DLP ZRXOG EHWR EULQJSUDFWLWLRQHUV WR DF NQRZOHGJH²DQGVRDFWXSRQWUHDWDVUHDVRQVWKDWDUHFDXVDOO\HIILFDFLRXVLQ WKH DHWLRORJ\ RI SUDFWLFDO SHUIRUPDQFHV ² WKRVH LPSOLFLWO\ XQGHUWDNHQ FRPPLWPHQWVµ 0LU JHKW HV QXQ EHL ZHLWHP QLFKW XP GLH $UWLNXODWLRQ HLQHUVROFKHQXPIDVVHQGHQ(WKLNXQGDXFKQLFKWVRVHKUXPGLHNDXVDOH :LUNVDPNHLW GLHVHU VSH]LILVFK PRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH ,P IROJHQ GHQVROOHVYLHOPHKUXPGLHVSH]LILVFKH)RUPGLHVHU1RUPDWLYLWlWJHKHQ GLH PLW GHU YRQ %UDQGRP KLHU DQJHVSURFKHQHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ GHUDUWLJHU PRUDOLVFKHU)HVWOHJXQJHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQDXIEHVWLPPWH+DQGOXQJHQE]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQHLQKHUJHKW 'LHEHLGHQLP)ROJHQGHQOHLWHQGHQ)UDJHQEH]LHKHQVLFKDOVR L DXI GLH )RUP PRUDOLVFKHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG LL DXI GHUHQ QRUPDWLYH .UDIW 2IIHQEDU PX GDPLW LL EHDQWZRUWHW ZHUGHQ NDQQ NODU VHLQ ZDV GLH $QWZRUWDXI L LVW'RFKOlXIWXPJHNHKUWGLH%HDQWZRUWXQJYRQ L VR]X VDJHQ LQV /HHUH VRODQJH LL QLFKW JHNOlUW LVW GLH $QWZRUW DXI L OLHIHUWH GDQQ OHGLJOLFK HLQH 1RPLQDOGHILQLWLRQ GHUHQ +DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlW QLFKW QXUIUDJOLFKVRQGHUQXQEHJUQGEDUEOLHEH (VPXDOVRYHUVXFKWZHUGHQEHLGH)UDJHQLQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$EKlQ JLJNHLWYRQHLQDQGHU]XEHDQWZRUWHQRGHUDOVKHXULVWLVFKHV3ULQ]LSIRUPX OLHUW HVPXXPGLH)HVWOHJXQJHLQHU3HUVRQDXIHLQH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQG OXQJVDEVLFKW JHKHQ ZHOFKH HLQHU 3HUVRQ HLQHUVHLWV ]XJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ XQDEKlQJLJ GDYRQ RE GLHVH 3HUVRQ GLHVH )HVWOHJXQJ DXFK DQHU NHQQWRGHUQLFKWGLHVLFKDQGHUHUVHLWVDEHUDXIHLQH%HUHFKWLJXQJVWW]W GLHJHHLJQHWLVWDXFKGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGLHVHU)HVWOHJXQJGXUFKGLHVH3HUVRQ]X EHJUQGHQ 'LH$QWZRUWDXIGLHEHLGHQ)UDJHQGLHLFKLP)ROJHQGHQHQWZLFNHOQ P|FKWHZLUGGDULQEHVWHKHQGDGLH$UWYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQDXI+DQGOXQ JHQ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ GLH HLQHU 3HUVRQ EHUHFKWLJWHUZHLVH ]XJH ZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ XQDEKlQJLJ GDYRQ RE GLH 3HUVRQ GLHVH )HVWOH JXQJ DXFK DQHUNHQQW RGHU QLFKW GDGXUFK JHNHQQ]HLFKQHW LVW GD GLH %HUHFKWLJXQJ]XLKULQSUlYDOHQWHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQOLHJW*UQGHQGLH
_____________ $QDORJ GD]X NDQQ PDQ VLFK DXFK LP HSLVWHPLVFKHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ ZHLJHUQ GLH )HVWOHJXQJDXIGLHhEHU]HXJXQJGDGHUYRUHLQHPVWHKHQGH+XQGHLQ:LUEHOWLHULVW DQ]XHUNHQQHQREZRKOPDQGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLHhEHU]HXJXQJGDGLHVHU+XQGHLQ 6lXJHWLHULVWDQHUNDQQWKDWZRUDXVMHGRFKHQWVSUHFKHQGHHSLVWHPLVFKH3UREOHPHUH VXOWLHUHQ %UDQGRPE
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
QLHPDQGYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH]XUFNZHLVHQNDQQ'LH+HUYRUKHEXQJGHUYHUQQI WLJHUZHLVHQLFKW]XUFNZHLVEDUHQ*UQGHGHXWHWGLHVSH]LILVFKH$UWPRUD OLVFKHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ DQ 'LHVH IHVWOHJHQGHQ SUl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·V XQGHYWO &·V'·V(·VHWF %HUHFKWLJXQJ]XP=XZHLVHQHLQHUVROFKHQ)HVWOHJXQJYRQ$ YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH QLFKW ]XUFNJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ ² .XUVLY JHVHW]W LQ GLHVHQ 'HILQLWLRQHQ LVW GDV GHRQWLVFKH 9RNDEXODU GRFK GHU 6FKULWW EHU GLHNRQVHTXHQWLHOOH5DWLRQDOLWlWKLQDXVZLHVLHVLFKREHQLQGHU5HIRUPX OLHUXQJ K\SRWKHWLVFKHU ,PSHUDWLYH PLW +LOIH %UDQGRPV 7HUPLQRORJLH HU JHEHQKDWILQGHWVLFKLQGHUXQWHUVWULFKHQHQ=XVDW]TXDOLILNDWLRQGHU9HU QQIWLJNHLW6LHEHGDUIVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKZHLWHUHU(UNOlUXQJ )HVWKDOWHQOlWVLFKDEHUEHUHLWVDQGLHVHU6WHOOHGDGDV=XZHLVHQYRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ HLQHU 3HUVRQ GXUFK HLQH DQGHUH 3HUVRQ E]Z GXUFK DQGHUH 3HUVRQHQQLFKWGDV6SH]LILNXPPRUDOLVFKHU$QVSUFKHLVW'LHPLW%UDQ GRPV GHRQWLVFKHP 9RNDEXODU HU|IIQHWH QRUPDWLYVR]LDOH 3HUVSHNWLYH DXFKDXIHSLVWHPLVFKH=XVDPPHQKlQJHZLHVLHREHQVNL]]LHUWZXUGHLVW GDULQ EHJUQGHW GD QDFK 6HOODUV· 9HUDEVFKLHGXQJ GHV ÅP\WK RI WKH JL YHQ´ DXFK (UNHQQWQLV E]Z :LVVHQ QXU LQQHUKDOE GHV ÄORJLFDO VSDFH RI UHDVRQV¶VWDWWILQGHQNDQQ1LFKWQXUIRUGHUQKlXILJDQGHUH3HUVRQHQYRQ XQV%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]XXQVHUHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQGLHVH$QGHUHQN|QQHQXQV LKUHUVHLWV YLHOPHKU DXFK HSLVWHPLVFKH )HVWOHJXQJHQ ]XZHLVHQ 6R NDQQ HLQH3HUVRQHLQHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQEHLVSLHOVZHLVHHLQHP.LQGRKQHZHLWH UHVGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLHhEHU]HXJXQJGD6WRIIO|ZHQNHLQH7LHUHVLQG
_____________ 9JOGD]XREHQ 'DVÄPVVHQ¶ HEHQVRZLHGDVÄN|QQHQ¶LPIROJHQGHQ6DW] HQWKlOWNHLQH1RUPDWLYLWlW GLHEHUGDVÄYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH¶KLQDXVJHKWXQGLVWGHVKDOEZHQQGDVÄYHUQQIWLJHU ZHLVH¶EHLJHIJWLVWGHVNULSWLY]XYHUVWHKHQ 9JOGD]XREHQ 9JO6HOODUV IVRZLHREHQ.DS)Q PLWGHPGD]XJHK|ULJHQ$EVDW]
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
]XZHLVHQ ZHLO GLH JHJHQWHLOLJH )HVWOHJXQJ LQNRPSDWLEHO GDPLW LVW GD 7LHUH KHWHURWURSKH 2UJDQLVPHQ VLQG 'HU :LW] GHV /HUQHQV VFKHLQW MD JHUDGHGDULQ]XEHVWHKHQGDHV]XU$QHUNHQQXQJYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQGLHVHU $UW GXUFK GLH OHUQHQGH 3HUVRQ IKUW 5DWLRQDOLWlW LQ HSLVWHPLVFKHQ =X VDPPHQKlQJHQ LVW GHPQDFK GDGXUFK FKDUDNWHULVLHUW GD PDQ LQ GLHVHU $QHUNHQQXQJIHKOJHKHQNDQQZHLOPDQGLH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XGLHVHU)HVWOH JXQJQRFKQLFKWNDQQWHRGHUZHLOPDQVLFKLUUWHLQGHPPDQVLFK]XLQ NRPSDWLEOHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQEHUHFKWLJWVDK'HULQWHUSHUVRQDOH8PJDQJPLW GLHVHU$UWYRQIHKOHQGHQ$QHUNHQQXQJHQHLJHQHU)HVWOHJXQJHQUHLFKWYRQ GHU =XVFKUHLEXQJ NLQGOLFKHU 8QZLVVHQKHLW EHU ,UUWXP ELV KLQ ]XU =X VFKUHLEXQJHSLVWHPLVFKHU,UUDWLRQDOLWlW GHP$EVSUHFKHQJHZLVVHUNRJQLWL YHU .DSD]LWlWHQ $OO GLHVH )RUPHQ YRQ IHKOHQGHQ $QHUNHQQXQJHQ EH VWLPPWHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ ² XQG GDV LVW LP JHJHQZlUWLJHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ ZLFKWLJ²EH]LHKHQVLFKDXI)RUPHQNRQVHTXHQWLHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlW 'LHHEHQHLQJHIKUWH2SHUDWLRQDOLVLHUXQJPRUDOLVFKHU$QVSUFKHGXUFK GLH 5HIRUPXOLHUXQJ LQ 7HUPLQL GHV =XZHLVHQV $QHUNHQQHQV RGHU =X UFNZHLVHQVYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQJHKW EHUGLHVH)RUPNRQVHTXHQWLHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlWLQVRIHUQKLQDXVDOV IHKOHQ GH $QHUNHQQXQJHQYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQGLHVHU$UWQLFKWV]XWXQKDEHQPLW 8QZLVVHQKHLW,UUWXPRGHU,UUDWLRQDOLWlW*OHLFKZRKOILQGHQVLFKDXFKKLHU $EVWXIXQJHQGHU=XUHFKHQEDUNHLWGLHEHLGHUMHZHLOLJHQ%HVWLPPXQJGHU REHQXQWHUVWULFKHQHQ9HUQQIWLJNHLWEHUFNVLFKWLJWZHUGHQPVVHQ'RFK VWDWW HQWZLFNOXQJV SV\FKRORJLVFK YHUVFKLHGHQH 6WXIHQ GHU 0RUDOLWlW ]X LGHQWLI]LHUHQ ² HLQ LQGXNWLYHV 9HUIDKUHQ YRQ GHP LQGLYLGXHOOH $XVQDK PHQVWHWVP|JOLFKVLQG²VFKHLQWHVPLUVLQQYROOHU]XVHLQQLFKWHUVW]XU %HVWlWLJXQJ GLHVHU SV\FKRORJLVFKHQ $QQDKPHQ VRQGHUQ WKHRUHWLVFK XQ PLWWHOEDUDXIGLHQRUPDWLYH(EHQHGHV=XZHLVHQVXQG$QHUNHQQHQVYRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X )HVWOHJXQJHQ ]X ZHFKVHOQ +LHU
_____________ 'LH (UNOlUXQJ GHP .LQG JHJHQEHU ILQGHW KRIIHQWOLFK HLQHQ LQGLUHNWHQ :HJ EHU .ROODWHUDOIHVWOHJXQJHQXQGHQWVSUHFKHQGH%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ :DOODFH UHNXUULHUW EHL VHLQHU %HVFKUHLEXQJ PRUDOSV\FKRORJLVFKHU 9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQ QLFKWDXIGDV.RKOEHUJ0RGHOO YJOGD]XXQWHQ.DS)QVRZLHGHQGD]XJHK|UL JHQ$EVDW] VRQGHUQDXI WHPSRUlUH $EZHLFKXQJHQYRQHLQHULQWDNWHQSV\FKLVFKHQ )XQNWLRQVZHLVHKLQVLFKWOLFKPRUDOLVFKHU=XUHFKHQEDUNHLWGLHHUDOVÅSRZHUVRIUHIOHF WLYHVHOIFRQWURO´EH]HLFKQHWXQGIROJHQGHUPDHQEHVFKUHLEW Å,WLQFOXGHVWKHFDSDFLW\ WRJUDVSDQGDSSO\WKHMXVWLILFDWLRQVWKDWVXSSRUWPRUDOGHPDQGVDVZHOODVWKHJHQH UDOFDSDFLW\WRFRPSO\ZLWKPRUDOGHPDQGVEHFDXVHRQHJUDVSVWKHMXVWLILFDWLRQVWKDW VXSSRUWWKHP´ :DOODFH 6HLQ$QOLHJHQLVWXQWHUDQGHUHPJHJHQHLQH$O OHVRGHU1LFKWV6WUDWHJLHKLQVLFKWOLFKPRUDOLVFKHU=XUHFKHQEDUNHLW]XDUJXPHQWLHUHQ 6WDWWGHVVHQ PDFKW HU )lOOH JHOWHQG LQ GHQHQ HV PLQGHVWHQV ]HLWZHLVH XQIDLU ZlUH PRUDOLVFKH 6WDQGDUGV DQ HLQH HQWVSUHFKHQGH 3HUVRQ KHUDQ]XWUDJHQ Å5DWKHU OLNH RWKHU IRUPV RI JHQHUDO FRPSHWHQFH RU FDSDFLW\ WKH SRZHUV RI UHIOHFWLYH VHOIFRQWURO DGPLWRIGHJUHHV WKH\FDQEHPRUHRUOHVVGHYHORSHGVRWKDWVRPHRQHWRZKRPWKHVH
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
ZHUGHQYRQ$QIDQJDQ,QGLYLGXHQLPVR]LDOQRUPDWLYHQ.RQWH[WEHWUDFKWHW 'RFKZRULQEHVWHKWGLHKLHUDQJHVSURFKHQH9HUQQIWLJNHLWGHUHQ1RUPD WLYLWlW QLFKW DXI HLQ 9HUERW YRQ 8QZLVVHQKHLW ,UUWXP RGHU ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW UHGX]LHUWZHUGHQNDQQ" 'LH)RUGHUXQJGLHVHU9HUQQIWLJNHLWNDQQ²VRZHQLJZLHGLHNRQVH TXHQWLHOOH 5DWLRQDOLWlW ² H[WHUQ EHJUQGHW ZHUGHQ GHU $PRUDOLVW ZXUGH EHUHLWVLQHUZlKQWXQGDP(QGHGLHVHV.DSLWHOVZHUGHLFKQRFKHLQ PDODXILKQ]XUFNNRPPHQ-HGRFKN|QQHQ6WDQGDUGVDQJHJHEHQZHUGHQ GHUHQ $QJHPHVVHQKHLWVNULWHULHQ VLQQYROOHUZHLVH GDULQ ]X VHKHQ VLQG GD VLHDXIGHQVSH]LILVFKHQ$QVSUXFKEH]RJHQVLQGGHULQGHUHQWVSUHFKHQ GHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQWKDOWHQLVW %HYRU QXQ DEHU GHU KLHU HLQJHIKUWH %HJULII GHU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW GHU GLH$QHUNHQQXQJEHVWLPPWHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHDOVDXIEHVWLPPWH+DQG OXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQIHVWOHJHQGOHLWHWZHLWHUTXDOLIL]LHUWZHU
_____________ SRZHUV DUHDVFULEHGPD\ILQGWKDWWKH\DUH VXEVWDQWLDOO\LPSDLUHGHLWKHUWHPSRUDULO\ GXHSHUKDSVWRORFDOFLUFXPVWDQFHVVXFKDVXQXVXDOVWUHVV RUSHUVLVWHQWO\DQGFRQVWL WXWLRQDOO\ DV IRU LQVWDQFH LQ FHUWDLQ FDVHV RI DGGLFWLRQ RU QHXURVLV ´ (EG 'LH LP YRUOLHJHQGHQ$QVDW]DQJHVWUHEWH2SHUDWLRQDOLVLHUXQJGHV*HEHQVXQG)RUGHUQVPRUD OLVFKHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ HUODXEW QXQ HEHQIDOOV HLQH $EVWXIXQJ GHU PRUDOLVFKHQ =XUH FKHQEDUNHLW MHGRFK QLFKW EHU HLQH %HVFKUHLEXQJ YRQ 9HUP|JHQ VRQGHUQ EHU GLH %HVFKUHLEXQJHLQHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQQRUPDWLYHQ3UDJPDWLN'LH=XUHFKHQEDUNHLWVWHOOW HLQH NRQWLQXLHUOLFKH *U|H GDU XQG NDQQ QXU LQ SUD[L EHVWLPPW ZHUGHQ =XUHFKHQ EDUNHLWPXVLFKDQGHUNRQNUHWHQ=XZHLVXQJYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQEHZlKUHQ GLH3KLOR VRSKLHNDQQQXU6WDQGDUGVGLHVHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVEHVFKUHLEHQ(LQHVWULNWH5H JHOXQJZDQQGLH(LQKDOWXQJGLHVHU6WDQGDUGVDXVUHLFKWXPDOVPRUDOLVFK]XUHFKHQEDU ]X JHOWHQ NDQQ SULQ]LSLHOO QLFKW JHJHEHQ ZHUGHQ GLHV KlQJW YRQ GHU MHZHLOLJHQ %H UFNVLFKWLJXQJ YLHOHU .ROODWHUDOIHVWOHJXQJHQ GHU EHWURIIHQHQ 3HUVRQ VRZLH YRQ GHU =LHOVHW]XQJ GHU 3HUVRQ HQ GLHVHU =XZHLVXQJ DE GHU 6DW] Å:HU HLQPDO OJW GHP JODXEWPDQQLFKWXQGZHQQHUDXFKGLH:DKUKHLWVSULFKW´ZLUGIUJHZ|KQOLFKQLFKW DOVZDKUHU6DW]EHKDQGHOW (EHQVRZLHLQ:DOODFH·9HUP|JHQVNRQ]HSWLRQ EHVLW]W LQ HLQHU VROFKHQ %HVFKUHLEXQJ GHU %HJULII GHU :LOOHQVIUHLKHLW NHLQHQ H[SODQDWRULVFKHQ :HUW Å7KHLPSRUWDQWLVVXH>«@LVQRWZKHWKHUWKHDFFRXQW>«@JLYHVRXUPRUDOGLV WLQFWLRQVDUHDOEDVLVLQWKHZRUOG>HJE\DVFULELQJIUHHGRPRIWKHZLOOWRKXPDQEH LQJV .3@EXWZKHWKHULWJLYHVWKRVHGLVWLQFWLRQVWKHULJKWNLQGRIEDVLV,QDVVHVVLQJ WKHDFFRXQWZHQHHGWRDVNZKHWKHUWKHIDFWVLQWHUPVRIZKLFKLWFKDUDFWHUL]HVUH VSRQVLELOLW\HQJDJHRXUJHQXLQHPRUDOLQWHUHVWV²ZKHWKHUWKH\DUHWKHNLQGVRIIDFWV ZH RXJKW WR EH FRQFHUQHG DERXW LQVRIDU DV ZH KROG SHRSOH PRUDOO\ UHVSRQVLEOH >«:@HGRQRWUHDOO\KDYHUHDVRQ WREHFRQFHUQHGDERXWZKHWKHUSHRSOH KDYHIUHH GRP RI ZLOO LQ GHFLGLQJ ZKHWKHU WKH\ DUH PRUDOO\ UHVSRQVLEOH DJHQWV ZKHUHDV IDFWV DERXWWKHLUSRZHUVRIUHIOHFWLYHVHOIFRQWUROKDYHJUHDWQRUPDWLYHVLJQLILFDQFHIRUWKLV SXUSRVHµ :DOODFH ,P9RUOLHJHQGHQJHKWHVQXQHEHQIDOOVZHGHUXPGHQ :LOOHQQRFKXPGHVVHQ)UHLKHLWXQGVFKRQJDUQLFKWXPGHUHQ5HODWLRQ HQ ]XU:HOW VRQGHUQXPGDVGXUFKXQGGXUFKQRUPDWLYH6SLHOGHV9HUODQJHQVXQG/LHIHUQV YRQ NRQWH[WVHQVLEOHQ*UQGHQ LQGLHVHU.RQWH[WVHQVLELOLWlWYRQ*UQGHQGLHVLFKLKUHU VHLWVQXULQSUD[LIL[LHUHQOlWlXHUQVLFKGLHYRQ:DOODFHDQJHVSURFKHQHQ9HUP| JHQRGHU)lKLJNHLWHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ
GHQ NDQQ VROO GHU =XVDPPHQKDQJ ]ZLVFKHQ (UIRUGHUQLV XQG 6ROOHQ 5HODWLRQHQ LP 6LQQH %URRPHV H[SOL]LHUW ZHUGHQ GD YRQ HLQHP VROFKHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ GDV *HOLQJHQ GHU ,QWHJUDWLRQ HLQHV PRUDOLVFKHQ RGHU XQEHGLQJWHQ 6ROOHQV LP 6LQQH SUlYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH LQ GHQ YRQ %UDQGRPV QRUPDWLYHU 3UDJPDWLN HU|IIQHWHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV SUDNWLVFKHU )HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQDEKlQJW
(UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ
,QKDWWHVLFKHUJHEHQGDQRUPDWLYH(UIRUGHUQLVVHLP*HJHQVDW]]X 6ROOHQXQG*UQGH5HODWLRQHQNHLQH$EWUHQQXQJGHU.RQNOXVLRQPLWWHOV PRGXV SRQHQV HUODXEHQ %URRPHV 1RUPDWLYLWlWV.RQ]HSWLRQ GHU LFK GDEHL JHIROJW ELQ XQWHUVFKLHG GLH 1RUPDWLYLWlW GLH EHL (UIRUGHUQLV 5HODWLRQHQ LP 6SLHO LVW YRQ GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW GHU 6ROOHQ XQG *UQGH 5HODWLRQHQGDKLQJHKHQGGDVLFKGLH1RUPDWLYLWlWLQGHQEHLGHQOHW]WHUHQ )lOOHQDXIGDV.RQVHTXHQVTXQGLPHUVWHQ)DOODXIGLH5HODWLRQ]ZLVFKHQ SXQGTLQVJHVDPWEH]RJ 'LH VLFK GDUDXV HUJHEHQGH XQG LP JHJHQZlUWLJHQ .RQWH[W HQWVFKHL GHQGH.OXIW]ZLVFKHQGHU6ROOHQ5HODWLRQXQGGHU(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQLVW DEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU 3UlPLVVH S LQ HLQHP SUDNWLVFKHQ .RQGLWLRQDO S Ⱥ T XQG KDW GHVKDOE LP 9RUVWHKHQGHQ ]X GHU )UDJH QDFK HLQHU DOOJHPHLQHQ )RUPYRQ3UlPLVVHQJHIKUWGLHHVHUODXEWGLH(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ2 S ȺT EHLGHUVLFKGLH1RUPDWLYLWlWDXIGDV.RQGLWLRQDOLQVJHVDPWEH]LHKW LQHLQH6ROOHQ5HODWLRQSȺ2T]XEHUIKUHQEHLGHUVLFKGLH1RUPDWLYL WlWGHU.RQNOXVLRQPLWWHOVPRGXVSRQHQVDEWUHQQHQOlW ,P *HJHQVDW] ]X HLQHP $QVDW] YRQ 6FDQORQ GHU LQ GLHVHP =XVDP PHQKDQJ SDXVFKDO YRQ ÅHQGRUVHPHQWµ VSULFKW NDQQ PLW GHP KLHU YHU ZHQGHWHQ 9RNDEXODU GHV =XZHLVHQVXQG $QHUNHQQHQVYRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQJHQDXHUEHVFKULHEHQZHUGHQLQZLH IHUQHLQH%LOOLJXQJ ÅHQGRUVHPHQW´ GHU3UlPLVVHGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ,QIHUHQ] S Ⱥ T GDV QRUPDWLYH (UIRUGHUQLV ]X T LQ HLQHQ SULPD IDFLH +DQGOXQJV JUXQGEHUIKUW 6FDQORQEHVFKUHLEWGHQhEHUJDQJYRQHLQHPQRUPDWLYHQ(UIRUGHUQLV ]X HLQHP SULPD IDFLH +DQGOXQJVJUXQG IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å7KH FODLP WKDW DQDJHQWPXVWLQVRIDUDVKHLVQRWLUUDWLRQDOWUHDWDFHUWDLQFRQVLGHUDWLRQ DVDUHDVRQFDQIDOOVKRUWRIWKHFODLPWKDWWKLVFRQVLGHUDWLRQLVDUHDVRQIRU WKDWDJHQW7KLVLVVREHFDXVHWKDWFODLPQHHGQRWLQYROYHDQHQGRUVHPHQW RI WKH DWWLWXGHV WKDW PDNH LW LUUDWLRQDO IRU WKH DJHQW WR IDLO WR WUHDW WKDW FRQVLGHUDWLRQ DV D UHDVRQ %XW D FODLP RI WKH IRUPHU VRUW FDQ EH WXUQHG
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
LQWRDFODLPDERXWWKHUHDVRQVWKDWWKHDJHQWLQIDFWKDVE\DGGLQJDQHQ GRUVHPHQWRIWKHVHDWWLWXGHVµ$XFK6FDQORQKDQGHOWYRQPDWHULDOJOWL JHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ G K VROFKHQ LQ GHQHQ GLH 3UlPLVVH HLQH 3URHLQVWHOOXQJ LPSOL]LHUW GLH GXUFK ORJLVFKHV 9RNDEXODU H[SOL]LW JHPDFKW ZHUGHQ NDQQ Å6XSSRVHIRUH[DPSOHWKDWDQDJHQWFRQFOXGHVWKDWWRPDWRHVDUHGDQJHU RXVWRKLVKHDOWKDQGWKDWKHWKHUHIRUHKDVUHDVRQWRDYRLGIRRGFRQWDLQ LQJWRPDWRHV7KLVGRHVQRWFKDQJHWKHUHDVRQVWKDWKHKDV,IKHLVPLV WDNHQDERXWWKHKHDOWKULVNVRIHDWLQJWRPDWRHVWKHQKHVWLOOKDVQRUHDVRQ QRWWRHDWWKHPHYHQWKRXJKKHWKLQNVKHGRHV%XWZKHWKHUKHLVPLV WDNHQRUQRWDVORQJDVKHMXGJHVWKDWKHKDVUHDVRQQRWWRHDWIRRGFRQ WDLQLQJ WRPDWRHV KH ZRXOG EH LUUDWLRQDO LI ZKHQ KH LV GHFLGLQJ ZKDW WR HDWKHGLGQRWWUHDWWKHIDFWWKDWDIRRGFRQWDLQVWRPDWRHVDVDUHDVRQQRW WRHDWLWµ'LH3URHLQVWHOOXQJGLHGLHVHPDWHULDOH,QIHUHQ]VWW]WN|QQWH HWZD ODXWHQ Ä0DQ VROOWH QLFKWV HVVHQ ZDV GHU HLJHQHQ *HVXQGKHLW VFKD GHW¶ 6LH VWHOOW ]XVDPPHQ PLW GHU hEHU]HXJXQJ GD 7RPDWHQ GHU *H VXQGKHLWVFKDGHQ GHQ IUDJOLFKHQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQG GDU 'RFK ZHOFKH GH RQWLVFKHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQKDWLPHLQ]HOQHQGLH%LOOLJXQJ ÅHQGRUVHPHQW´ YRQGHU6FDQORQVSULFKW"=XPHLQHQJLOWZLHEHUHLWVDQJHGHXWHWGD6FDQ ORQQXUYRQ*UQGHQVSULFKWGHUHQ%LOOLJXQJ²HUJlQ]H GXUFKDQGHUH3HU VRQHQ²GD]XIKUWGDGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQGLHIUDJOLFKHQ*UQGHWDW VlFKOLFK ÅLQIDFW´ KDW(VJHKWDOVRGDUXPGDHLQH3HUVRQ%HLQHU3HUVRQ $VWDWWGHU(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ2 SȺT QXQGLH*UQGH5HODWLRQSȺ 5T]XVFKUHLEW SVWHKWZLHGHUXPIUHLQHRGHUPHKUHUH(LQVWHOOXQJHQGLHLQVJHVDPW HLQH +DQGOXQJ T E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW ]X T EHJUQGHQ ZREHL T HLQH JDQ]H )DPLOLH VXEVWLWXWLRQVlTXLYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDE VLFKWHQEH]HLFKQHQNDQQ
_____________ 6FDQORQI%URRPHVSULFKWLP=XVDPPHQKDQJVHLQHU7KHRULHGHUÅQRUPD WLYHUHTXLUHPHQWV´ÅUHDVRQVUHODWLRQ´XQGÅRXJKWVUHODWLRQ´HEHQIDOOVYRQPDWHULDOHQ .RQGLWLRQDOHQ YJO%URRPH 9JOREHQ 6FDQORQ 'LH 3IOLFKW HLQHU 3HUVRQ ]X KHOIHQ NDQQ P|JOLFKHUZHLVH HEHQVR DXI YHUVFKLHGHQH +DQGOXQJVZHLVHQ DGlTXDW HLQJHO|VW ZHUGHQ ZLH GHU :XQVFK WURFNHQ ]X EOHLEHQ ² 'LH5HGHYRQ+DQGOXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQVROOHLQH,QGLIIHUHQ]JHJHQEHU GHU NDXVDOHQ (IIL]LHQ] YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ DXVGUFNHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH KDEHQ QLFKW +DQGOXQJHQ RGHU SK\VLNDOLVFKH (UHLJQLVVH DOV LKUH ÄSKlQRPHQDOH 2EHUIOlFKH¶ GXUFK ZHOFKH VLH EHUKDXSW HUVW OHVEDU ZUGHQ GLHVH ÄSKlQRPHQDOH 2EHUIOlFKH¶ LVW QXUVFKHLQEDUDXWKHQWLVFKHURGHUZHQLJHUDQIlOOLJIU7lXVFKXQJHQDOVHQWVSUHFKHQGH VSUDFKOLFKH bXHUXQJHQ 'LH VSUDFKOLFKH $UWLNXODWLRQ HLQHU +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW DOV .RQVHTXHQ]DXVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJHLQHVHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ+DQGOXQJVJUXQGHVPXDOV HEHQVR YHUOlOLFK EHWUDFKWHW ZHUGHQ ZLH GHUHQ QLFKWVSUDFKOLFKH $UWLNXODWLRQ E]Z 5HDOLVLHUXQJLQHLQHU+DQGOXQJ DOV%HOHJGHU)HKOHUKDIWLJNHLWGK8QZDKUKDIWLJNHLW GHUDUWLJHU$UWLNXODWLRQHQEOHLEWXQVQLFKWVDQGHUHVDOVGHUHQ,QNRPSDWLELOLWlWPLWHQW
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ
'LH(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ2 SȺT JLOWIU$JGZ $DQHUNHQQWGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIS JHKWGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXISHLQOHJWVLFK DXISIHVW 'DUDXVIROJWGD%$HLQH)HVWOHJXQJVRZRKODXISDOVDXFKDXIT]XZHLVW 'LHVH)HVWOHJXQJJLOWXQDEKlQJLJYRQ$·V%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XS (VEHVWHKWLQGHQ$XJHQ%·VHLQQRUPDWLYHV(UIRUGHUQLVIU$T]XUHDOLVLH UHQ ,P EHUHLWV JHQDQQWHQ %HLVSLHO EHGHXWHW GLHV GD $ HLQH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GHQ:XQVFKGLH1RUGZDQGGHV+DOI'RPHLPW@ODVVHQVLFKLPPHU8P VWlQGHGHQNHQXQWHUGHQHQLFKJODXEHQN|QQWHGDWHLQHEHVWLPPWH(LJHQVFKDIWEH VLW]H²EHLQDKHYRQHLQHP%lUHQJHIUHVVHQZRUGHQ]XVHLQLQGHU6WDQIRUG%LEOLRWKHN JHVWDQGHQ ]X KDEHQ HLQH =XFNHUVSXU LP 6XSHUPDUNW KLQWHUODVVHQ ]X KDEHQ XVZ ² XQGQLFKWLFK'DVNDQQVLFKLQPHLQHQ+DQGOXQJHQQLHGHUVFKODJHQGHQQHLQHhEHU ]HXJXQJ GLH LFK PLW ÄLFK¶ DXVGUFNHQ ZUGH NDQQ IU PHLQ SUDNWLVFKHV %HJUQGHQ XQG+DQGHOQLQDOOHQGHQNEDUHQ6LWXDWLRQHQLQHLQHU:HLVHYRQ%HGHXWXQJVHLQGHU NHLQH DQGHUV DXVJHGUFNWH hEHU]HXJXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQ NDQQ (V ZLUG LPPHU 6LWXDWLR QHQJHEHQLQGHQHQLFKQLFKWHUNHQQHQNDQQGDLFKWELQ,QGLHVHQ)lOOHQZLUGHV PLU QLFKW JHOLQJHQ LQ GHU JOHLFKHQ :HLVH $EVLFKWHQ XQG +DQGOXQJVPRWLYH DXI GHU *UXQGODJHYRQhEHU]HXJXQJHQGDUEHUDXV]XELOGHQZDVWWXQ VROOWHZLHLFKHVDQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
GDVQRUPDWLYH(UIRUGHUQLVMHGHQ7DJDQGHU.OHWWHUZDQG]XWUDLQLHUHQ2E$ LQ GHU 3HUVSHNWLYH YRQ % ]X GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI S EHVWHKHQG DXV GHQ JHQDQQWHQ EHLGHQ 7HLOIHVWOHJXQJHQ EHUHFKWLJW LVW VSLHOW KLHUEHL NHLQH 5ROOH 'LH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGLHVHU5HODWLRQQRUPDWLYHU(UIRUGHUQLVVHXQG GHU *UQGH5HODWLRQ YRQ GHU 6FDQORQ LQ VHLQHP 7RPDWHQ%HLVSLHO JH VSURFKHQ KDW EHVWHKW QXQ GDULQ GD LQ VHLQHP %HLVSLHO GLH ÄELOOLJHQGH¶ 3HUVRQ % GHU $XIIDVVXQJ LVW GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ $ KDEH JXWH *UQGH IU GLH3URHLQVWHOOXQJ GDPDQ QLFKWV HVVHQVROOWH ZDV GHU HLJHQHQ*H VXQGKHLWVFKDGHWVRZLHIUGLHhEHU]HXJXQJGD7RPDWHQJHVXQGKHLWV VFKlGOLFK VLQG 2E GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ VHOEVW GLHVH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GLH LQVJHVDPWSDXVPDFKHQ QXQLKUHUVHLWVEHVLW]WRGHUQLFKWLVWIUGLHRUG QXQJVJHPlH =XVFKUHLEXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQGHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GXUFK GLH ÄELOOLJHQGH¶3HUVRQLUUHOHYDQW 'LH*UQGH5HODWLRQSȺ5TJLOWIU$JGZ %ZHLVW$HLQH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XU)HVWOHJXQJDXIS]X 'DUDXVIROJWGD%$HLQH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XU)HVWOHJXQJDXIT]XZHLVW 'LHVH %HUHFKWLJXQJ JLOW XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ $·V $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU )HVWOH JXQJDXIS $EHVLW]WLQGHQ$XJHQ%·VHLQHQ*UXQGT]XUHDOLVLHUHQ
_____________ VRQVWHQWXQZUGHZHQQHVXPhEHU]HXJXQJHQGDUEHUJHKWZDVLFKWXQVROOWH>@ Ä,FK¶ KDW VHLQ 6SUDFK+HLPVSLHO EHL $QHUNHQQXQJHQ YRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXI HLQ +DQ GHOQXQGLQ]ZHLWHU/LQLHEHLP$XVGUFNHQYRQhEHU]HXJXQJHQXQG:QVFKHQGLH DOV3UlPLVVHQGLUHNWIUSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQUHOHYDQWVLQGGLH$EVLFKWVELOGXQJHQDOV .RQNOXVLRQHQKDEHQ>@Ä,FK¶LVW]ZDUXQWHUEHVWLPPWHQ%HGLQJXQJHQGXUFKDQGHUH $XVGUFNH DXVWDXVFKEDU DEHU GDV NDQQ VWHWV GXUFK HLQH bQGHUXQJ GHU NROODWHUDOHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQXQG:QVFKH DXIHLQH:HLVH DQQXOOLHUWZHUGHQ]XGHUHVLP)DOOYRQ ÄLFK¶NHLQH(QWVSUHFKXQJJLEW'DVOLHJWGDUDQGDGDVZDVÄLFK¶DXVGUFNWQlPOLFK GDV(LQJHKHQHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJGXUFK$QHUNHQQHQHWZDVLVWZDVQXULFKWXQNDQQ0LW :HQGXQJHQ GLH EHLP SUDNWLVFKHQ %HJUQGHQ QLFKW ZLH (UVWH3HUVRQ:HQGXQJHQ IXQJLHUHQ HWZD1DPHQRGHU%HVFKUHLEXQJHQ NDQQPDQMHPDQGHP)HVWOHJXQJHQ]X HUNHQQHQ >@ 'RFK GDV $QHUNHQQHQ YRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ LVW GLH JUXQGOHJHQGH :HLVH VLH HLQ]XJHKHQXQGGDV(LQJHKHQYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQOlWVLFKQLFKWDXIGDV=XHUNHQQHQUHGX ]LHUHQ DXFK QLFKW DQ VLFK VHOEVW´ %UDQGRP D 9JO GD]X 3HUU\ I Å7KHSURSRVDO>«@LVWKDWWKHUHLVQRWDQLGHQWLW\RUHYHQDQLVRPRUSKLFFRUUH VSRQGHQFHEXWRQO\DV\VWHPDWLFUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKHEHOLHIVWDWHVRQHLVLQDQG ZKDWRQHWKHUHE\EHOLHYHV>«@:HKDYHKHUHDPHWDSK\VLFDOO\EHQLJQIRUPRIOLPLWHG DFFHVVLELOLW\$Q\RQHDWDQ\WLPHFDQKDYHDFFHVVWRDQ\SURSRVLWLRQ%XWQRWLQDQ\ ZD\$Q\RQHFDQEHOLHYHRI-RKQ3HUU\WKDWKHLVPDNLQJDPHVV$QGDQ\RQHFDQEH LQWKHEHOLHIVWDWHFODVVLILHGE\WKHVHQWHQFHÄ,DPPDNLQJDPHVV¶%XWRQO\,FDQKDYH WKDWEHOLHIE\EHLQJLQWKDWVWDWH´
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ
:LHGHUXPEHLVSLHOKDIWEHGHXWHWGLHVGD%$HLQH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XGHP :XQVFK WURFNHQ ]X EOHLEHQ VRZLH ]X GHU hEHU]HXJXQJ GD GDV $XI VSDQQHQGHV6FKLUPV$YRU1lVVHVFKW]HQZUGH]XJHZLHVHQKDW'DPLW EHVWHKWDXV%·V3HUVSHNWLYHIU$HLQSULPDIDFLH*UXQGGHQ6FKLUPDXI]X VSDQQHQ2E$VHOEVWHLQH)HVWOHJXQJDXISDQHUNHQQWVSLHOWKLHUEHLNHLQH 5ROOH ,P *HJHQVDW] ]XP QRUPDWLYHQ (UIRUGHUQLV JHOWHQ *UQGH DOOJHPHLQ VLH VLQG QXU YRQ GHU %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]X HLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ )HVWOHJXQJ GHU KDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQLQGHQ$XJHQGHV=XZHLVHUVXQGQLFKWYRQGHU$QHU NHQQXQJ GLHVHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGH GXUFKGLH KDQGHOQGH3HUVRQVHOEVW DE KlQJLJ'DPLWLVW]XPHLQHQ6FDQORQV$XVGUXFNGHU%LOOLJXQJGHU+DQG OXQJVJUQGH ÅHQGRUVHPHQW´ GXUFK GLH 3HUVRQ GLH GHRQWLVFKH 6WDWXV ]XZHLVWQRUPDWLYTXDOLIL]LHUW=XPDQGHUHQLVWGDPLWGHU$EWUHQQEDUNHLW GHU .RQNOXVLRQ YRQ GHU %URRPH LP .RQWH[W GHU *UQGH5HODWLRQ JH VSURFKHQ KDW 5HFKQXQJ JHWUDJHQ 'LH *OWLJNHLW GHU .RQNOXVLRQ GLH %HUHFKWLJXQJ]XT LVWKLHULP*HJHQVDW]]XPQRUPDWLYHQ(UIRUGHUQLVDEKlQ JLJYRQGHU*OWLJNHLWGHU3UlPLVVH GLH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XS LQGHQ$XJHQ GHV=XZHLVHUV(UVWGLHGHRQWLVFKH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X )HVWOHJXQJHQ HUODXEW GDPLW HLQH DGlTXDWH %HVFKUHL EXQJ GHU 'LIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJV *UQGHQ XQG QRUPDWLYHQ +DQGOXQJV (UIRUGHUQLVVHQ )UPHLQJHJHQZlUWLJHV$QOLHJHQLVWQXQGHU8QWHUVFKLHGGHUEHLGHQ YRUJHQDQQWHQ5HODWLRQHQ]XU6ROOHQ5HODWLRQYRQEHVRQGHUHU%HGHXWXQJ 'LH6ROOHQ5HODWLRQSȺ2TJLOWIU$JGZ %ZHLVW$HLQH)HVWOHJXQJDXIS]X %ZHLVW$HLQH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XU)HVWOHJXQJDXIS]X 'DUDXVIROJWGD%$HLQH)HVWOHJXQJDXIT]XZHLVW 'LHVH)HVWOHJXQJJLOWXQDEKlQJLJYRQ$·V$QHUNHQQXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJ DXIS $VROOLQGHQ$XJHQ%·VTUHDOLVLHUHQ ,P HEHQIDOOV EHUHLWV EHNDQQWHQ %HLVSLHO EHGHXWHW GLHV GD % DXIJUXQG ZHOFKHUbXHUXQJHQ$·VXQGDQGHUHU8PVWlQGHDXFKLPPHU $ HLQH )HVWOHJXQJ XQG HLQH %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]X GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH 1RUP GDPDQQLHPDQGHPJUXQGORVVFKDGHQVROOWHVRZLHDXIGLHhEHU]HXJXQJ GD GDV :HLWHUYHUEUHLWHQ YRQ *HUFKWHQ HLQHU 3HUVRQ JUXQGORV VFKDGHQ ZUGH]XJHZLHVHQKDW'DPLWEHVWHKWIU$HLQSUlYDOHQWHU*UXQGGLH*H UFKWHQLFKWZHLWHU]XYHUEUHLWHQ DXVGHU6LFKWGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQ3HUVRQ%
_____________ 9JOREHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
VROO$HQWVSUHFKHQGKDQGHOQ2E$VHOEVWHLQH)HVWOHJXQJDXISDQHUNHQQW VSLHOWKLHUEHLNHLQH5ROOH ,P *HJHQVDW] ]XP QRUPDWLYHQ (UIRUGHUQLV JHOWHQ SUlYDOHQWH *UQGH DOVR VROFKH GLH DOV3UlPLVVH LQHLQHU 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ IXQJLHUHQ N|QQHQ DOOJH PHLQGKVLHVLQGQXUYRQHLQHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJGHUKDQGHOQ GHQ3HUVRQLQGHQ$XJHQGHV=XZHLVHUVXQGQLFKWYRQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ GLHVHU)HVWOHJXQJGXUFKGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQVHOEVWDEKlQJLJ,P*HJHQ VDW]]XP|JOLFKHQRGHUSULPDIDFLH*UQGHQDOVRVROFKHQGLHDOV3UlPLVVHLQ HLQHU*UQGH5HODWLRQIXQJLHUHQN|QQHQEHGUIHQSUlYDOHQWH*UQGHQLFKW QXUGHU=XZHLVXQJHLQHU%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXISVRQGHUQ GHU=XZHLVXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIS $OOHLQ GLHVH 'LIIHUHQ]HQ GHU 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ GLH LQ %UDQGRPV 9HU VWlQGQLVHLQHIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]DXVGUFNWJHJHQEHUHLQHU VHLWV GHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ GLH HEHQIDOOV HLQH IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH ,QIHUHQ] DXVGUFNWVRZLH DQGHUHUVHLWVGHU *UQGH5HODWLRQ GLH HLQH EH UHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]DXVGUFNWN|QQHQHUNOlUHQ D LQZLHIHUQLQGHU3HUVSHNWLYHYRQ%GDVQRUPDWLYH(UIRUGHUQLVHLQHU+DQG OXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW T QXQ QLFKWPHKU QXU IU $ DOOHLQ VRQGHUQ JHQHUHOOGKXQDEKlQJLJYRQ$·V$QHUNHQQXQJGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHS JLOWXQG E LQZLHIHUQ $ % & ' HWF PLW S QLFKW QXU HLQHQ P|JOLFKHQ VRQGHUQ HLQHQ SUlYDOHQWHQ *UXQG ]X HLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQG OXQJVDEVLFKWTEHVLW]W 'DUDXVIROJW GD GLH 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ GLH 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW GHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ EHVLW]W G K HV JHKW XP HLQH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQG OXQJVDEVLFKWTXQG]XJOHLFK GDGLH6ROOHQ5HODWLRQGLH:HLWHGHU*UQGH5HODWLRQEHVLW]WGKHV JHKW XP HLQH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW GLH XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GLHVHU )HVWOHJXQJ GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQVHOEVWJLOW'DPLWLVWDXFKKLHUGHU$EWUHQQEDUNHLWGHU.RQNOXVLRQ GLH %URRPH IU GLH 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ JHIRUGHUW KDW 5HFKQXQJ JHWUDJHQ 'LH*OWLJNHLWGHU.RQNOXVLRQLVWKLHUZLHGHUXPLP*HJHQVDW]]XPQRU PDWLYHQ (UIRUGHUQLV YRQ GHU *OWLJNHLW GHU 3UlPLVVH LQ GHQ $XJHQ GHV =XZHLVHUVDEKlQJLJ %URRPHVSULFKWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJYRQHLQHPÄVHWRIUHTXLUHG SURSRVLWLRQV¶ GKHUIRUGHUOLFKLQGHQ$XJHQGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQ3HUVRQ RKQH GLHV MHGRFK KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU GHRQWLVFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GHV =X ZHLVHQVE]Z$QHUNHQQHQV]XGLIIHUHQ]LHUHQ Å>«@VXSSRVHWKHFRGH>RI
_____________ 9JOREHQ 9JOREHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ
UDWLRQDOLW\@ KDV WKH VWUXFWXUDO IHDWXUH WKDW UDWLRQDOLW\ UHTXLUHV \RX WR ) ZKHQHYHULWERWKUHTXLUHV\RXWR*DQGUHTXLUHV\RXWR)LI\RX*7KHQ LIWKHVHWRIUHTXLUHGSURSRVLWLRQVFRQWDLQVWKHSURSRVLWLRQWKDW\RX*DQG WKHSURSRVLWLRQWKDW\RX)LI\RX*LWFRQWDLQVWKHSURSRVLWLRQWKDW\RX) ,I WKLV LV VR UDWLRQDO GHWDFKPHQW LV YDOLG´ ,Q GHP KLHU YRQ %UDQGRP EHUQRPPHQHQ0RGHOOGHUGHRQWLVFKHQ.RQWRIKUXQJEHVDJWGDVÄUHTXL UHG¶GLH=XZHLVXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJ XQEHVHKHQHLQHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ$Q HUNHQQXQJ 'LH$EWUHQQEDUNHLWGLHIUGHQhEHUJDQJYRQGHU(UIRUGHU QLV5HODWLRQ ]XU 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ HUIRUGHUOLFK LVW KlQJW GDPLW DQ GHU 3HUVSHNWLYHQGLIIHUHQ]LP=XZHLVHQE]Z$QHUNHQQHQGHU)HVWOHJXQJE]Z %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]XU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI * E]Z S LQ RELJHU 1RWDWLRQ :LUG * YRQ GHU KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ DQHUNDQQW XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU =XZHLVXQJ HLQHU%HUHFKWLJXQJGXUFKGLHEHXUWHLOHQGH3HUVRQVRJLOWGLH(UIRUGHUQLV 5HODWLRQ:LUGKLQJHJHQXQDEKlQJLJYRQGHUDNWXHOOHQ$QHUNHQQXQJYRQ *GXUFKGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQHLQH)HVWOHJXQJDXI*VRZLHHLQH%HUHFK WLJXQJ]XGLHVHU)HVWOHJXQJ]XJHZLHVHQVRNDQQGLH.RQNOXVLRQGLHGLH )RUGHUXQJQDFKE]Z)HVWOHJXQJDXI)DEJHOHLWHWZHUGHQ %URRPH EH]HLFKQHW DXV GHU 3HUVSHNWLYH UDWLRQDOHU (UIRUGHUQLVVH GLHVHV ÅUDWLRQDO GHWDFKPHQW´ DOV ÅXQDWWUDFWLYH´ LQVRIHUQ GLH Ä1RWZHQGLJNHLW¶ YRQ*RGHULPGHRQWLVFKHQ9RNDEXODUGLH=XZHLVXQJGHU)HVWOHJXQJDXI *XQEHVHKHQGHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQQLFKWXQPLWWHOEDU HLQVLFKWLJ LVW VRQGHUQ ZHLWHUHU 4XDOLIL]LHUXQJ EHGDUI 2GHU ZLHGHUXP GHRQWLVFK HLQHGHUDUWLJH=XZHLVXQJGHU)HVWOHJXQJDXI*EHGDUIGHVP|J OLFKHQ $XVZHLVHV LKUHU %HUHFKWLJXQJ 2KQH GLHVH 4XDOLIL]LHUXQJ JLOW ZDV %URRPH YRQ UDWLRQDOHQ (UIRUGHUQLVVHQ DXVJHPDFKW KDW Å5DWLRQDOLW\ UH TXLUHV \RX WR LQWHQG WR GR RQO\ ZKDW \RX ILUVWSHUVRQDOO\ EHOLHYH \RX RXJKWWRGR´)UPHLQ,QWHUHVVHKLQJHJHQLVWJHUDGHMHQH5HODWLRQPLW
_____________ %URRPH0V.DSÅ5HTXLUHPHQWVRI5DWLRQDOLW\´ %URRPH0V.DSÅ5HTXLUHPHQWVRI5DWLRQDOLW\´%URRPH GLVNXWLHUWHWOLFKH ÄUHTXLUHPHQWVRIUDWLRQDOLW\¶ZREHLOHGLJOLFK)RUPHQYRQ:LGHUVSUXFKVIUHLKHLWYDULLHUW ZHUGHQ,QGLHVHP6LQQHLVW%URRPHDXIMHGHQ)DOO]X]XVWLPPHQZHQQHUGLHVHÄUH TXLUHPHQWVRIUDWLRQDOLW\¶ DOVOHGLJOLFK]X QLFKWDEWUHQQEDUHQ5HODWLRQHQIKUHQGEH WUDFKWHW HUEH]HLFKQHWGLHVH(UIRUGHUQLVVHDOVÅZLGHVFRSHUHTXLUHPHQWV´ HEG LQVR IHUQVLHVLFKQLFKWDXIEHVWLPPWH(LQVWHOOXQJHQEH]LHKHQVRQGHUQOHGLJOLFKDXIJDQ]H .RQGLWLRQDOH Å5HODWLRQV DPRQJ \RXU EHOLHIV DQG LQWHQWLRQV DUH UHJXODWHG E\ RXJKWV WKDWJRYHUQWKHVHUHODWLRQV²ÄZLGHVFRSHRXJKWV¶,VKDOOFDOOWKHP7KH\LPSO\QRQDU URZVFRSHQRUPDWLYHFRQGLWLRQVRQLQGLYLGXDOEHOLHIVRULQWHQWLRQV´ %URRPH YJODXFKHEG II %URRPH0V.DSÅ5HTXLUHPHQWVRI5DWLRQDOLW\´,P3UDNWLVFKHQVRPHLQH DQ%URRPHV5HVWULNWLRQDQVFKOLHHQGH$UJXPHQWDWLRQIRUGHUWGHUhEHUJDQJYRQÄZL GHVFRSH¶]XÄQDUURZVFRSHUHTXLUHPHQWV¶HLQHHLJHQVWlQGLJH4XDOLIL]LHUXQJGLHVHU(U IRUGHUQLV6WDQGDUGV5DWLRQDOLWlWNDQQKLHUQLFKWGXUFKORJLVFKH:LGHUVSUXFKVIUHLKHLW DOOHLQHUIDWZHUGHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
GHU Ä1RWZHQGLJNHLW¶ YRQ * E]Z GHUHQ ZHLWHUH 4XDOLIL]LHUXQJ DWWUDNWLY 'HQQ GLHVH $EWUHQQEDUNHLW PDUNLHUW JHUDGH GHQMHQLJHQ %HUHLFK GHRQWL VFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GHU GLH IUDJOLFKHQ PRUDOLVFKHQ G K LQWHUVXEMHNWLY YHUELQGOLFKHQ+DQGOXQJVHUZDUWXQJHQHLQVFKOLHW
3UDNWLVFKH5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG9HUQQIWLJNHLW
(QWODQJ GHU LP YRUVWHKHQGHQ HQWZLFNHOWHQ 'LIIHUHQ]HQ GHRQWLVFKHU 5HLFKZHLWHQ KDW EHUHLWV :0 6LEOH\ GLH 6WDQGDUGV UDWLRQDO UDWLRQDO XQG YHUQQIWLJ UHDVRQDEOH DOVDXIGLHZHVHQWOLFKXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ(UIRUGHUQLV E]Z 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ LQ %URRPHV 7HUPLQRORJLH DQZHQGEDU XQWHU VFKLHGHQ Å>«@WRFRQGHPQ>DSHUVRQ@$DVXQUHDVRQDEOHLVQRWLSVRIDFWR WRPDUNKLPDVLUUDWLRQDO DQGKHQFHWKHVHWZRWHUPVDUHQRW>@V\QRQ\ PRXVµ 5DWLRQDOLWlW EHGHXWHW QDFK 6LEOH\ LQ HUVWHU 1lKHUXQJ GD GLH 3HUVRQLKUHHLJHQHQ+DQGOXQJV]LHOHNHQQWXQGVLFKGDUEHULPNODUHQLVW LQZLHIHUQ GHUHQ 5HDOLVLHUXQJ QLFKW QXU LKUH HLJHQHQ DQGHUHQ +DQGOXQJV ]LHOHVRQGHUQDXFKGLHMHQLJHQDQGHUHU3HUVRQHQDIIL]LHUHQNDQQOHW]WHUHV DOOHUGLQJV QXU PLW %OLFN DXI GLH P|JOLFKH 5FNZLUNXQJ GHU +DQGOXQJHQ DQGHUHU DXI HLQHQ VHOEVW 0LW %H]XJ DXI GLH 0LWWHO ]XU 5HDOLVLHUXQJ GHU +DQGOXQJV]LHOH YHUODQJW GLHVH VWUXNWXUHOOH 5DWLRQDOLWlW GLH :DKO XQG GLH (UJUHLIXQJ GHU 0LWWHO GLH IU HIIHNWLY JHKDOWHQ ZHUGHQ 9HUQQIWLJNHLW KLQJHJHQ EHGHXWHW QDFK 6LEOH\ ÅWR VHH WKH PDWWHU >«@ IURP WKH RWKHU SHUVRQ·VSRLQWRIYLHZWRGLVFRYHUKRZHDFKZLOOEHDIIHFWHGE\WKHSRVVL EOH DOWHUQDWLYH DFWLRQV DQG PRUHRYHU QRW PHUHO\ WR ÄVHH¶ WKLV IRU DQ\ PHUHO\SUXGHQWSHUVRQZRXOGGRDVPXFK EXWDOVRWREHSUHSDUHGWREH GLVLQWHUHVWHGO\LQIOXHQFHGLQUHDFKLQJDGHFLVLRQE\WKHHVWLPDWHRIWKHVH SRVVLEOHUHVXOWV,PXVWMXVWLI\P\FRQGXFWLQWHUPVRIVRPHSULQFLSOHFDSD EOH RI EHLQJ DSSHDOHG WR E\ DOO SDUWLHV FRQFHUQHG VRPH SULQFLSOH IURP ZKLFK ZH FDQ UHDVRQ LQ FRPPRQµ 'HU 6WDQGSXQNWGHU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW VROOLP1DFKIROJHQGHQQXQLP*HJHQVDW]]X6LEOH\QLFKWLQHLQHUÄGHVLQ WHUHVVLHUWHQ¶ %HREDFKWHUSHUVSHNWLYH VRQGHUQ VR]XVDJHQ PLWWHQ LP *H VFKHKHQORNDOLVLHUWZHUGHQ(VJHKWQLFKWXPGHQÄ%OLFNYRQ1LUJHQGZR¶
_____________ 6LEOH\ ,FKKDEH6LEOH\V%HVWLPPXQJKLHUQLFKWYROOVWlQGLJZLHGHUJHJHEHQ GLHJHJHQZlUWLJH 'HEDWWHLVWGLHVEH]JOLFKPLWWOHUZHLOH]XZHVHQWOLFKHODERULHUWHUHQ%HVWLPPXQJHQJH ODQJW0HLQHHLJHQH%HVWLPPXQJYHUKlOWVLFKLKUHUVHLWVLQGLIIHUHQWJHJHQEHUGHQGRUW YRUJHQRPPHQHQhEHUOHJXQJHQ]XZHLWHUUHLFKHQGHQ$QQDKPHQKLQVLFKWOLFKGHV:LV VHQVVWDQGV GHU KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ RGHU GHU ]HLWOLFKHQ 'LPHQVLRQ 9JO GD]X REHQ .DS)Q 6LEOH\ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3UDNWLVFKH5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG9HUQQIWLJNHLW
VRQGHUQXPHLQHÅ,QWHJUDWLRQYRQ7HLOQHKPHUXQG%HREDFKWHUSHUVSHNWL YHQ´ZLH+DEHUPDVVLHQHQQW'DVEHGHXWHWMHGRFKDXFKGDGDV*H VFKHKHQ VHOEVW GLH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV DOV GDV 9HUODQJHQ XQG /LHIHUQ YRQ*UQGHQDOVYHUQQIWLJDXVJHZLHVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQPX (EHQVRZHQLJZLH6LEOH\EHUFNVLFKWLJW5DZOVYRQGHPHEHQIDOOVHLQH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHP9HUQQIWLJHQXQGGHP5DWLRQDOHQVWDPPW GLHUHDOH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV'DV9HUQQIWLJHEHVWLPPW5DZOVDOVÅ>@ HLQH .RQ]HSWLRQ IDLUHU %HGLQJXQJHQ GHU .RRSHUDWLRQ G K VROFKHU %HGLQJXQ JHQ YRQ GHQHQ PDQ HUZDUWHQ GDUI GD MHGHU 7HLOQHKPHU VLH YHUQQIWL JHUZHLVH DQHUNHQQW YRUDXVJHVHW]W DOOH DQGHUHQ HUNHQQHQ VLH HEHQIDOOV DQ´ 'DV 5DWLRQDOH EH]HLFKQHW 5DZOV KLQJHJHQ DOV Å>@ $XVGUXFN HLQHU .RQ]HSWLRQGHVUDWLRQDOHQ9RUWHLOVGHUHLQ]HOQHQ7HLOQHKPHUGHVVHQZDV VLH DOV ,QGLYLGXHQ ]X HUUHLFKHQ WUDFKWHQ´ (QWVFKHLGHQG LVW IU PHLQ JHJHQZlUWLJHV,QWHUHVVHZHQLJHUGLH=LUNXODULWlWGHU'HILQLWLRQHQ²5DZOV *HVDPWNRQ]HSWLRQHLQHUÄ*HUHFKWLJNHLWDOV)DLUQH¶NDQQDOVVXEVWDQWLHOOHU QLFKW]LUNXOlUHU.RPPHQWDUGD]XGLHQHQ²HQWVFKHLGHQGLVWKLHUYLHOPHKU GLHEHJULIIOLFKH3ULRULVLHUXQJLQZHOFKHUVLFKGLHPRQRORJLVFKHXQGNRQ VHTXHQWLDOLVWLVFKH *UXQGRULHQWLHUXQJ YRQ 5DZOV· 7KHRULH ZLGHUVSLHJHOW DXVJHKHQG YRQ $NWHXUHQ GLH DXI LKUHQ ÄUDWLRQDOHQ 9RUWHLO¶ EHGDFKW VLQG ÄPVVHQ¶3ULQ]LSLHQJHIXQGHQZHUGHQXPGLHVH9RUWHLOHVR]LDO]XEDODQ FLHUHQXQGGLHVH3ULQ]LSLHQÄN|QQHQ¶JHIXQGHQZHUGHQZHLOGLH$NWHXUH EHU HLQHQ *HUHFKWLJNHLWVVLQQ YHUIJHQ Å>@ GDV 9HUQQIWLJH VHW]W GDV 5DWLRQDOH YRUDXV XQG LVW LKP EHUJHRUGQHW (V OHJW IDLUH %HGLQJXQJHQ VR]LDOHU .RRSHUDWLRQ IHVW GLH IU DOOH LQQHUKDOE HLQHU *UXSSH HLQ]HOQ LGHQWLIL]LHUEDUHU3HUVRQHQDN]HSWDEHOVLQGYRQGHQHQMHGHEHUGLH]ZHL PRUDOLVFKHQ 9HUP|JHQ YHUIJW XQG VLH DXVEHQ NDQQ $OOH KDEHQ HLQH 9RUVWHOOXQJGDYRQZDVIUVLHJXWLVWGLHIHVWOHJWZRULQMHZHLOVLKUUDWLR QDOHU 9RUWHLO EHVWHKW XQG MHGHU KDW HLQHQ QRUPDO ZLUNVDPHQ *HUHFKWLJ
_____________ 9JO+DEHUPDV ,QGHU)ROJH5DZOV·VWHKW1DJHOV.RQ]HSWLRQYRQ8QSDU WHLOLFKNHLW Ä7KH9LHZIURP1RZKHUH¶ GLHMHGRFKYRQHLQHUPHWDSK\VLVFKHQ5REXVW KHLWJHSUlJWLVWZLHVLHLP)ROJHQGHQQLFKWEHDQVSUXFKWZHUGHQVROO Å'HQQREMHNWLYH *UQGHUHSUlVHQWLHUHQGHQ:HUWGHU(UHLJQLVVHQ+DQGOXQJHQXQG6DFKYHUKDOWHQDQ LKQHQ VHOEVW ]XNRPPW QLFKW HWZD LKUHQ :HUW IU GLHVH RGHU MHQH 3HUVRQ 'D REMHNWLYH *UQGHLPSHUVRQDOEHVFKULHEHQH(UHLJQLVVHRGHU8PVWlQGHLQHLQHUQLFKWUHODWLYLHU WHQ)RUPDOVDQVLFKZQVFKHQVZHUWKLQVWHOOHQIROJWHEHQGDVLHEHLHLQHULPSHUVRQD OHQ $QZHQGXQJ QLFKWV YRQ LKUHP PRWLYDWLRQDOHQ *HKDOW HLQEHQ´ 1DJHO 6WDWWGLHVHV6WDQGSXQNWVLPÄ1LUJHQGZR·GHULPSHUVRQDOHQ%HXUWHLOXQJHLQHU6L WXDWLRQVROO9HUQQIWLJNHLWKLHUDXVGHUSULQ]LSLHOOQRUPDWLYYHUIDWHQ3HUVSHNWLYHGHU ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW EHWUDFKWHW ZHUGHQ 9JO DXFK 1DJHO LQVEHV .DS ,; XQG ; VRZLH'DUZDOO LQVEHV.DS VRZLHVHLQH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW1DJHOV3R VLWLRQLQ.DS XQG+DPSWRQ LQVEHVI 5DZOV (EG
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
NHLWVVLQQ GLH )lKLJNHLW IDLUH %HGLQJXQJHQ GHU .RRSHUDWLRQ ]X DFKWHQ 'DV9HUQQIWLJHVHW]WGDV5DWLRQDOHYRUDXVGHQQRKQHGLH0LWJOLHGHUGHU *UXSSHEHZHJHQGH.RQ]HSWLRQHQGHV*XWHQZlUHQVR]LDOH.RRSHUDWLRQ XQG %HJULIIH YRQ 5HFKW XQG *HUHFKWLJNHLW VLQQORV REZRKO GXUFK HLQH VROFKH.RRSHUDWLRQ:HUWHYHUZLUNOLFKWZHUGHQGLHEHUGDVKLQDXVJHKHQ ZDVGLHHLQ]HOQHQ.RQ]HSWLRQHQGHV*XWHQIUVLFKJHQRPPHQIHVWOHJHQ 'DV9HUQQIWLJHLVWGHP5DWLRQDOHQEHUJHRUGQHWGHQQVHLQH*UXQGVlW]H EHJUHQ]HQXQG]ZDULQHLQHPNDQWLVFKHQ6LQQHDEVROXWGLHOHW]WHQ=LHOH GLH YHUIROJW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ´ 'LH YRUOLHJHQGH .RQ]HSWLRQ JHKW KLQJH JHQGDYRQDXV XQGGLHVZLUGLP)ROJHQGHQQRFK]XYHUWLHIHQVHLQ GD GHP SULQ]LSLHOO VR]LDOHQ 6SLHO GHV 9HUODQJHQV XQG *HEHQV YRQ *UQGHQ HLQH9HUQQIWLJNHLWHLQJHVFKULHEHQLVWGLHGHP5DWLRQDOHQLQ5DZOV·6LQQH LQVRIHUQYRUJHRUGQHWLVWDOVVHOEVWGLHHLJHQH9RUWHLOVVXFKH QHEHQDQGH UHQ DXFK DOWUXLVWLVFKHQ 3URHLQVWHOOXQJHQ SUDNWLVFK UHOHYDQW HUVW GRUW ZLUGZRVLHDOV|IIHQWOLFK]XU'LVSRVLWLRQVWHKHQGHU+DQGOXQJVJUXQGDXI WULWW 'DV EHGHXWHW QLFKW GD GLH HLJHQH 9RUWHLOVVXFKH ² XQG HV VFKHLQW DGlTXDWHU]XVHLQKLHUDOOJHPHLQYRQSHUV|QOLFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQ]XVSUH FKHQ ² VLFK HUVW GLHVHU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW YHUGDQNW XQG HV EHGHXWHW DXFK QLFKW GD ZLU ÄLPPHU VFKRQ¶ YHUQQIWLJ VLQG YLHOPHKU LVW GLH JHQHUHOOH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVYHUZHLJHUXQJ GXUFKDXV ]XPLQGHVW GHQNP|JOLFK 'RFK HV EHGHXWHWXPJHNHKUWGDYRQGHUHLJHQHQ9RUWHLOVVXFKHNHLQDUJXPHQWDWL YHU :HJ ]XU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW IKUW YLHOPHKU VHW]W GLH UDWLRQDOH 'XUFKVHW ]XQJ GHV HLJHQHQ 9RUWHLOV ZHQQ VLH QLFKW DXI EOR SK\VLVFKHU *HZDOW EHUXKHQ VROO 6R]LDOLWlW LP 6LQQH HLQHU $QHUNHQQXQJ YRQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ XQG 6WDQGSXQNWHQ $QGHUHUDOV P|JOLFKH DOWHUQDWLYH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH YRU DXV ,FK ZHUGH DXI GLHVH ]HQWUDOH 5ROOH GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV QRFK ]XUFNNRPPHQ $P QlFKVWHQ VWHKHQ GLH VLFK LQ GHQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ *UQGH (UIRU GHUQLV XQG 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ DUWLNXOLHUHQGHQ )RUPHQ YRQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW
_____________ (EG YJO DXV .DQWLVFKHU 3HUVSHNWLYH NULWLVFK ]X 5DZOV DXFK +LOO I +DEHUPDV EDXW VHLQH GHP (UJHEQLV QDFK JOHLFKJHULFKWHWH .ULWLN DQ 5DZOVGDUDXIDXIGDGLHÅ+DXSWVRUJH´GHVVHQ YRQGHU7KHRULHGHU*HUHFKWLJNHLWZHLWHU HQWZLFNHOWHU 7KHRULHÅGHUJOHLFKHQ)UHLKHLWHLQHVMHGHQHLQVHOEVWEHVWLPPWHVDXWKHQ WLVFKHV/HEHQ]XIKUHQ´JLOWZRKLQJHJHQGHUÅ.DQWLVFKH5HSXEOLNDQLVPXVZLHLFK >VF +DEHUPDV@ LKQ YHUVWHKH´ GDYRQ DXVJHKW GD ÅGHU LP GHPRNUDWLVFKHQ 3UR]H UHFKWOLFK LQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWH |IIHQWOLFKH *HEUDXFK GHU 9HUQXQIW GHU 6FKOVVHO IU GLH *HZlKUOHLVWXQJ JOHLFKHU )UHLKHLWHQ´ LVW HEG 0RUDOHSLVWHPRORJLVFK SULPlU LVW GHPQDFK QLFKW GDV 6XEMHNW DOV VROFKHV VRQGHUQ GDV 6XEMHNW DOV HLQHV XQWHU DQGHUHQ 6XEMHNWHQ Å:HLO 3HUVRQHQ DOOHLQ DXI GHP :HJH GHU 9HUJHVHOOVFKDIWXQJ LQGLYLGXLHUW ZHUGHQ LVW GLH )UHLKHLW HLQHV ,QGLYLGXXPV PLW GHU DOOHU DQGHUHQ QLFKW QXU QHJDWLY EHUJHJHQVHLWLJH%HJUHQ]XQJHQYHUNQSIW5LFKWLJH$EJUHQ]XQJHQVLQGYLHOPHKUGDV (UJHEQLVHLQHUJHPHLQVDPDXVJHEWHQ6HOEVWJHVHW]JHEXQJ´ (EG
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3UDNWLVFKH5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG9HUQQIWLJNHLW
XQG 9HUQQIWLJNHLW ]ZHLIHOORV GHU +DEHUPDV·VFKHQ 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZL VFKHQ HLQHU ÅNRJQLWLYLQVWUXPHQWHOOH>Q@ 5DWLRQDOLWlW´ XQG HLQHU ÅNRPPX QLNDWLYH>Q@5DWLRQDOLWlW´GLH+DEHUPDVIROJHQGHUPDHQHUOlXWHUW (UVWHUH Å>«@ IKUW GLH .RQQRWDWLRQHQ HUIROJUHLFKHU 6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJ PLW VLFK ZHOFKHGXUFKLQIRUPLHUWH9HUIJXQJEHUXQGLQWHOOLJHQWH$QSDVVXQJDQ %HGLQJXQJHQHLQHUNRQWLQJHQWHQ8PZHOWHUP|JOLFKWZLUG´/HW]WHUHÅ>«@ IKUW .RQQRWDWLRQHQ PLW VLFK GLH OHW]WOLFK ]XUFNJHKHQ DXI GLH ]HQWUDOH (UIDKUXQJ GHU ]ZDQJORV HLQLJHQGHQ NRQVHQVVWLIWHQGHQ .UDIW DUJXPHQWD WLYHU5HGHLQGHUYHUVFKLHGHQH7HLOQHKPHULKUH]XQlFKVWQXUVXEMHNWLYHQ $XIIDVVXQJHQ EHUZLQGHQ XQG VLFK GDQN GHU *HPHLQVDPNHLW YHUQQIWLJ PRWLYLHUWHU hEHU]HXJXQJHQ JOHLFK]HLWLJ GHU (LQKHLW GHU REMHNWLYHQ :HOW XQG GHU ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW LKUHV /HEHQV]XVDPPHQKDQJV YHUJHZLVVHUQ´ ,QVEHVRQGHUH GLH 2ULHQWLHUXQJ NRPPXQLNDWLYHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW DQ GHU DUJX PHQWDWLYHQ5HGHGHP)RUGHUQXQG/LHIHUQYRQ*UQGHQVFKHLQWPLUEH ]JOLFKGHU6ROOHQ5HODWLRQXQGGHUVLFKLQLKUDUWLNXOLHUHQGHQ9HUQQIWLJ NHLW ]LHOIKUHQG ]X VHLQ +DEHUPDV· %HJULII GHU NRJQLWLYLQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlWKLQJHJHQXPIDW*UQGH5HODWLRQHQHEHQVRZLH(UIRUGHUQLV 5HODWLRQHQ GHUHQ 'LIIHUHQ] PDQ DP OHLFKWHVWHQ HUNHQQW ZHQQ PDQ GDV P|JOLFKH'HIL]LWDQNRJQLWLYLQVWUXPHQWHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlWEHWUDFKWHW 0LW %OLFN DXI GLH LP 9RUVWHKHQGHQ GXUFKJHIKUWH GHRQWLVFKH (QW VFKOVVHOXQJ SUDNWLVFKHU .RQGLWLRQDOH YHUKlOW VLFK5DWLRQDOLWlW E]Z 9HU QQIWLJNHLWGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQ$EHLGHQGUHLQRUPDWLYHQ5HODWLRQHQ ]ZLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ XQG +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ IROJHQGHUPDHQ ]X $·V IHKOHQGHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU )HVWOHJXQJ E]Z GHU %HUHFKWLJXQJ]XU)HVWOHJXQJDXIT (UVWHQV LP )DOO GHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ JLOW $·V IHKOHQGH $QHUNHQ QXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXITDOV,UUDWLRQDOLWlWLP6LQQHPDQJHOQGHUHSLVWHPL VFKHUXQGRGHUNRQDWLYHU.RQVHTXHQ] =ZHLWHQV LP)DOOGHU*UQGH5HODWLRQJLOW$·VIHKOHQGH$QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXITQLFKWDOV,UUDWLRQDOLWlWZHOFKHU)RUPDXFKLPPHU'LH IHKOHQGH $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU )HVWOHJXQJ ]X GHU PDQ OHGLJOLFK EHUHFKWLJW LVW KDW QLFKWV 'HIL]LWlUHV DQ VLFK VRQGHUQ NDQQ LKUHUVHLWV JXW EHJUQGHW VHLQ PDQPDJ]ZDUEHUHFKWLJWVHLQ]XGHP:XQVFKWURFNHQ]XEOHLEHQ XQG GHU hEHU]HXJXQJ GD QXU GDV 6FKLUPDXIVSDQQHQ HLQHQ YRU 1lVVH VFKW]WGRFKNDQQPDQVLFKVWDWWDXIGLHVHQ:XQVFKHEHQDXFKDXIHLQH DQGHUH NRQNXUULHUHQGH 3URHLQVWHOOXQJ IHVWOHJHQ ] % GDUDXI GHQ 6FKLUP HLQHU DQGHUHQ 3HUVRQ OHLKHQ ]X ZROOHQ $OV LUUDWLRQDO N|QQWH PDQ KLHU
_____________ +DEHUPDV , )ULHGPDQ PDFKW XQWHU 5HNXUV DXI 5DZOV XQG +DEHUPDV GLH YRUVWHKHQGH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ +DEHUPDV· IUXFKWEDU IU HLQH (UNOlUXQJ GHUMHZHLOLJHQ5DWLRQDOLWlWXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHU6WDQGDUGVGHU*HOWXQJZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHU $XVVDJHQXQG7KHRULHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
DOOHQIDOOV $·V IHKOHQGH $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]XU )HVWOHJXQJ DXITDQVHKHQGRFKGDHLQHEORH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XU)HVWOHJXQJDXITDOV HLQ(UEHGHU%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XU)HVWOHJXQJDXISPLW%OLFNDXIHLQH+DQG OXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlWVRODQJHWUlJHLVWDOVQRFKNHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH)HVWOHJXQJ DXI S YRUOLHJW LVW GLHVH IHKOHQGH $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]XU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI T SUDNWLVFK LUUHOHYDQW XQG VROOWH GDKHU QLFKW PLW )RUPHQ YRQ ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW YHUZHFKVHOW ZHUGHQ ZLH VLH LP =XVDPPHQKDQJ PLW (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQHQDXIWUHWHQN|QQHQ 'ULWWHQV LP )DOO GHU 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ JLOW $·V IHKOHQGH $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXIT QXQHLQHUVHLWV QLFKW DOV ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW LP 6LQQH PDQ JHOQGHUHSLVWHPLVFKHUXQGRGHUNRQDWLYHU.RQVHTXHQ]XQG]ZDUGHVKDOE QLFKW ZHLO KLHU GLH =XZHLVXQJ GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI S DQ $ LP *HJHQVDW] ]XP)DOOGHU(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQXQDEKlQJLJYRQ$·V$QHUNHQQXQJGLHVHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI S LVW $QGHUHUVHLWV EHVDJW GLH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI T QDWUOLFK GD JHPHVVHQ DQ GLHVHU =XZHLVXQJ LKUH IHKOHQGH $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK $ GHIL]LWlUHUVFKHLQW)UGLHVHV'HIL]LWVROOVWDWWGHV$XVGUXFNVGHU,UUDWLR QDOLWlW GHU $XVGUXFN GHU 8QYHUQQIWLJNHLW UHVHUYLHUW ZHUGHQ ZREHL VLFK QDWUOLFKGLH)UDJHVWHOOWLQZHOFKHP6LQQHKLHULQKDOWOLFKYRQ9HUQQIWLJ NHLWE]Z8QYHUQQIWLJNHLWGLH5HGHVHLQVROO 'LHLQSUDNWLVFKHQ.RQWH[WHQZRKOSURPLQHQWHVWH)RUPYRQÄPDWHULD OHU·5DWLRQDOLWlWE]Z,UUDWLRQDOLWlWDOVRHLQHUVROFKHQGLHEHUGLH.ULWH ULHQUHLQIRUPDOHU.RQVLVWHQ]XQG.RKlUHQ]ZLHVLHDOV5DWLRQDOLWlWVPD VWDE GHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ DXVJHPDFKW ZXUGHQ LVW GLHMHQLJH GLH GDV (LJHQLQWHUHVVH DOV 0DVWDE EHVLW]W 'LHVH )RUP YRQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW KDW MH GRFK NHLQH K|KHUH 'LJQLWlW DOV P|JOLFKH DQGHUH LQVRIHUQ (LJHQLQWHUHVVH DOVPDWHULDOHU0DVWDEGHU$N]HSWDQ]YRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQQXUZHQLJH +DQGOXQJHQDOVUDWLRQDOHUNOl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lUHQ] PLW DQGHUHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQGLHVHV,QGLYLGXXPV 2EGLHIHKOHQGH$QHUNHQQXQJ$·VLQEH]XJDXIGLH6ROOHQ5HODWLRQLQ HLQHP DQGHUHQ 6LQQH DOV GHP HLJHQLQWHUHVVLHUWHQ GHIL]LWlU LVW KlQJW DOVR
_____________ 9JO]XUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ%HVWLPPXQJEHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHU,QIHUHQ]HQREHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3IOLFKWXQG(UODXEQLVLP.RQWH[W
DOOJHPHLQGDYRQDEREGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHSGXUFK% LKUHUVHLWVEHUHFKWLJWLVW(VZLUG)lOOHJHEHQLQGHQHQHLQH:HLJHUXQJ$·V GLH)HVWOHJXQJDXITDQ]XHUNHQQHQEHUHFKWLJWLVWXQG)lOOHLQGHQHQHLQH VROFKH:HLJHUXQJ$·VXQEHUHFKWLJWLVW $OOJHPHLQOlWVLFKLQGHPELVKLHUKHUQRPLQHOOHLQJHIKUWHQ9RNDEX ODUVDJHQGDGLH:HLJHUXQJ$·VGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXITDQ]XHUNHQQHQGDQQ EHUHFKWLJWLVWZHQQGLH)HVWOHJXQJ$·VGXUFK%DXIGLH+DQGOXQJVJUQGH SVROFKH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXPIDWGLH$YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH]XUFNZHLVHQ NDQQZRPLWVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKQRFKQLFKWVEHUGLHLQKDOWOLFKH4XDOLIL]LH UXQJGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHSJHVDJWLVW 8QG PLW %OLFN DXI GLH $EWUHQQXQJVUHJHO OlW VLFK VDJHQ 2 S Ⱥ T OlWVLFKJHQDXGDQQLQSȺ2TEHUIKUHQZHQQSLQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ EHVWHKW GLH YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH QLFKW ]XUFNZHLVEDU VLQG XQG GDPLW GLH IHKOHQGH$QHUNHQQXQJGHU.RQNOXVLRQTGXUFK$DOVGHIL]LWlUHUVFKHLQHQ ODVVHQ :RULQ EHVWHKHQ QXQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GLH QLFKW YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH ]XUFNZHLVEDU VLQG" 2GHU ZHOFKH )RUP PVVHQ 3UlPLVVHQ EHVLW]HQ XP IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]HQVWW]HQ]XN|QQHQEHLGHQHQLP*HJHQ VDW]]XU(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQGLH.RQNOXVLRQDEWUHQQEDULVW"
3IOLFKWXQG(UODXEQLVLP.RQWH[W
0LWGLHVHU5HIRUPXOLHUXQJPRUDOLVFKHU$QVSUFKHLQ7HUPLQLGHRQWLVFKHU .RQWRIKUXQJ LVW HLQ NULWLVFKHU 3XQNW LQQHUKDOE GHU %HDQWZRUWXQJ GHU )UDJHHUUHLFKWREXQGZHQQMDDXIZHOFKH:HLVHHLQSUDNWLVFKHU.RKl UHQWLVPXVGHV3URGX]LHUHQV XQG .RQVXPLHUHQV YRQ *UQGHQ GDV (UNOl UXQJVEHGUIQLVKLQVLFKWOLFKGHU$GlTXDWKHLWYRQ.ULWHULHQVROFKHU*UQGH HUIOOHQNDQQ *HQHUHOO JLOW GD *UQGH NRQWH[WVHQVLEHO VLQG 'LH $QJHPHVVHQKHLW HLQHU$QWZRUWDXIGLH)UDJHQDFKHLQHP*UXQGKlQJWDEYRQNROODWHUDOHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X )HVWOHJXQJHQ 'LHV JLOW QDWUOLFK QLFKWQXUDEHUHEHQDXFKIU+DQGOXQJVJUQGH6RKlQJWGLH$QJHPHV VHQKHLW GHU %HDQWZRUWXQJ GHU )UDJH Å:DUXP KDVW 'X GLHVHV 7LHU JHW| WHW"´ZHVHQWOLFKGDYRQDEREVLHXQWHU-lJHUNROOHJHQRGHUXQWHU.ROOHJHQ LQHLQHPELRORJLVFKHQ/DERUJHVWHOOWZLUGREVLHYRQHLQHP0HW]JHUPHLV WHUDQHLQHQ$XV]XELOGHQGHQRGHUREVLHYRQHLQHP1DWXUVFKW]HUDQGHQ $QJHVWHOOWHQ HLQHU 1DWLRQDOSDUNDXIVLFKW JHULFKWHW ZLUG (LQH GHUDUWLJH .RQWH[WVHQVLELOLWlWWHLOHQDOOH*UQGH 'RFK PLW GHU 7HUPLQRORJLH LQIHUHQWLHOOHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG HQWVSUH FKHQGHU %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ODVVHQ VLFK YRQ GLHVHU HPSLULVFKHQ (EHQH DEV
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
WUDKLHUW]ZHLP|JOLFKH.ULWHULHQVROFKHU*UQGHIRUPXOLHUHQYRQGHQHQ ZLHGHUXPHLQHV]ZHLP|JOLFKHXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH,QGL]HVEHVLW]W =XPHLQHQNDQQGLHEHIUDJWH3HUVRQDXI)HVWOHJXQJHQUHNXUULHUHQGLH VLHH[SOL]LWRGHULPSOL]LWDQHUNDQQWKDW'HU-lJHUDQWZRUWHWGDHUGDYRQ DXVJHJDQJHQVHLGDDOOHHLQMlKULJHQ7LHUHGLHVHU$UWJHVFKRVVHQZHUGHQ VROOWHQGHU%LRORJHGDGLHVHV([HPSODUVHLQHQ9HUVXFKVEHGLQJXQJHQDP EHVWHQHQWVSURFKHQKDWGHU$XV]XELOGHQGHGDHUJHOHUQWKlWWHDOOHPRQ WDJVJHOLHIHUWHQ7LHUHPWHQDXFKDP0RQWDJJHVFKODFKWHWZHUGHQXQG GHU3DUNDXIVHKHUGDGLHVHV7LHUEHUHLWV]ZHLPDOVHLQHQ+XQGDQJHJULIIHQ KlWWH 'DPLW LVW JHPl GHP ZRUDXI VLFK GLH 3HUVRQ IHVWJHOHJW KDW GLH )UDJHEHDQWZRUWHWXQGGDV*HVSUlFKEHHQGHW'LH3HUVRQKDWY|OOLJUDWLR QDOJHKDQGHOWLQVRIHUQLKUHHLJHQHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQVRZLH UHOHYDQWH 3URHLQVWHOOXQJHQ LKU GLHVH +DQGOXQJ JHERWHQ KDEHQ 'LH 3HU VRQ KDW JHPl GHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ 2 S Ⱥ T JHKDQGHOW HLQHU +DQG OXQJVSIOLFKWGLHDXVLKUHQHLJHQHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQDOOHLQDEOHLWEDUZDU 'LH3HUVRQNDQQMHGRFKDXFKGDQDFKEHIUDJWZHUGHQREVLH]XGLHVHU +DQGOXQJEHUHFKWLJWZDU0LWGLHVHU)UDJHHUODQJWGDV*HVSUlFKHLQHQHXH 'LPHQVLRQ LQVRIHUQ QXQ QLFKW PHKU DXVVFKODJJHEHQG VHLQ VROO RE GLH 3HUVRQ VHOEVW LKUH +DQGOXQJ DOV EHJUQGHW DQVLHKW VRQGHUQ RE LKU GLHVH %HUHFKWLJXQJDXFKYRQHLQHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQRGHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQHQ]X JHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ ,VW /HW]WHUHV GHU )DOO XQG GLH 3HUVRQ LVW LQ GHQ $XJHQGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQGKQRUPDWLYH6WDWXV]XZHLVHQGHQ3HUVRQRGHU 3HUVRQHQ EHUHFKWLJW VR LVWGLH +DQGOXQJ HUODXEW 'LHVH (UZHLWHUXQJ GHU 3HUVSHNWLYH UHVXOWLHUW GDULQ GD GLH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ HLQHUVSH]LILVFKHQ)HVWOHJXQJGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQDXIVLHDOV5HFKWIHU WLJXQJGHUIUDJOLFKHQ+DQGOXQJJHOWHQ'LH3HUVRQKDWJHPlGHU*UQGH 5HODWLRQ S Ⱥ5T JHKDQGHOW HLQHU (UODXEQLV GLH XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHQ WDW VlFKOLFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQJDOW'LH$N]HSWDQ]GHU *UQGHLQGHQ$XJHQGHUGHRQWLVFKHQ.RQWRIKUHUEHVDJWGDGDV.RQ GLWLRQDO DOV VROFKHV LQ 2UGQXQJ LVW ZlKUHQG JHPl GHU (UIRUGHUQLV 5HODWLRQ GLH *OWLJNHLW GHV .RQGLWLRQDOV DEKlQJLJ LVW YRQ GHU $QHUNHQ QXQJGHV$QWH]HQGHQVGXUFKGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQXQGXQDEKlQJLJYRQ GHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ %HUHFKWLJXQJ LQ GHQ $XJHQ GHU EHXUWHLOHQGHQ 3HU VRQ 'DPLWLVWVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKQLFKWJHVDJWGDDOWHUQDWLYH+DQGOXQJHQ QLFKWHEHQVRHUODXEWZlUHQ'DSHLQJXWHU+DQGOXQJVJUXQGGKLQGHQ $XJHQGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQ3HUVRQHLQH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XTLVWVFKOLHWZHGHU DXVGDRQRGHUPQLFKWJOHLFKIDOOVJXWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHIUTJHZHVHQ ZlUHQQRFKGDUVRGHUWQLFKWGXUFKSHEHQIDOOVJXWEHJUQGHWH+DQG OXQJHQJHZHVHQZlUHQ 9HUZHLJHUW GLH EHXUWHLOHQGH 3HUVRQ MHGRFK LKUH =XVWLPPXQJ ]XU LQ )UDJH VWHKHQGHQ +DQGOXQJ ZHLVW VLH DOVR GHU KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ NHLQH %HUHFKWLJXQJ]XGHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJ]XVREHGHXWHWGLHVGD
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3IOLFKWXQG(UODXEQLVLP.RQWH[W
GLH *UQGH5HODWLRQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH S Ⱥ 5T QLFKW LQ 2UGQXQJ LVW 'LH 3HUVRQ PDJ ]ZDU JHPl LKUHQ HLJHQHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ Y|OOLJ UDWLRQDO JH KDQGHOWKDEHQQXULVWPLWGHU$N]HSWDQ]YHUZHLJHUXQJGXUFKGLHEHXUWHL OHQGH 3HUVRQ HEHQ NHLQH (UZHLWHUXQJ GHU *OWLJNHLWVSHUVSHNWLYH GHV .RQGLWLRQDOV P|JOLFK *LEW GLH EHXUWHLOHQGH 3HUVRQ QXQ LKUHUVHLWV HLQHQ DOWHUQDWLYHQ+DQGOXQJVJUXQGQDQDXIGHQGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQIHVWJHOHJW VHL VR NDQQ GLHV EHGHXWHQ GD GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ LQ GHQ $XJHQ GHU EHXUWHLOHQGHQ 3HUVRQ KlWWH DQGHUV KDQGHOQ VROOHQ DOVR HLQHU )HVWOHJXQJ XQWHUOLHJW GLH ZLHGHUXP XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ JLOW =XGLHVHU DOWHUQDWLYHQ+DQGOXQJ EHVWHKW GDPLW LQ GHQ$XJHQGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQ3HUVRQHLQH3IOLFKWHVJLOWIUVLHGLH6ROOHQ 5HODWLRQQȺ2V 0|JOLFKHGHRQWLVFKH%HVWLPPXQJHQYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQVLQGGD PLW (UODXEQLV XQG 3IOLFKW HWZDV ]X WXQ RGHU ]X XQWHUODVVHQ ,FK ZHUGH MHGRFKLP)ROJHQGHQVWDWWGLHVHUEHLGHQ%HJULIIHEHLP%HJULIIGHV+DQG OXQJVJUXQGVEOHLEHQXQGGLHVHQJHPlGHULP9RUVWHKHQGHQHLQJHIKUWHQ GHRQWLVFKHQ3HUVSHNWLYHQGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJZHLWHUTXDOLIL]LHUHQ,QVEHVRQGH UHGHU3IOLFKWEHJULIILVWZHQLJHUJXW]XHLQHU%HVFKUHLEXQJYRQ9HUELQG OLFKNHLWHQ JHHLJQHW DOV GHU %HJULII GHV +DQGOXQJVJUXQGV ZHQQ OHW]WHUHU KLQVLFKWOLFKVHLQHU5HODWLRQ]XGHRQWLVFKHQ6WDWXVHLQHU3HUVRQEHWUDFKWHW ZLUGLQVRIHUQGHU%HJULIIGHU3IOLFKWDOVVROFKHUHLQHGHUDUWXPIDQJUHLFKH Ä1DFKEDUVFKDIW¶EHVLW]WGDVHLQ(UNOlUXQJVZHUWRKQHZHLWHUH(UOlXWHUXQJ ]LHPOLFK JHULQJ DXVIlOOW 'DQHEHQ GUFNW ZHGHU GHU 3IOLFKW QRFK GHU
_____________ .RUVJDDUGQHQQWQXUHLQLJHÄ3IOLFKWHQ¶GLHGLHVYHUGHXWOLFKHQN|QQHQ Å,QSKLORVRSK\ ZHUDLVHTXHVWLRQVDERXWWKHQRUPDWLYLW\RIKLJKEURZODZVOLNHWKRVHRIPRUDOREOLJD WLRQRUWKHRUHWLFDODQGSUDFWLFDOUHDVRQ%XWLWLVZRUWKUHPHPEHULQJWKDWLQHYHU\GD\ OLIH WKH VDPH VRUW RI TXHVWLRQV FDQ EH UDLVHG DERXW WKH QRUPDWLYLW\ RI WKH ODZV DQG GHPDQGV RI SURIHVVLRQDO REOLJDWLRQ ILOLDO REHGLHQFH VH[XDO ILGHOLW\ SHUVRQDO OR\DOW\ DQGHYHU\GD\HWLTXHWWHµ .RUVJDDUG 'HU%HJULIIGHU3IOLFKWEHVLW]WGHPQDFK HLQHJHZLVVH$PELJXLWlW0DQNDQQLKQHLQHUVHLWVRKQHZHLWHUH4XDOLIL]LHUXQJDXIGHU VHOEHQ6WXIHGHU$EVWUDNWLRQVHKHQZLHEHLVSLHOVZHLVHGLH%HJULIIHGHU/R\DOLWlWRGHU GHU(WLNHWWH0DQNDQQLKQDEHUDXFKDXIHLQHUK|KHUHQ6WXIHDQVLHGHOQYRQGHUDXV HLQH 6SH]LIL]LHUXQJ GLHVHV %HJULIIV ]XGHQHQ GHU (WLNHWWH HWF IKUW 'HUDUWLJH 'LIIH UHQ]LHUXQJHQVLQGIUPHLQ$QOLHJHQMHGRFKEHUIOVVLJZHLOVLHGHU6DFKHQDFKGXUFK HLQH 3HUVSHNWLYHQGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ KLQVLFKWOLFK GHV =XZHLVHQV XQG $QHUNHQQHQV YRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQVRZLH%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQJHQDXHUHUIDWZHUGHQN|QQHQ :DVLQGHQ$XJHQGHUHLQHQ3HUVRQÄEORH(WLNHWWH¶LVWXQGDOV(LQVWHOOXQJEHKDQGHOW ZLUGGLHOHGLJOLFKEHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]HQVWW]WNDQQLQGHQ$XJHQHLQHU DQGHUHQ 3HUVRQ DOV ÄVWUHQJH 3IOLFKW¶ XQG GDPLW DOV (LQVWHOOXQJ HUVFKHLQHQ GLH IHVWOH JXQJVHUKDOWHQGH ,QIHUHQ]HQ VWW]W 'DV LP )ROJHQGHQ WKHPDWLVLHUWH 5HFKWIHUWLJHQ YRQ =XZHLVXQJHQ EHVWLPPWHU )HVWOHJXQJHQ HUP|JOLFKW JHJHQEHU HLQHU VWDUUHQ TXDVL GHILQLWRULVFKHQ %HKDQGOXQJ GHU %HJULIIH /R\DOLWlW (WLNHWWH RGHU 3IOLFKW GHUHQ NRQ WH[WVHQVLEOH%HVWLPPXQJ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
(UODXEQLVEHJULIIGDVDXVZDVGXUFKGLH(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQEHVFKULHEHQ ZLUG (VHUVFKHLQWGDKHUJHPlGHUJHQDQQWHQ3HUVSHNWLYHQGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ VLQQYROO L YRQ SULPD IDFLH *UQGHQ ]X VSUHFKHQ ZHQQ HV XP *UQGH JHKW GLH HLQH 3HUVRQ LQ GHQ $XJHQ HLQHU EHXUWHLOHQGHQ 3HUVRQ ]X HLQHU +DQGOXQJEHUHFKWLJHQ LL YRQSUlYDOHQWHQ*UQGHQZHQQHVXP*UQGH JHKW GLH HLQH 3HUVRQ LQ GHQ $XJHQ HLQHU EHXUWHLOHQGHQ 3HUVRQ DXI HLQH +DQGOXQJIHVWOHJHQXQG LLL YRQUDWLRQDOHQ(UIRUGHUQLVVHQRGHUVWUXNWX UHOOHQ*UQGHQZHQQHVXP*UQGHJHKWGLHHLQH3HUVRQLQGHQ$XJHQ GHU EHXUWHLOHQGHQ 3HUVRQ DXI HLQH EHVWLPPWH +DQGOXQJ QXU GDQQ IHVWOH JHQZHQQGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQGLHVH*UQGHDQHUNDQQWKDW L NRUUHOLHUW GHU *UQGH5HODWLRQ LL GHU 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ LLL GHU (UIRUGHUQLV 5HODWLRQ :DVVLQGQXQDEHUGLH.ULWHULHQSUDNWLVFKHQhEHUOHJHQVEHLPMHZHLOL JHQhEHUJDQJYRQS]XT" ,P)DOOYRQSULPDIDFLH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQJLEWHVEHUGLHEORH.RPSDWL ELOLWlWGHU]XJHZLHVHQHQ%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]XHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQ PLW DQGHUHQ H[SOL]LW RGHU LPSOL]LW ]XJHZLHVHQHQ GHRQWLVFKHQ 6WDWXV GHU KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ KLQDXV NHLQ .ULWHULXP GHU NRUUHNWHQ +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW-HPDQGGHUHLQHQSULPDIDFLH*UXQGKDWHLQH+DQGOXQJ ]XYROO]LHKHQNDQQVLFKY|OOLJNRUUHNWYHUKDOWHQLQGHPHUGLHVH+DQGOXQJ QLFKWYROO]LHKW $QGHUV OLHJHQ MHGRFK GLH )lOOH GHU VWUXNWXUHOOHQ XQG GHU SUlYDOHQWHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHLQVRIHUQGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQKLHUDOVDXIGLHHQWVSUH FKHQGH +DQGOXQJ IHVWJHOHJW EHWUDFKWHW ZLUG 'LH +DQGOXQJ NDQQ KLHU VR]XVDJHQ DXV GHP +DQGOXQJVJUXQG DEJHOHLWHW ZHUGHQ ZHQQJOHLFK LP )DOO GHU QRUPDWLYHQ (UIRUGHUQLVVH E]Z VWUXNWXUHOOHQ *UQGH QXU HLQJH VFKUlQNW G K QXU XQWHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ XQG RKQH %HUFNVLFKWLJXQJ GHU 4XDOLWlW GHU +DQG OXQJVJUQGHGXUFKGLHEHXUWHLOHQGH3HUVRQ ,P )DOO GHU UDWLRQDOHQ (UIRUGHUQLVVH RGHU VWUXNWXUHOOHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH UH VXOWLHUW GLH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW DXV GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI EHVWLPPWH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH3HUVRQ6LHKDQGHOWLUUDWLRQDOZHQQVLHGLHUHVXOWLHUHQGH)HVWOH
_____________ 0LWGHUWHUPLQRORJLVFKHQ8PJHKXQJGHV%HJULIIVGHU3IOLFKWZLUGDXFKHLQH]HQWUDOH WKHRUHWLVFKH5ROOHGHU%HJULIIHGHU(UODXEQLVXQGGHV9HUERWVDEJHOHKQWGLHIROJHQ GHUPDHQLQ2SSRVLWLRQ]XP3IOLFKWEHJULIIJHVHW]WZHUGHQN|QQHQ (VLVWJHERWHQS ]XWXQXQGHVLVWJHERWHQSQLFKW]XWXQ 3IOLFKW9HUERW HVLVWJHERWHQS]XWXQ XQGHVLVWQLFKWJHERWHQS]XWXQ 3IOLFKW(UODXEQLV $XFKEH]JOLFKGHU$UWLNXODWL RQ YRQ (UODXEQLVVHQ XQG 9HUERWHQ VROOWH GHRQWLVFK ]ZLVFKHQ 3HUVSHNWLYHQ XQWHU VFKLHGHQZHUGHQDXVZHOFKHQHLQH)HVWOHJXQJRGHUHLQH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XHLQHU)HVWOH JXQJ]XJHZLHVHQZLUG
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3IOLFKWXQG(UODXEQLVLP.RQWH[W
JXQJDXIGLH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWQLFKWHEHQIDOOVDQHUNHQQW .ULWHULXPSUDNWLVFKHQhEHUOHJHQVLQGHQ$XJHQGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQ3HUVRQ LVWKLHUGHPQDFK5DWLRQDOLWlWLP6LQQHHLQHU.RQVLVWHQ]XQG.RKlUHQ]LQQHU KDOEGHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQ ,P)DOOGHUSUlYDOHQWHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHKDQGHOWGLH3HUVRQEHL0LDFK WXQJGHV.RQGLWLRQDOVQLFKWLUUDWLRQDOGHQQVLHPXGLH+DQGOXQJVJUQGH VHOEVW QLFKW DQHUNDQQW KDEHQ 9LHOPHKU EHVWHKW GHU $QVSUXFK GLHVHU *UQGH XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ ZREHL GLHVH )RUPXOLHUXQJ QLFKW EHVDJW GD SUlYDOHQWH *UQGH GHVKDOE JOWLJ VLQG ZHLO GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ VLH QLFKW DQHUNHQQW VRQGHUQ YLHO PHKU REZRKO VLH VLH P|JOLFKHUZHLVH QLFKW DQHUNHQQW G K VLH JHOWHQ DXFK GDQQ ZHQQ GLH 3HUVRQ VLH DQHUNHQQW 'RFK KlQJW LKUH *OWLJNHLW HEHQ QLFKW YRQ GLHVHU IDNWLVFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ DE :HOFKHV .ULWHULXP UHJHOW RGHUEHVWLPPWGDQQDEHUGLH$EOHLWXQJGHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLH+DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW DXV GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH" :HOFKH%HUHFKWLJXQJNDQQGLHEHXUWHLOHQGH3HUVRQYRUZHLVHQXPGHUKDQ GHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ HLQH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDE VLFKW ]X]XZHLVHQ GLH GLHVH P|JOLFKHUZHLVH QLFKW DQHUNDQQW KDW LQ GHQ $XJHQGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQ3HUVRQDEHUDQHUNHQQHQVROOWH" %UDQGRPNQSIWGLH%HGLQJXQJGHU0|JOLFKNHLWHLQHU,QWHJUDWLRQGHU DUWLJ GRPLQLHUHQGHU *UQGH LQ GLH .RQ]HSWLRQ HLQHU QRUPDWLYHQ 3UDJ PDWLNGDUDQREXQGLQZLHIHUQÅ>«@SOD\LQJWKHJDPHRIJLYLQJDQGDVNLQJ IRU UHDVRQV FRXOG EH VKRZQ LPSOLFLWO\ WR LQYROYH XQGHUWDNLQJ FRPPLW PHQWV WR UHFRJQL]LQJ IHOORZ SUDFWLWLRQHUV DQG WR WUHDWLQJ WKHP LQ VRPH ZD\VUDWKHUWKDQRWKHUV>«@µ1XQKDWVLFKJH]HLJWGDGDV.ULWHULXP NRQVHTXHQWLHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlWOHGLJOLFKVROFKHSUDNWLVFKHQ,QIHUHQ]HQOHLWHW RGHUEHVWLPPWLQZHOFKHQGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIHLQH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQG OXQJVDEVLFKWYRQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGH GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ DEKlQJW 3UlYDOHQWH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH N|Q
_____________ 6FDQORQ JHKW ]ZDU QLFKW DXI %URRPHV XQG %UDQGRPV %HVWLPPXQJHQ SUDNWLVFKHU .RQGLWLRQDOHE]ZGHUHQGHRQWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHQGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJHLQGRFKZHLVWDXFK HUGDUDXIKLQGDHLQH)HVWOHJXQJDXIHLQH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWQLFKWYRQ GHUDNWXHOOHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGHUGDPLWIHVWJHOHJWHQ3HUVRQDEKlQJW Å>«@DSHUVRQFDQ IDOOVKRUWRIDPRUDOVWDQGDUGDQGEHRSHQWRFULWLFLVPRQWKDWDFFRXQWHYHQWKRXJK KHRUVKHLVXQDEOHWRVHHWKHIRUFHRIWKLVVWDQGDUGWKDWLVWRVD\WRVHHDQ\UHDVRQWR WDNHLWVHULRXVO\,QDELOLW\WRVHHDQ\UHDVRQWRFDUHDERXWWKHLQWHUHVWVRIRWKHUVLVDVH ULRXV IDXOW DQG KDV LPSOLFDWLRQV IRU RXU UHODWLRQV ZLWK D SHUVRQ :KHWKHU LW PDNHV VHQVHWRUHPRQVWUDWHZLWKWKHSHUVRQRUWRÄGHPDQG¶LQDPRUHOLWHUDOVHQVHWKDWVKH FRPSO\ ZLWK PRUDO UHTXLUHPHQWV LV >«@ D VHSDUDWH TXHVWLRQµ 6FDQORQ Å5HSOLHVµ 1RFKDOOJHPHLQHUVWHOOWVLFKDEHU]XQlFKVWGLH)UDJHZLHYHUKLQGHUWZHU GHQNDQQGDGHUDUWLJHQLFKWDQHUNDQQWH)HVWOHJXQJHQ]XQDFNWHP=ZDQJGHJHQHULH UHQ %UDQGRPE
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
QHQ ZLH DOOH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH ]XUFNJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ GLH =XZHLVXQJ HLQHU)HVWOHJXQJGXUFKHLQHDQGHUH3HUVRQQLFKWDQ]XHUNHQQHQPXNHL QHVZHJVDOVHLQ=HLFKHQGHU,UUDWLRQDOLWlWJHZHUWHWZHUGHQ'DV6SLHOGHV 3URGX]LHUHQV XQG .RQVXPLHUHQV YRQ *UQGHQ EHVLW]W GDKHU QHEHQ 5H JHOQ NRQVHTXHQWLHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW RIIHQEDU QRFK DQGHUH 5HJHOQ :HOFKH 5HJHOQVLQGGLHVRGHUNRQNUHWZHOFKH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHVLQGGD]XLQGHU /DJHÅ>«@WREULQJSUDFWLWLRQHUVWRDFNQRZOHGJH²DQGVRDFWXSRQWUHDWDV UHDVRQVWKDWDUHFDXVDOO\HIILFDFLRXVLQWKHDHWLRORJ\RISUDFWLFDOSHUIRUP DQFHV²WKRVHLPSOLFLWO\XQGHUWDNHQFRPPLWPHQWVµ" $QGLHVHU6WHOOHORKQWHVVLFKDXI6FDQORQVVXEVWDQWLHOOH7KHRULHYRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQHLQ]XJHKHQXQG]ZDUPLWGHU)UDJHQDFKGHUHQ.RP SDWLELOLWlW PLW HLQHP SUDNWLVFKHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV GHV 3URGX]LHUHQV XQG .RQVXPLHUHQVYRQ*UQGHQDXIGHU%DVLVHLQHUQRUPDWLYHQ3UDJPDWLN
%HJUQGXQJVXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV
6FDQORQ IDYRULVLHUW HEHQVR ZLH %UDQGRP HLQHQ %HJUQGXQJVNRKlUHQWLV PXV GHU VRZRKO hEHU]HXJXQJHQ DOV DXFK +DQGOXQJHQ HLQEH]LHKW Å,Q JHQHUDODJLYHQFRQVLGHUDWLRQFRXQWVLQIDYRURIDFHUWDLQEHOLHIRQO\JLYHQ DEDFNJURXQGRIRWKHUEHOLHIVDQGSULQFLSOHVZKLFKGHWHUPLQHLWVUHOHYDQ FH %HFDXVH RI WKHVH FRQQHFWLRQV DFFHSWLQJ D UHDVRQ IRU RU DJDLQVW RQH EHOLHIDIIHFWVQRWRQO\WKDWEHOLHIEXWDOVRRWKHUEHOLHIVDQGWKHVWDWXVRI RWKHUUHDVRQV´'LHVNDQQQHJDWLYEHUSODQH,QNRPSDWLELOLWlWHQJHVFKH KHQ DEHU DXFK EHU HLQ JUDGXHOOHV 8QWHUPLQLHUHQ YRQ WUDJHQGHQ hEHU ]HXJXQJHQGHP9HUULQJHUQGHUHQQRUPDWLYHUGKEHJUQGHQGHU.UDIW RGHUEHUHLQH'LVNUHGLWLHUXQJYRQ(LQZlQGHQJHJHQGLHIUDJOLFKHhEHU ]HXJXQJ 'LHVHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV YRQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQ EHUWUlJW 6FDQORQ QXQ DXI GHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ %HUHLFK Å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
_____________ %UDQGRPE +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 (LQ VROFKHU %HJUQGXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV LVW XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ HLQHU NRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHQ 6HPDQWLN LP 6LQQH %UDQGRPV ZHOFKH YRQ 6FDQORQ HEHQVR ZHQLJ WKHPDWLVLHUW ZLUG ZLHHLQHEHOLHELJHDQGHUHQLFKWLQIHUHQWLDOLVWLVFKH 6FDQORQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%HJUQGXQJVXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV
FRQVLGHUDWLRQV DUH UHOHYDQWWR D JLYHQ GHFLVLRQWKDW LVWR VD\ ZLWK LQWHU SUHWLQJDGMXVWLQJDQGPRGLI\LQJWKLVPRUHJHQHUDOIUDPHZRUNRISULQFL SOHVRIUHDVRQLQJµ'LHVHVWUXNWXUHOOH5DWLRQDOLWlWYHUODQJWGDQHXKLQ ]XNRPPHQGH )HVWOHJXQJHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHU Ä3DVVXQJ¶ JHJHQEHU GHQ EHUHLWV EHVWHKHQGHQ H[SOL]LWHQ RGHU LPSOL]LWHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ EHUSUIW ZHUGHQ²XQGYLFHYHUVD/HW]WHUHVLVWGHVKDOEYRQJURHU%HGHXWXQJZHLO QXUGDPLWGHP9RUZXUIGHV.RQVHUYDWLVPXVDQGHQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVHQW JDQJHQZHUGHQNDQQ6WUXNWXUHOOH5DWLRQDOLWlWLP6LQQHGHUKLHUYHUWUHWH QHQ7KHRULHEHVDJWQLFKWGDQHXHhEHU]HXJXQJHQXQG$EVLFKWHQNRQVL VWHQW XQG NRKlUHQW KLQVLFKWOLFK EHUHLWV EHVWHKHQGHU hEHU]HXJXQJHQ XQG $EVLFKWHQ VHLQ PVVHQ ZLH DXFK 6FDQORQ EHWRQW Å7KHVH EDFNJURXQG MXGJPHQWV DERXW WKH NLQGV RI WKLQJV WKDW FDQ FRXQW LQ IDYRU RI FHUWDLQ DWWLWXGHVDUHWKHPVHOYHVRSHQWRTXHVWLRQDQGSLHFHPHDOPRGLILFDWLRQ´ 9LHOPHKUHUIRUGHUWVWUXNWXUHOOH5DWLRQDOLWlWGDPDQ)HVWOHJXQJHQGLHLP /LFKWHQHXHUhEHUOHJXQJHQIUDJOLFKXQGVFKOLHOLFKPLWGLHVHQhEHUOHJXQ JHQ GLH LQ QHXHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ UHVXOWLHUHQ LQNRPSDWLEHO HUVFKHLQHQ GD GXUFKDXIKHEWGDPDQVLHQLFKWPHKUDQHUNHQQWRGHUVRJDUHLQH%HUHFK WLJXQJ]XLKQHQEHVWUHLWHW 'RFK XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU 0|JOLFKNHLW HLQHU GLDFKURQHQ '\QDPLVLH UXQJGHV.RKlUHQWLVPXVGXUFKGLHEHJUQGHWH5HYLVLRQEHUHLWVHLQJHJDQJH QHU)HVWOHJXQJHQKDW5LFKDUG%UDQGWGLHVH)RUPYRQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVPLW GHP DOOJHPHLQHQ $UJXPHQW XQWHU 'UXFN JHVHW]W GD HLQ 6\VWHP YRQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQ $EVLFKWHQ XQG DQGHUHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ JHJHQEHU HLQHP DOWHUQDWLYHQ6\VWHPYRQhEHU]HXJXQJHQ$EVLFKWHQXQGDQGHUHQ(LQVWHO OXQJHQQLFKWGHVKDOEEHVVHUJHUHFKWIHUWLJWVHLQPXZHLOHVLQVLFKEHVVHU JHUHFKWIHUWLJWLVWGKNRKlUHQWHUDOVGDVDOWHUQDWLYH6\VWHPLVWVRODQJHHV QLFKW HLQH *ODXEZUGLJNHLW RGHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ EHVLW]W GLH VWDWW DXI GHU
_____________ 6FDQORQ I6FDQORQ EHVFKUHLEWGDV(UZlJHQYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQIROJHQ GHUPDHQ Å>«@WKHSURFHVVKHUH LVWRWU\WRFKDUDFWHUL]HWKHSRWHQWLDOUHDVRQPRUH IXOO\WRDVNZKHWKHULWVHHPVVRFKDUDFWHUL]HGWREHDUHOHYDQWUHDVRQIRUWKHDWWLWXGH LQTXHVWLRQ,QDGGLWLRQRQHFDQORRNIRURWKHUFDVHVRQZKLFKLWZRXOGKDYHDEHDU LQJLILWZHUHDJRRGUHDVRQWRVHHZKHWKHULWVHHPVWREHDUHDVRQLQWKRVHFDVHVWR WHVWRQH·VUHDFWLRQVLQWKHVHFDVHVIRUVLJQVRIXQUHOLDELOLW\WRFRQVLGHUWKHSODXVLELOLW\ RI DOWHUQDWLYH H[SODQDWLRQV RI WKHVH UHDFWLRQV DQG VR RQ ,Q VKRUW RQH WULHV WR VHH ZKHWKHUWKLVUHDVRQZRXOGEHLQFOXGHGLQWKHPRVWFRKHUHQWDQGFRPSOHWHDFFRXQWRI ZKDWUHDVRQVWKHUHDUHµ 6FDQORQ 6FDQORQ YJOGD]XDXFK%URRPHVRZLHREHQ.DS)Q 6FDQORQlXHUWGLHVH$XIIDVVXQJRKQHMHGRFKGDEHLDXIGLH7HUPLQRORJLHGHUGHRQWL VFKHQ.RQWRIKUXQJ]XUHNXUULHUHQ Å>«@WKHDFFHSWHGMXGJPHQWVZLWKZKLFKZHEH JLQDUHQRWWKHPVHOYHVLPPXQHIURPFULWLFLVPDQGUHYLVLRQ>«@DQ\ZD\WKDW,FDQ LPDJLQHRIFULWLFL]LQJWKHVHMXGJPHQWVDQGDUULYLQJDWRWKHUVZRXOGDPRXQWWRDQLQ VWDQFHRIWKLVVDPHJHQHUDOPHWKRG>RIORRNLQJIRUWKHPRVWFRKHUHQWDQGFRPSOHWH DFFRXQWRIZKDWUHDVRQVWKHUHDUH@µ 6FDQORQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
.RKlUHQ] DXI GHU REMHNWLYHQ 5HDOLWlW GLHVHU hEHU]HXJXQJHQ HWF EHUXKW EHLVSLHOVZHLVHGXUFKGHQ9HUZHLVDXI%HREDFKWXQJVWDWVDFKHQ'LH3URE OHPH GHV WKHRUHWLVFKHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXVPVVHQKLHU QLFKW ZHLWHU YHUIROJW ZHUGHQ XQG GDPLW DXFK QLFKW GDV 3UREOHP YRQ %HREDFKWXQJVWDWVDFKHQ DOV%HJUQGXQJHLQHUhEHU]HXJXQJ'RFKLP%HUHLFKSUDNWLVFKHQhEHUOH JHQVIKUWGLHVHU(LQZDQGGD]XGDEHUGLHLQWHUQH.RKlUHQ]YRQ(LQ VWHOOXQJVV\VWHPHQKLQDXVHLQ.ULWHULXPJHIXQGHQZHUGHQPXXPHLQ LQ VLFK NRKlUHQWHV 6\VWHP SUDNWLVFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ YRU HLQHP DQGHUHQ DXV]X]HLFKQHQRGHUDXVGHU3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQIRUPX OLHUWXPGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHUHLJHQHQIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ(LQVWHOOXQ JHQ DXFK YRQ DQGHUHQ IRUGHUQ XQG GDPLW GLH VXEMHNWLYH *OWLJNHLW HLQHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQLQGLHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYH*OWLJNHLWHLQHU6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ EHUIKUHQ]XN|QQHQ 2ESDXVGHU3HUVSHNWLYHGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQ3HUVRQRGHU3HUVRQHQ² XQG GDV EHGHXWHW LQ GHU 5HDOLWlW DQJHVLFKWV DOWHUQDWLYHU 6\VWHPH YRQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQ :HUWHQ XQG DQGHUHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ² HLQ JXWHU +DQG OXQJVJUXQG LQ EHUHFKWLJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ RGHU RE S JDU HLQ SUlYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQG VHLQ NDQQ LQ IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ ]HQ REDOVRGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQLQGHQ$XJHQGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQ3HU VRQRGHU3HUVRQHQ]XGHU+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWTEHUHFKWLJW RGHU VRJDU DXI GLHVH IHVWJHOHJW LVW XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHUHQ HLJHQHU $QHU NHQQXQJ GLHVHU )HVWOHJXQJ LVW HLQH )UDJH GHUHQ %HDQWZRUWXQJ DXI GLH .RKlUHQ]GLHVHUNRPSOH[HQ(LQVWHOOXQJVV\VWHPHDE]LHOW ,FK P|FKWH GHVKDOE GLHVEH]JOLFK YRQ HLQHP SUDNWLVFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXVVSUHFKHQXPLKQYRQHLQHPSUDNWLVFKHQ%HJUQGXQJVNRKl UHQWLVPXV]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQZREHLOHW]WHUHUGLHLQWUDSHUVRQHOOHXQGHUVWHUHU GLHLQWHUSHUVRQHOOH3HUVSHNWLYHEHQHQQW:LHLQHUOlXWHUWZXUGHEH GHXWHW GLHV QLFKW GD HV EHLP %HJUQGXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV DXVVFKOLHOLFK XPGLH(LQVWHOOXQJHQHLQHVHLQ]HOQHQ,QGLYLGXXPVJHKWVRQGHUQOHGLJOLFK GD GLH .RKlUHQ] GHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ YRP 6WDQGSXQNW HLQHV HLQ]HOQHQ ,QGLYLGXXPV DXV EHXUWHLOW ZLUG G K GD GLH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ $QGHUHU QXU
_____________ 9JO%UDQGW YJOREHQ.DS)Q VRZLHGHQ$EVFKQLWW]XGHPGLHVH )XQRWHJHK|UW XQGNULWLVFKGD]X%ULQN IGHVVHQNRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHQPRUD OLVFKHQ 5HDOLVPXV LFK MHGRFK LP IROJHQGHQ ]XJXQVWHQ HLQHV 3UR]HGXUDOLVPXV DEOHKQH YJOXQWHQ)Q VRZLHGHQGD]XJHK|ULJHQ$EVDW] ,QGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGH5LFKWXQJ ZHLVW*LEEDUG +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 Å7RDFFHSWDQRUPDVDUHTXLUHPHQW RIUDWLRQDOLW\ZHPLJKWVD\LVWRDFFHSWLWDORQJZLWKKLJKHURUGHUQRUPVWKDWUHTXLUH LWV DFFHSWDQFH 7R WUHDW LW DV DQ H[LVWHQWLDO FRPPLWPHQW LV WR DFFHSW LW DORQJ ZLWK KLJKHURUGHUQRUPVWKDWSHUPLWLWEXWWKDWSHUPLWDFFHSWLQJDWOHDVWRQHLQFRPSDWLEOH DOWHUQDWLYHµ 8P GLH 3ULQ]LSLHQ GLH GLHVH %HUHFKWLJXQJ EHVWLPPHQ RGHU EHVVHU EH JUHQ]HQ VROO HV ZHQQJOHLFK QLFKW XQWHU *LEEDUGV PRUDOH[SUHVVLYLVWLVFKHQ 9RU]HL FKHQ LP)ROJHQGHQJHKHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%HJUQGXQJVXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV
LQVRIHUQ%HGHXWXQJKDEHQDOVVLHGLH.RKlUHQ]GHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQGLHVHV ,QGLYLGXXPVWDQJLHUHQ(LQVROFKHU%HJUQGXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXVEHVFKUHLEWHLQ 6\VWHPYRQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]%NRJQLWLYHQHYDOXDWLYHQHPRWLRQDOHQLQWHQWL RQDOHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK GHVVHQ VWUXNWXUHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlW (LQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVNR KlUHQWLVPXVEHVFKUHLEWHLQ6\VWHPYRQ6\VWHPHQVROFKHUDUW(LQVWHOOXQJHQKLQVLFKW OLFKGHVVHQVWUXNWXUHOOHU5DWLRQDOLWlW LQEHLGHQ)lOOHQVLQGLGHDOHUZHLVHGLH 7UlJHU GLHVHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DXFK 0LWJOLHGHU GHU *UXSSH GHU %HXUWHLOHU GLHVHUVWUXNWXUHOOHQ5DWLRQDOLWlW +LHUJHKWHVQXQQLFKWXPGLHPDWHULDOH$XVJHVWDOWXQJVROFKHU6\VWH PH P|JOLFKHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHQ VRQGHUQ OHGLJOLFK XP .ULWHULHQ LKUHU (WDEOLHUXQJGK.ULWHULHQGHU$EZlJXQJGLYHUJLHUHQGHU(LQVWHOOXQJVV\V WHPH ,P LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ.RQIOLNWIDOO VWHKHQVLFK PLQGHVWHQV ]ZHL XQ YHUHLQEDUH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ JHJHQEHU YRQ GHQHQ PLQGHVWHQV HLQH DXIJH JHEHQ ZHUGHQ PX XP GLH ,UUDWLRQDOLWlW GHU *HVDPWKHLW GLHVHU LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]X YHUPHLGHQ (V VROOWHQ KLHU GLHMHQLJHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DXIJHJHEHQ ZHUGHQ GLH HLQH JU|HUH .RKlUHQ] GHU *H VDPWKHLW YRQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ YHUKLQGHUQ E]Z VROOWHQ GLHMHQLJHQ (LQVWHO OXQJHQ +DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlW HUODQJHQ GLH HLQH JU|HUH .RKlUHQ] GHU *HVDPWKHLW YRQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ HUP|JOLFKHQ GLHV YHUODQJW GLH SUDNWLVFKH 5DWLRQDOLWlW GHV ,QGLYLGXXPV ,P LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ RGHU PRUDOLVFKHQ )DOO YRQ(LQVWHOOXQJVNRQIOLNWHQVWHKHQVLFK PLQGHVWHQV ]ZHLXQYHUHLQEDUH² ZHQQJOHLFK KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ .RKlUHQ] JHJHEHQHQIDOOV VWUXNWXUHOOUDWLRQDOH²(LQVWHOOXQJHQJHJHQEHU $XI GLHVHQ .RQIOLNWIDOO EH]LHKW VLFK QXQ 6FDQORQV 7KHRULH GHUHQ .HUQ LQ IROJHQGHU (LQVLFKW EHVWHKW (LQ +|FKVWPD DQ LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU
_____________ 0LW %H]XJ DXI 6FDQORQV *UQGHNRQ]HSWLRQ XQG %URRPHV *UQGH XQG 6ROOHQ 5HODWLRQHQGLIIHUHQ]LHUW:DOODFH]ZLVFKHQ*UQGHQGLHHLQHÅDVSLUDWLRQDOFKDUDFWHU´ KDEHQÅLQVRIDUDVWKH\FRXQWLQIDYRURIWKHDFWLRQVWKH\UHFRPPHQGLQDZD\WKDW OHDYHV WKH GHOLEHUDWLQJ DJHQW ZLWK VRPH GLVFUHWLRQ WR LJQRUH RU WR GLVFRXQW WKHLU FODLPV´ :DOODFH0V XQGÅGHRQWLFUHDVRQV>WKDW@DUHWREHXQGHUVWRRGLQUH ODWLRQWRFRQFOXVLRQVDERXWZKDWDQDJHQWRXJKWWRGR>«@$VSLUDWLRQDOUHDVRQV>«@ WDNHXVWRÄEHVWV¶UDWKHUWKDQÄRXJKWV¶ WKH\WKXVH[KLELWDGLIIHUHQWNLQGRIQRUPDWLYLW\ IURPWKHGHRQWLFLQVRIDUDVWKHSUDFWLFDOFRQFOXVLRQVWKH\WHQGWRVXSSRUWDUHFODLPV DERXWZKDWLWZRXOGEHEHVWWRGR´ (EGI :lKUHQGGDV 1LFKW %HIROJHQGLHVHU ÄDVSLUDWLRQDOUHDVRQV¶NHLQHUOHL$XVZLUNXQJHQDXIGDVLQWHUSHUVRQHOOH1HW]P|JOLFKHU SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ KDW EHVLW]HQ ÄGHRQWLF UHDVRQV¶ LKU *HZLFKW JHUDGH PLW %OLFN DXI HLQHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV Å1HJOHFWLQJ P\ PRUDO UHDVRQ >«@LWVHOIFKDQJHVP\QRUPDWLYHUHODWLRQVWRRWKHUSHRSOHLQZD\VWKDWLQWXUQJURXQG DOWHUDWLRQVLQWKHLUDWWLWXGHVWRZDUGPH´ (EG 0LW%OLFNDXI.DQWVFKOlJW2·1HLOO HLQH GHUDUWLJH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZHLHU $UWHQ YRQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV YRU GRFKEOHLEWVLH LQWHUSUHWDWRULVFKNRUUHNW KLQVLFKWOLFKGHULQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ3HUVSHNWLYH EHLP.DQWLVFKHQ0RQRORJLVPXVVWHKHQGKHVJHKWDXFKEHL0D[LPHQPLWLQWHUSHU VRQHOOHU.RQIOLNWDQIlOOLJNHLWQLFKWXP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ JHJHQEHUDQGHUHQ VRQGHUQXP GDV$EVFKlW]HQP|JOLFKHUDOOJHPHLQHU*HVHW]OLFKNHLWLQIRURLQWHUQR
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
.RKlUHQ]SUDNWLVFKHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQ DOVRVROFKHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQGLHEHVD JHQZLHGLH:HOWVHLQVROOWH ZLUGGDGXUFKHUUHLFKWGDGLHMHQLJHQ+DQG OXQJVDEVLFKWHQDXIJHJHEHQZHUGHQGLHDXV+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQUHVXOWLHUHQ ZHOFKH YRQ $QGHUHQ YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH ]XUFNJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ E]Z GD GLHMHQLJHQ $EVLFKWHQ +DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlW HUODQJHQ GLH DXV +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ UHVXOWLHUHQ ZHOFKH YRQ $QGHUHQ QLFKW YHUQQIWLJHU ZHLVH]XUFNJHZLHVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ :LHEHLPLQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ.RKlUHQWLVPXVGLHP|JOLFKH%HJUQGXQJVR VSLHOW EHLP LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ .RKlUHQWLVPXV GLH P|JOLFKH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ HLQHU SUDNWLVFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJ JHJHQEHU NRQNXUULHUHQGHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GLH]HQWUDOH5ROOH'HU8QWHUVFKLHGEHVWHKWGDULQGDLPLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ )DOOGLHP|JOLFKH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJYRQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQ]ZLVFKHQYHUVFKLHGH QHQ P|JOLFKHUZHLVH MHZHLOV LQ VLFK NRKlUHQWHQ 6\VWHPHQ YRQ (LQVWHO OXQJHQ VWDWWILQGHW ² 'LH GHXWVFKH 6SUDFKH EHKDQGHOW GDV 9HUE ÄEHJUQ GHQ¶ DOV ]ZHLVWHOOLJHQ 3UlGLNDWRU HWZDV ZLUG GXUFK HWZDV EHJUQGHW ZlKUHQGGDV9HUEÄUHFKWIHUWLJHQ¶HLQHQGUHLVWHOOLJHQ3UlGLNDWRUEH]HLFKQHW HWZDV ZLUG GXUFK HWZDV JHJHQEHU MPG JHUHFKWIHUWLJW %HJUQGXQJHQ EHWUHIIHQ ORJLVFKH 9HUKlOWQLVVH .RQVLVWHQ] XQG .RKlUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ HSLVWHPLVFKHQ XQGRGHU SUDNWLVFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ZlKUHQG 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJHQORJLVFKH9HUKlOWQLVVH .RQVLVWHQ]XQG.RKlUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQSUDN WLVFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJVV\VWHPHQEHWUHIIHQ 0LW %OLFN DXI HLQHQ VROFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV HUNOlUW 6FDQORQ LQZLHIHUQ GLH P|JOLFKH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ GHU +DQGOXQJHQ HLQHU 3HUVRQJHJHQEHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQHQGLH]HQWUDOH5ROOHLQXQVHUHQPRUDOL VFKHQ hEHUOHJXQJHQ VSLHOHQ NDQQ Å>«@ WKH LGHD RI MXVWLILDELOLW\ VKDSHV RXU WKLQNLQJ DERXW ULJKW DQG ZURQJ DQG GHWHUPLQHV WKH FRQWHQW RI WKLV SDUW RI PRUDOLW\ 7KLQNLQJ DERXW WKLV SDUW RI PRUDOLW\ LV >«@ WKLQNLQJ DERXWZKDWZRXOGEHDOORZHGE\SULQFLSOHVWKDWRWKHUVFRXOGQRWUHDVRQD EO\UHMHFW´(VJHKWDOVRXPGLH1LFKW=XUFNZHLVEDUNHLWYRQ3ULQ]LSLHQ GLH GHQ 5DXP LQWHUSHUVRQHOO UHFKWIHUWLJEDUHU +DQGOXQJHQ EHVFKUHLEHQ
_____________ 'DV HQJOLVFKH MXVWLILDELOLW\ VFKHLQW PLU PLW 5HFKWIHUWLJEDUNHLW HKHU XQVFK|Q EHUVHW]W GHVKDOE VSUHFKH LFK JOHLFKEHGHXWHQG OLHEHU YRQ P|JOLFKHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ RGHU DXFK 9HUWUHWEDUNHLW 6FDQORQ YJOGD]XDXFK6FDQORQI Å7KHYDOXHRIMXVWLILDELOLW\WR RWKHUVLVWKHXQLI\LQJLGHDXQGHUO\LQJWKDWSDUWRIPRUDOLW\WKDWKDVWRGRZLWKRXUGX WLHVWRRWKHUV%XWQRWHYHU\WKLQJFRPPRQO\FDOOHGÄPRUDO¶FDQSODXVLEO\EHDFFRXQWHG IRURQWKLVEDVLV,GHDOVRIPRUDOSXULW\REMHFWLRQVWRWKHGHVWUXFWLRQRIQDWXUHDQG WKHZURQJIXOQHVVRIIDLOLQJWRUHVSHFWDQGGHYHORSRXUWDOHQWVIRUH[DPSOHFDQQRWEH IXOO\H[SODLQHG DVSDUWVRIÄZKDW ZHRZHWR HDFKRWKHU¶6RRQHFRQVHTXHQFHRIP\ YLHZLVWKHIUDJPHQWDWLRQRIWKHPRUDO>«@7KHLGHDRIUHDVRQDEOHUHMHFWDELOLW\SUR YLGHVDIUDPHZRUNZLWKLQZKLFKZHFDQH[SODLQWKHPRUDOVLJQLILFDQFHRIGLYHUVHFRQ VLGHUDWLRQVLQFOXGLQJQRWRQO\IDFWRUVFRQWULEXWLQJWRSHRSOH·VZHOIDUHEXWDOVRIDLU QHVVFKRLFHDQGUHVSRQVLELOLW\´
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%HJUQGXQJVXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV
'LHVH1LFKW=XUFNZHLVEDUNHLWLVWJOHLFKEHGHXWHQGGDPLWGDDOOHEHWURI IHQHQ 3HUVRQHQ DOV DXI GLHVH 3ULQ]LSLHQ QLFKW EHUHLWV DXI GLH GXUFK VLH HUODXEWHQ+DQGOXQJHQ IHVWJHOHJWEHWUDFKWHWZHUGHQN|QQHQ ,Q)UDJHVWHKWEHLGHULQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ.RKlUHQ]DOVRGLHREHQDQJH VSURFKHQH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHU(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQHLQHUVHLWVXQGGHU *UQGHE]ZGHU6ROOHQ5HODWLRQDQGHUHUVHLWV:HQQLFKPLUDOVKDQGHOQ GH3HUVRQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQLQ)RUPGHV+DQGOXQJVJUXQGVS]XHLJHQPDFKH XQG PLFK JHPl 2 S Ⱥ T DXI GLH+DQGOXQJ E]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW T IHVWOHJHGLHVH)HVWOHJXQJDOVRHEHQVRZLHGLHMHQLJHDXISDQHUNHQQHVRLVW GLHVUDWLRQDO9HUQQIWLJLVWHVKLQJHJHQHUVWGDQQZHQQLFKYRQDQGHUHQ 3HUVRQHQ GHUHQ P|JOLFKHUZHLVH NRQIOLJLHUHQGH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GLH LQWHU SHUVRQHOOH.RKlUHQ]EHWUHIIHQHQWZHGHUGLH%HUHFKWLJXQJ]XSHUKDOWHVR GD LFK DXV GHUHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH JHPl S Ⱥ 5T SULPD IDFLH *UQGH ]X T KDEH RGHU JDU GLH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI S ]XJHZLHVHQ EHNRPPH VRGD LFK DXV GHUHQ3HUVSHNWLYHJHPlSȺ2TVRJDUSUlYDOHQWH*UQGH]XTKDEH'LH 1LFKW=XUFNZHLVEDUNHLWYRQ3ULQ]LSLHQTXDOLIL]LHUWLQHLQHPSUDNWLVFKHQ .RQGLWLRQDOGLH$EWUHQQEDUNHLWGHU.RQNOXVLRQTJHQDXGDQQZHQQSGHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ HQWVSULFKW 'LHV PX LQ GHU VR]LDOHQ 5HDOLWlW QLFKW EHU HLQH H[SOL]LWH $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ XP GLH 3ULQ]LSLHQ ODXIHQ VRQGHUQ NDQQ LPSOL]LWGXUFKGLHVFKOLFKWH=XZHLVXQJGHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIE]Z%HUHFKWL JXQJ ]X GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI S ² RGHU QRFK LPSOL]LWHU DXI T ² GXUFK GLH EHXUWHLOHQGH 3HUVRQ E]Z 3HUVRQHQ JHVFKHKHQ 'DV (QWVFKHLGHQGH LVW MHGRFK GD VLFK GLH 1LFKW=XUFNZHLVEDUNHLW XQG GDPLW GLH 9HUQQIWLJ NHLW GHU IUDJOLFKHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ DP MHZHLOLJHQ GHRQWLVFKHQ .RQWRVWDQG GHU %HWHLOLJWHQ ZHOFKH )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ VLH HLQDQGHU ]XJH ZLHVHQ E]Z DQHUNDQQW KDEHQ DEOHVHQ OlW ,P .RQIOLNWIDOO LVW HV GDPLW MHGHQIDOOV P|JOLFK +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ ]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGH 3ULQ]LSLHQ LQ )UDJH]XVWHOOHQ'LHVHÄ.RQWRVWlQGH¶DOVRGLHMHZHLOLJHQ9HUELQGOLFKNHL WHQVLFKWEDUZHUGHQ]XODVVHQPDFKWGDVNULWLVFKH3RWHQWLDOHLQHUGHUDUWL JHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVDXV²'LH$Q]DKOGHUKDQGHOQGHQEHXUWHLOHQ GHQ ² DOOJHPHLQ EHWHLOLJWHQ ² 3HUVRQHQ LVW KLHU HEHQVR RIIHQ ZLH GLH 9HUWHLOXQJGHU$XWRULWlWOHW]WHUHVROOLQGLHVHUIRUPDOHQ5ROOHQYHUWHLOXQJ
_____________ 9JOGD]X%UDQGRP Å'LHREHUVWH5HJHOLP.DPSIGHU9HUQXQIWJHJHQHLQ GXUFK9RUXUWHLOXQG3URSDJDQGDYHU]HUUWHV'HQNHQODXWHWGDSRWHQWLHOOVWULWWLJHPD WHULDOLQIHUHQWLHOOH )HVWOHJXQJHQ DOV %HKDXSWXQJHQ H[SOL]LW JHPDFKW ZHUGHQ VROOWHQ XPVLHDXIGLHVH:HLVHHLQHUVHLWVIUEHJUQGHWH$QIHFKWXQJHQYHUOHW]OLFK]XPDFKHQ XQGDQGHUHUVHLWVGHXWOLFK]XPDFKHQGDYHUQQIWLJH6WUDWHJLHQ]XLKUHU9HUWHLGLJXQJ JHIUDJWVLQG´9JODXFK%UDQGRPD 'LHVH([SOL]LHUXQJGHU%HUHFKWL JXQJ]XHLQHU=XZHLVXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDQHLQH3HUVRQLVWGHU2UWDQGHPVLFKGLH =XJlQJOLFKNHLWYRQ*UQGHQIUGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQHUZHLVHQPX XPZLHGHUXP UHFKWIHUWLJHQG XQG PRWLYLHUHQG VHLQ ]X N|QQHQ PX GLH =XJlQJOLFKNHLW SUDNWLVFKHU *UQGHVLFKHUJHVWHOOWVHLQ YJO(QGUHV
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
QLFKW DOV EHUHLWV HLQHU 3HUVRQ RGHU Ä3DUWHL¶ ]XJHZLHVHQ EHWUDFKWHW ZHUGHQ 2EDOVRGLH=XZHLVXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJEHUHFKWLJWLVWNDQQQLFKWHLQVHLWLJ YRQGHU:DUWHGHU%HXUWHLOHUDXVVRQGHUQPXLQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJPLW GHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQVHOEVWEHVWLPPWZHUGHQ GHUUHDOHE]ZLGHDOH&KD UDNWHUGLHVHU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJZLUGLPIROJHQGHQQRFKHLQH5ROOHVSLH OHQ0|JOLFKH.RQIOLNWIl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ÄLPPHU VFKRQ¶ XQWHUOLHJHQ ZUGHQ 9LHOPHKU VROO GLHVH 8QWHUVWHOOXQJ OHGLJOLFKEHVDJHQGDGLHEHLGHQ.RQIOLNWSDUWHLHQSHUIRUPDWLYLKUH%HUHLW VFKDIWHUNOlUHQGDV6SLHOGHV9HUODQJHQVXQG*HEHQVYRQ*UQGHQ HLQH UHFKWIHUWLJHQGH $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW GHP =LHO HLQHV $EJOHLFKV GHU EHWURIIHQHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ EHUKDXSW ]X VSLHOHQ ² DQVWDWW EHLVSLHOVZHLVH DXIGDV $UJXPHQW!GHU0DFKWGHV6WlUNHUHQ]XUHNXUULHUHQ'LHLQGHU $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ H[SOL]LHUWHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ VLQG GDPLW DEKlQJLJ ZHQQ JOHLFKQLFKWIRUPDODXVGLHVHUGHGX]LHUEDU YRQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHU$Q GHUHQLP6LQQHGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGHU)HVWOHJXQJDXI7HLOQDKPHDPLQWHU VXEMHNWLYHQ 6SLHO GHV )RUGHUQV XQG *HEHQV YRQ *UQGHQ 'HU %HUHLFK GHUXQWHUVWHOOWHQ9HUQQIWLJNHLWLVWGDPLWNRH[WHQVLRQDOPLWGHP%HUHLFK GHUDXIJUXQGZHOFKHU3HUIRUPDQ]DXFKLPPHUGXUFKGLH%HUHLWVFKDIW]XU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJXPVFKULHEHQLVW 6FDQORQ PDFKW GLHVH (LQVFKUlQNXQJ GHV (UNOlUXQJVEHUHLFKV HLQHU 0RUDOWKHRULHZHOFKH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGDPLWGLHP|JOLFKH5HFKWIHU WLJXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ DOV =HQWUXP EHVLW]W YRQ YRUQKHUHLQ GHXWOLFK Å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
_____________ 9JO]XGHQGLVWDQ]LHUHQGHQ$QIKUXQJV]HLFKHQREHQ(LQOHLWXQJ)Q
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWLRQGHV:KDW:H2ZHWR(DFK2WKHU
DQGRQO\LILWZRXOGEHGLVDOORZHGE\DQ\SULQFLSOHWKDWVXFKSHRSOHFRXOG QRW UHDVRQDEO\ UHMHFW µ 'LH +HUYRUKHEXQJ LQQHUKDOE GLHVHV =LWDWV EH WRQW QRFK HLQPDO GLH XQWHUVWHOOWH 9HUQQIWLJNHLW :HU GLH 7HLOQDKPH DQ GLHVHP6SLHOGHV9HUODQJHQVXQG*HEHQVYRQ*UQGHQGHUHQ6LWXDWLRQV DGlTXDWKHLW VLFK LKUHUVHLWV QXU LQ GLHVHP 6SLHO HUZHLVHQ NDQQ XQG PX YHUZHLJHUWVWHKWDXHUKDOEGLHVHU8QWHUVWHOOXQJ(VJLEWGHPQDFKNHLQHQ $XWRPDWLVPXV GHU YRP 6WDWXV GHV 0HQVFKHQ DOV HLQHV GHQNHQGHQ XQG KDQGHOQGHQ :HVHQV QRUPDWLY ]XU $QHUNHQQXQJ YRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXI +DQGOXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQIKUHQZUGH(LQHU8QWHUVWHOOXQJ NDQQ PDQ DQGHUV DOV HLQHU YHUPXWHWHQ .|USHUIXQNWLRQ JHUHFKW ZHUGHQ RGHUQLFKWJHUHFKWZHUGHQ(VJHKWEHLGLHVHP6SLHOGHV9HUODQJHQVXQG *HEHQV YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ DOVR XP 8UWHLOH GLH PLW GHP =LHO GHU LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ%LOOLJXQJSUDNWLVFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQH[SOL]LWPDFKHQ
6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWLRQGHV:KDW:H2ZHWR(DFK2WKHU
,Q GLHVHP 6LQQH HLQHU 6XFKH QDFK LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU%LOOLJXQJ SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQVSULFKW6FDQORQYRQVHLQHU7KHRULHDXFKLQ%HJULIIHQHLQHV .RQWUDNWXDOLVPXV (U LVW VLFK MHGRFK GHU P|JOLFKHUZHLVH LUUHIKUHQGHQ $VVR]LDWLRQHQGLHPLWGLHVHP%HJULIIYHUEXQGHQVLQGEHZXWXQGJUHQ]W GHVKDOE VHLQH $XIIDVVXQJ YRQ $XIIDVVXQJHQ GLH XQWHU GHPVHOEHQ 7LWHO YHUKDQGHOWZHUGHQDE'LHVWlUNVWH$IILQLWlWEHVWHKWYHUPXWOLFK]ZLVFKHQ 6FDQORQV HLJHQHU 7KHRULH XQG GHU 7KHRULH GHU *HUHFKWLJNHLW VHLQHV /HKUHUV -RKQ5DZOVGRFKXQWHUVFKHLGHW6FDQORQVHLQHHLJHQHQ%HPKXQJHQDXFK YRQ 5DZOV· 7KHPD GHU *HUHFKWLJNHLW VR]LDOHU ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ LQVRIHUQ 5DZOV· 7KHRULHLP*HJHQVDW]]XVHLQHUHLJHQHQQLFKWSULPlUGLH*WHHLQ]HOQHU (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ XQG +DQGOXQJVZHLVHQ EHWULIIW 'LHV KDW $XVZLUNXQJHQ DXIGLHUHVXOWLHUHQGHQ3ULQ]LSLHQZLH6FDQORQDP%HLVSLHOGHU3ULRULWlWGHU 6FKOHFKWHUJHVWHOOWHQYHUGHXWOLFKWZHOFKHLQ5DZOV·.RQ]HSWLRQHLQH]HQW UDOH5ROOHVSLHOW Å$SULQFLSOHJLYLQJWKHLQWHUHVWVRIWKHZRUVWRIISULRULW\ LQHYHU\VRFLDOGHFLVLRQZRXOGEHPXFKOHVVSODXVLEOHWKDQRQHJLYLQJWKHLU LQWHUHVWV SULRULW\ LQ DUJXPHQWV DERXW WKH MXVWLFH RI WKH LQVWLWXWLRQV WKDW OHDYHWKHPZRUVWRII´
_____________ 6FDQORQ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 6FDQORQ ZDVLQ5DZOV·7KHRULHDOVRVLQQYROOVHLQPDJHUVFKHLQWXQWHUGHU 3HUVSHNWLYH LQGLYLGXHOOHU $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJHQ QLFKW VWHWV XQG QRWZHQGLJ VLQQYROO %HL5DZOVODXWHWHHLQH7HLOIRUPXOLHUXQJGHV=ZHLWHQ*HUHFKWLJNHLWVJUXQGVDW]HVIU,Q VWLWXWLRQHQ Å6R]LDOH XQG ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKH 8QJOHLFKKHLWHQ PVVHQ >@ XQWHU GHU (LQ VFKUlQNXQJ GHV JHUHFKWHQ 6SDUJUXQGVDW]HV GHQ DP ZHQLJVWHQ %HJQVWLJWHQ GHQ JU|WP|JOLFKHQ9RUWHLOEULQJHQ>@´ 5DZOV
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
*HQHUHOOJLOWZLHEHUHLWVDQJHGHXWHWGHU8QWHUVFKLHG]ZLVFKHQ6FDQ ORQV7KHRULHGLHDXIGHU%HUHLWVFKDIW]XU7HLOQDKPHDQHLQHU5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVSUD[LV EDVLHUW XQG HLQHP OHGLJOLFK DXI 6HOEVWLQWHUHVVH JHJUQGHWHQ .RQWUDNWXDOLVPXV ZRUXQWHUMHGRFKDXFKGHU5DZOV·VFKHQLFKWIlOOW Å>«@ ÄFRQWUDFW¶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ÄFRQWUDFWXDOLVW¶ LV WR HPSKDVL]H LWV FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK WKLV WUDGLWLRQµ'RFKVROOWHGLHVH=XRUGQXQJQLFKWGD]XIKUHQ$UJXPHQWH DXV GLHVHU 7UDGLWLRQ VWLOOVFKZHLJHQG ]X DGDSWLHUHQ YLHOPHKU EHDQVSUXFKW 6FDQORQV7KHRULHÄDXIHLJHQHQ)HQ¶]XVWHKHQ'HP9RUZXUIGHU=LUNX ODULWlW²]XU)LQGXQJYHUQQIWLJHU3ULQ]LSLHQLP.RQIOLNWIDOOLQWHUSHUVRQHO OHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ZHUGH GLH 9HUQQIWLJNHLW EHUHLWV YRUDXVJHVHW]W ² PX DOVRHLJHQVEHJHJQHWZHUGHQ
_____________ 6FDQORQ %DUU\ EHWRQW GLH 9HUELQGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU 6R]LDOYHU WUDJVWKHRULHXQGHLQHU9HUVLRQGHV.RQVWUXNWLYLVPXV Å&RQVWUXFWLYLVPLQJHQHUDOLV, VKDOOVD\WKHGRFWULQHWKDWZKDWZRXOGEHDJUHHGRQLQVRPHVSHFLILHGNLQGRIVLWXDWL RQFRQVWLWXWHVMXVWLFH:KHWKHUWKHVLWXDWLRQLWVHOIKDVWREHFKDUDFWHUL]HGE\IDLUQHVV IRUWKHRXWFRPHWREHMXVWLVOHIWDVDQRSHQTXHVWLRQ´'LH7ULIWLJNHLWYRQ+DEHUPDV· (LQZDQGJHJHQGHQ.RQWUDNWXDOLVPXVKlQJWYRQGLHVHUÄRIIHQHQ)UDJH¶DE Å$EHUDXV GHU6XPPHGHUUDWLRQDOHQ0RWLYHGLHMHGHQ(LQ]HOQHQLP/LFKWVHLQHUMHHLJHQHQ3Ul IHUHQ]HQ]XU=XVWLPPXQJEHZHJHQHUNOlUWVLFKQRFKQLFKWGHUVSH]LILVFKYHUSIOLFK WHQGH&KDUDNWHUGHUYHUHLQEDUWHQ1RUPHQ²DOVRGLHGHRQWLVFKH9HUELQGOLFKNHLWPLW GHUZLUDOV0LWJOLHGHUHLQHUPRUDOLVFKHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWHLQEHVWLPPWHV9HUKDOWHQYRQ HLQDQGHUHUZDUWHQ´ +DEHUPDV %DUU\LVWVLFKGHU6FKZlFKHHLQHVVRNULWLV LHUEDUHQ .RQVWUXNWLYLVPXV DOV UHLQHV Ä%DUJDLQLQJ¶ EHZXW Å7KHUH LV DQ DOWHUQDWLYH YLHZZKLFKPDNHVDJUHHPHQWRQUHDVRQDEOHWHUPVVRPHWKLQJRIYDOXHLQLWVHOIUDWKHU WKDQ D PRUH RU OHVV HIILFLHQW PHDQV WR WKH VXFFHVVIXO SXUVXLW RI RQH·V HQGV´ %DUU\ 6HLQHLJHQHUVXEVWDQWLHOOHUDQ6FDQORQ DOOHUGLQJVZLH5DZOVPLW%OLFNDXI VR]LDOH,QVWLWXWLRQHQ RULHQWLHUWHU.RQVWUXNWLYLVPXVLVWGDKHUPHLQHV(UDFKWHQVJHJHQ +DEHUPDV·(LQZDQGLPPXQGDGDULQUHDOH3UR]HGXUHQ]XU)LQGXQJYHUELQGOLFKHU3ULQ ]LSLHQYRUJHVHKHQVLQG Å)LQDOO\WKHWKLUGVHWWLQJ>VFRIFRQVWUXFWLRQ@LVRQHWKDW5D SRSRUWFDOOVLQFRQWUDVWWRDJDPHDGHEDWHÄ7KHREMHFWLYHLVWRFRQYLQFH\RXURSSR QHQW WR PDNH KLP VHH WKLQJV DV \RX VHH WKHP¶ %XW ZH VKRXOG DGG WKDW FRQYLFWLRQ PXVW EH FRQFHLYHG RI DV D WZRZD\ SURFHVV 7KH SDUWLHV LQ WKLV WKLUG FRQVWUXFWLRQ PXVWGHEDWHLQJRRGIDLWKZKLFKPHDQVWKDWWKH\PXVWEHSUHSDUHGWREHFRQYLQFHG DVZHOODVWRWU\WRFRQYLQFHRWKHUV´ %DUU\ YJODXFK%DUU\
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWLRQGHV:KDW:H2ZHWR(DFK2WKHU
:DV 6FDQORQV 7KHRULH YRQ .DQWV .RQ]HSWLRQ GHV XQEHGLQJWHQ 6RO OHQVPLWGHUVLHQLFKWVGHVWRWURW]KLQVLFKWOLFKGHV8QLYHUVDOLVPXVXQGGHP 9RUUDQJ GHV *HUHFKWHQ YRU GHP *XWHQ HLQH HQJH 9HUELQGXQJ EHVLW]W XQWHUDQGHUHPXQWHUVFKHLGHWEHWULIIWGLH%HIROJXQJGHUÄDQDO\WLVFKHQ0H WKRGH¶ LP 6LQQH YRQ .DQWV 3UROHJRPHQD 6FDQORQ JHKW QlPOLFK YRP 6SLHO GHV9HUODQJHQVXQG*HEHQVYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQLPDOOJHPHLQHQXQG YRQ HLQHU PRUDOLVFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV LP EHVRQGHUHQ DXV XQG ÄVWHLJW]XGHQ%HGLQJXQJHQDXI¶GLHGLHVDOOHLQP|JOLFKPDFKHQ 0HWKR GLVFK DQDORJ ]X %UDQGRPV =XJDQJ ]X GHQ QRUPDWLYHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ GHV :LVVHQVXQGGHV+DQGHOQVEHUHLQHQRUPDWLYH 6SUDFK 3UDJPDWLNVHW]W 6FDQORQ PDWHULDOH SUDNWLVFKH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ YRUDXV GLH KDQGHOQGH :HVHQ LPVR]LDOHQ.RQWH[WDUWLNXOLHUHQXQGGLHJHQDXGDULQ]XHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ .RQIOLNWHQIKUHQN|QQHQ (LQ QRUPDWLYLVWLVFKHU $QVDW] SUlYDOHQWHU *UQGH ZLH HU KLHU XQWHU hEHUQDKPHEHVWLPPWHU$UJXPHQWHGLHVHU7KHRULHQYHUIROJWZLUGXQWHU OlXIWGDPLWGLHREHQLQIRUPXOLHUWH.ULWLNDQ.DQWV%HDQWZRUWXQJGHU )UDJH QDFK GHU %HVFKUHLEXQJ HLQHV XQEHGLQJWHQ 6ROOHQV 'LHVH 7KHRULHQ VXFKHQ UHNXUVLY QDFK 3ULQ]LSLHQ GLH GLH .RKlUHQ] NRJQLWLYHU HYDOXDWL YHULQWHQWLRQDOHUXQGDQGHUHU)HVWOHJXQJHQOHLWHQ2GHUXPHVPLW%OLFN DXI .DQW ]X SRLQWLHUHQ LP .DQWLVFKHQ 6LQQH KHWHURQRPH +DQGOXQJV JUQGHVLQGQLFKWQXUKlXILJJXWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHVLHVLQGGDUEHUKLQ DXV GDV JHPHVVHQ ZRUDQ VLFK DXFK GLH 9HUQQIWLJNHLW DOOJHPHLQHU 3ULQ]L SLHQHUZHLVHQPX+DQGOXQJV]ZHFNH,QWHUHVVHQ:QVFKHXQG$QGHUHV EHVFKUHLEHQ GDPLW GLH :HOW GLH EHL GHU )LQGXQJ PRUDOLVFKHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ QLFKW QXU EHUFNVLFKWLJW ZHUGHQ PX YLHOPHKU VLQG GLHVH NRQWLQJHQWHQ +DQGOXQJV]ZHFNH ,QWHUHVVHQ :QVFKH HWF GLHMHQLJHQ Ä*HJHQVWlQGH¶ RGHUEHVVHUSUDNWLVFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQJHJHQEHUZHOFKHQ LQVWDQWLLHUWLQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ3HUIRUPDQ]HQYRQ3HUVRQHQ GLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHUIROJHQ PX,QJHQDXGLHVHP6LQQHVLQGZLU%UJHUQXUHLQHUHLQ]LJHQ:HOW:DV ZLUHLQDQGHUVFKXOGHQ²JHPl6FDQORQVWLWHOJHEHQGHU)RUPXOLHUXQJGHV :KDW:H2ZHWR(DFK2WKHU²VFKXOGHQZLUHLQDQGHUDOV%UJHUGLHVHUVR]L DOHQ :HOW GHUHQ HLQHV .RQVWLWXHQV ZHQQJOHLFK UHFKW YLHOIDUELJ XQVHUH :QVFKH GLH .DQWLVFKHQ Ä1HLJXQJHQ¶ VLQG ,Q VFKURIIHP *HJHQVDW] ]X .DQWV PXQGXV VHQVLELOLV EHVLW]HQ GLHVH Ä1HLJXQJHQ¶ LQ GHU VR]LDOHQ :HOW YRQ+DXVDXVHLQQRUPDWLYHV.OHLG²VLHZHUGHQDOV*UQGHIU+DQGOXQ JHQ EHWUDFKWHW VSUHFKHQ IU RGHU JHJHQ EHVWLPPWH +DQGOXQJHQ 'DV .DQWLVFKHÄVHQVLELOLV¶LVWY|OOLJLUUHOHYDQWVREDOGÄ1HLJXQJHQ¶QLFKWKLQVLFKW OLFKLKUHVQDWXUDOHQ&KDUDNWHUVEHVFKULHEHQVRQGHUQKLQVLFKWOLFKLKUHULQWUD XQG LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ .RKlUHQ] EHZHUWHW ZHUGHQ ,P *HJHQVDW] ]X .DQWV
_____________ 9JO.DQW,9 9JO]XGLHVHP%HJULIIXQWHQ)Q
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
$UJXPHQWDWLRQGLHGLH9HUPHLGXQJYRQ*HVHW]ZLGULJNHLWHQLQQHUKDOEGHV PXQGXV LQWHOOLJLELOLV DOV 0D[LPHQNRUUHNWLY DXIVWHOOW NDQQ JHPl HLQHU 7KHRULH GHUHQ %H]XJVSXQNW NRQNUHWH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ VLQG HLQH /JH HLQ 9HUWUDJVEUXFK XQG VRJDU HLQH 7|WXQJ P|JOLFKHUZHLVH QLFKW QXU HUODXEW VRQGHUQ LQ GLVNXUVLY ]X UHFKWIHUWLJHQGHQ ([WUHPIlOOHQ VRJDU JHERWHQ VHLQ:LU²GDVVLQG+DQGHOQGHPLWDOOHQP|JOLFKHQNRQNUHWHQ(LQVWHOOXQ JHQ²VFKXOGHQ$QGHUHQ²GDVVLQGZLHGHUXP+DQGHOQGHPLWDOOHQP|JOL FKHQ NRQNUHWHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ² VROFKH +DQGOXQJHQ GHUHQ *UQGH YRQ GLHVHQ$QGHUHQQLFKWYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH]XUFNJHZLHVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ ,Q GLHVHP 6LQQH JHKW HV EHL GHU )LQGXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ DXFK QLFKW ZLH EHL .DQW GDUXP VLFK JHGDQNOLFK LQ GLH 3RVLWLRQ HLQHV UDWLRQDOHQ:LOOHQVLPPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLV]XYHUVHW]HQRGHULQ*HGDQNHQ GLH 3RVLWLRQ HLQHU DQGHUHQ YRQ PHLQHQ +DQGOXQJHQ EHWURIIHQHQ 3HUVRQ HLQ]XQHKPHQ VHL HV GXUFK +LQ]XIJHQ P|JOLFKVW YLHOHU ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ EHUGLHDNWXHOOHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQGLHVHU3HUVRQZLH+DUHGLHVYRUVFKOlJW VHL HV GXUFK :HJQDKPH P|JOLFKVW YLHOHU ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ ZLH 5DZOV GLHV PLWGHPÄ6FKOHLHUGHV1LFKWZLVVHQV¶YRUVFKOlJW6WDWWGHVVHQJHKWHVKLHU XP GLH GLUHNWH $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ GDV =XZHLVHQ XQG $QHUNHQQHQ YRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXI EHVWLPPWH +DQGOXQJVZHLVHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X VROFKHUDUW)HVWOHJXQJHQ 0LWGHP%HJULIIGHU9HUQQIWLJNHLWLP*HJHQVDW]]XP%HJULIIGHU5DWLR QDOLWlW VROOHQ QXQ hEHUOHJXQJHQ LQWHJULHUW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ GLH QLFKW GLH LQWUDSHUVRQHOOH .RKlUHQ] GHU SHUV|QOLFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GHV RGHU GHU +DQGHOQGHQDOV.ULWHULXPEHVLW]HQ'LHhEHUWUDJXQJGLHVHVLQWUDSHUVRQHOO ]ZHLIHOORV DXFK XQWHU %HGLQJXQJHQ VWUXNWXUHOOHU hEHUOHJXQJHQ JOWLJHQ +DQGOXQJVNULWHULXPV GHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW DXI GHQ LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ %HUHLFK ZUGH P|JOLFKHUZHLVH ]X 3ULQ]LSLHQ IKUHQ GLH YRQ $QGHUHQ PLW JXWHQ *UQGHQ]XUFNJHZLHVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQXQGLQGLHVHP6LQQHDXFKXQVH
_____________ 9JO+DUH 9JO5DZOV 5DZOVVWHOOWVHLQH7KHRULHLQGLHVHU+LQVLFKWMHGRFKDXFK H[SOL]LWLQHLQHQ.DQWLVFKHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJ Å:HQQHWZD.DQWXQVDXIIRUGHUWXQVH UH0D[LPH]XSUIHQLQGHPZLUXQVIUDJHQZDVGHU)DOOZlUHZHQQVLHHLQDOOJHPHL QHV1DWXUJHVHW]ZlUHVRPXHUYRUDXVVHW]HQGDZLUXQVHUHQ3ODW]LQGLHVHPYRU JHVWHOOWHQ6\VWHPGHU1DWXUQLFKWNHQQHQ´ 5DZOV 9JO GD]X 6FDQORQ DOOHUGLQJV ZLHGHUXP QLFKW LP DQDO\WLVFK WUDQVSDU HQWHUHQ 9RNDEXODU GHRQWLVFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ Å7KLV JLYHV XV D GLUHFW UHDVRQ WR EH FRQFHUQHGZLWKRWKHUSHRSOH·VSRLQWVRIYLHZ QRWEHFDXVHZHPLJKWIRUDOOZHNQRZ DFWXDOO\ EH WKHP RU EHFDXVH ZH PLJKW RFFXS\ WKHLU SRVLWLRQ LQ VRPH RWKHU SRVVLEOH ZRUOGEXWLQRUGHUWRILQGSULQFLSOHVWKDWWKH\DVZHOODVZHKDYHUHDVRQWRDFFHSW´ ²(LQH.DQW,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ²RGHUEHVVHU5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ²HQWODQJGLHVHUVR]LDORUL HQWLHUWHQ $UJXPHQWDWLRQVOLQLHQ 6FDQORQV ILQGHW VLFK EHL 5HDWK YJO GD]XDXFKXQWHQ)Q
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWLRQGHV:KDW:H2ZHWR(DFK2WKHU
UHQ PRUDOLVFKHQ $OOWDJVLQWXLWLRQHQ XP GHUHQ .RQ]HSWXDOLVLHUXQJ HV KLHU JHKWQLFKWJHUHFKWZHUGHQ 6RODQJH HV XP 3ULQ]LSLHQ JHKW GHUHQ %HIROJXQJ DOOH %HWHLOLJWHQ EHV VHUVWHOOHQ DOV DOWHUQDWLYH 3ULQ]LSLHQ GLHV WXQ ZUGHQ JHQJW HLQ EHU GLH $Q]DKOGHU%HWHLOLJWHQLQWHJULHUWHV.ULWHULXPGHU5DWLRQDOLWlW'RFKLQGHU 5HDOLWlWJHKWHVKlXILJXP3ULQ]LSLHQGLHHLQLJH%HWHLOLJWHQEHVVHUDOVDQ GHUHVWHOOHQXQGHVLVWQLFKWXQPLWWHOEDUHLQVLFKWLJGDGDV3ULQ]LSGHVVHQ %HIROJXQJVFKOLFKWZHJPHKU3HUVRQHQEHVVHUVWHOOHQZUGHDOVHLQDOWHUQD WLYHV3ULQ]LSGLHVWXQZUGHEHVVHUEHJUQGHWZHUGHQNDQQDOVGLHVHVDOWHU QDWLYH3ULQ]LS 'HQ 3UR]H GHU PDWHULDOHQ hEHUOHJXQJ XQG LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ $XVHLQDQ GHUVHW]XQJ DQVWHOOHHLQHUTXDQWLWDWLYHQ$XIUHFKQXQJHLQHVIRUPDOHQ.DO NOV GHULQGLHVHQ6LWXDWLRQHQ]X+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQIKUHQVROOGLHYRQ GHQ +DQGHOQGHQ E]Z GHQ YRQ GHU +DQGOXQJ %HWURIIHQHQ QLFKW ]XUFN JHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ EH]HLFKQHW 6FDQORQ DOV YHUQQIWLJ (V ZHUGHQ VXEVWDQWLHOOH8UWHLOHYHUODQJWGLHP|JOLFKHNRQNUHWH(LQZlQGHJHJHQGLH %HUHFKWLJXQJ]XHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIHLQHEHVWLPPWH+DQGOXQJZLHGHUJH EHQ XP GLH 'LVTXDOLILNDWLRQ HLQHU +DQGOXQJ EHJUQGHQ ]X N|QQHQ 'LH SKLORVRSKLVFKH7KHRULHVHOEVWJLEWJOHLFKZRKONHLQHVXEVWDQWLHOOHQ8UWHLOH RGHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ YRU VRQGHUQ EHVFKUHLEW OHGLJOLFK .ULWHULHQ ]XU )LQGXQJ VROFKHUVXEVWDQWLHOOHQ8UWHLOHRGHU3ULQ]LSLHQ,QGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJ JUHLIW6FDQORQGHQ9HUGDFKWDXIGD]XU)LQGXQJPRUDOLVFKYHUQQIWLJHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ LP .RQIOLNWIDOO LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ HLQ PRUDOLVFK EHVWLPPWHV.RQ]HSWYRQ9HUQQIWLJNHLWGHU%HWHLOLJWHQEHUHLWVYRUDXVJH VHW]WZHUGH Å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´ 'RFKOHW]WHUH6WUDWHJLH²HLQHQXUVFKHLQEDUPHWDSK\VLVFKDQVSUXFKV ORVHUH7KHRULH²EHVLW]WGLHVHOEH$UJXPHQWDWLRQVSIOLFKWKLQVLFKWOLFKHLQHV VROFKHQLQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ5DWLRQDOLWlWVNULWHULXPV'HQQOHW]WHUHVPXHEHQ QRWZHQGLJHUZHLVH HLQ PDWHULDOHV VHLQ 2GHU NRQNUHWHU (LJHQQXW] LVW DXFK LP LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ .RQWH[W HEHQ QLFKW LGHQWLVFK PLW ORJLVFKHU .RQVLVWHQ] XQG .RKlUHQ] $Q GLHVHU $UJXPHQWDWLRQVSIOLFKW VFKHLWHUW GLHVH 6WUDWHJLH VFKOLHOLFK LQVRIHUQ VLH QLFKW E]Z QXU PLW H[WUHP
_____________ 6FDQORQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
NRQWUDLQWXLWLYHQ0LWWHOQHLQ]XO|VHQLVW(VPWHHLQHEHOLHELJH)RUPYRQ ZLHDXFKLPPHUYHUVWDQGHQHP(LJHQLQWHUHVVH:RKOHUJHKHQRGHUDQGHUHQ DXIGDVHLJHQH:RKOJHULFKWHWHQ3UlIHUHQ]HQGHU%HWHLOLJWHQDOVXQLYHUVD OHV PDWHULDOHV .ULWHULXP HLQHV .RQVHQVHV DXVJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ 'LHVH 6WUDWHJLHLVWQXQQLFKWQXUSV\FKRORJLVFKIUDJZUGLJZHQQQLFKWJDUDXV VLFKWVORV VLH LVW YRU DOOHP GHU $OWHUQDWLYVWUDWHJLH ZHVHQWOLFK XQWHUOHJHQ LQVRIHUQOHW]WHUH]XPHLQHQGDV]XHQJH5DWLRQDOLWlWVNULWHULXPGHV(LJHQ LQWHUHVVHVQHEHQDQGHUHQ.ULWHULHQLQVLFKDXIQLPPWXQGRSHUDWLRQDOLVLHUW XQG]XPDQGHUHQHLQHQPDWHULDOHQ=LHONRQVHQVEHLVSLHOVZHLVHGDV:RKO HUJHKHQGHUPHLVWHQRGHUGLH%HVVHUVWHOOXQJGHU6FKOHFKWHVWJHVWHOOWHQYRQ GHPKHUVLFKGDV5DWLRQDOLWlWVNULWHULXPEHVWLPPHQODVVHQVROOQLFKWWKHR UHWLVFKYRUJLEWXQGLQGLHVHP6LQQHPHWDSK\VLVFKDQVSUXFKVORVHULVW 'LH$OWHUQDWLYVWUDWHJLHEHVWHKWDOVRGDULQQLFKWLPYRUDXVHLQHQPDWH ULDOHQ=LHONRQVHQV :RKOHUJHKHQGHUPHLVWHQ%HVVHUVWHOOXQJGHU6FKOHFK WHVWJHVWHOOWHQHWF ]XGHILQLHUHQGHUDOOHLQDXIJUXQGGLHVHV5DWLRQDOLWlWVNUL WHULXPV HUUHLFKEDU VHL VRQGHUQ IRUPDOH 9HUIDKUHQVQRUPHQ GHV 5HFKWIHUWLJHQV H[SOL]LW ]X PDFKHQ GLH QHEHQ DQGHUHP DXFK ZHVHQWOLFK 5DXPIUVXEVWDQWLHOOH$UJXPHQWHGHV(JRLVPXVXQGGHV$OWUXLVPXVELH WHQ9RUDXVJHVHW]WZLUG9HUQQIWLJNHLWGDPLWOHGLJOLFKLQGHP6LQQHGD GLH EHWURIIHQHQ 3HUVRQHQ EHUHLW VLQG LKUH SHUV|QOLFKHQ VXEVWDQWLHOOHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ PLW GHP $QVSUXFK DXI $QHUNHQQXQJ LQ GHQ Ä5DXP GHU *UQGH¶]XVWHOOHQ]XYHUWHLGLJHQXQGJHJHEHQHQIDOOV]XPRGLIL]LHUHQ DXI GLHVH%HUHLWVFKDIWZHUGHLFKQRFKHLQPDO]XUFNNRPPHQ:HOFKHPRUDOL VFKHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ HV MHGRFK VFKOLHOLFK VLQG GLH GLHVHQ 5DXP YHUQQIWL JHUZHLVHEHKHUUVFKHQZLUGYRQGHU7KHRULHQLFKWEHVWLPPW(LQWKHRUHWL VFKHU'XUFKJULII]XGHQPRUDOLVFKHQ1RUPHQILQGHWGDKHUQLFKWVWDWW
_____________ :DVPDWHULDOYRUDXVJHVHW]WZLUGVRHUOlXWHUW6FDQORQVLQGPRUDOLVFKUHOHYDQWH(LQVWHO OXQJHQ QLFKW MHGRFK GLHVH RGHU MHQH EHVWLPPWHQ PRUDOLVFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ (U UlXPW VHLQHU7KHRULHGDEHLGHQ$QVFKHLQHLQHVYLWL|VHQ=LUNHOVHLQÅVLQFHLWPXVWEHJLQZLWK VXEVWDQWLYHFODLPVDERXWPRUDOUHOHYDQFH%XWWKLVLVQRWDVHULRXVREMHFWLRQ1RWKH RU\ZKHWKHUFRQWUDFWXDOLVWRUQRWFDQDYRLGEHJLQQLQJZLWKVRPHFODLPRIWKLVNLQG «@ HLQH 6DFKH GHU JHJHQVHLWLJHQ 6WW]XQJYLHOHU(UZlJXQJHQGHV=XVDPPHQVWLPPHQV]XHLQHUHLQKHLWOLFKHQ$XIIDV VXQJ´EH]HLFKQHWZLUG YJO5DZOV VRZLHREHQ.DS)Q0LW%OLFN DXINRQNUHWHPRUDOLVFKH.RQIOLNWHEHLVSLHOVZHLVHGHUlU]WOLFKHQ/JHJHJHQEHU3DWL HQWHQKDW'H0DUFRGLHVH2IIHQKHLWVRHUOlXWHUW Å7KHDWWHPSWRIG\QDPLFFRKHUHQFH LVWRRUGHUDQGJXLGHPRUDOH[SHULHQFH,WVWULYHVWRILQGZD\VWRPDNHOHYHOVRIPRUDO FRQFHUQ DQG DVSHFWV ZLWKLQ WKRVH OHYHOV PXWXDOO\ VXSSRUWLQJ ,W DWWHPSWV WR VKRZ ZKRLQZKDWFLUFXPVWDQFHVKDVWKHPRUDOEXUGHQ RI SURRIDQGKRZLWPD\EHPHW $QGLWVXSSRUWVSULQFLSOHVUXOHVSUDFWLFHVQRUPVDQGVRRQLQUHODWLRQWRWKHZKROH RIPRUDOH[SHULHQFHµ 'H0DUFR I 'H0DUFRVNRKlUHQWLVWLVFKHU$QVDW]XQ WHUVFKHLGHWVLFKMHGRFKYRPYRUOLHJHQGHQLQVRIHUQDOVMHQHUVWDWWIRUPDOHU9RUJDEHQ IU GLH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV GUHL QHJDWLYH XQG GUHL SRVLWLYH PDWHULDOH 3ULQ]LSLHQ DQ JLEW GLH GLH .RKlUHQ] JDUDQWLHUHQ VROOHQ GLH QDFK GHU YRUOLHJHQGHQ .RQ]HSWLRQ MH GRFKHLQHUVHLWV]XYDJHVLQGXP]XHLQGHXWLJHQ+DQGOXQJVGLUHNWLYHQIKUHQ]XN|Q QHQXQGDQGHUHUVHLWV]XNRQNUHWXPPLW$XVQDKPHVLWXDWLRQHQXPJHKHQ]XN|QQHQ GDPLW N|QQHQ XQG PVVHQ VLH VHOEVW NRQNUHWLVLHUW DEJHZRJHQ EHJUQGHW XQGJHJH EHQHQIDOOV]XUFNJHZLHVHQZHUGHQ6HLQH3ULQ]LSLHQVLQG Å'RQRKDUP'RQRW LQWHUIHUHZLWKIUHHGRP'RQRWEHXQMXVW>«@(DFKSULPDU\SULQFLSOHKDVDÄGXDO¶ SULQFLSOHZKLFKLQDPRUHFRQVHTXHQWLDOLVWPDQQHUDGYRFDWHVEULQJLQJLQWRWKHZRUOG PRUHZHOIDUHIUHHGRPDQGMXVWLFH 3URPRWHJRRG(QKDQFHIUHHGRP3URPR WHMXVWLFH´ 'H0DUFR
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6WDQGSXQNWHP|JOLFKHU=XUFNZHLVXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ
DVNHGWRWDNHWKHUHOHYDQWLQWHUHVWVLQWRDFFRXQW :KHQLQWKHOLJKWRIRXU EHVWXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKLVPRUDOUDWLRQDOHZHPDNHDMXGJPHQWDERXWWKH VXIILFLHQF\RIWKHUHDVRQVIRUDQDFWLRQLQDSDUWLFXODUFDVHWKLVMXGJPHQW LVJXLGHGE\DQGH[SUHVVHVRXUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIDPRUDOSULQFLSOHµ
6WDQGSXQNWHP|JOLFKHU=XUFNZHLVXQJYRQ +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ
%HLGHU6XFKHQDFK3ULQ]LSLHQGLHQLHPDQGYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH]XUFNZHL VHQ NDQQ E]Z NRQNUHW GHP +DQGOXQJVJUXQG S GHU VROFKHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ HQWVSULFKW ZLUG JHIRUGHUW 6WDQGSXQNWH HLQHU P|JOLFKHQ =XUFNZHLVXQJ LQGLHhEHUOHJXQJHQHLQ]XEH]LHKHQGLH]XU=XZHLVXQJE]Z$QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW IKUHQN|QQHQ 'LH *OWLJNHLW GHU 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ GD GHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQG S DOVR QLFKW QXU DXIJUXQG VHLQHU IDNWLVFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQDXIGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWTIHVWOHJW 2 SȺT KlQJWYRQGLHVHU9HUQQIWLJNHLWYRQSDE(UVWGDPLWJLOW HLQ SUlYDOHQWHU RGHU GRPLQLHUHQGHU +DQGOXQJVJUXQG S EHVLW]W $QVSUXFK DXI *OWLJNHLW XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU IDNWLVFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK GLH KDQ GHOQGH3HUVRQ :HQQQXQGLH$EOHLWXQJGHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQG OXQJVDEVLFKWDXVGHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHGHVKDOEP|JOLFK VHLQ VROO ZHLO GLH *UQGH VROFKH VLQG GLH 3ULQ]LSLHQ HQWVSUHFKHQ GLH QLHPDQG G K DXFK QLFKW GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH ]X UFNZHLVHQNDQQVRZLUGPDQGDGXUFKWKHRUHWLVFK]XUFNJHIKUW]XHLQHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU )HVWOHJXQJ GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ 0LW DQGHUHQ :RUWHQ SUlYDOHQWH *UQGH JHOWHQ XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ QXU GDQQ ZHQQ VLH YRQ GLHVHU 3HUVRQ XQG DQGHUHQ3HUVRQHQGLHYRQGHUIUDJOLFKHQ+DQGOXQJEHWURIIHQVLQGDQHU NDQQWZHUGHQN|QQHQGKDQHUNHQQXQJVZUGLJVLQG 'DV0HVVHQHLQHV+DQGOXQJVJUXQGVDQGHUP|JOLFKHQ=XUFNZHLVXQJ GXUFK GLH EHWURIIHQHQ 3HUVRQHQ LVW LQVRIHUQ HLQ .RQVWLWXHQV SUlYDOHQWHU *UQGH DOV RKQH HLQH VROFKH (LQEH]LHKXQJ GLH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV VFKOLFKW DXIK|UW ]X H[LVWLHUHQ 'DV =XZHLVHQ GHU )HVWOHJXQJ OlXIW RKQH GHUHQ P|JOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJ OHHU GDV 6SLHO GHV )RUGHUQV XQG /LHIHUQV YRQ *UQGHQ GHJHQHULHUW JHQDX GDGXUFK ]XP EORHQ 6SLHO GHU 0DFKW ZHOFKHV *UQGH LQVJHVDPW EHUIOVVLJ PDFKW E]Z HQWZHUWHW :LUG GDV
_____________ 6FDQORQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQLPSUDNWLVFKHQ.RQWH[WPLW GHP=LHOJHVSLHOWSUlYDOHQWH*UQGH]XILQGHQDOVRVROFKHGHUHQ*OWLJ NHLW GLH )HVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWXQJ HLQHU ,QIHUHQ] GDGXUFK JDUDQWLHUW GD GLH XQLYHUVHOOH $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH ]ZDU QLFKW QRWZHQGLJ RGHU JDU ZLUNOLFK DEHU GRFK YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH P|JOLFK LVW VR EHGHXWHW GLHV GD GLH =XZHLVXQJ GHU )HVWOHJXQJ LKUHUVHLWV JHJHQEHU GHU KDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQDOVEHUHFKWLJWDXVJHZLHVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQPX8QGGLHVZLHGHU XPKHLWGDGHU6WDQGSXQNWGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQLKUHP|JOLFKH$Q HUNHQQXQJ GLHVHU )HVWOHJXQJ RGHU GHUHQ EHJUQGHWH =XUFNZHLVXQJ EHUFNVLFKWLJWZHUGHQPX'LHKLHUWKHPDWLVLHUWHSUDNWLVFKH9HUQQIWLJ NHLW OlW VLFK GDPLW DXFK IROJHQGHUPDHQ EHVWLPPHQ GHU 0|JOLFKNHLW GHU $QHUNHQQXQJDXIVHLWHQGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQNRUUHVSRQGLHUWHLQH1RWZHQGLJNHLWGHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHLQHU=XZHLVXQJGHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ)HVWOHJXQJDXIVHLWHQGHUEHXUWHLOHQ GHQ 3HUVRQ ZHQQGLHVH ]XJHZLHVHQH )HVWOHJXQJ HLQIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHU RGHUSUlYDOHQWHU+DQGOXQJVJUXQGVHLQVROO 'DUDXVIROJWZRKOJHPHUNWQLFKWGDGLH=XZHLVXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJ QXUGDQQEHUHFKWLJWLVWZHQQVLHYRQGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQDXFKWDWVlFK OLFK DQHUNDQQW ZLUG VRQVW N|QQWH HV EHLVSLHOVZHLVH NHLQH EHUHFKWLJWHQ 9RUZUIH SRVW IHVWXP JHEHQ GHU 6DW] ÅGX KlWWHVW DEHU DQGHUV KDQGHOQ VROOHQ´ZUGHVR]XVDJHQQRUPDWLYOHHUODXIHQ 'RFKDOOHLQGLHVH%HUFN VLFKWLJXQJ GHU 6WDQGSXQNWH P|JOLFKHU =XUFNZHLVXQJ NDQQ ]X GHU %H UHFKWLJXQJ IKUHQ GLH GLH EHXUWHLOHQGH 3HUVRQ YRUZHLVHQ N|QQHQ PX XP GHU KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQ HLQH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW]X]XZHLVHQGLHGLHVH P|JOLFKHUZHLVH QLFKWDQHUNDQQW KDW YRQ GLHVHU%HUFNVLFKWLJXQJ KlQJW GLH/HJLWLPLWlW GHU =XZHLVXQJ GHU IUDJOLFKHQ)HVWOHJXQJDE3UREOHPDWLVFKGDEHLLVWVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKQRFK GLH$XWRULWlWGHUEHXUWHLOHQGHQ3HUVRQE]Z3HUVRQHQ *UQGHVLQGQXUGDQQEHUKDXSW*UQGHZHQQHQWZHGHUGLHZLUNOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJ RGHU DEHU GLH P|JOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ JHZlKUOHLVWHW LVW *LOW GLH (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ VR EHGDUI HV GHU ZLUNOLFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ JLOW GLH *UQGH E]Z GLH 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ VR EHGDUIHVGHUP|JOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJ ]XHLQHP.RQIOLNWNDQQHVMHGRFK QXUNRPPHQZHQQGLH6ROOHQ5HODWLRQJHOWHQVROOGHQQQXUKLHUOLHJWLP *HJHQVDW]]XU*UQGH5HODWLRQHLQHIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]YRU 1XQ LVW GDV ,GHDO HLQHU P|JOLFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK GHUHQ ZLUNOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJ G K XQWHU YROO VWlQGLJ YHUQQIWLJHQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHQ WUDQVIRUPLHUHQ DOOH %HWURIIHQHQ DOV KDQGHOQGH XQG EHXUWHLOHQGH 3HUVRQHQ GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ 6ROOHQ 5HODWLRQHQLQ(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQHQ'RFKNDQQXQGPXYRQGLHVHP
_____________ .DQWVQRPLQHOOHLQJHIKUWH:HVHQPLWHLQHPÅKHLOLJHQ:LOOHQ´ .DQW9 HQWVSUl FKHQGLHVHP,GHDO,QGHP6LQQLQGHP%URRPHQRUPDWLYH(UIRUGHUQLVVHYRQ6ROOHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6WDQGSXQNWHP|JOLFKHU=XUFNZHLVXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ
,GHDOHEHQQLFKWDXVJHJDQJHQZHUGHQYLHOPHKUWUlJWJHUDGHGLH5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVSUD[LV GLH HUIRUGHUOLFKH $XVIDOOEUJVFKDIW XQG ZLUG GDPLW ]X HLQHP .RQVWLWXHQVGHU0RUDO GLH*OWLJNHLWSUlYDOHQWHU*UQGHJUQGHWVLFKDXI HLQHP|JOLFKH$QHUNHQQXQJGHU%HWURIIHQHQLKUH*HOWXQJKlQJWVFKOLH OLFKYRQGHUWDWVlFKOLFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKGLHVH3HUVRQHQDE 'LH=XZHLVXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJRKQHGLHVHYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVHP|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lYDOHQWHQ*UQGHDXVZHLVHQ]XN|QQHQ2GHUDQVFKDXOL FKHULQHLQHP%HLVSLHOIRUPXOLHUW (YHQWXHOOH*UQGHIUHLQH7|WXQJ ]% HLQHVEHZDIIQHWHQ$QJUHLIHUV PVVHQLP.RQIOLNWIDOOEHUFNVLFKWLJWZHU GHQ XP *UQGH JHJHQ GLHVH LQ )UDJH VWHKHQGH 7|WXQJDOV SUlYDOHQW DXV ZHLVHQ ]X N|QQHQ 6FDQORQ VWUHLFKW DQKDQG JOHLFKJHODJHUWHU )lOOH HLQHQ ZLFKWLJHQ $VSHNW GHU %HGHXWXQJ GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV IU GLH )LQ GXQJ GRPLQLHUHQGHU *UQGH KHUDXV Å>«@ QRW HYHU\ DFWLRQ WKDW FDQ EH IRUHVHHQWROHDGWRVRPHRQH·VGHDWKRUWKDWFDXVHVSDLQHYHQWRDEDE\LV ZURQJ6XFKDFWLRQVPD\RUPD\QRWEHZURQJGHSHQGLQJRQZKDWMXVWLIL FDWLRQWKHUHPD\EHIRUWKHP>«@0RUHRYHULQDVVHVVLQJVXFKMXVWLILFD WLRQVZHDUHQRW>«@PHUHO\EDODQFLQJWKHGLVYDOXHRIKDYLQJVRPHRQHGLH RUKDYLQJSDLQRFFXUDJDLQVWWKHYDOXHRIKDYLQJ>«@RWKHUWKLQJVKDSSHQ 5DWKHUZHDUHDVNLQJZKHWKHUWKHUHDVRQVIRUWKHVHRWKHUWKLQJVSURYLGH DQDGHTXDWHUHVSRQVHWRWKHUHDVRQVWKDWWKHYLFWLPVWKHPVHOYHVKDYHIRUZDQW LQJ WR OLYH ORQJHU RU WR QRW EH LQ SDLQ 7KDW LV WR VD\ ZH DUH DVNLQJ
_____________ 5HODWLRQHQ XQWHUVFKHLGHW VSULFKW .DQW PLW EH]XJ DXI GLHVH :HVHQ GDYRQ GD ÅGDV 6ROOHQ>@KLHUDPXQUHFKWHQ2UWH´ .DQW,9 VHL YJOGD]XREHQ 1LFKWPLW%OLFNDXI+DQGOXQJVJUQGHLPDOOJHPHLQHQXQGNRQNUHWH+DQGOXQJVJUQ GHGLHQLFKWYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH]XUFNJHZLHVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQLPEHVRQGHUHQVRQ GHUQ PLW %OLFN DXI 1RUPHQ GLH LQ HWZD GHP HQWVSUHFKHQ ZDV KLHU PLW 6FDQORQ DOV 3ULQ]LSLHQEH]HLFKQHWZXUGHVSULFKW+DEHUPDVDQDORJYRQ*HOWXQJ Å(VLVWGHU)DOO GDTJHERWHQLVW´ XQG*OWLJNHLW Å(VLVWJHERWHQGDT´ Å'DHLQH1RUPLGHDOL WHU JLOW EHGHXWHW VLH YHUGLHQW GLH =XVWLPPXQJ DOOHU %HWURIIHQHQ ZHLO VLH +DQGOXQJV SUREOHPHLQGHUHQJHPHLQVDPHP,QWHUHVVHUHJHOW'DHLQH1RUPIDNWLVFKEHVWHKWEH GHXWHW KLQJHJHQ GHU *HOWXQJVDQVSUXFK PLW GHP VLH DXIWULWW ZLUG YRQ GHQ %HWURIIHQHQ DQHUNDQQW XQG GLHVH LQWHUVXEMHNWLYH $QHUNHQQXQJ EHJUQGHW GLH VR]LDOH *HOWXQJ GHU 1RUP´ +DEHUPDV , I YJO 9JO ]XU GDPLW YHU ZDQGWHQ UHFKWVUHOHYDQWHQ 'LIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQ /HJDOLWlW XQG /HJLWLPLWlW +DEHUPDV· 7DQQHU/HFWXUHV Å5HFKWXQG0RUDO´LQ+DEHUPDV LQVEHV
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
ZKHWKHUWKHVHFRXQWHUYDLOLQJFRQVLGHUDWLRQVVXIILFHWRMXVWLI\WKHDFWLRQVWR WKHPµ 'LH(LQEH]LHKXQJDQGHUHU6WDQGSXQNWHLVWGHPJHPlHLQHQRWZHQGL JH %HGLQJXQJ GHU /HJLWLPDWLRQ SUlYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH 6LH LVW GLH QRWZHQGLJH%HGLQJXQJIUGLH%HUHFKWLJXQJHLQHU=XZHLVXQJHLQHU)HVW OHJXQJIDOOVOHW]WHUHXQDEKlQJLJYRQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGLHVHU)HVWOHJXQJ GXUFKGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQ*OWLJNHLWEHVLW]HQVROOGKIDOOVGHU6FKOX YRQ GHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ DXI GLH +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW QLFKW JHPl GHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ RGHU GHU *UQGH5HODWLRQ VRQ GHUQJHPlGHU6ROOHQ5HODWLRQJHOWHQVROO :DV NHQQ]HLFKQHW QXQ GHUDUWLJH 6WDQGSXQNWH" *HQHUHOO JLOW YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ GD VLH LQ HLQHU EHVWLPPWHQ +LQVLFKW |IIHQWOLFK VLQG 6HOEVW GLH (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ 2 S Ⱥ T JLOW ² EHL MHZHLOV VXEMHNWLYHU $QHUNHQQXQJYRQS²IUDOOH3HUVRQHQDXIGLHGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGH6LWXDWL RQVEHVFKUHLEXQJ]XWULIIW DIRUWLRULLVWGLHVEHLEHUHFKWLJXQJVRGHUIHVWOH JXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ,QIHUHQ]HQGHU)DOOLQZHOFKHQGLH.RQNOXVLRQPLWWHOV PRGXV SRQHQV DEWUHQQEDU LVW )U GLH (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ JLOW :HQQ HLQH 3HUVRQ ]X GHU hEHU]HXJXQJ JHODQJW GD EHVWLPPWH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GLHHLQHVSH]LILVFKH6LWXDWLRQEHWUHIIHQLQVJHVDPWHLQHEHVWLPPWH+DQG OXQJ E]Z HLQ 6XEVWLWXWLRQVlTXLYDOHQW HLQHV EHVWLPPWHQ +DQGOXQJVW\SV HUIRUGHUQ GDQQ JHKW GLHVH 3HUVRQ LPSOL]LW GDYRQ DXV GD MHGH DQGHUH 3HUVRQGLHLQGHPVHOEHQ9HUKlOWQLV]XGLHVHUVSH]LILVFKHQ6LWXDWLRQVWHKW GHPVHOEHQ (UIRUGHUQLV XQWHUOLHJW 6FDQORQ ZHLVW LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQ KDQJ GDUDXI KLQ GD GLHVH )RUP YRQ gIIHQWOLFKNHLW RGHU $OOJHPHLQKHLW *UQGHQDOVVROFKHQLQQHZRKQWÅ>«@VLQFHDQ\MXGJPHQWDERXWRXURZQ UHDVRQVHQWDLOVFODLPVDERXWWKHUHDVRQVWKDWRWKHUVKDYHRUZRXOGKDYHLQ FHUWDLQ FLUFXPVWDQFHV´ 2GHU QRFKPDOV LQ GHU KLHU YRUJHVFKODJHQHQ
_____________ 6FDQORQ 6FDQORQ YJOGD]XEHUHLWV.DPEDUWHO Å0LWGHP$QVSUXFKEHJUQGH WHUSUDNWLVFKHUXQGWKHRUHWLVFKHU2ULHQWLHUXQJHQGDVVROOKHLHQ EHJUQGHWHUGDVMH ZHLOLJH6LWXDWLRQVYHUVWlQGQLVOHLWHQGHU,QWHUHVVHQXQG)HVWVWHOOXQJHQYHUODVVHQZLU>@ GLH 6SKlUH SULYDWHU RGHU JUXSSHQUHODWLYHU 0HLQXQJHQ XQG =LHOVHW]XQJHQ LQ 5LFKWXQJ DXI HLQH QLFKWPDQLSXOLHUWH 9HUVWlQGLJXQJ GHU %HWURIIHQHQ NXU] HLQH WUDQVVXEMHNWLYH 2ULHQWLHUXQJ´ 9JO ]X HLQHU NDQWLDQLVFKHQ ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ GHU 7UDQVVXEMHNWLYLWlW DOV Å)UHLKHLWYRQVLFKVHOEVW´DXFK.DPEDUWHO +LQWHU.DPEDUWHOV9HUZHQ GXQJGHV%HJULIIVGHU7UDQVVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWHKW/RUHQ]HQVHQWVSUHFKHQGH%HVWLPPXQJ Å>«@ÄWUDQVVXEMHFWLYLW\¶>«@LVVWLOOVXEMHFWLYLW\EXWDVXEMHFWLYLW\ZKLFKLVDZDUHRILWV RZQOLPLWV²DQGWULHVWRRYHUFRPHWKHP7UDQVVXEMHFWLYLW\LVQRWDIDFWEXWLWLVQRWD SRVWXODWHHLWKHU7UDQVVXEMHFWLYLW\LVVLPSO\DWHUPFKDUDFWHUL]LQJWKDWDFWLYLW\LQZKLFKZH DUHDOZD\VDOUHDG\LQYROYHGLIZHEHJLQWRUHDVRQDWDOO´ /RUHQ]HQ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 9JO/RUHQ]HQHEG]XPH[SOL]LWHQ$QVFKOXGLHVHV3ULQ]LSVDQ.DQWVNDWHJRUL VFKHQ ,PSHUDWLY $XV /RUHQ]HQV 3ULQ]LS GHU 7UDQVVXEMHNWLYLWlW IROJW MHGRFK QLFKW XQGLVWDXFKQLFKWPLWLKPLGHQWLVFK GDVÅ3ULQ]LSGHU7UDQVVXEMHNWLYLWlW´RGHUÅ9HU
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
6WDQGSXQNWHP|JOLFKHU=XUFNZHLVXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ
$GDSWDWLRQ YRQ %URRPHV 9RNDEXODU GLH $OOJHPHLQKHLW GLH *UQGHQ DOV VROFKHQLQKlULHUWJLOWQLFKWQXUYRQ3UlPLVVHQGHU*UQGHRGHU6ROOHQ 5HODWLRQHQVRQGHUQDXFKYRQ3UlPLVVHQLQ(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQHQLQVR IHUQ KLHU GDV 9HUKlOWQLV GHU 3HUVRQ ]X GHU VSH]LILVFKHQ 6LWXDWLRQ RGHU GHRQWLVFKIRUPXOLHUWLKUH$QHUNHQQXQJGHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHYRUDXVJH VHW]WZLUG 6FDQORQ KDW DXI HQWVSUHFKHQGH (LQZlQGH *DXWKLHUV KLQ VHLQH .RQ ]HSWLRQGHUÅXQLYHUVDOLW\RIUHDVRQMXGJPHQWV´ZHLWHUSUl]LVLHUWZREHLHU VHLQH .RQ]HSWLRQ VFKOLHOLFK IROJHQGHUPDHQ UHVPLHUW Å>«@ WKH FODLP WKDW;LVDUHDVRQIRURQHSHUVRQWRGR$HQWDLOVWKHFODLPWKDWLWLVDOVRD UHDVRQ IRU DQ\RQH HOVH ZKRVH FLUFXPVWDQFHV DUH VLPLODU LQ UHOHYDQW UH VSHFWV >«@ 7KH XQLYHUVDOLW\ RI UHDVRQV MXGJPHQWV VHHPV WR PH ZRUWK QRWLQJGHVSLWHLWVWDXWRORJRXVFKDUDFWHUEHFDXVHLWLPSRVHVDXVHIXOGLVFL SOLQHRQRXUFODLPVDERXWUHDVRQV7KHUHLVDWHQGHQF\,WKLQNWRJUDQW WKDW RWKHUV PD\QRW KDYH WKH UHDVRQV ZH WDNH RXUVHOYHV WR KDYH ZLWKRXW FRQVLGHULQJZKDWWKLVLPSOLHVDERXWWKHQDWXUHRIRXURZQUHDVRQV7DNLQJ DFFRXQW RI WKH XQLYHUVDOLW\RI UHDVRQ MXGJPHQWVIRUFHV XVWRPDNH WKHVH FRQVHTXHQFHVH[SOLFLWDQGWKXVWRFODULI\WKHFODLPVZHDUHPDNLQJ´ 'LH DXINOlUHULVFKH)XQNWLRQYRQ6FDQORQVÅXQLYHUVDOLW\RIUHDVRQMXGJPHQWV´ 'RNWULQEHVWHKWLQ)ROJHQGHP Å>«@LIZHFODLPWKDW;LVDUHDVRQIRURQH RIWKHVHSHRSOHWRGR$EXWQRWIRUWKHRWKHUWKHQZHDUHFRPPLWWHGWR WKH FODLP WKDW WKHUH LV VRPH UHOHYDQW GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ WKHLUVLWXDWLRQV >«:HDUHIRUFHG@WRLGHQWLI\RXUGLVDJUHHPHQWDVDVXEVWDQWLYHGLVDJUHH PHQWDERXWZKLFKFRQVLGHUDWLRQVDUHUHOHYDQWWRWKHUHDVRQVDSHUVRQKDV ²LQSDUWLFXODUDERXWZKHWKHUWKHZD\DFRQVLGHUDWLRQÄVWULNHV¶DQDJHQWLV RULVQRWDUHOHYDQWFRQVLGHUDWLRQLQDVLWXDWLRQRIWKHNLQGLQTXHVWLRQµ
_____________ QXQIWSULQ]LS´ GDV 6FKZHPPHU IU VSH]LILVFK SUDNWLVFKH 'LVNXUVH DXIJHVWHOOW KDW Å'DV9HUQXQIWSULQ]LSN|QQHQZLUVROHVHQDOVGLH)RUGHUXQJNHLQHEORVXEMHNWLYHQ EOR IDNWLVFKHQ 0HLQXQJHQ RGHU =ZHFNVHW]XQJHQ ]X KDEHQ´ 6FKZHPPHU 'LHVLVWNHLQHVLQQYROOH)RUGHUXQJIU0HQVFKHQ GLHVLQQYROOH)RUGHUXQJODXWHW YLHOPHKUJHPl/RUHQ]HQV3ULQ]LSHLQHQ/HJLWLPDWLRQVRUWMHQVHLWVGHUIDNWLVFKHQXQG LUUHGX]LEHO VXEMHNWLYHQ =ZHFNVHW]XQJHQ ]X ILQGHQ 9JO GD]X DXFK -DQLFKV $EJUHQ ]XQJGHV%HJULIIVGHU7UDQVVXEMHNWLYLWlWYRP%HJULIIGHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW ZlKUHQG VLFKLQWHUVXEMHNWLYH*HOWXQJDXIGLHÅ]ZLVFKHQ6XEMHNWHQIDNWLVFKHhEHUHLQVWLPPXQJ´ EH]LHKWVROOPLWGHU7UDQVVXEMHNWLYLWlWÅGDVhEHUVFKUHLWHQGHU6XEMHNWLYLWlWDOVSULQ]L SLHOOHU *HOWXQJVDQVSUXFK ]XP $XVGUXFN JHEUDFKW ZHUGHQ 'LH *HOWXQJ HLQHV 6DW]HV WUDQVVXEMHNWLY ]X QHQQHQ KHLW DOVR VHLQH =XVWLPPXQJVIlKLJNHLW SULQ]LSLHOO IU MHGH 3HUVRQ ]X EHDQVSUXFKHQ XQG GDIU SULQ]LSLHOO IU MHGH 3HUVRQ QDFKYROO]LHKEDUH %H JUQGXQJHQYRU]XOHJHQ´ -DQLFKI 9JO]XP%HJULIIGHUWUDQVVXEMHNWLYHQ*HO WXQJDXFK+DEHUPDVXQGGHVVHQ5HNXUVDXI(PLO/DVNV6\VWHPGHU/RJLNLQ+DEHUPDV 6FDQORQ YJOGD]X*DXWKLHU 6FDQORQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
'D KDQGHOQGHQ 3HUVRQHQ LKUH )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXI EHVWLPPWH hEHU]HX JXQJHQRGHU3UR(LQVWHOOXQJHQQLFKWVWHWVEHZXWVLQGLQVRIHUQPDWHULDO JOWLJH ,QIHUHQ]HQ GLH XQVHUH DOOWlJOLFKH $UJXPHQWDWLRQVSUD[LV EHKHUU VFKHQ QRUPDOHUZHLVH HLQH JDQ]H $Q]DKO YRQ ZHLWHUHQ NRQVHTXHQWLHOOHQ RGHU.ROODWHUDOIHVWOHJXQJHQLPSOL]LHUHQGLHLQGHU$UJXPHQWDWLRQVSUD[LV HUVW H[SOL]LW JHPDFKW XQG GDPLW RIIHQJHOHJW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ LVW HV LQ HL QHPSUDNWLVFKHQ DEHUDXFKEHUHLWVLQHLQHPHSLVWHPLVFKHQ .RQWH[WYRQ %HGHXWXQJ GLH 6WDQGSXQNWH $QGHUHU ]X EHUFNVLFKWLJHQ 'HQQ GLHVH 6WDQGSXQNWHN|QQWHQ7HLOEHVFKUHLEXQJHQGHVHLJHQHQ6WDQGSXQNWVLPSOL ]LHUHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQDOVRDXIGLHPDQVLFKVHOEVWEHZXWRGHUXQEHZXW IHVWJHOHJWKDWGKGHUHQ)HVWOHJXQJPDQHQWZHGHUEHUHLWVDQHUNDQQWKDW RGHU HEHQ QRFK QLFKW RKQH MHGHQIDOOV VLFK GDUEHU LP NODUHQ ]X VHLQ ZRUDXIPDQVLFKGDPLWDXHUGHPIHVWJHOHJWKDW6FDQORQUHVPLHUWGDKHU IUGHQSUDNWLVFKHQ.RQWH[WXQGGLHSULQ]LSLHOOHgIIHQWOLFKNHLWYRQ+DQG OXQJVJUQGHQ Å7KH XQLYHUVDOLW\ RI UHDVRQ MXGJPHQWV LV D IRUPDO FRQVH TXHQFHRIWKHIDFWWKDWWDNLQJVRPHWKLQJWREHDUHDVRQIRUDFWLQJLVQRWD PHUH SURDWWLWXGH WRZDUG VRPH DFWLRQ EXW UDWKHU D MXGJPHQW WKDW WDNHV FHUWDLQ FRQVLGHUDWLRQV DV VXIILFLHQW JURXQGV IRU LWV FRQFOXVLRQ >«@ :H WKXV KDYH ZKROO\ VHOIUHJDUGLQJ UHDVRQV IRU KDYLQJ YLHZV DERXW WKH FRU UHFWQHVVRULQFRUUHFWQHVVRIWKHMXGJPHQWVSHRSOHPDNHDERXWWKHUHDVRQV WKH\KDYHVLQFHWKHVHMXGJPHQWVLPSO\FRQFOXVLRQVDERXWWKHUHDVRQVZH KDYHµ 'LHVH UHDOH $UJXPHQWDWLRQVSUD[LV EHVFKUHLEHQG IlKUW 6FDQORQ VFKOLHOLFKIRUW Å6RVLWXDWLRQVFDQDULVHLQZKLFKLIWKHLU>VFRWKHUSHR SOH·V@MXGJPHQWVDERXWWKHLUUHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQDUHFRUUHFWRXUMXGJPHQWV DERXWRXURZQUHDVRQVPXVWEHPLVWDNHQ,QRUGHUIRUVXFKFRQIOLFWVWREH UHDO ERWK SDUWLHV PXVW EH PDNLQJ MXGJPHQWV DERXW WKH VDPH WKLQJ IRU H[DPSOHDERXWZKHWKHUFHUWDLQFRQVLGHUDWLRQVGRLQIDFWFRXQWLQIDYRURI D JLYHQ DWWLWXGHIRU D SHUVRQ LQ D FHUWDLQ VLWXDWLRQ7KLV PHDQV WKDW WKH\ PXVWEHWDONLQJDERXWWKHVDPHDWWLWXGHDQGWKDWWKH\PXVWEHHPSOR\LQJ VLPLODU VHWV RI HYDOXDWLYH FDWHJRULHVµ $XI 6FDQORQV $QVLFKW GD GDV (LQ]HOXUWHLOVHOEVWXQGQLFKWZLHKLHUYHUWUHWHQGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV LQVJHVDPWGLH,QVWDQ]LVWYRUGHUGLH*OWLJNHLWSUlYDOHQWHU*UQGHVWDQG KDOWHQ PX ZHUGH LFK QRFK HLQJHKHQ ,FK EHWUDFKWH GLHVH 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVSUD[LV GHQ 2UW DOVR DQ GHP LPSOL]LWH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ H[SOL]LW JH
_____________ 9JO]XGLHVHU%HJULIIOLFKNHLW%UDQGRPD Å/HJWPDQVLFK DXIGLH%HKDXS WXQJ IHVW GD 3LWWVEXUJK ZHVWOLFK YRQ 3KLODGHOSKLD OLHJW VR LVW GDV HLQH :HLVH GLH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GLH %HKDXSWXQJ HLQ]XJHKHQ GD 3KLODGHOSKLD |VWOLFK YRQ 3LWWVEXUJK OLHJW'LHVHNRQVHTXHQWLHOOHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQZHUGHQQLFKWXQEHGLQJWDQHUNDQQW ZLUDQHU NHQQHQQLFKWLPPHUHLQH)HVWOHJXQJDXI DOOH)ROJHQGHU)HVWOHJXQJHQGLHZLU DQHU NHQQHQ1LFKWVGHVWRWURW]VLQGDXFKVLH)HVWOHJXQJHQ´ 6FDQORQ +HUYRUKHEXQJHQ .3 6FDQORQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
$OOJHPHLQH*UQGH
PDFKW ZHUGHQ DOV GLH 4XHOOH GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW SUlYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJV JUQGH PHLQHQWVSUHFKHQGHVSULQ]LSLHOOHV9HUWUDXHQLQGLH9HUQQIWLJNHLW GHUDQGHUHQ7HLOQHKPHUDP6SLHOGHV9HUODQJHQVXQG*HEHQVYRQ*UQ GHQVRZLHGDVGLHVHP9HUWUDXHQNRUUHVSRQGLHUHQGHSULQ]LSLHOOH0LWUDXHQ JHJHQEHUGHUHLJHQHQ8QIHKOEDUNHLWLP8UWHLOVWHKWGDPLWHLQHU2EMHNWL YLWlW YRQ JOWLJHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ DQ GHQHQ XQVHU ,QWHOOHNW JHZLVVHUPDHQ WHLOKDEHQ NDQQ JHJHQEHU 'RFK XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHP WKHRUHWLVFKHQ :HUWGHQPDQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVDOVVROFKHUEHLPLWLVWGLHKLHU DQJHVSURFKHQH SULQ]LSLHOOH gIIHQWOLFKNHLW YRQ *UQGHQ JOHLFKEHGHXWHQG PLW GHU P|JOLFKHQ hEHUHLQVWLPPXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ RGHU $EOHKQXQJ YRQ DQGHUHQ 6WDQGSXQNWHQGK$UWLNXODWLRQHQSHUV|QOLFKHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
$OOJHPHLQH*UQGH
8PGLH$UWGLHVHULQGLHSUDNWLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJHLQ]XEH]LHKHQGHQ6WDQG SXQNWHQlKHU]XEH]HLFKQHQIKUW6FDQORQGHQ%HJULIIGHUÅJHQHULFUHD VRQV´ HLQ %HUHLWV DXV GHU DOOJHPHLQHQ +DQGOXQJVVWUXNWXU GHU (LJHQDUW YRQ+DQGOXQJHQGDVLH(IIHNWHEHVLW]HQN|QQHQGLHQLFKWQXUGLHKDQ GHOQGH 3HUVRQ XQG DXFK QLFKW QXU GLH KDQGHOQGH XQG GLH EHXUWHLOHQGH 3HUVRQ JHPHLQVDP EHWUHIIHQ VRQGHUQ P|JOLFKHUZHLVH 'ULWWH EHUKUHQ IROJW GD EHL GHU )UDJH QDFK 3ULQ]LSLHQ GLH QLFKW YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH ]X UFNJHZLHVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQDXFKGLHVH6WDQGSXQNWHHLQEH]RJHQZHUGHQ PVVHQ 'XUFK GLH +DQGOXQJVRULHQWLHUXQJ DQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ VFKOLHOLFK GLH DOV 0DVWDE NRQNUHWHU VLWXDWLRQVDEKlQJLJHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH JHOWHQ VRO OHQLVWGHU+RUL]RQWYRQGHUVSH]LILVFKHQ+DQGOXQJKLQDXIHLQHDOOJHPHL QH 8Q 5HFKWPlLJNHLW GHUDUWLJHU +DQGOXQJHQ LQNOXVLYH GHUHQ .RQVH TXHQ]HQHUZHLWHUW :LHLPOHW]WHQ$EVFKQLWWEHUHLWVEHWRQWZXUGHXQWHUVFKHLGHQVLFK8U WHLOH GLH GLH 5LFKWLJNHLW RGHU )DOVFKKHLW HLQHU +DQGOXQJ EHWUHIIHQ ZH VHQWOLFK YRQ YLHOHQ DQGHUHQ 8UWHLOHQ GLH HEHQIDOOV HYDOXDWLYHQ &KDUDNWHU KDEHQ ,P *HJHQVDW] ]X 8UWHLOHQ GLH GLH 5LFKWLJNHLW HLQHU +DQGOXQJ EHWUHIIHQ YHUODQJHQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH 8UWHLOH GLH GLH *HOXQJHQKHLW HLQHV
_____________ 6FDQORQ ² )U NOlUHQGH 'LVNXVVLRQHQ ]X GLHVHP .RQ]HSW GHU ÅJHQHULF UHDVRQV´GDQNHLFK1DGHHP+XVVDLQ )RUVWIKUWPLW%OLFNDXIGLHDOOJHPHLQH*OWLJNHLWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQLQ6FDQORQV 6LQQHDXV Å6RNRQNUHWGLHMHZHLOLJH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVVLWXDWLRQDXFKLVWVRPVVHQGRFK GLH *UQGH GLH KLHU UHFKWIHUWLJHQG VLQG VROFKH VHLQ GLH IU HLQHQ MHGHQ 0HQVFKHQ YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVHDN]HSWDEHOZlUHQ+LHU]HLJWVLFKGLH9HUELQGXQJYRQ9HUQXQIWXQG 0RUDO 5HFKWIHUWLJHQGH *UQGH PVVHQ SULQ]LSLHOO HLQHU MHGHQ YHUQQIWLJHQ 3HUVRQ ]XJlQJOLFKXQGIUVLHHLQVLFKWLJVHLQ´ )RUVW E
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
.XQVWZHUNVRGHUDXFKHLQHV:LW]HVEHWUHIIHQQLFKWXQEHGLQJWQDFKHLQHU %HJUQGXQJ'RFKGHU6FKULWWEHUGLHEORH)HVWVWHOOXQJGHU5LFKWLJNHLW HLQHU +DQGOXQJ KLQDXV ]X HLQHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ %HJUQGXQJ LVW TXD %H JUQGXQJEHUHLWVHLQ6FKULWWLQ5LFKWXQJDXIGDKLQWHUVWHKHQGH3ULQ]LSLHQ 'LH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GLH VR]XVDJHQ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU 6LWXDWLRQVEHVFKUHL EXQJ XQG GHQ IUDJOLFKHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ VWHKHQ XQG YHUPLWWHOQ LQGHP VLH HL QHQ 6LWXDWLRQVLQGH[ WUDJHQ ]XJOHLFK DEHU EHU GLH YRUOLHJHQGH VLQJXOlUH 6LWXDWLRQ KLQDXVZHLVHQ FKDUDNWHULVLHUW 6FDQORQ DOV ÅJHQHULF UHDVRQV´ 6LH VLQGGXUFKDOOJHPHLQ]XJlQJOLFKH,QIRUPDWLRQHQJHNHQQ]HLFKQHWGLH3HU VRQHQ P|JOLFKHUZHLVH EHVLW]HQ XP GDV IUDJOLFKH 3ULQ]LS ]X DN]HSWLHUHQ RGHU ]XUFN]XZHLVHQ Å*HQHULF UHDVRQV DUH UHDVRQV WKDW ZH FDQ VHH WKDW SHRSOHKDYHLQYLUWXHRIWKHLUVLWXDWLRQFKDUDFWHUL]HGLQJHQHUDOWHUPVDQG VXFKWKLQJVDVWKHLUDLPVDQGFDSDELOLWLHVDQGWKHFRQGLWLRQVLQZKLFKWKH\ DUH SODFHG´ 'HU )LQGXQJVSUR]H GHUDUWLJHU *UQGH NDQQ QLFKW YRUDE GHWHUPLQLHUWZHUGHQ GLH4XHOOHGHU*OWLJNHLWHQWVSUHFKHQGHU3ULQ]LSLHQ EHVWHKWQLFKWLQVLQJXOlUHQ8UWHLOHQ6WDWWGHVVHQZLUGHLQ$EZlJXQJVSUR ]HHUIRUGHUWGHU$OWHUQDWLYHQEHUFNVLFKWLJWGHUHQ/DVWHQIUP|JOLFKH EHWURIIHQH3HUVRQHQUHIOHNWLHUWHYHQWXHOO$XVQDKPHQTXDOLIL]LHUWHWF 1XU DP 5DQGHVHL KLHU EHPHUNW GD GLHVHU |IIHQWOLFKH 3UR]H QLFKW IU MHGH +DQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQ HLJHQV GXUFKJHIKUW ZHUGHQ PX 9LHOPHKU NDQQEHLVSLHOVZHLVHDXFKGLH,QVWLWXWLRQGHV5HFKWVDOV%HVFKUHLEXQJHLQHU 7HLOPHQJHDOOHUUHOHYDQWHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQEHWUDFKWHWZHUGHQGLHVLFKGLH MHQLJHQ GLH XQWHU GHP 5HFKW OHEHQ XQWHUHLQDQGHU XQG GHU 6WDDWVJHZDOW ]XVFKUHLEHQ 8P EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GDV 3ULQ]LS ]X HUPLWWHOQ GDV EHVWLPPW ZLHYLHOH7HVWVHLQH%UFNHGXUFKODXIHQPXEHYRUVLHGHUgIIHQWOLFKNHLW EHUJHEHQZLUGZLUGGHUDOOJHPHLQH+DQGOXQJVJUXQG JHQHULFUHDVRQ XQWHU VWHOOWGDN|USHUOLFKH9HUOHW]XQJ]XYHUPHLGHQLVW:LUZLVVHQGDQQQLFKW ZHOFKH3HUVRQHQDXIZHOFKH:HLVHYRQGHP3ULQ]LSEHWURIIHQVHLQZHU GHQDEHUHVLVWEHNDQQWGDGLH$Q]DKOGHU3HUVRQHQPLWJHJHQOlXILJHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]% 6HOEVWPRUGDEVLFKWHQ QXU EHL XQJHIlKU GHU %HY|ONHUXQJOLHJW:lUHGHUHQ$Q]DKOMHGRFKZHVHQWOLFKJU|HUVRP WHQ GHUHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DXIZHQGLJHU LQ GHQ $EZlJXQJVSUR]H HLQEH]R JHQZHUGHQ'DVVHOEHJLOWKLHULQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ$EVWXIXQJHQDXFKIU GLHILQDQ]LHOOHQ,QWHUHVVHQGHU%DXE]ZGHUHQ9HUVLFKHUXQJVILUPHQGLH
_____________ 6FDQORQ YJOHUJlQ]HQGGD]XDXFK6FDQORQI Å:KHWKHUDSULQ FLSOHFRXOGUHDVRQDEO\EHUHMHFWHGGHSHQGVLQP\YLHZRQDFRPSDULVRQRIWKHUHD VRQVWKDWFDQEHRIIHUHGDJDLQVWLWZLWKWKRVHWKDWFDQEHRIIHUHGLQLWVIDYRUDJDLQVW DOWHUQDWLYH SULQFLSOHV>«@ >«@WKHSRLQWVRIYLHZ,WDNHWREHUHOHYDQW DUHWKRVHRI SHRSOH ZKR RFFXS\ YDULRXV SRVLWLRQV LQ D VLWXDWLRQ RI WKH NLQG LQ TXHVWLRQ WKDW RI ZRXOGEHDJHQWSRVVLEOHYLFWLPDQGVRRQ DQGZKDWP\YLHZFDOOVIRULVDFRPSDUL VRQRIWKHUHDVRQVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHVHSRVLWLRQV´
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
$OOJHPHLQH*UQGH
,QWHUHVVHQ GHU .RPPXQH DQ GHU VFKQHOOHQ ,QEHWULHEQDKPH XQG DQGHUH KDQGOXQJVUHOHYDQWH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ 'RFKVHOEVWZHQQGHU3UR]HQLFKWYRUDEEHVWLPPWZHUGHQNDQQVR NDQQGHQQRFKHLQHVDOOJHPHLQYRQHQWVSUHFKHQGUHVXOWLHUHQGHQ3ULQ]LSLHQ DXVJHPDFKW ZHUGHQ GD QlPOLFK XQEHJUQGHWH $XVQDKPHQ YRQ GHQ /DVWHQHLQHU(UODXEQLVHLQHV*HERWVRGHUHLQHV9HUERWV]XJXQVWHQHLQHU 3HUVRQ RGHU 3HUVRQHQJUXSSH YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH ]XUFNJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQGDLKQHQP|JOLFKHUZHLVHGDV²H[K\SRWKHVLXQEHUFNVLFKWLJWH² %HGUIQLV DQGHUHU 3HUVRQHQ QDFK HEHQVROFKHQ $XVQDKPHQ NRUUHVSRQ GLHUW 'HU 3UR]H HLQHU hEHUSUIXQJ YHUQQIWLJHU =XUFNZHLVEDUNHLW HLQHV3ULQ]LSVLVWVR]XVDJHQGHU6FKXW]ZDOOJHJHQEHUZLOONUOLFKHQ $XV QDKPH %HVWLPPXQJHQ YRQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ 'DV 6SLHO GHV)RUGHUQV XQG /LH IHUQVYRQ*UQGHQJHQDXHUGHVVHQ9HUIDKUHQVUHJHOQDXIGLHVLFK3HUVR QHQ LQ HLQHU KDQGOXQJVEH]RJHQHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV H[SOL]LW RGHU LPSOL]LW IHVWJHOHJW KDEHQ EHVLW]W DOVR DXIJUXQG GHU SULQ]LSLHOOHQ gIIHQW OLFKNHLWYRQ8UWHLOHQGLH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHEHQHQQHQHLQHQ%H]XJDXIGLH $OOJHPHLQKHLWGHUYRQGHU+DQGOXQJLQZHOFKHU:HLVHDXFKLPPHUEHWURI IHQHQ3HUVRQHQ 'LH KLHUEHL JHIRUGHUWH P|JOLFKH $QHUNHQQXQJ HLQHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWGXUFKGLHEHWURIIHQH3HUVRQEULQJW ]XU*HOWXQJGDGHU,QKDOWJHQHULVFKHU*UQGHXQGGHUHQ,QVWDQWLDWLRQLQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ6WDQGSXQNWHQGLHMHZHLOVLQGLYLGXHOOH$UWLNXODWLRQYRQ*UQ GHQ DXV HLQHP EHVWLPPWHQ 6WDQGSXQNW KHUDXV EHWULIIW 2GHU DQGHUV IRU PXOLHUW +DQGOXQJVJUQGHDOVGLH3UlPLVVHQSUDNWLVFKHU,QIHUHQ]HQEHGU IHQ HLQHU 9HUDQWZRUWXQJVLQVWDQ] VLH XPIDVVHQ GDPLW ZHVHQWOLFK SHUV|QOLFKH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DOVR hEHU]HXJXQJHQ :QVFKH :HUWH 1RU PHQHWFEHWURIIHQHU3HUVRQHQ Å*HQHULFUHDVRQVDUHUHDVRQVWKDWSHRSOH LQDFHUWDLQVLWXDWLRQKDYHIRUREMHFWLQJWRDSULQFLSOHÄRQWKHLURZQEHKDOI¶ >«@ 7KLV UXOHV RXW ÄLPSHUVRQDO¶ UHDVRQV WKDW D SHUVRQ PLJKW KDYH IRU REMHFWLQJ WR D SULQFLSOH VLPSO\ EHFDXVH LW ZRXOG OHDG WR VRPHWKLQJ WKDW ZRXOG EH EDG IURP DQ LPSHUVRQDO SRLQW RI YLHZ 7KH UHVWULFWLRQWR UHD VRQV WKDW SHRSOH KDYH ÄRQ WKHLU RZQ EHKDOYHV¶ DOVR UXOHV RXW DJJUHJDWLYH UHDVRQV ² WKDW LV WR VD\ UHDVRQV IRU UHMHFWLQJ D SULQFLSOH EHFDXVH RI WKH VXPRILWVHIIHFWVRQPDQ\GLIIHUHQWSHRSOH´'DPLWZLUGGLH5HOHYDQ] SHUV|QOLFKHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQLQV%OLFNIHOGJHUFNW
_____________ 6FDQORQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
3HUV|QOLFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
=XUFNJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ HLQ +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LS YRQ HLQHU 3HUVRQ P|JOLFKHUZHLVHZHQQGDVHQWVSUHFKHQGJHIRUGHUWH+DQGHOQGLHVHU3HUVRQ RGHUDXFKGDV+DQGHOQDQGHUHU3HUVRQHQJHPlGLHVHP3ULQ]LSJHJHQGLH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GLHVHU 3HUVRQ JHULFKWHW LVW 'LH =XUFNZHLVXQJVJUQGH HU ZDFKVHQ DOVR DXV GHU $IIHNWLRQ GHU HLJHQHQ 3HUVRQ GXUFK GLH IUDJOLFKH +DQGOXQJ (LQHQ .DWDORJ P|JOLFKHU YHUOHW]EDUHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ YRUDE ]X JHEHQVFKHLQWXQP|JOLFKMHGRFKDXFKXQQ|WLJ]XVHLQGHQQHQWVFKHLGHQG LVWOHGLJOLFKGDGLHIUDJOLFKH3HUVRQHLQHQ=XUFNZHLVXQJVJUXQGEHVLW]W 2EHUJHJHQEHUGHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQGLHDXVGHPMHZHLOVLQVLQXLHUWHQ 3ULQ]LSHUZDFKVHQGRPLQLHUHQGLVWNDQQQLFKWYRUDEEHVWLPPWZHUGHQ 6FDQORQ JLEW LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ HLQH NXU]H $XIOLVWXQJ GLH GHXWOLFKPDFKHQVROOGDGHUDUWLJH=XUFNZHLVXQJVJUQGHQLFKWVWHWVXQG DXVVFKOLHOLFK DXI GDV :RKOHUJHKHQ HLQHU 3HUVRQ EH]RJHQ VHLQ PVVHQ Å7KHVH UHDVRQV LQFOXGH QRW RQO\ FRQVLGHUDWLRQV RI ZHOOEHLQJ EXW DOVR VXFKWKLQJVDVWKHYDOXHRIKDYLQJRXWFRPHVGHSHQGRQRQH·VFKRLFHVDQG WKHGLVYDOXHRIEHLQJWUHDWHGDUELWUDULO\DQGRIKDYLQJRQH·V FHQWUDOLQWH UHVWVQRWWDNHQLQWRDFFRXQW´'HQPLWGLHVHU8QP|JOLFKNHLWGHUWKHRUH WLVFKHQ 9RUDEEHVWLPPXQJ JOWLJHU =XUFNZHLVXQJVJUQGH YHUEXQGHQHQ 9RUZXUIGHV,QWXLWLRQLVPXVNDQQPDQPLW6FDQORQLQGHP6LQQHDN]HSWLH UHQ GD HV WDWVlFKOLFK GHU %HXUWHLOXQJ NRQNUHWHU 6LWXDWLRQHQ EHGDUI XP GLH7ULIWLJNHLWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQEHVWLPPHQ]XN|QQHQ PDQGHQNH GDEHL DQ GDV TXDQWLWDWLYH Ä$XIZLHJHQ¶ VRZLH GDV TXDOLWLWDWLYH Ä$EZlJHQ¶ YRQ /DVWHQ E]Z $UWHQ YRQ /DVWHQ ZHOFKHV DXIJUXQGGHU GDULQ VWHFNHQ GHQ.RQWLQXDHLQHDSULRUL%HVWLPPXQJDXVVFKOLHW'RFKKDQGHOWHVVLFK QLFKW XP HLQHQ ,QWXLWLRQLVPXV GHPJHPl HLQH %HZHUWXQJ HLQHV +DQG OXQJVJUXQGV LKUHUVHLWV QLFKW ZHLWHU H[SOL]LHUW ZHUGHQ N|QQWH GD HV YRQ $QIDQJ DQ XP GDV VR]LDOH 6SLHO GHV )RUGHUQV XQG /LHIHUQV YRQ *UQGHQ JHKWVLQGGLH8UWHLOHIURGHUJHJHQHLQ+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSVWHWVNULWLVLHU EDUXQGYHUWHLGLJEDU (QWVFKHLGHQGLVWKLHUOHGLJOLFKGDHVDXIJUXQGGHU
_____________ 6FDQORQ 9JO GD]X 6FDQORQ GHU JHJHQ HLQHQ ,QWXLWLRQLVPXV GLHVHU 3ULFKDUG·VFKHQ $UW IRO JHQGHV$UJXPHQWDQIKUW HUKlOWHVIUWKHRUHWLVFKDEZHJLJÅ>«@WRFRQVWUXHWDNLQJ VRPHWKLQJWREHDUHDVRQDVDNLQGRISHUFHSWLRQVLQFHLWODFNVWKHFUXFLDOHOHPHQWRI EHLQJDPHFKDQLVPRIUHSUHVHQWDWLRQWKURXJKZKLFKWKLQJVDWDGLVWDQFHDUHSUHVHQWHG WRXV:HGRVRPHWLPHVVSHDNRIÄVHHLQJ¶VRPHWKLQJDVDUHDVRQEXWVLQFHLWLVQRWD PDWWHURISLFWXULQJRUUHSUHVHQWDWLRQLWLVQRWDNLQGRISHUFHSWLRQDQ\PRUHWKDQDQ\ RWKHUPRGHRILQWHOOHFWXDOXQGHUVWDQGLQJµ 6FDQORQ I 2KQHDXIHLQHHQW VSUHFKHQGH6LQQHVGDWHQWKHRULHHLQJHKHQ]XPVVHQVFKHLQWPLUNODU]XVHLQGDGDV +DEHQYRQ:DKUQHKPXQJHQXQGGDV%HDQVSUXFKHQYRQ*UQGHQPLW%OLFNDXIGLH MHZHLOLJH 9HUDQWZRUWOLFKNHLW ZHVHQWOLFK YHUVFKLHGHQ VLQG *UQGH ZLGHUIDKUHQ XQV
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3HUV|QOLFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
UHOHYDQWHQ$IIHNWLRQGXUFKGLHIUDJOLFKHQ+DQGOXQJHQE]ZGHUHQ.RQVH TXHQ]HQ XP JHQHUHOO QLFKWGHOHJLHUEDUH $UWLNXODWLRQHQ YRQ SHUV|QOLFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQJHKW 'LH ]ZHLIHOORV NRPSOH[H XQG DXHURUGHQWOLFK VFKZLHULJH )UDJH GHU 7UHXKDQGVFKDIWKLQVLFKWOLFKGHU$UWLNXODWLRQYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQNDQQ KLHU QLFKW XPIDVVHQG HU|UWHUW ZHUGHQ $OV HUVWH $QQlKHUXQJ XQG GDPLW HLQHQZHLWUHLFKHQGHQ.RQVHQVVSLHJHOQGVROOWHPHLQHV(UDFKWHQVMHGRFK GDYRQ DXVJHJDQJHQ ZHUGHQ GD GLH 0HQJH GHU :HVHQ ZHOFKHQ JHJHQ EHU QLFKW YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH ]XUFNZHLVEDUH+DQGOXQJVJUQGH YRUJHKDO WHQ ZHUGHQ PVVHQ DOO GLHMHQLJHQ XPIDW GLH YRQ 0HQVFKHQ JHERUHQ ZXUGHQRGHUZHUGHQZREHLGDV(QWVFKHLGHQGHLVWGDZLUGLHVHQ:HVHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]XVFKUHLEHQ GLH VLH P|JOLFKHUZHLVH DOV *UQGH EHKDQGHOQ DXFKZHQQVLHGLHVQRFKQLFKWRGHUDXIJUXQGN|USHUOLFKHU%HKLQGHUXQJHQ QLFKWRGHUQLFKWPHKUYHUEDOLVLHUHQN|QQHQ²:DVJHZ|KQOLFKDOV JHLV WLJH%HKLQGHUXQJ!EH]HLFKQHWZLUGIDVVHLFKXQWHUN|USHUOLFKH%HKLQGH UXQJ,FKKDOWHGHQ%HJULII JHLVWLJH%HKLQGHUXQJ!IUHLQH'LIIDPLHUXQJ GHUGDPLWDQJHVSURFKHQHQ0HQVFKHQ ZLHSROLWLVFKKLVWRULVFKDXFKLPPHU HUNOlUEDU LQVRIHUQ ÄJHLVWLJ¶ LP *HJHQVDW] ]X ÄN|USHUOLFK¶ LQVLQXLHUW RGHU PLQGHVWHQVLPSOL]LHUWGLHVH:HVHQVHLHQYHUDQWZRUWOLFKIULKUH%HKLQGH UXQJ 'DJHJHQ LVW PDQ VLFK KHXWH PHGL]LQLVFK HLQLJ GD DOOH GHU VRJH
_____________ QLFKW9JOGD]XDXFKGHQ7KHRULHQEHUEOLFNEHL+DOELJIIVRZLHREHQ.DS )Q 'LHVH %HVWLPPXQJ LVW EHZXW NRQVHUYDWLY JHIDW LQVRIHUQ VLH VLFK UHWURVSHNWLY DXI GLH XQV EHNDQQWH 0HQVFKKHLWVJHVFKLFKWH EH]LHKW 6LH LVW DEHU ]XJOHLFK RIIHQ JHQXJ XP SURVSHNWLY 9HUlQGHUXQJHQ DQ GHQ 6XEMHNWHQ GLHVHU *HVFKLFKWH QLFKW SULQ]LSLHOO DXV]XVFKOLHHQ SUREOHPDWLVFK VLQG GHUDUWLJH 9HUlQGHUXQJHQ QXU LP 9HUVWlQGQLV LQ WHQWLRQDOWHFKQLVFKHU(LQJULIIHZREHLGLHVHPHLQHV(UDFKWHQVQLFKWGHILQLWRULVFKHLQ RGHUDXVJHVFKORVVHQVRQGHUQQXULQUHDOHQ]HLWQDKHQXQGSUREOHPVSH]LILVFKHQ'LV NXUVHQJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHUXQGZLVVHQVFKDIWVHWKLVFKHU$UWEHZHUWHWZHUGHQVROOWHQ,P 6LQQHGLHVHUXQYROOVWlQGLJHQ%HVWLPPXQJGHV%HJULIIVGHV0HQVFKHQVWLPPHLFKGD KHU .|KOHU I ]X Å:HQQ GLH 0HQVFKHQUHFKWH IU DOOH XQG QXU IU 0HQ VFKHQ DOVR IU GLH 6SH]LHV 0HQVFK JHOWHQ GDQQ JHKW HV QLFKW XP GHQ VRJHQDQQWHQ 6SH]LH]LVPXVVRQGHUQXPGLH)UDJHREPDQDOOHPZDVHLQPHQVFKOLFKHV$QWOLW]KDW HLQHQ SHUVRQDOHQ 6WDWXV ]XVFKUHLEHQ VROO DOVR DXFK .RPDW|VHQ )|WHQ RGHU JHLVWLJ VFKZHU EHKLQGHUWHQ 0HQVFKHQ -HGH $QWZRUW DXI GLHVH )UDJH PXDPELYDOHQW NRQ WURYHUVXQGVFKZLHULJEOHLEHQ´1XUQHEHQEHLXQGHLQHPUDGLNDOHQ6NHSWL]LVPXV]X YRUNRPPHQGVHLKLHUEHPHUNWGDZLUQLFKWY|OOLJIUHLVLQGLQGHU=XVFKUHLEXQJSHU V|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ 'LH HQWVSUHFKHQGH :LOONU VW|W GRUW DQ LKUH *UHQ]HQ ZR VLFKXQVHUH.ROODWHUDOIHVWOHJXQJHQDXIGHQ8PJDQJPLWGLHVHQ:HVHQDXVZLUNHQ(L QHU IUHPGHQ DOWHQ 3HUVRQ NHLQHUOHL SHUV|QOLFKH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]X]XVFKUHLEHQ LVW EHL VSLHOVZHLVH LQNRPSDWLEHO PLW DQGHUZHLWLJHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ IDOOV GLHVH HLQH HQWVSUH FKHQGH $QGHUVEHKDQGOXQJ HLQHU JHOLHEWHQ 3HUVRQ EHLQKDOWHQ HV JHKW KLHU DXVGUFNOLFKQLFKWXPDIIHNWLYH'LIIHUHQ]HQVRQGHUQXPGLHÄ(QWVFKHLGXQJ¶GLH LQ :DKUKHLW HEHQ NHLQH (QWVFKHLGXQJ LVW ]ZLVFKHQ GHP =XVFKUHLEHQ SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQEHUKDXSWXQGGHVVHQ9HUZHLJHUXQJ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
QDQQWHQ JHLVWLJHQ%HKLQGHUXQJHQ!DXI+LUQVFKlGLJXQJHQEDVLHUHQXQG GDV*HKLUQLVWHLQ.|USHUWHLO%HKLQGHUWH0HQVFKHQVLQGZHGHUÄLUUH¶ÄYHU UFNW¶ RGHU ÄE|VH¶ QRFK EHVWUDIEDU IU LKUH %HKLQGHUXQJ ² ,Q GLHVHQ )lOOHQHLQHU%HKLQGHUXQJZlUHHLQHUHFKWOLFKH9HUWUHWXQJDOV%HWUHXXQJV WlWLJNHLW ]%$QJHK|ULJH YRU]XVHKHQGLH]XHLQHUK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ5HFKW IHUWLJXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ JHJHQEHU GLHVHQ :HVHQ IKUHQ PWH 1LPPW PDQ DOV .ULWHULXP GHV PRUDOLVFKHQ 6WDWXV QLFKWGLH)lKLJNHLW]XPRUDOLVFKHU5FNVLFKWQDKPHVRQGHUQGLH)lKLJNHLW ]XKDQGOXQJVUHOHYDQWHQSHUV|QOLFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQVRLVWGLH.ODVVHGHU PRUDOSDWLHQWVJU|HUDOVGLHGHUPRUDODJHQWV HLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH9HUWUHWXQJ EHPLW VLFK DQ GHU 8Q )lKLJNHLW (LQVWHOOXQJHQ HLQGHXWLJ ]X DUWLNXOLH UHQ (LQH GHUDUW SULQ]LSLHOOH $QWZRUW DXI GLH )UDJH QDFK GHU *U|H GHU .ODVVHGHUMHQLJHQ:HVHQJHJHQEHUZHOFKHQHLQH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJYHUODQJW ZLUGUHLFKWIUGDVJHJHQZlUWLJH$QOLHJHQDXV,QZHOFKHQ)lOOHQWDWVlFK OLFKHLQH$IIHNWLRQGHU,QWHUHVVHQYRQ$QGHUHQVWHOOYHUWUHWHQGEHUFNVLFK WLJWZHUGHQPXZDQQXQGLQZHOFKHP8PIDQJDOVRGLH,QWHUHVVHQEHL VSLHOVZHLVH YRQ QLFKW PHKU RGHU QRFK QLFKW OHEHQGHQ 0HQVFKHQ YRQ NOHLQHQ.LQGHUQYRQ6FKZHUVWEHKLQGHUWHQRGHUDOWHQ0HQVFKHQGLHLKUH (LQVWHOOXQJHQQLFKWPHKUDUWLNXOLHUHQN|QQHQVWHOOYHUWUHWHQGLQGLH5HFKW IHUWLJXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJHQE]Z+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQHLQEH]RJHQZHUGHQ PVVHQLVWHLQHPDWHULDOH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJGLHGHQUHDOHQ'LVNXUVXQG GDUDXV HUZDFKVHQGH 3ULQ]LSLHQ HUIRUGHUW ZLH VLH LQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ %HUHLFKVHWKLNHQ HUZRJHQ ZHUGHQ XQG VFKOLHOLFK (LQJDQJ LQV *HVHW]JH EXQJVYHUIDKUHQ ILQGHQ $XI GHU KLHU YHUKDQGHOWHQ 6WXIH DOOJHPHLQHU
_____________ $XFK ZHQQ GHU $XVGUXFN JHLVWLJH %HKLQGHUXQJ! QDFK ZLH YRU 7HLO GHV GHXWVFKHQ 5HFKWVLVWVRLVWVHLW GRFK]XPLQGHVWHLQH(QWPQGLJXQJLQ'HXWVFKODQGQLFKW PHKUP|JOLFK²=X XQG!DOVGLVWDQ]LHUHQGH$QIKUXQJV]HLFKHQYJOREHQ(LQOHL WXQJ)Q 9JO ]XP %HJULII GHV PRUDOLVFKHQ 6WDWXV DXFK PLW %OLFN DXI PHGL]LQHWKLVFKH )UDJH VWHOOXQJHQXQGZHLWHUIKUHQGH/LWHUDWXU'ZHOOVRZLH]XP3UREOHPGHUDGYR NDWRULVFKHQ'LVNXUVH:HUQHU GHU]XGHP(UJHEQLVNRPPWGDÅ>«@ DOOH :HVHQ GLH HPSILQGXQJVIlKLJ VLQG XQG %HGUIQLVVH KDEHQ DOV PRUDOLVFKH $Q VSUXFKVVXEMHNWH DQ]XVHKHQ´ HEG VLQG 0HLQHV (UDFKWHQV PX GLHVH %HVFKUHL EXQJGLHHYHQWXHOODXFKDXI7LHUH]XWULIIWGXUFKGHQ=XVDW]HUJlQ]WZHUGHQGDZLU GLHVHQ:HVHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQ]XVFKUHLEHQGLHVLHP|JOLFKHUZHLVH DOV *UQGHEHKDQGHOQ DXFKZHQQVLHGLHVQRFKQLFKWRGHUDXIJUXQGN|USHUOLFKHU%HKLQGHUXQJHQQLFKWRGHU QLFKWPHKUYHUEDOLVLHUHQN|QQHQ ,QHLQHPDOOJHPHLQHUHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJKDW*HWKPDQQIROJHQGH)RUPHQYRQ7UHX KlQGHUVFKDIW XQWHUVFKLHGHQ Å'HU )DOO YRQ =XVWLPPXQJVNRPSHWHQ] GLH IDNWLVFK QLFKWDXVJHEWZHUGHQNDQQRGHUVROOLVWOHEHQVZHOWOLFKGXUFKDXVEHNDQQW,QYLHOHQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ JHKHQ 0HQVFKHQ LQ OHEHQVZHOWOLFKHQ =XVWLPPXQJV]XVWlQGLJNHLWHQ YRQ GHU 'HOHJDWLRQ GLHVHU =XVWlQGLJNHLW DXV GLHV JLOW HWZD IU GHQ %HUHLFK GHU (U]LHKXQJ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3HUV|QOLFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
%HVWLPPXQJHQ YRQ IRUPDOHQ 9RUJDEHQ IU GHUDUWLJH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHQ NDQQEHLVSLHOVZHLVHHLQHlU]WOLFKH(QWVFKHLGXQJEHUGDVÄ,QWHUHVVH¶HLQHU LUUHYHUVLEHONRPDW|VHQ3HUVRQQLFKWDQWL]LSLHUWZHUGHQVRQGHUQEOHLEWGHU QRUPHQJHOHLWHWHQ $EZlJXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQGHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVWUlJHU DQ KHLPJHVWHOOW :HVHQWOLFKLVWKLHUMHGRFKGDGLHVH,GHHGHU7UHXKlQGHUVFKDIWQLFKW HLQ NRQVWLWXWLYHV 0RPHQW GHU 3ULQ]LSLHQILQGXQJ DXVPDFKW ZLH HV EHL VSLHOVZHLVHEHL5DZOV·0RGHOOHLQHVÄ6FKOHLHUVGHV1LFKWZLVVHQV¶LPÄ8U]X VWDQG¶GHU)DOOLVW'DUZDOOYHUZHQGHW²PLW5DZOV·=XVWLPPXQJ²GLHVHQ $XVGUXFN H[SOL]LW EHL GHU HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ %HVFKUHLEXQJ Å,W LV >«@ DS SURSULDWHWRFKDUDFWHUL]HLW>VF5DZOV·RULJLQDOSRVLWLRQ .3@DVDVWDQGSRLQW WKDWH[SUHVVHVDQLQWHUHVWLQVHOYHVRULQGLYLGXDOUDWLRQDODJHQWVDVVXFK7R XQGHUVWDQG WKLV VXSSRVH WKDW WKH SDUWLHV DUH QRW GLUHFWHG WR SLFN SULQFL SOHVRIMXVWLFHLQWKHLURZQLQWHUHVWEXWDUHDVVXPHGWREHXWWHUO\XQFRQ FHUQHG DERXW WKHPVHOYHV DQG FRQVXPHG ZLWK FRQFHUQ IRU WKH UDWLRQDO LQWHUHVWVRIDVLQJOHRWKHUSHUVRQ6XSSRVHWKDWLVWKDWWKH\DUHWUXVWHHVHDFK IRURQHRWKHUµ :lKOW PDQ DOV 3HUVSHNWLYH DXI SUlYDOHQWH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GLH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVGDV6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQ ZHOFKHOHW]WHUHDXIJUXQGLKUHU%LQGXQJDQGLH$UWLNXODWLRQGXUFK,QGLYL GXHQ VWHWV NULWLVLHUEDUH XQG YHUWHLGLJEDUH SHUV|QOLFKH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]X LKUHP,QKDOWKDEHQVRLVWHLQ$JJUHJDWLRQVNDONOYRQ9RUXQG1DFKWHL OHQGLHDXVGHU+DQGOXQJJHPlGHVMHZHLOVLQ)UDJHVWHKHQGHQ3ULQ]LSV HUZDUWHWZHUGHQDOVJHQHUHOOHU6WDUWSXQNWGHUhEHUOHJXQJHQDXVJHVFKORV VHQ3ULQ]LSLHQZHUGHQXQWHUGLHVHU3HUVSHNWLYHQLFKWDXIJUXQGHLQHV6LFK LQ$QGHUH+LQHLQYHUVHW]HQVLQPHKURGHUZHQLJHUHLQVDPHU(QWVFKHLGXQJ JHIXQGHQ VRQGHUQ VLQG YLHOPHKU GDV (UJHEQLV HLQHV SULQ]LSLHOO |IIHQWOL FKHQ $EZlJXQJVSUR]HVVHV ² SHUV|QOLFKH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ VLQG SULQ]LSLHOO
_____________ XQG 9RUPXQGVFKDIW (LQ DQGHUHU 7\S YRQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ LVW GXUFK GLH 1RWZHQGLJNHLW DXVJH]HLFKQHW $QWL]LSDWLRQHQ YRQ =XVWLPPXQJ YRU]XQHKPHQ E]Z ]X]XODVVHQ 6FKOLHOLFK XQWHUVWHOOHQ ZLU VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK GD )RUPHQ YRQ QLFKW LQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWHU 5HSUlVHQWDWLRQ EHL JUXQGVlW]OLFKHU $QHUNHQQXQJ YRQ =XVWLP PXQJVNRPSHWHQ]XQYHUPHLGOLFKVLQG)RUPHQGHOHJLHUWHUDQWL]LSLHUWHUXQGUHSUlVHQ WDWLYHU=XVWLPPXQJVNRPSHWHQ]VROOHQPLWGHP7HUPLQXVÄILNWLYH=XVWLPPXQJVKDQGOXQJ¶ ]XVDPPHQJHIDW ZHUGHQ >'@LH DXIJUXQG ILNWLYHU =XVWLPPXQJVKDQGOXQJHQ HQWVWH KHQGHQVR]LDOHQ5HDOLWlWHQVROOHQVRUHNRQVWUXLHUWZHUGHQGDGLH%HGLQJXQJHQLKUHU 'LVNXUV]XJlQJOLFKNHLW VLFKWEDU ZHUGHQ´ *HWKPDQQ I /HW]WHUHV LVW HQW VFKHLGHQGGDZLHDXFK*HWKPDQQEHWRQWGLHVH7UHXKlQGHUVFKDIWHQÅ>@GXUFK,UU WXPXQG0LEUDXFKMHGHU]HLWDQJHIRFKWHQVLQG´ HEG 9JOGD]XDXFK6FDQORQ VRZLH.DPP 'DUZDOO LQHLQHU)XQRWHIJWHUKLQ]X Å5DZOVKDVVXJJHVWHGWKLVWHUP>VF WUXVWHH .3@ WR PH LQ FRUUHVSRQGHQFHµ 9JO ]X 5DZOV· ÄRULJLQDO SRVLWLRQ¶ XQG GHP ÄYHLORILJQRUDQFH¶5DZOV
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
QLFKW GHOHJLHUEDU 2GHU DQGHUV JHVDJW GLH 3ULQ]LSLHQILQGXQJ ILQGHW GLHV VHLWV GHV 6FKOHLHUV GHV 1LFKWZLVVHQV VWDWW XQG QXU LQ EHJUQGHWHQ $XV QDKPHIlOOHQJUHLIWGDV.RQ]HSWGHU7UHXKDQGVFKDIW 'LHVHQRWZHQGLJH(LQEH]LHKXQJDOOHUUHOHYDQWHQSHUV|QOLFKHQ(LQVWHO OXQJHQEHGHXWHWQLFKWGDVLFKEHLVSLHOVZHLVHGLH(LQZlQGHYRQ0LQGHU KHLWHQ JHJHQ HLQ +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LS VWHWV JHJHQEHU DOWHUQDWLYHQ 3ULQ]L SLHQ GLH HLQHU 0HKUKHLW 9RUWHLOH YHUVFKDIIHQ ZUGHQ GXUFKVHW]HQ PVVHQ 'RFK HV JLOW XPJHNHKUW GD GDV 2SIHU GDV EHLVSLHOVZHLVH HLQH HLQ]LJH 3HUVRQ XQWHU GHU *HOWXQJ HLQHV EHVWLPPWHQ 3ULQ]LSV HUEULQJHQ PWH QLFKW VFKRQ DOOHLQ GDGXUFK DXIJHZRJHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ GD XQWHU GHPVHOEHQ 3ULQ]LS HLQH EHUZlOWLJHQGH 0HKU]DKO YRQ 3HUVRQHQ HLQHQ 1XW]HQ HUODQJHQ N|QQWH (V EHGDUI YLHOPHKU DXFK HLQHU TXDOLWDWLYHQ $E ZlJXQJGLHVHUSHUV|QOLFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQ6RVLQG]XP%HLVSLHOGLH7DVWD WXUHQRGHUWRXFKVFUHHQVYLHOHU*HOGDXWRPDWHQIUVHKUNOHLQJHZDFKVHQH 0HQVFKHQXQG5ROOVWXKOIDKUHUXQEHGLHQEDU'LH(LQEH]LHKXQJGHU$UJX PHQWHGLHVHU3HUVRQHQJUXSSHQ]%GDHVIUVLHGDQHEHQNHLQHHUUHLFK EDUH $OWHUQDWLYH GHU %DUJHOGEHVFKDIIXQJ JHEH N|QQWH ]XP hEHUGHQNHQ GHU HYHQWXHOO |NRQRPLVFK VLQQYROOHQ 2ULHQWLHUXQJ DP .RPIRUW IU GLH 0HKUKHLWGHU%DQNNXQGHQIKUHQ'LH$OWHUQDWLYH]XU0D[LPLHUXQJVSHU VSHNWLYH JOHLFKJOWLJ RE VLFK GLH 9RUWHLOVPD[LPLHUXQJ DXI +DQGOXQJHQ RGHU DXI +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ EH]LHKW IRUGHUW MHGHQIDOOV GLH 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJJHJHQEHUGHQSHUV|QOLFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQNRQNUHWHU,QGLYLGXHQ 6FDQORQVFKOlJWLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJHLQHLQWUDSHUVRQHOOHDQVWHOOH HLQHULQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ$JJUHJDWLRQYRUXPEHU3ULQ]LSLHQ]XHQWVFKHLGHQ GLHYLHOHQ3HUVRQHQUHODWLYJHULQJH9RUWHLOHHUEULQJHQZHQLJHQRGHUVRJDU HLQHUHLQ]LJHQ3HUVRQKLQJHJHQUHODWLYJURH2SIHUDEYHUODQJHQ,QHLQHP VROFKHQ )DOO VFKHLQW GLH =XUFNZHLVXQJ HLQHV 3ULQ]LSV P|JOLFKHUZHLVH YHUQQIWLJ GHVVHQ %HIROJXQJ GLH HUQVWKDIWH 9HUOHW]XQJ HLQHU 3HUVRQ LQ .DXIQLPPWXPGHQ.RPIRUWVHKUYLHOHU3HUVRQHQ]XHUK|KHQRGHUZH QLJVWHQV QLFKW ]X VFKPlOHUQ 'DV (QWVFKHLGHQGH LVW GHPHQWVSUHFKHQG GD DXFK LQ .RQIOLNWIlOOHQ YRQ GHU LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH DXI +DQG
_____________ )ROJHQGH6LWXDWLRQIKUW6FDQORQGDEHLDOV%HLVSLHODQ Å6XSSRVHWKDW-RQHVKDVVXI IHUHGDQDFFLGHQWLQWKHWUDQVPLWWHUURRPRIDWHOHYLVLRQVWDWLRQ(OHFWULFDOHTXLSPHQW KDVIDOOHQRQKLVDUPDQGZHFDQQRWUHVFXHKLPZLWKRXWWXUQLQJRIIWKHWUDQVPLWWHU IRUILIWHHQPLQXWHV$:RUOG&XSPDWFKLVLQSURJUHVVZDWFKHGE\PDQ\SHRSOHDQG LWZLOOQRWEHRYHUIRUDQKRXU-RQHV·VLQMXU\ZLOOQRWJHWDQ\ZRUVHLIZHZDLWEXWKLV KDQGKDVEHHQPDVKHGDQGKHLVUHFHLYLQJH[WUHPHO\SDLQIXOHOHFWULFDOVKRFNV6KRXOG ZHUHVFXHKLPQRZRUZDLWXQWLOWKHPDWFKLVRYHU"'RHVWKHULJKWWKLQJWRGRGHSHQG RQ KRZ PDQ\ SHRSOH DUH ZDWFKLQJ ² ZKHWKHU LW LV RQH PLOOLRQ RU ILYH PLOOLRQ RU D KXQGUHGPLOOLRQ",WVHHPVWRPHWKDWZHVKRXOGQRWZDLWQRPDWWHUKRZPDQ\YLHZ HUVWKHUH DUH >«@µ 6FDQORQ 9JOGD]X DXFK6FDQORQXQG .DPP
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
3HUV|QOLFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ
OXQJVJUQGHDXVJHJDQJHQZLUGXQGGLH(LQVFKUlQNXQJHLQHV,QGLYLGXXPV QXUGDQQP|JOLFKHUZHLVHJHUHFKWIHUWLJWZHUGHQNDQQZHQQGLH$OWHUQDWLYH HLQ DQGHUHV ,QGLYLGXXP RGHU DQGHUH ,QGLYLGXHQ PLQGHVWHQV LP VHOEHQ $XVPDHLQVFKUlQNHQZUGH 'RFKZHGHUVLQGGLHVH%HVWLPPXQJHQ]XIRUPDOLVLHUHQXQG]XYHUDOO JHPHLQHUQQRFKLVWGDYRQDXVJHKHQGHLQHUHOHYDQWH.DVXLVWLNHUKlOWOLFK GDZLHEHUHLWVEHPHUNW4XDQWLWlWXQG4XDOLWlWYRQ9RUXQG1DFKWHLOHQ GLHDXVGHU%HIROJXQJYRQ3ULQ]LSLHQHUZDFKVHQNHLQHGLVNUHWHQ*U|HQ GDUVWHOOHQ(VNRPPWKLHUOHGLJOLFKDXIGHQ6WDUWSXQNWGHUhEHUOHJXQJHQ DQ XQG GLHVHU NDQQ QLFKW HLQ EHU JHZLVVH 3HUVRQHQ]DKOHQ LQWHJULHUWHV .DONOVHLQVRQGHUQOHGLJOLFKGLH%HUFNVLFKWLJXQJLQGLYLGXHOOHU$UWLNXODWL RQHQSHUV|QOLFKHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQ(LQH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVGLH1DFKWHL OH IU 0LQGHUKHLWHQ SDXVFKDO HLQHU 0D[LPLHUXQJ GHV 1XW]HQV IU HLQH 0HKUKHLW XQWHURUGQHW LVW GDPLW EHUHLWV ]X HWZDV GHJHQHULHUW GDV QLFKW PHKUDQGLH6SLHOUHJHOQGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQJHEXQ GHQLVW ,P=XVDPPHQKDQJGHU([SOL]LHUXQJGHUÄ6SLHOUHJHOQ¶GHUKDQGOXQJV EH]RJHQHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV LVW QHEHQ GLHVHU LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ XQG TXDOLWDWLYHQ $JJUHJDWLRQ YRQ 9RU XQG 1DFKWHLOHQ GLH GLH %HIROJXQJ HLQHV +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSV PLW VLFK EULQJW QRFK HLQ ZHLWHUHU $VSHNW YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQHUZlKQHQVZHUWGLHGLH=XUFNZHLVXQJHLQHV3ULQ]LSV YHUQQIWLJ HUVFKHLQHQ ODVVHQ N|QQHQ 'LH %LQGXQJ GHU MHZHLOLJHQ +DQG OXQJVJUQGHDQGLH$UWLNXODWLRQGXUFK,QGLYLGXHQEHVDJWZLHELVKLHUKHU DXVJHIKUWGDGLH*UQGHGLHGLH=XZHLVXQJ²UHVSHNWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJ RGHU$EOHKQXQJ²HLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIHLQH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQGOXQJVDE VLFKW UHFKWIHUWLJHQ N|QQHQ SHUV|QOLFKH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]XP ,QKDOW KDEHQ 1HJDWLYIRUPXOLHUWEHGHXWHWGLHVGDXQSHUV|QOLFKH:HUWHNHLQH+DQGOXQJV JUQGH NRQVWLWXLHUHQ N|QQHQ 'LHVH $XVVDJH OlW VLFK IROJHQGHUPDHQ TXDOLIL]LHUHQ (V LVW QDWUOLFK NHLQHVZHJV XQJHZ|KQOLFK GD DOV *UQGH IU RGHU JHJHQJHZLVVH+DQGOXQJHQGHU6FKXW]EHVWLPPWHU*HJHQVWlQGHDQJHIKUW ZLUG 6R NDQQ PDQ GHU $XIIDVVXQJ VHLQ GD QRFK XQEHUKUWH RGHU GDIUJHKDOWHQH /DQGVFKDIWHQHLQHQ(LJHQZHUWGDUVWHOOHQGHUJHJHQ|NR QRPLVFKH RGHU DQGHUH ,QWHUHVVHQ LQV 6SLHO JHEUDFKW ZHUGHQ XQG JHJHQ EHUGLHVHQHLQH3ULRULWlWEHDQVSUXFKHQNDQQ*OHLFKHVJLOWIUEHVWLPPWH )RUPHQ YRQ 9LHOIDOW VHL HV YRQ 7LHUDUWHQ 3IODQ]HQDUWHQ RGHU DXFK YRQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ 6SUDFKHQ XQG 'LDOHNWHQ +LHU ZHUGHQ RGHU ]XPLQGHVW VFKHLQW HV VR DOV ZUGHQ KLHU XQSHUV|QOLFKH Ä:HUWH DQ VLFK¶ JHJHQEHU
_____________ =%XPPRUDOLVFKHQ'LOHPPDWD]XHQWJHKHQ LQVROFKHQ)lOOHQPDJGLH%HIROJXQJ HLQHV3ULQ]LSVJHELOOLJWZHUGHQN|QQHQRKQHMHGRFKGDPLWGLH9HUOHW]XQJGHVNRQNXU ULHUHQGHQ3ULQ]LSVDXI]XKHEHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
SHUV|QOLFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ LQV )HOG JHIKUW 'LHV NDQQ YRQ HLQIDFKHQ %HLVSLHOHQZLHGHP3URILWVWUHEHQHLQHV7RXULVPXVNRQ]HUQVGHUHLQHVHO WHQHJHIlKUOLFKH6FKODQJHQVRUWHLQHLQHPJURHQ$UHDOEHNlPSIWELVKLQ ]X NRPSOH[HQ 3KlQRPHQHQ GHU PHGLDOHQ $QJORPDQLH UHVSHNWLYH $XVO| VFKXQJ YRQ 0LQGHUKHLWHQ'LDOHNWHQ XQG NXOWXUHQ UHLFKHQ 1LFKW ]XOHW]W HQWKlOWEHLVSLHOVZHLVHGLH(XURSlLVFKH*UXQGUHFKWH&KDUWDYRP'H]HPEHU HLQHQ $UW LQ GHP HV KHLW Å'LH 8QLRQ DFKWHW GLH 9LHOIDOW GHU .XOWXUHQ5HOLJLRQHQXQG6SUDFKHQ´ 6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWGHVVHQZDVZLUHLQDQGHUVFKXOGHQGDVIUGLH$XV ]HLFKQXQJ SUlYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH LQVRIHUQ HLQVFKOlJLJ LVW DOV HV 6WDQGDUGVGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJYRQ=XZHLVXQJHQYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQGLHXQDE KlQJLJ YRQ LKUHU $QHUNHQQXQJ *OWLJNHLW EHVLW]HQ VROOHQ YHUIJEDU PDFKWHUP|JOLFKWHLQH+DQGKDEHGHUDUWLJHUXQSHUV|QOLFKHU:HUWHLQQHU KDOE GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV Å5HDVRQV IRU UHMHFWLQJ D SULQFLSOH >«@ FRUUHVSRQGWRSDUWLFXODUIRUPVRIFRQFHUQWKDWZHRZHWRRWKHULQGLYLGX DOV´8QSHUV|QOLFKH:HUWHZLHGLHHEHQJHQDQQWHQRGHUDQGHUHVLQGDOVR JHQDX GDQQ LQ GLH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV HLQ]XEH]LHKHQ ZHQQ VLH LQGLUHNW HUVFKHLQHQQlPOLFKLQ)RUPYRQSHUV|QOLFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQ'DVEHGHX WHW HQWVFKHLGHQGDQXQSHUV|QOLFKHQ:HUWHQLVW²XQGGLHVLVWNHLQHVZHJV HLQH 7ULYLDOLWlW VRQGHUQ ]HLJW GHQ KRKHQ 6WHOOHQZHUW GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV SUD[LVEHLGHU)LQGXQJSUlYDOHQWHU*UQGH²GDVLHDOV$QVSUFKHYRQ 7HLOQHKPHUQDP6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQDXIWUHWHQ PVVHQ 6FDQORQ GLIIHUHQ]LHUW GLHVH :HUWSHUVSHNWLYHQ IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å)URPDQLQGLYLGXDO·VSRLQWRIYLHZZKDWLVSULPDU\LQPRVWFDVHVLVWKH LPSHUVRQDO YDOXH RI WKHVH DLPV DQG SXUVXLWV ,Q GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKDW ZH RZH WR HDFK RWKHU KRZHYHU ZKDW PDWWHUV LV WKH FRQWULEXWLRQ WKDW WKHVH YDOXHV PDNH WR LQGLYLGXDO OLYHV´ 'HU HUVWH $QVFKHLQ HLQHV $QWKURSR ]HQWULVPXV GLHVHV .RQ]HSWV ZLUG DOVR LQ HLQHU +LQVLFKW EHVWlWLJW XQG LQ HLQHUDQGHUHQZLGHUOHJW XQSHUV|QOLFKH:HUWHKDEHQDOVVROFKHWDWVlFKOLFK NHLQH %HJUQGXQJVUHOHYDQ] HLQH RQWRORJLVFKH $UJXPHQWDWLRQ IU GHQ 1DWXUVFKXW] ZLH VLH VLFK EHLVSLHOVZHLVH LQ +DQV -RQDV· 9HUDQWZRUWXQJV HWKLNILQGHW OLHIHUWNHLQHGLUHNWHQ+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQLPKLHUYHUIROJ
_____________ 6FDQORQ 6FDQORQ =ZDUNRSSHOWDXFKGHU:HUWHREMHNWLYLVW-RQDVGLH:HUWKDIWLJNHLWYRQHWZDVDN]LGHQ WHOODQGLH:HUWVFKlW]XQJGXUFK-HPDQGHQ Å>@:HUWRGHUGDVÄ*XWH¶ZHQQHVGHU JOHLFKHQ JLEW LVW >@ GDV (LQ]LJH GDV YRQ VLFK KHU DXV GHU EORHQ 0|JOLFKNHLW DXI ([LVWHQ]GULQJW>@²DOVRHLQHQ$QVSUXFKDXI6HLQHLQ6HLQVROOHQEHJUQGHWXQGZR GDV6HLQYRQZDKOIUHLHP+DQGHOQDEKlQJWHVGLHVHP]XU3IOLFKWPDFKW(VLVW]XEH DFKWHQGDPLWGHUEORHQ=XVSUHFKEDUNHLWYRQ:HUWDQ6HLHQGHV>@GHU9RUUDQJGHV 6HLQVEHUGDV1LFKWV>@EHUHLWVHQWVFKLHGHQLVW>@'LH)lKLJNHLW]X:HUWLVWVHOEHU HLQ:HUWGHU:HUWDOOHU:HUWHGDPLWVRJDUDXFKGLH)lKLJNHLW]X8QZHUWLQVRIHUQGLH
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
9HUQQIWLJNHLWXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV
WHQ 6LQQH SUlYDOHQWHU *UQGH *OHLFKZRKO KDEHQ GLHVH XQSHUV|QOLFKHQ :HUWHHLQHKRKH'LJQLWlWLQQHUKDOENRQNUHWHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[HQXQG VLQG GDPLW DOV ,QKDOWH SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ LQ GLH $EZlJXQJ HQW VSUHFKHQGHU+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQHLQ]XEH]LHKHQ
9HUQQIWLJNHLWXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV
3UlYDOHQWH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH ² DOVR IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH +DQGOXQJV JUQGHGHUHQ*OWLJNHLWQLFKWYRQGHUIDNWLVFKHQ$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKGLH KDQGHOQGH3HUVRQDEKlQJWZHOFKHUGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIGLHVH*UQGH]X JHZLHVHQ ZXUGH RGHU QRFK HLQPDO DQGHUV IRUPXOLHUW +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GLH IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH ,QIHUHQ]HQ VWW]HQ LQ ZHOFKHQ GLH .RQNOXVLRQ DEWUHQQEDULVWZHLOGLH)HVWOHJXQJDXIVLHXQDEKlQJLJYRQGHUIDNWLVFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GXUFK GLH KDQGHOQGH 3HUVRQ JLOW ² SUlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHDOVRVLQGVROFKHGLHQLFKWYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH
_____________ EORH =XJlQJOLFKNHLW IU GHQ 8QWHUVFKLHG YRQ :HUW XQG 8QZHUW DOOHLQ VFKRQ GHP 6HLQ GLH DEVROXWH :lKOEDUNHLW EHU GDV 1LFKWV VLFKHUQ ZUGH´ -RQDV +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 :LFKWLJLVWQXQDEHUGLHSKLORVRSKLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHLQZHOFKHU :HUWHREMHNWLYLVWHQ HLQ 3ULPDW GHV Ä6HLQV¶ JHJHQEHU SHUV|QOLFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ VH KHQ Å'DVÄ*XWH¶RGHUGHQÄ:HUW¶LP6HLQJUQGHQKHLWGLHDQJHEOLFKH.OXIWYRQ6HLQ XQG6ROOHQEHUEUFNHQ'HQQGDV*XWHRGHU:HUWYROOHZHQQHVGLHVYRQVLFKKHU XQGQLFKWHUVWYRQ*QDGHQHLQHV%HJHKUHQV%HGUIHQVRGHU:lKOHQVLVWLVWHEHQVHL QHP%HJULIIHQDFKGDVMHQLJHGHVVHQ0|JOLFKNHLWGLH)RUGHUXQJQDFKVHLQHU:LUNOLFK NHLWHQWKlOWXQGGDPLW]XHLQHP6ROOHQZLUGZHQQHLQ:LOOHGDLVWGHUGLH)RUGHUXQJ YHUQHKPHQXQGLQ+DQGHOQXPVHW]HQNDQQ´ (EG 'LHGHRQWLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYH GHV YRUOLHJHQGHQ $QVDW]HV VFKOLHW HLQ VROFKHV WKHRUHWLVFKHV 3ULPDW GHV 2QWLVFKHQ YRUGHU3UD[LVDXV(LQH:HUWHDNWLYLWlWGHVÄ6HLQVDQVLFK¶N|QQWHVHOEVWZLHGHUXPQXU XQWHUGHUGHRQWLVFKHQ3HUVSHNWLYHGHV=XZHLVHQVEHJUQGHWZHUGHQXQGLVWGDPLWHL QHP ÄUHLQHQ 9HUQHKPHQ¶ EHUHLWV XQHUUHLFKEDU 6HOEVW 5D] GHU ]ZDU QLFKW DXI -RQDV· /LQLH DUJXPHQWLHUW DEHU GHQQRFK HLQGHXWLJHU :HUWHREMHNWLYLVW XQG 0RUDOUHDOLVW LVW NQSIW:HUWHDQGHUHQ6FKlW]XQJ Å0\FODLPZDVQRWRQO\WKDWWKHYDOXHRISDUWLFXODU REMHFWV LV SRLQWOHVV ZLWKRXW YDOXHUV EXW WKDW WKH H[LVWHQFH RI YDOXHV WKHPVHOYHV LV SRLQWOHVVZLWKRXWYDOXHUV7KHWKRXJKWLVQRZIDLUO\FOHDU ZKDWSRLQWFDQWKHUHEHLQ WKHH[LVWHQFHRIYDOXHVLIWKHUHLVQRSRLQWLQWKHLULQVWDQWLDWLRQLQREMHFWVRIYDOXH"´ 5D] 'RFKWUHQQW5D]GLHÅH[LVWHQFHRIYDOXHV´YRQGHUHQÅDSSUHFLDWLRQ´ XQGVLHKW:HUWHDOVP|JOLFKH'LQJHLJHQVFKDIWHQ Å,GRQRWPHDQWKDWZLWKRXWYDOXHUV QRWKLQJFDQEHRIYDOXH´ 5D] YJOMHGRFKDXFK5D] Å>«@LWLV XQLQWHOOLJLEOHWRVD\RIVRPHWKLQJWKDWLWLVJRRGRUYDOXDEOHLILWLVLPSRVVLEOHWKDWLW EHRIYDOXHWRDQ\RQH´ 9JODXFK:LOOLDPV·(LQZlQGHJHJHQ5D]LQ5D] 9JOGD]XDXFK6FDQORQ VRZLH:DWVRQV I .ULWLNDQ6FDQORQV .RSSHOXQJXQSHUV|QOLFKHU:HUWHDQSHUV|QOLFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQXQGVFKOLHOLFK6FDQ ORQV Å5HSOLHV´ (UZLGHUXQJDXI:DWVRQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
]XUFNJHZLHVHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ6LHN|QQHQDOV3UlPLVVHQLQIHVWOHJXQJV HUKDOWHQGHQ,QIHUHQ]HQGHU)RUPSȺ2T 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ IXQJLHUHQ ,QHSLVWHPLVFKHQ=XVDPPHQKlQJHQZHUGHQIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,Q IHUHQ]HQ GXUFK GLH 1RUPDWLYLWlW NRQVHTXHQWLHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW JHVWW]W :HUGHUhEHU]HXJXQJLVWGDGDVYRULKPVWHKHQGH7LHUHLQ6lXJHWLHULVW KDW VLFK GDPLW LPSOL]LW DXI GLH hEHU]HXJXQJ IHVWJHOHJW GD YRU LKP HLQ :LUEHOWLHUVWHKW'LH]ZHLWH)HVWOHJXQJNDQQDXVGHUHUVWHQDEJHOHLWHWZHU GHQZHLOVLHYRQHLQHPXQLYHUVDOJOWLJHQ*HVHW]JHVWW]WZLUGGDVVLFK GDULQ DXVGUFNW GD GLH hEHU]HXJXQJ GD DOOH 6lXJHWLHUH ]XJOHLFK :LU EHOWLHUH VLQG YRQ QLHPDQGHP UDWLRQDOHUZHLVH ]XUFNJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ)DOOVPDQGLHVH]ZHLWH)HVWOHJXQJQLFKWDQHUNHQQWE]Z]XUFNZHLVW ]HLJW PDQ GDPLW JHPHVVHQ DQ GHU LQWUD XQG LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHQ .RKlUHQ] YRQhEHU]HXJXQJHQHLQH)RUPYRQ8QZLVVHQ,UUWXPRGHUJDUHSLVWHPL VFKHU,UUDWLRQDOLWlW GDV1LFKW:DKUKDEHQ:ROOHQ ,PSUDNWLVFKHQ.RQWH[WN|QQHQQXQIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH,QIHUHQ]HQ QLFKW VFKOHFKWKLQ GXUFK GLH 1RUPDWLYLWlW NRQVHTXHQWLHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW JH VWW]WZHUGHQ1XUVWUXNWXUHOOH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHDOVRVROFKHGHUHQ*HO WXQJYRQLKUHU$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQDEKlQJWEHVLW ]HQ HLQH GHUDUWLJH 1RUPDWLYLWlW NRQVHTXHQWLHOOHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW :HU KLQJHJHQGHUh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lJW DOOHLQ GLH UHDOH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV GDV3URGX]LHUHQXQG.RQVXPLHUHQYRQ*UQGHQGLHVHPDWHULDOH%HJUQ GXQJVODVW9RQSKLORVRSKLVFKHU:DUWHDXVNDQQGLHVH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD [LVOHGLJOLFKWKHRUHWLVFKGDKLQJHKHQGEHVWLPPWZHUGHQGD L GLHNRQNUH WHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH LQQHUKDOE GLHVHU 3UD[LV LP %OLFN DXI VLWXDWLRQVVSH]LIL]LHUHQGH 3ULQ]LSLHQ YHUKDQGHOW ZHUGHQ GD LL PLW GHU SULQ]LSLHOOHQgIIHQWOLFKNHLWYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQGHUHQ3HUVSHNWLYHXQG GDPLW GHU VLWXDWLRQVYDULDQWH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVGUXFN NHLQH $XVQDKPH YRQ IU GLHVH 6LWXDWLRQ UHOHYDQWHQ 6WDQGSXQNWHQ ]XOlW XQG GD LLL +DQG OXQJVJUQGH DOV VROFKH HLQH 9HUDQWZRUWXQJVLQVWDQ] EHVLW]HQ XQG GDKHU SHUV|QOLFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQZLHGHUJHEHQPVVHQ:LHDOVRHLQHKDQGOXQJV EH]RJHQH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV EHVFKDIIHQ LVW ZRUDXIVLFK LKUH7HLOQHK PHU DOV 3URGX]HQWHQ XQG .RQVXPHQWHQ YRQ *UQGHQ IHVWJHOHJW KDEHQ ZXUGHKLHUSKLORVRSKLVFKEHVFKULHEHQ KLQJHJHQGD+DQGHOQGHDQGLHVHU
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
9HUQQIWLJNHLWXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV
5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV WHLOQHKPHQ NDQQ GLH 3KLORVRSKLH DOOHLQ QLFKW PLW *UQGHQIRUGHUQ ,QVHLQHU)RUWIKUXQJYRQ6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWGHV:KDW:H2ZHWR(DFK 2WKHUKDW5DLQHU)RUVWDXI]ZHL3XQNWHDXIPHUNVDPJHPDFKWGLHZHVHQW OLFK VLQG IU GLH KLHU YRUJHVWHOOWH )RUP HLQHV SUDNWLVFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXV =XPHLQHQ KDW HU 6FDQORQV%HJULII GHU 9HUQQIWLJ NHLW LQKDOWOLFK DXI HLQH :HLVH ZHLWHUEHVWLPPW GLH GLH 3UR]HGXUDOLVLHUXQJ GHU*OWLJNHLWHLQHVSUlYDOHQWHQ*UXQGHVE]ZGHU$QHUNHQQXQJVZUGLJ NHLW HLQHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKW EHWRQW XQGGDPLWGLHHEHQYRUJHVWHOOWHQQRUPDWLYHQ0RPHQWHSUDNWLVFKHU5HFKW IHUWLJXQJVYHUIDKUHQUHIOHNWLHUW ² GLH2ULHQWLHUXQJ DQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ GDV (LQ EH]LHKHQ VLWXDWLRQVUHOHYDQWHU 6WDQGSXQNWH VRZLH SHUV|QOLFKH (LQVWHOOXQ JHQ DOV HLQ]LJ P|JOLFKH *HKDOWH SUDNWLVFKHU *HOWXQJVDQVSUFKH =XP DQGHUHQKDWHUGDPLWYHUEXQGHQHLQHEHVWLPPWH)RUPYRQPRUDOLVFKHP 5HDOLVPXV HQWNUlIWHW GHU KLQWHU 6FDQORQV .RQ]HSW PRUDOLVFKHU +DQG OXQJVSULQ]LSLHQVWHKWRGHUZHQLJVWHQVPLWGLHVHPNRPSDWLEHOLVW LFKZHU GHLQQRFKGDUDXI]XUFNNRPPHQ =XQlFKVWLVWZLHLP9RUVWHKHQGHQDXVJHIKUWPLWGHUV\VWHPDWLVFKHQ %LQGXQJ DOOJHPHLQH $QHUNHQQXQJ YHUGLHQHQGHU +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ DQ GLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVDXFKGHUHQ%LQGXQJDQSHUV|QOLFKH(LQVWHOOXQ JHQXQGLQGLYLGXHOOH8UWHLOHJHJHEHQ+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQHQWVWHKHQOHJL WLPHUZHLVHQLFKWDQRQ\PÄLQGHU*HVHOOVFKDIW¶VRQGHUQVHW]HQGLHMHZHLOV NRQNUHWH $UWLNXODWLRQ YRQ HLQHP NULWLVLHUEDUHQ XQG YHUWHLGLJEDUHQ LQGL YLGXHOOHQ 6WDQGSXQNW YRUDXV 6FDQORQ KDW KLHUDXI EHUHLWV H[SOL]LW KLQJH ZLHVHQ GRFK VFKHLQW HV VR DOV ZUGH HU GLH UHDOH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV ]XUUHLQHQ,QIRUPDWLRQVYHUDQVWDOWXQJGHJUDGLHUHQ Å>«@ZKLOHLQWHUDFWLRQ ZLWKRWKHUVSOD\VDFUXFLDOUROHLQDUULYLQJDWZHOOIRXQGHGPRUDORSLQLRQV >«@ UHDFKLQJ D FRQFOXVLRQ DERXW ULJKW DQG ZURQJ UHTXLUHV PDNLQJ D MXGJPHQWDERXWZKDWRWKHUVFRXOGRUFRXOGQRWUHDVRQDEO\UHMHFW7KLVLVD MXGJPHQW WKDW HDFK RI XV PXVW PDNH IRU KLP RU KHUVHOIµ 6HOEVWYHU VWlQGOLFK JHKW 6FDQORQ QLFKW YRQ GHU 8QIHKOEDUNHLW GHV HLJHQHQ 8UWHLOV DXVDEHUHVZLGHUVSULFKWLQJHZLVVHU+LQVLFKWVRJDUVHLQHUHLJHQHQ%HWR QXQJ GHV LQGLYLGXHOOHQ 6WDQGSXQNWV ZHQQ IU GLH EHKDXSWHWH *OWLJNHLW HLQHV VROFKHQ 8UWHLOV GLH %HUFNVLFKWLJXQJ DNWXHOOHU DQGHUHU 6WDQGSXQNWH EHUJDQJHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ 6FDQORQ EH]HLFKQHW VHLQH HLJHQH 3RVLWLRQ LQ GLHVHPVSH]LILVFKHQ6LQQHVHOEVWPLW5HNXUVDXI+DEHUPDVDOVÅPRQRORJL FDO´ 'DVNULWLVFKH3RWHQWLDOSHUV|QOLFKHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQKLQVLFKWOLFKGHV
_____________ 6FDQORQ I 6FDQORQ YJODOV5HIHUHQ]GD]X+DEHUPDV I Å'HU.DWHJRULVFKH ,PSHUDWLY>.DQWV@ULFKWHWVLFKQLFKW]XIlOOLJDQHLQH]ZHLWH3HUVRQLP6LQJXODUXQGHU ZHFNW GHQ (LQGUXFN DOV N|QQH MHGHU IU VLFK LQ IRUR LQWHUQR GLH HUIRUGHUOLFKH 1RU
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
VHQÄZDVZLUHLQDQGHUVFKXOGHQ¶²6FDQORQV:KDW:H2ZHWR(DFK2WKHU² NDQQGDPLWQLFKWYROOHQWIDOWHWZHUGHQ 'HPJHJHQEHUVFKHLQWHVJHUDGHYRQGLHVHU3RVLWLRQDXVVLQQYROOHU]X VHLQGDVQRUPDWLYH*HZLFKWDXIGLHYRQ6FDQORQDQJHVSURFKHQHÄ,QWHUDN WLRQPLW$QGHUHQ¶]XOHJHQGKGLHDNWXHOOH$UWLNXODWLRQYRQMHZHLOVSHU V|QOLFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ 'LH 9HUDQWZRUWXQJVLQVWDQ] SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHO OXQJHQ 6FDQORQV ÄMXGJPHQW VHQVLWLYH DWWLWXGHV¶ LVW VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK GDV ,QGLYLGXXPGRFKGLH*OWLJNHLWHLQHV+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSV²REHVDOVR$QHU NHQQXQJ YHUGLHQW ² NDQQ QLFKW YRQ HLQHP ,QGLYLGXXP HWDEOLHUW ZHUGHQ 'HQQGHP,QGLYLGXXPHLQHQSULYLOHJLHUWHQ=XJDQJ]XHLQHUHQWVSUHFKHQ GHQ*OWLJNHLW]X]XELOOLJHQIKUWHLP.RQIOLNWIDOOOHW]WOLFKZLHGHUXP]XU LQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ3HUVSHNWLYHGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV ,P *HJHQVDW] ]X 6FDQORQ KDEHQ $OH[\3HF]HQLN HLQHQ DUJXPHQWDWL YHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ YRQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GHU .RKlUHQ]HLQHV6\VWHPVYRQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQXQGGHPUHDOHQ'LVNXUVKHUJH VWHOOWGHUPLUIUGDV*HJHQZlUWLJHHLQVFKOlJLJHUVFKHLQW Å>«@LWFDQEH VDLGWKDWWKHFRQFHSWRIMXVWLILFDWLRQLVUHODWHGWRWKDWRIVXSSRUW-XVWLILFD WLRQ LQ D VWURQJ VHQVH LQFOXGHV VXSSRUW DQG DGGLWLRQDO UHTXLUHPHQWV $ FHQWUDO RQH LV WKDW RI FRKHUHQFH 0RUHRYHU VXFK FRQFHSWV DV UDWLRQDOLW\ DQG FRUUHFWQHVV DUH UHODWHG WR WKDW RI MXVWLILFDWLRQ DQG WKXV FRKHUHQFH 7KHUHIRUH RQH FDQ VD\ WKDW FRKHUHQFH LV D FHQWUDO HOHPHQW RI D IXOO\ IOHGJHGFRQFHSWRIMXVWLILFDWLRQUDWLRQDOLW\DQGFRUUHFWQHVV7KLVUHODWLRQ FDQEHH[SUHVVHGDVIROORZV ,IWKHQRUPRUYDOXHV\VWHPLQTXHVWLRQLV PRUHFRKHUHQWWKDQDQ\FRPSHWLQJV\VWHPWKHQLWLVSULPDIDFLHEHWWHUMXVWL ILHGDQGPRUHUDWLRQDOWKDQDQ\FRPSHWLQJV\VWHP,IWKHQRUPRUYDOXH V\VWHP LQ TXHVWLRQ LV PRUH FRKHUHQW WKDQ DQ\ FRPSHWLQJ V\VWHP WKHQ WKHUHH[LVWVDSULPDIDFLHUHDVRQWKDWLWLVFRUUHFWµ $OH[\3HF]HQLNKDEHQ EHL 1RUPHQ RGHU :HUWHV\VWHPHQ SDUDGLJPDWLVFK 6\VWHPH SRVLWLYHQ 5HFKWVYRU$XJHQGRFKQLFKWQXUEHVWHKHQGLH.ULWHULHQGHUHQ/HJLWLPLWlW QDFK $OH[\3HF]HQLN LQ GHU P|JOLFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ GLHVHU 1RUPHQ RGHU :HUWHV\VWHPH JHJHQEHU DOOHQ GDYRQ %HWURIIHQHQ YLHOPHKU VHKHQ DXFK VLH LQ GHU .RKlUHQ] HLQHV VROFKHQ 6\VWHPV GDV ]HQWUDOH .ULWHULXP GHVVHQ .RUUHNWKHLW XQWHU GHU %HGLQJXQJ GD HV VLFK EHL GHU /HJLWLPLHUXQJ XP HLQHQ |IIHQWOLFKHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]H KDQGHOW ZRPLW DXVJHVFKORV
_____________ PHQSUIXQJYRUQHKPHQ7DWVlFKOLFKYHUODQJWDEHUGLHUHIOH[LYH$QZHQGXQJGHV9HU DOOJHPHLQHUXQJVWHVWVHLQH%HUDWXQJVVLWXDWLRQLQGHUMHGHUJHQ|WLJWLVWGLH3HUVSHNWLYH DOOHUDQGHUHQHLQ]XQHKPHQXP]XSUIHQREHLQH1RUPDXVGHU6LFKWHLQHVMHGHQYRQDO OHQJHZROOWZHUGHQN|QQWH'DVLVWGLH6LWXDWLRQHLQHVDXI9HUVWlQGLJXQJDE]LHOHQGHQ UDWLRQDOHQ'LVNXUVHVDQGHPDOOH%HWURIIHQHQEHWHLOLJWVLQG$XFKGHPHLQVDPXUWHLOHQ GHQ6XEMHNWHUOHJWGLHVH,GHHHLQHUGLVNXUVLYHQ9HUVWlQGLJXQJJU|HUH%HJUQGXQJV ODVWHQDXIDOVHLQPRQRORJLVFK]XKDQGKDEHQGHU9HUDOOJHPHLQHUXQJVWHVW´ $OH[\3HF]HQLN
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
9HUQQIWLJNHLWXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV
VHQZHUGHQNDQQGDHVVLFKEHLGHUUHVXOWLHUHQGHQ.RKlUHQ]XPHLQ²DQ GHU5HDOLWlWJHPHVVHQ²VXERSWLPDOHV(UJHEQLVKDQGHOW=XQlFKVWVWHOOHQ VLH XQWHU DQGHUHP IROJHQGH .RKlUHQ]NULWHULHQ DXI Å >«@ WKH PRUH VWDWHPHQWV EHORQJLQJ WR D WKHRU\ DUH VXSSRUWHG WKH PRUH FRKHUHQW WKH WKHRU\>«@ >«@WKHORQJHUWKHFKDLQVRIUHDVRQVEHORQJLQJWRDWKHRU\ DUHWKHPRUHFRKHUHQWWKHWKHRU\>«@ >«@WKHPRUHVWDWHPHQWVEH ORQJLQJWRDWKHRU\DUHVWURQJO\VXSSRUWHGE\RWKHUVWDWHPHQWVWKHPRUH FRKHUHQWWKHWKHRU\>«@ >«@WKHJUHDWHUWKHQXPEHURILQGHSHQGHQW VHWVRISUHPLVHVZLWKLQWKHWKHRU\LQTXHVWLRQVRWKDWWKHVDPHFRQFOXVLRQ IROORZVIURPHDFKRQHRIWKHVHVHWVWKHPRUHFRKHUHQWWKHWKHRU\>«@ ,I WKH WKHRU\ LQ TXHVWLRQ FRQWDLQV SULQFLSOHV WKHQ >«@ WKH JUHDWHU WKH QXPEHURISULRULW\UHODWLRQVEHWZHHQWKHSULQFLSOHVWKHPRUHFRKHUHQWWKH WKHRU\ >«@ >«@WKHJUHDWHUWKHQXPEHURIUHFLSURFDOHPSLULFDO DQDO\WLF DQG QRUPDWLYHUHODWLRQV EHWZHHQVWDWHPHQWV EHORQJLQJ WR D WKH RU\ WKH PRUH FRKHUHQW WKH WKHRU\ >«@ >«@ WKH PRUH VWDWHPHQWV ZLWKRXWLQGLYLGXDOQDPHVDWKHRU\XVHVWKHPRUHFRKHUHQWWKHWKHRU\>«@ >«@WKHJUHDWHUWKHQXPEHURIJHQHUDOFRQFHSWVEHORQJLQJWRDWKH RU\DQGWKHKLJKHUWKHLUGHJUHHRIJHQHUDOLW\WKHPRUHFRKHUHQWWKHWKH RU\>«@ >«@WKHPRUHFRQFHSWVDJLYHQWKHRU\7FRQWDLQVZKLFK UHVHPEOHFRQFHSWVXVHGLQDQRWKHUWKHRU\7WKHPRUHFRKHUHQWWKHVH WKHRULHVDUHZLWKHDFKRWKHU>«@ >«@WKHJUHDWHUQXPEHURILQGLYLGXDO FDVHV D WKHRU\ FRYHUV WKH PRUH FRKHUHQW WKH WKHRU\ >«@ >«@ WKH PRUHILHOGVRIOLIHDWKHRU\FRYHUVWKHPRUHFRKHUHQWWKHWKHRU\µ =ZL VFKHQGLHVHQ.ULWHULHQPXVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKMHZHLOVDEJHZRJHQZHUGHQ G K GD EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GLH .HWWH YRQ UHFKWIHUWLJHQGHQ *UQGHQ P|JOL FKHUZHLVH ]X ODQJ VHLQ N|QQWH ZHQQ GLHVH /lQJH DXI .RVWHQ GHU GDULQ DUWLNXOLHUWHQ$OOJHPHLQKHLWJLQJH LVROLHUWEHWUDFKWHWZHUGHQVROOWHLQMHGHP )DOONHLQHVGHU.ULWHULHQ'LHVHQRWZHQGLJH$EZlJXQJIKUWDEHUVFKOLH OLFK]XHLQHU9HUGHXWOLFKXQJGHV|IIHQWOLFKHQ&KDUDNWHUVGLHVHV5HFKWIHU WLJXQJVSUR]HVVHVXPGHQHVPLUKLHUJHKW Å7KHFULWHULDRIFRKHUHQFHGR
_____________ :HQQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ NROOLGLHUHQ VWHOOW VLFK KlXILJ QLFKW GLH )UDJH ZHOFKHV RGHU ZHOFKH GLHVHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ IDOOHQJHODVVHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ VRQGHUQ ZLH PDQ GLHVHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ LQQHUKDOE GHV 6\VWHPV MHZHLOV PD[LPDOH *HOWXQJ YHUVFKDIIHQ NDQQ ² $QPHUNXQJ .3 +LHULQVSLHJHOWVLFKZDV5DZOVÄhEHUOHJXQJVJOHLFKJHZLFKW¶QHQQW YJOREHQ)Q GRFKLVWGLHVHV.ULWHULXP²ZLHNHLQHVGHUKLHUJHQDQQWHQ²DOOHLQQLFKWDXVUHLFKHQG XP ]X GLHVHP hEHUOHJXQJVJOHLFKJHZLFKW ]X JHODQJHQ PX QlPOLFK JHJHEHQHQIDOOV HQWVFKLHGHQZHUGHQ REHLQH3ULRULWlW]XJXQVWHQDOOJHPHLQHUHURGHU HKHUEHVRQGHUHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ EHVWHKW ÄDQDO\WLF UHODWLRQV¶ VROOHQ VLFK KLHU EHLVSLHOVZHLVH DXI =XVDPPHQ KlQJH]ZLVFKHQGHP%HJULIIGHV5HFKWVVWDDWVXQGGHPGHU*UXQGUHFKWHEH]LHKHQ² $QPHUNXQJ .3 $OH[\3HF]HQLN
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
QRWDOZD\VOHDGWRDXQLTXHDQVZHUWRWKHTXHVWLRQRIZKHWKHURQHV\VWHP LVPRUHFRKHUHQWWKDQDQRWKHU>«@7KHFKRLFHEHWZHHQWKHV\VWHPVUH TXLUHVWKHQDQHYDOXDWLRQZKLFKFDQQRWEHEDVHGVROHO\RQFULWHULDRIFR KHUHQFH>«@IXOILOOPHQWRIWKHFULWHULDUHVWULFWVLUUDWLRQDOLW\DQGLQMXVWLFH $QRWKHU@ OLPLWDWLRQ >«@ UHVXOWV IURP WKH QHFHVVDU\ LQFRPSOHWHQHVV ÄRSHQ WH[WXUH¶ RI DOO QRUPDWLYH V\VWHPV UHJDUGOHVV RI WKHLU GHJUHHRI FRKHUHQFH >«@ 7KHVH OLPLWDWLRQV >«@VKRZ WKDW DQRWKHU OHYHOLVDOVRLPSRUWDQWWKDWLVWKHSURFHGXUDOOHYHOLQZKLFKSHUVRQVDQG WKHLUDFWVRIUHDVRQLQJSOD\WKHGHFLVLYHUROH7KHLGHDRIMXVWLILFDWLRQFRQQHFWV WKHVHOHYHOVZLWKHDFKRWKHU-XVWLILFDWLRQUHTXLUHVWZRWKLQJV)LUVWO\LWUHTXLUHV WKHFUHDWLRQRIDV\VWHPRIVWDWHPHQWVDVFRKHUHQWDVSRVVLEOH7KHUHIRUH LWLVWUXHSHUKDSVHYHQDQDO\WLFDOO\WUXHWKDWLIDQRUPRUYDOXHV\VWHPLQ TXHVWLRQ LV PRUH FRKHUHQW WKDQ DQ\ FRPSHWLQJ V\VWHP WKHQ FRQVHQVXV DERXW LW ZRXOG EH SULPD IDFLH UDWLRQDO 6HFRQGO\ MXVWLILFDWLRQ UHTXLUHV D SURFHGXUH RI DUJXPHQWDWLRQ DV UDWLRQDO DV SRVVLEOH ZKLFK DLPVDW D UHD VRQDEOH FRQVHQVXVµ 'LHVHU =XVDPPHQKDQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJ YRQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GHU .RKl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ÄEORHQ6SLHO¶YHUNRPPHQN|QQHQVROO 'DOHW]WHUHVDXFKQDFK6FDQORQDXVJHVFKORVVHQVHLQVROOEHOHJWGLH]HQW UDOH 5ROOH GLH HU WURW] DOOHP GHU ,QWHUDNWLRQ PLW $QGHUHQ EHL GHU (UUHL FKXQJPRUDOLVFKHUhEHU]HXJXQJHQ]XZHLVW ,P$QVFKOXDQ6FDQORQVSULFKWQXQ)RUVWDQHLQHUWKHRULHlTXLYDOHQ WHQ6WHOOHYRQHLQHPÅ3ULQ]LSGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ´GDVGDULQEHVWHKWÅ>@ GD QRUPDWLYH $QWZRUWHQ DXI SUDNWLVFKH )UDJHQ DXI JHQDX GLH :HLVH ]X
_____________ $OH[\3HF]HQLN I +HUYRUKHEXQJ .39JO]XGHQ1RUPHQHLQHUUDWLRQD OHQ$UJXPHQWDWLRQDXFK$OH[\ GLHGRUWDXIJHVWHOOWHQ5HJHOQXQG)RUPHQ GHVSUDNWLVFKHQ'LVNXUVHVVLQGJHJHQEHUGHQREHQYRUJHVWHOOWHQXQGDQ6FDQORQRUL HQWLHUWHQ IRUPDOHQ 9RUJDEHQ GHV 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVYHUIDKUHQV XQVSH]LILVFKHU ZHLO VLH QLFKW DXI GDV $UJXPHQWDWLRQV]LHO QLFKW YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH ]XUFNZHLVEDUHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ EHVFKUlQNWVLQGDQZHOFKHQVLFKNRQNUHWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGH]XRULHQWLHUHQKDEHQVRQ GHUQGLHYHUQQIWLJHGLVNXUVLYH%HDQWZRUWXQJMHGHUHLQ]HOQHQSUDNWLVFKHQ)UDJHEH VFKUHLEHQVROOHQ 9JO6FDQORQ I
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
9HUQQIWLJNHLWXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV
UHFKWIHUWLJHQ VLQG DXI GLH LKU *HOWXQJVDQVSUXFK YHUZHLVW´ XQG IKUW GD]X6FDQORQV%HJULIIGHV9HUQQIWLJHQVXEVWLWXLHUHQG)ROJHQGHVDXV Å'LH ]HQWUDOH%HVWLPPXQJGHU*UQGHGLHPRUDOLVFKH$QVSUFKHUHFKWIHUWLJHQ N|QQHQ ODXWHW >«@ GD GLHV QLFKW YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH ² G K QLFKW UH]LSURN DOOJHPHLQ ² ]XUFNZHLVEDUH *UQGH VHLQ PVVHQ $OV VROFKH EHJUQGHQ VLH 1RUPHQ ² XQG HQWVSUHFKHQG +DQGOXQJVZHLVHQ ² GLH HLQHQ PRUDOLVFK XQEHGLQJWHQ6ROOHQVFKDUDNWHUEHVLW]HQXQGLQHLQHPVWULNWHQ6LQQHNDWHJR ULVFK ELQGHQG VLQG >@´ 0LW GHQ %HJULIIHQ GHU 5H]LSUR]LWlW XQG GHU $OOJHPHLQKHLW LVW GDPLW HLQH 9HUQQIWLJNHLW EHQDQQW GLH REHQ ² PLW GHU 6XFKHQDFK3ULQ]LSLHQGHP(LQEH]LHKHQVLWXDWLRQVUHOHYDQWHU6WDQGSXQNWH VRZLH SHUV|QOLFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DOV GHQ LUUHGX]LEOHQ *HKDOWHQ SUDNWL VFKHU*HOWXQJVDQVSUFKH²DOVHLQH([SOL]LHUXQJGHVVHQZRUDXIVLFK3HU VRQHQGLH+DQGOXQJHQJHJHQEHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQHQUHFKWIHUWLJHQIHVWJH OHJW KDEHQ HUOlXWHUW ZXUGH ,QGLYLGXHOOH $XVQDKPHQ YRQ HLQHP EHVWLPPWHQ +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LS VLQG GHPQDFK ]XOlVVLJ XQG DXIJUXQG GHU .RPSOH[LWlWUHDOHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVVLWXDWLRQHQIDNWLVFKVHKUZDKUVFKHLQOLFK 'RFKPVVHQGHUDUWLJH$XVQDKPHQZLHREHQHUOlXWHUWLKUHUVHLWVZLHGHU XPEHJUQGEDUVHLQ
_____________ )RUVW E )RUVW E:LFKWLJVFKHLQWPLULQGLHVHU)RUPXOLHUXQJGLHÄPRUDOLVFKH8QEH GLQJWKHLW¶ DOV 4XDOLIL]LHUXQJ GHV 6ROOHQVFKDUDNWHUV GHQQ ZLH *HWKPDQQ EHWRQW KDW VLQGGHUDUWLJH3ULQ]LSLHQRGHU1RUPHQ]ZDUÄNRQWH[WYDULDQW¶DEHU]XJOHLFKÄSDUWHLHQ LQYDULDQW¶ Å6RZHLWXQLYHUVHOOH$XIIRUGHUXQJHQ]XUHFKWGHQ$QVSUXFKDXI*HOWXQJIU MHGHUPDQQ HUKHEHQ VLQG VLH SDUWHLHQLQYDULDQW 'HPJHJHQEHU LVW QLFKW QRWZHQGLJ GDLKUH*HOWXQJYRQ%HGLQJXQJHQIUHLLVW´ *HWKPDQQ 8QGZHLWHU Å>«@ GLH3DUWHLHQLQYDULDQ]>EHLQKDOWHW@GHQ9HU]LFKWDXIGLH$XV]HLFKQXQJ 3ULYLOHJLHUXQJ EHVWLPPWHU1RUPDXWRUHQ>«@ HVPXJUXQGVlW]OLFKEHOLHELJVHLQZHU$XWRUXQGZHU $GUHVVDW GHU $XIIRUGHUXQJ LVW´ (EG ² ,P +LQWHUJUXQG YRQ )RUVWV $QDO\VHQ VWHKW GHXWOLFK HUNHQQEDU GLH 'LVNXUVHWKLN +DEHUPDV· GHU PLW %OLFN DXI .RKOEHUJV 7KHRULHGHU(QWZLFNOXQJGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ8UWHLOVIlKLJNHLWGHUHQK|FKVWHRGHUÅSRVW NRQYHQWLRQHOOH(EHQH´IROJHQGHUPDHQFKDUDNWHULVLHUWKDW ÅGLHYROOVWlQGLJH5HYHUVLEL OLWlWGHU6WDQGSXQNWHYRQGHQHQDXVGLH%HWHLOLJWHQLKUH$UJXPHQWHYRUEULQJHQ 8QL YHUVDOLWlW LP 6LQQH HLQHU ,QNOXVLRQ DOOHU %HWURIIHQHQ VFKOLHOLFK GLH 5H]LSUR]LWlW GHU JOHLFKPlLJHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU $QVSUFKH HLQHV MHGHQ %HWHLOLJWHQ GXUFK DOOH DQGH UHQ´ +DEHUPDV 9JO ]X +DEHUPDV· $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW .RKOEHUJ DXFKXQWHQ.DS 9JO GD]X )RUVW D Å'LHVH EHLGHQ .ULWHULHQ ]XVDPPHQJHQRPPHQ YHUOHLKHQ PRUDOLVFKHQ 3HUVRQHQ HLQ JUXQGOHJHQGHV ZHQQJOHLFK TXDOLIL]LHUWHV 9HWRUHFKW ² HEHQ GDV EDVDOH 5HFKW DXI 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ 'LHVHV 9HWRUHFKW LVW LQVRIHUQ ÄTXDOLIL]LHUW¶ ]X QHQQHQ DOV GHU PRUDOLVFKH (LQVSUXFK VHOEVW GLH .ULWHULHQ YRQ 5H]LSUR]LWlW XQG $OO JHPHLQKHLWEHDFKWHQPX>«@'HU9RUWHLOGLHVHUQHJDWLYHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJ>VFÄQLFKW UH]LSURNDOOJHPHLQ¶@ OLHJW GDULQ GD DQVWHOOH HLQHV VLPSOHQ .RQVHQV.ULWHULXPV HLQ TXDOLIL]LHUWHUHVWULWWGDVHVHUODXEWDXFKLP)DOOHYRQ'LVVHQVHQGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV IlKLJNHLWYRQ3RVLWLRQHQ]XEHXUWHLOHQ´'LHREHQHUZlKQWH=XODVVXQJXQG4XDOLIL]LH UXQJYRQ$XVQDKPHQ YRQHLQHP 3ULQ]LSLVWGHPQRFKKLQ]X]XIJHQ GLHUHFKWIHUWL
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
3UlPLVVHQ LQ SUDNWLVFKHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ VLQG SHUV|QOLFKH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ GLHDXVHLQHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ3HUVSHNWLYHKHUDXVDUWLNXOLHUWZHUGHQGKHLQH EXFKVWlEOLFKH %HYRUPXQGXQJ LQGHP GLH $UWLNXODWLRQ $QGHUHU GXUFK HLJHQH *UQGH HUVHW]W ZLUG IKUW ]XU 'HJHQHUDWLRQ MHJOLFKHU 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVSUD[LV'LHVH%HVWLPPXQJHQVLQGLP%HJULIIGHU5H]LSUR]LWlWHQWKDO WHQ 'DV6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQNDQQQXU PLW YHUWHLOWHQ 5ROOHQ JHVSLHOW ZHUGHQ $QGHUHQIDOOV ZUGH GHRQWLVFKHV 9RNDEXODUGDV=XZHLVHQXQG$QHUNHQQHQYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFK WLJXQJHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQVLQQHQWOHHUWLQVRIHUQGDV=XZHLVHQYRQ)HVWOH JXQJHQ RKQH GLH %HUFNVLFKWLJXQJ GHUHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ XQG GDPLW GHU =XZHLVXQJ HLQHU %HUHFKWLJXQJ LQ XPJHNHKUWHU 5LFKWXQJ LQV /HHUH OlXIW GK]XPEORHQ=ZDQJZLUG:HQQLFKGDKHUREHQGLH6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ S Ⱥ2T VRJHNHQQ]HLFKQHWKDEHGDGLH=XZHLVXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIT DQ$XQDEKlQJLJYRQ$·V$QHUNHQQXQJHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXISJLOWVRKDW VLFK QXQ LP 9RUVWHKHQGHQJH]HLJW GD GLHV HLQH 4XDOLILNDWLRQ YRQ S DOV QLFKW UH]LSURNDOOJHPHLQ ]XUFNZHLVEDU YHUODQJW 'DV EHGHXWHW GD GLH %HVWLPPXQJYRQSDOVLQGLHVHP6LQQHDQHUNHQQXQJVZUGLJLGHDOHUZHLVHGD]X IKUW GD T YRQ $ QRUPDWLY HUIRUGHUW ZLUG ZHLO $ HLQH HQWVSUHFKHQGH IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJSDQHUNDQQWKDWGKIU$GLH(U IRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ2 SȺT JLOW 'LH$OOJHPHLQKHLWDOV]ZHLWH4XDOLIL]LHUXQJGHV%HJULIIVGHU9HUQQIWLJ NHLWEHVDJWQDFK)RUVWGDNHLQÅ$XVVFKOXGHU(LQZlQGH%HWURIIHQHU´
_____________ JXQJVEH]RJHQH4XDOLIL]LHUXQJLVWGHVKDOEHUIRUGHUOLFKZHLORKQHVLHWDWVlFKOLFKNHLQH 5H]LSUR]LWlWPHKUYRUOLHJHQZUGH )RUVWV%HVWLPPXQJGHU5H]LSUR]LWlWODXWHWÅ>«@GDVVEHLGHU%HJUQGXQJE]Z,QIUD JHVWHOOXQJHLQHUPRUDOLVFKHQ1RUP E]ZHLQHU+DQGOXQJVZHLVH QLHPDQGEHVWLPPWH $QVSUFKH HUKHEHQ GDUI GLH HU DQGHUHQ YHUZHLJHUW 5H]LSUR]LWlW GHU ,QKDOWH XQG GDVVQLHPDQGDQGHUHQGLHHLJHQH3HUVSHNWLYHHLJHQH:HUWVHW]XQJHQhEHU]HXJXQJHQ ,QWHUHVVHQ RGHU %HGUIQLVVH HLQIDFKKLQ XQWHUVWHOOHQ GDUI 5H]LSUR]LWlW GHU *UQGH VRGDVVPDQHWZDEHDQVSUXFKWHLPÄHLJHQWOLFKHQ¶,QWHUHVVHGHU$QGHUHQ]XVSUHFKHQ RGHU LP 1DPHQ HLQHU VFKOHFKWKLQ QLFKW EH]ZHLIHOEDUHQ :DKUKHLW GLH MHQVHLWV GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVWQGH´ )RUVW YJOGD]XEHUHLWV)RUVW E )RUVW E (U HUOlXWHUW GDV .ULWHULXP GHU $OOJHPHLQKHLW GDKLQJHKHQG Å>«@ GDVVGLH(LQZlQGHYRQNHLQHUEHWURIIHQHQ3HUVRQDXVJHVFKORVVHQZHUGHQGUIHQXQG GDVVGLH*UQGHGLHHLQH1RUPOHJLWLPLHUHQVROOHQYRQDOOHQ3HUVRQHQJHWHLOWZHUGHQ N|QQHQ PVVHQ >«@´ )RUVW =XU (UVHW]XQJ GHU Ä9HUQQIWLJNHLW¶ GXUFK Ä5H]LSUR]LWlW¶XQGÄ$OOJHPHLQKHLW¶ IKUW)RUVWVFKOLHOLFK)ROJHQGHVDXV Å'LHVH)RU PXOLHUXQJKDW]ZHL9RUWHLOH(UVWHQVEHUFNVLFKWLJWGLHVGHQ)DOOYRQPRUDOLVFK]XOlV VLJHQ1RUPHQGLHOHJLWLPHUZHLVHDEJHOHKQWZHUGHQN|QQHQ²XQGGDPLWQLFKWNDWHJR ULVFK YHUELQGOLFK VLQG ² GLH DEHU DXFK YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH DN]HSWLHUW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ XQG ]ZDU LP %HUHLFK GHV 6XSHUHURJDWRULVFKHQ 8QG ]ZHLWHQV ZLFKWLJHU QRFK HUODX EHQHVGLH.ULWHULHQGHUUH]LSURNDOOJHPHLQHQ=XUFNZHLVEDUNHLWDXFKLP)DOOHYRQ² HUZDUWEDUHQ²'LVVHQVHQRGHUEHLÄIDOVFKHQ¶.RQVHQVHQ GLH]XP%HLVSLHODXILOOHJLWL
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
9HUQQIWLJNHLWXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV
YRUOLHJHQGDUI1HEHQGHUHLJHQPlFKWLJHQ3URMHNWLRQHLJHQHUSHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQDXIDQGHUH3HUVRQHQVRZLHGHUXQEHJUQGHWHQ%HVWLPPXQJ YRQ$XVQDKPHQYRQHLQHP3ULQ]LSNDQQGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVDXFK GDGXUFK]XPEORHQ0DFKWVSLHOGHJHQHULHUHQGDGLH6WDQGSXQNWH$QGH UHU QLFKW EHUFNVLFKWLJW ZHUGHQ 'DPLW LVW QLFKW JDUDQWLHUW GD VLFK DOOH LQGLYLGXHOO DUWLNXOLHUWHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ LP UHVXOWLHUHQGHQ 3ULQ]LS SRVLWLY ZLHGHUILQGHQVRQGHUQOHGLJOLFKGDGDV3ULQ]LSLKQHQE]ZLKUHP6WDQG SXQNW JHJHQEHU JHUHFKWIHUWLJW ZHUGHQ NDQQ XQG LQIROJHGHVVHQ LKUH =X VWLPPXQJ HUKlOW $OOH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ %HWURIIHQHU PVVHQ GHPHQWVSUH FKHQG(LQJDQJLQGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVILQGHQ 0LW %H]XJ DXI GLH /HJLWLPDWLRQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHU +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ PDFKW)RUVWQXQ)ROJHQGHVJHOWHQG Å'DNHLQHJXWHQ*HJHQJUQGHJH JHQGLH1RUPVSUHFKHQEHGHXWHWGDVLHUH]LSURNHXQGDOOJHPHLQH*HO WXQJEHDQVSUXFKHQNDQQ JHJHQEHUMHGHUHLQ]HOQHQ3HUVRQXQGGHUPRUD OLVFKHQ *HPHLQVFKDIW LQVJHVDPW >@ )UDJW PDQ YRQ GLHVHP *HOWXQJVDQVSUXFKUHNXUVLY]XUFNQDFKVHLQHU(LQO|VXQJVRYHUODQJWGLHV QDFK HLQHP GLVNXUVLYHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVYHUIDKUHQ LQ GHP GLH $GUHVVDWHQ GHU 1RUP GHUHQ UH]LSURNDOOJHPHLQH *HOWXQJ EHUSUIHQ N|QQHQ ² HLQ 9HUIDKUHQ LQ GHP GLH .ULWHULHQ YRQ 5H]LSUR]LWlW XQG $OOJHPHLQKHLW EH VWLPPHQGVLQG´ :HVHQWOLFKYHUEXQGHQPLWGHP%HJULIIGHU9HUQQIWLJNHLWZLHHUKLHU JHIDWZXUGHHUVFKHLQWGDKHUHLQHJUXQGOHJHQGH)RUPYRQgIIHQWOLFKNHLW]X VHLQ 'HQQ GLH PLW GLHVHP %HJULII GHU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW XQYHUHLQEDUH %H
_____________ PHU%HHLQIOXVVXQJ(LQVFKFKWHUXQJRGHUPDQJHOQGHU,QIRUPDWLRQEHUXKHQ GLH4XD OLWlW GHU MHZHLOV HUKREHQHQ $QVSUFKH ]X EHUSUIHQ XQG ]X EHVWLPPHQ ZDQQ HLQH YHUQQIWLJH=XUFNZHLVXQJHLQHV$QVSUXFKVYRUOLHJWE]ZYRUOLHJHQN|QQWH´ )RUVW )RUVW E 9JO ]XP %HJULII GHU 5HNXUVLYLWlW DXFK GLH .DQW,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ 2·1HLOOV Å%HFDXVH WKH VWUXFWXUH RI KXPDQ FRPPXQLFDWLRQ LV QRW SUHHVWDEOLVKHG LWV FRQGXFWLVDSUDFWLFDOSUREOHP:HDUHQRWJXDUDQWHHGFRRUGLQDWLRQZLWKRWKHUVVRZH PXVW DVN ZKLFK PD[LPV RU SUDFWLFDO SULQFLSOHV FDQ EHVW JXLGH XV ZKHQ ZH VHHN WR FRPPXQLFDWHDQGPXVWWU\WRDYRLGSULQFLSOHVWKDWFRXOGQRWUHJXODWHFRPPXQLFDWLRQ DPRQJD SOXUDOLW\RI VHSDUDWHIUHHDQGSRWHQWLDOO\UHDVRQLQJEHLQJV ,IZHILQGVXFK ÄSULQFLSOHVRIFRPPXQLFDWLRQ¶WKHLUMXVWLILFDWLRQPXVWEHUHFXUVLYH WKH\ZLOOVLPSO\EH SULQFLSOHV E\ ZKLFK SUDFWLFHV RI FRPPXQLFDWLRQ FDQ EH PDLQWDLQHG DQG GHYHORSHG UDWKHU WKDQ VWXOWLILHG´ 2·1HLOO 8QG LQ (UOlXWHUXQJ GHV 3ULQ]LSV YRP 6WDQGSXQNW $QGHUHU DXV ]X GHQNHQ IlKUW 2·1HLOO IRUW Å7KHUH LV QR ORIW\ SRVLWLRQ DERYH WKH GHEDWH DV SHUKDSV WKHUH PLJKW EH LI KXPDQ UHDVRQ KDG D WUDQVFHQGHQW VRXUFH7KHUHLVRQO\WKHSRVLWLRQRIRQHZKRVWULYHVWRUHDFKDQGXQGHUVWDQGWKHSHU VSHFWLYHVRIRWKHUVDQGWRFRPPXQLFDWHZLWKUDWKHUWKDQSDVWWKHP2QO\FRPPXQL FDWLRQ WKDW FRQIRUPV WR WKH PD[LP RI HQODUJHG WKRXJKW FDQ UHDFK ÄWKH ZRUOG DW ODUJH¶´ (EG :HQLJHU LQ GLHVHP HWKLVFKHQ 6LQQH VRQGHUQ HKHU PHWKRGLVFK EH ]HLFKQHW)RUVWDOVUHNXUVLYÅ>«@GLH5HIOH[LRQGDUDXIIUZHOFKHSUDNWLVFKHQ1RUPHQ ZHOFKH$UWYRQJHOWXQJVHLQO|VHQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJJHERWHQLVW´ )RUVW E
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
YRUPXQGXQJ$QGHUHUVHLHVLPhEHUJHKHQYRQGHUHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQVHL HVLQGHUHLJHQPlFKWLJHQ)HVWVHW]XQJKDQGOXQJVUHOHYDQWHU3ULQ]LSLHQOLHJW ]XPLQGHVW DOV 0|JOLFKNHLW LQ MHJOLFKHU UHLQ SULYDWHQ %HVWLPPXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ DXFK GHU VRJHQDQQWHQ ÄJXW JHPHLQWHQ¶ HQWKDOWHQ %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXI +DQGOXQJHQ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWHQ VRZLH GLH QLFKW YHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH ]XUFNZHLVEDUHQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ GLH GLHVH %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ DOOJHPHLQ DUWLNXOLHUHQ YHUGDQNHQ VLFK GHPQDFK HLQHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV
5HFKWIHUWLJHQXQG%HJUQGHQ
'LHVHU6WHOOHQZHUWGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVDOV(QWVWHKXQJVRUWOHJLWLPHU +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQLVWQXQLQIROJHQGHP6LQQHYRQHQWVFKHLGHQGHU%H GHXWXQJ2EHQKDWWHQVLFKLP=XVDPPHQKDQJGHU%HVWLPPXQJGHUSUDN WLVFKHQ(UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQVRZLHGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ6ROOHQ5HODWLRQGHUHQ EHLGH*OWLJNHLWVNULWHULHQGHU5DWLRQDOLWlWE]ZGHU9HUQQIWLJNHLWDOVLUUH GX]LEHO HUZLHVHQ ZHGHU LVW HV LUUDWLRQDO HLQ QDFK GHQ KLHU EHVWLPPWHQ 9RUJDEHQ HUUHLFKWHV +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LS ]X LJQRULHUHQ XQG VWDWWGHVVHQ JH
_____________ )RUVW EHVWLPPW GLH VR]LDOH 3UD[LV GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ GHPHQWVSUHFKHQG Å5HFKWIHUWL JXQJZLUG>«@DOVGLVNXUVLYHU3UR]HYHUVWDQGHQGHVVHQSULPlUH$GUHVVDWHQGLHLQUH OHYDQWHU :HLVH %HWURIIHQHQ VLQG´ )RUVW E 'LH SULQ]LSLHOOH ]HLWOLFKH 2I IHQKHLW HLQHV VROFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]HVVHV KDW ]XYRU .DPEDUWHO I EHWRQW Å-HGHVEHJUQGHWH6\VWHPYRQ+DQGOXQJVUHJHOQNDQQ>@QXUDOV(UJHEQLVHL QHU(QWZLFNOXQJEHJULIIHQZHUGHQ $P$QIDQJVWHKHQSULPDIDFLHJXWH+DQGOXQJVUH JHOQGLHDXIEHJUQGHWH,QWHUHVVHQXQG3ULRULWlWVQRUPHQJHVWW]WVLQG(LQHHQWVSUH FKHQG RULHQWLHUWH 3UD[LV JHUlW LQ HLQH 6LWXDWLRQ LQ GHU QHXH ,QWHUHVVHQ RGHU +DQGOXQJVDOWHUQDWLYHQ ]X EHUFNVLFKWLJHQ VLQG 'DKHU PX GLH YRUKHULJH %HJUQ GXQJVEDVLVHLQHUWUDQVVXEMHNWLY]XOHLVWHQGHQhEHUDUEHLWXQJXQWHU]RJHQZHUGHQ'LH GDUDXV KHUYRUJHKHQGH EHJUQGHWH 0RGLILNDWLRQ LVW GHU $QIDQJ HLQHV QHXHQ 'UHL VFKULWWHVGHUEHVFKULHEHQHQ$UWXVIELV]XUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJVVLWXDWLRQ>@ 'D ZLU IU EHJUQGHWH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ DXIJHUXIHQ VLQG QLFKW QXU ELVKHULJH (QW ZLFNOXQJVVFKULWWHQRUPDWLY]XUHIOHNWLHUHQVRQGHUQDXFKELVKHU%HJUQGHWHVYRQGHU JHJHQZlUWLJHQ6LWXDWLRQKHUDXIGLH1RWZHQGLJNHLWHLQHU0RGLILNDWLRQ]XSUIHQGD ZLUXQVVHOEVWDOVRQLFKWQXUDOV%HWUDFKWHUVRQGHUQDXFKDOV$NWHXUHGHV9HUQXQIWSUR ]HVVHVEHJUHLIHQPVVHQYHUVWHKW VLFK DXVGHU8QDEVFKOLHEDUNHLWQRUPDWLYHU5HIOH [LRQYRQVHOEVW´0LWVHLQHUDQ:LWWJHQVWHLQRULHQWLHUWHQ(LQEHWWXQJPRUDOLVFKHU5H IOH[LRQ LQ Ä/HEHQVIRUPHQ¶ VFKHLQW .DPEDUWHO VSlWHU MHGRFK HLQH SULQ]LSLHOOH *UHQ]H GHU .ULWLVLHUEDUNHLW ]X LQWHQGLHUHQ ZHQQ HU YRQ Å/HEHQVJHZLKHLWHQ´ VSULFKW YJO .DPEDUWHO VRZLHYD 9JOLP*HJHQVDW]GD]X*HWKPDQQ GHU GDIU DUJXPHQWLHUW Å>«@ GD 7UDGLWLRQ ,QVWLWXWLRQ XQG 2UJDQLVDWLRQ ]ZDU QLFKW YRQ IDNWLVFKHQ =XVWLPPXQJVKDQGOXQJHQ DEKlQJHQ GLHV ZUGH LKUHQ KDQG OXQJVHQWODVWHQGHQ (IIHNW ]HUVW|UHQ JOHLFKZRKO DEHU QLFKW HR LSVR GLVNXUVHQW]RJHQ VLQG VRPLW MHGHU]HLW ]XP 'LVNXUVWKHPD JHPDFKW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ´ +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJHQXQG%HJUQGHQ
PlGHUHLJHQHQ)HVWOHJXQJDXIHLQH DOOJHPHLQ]XUFNZHLVEDUH (LQVWHO OXQJ]XKDQGHOQQRFKLVWHVXQYHUQQIWLJYRQHLQHU+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQG OXQJVDEVLFKW DE]XVHKHQ E]Z DE]XJHKHQ LQGHP PDQ GHU HLJHQHQ )HVWOH JXQJ NHLQH +DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlW YHUOHLKW G K GLH GDUDXV UHVXOWLHUHQGH )HVWOHJXQJQLFKWDQHUNHQQW'LH$UJXPHQWDWLRQELVDXIGLHVHQJHJHQZlU WLJHQ3XQNWKDWGLHVHEHLGHQ.RQWH[WHIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHU,QIHUHQ]HQ KLQVLFKWOLFKGHU$EWUHQQEDUNHLWGHUHQ.RQNOXVLRQHQXQGGDPLWHLQHUZH VHQWOLFKHQVSH]LILVFKHQ'LIIHUHQ]EHWUDFKWHW:HGHUNDQQGLH(UIRUGHUQLV 5HODWLRQDXIGLH6ROOHQ5HODWLRQUHGX]LHUWZHUGHQQRFKLVWGHUXPJHNHKU WH)DOOP|JOLFK LQGLHVHP6LQQHVLQG5DWLRQDOLWlWXQG9HUQQIWLJNHLWGH UHQLUUHGX]LEOH*OWLJNHLWVNULWHULHQ 'DPLWHUJLEWVLFKHLQHJHJHQEHUGHU.DQWLVFKHQ%HVWLPPXQJLQYHUVH 9RUDXVVHW]XQJIUHLQH3ULRULWlWGHU9HUQQIWLJNHLWJHJHQEHUGHU5DWLR QDOLWlWDOVGHUEHLGHQP|JOLFKHQ.ULWHULHQSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ]HQDXILKUH *OWLJNHLWKLQ]XSUIHQ²ZRKOJHPHUNWRKQHGDGDPLW5DWLRQDOLWlWDXI 9HUQQIWLJNHLW UHGX]LHUEDU ZlUH .DQWV HQWVSUHFKHQGH 9RUDXVVHW]XQJ HLQHUVROFKHQ3ULRULWlWEHVWDQGGDULQGDGHU0HQVFKQLFKWDOVSKlQRPH QDOHV G K JHPl .DQWV WKHRUHWLVFKHQ (UNHQQWQLVSULQ]LSLHQ REMHNWLY UHDOHV :HVHQ VRQGHUQ DOV 7HLO GHU LQWHOOLJLEOHQ :HOW DOV 1RXPHQRQ EH WUDFKWHWZLUG1XQLVWQDFKGHQKLHUJHPDFKWHQ9RUJDEHQQDWUOLFKNHLQH 8PNHKU GLHVHU 5HODWLRQ P|JOLFK LQVRIHUQ .DQWV 'XDOLVPXV KLHU QLFKW WKHRULHOHLWHQGZDUPLWZHOFKHU5DQJRUGQXQJ]ZLVFKHQ3KDHQRPHQDXQG 1RXPHQDDXFKLPPHU'LHQLFKWNDQWLVFKH9RUDXVVHW]XQJIUHLQH3ULRUL WlW GHU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW JHJHQEHU GHU5DWLRQDOLWlW PXDOVR LQ IROJHQGHP 6LQQH EHVWLPPW ZHUGHQ *UQGH (UIRUGHUQLV XQG 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQ GUIHQQLFKWTXDVLREMHNWLYDXVGHU3HUVSHNWLYHHLQHUGULWWHQ3HUVRQVRQ GHUQ PVVHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHU UHDOHQ $UWLNXODWLRQHQ LQ 5ROOHQYHUWHLOXQJ EHWUDFKWHWZHUGHQRGHUZLH%UDQGRPHVQHQQWDXVGHU3HUVSHNWLYHYRQ :HVHQGLHÄ:LU¶VDJHQN|QQHQ,QGLHVHP6LQQHEHVWLPPWHUGHQ%HJULII GHV 0HQVFKHQ QLFKW XQWHU 5HNXUV DXI GDV .ULWHULXP GHU 9HUQXQIW RGHU DQGHUH lTXLYDOHQWH (VVHQWLDOLHQ VRQGHUQ XQWHU 5HNXUV DXI GLH 3UD[LV 'LQJH DOV *UQGH IU DOOH P|JOLFKHQ )RUPHQ YRQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ XQG +DQGOXQJHQ]XEHWUDFKWHQXQGGLHVH*UQGHVFKOLHOLFKDXFK]XIRUGHUQ XQG ]X OLHIHUQ Å8QVHU 8PJDQJ PLW DQGHUHQ 'LQJHQ XQG PLWHLQDQGHU EHGHXWHW HWZDV IU XQV LQ HLQHP EHVRQGHUHQ XQG FKDUDNWHULVWLVFKHQ 6LQQH HUKDWIUXQVMHZHLOVHLQHQEHJULIIOLFKHQ,QKDOWZLUYHUVWHKHQLKQLQHLQHUEH VWLPPWHQ:HLVH*HQDXGLHVH$EJUHQ]XQJVVWUDWHJLHELOGHWGLH*UXQGODJH GDIU GD ZLU NODVVLVFKHUZHLVH DOV YHUQQIWLJH :HVHQ LGHQWLIL]LHUW ZHUGHQ )UGLH7LHUHGHV:DOGHVJLEWHVNHLQH9HUQXQIW:LUVLQGGLHMHQLJHQIU GLH *UQGH ELQGHQG VLQG GLH GHU HLJHQWPOLFKHQ .UDIW GHV EHVVHUHQ *UXQGHVXQWHUOLHJHQ'LHVH.UDIWLVWHLQHQRUPDWLYHHLQUDWLRQDOHVÄ6ROOHQ¶ 9HUQQIWLJVHLQKHLWGLHVHQ1RUPHQGHU$XWRULWlWYRQ*UQGHQXQWHU
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
ZRUIHQVHLQ,QGLHVHP6LQQHÄZLU¶]XVDJHQKHLWXQVJHPHLQVDPLQGHQ 5DXPGHU*UQGH]XVWHOOHQLQGHPZLU*UQGHIUXQVHUH(LQVWHOOXQJHQ XQG9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQJHEHQXQGYHUODQJHQ´ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVUHODWLRQHQ ]ZLVFKHQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ 6XEMHNWHQ VROOHQ GHPQDFKQLFKWGDGXUFKHUNOlUWZHUGHQGDGLHVH6XEMHNWHDOVYHUQQIWLJ XQGLQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU$EKlQJLJNHLWVWHKHQGDXVJHZLHVHQZHUGHQVRQGHUQ XPJHNHKUWZLUGHLQH.ODVVHYRQ:HVHQGDGXUFKDOVZHVHQWOLFKVR]LDOXQG YHUQQIWLJ EHVWLPPW GD VLH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DOV *UQGH EHKDQGHOQ N|QQHQ LQGHPVLHVLFKHQWVSUHFKHQGYHUKDOWHQGK*UQGHDOVJOWLJHXQJOWLJH RGHUIHKOHQGH3UlPLVVHQLQEHOLHELJHQ,QIHUHQ]HQEHKDQGHOQXQGVFKOLH OLFK H[SOL]LHUHQ N|QQHQ ,Q GLHVHP 6LQQH HLQHU QRUPDWLYHQ 3UDJPDWLN ZLUG .DQWV %HVWLPPXQJ GHV 0HQVFKHQ DOV HLQHV UDWLRQDOHQ KHWHURQRPHQ XQG ]XJOHLFKDXWRQRPHQ:HVHQVGHWUDQV]HQGHQWDOLVLHUWXPDOV9RUDXVVHW]XQJ GDIUGLHQHQ]XN|QQHQGDGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQQIWLJNHLWHLQHK|KHUH 'LJQLWlW ]XJHZLHVHQ ZLUG DOV GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW ² GLH %HJULIIH GHU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW XQG 5DWLRQDOLWlW LQ GHP KLHU HQWZLFNHOWHQ HQJHQ DXV GHU *HJHQEHUVWHOOXQJ YRQ 6ROOHQ XQG (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQHQ UHVXOWLH UHQGHQ 9HUVWlQGQLV QLFKW LP 6LQQH GHV YRUVWHKHQGHQ =LWDWV %UDQGRPV GHUÄYHUQQIWLJ¶XQGÄUDWLRQDO¶KLHUQLFKWLQ5HODWLRQ]XHLQDQGHUVRQGHUQ JOHLFKVHW]W 'LH3ULRULWlWGHU9HUQQIWLJNHLWYRUGHU5DWLRQDOLWlWJLOWQXQXQWHUGLH VHU 9RUDXVVHW]XQJ HLQHU QRUPDWLYHQ 3UDJPDWLN DOV GHP 6WDUWSXQNW GHU $UJXPHQWDWLRQLQIROJHQGHP9HUVWlQGQLV 'DV )RUGHUQ XQG /LHIHUQ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ KDW VHLQHQ ORJLVFKHQ 8U VSUXQJGRUWZR$QHUNHQQXQJHQYRQ]XJHZLHVHQHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQE]Z%H UHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X VROFKHQ =XZHLVXQJHQ SUREOHPDWLVLHUW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ XQG XPJHNHKUW LVW HLQH GHUDUWLJH 3UREOHPDWLVLHUXQJ ZHVHQWOLFK PLW GHP $Q
_____________ %UDQGRP D YJO GD]X DXFK %UDQGRP D VRZLH EHUHLWV +DEHU PDV I Å>@'LVNXUVH>VLQG@QLFKWQXUNRQWLQJHQWHUZHLVHVRQGHUQV\VWHPD WLVFKLQHLQHQ/HEHQV]XVDPPHQKDQJHLQJHODVVHQ>@GHVVHQHLJHQWPOLFK]HUEUHFKOL FKH)DNWL]LWlWLQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJGLVNXUVLYHU*HOWXQJVDQVSUFKHEHVWHKW:HUQLFKWDQ $UJXPHQWDWLRQHQ WHLOQLPPW RGHU WHLO]XQHKPHQ EHUHLW LVW VWHKW JOHLFKZRKO ÄLPPHU VFKRQ¶LQ=XVDPPHQKlQJHQNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ+DQGHOQV,QGHPHUGDVWXWKDWHUGLHZLH LPPHUDXFKNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHUKREHQHQLQ6SUHFKDNWHQHQWKDOWHQHQXQGDOOHLQGLVNXU VLY HLQO|VEDUHQ *HOWXQJVDQVSUFKH QDLY VFKRQ DQHUNDQQW ² DQGHUQIDOOV KlWWH HU VLFK YRPNRPPXQLNDWLYHLQJHOHEWHQ6SUDFKVSLHOGHU$OOWDJVSUD[LVO|VHQPVVHQ´+DEHU PDV·$VVLPLODWLRQVYRUZXUIDQ%UDQGRPKLQVLFKWOLFKGHUYHUVFKLHGHQHQ6ROOHQVIRUPHQ YJOREHQ VROOWHPLWGHU%UDQGRPV$QVDW]ZHLWHUIKUHQGHQ6SH]LILNDWLRQSUDNWL VFKHU IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHU ,QIHUHQ]HQ (UIRUGHUQLV E]Z 6ROOHQ5HODWLRQ 5HFK QXQJJHWUDJHQVHLQ 9JO%UDQGRP E GHUDXIGLH*OWLJNHLWVNULWHULHQDQGHQHQVLFKHLQhEHU JDQJ]ZLVFKHQ(UIRUGHUQLVXQG6ROOHQ5HODWLRQHQEHPLWMHGRFKQLFKW]XVSUHFKHQ NRPPW
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJHQXQG%HJUQGHQ
VSUXFK DXI $EJOHLFK SULQ]LSLHOO JOHLFKZHUWLJHU SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ YHUEXQ GHQ 9HUQQIWLJNHLW DOV *OWLJNHLWVNULWHULXP SUDNWLVFKHU ,QIHUHQ]HQ LVW DOVRPLW%OLFNDXIDOOHVR]LDOHQ,QWHUDNWLRQHQLQ.UDIWLQZHOFKHQGLH$Q HUNHQQXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQSUREOHPDWLVLHUWZHUGHQNDQQGKEHUHLWV GRUW ZR HV XP GLH LQWHUVXEMHNWLYH .RRUGLQDWLRQ VXEMHNWLYHU +DQGOXQJV VWUDWHJLHQJHKWZLHVLFKREHQLQXQGGHU7KHPDWLVLHUXQJYRQ%UDW PDQVVKDUHGFRRSHUDWLYHDFWLYLW\JH]HLJWKDW+LQJHJHQEHVLW]W5DWLRQDOLWlWDOVR JHPlGHP]XKDQGHOQZRUDXIPDQVLFKVHOEVWIDNWLVFKIHVWJHOHJWKDWDOV *OWLJNHLWVNULWHULXPSUDNWLVFKHU,QIHUHQ]HQLQVRIHUQNHLQHLQWHUVXEMHNWLYH 'LPHQVLRQDOVHV]ZDUDXI*UQGHQLFKWDEHUZHVHQWOLFKDXIGDVVR]LDOH 6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQUHNXUULHUW GLH(UIRUGHUQLV 5HODWLRQJLOWEHUKDXSWQXUZHQQGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHUIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDO WHQGHQ3UlPLVVHQGXUFKGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQVHOEVWJHJHEHQLVW 0LWGHUJHQDQQWHQ3UREOHPDWLVLHUXQJ²HLQHU)RUGHUXQJQDFK([SOLND WLRQ YRQ SUDNWLVFKHQ *HOWXQJVDQVSUFKHQ QDFK 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ RGHU 5FNIKUXQJ SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ DXI +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQ RGHU QRFKPDOV DQGHUV JHZHQGHW HLQHU )RUGHUXQJ GDQDFK GHQ HLJHQHQ 6WDQG SXQNW]XU'LVSRVLWLRQ]XVWHOOHQ²QLPPWPDQLSVRIDFWRDQHLQHP3UR]H WHLOGHU²XQWHUGHU%HGLQJXQJGDGLH%HWHLOLJWHQLKUH)HVWOHJXQJHQDXFK DQHUNHQQHQ²3ULQ]LSLHQDOVLGHDOH=LHOSXQNWHEHVLW]WGLHNHLQHGHUEHWHL OLJWHQ3HUVRQHQYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH]XUFNZHLVHQNDQQ'DEHLLVWIHVW]XKDO WHQGDGLH7HLOQDKPHDP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]HLKUHUVHLWVGXUFK+DQG OXQJHQ DOVR NHLQ EORHV 9HUKDOWHQ *HVFKHKHQ RGHU :LGHUIDKUQLV EHVWLPPWLVW'LH7HLOQDKPHDP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]HLVWZHGHUHLQQD WXUDOLVWLVFK ]X YHUVWHKHQGHU $XWRPDWLVPXV GHP 0HQVFKHQ DOV VROFKH XQWHUOlJHQ QRFK HLQH PHWDSK\VLVFK ]X YHUVWHKHQGH (LJHQVFKDIW ] % %UJHUHLQHVPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLV]XVHLQ VRQGHUQHLQGHRQWLVFKHU6WDWXV HLQH)HVWOHJXQJGLHVLFKDNWLYÄ]XJH]RJHQ¶KDWZHUSUDNWLVFKH)HVWOHJXQ JHQ ZLHLPSOL]LWDXFKLPPHU LQ)UDJHVWHOOW GLH7HLOQDKPHDP5HFKWIHU WLJXQJVSUR]H NDQQ JHOLQJHQ XQG PLOLQJHQ VLH LVW GDPLW LKUHUVHLWV HLQH )HVWOHJXQJ GHU PDQ JHUHFKW ZHUGHQ NDQQ DEHU QLFKW JHUHFKW ZHUGHQ PX
_____________ 'DV EHGHXWHW GD GHP 6SLHO GHV )RUGHUQV XQG /LHIHUQV YRQ *UQGHQ VHOEVW NHLQH +LHUDUFKLVLHUXQJ P|JOLFKHU )UDJH RGHU $QWZRUWSRVLWLRQHQ HLQJHVFKULHEHQ LVW YJO GD]XDXFK+DEHUPDV Å'HQ$XVJDQJVSXQNWELOGHW DOVRGHUQRUPDWLYH*H KDOWMHQHUÄXQDXVZHLFKOLFKHQ¶SUDJPDWLVFKHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQDXIGLHVLFK$UJXPHQ WDWLRQVWHLOQHKPHULPSOL]LWHLQODVVHQPVVHQVREDOGVLHVLFKEHUKDXSW²PLWGHP=LHO GHU(LQO|VXQJNRQWURYHUVHU*HOWXQJVDQVSUFKH²DQHLQHUNRRSHUDWLYHQ:DKUKHLWVVX FKHLQ*HVWDOWHLQHV:HWWEHZHUE>V@XPEHVVHUH$UJXPHQWHEHWHLOLJHQ'HUSHUIRUPD WLYH 6LQQ GHU $UJXPHQWDWLRQVSUD[LV EHVWHKW MD GDULQ GDVV LP +LQEOLFN DXI UHOHYDQWH )UDJHQ XQG DXI GHU *UXQGODJH DOOHU HLQVFKOlJLJHQ ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ GHU Ä]ZDQJORVH =ZDQJGHVEHVVHUHQ$UJXPHQWV¶GHQ$XVVFKODJJHEHQVROO ´
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
'LHHLQ]LJHEHJULIIOLFKH$OWHUQDWLYHKLQVLFKWOLFKGHV$EJOHLFKVSHUV|Q OLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ ]X GLHVHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV LVW GLH PHKU RGHU ZHQLJHU VSUDFKORVH LQ MHGHP )DOO DEHU %HYRUPXQGXQJ XQG =ZDQJ LQ .DXI QHKPHQGH 0DFKWSUD[LV ÄEHJULIIOLFKH $OWHUQDWLYH¶ GHVKDOE ZHLO GLH VR]LDOH 5HDOLWlW QDWUOLFK YRQ HLQHP JDQ]HQ 6SHNWUXP ]ZLVFKHQ GLHVHQ EHLGHQ$OWHUQDWLYHQJHNHQQ]HLFKQHWLVW²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lQHPLWGDUDQ%HWHLOLJWHQ LQWHUHVVLHUWLVW([SOL]LW]XPDFKHQZDVHLQ+DQGOXQJVJUXQGMHZHLOVLVW E]Z H[SOL]LW ]X PDFKHQ ZDV LPSOL]LW DOV HLQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQG EHKDQGHOW ZHUGHQ NDQQ LVW GLH )RUGHUXQJ LQQHUKDOE GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV VHL QHQHLJHQHQ6WDQGSXQNW]XU'LVSRVLWLRQ]XVWHOOHQ 'DV6SLHOIHOGGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVZLUGDOVRPLW%OLFNDXI+DQG OXQJHQ EHWUHWHQ VRZRKO L PLW GHU +HUDXVIRUGHUXQJ GHU *OWLJNHLW GHU 3UlPLVVHLQHLQHU6ROOHQ5HODWLRQGXUFK3HUVRQ$ZHOFKHUYRQ3HUVRQ% GLH )HVWOHJXQJ DXI GDV LQ GHU 3UlPLVVH HQWKDOWHQH +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LS ]X JHZLHVHQZXUGHDOVDXFK LL PLWGHU+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJGHU*OWLJNHLWGHU 3UlPLVVH LQ HLQHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ GXUFK GLH ]XZHLVHQGH 3HUVRQ % GLHYRQGHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQGHUKDQGHOQGHQ3HUVRQ$EHWURIIHQLVWGKLQ EHLGHQ )lOOHQ PLW GHU 3UREOHPDWLVLHUXQJ GHU %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]X GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI EHVWLPPWH SHUV|QOLFKH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ (QWVFKHLGHQG LVW KLHUEHL GD GLH VR]LDOH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV GDV UHDOH 6SLHO GHV LQWHUVXEMHNWLYHQ )RUGHUQV XQG
_____________ 9JOGD]XDXFK+DEHUPDV I9RQHLQHUÅ2ULHQWLHUXQJVSUD[LV´VSULFKWGDKHU .HWWQHUPLW%OLFNDXIGLHVHQJUXQGOHJHQGHQ&KDUDNWHUGHU9HUQQIWLJNHLW²RGHUZLH HU VLH EH]HLFKQHW GHU ÅGLVNXUVLYHQ 9HUQXQIW´ ÅGLVNXUVLYHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlW´ RGHU Å'LV NXUVUDWLRQDOLWlW´ Å=ZHFNGLHVHU2ULHQWLHUXQJVSUD[LVLVWHVVLFKPLW*UQGHQDQ*UQGHQ ]XRULHQWLHUHQXQG]ZDUVRGDZLU>«@XQVDXIP|JOLFKVWEHU]HXJHQGH:HLVHGDUEHU YHUVWlQGLJHQ ZHOFKH *UQGH LQ EH]XJ DXI HWZDV IU XQV ,QIUDJHVWHKHQGHV UHOHYDQW XQGZHOFKHGDQQYRQGLHVHQEHVVHUZHOFKHVFKOHFKWHUDOVDQGHUHVLQGLQHLQXQGGHU VHOEHQ +LQVLFKW :DV DOVR LVW GLVNXUVLYH 9HUQXQIW" )DVVHQ ZLU HV LQ HLQH NRPSOH[H )RUPHO ]XVDPPHQ 'LVNXUVUDWLRQDOLWlW LVW GHUMHQLJH 6LQQ YRQ 9HUQQIWLJNHLW LQ ZHO FKHP ZLU GLH DNWXDOLVLHUHQGH 5HYLVLRQ YRQ .RQVHQV DOV (LQKHLW YRQ .RQVHQV XQG 'LVVHQV EHUGLH*WHYRQ*UQGHQÄPHKURGHUZHQLJHUYHUQQIWLJ¶GKDXVPHKU RGHU ZHQLJHU JXWHQ *UQGHQ YROO]LHKHQ >«@ 'LVNXUVLYH 5DWLRQDOLWlW LVW QLFKW GLH JDQ]H5DWLRQDOLWlWDEHUNHLQHDQGHUH5DWLRQDOLWlWNDQQJDQ]RKQHVLHVHLQ´ .HWWQHU I
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJHQXQG%HJUQGHQ
/LHIHUQV YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ GHU (QWVWHKXQJVRUW SUlYDOHQWHU +DQG OXQJVJUQGH LVW JHJHQEHU ZHOFKHP GLH OHGLJOLFK LQWUDSHUVRQHOOH *OWLJ NHLW HWDEOLHUHQGH VR]XVDJHQ PRQRORJLVFKH Ä%HJUQGXQJVSUD[LV¶ DOV GHU (QWVWHKXQJVRUW PRPHQWDQLQVWUXPHQWHOOHU RGHU DXFK LQWHUWHPSRUDO H[LVWHQWLHOOHU*UQGHVHNXQGlUHQ&KDUDNWHUEHVLW]W OHW]WHUHEHWUHIIHQGHQ /HEHQVHQWZXUI HLQHV ,QGLYLGXXPV LP JDQ]HQ RGHU .DQWLVFK GHVVHQ *OFNVHOLJNHLW5DWLRQDOLWlWDOVGDV*OWLJNHLWVNULWHULXPYRQIHVWOHJXQJV HUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ]HQ GHUHQ .RQNOXVLRQ QLFKW DEWUHQQEDU LVW PDJ HLQ QRWZHQGLJHV GHILQLHQV GHV 0HQVFKHQ DXVPDFKHQ 'RFK HV EOLHEH UHLQ YLUWXHOOVWQGHVR]XVDJHQQRFKÄXQWHU9RUEHKDOW¶ZHQQHVQLFKWDXIHLQHU 3UD[LVDXIUXKHQZUGHGLHGDV)RUGHUQXQG/LHIHUQYRQ*UQGHQEHU KDXSWHUVWHWDEOLHUWH9HUQQIWLJNHLWDOV*OWLJNHLWVNULWHULXPIHVWOHJXQJVHU KDOWHQGHU ,QIHUHQ]HQ GHUHQ .RQNOXVLRQ DEWUHQQEDU LVW EHVLW]W GDPLW IU :HVHQGLHÄ:LU¶VDJHQN|QQHQGLHDOVRJHPl%UDQGRPV%HVWLPPXQJHQ GDGXUFK JHNHQQ]HLFKQHW VLQG GD VLH VLFK JHPHLQVDP LQ GHQ 5DXP GHU *UQGHVWHOOHQLQGHPVLH*UQGHIULKUH(LQVWHOOXQJHQXQG9HUKDOWHQV ZHLVHQ JHEHQ XQG YHUODQJHQ HLQ 3ULPDW JHJHQEHU GHU OHGLJOLFK LQWUD SHUVRQHOOH(LQVWHOOXQJVNRKlUHQ]UHJXOLHUHQGHQ5DWLRQDOLWlW $XI6\VWHPHYRQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQVWDWWDXIHLQ]HOQHSUDNWLVFKH,QIHUHQ ]HQEH]RJHQEHGHXWHWGLHVGDGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWHLQHVSUDNWLVFKHQ5HFKW IHUWLJXQJVNRKlUHQWLVPXVVWlUNHULVWDOVGLHMHQLJHHLQHVSUDNWLVFKHQ%HJUQGXQJVNR KlUHQWLVPXV 0RUDOLVFKH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH LP 6LQQH YRQ QLFKWUH]LSURN DOOJHPHLQ ]XUFNZHLVEDUHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ EHVLW]HQ GDPLW LP .RQ IOLNWIDOO JHJHQEHU VWUXNWXUHOOHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGHQ GHUHQ /HJLWLPDWLRQV LQVWDQ]GLHHUVWH3HUVRQ6LQJXODULVWHLQHQ9RUUDQJ'LHVH3ULRULWlWEH
_____________ 9JO +DEHUPDV GHU GLHVH LQWHUWHPSRUDOH[LVWHQWLHOOHQ +DQGOXQJVJUQGH DXFKDOVHWKLVFK²LP*HJHQVDW]]XHLQHUVHLWVLQVWUXPHQWHOOXQGDQGHUHUVHLWVPRUDOLVFK ²EH]HLFKQHW VLH EH]LHKHQ VLFK DXIVXEMHNWLYH)UDJHQGDQDFKZHU PDQLVW RGHUVHLQ P|FKWH 9JOREHQ)QVRZLHGHQGD]XJHK|ULJHQ$EVDW] 'DGLHVQLFKWDXIGLHSULQ]LSLHOOH9RUUDQJVWHOOXQJHLQHV$OWUXLVPXVJHJHQEHUHLQHP (JRLVPXVKLQDXVOlXIWHLQHP0HKUZHUWGHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQ$QGHUHUJHJHQEHUPHLQHQ HLJHQHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQZXUGHREHQLP=XVDPPHQKDQJPLW6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWGHVVHQ ZDVZLU HLQDQGHUVFKXOGHQHUOlXWHUW VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKLVW HLQ+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LS YHU QQIWLJHUZHLVH ]XUFNZHLVEDU GDV PHLQH HLJHQQW]LJHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ QLFKW DGlTXDW EHUFNVLFKWLJWRGHULKQHQJDUGHQ=XWULWW]XU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVYHUZHLJHUW 9LHOOHLFKW GHXWOLFKHU QRFK DOV LQ GLHVHU )RUPXOLHUXQJ ZLUG GLH 2ULHQWLHUXQJ GLHVHU +LHUDUFKLHDQ.DQWLQ:RRGV%HVFKUHLEXQJ Å7KHRQO\YDOXHIURPZKLFKZHFDQQRW DEVWUDFWLVWKHYDOXHRIWKHFDSDFLW\WRZHLJKUHDVRQVLWVHOIZKLFKZHILQGLQRXUVHOYHV EXWDOVRHTXDOO\LQHYHU\RWKHUPHPEHURIWKHXQLYHUVDOFRPPXQLW\RIUDWLRQDODJHQWV 7KLVLVWKHEDVLVRIPRUDOUHDVRQLQJ,WVSULQFLSOHLVWRWUHDWDOOUDWLRQDODJHQWVDVKDYLQJ DQ REMHFWLYH YDOXH WKDW LV IXQGDPHQWDO VXSUHPH DQG HTXDO ,W LV VROHO\ WKURXJK WKLV PRUDOYDOXHWKDWKDSSLQHVVDFTXLUHVLWVYDOXHDQGWKHSULQFLSOHRISUXGHQFHEHFRPHV
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
UXKWDEHU²XQGGLHVLVWJHJHQEHUHLQHPPRUDOLQWHOOHNWXDOLVWLVFKHQ)XQ GDPHQWDOLVPXV ]X EHWRQHQ ² DXI GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ DQGHUHU ,QVWDQ]HQ DOV GHUHUVWHQ3HUVRQ6LQJXODU]XU/HJLWLPDWLRQYRQ+DQGOXQJHQ :HUVHLQHQ GHRQWLVFKHQ 6WDWXV DOV 7HLOQHKPHU HLQHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJHPHLQVFKDIW QLFKW DQHUNHQQW ZLUG YRQ GHU ELQGHQGHQ .UDIW QLFKW UH]LSURNDOOJHPHLQ ]XUFNZHLVEDUHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQLFKWEHU]HXJWZHUGHQN|QQHQ2GHU HWZDV SODNDWLY JHVDJW *HJHQ GHQ $PRUDOLVWHQ LVW NHLQ DUJXPHQWDWLYHV .UDXW JHZDFKVHQ ² %HUXKLJHQGHUZHLVH H[LVWLHUW HU KDXSWVlFKOLFK LQ PR UDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ7KHRULHQXQGZRHUVLFKGRFKUHDOLWHU]HLJWNDQQLKP QXU ZRUDXI REHQ EHUHLWV PLW %D\HUW] KLQJHZLHVHQ ZXUGH PLW 3V\FKR WKHUDSLHXQGJHJHEHQHQIDOOVPLWGHU-XVWL]EHJHJQHWZHUGHQ YRQOHW]WHUHU KDW MHGRFK EHUHLWV .DQW HLQH LKUHUVHLWV GHU /HJLWLPDWLRQ EHGUIWLJH =ZDQJVEHIXJQLVDXVJHPDFKW )U HLQHQ 9RUUDQJ GHV 9HUQQIWLJHQ YRU GHP 5DWLRQDOHQ ZHOFKHV OHW]WHUHDXIGLH,FK3HUVSHNWLYHHLQJHVFKUlQNWLVWDUJXPHQWLHUWPLWH[SOL]L WHP5HNXUVDXI.DQWXQG%UDQGRPDXFK3LUPLQ6WHNHOHU:HLWKRIHUZR EHLHUGHQ)RNXVQLFKWVRVHKUDXIGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWYRQSHUV|QOLFKHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQVRQGHUQHKHUDXIGHUHQ0|JOLFKNHLWVEHGLQJXQJHQÅVR]LDO NXOWXUHOOH .RPSHWHQ]HQ XQG GDPLW GLH 7HLOKDEH DQ HLQHU HSLVWHPLVFKHQ :LU*HPHLQVFKDIW´ OHJW Å'DV LQGLYLGXHOOH VWUDWHJLVFKH 'HQNHQ VHW]W QlPOLFK VFKRQ GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW GHU 5HSUlVHQWDWLRQ YRQ =ZHFNHQ GLH $XVZDKO HLQHV OHLWHQGHQ =ZHFNV ]XVDPPHQ PLW GHU %HXUWHLOXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVRSWLRQHQ DOV P|JOLFKH 0LWWHO ]XU =ZHFNYHUIROJXQJ GXUFK GLH LQGLYLGXHOOH3HUVRQYRUDXV'HUUHFKWH8PJDQJPLWH[SOL]LWHQ5HJHOQRGHU 3ULQ]LSLHQVHW]WGLH%HKHUUVFKXQJGHV*HEUDXFKVYRQ5HJHOEHQHQQXQJHQ RGHU )RUPXOLHUXQJHQ GHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ YRUDXV 'HU 0|JOLFKNHLWVUDXP LP VWUDWHJLVFKHQ3ODQHQXQGGLH.ULWHULHQ 1RUPHQ GHUÄULFKWLJHQ¶RGHUÄUDWL RQDOHQ¶ +DQGOXQJVZHLVHQ ]XU (UIOOXQJ YRQ 3UlIHUHQ]HQ VLQG QLFKW HLQ
_____________ ELQGLQJRQXV LWLVOLNHZLVHVROHO\WKURXJKWKHYDOXHRIKDSSLQHVVWKDWPRUH OLPLWHG HQGVDQGKHQFHWKHPHDQVWRWKHPDFTXLUHWKHLUYDOXH7KHUHIRUHWKHWKUHHVSHFLHV RI SUDFWLFDO UHDVRQLQJ VWDQG LQ D GHILQLWH RUGHU RI SULRULW\ 0RUDO UHDVRQLQJ WDNHV SUHFHGHQFH RYHU DQG JRYHUQV SUXGHQWLDO UHDVRQLQJ DQG SUXGHQWLDO UHDVRQLQJ WDNHV SUHFHGHQFHRYHUDQGJRYHUQVLQVWUXPHQWDOUHDVRQLQJ´ :RRGE 9JOREHQ ,Q GHU 5HFKWVOHKUH ILQGHW PDQ GD]X IROJHQGHV .RQGLWLRQDO ÅZHQQ HLQ JHZLVVHU *HEUDXFK GHU )UHLKHLW VHOEVW HLQ +LQGHUQL GHU )UHLKHLW QDFK DOOJHPHLQHQ *HVHW]HQ GLXQUHFKW LVWVRLVWGHU=ZDQJGHUGLHVHPHQWJHJHQJHVHW]WZLUGDOV9HUKLQGHUXQJ HLQHV +LQGHUQLVVHV GHU )UHLKHLW PLW GHU )UHLKHLW QDFK DOOJHPHLQHQ *HVHW]HQ ]XVDP PHQVWLPPHQGGLUHFKW´ .DQW9,
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJHQXQG%HJUQGHQ
IDFKGXUFKGDV,QGLYLGXXPVHOEVWEHVWLPPWVRQGHUQGXUFKHLQH:LVVHQV XQG8UWHLOVJHPHLQVFKDIWGXUFKÄXQV¶´ 8QWHU HLQHU ]XU YRUVWHKHQGHQ $QDO\VH GHU QRUPDWLYHQ .UDIW SUDNWL VFKHU.RKlUHQ]NULWHULHQDQDORJHQGKDXIGLH'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQQLFKW DEWUHQQEDUHQE]ZDEWUHQQEDUHQ.RQNOXVLRQHQLQSUDNWLVFKHQ,QIHUHQ]HQ DEELOGEDUH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ VWUXNWXUHOOHQ XQG PRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJVNRQWH[WHQ EHWRQW )RUVW GLH 3UREOHPDWLVLHUXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJV JUQGHQGXUFKHLQH]ZHLWH3HUVRQ Å(UVWGDGXUFKWULWWGHURGHUGLHhEHU OHJHQGHLQGHQ5DXPLQWHUVXEMHNWLY]XYHUWUHWHQGHU*UQGHHLQGKDOV MHPDQGGHURGHUGLHEHUHLWLVWHLQHQ$QVSUXFKDXIPRUDOLVFKH5LFKWLJNHLW HWZDHLQ]XO|VHQ>@'DV9HUP|JHQ]XSUDNWLVFKYHUQQIWLJHU5HFKWIHUWL JXQJLVWVRPLWIXQGDPHQWDOHUDOVGDV9HUP|JHQ]XUDWLRQDOHU%HJUQGXQJ ZHLOHVGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVGLPHQVLRQGHV+DQGHOQVHLQVFKOLHWGHUOHW]WH UHV OHGLJOLFK DXIUXKW HUVW GLHVHV 9HUP|JHQ HUODXEW HV YRQ DXWRQRPHQ +DQGOXQJHQ]XVSUHFKHQGLHHLQH3HUVRQYRUVLFKXQGDQGHUHQYHUDQWZRUWHQ NDQQ´ 'LH 0|JOLFKNHLW ]XU 3UREOHPDWLVLHUXQJ XQVHUHV +DQGHOQV XQG GDPLWGDV%HWUHWHQGHV5DXPVLQWHUVXEMHNWLY]XYHUWUHWHQGHU*UQGHEH JUQGHW GHPQDFK HLQ Ä$XIUXKHQ¶ GHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW DXI GHU 9HUQQIWLJNHLW HLQHQRWZHQGLJH9HUNQSIXQJGHU3HUVRQDOLWlWPLW,QWHUSHUVRQDOLWlW $XV GHU XPJHNHKUWHQ 3HUVSHNWLYH KDEHQ GLH YRUVWHKHQGHQ $QDO\VHQ JH]HLJW GD GLH $EWUHQQEDUNHLW GHU .RQNOXVLRQ HLQHU SUDNWLVFKHQ IHVWOH JXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ] QRWZHQGLJ PLW GHU QLFKWWULYLDOHQ *OWLJNHLW GHU3UlPLVVHYHUEXQGHQLVWGLHDOVVROFKHGKDXIJUXQGLKUHVSUREOHPD WLVFKHQ&KDUDNWHUVQDFKHLQHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJYHUODQJW'LHVH1LFKW7ULYLDOLWlW GHU *OWLJNHLW HLQHU 3UlPLVVH LVW JOHLFKEHGHXWHQG PLW LKUHU P|JOLFKHQ 3UREOHPDWLVLHUXQJ2GHUDQGHUVJHZHQGHWGLH7ULYLDOLWlWGHU*OWLJNHLWGHU 3UlPLVVH HLQHU SUDNWLVFKHQ IHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ ,QIHUHQ] LVW DQ HLQHQ PRQRORJLVFKHQ XQG GDPLW GHULYDWLYHQ 0RGXV GHV 5HFKWIHUWLJHQV JHEXQ GHQ 8QP|JOLFK VLQG GHUDUWLJH LQWUDSHUVRQHOOHQ %HJUQGXQJHQ HQWODQJ GHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ GDPLW VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK QLFKW ² ZLU VLQG PLW LKQHQ XQG GHU VLH OHLWHQGHQ5DWLRQDOLWlW VFKOLHOLFK QXU DOO]XYHUWUDXW 1XU VLQG VLHHEHQLQJHQDXGHP0DHP|JOLFKDOVHLQ5HGHQ]XVLFKVHOEVWP|JOLFK
_____________ 6WHNHOHU:HLWKRIHUI0LW%OLFNEHUGHQ5DKPHQJHQXLQHU+DQGOXQJVJUQ GH KLQDXV HUZHLWHUW 6WHNHOHU:HLWKRIHU GHQ 3ULPDW GHV Ä:LU¶ QRFK IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å'DKHULVWMHGHVVXEMHNWLYH6LQQYHUVWHKHQ>@VHOEVWVFKRQDOVLPSOL]LWH7HLOQDKPHDQ HLQHPNRRSHUDWLYHQ+DQGOXQJVUDKPHQ]XEHJUHLIHQXQGNDQQGDKHUQLFKWHLQIDFKDOV XQHUNOlUWH 9RUDXVVHW]XQJ MHGHU )RUP JHPHLQVDPHQ XQG LQGLYLGXHOOHQ +DQGHOQV XQ WHUVWHOOWZHUGHQ6RJDUVFKRQMHGHVÄ0HLQHQ¶LVWLQJHZLVVHP6LQQÄ7HLOQDKPH¶DQHLQHU :LU+DQGOXQJZHQQZLUQlPOLFKEHDFKWHQGDLQQHUH5HGHQDOV5ROOHQVSLHOHJHOHUQW ZHUGHQZHOFKHGLHNRPSHWHQWH7HLOQDKPHDQHLQHU|IIHQWOLFKHQ3UD[LVIRUPLQlKQOL FKHU:HLVHYRUDXVVHW]HQZLHGDVOHLVH/HVHQGDVODXWH6SUHFKHQ´ (EGI )RUVW EI +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
LVW QlPOLFK DOV GHULYDWLYHU 0RGXV VR]LDOHU .RPPXQLNDWLRQ XQG QLFKW DOV SULYDWVSUDFKOLFKHV)XQGDPHQWXQVHUHUVR]LDOHQ6SUDFKOLFKNHLW (LQH %UFNH YRQ GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV ]X GHUHQ VXEVWDQWLHOOHQ PRUDOLVFKHQ,PSOLNDWLRQHQOlWVLFKGDQDFKIROJHQGHUPDHQVFKODJHQ $OV Ä=ZHFN¶XQGQLFKWQXUDOVÄ0LWWHO¶EHWUDFKWHQZLUVR)RUVW:HVHQGHQHQ ZLU HLQ Å5HFKW DXI 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ´ ]XVFKUHLEHQ HLQ Å5HFKW DOV PRUDOL VFKH3HUVRQJHDFKWHW]XZHUGHQGLH]XPLQGHVWLQGHP6LQQHDXWRQRPLVW GDVLHQLFKWDXIHLQH:HLVHEHKDQGHOWZHUGHQGDUIIUGLHLKUQLFKWDQ JHPHVVHQH *UQGH JHOLHIHUW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ hEHU GLH Ä$QJHPHVVHQKHLW¶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´ 'DPLW LVW QLFKW JHVDJW GD ZLU VWHWV QDFK GHUDUW YHUQQIWLJHQ RGHU SUlYDOHQWHQ*UQGHQKDQGHOQZUGHQVROFKHQDOVRGLH]XU$EWUHQQEDU NHLWGHU.RQNOXVLRQLQHLQHUSUDNWLVFKHQIHVWOHJXQJVHUKDOWHQGHQ,QIHUHQ] IKUHQ XQG GDPLW FHWHULV SDULEXV IU MHGHUPDQQ JHOWHQ =ZLVFKHQ GHU )HVWOHJXQJ DXI HLQH +DQGOXQJ E]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWXQG GHU $QHUNHQ QXQJ GLHVHU )HVWOHJXQJ NDQQ ² ZLH GDV 3KlQRPHQ GHU :LOOHQVVFKZlFKH DEHUQLFKWQXUGLHVHVVRQGHUQDXFKDOOH)RUPHQPRUDOLVFKHU.RUUXSWLRQ EHZHLVHQ²HLQZHLWHU:HJOLHJHQZHVKDOEGLH0RWLYDWLRQ]XHLQHUVROFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJHLQHUHLJHQVWlQGLJHQ7KHPDWLVLHUXQJEHGDUI .DQWKDWKLHU EHL PXWDWLV PXWDQGLV YRQ +DQGHOQ DXV $FKWXQJ IUV *HVHW] JHVSUR FKHQ'DPLWLVWDXFKQLFKWJHVDJWGDGLHVH*UQGHÄDEVROXWH¶*OWLJ NHLW EHVlHQ RGHU JHJHQEHU DQGHUHQ *UQGHQ RQWRORJLVFK ZLH DXFK LPPHUDXVJH]HLFKQHWZlUHQ'DPLWLVWOHGLJOLFKJHVDJWGDZLUXQWHUGHU 9RUDXVVHW]XQJGDZLUDP6SLHOGHV9HUODQJHQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQ GHQ WHLOQHKPHQ DXI GLH /LHIHUXQJ GHU JHIRUGHUWHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ $QGH UHQJHJHQEHUIHVWJHOHJWVLQG'LHVHV(UNHQQHQXQG$QHUNHQQHQGHU$QGH UHQ DOV HEHQEUWLJH7HLOQHKPHU DP 6SLHO GHV )RUGHUQVXQG /LHIHUQV YRQ
_____________ 9JO]X:LWWJHQVWHLQV$UJXPHQWDWLRQJHJHQ3ULYDWVSUDFKHQVHLQH3KLORVRSKLVFKH8QWHUVX FKXQJHQLQVEHV )RUVW DI 9JOGD]XXQWHQ.DS
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJHQXQG%HJUQGHQ
*UQGHQPDFKW GLH ÅLPSOLFLWO\ XQGHUWDNHQ FRPPLWPHQWV´ DXV GLH %UDQ GRPDOVDXV]XZHLVHQGH%HGLQJXQJGDIUDQJHJHEHQKDWGDGLHYRQLKP HQWZRUIHQHQRUPDWLYH3UDJPDWLNPLWHLQHU.RQ]HSWLRQSUlYDOHQWHU+DQG OXQJVJUQGHYHUEXQGHQZHUGHQNDQQGKREXQGLQZLHIHUQÅ>«@SOD\LQJ WKH JDPH RI JLYLQJ DQG DVNLQJ IRU UHDVRQV FRXOG EH VKRZQ LPSOLFLWO\ WR LQYROYHXQGHUWDNLQJFRPPLWPHQWVWRUHFRJQL]LQJIHOORZSUDFWLWLRQHUVDQG WRWUHDWLQJWKHPLQVRPHZD\VUDWKHUWKDQRWKHUV>«@µ 'LH3RLQWHEHVWHKWQXQGDULQGD%UDQGRPV)RUGHUXQJLQHLQHUJH ZLVVHQ +LQVLFKW HQWWlXVFKW XQG LQ HLQHU DQGHUHQ HUIOOW ZLUG $XV GHP %HJULII GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV ODVVHQ VLFK NHLQH PRUDOLVFKHQ 1RUPHQ GHGX]LHUHQ G K HV LVW ZLH )RUVW DXVIKUW Å>«@ QLFKW YRUKHUEHVWLPPW ZHOFKH VXEVWDQWLHOOHQ *UQGH DQJHPHVVHQ VLQG ZHOFKH 5HFKWH JHIRUGHUW ZHUGHQRGHUZHOFKH,QVWLWXWLRQHQRGHUVR]LDOHQ9HUKlOWQLVVHJHUHFKWIHUWLJW ZHUGHQN|QQHQ$OVXQLYHUVDOHU.HUQHLQHUMHGHQLQWHUQHQ0RUDOEHUOlW GDV5HFKWDXI5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGLHVGHQ0LWJOLHGHUQEHVWLPPWHUNXOWXUHOOHU RGHUVR]LDOHU.RQWH[WH´(VLVWHLQNODUHVQRQVHTXLWXUDXVGHU7HLOQDKPH DP6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQEHLVSLHOVZHLVHDEOHLWHQ ]X ZROOHQ GD GLH 0HLQXQJV XQG 5HGHIUHLKHLW QLFKW HLQJHVFKUlQNW ZHU GHQGUIWHGD/JHXQG7lXVFKXQJYHUERWHQZlUHQRGHUGD0HQVFKHQ QLFKW JHW|WHW ZHUGHQ GUIWHQ :LH VLFK REHQ LQ $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW 6FDQORQV.RQ]HSWLRQGHVVHQZDVZLUHLQDQGHUVFKXOGHQJH]HLJWKDWVLQG GHUDUWLJH ÄDEVROXWH¶ 1RUPHQ LQVRIHUQ XQJOWLJ DOV .RQWH[WH YRUVWHOOEDU VLQGGLHLKUH=XUFNZHLVXQJYHUQQIWLJHUVFKHLQHQODVVHQN|QQHQ 'RFKZHUVLFKDXIGDV6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQ HLQOlW LVW GDPLW DXI HLQH NRQWH[WJHUHFKWH 7HLOQDKPH DQ GLHVHP 6SLHO IHVWJHOHJW QXUGLHVH)HVWOHJXQJHUP|JOLFKWHVIHKOHQGH.RQWH[WVHQVLELOLWlW ²VHLHVGXUFK0LYHUVWlQGQLV%|VDUWLJNHLWRGHUZHOFKH$UWYRQ.RPPX QLNDWLRQVVW|UXQJ DXFK LPPHU EHGLQJW ² DOV VROFKH IHVW]XVWHOOHQ XQG ]X NULWLVLHUHQ1LFKWQXUGLH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVDOV([SOL]LHUXQJ.ULWLVLH UXQJ XQG 9HUWHLGLJXQJ YRQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ XQG %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ ]X )HVWOH
_____________ %UDQGRPE1LFKWXQWHU5HNXUVDXI%UDQGRPVRQGHUQLQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW ]XQJPLW+RQQHWK IKUW)RUVW]XPSUDNWLVFKHQ $Q (UNHQQHQ)ROJHQGHVDXV Å(VJLEWLQSUDNWLVFKHQ.RQWH[WHQNHLQUHLQHVÄ(UNHQQHQ¶DQGHUHUGDVQLFKWDXFKHLQ $QHUNHQQHQ LQ ZHOFKHU )RUP DXFK LPPHU ZlUH )U GLH 0RUDO KHLW GDV GDVV GLH PRUDOLVFKH3HUVRQQLFKWHLQHQ0HQVFKHQVLHKWXQGGDQQXQWHU+LQ]XQDKPHZHLWHUHU hEHUOHJXQJHQ ]X GHP 6FKOXVV NRPPW GLHV VHL HLQH DQGHUH PRUDOLVFKH 3HUVRQ´ )RUVW ,QGHUKLHU YRUJHVFKODJHQHQGHRQWLVFKHQ7HUPLQRORJLHKDQGHOWHV VLFK EHL GLHVHU JUXQGOHJHQGHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ DOOJHPHLQ PLQGHVWHQV HLQHUVHLWV XP GLH =XZHLVXQJHLQHU%HUHFKWLJXQJ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQDXISHUV|QOLFKHSUDNWLVFKH(LQVWHOOXQ JHQDQGLHVHDQGHUHQ:HVHQVRZLHDQGHUHUVHLWVGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHU)HVWOHJXQJDXI 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGHUHLJHQHQSHUV|QOLFKHQSUDNWLVFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQJHJHQEHUGLHVHQ :HVHQ )RUVW D
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
JXQJHQ VRQGHUQ GDV )XQNWLRQLHUHQ MHJOLFKHU DOVR DXFK GHU QLFKW DUJXPHQWDWLYHQ .RPPXQLNDWLRQ LVW HLQH )ROJH DXV GHU $GlTXDWKHLW YRQ H[SOL]LWHQ G K GLVNXUVLYHQ RGHU LPSOL]LWHQ G K SUDJPDWLVFK EHGHXWXQJVYROOHQ=JHQLQGLHVHP6SLHO'DV9HUVWlQGQLVGHVMHZHLOLJHQ .RQWH[WHVUHVXOWLHUWDXVEHUHLWVHLQJHJDQJHQHQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG]XJHZLH VHQHQ %HUHFKWLJXQJHQ GDV 9HUVWlQGQLV GHV MHZHLOLJHQ .RQWH[WHV ]LHKW DEHUDXFKEHVWLPPWH)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQQDFKVLFKXQGLVW PLW ZLHGHUXP DQGHUHQ LQNRPSDWLEHO 8P GLHV ]X EHKDXSWHQ PX PDQ VLFKQLFKWEHUHLWVDXIHLQHKROLVWLVFKHGKÄGXUFKXQGGXUFK¶LQIHUHQWLD OLVWLVFKH 6HPDQWLN IHVWOHJHQ HV JHQJW EHUHLWV GLH $N]HSWDQ] GHU 8Q P|JOLFKNHLWYRQ3ULYDWVSUDFKHQGKGHU KLHUYRUDXVJHVHW]WHQ SULQ]LSLHO OHQ 6R]LDOLWlW ² XQG GDV EHGHXWHW HEHQ .RQWH[WDEKlQJLJNHLW ² GHU .RPPXQLNDWLRQ 'LH(UIOOXQJYRQ%UDQGRPV)RUGHUXQJQDFKHLQHP.RPSDWLELOLWlWV DXVZHLV VHLQHV PRUDOLQYDULDQWHQ GHRQWLVFKHQ .RQWRIKUXQJVPRGHOOV EH ]JOLFKSHUV|QOLFKHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQHLQHUVHLWVXQGHLQHU.RQ]HSWLRQSUlYD OHQWHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH DQGHUHUVHLWV OlW VLFK GHPQDFK IROJHQGHUPDHQ IRUPXOLHUHQ :HUVLFKDXIGDVQRUPDWLYH6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQV YRQ*UQGHQHLQOlWKDWGDPLWLSVRIDFWRVHLQHLJHQHVXQGGDV5HFKWGHU $QGHUHQDXI5HFKWIHUWLJXQJDQHUNDQQWXQGJHUDGHGLHVH$QHUNHQQXQJLVW GHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH6FKULWWDXIGHP:HJ]XUNRQWH[WUHODWLYHQ$XVHLQDQGHU VHW]XQJEHUPRUDOLVFKH1RUPHQ QXUEHUGLHVH$QHUNHQQXQJNDQQGHU 'LVNXUV ]X 3ULQ]LSLHQ IKUHQ GLH YRQ NHLQHP GHU %HWHLOLJWHQ YHUQQIWL JHUZHLVH G K UH]LSURNDOOJHPHLQ ]XUFNJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ 'LH 5HJHOQ GLHVHV 6SLHOV JHOWHQ IU XQV QLFKW LQ JOHLFKHU :HLVH ZLH ZLU GHQ *HVHW]HQGHU1DWXUXQWHUZRUIHQVLQG6LHJHOWHQQXUZHQQZLUVLHDQHU NHQQHQ G K ZHQQ ZLU VHOEVW ]X H[SOL]LWHQ RGHU LPSOL]LWHQ 6SLHO]JHQ EHUHLWVLQG'RFKLVWGLHVHVÄ6SLHO¶DXFKQLFKWHLQ6SLHOZLHDQGHUHYLHO PHKULVWGDV)RUGHUQXQG/LHIHUQYRQ*UQGHQ²ZLHLPSOL]LWRGHUH[SOL ]LWYHUEDORGHUQRQYHUEDODXFKLPPHU²HLQJUXQGOHJHQGHV.HQQ]HLFKHQ
_____________ 9JO]%%UDQGRPI 9JO GD]X DXFK %UDQGRP D I GHU LP =XVDPPHQKDQJ VHLQHU .DQW 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ YJO .DQW ,9 JHOWHQG PDFKW Å1LFKW GLH 5HJHO RGHU 1RUP VHOEVW YHUDQODW XQVHU +DQGHOQ VRQGHUQ GLH 7DWVDFKH GD ZLU VLH DQHUNHQQHQ ,Q GHU 5HODWLRQ]ZLVFKHQUHLQQDWUOLFKHQ*HJHQVWlQGHQXQGGHQVLHEHKHUUVFKHQGHQ5HJHOQ IHKOWHVDQHLQHUVROFKHQLQWHUYHQLHUHQGHQ(LQVWHOOXQJ>«@'DV%HVRQGHUHDQXQVLVW GLH $UW GHV (UIDVVHQV RGHU $XIQHKPHQV QRUPDWLYHU 6LJQLILNDQ] ]X GHP ZLU LQ GHU /DJHVLQG,QGLHVHP6LQQHHLQHUYRQÄXQV¶]XVHLQKHLW6XEMHNWQRUPDWLYHU(LQVWHOOXQ JHQ ]X VHLQ KHLW 5LFKWLJNHLWHQ XQG 8QULFKWLJNHLWHQ YRQ 9HUKDOWHQVZHLVHQ DQHUNHQ QHQ]XN|QQHQ KHLWHLQH3HUIRUPDQ]DOVULFKWLJRGHUXQULFKWLJEHKDQGHOQ]XN|Q QHQ´ 9JO ]XU GLHVEH]JOLFKHQ &KDUDNWHULVLHUXQJ GHU 'LVNXUVVXEMHNWH DOV 0LWJOLHGHU HLQHU ÅHUVWUHFNXQJVLQGHILQLWH>Q@ *HPHLQVFKDIW WUDQV]HQGHQWDOHU ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW´ 1LTXHW KLHU
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJHQXQG%HJUQGHQ
XQVHUHU)RUPYRQ6R]LDOLWlW'DVIU:HVHQGLHÄ:LU¶VDJHQN|QQHQZH VHQWOLFKH6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQEHLQKDOWHWGDPLW HLQH)HVWOHJXQJGLHGLH6SLHOHUTXD7HLOQHKPHUDQGLHVHP6SLHOHLQJHJDQ JHQVLQGQlPOLFKGDV=XZHLVHQHLQHU)HVWOHJXQJDXIHLQH+DQGOXQJE]Z +DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWGHUHQ$QHUNHQQXQJQLFKWYRUDXVJHVHW]WZHUGHQNDQQ NRQWH[WUHODWLY G K JHJHQEHU DOOHQ %HWHLOLJWHQ DOVR GHQ 3HUVRQHQ GLH YRQGHU)HVWOHJXQJRGHUGHUHQ.RQVHTXHQ]HQEHWURIIHQVLQGDOVEHUHFK WLJW DXV]XZHLVHQ (UVW DXIJUXQG GLHVHV $XVZHLVHV GHU GLH (LQEH]LHKXQJ NRQIOLJLHUHQGHU SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQ LQ GLH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV YHUODQJW NDQQ GHU HQWVSUHFKHQGH +DQGOXQJVJUXQG EHUKDXSW HUVW GRPL QLHUHQGHQ &KDUDNWHU XQG GDV GDKLQWHU VWHKHQGH 3ULQ]LS GLH NDWHJRULVFKH 9HUELQGOLFKNHLWHLQHUPRUDOLVFKHQ1RUPHUKDOWHQ 'LH.RQWH[WUHODWLYLWlWYRQGHUKLHUGLH5HGHLVWEHVDJW²XQGGLHVVHL KLHU EHVRQGHUV EHWRQW ² GD GDV 6SLHO GHV )RUGHUQV XQG /LHIHUQV YRQ *UQGHQQLFKWVHOEVWEHUHLWVYRQPRUDOLVFKHQ5HJHOQEHVWLPPWZLUG GHU 6WDQGSXQNWGHU9HUQQIWLJNHLWLVWQLFKWJOHLFKEHGHXWHQGPLWHLQHU6XPPH PRUDOLVFKHU 1RUPHQ GLH DXV GLHVHP ² lKQOLFK GHU VSHNWUDOHQ =HUOHJXQJ GHV/LFKWVEHLP'XUFKJDQJGXUFKGDV3ULVPD²VFKOLFKWDQDO\VLHUWZHUGHQ N|QQWHQ 6LH EHGUIHQ YLHOPHKU HLQHU DNWXDOHQ (LQJDEH SHUV|QOLFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJHQLQGHQ'LVNXUV
_____________ 9JO ]X HLQHP VROFKHQ GLVNXUVHWKLVFKHQ .XU]VFKOX EHLVSLHOVZHLVH .HOOHUZHVVHO Å=XQlFKVW ZLUG XQWHU HLQHP 'LVNXUV GDVMHQLJH VSUDFKOLFKH 0HGLXP YHUVWDQGHQ LQ QHUKDOE GHVVHQ $UJXPHQWLHUHQ %HVWUHLWHQ XQG %HJUQGHQ VWDWWILQGHQ N|QQHQ ´ .HOOHUZHVVHO Å)HVW]XKDOWHQLVWELVKLHUKHUÄGDGHUMHQLJHGHU%HKDXSWXQ JHQ XQG %HJUQGXQJHQ YRUQLPPW VLFK QRWZHQGLJ DXI HLQ 6SLHO HLQOlW GDV GXUFK 'LVNXUVUHJHOQ GHILQLHUW LVW¶´ (EG Å'LH *UXQGLGHH GLHVHU GLVNXUVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ 1RUPHQEHJUQGXQJ ]LHOW GDUDXI DE GD ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ 'LVNXUVUHJHOQ XQG GHP (LQ KDOWHQYRQHLQLJHQ*UXQGQRUPHQGXUFKDXV%H]LHKXQJHQEHVWHKHQGLHQLFKWNRQWLQ JHQWVLQG9LHOPHKUVLQGHLQLJHGLHVHU1RUPHQE]ZLKUH(LQKDOWXQJQRWZHQGLJH%H GLQJXQJHQ IU GDV $FKWHQ GHU 'LVNXUVUHJHOQ :HUGHQ MHQH JUXQGOHJHQGHQ 1RUPHQ YHUOHW]W ZHUGHQ SHU VH GLH ]X DN]HSWLHUHQGHQ 5HJHOQ GHV 'LVNXUVHV JOHLFKHUPDHQ YHUOHW]W´ (EG Å 'LH(UPRUGXQJHLQHV'LVNXUVWHLOQHKPHUV>«@ 'LH9HUHL WHOXQJIUHLHU:DKOYRQ6SUHFKDNWHQVHLWHQV'LVNXUVWHLOQHKPHUQGXUFK(LQJULIIHLQGH UHQ,QWHJULWlWE]Z$XWRQRPLH>«@ 5HFKWDXI0HLQXQJVXQG5HGHIUHLKHLW/JHQ XQG 7lXVFKXQJVYHUERW´ (EG 'LH SKLORVRSKLVFKH %HVWLPPXQJ GHUDUWLJHU ÄQLFKWNRQWLQJHQWHU %H]LHKXQJHQ¶ ]ZLVFKHQ 'LVNXUVUHJHOQ XQG PRUDOLVFKHQ 1RUPHQ NDQQMHGRFKLQVRIHUQQLFKWEHU]HXJHQDOVGLHQRUPDWLYH.UDIWRGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLW PRUDOLVFKHU1RUPHQVHOEVWQLFKWDSULRULIHVWVWHKWVRQGHUQVLFKJHUDGHLP6SLHOGHV )RUGHUQV XQG /LHIHUQV YRQ *UQGHQ NRQVWLWXWLHUW *HJHQ GLH 9RUVWHOOXQJ HLQHU VRO FKHQ$EOHLWEDUNHLWGHUHQ:XU]HOQLQ$SHOV7UDQV]HQGHQWDOSUDJPDWLNOLHJHQ YJOEH UHLWV$SHO KDW+DEHUPDV IUHLQH(EHQHQGLIIHUHQ]LHUXQJDUJX PHQWLHUW Å(LQH PRUDOLVFKH 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW NDQQ VLFK DXV GHU JOHLFKVDP WUDQV]HQGHQWDOHQ 1|WLJXQJ XQYHUPHLGOLFKHU $UJXPHQWDWLRQVYRUDXVVHW]XQJHQ DOOHLQH QLFKWHUJHEHQ VLHKDIWHWYLHOPHKUGHQVSH]LHOOHQ*HJHQVWlQGHQGHVSUDNWLVFKHQ'LV NXUVHVDQ²GHQLQLKQHLQJHIKUWHQ1RUPHQDXIGLHVLFKGLHLQGHU%HUDWXQJPRELOLVLHU
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVXQG5HDOLVPXV²*OWLJNHLWXQG *HOWXQJ
'LHIXQGDPHQWDOH%HGHXWXQJGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVDOV/HJLWLPDWLRQV RUWPRUDOLVFKHU1RUPHQEULQJWHVPLWVLFKGDGLHÄ5HDOLWlW¶GLHVHU1RU PHQE]ZGHUGDUDXVUHVXOWLHUHQGHQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHHUVWGXUFKGLHRGHU LQGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJNRQVWLWXLHUWZLUGHLQH$QVLFKWDXIGLH6FDQORQVHLQH .RQ]HSWLRQ GHVVHQ ZDV ZLU HLQDQGHU VFKXOGHQ QLFKW IHVWJHOHJW VHKHQ ZLOO6FDQORQV3RVLWLRQVFKHLQWHLQHEHVWLPPWH)RUPYRQ5HDOLVPXV]X LPSOL]LHUHQ PLQGHVWHQVDEHU]XEHJQVWLJHQ LQVRIHUQHUGDYRQDXVJHKW GD8UWHLOHEHU*UQGHZDKURGHUIDOVFKVHLQN|QQHQ:RULQGLHVHVÄVHLQ¶ MHGRFK EHVWHKW ZLUG YRQ LKP QLFKW ZHLWHU HUOlXWHUW (LQHV LVW MHGRFK DXFK QDFK 6FDQORQ DXVJHVFKORVVHQ Å7KH TXHVWLRQ Ä:KDW LV D UHDVRQ"¶ LV PLVOHDGLQJLQVRIDUDVLWVXJJHVWVWKDWUHDVRQVDUHDVSHFLDORQWRORJLFDOFODVV :KDWLVVSHFLDODERXWUHDVRQVLVQRWWKHRQWRORJLFDOFDWHJRU\RIWKLQJVWKDW FDQ EH UHDVRQV EXW UDWKHU WKH VWDWXV RI EHLQJ D UHDVRQ >«@ 7KH WKLQJV WKDWDUHUHDVRQVDUH>«@WKHVDPHNLQGRIWKLQJVWKDWFDQEHWKHFRQWHQWV RIEHOLHIV²SURSRVLWLRQVRQHPLJKWVD\µ,QVRIHUQ8UWHLOHEHU+DQG OXQJVJUQGHMHGRFKZDKURGHUIDOVFKVHLQN|QQHQEHGDUIHV.ULWHULHQGLH ,UUWPHUDOVVROFKHDXVZHLVHQODVVHQ Å>«@LQRUGHUIRUMXGJPHQWVDERXW UHDVRQVWREHWDNHQWREHDERXWVRPHVXEMHFWPDWWHULQGHSHQGHQWRIXVLQ WKHVHQVHUHTXLUHGIRULWWREHSRVVLEOHIRUXVWREHPLVWDNHQDERXWWKHP ZKDWLVQHFHVVDU\LVIRUWKHUHWREHVWDQGDUGVIRUDUULYLQJDWFRQFOXVLRQV DERXW UHDVRQV &RQFOXVLRQV DERXW UHDVRQV WKDW FDQ EH UHDFKHG RQO\ WKURXJKPRGHVRIWKRXJKWWKDWDUHGHIHFWLYHE\WKHVHVWDQGDUGVDUHPLV WDNHQ>«@,WQHHGQRWEHDPHWDSK\VLFDOTXHVWLRQDERXWZKDWH[LVWVRUDQ HSLVWHPRORJLFDORQHDERXWKRZZHDUHLQWRXFKZLWKLWµ8PHLQHQUR EXVWHQ 5HDOLVPXV ZLH DXFK 6FDQORQ LKQ GDPLW DEOHKQW ]X YHUPHLGHQ
_____________ WHQ *UQGH EH]LHKHQ´ 9JO GD]X EHUHLWV +DEHUPDV VRZLH +DEHUPDV (V LVW GXUFKDXV HLQ 'LVNXUV HLQH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV YRU VWHOOEDU EHNDQQWOLFKDXFKLQUHFKWVWDDWOLFKHQ'HPRNUDWLHQ GHUHQ(UJHEQLVEHLVSLHOV ZHLVH GLH (LQVFKUlQNXQJ GHV 5HFKWV DXI IUHLH 0HLQXQJVlXHUXQJ LVW XQG XQWHU H[ WUHPHQ8PVWlQGHQVRJDUGHQ7RGYRQ0HQVFKHQLQ.DXIQLPPW 9JOGD]XDXFK+DEHUPDV I 9JOGD]XDXFKREHQ 'LHYRQ6FDQORQQDKHJHOHJWH)RUPYRQJHOWXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHP*UQGHUHDOLVPXVLVWLQ MHGHP)DOO]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ YRQ HLQHP:HUWHUHDOLVPXVZLHLKQJHJHQZlUWLJSURPL QHQWHUZHLVH5D]YHUWULWW YJOGD]XREHQ)Q 6FDQORQ I 6FDQORQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVXQG5HDOLVPXV²*OWLJNHLWXQG*HOWXQJ
VFKHLQWHVPLUVLQQYROO]XVHLQGLH6WDQGDUGVGHU5LFKWLJNHLWYRQ8UWHL OHQ EHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH DOV LQ GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV HQWKDOWHQ ]X EHWUDFKWHQ 5LFKWLJH 8UWHLOH EH]JOLFK SUlYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH VLQG GDV5HVXOWDWGHVSULQ]LSLHOO|IIHQWOLFKHQ6SLHOVGHV3URGX]LHUHQVXQG.RQ VXPLHUHQV YRQ *UQGHQ GHVVHQ LGHDOHU =LHOSXQNW GDGXUFK JHNHQQ]HLFK QHW LVW GD HU DXVVFKOLHOLFK QLFKW UH]LSURNDOOJHPHLQ ]XUFNZHLVEDUH 3ULQ]LSLHQ PDUNLHUW HLQH ZHLWHUUHLFKHQGH 9RUDEEHVWLPPXQJ LVW QXU LP :LGHUVSUXFK]XGLHVHU5H]LSUR]LWlWXQG$OOJHPHLQKHLWGHU*OWLJNHLWGHU (UJHEQLVVHGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]HVVHVP|JOLFK 'LHVH LGHDOLVLHUHQGH Ä9HUIOVVLJXQJ¶ GHU 2EMHNWLYLWlW SUlYDOHQWHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH PHLQW +DEHUPDV ZHQQ HU GDV ÅPHUNZUGLJH -DQXVJH VLFKW XQEHGLQJWHU *HOWXQJVDQVSUFKH´ EHVFKUHLEW Å$OV $QVSUFKH VLQG GLHVHDXILQWHUVXEMHNWLYH$QHUNHQQXQJDQJHOHJW GDUXPNDQQGLH|IIHQWOL FKH $XWRULWlW HLQHV XQWHU %HGLQJXQJHQ GHV 1HLQVDJHQN|QQHQV GLVNXUVLY HU]LHOWHQ.RQVHQVHVOHW]WOLFKQLFKWGXUFKGLHSULYDWH(LQVLFKW GHVEHVVHU ZLVVHQGHQ (LQ]HOQHQ VXEVWLWXLHUW ZHUGHQ $OV $QVSUFKH DXI XQEHGLQJWH *HOWXQJZHLVHQVLHDEHUEHUMHGHVIDNWLVFKHU]LHOWH(LQYHUVWlQGQLVKLQDXV :DVKLHUXQGKHXWHDOVUDWLRQDODN]HSWLHUWZLUGNDQQVLFKXQWHUEHVVHUHQ HSLVWHPLVFKHQ%HGLQJXQJHQYRUHLQHPDQGHUHQ3XEOLNXPXQGJHJHQEHU NQIWLJHQ(LQZlQGHQDOVIDOVFKKHUDXVVWHOOHQ'LHVHP-DQXVJHVLFKWXQEH GLQJWHU*HOWXQJVDQVSUFKHZLUGHLQH'LVNXVVLRQQXUXQWHUGHULGHDOLVLHUHQ GHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJJHUHFKWGDVVDOOHUHOHYDQWHQ*UQGHXQG,QIRUPDWLRQHQ GLHEHUKDXSWHUUHLFKEDUVLQG]XP=XJHNRPPHQ0LWGLHVHUVWHLOHQ,GHD OLVLHUXQJEHJHJQHWGHUHQGOLFKH*HLVWGHUWUDQV]HQGHQWDOHQ(LQVLFKWLQGLH
_____________ 0LWGHU9HUZHQGXQJGHV%HJULIIVGHU5LFKWLJNHLWGHUGHQ*HOWXQJVDQVSUXFKKLQVLFKW OLFK 6SUDFK +DQGOXQJHQ]XU+HUVWHOOXQJYRQLQWHUSHUVRQDOHQ%H]LHKXQJHQEH]HLFK QHWLP*HJHQVDW]]XP%HJULIIGHU:DKUKHLWGHUVLFKDXIGLH'DUVWHOOXQJYRQ6DFK YHUKDOWHQ EH]LHKW IROJH LFK +DEHUPDV· XQLYHUVDOSUDJPDWLVFKHP 6SUDFKPRGHOO GDUJHVWHOOWXDLQ+DEHUPDV hEHU GLH NRQNUHWH GHPRNUDWLVFKH $XVJHVWDOWXQJ GLHVHV 3UR]HVVHV GHV )RUGHUQV XQG /LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQLVWGDPLWQRFKQLFKWVDXVJHPDFKWGRFKVFKHLQWPLUGLHVEH]J OLFKZHQLJVWHQVHLQH9RUHQWVFKHLGXQJEHUHLWVJHWURIIHQ]XVHLQ(VVWLPPWEHLGHV HV LVWVRZRKOGHU)DOOGD$QWZRUWHQDXI)UDJHQZLHZLUGHPRNUDWLVFKLQWHUDJLHUHQVROO WHQULFKWLJRGHUIDOVFK VHLQN|QQHQMHQDFKGHPZHOFKHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]HVLH GXUFKODXIHQKDEHQDOVDXFKGDGHUHQ5LFKWLJNHLWXQDEKlQJLJYRQGHQWDWVlFKOLFKHQ (UJHEQLVVHQ GLHVHV 3UR]HVVHV EHVWLPPEDU VHLQ NDQQ 'LHV LVW QXU GDGXUFK P|JOLFK GDGLH6WUXNWXUHQGLHVHV3UR]HVVHVVHOEVWHLQH)RUPEHVLW]HQGLHVLHJHHLJQHWPDFKW ]XU 5LFKWLJNHLW HQWVSUHFKHQGHU 8UWHLOH ]X IKUHQ GHU GHPRNUDWLVFKH 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVSUR]H VSLHOW DOVR HLQH ZHVHQWOLFKH 5ROOH EHL GHU )LQGXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVQRU PHQ XQG HU LVW ]XJOHLFK 6WDQGDUGV XQWHUZRUIHQ GLH VHOEVW XQDEKlQJLJ YRQ GLHVHP 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]HVLQG9JO]XGHQ(LQ]HOKHLWHQGLHVHUNRQNUHWHQLQVWLWXWLRQHQ EH]RJHQHQ$UJXPHQWDWLRQ&RKHQ (VWOXQG XQG5L FKDUGVRQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
XQKLQWHUJHKEDUH%HJUQGXQJYRQ2EMHNWLYLWlWLQVSUDFKOLFKHU,QWHUVXEMHN WLYLWlW´ &ULVWLQD/DIRQWKDWQXQLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJGHQ(LQZDQGYHU WLHIWGD5HFKWIHUWLJXQJQLFKWVFKRQ5LFKWLJNHLWEHGHXWH:HQQPDQPLW %OLFNDXI+DQGOXQJVJUQGHHLQHQ.RJQLWLYLVPXVYHUWULWWGDQQLVWPDQVR /DIRQWDXIHLQH)RUPYRQPRUDOLVFKHP5HDOLVPXVIHVWJHOHJW'DLP9RU VWHKHQGHQQXQHLQHUVHLWVHLQHNRJQLWLYLVWLVFKH3RVLWLRQEH]RJHQXQGDQGH UHUVHLWV HLQ PRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHU 5HDOLVPXV DEJHOHKQW ZXUGH VFKHLQHQ /DIRQWV (LQZlQGH KLHU HLQVFKOlJLJ ]X VHLQ *HJHQ +DEHUPDV· 'LVNXUV HWKLN DOV HLQH )RUP YRQ .RJQLWLYLVPXV ² /DIRQW VFKOLHW LQ LKUH .ULWLN H[SOL]LWDOOH)RUPHQYRQ.DQWLDQLVPXVUHVSHNWLYH.RJQLWLYLVPXVHLQ² ZHQGHW /DIRQW GDKHU HLQ Å:HQQ >«@ JOHLFKHUPDHQ LP JHPHLQVDPHQ ,QWHUHVVHDOOHU%HWURIIHQHQ]XVHLQEHGHXWHWGDV(UJHEQLVGLVNXUVLYHU9HU VWlQGLJXQJGHU%HWURIIHQHQ]XVHLQGDQQZHUGHQVREDOGGLH%HWURIIHQHQ IDNWLVFKEHVFKORVVHQKDEHQDXIZHOFKH1RUPHQVLHVLFKHLQLJHQZROOHQ.ULWLN XQG 5HYLVLRQ GLHVHU 1RUPHQ ]X VLQQORVHQ 8QWHUQHKPXQJHQ´ 'LHV VFKHLQWPLUHLQHUVHLWVULFKWLJ ZHQQJOHLFKQLFKWSUREOHPDWLVFK ]XVHLQXQG DQGHUHUVHLWV GLH 2IIHQKHLW JHJHQEHU .ULWLN YRQ DQGHUHQ 6WDQGSXQNWHQ DXV ]X XQWHUVFKODJHQ ZREHL EHL ZHLWHUHU .ULWLN HEHQ JHZlKUOHLVWHW VHLQ PXGDVLHJOHLFKIDOOVYRQHLQHPEHWURIIHQHQ6WDQGSXQNWDXVIRUPXOLHUW ZLUG .ULWLN YRQ HLQHP QLFKWEHWURIIHQHQ 6WDQGSXQNW DXV VFKHLQW PLU VLQQORV]XVHLQXQG]ZDUQLFKWLP6LQQHYRQÄYHUJHEOLFK¶ZLHLKQ/DIRQW LQWHQGLHUWVRQGHUQVLQQORVLQGHP6LQQHGDVLHVFKOLFKWQLFKWV]XPYHU KDQGHOWHQ7KHPDEHLWUlJWXQGGLHVHVGDPLWYHUIHKOW/DIRQWYHUODQJWGDPLW HLQHUVHLWV ]X YLHO XQG DQGHUHUVHLWV ]X ZHQLJ ,Q GHU 7DW Å>«@ ZHQQ GDV 9HUIDKUHQ 5DXP IU ,UUWPHU OlVVW GDQQ N|QQHQ GLH PLW LKP HUODQJWHQ (UJHEQLVVH QLFKW SHU VH DOV PRUDOLVFK ULFKWLJ EHWUDFKWHW ZHUGHQ´ 'RFK GLHVHV ÄSHU VH¶ HQWKlOW LQ /DIRQWV ,QWHQWLRQ PHKU DOV HLQH 0RUDO OHLVWHQ NDQQ/DIRQWIlKUWGHPHQWVSUHFKHQGIRUW Å'LH(UIOOXQJGHU9HUIDKUHQV UHJHOQPDFKWQLFKWDOOHVDXVZDVÄPRUDOLVFKULFKWLJ¶KHLW9LHOPHKUVWHOOW VLHGLHEHVWHYHUIJEDUHHSLVWHPLVFKH6WW]XQJGHU$QQDKPHGDUGDVVGLH IUDJOLFKHQ1RUPHQWDWVlFKOLFKPRUDOLVFKULFKWLJVLQG(LQHVROFKH3UR]HGXU NDQQGDPLWQLFKWJDUDQWLHUHQGDVVHLQH1RUPPRUDOLVFKULFKWLJLVW²QLFKWV YHUPDJGDV'RFKVLHNDQQXQVGD]XEHUHFKWLJHQGHQ$QVSUXFKDXIPRUDOL VFKH5LFKWLJNHLWIUHLQH1RUP]XHUKHEHQVRODQJHNHLQH*HJHQDUJXPHQ WH DXINRPPHQ VHL HV DXI *UXQG YRQ QHXHQ (UIDKUXQJHQ YRQ )ROJHQ
_____________ +DEHUPDVI $OV5HSUlVHQWDQWHQQHQQWVLH.DQW5DZOVXQG+DEHUPDV YJO/DIRQW /DIRQW YJOGD]XDXFK/DIRQWD /DIRQW
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVXQG5HDOLVPXV²*OWLJNHLWXQG*HOWXQJ
1HEHQIROJHQ RGHU /HUQSUR]HVVHQ EHUKDXSW ´ 0HKU LVW WDWVlFKOLFK QLFKW]XEHNRPPHQGHU SULYLOHJLHUWH!%OLFNDXIGLH ZLUNOLFKHQ!:HUWH LVWQXUXQWHU,QNDXIQDKPHP|JOLFKHU%HYRUPXQGXQJP|JOLFKRGHUDEHU XQWHU GHQ LP 9RUVWHKHQGHQ DXVJHIKUWHQ %HGLQJXQJHQ HLQ %OLFN QDFK 1LUJHQGZR 'RFK EHGHXWHW GLHV ² XQG KLHU VFKHLQW /DIRQW GHP 5HFKWIHUWL JXQJVSUR]H ]X ZHQLJ ]X]XWUDXHQ E]Z ]X YLHO YRQ LKP ]X YHUODQJHQ ² QLFKWGLH8QP|JOLFKNHLWZHLWHUHU.ULWLN'HQQ]XPHLQHQLVWHVSULQ]LSLHOO VWHWVP|JOLFKGDQHXHSHUV|QOLFKH(LQVWHOOXQJHQGLHEH]JOLFKGHUIUDJ OLFKHQ1RUPUHOHYDQWVLQGDUWLNXOLHUWZHUGHQ]XPDQGHUHQVLQGGLH9HU IDKUHQVQRUPHQLKUHUVHLWVNRQWUDIDNWLVFKH.ULWHULHQGLHGDV5HVXOWDWEHXU WHLOHQODVVHQ'DGLHVH9HUIDKUHQVQRUPHQQLFKWDEVROXWRGHUREMHNWLY LP 6LQQHYRQQLFKWQRUPDWLY EHJUQGHWZHUGHQN|QQHQE]ZGDGHU$PR UDOLVW ZHQQ HV LKQ GHQQ JLEW RGHU .DQWV ÅlUJVWHU %|VHZLFKW´ GLHVHP 9HUIDKUHQ VR]XVDJHQ GLH NDOWH 6FKXOWHU ]HLJW LVW HLQ 3UREOHP GDV HLQH 0RUDO ZHOFKH DXFK LPPHU QLFKW O|VHQ NDQQ GHQQ XP HV PLW )RUVW ]X SRLQWLHUHQHVIKUWÅ>«@NHLQHQLFKWQRUPDWLYH7ULQGHQ5DXPPRUDOL VFKHU1RUPDWLYLWlW>«@VRIHUQZLUGLH3HUVSHNWLYHVHLQHU%HZRKQHUYHU VWHKHQZROOHQ´'DMHGRFKLQGHUVR]LDOHQ5HDOLWlWUHOHYDQWH,QIRUPDWL RQHQ GLH GLH =XUFNZHLVXQJ HLQHV +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LS UHFKWIHUWLJHQ ZUGHQ QLFKW LPPHU DXVUHLFKHQG EHUFNVLFKWLJW ZHUGHQ LVW NHLQ )HKOHU GHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVDOV/HJLWLPDWLRQVRUWVROFKHU3ULQ]LSLHQVRQGHUQ LQXQGDXIJUXQGGLHVHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVEHUKDXSWHUVWIHVWVWHOOEDU
_____________ (EG 'DPLWHUVFKHLQWDXFK%ULQNV5HDOLVPXVDOVK\SHUWURSKZHQQHUGHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV EHJULIIPRUDOWKHRUHWLVFKIU]XOHLVWXQJVVFKZDFKHLQVWXIW Å$VHFRQGUHDVRQIRUWKLQ NLQJWKDWDFRKHUHQFHWKHRU\RIMXVWLILFDWLRQLQHWKLFVLPSOLHVDQDQWLUHDOLVWFRQVWUXFWL YLVWPHWDHWKLFVLVREMHFWLYLVPDERXWMXVWLILFDWLRQ,IMXVWLILFDWLRQPXVWJXDUDQWHHWUXWK DV REMHFWLYLVP DERXW MXVWLILFDWLRQ FODLPV WKHQ D FRKHUHQFH WKHRU\ RI MXVWLILFDWLRQ LQ HWKLFVFRXOGSURYLGHHYLGHQFHRIPRUDOWUXWKRQO\LIWKHWUXWKRIPRUDOEHOLHIFRQVLVWHG LQLWVFRKHUHQFH´ %ULQN (VVWLPPW]ZDUHLQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVREMHNWLYLVPXV LVW ]X HLQHP SKLORVRSKLVFK YHUWUHWEDUHQ 3UHLV QLFKW ]X KDEHQ PRUDOLVFKH :DKUKHLW NDQQ QLFKW JDUDQWLHUW ZHUGHQ 'RFK %ULQNV ÅREMHFWLYH FRQFHSWLRQ RI ZHOIDUH´ HEG LVW]XVWDUUXP)lOOH]XO|VHQZLH6FDQORQVLHVNL]]LHUWKDWLQZHOFKHQGLH:RKO IDKUWQLFKWÄH[FDWKHGUD¶DOVREHUVWHU:HUWEHVWLPPWZHUGHQNDQQVRQGHUQVWDWWGHVVHQ GDVÄZDVZLUHLQDQGHUVFKXOGHQ¶QXUSUR]HGXUDOLVWLVFKEHVFKULHEHQZHUGHQNDQQ XQG PDQFKPDO]X(UJHEQLVVHQIKUWLQZHOFKHQGLH:UGHHLQHV(LQ]HOQHQGLH:RKOIDKUW GHU9LHOHQEHUZLHJW Ä0RUDOLVFKH:DKUKHLW¶VROOWHGHPQDFKDOVGLHLP)ROJHQGHQPLW +DEHUPDV YHUWHLGLJWH ÅLGHDO JHUHFKWIHUWLJWH %HKDXSWEDUNHLW´ +DEHUPDV YJODXFK YHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQ .DQW,9 )RUVW
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
(LQHKLVWRULVWLVFKH5HGXNWLRQGHV5LFKWLJHQDXIGDVIUULFKWLJ*HKDO WHQHZLUGGDGXUFKYHUPLHGHQGD]ZLVFKHQYHUVFKLHGHQHQ7KHRULHHEHQHQ XQWHUVFKLHGHQ ZLUG GLH PRUDOLVFKHQ 1RUPHQ GLH XQVHU VR]LDOHV /HEHQ SURVSHNWLYDOV*UQGH]XHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ$EVLFKWHQXQGUHWURVSHNWLYDOV 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHQHQWVSUHFKHQGHU+DQGOXQJHQOHLWHQVLQGQLFKWDSULRUL]X EHVWLPPHQ6RLVWGDV*HERWÅ'XVROOVWQLFKWW|WHQ´PLW6LFKHUKHLWHLQH 1RUP KRKHU 'LJQLWlW XQGVWHOOW LQ GHQ PHLVWHQ )lOOHQHLQHQ SUlYDOHQWHQ +DQGOXQJVJUXQGGDU'RFKGLHVHZLHDXFKDQGHUH1RUPHQ²5FNVLFKW QDKPH9HUWUDJVXQG9HUVSUHFKHQVWUHXH3ULRULWlWGHV:RKOHUJHKHQVGHU 6FKOHFKWHUJHVWHOOWHQJHJHQEHUGHPGHU%HVVHUJHVWHOOWHQXD²VLQGQLFKW GD]X JHHLJQHW HLQHQ .DQRQ REMHNWLYHU :HUWH ]X NRQVWLWXLHUHQ $XI GHU (EHQHGLHVHU+DQGOXQJVJUQGHGLHQLFKWVGHVWRWURW]LQYLHOHQ6LWXDWLRQHQ SUlYDOHQWH +DQGOXQJVJUQGH EH]HLFKQHQ XQG LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH HLQ XQEH GLQJWHV 6ROOHQ DXVGUFNHQ N|QQHQ VLQG OHW]WJOWLJH PDWHULDOH %HVWLPPXQ JHQQLFKWP|JOLFKZHLOVRZRKOGLH'LIIHUHQ]HQYRQ+DQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQHQ DOVDXFKGLH:HUWHNRQ]HSWLRQHQ6WUXNWXUHQGHU3OXUDOLWlWXQG.RQWLQXLWlW EHVLW]HQ GLH HV XQP|JOLFK PDFKHQ HLQ DSULRULVFKHV 6FKHPD P|JOLFKHU ZHLVHNRQNXUULHUHQGHU1RUPHQ]XHUVWHOOHQ :DV MHGRFK GHU 6LWXLHUXQJ LQ VR]LDOHPSLULVFKHQ =XVDPPHQKlQJHQ HQW]RJHQ LVW LVW GDV .ULWHULXP GDV GLH MHZHLOLJH *OWLJNHLW PRUDOLVFKHU 1RUPHQGKGHUHQ8QEHGLQJWKHLWEHVWLPPHQOlW:DVDXFKLPPHULQ HLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ+DQGOXQJVVLWXDWLRQGHUSUlYDOHQWH*UXQG]XHLQHUHQW VSUHFKHQGHQ+DQGOXQJLVWHUPXDXI3ULQ]LSLHQEHUXKHQGLHQLFKWUH]L SURNDOOJHPHLQ ]XUFNJHZLHVHQ ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ 'DPLW EH]LHKW VLFK GDV IU ULFKWLJ *HKDOWHQH ]XP HLQHQ DXI NRQNUHWH 6LWXDWLRQHQ RULHQWLHUW VLFK ]XP DQGHUHQ DEHU DQ SUR]HGXUDOHQ .ULWHULHQ GLH LKUHUVHLWV LQ GHU 3UD[LV GHU.RQVXPWLRQXQG3URGXNWLRQYRQ*UQGHQJUQGHQ,QGLHVHP6LQQH KDW +DEHUPDV GHQ IU GLH*OWLJNHLW HLQHV +DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSV NRQVWLWXWL YHQ&KDUDNWHUGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVKHUDXVJHVWULFKHQ Å,GHDOJHUHFKW IHUWLJWH %HKDXSWEDUNHLW LVW GDV ZDV ZLU PLW PRUDOLVFKHU *HOWXQJ PHLQHQ VLHEHGHXWHWQLFKWQXUGDGDV)UXQG:LGHULQ$QVHKXQJHLQHVNRQWUR
_____________ ,Q GLHVHP 6LQQH NRPPHQWLHUW +DEHUPDV ]XVWLPPHQG GLH $XVVDJH GHV .DQWLDQHUV 5DZOV·Å>O@RVJHO|VWYRQGHP9HUIDKUHQGLH*HUHFKWLJNHLWVJUXQGVlW]H]XNRQVWUXLHUHQ JLEWHVNHLQHPRUDOLVFKHQ7DWVDFKHQ´ 5DZOV IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å%HLGH0R PHQWH GLH GHU 9HUQXQIW HLQJHVFKULHEHQH 3DVVLYLWlW XQG GLH GHP :LOOHQ ]X]XVFKUHL EHQGH$NWLYLWlWPVVHQVLFKYHUELQGHQODVVHQ²LP%HJULIIHLQHUSUR]HGXUDOHQ0RUDOL WlW 'DV 9HUIDKUHQ QDFK GHP ZLU 1RUPHQ EHXUWHLOHQ XQG DOV JOWLJ DN]HSWLHUHQ N|QQHQ VWHKW XQV QLFKW ]XU 'LVSRVLWLRQ VRQGHUQ GUlQJW VLFK XQV DXI JOHLFK]HLWLJ GLHQWGLH9HUIDKUHQVSUD[LVHEHQVRVHKUGHU(U]HXJXQJRGHU.RQVWUXNWLRQZLHGHU(QWGH FNXQJ DOVR GHU PRUDOLVFKHQ (UNHQQWQLV YRQ 3ULQ]LSLHQ HLQHV ULFKWLJ JHUHJHOWHQ =X VDPPHQOHEHQV´ +DEHUPDV 'LH 'LIIHUHQ]HQ ]ZLVFKHQ 5DZOV XQG +D EHUPDV KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU 5HODWLRQ ]ZLVFKHQ %HREDFKWHU XQG 7HLOQHKPHUSHUVSHNWLYHQ EOHLEHQGDYRQXQEHUKUW YJOGD]XREHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVXQG5HDOLVPXV²*OWLJNHLWXQG*HOWXQJ
YHUVHQ *HOWXQJVDQVSUXFKV HUVFK|SIW LVW VRQGHUQ VLH VHOEVW HUVFK|SIW GHQ 6LQQ YRQ QRUPDWLYHU 5LFKWLJNHLW DOV $QHUNHQQXQJVZUGLJNHLW 'LH LGHDO JHUHFKWIHUWLJWH%HKDXSWEDUNHLWHLQHU1RUPZHLVWQLFKW²ZLHLP)DOOHHLQHV UHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWUDQV]HQGHQWHQ :DKUKHLWVDQVSUXFKV ² EHU GLH *UHQ]HQ GHV'LVNXUVHVKLQDXVDXIHWZDVKLQGDVXQDEKlQJLJYRQGHUIHVWJHVWHOOWHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVZUGLJNHLW Ä%HVWDQG¶ KDEHQ N|QQWH 'LH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV LPPDQHQ] YRQ Ä5LFKWLJNHLW¶ VWW]W VLFK DXI HLQ VLQQNULWLVFKHV $UJXPHQW ZHLO GLH Ä*HOWXQJ¶ HLQHU 1RUP GDULQ EHVWHKW GD GLHVH XQWHU LGHDOHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVEHGLQJXQJHQ DN]HSWLHUW G K DOV JOWLJ DQHUNDQQW ZUGH LVWÄ5LFKWLJNHLW¶HLQHSLVWHPLVFKHU%HJULII´'LHVH$QHUNHQQXQJVZUGLJ
_____________ +DEHUPDV I YJODXFK+DEHUPDV )RUVW VSULFKWGLHV EH]JOLFK XQG DXI .DQW UHNXUULHUHQG YRP Å)HKOHU HLQHU 2QWRORJLVLHUXQJ UHJXODWLYHU ,GHHQ´9JO]X+DEHUPDV·DQWLUHDOLVWLVFKHU,QWHUSUHWDWLRQYRQ1RUPHQEHLJOHLFK]HL WLJHP)HVWKDOWHQDP.RJQLWLYLVPXVEHUHLWV+DEHUPDV VRZLH+DEHU PDV I,QVHLQHP$XIVDW]Å5LFKWLJNHLWYHUVXV:DKUKHLW´IKUW+DEHUPDVHU OlXWHUQG GD]X DXV Å2KQH HLQHQ UHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWUDQV]HQGHQWHQ %H]XJVSXQNW IU GLH (UIOOXQJ YRQ *HOWXQJVEHGLQJXQJHQ EHKDOWHQ LP SUDNWLVFKHQ 'LVNXUV *UQGH DXFK GHU,GHHQDFKGDVOHW]WH:RUW1XQJLEWHVDEHUVWHWVEHVVHUHRGHUVFKOHFKWHUH*UQ GHQLHPDOVGHQÄHLQ]LJULFKWLJHQ¶*UXQG:HLOGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]HDOOHLQGXUFK *UQGHJHVWHXHUWZLUGVLQGPHKURGHUZHQLJHUÄJXWH¶5HVXOWDWH]X HUZDUWHQMHGRFK NHLQHHLQGHXWLJHQ´ YJOKLHUDXFKIIII ,QHLQHUQHXHUHQ3XEOLND WLRQEULQJW+DEHUPDVGLHVH$UJXPHQWDWLRQVFKOLHOLFKNRQNUHWLVLHUHQGJHJHQGLHQHX HQ+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJHQGXUFKGLH%LRWHFKQRORJLHLQ6WHOOXQJ Å'LH,UUHYHUVLELOLWlWGHU )ROJHQ HLQVHLWLJ YRUJHQRPPHQHU *HQPDQLSXODWLRQHQ EHGHXWHW HLQH SUREOHPDWLVFKH 9HUDQWZRUWXQJIUGHQGHUVLFKHLQHVROFKH(QWVFKHLGXQJ]XWUDXW$EHUPXVVVLHSHU VHIUGHQ%HWURIIHQHQHLQH(LQVFKUlQNXQJVHLQHUPRUDOLVFKHQ$XWRQRPLHEHGHXWHQ" $OOH3HUVRQHQDXFKGLHQDWUOLFKJHERUHQHQVLQGYRQLKUHPJHQHWLVFKHQ3URJUDPP LQ GHU HLQHQ RGHU DQGHUHQ :HLVH DEKlQJLJ 'LH $EKlQJLJNHLW YRQ HLQHP DEVLFKWOLFK IHVWJHOHJWHQ JHQHWLVFKHQ 3URJUDPP ZLUG IU GDV PRUDOLVFKH 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLV GHU SURJUDPPLHUWHQ3HUVRQDXVHLQHPDQGHUHQ*UXQGHUHOHYDQW,KULVWHVSULQ]LSLHOOYHU VDJWPLWLKUHP3URJUDPPLHUHUGLH5ROOHQ]XWDXVFKHQ'DV3URGXNWNDQQXPHV]X ]XVSLW]HQIUVHLQHQ'HVLJQHUQLFKWVHLQHUVHLWVHLQ'HVLJQHQWZHUIHQ>@'LHHXJHQL VFKH 3URJUDPPLHUXQJ YHUVWHWLJW HLQH $EKlQJLJNHLW ]ZLVFKHQ 3HUVRQHQ GLH ZLVVHQ GDVVHVIUVLHSULQ]LSLHOODXVJHVFKORVVHQLVWLKUHVR]LDOHQ3OlW]H]XZHFKVHOQ(LQHVRO FKH XQXPNHKUEDUH ZHLO DVNULSWLY YHUDQNHUWH VR]LDOH $EKlQJLJNHLW ELOGHW DEHU LQ GHQ UH]LSURNV\PPHWULVFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJVYHUKlOWQLVVHQ HLQHU PRUDOLVFKHQ XQG UHFKWOL FKHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWYRQIUHLHQXQGJOHLFKHQ 3HUVRQHQHLQHQ)UHPGN|USHU´ +DEHU PDV I 'RFKVFKHLQW+DEHUPDVKLHUGHPVR]LDOHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]H GHUDUWVNHSWLVFKRGHUJDUUHVLJQDWLYJHJHQEHU]XVWHKHQGDHUTXDVLHVVHQWLDOLVWLVFKLQ GLH 5LFKWXQJ HLQHU Ä*DWWXQJVHWKLN¶ ZHLVW ]X GHU XQV GLH ELRWHFKQRORJLVFKHQ XQG VFKOLHOLFK WHFKQLVFKHQ*HIDKUHQQ|WLJWHQ(UJLEW]X EHGHQNHQÅ>@GDVVGLHJHQ WHFKQLVFKH(QWZLFNOXQJLP+LQEOLFNDXIGLHPHQVFKOLFKH1DWXUDQWKURSRORJLVFKWLHI VLW]HQGH NDWHJRULDOH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJHQ ]ZLVFKHQ 6XEMHNWLYHP XQG 2EMHNWLYHP *H ZDFKVHQHPXQG*HPDFKWHPXQVFKDUIZHUGHQOlVVW'HVKDOEVWHKWPLWGHU,QVWUXPHQ WDOLVLHUXQJGHVYRUSHUVRQDOHQ/HEHQVHLQJDWWXQJVHWKLVFKHV6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVDXIGHP 6SLHOGDVGDUEHUHQWVFKHLGHWREZLUXQVDXFKZHLWHUKLQDOVPRUDOLVFKXUWHLOHQGHXQG KDQGHOQGH :HVHQ YHUVWHKHQ N|QQHQ :R XQV ]ZLQJHQGH PRUDOLVFKH *UQGH IHKOHQ
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
NHLWRGHUDXFK*OWLJNHLW LP*HJHQVDW]]XUVR]LDOHQ*HOWXQJ YRQGHU KLHU GLH5HGH LVW PDFKW GLH %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]X HLQHU =XZHLVXQJ HLQHU )HVWOH
_____________ PVVHQZLUXQVDQGHQJDWWXQJVHWKLVFKHQ:HJZHLVHUKDOWHQ´ (EG 'LHVH6NHS VLVJHJHQEHUGHPÄ9HUKDQGOXQJVZHJ¶EHGDUIMHGRFKGHU(UOlXWHUXQJ]XGHU+DEHU PDVVFKOLHOLFKIROJHQGHVDQIKUW Å:lKUHQGVLFKGLH:LUNXQJVJHVFKLFKWHYRQNXOWX UHOOHQhEHUOLHIHUXQJHQXQG%LOGXQJVSUR]HVVHQZLH*DGDPHUJH]HLJWKDWLP0HGLXP YRQ)UDJHXQG$QWZRUWHQWIDOWHWZUGHQJHQHWLVFKH3URJUDPPHGLH1DFKJHERUHQHQ QLFKW]X:RUWNRPPHQODVVHQ(LQH*HZ|KQXQJDQGLHSUlIHUHQ]JHOHLWHWHELRWHFKQL VFKH 9HUIJXQJ EHU PHQVFKOLFKHV /HEHQ NDQQ XQVHU QRUPDWLYHV 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLV QLFKWXQEHUKUWODVVHQ>«@,QVROFKHQLQVWUXPHQWHOOYHUZLUNOLFKWHQ$EVLFKWHQlXHUQ VLFKQLFKW3HUVRQHQ]XGHQHQGLHEHWURIIHQHQ3HUVRQHQDOV$QJHVSURFKHQH6WHOOXQJ QHKPHQN|QQWHQ'HVKDOEEHXQUXKLJWXQVGLH)UDJHREXQGZLHHLQGHUDUWYHUGLQJOL FKHQGHU $NW XQVHU 6HOEVWVHLQN|QQHQ XQG XQVHU 9HUKlOWQLV ]X DQGHUHQ DIIL]LHUW >@ 'LHVHU 8PVWDQG YHUOHLKW GHU DNWXHOOHQ $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ IUHLOLFK LKUH 6FKlUIH QXU VRODQJHZLHZLUEHUKDXSWQRFKHLQH[LVWHQWLHOOHV,QWHUHVVHGDUDQKDEHQHLQHUPRUDOL VFKHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWDQ]XJHK|UHQ(VLVWMDQLFKWVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKGDVVZLUGHQ6WD WXVHLQHV0LWJOLHGVLQHLQHU*HPHLQVFKDIWHLQQHKPHQP|FKWHQGLHJOHLFKH$FKWXQJIU MHGHQ XQG VROLGDULVFKH 9HUDQWZRUWXQJ IU DOOH YHUODQJW 'DVV ZLU PRUDOLVFK KDQGHOQ VROOHQ OLHJW LP 6LQQ GHU GHRQWRORJLVFK EHJULIIHQHQ 0RUDO VHOEVW EHVFKORVVHQ $EHU ZDUXPVROOWHQZLUPRUDOLVFKVHLQZROOHQ²ZHQQGLH%LRWHFKQLNVWLOOVFKZHLJHQGXQVHUH ,GHQWLWlW DOV *DWWXQJVZHVHQ XQWHUOlXIW (LQH %HZHUWXQJ GHU 0RUDO LP *DQ]HQ LVW QLFKWVHOEVWHLQPRUDOLVFKHVVRQGHUQHLQHWKLVFKHVHLQJDWWXQJVHWKLVFKHV8UWHLO2KQH GDV %HZHJHQGH YRQ PRUDOLVFKHQ *HIKOHQ GHU 9HUSIOLFKWXQJ XQG GHU 6FKXOG GHV 9RUZXUIV XQG GHU 9HU]HLKXQJ RKQH GDV %HIUHLHQGH PRUDOLVFKHU $FKWXQJ RKQH GDV %HJOFNHQGH VROLGDULVFKHU 8QWHUVWW]XQJ XQG RKQH GDV %HGUFNHQGH PRUDOLVFKHQ 9HUVDJHQV RKQH GLH Ä)UHXQGOLFKNHLW¶ HLQHV ]LYLOLVLHUWHQ 8PJDQJV PLW .RQIOLNW XQG :LGHUVSUXFK PVVWHQ ZLU VR PHLQHQ ZLU KHXWH QRFK GDV YRQ 0HQVFKHQ EHZRKQWH 8QLYHUVXPDOVXQHUWUlJOLFKHPSILQGHQ´ (EGI +DEHUPDVVFKHLQWKLHUPLW%OLFN DXIHLQHQ6WDQGSXQNW]XDUJXPHQWLHUHQGHUEHUHLWVDXHUKDOEGHV5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR ]HVVHVKLQVLFKWOLFKGHU&KDQFHQXQG5LVLNHQGHU%LRWHFKQRORJLHVHOEVWOLHJW'DPLWJLOW DEHU DXFK +DEHUPDV EHVWlWLJW SHUIRUPDWLY GLH *OWLJNHLW HLQHV SUR]HGXUDOHQ 9HU VWlQGQLVVHVGHU/HJLWLPLWlWYRQ+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSLHQGHQQEHUGLHVHJDWWXQJVGLPHQ VLRQLHUWHQ5LVLNHQGLH+DEHUPDVJHJHQEHUXQVHUHUKHUN|PPOLFKHQ0RUDODXVPDFKW ZLUG²OHJLWLPHUZHLVH²LQHLQHU YRQLKPQLFKWXQZHVHQWOLFKPLWEHVWLPPWHQ 5HFKW IHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVHQWVFKLHGHQLQZHOFKHUQLFKWQXUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHXQG|NRQRPLVFKH ,QWHUHVVHQYHUKDQGHOWZHUGHQVRQGHUQDXFKPRUDOLVFKHRGHUUHOLJL|VH,QWHUHVVHQGH UHU EHUFNVLFKWLJW ZHUGHQ PVVHQ GLH LQ GHU VR]LDOHQ 1DFKEDUVFKDIW GLHVHU ÄQHXDUWL JHQ¶:HVHQOHEHQPWHQÅ'LH%LRWHFKQLN´JLEWHVQLFKWHVKDQGHOWVLFKGDEHLYLHO PHKU XP 3HUVRQHQ GLH HLQJHEHWWHW LQ JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH XQG SDUODPHQWDULVFK GHPRNUDWLVFKH 'LVNXUVH IRUVFKHQ XQG (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ KHUEHLIKUHQ 'HUHQ PRUDOL VFKH5HOHYDQ]]HLJWVLFKLQZLHGHUXPYRQGHU'LVNXUVJHPHLQVFKDIWKHUDXVJHIRUGHUWHQ %HJUQGXQJHQ GLH LKUHUVHLWV ]X ZHLWHUHQ 6WHOOXQJQDKPHQ IKUHQ 'LHVHU 3UR]H LVW GHU HLQHU PRUDOLVFKHQ 1RUPHQEHJUQGXQJ LQ GHQ VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK DXFK HWKLVFKH XQG JDWWXQJVHWKLVFKH 8UWHLOH HLQJHKHQ .XU] JDWWXQJVHWKLVFKHQ 8UWHLOHQ LVW LP *H JHQVDW]]XLQGLYLGXDOHWKLVFKHQ8UWHLOHQ LQ+DEHUPDV·6LQQ SHUVHHLQLQWHUVXEMHNWL YHV NRQIOLNW XQG GDV EHGHXWHW PRUDOUHOHYDQWHV 0RPHQW HLQJHVFKULHEHQ YJO GD]X DXFK+DEHUPDV 9JO]XGLHVHU8QWHUVFKHLGXQJREHQ)Q
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVXQG5HDOLVPXV²*OWLJNHLWXQG*HOWXQJ
JXQJDXIHLQH+DQGOXQJE]Z+DQGOXQJVDEVLFKWDXVLQVRIHUQGLHIDNWLVFKH $QHUNHQQXQJGLHVHU)HVWOHJXQJGXUFKGLHKDQGHOQGH3HUVRQQLFKWVHOEVW YHUVWlQGOLFK LVW G K QLFKW LP 6LQQH GHU (UIRUGHUQLV5HODWLRQ YRUDXVJH VHW]WZHUGHQNDQQ 'DV UHDOH RGHU EHVVHUQLFKWNRQVWUXNWLYH 0RPHQW GHUMHQLJHQ *UQ GHGLHQLFKWYHUQQIWLJHUZHLVH]XUFNZHLVEDUVLQGLVWDOVRQLFKWLQ3ULQ ]LSLHQ]XILQGHQGLHÄDQVLFK¶JHOWHQZUGHQXQGGHUHQZLUQXUWHLOKDIWLJ RGHU DQVLFKWLJ ZHUGHQ N|QQWHQ 'DV QLFKWNRQVWUXNWLYH 0RPHQW GHU *UQGHLVWYLHOPHKUGLHVH5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LVVHOEVWLQGHUVLFKGLHYRQ %UDQGRPVREHQDQQWH)lKLJNHLWÄZLU¶VDJHQ]XN|QQHQDUWLNXOLHUW%UDQ GRP KDW GLHVHV QLFKWNRQVWUXNWLYH 0RPHQW GHU 1RUPDWLYLWlW YRQ +DQG OXQJVJUQGHQLQHLQHPDOOJHPHLQHUHQ.RQWH[WIROJHQGHUPDHQKHUYRUJH KREHQ Å>@WKHGHWHUPLQDF\RIWKHFRQWHQWRIZKDW\RXKDYHFRPPLWWHG \RXUVHOI WR ² WKH SDUW WKDW LV QRW XS WR \RX LQ WKH ZD\ WKDW ZKHWKHU \RX FRPPLW\RXUVHOIWRLWLVXSWR\RX²LVVHFXUHGE\WKHDWWLWXGHVRIRWKHUVWR ZKRP RQH KDV DW OHDVW LPSOLFLWO\ JUDQWHG WKDW DXWKRULW\ >@ +DYLQJ D FRPPLWPHQWZLWKDGHILQLWHFRQWHQWLVLQWHOOLJLEOH>@RQO\LQWKHFRQWH[W RIDGLYLVLRQRIODERXUEHWZHHQWKHRQHZKRXQGHUWDNHVWKHFRPPLWPHQW DQGWKRVHZKRDWWULEXWHLWDQGKROGWKHXQGHUWDNHUWRLW>«@0\DXWKRULW\ LVUHDOEXWLWLVSDUWLDO´ 'HUIHVWH3XQNWDQGHQPRUDOLVFKH*UQGHJHEXQGHQVLQGLVWQLFKW UHFKWIHUWLJXQJVWUDQV]HQGHQW VRQGHUQ OLHJW LQ GHU $Q(UNHQQWQLV GLH XQV HUVW]X:HVHQGLHÄZLU¶VDJHQN|QQHQPDFKWGHU$Q(UNHQQWQLVGHU$X WRULWlW GHV $QGHUHQ DOV EXFKVWlEOLFK XQYHUIJEDU :DV GHQ $QGHUHQ XQV XQYHUIJEDU PDFKW LVW QLFKW GHVVHQ /HEHQ :LH EHUHLWV HUOlXWHUW NDQQ GLHVHVXQWHUEHVWLPPWHQ([WUHPEHGLQJXQJHQ]XU'LVSRVLWLRQVWHKHQ:DV GHQ $QGHUHQ XQV XQYHUIJEDU PDFKW LVW VHLQH $XWRULWlW GHV =XZHLVHQV XQG$QHUNHQQHQVYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQXQG%HUHFKWLJXQJHQ]X)HVWOHJXQJHQ (UVW GLH 9HUHLQLJXQJ GLHVHU VXEMHNWLYHQ $XWRULWlW PLW LKUHU LQWHUVXEMHNWL YHQ 8QYHUIJEDUNHLW HU|IIQHW GHQ 5DXP GHV Ä:LU¶VDJHQN|QQHQV .DQW KDW GLHVH $XWRULWlW DOV Å,GHH GHU :UGH HLQHV YHUQQIWLJHQ :HVHQV´ EH]HLFKQHW'RFKEOHLEWGHU.DQWLVFKHPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLVVRODQJHRSDN ELVZLUJHJHQ.DQWV,QWHQWLRQGHQ%OLFNDXIGLH3UD[LVGHV)RUGHUQVXQG /LHIHUQV YRQ *UQGHQ ULFKWHQ :HOFKHV 9HUKDOWHQ ZLUGHQ $QGHUHQXQG GLHVH XQV LP HLQ]HOQHQ VFKXOGHQ NDQQ QXU LP )RUGHUQ XQG /LHIHUQ YRQ *UQGHQ GHP $EZlJHQ UH]LSURNDOOJHPHLQHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ EHVWLPPW ZHU GHQ DEHU GD ZLU LKQHQ NRQWH[WUHODWLY *UQGH VFKXOGHQ XQG GDPLW LKUH $XWRULWlW DQHUNHQQHQ GDUDXI KDEHQ ZLU XQV PLW GHU 7HLOQDKPH DQ GHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUD[LV IHVWJHOHJW 'LHVH $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU $XWRULWlW GHU
_____________ %UDQGRP .DQW,9
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIWXQG5DWLRQDOLWlW
$QGHUHQ YHUELHWHW XQG JHELHWHW +DQGOXQJVIRUPHQ XQGVFKOLHOLFK +DQG OXQJHQ GHUHQ 9HUQQIWLJNHLW QLFKW D SULRUL EHVWLPPEDU LVW VRQGHUQ VLFK LP5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVSUR]HHUZHLVHQPX 0RUDOLVFKH1RUPHQZHOFKHU$UWDXFKLPPHUEH]LHKHQLKUHQRUPDWL YH.UDIWDXVGHU$QHUNHQQXQJSHUV|QOLFKHU(LQVWHOOXQJHQ$QGHUHUDOVGH UHQP|JOLFKH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHGLHXQVDOVVROFKHXQYHUIJEDUVLQG:R GLH $QHUNHQQXQJ GHU HLJHQHQ )HVWOHJXQJ GDUDXI VRZRKO GLH %HUHFKWLJXQJ ]XU=XZHLVXQJYRQ)HVWOHJXQJHQDQDQGHUH3HUVRQHQDOVDXFKGLH%HUHFK WLJXQJ ]X HLJHQHQ LQWHUDNWLRQVIROJHQUHOHYDQWHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ DXV]XZHL VHQ IHKOW KDQGHOW HV VLFK XP HLQHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ 6ROLSVLVPXV (LQHP VRO FKHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ 6ROLSVLVPXV RGHU $PRUDOLVPXV PLW $UJXPHQWHQ ÅGHQ $XVZHJDXVGHP)OLHJHQJODV]X]HLJHQ´LVWXQP|JOLFKGHQQGLHVH$U JXPHQWH N|QQHQ LQ HLQHP VROFKHQ *ODV SHU GHILQLWLRQHP QLFKW JHK|UW ZHUGHQ
_____________ :LWWJHQVWHLQ38 YJODXFKHEG
Brought to you by | McMaster University Authenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DSLWHO 3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQG PRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ .DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
(LQOHLWXQJ
'LHYRUVWHKHQGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQVLQGXQVFKZHUHUNHQQEDUHLQHUH[WHUQD OLVWLVFKHQ3RVLWLRQLQGHU0RUDOWKHRULH]X]XRUGQHQ²GDVYRQ:LOOLDPVVR JHQDQQWH XQG HODERULHUWH ÅVXE+XPHVFKH 0RGHOO´ VWHKW GLHVHU 3RVLWLRQ JHUDGH]X GLDPHWUDO JHJHQEHU 'RFK LVW PLW GLHVHP ([WHUQDOLVPXV HLQH 6FKZLHULJNHLWYHUEXQGHQGLH1LFR6FDUDQRIROJHQGHUPDHQVNL]]LHUWKDW Å>«@ZHQQZLUZLVVHQZROOHQZDUXPZLUHLQHPRUDOLVFKJHERWHQH+DQG OXQJDXVIKUHQVROOHQZHQQZLUDOVRQDFKGHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJGHU+DQG OXQJIUDJHQGDQQLVWXQWHULQWHUQDOLVWLVFKHQ3UlPLVVHQGDPLWQXUQDFKGHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ HLQHV PRUDOLVFKHQ 8UWHLOV JHIUDJW 8QWHU H[WHUQDOLVWLVFKHQ $QQDKPHQ LVW MHGRFK QRFK PHKU YHUODQJW =XVlW]OLFK ]X GHP HQWVSUH FKHQGHQPRUDOLVFKHQ8UWHLOPXVVDXFKGDV0RWLYQRFKEHJUQGHWZHUGHQ :DUXPVROOWHLFKHLQ0RWLYKDEHQGDVDOVPRUDOLVFKULFKWLJ(LQJHVHKHQH DXFKXP]XVHW]HQ"´ :LH VFKRQ EHL GHU 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHP %HUHLFK JHQXLQ PRUDOLVFKHQXQGHLQHP%HUHLFKLQVWUXPHQWHOOHQ5HIOHNWLHUHQVGLHHLQHU$OOWDJV LQWXLWLRQ HQWVSULFKW XQG ZHOFKHU LQ HLQHU (UNOlUXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVJUQ GHQDGlTXDW5HFKQXQJJHWUDJHQZHUGHQPXVROlWVLFKDXFKLQ%H]XJ DXI GLH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ XQG %HIROJXQJ HLQHV +DQG OXQJVSULQ]LSV.DQWDOV*HZlKUVSHUVRQDQIKUHQ,Q.DQWV0RUDOSKLORVR SKLHWULWW]XPHUVWHQ0DOGHUGHXWOLFKHXQGDUJXPHQWDWLYJHVWW]WH8QWHU VFKLHG ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHP SULQFLSLXP GLMXGLFDWLRQLV XQG HLQHP SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV DXI 'DV SKLORVRSKLVFKH 3UREOHP GLHVHV 8QWHUVFKLHGV VRZLH GHV 9HUKlOWQLVVHV EHLGHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ ]XHLQDQGHU KDW .DQW EHUHLWV DP %H JLQQ GHU $XVDUEHLWXQJ VHLQHU .ULWLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLH IRUPXOLHUW Å:HQQ LFKGXUFKGHQ9HUVWDQGXUWKHLOHGDGLH+DQGOXQJVLWWOLFKJXWLVWVRIHKOW QRFK VHKU YLHO GD LFK GLHVH +DQGOXQJ WKXH YRQ GHU LFK VR JHXUWKHLOW
_____________ :LOOLDPV YJOGD]XREHQ 6FDUDQRD
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
KDEH%HZHJWPLFKDEHUGLHVHV8UWKHLOGLH+DQGOXQJ]XWKXQVRLVWGDV GDVPRUDOLVFKH*HIKO'DVNDQQXQGZLUGDXFKNHLQHUHLQVHKHQGDGHU 9HUVWDQGVROOWHHLQHEHZHJHQGH.UDIIW]XXUWKHLOHQKDEHQ8UWKHLOHQNDQQ GHU 9HUVWDQG IUH\OLFK DEHU GLHVHP 9HUVWDQGHV8UWKHLO HLQH .UDIIW ]X JH EHQXQGGDHVHLQH7ULHEIHGHUZHUGHGHQ:LOOHQ]XEHZHJHQGLH+DQG OXQJDXV]XEHQGDVLVWGHU6WHLQGHU:HLVHQ´ :HQQQXQZLHGDVYRUVWHKHQGH.DSLWHOXQWHUDQGHUHPJH]HLJWKDEHQ VROOHLQLPZHLWHUHQ6LQQHGLVNXUVWKHRUHWLVFKHU$QVDW]DOVHLQHÄ6R]LDOLVLH UXQJ¶ .DQWLVFKHU $QVSUFKH KLQVLFKWOLFK GHV SULQFLSLXP GLMXGLFDWLRQLV DXIJHIDWZHUGHQNDQQVROHJWVLFKHLQHQWVSUHFKHQGHU9HUJOHLFKKLQVLFKW OLFKGHVSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLVXQGGHVVHQH[SODQDWRULVFKHU6WlUNHLQQHU KDOE GHU MHZHLOLJHQ 7KHRULH EHLQDKH YRQ VHOEVW QDKH 'RFK .DQWV XQG +DEHUPDV·7KHRULHQPRUDOLVFKHU0RWLYDWLRQHUVFKHLQHQ²]XPLQGHVWSUL PD IDFLH ² ]X KHWHURJHQ XP DXIHLQDQGHU EH]RJHQ ZHUGHQ ]X N|QQHQ +DEHUPDV VXFKW ]ZDU KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU &KDUDNWHULVWLND GHRQWRORJLVFK NRJQLWLYLVWLVFK IRUPDOLVWLVFK XQG XQLYHUVDOLVWLVFK HLQH HQJH $QELQGXQJ VHLQHU 'LVNXUVWKHRULH GHU 0RUDO DQ GLH .DQWLVFKH (WKLN $XVJHUHFKQHW GDV LP JHJHQZlUWLJHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ UHOHYDQWH GULWWH +DXSWVWFN GHU .ULWLNGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWÅ9RQGHQ7ULHEIHGHUQGHUUHLQHQSUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW´OlWHUDEHUXQEHUFNVLFKWLJW+LHUPDJVLFKLQ+DEHUPDV·$X JHQGLH9HUZHFKVOXQJGHVÅDXWRQRPHQ:LOOHQ>V@PLWGHPRPQLSRWHQWHQ´ EHVRQGHUV GUDVWLVFK ]HLJHQGHUHQWKDOEHQ .DQW GLHVHQ DXWRQRPHQ :LOOHQ LQV Å5HLFK GHV ,QWHOOLJLEOHQ´ YHUVHW]WH $QVWHOOH HLQHU PLW GLHVHU =ZHL :HOWHQ/HKUHEHODVWHWHQ(WKLNEHDEVLFKWLJW+DEHUPDVMDJHUDGHGLH.RQ ]HSWLRQ HLQHU ÅQDFKPHWDSK\VLVFKHQ´0RUDOWKHRULH IU GLH Å:HOW ZLH ZLU VLHNHQQHQ´LQGHUÅGHU:LOOH:LUNVDPNHLWQXULQGHP0DH>HUODQJW@ZLH VLFK GLH 0RWLYDWLRQVNUDIW JXWHU *UQGH JHJHQ GLH 0DFKW DQGHUHU 0RWLYH GXUFKVHW]HQ NDQQ´ 'HVKDOE LVW LQ +DEHUPDV· Å8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJVJUXQG VDW]´ VFKOLHOLFK GLH 5HGH YRQ GHQ Å,QWHUHVVHQ HLQHV MHGHQ (LQ]HOQHQ´ $XI GHQ QHEHQ GLHVHP 0HWDSK\VLNYRUZXUI ]ZHLWHQ ]HQWUDOHQ XQG PLW
_____________ .DQW 'D .DQW ]XU =HLW GLHVHU 9RUOHVXQJ EHU 0RUDOSKLORVRSKLH LQ GHQ HU-DKUHQQRFKZHLWYRQGHU/|VXQJGLHVHV3UREOHPVZLHHUVLHLQXQGQDFKGHU *UXQGOHJXQJ NRQ]LSLHUW KDW HQWIHUQW LVW EHWRQW .KQ LQ VHLQHU (LQOHLWXQJ ]X GLHVHU (GLWLRQYJOHEGYLL[[[YVRZLH EHUHLWV+HQULFK XQG+HQULFK 9JOGD]XXD+DEHUPDV II +DEHUPDV (EG +DEHUPDV 9JO DEHU DXFK VHLQH VSlWHUH (UZHLWHUXQJ GLHVHV ,QWHUHVVHEH JULIIV LP 6LQQH YRQ Å,QWHUHVVHQODJHQ XQG :HUWRULHQWLHUXQJHQ´ VRZLH VFKOLHOLFKGLHGDUEHUQRFKKLQDXVUHLFKHQGH(UZHLWHUXQJGXUFKGHQ%HJULIIGHUÅHLQ VFKOlJLJHQ$QVSUFKH´ YJOGD]XDXFK*RWWVFKDON0D]RX] I
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
GHPHUVWHQYHUEXQGHQHQ 9RUZXUIGHV6XEMHNWLYLVPXV²Å.DQW>KDW@GDV PRUDOLVFKH%HZXWVHLQLPLQWHOOLJLEOHQ,FKGHVHLQ]HOQHQ6XEMHNWVYHUDQ NHUW´²ZHUGHLFKQRFK]XUFNNRPPHQ+DEHUPDVVFKHLQWQLFKWQXUNHLQ ,QWHUHVVH DP .DQWLVFKHQ SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV VRQGHUQ DQ EHUKDXSW NHLQHU 7KHRULH PRUDOLVFKHU0RWLYDWLRQ ]X KDEHQ ZLH VHLQH +LQZHQGXQJ ]XHLQHUVR]LDOSKlQRPHQDOHQ7KHRULHGHU0RUDODQGHXWHQN|QQWHGHUHQ OHW]WHV=LHOVWHWVHLQH,QVWLWXWLRQHQWKHRULHLVW 8PGHQJHQDQQWHQ9HUGDFKWDXV]XUlXPHQHUVFKHLQWHVVLQQYROO]X QlFKVW GHQ %HJULII GHU $FKWXQJ GHQ GHU NULWLVFKH .DQW DOV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV PRUDOLVFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ HLQJHIKUW KDW VHPDQWLVFK XQG PH WKRGRORJLVFK]XGLIIHUHQ]LHUHQXQGGDQDFKGLH7KHVHPHLQHU5HNRQVWUXN WLRQ GHU LQ)UDJH VWHKHQGHQ 7KHRULHQ ]XIRUPXOLHUHQ(V ZLUG GDEHL ]X QlFKVW ]X ]HLJHQ VHLQ GD QLFKW QXU .DQW VRQGHUQ DXFK +DEHUPDV $FKWXQJ DOV PRUDOWKHRUHWLVFK UHOHYDQWHQ %HJULII EHKDQGHOW ZHVKDOE VLFK HLQH 8QWHUVXFKXQJ GHU GLHVEH]JOLFKHQ EHLGHQ 3RVLWLRQHQ ORKQW 9RQ ,QWHUHVVHLVWKLHUDXFKDQZHOFKHU6WHOOH+DEHUPDVGLHPRWLYDWLRQVWKHRUH WLVFKHQ:HJHGHU.DQWLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHYHUOlWXQGREGDV7HUUDLQDXI GDVHUVLFKYRQGRUWDXVEHJLEWVLFKHUHULVWDOVGDV.DQWLVFKH (VHUVFKHLQWVLQQYROOEHLP%HJULIIGHU$FKWXQJ]ZLVFKHQPLQGHVWHQV GUHLVHPDQWLVFKHQ+LQVLFKWHQXQGGDUEHUKLQDXV]ZLVFKHQ]ZHLPHWKRGL VFKHQ$QDO\VHHEHQHQ]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ ,Q$EZDQGOXQJHLQHV%HJULIIVVFKHPDVYRQ8UVXOD:ROIXQWHUVFKHLGH LFK VHPDQWLVFK ]ZLVFKHQ GHU $FKWXQJ LP 6LQQ HLQHU ]ZHFNUDWLRQDOHQ %HUFNVLFKWLJXQJE]Z%HDFKWXQJYRQHPSLULVFKHQ7DWVDFKHQE]Z:Q VFKHQ GHU $FKWXQJ LP 6LQQ GHU VSH]LILVFKHQ :HUWVFKlW]XQJ HLQHU EHVWLPPWHQ 3HUVRQ XQG GHU $FKWXQJ LP 6LQQ HLQHU DEVROXWHQ :HUW
_____________ +DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV IDW VHLQH .ULWLN DQ GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 0RUDOWKHRULH IROJHQGHUPDHQ ]XVDPPHQ Å(UVWHQV JLEW GLH 'LVNXUVHWKLN GLH =ZHL5HLFKH/HKUH >LP2ULJLQDOVWHKWKLHU=ZHL5HFKWH/HKUH LFKJHKHGDYRQDXVGDPHLQH/HVDUWLQWHQ GLHUWLVWGHQQYRQGHUDUW]ZHLHUOHL5HFKWHQLVWEHL.DQWQLFKWGLH5HGH YJOHEG $QP .3@ DXI VLH YHU]LFKWHW DXI GLH NDWHJRULDOH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHP 5HLFKGHV,QWHOOLJLEOHQGHP3IOLFKWXQGIUHLHU:LOOHDQJHK|UHQXQGGHP5HLFKGHV3Kl QRPHQDOHQGDVXDGLH1HLJXQJHQGLHEORVXEMHNWLYHQ0RWLYHDXFKGLH,QVWLWXWLRQHQ GHV 6WDDWHV XQG GHU *HVHOOVFKDIW XPIDW >@ =ZHLWHQV EHUZLQGHW GLH 'LVNXUVHWKLN GHQEORLQQHUOLFKHQPRQRORJLVFKHQ$QVDW].DQWVGHUGDPLWUHFKQHWGDMHGHU(LQ ]HOQHLQIRURLQWHUQR>@GLH3UIXQJVHLQHU+DQGOXQJVPD[LPHQYRUQLPPW>@'DJH JHQHUZDUWHWGLH'LVNXUVHWKLNHLQH9HUVWlQGLJXQJEHUGLH9HUDOOJHPHLQHUXQJVIlKLJ NHLW YRQ ,QWHUHVVHQ QXU DOV (UJHEQLV HLQHV LQWHUVXEMHNWLY YHUDQVWDOWHWHQ |IIHQWOLFKHQ 'LVNXUVHV >@ 'ULWWHQV HUKHEW GLH 'LVNXUVHWKLN GHQ $QVSUXFK MHQHV %HJUQGXQJV SUREOHPGHP.DQWOHW]WOLFKGXUFKGHQ+LQZHLV DXIHLQ)DNWXPGHU9HUQXQIW²DXI GLH(UIDKUXQJGHV*HQ|WLJWVHLQVGXUFKV6ROOHQ²DXVZHLFKWPLWGHU$EOHLWXQJYRQÄ8¶ >VF GHP 8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJVJUXQGVDW] .3@ DXV DOOJHPHLQHQ $UJXPHQWDWLRQVYRUDXV VHW]XQJHQJHO|VW]XKDEHQ´ +DEHUPDV I
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
VFKlW]XQJ HLQHU DQGHUHQ 3HUVRQ DOV 3HUVRQ $OV 6RQGHUIDOO PX LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ QRFK GLH 6HOEVWDFKWXQJ JHQDQQW ZHUGHQ GLH EHL .DQWHLQHQZLFKWLJHQ$VSHNWGHVPRUDOLVFKHQ$FKWXQJVEHJULIIVDXVPDFKW XQG YRQ +DEHUPDV LQ HLQHU 5HDNWLRQ DXI (UQVW 7XJHQGKDW DP 5DQGH EHKDQGHOWZLUG 'LHEHLGHQPHWKRGLVFKHQ$QDO\VHHEHQHQGHV$FKWXQJVEHJULIIVEH]LHKHQ VLFK D DXI GLH $FKWXQJ DOV %HJULII HLQHU %HJUQGXQJVWKHRULH GHU 0RUDO XQG E DXI GLH $FKWXQJ DOV %HJULII HLQHU 0RUDOHQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLH E]Z0RUDOSlGDJRJLN 'HU 8QWHUVXFKXQJVJHJHQVWDQG OlW VLFK GDPLW IU GLH JHJHQZlUWLJH 7KHPHQVWHOOXQJHLQJUHQ]HQXQGHQGJOWLJSUl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lGDJRJL VFKHQ.RQWH[WXPGLH:HUWVFKlW]XQJHLQHU3HUVRQDXIJUXQGGHUHQVSH]L ILVFKHQ .HQQ]HLFKHQ RGHU (LJHQVFKDIWHQ 'HU 8QLYHUVDOLVPXV GHU EHLGH 7KHRULHQ ZHVHQWOLFK FKDUDNWHULVLHUW VROO JHUDGH]X DOV *HJHQRSWLRQ ]X HLQHUSDUWLNXODULVWLVFKHQ:HUWHWKLNYHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQ (V EOHLEW DOVR GHU %HJULII GHU $FKWXQJ LP 6LQQ HLQHU DEVROXWHQ :HUWVFKlW]XQJDQGHUHU3HUVRQHQDOV3HUVRQHQ GLHVHU%HJULIIVFKHLQWPLU EHL.DQWXQG+DEHUPDVKLQVLFKWOLFKGHUEHLGHQJHQDQQWHQPHWKRGLVFKHQ
_____________ 9JO ]X GLHVHU %HJULIIVDQDO\VH :ROI PHLQH $EZHLFKXQJ YRQ :ROIV (LQWHLOXQJ²Å D $FKWXQJLP6LQQGHU%HDFKWXQJRGHU%HUFNVLFKWLJXQJ E $FKWXQJ LP6LQQHGHV5HVSHNWV YRUGHP0lFKWLJHUHQ F $FKWXQJLP6LQQHGHU:HUWVFKlW ]XQJ´²UKUWGDKHUGDLFKHUVWHQVGHQ5HVSHNWYRUHLQHU3HUVRQTXDPlFKWLJHUHU 3HUVRQDOVHLQH$FKWXQJGHU3HUVRQDXIJUXQGGHUHQVSH]LILVFKHQ(LJHQVFKDIWHQDXI IDVVHXQG]ZHLWHQVLQQHUKDOEGHU%HGHXWXQJGHV$FKWXQJVEHJULIIVDOV:HUWVFKlW]XQJ GLHVSH]LILVFKHYRQGHUXQVSH]LILVFKHQXQGGDPLWDEVROXWHQ$FKWXQJYRUHLQHUDQGH UHQ 3HUVRQ XQWHUVFKHLGH 9JO ]X +DEHUPDV· $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW 7XJHQGKDWV .RQ]HSWGHU6HOEVWDFKWXQJ+DEHUPDV VRZLH]X7XJHQGKDWV$XVHLQ DQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW :ROI XQG VHLQHU HLJHQHQ $XIIDVVXQJ YRP 9HUKlOWQLV GHU 6HOEVW VFKlW]XQJ XQG GHV ZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ 5HVSHNWV 7XJHQGKDW 'DUZDOOV SURPLQHQWH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ GHV $FKWXQJVNRQ]HSWV ZHUGH LFK NXU] EHUKUHQ QDFK GHP LFK GDV HQWVSUHFKHQGH .DQWLVFKH 7KHRULHVWFN GLVNXWLHUW KDEH YJO XQWHQ )Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
$QDO\VHHEHQHQHLQH]HQWUDOH5ROOHLQGHUPRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ$XVHLQDQ GHUVHW]XQJ]XVSLHOHQ 'LHPHWKRGLVFKHQ$QDO\VHHEHQHQ D XQG E ODVVHQVLFKPLWHQWVSUH FKHQGHQ)UDJHQFKDUDNWHULVLHUHQ:lKUHQGPDQLQHLQHU%HJUQGXQJVWKH RULH GHU 0RUDO QDFK GHQ $GlTXDWKHLWVEHGLQJXQJHQ HLQHV %HVWLPPXQJV JUXQGHV PRUDOLVFK ULFKWLJHU +DQGOXQJHQ IUDJW GLH 1RUPDWLYLWlW GLHVHU )UDJHXQWHUVFKHLGHWVLHYRQGHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQGHVNULSWLYHQ)UDJHVWHOOXQJ GHU0RWLYDWLRQVSV\FKRORJLH JHKWHVEHLGHUHQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ E]ZSlGDJRJLVFKHQ)UDJHQDFKGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ$FKWXQJXPGLH(QWGH FNXQJ GHU /HKU XQG /HUQSUR]HVVH GLH EHL HLQHP ,QGLYLGXXP DOV 7HLO HLQHU *UXSSH ]XU $XVELOGXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQGHU +DQGOXQJVNRPSHWHQ]HQ IKUHQ'DPLWEH]XJDXI E ZHGHU.DQWQRFK+DEHUPDVVWUHQJ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ VLFK ]ZHLIHOORV EHUODSSHQGHQ )UDJHVWHOOXQJHQ ² ÄZHOFKH SV\FKL VFKHQ3UR]HVVHIKUHQ]XGLHVHU+DQGOXQJVNRPSHWHQ]"¶XQGÄZLHHU]LHKW PDQHLQ,QGLYLGXXP DOV7HLOHLQHU*UXSSH ]XGLHVHU+DQGOXQJVNRPSH WHQ]"¶²XQWHUVFKHLGHQZHUGHLFKLPIROJHQGHQGLHVHEHLGHQ$VSHNWHGHU (QWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLH GHU 0RUDO XQG GHU 0RUDOSlGDJRJLN HEHQIDOOV JHPHLQVDPEHKDQGHOQ 'DV PRWLYDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKH 3UREOHP GHU (WKLN LVW QHEHQEHL DXFK QRFK ]X XQWHUVFKHLGHQ YRP QDKHOLHJHQGHQ 3UREOHP GHU $QZHQGXQJ =ZDUEH]LHKHQVLFKEHLGH3UREOHPHDXIGLH$NWXDOLVLHUXQJRGHU5HDOLVLH UXQJHLQHVNDWHJRULVFKE]ZXQLYHUVDOJOWLJHQ0RUDOSULQ]LSVLQGHU+DQG OXQJVSUD[LV 'RFK ZlKUHQG GDV $QZHQGXQJVSUREOHP GLH (LJQXQJ RGHU 3DVVXQJ HLQHV DEVWUDNWHQ 3ULQ]LSV IU HLQH NRQNUHWH 6LWXDWLRQ EHQHQQW VWHKWEHLGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ0RWLYDWLRQGHUVLWXDWLRQVXQDEKlQJLJHDXVO|VHQ GH$VSHNWDGlTXDWHUGKJHERWHQHU+DQGOXQJHQLQ)UDJH,P*HJHQVDW] ]X.DQWLVWVLFK+DEHUPDVGLHVHU'LIIHUHQ]EHZXW:lKUHQG+DEHUPDV QlPOLFK $QZHQGXQJVSUREOHPH DXV VHLQHU 7KHRULHELOGXQJ VFKZHUSXQNW PlLJDXVNODPPHUW²Å(WKLNHQGHV.DQWLVFKHQ7\SVVLQGDXI)UDJHQGHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ VSH]LDOLVLHUW )UDJHQ GHU $QZHQGXQJ ODVVHQ VLH XQEHDQWZRU WHW´²LVWIULKQGLH+DQGOXQJVPRWLYDWLRQHLQ]XNOlUHQGHU$VSHNWGHU
_____________ +DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV JHKW GHQQRFK EHUHLWV LQ VHLQHQ Å(UOlXWHUXQJHQ ]XU 'LVNXUVHWKLN´ DXI GDV 9HUKlOWQLV YRQ 1RUPHQEHJUQGXQJ XQG 1RUPHQDQZHQGXQJ HLQXQGQLPPWGDEHLGLH$XVIKUXQJHQ*QWKHUV IUVHLQH(UNOlUXQJLQ $QVSUXFK YJO +DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV I MHGRFK DXFK *RWW VFKDON0D]RX] VRZLH:HUQHU7HLO $QVWHOOHGHUQHRDULVWRWHOL VFKHQ(UVHW]XQJGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWGXUFKHLQHNRQWH[WJHEXQGHQH8UWHLOVNUDIW EHKDUUW +DEHUPDV VFKOLHOLFK GDUDXI Å>@ GD VLFK DXFK LQ GHU NOXJHQ $QZHQGXQJ YRQ1RUPHQDOOJHPHLQH*UXQGVlW]HGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWGXUFKVHW]HQ>@]% GLHYRQGHUMXULVWLVFKHQ7RSLNHQWZLFNHOWHQ*UXQGVlW]HGHU%HDFKWXQJDOOHUUHOHYDQ WHQ$VSHNWHHLQHV)DOOHVRGHUGHU9HUKlOWQLVPlLJNHLWGHU0LWWHOZHOFKHGHPPRUDOL VFKHQ*HVLFKWVSXQNWHLQHUXQSDUWHLOLFKHQ$SSOLNDWLRQ*HOWXQJYHUVFKDIIHQ´ +DEHUPDV 9JO]XU'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQGHPÅNRJQLWLYH>Q@3UREOHP D GHU$QZHQGXQJ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
0RUDOWKHRULH XQG GDPLW DXFK GHU (QWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLH GHU 0RUDO E]ZGHU0RUDOSlGDJRJLN 6RZRKO.DQWDOVDXFK+DEHUPDVGLIIHUHQ]LHUHQ]ZLVFKHQGHU$FKWXQJ HLQHU3HUVRQYRUHLQHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQDOV3HUVRQXQGGHU$FKWXQJHLQHU 3HUVRQYRUHLQHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQ ZHJHQGHUHQÅKHUYRUUDJHQGHQ/HLVWXQ JHQ´%HLGHVSUHFKHQYRQ+DQGOXQJHQÅDXV3IOLFKW´GLHZLU]XPHLQHQ QLFKW GHVKDOE YROO]LHKHQ ZHLO XQV GLH HQWVSUHFKHQGH 1RUP ÄDXIHUOHJW¶ ZRUGHQLVWVRQGHUQZHLOZLUVLHXQVVHOEVWÄJHJHEHQ¶KDEHQGLHZLU]XP DQGHUHQDEHUDXFKQLFKWGHVKDOEYROO]LHKHQZHLOGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGH1RUP GXUFK7UDGLWLRQXQG*HZRKQKHLWÄEHJODXELJW¶ZRUGHQLVWVRQGHUQZHLOZLU VLH IU ÄEHJUQGHW¶ KDOWHQ $XFK VFKHLQW KLQVLFKWOLFK GHU (QWZLFNOXQJV SV\FKRORJLHGHU0RUDOE]Z0RUDOSlGDJRJLN+DEHUPDV GHUHQWVSUHFKHQ GHQ.RQ]HSWLRQ.DQWVQDKH]XVWHKHQGLHGLHVHULQVHLQHUÅ0HWKRGHQOHKUH GHUUHLQHQSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW´GDUJHVWHOOWKDWLQVRIHUQHUPLWVHLQHPDQ .RKOEHUJVVR]LRPRUDOLVFKHQ3HUVSHNWLYHQRULHQWLHUWHQ0RGHOOGHUÅ,QWHU DNWLRQVVWXIHQ 6R]LDOSHUVSHNWLYHQ XQG 0RUDOVWXIHQ´ GLH RQWRJHQHWLVFKH .RQVWLWXWLRQHLQHUPRUDOLVFKHQ:HOWVLFKWUHNRQVWUXLHUW+DEHUPDVWKHPD WLVLHUW GHQ PRUDOLVFKHQ %HJULII GHU $FKWXQJ DOVR QLFKW QXU DXI GHQ JH QDQQWHQEHLGHQPHWKRGLVFKHQ(EHQHQVRQGHUQIROJWGDEHLSDUWLHOO.DQWL VFKHQ ,QWXLWLRQHQ XQG LVW GDKHU LPSOL]LW DXI ZHVHQWOLFK .DQWLVFKH $QQDKPHQ IHVWJHOHJW ZHQQ HU REJOHLFK LQ PRGHUQHU 'LNWLRQ DQ GHU 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ ÄSIOLFKWJHPl¶ XQG ÄDXV 3IOLFKW¶ IHVWKlOW +D EHUPDV· $QWZRUW DXI GLH 6FKZLHULJNHLWHQ GLH PLW .DQWV 7ULHEIHGHUOHKUH YHUEXQGHQVLQGEHVWHKWLQHLQHU(QWNRSSHOXQJGHVSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLV YRPSULQFLSLXPGLMXGLFDWLRQLV
_____________
DOOJHPHLQHU3ULQ]LSLHQDXIJHJHEHQH6LWXDWLRQHQ´XQGGHPÅPRWLYDWLRQDOH>Q@3UREOHP E GHU9HUDQNHUXQJHLQHV9HUIDKUHQVGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJLP3HUV|QOLFK NHLWVV\VWHP´DXFK+DEHUPDV %HUHLWV+DEHUPDV ISUREOHPDWL VLHUW DXFK GLH VLWXDWLYH =XPXWEDUNHLW PRUDOLVFK JHERWHQHU +DQGOXQJHQ Å>«@ QDFK GHP ZLU GLH GHP )DOO HLQ]LJ DQJHPHVVHQH 1RUP IHVWJHVWHOOW KDEHQ NDQQ HV HUIRUGHUOLFKZHUGHQ]XSUIHQREGDVGDUDXVIROJHQGHVLQJXOlUH8UWHLOHLQH+DQGOXQJ IRUGHUWGLHH[LVWHQWLHOOXQ]XPXWEDULVW´ (EG (VLVW DOVRP|JOLFK GDHLQHJOWLJH PRUDOLVFKH1RUPLP/LFKWHHWKLVFKHU(UZlJXQJHQLP(LQ]HOIDOOVXVSHQGLHUWXQGGD PLWVLWXDWLYUHODWLYLHUWZLUG(VVFKHLQWPLUMHGRFKIHVW]XVWHKHQGDDXFKHLQHVROFKH 5HODWLYLHUXQJ DXIJUXQG HLQJHVFKUlQNWHU =XPXWEDUNHLW DOOJHPHLQ ]XJHVWDQGHQ ZHUGHQ PXXQGGDVEHGHXWHWLP'LVNXUVDOVWUDQVVXEMHNWLYJOWLJEHJUQGHWZHUGHQNDQQ 9JOGD]XXDGLH7DEHOOHLQ+DEHUPDV I².DQWKLQJHJHQVSULFKWLQ9 PLW %OLFN DXI GDV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV DXVGUFNOLFK YRQ $QZHQGXQJ XQG XQWHU VFKHLGHWGDPLWEHLGH%HUHLFKHQLFKW +DEHUPDV .DQW,9 9JOGD]X+DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV I
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
(LQOHLWXQJ
8PGLHVH$UJXPHQWDWLRQVVWUDWHJLHMHGRFKDGlTXDWEHOHXFKWHQ]XN|Q QHQJLOWHV]XQlFKVWGHQPRUDOLVFKHQ%HJULIIGHU$FKWXQJEHLGHU3KLORVR SKHQ LQ GHQ EHLGHQ JHQDQQWHQ +LQVLFKWHQ ]X SURILOLHUHQ XQG ]X NULWLVLH UHQ=XQlFKVWVROOGHVKDOE.DQWVPRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHV.RQ]HSWGHU$FKWXQJ YRQ3HUVRQHQJHJHQEHU3HUVRQHQDOV3HUVRQHQH[SRQLHUWZHUGHQ'DEHL ZHUGH LFK PLFK DXI GHQ ÄNULWLVFKHQ¶ .DQW GHU *UXQGOHJXQJ GHU .ULWLN GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW XQG LQ QDFKJHRUGQHWHU %HGHXWXQJ GHU 6FKULIWHQ GHU HU -DKUH EHVFKUlQNHQ XQG LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH GLH $FKWXQJ YRQ 3HUVRQHQ JHJHQEHU3HUVRQHQDOV3HUVRQHQJOHLFKVHW]HQPLWGHU$FKWXQJYRUGHP 6LWWHQJHVHW]'LHVH3Ul]LVLHUXQJLVWGHVKDOEYRQ%HGHXWXQJZHLO.DQWLQ GHQHU-DKUHQEHLVSLHOVZHLVHLQ9RUOHVXQJHQEHU0RUDOGLHVH,GHQWLIL NDWLRQ XQG GDPLW HUKHEOLFKH NRQ]HSWLRQHOOH 6FKZLHULJNHLWHQ QRFK QLFKW KDWWH ZDV QLFKW KHLHQ VROO GD GLH IUKHUH 7KHRULH VHLQHU NULWLVFKHQ EHUOHJHQLVW ,Q HLQHP ]ZHLWHQ 6FKULWW ZHUGH LFK +DEHUPDV· .RQ]HSW HLQHU SRVW NRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ(QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHPRUDOLVFKHU0RWLYDWLRQVRZLHGLHMHQL JH6\VWHPVWHOOHLQQHUKDOEVHLQHU'LVNXUVHWKLNEHQHQQHQDQGHUHQ$QDOR JRQ .DQW GHQ $FKWXQJVEHJULII ORNDOLVLHUWKDWWH (V ZLUG VLFK ]HLJHQ GD +DEHUPDVEH]JOLFKGHVVXEMHNWLYHQ%HVWLPPXQJVJUXQGHVPRUDOLVFKULFK WLJHU+DQGOXQJHQHLQHPHWKRGLVFKH(QJIKUXQJGHUEHJUQGXQJVWKHRUHWL VFKHQ VRZLH GHU HQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ E]Z PRUDOSlGDJRJLVFKHQ %HJULIIH GHU $FKWXQJ E]Z GHUHQ )XQNWLRQVlTXLYDOHQWH YRUQLPPW 'LHVH $XVIKUXQJHQ+DEHUPDV·HUZHLVHQVLFKDOVNRPSDWLEHOPLWGHU EORUX GLPHQWlU GXUFKJHIKUWHQ HQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ E]Z PRUDOSlGD JRJLVFKHQ $UJXPHQWDWLRQ .DQWV LQ GHU 0HWKRGHQOHKUH GHVVHQ ]ZHLWHU .ULWLN GLHVH.DQWLVFKH$UJXPHQWDWLRQZHUGHLFKKLHUQXUVWUHLIHQ 'DPLWVROOWHQGLH*UXQGODJHQHLQHUNULWLVFKHQ.RQIURQWDWLRQGHUEHL GHQ .RQ]HSWLRQHQ XQG HLQHU NULWLVFKHQ $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW GLHVHQ JHVFKDIIHQ VHLQ XP VFKOLHOLFK DE]XZlJHQ D RE +DEHUPDV· NULWLVFKH )RUWIKUXQJGHU.DQWLVFKHQ0RUDOWKHRULHHLQ/HLVWXQJVlTXLYDOHQWIUGLH 7ULHEIHGHU'RNWULQ .DQWV DXIZHLVW XQG E RE +DEHUPDV· 7KHRULH PLW GHUVHOEHQ +\SRWKHN EHODVWHW LVW ZLH GLH .DQWLVFKH KLHUEHL ZLUG PLQGHV WHQVSDUWLHOOGLHNRQ]HSWXHOOH8PJHEXQJGHU'LVNXUVHWKLNPLWHLQEH]RJHQ ZHUGHQPVVHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
Ä7UDQV]HQGHQWDOHbVWKHWLN¶LQSUDNWLVFKHU+LQVLFKW² $FKWXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU $FKWXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU
Å+DQGOHVRGDGLH0D[LPHGHLQHV:LOOHQVMHGHU]HLW]XJOHLFKDOV3ULQ]LS HLQHUDOOJHPHLQHQ*HVHW]JHEXQJJHOWHQN|QQH´.DQWV]ZHLWH.ULWLNVHW]W HLQPLWGLHVHPÅ*UXQGJHVHW]GHUUHLQHQSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW´GHPND WHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYJHKWEHU]XGHQÅ.DWHJRULHQGHU)UHLKHLWLQ$Q VHKXQJGHU%HJULIIH GHV*XWHQXQG%|VHQ´XPLPGULWWHQ+DXSWVWFN GLH )UDJH ]X EHDQWZRUWHQ ZLH ÅHLQ *HVHW] GHU )UHLKHLW DXI +DQGOXQJHQ DOV %HJHEHQKHLWHQ GLH LQGHU 6LQQHQZHOW JHVFKHKHQ >@ DQJHZDQGW ZHU GHQVROO´ 'HU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW JHKW HV QLFKW XP GLH (UNHQQWQLV YRQ *H JHQVWlQGHQ VRQGHUQ XP GLH (UNHQQWQLV GHU 5HDOLVLHUXQJVEHGLQJXQJHQ YRQ*HJHQVWlQGHQQLFKWXPGLH(UNHQQWQLVGHVVHQZDVLVWVRQGHUQGHV VHQZDVVHLQVROO 'DV%HZXWVHLQHLQHV*HVHW]HVGLHVHU5HDOLVLHUXQJLVW GDV (UVWH GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW HLQ ÄDSULRULVFKHV )DNWXP¶ GHPJH
_____________ .DQW9 .DQW9 .DQW9 YJO]XPPHWKRGLVFKHQ9RUJHKHQ.DQWVLQGHU.S9LP*HJHQVDW]]XU .U9%UDQGW8QWHUHLQHU7ULHEIHGHUYHUVWHKW.DQWGHQÅVXEMHFWLYH>Q@ %HVWLPPXQJVJUXQGGHV:LOOHQV´ .DQW9 YJODXFK9VRZLHGLH.DQWLVFKHQ 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJHQ GHU %HJULIIH Å%HVWLPPXQJVJUXQG´ Å%HZHJJUXQG´ XQG Å7ULHEIH GHU´EHL/HH 9JO.U9$X| 9JO.DQW98PGHQHSLVWHPLVFKHQ6WDWXVGLHVHV)DNWXPVLQ.DQWV6LQQH ]XYHUVWHKHQLVWHVKLOIUHLFKVLFKGLHÅlVWKHWLVFKH>Q@9RUEHJULIIHGHU(PSIlQJOLFKNHLW GHV*HPWKVIU3IOLFKWEHJULIIHEHUKDXSW´GLHÅPRUDOLVFKH>Q@%HVFKDIIHQKHLWHQGLH ZHQQPDQVLHQLFKWEHVLW]WHVDXFKNHLQH3IOLFKWJHEHQNDQQVLFKLQLKUHQ%HVLW]]X VHW]HQ´ .DQW9, YRU$XJHQ]XIKUHQGHQQKLHUEHKDQGHOW.DQWQHEHQ GHP ÅPRUDOLVFKH>Q@ *HIKO´ GHU Å0HQVFKHQOLHEH´ XQG GHU Å$FKWXQJ´ DXFK GDV Å*HZLVVHQ´ GDV ]XP HLQHQ XQVHUHP KHXWLJHQ 6SUDFKJHEUDXFK QlKHU VWHKW DOV GDV Ä)DNWXPGHU9HUQXQIW¶XQGGDV]XPDQGHUHQQDFK.DQWGDVÅ%HZXWVHLQHLQHVLQQH UHQ*HULFKWVKRIHVLP0HQVFKHQ ÄYRUZHOFKHPVLFKVHLQH*HGDQNHQHLQDQGHUYHUNOD JHQRGHUHQWVFKXOGLJHQ¶ ´ HEG9, LVW*OHLFKJOWLJZLHPDQGLH0HWDSKHUYRP SUDNWLVFKHQ Ä*HULFKWVKRI¶ XQG GHVVHQ 9HUKlOWQLV ]XP GRUW DQJHZDQG WHQDXVJHOHJWHQ Ä6LWWHQJHVHW]¶ DXIO|VW EHLGH GDV %HZXWVHLQ GHV 6LWWHQJHVHW]HV XQG GDV*HZLVVHQEHVLW]HQGHQ6WDWXVHLQHVLQWHOOLJLEOHQ)DNWXPVLQVRIHUQZLUVLHXQVHLQHU VHLWV]XUHFKQHQDEHUDQGHUHUVHLWVLQDFWXQLFKWEHUVLHYHUIJHQN|QQHQ'HU=XVDW] ÄLQDFWX¶LVWZLFKWLJZHLOXQVGDV *HZLVVHQ QDWUOLFKLQHLQHULQGLUHNWHQ3HUVSHNWLYH GDV KHLW LP 6LQQH VHLQHU .XOWLYLHUXQJ YHUJOHLFKEDU GHU SHUVSHNWLYLVFKHQ 'LIIHUHQ] ]ZLVFKHQVSRUWOLFKHUhEXQJXQG:HWWNDPSI VHKUZRKO]XU'LVSRVLWLRQVWHKW²:LO ODVFKHN YJO DXFK HEG KDW DXI GLH 1RWZHQGLJNHLW KLQJHZLHVHQ ÄIDFWXP¶ EHJULIIOLFK VWUHQJ YRQ ÄGDWXP¶ ]X XQWHUVFKHLGHQ XQG GDV HUVWHUH LP .DQWL VFKHQ6LQQHPLW%HFN II DOVÅÄ7DW¶GHU9HUQXQIW´]XYHUVWHKHQÅGLHGDULQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
$FKWXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU
PlGLH%HJULIIHGHU*HJHQVWlQGHGHU+DQGOXQJGDV*XWHXQGGDV%|VH EHVWLPPWXQGVFKOLHOLFKGLH0RGLVHLQHUP|JOLFKHQ%HIROJXQJDXIJH]HLJW ZHUGHQ(VVFKHLQWQDFK.DQWP|JOLFK]XVHLQVR]XVDJHQRKQH3URILWG KVFKOLPPVWHQIDOOVXQWHU7RGHVGURKXQJPRUDOLVFK]XKDQGHOQDOVREHL VSLHOVZHLVH HLQ IDOVFKHV =HXJQLV ]X YHUZHLJHUQ REZRKO PDQ GDIU PLW GHP7RGEHVWUDIWZHUGHQZLUG'LHVH+DQGOXQJVP|JOLFKNHLW QLFKWLKUH :LUNOLFKNHLW GHPRQVWULHUWGDV%HZXWVHLQGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVDOVHLQ)DN WXP*OHLFKZRKO²XQGGDVLVWHLQZHQQQLFKWGHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH6FKULWWLQ GHU.DQWLVFKHQ7KHRULH²LVWGDV%HZXWVHLQGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVGLH(LQ VLFKWLQVHLQH*HOWXQJQLFKWJOHLFK]XVHW]HQPLWGHUHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ+DQG OXQJVPD[LPH :LU N|QQHQ GLH 5LFKWLJNHLW GHV 6LWWHQJHVHW]HV HLQVHKHQ RKQHGDQDFK]XKDQGHOQ GDV:LVVHQGHV*XWHQLVWQLFKWVFKRQGDV*XWH VHOEVW(VEHGDUIDOVRHLQHV=ZLVFKHQVFKULWWHVYRP6LWWHQJHVHW]]XUVLWWOL FKHQ +DQGOXQJ GDV %HZXWVHLQ GHV 6LWWHQJHVHW]HV VROO KDQGOXQJVDXVO| VHQGVHLQ ,P GULWWHQ XQG OHW]WHQ +DXSWVWFN GHU Å$QDO\WLN GHU UHLQHQ SUDNWL VFKHQ9HUQXQIW´WKHPDWLVLHUW.DQWGHPHQWVSUHFKHQGGLHÅ7ULHEIHGHUQGHU UHLQHQSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW´ DXIJUXQGZHOFKHUSUDNWLVFKHQ/HLVWXQJLVW GHU 0HQVFK ² GHQQ QXU EH]JOLFK HQGOLFKHU :HVHQ ZLH GHP 0HQVFKHQ VWHOOWVLFKGHUHPRWLYH$QWULHEDOVPRUDOWKHRUHWLVFKHV3UREOHP²]XHLQHU JXWHQ+DQGOXQJIlKLJ"'LHVHV7KHRULHVWFN]XP%HJULIIGHU$FKWXQJLVW EHL .DQW VWUHQJ ]X XQWHUVFKHLGHQ YRP PRUDOSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ E]Z SlGDJRJLVFKHQ.RQWH[W(VVROOXPGLH0|JOLFKNHLWGHU5HDOLVLHUXQJHLQHV PRUDOLVFKHQ *HVHW]HV LQ HLQVFKOlJLJHQ 6LWXDWLRQHQ JHKHQ QLFKW XP GLH )UDJHZLHPDQ0HQVFKHQ]XJXWHQ7DWHQEHZHJHQN|QQH'DV%HZXW VHLQGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVGKGLH$FKWXQJYRUOHW]WHUHPVROODOV7ULHEIHGHU ]XU WDWVlFKOLFKHQ +DQGOXQJVLQLWLDWLYH ZHUGHQ $FKWXQJ VROO VRZRKO EH JULIIOLFK XQG REMHNWLY VLWWOLFK VHLQ DOV DXFK NRQNUHW XQG VXEMHNWLY KDQG OXQJVEHVWLPPHQG.DQWIKUWLQGLHVHP.RQWH[WEHNDQQWOLFKHLQHIROJHQ
_____________ EHVWHKW GHP ÄREMHNWLYHQ¶ 6LWWHQJHVHW] VXEMHNWLYH *HOWXQJ ]X YHUVFKDIIHQ LQGHP VLH HLQ *HIKO GHU $FKWXQJ YRU GHP *HVHW] ÄZLUNW¶ XQG VR GHQ Ä:LOOHQ ]XU 7KDW EH VWLPPW¶´ :LOODVFKHN 9JO GD]X EHUHLWV +HQULFK VRZLH /DXHQHU LQVEHVII.RQKDUGW )RUVW .HXO 2·1HLOO 6FDUDQR E 6WHLJOHGHU VRZLH LP $QVFKOX DQ +HQULFK )RUVW YJODXFKREHQ.DS)Q .DS)Q 9JO.DQW9 .DQW9 'LH/HJLWLPDWLRQGLHVHU$EWUHQQXQJOLHJWGDULQGDVRODQJHQLFKWGHU%HJULIIVLQKDOW GHU$FKWXQJJHNOlUWLVWHLQHPRUDOSV\FKRORJLVFKHXQGSlGDJRJLVFKH%HKDQGOXQJGHV 3UREOHPVRKQH)XQGDPHQWLVW'LH.DQWLVFKH0HWKRGHQOHKUHVHW]WGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGH (OHPHQWDUOHKUH YRUDXV 2GHU DXI GHU +DQGOXQJVHEHQH IRUPXOLHUW PDQ PX ZLVVHQ ZDV PDQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH .LQGHUQ DQHU]LHKW ZHQQ PDQ VLH $FKWXQJ YRU GHP *HVHW] OHKUW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
VFKZHUH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJHLQ YRQ0RUDOLWlWN|QQHQXUJHVSURFKHQZHUGHQ VRIHUQGDV6LWWHQJHVHW]DXFKVXEMHNWLYHU%HVWLPPXQJVJUXQG]XU+DQGOXQJ LVW :LUG KLQJHJHQ DXV EHOLHELJHQ DQGHUHQ 0RWLYHQ KHUDXV PRUDOLVFK JH KDQGHOW VR ZLUG HLJHQWOLFK QLFKW PRUDOLVFK JHKDQGHOW 'LH +DQGOXQJ JH VFKLHKWÅSIOLFKWPlLJDEHUQLFKWDXV3IOLFKW´DOVRQLFKWDXV$FKWXQJIUV *HVHW]'LH+DQGOXQJLVWOHJDODEHUVLHLVWQLFKWPRUDOLVFK (LQ K\SRWKHWLVFKHU 9RUEOLFN DXI GDV )ROJHQGH VROO YHUGHXWOLFKHQ LQ ZHOFKHP$XVPDGLH7UDJIlKLJNHLWGHUJHVDPWHQ.DQWLVFKHQ0RUDOWKHR ULH YRQ GHU *OWLJNHLW GLHVHV $FKWXQJVEHJULIIV DEKlQJW VROOWH GHU .DQWL VFKH %HJULII GHU $FKWXQJ DOV 7ULHEIHGHU PRUDOLVFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ QLFKW KLQUHLFKHQGEHVWLPPWVHLQVREOLHEHDXFKGHU%HJULIIGHU0RUDOLWlWXQJH NOlUW GD QDFK .DQW HEHQ QXU GLHMHQLJH +DQGOXQJ PRUDOLVFK LVW GLH DXV 3IOLFKW G K DXV $FKWXQJ YRU GHP 6LWWHQJHVHW] JHVFKLHKW 1HUYXV SUR EDQGLGHU7KHRULHLVW]ZDUGLHP|JOLFKH%HXUWHLOXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJHQGRFK VHW]WGLH%HZHUWXQJHLQHU+DQGOXQJJHPlGHPSULQFLSLXPGLMXGLFDWLRQLV DOVPRUDOLVFKHP.ULWHULXPDOVRGHP6LWWHQJHVHW]HLQ:LVVHQGDYRQYRU DXVZDVLPMHZHLOLJHQ)DOOKDQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYDOVRSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLV LVWRGHUZDU'DGLH0RUDOLWlWGKGLH$FKWXQJYRUGHP*HVHW]LQGHU ,QWHQWLRQ HLQHV +DQGHOQGHQ GHU +DQGOXQJ QLFKW ÄDQJHVHKHQ¶ MD QLFKW HLQPDO YRP +DQGHOQGHQ VHOEVW PLW 6LFKHUKHLW JHZXW ZHUGHQ NDQQ EHGDUIHVQDFK.DQWHLQHV,QGLNDWRUVXPGLH+DQGOXQJKLQVLFKWOLFKLKUHU 0RUDOLWlW ]X TXDOLIL]LHUHQ'LHVHU,QGLNDWRU IU GDV XQHUNHQQEDUH *HIKO GHU $FKWXQJ LVW GDV JXW HUNHQQEDUH *HIKO GHU 8QOXVW 'LH SDUDGR[H .RQVHTXHQ] ZlUH GHPQDFK GD LQ GHU%HXUWHLOXQJ ² XQG QXU KLHU ]HLJW VLFK GLH 0RUDOLWlW ² GLH VLWWOLFKH 4XDOLWlW HLQHU +DQGOXQJ QXQ GRFK GHU 6FKLOOHUVFKHQ %HIUFKWXQJ HQWVSUHFKHQG DQ GHU hEHUZLQGXQJ HLQHV VLQQOLFKHQ +LQGHUQLVVHV KlQJW 'DPLW JlEH GLH SDWKRORJLVFKH bXHUXQJ GHU 8QOXVW XQG QLFKW GLH $FKWXQJ GHQ .DQWLVFKHQ .RPSD PRUDOLVFKHU %HZHUWXQJ DE 6ROOWH GLHV ]XWUHIIHQ VR ZlUH GHU 5HLQKHLWVDQVSUXFK GHU .DQWLVFKHQ0RUDOWKHRULHYRQ*UXQGDXINRUUXPSLHUW
_____________ .DQW,9 9JO.DQW9XQG .DQWVFKHLQWGLHVH.RQVHTXHQ]QLFKWJHJHQZlUWLJJHZHVHQ]XVHLQ YJO.DQW9 9JO ]XU 8QP|JOLFKNHLW YROOVWlQGLJHU ,QWURVSHNWLRQ .DQW .U9 $ ,9 XQG 9,,,IIVRZLHXQWHQ)Q 9JOEHLVSLHOVZHLVH.DQW,9 IVRZLH9IXQG9, Å*HUQHGLHQ·LFKGHQ)UHXQGHQGRFKWKX·LFKHVOHLGHUPLW1HLJXQJ8QGVRZXUPW HVPLURIWGDLFKQLFKWWXJHQGKDIWELQ'DLVWNHLQDQGHUHU5DWKGXPXWVXFKHQ VLH]XYHUDFKWHQ8QGPLW$EVFKHXDOVGDQQWKXQZLHGLH3IOLFKWGLUJHEHXW´ 6FKLO OHU ;HQLHQÅ'LH3KLORVRSKHQ´ 9JOGD]X5HLQHU
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
$FKWXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU
(V HUVFKHLQW QXQ XQP|JOLFK HLQHP 9HUVWlQGQLV GLHVHV $FKWXQJVEH JULIIVXQGGDPLWHLQHU$QWZRUWDXIGLH)UDJHQDFKGHPZDVZLUWXQZHQQ ZLUDXV3IOLFKWDXV$FKWXQJIUV*HVHW]KDQGHOQGDGXUFKQlKHU]XNRP PHQ GD PDQ YRUNDQWLVFKH (WKLNHQ QDFK GLHVHP %HJULII EHIUDJW 9LHO PHKUEOHLEWPDQEHLGHU$QDO\VHGHV$FKWXQJVEHJULIIVLQHWKLVFKHP=X VDPPHQKDQJYHUZLHVHQDXIGLHNULWLVFKHQ7H[WH.DQWVYRUQHKPOLFKDOVR GLH*UXQGOHJXQJGLH]ZHLWH.ULWLNVRZLHGLH0HWDSK\VLVFKHQ$QIDQJVJUQGHGHU 7XJHQGOHKUH 'HU %HJULII ILQGHW VLFK V\VWHPDWLVFK DXVJHIKUW LQ NHLQHU
_____________ 'DGHU%HJULIIGHU$FKWXQJEHL.DQWLQNRQVWLWXWLYHP=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHPGHV .DWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYVVWHKWGHUHUVWLP/DXIHGHUVLHE]LJHU-DKUHYRQLKPHQWZL FNHOW ZXUGH WUDJHQ DXFK GLH YRUNULWLVFKHQ 6FKULIWHQ QLFKWV ]XU (UKHOOXQJ GLHVHV %H JULIIVEHL:HQQ.DQWDOVRLQGHQ%HREDFKWXQJHQEHUGDV*HIKOGHV6FK|QHQXQG(UKDEHQHQ YRQ $FKWXQJ VSULFKW VR LVW GDPLW QLFKW GDV 9HUELQGXQJVJOLHG ]ZLVFKHQ GHP UHLQHQ6LWWHQJHVHW]XQGGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ+DQGOXQJLQWHQGLHUW YJO.DQW,, 'DV PRUDOLVFKH*HIKOLVWKLHUVHOEVWYLHOPHKU*UXQGPRUDOLVFKHU*UXQGVlW]H YJODXFK .DQW ,, *HJHQ (QGH GHV -DKUHV VFKUHLEW .DQW VFKOLHOLFK DQ 0DUFXV +HU] Å'HUREHUVWH*UXQGGHU0RUDOLWlWPXQLFKWEORVDXIGDV:RKOJHIDOOHQVFKOLH HQODVVHQHUPXVHOEVWLPK|FKVWHQ*UDGHZRKOJHIDOOHQGHQQHULVWNHLQHEORVVSH NXODWLYH9RUVWHOOXQJVRQGHUQPX%HZHJNUDIWKDEHQXQGGDKHUREHU]ZDULQWHOOHFWXDO LVWVRPXHUGRFKHLQHJHUDGH%H]LHKXQJDXIGLHHUVWH7ULHEIHGHUQGHV:LOOHQVKD EHQ´ .DQW; 'DPLWLVWHLQZLFKWLJHU6FKULWWKLQ]XUNULWLVFKHQ7KHRULHPRUDOL VFKHU+DQGOXQJHQJHWDQGLHHQGJOWLJH$ENHKUYRQGHUYRUNULWLVFKHQ0RUDOSKLORVR SKLH MHGRFK QRFK QLFKW YROO]RJHQ :RKOJHIDOOHQ DXFK HLQ UHOLJL|V JHIlUEWHV LVW IU GHQNULWLVFKHQ.DQWPRUDOLUUHOHYDQW,QGHUVRJHQDQQWHQ0RUDO9RUOHVXQJ.DHKOHUDXV GHU0LWWHGHUHU-DKUHGLIIHUHQ]LHUW.DQWQDFKULFKWOLFK]ZDUEHUHLWV]ZLVFKHQGHP ÅSULQFLSLXPGHUGLLXGLFDWLRQGHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLW´XQGGHPÅSULQFLSLXPGHU([HFXWLRQRGHU /HLVWXQJ GHU 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW´ XQG IKUW GD]X DXV Å5LFKWVFKQXU XQG 7ULHEIHGHU LVW KLHU]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQ5LFKWVFKQXULVWGDV3ULQFLSLXPGHU'LLXGLFDWLRQXQG7ULHEIHGHU >VF GDV 3ULQFLSLXP@ GHU $XVEXQJ GHU 9HUELQGOLFKNHLW LQGHP PDQ QXQ GLHVHV YHU ZHFKVHOWHVRZDUDOOHVLQGHU0RUDOIDOVFK´ .DQW .DQWNRQNUHWLVLHUWGLHVH %HVWLPPXQJZHLWHULQGHP6LQQHGHQZLUDXVGHQ3XEOLNDWLRQHQGHUHU-DKUHNHQ QHQ Å'LH%LOOLJXQJGHU+DQGOXQJLVWGHURELHFWLYH*UXQGDEHUQRFKQLFKWGHUVXEMHF WLYH*UXQG'DVMHQLJHZDVPLFKDQWUHLEWGDV]XWKXQZRYRQGHU9HUVWDQGVDJWLFK VROOHVWKXQGDVVLQGGLHPRWLYDVXEMHFWLYHPRYHQWLD´ .DQW 'RFKYRQHL QHPYHUQXQIWEHZLUNWHQ*HIKOLVWKLHUQRFKLPPHUNHLQH5HGH VWDWWGHVVHQZLUGGLH PRUDOLVFKH 0RWLYDWLRQ DOV JHQXLQHV *HIKO DQJHVSURFKHQ Å>@ GDV REHUVWH SULQFLSL XP DOOHV PRUDOLVFKHQ $QWULHEHV GLHVH +DQGOXQJ ]X WKXQ OLHJW LP +HUW]HQ GLHVH 7ULHEIHGHULVWGDVPRUDOLVFKH*HIKO´ (EG 8QGVFKOLHOLFKILQGHWPDQZHQLJH$E VlW]H VSlWHU LQ GLHVHU 1DFKVFKULIW HLQH )RUPXOLHUXQJ JHJHQ GHUHQ 7HQGHQ] VLFK GHU NULWLVFKH .DQW JHUDGH ZHQGHW Å0DQ KDW DOVR PLW 5HFKW HLQJHVHKHQ GD RKQH HLQHQ REHUVWHQ 5LFKWHU DOOH PRUDOLVFKHQ *HVHW]H RKQH (IIHFW ZlUHQ DOVGHQQ ZlUH NHLQH 7ULHEIHGHUNHLQH%HORKQXQJXQGNHLQH%HVWUDIXQJ$OVRGLH(UNHQQWQL*RWWHVLVWLQ $QVHKXQJGHU$XVEXQJGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ*HVHW]HQRWKZHQGLJ´ .DQW ,P 6LQQHGHVNULWLVFKHQ.DQWNULWLVLHUW+HQULFKGLHVHQ$VSHNWGHUYRUNULWLVFKHQ0RUDOSKL ORVRSKLH .DQWV Å(LQ *HVHW] GDV QLFKW IU VLFK VHOEVW YHUELQGOLFK LVW VRQGHUQ HUVW GDQQYHUELQGHQGH.UDIWJHZLQQWZHQQLFKYRP'DVHLQHLQHVLQWHOOLJLEHOHQ8UZHVHQV EHU]HXJWELQHQWKlOWNHLQH0RWLYHLQVLFKHLQVROFKHV'DVHLQDQ]XQHKPHQ´ +HQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
IUKHUHQ 0RUDONRQ]HSWLRQ $FKWXQJ KDW LQ GHU 3KLORVRSKLH ELV ]X .DQW OHGLJOLFKGLHHLQJDQJVJHQDQQWHPRUDOSKLORVRSKLVFKDEHUK|FKVWHQVPDU JLQDOH%HGHXWXQJYRQ$XIPHUNVDPNHLW DWWHQWLRREVHUYDWLR 8PHLQHLQKDOWOLFKH)OOXQJGHV$FKWXQJVEHJULIIV]XHUUHLFKHQ NDQQ HUKLQVLFKWOLFKVHLQHVP|JOLFKHQ2EMHNWEHUHLFKVPLWGHP%HJULIIGHU1HL JXQJ NRQWUDVWLHUW ZHUGHQ 1HLJXQJHQ N|QQHQ VLFK QDFK .DQW HLQHUVHLWV DXI +DQGOXQJHQ DQGHUHUVHLWV DXI 3URGXNWH YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ EH]LHKHQ $FKWXQJKLQJHJHQVROOVLFKZHGHUDXI+DQGOXQJHQQRFKDXI+DQGOXQJVHU JHEQLVVH QRFK DXI 1HLJXQJHQ EH]LHKHQ N|QQHQ ,KU 2EMHNW LVW DOOHLQ GLH ,QWHQWLRQHLQHU3HUVRQ²RGHULQ.DQWV:RUWHQ QLFKWGLH:LUNXQJVRQ GHUQ EOR GLH Å7KlWLJNHLW HLQHV :LOOHQV´ /DSLGDU KHLW HV LQ GHU .ULWLN GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW Å$FKWXQJ JHKW MHGHU]HLW QXU DXI 3HUVRQHQ >@´ $XVIRUPXOLHUW EHGHXWHW GLHV GD XQVHUH $FKWXQJ YRU HLQHU 3HUVRQ HLQH $FKWXQJYRUGHU0HQVFKKHLW²XQPLYHUVWlQGOLFKHU GHP0HQVFKVHLQG KGHU)UHLKHLW²GLHVHU3HUVRQYRUGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWGLHVHU3HU VRQXQGGDPLWYRUGHP6LWWHQJHVHW]LVW 'RFK DXFK QDFK GLHVHU GHQ %HJULII GHU 3HUVRQ XQG GHQ %HJULII GHV 6LWWHQJHVHW]HVYHUNQSIHQGHQ%HVWLPPXQJGHVP|JOLFKHQ2EMHNWEHUHLFKV GHU $FKWXQJ EOHLEW GLH )UDJH QDFK GHP ,QKDOW GHV $FKWXQJVEHJULIIV EH VWHKHQ 8QG .DQWV $QWZRUW ODXWHW Å(LJHQWOLFK LVW $FKWXQJ GLH 9RUVWHO OXQJYRQHLQHP:HUWKHGHUPHLQHU6HOEVWOLHEH$EEUXFKWKXW´:LHVLFK REHQ LQ JH]HLJW KDW EHVWHKW GHU +LQWHUJUXQG GLHVHU 1HJDWLYEHVWLP PXQJ GDULQ GD PRUDOLVFKH +DQGOXQJHQ GLH XQWHU GHP %HJULII GHU 3IOLFKWVWHKHQN|QQHQVLQQYROOHUZHLVHQXUYRQVROFKHQ:HVHQ]XIRUGHUQ VLQG GLH GDEHL +LQGHUQLVVH EHUZLQGHQ PVVHQ %HL K\SRWKHWLVFK ]X GHQNHQGHQ :HVHQ GLH QLFKW JHJHQ QHLJXQJVEHGLQJWH +LQGHUQLVVH DQ
_____________
ULFK ,QQHUKDOE GHU HLQVFKOlJLJHQ NULWLVFKHQ 6FKULIWHQ NDQQ LFK NHLQHQ :DQGHOKLQVLFKWOLFKGHV%HJULIIVGHU$FKWXQJDXVPDFKHQ6LHN|QQHQPHLQHV(UDFK WHQVGLHVEH]JOLFKJOHLFKZHUWLJEHKDQGHOWZHUGHQ9JOGD]X/HH XQG GDJHJHQ %HFN YJO ]XU (QWZLFNOXQJ GHU YRUNULWLVFKHQ (WKLN .DQWV +HQ ULFK XQG VRZLH /HH 0D\HU KDW JHJHQEHU 1XQQHU:LQNOHU I XQG JH]HLJW LQZLHIHUQ GHU NULWLVFKH .DQW JHUDGH QLFKWDXIUHOLJL|VH$UJXPHQWHUHNXUULHUW YJOGD]XDXFK/HLVW5LFNHQ XQG6WHLJOHGHU 9JOGD]X0LVJHOG I .DQW,9 .DQW9 YJO]XP%HJULIIGHU3HUV|QOLFKNHLWDXFKGLHLQ.DS)QDQJHJHEH QHQ3DVVDJHQLQ.DQWV7H[WHQ 9JO.DQW,9I9$QPVRZLHGD]X.|KO XQGGLH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ GHU JHQDQQWHQ %HVWLPPXQJHQ EHL .OLPFKXN 9JO]XGHQ%H JULIIHQGHV0HQVFKHQXQGGHU0HQVFKKHLW.U9$VRZLHGLH$QWKURSRORJLH)ULHG OlQGHU :LQWHU .DQW;;9IIXQGREHQ.DS)Q .DQW,9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
$FKWXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU
NlPSIHQPVVHQPDFKWGLH9HUZHQGXQJGHV%HJULIIVÄ6ROOHQ¶XQGGDPLW YHUEXQGHQ GLH GHU %HJULIIH GHV *HERWHV XQG GHU $FKWXQJ GDYRU NHLQHQ 6LQQ %HL :HVHQ PLW HLQHP GHUDUWLJHQ YROONRPPHQ JXWHQ KHLOLJHQ RGHU J|WWOLFKHQ:LOOHQN|QQWHOHGLJOLFKYRQHLQHPÄ:ROOHQ¶JHVSURFKHQZHUGHQ LKUH+DQGOXQJVPD[LPHQHQWVSUlFKHQVWHWVXQGDXVVFKOLHOLFKGHP6LWWHQ JHVHW] YRQ1|WLJXQJHLQHUÅQHFHVVLWDWLRRELHFWLYD´N|QQWHGDEHLNHLQH 5HGHVHLQ (LQ+DQGHOQDXV$FKWXQJVHW]WEHL0HQVFKHQDOVRDOVPRUDOLVFKUHOH YDQW GDV 1HJDWLYH GLH hEHUZLQGXQJ YRQ +LQGHUQLVVHQ YRQ 1HLJXQJHQ YRUDXV RKQHMHGRFKGXUFK1HLJXQJHQYHUXUVDFKW]XVHLQ *OHLFKZRKOLVW GLHVH hEHUZLQGXQJ QLFKW VFKRQ GLH ]XUHLFKHQGH %HGLQJXQJ ² QLFKW MHGH +DQGOXQJ GLH GHU 1HLJXQJ ]XZLGHUOlXIW LVW GDGXUFK DOOHLQ VFKRQ PRUD OLVFK(LQ$OWUXLVWGHUVLFKJHOHJHQWOLFKHJRLVWLVFKYHUKlOWKDQGHOWGHVZH JHQQLFKWVFKRQPRUDOLVFK (VEHGDUIDOVRHLQHUZHLWHUUHLFKHQGHQSRVLWLYHQ%HVWLPPXQJGHV$FK WXQJVEHJULIIV $FKWXQJ EHVWHKW JHPl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lWGHV,QWHOOLJLEOHQLVW
_____________ .DQW;,; 5HIO YJODXFK.DQW,9.DQW9X| 9JO.DQW,9 DXFK9XQG9,I 9RU $OOLVRQ GHU GLHVEH]JOLFK YRQ Å.DQW·V LQWHUQDOLVP´ VSULFKW KDW EHUHLWV1DJHO.DQWPLW%OLFNDXIGHQNDWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYDOV0RWLYDWLRQVLQWHUQD OLVWHQ FKDUDNWHULVLHUW Å:DV GLH )RUGHUXQJHQ IU XQV EHUKDXSW JOWLJ PDFKW PX VHOEVWGDVMHQLJHVHLQZDVXQVHUH0RWLYDWLRQVVWUXNWXUGD]XEHVWLPPWHQWVSUHFKHQG]X KDQGHOQ>«@*LQJHHVQDFK .DQWZUGHXQVHUH %LQGXQJDQPRUDOLVFKH,PSHUDWLYH DXVXQVHUHP6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLV DOVIUHLH:HVHQKHUIOLHHQXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ IlQGHLKUH (UNOlUXQJMHGHU]HLWLQ GHUVRKHUJHOHLWHWHQ$QHLJQXQJGHV*HVROOWHQ'DV ZlUH]XGHPNHLQH(UNOlUXQJDXV0RWLYHQVRQGHUQHLQH(UNOlUXQJVDUWGLHVWDWWYRQ GHP 0RWLYDWLRQVJHIJH *HEUDXFK ]X PDFKHQ HLQHQ VHLQHU JUXQGOHJHQGHQ =JH HU NOlUHQG EHVFKUHLEW´ 1DJHO (V LVW ZLFKWLJ IHVW]XKDOWHQ GD DXFK QDFK .DQWV $QVLFKW GLHVHV *HIKO GHU $FKWXQJ YRQ DQGHUHQ SDWKRORJLVFKHQ *HIKOHQ EHJOHLWHW²XQGGDVEHGHXWHW XQWHUVWW]WRGHUEHUVWLPPW²ZHUGHQNDQQ:HGHUJLEW HV HLQHQ $XWRPDWLVPXV GHU YRP *HIKO GHU $FKWXQJ ]XU PRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
6RZHLWGLHPHWDSK\VLVFKH.RQVWUXNWLRQGLHLQIROJHQGHP6LQQHVFKRQ DEHQWHXHUOLFKJHQXJLVW 'HU%HJULIIVLQKDOWGHU$FKWXQJLVWQLFKWHLQHUVHLWV LQWHOOHNWXHOO 6LWWHQJHVHW] XQGDQGHUHUVHLWVVLQQOLFK *HIKO ZLHGLHVEHL HLQHP hEHUJDQJ YRP PXQGXV LQWHOOLJLELOLV ]XP PXQGXV VHQVLELOLV HUIRU GHUOLFKZlUH 9LHOPHKULVWQDFKGHU.DQWLVFKHQ.RQ]HSWLRQGLH8UVDFKH GHV $FKWXQJVJHIKOV HLQ *HJHQVWDQG GHU 9HUQXQIW VLH VHOEVW DEHU LVW QLFKWV DQGHUHV DOV HLQ *HIKO GDV EHJULIIOLFK PHVVHUVFKDUI JHWUHQQW LVW YRP 9HUQXQIWJHVHW] HEHQ GXUFK GDV UHODWLRQDOH %HJULIIVSDDU 8UVDFKH :LUNXQJ G K GHU .DWHJRULH GHU .DXVDOLWlW GLH LKUHUVHLWV DOV .DXVDOLWlW GHU)UHLKHLWXQGGDPLWDOVQLFKWVFKHPDWLVLHUW LQWKHRUHWLVFKHP9HUVWlQG QLV G K DOV XQ]HLWOLFK YRUJHVWHOOW ZHUGHQ VROO $EJHVHKHQ KLHUYRQ LVW DEHU GDGXUFK GD GLHVH .RQVWUXNWLRQ EOR EHU 9HUKlOWQLVVH EHILQGHW QRFKNHLQHLQKDOWOLFKH$XVVDJHEHUGLH5HODWLRQVEHJULIIHVHOEVWJHWURIIHQ 'HUHLQHGHUEHLGHQ%HJULIIHGLH8UVDFKH 9HUQXQIWJHVHW] VROOKLHUQLFKW ZHLWHUXQWHUVXFKWVHLQH,QKDOWVEHVWLPPXQJVROODOVNRQVLVWHQWXQGNRKl UHQWYRUDXVJHVHW]WZHUGHQ'HUDQGHUH%HJULIIDEHUGDVVLQQOLFKH*HIKO GHU $FKWXQJ ² ÅGHQQ HLQ LQWHOOHFWXHOOHV ZlUH HLQ :LGHUVSUXFK´ ² DOV :LUNXQJPXQRFKZHLWHUEHVWLPPWZHUGHQ 'DV QHJDWLYH *HIKO GHU 'HPWLJXQJ XQG GHV 6FKPHU]HV DQOlOLFK GHU (LQVFKUlQNXQJ RGHU 9HUQLFKWXQJ GHU 6HOEVWOLHEH GXUFK GDV %HZXW
_____________ IKUWQRFKGUIHQRGHUEHVVHUPVVHQZLUXQVGHQÅlUJVWH>Q@%|VHZLFKW´ .DQW,9 DOVHLQHPRUDOLVFKWDXEH3HUVRQYRUVWHOOHQGLHGDQQHEHQQLFKWHLQPDOPHKU3HU VRQ ZlUH ZHLO VLH LP VWULNWHQ 6LQQH NHLQH PRUDOLVFKH 9HUDQWZRUWXQJ PHKU WUJH 'RFKVHOEVWZHQQLPSRVLWLYHQ)DOOGLH$FKWXQJIUV*HVHW]QLFKWDOOHLQKLQUHLFKWGLH PRUDOLVFKH +DQGOXQJ ]X PRWLYLHUHQ XQG DQGHUH *HIKOH XQWHUVWW]HQG KLQ]XNRP PHQVREOHLEWIU.DQWGRFKHQWVFKHLGHQGGDGLHVHV+LQ]XWUHWHQIUGHQPRUDOLVFKHQ 6WDWXVGHU+DQGOXQJY|OOLJLUUHOHYDQWLVW9JOGD]XDXFK7LPPHUPDQQ JHJHQ .|KO 7LPPHUPDQQ EHWRQW ]XGHP LQ $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW $OOLVRQ XQG 0F&DUW\ ]X 5HFKW GD GDV .UlIWHVSLHO KDQG OXQJVUHOHYDQWHU*HIKOHQLFKWPHFKDQLVWLVFKYHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQGDUI DXFK1HLJXQJHQ PVVHQ DOV +DQGOXQJVJUQGH DEJHZRJHQ ZHUGHQ GHQQ ZUGHQ *HIKOH QXU ÄKLQWHU XQVHUHP5FNHQ¶ZLUNHQN|QQWHYRQHLQHU+DQGOXQJVFKOLHOLFKNHLQH5HGHVHLQGDV 9HUKDOWHQZlUHQLFKW]XUHFKHQEDU (LQH VROFKH $UJXPHQWDWLRQ KlWWH LKU WKHRUHWLVFKHV $QDORJRQ LP Ä6FKHPDWLVPXV GHU UHLQHQ9HUVWDQGHVEHJULIIH¶ YJOGD]X.U9$I 'LH3UREOHPDWLNGHU.DQWLVFKHQ $XVIKUXQJHQ]XHLQHPÄSUDNWLVFKHQ6FKHPDWLVPXV¶EHVWHKWGDULQGDDQGHU6FKQLWW VWHOOH ]ZLVFKHQ PXQGXV LQWHOOLJLELOLV GHP 6LWWHQJHVHW] XQG GHP PXQGXV VHQVLELOLV GHU+DQGOXQJGHU]ZHLVWHOOLJH5HODWLRQVEHJULIIGHU.DXVDOLWlWHLQJHIKUWZLUGGHVVHQ HLQHV 5HODWXP GLH 8UVDFKH 6LWWHQJHVHW] PLW GHP DQGHUHQ 5HODWXP GHU :LUNXQJ *HIKO LP$FKWXQJVEHJULIIYHUNQSIWZHUGHQVROO YJOGD]X.DQW9II 7KHR ULHDUFKLWHNWRQLVFKSUREOHPDWLVFKDQGLHVHU(LQIKUXQJGHU.DXVDOLWlWLVW.DQWVHLJHQH VLQQJHPlH'HILQLWLRQGHV7ULHEIHGHU.DSLWHOVDOVÄ7UDQV]HQGHQWDOHbVWKHWLN·LQSUDN WLVFKHU+LQVLFKW YJOGD]X.DQW9 IVRZLH%UDQGW .DQW9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
$FKWXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU
VHLQGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVKDWQDFK.DQWDOVSRVLWLYH.HKUVHLWHHLQ%HZXW VHLQ GHV 0HQVFKHQ DOV 3HUVRQ ÅVR LVW GLH +HUDEVHW]XQJ GHU $QVSUFKH GHUPRUDOLVFKHQ6HOEVWVFKlW]XQJGLGLH'HPWKLJXQJDXIGHUVLQQOLFKHQ 6HLWHHLQH(UKHEXQJGHUPRUDOLVFKHQGLGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ6FKlW]XQJGHV *HVHW]HV VHOEVW DXI GHU LQWHOOHFWXHOOHQ PLW HLQHP :RUWH $FKWXQJ IUV *HVHW]DOVRDXFKHLQVHLQHULQWHOOHFWXHOOHQ8UVDFKHQDFKSRVLWLYHV*HIKO GDVDSULRULHUNDQQWZLUG´6HOEVWOLHEHLVWQDFK.DQWHLQSDWKRORJLVFKHV *HIKO G K QLFKW JHVHW]HV VRQGHUQ QHLJXQJVEHGLQJW 6LH PX GXUFK HWZDV EHUVWLPPW ZHUGHQ GDV QLFKW SDWKRORJLVFKHU 1DWXU LVW 'D GLHVH 6HOEVWOLHEHDOV*HIKOQXQHLQPDOVREHVWLPPWLVWEOHLEWHVQDFK.DQW² ]XPLQGHVWGHPNULWLVFKHQ.DQW²QDWUOLFKDXVJHVFKORVVHQGDVLHGXUFK HLQH DQGHUH )RUP YRQ /LHEH EHUVWLPPW ZHUGHQ NDQQ RKQH GDPLW GDV )HOGGHU0RUDOLWlW]XYHUODVVHQ.DQWYHUVWHKW/LHEHDOV=XQHLJXQJXQGHLQH
_____________ .DQW9 .DQWV3RVLWLRQXQWHUVWW]HQGEHVFKUHLEW+RQQHWKGHQV\VWH PDWLVFKHQ=XVDPPHQKDQJ]ZLVFKHQGHU6HOEVWOLHEHGHU$EEUXFKJHWDQZLUGXQGGHU 9RUVWHOOXQJYRP:HUWHLQHU3HUVRQDXVLQWHUVXEMHNWLYLVWLVFKHU3HUVSHNWLYH Å>«@GDV 6XEMHNW HUZLUEW JHZLVVHUPDHQ JOHLFKXUVSUQJOLFK PLW GHU $FKWXQJ DXFK EHUHLWV GLH 0RWLYDWLRQJHJHQEHUGHPJHDFKWHWHQÄ:HUW¶DXIDOOH+DQGOXQJHQ]XYHU]LFKWHQGLH HLQIDFK GDV 5HVXOWDW VHLQHU HJR]HQWULVFKHQ ,PSXOVH ZlUHQ >@ ,Q GHQ H[SUHVVLYHQ *HVWHQGLHDXIHLQIDFKHU6WXIHJHZ|KQOLFK$QHUNHQQXQJVLJQDOLVLHUHQNRPPWH[DNW GLHVHOEHPRWLYDWLRQDOH%HUHLWVFKDIW]XP$XVGUXFNGLH.DQWDOVÄ$EEUXFK¶YRQ6HOEVW OLHEH EHVFKUHLEW >@ ,P DQHUNHQQHQGHQ 6XEMHNW YROO]LHKW VLFK HLQH 'H]HQWULHUXQJ ZHLOHVHLQHPDQGHUHQ6XEMHNWHLQHQ:HUWHLQUlXPWGHUGLH4XHOOHYRQOHJLWLPHQ$Q VSUFKHQLVWGLHGHUHLJHQHQ6HOEVWOLHEH$EEUXFKWXQ´(LQHV\VWHPDWLVFKLQWHUHVVDQWH 9DULDWLRQGHU.DQWLVFKHQ%HJULIIHGHU$FKWXQJXQGGHU/LHEHVFKOLHW+RQQHWKXQ PLWWHOEDUGDUDQDQ Å>«@REZLUHLQHQDQGHUHQ0HQVFKHQDOVOLHEHQVZHUWDOVDFKWHQV ZHUWRGHUDOVVROLGDULWlWVZUGLJEHWUDFKWHQVWHWVNRPPWLQGHPHUIDKUHQHQ:HUWQXU HLQDQGHUHU$VSHNWGHVVHQ]XU*HOWXQJZDVHVKHLWGD0HQVFKHQLKU/HEHQLQUDWL RQDOHU 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ YROO]LHKHQ PVVHQ %H]LHKW VLFK GLHVH Ä9RUVWHOOXQJ YRQ HL QHP:HUW¶GDVHLQH0DOVWlUNHUDXIGLH:HLVHGHUELRJUDSKLVFKHQ/HEHQVEHZlOWLJXQJ /LHEH GDVDQGHUH0DOVWlUNHUDXIGLH$UWGHVSUDNWLVFKHQ(QJDJHPHQWV 6ROLGDULWlW VRJLOWVLHLP)DOOGHU$FKWXQJGHU7DWVDFKHVHOEHUGD0HQVFKHQ]XUUHIOH[LYHQ2UL HQWLHUXQJDQ*UQGHQNHLQH$OWHUQDWLYH KDEHQ LQVRIHUQDXFKLVWMHQHOHW]WH(LQVWHO OXQJQLFKWZHLWHUJUDGXLHUEDUZlKUHQGGLHEHLGHQDQGHUHQ)RUPHQGHU$QHUNHQQXQJ YLHOH6WXIHQGHU6WHLJHUXQJHUODXEHQ´ (EG (LQH(UNOlUXQJGLHVHV$FKWXQJVEHJ ULIIVHLQH'HWDLODUJXPHQWDWLRQPLWRGHUJHJHQ.DQWOLHJWQLFKWLP)RNXVYRQ+RQ QHWKV$XVIKUXQJHQGLHVLFKDXIGLH0DNURHEHQHGHU$FKWXQJGKGHUHQ5ROOHEHL GHU .RQVWLWXWLRQ YRQ ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW NRQ]HQWULHUHQ :DV GLH ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 7KHRULH EHWULIIW VR VLQG /|KUHUV =ZHLIHO DQ GHU $QJHPHVVHQKHLW YRQ .DQWV %HVFKUHLEXQJ GLHVHV Å=XVDPPHQKDQJ>V@ YRQ +DQGOXQJVKHPPQLVVHQ XQG EHI|UGHUXQJHQQDFK$UWNRPPXQL]LHUHQGHU5|KUHQ´GXUFKDXVQDFK]XYROO]LHKHQ Å6R LVWIUDJOLFKREGLH(QWIHUQXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVKLQGHUQLVVHQ]ZLQJHQGKDQGOXQJVPRWL YLHUHQGZLUNWXQGREPLWGHU,QWHQVLYLHUXQJYRQ'HPWLJXQJHQGLH(LQVLFKWLQ*H JHQVWlQGHGHU$FKWXQJ]XQLPPW FI.S9 ´ /|KUHU *OHLFKZRKO VROOHVEHLGHUYRUOLHJHQGHQ.ULWLNDQ.DQWV$FKWXQJVNRQ]HSWQLFKWXPGLH$EZlJXQJ GHVVHQSV\FKRORJLVFKHU3ODXVLELOLWlWJHKHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
VROFKHLVWZLHGHU$XVGUXFNLP'HXWVFKHQDQ]HLJWVLQQOLFKXQGGDPLWLP .DQWLVFKHQ-DUJRQSDWKRORJLVFKHJDOREVLHVLFKDXIPLFKRGHUDXIDQGHUH 3HUVRQHQULFKWHW VLHLVWEORVXEMHNWLY'DGXUFKVFKHLGHWVLHIU.DQWDOV LQKDOWOLFKH%HVWLPPXQJGHV$FKWXQJVEHJULIIVDXV'DDEHUGLHhEHUZLQ GXQJ HLQHV1HLJXQJVKLQGHUQLVVHV GXUFK GLH 9HUQXQIWWlWLJNHLW EHZHUNVWHOOLJW ZLUG XQG GDGXUFK ]X HLQHP VLQQOLFKHQ *HIKO GHU $FKWXQJ ZLUG ² DQ VRQVWHQEOHLEWGHUhEHUJDQJXQJHNOlUW²LVWGDPLWQLFKWHUZLHVHQ:DVLVW HLQH9HUQXQIWZLUNXQJDXIGLH6LQQOLFKNHLWXQGZLHNDQQVLHVHOEVWDOV*H IKODXIJHIDWZHUGHQ" .DQWVXQJHO|VWHV3UREOHPKLQVLFKWOLFKGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ7ULHEIHGHUEH VWHKWDOVRLQIROJHQGHP'LOHPPD HLQ*HIKOLVWVLQQOLFKXQGNDQQHRLSVR QLFKW DSULRULVFK VHLQ ² GLHV LVW DXFK GHU *UXQG ZHVKDOE HV QDFK .DQW QLFKW*UXQGGHU0RUDOVHLQGDUI$XIGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWHDEHUPXHLQEH VWLPPWHV *HIKO DSULRULVFKHV (OHPHQW GHU 0RUDO VHLQ VRQVW LVW HEHQ GLH .OXIW ]ZLVFKHQ REMHNWLYJHVHW]JHEHQGHP :LOOHQ XQG VXEMHNWLY KDQGOXQJVEHVWLPPHQGHU:LOONUXQEHUEUFNEDU'DWUlJWDXFKGLHLQGHU 6HNXQGlUOLWHUDWXUELVZHLOHQYRUJHEUDFKWH(UNOlUXQJ$FKWXQJVHLREMHNWLY EHWUDFKWHWGDV%HZXWVHLQGHU:LOOHQVEHVWLPPXQJVXEMHNWLYDEHUVHLGLH VHOEH$FKWXQJHLQ*HIKOQLFKWV]XU/|VXQJGHV3UREOHPVEHLGHQQGLH 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ REMHNWLY XQG VXEMHNWLY LVW HKHU GD]X JHHLJQHW GLHEHVWHKHQGH.OXIW]XEHQHQQHQDOVVLH]XVFKOLHHQ $XFKGLH'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJDOOHU*HIKOH²VLHVLQGLQVJHVDPWVLQQOLFK² LQSDWKRORJLVFKHGLHHLQHP*HVHW]YRUDXVJHKHQXQGPRUDOLVFKHE]ZHLQ PRUDOLVFKHVGDVDXIGDV6LWWHQJHVHW]IROJWNDQQ]XU.OlUXQJGLHVHVSDUD GR[HQ%HJULIIVQLFKWVEHLWUDJHQZHLOGLH)UDJHQDFKHLQHP*HIKOGDVDXI HLQ EHJULIIOLFKHV *HVHW] QLFKW QXU IROJHQ VRQGHUQ YRQ GLHVHP EHZLUNW VHLQ VROO EHVWHKHQ EOHLEW (LQ PRWLYDWLRQDOHU *UXQG GHU 8QWHUZHUIXQJ GHV:LOOHQVXQWHUGDV6LWWHQJHVHW]LVWGDPLWHQWJHJHQGHU3UlWHQWLRQQLFKW
_____________ 9JO DXFK .DQW 9 I VRZLH /DXHQHU 6FDUDQR E XQG EHUHLWV+HQULFKGHUGD]XNULWLVFKEHPHUNW Å'LH.DQWLVFKH7KHRULHPDFKW>«@QLFKW PHKU YHUVWlQGOLFK DOV GLH :HUWVFKlW]XQJ HLQHV *HJHQVWDQGHV ÄHLQJHVFKUlQNWH 6LQQ OLFKNHLW¶'LH:HUWVFKlW]XQJJLOWDOVRQLFKWGHU0DFKWXQGGHP$QVSUXFKGHV*HVHW ]HV GHU PLU HQWJHJHQWULWW VRQGHUQ VHLQHU :LUNXQJ LQ GHU 6LQQOLFKNHLW 'DPLW LVW GLH ,QWHQWLRQGHVVLWWOLFKHQ%HZXWVHLQVJHUDGH]XLQLKU*HJHQWHLOYHUNHKUWXQG]ZDULP *HJHQVDW] ]X GHP ZDV LQ GHU $EVLFKW GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 7KHRULH ODJ 'LHVH KDW NHLQH 0|JOLFKNHLW HLQH SRVLWLYH %H]LHKXQJ GHV %HZXWVHLQV ]XP *HVHW] ]X HUNOlUHQ GLH ,GHQWLIL]LHUXQJZlUHXQGGDPLW'LVWDQ]XQG(LQKHLW]XJOHLFK´ +HQULFK 9JO.DQW,9I 9JO]%:HLSHU 9JO.DQW9XQGEHUHLWVGLH5HIOYRP(QGHGHUHU-DKUH.DQW;9, ,,
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
$FKWXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU
EHQDQQW ² GLH $FKWXQJ YRU GHP *HVHW] VROOWH MD VRZRKO HLQH TXDVL ]XIlOOLJHDOVDXFKHLQHTXDVLPHFKDQLVFKH3IOLFKWJHPlKHLWYHUKLQGHUQ $XI GLH 8Q]XOlQJOLFKNHLW GHU 7ULHEIHGHUEHVWLPPXQJ KDEHQ GLH 5H]L SLHQWHQYRQ.DQWV0RUDOSKLORVRSKLHVFKRQ]XGHVVHQ/HE]HLWHQDXIPHUN VDPJHPDFKW,FKZLOODQGLHVHU6WHOOHMHGRFKQLFKWZHLWHUDXIGHUDUWLJH LQJHZLVVHU1lKH]XUYRUVWHKHQGHQ'LDJQRVHVWHKHQGH.ULWLNGHU.DQWL VFKHQ (WKLN GXUFK IUKH 5H]LSLHQWHQ HLQJHKHQ VRQGHUQ VWDWWGHVVHQ HLQH $OWHUQDWLYHHUZlJHQGLHVLFKLP$QVFKOXDQGLH.DQWLVFKH7KHRULHVHOEVW E]Z GHUHQ :HLWHUELOGXQJ GXUFK .DQW DQELHWHW 'DEHL PX HV VRYLHO VFKHLQWPLUDQGLHVHU6WHOOHEHUHLWVIHVW]XVWHKHQXPHLQH'HLQWHOOHNWXDOL VLHUXQJGHV0RWLYDWLRQVEHJULIIVGHU$FKWXQJJHKHQ1XUVRNDQQGDVVSH ]LILVFK HPRWLRQDOH (OHPHQW GHU 0RWLYDWLRQ DOV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV PRUDOLVFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ DGlTXDW EHVWLPPW ZHUGHQ (V OHJW VLFK GDKHU QDKH GDV HQJH -XQNWLP GDV QDFK .DQW GLH 3ULQ]LSLHQ GHU 'LMXGLNDWLRQ XQGGHU([HNXWLRQNHQQ]HLFKQHWDXI]XKHEHQRGHUPLQGHVWHQV]XORFNHUQ )ROJHQGH 2SWLRQ VFKHLQW VLFK DXI GHQ HUVWHQ %OLFN DQ]XELHWHQ (LQH )RUGHUXQJVUHVWULNWLRQ DXI VLWWOLFKH 3IOLFKWHUIOOXQJ GXUFK 3IOLFKWJHPlKHLW N|QQWH GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW VFKDIIHQ GHQ LQ GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 0RUDOWKHRULH SDUDGR[HQ%HJULIIGHU$FKWXQJPLWGHU$QVFKDXXQJGHV:RKOZROOHQV]X IOOHQGLHLKQQXQDXFKXQZLGHUVSUFKOLFKDOV*HIKOTXDOLIL]LHUHQZUGH 'LH7DWVDFKHGDHLQVROFKHV:RKOZROOHQ ZLHMHGHVDQGHUH*HIKOHEHQ VR QLFKWJHIRUGHUWZHUGHQNDQQN|QQWHHLQ*UXQGGDIUVHLQLP%HUHLFK PRUDOLVFKHU)RUGHUXQJYHUVFKLHGHQHVLWWOLFKH+DQGOXQJVPRWLYH]X]XODVVHQ 'HUDXIGLHVH:HLVHLVROLHUWHVLWWOLFKH%HUHLFKGHUÅ/HJDOLWlW´HQWKLHO WHGLH*DUDQWLHGDIUGDQLFKWHLQ*HIKOGLH4XHOOHPRUDOLVFKHU%HZHU WXQJRGHUJDUGHQ*UXQGGHV6LWWHQJHVHW]HVDXVPDFKWGHQQNHLQHU3HUVRQ ZUGHKLHUGDV5HFKWHLQJHUlXPWZHUGHQVLFKXQWHU%HUXIXQJDXIHYHQWX
_____________ 5HSUlVHQWDWLY VHL KLHU QXU GLH .ULWLN YRQ 5HKEHUJ DQJHIKUW Å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lUPHUH\'HQQZDVLVWHVDQGHUVDOV6FKZlUPHUH\" GLHLQGHU(UGLFKWXQJEHU VLQQOLFKHU *HJHQVWlQGH EHVWHKW ZHQQ $FKWXQJ IUV *HVHW] HLQ *HIKO XQG GRFK NHLQHVLQQOLFKH(PSILQGXQJVH\QVROO"´ 5H]HQVLRQGHU.ULWLNGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIW ,Q $OOJHPHLQH/LWHUDWXU=HLWXQJ1UDXQGEYRP$XJXVW6S KLHU II ]LWLHUWQDFK6FKXO] 9JO]X*DUYHV.ULWLNXQG.DQWV5HSOLN7HLO,,,GHU Å(LQOHLWXQJ´YRQ.KQLQ.DQW[YL[[YVRZLHIUZHLWHUH]HLWJHQ|VVLVFKH5H DNWLRQHQDXI.DQWV(WKLN%LWWQHU&UDPHU .DQW9
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
HOOH8QDQQHKPOLFKNHLWHQGHUVLWWOLFKHQ3IOLFKW]XHQW]LHKHQ'LHJHIRUGHU WH3IOLFKWJHPlKHLWPHQVFKOLFKHU+DQGOXQJHQEHVWQGHXQDQJHVHKHQGHV 6SHNWUXPV VLWWOLFKHU 0RWLYDWLRQ 'DV 3UREOHP GHU ,QWURVSHNWLRQ WUlWH GHPHQWVSUHFKHQG LP %HUHLFK PRUDOLVFKHU %HXUWHLOXQJ XQG (LQNODJEDUNHLW QLFKW DXI 0RUDOLWlW ZlUH GDPLW LQWHUVXEMHNWLY EHUSUIEDU XQG VDQNWLR QLHUEDU 8QDEKlQJLJ YRQ GLHVHU PRUDOLVFKHQ %HZHUWXQJ N|QQWHQ GLH JHQXLQ HPRWLYHQ $QWULHEH UHIOHNWLHUW ZHUGHQ ZREHL VLFK ]XPLQGHVW SULPD IDFLH GHU%HJULIIGHU3KLODQWKURSLHDOVRGHV0LWJHIKOVRGHUGHU6\PSDWKLHDXI GHU *UXQGODJH HLQHU (PSDWKLH DOV HLQ JHHLJQHWHU .DQGLGDW IU GHQ %H VWLPPXQJVJUXQG VLWWOLFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ ]X HPSIHKOHQ VFKHLQW 'DPLW ZlUH GLH %HVWLPPXQJ GHU 6\PSDWKLH ZHQLJHU ÅZLQGLJH EHUIOLHJHQGH SKDQWDVWLVFKH 'HQNXQJVDUW´ DOV HV GLH XQVSH]LILVFKH )RUGHUXQJ HLQHV ÄYHUQXQIWEHZLUNWHQ *HIKOV¶ LVW ² $XI GLH YRQ +DEHUPDV LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ JHOWHQG JHPDFKWH hEHUOHJHQKHLW HLQHV 6ROLGDULWlWVNRQ ]HSWVJHJHQEHUGLHVHP%HQHYROHQ]NRQ]HSWZHUGHLFKLQQRFKHLQ JHKHQ 'HU .DQW GHV NULWLVFKHQ -DKU]HKQWV VWHKW HLQHU VROFKHQ .RQ]HSWLRQ ]ZDUHQWJHJHQGRFKHVJLEWDXFKHLQHQDQGHUHQ.DQWGHQPDQLQ2SSR VLWLRQ]XGHP$XWRUGHU.ULWLNGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ9HUQXQIWEULQJHQNDQQ'LHVHU DQGHUH.DQWIOOWLQVHLQHP HUVFKLHQHQHQXQGZHQLJEHDFKWHWHQ$XI VDW]'DV(QGHDOOHU'LQJHGHQ%HJULIIGHU$FKWXQJLQKDOWOLFK²XQG]ZDULP YRUJHQDQQWHQ6LQQH Å>@ZHQQHVQLFKWEORDXI3IOLFKWYRUVWHOOXQJVRQ GHUQDXFKDXI3IOLFKWEHIROJXQJDQNRPPWZHQQPDQQDFKGHPVXEMHFWL YHQ *UXQGH GHU+DQGOXQJHQ IUDJW DXV ZHOFKHP ZHQQ PDQ LKQ YRUDXV VHW]HQGDUIDPHUVWHQ]XHUZDUWHQLVWZDVGHU0HQVFKWKXQZHUGHQLFKW EORQDFKGHPREMHFWLYHQZDVHUWKXQVROO VRLVWGRFKGLH/LHEHDOVIUHLH $XIQDKPHGHV:LOOHQVHLQHV$QGHUQXQWHUVHLQH0D[LPHQHLQXQHQWEHKUOL FKHV(UJlQ]XQJVVWFNGHU8QYROONRPPHQKHLWGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ1DWXU ]X
_____________ 9JOGD]XEHUHLWV+HQULFK I Å(V>VFGDVVLWWOLFKH%HZXWVHLQ .3@HUNHQQW QXUMHQH%HIULHGLJXQJDOVVLWWOLFKHDQGLH]XJOHLFK%HZXWVHLQJHWDQHU3IOLFKWXQGGHU )UHXGHEHUGLHJHOXQJHQH=XZHQGXQJRGHUGHU7UDXHUEHULKU0LOLQJHQLVW(VLVW ZRKO ZDKU GD GDQQ ZHQQ QDFK EHVWHP :LVVHQ XQG EHVWHU .UDIW JHJHEHQH +LOIH XQZLUNVDP EOHLEW GHU JXWH :LOOH GHQQRFK ÄZLH HLQ -XZHO JOlQ]HW¶ (EHQVR ZDKU LVW DEHUGDGLHVHUJXWH:LOOHGDQQYHUGlFKWLJZLUGZHQQHUVLFKPKHORVDXFKLP8Q WHUJDQJGHVVHQGHPHUKHOIHQVROOWHGDPLWWU|VWHWGDHVJHQXJLVWQDFKGHP5HFK WHQ]XVWUHEHQ8QGGDVGHVKDOEZHLOLP)DOOHGHU3IOLFKWJHJHQGHQ$QGHUHQGLH,Q WHQWLRQGHVJXWHQ:LOOHQVDXILKQDOVGHQ$QGHUHQJHKWXQGKLHUQLFKWQXUHLQHQ)DOO GHU$QZHQGXQJYRQ*HVHW]HQYRUVLFKVLHKW´ .DQW9 9JO.DQW9I
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
$FKWXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU
GHP ZDV GLH 9HUQXQIW GXUFKV *HVHW] YRUVFKUHLEW JHQ|WKLJW ZHUGHQ ]X PVVHQ >@´ (LQHVROFKH.RUUHNWXUDPHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ7KHRUHPGHU]ZHLWHQ.UL WLN GLH 8QWHUIWWHUXQJ GHV $FKWXQJVEHJULIIV GXUFK HLQ .RQ]HSW GHU Å0HQVFKHQOLHEH 3KLODQWKURSLH ´NDQQMHGRFKQLFKWEUXFKORVLQGLHDOWH 7KHRULHHLQJHIJWZHUGHQ'HQQ]XPHLQHQLVWGDPLWGLHÄ5HLQKHLW¶PRUD OLVFKHU %HZHJJUQGH XQWHUZDQGHUW ² HLQH 7ULHEIHGHU GHU 6\PSDWKLH KlOW GHU NULWLVFKH .DQW VFKOLFKWZHJ IU ÅSDWKRORJLVFK´ =XP DQGHUHQ EOHLEW GLH6FKZLHULJNHLWGHU.RSSHOXQJGHV([HNXWLRQVSULQ]LSVDQGDV'LMXGLND WLRQVSULQ]LSGKGHU%HXUWHLOXQJHLQHU+DQGOXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKULFKWLJMH QDFKGHPREVLHDXV3IOLFKWRGHUEORSIOLFKWPlLJJHVFKHKHQLVWZHLWHU KLQEHVWHKHQ .DQWVWLPPWLQGHU0HWDSK\VLNGHU6LWWHQ]ZDUGHQ$QVSUXFKGHU0RUD OLWlW]XHLQHUZLHHUHVQHQQWÅZHLWH>Q@9HUELQGOLFKNHLW´KHUDEVRGD QLFKWPHKUGLH+DQGOXQJHQVHOEVWDXV3IOLFKWJHVFKHKHQPVVHQVRQGHUQ OHGLJOLFK GDV $XVELOGHQ HQWVSUHFKHQGHU 0D[LPHQ GHP VLWWOLFKHQ *UXQG VDW]GHU0RUDOLWlWJHKRUFKHQVROOWH'DPLWLVWQHEHQGHU'HLQWHOOHNWXDOLVLH UXQJ GHV $FKWXQJVEHJULIIV DXFK GLH ]ZHLWH NULWLVFKH )RUGHUXQJ HUIOOW QlPOLFKGLH%HXUWHLOXQJGHU+DQGOXQJHQYRQGHU XQP|JOLFKHQ ,QWURVSHN WLRQ ]X HQWODVWHQ 'RFK ]XP HLQHQ ULFKWHW VLFK QXQ GLH ,QWURVSHNWLRQLV PXVNULWLNVWDWWDXI+DQGOXQJHQDXI+DQGOXQJVPD[LPHQXQG]XPDQGHUHQ LVWDXFKGDPLWHLQHKLQUHLFKHQGH7UHQQXQJYRQSULQFLSLXPGLMXGLFDWLRQLV XQGSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLVQRFKQLFKWHUUHLFKWLQVRIHUQVLFKGDV%HZHU WXQJVSUREOHPOHGLJOLFKDXIGLHKLQWHUGHQ+DQGOXQJHQOLHJHQGHQ0D[LPHQ YHUVFKREHQKDW
_____________ .DQW9,,,I +HUYRUKHEXQJ .39JOGD]XDXFKGLHVXEWLOHXQGV\PSDWKHWLVFKH ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ:RRGVGHUEH]JOLFKGHV.RQ]HSWVGHU/LHEHHLQHV\VWHPDWLVFKH9HU ELQGXQJ]ZLVFKHQ.DQWV(WKLNLQGHU*UXQGOHJXQJXQGLQGHU0HWDSK\VLNGHU6LWWHQKHU VWHOOW :RRGD Å>«@LIWKH*URXQGZRUNDQGWKHVHFRQG&ULWLTXHDUHWREH SURSHUO\XQGHUVWRRGWKHQWKH\QHHGWREHUHDGLQWKHOLJKWRI7KH0HWDSK\VLFVRI0R UDOV´ (EG .DQW9, .DQW9 .DQW9, =XP3UREOHPGHU,QWURVSHNWLRQYJODXFK.DQW,99,9,, XQG9,,,IIVRZLH%UDQGW IXQG1HLPDQ 9JODXFK %HUQHFNHU LQVEHV GHU LQ VHLQHU 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ GLHVEH]JOLFK ]X HL QHPZHVHQWOLFKRSWLPLVWLVFKHUHQ(UJHEQLVJHODQJW 8QWHU V\VWHPDWLVFKHQ *HVLFKWVSXQNWHQ KDW 'DUZDOO ]ZLVFKHQ ]ZHL $UWHQ YRQ $FK WXQJ XQWHUVFKLHGHQ ZREHL VHLQ %HJULII GHV ÅUHFRJQLWLRQ UHVSHFW´ GHP .DQWLVFKHQ $FKWXQJVEHJULIILQVRIHUQQDKHVWHKWDOV'DUZDOOKLHUEHLYRQHLQHPUDWLRQDOHQ(OHPHQW LQHLQHU(LQVWHOOXQJDQGHUHQJHJHQEHUDXVJHKW Å5HVSHFWLQWKLVVHQVHLVVRPHWKLQJ RQHFDQJLYHRUIDLOWRJLYH>«@5HFRJQLWLRQUHVSHFWLQYROYHVDQRWLRQRILQWHUVXEMHF WLYHYDOXH>«@>DQRWLRQRI@LPSHUVRQDOSUHIHUHQFH>«DQG@WKHMXGJPHQWWKDWVRPH
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
+DEHUPDV·.RQ]HSWHLQHUSRVWNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ (QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHPRUDOLVFKHU0RWLYDWLRQ +DEHUPDV·.RQ]HSWPRUDOLVFKHU0RWLYDWLRQ
0DQ N|QQWH QXQ YHUVXFKW VHLQ GLH 6FKZLHULJNHLWHQ GLH PLW GHP .DQWL VFKHQ $FKWXQJVEHJULII YHUEXQGHQ VLQG GHU VSH]LILVFK .DQWLVFKHQ .RQ ]HSWLRQ HLQHU UHLQHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW ]X]XUHFKQHQ XQG LQ GLHVHP 3XQNW DEZHLFKHQGH 3RVLWLRQHQ GDYRQ XQEHUKUW JODXEHQ 6R EHWRQW +D EHUPDV DOV HLQ VROFKHU .DQW.ULWLNHU ZLHGHUKROW GHQ VR]LDOHQ &KDUDNWHU VHLQHV 9HUQXQIWNRQ]HSWV ZHVKDOE HLQH SULYDWH ,QWURVSHNWLRQ ]XU 9HUJH ZLVVHUXQJ GHU 0RUDOLWlW EHL LKP DXFK JDU QLFKW HUVW LQV %OLFNIHOG JHUlW 0DQVXFKWLQ+DEHUPDV·GLVNXUVHWKLVFKHQ$XVIKUXQJHQYHUJHEOLFKQDFK HLQHP Ä+DXSWVWFN¶ EHU GLH Ä7ULHEIHGHUQ GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW¶ GDV VXEMHNWLYPRWLYDWLRQDOH 0RPHQW GHU 0RUDO (V JHKW LKP LQ HUVWHU /LQLH XP GLH $XIVWHOOXQJ XQG +HUOHLWXQJ HLQHV 8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJVJUXQGVDW]HV YRQGHPHUVFKUHLEW Å'DV0RUDOSULQ]LS>VFGHU8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJVJUXQG VDW] .3@ EHUQLPPW QXU GLH 5ROOH HLQHU $UJXPHQWDWLRQVUHJHO IU GLH %HJUQGXQJPRUDOLVFKHU8UWHLOH DOVVROFKHNDQQHVZHGHU]XP(LQWULWWLQ
_____________ WKLQJLVZRUWK\RIUHVSHFWWKDWLVZRUWK\RIDQ\RQH·VUHVSHFWµ 'DUZDOO I YJODXFK'DUZDOO I 'DUZDOOV.RQ]HSWGHVÅDSSUDLVDOUHVSHFW´DXIGHUDQGH UHQ6HLWHNRPPWGHU.DQWLVFKHQ6\PSDWKLHQDKHLQVRIHUQGDULQHLQJHQXLQDIIHNWLYHV 0RPHQWHQWKDOWHQLVW'RFKGLH6FKZLHULJNHLWYRQ'DUZDOOV.RQ]HSWLRQEHVWHKWGDU LQ GD HU YRQ GLHVHU )RUP GHU $FKWXQJ HLQHUVHLWV EHKDXSWHW Å8QOLNH UHFRJQLWLRQ UHVSHFWLWLVQRWVRPHWKLQJWKDWZHJLYHRUIDLOWRJLYH>«@$Q\SHUVRQFDQFODLPWLWOH WRUHFRJQLWLRQUHVSHFW DSHUVRQPD\RUPD\QRWGHVHUYHDSSUDLVDOUHVSHFW´ 'DUZDOO 'DPLWLVWGHUJHQXLQH*HIKOVFKDUDNWHUGHVOHW]WHUHQEH]HLFKQHW$QGHUHU VHLWVPDFKW'DUZDOOSDXVFKDOJHOWHQG Å5HVSHFWLVDIWHUDOODQDWWLWXGHFORVHO\DVVRFLD WHGZLWKWKHPRUDO$SSUDLVDOUHVSHFWPD\EHFRQVLGHUHGDQDVVHVVPHQWRIDVSHFWVRID SHUVRQ UHOHYDQW WR PRUDO SUDLVH DQG EODPHµ 'DUZDOO I 9JO GD]X DXFK 'DUZDOO Å$SSUDLVDOUHVSHFWEULQJVLQWRIRFXVWKHLGHDRIYLUWXH>«@7KHODW WHU>VFDSSUDLVDOUHVSHFW .3@LVDSRVLWLYHDSSUDLVDORIDQLQGLYLGXDOPDGHZLWKUHJDUG WRWKRVHIHDWXUHVZKLFKDUHH[FHOOHQFHVRISHUVRQV$VVXFKLWLVQRWRZHGWRHYHU\ RQHIRULWPD\RUPD\QRWEHPHULWHGµ'DJHJHQKDW*LEEDUGDUJXPHQWLHUWGDDXFK 'DUZDOOV ÅUHFRJQLWLRQ UHVSHFW´ DOV JHQXLQHV *HIKO TXDOLIL]LHUW ZHUGHQ PX XP +DQGOXQJVHIIHNWLYLWlW]XHUP|JOLFKHQXQGGDIUVHLGLHVHV*HIKO]XVFKZHUYRQDQ GHUHQ HLQVFKOlJLJHQ *HIKOHQ ZLH :RKOZROOHQ ]X WUHQQHQ Å5HVSHFW LQ VKRUW PD\ VHHP WKH FUXFLDO PRUDO VHQWLPHQW EXW LWV FRQWHQW LV HOXVLYH´ *LEEDUG 0DQN|QQWH DXFKXPJHNHKUW DUJXPHQWLHUHQGDÅDSSUDLVDOUHVSHFW´ZHQQHVGHQQ ZLH'DUZDOOEHKDXSWHWJHJHQEHUHLQHU3HUVRQHUEUDFKWZLUGRGHU HEHQ DXFKQLFKW NDXPPHKU]XXQWHUVFKHLGHQLVWYRQLGLRV\QNUDWLVFKHQ(LQVWHOOXQJHQZLHSHUV|QOLFKHU =XQHLJXQJ)UHXQGVFKDIW%HZXQGHUXQJRGHUbKQOLFKHPXQGGDPLWYRP=HQWUDOEH UHLFK GHU PRUDOLVFKHQ )RUGHUXQJ LQ GHQ %HUHLFK GHV 6XSHUHURJDWLYHQ YHUVFKREHQ ZXUGH'DUZDOOYHUVWHKWÅDSSUDLVDOUHVSHFW´VFKOLHOLFKDXFKLQ $ULVWRWHOLVFKHQ 7HU PLQLGHV&KDUDNWHUVZDVGLH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJRGHUbKQOLFKNHLW]ZLVFKHQGHQEHLGHQ )RUPHQ YRQ $FKWXQJ EH]JOLFK LKUHU HPRWLYHQ .RPSRQHQWH QRFK HUVFKZHUW YJO 'DUZDOO
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DEHUPDV·.RQ]HSWPRUDOLVFKHU0RWLYDWLRQ
PRUDOLVFKH $UJXPHQWDWLRQHQ YHUSIOLFKWHQ QRFK ]XU %HIROJXQJ PRUDOL VFKHU(LQVLFKWHQPRWLYLHUHQ´ 'RFK )ROJHQGHV VWHKW HLQHU 0DUJLQDOLVLHUXQJ GHU 0RWLYDWLRQVSUREOH PDWLNHQWJHJHQ.DQWV.RQ]HSWGHU$FKWXQJKlQJW]XPLQGHVWLQGHVVHQ +DXSWZHUNHQDQGHP3RVWXODW]ZLVFKHQ EOR OHJDOHQXQGPRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJHQ]ZLVFKHQSIOLFKWJHPlHQ+DQGOXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJHQDXV 3IOLFKW XQWHUVFKHLGHQ ]X N|QQHQ XQG ]X PVVHQ 'LH %HXUWHLOXQJ HLQHU +DQGOXQJDOVPRUDOLVFKVRVWHOOWHVLFKKHUDXVKlQJWDQGHUHQWVSUHFKHQ GHQ LQKDOWOLFKHQ )OOXQJ GHV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV 6ROOWH +DEHUPDV GLHVHRGHUHLQHDQDORJH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJHEHQIDOOVWUHIIHQVRLVWHUPLQGHV WHQV DXI HLQH DQDORJH WKHRUHWLVFKH )UDJHVWHOOXQJ ² ZHQQ DXFK QLFKW DXI GLHVHOEH$QWZRUW²IHVWJHOHJW :lKUHQG PDQ EHL .DQW GDV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV LQ GHU %HJUQ GXQJVWKHRULH GHU 0RUDO MHGRFK GLUHNW DQVWHXHUQ NDQQ HPSILHKOW HV VLFK EHL+DEHUPDVGHQPHWKRGLVFKHQ8PZHJEHUGHQHQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKR ORJLVFKHQ E]Z PRUDOSlGDJRJLVFKHQ $VSHNW VHLQHU 7KHRULH ]X JHKHQ ,Q GLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJVHLQHPDQ.RKOEHUJVVR]LRPRUDOLVFKHQ3HUVSHN WLYHQRULHQWLHUWHQ0RGHOOGHUÅ,QWHUDNWLRQVVWXIHQ6R]LDOSHUVSHNWLYHQXQG 0RUDOVWXIHQ´KDQGHOW+DEHUPDVH[SOL]LWYRPÅ%HJULIIGHU0RWLYDWLRQ´ (UVWHOOWLQVHLQHP0RGHOOGHURQWRJHQHWLVFKHQ.RQVWLWXWLRQHLQHUPR UDOLVFKHQ :HOWVLFKW GLH YHUVFKLHGHQHQ P|JOLFKHQ +DQGOXQJVW\SHQ XQWHU DQGHUHPLQ5HODWLRQ]XHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ%HJULIIHQGHU0RWLYDWLRQ'DEHL ]HLJW VLFK GD DXI HLQHU SUlNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ (QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIH GHV ,QGLYL GXXPVDOVREHLDXWRULWlWVJHVWHXHUWHQ,QWHUDNWLRQHQE]ZLQWHUHVVHQJHVWHX HUWHQ .RRSHUDWLRQHQ OHGLJOLFK GLH /R\DOLWlW JHJHQEHU 3HUVRQHQ XQG GLH 2ULHQWLHUXQJ DQ %HORKQXQJ E]Z %HVWUDIXQJ P|JOLFKH +DQGOXQJVPRWLYH EHVWLPPHQ(LQH]ZHLWHNRQYHQWLRQHOOH(QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHVHLJHNHQQ]HLFK QHWGXUFK5ROOHQKDQGHOQVRZLHQRUPHQJHOHLWHWH,QWHUDNWLRQ KLHUNRQNXU ULHUHQ RGHU NRRSHULHUHQ DOV HQWVSUHFKHQGH +DQGOXQJVPRWLYDWLRQHQ
_____________ +DEHUPDV 'HU8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJVJUXQGVDW]Ä8¶ODXWHW ÅEHLJOWLJHQ1RU PHQ PVVHQ (UJHEQLVVH XQG 1HEHQIROJHQ GLH VLFK YRUDXVVLFKWOLFK DXV HLQHU DOOJH PHLQHQ%HIROJXQJIUGLH%HIULHGLJXQJGHU,QWHUHVVHQHLQHVMHGHQHUJHEHQYRQDOOHQ ]ZDQJORVDN]HSWLHUWZHUGHQN|QQHQ´ +DEHUPDV 9JO]X)RUPXOLHUXQJVYD ULDQWHQ VRZLH QHXHUHQ GLVNXUVHWKLVFKHQ $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJHQ PLW Ä8¶ XQG GHP GLV NXUVHWKLVFKHQ*UXQGVDW]Ä'¶2WW XQG*RWWVFKDON0D]RX] +DEHUPDV I YJO]X.RKOEHUJV(QWZLFNOXQJVPRGHOODEHUDXFKGLHHPSLUL VFKHQ8QWHUVXFKXQJHQYRQ1XQQHU:LQNOHU GLHQDKHOHJHQGDEHUHLWVNOHLQH .LQGHU)RUPHQPRUDOLVFKHU6HOEVWELQGXQJNHQQHQGLHGXUFK6DQNWLRQVRGHU$XWRUL WlWVPRGHOOH QLFKW YROOVWlQGLJ HUNOlUEDU ]X VHLQ VFKHLQHQ YJO GD]X DXFK +DEHUPDV 'LHVHV NRRSHULHUHQ LVW HLQH ,QWHUSRODWLRQ PHLQHUVHLWV ZlKUHQG DXI GHU SRVWNRQYHQWLR QHOOHQ6WXIHGLHH[NOXVLYH2SSRVLWLRQYRQÅLGHDOH>U@YVVR]LDOH>U@*HOWXQJ´DOV%HJULII GHU$XWRULWlWVRZLHGLHHEHQIDOOV H[NOXVLYH2SSRVLWLRQYRQÅ$XWRQRPLHYV+HWHUR
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
3IOLFKWXQG1HLJXQJEH]JOLFKGHQDXVGHU%HREDFKWHUSHUVSHNWLYHHUZDUW EDUHQ +DQGOXQJHQ 6FKOLHOLFK NRQNXUULHUHQ DXI GHU SRVWNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ (QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHGHVNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ+DQGOXQJVW\SVDOVRGHV'LVNXU VHV $XWRQRPLH XQG +HWHURQRPLH ZREHL GLH DXWRQRPH +DQGOXQJ GD GXUFKJHNHQQ]HLFKQHWVHLGDVLHDXV(LQVLFKWLQGLH*UQGHGHUHQWVSUH FKHQGHQ1RUPHUIROJW²YRUOlXILJXQG.DQWLVFKJHVSURFKHQÄDXV3IOLFKW¶ E]Z ÄDXV $FKWXQJ IUV *HVHW]¶ +DEHUPDV DUJXPHQWLHUW DXVIKUOLFK GDIUGDGLHVH+LHUDUFKLVLHUXQJGHUSUlNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ XQG SRVWNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ (QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHQ WDWVlFKOLFK HLQHQ HQWZLFN OXQJVORJLVFKHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ GDUVWHOOW LQVRIHUQ GLH YHUVFKLHGHQHQ (OH PHQWH GHU Å3HUVSHNWLYHQVWUXNWXU´ GHU Å6WUXNWXU GHU 9HUKDOWHQVHUZDU WXQJ´ GHV Å%HJULIIV GHU $XWRULWlW´ GHV Å%HJULIIV GHU 0RWLYDWLRQ´ GHU Å6R]LDOSHUVSHNWLYHQ´XQGGHUGLHVHQHQWVSUHFKHQGHQÅ*HUHFKWLJNHLWVYRU VWHOOXQJHQ´ VRZLH GHU Å6WXIHQ GHV PRUDOLVFKHQ 8UWHLOV´ DXI GHU MHZHLOV K|KHUHQ6WXIHDOVRGHUNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQE]ZGHUSRVWNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQGLH HQWVSUHFKHQGHQ(OHPHQWHGHUMHZHLOVQLHGULJHUHQ6WXIHQDOVRGHUSUlNRQ YHQWLRQHOOHQE]ZGHUNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQYRUDXVVHW]HQ)UGHQJHJHQZlUWL JHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ GHV %HJULIIV GHU +DQGOXQJVPRWLYDWLRQ YHUDQVFKDX OLFKW+DEHUPDVGLHVIROJHQGHUPDHQ Å%HLVSLHOVZHLVHYHUZDQGHOWVLFKGLH $XWRULWlWVDXVEXQJGHU%H]XJVSHUVRQDXIGHUQlFKVWHQ6WXIHLQGLHEORH :LOONU GLH PLW OHJLWLPHU :LOOHQVlXHUXQJ NRQWUDVWLHUW DXV SHUV|QOLFKHQ /R\DOLWlWHQRGHU/XVW8QOXVW2ULHQWLHUXQJHQZHUGHQEORH1HLJXQJHQGLH PLW3IOLFKWHQNRQWUDVWLHUHQ(QWVSUHFKHQGZLUGGLH/HJLWLPLWlWYRQ+DQG OXQJVQRUPHQDXIGHUQlFKVWHQ6WXIHDOVHLQHQXUQRFKIDNWLVFKHEORVR ]LDOH*HOWXQJNRQ]LSLHUWGLHGHULGHDOHQ*HOWXQJHQWJHJHQJHVHW]WLVWZlK UHQG GDV +DQGHOQ DXV NRQNUHWHQ 3IOLFKWHQ QXQ DOV HWZDV +HWHURQRPHV JLOWGHPGLH$XWRQRPLHJHJHQEHUVWHKW´'DV/HW]WHUHLVWHQWVFKHLGHQG /HJLWLPLWlWZLUGLPhEHUJDQJYRQGHUNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ]XUSRVWNRQYHQWL RQHOOHQ6WXIH]XEORHU/HJLWLPLWlWSIOLFKWJHPlH+DQGOXQJHQVWHKHQDX WRQRPHQ +DQGOXQJHQ JHJHQEHU XQG ]ZDU EH]JOLFK GHUVHOEHQ 6\VWHP VWHOOH GLH GLHVH %HJULIIH LQ GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 7KHRULH HLQQHKPHQ (V JHKW KLHUXPGHQ%HJULIIGHUPRUDOLVFKHQ0RWLYDWLRQXQG+DEHUPDVGLIIHUHQ ]LHUW GDEHL .DQW YHUJOHLFKEDU ]ZLVFKHQ EOR OHJDOHQ XQG PRUDOLVFKHQ
_____________ QRPLH´NRQVWLWXWLYIUGDV9HUVWlQGQLVGLHVHU6WXIHXQGGDV6HOEVWYHUVWlQGQLVGHU$N WRUHQDXIGLHVHU6WXIHLVWJLEW+DEHUPDV·7KHRULHNHLQHQ$QKDOWVSXQNWGDIUDXIGHU NRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ 6WXIH 3IOLFKW XQG 1HLJXQJ DOV %HJULIIH GHU 0RWLYDWLRQ H[NOXVLY ]X RSSRQLHUHQLQVRIHUQGDVÅ5ROOHQKDQGHOQ´HEHQVRJXWZLHGLHÅQRUPHQJHOHLWHWH,QWHU DNWLRQ´DXVLQWHUQDOLVLHUWHU9HUSIOLFKWXQJRGHUXQGDXV1HLJXQJHQKHUDXVJHVFKHKHQ NDQQ 9JOGD]XGLHhEHUVLFKWLQ+DEHUPDV IVRZLH+DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV YJO]XP9HUKlOWQLVÄEORHU1HLJXQJHQ¶LP.RQWUDVW]X3IOLFK WHQDXIGHUNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ6WXIHREHQ)Q
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DEHUPDV·.RQ]HSWPRUDOLVFKHU0RWLYDWLRQ
+DQGOXQJHQ ZREHL HU GDV :RUW Ä$FKWXQJ¶ YRQ .DQW DEZHLFKHQG LP 6LQQH GHU EOR ÅIDNWLVFKHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ´ YHUZHQGHW ÅQXQ ]lKOW QLFKW PHKUGLH$FKWXQJYRUGHP*HVHW]SHUVHDOVVLWWOLFKHV0RWLY'HU+HWH URQRPLHGKGHU$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQEHVWHKHQGHQ1RUPHQZLUGGLH)RU GHUXQJ HQWJHJHQJHVHW]W GD GHU +DQGHOQGH DQVWHOOH GHU VR]LDOHQ *HOWXQJ HLQHU1RUPYLHOPHKUGHUHQ*OWLJNHLW]XP%HVWLPPXQJVJUXQGVHLQHV+DQGHOQV HUKHEW´ ([NXUV .DQWV0RUDOSlGDJRJLN .DQWGDVVHLKLHUOHGLJOLFKQHEHQEHLEHPHUNWKDWVLFKLQGHU0HWKRGHQ OHKUHVHLQHU]ZHLWHQ.ULWLNHEHQIDOOV]XGLHVHPPRUDOSV\FKRORJLVFKHQE]Z SlGDJRJLVFKHQ$VSHNWJHlXHUWZHQQHUIUDJWÅ>@ZLHPDQGHQ*HVHW ]HQ GHU UHLQHQ SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW (LQJDQJ LQ GDV PHQVFKOLFKH *HPW (LQIOX DXI GLH 0D[LPHQ GHVVHOEHQ YHUVFKDIIHQ´ N|QQH (U EULQJW GD]X GUHL(QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIHQLQ$QVFKODJ=XQlFKVWJHKHHVGDUXPGHU-XJHQG %HLVSLHOHYRQ0RUDOLWlWYRU$XJHQ]XIKUHQXQWHUDQGHUHPLQÅ%LRJUD SKLHQDOWHUXQGQHXHU=HLW´'DPLWVROOGHQ+HUDQZDFKVHQGHQGLHPRUD OLVFKH3HUVSHNWLYHDXILKUH8PZHOWÅJOHLFKVDP]XU*HZRKQKHLW´ZHUGHQ VLH VROOHQ GXUFK Å%HREDFKWXQJ´ XQG Å%HXUWHLOXQJ´ OHUQHQ Å>@ RE GLH +DQGOXQJREMHNWLYGHPPRUDOLVFKHQ*HVHW]H´JHPlVHL$XIHLQHU]ZHLWHQ 6WXIHVROOGLH$XIPHUNVDPNHLWYRQGHU/HJDOLWlWGHU+DQGOXQJDXIGHUHQ 0RUDOLWlWLPHQJHUHQ6LQQHJHOHQNWZHUGHQXP]XHUNHQQHQÅ>@REGLH +DQGOXQJ DXFK VXEMHNWLY XP GHV PRUDOLVFKHQ *HVHW]HV ZLOOHQ JHVFKHKHQ´ VHL'HUZLFKWLJVWH6FKULWWLQGHU$XVELOGXQJHLQHUPRUDOLVFKHQ:HOWVLFKW EHVWHKW MHGRFK QLFKW LQ GHU %HXUWHLOXQJ IUHPGHU +DQGOXQJHQ QDFK GHUHQ REMHNWLYHQXQGVXEMHNWLYHQ9HUIDVVXQJGHQQGDEHLLVWYRQGHPHQWVFKHL GHQGHQ Å,QWHUHVVH DQ GHQ +DQGOXQJHQ XQG LKUHU 0RUDOLWlW VHOEVW´ QRFK JDUNHLQH5HGH
_____________ +DEHUPDV I +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 .DQW9 ZXUGHREHQDXIGLHEHJUQGXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKH'LIIHUHQ]GHUPRUDOLVFKHQ 0RWLYDWLRQ]ZLVFKHQGHPYRUNULWLVFKHQXQGGHPNULWLVFKHQ.DQWKLQJHZLHVHQVROlW VLFK LP PRUDOSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ E]Z SlGDJRJLVFKHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ HLQH ZHLWUHL FKHQGH hEHUHLQVWLPPXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ 6FKDIIHQVSKDVHQ IHVWVWHOOHQ YJO.DQW .DQW9 .DQW9 (EG .DQW9 +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
(UVWGLH6HOEVWDFKWXQJGLHLFKLQPHLQHU%HJULIIVDQDO\VHHLQJDQJVDOV 6RQGHUIDOO GHU$FKWXQJLP6LQQHLQHUDEVROXWHQ:HUWVFKlW]XQJHLQHU 3HUVRQDOV3HUVRQHLQJHIKUWKDEHNDQQGLHVHV,QWHUHVVHDQGHU0RUDOLWlW HUZHFNHQ 0DQ NDQQ GLHVH 6HOEVWDFKWXQJ GHP -XJHQGOLFKHQ VR .DQW GDGXUFK DQGHPRQVWULHUHQ GD PDQ LKP %HLVSLHOH HLQHU Å5HLQLJNHLW GHV :LOOHQV´ YRUOHJW Å>@ YRUHUVW QXU DOV QHJDWLYHU 9ROONRPPHQKHLW GHVVHO EHQVRIHUQLQHLQHU+DQGOXQJDXV3IOLFKWJDUNHLQH7ULHEIHGHUQGHU1HL JXQJHQDOV%HVWLPPXQJVJUQGHDXILKQHLQIOLHHQ ZRGXUFKGHU/HKUOLQJ GRFKDXIGDV%HZXWVHLQVHLQHU)UHLKHLWDXIPHUNVDPHUKDOWHQZLUGXQG REJOHLFK GLHVH (QWVDJXQJ HLQH DQIlQJOLFKH (PSILQGXQJ YRQ 6FKPHU] HUUHJW GHQQRFK >@ GDV *HPWK IU GLH (PSILQGXQJ GHU =XIULHGHQKHLW DXV DQGHUHQ 4XHOOHQ HPSIlQJOLFK JHPDFKW ZLUG´ :LH EHUHLWV LP EH JUQGXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ.RQWH[WQlKHUWVLFK.DQWDOVRDXFKLPHQWZLFN OXQJVSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ E]Z PRUDOSlGDJRJLVFKHQ .RQWH[W GHU SRVLWLYHQ )UHLKHLWDOV$XWRQRPLHEHUGLHQHJDWLYH)UHLKHLWDOV/RVO|VXQJYRQ1HL JXQJHQ,KUHÅLQQHUH)UHLKHLW´HUNHQQHQ+HUDQZDFKVHQGHLQGHU'LVWDQ ]LHUXQJYRQGHUÅXQJHVWPHQ=XGULQJOLFKNHLWGHU1HLJXQJHQ´0LWGLH VHU (UNHQQWQLV LVW VFKOLHOLFK GLH SV\FKRORJLVFKH XQG SlGDJRJLVFKH 9RUDXVVHW]XQJIUGLHWDWVlFKOLFKH(UJUHLIXQJXQG$QHLJQXQJGHU0RUDOL WlW JHJHEHQ Å$XI GLHVH >VF $FKWXQJ IU XQV VHOEVW@ ZHQQ VLH ZRKO JH JUQGHWLVWZHQQGHU0HQVFKQLFKWVVWlUNHUVFKHXHWDOVVLFKLQGHULQQH UHQ6HOEVWSUIXQJLQVHLQHQHLJHQHQ$XJHQJHULQJVFKlW]LJXQGYHUZHUIOLFK ]XILQGHQNDQQQXQMHGHJXWHVLWWOLFKH*HVLQQXQJJHSIURSIWZHUGHQ´ .DQW KDW VHLQH HQWZLFNOXQJVSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ E]Z PRUDOSlGDJRJL VFKHQ 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ GHU PRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJVPRWLYDWLRQ LQ GHU .ULWLN GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW PHKU DQJHGHXWHW DOV DXVJHIKUW *OHLFKZRKO NDQQ PDQKLHUHLQHGHP+DEHUPDV·VFKHQ.RQ]HSWGHURQWRJHQHWLVFKHQ$XINOl UXQJ ]XU SRVWNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ 6WXIH lKQOLFKH 7KHRULH ILQGHQ GHQQ GLH VXN]HVVLYH Å,QWHJUDWLRQ YRQ 7HLOQHKPHU XQG %HREDFKWHUSHUVSHNWLYHQ´ ZLH+DEHUPDVVLHQHQQWLVWZHQQJOHLFKXQWHUXPJHNHKUWHQ9RU]HLFKHQ GHU .HUQJHGDQNH YRQ .DQWV SUDNWLVFKHU 0HWKRGHQOHKUH :lKUHQG +D EHUPDVGHQ)RUWVFKULWWLQGHU(LQEH]LHKXQJHLQHU%HREDFKWHUSHUVSHNWLYH LQGLH5HIOH[LRQDXIVR]LDOH,QWHUDNWLRQVLHKWJHKHQ.DQWLVFKH0RUDODWKOH WHQGHQXPJHNHKUWHQ:HJYRQGHU=XVFKDXHUWULEQHDXIGDV6SLHOIHOG
_____________
.DQW9I YJOGD]XDXFK.|KO .DQW9 (EG 9JO+DEHUPDV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGDVHPRWLYH)XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW
'LH([SOL]LHUXQJYRQ+DQGOXQJVJUQGHQXQGGDV HPRWLYH)XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW +DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGDVHPRWLYH)XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW
.DQWIKUWZLHDXVGHP9RUVWHKHQGHQGHXWOLFKZHUGHQVROOWHLPEHJUQ GXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ .RQWH[W GHQ %HJULII GHU $FKWXQJ HLQ XP GDPLW GLH 0RUDOLWlW YRQ +DQGOXQJHQ ]X EH]HLFKQHQ 'LH PDWHULDOH hEHUHLQVWLP PXQJYRQSULQFLSLXPGLMXGLFDWRQLVXQGSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLVVROOWHGLH REMHNWLYH XQG VXEMHNWLYH 5LFKWLJNHLW GHU +DQGOXQJ JDUDQWLHUHQ 'D .DQW GLHVH 5HLQKHLW GHU %HVWLPPXQJVJUQGH YRQ 1HLJXQJHQ DOV ,QGLNDWRU GHU 0RUDOLWlW DQVHW]W PX LKP OHW]WHUH XQHUNHQQEDU EOHLEHQ 'HU .DQW GHU HU-DKUHPWH²GLHVHV\VWHPDWLVFKH/FNHDN]HSWLHUW²GDV.ULWHUL XP PRUDOLVFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ KHUDEVWLPPHQ YRQ GHU 0RUDOLWlW DXI GLH /HJDOLWlWGHQQQXUOHW]WHUHNDQQVLFKHUHUNDQQWXQGGDPLW0DVWDEHLQHU SUDNWLVFKHQ%HXUWHLOXQJZHUGHQ 'RFK MHQH .ULWLN GHU 8QHUNHQQEDUNHLW DN]HSWLHUW VWHOOW VLFK QXQ GLH )UDJHREHLQHGHUDUWLJH+HUDEVWLPPXQJDXI/HJDOLWlWQLFKWEHUHLWVJOHLFK EHGHXWHQG LVW PLW HLQHP +REEHVLDQLVPXV GHU LQ MHGHP )DOO XQYHUHLQEDU ZlUHPLWHLQHU.RQ]HSWLRQSUlYDOHQWHU*UQGHZLHVLHLQGHQYRUVWHKHQ GHQ .DSLWHOQ DXVJHIKUW ZXUGH 8QWHU ]DKOUHLFKHQ P|JOLFKHQ )RUPHQ HLQHU NRQWUDNWXDOLVWLVFKHQ .RQVHTXHQ] DXV GLHVHU.DQW.ULWLNILQGHW VLFK HLQH ]HLWJHQ|VVLVFKH 9DULDQWH EHL *UHJRU\ .DYND GHU LQ GLHVHP 6LQQH ÅPRUDOLVFKH$QIRUGHUXQJHQQLFKWLP6LQQHGHU(LQVHLWLJNHLWVRQGHUQGHU *HJHQVHLWLJNHLWLQWHUSUHWLHUW´'DPLWYHUEXQGHQLVWHLQH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ HLQHU ÄLGHDOHQ¶ 0RUDO GLH VLFK DXI Å6WDQGDUGVPRUDOLVFKHU 9RU WUHIIOLFKNHLW DXI 9HUKDOWHQVIRUPHQ GLH LQ HLQHU 7UDGLWLRQ DOV YRUELOGOLFK XQGGDKHUDOVQDFKDKPHQVXQGEHZXQGHUQVZHUWJHOWHQ´XQGHLQHUÄSUDN WL]LHUWHQ¶ 0RUDO GLH VLFK DXI 6WDQGDUGV EH]LHKW ÅXP GHUHQWZLOOHQ 0HQ VFKHQYHUDQWZRUWOLFKJHPDFKWNULWLVLHUWXQGEHVWUDIWZHUGHQZHLOVLHVLFK QLFKW LKQHQ JHPl YHUKDOWHQ KDEHQ´ ,P $QVFKOX DQ +REEHV XQWHU VFKHLGHW.DYND]ZLVFKHQRIIHQVLYHQXQGGHIHQVLYHQ9HUVW|HQJHJHQGLH EHVWHKHQGH0RUDOZREHLRIIHQVLYH9HUVW|HDOVRHLQ$EZHLFKHQYRQGHQ 5HJHOQ REZRKO VLFK DQGHUH GDUDQ KDOWHQ DOV XQNOXJ TXDOLIL]LHUW ZHUGHQ XQG GHIHQVLYH 9HUVW|H DOVR HLQ $EZHLFKHQ YRQ GHU 5HJHO XQWHU GHU ZDKUVFKHLQOLFKHQ $QQDKPH GD GLH DQGHUHQ VLFK HEHQIDOOV QLFKW DQ VLH KDOWHQQLFKWJHJHQGLH0RUDOYHUVWRHQLQGHPGLHVHHEHQQLFKWYHUODQJHQ NDQQÄHLQVHLWLJ¶PRUDOLVFK]XKDQGHOQ Å'DVOHLWHQGH3ULQ]LSGHU+REEHVV FKHQ0RUDOLVWDOVRGLHYRQPLUVRJHQDQQWH.XSIHUQH5HJHO ÄWXHDQGHUHQ ZDVVLHGLUWXQ¶>«@:HQQZLUXQV>«@GHU3UD[LVXQGMHQHQ9HUKDOWHQV
_____________ .DYND (EG
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
VWDQGDUGV ]XZHQGHQ GLH DOV PRUDOLVFKH $QIRUGHUXQJHQ ZLUNOLFK*HOWXQJ KDEHQGDQQVWHOOHQZLUIHVWGDGLH.XSIHUQH5HJHOPLWLKUHU*HJHQVHL WLJNHLWHLQLJHUPDHQZLHGHUJLEWZDVZLUKlXILJEHREDFKWHQN|QQHQ>«@ 'HPHQWVSUHFKHQG GDUI GHU HLQ]HOQH LQ 1RWZHKU W|WHQ GLH *HVHOOVFKDIW GDUI9HUEUHFKHULKUHU)UHLKHLWEHUDXEHQ9HUWUlJHGUIHQJHEURFKHQZHU GHQ ZHQQ QLFKW ]X HUZDUWHQ LVW GD GLH *HJHQVHLWH VLH HUIOOW XQG VR ZHLWHU´'RFKXPHLQY|OOLJHVÄ9HUGDPSIHQ¶GHU0RUDOLQGHU.OXJKHLW ]XYHUKLQGHUQGKXPGHU+REEHV·VFKHQ([WHUQDOLVLHUXQJGHU0RWLYDWL RQGLHLQVRIHUQSUREOHPDWLVFKLVWDOVVLH]XPHLQHQELVZHLOHQGUDNRQLVFKH 6WUDIDQGURKXQJHQYHUODQJWXPHLQH+DQGOXQJDOVNOXJHUVFKHLQHQ]XODV VHQXQG]XPDQGHUHQVHOEVWGDPLW*HOHJHQKHLWHQ]XXQODXWHUHP9RUWHLO QLFKWYHUKLQGHUQNDQQ]XHQWJHKHQPXDXFK.DYND DXIHWZDV]XUFN JUHLIHQZDVEHL.DQWXQWHUGHP7LWHOÅbVWKHWLVFKH9RUEHJULIIHGHU(PS IlQJOLFKNHLWGHV*HPWKVIU3IOLFKWEHJULIIHEHUKDXSW´ILUPLHUW .DYND VSULFKW GDKHU YRQ ÅSV\FKLVFKHQ 6WUXNWXUHQ GLH XQPRUDOLVFKHV 9HUKDOWHQ EHVWUDIHQXQGWXJHQGKDIWHV%HQHKPHQEHORKQHQ´0LWHLQHPGHUDUWLJHQ %HJULII YRQ ÅLQQHUHQ 6DQNWLRQHQ´ GLH .DYND QRFK KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHV QHJDWLYHQ UHVSHNWLYH SRVLWLYHQ &KDUDNWHUV GLIIHUHQ]LHUW LVW MHGRFK JHQDX GHU %HUHLFK GHU 0RUDOLWlW DQJHVSURFKHQ GHU HLJHQVWlQGLJH YRQ OHJDOLVWL VFKHQ.DONOHQXQDEKlQJLJH([HNXWLRQVSULQ]LSLHQP|JOLFKHU+DQGOXQJHQ HQWKlOW 2EZRKO+DEHUPDVQXQGLHGHP.RQWUDNWXDOLVPXV]XJUXQGHOLHJHQGH .ULWLNDQ.DQWV8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQ0RUDOLWlWXQG/HJDOLWlWDN]HS WLHUWZLOOHUGHQQRFKHUVWHUHQLFKWDXIOHW]WHUHUHGX]LHUWZLVVHQ6HLQH9RU VWHOOXQJ HLQHU +LHUDUFKLVLHUXQJ GHU +DQGOXQJVW\SHQ XQG GHUHQ HQWZLFN OXQJVORJLVFKHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJV LQVEHVRQGHUH VHLQH 9RUVWHOOXQJ HLQHV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV PRUDOLVFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ DXI GHU EHUHLWV DQJHVSUR
_____________ .DYNDI YJO+REEHV .DS 'LH8QNOXJKHLWGHVRIIHQ VLYHQ 5HJHOYHUVWRHV EH]LHKW VLFK DXI LQGLYLGXHOOHU (EHQH GDUDXI GD LQ DOOHU 5HJHO hEHOWlWHU IUKHU RGHU VSlWHU DOV VROFKH HQWGHFNW XQG EHVWUDIW ZHUGHQ YJO .DYND $XI LQWHUSHUVRQHOOHU (EHQH LVW .DYND VFKOLHOLFK GHUVHOEHQ RSWLPLVWL VFKHQ $QVLFKWGDHVOHW]WOLFKVRJDUIUUHLFKHXQGPlFKWLJH*UXSSHQLQHLQHU*H VHOOVFKDIWVRZLHDXILQWHUQDWLRQDOHU(EHQHIUUHLFKHXQGPlFKWLJH1DWLRQHQMDGDU EHU KLQDXV DXIJUXQG XQVHUHV Å%HGUIQLV>VHV@ QDFK Ä6HOEVWWUDQV]HQGHQ]¶´ HEG VRJDUIU/HEHQGHJHJHQEHU]XNQIWLJHQ*HQHUDWLRQHQGRFKLP,QWHUHVVHGHU+DQ GHOQGHQLVWGLHMHZHLOLJHQÅ>«@0LWJOLHGHUVFKZDFKHU*UXSSHQGLHRIIHQEDUQLFKWLQ GHU/DJHVLQG*XWHVPLW*XWHPXQG%|VHVPLW%|VHP]XYHUJHOWHQDQVWlQGLJ]XEH KDQGHOQXQGLKQHQ]XKHOIHQVRZLHHVGLH0RUDOYHUODQJW´ HEG 9JO]XHLQHU ZHVHQWOLFKSHVVLPLVWLVFKHUHQ(LQVFKlW]XQJREHQ.DS)QVRZLHGHQ$EVFKQLWW ]XGHPGLHVH)XQRWHJHK|UW 9JO.DQW9, .DYND 9JOHEG
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGDVHPRWLYH)XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW
FKHQHQ SRVWNRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ (QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIH VFKOLHW HLQH GHUDUWLJH 5HGXNWLRQDXV .RQGLWLRQDOKDWWHLFKYRUDXVJHVFKLFNWGDZHQQ+DEHUPDVHLQH8Q WHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQSIOLFKWJHPlHQ+DQGOXQJHQXQG+DQGOXQJHQDXV 3IOLFKW YRUVHKH HU DXFK HWZDV EHU GHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU 'LMXGLNDWLRQ XQG GHU ([HNXWLRQ PRUDOLVFKHU +DQGOXQJHQ VDJHQ PVVH 1XQ]HLJWHVLFKGDHUGLHVHU.DQWLVFKHQ'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJPLWVHLQHU8Q WHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJHQ DXV (LQVLFKW LQ GLH *OWLJNHLW HLQHU 1RUPXQG+DQGOXQJHQDXV(LQVLFKWLQGLHEORVR]LDOH*HOWXQJIROJWXQG HUZDUWXQJVJHPllXHUWHUVLFKDXFK]XHLQHUK|FKVWHQ(QWZLFNOXQJVVWXIH PRUDOLVFKHU 0RWLYDWLRQ Å$XWRQRPLH YV +HWHURQRPLH´ 6SlWHVWHQVPLW GHP%HJULIIGHU$XWRQRPLHLVWGLH2SWLRQHLQHVKREEHVLDQLVFKHQ7KHRULH UDKPHQV NHLQHUHDOH 0|JOLFKNHLW PHKU +DEHUPDV PX DOVR HLQ (OHPHQW LQ VHLQH 7KHRULH LQWHJULHUHQ GDV HLQHUVHLWV HLQH VROFKH 8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ HUP|JOLFKWGDVDEHUDQGHUHUVHLWVGLH.ULWLNDP.DQWLVFKHQ$FKWXQJVNRQ ]HSW XQWHUOlXIW 'HQQ GLH HQWVFKHLGHQGH )UDJH EHL HLQHU $GDSWDWLRQ GHV .DQWLVFKHQ 7KHRUHPV ÄDXV 3IOLFKW¶ LVW RE +DEHUPDV· NULWLVFKH )RUWIK UXQJ GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 0RUDOWKHRULH HLQ /HLVWXQJVlTXLYDOHQW IU GDV SURE OHPDWLVFKH7ULHEIHGHU.DSLWHOGHU]ZHLWHQ.ULWLN.DQWVDXIZHLVW:LHVLFK LP )ROJHQGHQ ]HLJHQ VROO VLQG HV GLH NROODWHUDOHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ VHLQHU GLVNXUVLYHQ$XVOHJXQJYRQ$XWRQRPLHXQGGHUHQPRWLYDWLRQDOHU,QVXIIL ]LHQ]GLHGHQ*UXQGGHUhEHUOHJHQKHLWEHU.DQWV.RQ]HSWPRUDOLVFKHU +DQGOXQJVPRWLYDWLRQHUZHLVHQ 'LHNULWLVFKH)UDJHODXWHW ZLHOlWVLFKPLW+DEHUPDV·PRUDOWKHRUHWL VFKHQ0LWWHOQDXVEXFKVWDELHUHQZDVXQWHUHLQHU+DQGOXQJDXV3IOLFKWHLQHU PRUDOLVFKULFKWLJHQ+DQGOXQJ]XYHUVWHKHQLVW":LHJHVFKLHKWHLQH+DQG OXQJDXV(LQVLFKWLQGLH*OWLJNHLWHLQHU1RUP"+DEHUPDV·ODSLGDUH8P IRUPXOLHUXQJ GHV .DQWLVFKHQ $XVGUXFNV ÄDXV 3IOLFKW¶ ² ÅPRUDOLVFK KDQ GHOW ZHU DXV (LQVLFKW KDQGHOW´ ² VFKHLQW QDKH]XOHJHQ HU ZROOWH GDV .DQWLVFKH3UREOHPGHU$FKWXQJVFKOLFKWPLW+LOIHHLQHUEHU.DQWQRFK KLQDXVJHKHQGHQ ,QWHOOHNWXDOLVLHUXQJ PRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGHOQV O|VHQ 'RFK NDQQ GDPLW VHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK NHLQ ,QWURVSHNWLRQLVPXV XQG DXFK NHLQ SUDNWLVFKHU .XU]VFKOX GHU )RUP JHPHLQW VHLQ GD QXQ ² HWZDV EHU VSLW]W IRUPXOLHUW ² GLH .DQWLVFKH :LUNXQJ GHU 9HUQXQIW DXI GDV *HIKO GXUFK HLQH :LUNXQJ GHV 9HUVWDQGHV DXI GDV *HIKO HUVHW]W ZUGH *H PHLQW LVW GDPLW YLHOPHKU HLQH GLVNXUVLYH 2IIHQOHJXQJ GHU $FKWXQJ YRU
_____________ (UVWDXIGLHVHU6WXIHN|QQHQ*HOWXQJVDQVSUFKHQLFKWQXUSUDNWLVFKHVRQGHUQDXFK WKHRUHWLVFKH XQG VXEMHNWLYH[SUHVVLYH DOV VROFKH WKHPDWLVLHUW ZHUGHQ YJO GD]X +D EHUPDV IVRZLH I +DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
GHP*HVHW](LQH+DQGOXQJDXV(LQVLFKWJHKWIU+DEHUPDVPLWGHU)l KLJNHLW HLQKHU PRUDOLVFKH *UQGH IU GLHVH RGHU MHQH +DQGOXQJ JHEHQ ]X N|QQHQ VDJHQ ]X N|QQHQ LQZLHIHUQ GLHVH RGHU MHQH +DQGOXQJ PRUDOLVFK JHERWHQLVW 'LHVVFKHLQWDXIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNQLFKWDOO]XZHLWYRQGHU.DQWLVFKHQ +DQGOXQJ ÄDXV $FKWXQJ IUV *HVHW]¶ HQWIHUQW ]X VHLQ 'HQQ GHU Å$Q VSUXFK GD VLFK GLH %HLOHJXQJ YRQ +DQGOXQJVNRQIOLNWHQ DOOHLQ DXI EH JUQGHWH 8UWHLOH VWW]W´ JLOW DXFK YRQ .DQWV 7KHRULH 'RFK GHU VSULQ JHQGH 3XQNW LVW 0RUDOLWlW KlQJW IU .DQW JHUDGH QLFKW DQ HLQHU ([SOL]LHUXQJ GHU +DQGOXQJVJUQGH GLHVH N|QQWHQ MD OHLFKWKLQ YRUJHVFKREHQ RGHUJDUYRUJHWlXVFKWVHLQ VRQGHUQDPVLWWOLFKHQ%HZXWVHLQGHV+DQGHOQ GHQ'LHREHQDXVJHIKUWH.ULWLNHLQHVPRWLYDWLRQDOHQ,QWURVSHNWLRQLVPXV EOHLEWDOVREHVWHKHQ +DEHUPDV VSULFKW LQ GLHVHP =XVDPPHQKDQJ ]ZDU GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 3RVLWLRQ YHUJOHLFKEDU YRP DXWRQRPHQ :LOOHQ XQG YRQ SUDNWLVFKHU 9HU QXQIW Å$XV 3IOLFKW EHIROJHQ ZLU JHOWHQGH 1RUPHQ QLFKW ZHLO GLHVH XQV XQWHU$QGURKXQJYRQ6DQNWLRQHQDXIHUOHJWZRUGHQVLQGVRQGHUQZHLOZLU VLHXQVVHOEVWJHJHEHQKDEHQ>@$XV3IOLFKWEHIROJHQZLUJHOWHQGH1RUPHQ QLFKW ZHLO VLH GXUFK 7UDGLWLRQ XQG *HZRKQKHLW EHJODXELJW VLQG VRQGHUQ ZHLOZLUVLHIUEHJUQGHWKDOWHQ>@(UVWDXVGHU9HUELQGXQJEHLGHUhEHU OHJXQJHQJHKHQÄDXWRQRPHU:LOOH¶XQGÄSUDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIW¶DOVJOHLFKXU VSUQJOLFKH .RQ]HSWH KHUYRU´ 'LHVH %HVWLPPXQJHQ VLQG PLQGHVWHQV QRFKNRPSDWLEHOPLWGHQ$XVIKUXQJHQ.DQWV'DVlQGHUWVLFKDXFKGRUW QRFKQLFKWZHVHQWOLFKZR+DEHUPDVGLHUHIOH[LYH(EHQHGHUHUVWHQ3HU VRQ 6LQJXODU .DQWV .RQVWLWXWLRQVUDKPHQ GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 9HUQXQIW XQG GHV DXWRQRPHQ :LOOHQV YHUOlW XQG GDV 6R]LDOH GLH $QHUNHQQXQJVYHU KlOWQLVVHGHVÄ,FK¶XQGÄ'X¶XQGVFKOLHOLFKGHVÄ:LU¶PLWHLQEH]LHKW Å$XV GHU6LFKWGHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWVWKHRULHEHGHXWHW$XWRQRPLHQLFKWGLH9HU IJXQJVJHZDOWHLQHV6XEMHNWVGDVVLFKVHOEVW]XP(LJHQWXPKDWVRQGHUQ GLH GXUFK %H]LHKXQJHQ UH]LSURNHU $QHUNHQQXQJ HUP|JOLFKWH 8QDEKlQ JLJNHLW GHV (LQHQ GLH QXU PLW GHU V\PPHWULVFKHQ 8QDEKlQJLJNHLW GHV $QGHUHQ]XVDPPHQEHVWHKHQNDQQ´$XFK.DQWPXDXIGHU.RQVWLWXWL RQVHEHQHVHLQHU0RUDOGHQ$QGHUHQPLWUHIOHNWLHUHQ²GLH9HUVHKUEDUNHLW XQG GLH )UHLKHLW GHU DQGHUHQ 3HUVRQ PVVHQ YRUDXVJHVHW]W ZHUGHQ XP GHP $GUHVVDWHQ GHV .DWHJRULVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYV HLQHQ Ä2EMHNWEHUHLFK¶ VHL QHUDOOJHPHLQHQ*HVHW]JHEXQJ]XHU|IIQHQ
_____________
(EG +DEHUPDV I (EG 9JO GD]X DXFK GLH ]ZHLWH Å0D[LPH>@ GHV JHPHLQHQ 0HQVFKHQYHUVWDQGHV´ LQ GHU .ULWLNGHU8UWHLOVNUDIW Å$QGHU6WHOOHMHGHVDQGHUQGHQNHQ´'HQÅ0DQQYRQHUZHLWHU
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGDVHPRWLYH)XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW
'RFK GHU QXQ IROJHQGH XQG ULFKWXQJVZHLVHQGH 6FKULWW LQ +DEHUPDV· 7KHRULHVWDQG.DQW]ZHLIHOORVQLFKWDOVP|JOLFKH2SWLRQYRU$XJHQGK JHQDX KLHU YHUOlW+DEHUPDV GHQ :HJ .DQWV Å'HUPRUDO SRLQW RIYLHZ NDQQ QLFKW LQ HLQHP ÄHUVWHQ¶ 3ULQ]LS RGHU LQ HLQHU ÄOHW]WHQ¶ %HJUQGXQJ DOVR DXHUKDOE GHV .UHLVHV GHU $UJXPHQWDWLRQ VHOEHU JHIXQGHQ ZHUGHQ 5HFKWIHUWLJHQGH .UDIW EHKlOW DOOHLQ GDV GLVNXUVLYH 9HUIDKUHQ GHU (LQO| VXQJQRUPDWLYHU*HOWXQJVDQVSUFKH XQGGLHVH.UDIWYHUGDQNWGLH$UJX PHQWDWLRQ OHW]WOLFK LKUHU 9HUZXU]HOXQJ LP NRPPXQLNDWLYHQ +DQGHOQ´ +DEHUPDVNHQQ]HLFKQHWDXIGLHVH:HLVHMHGRFKQLFKWQXUGLH.RQVWLWXWL RQVHEHQHVHLQHU'LVNXUVWKHRULHGHU0RUDOVRQGHUQNQSIWDQHEHQGLHVHQ *HGDQNHQ GHU DUJXPHQWDWLYHQ ([WHUQDOLVLHUXQJ YRQ .DQWV EHJUQGXQJV WKHRUHWLVFKHU (LQVLHGHOHL DXFK HLQH GLVNXUVWKHRUHWLVFKH )XQGLHUXQJ GHV SULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLV Å9HUSIOLFKWHWIKOHQZLUXQVQXUGXUFK1RUPHQYRQ GHQHQ ZLU PHLQHQ JHJHEHQHQIDOOV HUNOlUHQ ]X N|QQHQ ZDUXP VLH $QHU NHQQXQJLP.UHLVHGHU$GUHVVDWHQ XQGGHU%HWURIIHQHQ YHUGLHQHQ>«@ 3IOLFKWHQ ELQGHQ GHQ :LOOHQ GHU $GUHVVDWHQ DEHU VLH EHXJHQ LKQ QLFKW 6LH ZHLVHQ GHP :LOOHQ HLQH 5LFKWXQJ RULHQWLHUHQ LKQ DEHU VLH WUHLEHQ LKQ QLFKW ZLH ,PSXOVH DQ VLH PRWLYLHUHQ GXUFK *UQGH XQG YHUIJHQ QLFKW EHUGLH7ULHENUDIWDXVVFKOLHOLFKHPSLULVFKHU0RWLYH´ $XI +DEHUPDV· $QVLFKW GD GLH PRWLYDWLRQDOH .UDIW GLHVHU *UQGH QLFKW EHUVFKlW]W ZHUGHQ VROOWH ZHUGH LFK QRFK ]XUFNNRPPHQ 'RFK GHU HQWVFKHLGHQGH 6FKULWW YRQ .DQWV $FKWXQJVNRQ]HSW KLQ ]X HLQHU GLV NXUVHWKLVFKHQ (LQO|VXQJ GHVVHOEHQ WKHRUHWLVFKHQ $QVSUXFKV LVW GDPLW EHUHLWV JHWDQ :LH VLFK VRJOHLFK ]HLJHQ ZLUG EDKQW VLFK GDPLW DXFK +D EHUPDV· (QWNRSSHOXQJ GHV SULQFLSLXP GLMXGLFDWLRQLV YRP SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV DQ GHU $QVSUXFK GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 7KHRULH QlPOLFK EHLGH 3ULQ]LSLHQGHFNXQJVJOHLFK]XIDVVHQZLUGIDOOHQJHODVVHQXQGGLH0RUDOLWlW DOV GLVNXUVLY HLQO|VEDUH )HVWOHJXQJHQ EHVWLPPW 'LH (QWVFKHLGXQJ GDU
_____________ WHU 'HQNXQJVDUW´ HUNHQQW PDQ GHPJHPl GDUDQ ÅGD HU VLFK EHU GLH VXEMHFWLYHQ 3ULYDWEHGLQJXQJHQGHV8UWKHLOVZR]ZLVFKHQVRYLHOHDQGHUHZLHHLQJHNODPPHUWVLQG ZHJVHW]W XQG DXV HLQHP DOOJHPHLQHQ 6WDQGSXQNWH GHQ HU GDGXUFK QXU EHVWLPPHQ NDQQGDHUVLFKLQGHQ6WDQGSXQNW DQGHUHUYHUVHW]W EHUVHLQHLJHQHV 8UWKHLOUHIOHFWLUW´ .DQW 9 I +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 9JO GD]X DXFK :RRG VRZLH .HXO ]X HLQHP HLQJHKHQGHQ 9HUJOHLFK GHU 3RVLWLRQHQ .DQWV XQG +DEHUPDV· EH]JOLFK GHV 3UREOHPIHOGV 6XEMHNWLYLWlW,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW LQ GHU SUDNWLVFKHQ 3KLOR VRSKLH .HXO DUEHLWHW VRZRKO bKQOLFKNHLWHQ GLHVHU 7KHRULHQ XQG HQWVSUHFKHQGH %H ]XJQDKPHQGHU'LVNXUVWKHRULHDXI.DQWDOVDXFK'LIIHUHQ]SXQNWHKHUDXV +DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV (LQH PRUDOHSLVWHPRORJLVFKH ,VRODWLRQ YRQ 8UWHLOHQ XQG *HIKOHQ LVW PLW GLHVHU (QWNRSSHOXQJMHGRFKQLFKWLQWHQGLHUW Å9RQDQGHUHQ*HIKOHQXQWHUVFKHLGHQVLH>PR UDOLVFKH *HIKOH GHU $EVFKHX (PS|UXQJ .UlQNXQJ 5HVVHQWLPHQW 6FKDP 6FKXOG DEHUDXFK%HZXQGHUXQJ/R\DOLWlW'DQNEDUNHLW .3@VLFKQlPOLFKGDGXUFKGDVLH
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
EHU RE HLQH +DQGOXQJ DXV 3IOLFKW HUIROJW RGHU QLFKW ZLUG QLFKW LQ IRUR LQWHUQR JHWURIIHQ VRQGHUQ PX DXV GHU lXHUHQ 'LVNXUVWHLOQHKPHUSHU VSHNWLYHJHPlGHUGLVNXUVLYHQ5HDOLVLHUXQJGHV8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJVJUXQG VDW]HVDPNRQNUHWHQ)DOOJHWURIIHQZHUGHQ0RUDOLWlWEHPLWVLFKLQGLH VHP 6LQQH DQ GHU %HZlKUXQJ LQ IRUR H[WHUQR RKQH GDGXUFK ]XU EORHQ /HJDOLWlW GHJUDGLHUW ]X ZHUGHQ GHQQ ]ZLVFKHQ GHU EORHQ .RQIRUPLWlW PLW HLQHP EHVWHKHQGHQ 1RUPHQV\VWHP XQG GHU +DQGOXQJ DXV (LQVLFKW EHVWHKWHLQZLFKWLJHU8QWHUVFKLHG :lKUHQGGLH1RUPHQNRQIRUPLWlW GHV NRQYHQWLRQHOOHQ+DQGOXQJVW\SV QLFKWQDFK*UQGHQIUDJWPXVLFKGLH UDWLRQDOH6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJGHU0RUDOLWlWLP9HUODXIGHVNRPPXQLNDWLYHQ +DQGHOQVGLVNXUVLY]HLJHQXQGDXVZHLVHQODVVHQ GLH9RUWlXVFKXQJPRUD OLVFKHU0RWLYHOlWVLFKDXIGLHVHP:HJGLVNXUVLYHQWODUYHQ'DPLWVWHKW +DEHUPDV GHP ORJLVFKHQ ([SUHVVLYLVPXV %UDQGRPV GHU GHP 6SLHO GHV )RUGHUQVXQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQNRQNUHWGHP([SOL]LHUHQYRQ.RO ODWHUDOIHVWOHJXQJHQ GLH /DVW MHJOLFKHU $QVSUXFKVOHJLWLPDWLRQ DXFK GHU PRUDOLVFKHQDXIHUOHJWQlKHUDOVHV]XQlFKVWGHQ$QVFKHLQKDEHQPRFK WH 8QDEKlQJLJ YRQ GHU %HXUWHLOXQJ HLQHU +DQGOXQJ DOV PRUDOLVFK RGHU XQPRUDOLVFKEHVWLPPW+DEHUPDVGDVSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLVQRFKZHLWHU 'LH GDEHL VWDWWILQGHQGH (QWODVWXQJ GHV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV YRQ GHU 0RUDOLWlWHLQHU+DQGOXQJPDUNLHUWDXVPRWLYDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKHU3HUVSHNWL YHGHQVRHEHQYRP'LMXGLNDWLRQVSULQ]LSDXVEHWUDFKWHWHQ'LIIHUHQ]SXQNW ]ZLVFKHQGHUGLVNXUVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ6R]LDOHWKLN+DEHUPDV·XQGGHPPRUDO WKHRUHWLVFKHQ,QWURVSHNWLRQLVPXV.DQWV +DEHUPDVLVW²VRZHQLJZLH.DQW²HLQEOLQGHU5DWLRQDOLVW Å9RQGHU GLVNXUVLY JHZRQQHQHQ (LQVLFKW JLEW HV NHLQHQ JHVLFKHUWHQ 7UDQVIHU ]XP +DQGHOQ´(UGHSRWHQ]LHUWGLHPRWLYDWLRQDOH.UDIWGHU(LQVLFKWVFKOLHOLFK VRZHLWGDLKUH,QVXIIL]LHQ]XQG(UJlQ]XQJVEHGUIWLJNHLWGHXWOLFKVLFKW EDU ZHUGHQ ZHQQ HU YRQ GHU ÅLUULJHQ $QQDKPH´ PDQ GDUI HUJlQ]HQ PRGHUQHU ,QWHUQDOLVWHQ VSULFKW ÅNRJQLWLYLVWLVFKH (WKLNHQ ZUGHQ RGHU PWHQEHKDXSWHQGDGLHPRUDOLVFKH(LQVLFKWVFKRQHLQKLQUHLFKHQGHV 0RWLYIUPRUDOLVFKHV+DQGHOQVHL(VJHK|UWDEHU]XPNRJQLWLYLVWLVFKHQ 9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ0RUDOGDEHJUQGHWHPRUDOLVFKH*HERWHXQGHQWVSUH FKHQGH PRUDOLVFKH (LQVLFKWHQ QXU GLHVFKZDFK PRWLYLHUHQGH .UDIW JXWHU
_____________ PLWUDWLRQDOHLQNODJEDUHQ9HUSIOLFKWXQJHQYHUZREHQVLQG:LUYHUVWHKHQGLHVHbXH UXQJHQ HEHQ QLFKW DOV $XVGUXFN EOR VXEMHNWLYHU (PSILQGXQJHQ XQG 3UlIHUHQ]HQ´ +DEHUPDV +HUYRUKHEXQJ .3 9JO]XP%HJULIIGHU.ROODWHUDOIHVWOHJXQJHQREHQXQG.DS)QVRZLH]X +DEHUPDV·.ULWLNDQ%UDQGRPREHQ +DEHUPDV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGDVHPRWLYH)XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW
*UQGHPLWVLFKIKUHQ´ (VEHGDUIDOVRHLQHU(UJlQ]XQJXPHLQVSH]L ILVFKHPRWLYHV0RPHQW'HQQGLHPRWLYDWLRQDOH(QWODVWXQJGLHVHU*UQ GHLVWQLFKWEHUHLWVGXUFKHLQHÅ(UJlQ]XQJGHUQXUVFKZDFKPRWLYLHUHQGHQ 0RUDOGXUFK]ZLQJHQGHVXQGSRVLWLYHV5HFKW´ HUOHGLJWLQVRIHUQGLH,Q VWLWXWLRQHQGHU0RUDOXQGGHV5HFKWVVLFKJHUDGHLQGHU+HWHURQRPLHLQ .DXI QHKPHQGHQ 6WUDIEHZHKUWKHLW GHU OHW]WHUHQ XQG GHU DXI $XWRQRPLH JUQGHQGHQ8QEHGLQJWKHLWGHUHUVWHUHQXQWHUVFKHLGHQ 'RFKZDVYHUVWHKWQXQ+DEHUPDVVHLQHUVHLWVXQWHUHLQHUÅ$QWHLOQDK PHDP6FKLFNVDOGHVÄ1lFKVWHQ¶GHURIWGHU)HUQVWHLVW´ HLQHUÅPRWLYD WLRQDOHQ9HUDQNHUXQJPRUDOLVFKHU(LQVLFKWHQ´GLHHUDXFKDOVÅ9HULQQHU OLFKXQJ YRQ $XWRULWlW´ DQVSULFKW" :HQQ LFK ULFKWLJ VHKH EHVWHKW LQ GLHVHU+LQVLFKWHLQHJHZLVVH8QEHVWLPPWKHLWLQQHUKDOE+DEHUPDV·7KHR ULH 'HQQ LQ VHLQHP $XIVDW] Å0RUDOEHZXWVHLQ XQG NRPPXQLNDWLYHV +DQGHOQ´YRQ QlKHUWVLFK+DEHUPDVPLWGHPHEHQDQJHVSURFKHQHQ .RQ]HSW GHU 9HULQQHUOLFKXQJ RKQH H[SOL]LWHQ 5HNXUV GHU HQWVSUHFKHQ GHQ3RVLWLRQGHV.DQWGHU HU-DKUH+DEHUPDVVSULFKWGDEHLYRQHLQHU Å,QWHJUDWLRQ YRQ (UNHQQWQLVOHLVWXQJHQ XQG *HIKOVHLQVWHOOXQJHQ´ GLH ÅMHGHV DXVJHUHLIWH PRUDOLVFKH 8UWHLOVYHUP|JHQ´ NHQQ]HLFKQHQ XQG JUHQ]W ÅGLHVHV .RQ]HSW GHU 5HLIH´ YRQ GHQ Å(UVFKHLQXQJHQ GHV PRUDOLVFKHQ 5LJRULVPXVDOV%HHLQWUlFKWLJXQJHQGHV8UWHLOVYHUP|JHQV´ DE6FKOLHOLFK IRUGHUWHUDOVPRWLYDWLRQDOHV(OHPHQWPRUDOLVFKHU+DQGOXQJHQHLQHÅLGHD OH5ROOHQEHUQDKPH´ Å6LHYHUODQJWDQVSUXFKVYROOHNRJQLWLYH2SHUDWLRQHQ 'LHVH VWHKHQ ZLHGHUXP LQ LQWHUQHQ %H]LHKXQJHQ ]X 0RWLYHQ XQG *H IKOVHLQVWHOOXQJHQ ZLH ] % GHU (PSDWKLH >@ bKQOLFKH 9HUELQGXQJHQ ]ZLVFKHQ .RJQLWLRQ (LQIKOXQJVYHUP|JHQ XQG $JDSH N|QQHQ IU GLH KHUPHQHXWLVFKH /HLVWXQJ GHU NRQWH[WVHQVLWLYHQ $QZHQGXQJ DOOJHPHLQHU 1RUPHQ JHOWHQG JHPDFKW ZHUGHQ´ :LH EHUHLWV GHU VSlWH .DQW VR IRUGHUWDXFK+DEHUPDVHLQH,QWHJUDWLRQYRQ.RJQLWLRQXQG(PSDWKLH ,QVHLQHP$XIVDW]Å*HUHFKWLJNHLWXQG6ROLGDULWlW´YRQ DOV9RU WUDJ JHKDOWHQ VWHOOWHUGHPPRUDOLVFKHQSULQFLSLXPGLMXGLFDWLRQLVGHU *HUHFKWLJNHLWDXIGHUÅ(LQVWHOOXQJVHEHQH´GKDOVSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLR QLV MHGRFK GLH 6ROLGDULWlW DQ GLH 6HLWH ² XQG H[SOL]LW QLFKW Å>@ 0LWOHLG
_____________
+DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV ZHLVWLQGLHVH5LFKWXQJ +DEHUPDV I 9JOGD]XHEG (EG (EG I 9JO.DQW9,,,IXQGREHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
/LHEH]XP1lFKVWHQ+LOIVEHUHLWVFKDIWLPZHLWHVWHQ6LQQHDEHUDXFK*H PHLQVLQQ´ 'LH ZHVHQWOLFKH hEHUOHJHQKHLW GLHVHV GLVNXUVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ 6ROLGDUL WlWVNRQ]HSWV EHU GDV JHQDQQWH %HQHYROHQ]NRQ]HSW ² XQG QLFKW +DEHU PDV·hEHUZLQGXQJGHVÄ5LJRULVPXV¶GXUFKGLH(LQEH]LHKXQJGHUGH]LGLHUW HPRWLRQDOHQ .RPSRQHQWH LQ VHLQH (WKLN ² EHJUQGHW PHLQHV (UDFKWHQV GLHPRWLYDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKHhEHUOHJHQKHLWYRQ+DEHUPDV·'LVNXUVWKHRULH GHU 0RUDO EHU .DQWV 0RQRORJLVPXV (UVW PLW GHU 'LVNXUVRULHQWLHUXQJ GHU6ROLGDULWlWWULWW+DEHUPDVHQGJOWLJDXVGHP.DQWLVFKHQ6FKDWWHQGHU 3ULYDWKHLWPRUDOLVFKULFKWLJHU+DQGOXQJHQXQGGHUKDQGOXQJVDXVO|VHQGHQ 0RWLYHKHUDXV+DEHUPDVKHEW]ZDUQLFKWGHXWOLFKKHUYRUGD6ROLGDULWlW LQVHLQHU.RQ]HSWLRQGLHHLJHQWOLFKH)XQNWLRQGHVSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLV EHUQLPPW GRFK VFKHLQW PLU GLHV HLQ V\VWHPDWLVFK DQJHPHVVHQHV 9HU VWlQGQLV]XVHLQ Å$XVNRPPXQLNDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKHU6LFKWHUJLEWVLFK>@ HLQHQJHU=XVDPPHQKDQJGHU6RUJHIUGDV:RKOGHV1lFKVWHQPLWGHP ,QWHUHVVHIUGDVDOOJHPHLQH:RKO GLH,GHQWLWlWGHU*UXSSHUHSURGX]LHUW VLFKEHULQWDNWH9HUKlOWQLVVHUH]LSURNHU$QHUNHQQXQJ'DUXPLVWGHU]XU LQGLYLGXHOOHQ *OHLFKEHKDQGOXQJ NRPSOHPHQWlUH *HVLFKWVSXQNW QLFKW %HQHYROHQ]VRQGHUQ6ROLGDULWlW'LHVHV3ULQ]LSZXU]HOWLQGHU(UIDKUXQJ GDHLQHUIUGHQ$QGHUHQHLQVWHKHQPXZHLODOOHDOV*HQRVVHQDQGHU ,QWHJULWlW LKUHV JHPHLQVDPHQ /HEHQV]XVDPPHQKDQJV LQ GHUVHOEHQ :HLVH LQWHUHVVLHUWVHLQPVVHQ´ $QGLHVHU6WHOOH]HLJWVLFKIROJHQGHDQGHQEHLGHQ%HJULIIHQGHVSULQ FLSLXPGLMXGLFDWLRQLVXQGGHVSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLVDXVJHULFKWHWH6WUXN WXU GHU 7KHRULH +DEHUPDV· EHLGH 3ULQ]LSLHQ GDV GHU *HUHFKWLJNHLW XQG GDV GHU 6ROLGDULWlW ZHUGHQ EHU GHQ 'LVNXUV DXIHLQDQGHU EH]RJHQ ZR GXUFK LQVEHVRQGHUH OHW]WHUHV VHLQHQ .DQWLVFK RSDNHQ &KDUDNWHU YHUOLHUW %HLGH3ULQ]LSLHQZHUGHQDEHUDXFKGHXWOLFKYRQHLQDQGHUJHWUHQQW 8P GLHVH 6WUXNWXU IUHL]XOHJHQ LVW HV MHGRFK HUIRUGHUOLFK HLQH 'LIIH UHQ]LHUXQJLP%HJULIIGHU6ROLGDULlWYRU]XQHKPHQGLHLQ+DEHUPDV·7KH RULH YRUJH]HLFKQHW LVW YRQ LKP VR DEHU QLFKW QDPHQWOLFK EHQDQQW ZLUG YLHOPHKUODXIHQEHL+DEHUPDVGLHREMHNWLYHXQGGLHVXEMHNWLYH'LPHQVLRQ GLHVHV%HJULIIVGXUFKHLQDQGHU'LH8QWHUVFKHLGXQJGLHVHUEHLGHQ'LPHQ VLRQHQYHUVFKDIIWVHLQHU7KHRULHMHGRFKQLFKWQXUPHKU.ODUKHLWVRQGHUQ HU|IIQHW]XJOHLFKGLH0|JOLFKNHLW]ZHL)XQNWLRQVHOHPHQWHVHLQHU7KHRULH QHX]XEHVWLPPHQ 'LHREMHNWLYH6HLWHGHV%HJULIIVGHU6ROLGDULWlWEH]LHKWVLFKDXIHLQH,Q WHUDNWLRQVVWUXNWXUGLHQLFKWGXUFKGLHUHLQH5H]LSUR]LWlWGHU+DQGOXQJHQ EHVWLPPW LVW VRQGHUQ HLQVHLWLJH +LOIHOHLVWXQJHQ HLQVFKOLHW ,Q GLHVHP
_____________ +DEHUPDV (EG
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGDVHPRWLYH)XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW
6LQQH VSULFKW +DEHUPDV QLFKW QXU YRQ *HUHFKWLJNHLW VRQGHUQ DXFK YRQ 6ROLGDULWlWDOVÅQRUPDWLYHQ9HUSIOLFKWXQJHQ´XQGEHVWLPPWEHLGHIROJHQ GHUPDHQ Å*HUHFKWLJNHLWEH]LHKWVLFKDXIGLHJOHLFKHQ)UHLKHLWHQXQYHUWUHW EDUHU XQG VLFK VHOEVW EHVWLPPHQGHU ,QGLYLGXHQ ZlKUHQG VLFK 6ROLGDULWlW DXIGDV:RKOGHULQHLQHULQWHUVXEMHNWLYJHWHLOWHQ/HEHQVIRUPYHUVFKZLV WHUWHQ*HQRVVHQEH]LHKW²XQGGDPLWDXFKDXIGLH(UKDOWXQJGHU,QWHJULWlW GLHVHU/HEHQVIRUPVHOEVW´ 'LHVXEMHNWLYH6HLWH²XQGGDPLWLVWGLH6ROLGDULWlWDOVSULQFLSLXPH[H FXWLRQLVDQJHVSURFKHQ²EH]LHKWVLFKDXIGHQHPRWLYHQ$VSHNWGHUDXFK GHUDOOWDJVVSUDFKOLFKHQ9HUZHQGXQJGHV%HJULIIVDOV*HPHLQVLQQDOV=X VDPPHQJHK|ULJNHLWVJHIKO5HFKQXQJWUlJW 'D +DEHUPDV GHQ VXEMHNWLYHQ $VSHNW GHV 6ROLGDULWlWVEHJULIIV DOV .DQGLGDW IU HLQ SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV LQ QRWZHQGLJHU (UJlQ]XQJ GHU ÄVFKZDFKPRWLYLHUHQGHQ.UDIWJXWHU*UQGH¶ LP%OLFNKDWZLUGGHXWOLFK ZHQQHUGLHVH6ROLGDULWlWDOVDIIHNWLYH%HGLQJXQJGHU |IIHQWOLFKHQ 5HDOL VLHUXQJ YRQ *HUHFKWLJNHLW FKDUDNWHULVLHUW Å%HLGHV WULIIW ]X RKQH GLH XQ HLQJHVFKUlQNWH LQGLYLGXHOOH )UHLKHLW GHU 6WHOOXQJQDKPH ]X QRUPDWLYHQ *HOWXQJVDQVSUFKHQ N|QQWH GLH IDNWLVFK HU]LHOWH hEHUHLQVWLPPXQJ QLFKW ZDKUKDIWDOOJHPHLQVHLQ DEHURKQHGLHVROLGDULVFKH(LQIKOXQJHLQHVMHGHQ LQ GLH /DJH DOOHU DQGHUHQ N|QQWH HV ]X HLQHU NRQVHQVIlKLJHQ /|VXQJ JDU QLFKWNRPPHQ´ 'LHREMHNWLYH*HUHFKWLJNHLWJLOWDOV,QGLNDWRUDOVSULQFL SLXPGLMXGLFDWLRQLVPRUDOLVFKHQ+DQGHOQV'LHVXEMHNWLYHPSIXQGHQH6ROLGD ULWlW ZLUNW DOV 0RWRU DOV SULQFLSLXP H[HFXWLRQLV PRUDOLVFKHQ +DQGHOQV $OV VROFKHVLQGEHLGH3ULQ]LSLHQYRQHLQDQGHUIXQNWLRQDOYHUVFKLHGHQ ZlKUHQG 3HUVRQHQ]XJHUHFKWHP+DQGHOQYHUSIOLFKWHWZHUGHQN|QQHQLVWGLH9HU SIOLFKWXQJ]XHLQHP=XVDPPHQJHK|ULJNHLWVJHIKO ZLHGLH9HUSIOLFKWXQJ ]XMHGZHGHP*HIKO HLQEHJULIIOLFKHV8QGLQJ %HLGH *HUHFKWLJNHLW XQG 6ROLGDULWlW VLQG QDFK +DEHUPDV DEHU DXFK DXIHLQDQGHU EH]RJHQ ² XQG KLHU ]HLJW VLFK GLH 1RWZHQGLJNHLW QLFKW QXU HLQHU(QJIKUXQJGHUVXEMHNWLYHQXQGREMHNWLYHQ'LPHQVLRQHQGHV6ROL GDULWlWVEHJULIIVVRQGHUQDXFKHLQHU(QJIKUXQJYRQEHJUQGXQJVWKHRUH WLVFKHQXQGPRUDOSV\FKRORJLVFKHQE]ZSlGDJRJLVFKHQ+LQVLFKWHQ 'HQQ *HUHFKWLJNHLWXQG6ROLGDULWlWVSHLVHQVLFKEHJUQGXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKDXVGHQ 'LVNXUVYRUDXVVHW]XQJHQ EHU GHQ 'LVNXUV N|QQHQ DEHU EHLGH DXFK HUVW PRUDOSV\FKRORJLVFKE]ZSlGDJRJLVFKHWDEOLHUWZHUGHQ 'LHHUVWHEHJUQGXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKH+LQVLFKWEHWULIIW+DEHUPDV·$EOHL WXQJ GHV 8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJVJUXQGVDW]HV DOV $UJXPHQWDWLRQVUHJHO IU GLH %HJUQGXQJ PRUDOLVFKHU 8UWHLOH DXV GHQ DOOJHPHLQHQ 'LVNXUVYRUDXVVHW ]XQJHQ gIIHQWOLFKNHLW*OHLFKEHUHFKWLJXQJ:DKUKDIWLJNHLWXQG=ZDQJOR
_____________ (EGI (EG
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
VLJNHLW 'LH ]ZHLWH PRUDOSV\FKRORJLVFKH E]Z SlGDJRJLVFKH +LQVLFKW EHWULIIW GLH GLVNXUVWKHRUHWLVFKH 9HUNQSIXQJ EHLGHU 3ULQ]LSLHQ Å6R WUlJW GDV 9HUIDKUHQ GLVNXUVLYHU :LOOHQVELOGXQJ GHP LQQHUHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ EHLGHU$VSHNWH5HFKQXQJ GHU$XWRQRPLHXQYHUWUHWEDUHU,QGLYLGXHQXQG LKUHU YRUJlQJLJHQ (LQEHWWXQJ LQ LQWHUVXEMHNWLY JHWHLOWH /HEHQVIRUPHQ EHUKDXSW´ 'HXWOLFK ZLUG EHL GLHVHU (QJIKUXQJ YRQ *HUHFKWLJNHLW XQG 6ROLGDULWlW MHGRFK DXFK GD HV VLFK KLHU QLFKW XP GLH %HREDFKWXQJ HLQHV XUZFKVLJHQ 6DFKYHUKDOWV KDQGHOW VRQGHUQ XP GHQ =LHOSXQNW GHU 6R]LDOLVDWLRQ XQG 0RUDOHQWZLFNOXQJ (UVW HLQH .XOWXU UDWLRQDO JHIKUWHU 'LVNXUVHNDQQGLHÅ*UHQ]HQHLQHUNRQNUHWHQ/HEHQVZHOWGHU)DPLOLHGHV 6WDPPHV GHU 6WDGW RGHU GHU 1DWLRQ´ EHUVFKUHLWHQ XQG GDPLW ]X GHU DOOJHPHLQHQ XQG ÅUH]LSURNHQ $QHUNHQQXQJ ]XUHFKQXQJVIlKLJHU 6XEMHNWH >IKUHQ .3@GLHLKU+DQGHOQDQ*HOWXQJVDQVSUFKHQRULHQWLHUHQ´ 0LWGHPVSlWHQ.DQWGHUQLFKWQXUGLHXQLYHUVHOOH*OWLJNHLWGHV6LW WHQJHVHW]HVYHUWHLGLJWVRQGHUQDXFKGHQ%HJULIIGHUÅ/LHEHDOVIUHLH$XI QDKPHGHV:LOOHQVHLQHV$QGHUQXQWHUVHLQH0D[LPHQ´HLQEH]LHKWJHKW GLHVH.RQ]HSWLRQGHVSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLVLQVRIHUQNRQIRUPDOV HQW JHJHQ GHU +DEHUPDV·VFKHQ $EJUHQ]XQJ EHLP VSlWHQ .DQW YRQ HLQHU UDWLRQDOLVWLVFKHQ,QGLYLGXDOLVLHUXQJNHLQH5HGHPHKUVHLQNDQQ GHUVSlWH .DQW WKHPDWLVLHUW GLH DIIHNWLYH Ä(LQEH]LHKXQJ GHV $QGHUHQ¶ 'HU 8QWHU VFKLHGEHWULIIWYLHOPHKUZLHEHUHLWVEHWRQWGLH'LVNXUVLYLWlWGHU:LOOHQV ELOGXQJGLH.DQWDXHU$FKWJHODVVHQKDWWH+DEHUPDV·SULQ]LSLHOOH'LV NXUVRULHQWLHUXQJGLHVLFKLQGHPGLVNXUVHWKLVFKHQ*UXQGVDW]Ä'¶lXHUW Å>@GDQXUGLH1RUPHQ*HOWXQJEHDQVSUXFKHQGUIHQGLHGLH=XVWLP PXQJDOOHU%HWURIIHQHQDOV7HLOQHKPHUHLQHVSUDNWLVFKHQ'LVNXUVHVILQGHQ RGHUILQGHQN|QQWHQ ´IKUW]XHLQHUUHFKWIHUWLJXQJVRULHQWLHUWHQ6R]LD OLVLHUXQJ GHU .DQWLVFKHQ 0RUDOWKHRULH GHUHQ $XIJDEH QlPOLFK Å>@ GLH %HGLQJXQJHQ]XH[SOL]LHUHQXQWHUGHQHQMHZHLOVGLH%HWHLOLJWHQVHOEVWHLQH YHUQQIWLJH $QWZRUW ILQGHQ N|QQWHQ´ LP 9HUJOHLFK ]XU .DQWLVFKHQ 0HWDSK\VLNGHU6LWWHQJUXQGOHJHQGQHXEHVWLPPWLVW +DEHUPDV· $XIIDVVXQJ YRQ ,QWHUSHUVRQDOLWlW NDQQ LP JHJHQZlUWLJHQ PRWLYDWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKHQ 5DKPHQ DOV HLQ ZHLWHUHU 'LIIHUHQ]SXQNW GHU 7KHRULHLP*HJHQVDW]]X.DQWVDWRPLVWLVFKHUERWWRPXS.RQ]HSWLRQQXU EHQDQQWQLFKWDEHUZHLWHUYHUIROJWRGHUNULWLVLHUWZHUGHQ 3HUVRQHQZHU
_____________ 9JO+DEHUPDV VRZLHGHUV I +DEHUPDV (EG .DQW9,,, +DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV +DEHUPDV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGDVHPRWLYH)XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW
GHQQDFK+DEHUPDVÅ]X,QGLYLGXHQDOOHLQGDGXUFKKHUDQJHELOGHWGDVLH LQ HLQH 6SUDFKJHPHLQVFKDIW XQG GDPLW LQ HLQH LQWHUVXEMHNWLY JHWHLOWH /H EHQVZHOW KLQHLQZDFKVHQ ,Q GLHVHQ %LOGXQJVSUR]HVVHQ HQWVWHKHQ XQG HU KDOWHQ VLFK JOHLFKXUVSUQJOLFK GLH ,GHQWLWlW GHV (LQ]HOQHQ XQG GLH GHV .ROOHNWLYV GHP GLHVHU DQJHK|UW´ :lKUHQG .DQW VHLQ %LOG YRQ GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ3UD[LVLPGRSSHOWHQ5DKPHQGHVPXQGXVLQWHOOLJLELOLVXQG GHV PXQGXV VHQVLELOLV ]HLFKQHW EHILQGHW VLFK +DEHUPDV· %LOG ZLH EHL PRGHUQHQ%LOGHUQKlXILJ QLFKWLQHLQHP5DKPHQVRQGHUQLQWHJULHUWGLH PHWDSK\VLVFKHQRGHUNRQWUDIDNWLVFKHQ$QQDKPHQLQGDV%LOGVHOEVW'LH $QHUNHQQXQJVWKHRULHDXIGHUVHLQH'LVNXUVWKHRULHGHU0RUDODXIUXKWLVW VHOEVW7HLOHLQHUXPIDVVHQGHQ(UNOlUXQJPHQVFKOLFKHU3UD[LV 1LFKW QXU GLH *HUHFKWLJNHLW VRQGHUQ DXFK GLH 6ROLGDULWlW VXEMHNWLY ZLH REMHNWLY KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHV *HOWXQJV ZLH LKUHV (QWVWHKXQJVDVSHNWV EHGUIHQ]XLKUHU(UNOlUXQJZHVHQWOLFKGHUGLVNXUVLYHQ(LQEH]LHKXQJGHV $QGHUHQ 0LW +DEHUPDV· 0RUDOSULQ]LS GHP 8QLYHUVDOLVLHUXQJVJUXQGVDW] Ä8¶DOV$UJXPHQWDWLRQVUHJHO]XU$XIILQGXQJPRUDOLVFKHU1RUPHQPLWÄ'¶ GHU9HUIDKUHQVUHJHOPRUDOLVFKHU$UJXPHQWDWLRQVRZLHPLWGHP.RQ]HSW GHU $QHUNHQQXQJ VLQG GLH NROODWHUDOHQ )HVWOHJXQJHQ VHLQHV 6\VWHPV EH QDQQWGLHHLQJDQJVGLHVHV.DSLWHOVDOVNRQ]HSWLRQHOOQRWZHQGLJH9HUDQNH UXQJ YRQ +DEHUPDV·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lW²QLFKWGHPGHUSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ%HJUQGXQ JHQ²HLQ.RQYHUJHQ]SXQNW]XU(WKLN.DQWVGHUMD]XPLQGHVWLQGHU$XV DUEHLWXQJ YRQ KLQWHU GLH Ä%HJUQGXQJVOHKUH¶ GHU 0RUDO HLQH 0HWKR GHQOHKUH LQ SUDNWLVFKHU E]Z SUDJPDWLVFKHU +LQVLFKW JHVWHOOW KDW .DQW HLQVFKOLHHQG EHVFKUHLEW +DEHUPDV GHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ ]ZLVFKHQ DEV WUDNWHQ 1RUPHQ XQG GHU /HEHQVZHOW IROJHQGHUPDHQ Å:DV PRUDOLVFKHV XQGYRUDOOHPXQPRUDOLVFKHV9HUKDOWHQEHGHXWHWHUIDKUHQZLUXQGOHUQHQ ZLUYRUDOOHU3KLORVRSKLH GDVEHJHJQHWXQVLP0LWOHLGHQPLWGHUYHUVHKUWHQ ,QWHJULWlWDQGHUHUQLFKWZHQLJHUDXIGULQJOLFKDOVLP/HLGHQDQGHUYHUOHW]
_____________ +DEHUPDV 9JO +DEHUPDV ÅhEHUIRUGHUW ZLUG GLH 3KLORVRSKLH YRQ MHQHU )UDJH GLH $SHO ÄGLH H[LVWHQWLHOOH )UDJH QDFK GHP 6LQQ GHV 0RUDOLVFKVHLQV¶ QHQQW´ 9JO GD]X $SHO
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
.DS²3UlYDOHQWH+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGPRUDOLVFKH0RWLYDWLRQ
WHQHLJHQHQ,GHQWLWlWRGHULQGHU$QJVWXPGHUHQ*HIlKUGXQJ'LHXQDXV GUFNOLFKHQ 6R]LDOLVDWLRQVHUIDKUXQJHQ YRQ 6FKRQXQJ VROLGDULVFKHU +LOIH XQG)DLUQHSUlJHQXQVHUH,QWXLWLRQHQXQGEHOHKUHQXQVGDUEHUEHVVHU DOV DOOH $UJXPHQWH HV YHUP|FKWHQ´ 'DPLW VLQG ZLU HQGJOWLJ EHL GHQ ÅHQWJHJHQNRPPHQGHQ/HEHQVIRUPHQ´DQJHNRPPHQDXIGLHMHGHXQLYHU VDOLVWLVFKH 0RUDO DQJHZLHVHQ LVW %HGDXHUQ NDQQ GLHV QXU ZHU GHQ JUXQGOHJHQGHQ 8QWHUVFKLHG ]ZLVFKHQ LQWUDSHUVRQDOHQ %HJUQGXQJHQ XQG LQWHUSHUVRQDOHQ5HFKWIHUWLJXQJHQEHUVLHKWRGHUHLQHEQHW +DEHUPDVJHKWZLHYRULKP.DQWYRQHLQHU8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ]ZLVFKHQ EORHU /HJDOLWlW XQG 0RUDOLWlW DXV 3IOLFKWJHPlH +DQGOXQJHQ VWHKHQ KLQVLFKWOLFK LKUHU PRUDOLVFKHQ 'LJQLWlW XQWHUKDOE GHU +DQGOXQJHQ DXV 3IOLFKW'RFKZlKUHQGGHUNULWLVFKH.DQWGLHVH0RUDOLWlWHLQHU+DQGOXQJLQ HLQH MHJOLFKHU 9HULILNDWLRQ XQ]XJlQJOLFKH :LUNXQJ GHU 9HUQXQIW DXI GDV *HIKOYHUOHJWZHQGHW+DEHUPDVGLHVHQ,QWURVSHNWLRQLVPXVQDFKDXHQ XQGNDSSWGDPLWGLH.DQWLVFKH9HUELQGXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHPREMHNWLYHQXQG GHPVXEMHNWLYHQ+DQGOXQJVSULQ]LSGHU0RUDOGHPSULQFLSLXPGLMXGLFDWL RQLVXQGGHPSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLVZREHLGLHIROJHQGHQEHLGHQ3XQNWH YRQ]HQWUDOHU%HGHXWXQJVLQG (UVWHQV (LQH+DQGOXQJDXV3IOLFKWZLUGQLFKWOlQJHUGDUDQJHPHVVHQ ZHOFKHKDQGOXQJVDXVO|VHQGHQ0RWLYH]XGLHVHU+DQGOXQJJHIKUWKDEHQ VRQGHUQGDUDQREGLH+DQGOXQJ]XPHLQHQYRQHLQHU(LQVLFKWLQGLHHQW VSUHFKHQGH1RUPXQG]XPDQGHUHQYRQGHU(LQVLFKWLQGLHHLJHQH)HVWOH JXQJDXIGLHVH1RUPJHOHLWHWLVW'LHVH(LQVLFKWHQPVVHQ²XQGGDVLVW GHUHQWVFKHLGHQGH6FKULWWLQGHU$UJXPHQWDWLRQ²LP6SLHOGHV)RUGHUQV XQG/LHIHUQVYRQ*UQGHQGLVNXUVLYHLQJHO|VWZHUGHQN|QQHQ'DPLWLVW +DEHUPDV· $UJXPHQWDWLRQ IU GDV SULQFLSLXP GLMXGLFDWLRQLV HLQHU PRUDOL VFKHQ+DQGOXQJJHVFKORVVHQXQG]XJOHLFK%UDQGRPV3URMHNWGHU([SOLND WLRQ GHRQWLVFKHU 6WDWXV XQG (LQVWHOOXQJHQ LQ GHU 0RUDOSKLORVRSKLH UHDOL VLHUW =ZHLWHQV 'DVSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLVHLQHU+DQGOXQJZLUGGDGXUFKYRQ GHU QRUPDWLYHQ /DVW GHU 0RUDOLWlW EHIUHLW GD HV DOV $QWZRUW DXI HLQH DQGHUH)UDJHDXIJHIDWZLUG'DVSULQFLSLXPH[HFXWLRQLVOLHIHUWQLFKWZLH EHL.DQWGHQ%HZHLVJUXQGPRUDOLVFKHU+DQGOXQJHQVRQGHUQEHQHQQWGLH EHLHQGOLFKHQ:HVHQZLHXQV0HQVFKHQIDNWLVFKHUIRUGHUOLFKH5DKPHQEH GLQJXQJVROFKHU+DQGOXQJHQ'DVLVWQLFKWQLFKWVDEHUHVLVWZHQLJHUDOV GDVEHJUQGXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKUHOHYDQWH*HIKOGHU$FKWXQJEHL.DQW+D EHUPDV·.RQ]HSWGHU6ROLGDULWlWDOVVXEMHNWLYH'LVSRVLWLRQDOVNXOWLYLHUED UHV XQG ]X NXOWLYLHUHQGHV (LQIKOXQJVYHUP|JHQ VWHKW DOV VROFKHV QLFKW ]XUPRUDOLVFKHQ%HZHUWXQJHLQHUDNWXHOOHQ+DQGOXQJDQ'D PLWGLHVHP
_____________ +DEHUPDV 9JO+DEHUPDV
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
+DQGOXQJVJUQGHXQGGDVHPRWLYH)XQGDPHQWGHU6ROLGDULWlW
:LVVHQ JHVHOOVFKDIWVSROLWLVFKGLH6FKDIIXQJHLQHVVROLGDULVFKHQ.OLPDVDOV %HGLQJXQJJHOHEWHU0RUDOLWlWVHOEVW]XHLQHU$XIJDEHXQG3IOLFKWZHUGHQ NDQQ VWHKW DXI HLQHP DQGHUHQ %ODWW 6R]LDOH 5DKPHQEHGLQJXQJHQ IU 6ROLGDULWlW ]X VFKDIIHQ LVW VHOEVW HLQ PRUDOLVFK XQG VFKOLHOLFK SROLWLVFK UHOHYDQWHV=LHO'RFKLQQHUKDOEGLHVHV5DKPHQVZLUG0RUDOLWlWQLFKWXQG NDQQ0RUDOLWlWQLFKWDQ*HIKOHQJHPHVVHQZHUGHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%LEOLRJUDSKLH
$GLFNHV (ULFK .DQWV /HKUH YRQ GHU GRSSHOWHQ $IIHNWLRQ XQVHUHV ,FK DOV 6FKOVVHO]XVHLQHU(UNHQQWQLVWKHRULH7ELQJHQ $OH[\5REHUW Å(LQH7KHRULHGHVSUDNWLVFKHQ'LVNXUVHV´LQ 1RU PHQEHJUQGXQJ²1RUPHQGXUFKVHW]XQJ0DWHULDOLHQ]XU1RUPHQGLVNXVVLRQ KJY:LOOL2HOPOOHU%G3DGHUERUQ 6 $OH[\5REHUW3HF]HQLN$OHNVDQGHU Å7KH&RQFHSWRI&RKHUHQFH DQG ,WV 6LJQLILFDQFH IRU 'LVFXUVLYH 5DWLRQDOLW\µ LQ 5DWLR -XULV $OH[\ 5REHUW Å1RUPHQEHJUQGXQJ XQG 1RUPDQZHQGXQJ´ LQ GHUV 5HFKW 9HUQXQIW 'LVNXUV 6WXGLHQ ]XU 5HFKWVSKLORVRSKLH )UDQN IXUW0 $OOLVRQ +HQU\ ( Å7UDQVFHQGHQWDO ,GHDOLVP 7KH ¶7ZR $VSHFW· 9LHZ´ LQ 1HZ (VVD\V RQ .DQW KJ Y % G 2XGHQ 0 0RHQ 1HZRULJ @ +DEHUPDV -UJHQ 0RUDOEHZXWVHLQ XQG NRPPXQLNDWLYHV +DQGHOQ )UDQNIXUW0>RULJ @ +DEHUPDV-UJHQ (UOlXWHUXQJHQ]XU'LVNXUVHWKLN)UDQNIXUW0 +DEHUPDV-UJHQ )DNWL]LWlWXQG*HOWXQJ%HLWUlJH]XU'LVNXUVWKHRULH GHV 5HFKWV XQG GHV GHPRNUDWLVFKHQ 5HFKWVVWDDWV )UDQNIXUW0 >RULJ @ +DEHUPDV-UJHQ 'LH(LQEH]LHKXQJGHV$QGHUHQ6WXGLHQ]XUSROLWLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLH)UDQNIXUW0 +DEHUPDV -UJHQ 'LH SRVWQDWLRQDOH .RQVWHOODWLRQ 3ROLWLVFKH (VVD\V )UDQNIXUW0 +DEHUPDV-UJHQ :DKUKHLWXQG5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ3KLORVRSKLVFKH$XIVlW]H )UDQNIXUW0
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%LEOLRJUDSKLH
+DEHUPDV -UJHQ .RPPXQLNDWLYHV +DQGHOQ XQG GHWUDQV]HQGHQWDOLVLHUWH 9HUQXQIW6WXWWJDUW +DEHUPDV-UJHQ 'LH=XNXQIWGHUPHQVFKOLFKHQ1DWXU$XIGHP:HJ ]XHLQHUOLEHUDOHQ(XJHQLN)UDQNIXUW0>RULJ@ +DEHUPDV -UJHQ =ZLVFKHQ 1DWXUDOLVPXV XQG 5HOLJLRQ 3KLORVRSKLVFKH $XIVlW]H)UDQNIXUW0 +DKQ6XVDQQH hEHUOHJXQJVJOHLFKJHZLFKW H 3UIXQJHLQHU5HFKWIHUWLJXQJV PHWDSKHU)UHLEXUJ%U +DOELJ&KULVWRSK Å1RUPDWLYH*UQGH1HXH%HLWUlJH]XU7KHRULH SUDNWLVFKHU9HUQXQIW ,, ´LQ 'HXWVFKH=HLWVFKULIWIU3KLORVRSKLH +DPDQQ-RKDQQ*HRUJ Å0HWDNULWLNEHUGHQ3XULVPXPGHU9HU QXQIW´ LQ %ULHIZHFKVHO %G KJ Y $ +HQNHO )UDQN IXUW0 +DPSWRQ -HDQ 7KH $XWKRULW\ RI 5HDVRQ +J Y 5LFKDUG +HDOH\ &DPEULGJH +DPSWRQ-HDQ Å&RQWUDFWVDQG&KRLFHV'RHV5DZOV+DYHD6RFLDO &RQWUDFW7KHRU\µLQ -RXUQDORI3KLORVRSK\ +DUH5LFKDUG0 0RUDOLVFKHV'HQNHQ6HLQH(EHQHQVHLQH0HWKRGHVHLQ :LW] hEHUV 9 &KULVWRSK )HKLJH XQG *HRUJ 0HJJOH )UDQN IXUW0>HQJO2ULJLQDO 0RUDO7KLQNLQJ,WV/HYHOV0HWKRGDQG3RLQW 2[IRUG @ +HQULFK 'LHWHU ÅhEHU .DQWV IUKHVWH (WKLN 9HUVXFK HLQHU 5H NRQVWUXNWLRQ´LQ .DQW6WXGLHQ +HQULFK 'LHWHU Å'HU %HJULII GHU VLWWOLFKHQ (LQVLFKW XQG .DQWV /HKUHYRP)DNWXPGHU9HUQXQIW´LQ .DQW=XU'HXWXQJVHLQHU7KH RULHYRQ(UNHQQHQXQG+DQGHOQKJY*HUROG3UDXVV.|OQ +HQULFK'LHWHU Å(WKLNGHU$XWRQRPLH´LQ GHUV6HOEVWYHUKlOWQLVVH 6WXWWJDUW +HQULFK 'LHWHU Å.DQW·V 1RWLRQ RI D 'HGXFWLRQ DQG WKH 0HWKR GRORJLFDO%DFNJURXQGRIWKH)LUVW&ULWLTXHµLQ .DQW·V7UDQVFHQGHQWDO 'HGXFWLRQV7KH7KUHH&ULWLTXHVDQGWKH2SXV3RVWXPXPKJY(FNDUW )|UVWHU6WDQIRUG +LOO7KRPDV(-U Å7KH+\SRWKHWLFDO,PSHUDWLYH´LQ 3KLORVRSKLFDO 5HYLHZ +LOO7KRPDV(-U 'LJQLW\DQG3UDFWLFDO5HDVRQLQ.DQW·V0RUDO7KHRU\ ,WKDFD +LQFKPDQ(GZDUG6 Å7UXVWDQG'LDFURQLF$JHQF\´LQ 1RXV +REEHV 7KRPDV /HYLDWKDQ RGHU 'LH 0DWHULH )RUP XQG 0DFKW HLQHV NLUFKOLFKHQ XQG VWDDWOLFKHQ *HPHLQZHVHQV >2ULJLQDO /RQGRQ @ +DPEXUJ +RHUVWHU1RUEHUW Å=XP3UREOHPHLQHUDEVROXWHQ1RUPJHOWXQJ´ LQ 6WDDWVUHFKWLQ7KHRULHXQG3UD[LV)HVWVFKULIWIU5REHUW:DOWHUKJY +HLQ]0D\HU:LHQ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%LEOLRJUDSKLH
+ROWRQ 5LFKDUG Å5DWLRQDO 5HVROYH´ LQ 3KLORVRSKLFDO 5HYLHZ +RQQHWK $[HO +J .RPPXQLWDULVPXV (LQH 'HEDWWH EHU GLH PRUDOL VFKHQ*UXQGODJHQPRGHUQHU*HVHOOVFKDIWHQ)UDQNIXUW0 +RQQHWK$[HO Å8QVLFKWEDUNHLWhEHUGLHPRUDOLVFKH(SLVWHPROR JLH YRQ Ä$QHUNHQQXQJ¶´ LQ GHUV 8QVLFKWEDUNHLW 6WDWLRQHQ HLQHU 7KHRULHGHU,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW)UDQNIXUW0 +XPH'DYLG $7UHDWLVHRI+XPDQ1DWXUH %HLQJDQ$WWHPSWWR,QWUR GXFHWKH([SHULPHQWDO0HWKRGRI5HDVRQLQJLQWR0RUDO6XEMHFWV/RQGRQ +XVVDLQ1DGHHP-= Å'LVFXVVLRQ²¶7KH*XLVHRID5HDVRQ·µLQ 3KLORVRSKLFDO6WXGLHV -DQLFK 3HWHU .XOWXU XQG 0HWKRGH 3KLORVRSKLH LQ HLQHU ZLVVFKHQVFKDIWOLFK JHSUlJWHQ:HOW)UDQNIXUW0 -RQDV +DQV 'DV 3ULQ]LS 9HUDQWZRUWXQJ 9HUVXFK HLQHU (WKLN IU GLH WHFKQRORJLVFKH=LYLOLVDWLRQ)UDQNIXUW0 .DLQ 3DWULFN Å3UXGHQWLDO 5HDVRQ LQ .DQW·V $QWKURSRORJ\´ LQ (VVD\VRQ.DQW·V$QWKURSRORJ\KJY%ULDQ-DFREVXQG3DWULFN.DLQ &DPEULGJH .DPEDUWHO)ULHGULFK Å0RUDOLVFKHV$UJXPHQWLHUHQ²0HWKRGLVFKH $QDO\VHQ]XU(WKLN´LQ 3UDNWLVFKH3KLORVRSKLHXQGNRQVWUXNWLYH:LV VHQVFKDIWVWKHRULHKJY)ULHGULFK.DPEDUWHO)UDQNIXUW0 .DPEDUWHO)ULHGULFK 3KLORVRSKLHGHUKXPDQHQ:HOW)UDQNIXUW0 .DPP )UDQFHV 0 Å2ZLQJ -XVWLI\LQJ DQG 5HMHFWLQJ´ LQ 0LQG .DQW ,PPDQXHO *HVDPPHOWH 6FKULIWHQ +HUDXVJHJHEHQ YRQ GHU .| QLJOLFK 3UHXLVFKHQ $NDGHPLH GHU :LVVHQVFKDIWHQ %HUOLQ >5|PL VFKH=LIIHUQJHEHQGHQ%DQGDQDUDELVFKH=LIIHUQGLH6HLWHQ]DKO GHV%DQGHV GLH.ULWLNGHUUHLQHQ9HUQXQIW .U9 ZLUGQDFKGHQ2UL JLQDOSDJLQLHUXQJHQGHU$XVJDEHQYRQ $ XQG % ]L WLHUW@ .DQW,PPDQXHO 9RUOHVXQJ]XU0RUDOSKLORVRSKLH+JY:HUQHU6WDUN PLW HLQHU (LQOHLWXQJ YRQ 0DQIUHG .KQ %HUOLQ >]LWLHUW QDFK GHU RULJLQDOHQ3DJLQLHUXQJ@ .DYND*UHJRU\6 Å'DV9HUV|KQXQJVSURMHNW´LQ :DUXPPRUDOLVFK VHLQ"KJY.XUW%D\HUW]3DGHUERUQ .HWWQHU 0DWWKLDV Å*XWH *UQGH 7KHVHQ ]XU GLVNXUVLYHQ 9HU QXQIW´LQ 'LHHLQH9HUQXQIWXQGGLHYLHOHQ5DWLRQDOLWlWHQKJY.DUO 2WWR$SHOXQG0DWWKLDV.HWWQHU)UDQNIXUW0 .HXO+DQV.ODXV Å6XEMHNWLYLWlWXQG,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlW=XP)UHL KHLWVEHJULIIEHL.DQWXQG+DEHUPDV´LQ 'HXWVFKH=HLWVFKULIWIU3KL ORVRSKLH .OLPFKXN 'HQQLV Å7KUHH $FFRXQWV RI 5HVSHFW IRU 3HUVRQV LQ .DQW·V(WKLFV´LQ .DQWLDQ5HYLHZ
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%LEOLRJUDSKLH
.QHOO6HEDVWLDQ D Å(LQHGHIODWLRQLVWLVFKH7KHRULHGHU,QWHQWLRQDOL WlW" %UDQGRPV $QDO\VH GHUHVSH]LIL]LHUHQGHU (LQVWHOOXQJV]X VFKUHLEXQJHQ´LQ 'HXWVFKH=HLWVFKULIWIU3KLORVRSKLH .QHOO 6HEDVWLDQ E Å'LH QRUPDWLYLVWLVFKH :HQGH GHU DQDO\WLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLH=X5REHUW%UDQGRPV7KHRULHEHJULIIOLFKHQ*HKDOWV XQG GLVNXUVLYHU 3UD[LV´ LQ $OOJHPHLQH =HLWVFKULIW IU 3KLORVRSKLH .QHOO6HEDVWLDQ 3URSRVLWLRQDOHU*HKDOWXQGGLVNXUVLYH.RQWRIKUXQJ(LQH 8QWHUVXFKXQJ ]XU %HJUQGXQJ GHU 6SUDFKDEKlQJLJNHLW LQWHQWLRQDOHU =X VWlQGHEHL%UDQGRP%HUOLQ .|KO+DUDOG .DQWV*HVLQQXQJVHWKLN%HUOLQ .|KO +DUDOG Å0RUDO XQG .OXJKHLW 5RUW\V .ULWLN DQ HLQHU NDQWL VFKHQ8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ´LQ 'HXWVFKH=HLWVFKULIWIU3KLORVRSKLH .|KOHU :ROIJDQJ 5 Å'DV 5HFKW DXI 0HQVFKHQUHFKWH´ LQ 5HFKW DXI0HQVFKHQUHFKWH0HQVFKHQUHFKWH'HPRNUDWLHXQGLQWHUQDWLRQDOH3ROLWLN KJ Y +DXNH %UXQNKRUVW :ROIJDQJ 5 .|KOHU 0DWWKLDV /XW] %DFKPDQQ)UDQNIXUW0 .RQKDUGW .ODXV Å)DNWXP GHU 9HUQXQIW" =X .DQWV )UDJH QDFK GHP ÄHLJHQWOLFKHQ 6HOEVW¶ GHV 0HQVFKHQ´ LQ +DQGOXQJVWKHRULH XQG 7UDQV]HQGHQWDOSKLORVRSKLHKJY*HUROG3UDXVV)UDQNIXUW0 .RUVJDDUG&KULVWLQH0 D &UHDWLQJWKH.LQJGRPRI(QGV&DPEULGJH .RUVJDDUG&KULVWLQH0 E 7KH6RXUFHVRI1RUPDWLYLW\&DPEULGJH .RUVJDDUG &KULVWLQH 0 Å7KH 1RUPDWLYLW\ RI ,QVWUXPHQWDO 5HD VRQ´LQ (WKLFVDQG3UDFWLFDO5HDVRQKJY*DUUHWW&XOOLW\XQG%HU\V *DXW2[IRUG .RUVJDDUG &KULVWLQH 0 6HOI&RQVWLWXWLRQ $JHQF\ ,GHQWLW\ DQG ,QWHJ ULW\2[IRUG .XHKQ0DQIUHG 0V Å,V.DQW·V(WKLFVD7\SHRI9LUWXH(WKLFV"´ .XKQ7KRPDV6 'LH6WUXNWXUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHU5HYROXWLRQHQ$XIO )UDQNIXUW 2ULJLQDO 7KH 6WUXFWXUH RI 6FLHQWLILF 5HYROXWLRQV &KLFDJR .XVVHU$QQD Å=ZHL6WXIHQ7KHRULHXQGSUDNWLVFKHhEHUOHJXQJ´ LQ $XWRQRPHV+DQGHOQ%HLWUlJH]XU3KLORVRSKLHYRQ+DUU\*)UDQNIXUW KJY0RQLND%HW]OHUXQG%DUEDUD*XFNHV%HUOLQ /DIRQW &ULVWLQD D Å+RZ &RJQLWLYLVW LV 'LVFRXUVH (WKLFV´ LQ 1L TXHW 0DUFHO +J 'LVNXUVHWKLN *UXQGOHJXQJHQ XQG $QZHQGXQJHQ :U]EXUJ /DIRQW &ULVWLQD E Å,VW 2EMHNWLYLWlW SHUVSHNWLYLVFK" (LQ 9HUJOHLFK ]ZLVFKHQ %UDQGRPV XQG +DEHUPDV· .RQ]HSWLRQ YRQ 2EMHNWLYL WlW´LQ 'LHgIIHQWOLFKNHLWGHU9HUQXQIWXQGGLH9HUQXQIWGHUgIIHQWOLFK NHLW)HVWVFKULIWIU-UJHQ+DEHUPDVKJY/XW]:LQJHUWXQG.ODXV *QWKHU)UDQNIXUW0
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%LEOLRJUDSKLH
/DIRQW&ULVWLQD Å5HDOLVPXVXQG.RQVWUXNWLYLVPXVLQGHUNDQWLDQL VFKHQ0RUDOSKLORVRSKLH²GDV%HLVSLHOGHU'LVNXUVHWKLN´LQ 'HXW VFKH=HLWVFKULIWIU3KLORVRSKLH /DQFH 0DUN Å7KH 6LJQLILFDQFH RI $QDSKRULF 7KHRULHV RI 7UXWK DQG 5HIHUHQFH´ LQ 7UXWK KJ Y (QULTXH 9LOODQXHYD 3KLORVRSKLFDO ,VVXHV /DXHQHU +HQUL Å'HU V\VWHPDWLVFKH 6WHOOHQZHUW GHV *HIKOV GHU $FKWXQJLQ.DQWV(WKLN´LQ 'LDOHFWLFD /HH0LQJ+XHL 'DV3UREOHPGHVPRUDOLVFKHQ*HIKOVLQGHU(QWZLFNOXQJ GHU.DQWLVFKHQ(WKLN%RQQ 8QLY'LVV /HLVW $QWRQ Å6HOEVWELQGXQJ PLW RGHU JHJHQ 8QLYHUVDOLWlW´ LQ (UZlJHQ:LVVHQ(WKLN /HZLV'DYLG. Å6FRUHNHHSLQJLQD/DQJXDJH*DPH´LQ -RXUQDORI 3KLORVRSKLFDO/RJLF /LSWRZ -DVSHU %HUWUDP *HRUJ : Å=X HLQHU DQWLGXDOLVWLVFKHQ 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQVSUDFKOLFKHU%HGHXWXQJ 5REHUW%%UDQGRPXQG :LOIULG6HOODUV´LQ 3KLORVRSKLVFKH5XQGVFKDX /|KUHU*XLGR Å.DQWV3UREOHPHLQHU1RUPDWLYLWlWDXVUHLQHU9HU QXQIW´ LQ 1RUPDWLYLWlW XQG )DNWL]LWlW 6NHSWLVFKH XQG WUDQV]HQGHQ WDOSKLORVRSKLVFKH 3RVLWLRQHQ LP $QVFKOX DQ .DQW KJ Y *HUKDUG 6FK|QULFK'UHVGHQ /RUHQ]HQ3DXO 1RUPDWLYH/RJLFDQG(WKLFV0DQQKHLP /XEDQ'DYLG /DZ\HUVDQG-XVWLFH $Q(WKLFDO6WXG\3ULQFHWRQ /XGZLJ%HUQG Å:DUXPHVNHLQHÄK\SRWKHWLVFKHQ,PSHUDWLYH¶JLEW XQGZDUXP.DQWVK\SRWKHWLVFKJHELHWHQGH,PSHUDWLYHNHLQHDQD O\WLVFKHQ 6lW]H VLQG´ LQ $XINOlUXQJ XQG ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ 6WXGLHQ ]X .DQWV 3KLORVRSKLH XQG LKUHP 8PNUHLV KJ Y +HLQHU ) .OHPPH %HUQG/XGZLJ0LFKDHO3DXHQXQG:HUQHU6WDUN:U]EXUJ 0DFEHWK 'DQLHOOH Å%UDQGRP RQ ,QIHUHQFH DQG WKH ([SUHVVLYH 5ROH RI /RJLF´ LQ 7UXWK KJ Y (QULTXH 9LOODQXHYD 3KLORVRSKLFDO ,VVXHV 0F&DUW\5LFKDUG Å0RWLYDWLRQDQG0RUDO&KRLFHLQ.DQW·V7KHRU\ RI5DWLRQDO$JHQF\´LQ .DQW6WXGLHQ 0D\HU9HUHQD Å6HOEVWELQGXQJZR]X"´LQ (UZlJHQ:LVVHQ(WKLN 0F'RZHOO-RKQ Å%UDQGRPRQ5HSUHVHQWDWLRQDQG,QIHUHQFH´LQ 3KLORVRSK\DQG3KHQRPHQRORJLFDO5HVHDUFK 0HOH$OIUHG5 Å'LVFXVVLRQ²9HOOHPDQRQ$FWLRQDQG$JHQF\µ LQ 3KLORVRSKLFDO6WXGLHV 0LFKDHO%HUQG -RKDQQHV%XULGDQ6WXGLHQ]XVHLQHP/HEHQVHLQHQ:HU NHQXQG]XU5H]HSWLRQVHLQHU7KHRULHQLP(XURSDGHVVSlWHQ0LWWHODOWHUV 8QLY'LVV%HUOLQ 0LOOJUDP (OLMDK Å&RKHUHQFH 7KH 3ULFH RI WKH 7LFNHWµ LQ 7KH -RXUQDORI3KLORVRSK\
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%LEOLRJUDSKLH
0LVJHOG'LHWHU $UWLNHOÅ$FKWXQJ´LQ 5LWWHU-RDFKLP*UQGHU .DUOIULHG +LVWRULVFKHV:|UWHUEXFKGHU3KLORVRSKLH%G%DVHO 1DJHO7KRPDV 7KH9LHZIURP1RZKHUH2[IRUG 1DJHO7KRPDV 'LH0|JOLFKNHLWGHV$OWUXLVPXV%RGHQKHLP>2ULJLQDO 7KH3RVVLELOLW\RI$OWUXLVP2[IRUG @ 1HLPDQ6XVDQ 7KH8QLW\RI5HDVRQ5HUHDGLQJ.DQW2[IRUG 1LGD5PHOLQ -XOLDQ Å3UDFWLFDO 5HDVRQ RU 0HWDSUHIHUHQFHV" $Q 8QGRJPDWLF'HIHQVHRI.DQWLDQ0RUDOLW\´LQ 7KHRU\DQG'HFLVLRQ 1LGD5PHOLQ-XOLDQ +J 3UDNWLVFKH5DWLRQDOLWlW*UXQGODJHQSUREOHPH XQGHWKLVFKH$QZHQGXQJHQGHVUDWLRQDOFKRLFH3DUDGLJPDV%HUOLQ 1LGD5PHOLQ-XOLDQ Å$QJHPHVVHQKHLWDOVSUDNWLVFKH.RKlUHQ]´ LQ $QJHPHVVHQKHLW =XU 5HKDELOLWLHUXQJ HLQHU SKLORVRSKLVFKHQ 0HWDSKHU KJY%DUEDUD0HUNHU*HRUJ0RKUXQG/XGZLJ6LHS:U]EXUJ 1LGD5PHOLQ-XOLDQ 6WUXNWXUHOOH5DWLRQDOLWlW(LQSKLORVRSKLVFKHU(VVD\ EHUSUDNWLVFKH9HUQXQIW6WXWWJDUW 1LGD5PHOLQ-XOLDQ (WKLVFKH(VVD\V)UDQNIXUW0 1LHOVHQ.DL Å1RFK(LQPDO :DUXPVROOLFKPRUDOLVFKVHLQ"´LQ :DUXPPRUDOLVFKVHLQ"KJY.XUW%D\HUW]3DGHUERUQ 1LTXHW0DUFHO 1LFKWKLQWHUJHKEDUNHLWXQG'LVNXUV3UROHJRPHQD]XHLQHU 'LVNXUVWKHRULHGHV7UDQV]HQGHQWDOHQ%HUOLQ 1R]LFN 5REHUW 7KH 1RUPDWLYH 7KHRU\ RI ,QGLYLGXDO &KRLFH >2ULJ @1HZ2ULJLQDO @ 7LHW]8GR Å1RUPHQ5HJHOQXQG,QWHUSUHWDWLRQHQ5REHUW%UDQ GRPV 3URMHNW HLQHU SUDJPDWLVFKHQ 7KHRULH GHU 5DWLRQDOLWlW´ LQ =HLWVFKULIWIUSKLORVRSKLVFKH)RUVFKXQJ 7LPPHUPDQQ-HQV 6LWWHQJHVHW]XQG)UHLKHLW8QWHUVXFKXQJHQ]X,PPD QXHO.DQWV7KHRULHGHVIUHLHQ:LOOHQV%HUOLQ 7XJHQGKDW(UQVW 3UREOHPHGHU(WKLN6WXWWJDUW 9HOOHPDQ-'DYLG 7KH3RVVLELOLW\RI3UDFWLFDO5HDVRQ2[IRUG 9HOOHPDQ-'DYLG D Å3UpFLVRI7KH3RVVLELOLW\RI3UDFWLFDO5HDVRQµLQ 3KLORVRSKLFDO6WXGLHV 9HOOHPDQ - 'DYLG E Å5HSOLHV WR 'LVFXVVLRQ RQ 7KH 3RVVLELOLW\ RI 3UDFWLFDO5HDVRQLQ 3KLORVRSKLFDO6WXGLHV 9HOOHPDQ-'DYLG F Å:KDW*RRGLVD:LOO"µLQ $FWLRQLQ&RQWH[W KJY$QWRQ/HLVW%HUOLQ 9RVVHQNXKO:LOKHOP Å)UHLKHLW]XKDQGHOQ$QDO\WLVFKHXQGWUDQV ]HQGHQWDOH $UJXPHQWH IU HLQH NDXVDOH +DQGOXQJVWKHRULH´ LQ 3ULQ]LS )UHLKHLW (LQH $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ XP &KDQFHQ XQG *UHQ]HQ WUDQV]HQGHQWDOSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ 'HQNHQV KJ Y +DQV 0LFKDHO %DXP JDUWQHU)UHLEXUJ 9RVVHQNXKO :LOKHOP Å)UHH $JHQF\ $ 1RQ5HGXFWLRQLVW &DXVDO $FFRXQW´LQ *UD]HU3KLORVRSKLVFKH6WXGLHQ :DOODFH 5 -D\ 5HVSRQVLELOLW\ DQG WKH 0RUDO 6HQWLPHQWV &DP EULGJH0DVV :DOODFH5-D\ Å5HDVRQDQG5HVSRQVLELOLW\´LQ (WKLFVDQG3UDFWLFDO 5HDVRQKJY*DUUHWW&XOOLW\XQG%HU\V*DXW2[IRUG :DOODFH 5 -D\ Å1RUPDWLYLW\ &RPPLWPHQW DQG ,QVWUXPHQWDO 5HDVRQµLQ 3KLORVRSKHU·V,PSULQW
Unauthenticated Download Date | 4/21/16 3:39 PM
%LEOLRJUDSKLH
:DOODFH5-D\ 0V Å'HRQWLF6WUXFWXUH´XQYHU|IIHQWOLFKWHV0DQX VNULSW :DO]HU 0LFKDHO 6SKlUHQ GHU *HUHFKWLJNHLW (LQ 3OlGR\HU IU 3OXUDOLWlW XQG*OHLFKKHLW)UDQNIXUW0>HQJO2ULJLQDO 6SKHUHVRI-XVWLFH$'H IHQVHRI3OXUDOLVPDQG(TXDOLW\1HZ