Li Ta-chao and the origins of Chinese Marxism 9780674180819

Table of contents :
Frontmatter
INTRODUCTION (page xiii)
CHRONOLOGY (page xviii)
Part One: The Origins of a Chinese Marxist
I THE EARLY YEARS (page 1)
II PRELUDE TO REVOLUTION (page 29)
III THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION AND THE INTRODUCTION OF MARXISM (page 52)
IV THE POPULIST STRAIN (page 71)
V MARXISM AND THE MAY FOURTH MOVEMENT (page 90)
Part Two: The Reinterpretation of Marxism
VI DETERMINISM AND ACTIVISM (page 125)
VII PHILOSOPHY OF HISTORY (page 155)
VIII NATIONALISM AND INTERNATIONALISM (page 176)
Part Three: Politics
IX LENINISM AND POPULISM (page 197)
X NATIONAL REVOLUTION (page 210)
XI PEASANT REVOLUTION (page 234)
EPILOGUE (page 257)
NOTES (page 269)
BIBLIOGRAPHY (page 299)
GLOSSARY (page 315)
INDEX (page 319)

Citation preview

LI TA-CHAO AND THE ORIGINS OF CHINESE MARXISM | Harvard East Asian Series 27 The East Asian Research Center at Harvard University administers research projects designed to further scholarly understanding of China, Korea, Japan, and adjacent areas.

BLANK PAGE

BLANK PAGE

FR ee SR .

ESE eReAgNy RESaRO Sa hey Fee a NR Sein ole Oe an ES . ont eed eaatea ne eR ead RL FpPres SEecient EESTI RERenae NNN Te eteet SET

PS: ee So o 7 TSaaa SESS EET GED OLE EE ME EO FePee peaEs ae ogni aegenDRE aetna CORSET DEAeoft

Foe a BOER EE IEEE Pn eeger eag etptaNe eo OM ace eeIDOE ON ETEEE LCE SESS EES SEcst segSES gl OSES SEE AeER PaisOe age eas . .

LEI RIES SRLSSOS IES ROR a SLA SNLESD RRO he SEO SRNSAO SanRR eRER ORR ESS RE OeShaa. .

eee Ly SEI ROR ence CORRS SEMI RL Dh af So SER ERE SS.: 3EEE eeOeLEE Spies LELO EUS RaeREE i aniline JER EB SLE SEESID ETRE Recess RGR NG TESS - Oe . PORIASS LILES ALIENBRIE ASS SLOPED PIsTene MRToCER Re nn

3 OES ee ee Ree Rene aoeRe eR PESEE” eSa ne BEE EEeen ESS ::a“SEE er :. FE See mee CEES Bec oon arent SNL eons SEER acmmgitaia, .oR ey Ba SRE eee aa aeEO Py asrr. . :.

At Ar2x% 69 2f 34> (Discussions concerning socialism); She-hui chu-i t'ao lun chi

At x BM at sey 4. (A collection of discussions on socialism), pp. 32-73. ~ Canton: Hsin-ch'ing-nien she, 1922, ----~ Tu-hsiu wen-ts ‘un x 4) Fe mK 5. (The collected works of Ch'en |

Tu-hsiu). 4 vols.; Shanghai: Ya-tung t'u-shu-kuan, 1922, _

-----"Chung-kuo nung-min wen-t!i"' 7 @B Te A, Pe AR (The Chinese peasant question); Ch'ien-feng Al BE (Vanguard),

No. 1:51-57 (1923). | a

~----"Chung~kuo kuo-min ko-ming yti she-hui ko-chieh-chi" 7 &

A, ei op 5 Ft BA ps 4& —s (The Chinese national revolution and the various social classes); Chung-kuo ko-ming

; wen-t'i Jun-wen chi ¥ &) % oe Fol 7a Ha XH. (A collection of articles on problems of the Chinese revolution), pp. 33-50.

Shanghai: Hsin-ching-nien she, 1927. , -~----Kao ch'tian-tang t'ung~—chih shu x oa ce a 2; z (A letter

to all party comrades). Shanghai, 1929. , -----Ch'en Tu~hsiu tsui-hou tui-yti min-chu cheng-chih ti chien-chieh

300, , _ | ,

RID A RA Tt OB eos 64 DL AA Chien

Tu-hsiu's last views on democracy). Hong Kong: Tzu-yu Chungkuo she, 1949.

Chia Chih at y - "Li Ta-chao t'ung-chih erh-san-shih"' A KI aes s ¥ (A few things about Comrade Li Ta-chao); Hsin kuan-ch'a a aR IR (New observer; July 1, 1956), pp. 36-37.

-----"Li Ta-chao t'ung-chih ti ku-shih" a K B'} Fi] Z 64) o& E _ (The story of Comrade Li Ta~chao); Chung-kuo ch'ing-nien sf

@) - +4 (Chinese youth), No. 8:9-12 (1957). -----"Li Ta-chao t'ung-chih chan-tou ti i-sheng" & KA '| fa) 2. $y +t oe) — of (Comrade Li Ta-chao's life of struggle); Kuang—hui ti wu-ssu x Ag &*) 2. WZ (The glorious May Fourth),

pp. 29-46. Peking: Chung-kuo ch'ing-nien ch'u-pan she, 1959.

| Chih-shen 4-4 (Chu Chih-hsin R 3A, 4% ). "Te-i-chih she~hui ko-ming-chia hsiao-chuan" 4B. z. 3 4a. A & ay WK r) 4% (Short biographies of German social revolutionaries); Min-pao

(June 1906). |

x aR (People's paper), No. 2:1-17 (January 1906)and No. 3:1-20

Ch'in Te-chun A 4B. # . “Hui-i Li Ta-chao, Teng Chung~-hsia, Yiin

“Tai-ying san t'ung-chih" fe) 1& % K 4, Xf i A 1B 44 $b. [a] &,. (Memories of Comrades Li Ta-chao, Teng Chung-~hsia, and YUn Tai-ying); Hsin kuan-ch'a (Sept. 15, 1956), pp. 9-11.

Chow Tse-tsung. The May Fourth Movement. Cambridge, Mass.:

Harvard University Press, 1960. |

Chu Chih-hsin, see Chih-shen. , : Chu Wu-shan KES. "Hui-i Shou~ch'ang t'ung-chih" re) t u a @ (a) Zs: (Memories of Comrade Shou-ch'ang); Jen-min jih-pao

| A. FKL @ F& (People's daily; Apr. 29, 1957), p. 2. Ch'ti Ch'iu-pai i FRA . Chung-kuo ko-ming chung chih cheng-lun

wen-t'i 7 Bs oe Zz 2 Say f | AR (Controversial problems of the Chinese revolution). Shanghai, 1927. | 301

-----"Hsien-tai Chung-kuo ti kuo-hui-chih yt chtin-fa" 3% 4* ? BS)

») Ae 4] 45 @ Bs (The parliamentary system of contemporary China and the warlords); Chung-kuo ko-ming

wen-t'i lun-wen chi ? ay # op Po Aa Say K (A collection of articles on problems of the Chinese revolution),

pp. 439-467. Shanghai: Hsin ch'ing-nien she, 1927. --~-- "Chung~kuo ko-ming ho nung-min yltin-tung ti ts'e-ltieh" si i)

3 opr Ao RR A §é af @4 mR #& (The Chinese revolution and the strategy of the peasant movement); Pu-erh~sai-wei~k'e

Ap 3. R ME A, (The Bolshevik), 3.4-5:111-149 (May 15, 1930).

Deutscher, Isaac. The Prophet Armed. London: Oxford University Press, 1954. Dunayevskaya, Raya. Marxism and Freedom. New York, 1958. Eto Shinkichi. "Hai-lu-feng: The First Chinese Soviet Government, "' The China Quarterly, No. 8:160-183 (October-December 1961); and No. 9:149-181 (January-March 1962).

Fang Lu 3% 2B. . "Ch'ing-suan Ch'en Tu-hsiu" 4 2 PR 18) Fi (Liquidating Ch'en Tu-hsiu); Ch'en Tu-hsiu p'ing-lun [ R AB) fs

34+ 4 (Critical discussions of Ch'en Tu-hsiu), pp. 67-71.

Peking, 1933. , Garushiants, Iu. M. "Bor'ba Kitaiskikh Marksistov za sozdanie Kommunisticheskoi Partii Kitaia" (The struggle of the Chinese

(1961).

Marxists for the foundation of the Chinese Communist party); Narody Azii i Afriki (Peoples of Asia and Africa), No. 3:81-96

302 |

Haimson, Leopold H. The Russian Marxists and the Origins of

Bolshevism. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, |

: 1955.

Ho Hui 44] z - "Kuang~jung ti i-sheng: Li Ta-chao t'ung-chih ko-ming

shih-chi chien-chieh" 2 na 6) - = — B A ) f) & #. ap $ taf Fal sy (A glorious life: A brief introduction to the revolutionary work of Comrade Li Ta-chao); Kung-jen jih-pao

x A @ 4k (workers! daily; Apr. 27, 1957), p. 3. _ Hsi-wu lao-jen KE FB Z€ AL. "Hui-i Li Ta-chao t'ung—-chih" ra Tl & A 4s) [3] a; (Memories of Comrade Li Ta-chao); Chung-kuo kung-jen - jk) Z A (The Chinese worker), No. 9:21-23 (May 1957).

Hsia Chia RAhe . ''Pei-ching-ta-hstieh ti Mao chu-hsi ho Li Ta-chao

t'ung chih chi-nien-shih" Jt WAH 4) £E Tt #e zi K S| ja) & 4b Ly =e (The Peking University memorial room for Chairman Mao and Comrade Li Ta-chao); Ch'ang-chiang jih-pao

& 5x. € +h (June 29, 1951), p. 4. Hsiao YU (Siao YU). Mao Tse-tung andI Were Beggars. Syracuse, 1959.

Hu Shih $f if . Hu Shih wen-ts tun $F] iB} X 4 (Collected essays of Hu Shih). 4 vols.; Shanghai: Ya-tung t'u-shu-kuan, 1926.

~~--- Hu Shih wen-ts'un san-chi #f Nc] K i, 2. 4g. (The third collection of the essays of Hu Shih). 4 vols.; Shanghai: Ya-tung t'u-shu-kuan, 1930.

Hua Kang x# Fa . Wu-ssu ytin-tung shih A LB BY gv (History of the May Fourth Movement). Shanghai, 1951.

Hua Ying-shen # Fg. @ , ed. Chung-kuo Kung-ch'an-tang lieh~shih

chuan f & KA HR FIs {$ (Biographies of heroes of the Chinese Communist party). Hong Kong, 1949. Huang Ho $ +4]. Chung-kuo Kung-ch'an-tang san-shih-wu-nien

chien-shih f &) % 7 K STB FF Pe Qo (A brief history of thirty-five years of the Chinese Communist

party). Peking, 1957. 303

Hughes, H. Stuart. Consciousness and Society. New York, 1958. Isaacs, Harold R. The Tragedy of the Chinese Revolution. Stanford:

Stanford University Press, 1951. | Jung Meng-ytian a Qe iB . "Hsin-hai ko-ming ch'ien Chung-kuo

shu-k'an shang tui Ma-k'o-ssu chu-i ti chieh-shao" 4 % ¥ oe ,

# 7 Bl ze #1 LE x4 BE ELH i» 42 (The introduction

(1953). : ,

of Marxism in Chinese publications before the revolution of

1911); Hsin chien-she ay @ 3h (New reconstruction), No. 3_

Kao Chiian-p'u cs A and Chang Ch'i-chih aa 32. "Wu-ssu , shih-ch'i Li Ta-chao t'ung-chih fan-tui tzu-ch'an chieh-chi

kai-leng chu-i ti tou-cheng"' hh ww ay BAS KA fa} 25 In xq

eh ja. pet 4B PL RSX +f 2 (Comrade Li Ta-chao's struggle against bourgeois reformism in the May Fourth period);

| Li-shih yen-chiu, No. 6:19-32 (1959). _ | Dc -----"Wu-ssu ylin-tung ch'i-chien Li Ta-chao ti Ma-k'o-ssu chu-i

hstian-ch'uan ytin-tung" hw in ap FP Fal & KA! a4) & x, iB. Emp 3 1s ‘% 47) (Li Ta-chao's propagation of Marxism during

the period of the May Fourth Movement); Li-shih chiao-hstieh Fi LAF (Historical education; May 1959), pp. 5-10. Kao I 3 Ad. tT tan hsien-lieh Li Ta~chao t'ung-chih ti i-wen" 7 R a Hl % K 4] fa) 2 6] 3% “ F. # 44 (e) +, (Memories of sixteen years ago); in Hua Ying-shen

# ia. y , ed., Chung-kuo Kung-ch'an-tang lieh-shih chuan

- &) cin jh R, wl + AZ (Biographies of heroes of the Chinese Communist party), pp. 10-16. Hong Kong, 1949. --—--—"J-nien" 3. A> (Thoughts); Chiao-shih~pao AB bp HR (Teachers'

news; Apr. 23, 1957), p. 4.

~---~"Hui-i wo-ti fu-chin Li Ta-chao fe} te A a) oe #. A K4 ] (Memories of my father, Li Ta-chao); Chung-kuo ch'ing-nien, No. 8:19-25 (1959).

| Li Jui LA 44,. Mao Tse-tung t'ung-chih ti chu-ch'i ko-ming huo-tung

4, if H. fe) 2; 09 4n FA x ae i$ 27] \(The early revolutionary activities of Comrade Mao Tse-tung). Peking: Chung-

kuo ch'ing-nien ch'u-pan she, 1957. | Li Lung-mu &. He ak. "Li Ta-chao t'ung-chih ho wu-ssu shih-ch'i Ma-k'o-ssu chu-i ssu-hsiang ti hsfian-ch'uan" 5 K i | [=] A>

AORM a Hq HR BEX SE 1 0d SAB (Comrade Li Ta-chao and the propagation of Marxism during the May Fourth period); Li-shih yen-chiu, No. 5:1-18 (1957).

Li Ta-chao 3 K4'] . “Hsin-te chiu-te" #f 49 19 #9) (The new and the old); Hsin ch'ing-nien, 4. 5:446-449., ~----'' Jen-chung wen-t!it_A 49 fel xa (The race question); Hsin min-kuo

tsa-chih ¥f B) K A 324; (New republic magazine), 1.6:1-8. -----"An-sha yti chiin-te" ee) FR FA hs he. (Assassination and social morality); Yen-chih % :4 (Statesman), No. 2:97~99 (May 1, 1913).

----—'"J-ylian-chih yli erh-ytian-chih"' — ee 4 4 > FR. §'| (Unicameralism and bicameralism); Yen-chih, No. 4:53-57 (Sept. 1, 1913).

| ~----"Tun kuan-liao chu-i 32> eS 1& + SX (On bureaucracy); Yen-chih, ~ No. 4:17-20(Sept. 1, 1913). 306

--~--"Shih-fei-p'ien" z At ye (Essay on right and wrong); Yen-chih, No. 4:71-73 (ept. 1, 1913).

~----"Ytian-sha: an-sha ytt tzu-sha" Je AX — ag AR FA #) AX (Death: Assassination and suicide), Yen-chih, No. 4:11-16 (Sept. 1, 1913).

-~-~-~—''Feng-su "BAR (Customs); Chia-yin tsa-chih, Vol. 1, No. 3

(Summer 1914).

-----"Ch'ing-ch'un" ¥ A (Spring); Hsin ch'ing-nien, 2.1:1-12 (Sept. 1. 1916). English tr. by Yang Hsien-yi and Gladys Yang, in Chinese Literature (May 1959), pp. 11-18.

_----"Ch'ing-nien yi lao-jen" 4 -F 5 4% A. (youth and old people); Hsin ch'ing-nien, 3,.2:1-4 (Apr. 1, 1917).

--~--"'Pao-li yti cheng-chih" & t 4 F456 (Violence and politics); T'ai-p'ing yang A -$ 5¥# (Pacific ocean), 1.7:1-12 (Oct. 15, 1917).

-----"Chin" 4> (Now); Hsin ch'ing-nien, 4.4:307-310 (Apr. 15, 1918). -----"Bolshevism ti sheng-li" 44 4% #| (The victory of Bolshevism); Hsin ch'ing-nien, 5. 5:442-448 (Oct. 15, 1918). -----"Shu-min ti sheng-li"' Pe. A a4) Ald F'| (Victory of the masses); Hsin ch'ing-nien, 5. 5:436-438 (Oct. 15, 1918). ~-—--''Huan-ying Tu-hsiu ch'u-yti" wk itp ok) Z, ih 2X (Welcoming Ch'en Tu-hsiu on his release from prison); Hsin ch'ing—nien, 6. 6:588 (Nov. 1, 1919).

-----'"Wo ti Ma-k'o-ssu chu-i kuan" K 8) A, B, a BX oe | (My Marxist views), Pt. 1; Hsin ch'ing nien, 6. 5:521--537 (May

1919); Pt. 2, ibid. , 6.6:612-624 (November 1919). | ----—"Ch'ing-nien yen-shih tzu-sha wen-t!i"' 4 # JéK +r B AX Pa AG (The problem of pessimism and suicide among youth); Hsin ch'ao 4f 4A (New tide), 2.2:351-356 (Dec. 1, 1919).

307

-----"Yu ching-chi shang chieh-shih Chung-kuo chin-tai ssu-hsiang

pien-tung ti ylian-yin' & 4% sie aK AA 4G P A) Ay 2 AB. & ah 6) /& fk) (An economic explanation of the changes

(Jan. 1, 1920).

in modern Chinese thought); Hsin ch'ing-nien, 7. 2:47-53

~----'Wu-i ytin-tung shih" Dh —- ih 4 gL (The history of May Day);

Hsin ch'ing-nien, 7.6:1-13 (May 1, 1920). | --~--"Q-lo-ssu ko—ming ti kuo-ch'ti ho hsien-tsai"' 4 % By 2 a 9°) if & 4o 24, Hs. (The past and present of the Russian revolution}; Hsin ch'ing-nien, Vol. 9, No. 3 (July 1, 1921); photo-reproduction copy, 9. 3:375~394.,

-----—"TLun tzu-sha" za # FR (On suicide); Hstieh-i tsa-chih es % # z; (Scholarship and art magazine), 3. 8:1-20 (February 1922). -----P'ing—-min chu-i +. K HM (Democracy). Shanghai: Shang-wu yin-shu kuan, 1923.

---~-"P'u-pien ch'tian-kuo ti Kuo~min-tang" b vy em Bi) A A F (The Kuomintang which spread throughout the country); Hsiang-

tao chou~pao v (9) i fz) +f (Guide weekly), No. 21:154-155

(Apr. 18, 1923), -----"K'ung-tao-hsi ti li-shih kuan" 4 L wl] wh 8‘) Fee x a (The historical view of Condorcet); She-hui k'o-hstieh yleh-k'an #4. yx 44, Ze Fl +1] (Social science quarterly), 2.1:59-66 (November

1923). ,

-~--—-Shih-hstieh yao—lun Eq zg BR 3 (The essentials of historical

study). Shanghai: Shang-wu yin-shu kuan, 1924. | _-----Shou-ch'ang wen~chi of “4 K & (Collected writings of Shou-ch'ang). Shanghai, 1950.

-----Li Ta-chao hstian-chi B. K 4 ik pa (Selected writings of Li

Ta-chao). Peking: Jen-min ch'u-pan she, 1959. Lichtheim, George. Marxism: An Historical and Critical Study. New York, 1961.

308

Liu Ching-chtin %°| ae A. "Chi-i-li ti Li Shou-ch'ang hsien-sheng"

abt TL P ay # ef “h x. 1B. (In memory of Mr. Li Shou-ch'ang); Jen-min jih-pao (May 7, 1957), p. 8.

Liu Li-k'ai x'] % WU and Wang Chen + rl . 1919-1927-nien ti Chungkuo kung-jen ylin-tung 1919-1927 $64 f Bl HAZ 47) (The Chinese Workers'Movement from 1919-1927). Peking: Kung-jen .

ch'u-pan she, 1957.

Liu Yeh 3| 4g . "Li Ta-=chao i-wen 'Tzu-jih' k'ao" Za KF'| G2 X “th a” #z (Notes on the article ''This Day" by Li Ta-chao); Li-~shih yen-chiu, No. 1:98 (1957).

Lo Chia-lun a Vey . "Chin-jih chih shih-chieh hsin-ch'ao" — AB = te RA SHA (rhe new tide of today's world); Hsin-ch'ao,

Vol. 1, No. 1 (January 1919). , Lowith, Karl. "Man's Self-Alienation in the Early Writings of Marx,"

Social Research, 21. 2:204-230 (Summer 1954). , Lu Hstin. Selected Works of Lu Hstin. 4 vols.; Peking: Foreign Languages Press, 1956. LU Chien §% Mea . Li Ta-chao ho Ch't Ch'iu-pai ZA AA u $0 eg $KO (Li Ta-chao and Ch'ti Ch'iu-pai). Shanghai, 1951.

Mannheim, Karl. Ideology and Utopia. New York: Harcourt, Brace and Co., and London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, Ltd. , 1952.

Mao Tse-tung #, 1Z R . Mao Tse-tung hstian-chi $, IF RAB (Selected works of Mao Tse-tung). 4 vols.; Peking: Jen-min ch'u-

pan she, 1960. , | Marcuse, Herbert. Reason and Revolution. New York, 1954. Marx, Karl. "Revolution in China and Europe, ' New York Tribune

(June 14, 1853), p. 4. |

----~-Capital. 3 vols.; Chicago: Kerr, 1912. | , 309

----- The Eighteenth Brumaireof Louis Bonaparte. Chicago, 1919. -~---Selected Writings in Sociology and Social Philosophy, ed. T. B. Bottomore and Maximilian Rubel. London: Watts, 1956.

-~--~!''Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts," tr. T.B. Bottomore, in Erich Fromm, Marx's Concept of Man. New York, 1961.

Marx, Karl and Frederick Engels. The German Ideology. New York: International Publishers, 1939 and 1947. ~~-=-=The Russian Menace to Europe, ed. Paul Blackstock and Bert

Hoselitz. Glencoe, Illinois: Free Press, 1952. -----Selected Correspondence. Moscow: Foreign Languages’ Publishing House, 1953.

-----Ma-k'o-ssu En-ke-ssu lun Chung-kuo § 4 2 B. #& By 3 {&) (Marx and Engels on China). Peking: Jen-min ch'u-pan she, 1957.

--~--Werke, Vols. 1 and 4. Berlin: Dietz, 1957. ~----Selected Works. 2 vols.; Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House, 1958.

Michel, Robert. First Lectures in Political Sociology. Minneapolis, 1949,

North China Star. Tientsin, Apr. 25, 1931. P'eng Ming ry ®f]. '"Wu-ssu shih-ch'i ti Li Ta-chao ho Ch'en Tu-hsiu"

2Aw at BA a4 4 K 4'| Fe [RIG Fr (Li Ta-chao and Ch'en Tu-hsiu in the May Fourth period); Li-shih yen-chiu,

No. 6:47-68 (1962). | Pling Hsin -F 6S. = "Lun Wu-ssu ylin-tung ch'ien-hou Li Ta-chao

ssu-hsiang ti fa-chan" ey Lh Oise a al ja z3 K #'| 2. #8. a’) R ie (On the development of Li Ta-chao's thought before and after the May Fourth Movement); Li-shih chiao-hstieh wen t'i

310

fit 2 FX F Fl 4G (Problems of historical education), No. 4:13-17 and No. 5:10-16 (1959).

Plekhanov, George. Fundamental Problems of Marxism. New York: International Publishers, 1930. ----~Selected Philosophical Works. 2 vols.; Moscow, n.d.

and Unwin, 1922. ,

Russell, Bertrand. The Problem of China. London: George Allen

Satoi Hikoshichiro ¥ Hf % « BA . "Ri Taisho no shuppatsu,

Genji ki no seiron o chushin ni" 4% K 4) | D Fe —

‘3 34" FA o EX 2 EPO (The departure of Li Ta-chao, with emphasis on the political writings of the Statesman period); Shirin ¥ #4 (History), 40.3:1-39 (May 1957).

| Scalapino, Robert and George Yu. Chinese Anarchism. Berkeley: Center for Chinese Studies of the University of California, 1961.

1963. ,

Schram, Stuart R. The Political Thought of Mao Tse-tung. New York, Schwartz, BenjaminI. '"Ch'en Tu-hsiu and the Acceptance of the Modern West, '' Journal of the History of Ideas, 12. 1:61~-74 (January 1951).

-----Chinese Communism and the Rise of Mao. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1952. -----''The Intelligentsia in Communist China, a Tentative Comparison," Daedalus (Summer 1960), pp. 604-621.

-----In Search of Wealth and Power: Yen Fu and the West. | Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1964.

She-hui chu-i t'ao-lun chi #4 . Es K zt Bey 4 (A collection of discussions on socialism). Hsin ch'ing-nien she ay 5 At (New youth society), ed. Canton: Hsin ch'ing-nien she, 1922.

311

Shen Ytin-lung 37% p4 ae. Chung-kuo Kung~ch'an-tang chih lai-ytlan

7 Bi) 3 K Z R 3. (The origin of the Chinese Communist party). Taipei: Min-chu ch'ao she, 1959. Shih Tstin & Lie ed. Chung-kuo chin-tai ssu-hsiang-shih ts'an-k'ao

tzu-liao chien-pien f Bl th AV & 7B 2 HA 4B ¥ #4 fi 4p (Source materials for the study of the history of modern Chinese

thought). Peking: San-lien, 1957. , Snow, Edgar. Red Star Over China. New York: Random House, 1938.

T'an Pi-an 38 AR BS . "O-kuo min-ts'ui chu-i tui T'ung-meng-hui

ti ying-hsiang" 14 MAZ# 2 Xx} 2) BA 64 Betwq (The influence of Russian populism on the T'ung-meng-hui):

Li-shih yen-chiu, No. 1:35-44 (1959). Teng Hua a AR . "Li Ta-chao t'ung-chih tui Chung~kuo che-hstieh

ssu-hsiang fa-chan ti kung-hsien" 4 KA) 8) % at ¥ +h re @. #B rt ‘x 69 @ #K (Comrade Li Ta-chao's contribution to the development of Chinese philosophic thought);

Pei-ching jih-pao It a a th (Apr. 26, 1957), p. 3. Teng Ssu-yti and John K. Fairbank. China's Response to the West: _ , A Documentary Survey. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University

Press, 1954. oo

Ting Shou-ho 7 ef Fe and Yin Hsti-i BR AX $ . “Wu-ssu hsin-wenhua ytin-tung" A, F af BAL ‘4 ZH) (The May Fourth New Culture Movement): Li-shih yen-chiu, No. 4:1+35 (1959).

Ting Shou-ho, Yin Hsti-i and Chang Po-chao ae 4993. Shih-ytich ko-ming

tui Chung-kuo ko-ming ti ying-hsiang -+ fF x ee af i) ¥ ae 64 a3 v fe) (The influence of the October revolution on the Chinese revolution). Peking: Jen-min ch'u-pan she, 1957.

Trotsky, Leon. Our Revolution. ‘New York, 1918. | , _----The Bolsheviki and World Peace. New York, 1918. | 312

-----Problems of the Chinese Revolution. New York: Pioneer Publishers, 1932.

---~-The Third International After Lenin. New York: Pioneer Publishers, 1936.

Ts'ai Ylan~p'ei a A dE, "Lao~kung shen-sheng" AB 4 Ae Hp

1918),

(The dignity of labor); Hsin ch'ing-nien, 5. 5:438-439 (Nov. 15,

Tso Shun~sheng Je. 9A 23 . Chin san-shih nien chien-wen tsa-chi

if = + F. A Pa Fe $f, (Recollections of the past thirty years). Hong Kong: Tzu-yu ch'u-pan she @ ® i FR #4 (Free press), 1952. Tung-fang tsa~chih 7% #8 2% (Eastern miscellany). 17.16:133-134 (Aug. 25, 1920); and 19. 8:138-140 (Apr. 25, 1922).

United States Hong Kong Consul General. Survey of the Current

Mainland Press, Nos. 82 (Mar. 11-12, 1951) and 3038 (Aug. 13, 1963).

Venturi, Franco. Roots of Revolution. London, 1960.

Wang Shen-jan A. 4%. Chin-tai erh-shih-chia p'ing-chuan itt 4X =T %- oF 43 (Critical biographies of twenty contemporary scholars). Peking: Hsing~yen, 1934.

Weber, Max. From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, tr. and ed. H.H. Gerth and C. Wright Mills. New York: Oxford

University Press, 1958. ,

~----The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1958.

Wen Ts'ao % 4 . "Shih-pien Li Ta-chao (Shou-ch'ang) i-chu hsi-nien

mu-lu'' 3A, 4 % K'| ( F @) A % SS if a BRR (A preliminary chronological index to the writings of Li Ta-chao); Hstleh-shu 313

ylieh-k'an eZ A A +1 (Scholarship monthly), Nos. 1-5 and 9 (1957). No. 1, pp. 48-49; No. 2, pp. 64-66; No. 3, pp. 61-62;

No. 4, pp. 66-68; No. 5, p. 58; No. 9, pp. 76-77. Wilbur, C. Martin and Julie Lien-ying How. Documents on Communism, Nationalism and Soviet Advisers in China, 1918-1927. New York: Columbia University Press, 1956.

Wittfogel, Karl A. Oriental Despotism. New Haven, 1957.

Wu-ssu shih-ch'i ch'i-k'an chieh-shao & W at #9 HA F'] 4 4B (An introduction to the publications of the May Fourth period).

3 vols.; Peking: Jen-min ch'u-pan she, 1958-1959.

Yti I AR #. "Sung Li Kuei-nien yu-hstieh Jih-pen hsti" tk 5 6

% ide a A J} (A farewell to Li Kuei-nien [Li Ta-chao] on his leaving for study in Japan); Yen-chih, No. 4:85-86

(Sept. 1, 1913).

314 ,

GLOSSARY

ai kuo x Chiang Meng-lin ih Z BF Ariga Nagao ¥ Ag ke Uk Ch'ien-feng #] Be | Ch'ien Hstian-t'ung BX % PP

Chang Chi oR a chih-chieh hsing-tung rl 4h {TF $y

Chang Hstin §-& $4 Chin-pu tang 2 a g. Chang Kuo-t'ao Cae & Chiu-kuo hui #4 & a Chang Shih-chao 4 + 4 Chou Fu-hai [8] (# iB Chang Tso-lin tk 1F Fe Chou Tso-jen 2) 44 A Chang Tung-sun $& ® 7% Chu Teh K {&, Ch'ang-hs in-tien k& Es Jé Chung-hua ko-ming tang

Ch'ang-li-wu-feng % BRB ue Y # ¥ ioe =

Chao Chi-lan £8 4a fi Chung-kuo nung-min ¢ i 8 Chao Yu-shu AB 2: z Ch'ti YUan Je, /

chen chu rl £ Chtieh-wu she ie TB AL Ch'en Ch'i-hsiu PR BLAH

(Ch'en Pao-yin oR $4 fe.) Fa-yen pao j& Z #R | Ch'en Chiung-ming [R te) af “Fei Chiteh-ttien & HR

Ch'en-chung pao gz 4a aR Feng-t'ien EN A , Ch'en-pao fu-k'an Rah %\5) Feng Yu-hsiang 1B F; AF

Ch'en Pao-yin, see Ch'en Feng Yti-tung 1B rt R

Ch'i-hsiu fu-ch'iang S 5x

Ch'en Wang-tao PR 2] iB Fu Ssu-nien {2 FA f

Ch'en Yi PR a 0 4 Cheng-chih sheng-huo Ho Tang 4 He , sk 3h a 34 Ho Meng-hsiung AA ab Jb Chia-yin jih-k'an 9 % 4 4 Hsiang-chiang p'ing-lun

Chiang K'ang-hu 52. 7, JE, HE It BF Fay 315

hsiang-yltian $ER Ae. Lan Kung-wu Ea “Ls A (Lan Chih-

Hsien-fa t'ao-lun hui hsien ae 3 x, ) z id af sa as lao-kung chieh-chi By ZL pee 4m Hsin-ch'ao she Aff 3A FL Lao-tung chieh oe oy) RR

Hsin-min hstieh-hui Lao-tung yin af $n a

Af A ae aS Li Fu-ch'un 3 ze &R

Hsin shih-chieh Aff tt IR Li Hsing-hua % A Ay | ,

Hsin wen-hua ytin-tung _ Li Li-san B Bs |

By KALB G Lisao # 4%

hsin Ya-hsi-ya chu-i - Liang Ch'i-ch'ao 22. RX #S

3h op to oe EX Liu Chen-hua yo 4h # Hu Han-min 4} iz A Liu Fu %'| tq | Hung-ch'iang hui 42 ee | Liu Jen-ching %'| A= a#

| By 4 40

hung lou 4x #¥ | _ Liu Jih hsueh-sheng tsung-hui

jen-chung A 4 | Liu Pai-ching $1] 49 4 oo Kang Yu-wei J 4% 4, Liu Ping-lin %"| Rh , Kao L-han z 53, | Lo Chang-lung & e. 4 a Kawakami Hajime yy + rg - Lo Chia-lun g # Vey

Ko-lao hui of 4 AS | Lo-ting nsien ae , t Hg Ku Chao-hsiung, see Ku Meng-~yti Lu Hetn e ik | |

nsns iLL A) eee re ae

Ku Meng-yti Ai EA BGR (Ku Chao- Ma-k'e-shih chu-i yen-chiu hui

Kung-ch’an tang A fi ‘7 Ma-k'o-ssu hsueh-shuo yen-chiu hui

yer se: By co @: eB a AA K ct , , Mao I-heng $, vA ¥ |

Kuo-min-chin &) A # - Mei-chou p'ing-lun He i 34 a

Kuo-min jih-pao_ Bi) Aa HR min-chih chu-i Ky a a

Lan Chih-hsien, see Lan Kung-wu man} A # ! - - | 316

,a

Min pao f #h Sun Hung-i 45% 5% 4P min-sheng A, E Sung Chiao-jen AK A=

min-tsu A 7% | Ta~hei-t'o K &. FU, min-t'uan A 2\

Ta-kung pao K > #R "Nan-Ch'en, Pei-Li"' A) FRIL % tatao XK iB

; ; BA xX . .

Ning Yang '# fH ta Ya-hsi-ya chu-i

KH fe BERK Pai Chien-wu © A Tai Chi-t'ao wy a F £)

Pei-ta oar _—— Tan Pu-an % Z. Jb SEA B38 Ap Tan Pling-shan 3% —P 4

,. ~s#hstiehFf oe

° s _ i 1Q os :

Pei-yang fa-cheng chuan i - Ttang Hua-ling jf) 1. He

hsiao at 4 hs A 4 1 Tt T'ang-shan gE uy

Pei-yang ares hui Teng Chung-hsia Fgh ¥ a

t °F v4 BX + T'ien-an men Kt P*

+3 >87 7 #4 t'ien-chih tzu-yu K 74AO Preng -Plat

ia0— iang~ t'uan Pling-min chiae i oe yen Tlien-i pao ~ % ap

. S 7@

FA AKA OF PR, Tien-ti hui K 3%, S p'ing-min chu-i # - 2 Ts'ai Ao g& 4,

p'u-pien ch'tian-kuo B A E (a Ts'ai Ho-shen BR fo Fy xt GAH = 3 lai YUan-p'ei Shao-nien Chung-kuo hstieh-hul Ts'al Yuan - Age AL 7?

De: + B a Ts'ao K'un & At.

, . tsung-i She-hui chu-i yen-chiu w hui#2 at se xh - t'ung~chih BRK72

She-hui fu-lihui #4454] 2 DN T'ung-meng hui fe) 10. ~~

) 317 Shen-chou hsteh-hui #9 + 3 ¢

Shen pao P #R . wan-jen KR A

Shen Yin-mo TK. P BK Wang Ching-wei +4 i BF Shou-ch'ang f h (Li Ta-chao) wang-kuo +.

|

Wang Kuo-wei ZF. [¥] ae Yang Tu-sheng 4% @ 4%

wei-min chu-i 3 A Me Yen Chen Pe| th

Wen Shang 3x + Yen-chiu hsi Ff FW *#, wen-t'i yi chu-i Pe AK jd. x Yu I Af Bh

Wu Plei-fu & (Al, # YU Shu-te + #84 4®.

Wu Ytieh & Atk Yan Shih-k'ai ROW BL

oe y Yang Ch'ang-chi AG, & Ae . ae fF " ‘ Yang Ming-chai #4, @f| Ae spe ANT A

, 318

INDEX

Activism (political): and Li’s pre-Marx- Bakunin, M., 54, 100, 28on1

ian world view, 7, 23-28 passim, Bergson, Henri, 21, 23, 25, 28, 49,

38-40, 48-51, 155, 161, 166; and 272n53

Chinese reception of Marxism, 56- Bernstein, Eduard, 90, 198, 214, 57; and Li’s interpretation of Marx- 293nI ism, 91-95, 140-154 passim, 156, Blanqui, A., 78

158-170, 198; and May Fourth era, Bodin, Jean, 167 99-104 passim, 106, 109; and “ethic Bolshevism. See Russian October Rev-

of responsibility,” 109-111; in Marx- olution | ist theory, 113-114, 128-139 pas- Bortman, N., 115, 282n61 sim; and doctrines of inevitability, Boxer Protocol, 287n61 163-165; and unity of theory and Boxer Rebellion, 2, 4-6, 174 practice, 197-198. See also Volun- Buddhism, 14, 28

tarism _s 131, 133-I 28 ; infl fo”

Alienation, Marxist concept of, 128- Cant ee ee 4 27onr | 3ty 135 34, ont; Invuence ©) CCP. See Chinese Communist Party Li, 148, 184; and nationalism, 176- Chane Chi. 220. 2 36

177; 176-17773, Ch 88, 8 are277n8; 94 aeand - , proletariat, ang Kuo-t’ao,

and

Anarchism: Lion, 11-14, 35; in China, labor movement, 114-115, 211; and 30, 53> 34) TOO, ET7s and Popu- organization of CCP, 117, 119; and lism, 77; and Society for Study of CCP-KMT alliance, 219

Socialism, 116, 277n3 Ch , 159, , , 3 ang Shih-chao, 21,; 84,

. 9ng

Antiforeignism: of Li, 15-20, 36, 181, ayona8; and Tiger Daily and

eb. ee oF Sean 250-251, agrarian socialism, 278n28

266. vee also Nationalism Chang Tso-lin, xii, 257-260, 296n7

lism 26 > ? ? ? o >

Antiurbanism, 81-84, 87-88, 222, Chang Tung-sun, 150-151 237, 253-254, 265. See also Popu- Chao Ch’i-lan, 3-4, 6, 118, 258-259

Ariga Nagao, 16, 271n39 Chao Yii-shu, 260

“Asiatic mode of production,’ 173, Ch’en Ch’iung-ming, 117 225-226, 288n38, 288n46. See also Ch’en-chung pao; 30, 33, 272n2

Oriental despotism Ch’en-pao, 75, 101-102, I15, 272n2,

287n30 Backwardness, Advantages of: Li on, Ch’en-pao fu-k’an, 115, 283n62

65-67, 151-154; Trotsky on, 66- Cheng-chih sheng-huo, 228, 237, 67, 77; 126, 1533 Populists on, 76. 297n40

, See also Rebirth of China Ch’en Tu-hsiu, 6, 39, i110, 126, Bacon, Francis, 167 279n1; and CCP, xi, 117--120, 260319

INDEX , 261; on Chinese tradition, 4-5, 37- (254-255; Ch’en Tu-hsiu on, 21839, 179; on Chinese republic, 9; on 219, 230-232, 254; Mao on, 264

patriotism, 21-25 passim, 178; re- Chinese tradition. See Traditional Chi-

sponse to Marxism-Leninism, 24, nese values

177, 217; on nationalism, 24-25, Ch’ing Dynasty, 1, 4, 6, 8-9; and Chi177-178; on determinism, 25, 230- nese anarchist movement, 13 232; and HCN group, 35-48 pas- Chinputang (Progressive Party), 111, sim, 2°73nn15,17, 294n29; on polit- 150; and Li, 14-15, 28-34, 271n32, ical activism, 36, 38-39; compared 272nI; opposition to Yiian govern-

to Li, 37, 40-42,°155, 181, 183, ment, 28-29; and constitutionalism,

220; on Western civilization, 38; 31

on East-West differences, 42-43, 46; Chiu-kuo hui (Save the Country So-

response to Bolshevik Revolution, ciety), 71 45-46, 60, 95, I12-113, 282n50; Chou En-lai, 117, 283n74 on socialism, 55, 151; and Peking Chou Fu-hai, 119, 290n15 University, 57, 281n33; on Russian Chou Tso-jen, 275n9

February Revolution and World War Chow Tse-tsung, 98, 108 |

I, 59, 60; on labor, 86-87, 102; Christensen, Arthur, 273n27

imprisonment of, 103-104, 281n30; Chuang Tzu, 28 conversion to Marxism, 103, 112— Chu Chih-hsin, 52-54

113, 241; on internationalism, 177- Ch’ii Ch’iu-pai, 73, 213, 278n28, 178; on CCP-KMT alliance, 218- 283n74; and Ch’en Tu-hsiu, 241, 219, 230-232; on proletariat, 221, 243, 246; and Hsin ch’ing-nien, 241-243, 256; and Ch’tt Ch’iu-p’ai, 294n29 241, 243, 246; on peasantry, 241- Chiieh-wu she CAwakening Society),

246; on revolutionary process in IIl4, 117

China, 242-243, 297n22; and Trots- Chung-hua ko-ming tang (Chinese

kyism, 260; and New Culture Revolutionary Party), 15, 271n38 Movement, 261; Mao’s attitude to- Chung-kuo nung-min, 296n10 ward, 283; and Sun Yat-sen, 295n5 Chu Teh, 283n74

Ch’en Wang-tao, 116 Chu Wu-shan, 116, 219 Ch’en Yi, 283n74 Ch’ti Yiian, 2, 7, 21, 24, 269nrz

Chernyshevskii, N., 75, 77, 164, 205 Class struggle, Marx’s concept of, 127,

Chiang K’ai-shek, xii, 117, 286nq41 141, 143; Li on, go, 85, 91-93,

Chiang Kang-hu, 55 II2, 139-146, 193; and populism, Chiang Meng-lin, 259 79; and “proletarian nation” theory,

Chia-yin jih-k’an (Tiger Daily), 33, 188, 255; and racial conflict, 191-

273nI1 : 193; and “mutual aid” theory, 206;

Chia-yin tsa-chih, 16, 21, 272n48 and peasant revolution, 239, 251Ch’ien Hsiian-t’ung, 41-42, 273n15 252; Li and Mao on, 263-264 China Labor Union Secretariat, 211 Cole, G. D. H., roo

Chinese Communist Party CCCP): on Comintern: and CCP-KMT.° alliance,

Li, xii-xiii, 261; political strategies xi, 189, 213-220 passim, 293n22; of, xii-xv, 89, 211-213, 216, 218, in organization of CCP, 114-120 264-266; internal struggles of, xii, passim, 210; and Communist strat241, 246; origins of, 71, ILoo—-I04, egy in China, 211, 213, 216, 218;

Il1-114, 261; early leaders of, 72- Second Congress of, 216; Fifth

73, II4-I19 passim; organization Congress of, 235; and peasant quesof, 114-121; First Congress of, 119, tion, 240-241, 243-246, 253 210; and peasant movement, 240- Communist Manifesto, 52, 115-116, 246, 248, 253; and Ch’en Tu-hsiu, 133, 176, 277n3 260-261; Youth Corps, 283n78 Comte, A., 159, 161-163 Chinese Communist alliance with Condorcet, J. A. N. de, 159, 161-163 Kuomintang, xi, xii, 213, 216-225, Confucianism. See Traditional Chi-

228-233, 239-247 passim, 253, nese values

293n19; Li’s role in, and view of, Consciousness: Ch’en Tu-hsiu’s and

189, 191, 218-238 passim, 247, Li’s pre-Marxian views on, com- .

320

INDEX pared, 21-25; in Li’s treatment of Fu Ssu-nien, 277n7

Marxism, 91-93, 105, 126-127; in ,

original Marxism, 128-134, 136, George, Henry, 54 145; in Leninism, 137-139, 141, Gobineau, J. A. de, 191 145, 164; Li on, 140-155, 165- Goodnow, Dr. Frank, 16-17 166, 170, 202-209 passim; Lenin Guild socialism, 100, 150

on, I99-20I, 205-206, 208-209; | | and Populism, 205-206; Li’s and Haimson, Leopold, 200, 205-206

264 Hatano Ken’ichi, 72

Mao’s treatment of, compared, 262—- Hakewill, George, 167

Croce, Benedetto, 157 _ , Hegel, G. W. F., 30, 138, 157-158;

influence on Lenin, 200, 285n28;

Darwin, Charles, 99, 286n33 ‘law of the contact of extremes,” Determinism: Li on, 23, 74, 120, 156, Herzen, Alexander, 75

Descartes, 167 226

158; Ch’en Tu-hsiu on, 25, 230- Historical materialism. See Material232; Plekhanov on, 78-79; and Li’s ist conception of history

treatment of Marxism, 91-95, 112, Ho Lung, 298n41 125-127, 140-154, 157, 161-170; Ho Meng-hsiung, T17, 219 in Marxist theory, 128-137, 157, Hsin-ch’ao, 186

164-165, 169-170, 285n19; in Le- Hsin-ch ao she (New Tide Society), 71 ninism, 137-139; Li’s and Mao’s Hsin ch’ing-nien CHCN), 21, 56, 71,

views of, compared, 262-266 90, 119, 147, 182, 273n17, 275N5,

Deutscher, Isaac, 185 279nI, 249n29g

Dewey, John, 105, 107-108, 112-113, HCN group: character of, 35-48, 575

150 and internationalism, 35, 98-99;

Dialectical Materialism, 137, 274n43 Li’s relation to, 36-42, 48, 59-60,

Dobrolyubov, N., 164 IOI, 141-142, 220-221; and political action, 38, 43-46 passim; and

, Social Darwinism, 39; and Chinese

East-West differences: controversies culture, 43-45; and socialism, 54-

43) ian oo ee 5 5Revolution, and World War f 59 Gos and ’ >ree , , ee olshevik 62, 282n50; 179-180; and Li’s response to Oc- relation to May Fourth Movement, tober Revolution, 64, 181; Marxism 98-101; split in, 104-114, 220-

and synthesis of, 67-68 321

Emerson, Ralph Waldo: influence on yygjn-min _ hsiieh-hui (New People’s

Li, 21, 25-28, 36-37; concept of Study Society), 114

time, 69, 166-167 Hsin shih-chieh, 53

Engels, Friedrich, 52-54, 277n3; on yy Han-min, 90, 280n3 politics, 134; on dialectical matel- Hy Shih: on Chinese tradition, 37, ialism, 137; on T’ai-p’ing Rebellion, 43-45; “problems and isms” debate,

227; on the state, 284-28 5n17 104-112, 140, 146, 198; and Li,

Ethics, 93-94, 184; ethic of respon- 220-221; and Bolshevism, 282n50 sibility,’ 1og—-111; “ethic of ulti- Huxley, T. H., 99 mate ends,” ro8—111; Li on func- ,

tion of, 142-143, 146-147 Internationalism: and HCN group, 35,

| 98-99; Li on, 37, 178-188, 255-

Fa-yen pao, 8 , 256; and Bolshevik Revolution, 63-

, “February Seventh” incident, 212, 230 65, 180-185; of Marx, 129, 176-

roeng-tien, Chiieh-t’ien, | 773an OF‘en Trotsky, Tt 53,177-178, 185, 255240151256; Tu-hsiu,

Feng Yii-hsiang, 235-236, 247, 296n5- 256, 261 6, 298n42

Fung Yii-tung, 250 Kang Yu-wei, 32

Franklin, Benjamin, 120 Kao I-han, 56, 118, 283n65 Fu-ch’iang (Wealth and Strength), 8-9 Karakhan, Leo, 236

321

INDEX Kautsky, Karl, 115, 137-138, 291n3 254; Li on, 201-209 passim; strat-

Kawakami Hajime, 56 egy for Asia, 213-217; theory of

Kepler, J., 159 democratic dictatorship, 215; on KMT. See Kuomintang revolutionary stages, 232-233 Ko-lao-hui (Society of Elder Brothers), Levenson, Joseph, 47

240, 298n41 Liang Ch’i-ch’ao, 52; and Chinputang,

Kropotkin, Michael, 54, 90, 100; in- 14; and Research Clique, 30; and fluence on Li, 13-14; theory of Tuan Ch’i-jui alliance, 33; Li’s critmutual aid, 141-144, 206, 275n9 icism of, 34-35, 159; and Marxism,

Ku Meng-yii, 279n1, 283n65 274n2; and Hu Shih, 294n31

Kung-ch’an tang, 119 Liao Chung-k’ai, 84

ciation), 118 261

Kung-jen chu-le-pu (CWorkers’ Asso- Liberalism in China, 108-111, 120,

Kuo-min jih-pao, 62, 235 Li Chung-hua, 269n9g Kuomintang (KMT), 9-10, 30, too— Li Fu-ch’un, 283n74 101, 296nro; Li on, 11, 14, 233; Li Hsing-hua, 257-259, 269n5 , and Ch’ien Hsiian-t’ung, 41; and Li Li-san, 283n74 Chu Chih-hsin, 53; First National Li Ta-chao: youth, 1-6; at Peiyang Congress of, 220, 235; left-wing of, College, 6-8; early political orienta-

, 234, 236, 247, 259; Western Hills tions, 8-15, 29-35; student in Ja-

faction, 234-236, 296n8. See also pan, 15-21, 56; pre-Marxian world Chinese Communist alliance with view, 26-28, 46-51, 166-167; role

Kuomintang in founding CCP, 114-121; role in

Kuo Mo-jo, 171 CCP-KMT alliance, 218-221, 234236; arrest and execution, 257Lan Kung-wu, III 260. See also specific topics Lao-tung chieh, 118 Liu Chen-hua, 249, 298n42 _ Lao-tung yin (The Sound of Labor), Liu Fu, 273n15

118, 211 Liu Jen-ching, 117, 29o0nI5

Lao Tzu, 21, 24 Liu-Jih hsiieh-sheng tsung-hui (AssoLassalle, Ferdinand, 52, 55 ciation of Chinese Students in JaLenin, V. I.: on World War I, 60; on pan), 18

Russia’s backwardness, 65; influence Liu Pai-ching, 291n36

on Li, 69, 94, 139-140, 204, Liu Ping-lin, 28o0nz

292n25; and Populism, 77; on cap- Lo Chang-lung, 117, 219 italism, 78, 214, 278n19; on anti- Lo Chia-lun, 71, 88, 276nr1, 277n7 imperialism, 97; Chinese translation Lowith, Karl, 133

of, 116, 275n5; on subjective fac- Lu Hsiin, 44-45 tors in history, 164; on historical Lukacs, George, 132 © periodization, 171; on “world rev- _ olution,” 178-179, 185-186; con- Ma-k’e-shih chu-i yen-chiu hui (Marxcept of spontaneity, 199-201, 205- ist Research Society), 71-73, 102,

206; on Asia, 204, 213, 216-217, 116

293nr2; on “national revolution,” Ma-k’o-ssu- hsiieh-shuo yen-chiu hui

229; on China, 278n21; influence CSociety for the Study of Marxist of Hegel on, 285n28. See also Le- Theory), 72, 116, 283n65

ninism Malthusian theory, 39

Leninism: and Li, 69, 94, 138-140, Manaev, I. K., 283n66 201-209, 295n25; appeals of in Mannheim, Karl, 106, 169 May Fourth period, 100; on im- Mao J-heng, 296n6 perialism, 126, 199, 213-214; on Mao Tse-tung, xii, 3, 277n7, 296nI0; determinism, 137-139, 205; nature influence of Li on, xii—xiii, xv, 72, of, 138-140, 198-201; on economic 261-262, 264; and anarchism, 13, prerequisites for socialism, 150; on 271n1; nationalism of, 48, 189, unity of theory and practice, 198; 193, 194; on peasantry, 80, 239, on party organization, 199-201, 240, 253; and Leninism, 85; views 208-209; on peasantry, 199, 253- of, compared to Li’s, 95, 145, 193-

322

INDEX 194, 205, 239, 261-266; and CCP, Materialist conception of history, 131-

Ilq, 117, 277n8; and Marxism, 138, 155-158, 284n8; Li on, 90: 145; on CCP-KMT alliance, 221; 95, III-I12, 140, 146-149, 158and Young China Society, 29o0n15; 175 passim; and Chinese Marxists,

and secret societies, 298n41 139 Marcuse, Herbert, 133 104; and radical student organiza-

“March Eighteenth Massacre,” 247 May Fourth Movement, 71-73, 96-

_ Maring CH. Sneevliet), 211, 218 tions, 88-89, 102, LI4q-I1g pasMarx, Karl, 52, 28o0n1z; and the dialec- sim; and nationalism, 96-104, 109,

tic, 30; Chinese translations of, 52- 177; and New Culture Movement, 54; appeals of, in China, 52-56, 98-100; Li’s role in, ro1—112, 118,

100; on Russia, 77-78, 227; on 261; Li’s evaluation of, 103, 182,

activism, 113-114; on capitalism, 202, 290n12; and Ch’en Tu-hsiu, , 126, 131, 134-135, 169, 171, 173, 103-104, I12-I14, 120; and “prob176; on the proletariat, 129-131, lems and isms” debate, 104-112; 136; concept of progress, 157-158; and early Communist organization,

historical periodization, 171, 173; 114-120

on geography in history, 172-173; Mei-chou p’ing-lun, 103, 105, IIT, “Asiatic mode of production,” 173, 112, 281n30, 282n50 288n38, 288n46; on nationalism, Mencius, 32 176-177, 289nn1,2; First Interna- Mensheviks, 150 , tional of, 224; on India, 225-227; Michel, Robert, 157 on China, 225-227, 295n48; on Mill, John Stuart, 31, 40, 41, 99 “Irish question,” 227; on the state, Min-i CRule of the people). See Pop284n17; on human nature, 289nr1; ulism Civil War in France, 292n26. See Min pao, 52 also Alienation; Determinism: Marx- Montesquieu, 31

ism; Materialist conception of his- Muller, A. A., 115 tory

Marxism, xii-xiv; and Chinese Com- Napoleon III, 135 munist politics, xiii-xv, 264-266; Narodnaya Volya (Peoples will), 203.

origins in China, 13, 52-56; and See also Populism Ch’en Tu-hsiu, 45-46, 113, 217; Nationalism: and_ Li’s pre-Marxian Li’s acceptance of, 48, 67-69, 71- philosophy, 15-20, 24, 26-28, 36, 74, ILO-I1I1; reception in China, 42, 51; Ch’en Tu-hsiu on, 24-25, 56-58, 63, 103-104, 106, 115-116; 177-178; in Li’s basic views, 47-48,

and Populism, 78-79; Li’s interpre- 84, 101, 177-178, 219-220; and

tation of, 86, 90-95, 112, 120-121, Li’s response to Russian Revolution, 125-127, 140-156, 158-175 pas- 64-69 passim, 177; and May Fourth sim, 204; and relation between po- era, 96-104, 109; in Li's interprelitical and economic forces, 93, 127, tation of Marxism, 141-146, 151-

131-135, 150-154; determinism 154, 171-175, 188-194, 222-225, and activism in, 126-141 passim, 228-230, 232-233, 254-256; and 157, 164-165, 169-170, 285n19; Marxism, 178-188, 192-194; and and doctrine of inevitability, 161- Maoism, 189, 193-194, 261; and 166; and nationalism, 178-188, united front strategy, 194; and Le-

192-194; Li’s and Mao’s views of, ninism, 213, 214-216; and peasant compared, 261-266. See also Class revolution, 250-251, 255-256, 265Struggle; Consciousness; Leninism; 266; Li’s and Mao’s views of, com-

Materialist Conception of History; pared, 261-266. See also “Prole-

Theory and Practice, Unity of tarian nation” theory; “Rebirth of

Mass Education Speech Corps (P’ing- China”

min chiao-yii chiang-yen t’'uan), 88, New Asianism Chsin Ya-hsi-ya chu-i),

102, II4, 210 186-188

Materialism in Marxist theory, 157; Li New Culture Movement, 98-100, 177,

on, 92-93, 111; influence on Li 261. See also HCN Group; May

and Mao, 263 Fourth Movement

323

INDEX

Newton, Isaac, 159 pared, 262, 264-265; in T’ungNew Village Movement, 56, 275n9 meng hui era, 278n21. See also Nietzsche, 274n2_ Peasantry; Peasant revolution

| Positivism, 163

October Revolution. See Russian Oc- “Problems and Isms” debate, 104-112,

tober Revolution 140, 146, 198, 220

Oriental despotism, 135, 225-226, Progress: Li’s view of, 40-41, 161-

285n19 163; Marxist concept of, 157-158 “Proletarian nation” theory, 144-146,

Pai Chien-wu, 211-212 I51I-154, 188-194 passim, 217, Palmerston, Lord, 227 | 219, 263-264, 291; and Chinese Paris Commune, 133, 284n13, 292n26 revolution, 222-225, 230, 233, Patriotism: Ch’en Tu-hsiu on, 21-25 237, 255

passim, 37, 178; Lion, 22-25, 178, Proletariat: in May Fourth movement,

181-183, 190. See also Nationalism 96, 102-103; and Marxism, 102Peasant revolution, 80-89, 201, 237- 103, 129-131, 176-177; organiza-

240; Li on, 193-194, 246-256; tion of, in China, 114-115, 118,

views of Li, Lenin, and Ch’en Tu- 210-212, 218, 235-236; and Lehsiu, compared, 253-256. See also ninism, 141, 199-201, 205, 213Populism; Red Spear Societies 217 passim, 253-254; Li on, 201, Peasantry: Li on, 75, 202, 205-207, 221-223, 253-256; Ch’en Tu-hsiu 222, 262; and Li’s “go to the vil- On, 231-232, 241-243, 256; Chiii lages” movement, 80-89, 101; and Ch’iu-pai on, 243, 246 |

nationalism, 194, 265-266; and ,

Leninism, 215-216; Ch’en Tu-hsiu Race Question, 188-193 on, 241-246; movement of, 248; “Rebirth of China”: Li on, 26-28, 59-

Mao on, 262, 264; and CCP suc- 60, 179, 183, 266; and May

cess, 265-266 ! Fourth movement, 27, 103; and Li’s Science, 6, 8, 211 67, 69, 154; and Li’s treatment of

Peiyang College of Law and Political response to Russian Revolution, 65-

Peiyang Legal and Political Study So- Marxism, 161, 181; Mao’s and Li’s

ciety, 7, 10-11 views on, compared, 263

Peiyang warlord clique, 234 Red Spear Societies (Hung-chiang-

Peking-Hankow Railroad Workers’ hui), 240; CCP views on, 244-245, Union, 115, 193, 211-212, 234- 254; Li on, 248-250, 252-254

235 Reinsch, Paul, 276n24

Peking University Political Study So- Revolution of 1911, 6, 17, 54, 108, ciety (Pei-ta cheng-chih hstieh-hui), 212; Li on, 10, 19

190 , Robinson, Arthur G., 15, 269n3,

P’eng P’ai, 88, 240, 296nI0 271n36

P’ing-min chiao-yii chiang-yen t'uan. Rousseau, Jean Jacques, 31, 34-35 See Mass Education Speech Corps Russell, Bertrand, 42, 100, 150-151,

Pisarev, D., 164 286n52 Plekhanov, George: and Marxism, 76, Russian February Revolution, 58-60

79, 134, 137-138; on Populism, Russian October (Bolshevik) Revolu-

78-79, 150; on geography in his- tion: Li’s response to, 42, 45-48

tory, 173 passim, 51, 60-70, 73-74, 94, 125-

Polevoy, Sergei A., 283n67 _ 126, 140, 224-225, 262; Ch’en

Populism, 75-80; in Li’s thought, 9, Tu-hsiu’s response to, 45-46, 60, 31-32, 75, 80-88, 222, 225; Li’s 95, 112-113, 282n50; reception in notion of min-i, 31-32, 272n3; and China, 45-46, 56-57, 286n52; economic backwardness, 76-77; dif- HCN group on, 60, 62-63; KMT ferences with Marxism, 78-79; in on, 61-62; Lo Chia-lun on, 71; Li’s views of peasant revolution, 8o0- and French Revolution, 180-181;

88, 237-240, 248-256; Li’s and internationalist appeals of, 180- |

Lenin’s views of, compared, 205- 185; and hopes of Chinese Com209; Mao’s and Li’s views of, com- munists, 218; Li's view of peasant

324

INDEX role in, 237-238; Mao’s response to, ‘T’ai-p’ing yang, 34, 111 |

262 “Taku Ultimatum,” 297n35-

Russian Socialist Revolutionary Move- ‘T’ang Hua-lung: and Li, 14-15, 28-

ment. See Socialist Revolutionary 30, 33, 271n32, 272n1; and Tuan

Movement (Russian ) Ch’i-jui, 33

T’an P’ing-shan, 294n25

Saint-Simon, Comte de, 54, 56, 100; Tan Pu-an, 294n31

influence on Li, 161-163 Taoism, I10

Schram, Stuart, 85, 189, 262 Teng Chung-hsia, 71, 73, 88, 277n8,

Schwartz, Benjamin, 35, 113, 243 290n15; and labor movement, 102,

Self-consciousness. See Consciousness 114, 211; and Communist politics,

Shao-nien Chung-kuo __ hsiieh-hui 117, 219-220 , (Young China Society), 182-183, Theory and Practice, Unity of, 106, 220, 29o0nI5 I21, 130, 197-198 She-hui-chu-i yen-chiu hui (Society Tien-i pao, 53, 277n3

for the Study of Socialism), 116, ‘T’ien-ti hui (Heaven and. Earth So-

118, 151, 277n3 ciety), 224 Z

Shen-chou hsiieh-hui CChina Study Time: Li on, 48-51, 166-170; Marx-

Society), 15 } ism on, 168-170

Shen Yin-mo, 273nt5 Toilers of the Far East, First Congress Social Darwinism, 39, 66, 141-142, of, 213. |

286n33 Oo , Tolstoy, Leo, 32, 100, 275n9; influ-

Social-Democratic tradition: absence in ence on Li, 8, 31, 63 China, xi, 56-57, 63, 119-120, 150, Traditional Chinese values, 4-6, 54,

261; in Western Europe, 137; in 120; and Li, 2-5, 7-9, 12, 17-18, ,

Germany, 291n3 | 24, 31-39 passim, 42, 46--48, 50,

Socialism, Li’s early interest in, 55-56 86, 110, 179, 183-184, I90, 290-

Socialist Revolutionary Movement ( Rus- 291n35; and public service, 6, 110;

sian), 53, 76-77, 80 and antiforeignism, 19; and Con-

Socialist Youth Corps, 88-89, 119 fucius, 32, 159; Ch’en ‘Tu-hsiu’s

Social Welfare Society, 114 view of, 35, 37-39, 43-46 passim,

Spencer, H., 99 179; and _ Social-Darwinism, 39;

Stalin, J., 171, 223, 243, 285n17 HCN group’s view of, 43-45; and State: Confucian view of, 9; Li on, Hu Shih, 44, 109; and May Fourth 10, 12-13, 17-18, 207-208; aliena- students, 99; and socialism, 1I00; tion of intellectuals from, 35-36; and Li’s Marxist principles, 184;

as interpreted by Populists and Marx- and nationalism, 263 ists, 77, 79; Marx and Engels on, Triad Society, 174 284-285n17; Stalinist view of, Trotsky, Leon: on economic backward-

285n17 ness, 65, 77; theory of permanent

State and Revolution (Lenin), 204, revolution, 66-67, 126, 215; com-

208, 292n25 pared with Li, 66-67, 69-70, 152-

Sung Chiao-jen, 9, 11, 271n38 153, 192-193, 255-256; influence

Sun Hung-i, 271n32 on Li, 69-70, 185-186; on antiSun Yat-sen, 9-10, 55, 224-225, 238; imperialism, 97; law of uneven and CCP-KMT alliance, xi, 218, development, 152~—153; on a United

220, 293nnr9g, 22; Li’s admiration States of Europe, 185-186, 188; for, 11, 233; Revolutionary Party on nationalism, 192-194; on peasof, 15, 30, 35, 52; and Russian antry, 255-256; and Ch’en Tu-hsiu, Revolution, 53, 62; and 1925 mis- 260

sion to Peking, 236, 295n5 Ts’ai Ao, 29 Ts’ai Ho-shen, 118 Tagore, Rabindranath, 42 Ts’ai Yiian-p’ei, 57, 86-87, 102, 118, Tai Chi-t’ao, 117, 145, 286n41 279n32

T’ai-p’ing Rebellion: Marx on, 135, Tsung-i CRules of the Clan), 31 226-227, 289n2; Li on, 174-175, Tuan Chii-jui, 235-236, 247, 295n5

224, 228, 230, 238 T’ung-meng hui (Alliance Society), 325

INDEX 52, 63, 80, 271n38; and Li, 11, Wang Kuo-wei, 294n31 220; anarchist influences in, 54; Waseda University, 15, 28, 56, 88,

Populist influences in, 278n21 269n3

Turgot, 161 Weale, Putnam, 191

“Twenty-one Demands”: 18, 25, 96 Weber, Max, 1og-111, 163-164 Well-field system, 279n28

phen Mexander, 203 3109, What ‘0 Be Done? (Lenin), 199oplanism, 157-150, 20 Is 204, 285n27 Utopian Socialism, 56, 99-100, World War I: Chinese intellectuals,

275N9 attitude to, 57-60, 62, 70; Li’s views

, on, 59-60, 68, 96-98, 182; and ©

Versailles Peace conterence: Ciinese growth of Chinese proletariat, 102 responses to, 58, 96-104; Lis re- Wu Pei-fu, 211-212 296n7 sponse to, 96-98; effect on Ch’en Wu Yiieh, ‘a7 8n2 I Tu-hsiu, 113; and Chinese nation-

alism, 181-182 Yang Ch’ang-chi, 72 |

Voitins®y, Gregori, II14-117, 283n66 Yang Ming-chai, 116 , Voltaire, 31 . , . Yang Tu-sheng,view, 278n21 Voluntarism: in Li’s pre-Marxian Yen-chen, 268

22-28 passim, 125-126; and Rus- Yen-chih tsa-chih 9

84-85; Li’s Yon sh hei (R ? a Cl; | interpretationsian of Populists, Marxism,77, 145, 155-inenecniu-nsi C esearc ique ), 30

156, 158, 166-170 passim, 202— Young China Society. See Shao-nien 209, 262-266; in Leninism, 164, _Chung-kuo hstieh-hui 199-201, 205, 208, 285n28; and Yiian Shih-k’ai: Li’s view of, 9-1T; Chinese nationalism, 194; and “na- and Chinputang, I4; Opposition fo, tional revolution,” 232; and peasant 15, 56; and Twenty-one Demands,

revolution, 255-256; in Maoism, 18, 253 decline and death of, 28261-266. See also Activism; Con- 29; Ch en Tu-hsiu’s view of, 59; and

, sciousness; Determinism Tiger Daily, 278n48 Wang Ching-wei, 54, 119, 279n1Z; Yiin Tai-ying, 115, 290n15

293nI9 Yu Shu-te, 294n25

326