Bewusstsein und Gewissen. Die Suche nach Wahrheit

Citation preview

I(=(
HNLI>GLDR
-/;97787/24
94.
0/;277/4 =B>
LN
G:BM

75124d]b_iY^[d
led
Keb\
A(
@b[_Y^cWdd

_][dm_bb[

3/ G[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[

+,;[c[hakd][d
pkh
:hX[_j

+.-

/EIBEEDKNIC

P[dd
cWd
i_Y^
[_d[c
Z[h
led
I(=(
Hkif[diao
l[ht\\[djb_Y^j[d
P[ha[
ds^[hj&
led
:COQGRK
6OE?LRK
"pk[hij
_d
KkiibWdZ
_c
CW^h[
+3+,
^[hWki][][X[d&
ifsj[h
uX[hi[jpj
kdZ
+3,*
_d
>d]bWdZ
l[ht\\[djb_Y^j
kdZ
i[_j^[h
l_[b[
FWb[
d[k
Wk\][b[]j#
X_i
pk
Z_[i[h
d[k[d
LWccbkd]
akhp[h
:hX[_j[d&
ie
_ij
[i
m_Y^j_]&
i_Y^
pk
l[h][][dmshj_][d&
ZWii
Hkif[diao
i[bXij
m[d_]
O[hjhWk[d
_d
ZWi
][iY^h_[X[d[
Pehj
Wbi
lehhWd]_][
F[j^eZ[
pkh
>hbWd]kd]
Z[h
PW^h^[_j
][i[jpj
^Wjj[(
G_Y^j
ZWii
yHz
"m_[
_^d
F_j]b_[Z[h
i[_d[i
Dh[_i[i
kdj[h[_dWdZ[h
dWddj[d#
;_bZkd]
kdZ
ZWi
O[hbWd' ][d
dWY^
Sk]Wd]
pk
P_ii[d
_c
][h_d]ij[d
l[hWY^j[j
^sjj[(
Hkif[diao
mWh
i[bXij
[_d
kd[hisjjb_Y^[h
WX[h
ah_j_iY^[h
E[i[h&
kdZ
_c
:bj[h
led
i[Y^i
CW^h[d
bWi
[h
[hijcWbi
Mkh][d`[m
'
_d
ie
`kd][d
CW^h[d
[_d
abWh[h
A_dm[_i
Wk\
i[_d
Wkii[h][mt^db_Y^[i
MWb[dj(
F_j
pmtb\
CW^h[d
^Wjj[
[h
Z[d
]htiij[d
M[_b
Z[h
_^c
pk]sd]b_Y^[d
dWjkhm_ii[diY^W\jb_Y^[d
kdZ
fioY^ebe]_iY^[d
E_j[' hWjkh
l[hiY^bkd][d(
:bi
[h
i[Y^p[^d
mWh&
^Wjj[
[h
i_Y^
bWkj
[_][d[c
S[k]d_i
[djiY^beii[d&
a[_d[d
e\\_p_[bb[d
:XiY^bkii
pk
[hm[hX[d&
iedZ[hd
i[_d[
LjkZ_[d
Wk\
`[d[
:if[aj[
Z[i
P_ii[di
pk
aedp[djh_[h[d&
Z_[
Wkii[h^WbX
kdZ
uX[h
Z[d
jhWZ_j_ed[bb[d
P_ii[di][X_[j[d
ijWdZ[d(
y=_[
Ihe\[iieh[d
jtj[d
Z_[
P_ii[d' iY^W\jz&
iW]j[
[h&
y][dWkie&
m_[
Z_[
Ih_[ij[h
Z_[
K[b_]_ed
jtj[d(z
L[_d[c
>cf\_dZ[d
dWY^
]_d]
a[_d[
Z[h
[jWXb_[hj[d
P_ii[diY^W\' j[d
_d
Z[h
>h\ehiY^kd]
WdZ[h[h
=_c[di_ed[d&
Z_[
[i
][m_ii
]WX&
m[_j
][dk]5
i_[
Xb_[X[d
_c
yb[[h[d
KWkcz
ij[^[d&
m_[
[h
i_Y^
WkiZhuYaj[( Hkif[diaoi
ifsj[h[h
P_Z[hm_bb[&
i_Y^
Wk\
ZWi
][iY^h_[X[d[
Pehj
Wbi
F_jj[b&
P_ii[d
m[_j[hpk][X[d&
pk
l[hbWii[d&
X[hk^j[
Wk\
pm[_
AWkfjfkdaj[d&
X[_Z[
m[i[djb_Y^[h
M[_b
Z[i
Loij[ci&
ZWi
[h
b[^hj[(
>hij[di&
Z_[
P_Y^j_]a[_j&
Wd
Z[h
[_][d[d
>djm_Yabkd]

c_j
kdZ
ZkhY^
[_d[
LY^kb[
eZ[h
Z[d
ijhkajkh_[hj[d
Dedj[nj
[_d[h
@hkff[
pk
WhX[_j[d(
Hkif[diaoi
I^_beief^_[
X[hk^j[
Wk\
Z[h
Oehij[bbkd]&
ZWii
Z[h
F[diY^
[_d[
FWiY^_d[
_ij&
Z_[
i_Y^
_d
[_d[c
jhWkcs^db_Y^[d&
c[Y^Wd_iY^[d
SkijWdZ
ZkhY^
_^h[
>n_' ij[dp
X[m[]j&
kdZ
ZWii
[h&
kc
i[_d
][iWcj[i
Iej[dj_Wb
pk
[h'
iY^b_[ii[d&
c_jj[bi
Z_ip_fb_d_[hj[h
;[cu^kd][d&
yi_Y^
i[_d[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hdz&
[hmWY^[d
ckii
'
\s^_]
pk
i[_d&
`[Z[hp[_j
i[_d[h
i[bXij
lebb
][mW^h
pk
m[hZ[d(
L_Y^
i[_d[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd
_ij
iY^m[h
kdZ
[h\ehZ[hj
[_d[
K[_^[
led
LY^h_jj[d
_d
[_d[h
X[ij_cc' j[d
?eb][
pkiWcc[d
c_j
Z[h
A_b\[
[_d[h
LY^kb[5
Z_[
ct]b_Y^[
;[be^dkd]
_ij
ZWi
>hbWd][d
eX`[aj_l[d
;[mkiiji[_di
c_jj[bi
L[bXij'LjkZ_kci&
Dedjhebb[
kdZ
NcmWdZbkd]
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[(
=_[i
_ij
[_d
[hmWY^j[h
SkijWdZ&
_d
Z[c
[_d
F[diY^&
led
i[_d[c
SkijWdZ
Z[i
PWY^'LY^bW\i
X[\h[_j&
\s^_]
_ij&
Z_[
^t^[h[
P_hab_Y^' a[_j
"y[iej[h_iY^[i
P_ii[dz#
mW^hpkd[^c[d&
Z_[
_^c
_d
i[_d[c
][mt^db_Y^[d&
kd[djm_Ya[bj[d
L[_dipkijWdZ
l[hXeh][d
_ij(
=[h
LY^buii[b
pk
Wbb
Z_[i[c
X_bZ[j
dWjuhb_Y^
Z_[
:hX[_j
_dd[h^WbX
Z[h
LY^kb[&
Z_[
Wk\
Z[c
Ih_dp_f
X[hk^j&
ZWii
Z_[
>djm_Yabkd]
led
P_ii[d
kdZ
ZWi
PWY^i[d
Z[i
L[_di
][c[_diWc
pkc
h[Y^j[d
O[hij[^[d
\ehjiY^h[_j[d
cuii[d(
Bc
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
pk
l_[b[d
WdZ[' h[d
Loij[c[d
aWdd
ZWi`[d_][
led
Hkif[diao
Z[c
>_dp[bd[d
d_Y^j
Wbb[_d
c_jj[bi
Dedj[cfbWj_ed
>h\eb]
Xh_d][d
eZ[h
b[Z_]b_Y^
ZkhY^
:dm[dZ[d
Z[h
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[d
?s^_]a[_j[d
pkc
O[hij[^[d
\u^' h[d(
:ki
Z_[i[c
@hkdZ
X[jedj[
Hkif[diao
i[_d
E[X[d
bWd]&
ZWii
yZWi
Loij[c
Wki
a[_d[c
;kY^
[hb[hdj
m[hZ[d
aWddz(
HXme^b
][b[][djb_Y^
DWf_j[b
Wki
i[_d[c
;kY^
(RD
BCO
9RAFC
L?AF
BCK
=RLBCO@?OCL%
7COPNCIQGSCL
BCO
9CJ@PQCOD?FORLE
RLB
=CJQCOICLLQ"
LGP
sbj[h[d
F_j]b_[Z[hd
i[_d[h
EedZed[h
@hkff[d
bWkj
leh][b[i[d
mkhZ[d&
][iY^W^
Z_[i
d_Y^j
dkh
pkh
:dh[]kd]
led
=_iakii_ed[d&
iedZ[hd
WkY^&
kc
ZWi
G_l[Wk
kdZ
Z_[
Bdj[di_jsj
Z[h
khifhud]b_' Y^[d
hkii_iY^[d
@hkff[
pk
Z[cedijh_[h[d(
?eb]b_Y^
atddj[d
Wbb[
;uY^[h
Hkif[diaoi
[^[h
Wbi
>_d\u^hkd]
_d
Z_[
:hX[_j
Z[i
Loij[ci
Z[dd
Wbi
yK[_i[\u^h[hz
Wd][i[^[d
m[hZ[d&
c_j
Z[h[d
A_b\[
i_Y^
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
kdj[hd[^c[d
b_[ii[( =[h
pm[_j[
AWkfjfkdaj
\uh
Hkif[diaoi
Sm[_\[b
Wc
P[hj
led ;uY^[hd
Wbi
E[^h'F_jj[b
mWh
i[_d
[_][d[h
X[jhsY^jb_Y^[h
K[if[aj

leh
Z[h
FWY^j
Z[i
Pehj[i(
:bi
^[hlehhW][dZ[h
CekhdWb_ij
_c
leh' h[lebkj_edsh[d
KkiibWdZ
^Wjj[
Hkif[diao
i[_d[d
E[X[dikdj[h' ^Wbj
c_j
Z[c
Pehj
l[hZ_[dj
kdZ
mWh
i_Y^
ieme^b
Z[ii[d
P_ha' iWca[_j
Wbi
WkY^
Z[h
LY^m_[h_]a[_j
[i
pk
^WdZ^WX[d&
X[mkiij(
:k\
[_d[c
;bWjj
me^b
pkiWcc[d][ij[bbj[
Pehj[
atdd[d
[_d[d
@[ZWda[d
l[hc_jj[bd&
m_[
[i
Z_[
][mt^db_Y^[
K[Z[
d_Y^j
l[h' cW]5
WdZ[h[hi[_ji
aWdd
[_d
c_dZ[h
lebbaecc[d
][iY^h_[X[d[h
LWjp&
[X[d
ZkhY^
i[_d[
O[hiY^mecc[d^[_j&
c[^h
l[hX[h][d
Wbi
[dj^ubb[d(
Hkif[diao
mWh
i_Y^
Z[h
P_Y^j_]a[_j
Z[i
h_Y^j_][d
Pehj[i
_c
h_Y^j_][d
Dedj[nj
ie
X[mkiij&
ZWii
[h
e\jcWbi
[_d
FWdkiah_fj
m_[Z[h
kdZ
m_[Z[h
uX[hWhX[_j[j[&
mWi
dWY^
:X' iY^bkii
Z[h
[hij[d
?Wiikd]
CW^h[
X[WdifhkY^j[(
>_d
jof_iY^[i
;[_if_[b
_ij
i[_d[
Gel[bb[
9QO?LEC
3GDC
MD
0S?L
6PMIGL!
+3*/
][iY^h_[X[d&
WX[h
[hij
+3+/
l[ht\\[djb_Y^j(
O[hiY^_[Z[d[
i[_d[h
;uY^[h&
[_diY^b_[iib_Y^
Z[i
X[aWddj[d
(RD
BCO
9RAFC
L?AF
BCK
=RLBCO@?OCL!
^Wjj[
[h
uX[h^Wkfj
d_[
pkh
O[ht\\[djb_Y^kd]
\h[_' ][][X[d(
(RD
BCO
9RAFC
L?AF
BCK
=RLBCO@?OCL
[hiY^_[d
Wbi
FWdkiah_fj
X[h[_ji
+3,/&
mkhZ[
_d
Z[d
Zh[_ii_][h
CW^h[d
Z[d
F_j]b_[Z[hd
i[_d[h
EedZed[h
@hkff[
bWkj
leh][b[i[d&
ZkhY^b_[\
[_d[
:dpW^b
K[l_i_ed[d
kdZ
mWh
X[_
Hkif[diaoi
MeZ
_c
CW^h[
+3.1
_cc[h
deY^
kdl[ht\\[djb_Y^j( E[kj[&
Z_[
Hkif[diao
]kj
aWddj[d
kdZ
Wd
i[_d[d
Mh[\\[d
e\j
j[_bdW^c[d&
[h_dd[hd
Wd
Z[d
GWY^ZhkYa&
Z[d
[h
Wk\
Z_[
PW^b
Z[i
fWii[dZ[d
Pehj[i
b[]j[&
kc
[_d[d
X[ij_ccj[d
SkijWdZ
pk
Z[\_' d_[h[d&
Wd
i[_d[
P[_][hkd]&
i_Y^
c_j
h[b_]_ti[c
kdZ
f^_beief^_' iY^[c
CWh]ed
[_dpkbWii[d
iem_[
Wd
i[_d[
abWh[
>ha[ddjd_i&
ZWii
`[Z[
;[^Wkfjkd]
_^h[
;[Z[kjkd]
l[hb_[hj&
m[dd
i_[
Wki
_^h[c
SkiWcc[d^Wd]
][decc[d
m_hZ(
>_d[h
i[_d[h
[^[cWb_][d
LY^u' b[h
[habshj[&
ZWii
[h&
m[dd
`[cWdZ
[_d[
?hW][
c_j
yFh(
Hkif[di'
ao
iW]j[
b[jpj[
PeY^[
(((
z
X[]Wdd&
i_Y^
Z_[
?hW][
pk
>dZ[
Wd^thj[
kdZ
ZWdd
\hW]j[&
yWX[h
_d
m[bY^[c
SkiWcc[d^Wd]
iW]j[
_Y^
ZWi9z
L_[
[h_dd[hd
i_Y^
WkY^
i[_d[i
K[if[aj[i
leh
Z[h
h[Y^j
[hiY^h[Ya[dZ[d
:kjeh_jsj
Z[i
l[ht\\[djb_Y^j[d
Pehj[i
'
ZWi
^[_iij
leh
Z[h
:kii_Y^j&
ZWii
[_d[
I^_beief^_[&
[_dcWb
_d
[_d[c
;kY^
\[ij][^Wbj[d&
@[\W^h
bsk\j&
ZWh_d
X[[hZ_]j&
HX`[aj
[dZbei[h
:dWboi[
eZ[h
Wbi
>lWd][b_kc
][decc[d
pk
m[hZ[d&
ie

ZWii
i_[
ie
jej
m_hZ
m_[
Z_[
@[i[jp[
Z[h
F[Z[h
kdZ
I[hi[h(
=W^[h
Hkif[diaoi
>ha[ddjd_i&
m_[
h_iaWdj
Z_[
>djiY^[_Zkd]
_ij&
[_d
;kY^
pk
l[ht\\[djb_Y^[d
kdZ
i[_d[
Oehi_Y^j
^_di_Y^jb_Y^
Z[i
>djiY^bkii[i&
i[_d
[_][d[i
P[ha
pm_iY^[d
\[ij[d
=[Ya[bd
pk
i[^[d( Hkif[diao
mWh
[_d
F[_ij[h
ieme^b
Z[i
][ifheY^[d[d
Wbi
WkY^
Z[i
][iY^h_[X[d[d
Pehj[i(
>h
mWh
_d
[hij[h
E_d_[
[_d
E[^h[h&
kdZ
Z_[
\ud\
:hX[_j[d
_d
Z_[i[c
ab[_d[d
;WdZ
i_dZ
d_Y^j
ZWi
IheZkaj
[_d[i
FWdd[i&
Z[h
pkhuYa][pe][d
[_d[
LjkZ_[
l[h\Wiij&
iedZ[hd
ZWi&[_d[i
E[^h[hi&
Z[h
[_d
Loij[c
led
@[ZWda[d
[hbskj[hj&
Z_[
dkh
c_jj[bi
X[iedd[d[h
?hW][d
i[_j[di
i[_d[h
Sk^th[h
kdZ
_^h[i
Wk\h_Y^j_][d
PkdiY^[i
pk
b[hd[d
Wbbcs^b_Y^
][muhZ_]j
kdZ
h_Y^' j_]
l[hijWdZ[d
m[hZ[d
aeddj[d(
L[Y^ikdZpmWdp_]
CW^h[
bWd]
"+3,+'.1#
b[_j[j[
Hkif[diao
Mh[\\[d&
X[_
Z[d[d
E[kj[&
Z_[
Wd
Z[h
:hX[_j
c_j
Z[c
Loij[c
_dj[h[ii_[hj
mWh[d&
[_d[
]hkdZb[][d' Z[
Oehb[ikd]
^th[d
kdZ
ZWdd
Z[h[d
;[Z[kjkd]
\uh
i_Y^
i[bXij
absh[d
aeddj[d&
_dZ[c
i_[
fhsp_i[
?hW][d
ij[bbj[d
"Z_[
h_Y^j_][
?ehckb_[hkd]
[_d[h
?hW][
mWh
m_Y^j_][h
M[_b
Z[h
L[bXij'SkY^j&
Z_[
Hkif[diao
\ehZ[hj[#(
P_[
i_Y^
[_d[i
Z[h
F_j]b_[Z[h
led
yHz!i
Dh[_i
[h_dd[hj4 =_[
Oehjhs][
i_dZ
\uh
_^d
[_dcWb
mtY^[djb_Y^
uX[h
[_d[d
S[_jhWkc
led
Zh[_
FedWj[d
@hkff[d
led
i[Y^p_]
eZ[h
i_[Xp_]
E[kj[d
leh][b[i[d
mehZ[d(
=_[
Mh[\\[d
ZWk[hj[d
pm[_
Ljkd' Z[d5
][mt^db_Y^
mkhZ[
X[_
`[Z[c
Mh[\\[d
[_d[
^WbX[
E[aj_ed
][b[i[d&
kdZ
ZWdd
mkhZ[
ZWpk
[_d][bWZ[d&
?hW][d
pk
ij[bb[d&
Z_[
Hkif[diao
i[bXij
X[Wdjmehj[j[
(((
Oed
Z[d
c[_ij[d
Mh[\' \[d
Hkif[diaoi
mkhZ[d
ij[de]hW\_iY^[
:k\p[_Y^dkd][d
Wk\' X[mW^hj&
kdZ
pW^bh[_Y^[
:kipu][
Wki
_^d[d
mkhZ[d
dWY^
i[_d[c
MeZ[
pkiWcc[d][ij[bbj
kdZ
Wbi
:FC
-MROQF
=?V
_c
CW^h[
+3/1
l[ht\\[djb_Y^j(
Bd
Z_[i[c
;kY^
\_dZ[j
i_Y^
l_[b LjkZ_[dcWj[h_Wb(((
WX[h
Z_[
@ebZathd[h
i_dZ
iY^m[h
^[hWki' pkf_Ya[d( =[h
lehb_[][dZ[
;WdZ
X[ij[^j
Wki
\ud\
akhp[d
:k\isjp[d&
Z_[
khifhud]b_Y^
dWY^
Hkif[diaoi
MeZ
kdZ
leh
Z[h
SkiWcc[dij[b' b*

bkd]
Z[i
-MROQF
=?V
_d
Z[d
CW^h[d
+3/,'+3//
Wbi
;uY^[h
][' ZhkYaj
mehZ[d
i_dZ(
=_[
;uY^[h
i_dZ
pm[Yai
fh_lWj[h
O[hj[_bkd] ][ZhkYaj
mehZ[d
'
_d
a[_d[c
?Wbb
c[^h
Wbi
Zh[_^kdZ[hj
Def_[d
'
i_[
aWc[d
d_Y^j
_d
Z[d
O[haWk\
kdZ
mWh[d
X_i
ZW^_d
\uh
Z_[
:bb][c[_d^[_j
d_Y^j
[h^sbjb_Y^( P_[
:FC
-MROQF
=?V
ijWccj
Z[h
Bd^Wbj
Z[h
\ud\
;uY^[h
_d
Z_[i[c
;WdZ
Wki
qkii[hkd][d
Hkif[diaoi
Wdbsiib_Y^
i[_d[h
Mh[\\[d5
WdZ[hi
Wbi
_d
Z[h
P[_j[
`[d[i
]htii[h[d
;WdZ[i
aedp[d' jh_[hj
i_Y^
^_[h
`[Z[h
>iiWo
Wk\
[_d[d
m_Y^j_][d
E[^hiWjp
Z[i
Loij[ci&
ie
ZWii
Z_[
y@ebZathd[hz
b[_Y^j[h
y^[hWki][btijz
m[h' Z[d
atdd[d(
=[h
P[hj&
Z_[i[
Dedp[fj[
kdj[h
Z[d
`[m[_b_][d
;[]h_\\
][XhWY^j
kdZ
pkiWcc[d][ij[bbj
pk
\_dZ[d&
X[ij[^j
ZWh_d&
ZWii
Z_[
:k\isjp[
_di][iWcj
Z_[
fhWaj_iY^
fioY^ebe]_iY^[
L[_j[
Z[i
led
Hkif[diao
l[hc_jj[bj[d
Loij[ci
WXZ[Ya[d5
i[fWhWj
][' decc[d&
aWdd
`[Z[h
>iiWo
_d
[_d[h
[_dp_][d
L_jpkd]
[h\Wiij
m[hZ[d
kdZ
iec_j
Wbi
yLY^buii[bz
Z_[d[d&
kc
i_Y^
Z[c
K[_Y^jkc
Wd
FWj[h_Wb
pk
ds^[hd&
Z[h
_d
Hkif[diaoi
Wki\u^hb_Y^[h[d
;u' Y^[hd
[dj^Wbj[d
_ij(
@htiij[
Leh]\Wbj
mWbj[j[
X[_
Z[h
:kimW^b
led
IWiiW][d
Wki
:XiY^h_\j[d
Z[h
Mh[\\[d
Hkif[diaoi&
kc
i_[
Wk\
bWd][
L_Y^j
^[hWkipk][X[d
kdZ
kc
O[hp[hhkd]
eZ[h
:kiiY^cua'
akd]
Z[h
@[ZWda[d
Hkif[diaoi
pk
l[hc[_Z[d(
Bd
dW^[pk
`[Z[c
?Wbb[
mkhZ[d
Hkif[diaoi
Decc[djWh[
ymthjb_Y^z
Wk\][p[_Y^' d[j(
GWjuhb_Y^
iebbj[
cWd
ZWhWd
Z[da[d&
ZWii
Z_[
SkiWcc[d' aud\j[&
Wki
Z[d[d
Z_[
F_jiY^h_\j[d
ijWcc[d&
i_Y^
uX[h
[_d[d
S[_jhWkc
led
dW^[pk
Zh[_ii_]
CW^h[d
[hijh[Ya[d
kdZ
ZWii
Hki'
f[diao
i[_d[
Oehij[bbkd][d
ms^h[dZ
Z_[i[h
CW^h[
[hm[_j[hj[&
l[hj_[\j[
kdZ
l[hX[ii[hj[(
:kii[hZ[c
^sd]j
ZWi
lebbijsdZ_][
O[hij[^[d
[_d_][h
;[]h_\\[&
Z_[
_d
Z_[i[d
:k\isjp[d
l[hm[dZ[j
mehZ[d
i_dZ&
led
yif[p_[bb[d
;[Z[kjkd][d
_d
SkiWcc[d^Wd]
c_j
[_d[c
Loij[c
Z[i
O_[hj[d
P[]i&
ZWi
Hkif[diao
b[^hj[z&
WX(
P[h
[_d[d
pkiWcc[d^sd][dZ[d
rX[hXb_Ya
uX[h
Hkif[diaoi
I^_beief^_[
eZ[h
[_d[
m[_j[h\u^h[dZ[
:kiWhX[_jkd]
Z[h
;[Z[k' jkd]
X[ij_ccj[h
;[]h_\\[&
Z_[
_d
Z_[i[c
;kY^
l[hmWdZj
m[hZ[d&
ikY^j&
iebbj[
led
Z_[i[d
yIheX[dz
pk
i[_d[d
Wki\u^hb_Y^[h[d
;uY^[hd
uX[h][^[d&
Z_[
,GL
LCRCP
4MBCJJ
BCP
;LGSCOPRKP&
(RD
BCO
9RAFC
L?AF
BCK
=RLBCO@?OCL%
7COPNCIQGSCL
BCO
9CJ@PQCO" ""

ICLLQLGP
RLB
=CJQCOD?FORLE&
kdZ
n_ij[dp
ij[Yaj&
Wbi
Z_[
[_djtd_][d
Fkij[h
Z[i
:bbjW]ib[X[di
pk
[dj^ubb[d
iY^[_d[d(
FWd
aeccj
d_Y^j
kc^_d&
i_Y^
X[_if_[bim[_i[
led
Hkif[diaoi
[_dZh_d]b_Y^[d
Pehj[d
Wk\
Z[d
[hij[d
L[_j[d
led
,OGLLCORLEPSCOK[ECL
Wd][' ifheY^[d
pk
\u^b[d4 =[h
F[diY^
^Wj
][b[][djb_Y^[
:k][dXb_Ya[
led
L[bXijX[' mkiiji[_d&
WX[h
[h
^Wj
a[_d[
@[mWbj
uX[h
i_[(
L_[
aecc[d
kdZ
][^[d&
X[^[hhiY^j
led
skii[h[d
NcijsdZ[d
kdZ
][b[][djb_' Y^[d
:iiep_Wj_ed[d
kdZ
@[\u^b[d(
=_[
?hW][
[h^[Xj
i_Y^4
Bij
[i
ct]b_Y^&
A[hhiY^W\j
uX[h
Z_[i[
\buY^j_][d
:k][dXb_Ya[
led
;[mkiiji[_d
pk
[hbWd][d&
i_[
t\j[h
^[hlehpkhk\[d
kdZ
i_[
bsd][h
pk
[h^Wbj[d
eZ[h
i_[
ie]Wh
f[hcWd[dj
pk
cWY^[d9 L[_j
Z[c
Sm[_j[d
P[bjah_[]
]_Xj
[i
dWjuhb_Y^
[_d
ij[j_][i
PWY^' i[d
Z[i
t\\[djb_Y^[d
Bdj[h[ii[i
Wc
LjkZ_kc
Z[i
y;[mkiiji[_diz&
d_Y^j
m_[
[i
Z_[
F[Z_p_d
Z[\_d_[hj&
iedZ[hd
Wbi
[jmWi
WdZ[h[i
'
[_d
@[mW^hi[_d
kdZ
:k\d[^c[d
[_d[h
P[bj
uX[h
kdZ
`[di[_ji
kdi[h[h
][mt^db_Y^[d
>h\W^hkd](
Oeh
Wbb[c
_d
Z[d
b[jpj[d
pmWd' p_]
CW^h[d
^WX[d
m_h
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
M[Y^d_a[d
Wk\jWkY^[d
i[^[d&
Z_[
l[hikY^[d&
Z_[
At^[
Z[i
;[mkiiji[_di
eZ[h
Z[i
yL[_diz
pk
^[X[d5
M[Y^d_a[d&
Z_[
=he][d
l[hm[dZ[d
X_i
^_d
pk
`[d[d&
Z_[
]Wdp
eZ[h
j[_bm[_i[
Wk\
Z[d
Wbj[d
tijb_Y^[d
K[b_]_ed[d
X[hk^[d(
Skisjpb_Y^
p_[^j
i_Y^
ZkhY^
Z_[
ie][dWddj[d
yWd[haWddj[d
P_i' i[diY^W\j[dz
[_d
[hd[k[hj[i
kdZ
[hdij^W\j[i
LjkZ_kc
Wk\
Z[d
@[X_[j[d&
Z_[
[_dij
Wbi
Z[c
Haakbj[d
pk][^th_]
[j_a[jj_[hj "#

mkhZ[d4
Wkii[hi_ddb_Y^[
PW^hd[^ckd]&
fioY^_iY^[
I^sdec[d[&
d[k[
=_c[di_ed[d&
;_e\[[ZXWYa&
M[b[fWj^_[
kdZ
WdZ[h[
@[X_[' j[&
Z_[
[_dij
Wbi
;[h[_Y^
Z[h
PW^hiW][h
kdZ
LY^WhbWjWd[
Wd][i[^[d
mkhZ[d(
FWd
atddj[
iW][d&
ZWii
Z_[
][iWcj[
^[kj_][
P[bj
m_[Z[h
pk
Z[h
;[eXWY^jkd]
pkhuYaa[^hj&
Z_[
leh
l_[h^kdZ[hj
CW^h[d
_d
/?KJCQ
][cWY^j
mkhZ[4
y>i
]_Xj
c[^h
=_d]!
_c
A_cc[b
kdZ
Wk\
>hZ[d&
Wbi
[kh[
LY^kbm[_i^[_j
i_Y^
jhskc[d
bsiij(z :ki
Z_[i[d
@hudZ[d
_ij
[i
^[kj[
Wd][XhWY^j&
Z_[i[
\ud\
;u' Y^[h
m_[Z[h
^[hWkipk][X[d&
pk
[_d[h
S[_j&
ZW
ZWi
Bdj[h[ii[
Wd
I(=(
Hkif[diao
kdZ
WdZ[h[d
I^_beief^[d
m_[Z[h[hmWY^j&
Z_[&
[_dij
Wkii[h^WbX
Z[i
Xh[_j[d
Ljheci&
leh
bWd][h
S[_j
iW]j[d&
ZWii
[i
y[_d
P_ii[d
]_Xj&
ZWi
Wbb[i
][mt^db_Y^[
c[diY^b_Y^[
P_ii[d
uX[hjh_\\j
kdZ
Z[c
=khY^iY^d_jjic[diY^[d
kdpk]sd]b_Y^
_ij&
ZWi
WX[h
_h][dZme
[n_ij_[hj
kdZ
`[cWdZ[c
][^thjz(
Hkif[diaoi
LY^h_\j[d&
Z_[
dkd
_d
Z[h
LWccbkd]
led
FWdkiah_fj[d
kdZ
NhakdZ[d
Z[h
;uY^[h[_
Z[h
RWb[
Nd_l[hi_jsj
WkbX[mW^hj
i_dZ
"Z_[
I(
=(
Hkif[diao
@[ZsY^jd_i
LWccbkd]
mkhZ[
D[dd[hd
Wdbsiib_Y^
[_d[h
kc\Wii[dZ[d
:kiij[bbkd]
_c
HajeX[h
+312
pk' ]sd]b_Y^
][cWY^j#
X[p[k][d
Wki\u^hb_Y^&
ZWii
I(
=(H(
kdZ
i[_d[
yE[kj[z
dWY^
[_d[c
P[]
ikY^j[d&
^t^[h[i
P_ii[d
pk
[hh[_Y^[d&
bWd][
X[leh
Z_[i
ceZ[hd
'
eZ[h
ie]Wh
Wap[fjWX[b
mkhZ[(
GeY^
l[hbWd]j[
ZWi
;[\eb][d
Z[i
yO_[hj[d
P[][iz
\_dWdp_[bb[
;[_jhs' ][&
>_ddW^c[
led
=he][d
eZ[h
ie]Wh
iabWl_iY^[i
:ap[fj_[h[d
Z[h
=Whij[bbkd][d&
Z_[
Hkif[diao
i[bXij
]WX
'
_d
Z[h
MWj
[h_d' d[hj
i_Y^
[_d[h
i[_d[h
Dh[_i[4
y>h
\ehZ[hj[
kdi
Wk\&
a[_d[
BZ[[d
pk
Wap[fj_[h[d&
Z_[
d_Y^j
_d
Z[h
IhWn_i
X[m_[i[d
m[hZ[d
aedd' j[d(z
:X[h
kdX[Z_d]j
dejm[dZ_]
mWh
Z_[
;[h[_jiY^W\j&
i[_d
[_][' d[i
c[Y^Wd_iY^[i
?kdaj_ed_[h[d
kdZ
ZWi
?[^b[d
[_d[i
kc\Wii[d' Z[d
;[mkiiji[_di
pk
Wap[fj_[h[d
iem_[
Z[d
P_bb[d&
i_Y^
i[_d[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd&
Wk\pkX_[j[d&
kc
ZWi
[_d[
pk
uX[hm_dZ[d
kdZ
ZWi
WdZ[h[
pk
[hbWd][d(
=[h
E[i[h&
Z[h
Z[d
m_Z[hijh[_j[dZ[d
S_[b[d
kdZ
F[j^eZ[d
l_[b[h
^[kj_][h
Dkbj[
kdZ
I^_beief^_[d
l[hm_hhj
][][duX[hij[^j&
iebbj[
_d
Z[d
S_[b[d
Hkif[diaoi&
m_[
i_[
_d
9AFCGLNCOP[LJGAFICGQ
Wki][ZhuYaj
i_dZ&
[_d[
m_bbaecc[d[
DbWh^[_j
\_dZ[d4
y=Wi
S_[b
Z_[i[i
Loij[ci
_ij&
Z[d
F[diY^[d
pkc
;[mkiiji[_d
pk
\u^h[d(z "$

=[h
E[i[h
m_hZ
Z[d
c[_ij[d
Gkjp[d
Wki
Z_[i[d
\ud\
akhp[d
:hX[_j[d
Hkif[diaoi
p_[^[d&
m[dd
[h
i_[
b_[ij&
WdijWjj
\@CO
i_[
pk
b[i[d4
=[ddeY^
[_d
fWWh
adWff[
>hbskj[hkd][d4 ,OGLLCORLEPSCOK[ECL%
(RPW\EC
?RP
BCL
8CBCL
RLB
9AFOGDQCL
SML
7#+#
$#
\@CO
,OGLLCORLEPSCOK[ECL!
9CJ@PQ",OGLLCOL
RLB
=GCBCO"
ICFO P_[
Z_[
WdZ[h[d
:hX[_j[d
_d
Z_[i[c
;WdZ
mkhZ[
,OGLLC" ORLEPSCOK[ECL
X[_
Ljekhjed
Ih[ii
_d
_][d' i_dd
"y[jmWi
jkd
pk
mebb[d&
[_d\WY^&
m[_b
m_h
[i
d_Y^j
jkd
iebb' j[dz#(
;[_Z[
[djifh_d][d
cec[djWd[d
PudiY^[d
Z[h
l_[b[d
yBY^iz
eZ[h
yL[bXij[z&
Wki
Z[d[d
Z[h
F[diY^
X[ij[^j(
PW^h[h
P_bb[
\_dZ[j
i_Y^
dkh
_d
X[mkiij[d
F[diY^[d
kdZ
_ij
[_d
S_[b&
ZWi
ZkhY^
ZWi
Loij[c
[hbWd]j
m[hZ[d
aWdd5
m_h
[hm[hX[d
P_bb[d&
_dZ[c
m_h
kdi
c_jj[bi
Z[i
Loij[ci
_d
:hX[_j
uX[d&
_d
[_d[h
LY^kbi_jkWj_ed(
>_][dm_bb[
kdZ
>_][di_dd
i_dZ
X[iedZ[hi
iY^m[h
pk
X[i[_j_][d&
Z[dd
i_[
i_dZ
M[_b
kdi[h[h
Bbbki_ed&
ZWii
m_h
X[h[_ji
X[mkiij
i_dZ
kdZ
yjkdz
atdd[d&
ZWi
^[_iij&
[^[h
[jmWi
Wki
kdWX^sd]_][h
:Xi_Y^j
pkijWdZ[
pk
Xh_d][d
Wbi
Wki
[_d[h
c[Y^Wd_' iY^[d&
h[\b[n^W\j[d
K[Waj_ed
Wk\
skii[h[
>_d\buii[( ,GLC
9VLQFCPC
?RP
CGLGECL
8CBCL
RLB
9AFOGDQCL
SML
7#+#
6#
\@CO
B?P
:FCK?%
5CE?QGSC
.CD\FJC =_[i[
:hX[_j&
khifhud]b_Y^
+3/-
][ZhkYaj&
mWh
kdl[ht\\[dj' "&

b_Y^j[d
K[Z[d
kdZ
LY^h_\j[d
I(=(H(!i
[djdecc[d&
c_j
:kidW^' c[
[_d_][h
;[]h_\\i[hbskj[hkd][d&
Z_[
Wki
Z[d
fh_lWj
l[ht\\[dj' b_Y^j[d
7PVAFMJMEGPAFCL
3CPRLECL!
+3-.'.*&
ijWcc[d(
yG[]Wj_' l[
@[\u^b[z
i_dZ
Wbb[
@[\u^b[
Z[h
@[mWbj
eZ[h
=[fh[ii_ed(
Hkif[diao
X[^Wkfj[j[&
iebY^[
@[\u^b[
i[_[d
dkjpbei
kdZ
p[hijt' h[h_iY^&
kdZ
ZWii
i_[
jhejp
kdi[h[h
ZWi
@[][dj[_b
X[^Wkfj[dZ[d
Ihej[ij[
d_Y^j
Wk\]hkdZ
skii[h[h
IheleaWj_ed[d
Wk\jhsj[d&
ied' Z[hd
Wki
kdi
i[bXij
ijWcc[d(
P_[
WkY^
_cc[h&
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
i_dZ
audijb_Y^
'
i_[
[djifh_d][d
Z[h
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
"kdi[h[h
Nd\s' ^_]a[_j&
kdi
i[bXij
led
@[][dijsdZ[d&
E[kj[d
eZ[h
>cej_ed[d
kc
kdi
^[hkc
pk
Z_ijWdp_[h[d#
kdZ
atdd[d
ZW^[h
p[hijthj
m[h' Z[d&
ieXWbZ
m_h
i_[
X[c[ha[d
kdZ
i_[
c_jj[bi
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
pk
X[i[_j_][d
l[hikY^[d(
=[h
[hij[
LY^h_jj
pkh
>dj\[hdkd]
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[
X[ij[^j
ZWh_d&
i_[
_d
_^h[c
:kiZhkYa
pk
X[iY^hsda[d5
m[dd
Z_[i
][iY^_[^j&
m_hZ
[i
ct]b_Y^&
Wd
Z_[
Pkhp[bd
Z[h
d[]Wj_' l[d
@[\u^b[
i[bXij
pk
hu^h[d( )CKCOIRLECL
WRO
(O@CGQ )CKCOIRLECL
WRO
(O@CGQ!
pk[hij
+3/,
][ZhkYaj&
X[ij[^j
Wki
Zh[_
akhp[d
:k\isjp[d4
y;[c[hakd][d
pkc
>djiY^bkii
pk
WhX[_' j[dz&
y;[c[hakd][d
pkh
:hX[_j
Wd
i_Y^
i[bXijz
kdZ
yPWi
_ij
Z_[
LY^kb[9z(
:bb[
X[\Wii[d
i_Y^
c_j
Z[c
@hWZ
_dZ_l_Zk[bb[h
O[h' f\b_Y^jkd]&
Z_[
led
`[cWdZ[c
l[hbWd]j
m_hZ&
Z[h
Z_[
:hX[_j
_c
Loij[c
X[]_ddj(
=_[
AWkfjXejiY^W\j
Z[h
)CKCOIRLECL
WRO
(O" @CGQ
_ij
_d
Hkif[diaoi
[_db[_j[dZ[c
:XiY^d_jj
[dj^Wbj[d4
y=[d' a[d
L_[
i[^h
[hdij^W\j
dWY^&
X[leh
L_[
i_Y^
[djiY^b_[ii[d&
Wd
i_Y^
c_j
Z[h
:Xi_Y^j
pk
WhX[_j[d&
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
sdZ[hd
(((
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
bsiij
a[_d[
Decfhec_ii[
pk
kdZ
l[hbWd]j
[_d[
]heii[
F[d][
L[bXij'=_ip_fb_d
kdZ
;[h[_jiY^W\j&
Wbb[d
K[][bd
pk
][^eh' Y^[d
(((
z =_[i[
\ud\
;uY^[h
mkhZ[d
lehcWbi
_d
i[^h
X[]h[dpj[h
F[d][
][ZhkYaj
kdZ
[_d[h
ab[_d[d
@hkff[
led
E[kj[d
pk]sd]b_Y^
][' cWY^j&
Z_[
i_Y^
i[_j
CW^h[d
Z[c
LjkZ_kc
Z[h
I^_beief^_[
Hki'
f[diaoi
][m_Zc[j
^Wjj[d(
=[h
>djiY^bkii&
,OGLLCORLEPSCOK["
ECL!
9AFCGLNCOP[LJGAFICGQ!
,GECLTGJJC!
5CE?QGSC
.CD\FJC
kdZ
)C" "'

KCOIRLECL
WRO
(O@CGQ
d[k
pk
ZhkYa[d&
kc
i_[
[_d[c
]htii[h[d
E[i[hah[_i
lehpkij[bb[d&
X[hk^j
Wk\
[_d[h
[hd[kj[d
t\\[djb_Y^[d
;[][_ij[hkd]&
Z_[
i_Y^
]htiij[dj[_bi
_d
?ehc
led
GWY^\hW][d
uX[h
Z_[
I(
=(
Hkif[diao
@[ZsY^jd_i
LWccbkd]
_d
Z[h
;_Xb_ej^[a
Z[h
RWb[
Nd_l[hi_jsj
skii[hj(
>i
Xb[_Xj
pk
^e\\[d&
ZWii
Z_[
O_[b[d&
Z_[
Hkif[diao
^_[hZkhY^
kdZ
Wk\
WdZ[h[d
P[][d
X[][]' d[j
i_dZ&
ZkhY^
Z_[
>djZ[Yakd]
Z_[i[h
X[c[ha[dim[hj[d
d[k[d
LWccbkd]
[_d[
j_[\[h[
>_di_Y^j
_d
I(=(H(
'
kdZ
i_Y^
i[bXij
'
[hbWd][d
m[hZ[d( 4COOGJV
,#
:?VJMO

"(

/KEIIAKNICLOAKHRCAI

(RPW\EC
?RP
BCL
8CBCL
RLB
9AFOGDQCL
7#
+#
6RPNCLPIVP
\@CO
,OGLLCORLEPSCOK[ECL!
9CJ@PQ",OGLLCOL
RLB
=GCBCOICFO

"*

&138135

=_[
:Xi_Y^j
Z[i
DWf_j[bi
,OGLLCORLEPSCOK[ECL
_ij
[i&
pkiWc' c[dpkij[bb[d&
mWi
Hkif[diao
uX[h
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d&
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
kdZ
P_[Z[ha[^h
][ifheY^[d
kdZ
][iY^h_[X[d
^Wj(
=[h
Bd^Wbj
led
,OGLLCORLEPSCOK[ECL
_ij
d_Y^j
[dZ]ubj_]&
iedZ[hd
iebb
ZWi
[h]sdp[d&
mWi
Hkif[diao
uX[h
Z_[i[
M^[c[d
_d
:COQGRK
6OE?LRK
kdZ
,GL
LCRCP
4MBCJJ
BCP
;LGSCOPRKP
iY^h_[X(
,OGLLCORLEPSCOK[ECL
aWdd
d_Y^j
e^d[
;[pk]
Wk\
`[d[
;uY^[h
l[hijWdZ[d
m[hZ[d
kdZ
e^d[
Hkif[diaoi
Loij[c&
Z[d
O_[hj[d
P[]
pk
ijkZ_[h[d&
pk
a[dd[d( =_[
[hij[d
l_[h
:XiY^d_jj[
Z_[i[i
;kY^[i
\_dZ[d
i_Y^
_d
b[_Y^j
kdj[hiY^_[Zb_Y^[h
?ehc
_d
h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d&
eZ[h
:k][d' Xb_Ya[
Z[i
>h_dd[hdi
X[jh_\\j&
ie
[h_dd[hd
m_h
kdi
dkh
Z[h
:k][d' Xb_Ya[
Z[i
;[mkiiji[_di&
eXme^b
m_h
d_Y^j
i[^[d&
ZWii
Z[c
ie
_ij( PWi
@[ZsY^jd_i
_c
j[Y^d_iY^[d
L_dd[
X[Z[kj[j&
m[hZ[
_Y^
ifsj[h
[habsh[d(
Gkd
ctY^j[
_Y^
[_d\WY^&
ZWii
L_[
B^h[
:k\c[ha' iWca[_j
Wk\
B^h[
[_][d[d
;[eXWY^jkd][d
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
ZWi
>h_d' d[hkd]il[hct][d
b[da[d(
L_[
m[hZ[d
X[c[ha[d&
ZWii
L_[
=_d][
kdj[hiY^_[Zb_Y^
[h_dd[hd4
:d
[_d_][i
[h_dd[hd
L_[
i_Y^
deY^
h[Y^j
b[X^W\j&
Wd
WdZ[h[i
i[^h
lW][
kdZ
Wd
[_d_][
=_d][
[h_dd[hd
L_[
i_Y^
uX[h^Wkfj
d_Y^j(
L_[
TGPPCL
b[Z_]b_Y^&
ZWii
i_[
ijWjj\WdZ[d( =Wi
^[_iij&
m[dd
L_[
pkc
;[_if_[b
m_ii[d&
ZWii
L_[
leh
[_d_][h
S[_j
Wd
[_d[d
X[ij_ccj[d
Hhj
]_d][d&
kc
c_j
`[cWdZ[c
pk
ifh[Y^[d&
ie
ct][d
L_[
i_Y^
l_[bb[_Y^j
Wd
pm[_
eZ[h
Zh[_
=_d][
[h_dd[hd&
Z_[
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
pk
B^h[c
@[ifhsY^
c_j
Z_[i[h
I[hied
ij[^[d5
WX[h
ct]b_Y^[hm[_i[
[h_dd[hd
L_[
i_Y^
uX[h^Wkfj
d_Y^j&
m_[
L_[
Zehj^_d
][bWd]j[d
eZ[h
m_[
L_[
pkhuYaaWc[d(
P[dd
cWd
L_[
dkd
\hW]j&
eX
L_[
i_Y^
[h_dd[hd&
m_[
L_[
Zehj^_d
aWc[d
kdZ
m_[Z[h
pkhuYaa[^hj[d&
ie
m[hZ[d
L_[
iW][d&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
Z[kjb_Y^
[h_dd[hd&
ms^h[dZ
L_[
[i
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
b[Z_]b_Y^
m_ii[d #$

kdZ
TGPPCL!
me^_d
L_[
]_d][d5
WX[h
L_[
COGLLCOL
i_Y^
d_Y^j&
Wki][decc[d
led
[l[djk[bb
pm[_
eZ[h
Zh[_
@[ZsY^jd_iXb_jp[d( L_[
m[hZ[d
[hijWkdj
i[_d&
m[dd
L_[
[ha[dd[d&
Wd
m_[
m[d_]
L_[
i_Y^
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
[h_dd[hd(
NdZ
[i
][iY^_[^j
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj&
m[_b
L_[
i_Y^
LRO
BCO
(RECL@JGAIC
COGLLCOL!
GL
BCLCL
9GC
@CTRPPQ
T?OCL#
L_[
m[hZ[d
X[ii[h
l[hij[^[d&
mWi
_Y^
c[_d[&
m[dd
L_[
l[hikY^[d&
B^h[d
@[_ij
ie
m[_j
L_[
atdd[d
Wk\
B^h[
\hu^[
D_dZ' ^[_j
pkhuYapkb[da[d&
eZ[h
Wk\
`[Z[d
?Wbb
Wk\
[jmWi&
ZWi
leh
bWd][h
S[_j
][iY^W^(
=Wdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
[ha[dd[d&
Wd
m_[
m[d_]
L_[
i_Y^
jWjisY^b_Y^
[h_dd[hd
kdZ
m_[l_[b
[i
]_Xj&
led
Z[c
L_[
b[Z_]b_Y^
TGPPCL
eZ[h
ECF[OQ
F?@CL!
B?PP
CP
PQ?QQD?LB# =W^[h
atdd[d
m_h
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Z[d
Zh_jj[d
;[mkiiji[_dipk' ijWdZ
iW][d&
ZWii
Z[h
F[diY^
][b[][djb_Y^[
:k][dXb_Ya[
led
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_d
^Wj&
`[ZeY^
aWdd
[h
Z_[i[
d_Y^j
X[^[hhiY^[d(
L_[
aecc[d
kdZ
][^[d
led
i[bXij&
kdZ
m[hZ[d
led
skii[h[d
NcijsdZ[d
kdZ
][b[][djb_Y^[d
:iiep_Wj_ed[d
eZ[h
@[\u^b[d
X[ij_ccj( =_[
?hW][
jWkY^j
Wk\4
Bij
[i
ct]b_Y^&
A[hhiY^W\j
uX[h
Z_[i[
\buY^j_][d
:k][dXb_Ya[
led
;[mkiiji[_d
pk
[hbWd][d&
i_[
t\j[h
^[hlehpkhk\[d
kdZ
bsd][h
pk
^Wbj[d&
eZ[h
i_[
ie]Wh
f[hcWd[dj
pk
cWY^[d9

=[h
[hij[
eZ[h
d_[Zh_]ij[
;[mkiiji[_dipkijWdZ
_ij
LY^bW\
(((
=[h
F[diY^
_ij
led
Mhskc[d
kc][X[d
(((
K[_d
ikX`[aj_l[
;_bZ[h
'
[djm[Z[h
Lf_[][bkd][d
\hu^[h[h
>h\W^hkd][d
eZ[h
Lf_[][bkd][d
lW][h
PW^hd[^ckd][d
Z[i
:k][dXb_Yai&
m_[
@[hskiY^[&
Z_[
Z[d
LY^bW\[dZ[d
[hh[_Y^[d&
>cf\_dZkd][d&
Z_[
Wki
Z[c
Dthf[h
ijWcc[d&
b[_Y^j[h[
LY^c[hp[d&
O[hifWddkd]i][\u^b[
'
\b_[][d
ZkhY^
Z[d
@[_ij
"F_dZ#
kdZ
^_dj[hbWii[d
dkh
[_d[
i[^h
iY^mWY^[
Lfkh
_c
@[ZsY^jd_i
kdZ
e\j
uX[h^Wkfj
]Wh
a[_d[( =[h
pm[_j[
;[mkiiji[_dipkijWdZ
jh_jj
Wk\&
m[dd
Z[h
F[diY^
[hmWY^j(
=_[i[d
pm[_j[d
SkijWdZ
'
Z[h
SkijWdZ&
_d
Z[c
m_h
`[jpj
i_dZ5
Z[d
SkijWdZ&
_d
Z[c
m_h
WhX[_j[d&
ifh[Y^[d&
kdi
\uh #%

X[mkiij[
P[i[d
^Wbj[d
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h
'
X[p[_Y^d[d
m_h
][mt^d' b_Y^
Wbi
yPWY^';[mkiiji[_dz
eZ[h
yabWh[i
;[mkiiji[_dz&
WX[h
[h
iebbj[
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
yPWY^'LY^bW\z
eZ[h
yh[bWj_l[i
;[mkiij' i[_dz
^[_ii[d( Bc
SkijWdZ
Z[i
LY^bW\i
atdd[d
m_h
LY^_cc[h
h[bWj_l[d
;[' mkiiji[_di
^WX[d(
Bc
SkijWdZ
Z[i
h[bWj_l[d
;[mkiiji[_di
atd' d[d
m_h
LY^_cc[h
led
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_d
^WX[d(
:X[h
m[dd
m_h
Wki][Z[^dj[h[
I[h_eZ[d
led
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_d
kdZ
d_Y^j
dkh
\buY^j_][
>_dXb_Ya[
^WX[d
mebb[d&
cuii[d
m_h
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
i_[
d_Y^j
led
Wbb[_d[
aecc[d
atdd[d(
L_[
[h\ehZ[hd
TGJJCLQJGAFCP
/?LBCJL#
=Wi
^[_iij&
ZWii
Ask\_]a[_j
kdZ
=Wk[h
led
:k][dXb_a'
a[d
Z[i
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_di
led
Z[h
A[hhiY^W\j
WX^sd][d&
Z_[
cWd
uX[h
i_Y^
i[bXij
^Wj(
=W^[h
X[Z[kj[j
Z_[i
WkY^&
ZWii
;[' mkiiji[_d
kdZ
P_bb[
dW^[pk
[_d
kdZ
ZWii[bX[
i_dZ
eZ[h
Wk\
`[Z[d
?Wbb
:if[aj[
Z[h
i[bX[d
LWY^[( Gkd
cuii[d
m_h
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
ZWi
[hij[
A_dZ[hd_i
Wk\
Z[c
P[][
pkh
>djm_Yabkd]
Z[i
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_di
_c
F[diY^[d
i[_d[
rX[hp[k]kd]
_ij&
Z_[i[i
X[h[_ji
pk
X[i_jp[d
eZ[h
[i
pkc_d' Z[ij
_d
Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya
^WX[d
pk
atdd[d&
_d
Z[c
[h
[i
mudiY^j(
>i
_ij
i[^h
iY^m[h&
[_d[d
F[diY^[d
ZWled
pk
uX[hp[k][d&
ZWii
[h
d_Y^j
X[mkiij
_ij
kdZ
d_Y^j
dWY^
;[b_[X[d
X[mkiij
m[hZ[d
aWdd(
>i
_ij
Z_[i
X[iedZ[hi
iY^m[h&
ZW
_^c
Z_[
GWjkh
^_[h
[_d[d
i[bjiWc[d
Ljh[_Y^
if_[bj(
P[dd
L_[
`[cWdZ[d
\hW][d&
eX
[h
X[mkiij
_ij&
eZ[h
m[dd
L_[
_^c
iW][d&
[h
i[_
d_Y^j
X[mkiij&
m_hZ
[h
Wdjmehj[d&
ZWii
[h
ltbb_]
X[mkiij
i[_
kdZ
[i
WXikhZ
msh[
pk
iW][d&
[h
i[_
[i
d_Y^j&
ZW
[h
L_[
ZeY^
^th[
kdZ
l[hij[^[(
NdZ
[h
m_hZ
lebbaecc[d
h[Y^j
^WX[d&
Z[dd
B^h[
?hW][
eZ[h
;[c[hakd]
^Wj
_^d
[_d[d
:k][dXb_Ya
bWd]
lW][
X[mkiij
][cWY^j(
Bc
dsY^' ij[d
:k][dXb_Ya
m_hZ
ZWi
;[mkiiji[_d
m_[Z[h
l[hiY^m_dZ[d(
:X[h
[h
m_hZ
i_Y^
Z[ii[d
[h_dd[hd&
mWi
L_[
_^c
iW]j[d
kdZ
mWi
[h
Wdjmehj[j[&
kdZ
[h
m_hZ
i_Y^
][m_ii
Wbi
X[mkiij
[hWY^j[d( Bd
P_hab_Y^a[_j
[h\ehZ[hj
ZWi
>hbWd][d
led
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_d
[_d[
bWd][
kdZ
^Whj[
:hX[_j(
P_[
atddj[
[_d
F[diY^
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
X[`W^[d&
m[dd
[h
][dWk
ZWi
X[h[_ji
pk
X[i_jp[d
]bWkXj&
mWi
cWd
_^c
Wbi
>h][Xd_i
bWd][h
kdZ
^Whj[h
:hX[_j
l[hifh_Y^j9
GWjuhb_Y^
m_hZ
a[_d
F[diY^
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
kdj[hd[^c[d
kdZ
i_[ #&

Wbi
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
[hWY^j[d&
X_i
[h
ZWled
uX[hp[k]j
_ij&
ZWii
[h
m[Z[h
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_d
X[i_jpj
deY^
Wbb
ZWi&
mWi
ZWc_j
l[hXkd' Z[d
_ij&
m_[
>_d^[_j
eZ[h
BdZ_l_ZkWb_jsj&
[_d
X[ijsdZ_][i
yBY^z
kdZ
Z[d
P_bb[d(

 "Nc
Z[d
\eb][dZ[d
:XiY^d_jj
l[hij[^[d
pk
atdd[d&
ckii
cWd
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
Z_[
uXb_Y^[
:diY^Wkkd]&
Z[h
F[diY^
^WX[
dkh
[_d[d
@[_ij
TZ[d
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[d
@[_ijU
\WbiY^
_ij(
Bd
P_hab_Y^a[_j
_ij
ZWi
G[hl[dioij[c
Z[d
?kdaj_ed[d
Z[i
Dthf[hi
dWY^
kdj[h' j[_bj&
kdZ
`[Z[h
M[_b
X[i_jpj
i[_d[d
[_][d[d
@[_ij
TF_dZU(
Hki'
f[diaoi
@[XhWkY^
Z[i
Pehj[i
yS[djhkcz
kdj[hiY^[_Z[j
i_Y^
led
Z[h
][][dmshj_][d
m_ii[diY^W\jb_Y^[d
;[Z[kjkd]&
Z[dd
[i
kc' \Wiij
ieme^b
Z[d
X[iedZ[h[d&
aedjhebb_[h[dZ[d
@[_ij
Wbi
WkY^
Z_[
G[hl[d
kdZ
Z_[
kdj[h][ehZd[j[d
:d^sk\kd][d
led
G[hl[dp[b' b[d&
Z_[
_^d
c_j
WdZ[h[d
M[_b[d
Z[i
Dthf[hi
l[hX_dZ[d(# P_h
cuii[d
[h]hudZ[d&
mWhkc
m_h
kdi
e^d[
[_d[
bWd][
I[h_eZ[
led
LY^kbWhX[_j
d_Y^j
iY^d[bb[h
[djm_Ya[bd
atdd[d(
P_h
m_ii[d&
ZWii
m_h
d[k[i
FWj[h_Wb
_d
kdi[h[c
@[ZsY^jd_i
WdiWcc[bd&
m[dd
m_h
[jmWi
b[hd[d(
:X[h
mWi
_ij
kdi[h
@[ZsY^jd_i9
NdZ
mWi
_ij
d[k[i
FWj[h_Wb9 Nc
Z_[i
pk
l[hij[^[d&
cuii[d
m_h
`[Z[i
S[djhkc
Wbi
[_d[
][iedZ[hj[
kdZ
kdWX^sd]_][
FWiY^_d[
pk
X[jhWY^j[d
b[hd[d&
Z_[
Wki
[cf\_dZb_Y^[c
Lje\\
X[ij[^j&
led
i[_d[h
?kdaj_ed
^[h
Z[h
LkXijWdp
s^db_Y^&
Wki
Z[h
LY^WbbfbWjj[d
X[ij[^[d(
:bb[i&
mWi
c_j
kdi
][iY^_[^j&
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
i[^[d&
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
^th[d&
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
\u^b[d&
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
b[hd[d&
m_hZ
Wk\
Z_[i[d
IbWjj[d
Wk\][p[_Y^d[j(
=_[i
X[Z[kj[j&
ZWii
Wbb[
skii[h[d
kdZ
_dd[h[d
>h[_]d_ii[
X[ij_ccj[
>_dZhuYa[
Wk\
Z[d
IbWjj[d
^_dj[hbWii[d(
y>_dZhuYa[z
_ij
[_d
i[^h
]kj[i
Pehj&
Z[dd
jWjisY^b_Y^
^_dj[hbWi' i[d
i_[
>_dZhuYa[
eZ[h
Ihs]kd][d(
>_d
>_dZhkYa
aWdd
j_[\
eZ[h
eX[h\bsY^b_Y^
i[_d&
eZ[h
[i
aWdd
[_d\WY^
[_d
\buY^j_][h
>_dZhkYa
i[_d&
Z[h
i[^h
iY^d[bb
l[hiY^m_dZ[j
kdZ
a[_d[
Lfkh
pkhuYabsiij( #'

HX
WX[h
j_[\
eZ[h
eX[h\bsY^b_Y^&
[i
^WdZ[bj
i_Y^
kc
[_d[d
>_d' ZhkYa(
NdZ
Z_[i[
>_dZhuYa[
Wk\
IbWjj[d
i_dZ
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
^WX[d&
kdi[h
]Wdp[h
;[i_jp(
:bb[i&
mWi
m_h
m_ii[d&
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
][b[hdj
^WX[d&
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
[h\W^h[d
^WX[d&
[i
X[\_dZ[j
i_Y^
Wbb[i
^_[h
Wk\
kdi[h[d
IbWjj[d( @[dWk
]b[_Y^
X[ij[^[d
kdi[h[
=[dafhep[ii[&
;[h[Y^dkd][d
kdZ
O[hckjkd][d
dkh
ZWhWki&
ZWii
m_h
kdi[h[
IbWjj[d
c_j[_dWd' Z[h
l[h]b[_Y^[d&
_^d[d
m_[Z[h
kdZ
m_[Z[h
pk^th[d&
i_[
ZWZkhY^
pk
l[hij[^[d
l[hikY^[d&
ZWii
m_h
i_[
aecX_d_[h[d
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
P_h
atdd[d
d_Y^ji
G[k[i
[hZ[da[d&
d_Y^ji&
ZWi
i_Y^
d_Y^j
X[h[_ji
Wk\
kdi[h[d
IbWjj[d
X[\_dZ[j(
P_h
atdd[d
d_Y^ji
iW][d
eZ[h
jkd&
ZWi
d_Y^j
_h][dZ[jmWi
Wk\
Z[d
IbWjj[d
[djifhsY^[(
P_h
atdd[d
a[_d[d
d[k[d
@[ZWda[d
[h\_dZ[d&
][dWkie&
m_[
m_h
a[_d
d[k[i
M_[h
[h\_dZ[d
atdd[d&
Z[dd
Wbb
kdi[h[
Oehij[bbkd][d
led
M_[h[d
[hmWY^i[d
Wki
kdi[h[d
;[eXWY^jkd][d
b[X[dZ[h
M_[h[( =_[
>_dZhuYa[
Wk\
kdi[h[d
IbWjj[d
i_dZ
ZkhY^
:iiep_Wj_ed[d
c_j[_dWdZ[h
l[hXkdZ[d(
:iiep_Wj_ed[d
l[hX_dZ[d
>_dZhuYa[&
Z_[
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
[cf\Wd][d
mkhZ[d
eZ[h
i_Y^
Wk\
WdZ[h[
:hj
s^d[bd( =W
ZWi
@[ZsY^jd_i
lec
;[mkiiji[_d
WX^sd]j
kdZ
m_h
kdi
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
dkh
Z[h
>_dZhuYa[
[h_dd[hd&
_d
Z[d[d
;[mkiiji[_d
Wk\Xb_jpj[&
_ij
[i
ltbb_]
abWh&
ZWii
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
]b[_Y^p[_j_][
>_d' ZhuYa[&
Z_[
c_j[_dWdZ[h
l[hXkdZ[d
i_dZ&
bsd][h
Wbi
d_Y^j
l[h' aduf\j[
>_dZhuYa[
_c
@[ZsY^jd_i
Xb[_X[d
m[hZ[d(
;[_c
:k\' Xb_jp[d
led
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_d&
eZ[h
WkY^
X[_
[_d[h
b[Z_]b_Y^[d
:dds^[hkd]
ZWhWd&
i_dZ
Wbb[
>_dZhuYa[
Z[i
:k][dXb_Yai
c_j[_d' WdZ[h
l[haduf\j
kdZ
Xb[_X[d
_c
@[ZsY^jd_i
_d
O[hX_dZkd](
=Wii[bX[
]_bj
\uh
>_dZhuYa[&
Z_[
ZkhY^
_^h[
_dd[h[
q^db_Y^a[_j
l[hXkdZ[d
i_dZ(
P[dd
m_h
_d
Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya&
_d
Z[c
m_h
[_d[d
>_dZhkYa
[cf\Wd][d&
X[mkiij
i_dZ&
l[hX_dZ[d
m_h
Z[d
d[k[d
>_dZhkYa
Z[\_d_j_l
c_j
s^db_Y^[d
Wbj[d
>_dZhuYa[d&
kdZ
i_[
Xb[_' X[d
_c
@[ZsY^jd_i
l[haduf\j(
P[dd
m_h
>_dZhuYa[
WdZ[h[hi[_ji
_d
[_d[c
SkijWdZ
led
LY^bW\
[cf\Wd][d&
X[c[ha[d
m_h
i_[
[_d\WY^
d_Y^j&
kdZ
_^h[
Lfkh[d
l[hiY^m_dZ[d&
X[leh
i_[
][muh' Z_]j
eZ[h
Wiiep__[hj
m[hZ[d
atdd[d( "Bd
[_d[c
i[_d[h
Mh[\\[d
mkhZ[
Hkif[diao
][\hW]j&
eX
Wbb[ #(

>_dZhuYa[
Wk\
kdi[h[d
IbWjj[d
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d
][X_bZ[j
m[hZ[d
eZ[h
eX
m_h
c_j
[_d_][d
led
_^d[d
][Xeh[d
mehZ[d
i_dZ(
>h
Wdjmehj[j[4# =_[
>_dZhuYa[
_c
_dij_daj_l[d
S[djhkc
i_dZ
kdi
Wd][Xeh[d5
i_[
i_dZ
X[h[_ji
ZW&
[X[die
m_[
[_d_][i
m[d_][
_c
[cej_edWb[d
S[djhkc(
=Wi
uXh_][
aeccj
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d5
_c
;[m[]kd]i' kdZ
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[d
S[djhkc
ckii
Wbb[i
[hb[hdj
m[hZ[d(

.

Nc
abWh[h
pk
l[hij[^[d&
mWi
_Y^
iW][d
m[hZ[&
cuii[d
L_[
l[hikY^[d
ZWhWd
pk
Z[da[d&
ZWii
m_h
a[_d[
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
kdi[h
;[mkiiji[_d
^WX[d(
:bi
_Y^
iW]j[&
m_h
atddj[d
X[mkiij[h
m[hZ[d
eZ[h
ZWii
[_d
F[diY^
\uh
[_d[d
:k][dXb_Ya
X[mkiij
][cWY^j
m[hZ[d
aWdd&
m[dd
cWd
_^d
\hW]j&
eX
[h
X[mkiij
i[_
eZ[h
d_Y^j&
l[hmWdZj[
_Y^
Z_[
Pthj[h
yX[mkiijz
kdZ
ykdX[mkiijz
_d
[_d[c
h[bWj_l[d
L_dd(
>i
]_Xj
ie
l_[b[
;[mkiiji[_di]hWZ[&
kdZ
`[Z[h
^t^[h[
@hWZ
X[Z[kj[j
yX[mkiij[hz
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
[_d[d
d_[Zh_][' h[d
@hWZ(
:X[h
m[dd
m_h
WkY^
ZWi
;[mkiiji[_d
i[bXij
d_Y^j
X[^[hhiY^[d
atdd[d&
ie
^WX[d
m_h
ZeY^
[_d[
][m_ii[
Dedjhebb[
ZWhuX[h&
mWi
m_h
uX[h
;[mkiiji[_d
Z[da[d&
kdZ
m_h
atdd[d
kdi[h
=[da[d
ie
WdehZd[d&
ZWii
[i
;[mkiiji[_d
Xh_d]j(
PWi
_Y^
ZWc_j
c[_dj[&
_ij&
ZWii
m_h
;[mkiiji[_d
^[hlehhk\[d
atdd[d&
_dZ[c
m_h
kdi[h[d
@[ZWda[d
[_d[
K_Y^jkd]
][X[d&
m_[
i_[
i_[
_d
[_d[c
:k][dXb_Ya
Z[i
;[mkiiji[_di
Wdd[^c[d
muhZ[d( O[hikY^[d
L_[
dkd
pk
\ehckb_[h[d&
mWi
L_[
X[c[haj[d&
Wbi
L_[
i_Y^
pk
X[eXWY^j[d
l[hikY^j[d(
L_[
iebbj[d
Zh[_[hb[_
X[eXWY^j[j
^WX[d(
>hij[di&
ZWii
i_[
L_[
i_Y^
d_Y^j
0FOCO
PCJ@PQ
COGLLCOL!
ZWi
^[_iij&
L_[
i_dZ
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
d_Y^j
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
][mW^h&
m[dd
L_[
l[hikY^[d&
i_Y^
pk
X[eXWY^j[d(
Sm[_j[di&
ZWii
Z_[
;[eXWY^' jkd]
ZkhY^
Z[d
ZWk[hdZ[d
Ljhec
led
@[ZWda[d&
;_bZ[hd&
GWY^' absd][d
led
@[ifhsY^[d
kdZ
;hkY^ijuYa[d
led
@[\u^b[d
[h' iY^m[hj
m_hZ&
Z[h
ZkhY^
B^h[d
@[_ij
\b_[iij
kdZ
i[^h
e\j
B^h[
:k\c[haiWca[_j
led
Z[h
;[eXWY^jkd]
WXp_[^j(
NdZ
Zh_jj[di&
ZWii
[jmWi
_d
B^d[d&
ieXWbZ
L_[
c_j
Z[h
L[bXijX[eXWY^jkd] #)

X[]_dd[d&
pk
f^WdjWi_[h[d
Wd\sd]j&
kdZ
L[bXijX[eXWY^jkd]
'
m[dd
L_[
[i
m_hab_Y^
l[hikY^[d
'
_ij
[_d
ZWk[hdZ[h
DWcf\
][][d
>_dX_bZkd]( =_[i
_ij
dkd
Z[h
AWkfjfkdaj
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wd
i_Y^
i[bXij(
P[dd
cWd
[ha[ddj&
ZWii
Wbb[
LY^m_[h_]a[_j[d
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wk\
Z[h
MWjiWY^[
X[hk^[d&
ZWii
cWd
i_Y^
d_Y^j
i[_d[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hj&
m[_ii
cWd
X[h[_ji&
mWi
cWd
pk
jkd
^Wj(
FWd
KRPP
SCOPRAFCL!
i_Y^
i[_d[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd( Nc
Z_[i
pk
jkd&
ckii
cWd
c_j
c[Y^Wd_iY^[d
@[ZWda[d
ascf\[d&
kdZ
cWd
ckii
c_j
>_dX_bZkd][d
ascf\[d(
P[dd
cWd
Z_[i
][m_ii[d^W\j
kdZ
WkiZWk[hdZ
jkj&
m_hZ
cWd
_d
[_d[h
l[h^sbj' d_icsii_]
akhp[d
S[_j
>h][Xd_ii[
i[^[d(
:X[h
cWd
ZWh\
d_Y^j
Z[da[d&
[i
i[_
b[_Y^j&
eZ[h
cWd
atdd[
Z_[i[
rXkd]
ie\ehj
X[^[hhiY^[d(
=_[
rXkd]
Z[i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hdi&
m_[
i_[
][dWddj
m_hZ&
_ij
iY^m[h
[hb[hdXWh(
L_[
ZWh\
d_Y^j
Wk\
Z[h
>hmWhjkd]
led
>h][Xd_ii[d
]hudZ[d&
iedij
l[hb_[hj
cWd
i_Y^
_d
@[ZWda[d
uX[h
i[_d[
:dijh[d]kd][d(
L_[
ckii
Wk\
Z[h
>ha[ddjd_i
Z[h
MWjiWY^[
X[hk^[d&
ZWii
m_h
kdi
d_Y^j
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd&
kdZ
ZWii
m_h
kdi
Z[ddeY^
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd
I[LLCL!
m[dd
m_h
kdi
Wk\i
qkii[hij[
kdZ
_d
Z[h
h_Y^j_][d
P[_i[
Wdijh[d][d( P_h
atdd[d
_d
Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya&
_d
Z[c
m_h
[i
mudiY^[d&
d_Y^j
m_bb[djb_Y^
X[mkiij
m[hZ[d&
Z[dd
m_h
^WX[d
a[_d[
@[mWbj
uX[h
kdi[h[
;[mkiiji[_dipkijsdZ[(
:X[h
m_h
atdd[d
kdi
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
\uh
[_d[
akhp[
S[_j
m_bb[djb_Y^
[h_dd[hd&
m[_b
m_h
[_d[
][m_ii[
A[hhiY^W\j
uX[h
kdi[h[
@[ZWda[d
^WX[d(
NdZ
m[dd
m_h
kdi
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
c_j
A_b\[
Z[h
X[iedZ[h[d
:dehZdkd][d
kdi[' h[h
@[ZWda[d
[h_dd[hd&
ZWi
^[_iij&
ZkhY^
Z_[
>ha[ddjd_i&
ZWii
m_h
kdi
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
d_Y^j
[h_dd[hd5
ZWii
d_[cWdZ
i_Y^
i[_d[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hj&
kdZ
_dZ[c
m_h
h[Wb_i_[h[d&
mWi
ZWc_j
][c[_dj
_ij&
m_hZ
kdi
Z_[i[
>ha[ddjd_i
pkc
;[mkiiji[_d
\u^h[d( L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
m_h
Z[d
iY^mWY^[d
Ikdaj
_d
kdi[h[h
F[Y^Wd_i_[hj^[_j
[djZ[Yaj
^WX[d(
>i
_ij
Z_[i
ZWi
P_ii[d&
ZWii
m_h
kdi
d_Y^j
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd
kdZ
Z_[
>ha[ddjd_i&
ZWii
m_h
l[hikY^[d
atdd[d&
kdi
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd(
F_j
Z[c
O[hij[^[d
Z[h
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j&
kdi
jWjisY^b_Y^
pk
sdZ[hd&
X[]_ddj
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
Z[h
:hX[_j( #*

Lfsj[h
m[hZ[d
L_[
b[hd[d&
ZWii
Z_[
IhWn_i
Z[i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hdi
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
L[bXijX[eXWY^jkd]
kdZ
Z[c
DWcf\
][][d
>_dX_bZkd]
d_Y^j
dkh
[_d[
fhWaj_iY^[
;[Z[kjkd]
^Wj&
iedZ[hd
ZWii
i_[
WkY^
Z[d
\[_dij[d
;[h[_Y^
kdi[h[i
Lje\\m[Y^i[bi
sdZ[hj
kdZ
X[ij_ccj[
Y^[c_iY^[
'
l_[bb[_Y^j
X[ii[h
][iW]j&
WbY^_c_ij_' iY^[
'
P_hakd][d
_d
kdi[h[c
Dthf[h
^[hlehhk\j(
Le
][bWd][d
m_h
led
Z[h
IioY^ebe]_[
pkh
:bY^_c_[5
pkc
@[ZWda[d
Z[h
MhWdi' \ehcWj_ed
]htX[h[h
>b[c[dj[
_d
\[_d[h[(

"L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
kdZ
i[_d[
P_hakd]
Wk\
ZWi
@[ZsY^jd_i
m[hZ[d
Wk\
[_d[
f[hitdb_Y^[h[
:hj
Wbi
_c
leh^[h][]Wd][d[d
:XiY^d_jj
_d
7COPNCIQGSCL
BCO
9CJ@PQCOD?FORLE
RLB
=CJQCOICLLQLGP!
Z[c
Z_[
\eb][dZ[d
IWhW]hWf^[d
[djdecc[d
i_dZ&
X[iY^h_[X[d(# (((
Wbb[i&
mWi
c[_d[
O[hikY^[
Z[i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hdi
c_h
][p[_]j
^Wjj[d&
uX[hp[k]j[
c_Y^
i[^h
XWbZ&
ZWii
_Y^
[_d[c
S[JJGE
LCRCL
7OM@JCK
ECECL\@CO
PQ?LB!
?RD
B?P
7FGJMPMNFGC
RLB
=GPPCLPAF?DQ
@GPFCO
LGAFQ
ECPQMPPCL
T?OCL
### BY^
iW^&
ZWii
ZWi
IheXb[c
ZWh_d
X[ijWdZ&
Z_[
:k\c[haiWca[_j
Wk\
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
b[da[d&
e^d[
Z_[
Wk\
[jmWi
WdZ[h[i
][h_Y^j[j[
:k\c[haiWca[_j
pk
iY^msY^[d
eZ[h
Wk\pk][X[d(
=WhuX[h
^_d' Wki
aeddj[
i_Y^
Z_[i[i
y[jmWi
WdZ[h[iz
ieme^b
_d
c_h
Wbi
WkY^
Wkii[h^WbX
led
c_h
X[\_dZ[d( ;[h[_ji
Z_[
[hij[d
O[hikY^[
(((
p[_]j[d
c_h
Z_[
ZWh_d
b_[][dZ[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j(
@b[_Y^p[_j_]
mkhZ[
c_h
pm[_[hb[_
abWh( :bi
[hij[i
[haWddj[
_Y^&
ZWii
ZWi
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
Wbi
>h][Xd_i
Z_[i[h
F[j^eZ[
d_Y^ji
c_j
yL_Y^'i[bXij'\u^b[dz
eZ[h
yL[bXij' :dWboi[z
pk
jkd
^Wj(
>i
mWh
[_d
d[k[h
kdZ
i[^h
_dj[h[iiWdj[h
SkijWdZ
c_j
[_d[c
c[hamuhZ_]
l[hjhWkj[d
@[iY^cWYa( Sm[_j[di
[haWddj[
_Y^&
ZWii
:k][dXb_Ya[
led
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
_c
E[X[d
lehaecc[d&
m[dd
WkY^
i[bj[d(
Gkh
ZWi
WXi_Y^jb_Y^[ !
I(
=(
Hkif[diao&
(RD
BCO
9RAFC
L?AF
BCK
=RLBCO@?OCL!
;[hd&
FudY^[d&
P_[d
+300&
,(
:k\bW][
+312&&
L(
+1+

$!

>hp[k][d
iebY^[h
:k][dXb_Ya[
iY^k\
[_d[
>cf\_dZkd]
led
G[k' ^[_j(
Bd
Z[h
MWj
mWh
_Y^
i[_j
\hu^ij[h
D_dZ^[_j
c_j
_^d[d
l[hjhWkj(
L_[
jhWj[d
[djm[Z[h
_d
d[k[d
kdZ
kd[hmWhj[j[d
Nc][Xkd][d
Wk\&
Wd
[_d[c
d[k[d
Hhj&
X[_
[_d[h
K[_i[
kdj[h
d[k[d
F[diY^[d&
m[dd
cWd
pkc
;[_if_[b
fbtjpb_Y^
kc
i_Y^
Xb_Yaj
kdZ
iW]j4
=GC
PCJQP?K
0AF
RLB
?L
BGCPCK
6OQ
HZ[h
_d
i[^h
[cej_edWb[d
:k][dXb_Ya[d&
_d
:k][dXb_Ya[d
Z[h
@[\W^h&
_d
:k][dXb_Ya[d&
_d
Z[d[d
cWd
i[_d[d
Def\
d_Y^j
l[hb_[h[d
ZWh\&
ZW
cWd
i[_d[
[_][d[
Lj_cc[
^thj
kdZ
i_Y^
i[bXij
led
Wkii[d
i_[^j
kdZ
X[eXWY^j[j( BY^
iW^
]Wdp
abWh&
ZWii
c[_d[
[hij[d
E[X[di[h_dd[hkd][d
_d
c[_d[c
[_][d[d
?Wbb
i[^h
\hu^[
:k][dXb_Ya[
Z[i
9CJ@PQ",OGL"
LCOLP
mWh[d(
=_[i[
b[jpj[
>ha[ddjd_i
[dj^ubbj[
c_h
deY^
l_[b[i
WdZ[h[(
=Wi
^[_iij&
_Y^
[haWddj[&
ZWii
_Y^
c_Y^
m_hab_Y^
dkh
Wd
`[d[
:k][dXb_Ya[
Z[h
O[h]Wd][d^[_j
[h_dd[hj[&
me
_Y^
c_Y^
KCGLCO
PCJ@PQ
COGLLCOQ
F?QQC#
Oed
Z[d
WdZ[h[d
TRPPQC
GAF
JCBGEJGAF!
B?PP
PGC
PQ?QQD?LBCL#
BY^
X_d
d_Y^j
_cijWdZ[&
i_[
m_[Z[h
ltbb_]
_di
E[X[d
pk
hk\[d&
i_[
deY^
[_dcWb
pk
ZkhY^b[X[d(
:X[h
Z_[
:k][d' Xb_Ya[&
_d
Z[d[d
_Y^
c_Y^
c[_d[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hj
^Wjj[&
mWh[d
b[X[dZ_]
kdZ
kdj[hiY^_[Z[d
i_Y^
_d
a[_d[h
P[_i[
led
Z[h
@[][d' mWhj(
BY^
^Wjj[
m[_j[h^_d
:d]ij
ZWleh&
[dZ]ubj_][
LY^buii[
pk
p_[^[d(
:X[h
_Y^
iW^
X[h[_ji&
ZWii
_Y^
Wk\
Z[h
LY^m[bb[
pk
[_d[h
i[^h
]heii[d
>djZ[Yakd]
ijWdZ(
=_[
LY^msY^[
kdZ
Ndpkbsd]' b_Y^a[_j
kdi[h[i
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][di
^Wjj[d
c_Y^
iY^ed
_c' c[h
[hijWkdj(
Le
l_[b[i
l[hiY^m_dZ[j(
Bh][dZm_[
iW^
_Y^
ZWh_d
Z_[
AWkfjWXikhZ_jsj
c[_d[i
E[X[di(
PWhkc
iebb
cWd
ie
l_[b
[hb[' X[d&
m[dd
cWd
[i
dWY^^[h
l[h]_iij9
?[hd[h
bW]
ZWh_d
[jmWi
>djmuhZ_][dZ[i(
FWd
\u^bj
[jmWi&
ZWi
i[^h
]heii
pk
i[_d
iY^[_dj
kdZ
Z[daj&
cWd
m_hZ
[i
d_[
l[h][ii[d5
[_d
eZ[h
pm[_
CW^h[
l[h][^[d&
kdZ
d_Y^ji
Xb[_Xj
ZWled
uXh_](
Gkd
mkhZ[
c_h
abWh&
mWhkc
Z[c
ie
mWh
kdZ
mWhkc
[i
d_Y^j
WdZ[hi
i[_d
aeddj[(
P[dd
kdi[h
@[ZsY^jd_i
jWjisY^b_Y^
dkh
_d
:k][dXb_Ya[d
Z[i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hdi
b[X[dZ_]
_ij&
m_hZ
Z[h
@hkdZ
i[_d[h
:hckj
abWh
((( FWdY^cWb
XhWY^j[
ZWi
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
a[_d[d
>h\eb]5
pk
WdZ[h[d
S[_j[d
mkhZ[
[i
led
c[hamuhZ_][d
;[eXWY^jkd][d
X[]b[_j[j( $"

BY^
ifWp_[hj[
[_dcWb
Z[d
E_j[`d_`
[djbWd]
_d
K_Y^jkd]
Wk\
Z[d
G[miao&
kdZ
jhejp
Wbb
c[_d[h
:dijh[d]kd][d
mWh
_Y^
kd\s^_]&
c[_d[
:k\c[haiWca[_j
Wk\
ZWi
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
][h_Y^j[j
pk
^Wbj[d(
=[h
Eshc&
Z_[
;[m[]kd]&
Wbb[i
b[daj[
c_Y^
WX(
C[Z[d
:k][dXb_Ya
l[hbeh
_Y^
Z[d
?WZ[d
Z[h
:k\c[haiWca[_j&
\WdZ
_^d
m_[Z[h
kdZ
l[hbeh
_^d
m_[Z[hkc(
LY^b_[iib_Y^
\u^bj[
_Y^
[_d[
:hj
bsY^[hb_Y^[d
qh][hi
uX[h
c_Y^
kdZ
Xe]
_d
[_d[
LjhWii[
dWY^
b_dai
[_d
c_j
Z[c
\[ij[d
OehiWjp&
c[_d[
:k\c[haiWca[_j
m[d_]ij[di
\uh
[_d_][
S[_j&
`[Z[d\Wbbi
X_i
_Y^
Z_[
\eb][dZ[
LjhWii[
[hh[_Y^j
^WX[d
muhZ[&
ZWhWk\
pk
aedp[djh_[h[d&
c_Y^
c[_d[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd(
BY^
[hh[_Y^j[
Z_[
GWZ[`pZ_diaWoW&
e^d[
Z[d
][ZWdab_' Y^[d
?WZ[d&
Wkii[h
l_[bb[_Y^j
\uh
akhp[
Fec[dj[&
pk
l[hb_[h[d(
=Wdd
m[dZ[j[
_Y^
c_Y^
m_[Z[h
Z[c
G[miao
pk
kdZ
[haWddj[&
ZWii
[i
c_h
_d
hk^_][h[d
LjhWii[d
b[_Y^j[h
][bWd]&
Z[d
][ZWdab_' Y^[d
?WZ[d
d_Y^j
pk
l[hb_[h[d
kdZ
mebbj[
[i
ZW^[h
WkY^
_d
bshc_][h[d
LjhWii[d
l[hikY^[d(
BY^
[hh[_Y^j[
Z[d
G[miao&
c_Y^
m[_j[h^_d
c[_d[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hdZ&
kdZ
X[]Wdd
X[h[_ji&
Z[d
i[bjiWc[d
@[\u^bipkijWdZ
_dd[h[d
?h_[Z[di
kdZ
O[hjhWk[di
pk
l[hifuh[d&
Z[d
]heii[
:dijh[d]kd][d
Z_[i[h
:hj
dWY^
i_Y^
p_[' ^[d(
@[hWZ[
kc
Z_[
>Ya[
Wc
G[miao
mWh
[_d
MWXWabWZ[d&
me
c[_d[
S_]Wh[jj[d
Wd][\[hj_]j
mkhZ[d(
F_Y^
m[_j[h^_d
c[_d[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hdZ&
][ZWY^j[
_Y^
Zehj
lehpkifh[Y^[d
kdZ
[_d_][
S_]Wh[jj[d
pk
X[ij[bb[d( Sm[_
LjkdZ[d
ifsj[h
COT?AFQC
GAF
_d
Z[h
MWmh_jiY^[iaW`W&
ZWi
^[_iij
m[_j
m[]
led
Zehj(
BY^
mWh
c_j
[_d[h
BimeijiY^_a
kdj[hm[]i
pk
Z[d
=hkYa[hd(
=_[
>cf\_dZkd]
Z[i
>hmWY^[di
mWh
Wkii[heh' Z[djb_Y^
b[X^W\j(
BY^
aWdd
X[_dW^[
iW][d&
ZWii
_Y^
WR
KGO
I?K#
Le\ehj
[h_dd[hj[
_Y^
c_Y^
Wd
Wbb[i(
P_[
_Y^
[djbWd]
Z[h
GWZ[`p'
Z_diaW`W
ifWp_[hj
mWh&
m_[
_Y^
c_Y^
c[_d[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hj
^Wjj[&
m_[
_Y^
Wd
S_]Wh[jj[d
][ZWY^j
^Wjj[
kdZ
m_[
_Y^
X[_
Z_[i[c
@[ZWda[d
WdiY^[_d[dZ
khfbtjpb_Y^
_d
[_d[d
j_[\[d
LY^bW\
][\Wbb[d
kdZ
ZWh_d
l[hiY^mkdZ[d
mWh(
Ps^h[dZ
_Y^
_d
Z_[i[d
LY^bW\
l[hikda[d
mWh&
^Wjj[
_Y^
m[_j[h^_d
pkiWcc[d^sd][dZ[
kdZ
dujpb_Y^[
AWdZbkd][d
Wki][\u^hj(
BY^
^Wjj[
Z[d
MWXWamWh[d' ^sdZb[h
l[hbWii[d&
mWh
_d
c[_d[
Pe^dkd]
_d
Z[h
E_j[`d_`
][]Wd' ][d
kdZ
^Wjj[
c_j
Z[d
=hkYa[hd
j[b[\ed_[hj(
BY^
^Wjj[
pm[_
;h_[\[ $#

][iY^h_[X[d(
=Wdd
mWh
_Y^
m_[Z[h
Wki
Z[c
AWki
][]Wd][d(
BY^
mWh
Wk\
Z[h
b_da[d
L[_j[
Z[i
G[miao
X_i
pkc
@eij_d_`
=leh
][]Wd][d
_d
Z[h
:Xi_Y^j&
pkh
H\\_p[hiaW`W
pk
][bWd][d(
=Wdd
^Wjj[
_Y^
c_Y^
WdZ[hi
X[iedd[d&
m[_b
[i
ifsj
][mehZ[d
mWh(
BY^
^Wjj[
[_d[
BijmeijiY^_a
][Zkd][d
kdZ
mWh
_d
Z_[
DWlWb[h]WhZiaW`W
pk
c[_d[d
=hkYa[hd
][\W^h[d(
NdZ
kdj[hm[]i&
ms^h[dZ
Z[h
?W^hj
[djbWd]
Z[h
MWmh_jiY^[iaW`W&
X[]Wdd
_Y^
[_d[
i[bjiWc[
Ndhk^[
pk
l[hifuh[d&
m_[
m[dd
_Y^
[jmWi
l[h][ii[d
^sjj[(
;LB
NJ[QWJGAF
DGCJ
KGO
CGL!
B?PP
GAF
SCOECPPCL
F?QQC!
KGAF
KCGLCO
PCJ@PQ
WR
COGLLCOL#

 ":k\
i[_d[d
O[hiWccbkd][d
_d
EedZed
pm_iY^[d
+3-/
kdZ
+3.+
kdZ
`[d[d
_d
G[m
Reha
+3..
kdZ
+3./
mkhZ[d
Hkif[diao
l_[b[
?hW][d
uX[h
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
kdZ
P_[Z[ha[^h
][ij[bbj(
=[h
\eb][dZ[
:XiY^d_jj
X[ij[^j
Wki
[_d[h
K[aedijhkaj_ed
Z[h
:djmehj[d
Wk\
[_d_][
Z_[i[h
?hW][d
Wdbsiib_Y^
i[_d[h
O[hiWcc' bkd][d
_d
EedZed(
:XiY^d_jj
i_[X[d
l[hikY^j
Wk\
s^db_Y^[
:hj
[_d_][
Z[h
_d
G[m
Reha
][][X[d[d
:djmehj[d
pk
h[aedijhk' _[h[d(
Nc
[_d[d
X[ii[h[d
_dd[h[d
SkiWcc[d^Wd]
pk
X[m_ha[d
kdZ
kc
P_[Z[h^ebkd][d
pk
l[hc[_Z[d&
i_dZ
[_d_][
?hW][d
kd' j[hij[bbj
eZ[h
_d
Hkif[diaoi
:djmehj[d
[_dX[pe][d
mehZ[d(
:dZ[hd\Wbbi
[hiY^[_d[d
i_[
_d
:d\u^hkd]iijh_Y^[d&
kc
i_[
led
Hkif[diaoi
Pehj[d
pk
kdj[hiY^[_Z[d&
Z_[
d_Y^j
_d
:d\u^hkd]i' ijh_Y^[
][i[jpj
i_dZ&
ZW
i_[
Z_[
AWkfjcWii[
Z[i
M[nj[i
WkicW' Y^[d(
=_[
K[_^[d\eb][
Z[h
?hW][d
mkhZ[
d[k
Wd][ehZd[j&
kdZ
dkh
Z_[
mkhZ[d
Wk\][decc[d&
Z_[
i_Y^
Wk\
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct' ][d
kdZ
P_[Z[ha[^h
X[p_[^[d(# =Wi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
_ij
[jmWi
F[hamuhZ_][i(
;[_
`[Z[c
WhX[_j[j
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
WdZ[hi(
>_d[h
[h_dd[hj
i_Y^
[^[h
_d
Z_[i[h
K_Y^jkd]&
[_d
WdZ[h[h
c[^h
_d
`[d[h(
FWd
aWdd
d_Y^j
iW][d&
ZWi
[_d[
i[_
X[ii[h
Wbi
ZWi
WdZ[h[(
=Wi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct' ][d
aWdd
l[hbeh[d
][^[d5
[i
]_Xj
ZW
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
Ljk\[d(
>_d_][i
aWdd
l[h][ii[d
kdZ
ifsj[h
ZkhY^
X[iedZ[h[
F[j^eZ[d
m_[Z[h
^[hleh][^ebj
m[hZ[d
eZ[h
[i
aWdd
ltbb_]
l[hiY^m_dZ[d( $$

yPWhkc
^WX[d
[_d_][
E[kj[
X[ii[h[
:dbW][d
pkc
;Wbbif_[b[d
Wbi
WdZ[h[9z >i
]_Xj
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
:hj[d
led
;[m[]kd]ip[djh[d
c_j
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
:hj[d
led
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d(
D[_d
F[diY^
_ij
][dWkie
m_[
[_d
WdZ[h[h(
>_d[h
aWdd
ZWi
[_d[
X[ii[h&
[_d
WdZ[h[h
[jmWi
WdZ[h[i(
>i
]_Xj
MWki[dZ[
led
>_dZhuYa[d&
ie
ZWii
Z_[
DecX_dWj_ed[d
_cc[h
l[hiY^_[Z[d
i_dZ(
BY^
^WX[
c[^hcWbi
uX[h
Z_[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
:hj[d
led
F[diY^[d
][ifheY^[d
'
F[diY^
Gh(
b&
Gh(
,&
Gh(
-
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
>_d[h
[h_dd[hj
i_Y^
X[ii[h
[_d[h
:hj
led
>_dZhuYa[d&
[_d
WdZ[h[h
[_d[h
WdZ[h[d
:hj( y;[ij[^j
[_d
E[X[d
Wki
Z[d
>h_dd[hkd][d
led
[_d[c
:k][d' Xb_Ya
pkc
WdZ[h[d9z G[_d&
ZWi
_ij
pk
aecfb_p_[hj(
L_[
m_ii[d&
ZWii
[i
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[' d[
@[ZsY^jd_iWhj[d
]_Xj(
NdZ
ZWi
@[ZsY^jd_i
_ij
fWii_l5
L_[
m[dZ[d
[i
d_Y^j
Wd(
FWd
aWdd
ZWi
E[X[d
Wbi
[_d[d
Ihep[ii
X[jhWY^j[d( yPWi
aWdd
cWd
jkd&
kc
i[_d
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
pk
l[h' X[ii[hd9z P[dd
L_[
i_Y^
c[^h
B^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd&
m[hZ[d
L_[
B^h
@[ZsY^jd_i
l[hX[ii[hd( y;[leh
_Y^
pkc
Loij[c
ij_[ii&
^Wjj[
_Y^
[_d[
i[^h
Z[kjb_Y^[
>h_dd[hkd]
Wd
[jmWi&
ZWi
leh
bWd][h
S[_j
][iY^W^(
P[dd
_Y^
i_[
dkd
pkhuYahk\[&
_ij
i_[
dkh
Z_[
>h_dd[hkd]
[_d[h
>h_dd[hkd](
E_[]j
ZWi
ZWhWd&
ZWii
_Y^
[_d
X_iiY^[d
mWY^[h
X_d9z PW^hiY^[_db_Y^
mWh
i_[
c_j
ijWha[h
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
l[haduf\j(
P[dd
L_[
i_[
e^d[
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
X[jhWY^j[d&
m_hZ
i_[
iY^msY^[h
m[hZ[d
kdZ
me^b
l[hiY^m_dZ[d( yBij
lebbijsdZ_][i
L_Y^'d_Y^j'BZ[dj_\_p_[h[d
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_d9z BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
kdZ
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_d
i_dZ
pm[_
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
L[_j[d
Z[h
i[bX[d
:d][b[][d^[_j( yBij
[i
led
fhWaj_iY^[c
Gkjp[d&
i_Y^
Z_[
>h[_]d_ii[
i[_d[i
l[h]Wd][d[d
E[X[di
pk
l[h][][dmshj_][d&
m[dd
cWd
l[hikY^j&
i_Y^
i[_d[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd9
BY^
c[_d[&
_d
Z[h
:Xi_Y^j&
i_[
\uh
[_d[
ifsj[h[
P_[Z[ha[^h
pk
\_n_[h[d9z G[_d&
ZWi
_ij
d_Y^j
fhWaj_iY^(
>hij[di
cuii[d
L_[
i_Y^[h
i[_d&
ZWii
[i
[_d[
pkaud\j_][
P_[Z[ha[^h
]_Xj(
Sm[_j[di
cuii[d
L_[
i_Y^[h

%$ i[_d&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd(
P[dd
L_[
[i
i_Y^
m_[
`[jpj
_d
B^h[h
?hW][
lehij[bb[d&
m_hZ
[i
i_Y^
_d
>_dX_bZkd]
l[hmWdZ[bd&
d_Y^ji
WdZ[h[i(
:X[h
m[dd
L_[
pk
Wbb[h[hij
l[hikY^[d&
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd&
e^d[
[jmWi
^_dpkpkhu][d
kdZ
i_Y^
ZWdd
'
m[dd
L_[
atdd[d
'
WkY^
Wd
B^h
l[h]Wd][d[i
E[X[d
[h_dd[hd
kdZ
Dh[kpm[][
pk
\_dZ[d
l[hikY^[d5
_d
Z_[i[h
O[hX_dZkd]
m[hZ[d
i_[
ZWdd
i[^h
dujpb_Y^
i[_d(
Gkh
]bWkX[d
L_[
d_Y^j&
ZWii
L_[
[i
jkd
atdd[d5
L_[
atdd[d
[i
deY^
d_Y^j
jkd( yPWi
i_dZ
Dh[kpm[][9z Dh[kpm[][
i_dZ
:k][dXb_Ya[&
_d
Z[d[d
cWd
yjkdz
aWdd(
>i
aeccj
[_d
:k][dXb_Ya&
ZW
cWd
_d
Z_[i[h
:hX[_j
[jmWi
[hh[_Y^[d
aWdd
eZ[h
d_Y^j(
P[dd
[_d[
@[b[][d^[_j
aeccj
kdZ
cWd
i_[
l[hiskcj&
ie
aeccj
[_d[
m[_j[h[
l_[bb[_Y^j
[hij
dWY^
[_d[c
CW^h
eZ[h
deY^
ifsj[h(
>i
]_Xj
I[h_eZ[d
kdj[h
dehcWb[d
;[Z_d]kd][d&
_d
Z[d[d
d_Y^ji
][iY^_[^j&
kdZ
ZWdd
aeccj
cWd
pk
[_d[c
Dh[kpm[](
=Wi
]Wdp[
E[X[d
X[ij[^j
Wki
Dh[kpkd][d
kdZ
LjhWii[d( P_[Z[ha[^h
aWdd
dujpb_Y^
i[_d&
m[dd
cWd
i_Y^
pk
[h_dd[hd
kdZ
pk
sdZ[hd
X[]_ddj
kdZ
i_Y^
d_Y^j
`[Z[i
FWb
[djbWd]
Z[di[bX[d
;W^d[d
Zh[^j&
iedZ[hd
jkj&
mWi
cWd
ctY^j[
kdZ
mWi
cWd
\uh
X[ii[h
^sbj(
:X[h
m[dd
cWd
d_Y^ji
uX[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
m[_ii&
eZ[h
m[dd
cWd
ie]Wh
ZWled
m[_ii
kdZ
d_Y^ji
kdj[hd_ccj&
ie
Xh_d]j
ZWi
uX[h^Wkfj
a[_d[d
Oehj[_b(
=Wdd
m[hZ[d
Z_[i[bX[d
=_d][
\uh
][mt^db_Y^
m_[Z[h^ebj
kdZ
m_[Z[h^ebj( y@[^[
_Y^
h_Y^j_]
_d
Z[h
:ddW^c[&
ZWii
Z_[
>ii[dp
Z[i
F[diY^[d
m_[Z[ha[^hj9z @Wdp
h[Y^j(
P_h
m_ii[d
i[^h
m[d_]
uX[h
P_[Z[ha[^h(
>_d[i
MW][i
m[hZ[d
m_h
l_[bb[_Y^j
ZWi
pk
iWcc[bd
X[]_dd[d&
mWi
uX[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
][iW]j
mkhZ[
kdZ
Wbi
l[hbsiib_Y^
Wd][i[^[d
m[hZ[d
aWdd5
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
m_h
i[^[d&
mWi
m_h
ZWled
pk
^Wbj[d
^WX[d(
:X[h
X_i
ZW^_d
_ij
i_[
dkh
[_d[
M^[eh_[( P_[Z[ha[^h
\_dZ[j
_d
Z[h
>m_]a[_j
ijWjj5
i_[
_ij
d_Y^j
ZWii[bX[
E[X[d(
=_[i[i
E[X[d
[dZ[j&
kdZ
Z_[
S[_j
[dZ[j(
>i
]_Xj
[_d[
M^[eh_[&
kdZ
Z_[i[i
Loij[c
bsiij
Z_[
M^[eh_[
pk&
ZWii
[_d[
S[_jl[hbsd][hkd]
ct]b_Y^
_ij(
BY^
^WX[
a[_d[
;[m[_i[(
;[Z[d' a[d
L_[&
m_[l_[b[
O[hikY^[&
Z_[
S[_j
pk
[h\ehiY^[d&
led
Lf_h_jkW' $&

b_ij[d
kdZ
WdZ[h[d
kdj[hdecc[d
mkhZ[d(
:X[h
[i
]_Xj
a[_d[
;[m[_i[( =[h
b[_Y^j[ij[
P[]&
P_[Z[ha[^h
pk
ijkZ_[h[d&
_ij
ZWi
LjkZ_kc
led
D_dZ[hd(
P[dd
m_h
][dk]
FWj[h_Wb
^sjj[d&
atddj[d
m_h
l_[b[
?hW][d
X[Wdjmehj[d(
PWhkc
jWkY^[d
pkc
;[_if_[b
_d
D_dZ[hd
i[bjiWc[
G[_]kd][d
Wk\&
]Wdp
_c
@[][diWjp
pk
_^h[h
Nc][Xkd]
kdZ
ltbb_]
d[kWhj_]
\uh
Z_[
E[kj[&
Z_[
i_[
kc][X[d9
=_[i
][' iY^_[^j
cWdY^cWb
kdZ
Wk\
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
:hj[d(
NdZ
[i
atdd[d
i[^h
ijWha[
G[_]kd][d
i[_d&
Z_[
ZWi
E[X[d
sdZ[hd
kdZ
_d
]sdpb_Y^
kd[hmWhj[j[
K_Y^jkd][d
][^[d&
ms^h[dZ
d_Y^ji
_d
Z[h
O[h[hXkd]
i_[
[habshj( P_[
_Y^
e\j
][iW]j
^WX[&
\kdaj_ed_[hj
Z_[
BZ[[
Z[h
O[h[hXkd]
_c
F[diY^[d
d_Y^j(
L_[
_ij
[_d[
\WdjWij_iY^[
Oehij[bbkd](
L_[
m_haj
_d
AkdZ[d
kdZ
I\[hZ[d&
WX[h
d_Y^j
_d
F[diY^[d( yLf_[bj
^_[h
Z_[
?hW][
Z[h
Mof[d
^_d[_d9z CW&
WX[h
m_h
m_ii[d
d_Y^ji
uX[h
Mof[d(
Skc_dZ[ij
d_Y^j
][' dk]&
kc
ZWhuX[h
pk
ifh[Y^[d(
:ki
Z_[i[c
@hkdZ
l[hij[^[d
>bj[hd
_^h[
D_dZ[h
c[_ij
d_Y^j&
kdZ
Z_[
D_dZ[h
l[hij[^[d
_^h[
>bj[hd
d_Y^j(
L_[
atdd[d
[_dWdZ[h
d_[cWbi
m_hab_Y^
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
eZ[h
h_Y^j_]
l[hij[^[d&
Z[dd
i_[
i_dZ
ltbb_]
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
E[kj[
\uh[_dWdZ[h(
?h[cZ[&
Z_[
i_Y^
h[_d
pk\sbb_]
Wd
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
Ikdaj
jhW\[d
kdZ
dkd
m_[Z[h
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
K_Y^jkd][d
[_d' iY^bW][d( =Wi
LjkZ_kc
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
ckii
X[_c
LjkZ_kc
Z[i
a_dZb_' Y^[d
@[_ij[i
Wdi[jp[d5
X[iedZ[hi&
X[leh
i_[
pk
ifh[Y^[d
X[]_d' d[d(
P[dd
D_dZ[h
i_Y^
Z_[i[h
S[_j
[h_dd[hj[d&
muhZ[d
_^d[d
i[^h
_dj[h[iiWdj[
=_d][
m_[Z[h
[_d\Wbb[d(
:X[h
m[dd
i_[
pk
ifh[Y^[d
X[]_dd[d&
m[hZ[d
i_[
kd]buYab_Y^[hm[_i[
h_Y^j_][
D_d' Z[h&
kdZ
dWY^
i[Y^i
FedWj[d
eZ[h
[_d[c
CW^h
^WX[d
i_[
l[h][i' i[d(
E[kj[
[h_dd[hd
i_Y^
i[^h
i[bj[d
Wd
ZWi&
mWi
i_[
leh^[h&
_d
[_d[c
i[^h
\hu^[d
:bj[h&
ZWY^j[d(
P[dd
i_[
ZWi
atddj[d&
muh' Z[d
i_[
i_Y^
[h_dd[hd&
m_[
i_[
Wbi
>hmWY^i[d[
mWh[d(
L_[
mWh[d
uX[h^Wkfj
a[_d[
D_dZ[h5
i_[
mkhZ[d
[hij
ifsj[h
pk
D_dZ[hd(
P[dd
i_[
i_Y^
_^h[h
\hu^[d
=[dam[_i[
[h_dd[hj[d&
ie
msh[d
[i
Z_[
]b[_Y^[d&
m_[
i_[
>hmWY^i[d[
^WX[d( yP_ii[d
L_[&
mWhkc
[_d
D_dZ
i_Y^
Wki][h[Y^d[j
i[_d[i
[h' $'

mWY^i[d[d
@[_ij[i
[h_dd[hj
kdZ
d_Y^j
i[_d[i
l[h]Wd][d[d
a_dZ' b_Y^[d
@[_ij[i9z P_h
^WX[d
ie
m[d_]
FWj[h_Wb&
dWY^
Z[c
m_h
khj[_b[d
atdd[d(
BY^
ifh[Y^[
dkh
led
Z[h
:hj&
m_[
][b[hdj
m[hZ[d
aWdd(
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
m_h
iebbj[d
kdi
ZWhWd
[h_dd[hd&
m_[
kdi[h
@[_ij
_d
[_d[c
i[^h
\hu^[d
:bj[h
X[iY^W\\[d
mWh&
ct]b_Y^ij
e^d[
ZWii
i_Y^
>_dX_bZkd]
[_diY^b[_Y^j(
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
m_h
\sdZ[d
^[hWki&
ZWii
[h
ie
kdZ
ie
X[iY^W\\[d
mWh(
:bb[i&
mWi
m_h
\sdZ[d&
msh[
FWj[h_Wb(
Bd
Z[h
E_j[hWjkh
\_dZ[d
L_[
^_[huX[h
i[^h
m[d_]&
m[_b
Z_[
E[kj[
d_Y^j
l[hij[^[d&
m_[
cWd
P_[Z[ha[^h
ijkZ_[h[d
ckii&
WX[h
_c
;[h[_Y^
c[_d[h
[_][d[d
>h\W^hkd]
X_d
_Y^
Wk\
i[^h
_dj[h[iiWdj[
=_d][
][ijeii[d(
>_d_][
E[kj[&
Z_[
_Y^
aWddj[&
^Wjj[d
>h_dd[hkd][d
_^h[h
[hij[d
E[X[di`W^h[&
kdZ
i_[
Wbb[
^Wj' j[d
Z[d
>_dZhkYa&
_^h[
=[dam[_i[
i[_
d_Y^j
Z_[
[_d[i
D_dZ[i
][m[i[d(
P_[
i_[
E[kj[d
X[][]d[j[d&
m_[
i_[
E[kj[
[haWddj[d
'
[i
mWh
a[_d[
a_dZb_Y^[
IioY^ebe]_[(
L_[
^Wjj[d
[_d[d
lebb
Wki][' X_bZ[j[d
O[hijWdZ
c_j
]sdpb_Y^
[hmWY^i[d[d
K[Waj_ed[d&
m_[
cWd
_^d
i_Y^
d_Y^j
Wbi
>h][Xd_i
led
i[Y^i
FedWj[d
kdX[mkiij[d
E[X[di
lehij[bb[d
aWdd(
LebY^[
@[_ij[h
cuii[d
pkleh
[n_ij_[hj
^WX[d&
m[dd
_^h[
>h_dd[hkd][d
m_hab_Y^
h_Y^j_]
mWh[d(
:X[h&
m_[
_Y^
iW]j[&
_ij
[i
i[^h
iY^m[h&
FWj[h_Wb
pk
\_dZ[d&
kdZ
Z_[
c[_ij[d
E[kj[
[h_dd[hd
i_Y^
Wd
uX[h^Wkfj
d_Y^ji( yPWhkc
iebbj[
Z_[i
\hu^[
@[ZsY^jd_i
[hbtiY^[d&
m[dd
ZWi
D_dZ
pk
ifh[Y^[d
X[]_ddj9z =Wi
D_dZ
X[]_ddj&
WdZ[h[
D_dZ[h
dWY^pkW^c[d
kdZ
][dWk
ZWi
pk
jkd&
mWi
Z_[
>hmWY^i[d[d
led
_^c
[hmWhj[d(
L_[
[hmWh' j[d&
ZWii
[i
[_d
Zkcc[i
D_dZ
_ij&
kdZ
[i
m_hZ
[_d
Zkcc[i
D_dZ( yP_[
aWdd
cWd
m_ii[d&
Wd
mWi
i_Y^
[_d
D_dZ
[h_dd[hj9
BY^
ZWY^j[&
ZWii
cWd
c_j
ltbb_]
b[[h[d
S[djh[d
][Xeh[d
m_hZ
kdZ
ZWii
cWd
i_Y^
c_j
A_b\[
Z[h
S[djh[d
[h_dd[hj(z =_[i
_ij
[_d[
i[bjiWc[
LWY^[(
=[ddeY^
^WX[d
Z_[
E[kj[&
led
Z[d[d
_Y^
ifhWY^
kdZ
Z_[
i_Y^
d_Y^j
i[^h
led
WdZ[h[d
kdj[hiY^[_' Z[d&
ie]Wh
]Wdp
X[ij_ccj[
>h_dd[hkd][d
_^h[h
[hij[d
FedWj[&
kdZ
i_[
]bWkX[d&
=_d][
m_[
>hmWY^i[d[
mW^h][decc[d
pk
^WX[d
kdZ
d_Y^j
m_[
D_dZ[h(
L_[
l[hikY^[d
d_Y^j&
audijb_Y^[
>h_dd[hkd][d
Wki
p[hijh[kj[d
kdZ
XhkY^ijuYa^W\j[d
>h_dd[hkd' $(

][d
pkiWcc[dpki[jp[d5
i_[
^WX[d
]Wdp
[_dZ[kj_][
>h_dd[hkd][d
Wd
Aski[h&
E[kj[
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
L_[
iY^[_d[d
[_d[
ltbb_]
[hmWY^' i[d[
@[_ij[i^Wbjkd]
][^WXj
pk
^WX[d( yBY^
aWdd
c_Y^
Wd
=_d][
_c
:bj[h
led
pm[_
CW^h[d
[h_dd[hd&
Z_[
uX[h^Wkfj
d_Y^j
ijWjj\WdZ[d(
P_[
aWdd
cWd
uX[hfhu\[d&
Wd
mWi
[_d
;WXo
i_Y^
[h_dd[hj&
X[leh
[i
ifh[Y^[d
aeddj[9z Pe^[h
m_ii[d
L_[&
ZWii
i_[
d_Y^j
][iY^W^[d9
>i
aeddj[
[_d
MhWkc
][m[i[d
i[_d(
BY^
^Wjj[
[_d[
iebY^[
>h\W^hkd](
BY^
m[_ii
deY^&
ZWii
_Y^
Wbi
ab[_d[i
D_dZ
Wd
[_d[c
Hhj
_d
Z[h
Gs^[
FeiaWki
mWh&
kdZ
ZWi
;_bZ
Z[i
Hhj[i
Xb_[X
_d
c[_d[c
@[ZsY^j' d_i(
Bd
P_hab_Y^a[_j
mWh
_Y^
[hij
l_[h
CW^h[
ifsj[h
Wd
Z_[i[h
Lj[bb[(
:bi
_Y^
ifsj[h
Zehj^_d
aWc&
iW^
_Y^&
ZWii
Z[h
Hhj
d_Y^j
ie
mWh&
m_[
_Y^
_^d
_c
@[ZsY^jd_i
^Wjj[&
kdZ
_Y^
[haWddj[&
ZWii
c[_d[
>h_dd[hkd]
[_d
MhWkc
][m[i[d
mWh( Sk
Z[h
?hW][
\hu^[h[h
E[X[d4
BY^
]bWkX[&
ZWii
[_d_][
E[kj[
i_Y^
Wd
[jmWi
[h_dd[hd
atdd[d&
m[dd
WkY^
i[^h
i[bj[d&
Z[dd
i_Y^
pk
[h_dd[hd
X[Z[kj[j
X[h[_ji
[_d[d
][m_ii[d
@hWZ
Z[h
>djm_Ya' bkd](
=[h
][mt^db_Y^[
F[diY^
'
Gh(
b&
Gh(
,
kdZ
Gh(
-
'
^Wj
a[_d
Hh]Wd
\uh
iebY^
[_d
@[ZsY^jd_i(
=_[
>ii[dp
_ij
c[Y^Wd_iY^(
L_[
b[Xj
d_Y^j
Wki
i_Y^
i[bXij5
i_[
^Wj
a[_d[d
X[iedZ[h[d
=[daWffW' hWj&
iedZ[hd
ckii
ZkhY^
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
Z[da[d&
kdZ
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
^Wj
a[_d[
>h\W^hkd]( yPWi
c[_dj[d
L_[&
Wbi
L_[
iW]j[d
6;[eXWY^j[d
L_[
D_dZ[h89z @[hWZ[
ZWi
_ij
ie
iY^m[h(
P[dd
L_[
[_d[
K[_^[
led
M[dZ[d' p[d
X[eXWY^j[d&
atdd[d
L_[
Wk\
ltbb_]
uX[hhWiY^[dZ[
M[dZ[dp[d
ijeii[d(
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
iW][d&
i_[
i[_[d
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
[_d[h
X[ij_ccj[d
NhiWY^[
eZ[h
Nc][Xkd]&
m[_b
ltbb_]
kd[hmWhj[j[
M[dZ[dp[d
Wk\jWkY^[d
kdZ
l[hiY^m_dZ[d
atdd[d(
L_[
m[hZ[d
ms^h[dZ
Z[i
ifsj[h[d
E[X[di
\ehjZWk[hd(
Bd
[_d[c
iebY^[d
?Wbb
aWdd
Z_[
M[dZ[dp&
][csii
Z[h
M^[eh_[
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h&
_d
[_d[c
l_[b
ifsj[h[d
:bj[h
[hmehX[d
mehZ[d
i[_d&
kc
ZWdd
i[^h
\hu^
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d
Wk\pkjWkY^[d( yDWdd
[i
ZWdd
lec
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
Wki
d_Y^j
i[_d&
ZWii
[_d_][
m_Y^j_][
AWdZbkd][d&
Z_[
m_h
led
`[jpj
Wd
X_i
pkc
S[_jfkdaj
kdi[h[i
MeZ[i
X[][^[d&
_d
Z[h
MWj
\uh
kdi[h[
G[_]kd][d
l[hWdjmehjb_Y^
i_dZ9z $)

L_[
c[_d[d&
_c
l[h]Wd][d[d
E[X[d(
=khY^Wki
ct]b_Y^(
;[' Z[da[d
L_[
`[ZeY^&
ZWii
[i
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
\hu^[h
dscb_Y^
deY^
d_Y^j
]WX5
ct]b_Y^[hm[_i[
[_d[
WdZ[h[
:hX[_j
"[i
]_Xj
l_[b[
:hj[d#&
WX[h
d_Y^j
Z_[i[(
L_[
[n_ij_[hj[
\hu^[h
d_Y^j&
Z[ii[d
X_d
_Y^
lebbaecc[d
i_Y^[h( yBY^
c[_d[&
ZWii
[i
[_d
uX[hmsbj_][dZ[h
@[ZWda[
_ij&
ZWii
m_h
_d
Z[h
S[_j
X_i
pk
kdi[h[c
MeZ[
l[h^sd]d_ilebb[
MWj[d
X[][^[d
atddj[d&
Z_[
kdi
\uh
ZWi
dsY^ij[
FWb
G[_]kd][d
[_dfhs][d(z @[m_ii
atdd[d
m_h
_d
`[Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya
kdi[h[i
E[X[di
G[_]kd][d
[hp[k][d&
Z_[
m_h
ct]b_Y^[hm[_i[
ms^h[dZ
p[^d
E[' X[d
d_Y^j
c[^h
bei
m[hZ[d(
=[i^WbX
m_hZ
Z_[i[h
Ikdaj
_d
Z[h
_dZ_iY^[d
E_j[hWjkh
_cc[h
m_[Z[h
^[hleh][^eX[d(
>i
cW]
_d
FshY^[d\ehc
][iY^[^[d&
WX[h
ZWi
Ih_dp_f
Xb[_Xj
ZWii[bX[( yBij
[i
ct]b_Y^&
c_jj[bi
D_dZ^[_ji[h_dd[hkd][d
[jmWi
uX[h
>ii[dp
pk
b[hd[d9z =Wi
atdd[d
L_[&
m[dd
L_[
[_d
]kj[i
@[ZsY^jd_i
^WX[d
kdZ
=_d][
_d
i_Y^
\_dZ[d&
Z_[
i_Y^
][sdZ[hj
^WX[d
kdZ
iebY^[&
Z_[
i_Y^
d_Y^j
sdZ[hd( y@_Xj
[i
[_d
:dp[_Y^[d&
Wk\]hkdZ
Z[ii[d
L_[
iW][d
atdd[d&
ZWii
m_h
d_Y^j
iY^ed
[_dcWb
_d
Z_[i[c
AWki
mWh[d9z G_[cWdZ
aWdd
ZWi
iW][d(
BY^
m[_ii
b[Z_]b_Y^&
ZWii
_Y^
deY^
d_Y^j
pkleh
_d
Z_[i[c
AWki
][m[i[d
X_d( y=Wdd
mWh[d
m_h
[i
WkY^
d_Y^j(z BY^
m[_ii
d_Y^j(
:X[h
L_[
asc[d
Z[h
PW^h^[_j
l_[b
ds^[h&
m[dd
L_[
c_j
Z[c
C[jpj
Wbi
Z[c
[hij[d
FWb
Wd\Wd][d
muhZ[d(
P[dd
m_h
pkleh
[jmWi
jWj[d&
ZWdd
mWh
[i
_cc[h
ie
l_[b&
m_[
X_i
Wd^_d
ct]b_Y^
mWh( y;[Z[kj[j
Z[h
@[ZWda[
fWhWbb[b[h
S[_j&
ZWii
Wbb[
:k][dXb_Ya[
WdZWk[hdZ
[n_ij_[h[d9z CW&
[i
_ij
i[^h
iY^m[h&
ZWhuX[h
dWY^pkZ[da[d(
L_Y^[hb_Y^
X[Z[kj[j
[h
>m_]a[_j
Z[i
:k][dXb_Yai&
WX[h
kdi[h
O[hijWdZ
l[hij[^j
[i
d_Y^j
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
pk
Z[da[d(
Ndi[h
O[hijWdZ
_ij
[_d[
i[^h
X[iY^hsdaj[
FWiY^_d[(
P_h
cuii[d
Wk\
Z_[
[_d\WY^ij[
:hj
Z[da[d
kdZ
Z_[i
X[huYai_Y^j_][d(
>i
_ij
[_d\WY^[h&
Wd
P_[' Z[h^ebkd]
pk
Z[da[d
Wbi
Wd
Z_[
[m_][
>n_ij[dp
Z[i
:k][dXb_Yai(
L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
kdi[h
O[hijWdZ
Z_[
=_d][
d_Y^j $*

WkiZhuYa[d
aWdd&
m_[
i_[
m_hab_Y^
i_dZ(
P_h
atdd[d
dkh
Wk\
[_d[
:hj
\ehckb_[h[d&
Z_[
Z[h
PW^h^[_j
ds^[h
aeccj
Wbi
ZWi
][mt^d' b_Y^[
=[da[d(
F[^h
_ij
d_Y^j
ct]b_Y^(
Ndi[h
O[hijWdZ
kdZ
kdi[h[
LfhWY^[
i_dZ
i[^h
]heX[
Bdijhkc[dj[&
kdZ
m_h
^WX[d
[i
c_j
i[^h
\[_d[d
@[][dijsdZ[d
kdZ
\[_d[d
?hW][d
pk
jkd( yP[dd
cWd
Z[c
Loij[c
X[h[_ji
_d
[_d[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
X[][]' d[j
_ij&
_ij
[i
Z_[
?hW][&
eX
cWd
_^c
_c
dsY^ij[d
WkY^
m_[Z[h
X[][]d[d
m_hZ9z =Wi
^sd]j
ZWled
WX&
m_[
cWd
c_j
Z[c
Loij[c
kc]_d](
FWd
atddj[
Z[c
Loij[c
X[][]d[d
kdZ
iW][d4
yPWi
\uh
[_d[d
Ndi_dd
Z_[i[
E[kj[
h[Z[d(z
:bie
^sd]j
[i
ZWled
WX&
m_[l_[b
Fu^[
cWd
i_Y^
][][X[d
^Wj(
P[dd
cWd
i_Y^
Wdijh[d]j[&
atddj[
cWd
[jmWi
[h' h[_Y^j
^WX[d&
kdZ
Z_[i
atddj[
Xb[_X[d&
m[dd
[i
d_Y^j
b[Z_]b_Y^
M[_b
Z[h
9AFCGLNCOP[LJGAFICGQ
mWh5
m[dd
[i
d_Y^j
dkh
Wd[hpe][d
mWh( yD[^hj
cWd
Wbi
F[diY^
Gh(
.
m_[Z[h&
m[dd
cWd
Wbi
F[diY^
Gh(
.
ijWhX&
eZ[h
aWdd
cWd
ZWi
>hh[_Y^j[
ZkhY^
GWY^W^c[d
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h
l[hb_[h[d9z G[_d&
dkh
F[diY^
Gh(
/
aWdd
Wbi
F[diY^
Gh(
/
m_[Z[ha[^h[d(
O_[bb[_Y^j
m[_ii
[h
[i
d_Y^j&
WX[h
[h
m_hZ
[i
b[_Y^j[h
^WX[d(
Gh(
.
ckii
m_[Z[h^eb[d&
Wbb[hZ_d]i
m_hZ
[i
\hu^[h
kdZ
b[_Y^j[h
i[_d( yDWdd
[_d[
G[_]kd]
_d
[_d[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
[_d[
@[me^d^[_j
_d
Z[h
dsY^ij[d
i[_d9z =Wi
aeccj
Wk\
Z_[
G[_]kd]
Wd(
P[dd
i_[
c[Y^Wd_iY^
_ij&
m_hZ
i_[
pkh
@[me^d^[_j
m[hZ[d5
m[dd
[i
[_d[
X[mkiij[
G[_]kd]
_ij&
aWdd
i_[
d_Y^j
pkh
@[me^d^[_j
m[hZ[d&
m[_b
[i
i_Y^
ZWX[_
kc
pm[_
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
=_d][
^WdZ[bj(
:bb[
[hmehX[d[d
G[_]kd][d
m_[Z[h' ^eb[d
i_Y^(
>_d[
I[hied
[hm_hXj
Z_[
G[_]kd]&
X[ij_ccj[
=_d][
pk
ijkZ_[h[d
eZ[h
i_Y^
\uh
i_[
pk
_dj[h[ii_[h[d(
L_[
m_hZ
m_[Z[h
_dj[h' [ii_[hj
i[_d(
>_d[
WdZ[h[
I[hied
[hm_hXj
[_d[
G[_]kd]&
leh
X[' ij_ccj[d
=_d][d
ZWledpkbWk\[d(
L_[
m_hZ
m_[Z[h
ZWledbWk\[d(
=_[i[
G[_]kd][d
atdd[d
i_Y^
l[hijsha[d
eZ[h
i_[
atdd[d
_d
[_d[
WdZ[h[
K_Y^jkd]
mWY^i[d(
>i
]_Xj
ie
bWd][
a[_d[
@WhWdj_[&
X_i
cWd
[_d[d
][m_ii[d
@hWZ
X[mkiij[h
AWdZbkd]i\s^_]a[_j
[hmehX[d
^Wj&
[hij
ZWdd
X[ij[^j
[_d[
][m_ii[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j&
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
jhWk[d( yPuhZ[d
L_[
[habsh[d&
m_[
[_d
F[diY^
pm[_
]b[_Y^p[_j_][
E[' X[d
i_ckbjWd
_d
pm[_
S[_jhskc[d
pkh
i[bX[d
S[_j
hu^h[d
aWdd9z %!

O_[b[i
i_[^j
kdct]b_Y^
Wki&
WX[h
dkh
Z[i^WbX&
m[_b
kdi[h
=[daWffWhWj
d_Y^j
Wkih[_Y^j&
kc
uX[h
iebY^[
=_d][
dWY^pkZ[d' a[d(
>h
l[h[_d\WY^j
Z_[
=_d][
pk
ijWha(
=_[i[
?hW][d
[h\ehZ[hd
cWj^[cWj_iY^[i
=[da[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
atdd[d
m_h
kdi
Z_[
S[_j
d_Y^j
Wbi
Dkhl[&
iedZ[hd
dkh
Wbi
@[hWZ[
Z[da[d(
P[dd
m_h
Z_[
S[_j
Wbi
Dkhl[
Z[da[d
atddj[d
kdZ
Wbb[
Bcfb_aWj_ed[d
l[hijsd' Z[d&
muhZ[
Z_[i[
?hW][
_d
B^d[d
d_Y^j
[djij[^[d(
=_[iX[pu]b_Y^
i_dZ
m_h
_d
][dWk
Z[hi[bX[d
EW][
m_[
[_d
pm[_Z_c[di_edWb[i
P[i[d&
ZWi
i_Y^
[_d[
Zh[_Z_c[di_edWb[
P[bj
lehpkij[bb[d
l[h' ikY^j(
Bd
P_hab_Y^a[_j
]_Xj
[i
a[_d
Z[hWhj_][i
IheXb[c(
=Wi
IheXb[c
_ij
Z_[
Ljhkajkh
kdi[h[i
[_][d[d
O[hijWdZ[i(
S_[b
kdi[' h[h
]Wdp[d
:hX[_j
_ij&
Z[d
Zh_jj[d
kdZ
l_[hj[d
;[mkiiji[_dipk' ijWdZ
pk
[hh[_Y^[d&
mWi
X[Z[kj[j&
c_jj[bi
^t^[h[h
S[djh[d
pk
Z[da[d(
P[dd
m_h
ZWi
atddj[d&
muhZ[d
IheXb[c[
Z[i
pkaud\j_' ][d
E[X[di&
:XikhZ_jsj[d
m_[
Z_[i[
?hW][
dWY^
Z[h
S[_j
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h&
d_Y^j
Wk\jWkY^[d(
P_[
Z_[
=_d][
b_[][d&
atdd[d
m_h
dkh
j^[eh[j_i_[h[d(
P_h
m_ii[d
c[^h
eZ[h
m[d_][h&
m_[
m_h
kdi
Z_[i[d
IheXb[c[d
ds^[hd&
WX[h
m_h
atdd[d
d_Y^ji
L_Y^[h[i
m_ii[d( yDWdd
[_d
F[diY^
_d
[_d[c
E[X[d
Gh(
/
i[_d
kdZ
_d
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
Gh(
-9z =Wi
m[_ii
_Y^
m_hab_Y^
d_Y^j(
FWd
aWdd
Gh(
/
d_Y^j
fbtjpb_Y^
m[hZ[d&
cWd
ckii
i_Y^
bWd]iWc
Wdds^[hd&
kdZ
m[dd
[_d
F[diY^
i_Y^
Wkii[h^WbX
[_d[h
LY^kb[
_d
K_Y^jkd]
Wk\
Gh(
/
[djm_Ya[bj&
ZWdd
_ij
ZWi
[_d
i[^h
bWd]iWc[h
Ihep[ii5
ZW^[h
Z[da[
_Y^&
ZWii
Z[h
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
led
[_d[c
E[X[d
pkc
WdZ[h[d
d_Y^j
ie
]heii
i[_d
m_hZ(
BY^
aWdd
dkh
[_d[i
ZWhuX[h
iW][d(
BY^
Z[da[&
ZWii
cWd
[i
ZWi
dsY^ij[
FWb
d_Y^j
ltbb_]
l[h][ii[d
^WX[d
aWdd&
m[dd
cWd
X[mkiij
kdZ
lebbijsdZ_]
led
P_[Z[ha[^h
D[ddjd_i
^Wj
kdZ
uX[h
i_[
ifh[Y^[d
kdZ
i_[
Wap[fj_[h[d
aWdd(
P[dd
L_[
i_[
ZW^[h
Wap[fj_[h[d
kdZ
_d
[_d[c
E[X[d
a[dd[d&
X[ij[^j
[_d[
]kj[
:kii_Y^j&
i_Y^
ZWi
dsY^ij[
FWb
Wd
l_[b
c[^h
pk
[h_dd[hd(
P_h
^WX[d
a[_d[
>h\W^hkd]im[hj[&
WX[h
L_[
m[hZ[d
X[c[ha[d&
m_[
cWd
_d
E_j[hWjkh&
@[iY^_Y^j[
kdZ
I^_beief^_[
m_[Z[h
kdZ
m_[Z[h
Wk\
Z_[
BZ[[
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
pkhuYaaeccj(
L_[
][hsj
d_[
ltbb_]
_d
O[h][ii[d^[_j&
WX[h
i_[
_ij
i[^h
iY^m[h
_d
[_d[
Zh[_Z_c[di_edWb[
P[bj
[_dpkfWii[d(
L_[
X[dtj_]j
[_d[
\ud\Z_c[di_edWb[
P[bj&
kdZ %"

Z_[
?hW][
Z[i
>h_dd[hdi
X[p_[^j
i_Y^
_d
Z[h
MWj
X[h[_ji
Wk\
i[Y^i
=_c[di_ed[d(
Bd
Z[h
\ud\j[d
=_c[di_ed
a[^hj
Z[h
F[diY^
m_[' Z[h
kdZ
m_[Z[h&
e^d[
[i
pk
m_ii[d(
L_Y^
pk
[h_dd[hd
X[Z[kj[j
[_d
][m_ii[i
PWY^i[d
_d
Z[h
i[Y^ij[d
=_c[di_ed( =_c[di_ed[d
atdd[d
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
[_d\WY^
l[hijWdZ[d
m[h' Z[d(
=_[
l_[hj[
=_c[di_ed
_ij
ZWi
>ha[dd[d
[_d[h
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
_d
`[Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya5
mWi
m_h
S[_j
d[dd[d(
=_[
\ud\j[
=_c[di_ed
_ij
Z_[
P_[Z[h^ebkd]
^_[hled(
=_[
i[Y^ij[
=_c[di_ed
_ij
ZWi
>ha[dd[d
SCOPAFGCBCLCO
Ft]b_Y^a[_j[d(
:X[h
[i
_ij
iY^m[h&
ZWh' uX[h
dWY^pkZ[da[d&
iebWd][
m_h
kdi
S[_j
Wbi
[_d[
@[hWZ[
leh' ij[bb[d(
=Wi
IheXb[c
[n_ij_[hj
d_Y^j
m_hab_Y^5
[i
_ij
dkh
kdi[h[
LY^msY^[&
d_Y^j
c[^h( yBY^
l[hij[^[
d_Y^j&
mWi
L_[
c[_d[d&
m[dd
L_[
iW][d&
Z_[
l_[hj[
=_c[di_ed
i[_
ZWi
>ha[dd[d
[_d[h
Ft]b_Y^a[_j(z =Wi
E[X[d
_ij
Z_[
l_[hj[
=_c[di_ed&
[_d
Dh[_i&
ZWi
>ha[dd[d
[_d[h
Ft]b_Y^a[_j(
P[dd
[i
pk
i[_d[c
>dZ[
aeccj&
X[][]d[j
[i
Z[c
[_][d[d
:d\Wd](
=[h
:k][dXb_Ya
Z[i
MeZ[i
[djifh_Y^j
Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya
Z[h
@[Xkhj&
kdZ
ZWdd
X[]_ddj
ZWi
E[X[d
led
d[k' [c&
l_[bb[_Y^j
c_j
][h_d][d
:Xm[_Y^kd][d&
Z_[
d_Y^ji
X[Z[kj[d(
>i
a[^hj
_cc[h
pkc
i[bX[d
@[b[_i[
pkhuYa(
>_d[
AWkfjj[dZ[dp
pk
X[[dZ[d&
ZWi
E[X[d
Wk\
[_d[
ltbb_]
WdZ[h[
:hj
pk
X[]_dd[d&
m_hZ
Z_[
i[Y^ij[
=_c[di_ed
i[_d( P_h
atdd[d
kdi
i_ckbjWd[
:k][dXb_Ya[
d_Y^j
lehij[bb[d&
m_h
cuii[d
Wk\[_dWdZ[h\eb][dZ[
:k][dXb_Ya[
Wdd[^c[d&
eXme^b
i_[
Wk\
[_d[h
WdZ[h[d
LaWbW
i_ckbjWd
i_dZ(
Skc
;[_if_[b
_ij
kdi[h[
[_][d[
>h\W^hkd]
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
ab[_d[
IWhj_a[b
m_[
>b[a' jhed[d
Z[hWhj&
ZWii
_^h[
,TGEICGQ
_d
kdi[h[h
>CGQ
b_[]j(
PWhkc
aWdd
ZW^[h
kdi[h
TGCBCOFMJQCP
(RDQOCQCL
d_Y^j
_d
Z[h
>CGQ
Z[h
>hZ[
ijWjj\_dZ[d9 yOed
c[_d[c
O[hijsdZd_i
Z[i
@[ZsY^jd_ii[i
^[h
i[^[
_Y^
d_Y^j&
m_[
[i
ct]b_Y^
i[_d
iebb&
i_Y^
[_d[h
l[h]Wd][d[d
P_[Z[h' a[^h
pk
[h_dd[hd(
BY^
ZWY^j[&
ZWi
@[ZsY^jd_i
X[hk^[
Wk\
Z[c
Bd^Wbj
Z[h
S[djh[d&
Z_[
_d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
b_[][d(
P_[
aWdd
i_Y^
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
Wd
P_[Z[ha[^h
[h_dd[hd9z L_[
atdd[d
i_Y^
d_Y^j
[h_dd[hd&
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
d_Y^j
^_[h
[h_dd[hd&
_d
Z_[i[h
P_[Z[ha[^h(
P_h
^WX[d
pkleh
][b[Xj( %#

O_[b[
MWjiWY^[d
X[m[_i[d
[i(
=[h
@hkdZ&
mWhkc
m_h
kdi
d_Y^j
[h_dd[hd&
b_[]j
ZWhWd&
ZWii
m_h
kdi
d_Y^j
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hj
^WX[d(
=Wii[bX[
jh_\\j
Wk\
Z_[i[i
E[X[d
pk(
P_h
[h_dd[hd
kdi
d_Y^j
m_hab_Y^
Z[h
=_d][&
Z_[
m_h
c[Y^Wd_iY^
jkd&
m_h
m_ii[d
dkh&
ZWii
i_[
ijWjj\WdZ[d(
Gkh
ZkhY^
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
atdd[d
m_h
>_dp[b^[_j[d
_c
@[ZsY^jd_i
X[^Wbj[d( I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
_ij
_cc[h
c_j
>ii[dp
l[hc_iY^j(
=Wi
@[ZsY^j' d_i
b_[]j
_d
Z[h
>ii[dp&
d_Y^j
_d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
WX[h
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
aWdd
[i
ltbb_]
h_Y^j_]
X[iY^h[_X[d&
m[dd
ZWi
@[' ZsY^jd_i
ijWha
][dk]
_ij( y>i
_ij
i[^h
iY^m[h
i_Y^
lehpkij[bb[d&
ZWii
cWd
i_Y^
ZWhWk\
lehX[h[_j[j&
Z[c
Loij[c
\hu^[h
pk
X[][]d[d(z L_[
atdd[d
i_Y^
Wk\
d_Y^ji
lehX[h[_j[d(
Gkh
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd&
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
i_Y^
Z[h
=_d][
X[ii[h
[h_dd[hd(
:bb[i
b_[]j
Wd
Z[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d4
P_h
][d_[ii[d
i_[
ie
i[^h&
ZWii
m_h
Wd
d_Y^ji
WdZ[h[c
Bdj[h[ii[
^WX[d(
P[dd
L_[
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
`[jpj
[h_dd[hd&
ZWdd
ct][d
L_[
i_Y^
ZWi
dsY^ij[
FWb
[h_dd[hd( yBij
ZWi
Z[h
@hkdZ
\uh
ZWi
6A_[h
mWh
_Y^
iY^ed
[_dcWb8
@[\u^b9
=Wi
@[\u^b&
X[h[_ji
[_d
LjuYa
P_ii[d
pk
^WX[d&
ZWi
cWd
kdct]b_Y^
leh^[h
[h\W^h[d
^WX[d
aeddj[9z BY^
m_bb
MWjiWY^[d(
O_[bb[_Y^j
^WdZ[bj
[i
i_Y^
[_d\WY^
kc
[_d
Wki
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
Oehij[bbkd][d
pkiWcc[d][i[jpj[i
;_bZ(
P[dd
L_[
i_Y^
m_hab_Y^
Wd
[jmWi
=[hWhj_][i
[h_dd[hd&
ie
X[Z[kj[j
ZWi&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd
atdd[d(
P[dd
L_[
i_Y^
d_Y^j
i[bXij'[h_dd[hd
atdd[d&
_ij
[i
dkh
>_dX_bZkd]( yDWdd
pk\sbb_][i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
pk
Z_[i[c
Sm[Ya
dujpb_Y^
i[_d9z Sk\sbb_][i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
_ij
[_d
cec[djWd[i
:k\Xb_jp[d(
FWd
aWdd
i_Y^
d_Y^j
ZWhWk\
l[hbWii[d( =_[
[_dp_][
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
Z[i
PWdZ[bi
X[]_ddj
c_j
Z[h
Ft]' b_Y^a[_j&
ZWii
L_[
Wd\Wd][d&
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
`[jpj
pk
[h_dd[hd(
P_[Z[ha[^h
_ij
_dd[h^WbX
Z[i
Loij[ci
d_Y^j
dejm[dZ_](
L_[
cW]
_dj[h[iiWdj
eZ[h
dujpb_Y^
i[_d5
L_[
atdd[d
ie]Wh
ZWc_j
X[]_dd[d&
WX[h
\uh
Z_[
jWjisY^b_Y^[
:hX[_j
_ij
Z[h
@[ZWda[
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
d_Y^j
dejm[dZ_](
:ki
Z_[i[c
@hkdZ
^WX[d
m_h
led
Z_[i[c %$

Loij[c
d_Y^ji
ZWhuX[h
[h\W^h[d5
i_[
aWc
led
Wkii[h^WbX&
led
Z[h
E_j[hWjkh
kdZ
led
c_h(
=Wdd
i[^[d
L_[&
ZWii
i_[
fWiij5
i_[
ij[^j
d_Y^j
_c
P_Z[hifhkY^(
:X[h
i_[
_ij
d_Y^j
dejm[dZ_]&
Z[dd
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
jkd
atdd[d&
atdd[d
m_h
dkh
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d
jkd(
P[dd
m_h
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d
d_Y^ji
jkd&
ZWdd
m_hZ
ZWi
dsY^ij[
E[X[d
][dWkie
i[_d&
eZ[h
[i
aWdd
_d
b[_Y^j[d
OWh_Wj_ed[d
ZWii[bX[
i[_d&
WX[h
e^d[
m_hab_Y^[
qdZ[hkd]( yDtdd[d
L_[
[habsh[d&
mWhkc
O[hikY^[&
i_Y^
i[bXij'pk'[h_d'
d[hd&
ie
[hcuZ[dZ
pk
i[_d
iY^[_d[d&
m[dd
cWd
[i
uX[h
bsd][h[
S[_j
l[hikY^j9z =[c
cuiij[
d_Y^j
ie
i[_d(
>_d[
ct]b_Y^[
>habshkd]
X[ij[^j
ZWh_d&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
c_j
B^h[d
][_ij_][d
;[cu^kd][d
athf[hb_Y^
Wdijh[d][d(
BY^
c[_d[&
ZWii
:dijh[d]kd][d&
i_Y^
i[_d[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd&
dkh
ZWdd
[hcuZ[dZ
i[_d
atdd[d&
m[dd
[jmWi
?WbiY^[i
ZWc_j
l[hXkdZ[d
m_hZ(
Sk[hij
i_dZ
m_h
kd\s^_]&
kdi
\uh
bsd][h[
S[_j
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd&
kdZ
[i
_ij
uX[h^Wkfj
X[ii[h&
m[dd
i_[
ZWhWd
Z[da[d
eZ[h
F[j^eZ[d
\_dZ[d&
Z_[
B^d[d
B^h[
:Xi_Y^j
ie
e\j
m_[
ct]b_Y^
_di
@[ZsY^jd_i
hk\j(
>i
aWdd
[hcuZ[d&
m[dd
L_[
b[Z_]b_Y^
l[hikY^[d&
i_Y^
ZWhWk\pk
aedp[djh_[h[d(
=Wi
_ij
a[_d
m_hab_Y^[i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd&
iedZ[hd
ZWi
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
_c
@[ZsY^jd_i
X[^Wbj[d(
=Wi
_ij
WkY^
pk
;[]_dd
Z[i
LjkZ_kci
dujpb_Y^&
WX[h
ifsj[h
cuii[d
L_[
WdZ[h[
F[j^eZ[d
\_dZ[d( y:bb[
:dijh[d]kd][d
Z[i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hdi&
Z_[
_Y^
kdj[hdec' c[d
^WX[&
iY^_[d[d
d_[
j_[\[h
pk
][^[d
eZ[h
[_d[
^t^[h[
>X[d[
pk
[hh[_Y^[d(
>i
pk
jkd&
iY^[_dj
_cc[h
Wdijh[d][dZ
pk
i[_d(z @[dWk
ZWhkc
][^j
[i(
L_[
cuii[d
jkd&
mWi
L_[
atdd[d(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
[hij&
i_Y^
Wk\
Z_[
][mt^db_Y^[
:hj
Wd
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd&
ZWdd
_d
iY^m_[h_][d
:k][dXb_Ya[d&
Z[d
:k][dXb_Ya[d&
_d
Z[d[d
L_[
i_Y^
Wc
b[_Y^j[ij[d
l[h][ii[d(
GWY^
l_[b[d
Z[hWhj_' ][d
P_[Z[h^ebkd][d
m[hZ[d
L_[
i[^[d&
ZWii
[i
fbtjpb_Y^
Wk\
[_d[
WdZ[h[
>X[d[
uX[h][^[d
m_hZ(
:X[h
ZWi
m_hZ
e^d[
B^h[
[_][d[d
Z_h[aj[d
:dijh[d]kd][d
][iY^[^[d( yP[dd
[_d
F[diY^
[_d[d
^t^[h[d
;[mkiiji[_dipkijWdZ
[h' bWd]j&
m_[
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_d&
sdZ[hj
i_Y^
ZWdd
Z_[
@[iY^m_dZ_]' a[_j
i[_d[h
?kdaj_ed[d9
F_j
WdZ[h[d
Pehj[d&
aWdd
[h
`[cWbi
^e\\[d&
[_d
>_dZhkYa
m[hZ[
\uh
_^d
bsd][h
Wbi
[_d[
p[^djWki[dZ' %%

ij[b
L[akdZ[&
[_d
:j[cpk]
bsd][h
Wbi
Zh[_
L[akdZ[d
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h
ZWk[hd9z =_[
@[iY^m_dZ_]a[_j
Z[h
?kdaj_ed[d
aWdd
i_Y^
sdZ[hd(
=_[i
[djifh_Y^j
d_Y^j
Z[h
=Wk[h
led
>_dZhuYa[d&
kdZ
[i
_ij
dkjpbei&
Z[d
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
pk
kdj[hikY^[d(
=_[
>_dZhuYa[
ZWk[hd
ZWdd
bsd][h(
P[dd
m_h
lec
p[^djWki[dZij[d
M[_b
[_d[h
L[akdZ[
ifh[Y^[d&
X[p_[^[d
m_h
kdi
dkh
Wk\
[_d[d
>_dZhkYa
Z[i
_dj[bb[a' jk[bb[d
S[djhkci(
>i
]_Xj
m[_j[h[( yP[dd
[_d[
S[bb[
i_Y^
_^h[h
?kdaj_ed
Wbi
M[_b
[_d[i
F[diY^[d
X[mkiij
muhZ[&
muhZ[
i_[
l[h][ii[d&
ZWii
i_[
[_d[
S[bb[
_ij9
P[dd
Z[c[djifh[Y^[dZ
[_d
F[diY^
i_Y^
Z[h
:hj
X[mkiij
muhZ[&
_d
Z[h
[h
pkc
;[_if_[b
pkc
E[X[d
[_d[i
Lj[hdi
X[_jhs]j&
muhZ[
[h
Z_[
>h_dd[hkd]
Wd
i[_d
E[X[d
Wbi
F[diY^
l[hb_[h[d
kdZ
Wki
Z[c
Dh[_i
i_Y^
[dZbei
m_[Z[h^eb[dZ[h
E[X[diifWdd[d
l[h' iY^m_dZ[d9z @[dWk
_c
@[][dj[_b(
>_d[
S[bb[
muhZ[
ZWhWd
Z[da[d&
ZWii
i_[
[_d[
S[bb[
mWh(
=Wii[bX[
]_bj
\uh
Z[d
F[diY^[d
'
[h
muhZ[
i_Y^
ZWhWd
[h_dd[hd&
ZWii
[h
[_d
F[diY^
mWh(
>i
msh[
ZWii[bX[
m_[
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd(
>h
muhZ[
i[_d
@[ZsY^jd_i
d_Y^j
l[hb_[h[d&
ied' Z[hd
@[ZsY^jd_i
[hbWd][d( yP[dd
cWd
i[_d
E[X[d
pkhuYal[h\eb]j&
i_[^j
cWd
X[ij_ccj[
Dh[kpm[][&
Wd
Z[d[d
[_d[
>djiY^[_Zkd]
][\sbbj
mkhZ[&
Z_[
cWd
\uh
iY^b[Y^j
^sbj(
@_Xj
[i
_h][dZ[jmWi&
ZWi
cWd
_d
Z_[i[h
P_[Z[h' a[^h
jkd
aWdd&
ie
ZWii
i_Y^
Z_[
PW^hiY^[_db_Y^a[_j&
_d
Z[h
dsY^ij[d
P_[Z[ha[^h
Z[di[bX[d
?[^b[h
pk
X[][^[d&
l[hh_d][hj9z CW&
][m_ii(
FWd
aWdd
i_Y^
lehij[bb[d&
ZWii
cWd
i_Y^
_d
Z_[i[d
X[iedZ[h[d
Ikdaj[d
sdZ[hd
aWdd&
kdZ
ZWdd
'
m[dd
ZWi
=[da[d
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
j_[\
_ij
'
TGOB
cWd
i_Y^
[h_dd[hd(
P[dd
[i
d_Y^j
ie
j_[\
_ij&
I?LL
cWd
i_Y^
[h_dd[hd(
:k\
`[Z[d
?Wbb
X[ij[^j
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j&
ZWii
cWd
[i
iY^b_[iib_Y^
iY^W\\j&
CQT?P
LGAFQ
WR
QRL!
ZWi
cWd
pkleh
Q?Q#
O_[b[
Z[hWhj_][
@[ZWda[d
kdZ
=_d][
atdd[d
led
[_d[c
E[X[d
Wk\i
WdZ[h[
uX[h][^[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
\hW]j[
`[cWdZ&
mWi
[_d[c
Z_[
Oehij[bbkd]
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
X_[j[d
atd'

LC#
P[dd
cWd
Z_[i[h
Oehij[bbkd]
_dj[bb[ajk[bb
][mW^h
muhZ[
kdZ
m[dd
Z_[
Oehij[bbkd]
M[_b
Z[h
>ii[dp
muhZ[
'
M[_b
Z[h
Wbb][c[_d[d
E[X[di^Wbjkd]
'
ZWdd
atddj[
cWd
i_[
d_Y^j
l[h][i' %&

i[d&
kdZ
[i
msh[
led
Oehj[_b&
\hu^
_c
dsY^ij[d
E[X[d
ZWled
pk
m_ii[d( yAWj
[_d
F[diY^
_d
`[Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya
]Wdp
X[ij_ccj[
Ft]' b_Y^a[_j[d9z =_[
E[kj[
]bWkX[d&
[i
]sX[
l_[b[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j[d(
Skc_dZ[ij
i_[^j
[i
ie
Wki&
WX[h
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
]_Xj
[i
dkh
[_d[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
eZ[h
cWdY^cWb
pm[_(
=[h
F[diY^
aWdd
i_Y^
dkh
_c
L_dd[
Z[h
i[Y^ij[d
=_c[di_ed
sdZ[hd(
=_[
=_d][
][iY^[^[d
Wk\
[_d[
X[' ij_ccj[
P[_i[&
kdZ
[_d[
Wki
l_[b[d
Wd][decc[d[d
Ft]b_Y^a[_' j[d
m_hZ
_d
`[Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya
mW^h][decc[d&
kdZ
ZWi
[h]_Xj
Z_[
E_d_[
Z[h
l_[hj[d
=_c[di_ed(
:X[h
X[mkiij[
qdZ[hkd]&
pk
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
Sm[Ya&
mWi
Z_[
BZ[[
Z[h
:hX[_j
_ij&
Z_[
BZ[[
Z[h
>djm_Yabkd]&
m[dd
L_[
_d
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
[hdij^W\j
X[]_dd[d4
=_[i
_ij
X[h[_ji
[_d
:d\Wd]
Wk\
Z[h
i[Y^ij[d
=_c[di_ed( yL_[
iW]j[d&
[i
]sX[
l_[bb[_Y^j
pm[_
Ft]b_Y^a[_j[d
_d
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
:k][dXb_Ya(
F[_d[d
L_[
ZWc_j
[_d[
c[Y^Wd_iY^[
kdZ
[_d[
WdZ[h[9z G[_d&
[i
aWdd
c[^h[h[
c[Y^Wd_iY^[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j[d
][X[d&
Z[dd
ab[_d[
:Xm[_Y^kd][d
i_dZ
ct]b_Y^&
WX[h
i_[
][hWj[d
_cc[h
_d
ZWii[bX[
@[b[_i[
pkhuYa(

yDtdd[d
L_[
[_d_][
Z[h
?ehc[d
d[dd[d&
Z_[
Z_[
[hij[
X[mkiij[
:dijh[d]kd]
Wdd_ccj9z L_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
][mW^h
pk
i[_d(
=_[
b[X[dZ_][
Oehij[bbkd]
Z[i
yBY^
X_d
^_[hz(
:X[h
a[_d[
Pehj[(
?u^b[d(
PW^hd[^c[d&
m[h
kdZ
me
m_h
i_dZ( BY^
hWj[
B^d[d&
^WkfjisY^b_Y^
uX[h
;[mkiiji[_d
dWY^pkZ[d' a[d(
P_[
cWd
pk
l[hij[^[d
Wd\sd]j&
mWi
;[mkiiji[_d
_ij&
m_[
cWd
i_Y^
_^c
ds^[hj(
P_h
atdd[d
;[_if_[b[
led
;[mkiiji[_d
_d
kdi[h[c
[_][d[d
l[h]Wd][d[d
E[X[d
\_dZ[d(
>_d
:k][dXb_Ya
Z[i
;[mkiiji[_di
hk\j
[_d[
ijWha[
>h_dd[hkd]
^[hleh5
m[dd
m_h
ZW^[h
:k][dXb_Ya[
abWh[h
kdZ
i[^h
b[X^W\j[h
>h_dd[hkd]
_d
Z[h
O[h]Wd][d^[_j
[djZ[Ya[d
atdd[d&
ie
m_ii[d
m_h&
ZWii
i_[
ZWi %'

>h][Xd_i
led
;[mkiiji[_d
i_dZ(
F_j
[_d[c
:k\Xb_jp[d
Z[i
;[' mkiiji[_di
^WX[d
L_[
i[^h
Z[kjb_Y^[
>h_dd[hkd][d5
Hhj&
MW][i' p[_j&
PeY^[djW]
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
=_[i[
:k][dXb_Ya[
led
;[mkiij' i[_d
[h][X[d
[_d[
i[^h
b[X[dZ_][
>h_dd[hkd]( yPsh[
[i
_d
[_d[c
:k][dXb_Ya
Z[i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hdi
ct]b_Y^&
[jmWi
pk
^th[d&
ZWi
cWd
][mt^db_Y^
d_Y^j
^thj9z =khY^Wki
ct]b_Y^5
WX[h
[i
aeccj
ZWhWk\
Wd&
mWi(
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
[hmWhj[d&
>d][b
i_d][d
pk
^th[d( =[h
[_dp_][
P[]&
i[_d
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
pk
l[hX[ii[hd&
b_[]j
ZWh_d&
X[mkiij[h
pk
i[_d(
Bd
a[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
Loij[c
\_dZ[j
i_Y^
[_d[
F[j^eZ[&
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
pk
l[hX[ii[hd(
Bd
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
_ij
i_[
][dWk
X[ij_ccj4
,OGLLCOC
+GAF
+CGLCO
PCJ@PQ# O_[bb[_Y^j
d[^c[d
L_[
i_Y^
Wc
Feh][d
leh&
i_Y^
kc
+,
N^h
B^h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd(
=Wdd
Z[da[d
L_[
uX[h^Wkfj
d_Y^j
c[^h
ZWhWd&
WX[h
l_[bb[_Y^j
\sbbj
[i
B^d[d
kc
[_d
N^h
[_d(
Le
bWk\[d
Z_[
=_d][(
:X[h
m[dd
L_[
m[_j[h
ZWhWd
WhX[_j[d&
aWdd
Z_[i
i[^h
kd[hmWhj[j[
>h][Xd_ii[
p[_j_][d(
>i
][^j
[_dp_]
kdZ
Wbb[_d
ZWhkc&
Dedj_dk_jsj
pk
[hp[k][d(
?buY^j_][
>_dXb_Ya[
aecc[d
leh&
WX[h
Dedj_dk_jsj
[h\ehZ[hj
:dijh[d]kd](
@b[_Y^' p[_j_]
Zuh\[d
L_[
d_Y^j
]b[_Y^
[djckj_]j
i[_d&
Z[dd
Z[h
>h\eb]
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
msY^ij
bWd]iWc(
FWdY^cWb
[djiY^b_[ii[d
i_Y^
[_d_][&
Wbi
rXkd]
_d
Z_[i[c
Loij[c&
i_Y^
Wc
dsY^ij[d
MW]
pk
[_d[h
X[ij_ccj[d
S[_j
kdj[h
X[ij_ccj[d
NcijsdZ[d
_^h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd(
Oeh
Z[c
Dh_[]&
Wbi
Z_[
E[kj[
dWY^
IWh_i
\k^h[d&
jhk]
_Y^
_^d[d
Wk\&
i_Y^
Wd
Z[h
@Wh[
Zk
GehZ
_^h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_d' d[hd(
D[_d[h
aeddj[
[i(
>_dcWb
iebbj[
c_Y^
[_d
?h[kdZ
Wd
Z[h
@Wh[
Zk
GehZ
jh[\\[d&
kdZ
_Y^
\ehZ[hj[
_^d
Wk\&
i_Y^&
iem_[
[h
Zehj
WdaWc&
i[_d[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd(
:X[h
[h
jWkY^j[
dkh
c_j
[_d[c
i[^h
X[ieh]j[d
@[i_Y^j
Wk\
kdZ
iW]j[4
yBY^
^WX[
[jmWi
l[h][ii[d&
mehkc
L_[
c_Y^
XWj[d&
mWh
[i
[jmWi&
ZWii
_Y^
^sjj[
X[ieh][d
iebb[d9z FWd
ckii
kdj[hiY^[_Z[d&
mWi
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
_ij
kdZ
mWi
d_Y^j(
Skc
;[_if_[b
_ij
[i
[_d
h_[i_][h
Ndj[hiY^_[Z&
i_Y^
Z[h
SkiW][
pk
[h_dd[hd&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
kc
pmtb\
N^h
B^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd
mebbj[d
kdZ
Z[c
jWjisY^b_Y^[d
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd(
FWd %(

ckii
kdX[Z_d]j
pk
Z[da[d
b[hd[d(
P_h
^WX[d
l_[b
Lje\\
pkc
h_Y^j_][d
=[da[d&
WX[h
cWd
ZWh\
[i
d_Y^j
l[h][ii[d( Nc
_d
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
ijsha[h
pk
m[hZ[d&
cuii[d
L_[
P_ii[d
kdZ
L[_d
WdiWcc[bd(
=W
ZWi
L[_d
c_j
Z[h
>h_dd[hkd]
Z[ii[d&
mWi
m_h
kdi
l[hifheY^[d
^WX[d&
pkiWcc[d^sd]j&
atdd[d
m_h
kdi[h
L[_d
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
ijsha[d(
=_[
>h_dd[hkd]
Wd
kdi[h[
F_ii[h\eb][
aWdd
WkY^
i[^h
dujpb_Y^
i[_d&
WX[h
cWdY^cWb
_ij
i_[
ltbb_]
kdXhWkY^XWh(
P[dd
L_[
i_Y^
B^h[h
F_ii[h\eb][
[h_dd[hd
kdZ
m[_d[dZ
ZWi_jp[d&
eZ[h
`[cWdZ
WdZ[h[c
Z_[
LY^kbZ
][X[d&
m_hZ
ZWi
d_Y^j
^[b\[d( y=Wi
>cf\Wd][d
led
>_dZhuYa[d
_ij
[_d
c[Y^Wd_iY^[h
Oeh' ]Wd]&
d_Y^j
mW^h9z L_[
m[hZ[d
Wk\
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
:hj[d
X[dkjpj(
G[^c[d
L_[
P_ii[d
'
cWd
aWdd
c_j
][du][dZ
Y^_d[i_iY^[d
Pthj[hd
h_dd[' hkd][d
[_d[h
LjhWii[
eZ[h
[_d[i
Hhj[i( yLW]j[d
L_[&
ZWi
FW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
i[_
[_d[
@hkff[
X[' ijsdZ_][h
Bdj[h[ii[d9
PuhZ[d
L_[
ZWi
[hbskj[hd9z CW(
P[dd
m_h
kdi
[h_dd[hd
atddj[d&
mWi
m_h
b[jpj[
PeY^[&
b[jpj[d
FedWj&
b[jpj[i
CW^h
][hd[
^Wjj[d
'
m[dd
m_h
kdi
[h_dd[hd
atddj[d
'
ie
muhZ[
ZWi
[_d
f[hcWd[dj[i
@hWl_jWj_edip[djhkc
X_bZ[d(
Bc
Wbb][c[_d[d
l[h][ii[d
m_h(
:X[h
m[dd
m_h
kdi
[h_dd[hd
atdd[d
kdZ
ZWc_j
\ehj\W^h[d&
Z_[i[bX[d
=_d][
pk
b_[X[d&
X[m_haj
Z_[i
[_d
@hWl_jWj_edip[djhkc(
>i
_ij
ie]Wh
X[ii[h
i_Y^
Z[ii[d
pk
[h_dd[hd&
mWi
cWd
WXb[^dj&
Wbi
i_Y^
]Wh
d_Y^j
pk
[h_dd[hd( yP_[
aWdd
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
Z[d
MeZ
uX[hb[X[d9z =[h
MeZ
_ij
d_Y^ji&
L_[
X[c[ha[d
_^d
l_[bb[_Y^j
d_Y^j
[_dcWb(
P[dd
L_[
d_Y^j
c[ha[d&
ZWii
L_[
ij[hX[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
WkY^
d_Y^j
c[ha[d&
ZWii
L_[
][Xeh[d
m[hZ[d( yBij
Ndij[hXb_Y^a[_j
\uh
F[diY^
Gh(
b&
,
kdZ
-
kdct]b_Y^9z CW&
[h
ckii
F[diY^
Gh(
/
m[hZ[d(
=Wi
_ij
CGLC
:djmehj(
:X[h
[i
cW]
WdZ[h[
:djmehj[d
][X[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
atdd[d
F[diY^
Gh(
b&
,
kdZ
-
lec
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
[hd[kj
b[X[d&
m_[Z[h
pkhuYaa[^h[d&
WX[h
i_[
[h_dd[hd
i_Y^
d_Y^j(
Nc
i_Y^
pk
[h_dd[hd&
cuii[d
i_[
F[diY^
Gh(
/
m[hZ[d( %)

yPWi
][dWk
m_hZ
kdij[hXb_Y^&
Z_[
>ii[dp
eZ[h
Z[h
f^oi_iY^[
Dthf[h
kdZ
Z_[
L[[b[9z Gkh
ZWi
@[ZsY^jd_i(
=[h
Dthf[h
m_hZ
m_[Z[h
][Xeh[d5
Z_[
>ii[dp
m_hZ
m_[Z[h
][Xeh[d5
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
m_hZ
m_[Z[h
][X_bZ[j(
=W^[h
_ij
[i
a[_d[
?hW][
Z[h
Ndij[hXb_Y^a[_j&
iedZ[hd
Z[i
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][di(
P_h
atdd[d
p[^djWki[dZ
FWb
e^d[
`[Z[d
@[m_dd
b[X[d&
m[dd
m_h
kdi
d_Y^j
[h_dd[hd(
P[dd
c[' Y^Wd_iY^[
Ndij[hXb_Y^a[_j
ct]b_Y^
msh[&
muhZ[
i_[
d_Y^ji
duj' p[d(
P_h
cuii[d
kdi
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
kdZ
Z[h
@[][X[d^[_j[d
[h_dd[hd5
`[
c[^h&
Z[ije
X[ii[h(
P_[Z[h
[hcW^d[
_Y^
L_[4
PWi
[i
pk
[h_dd[hd
]_bj&
_ij&
ZWii
m_h
LGAFQ
[h_dd[hd5
LGC
[h_dd[hd
kdZ
ZWii
m_h
d_Y^j
m_ii[d&
ZWii
m_h
kdi
d_Y^j
[h_dd[hd( yAWX[
_Y^
L_[
ZW^_d][^[dZ
h_Y^j_]
l[hijWdZ[d&
ZWii&
m[dd
uX[h^Wkfj
[jmWi&
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
uX[hb[Xj9z PW^hiY^[_db_Y^
d_Y^j
]Wdp5
m[_b
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
][mt^db_Y^
Wbi
[hij[i
l[hiY^m_dZ[j&
\Wbbi
[jmWi
uX[hb[Xj(
=Wi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
_ij
i[^h
kdX[ijsdZ_]( y>i
iY^[_dj
c_h&
ZWii
m_h
[hij
[_dcWb
[_d[d
:k][dXb_Ya
Z[i
>hmWY^[di
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d
[hh[_Y^[d
iebbj[d
kc
pk
[ha[dd[d&
me
m_h
[_d[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
_c
b[jpj[d
E[X[d
l[hiskcj
^WX[d(z L[^h
]kj(
Gkh&
jkd
L_[
ZWi
[hij
[_dcWb( yP[dd
_Y^
Wk\
Z_[
l[hiskcj[d
@[b[][d^[_j[d
_d
Z_[i[c
E[' X[d
pkhuYaXb_Ya[&
^WX[
_Y^
ZWi
@[\u^b&
ZWii
_Y^
dkh
ZWdd
^sjj[
WdZ[hi
^WdZ[bd
atdd[d&
m[dd
_Y^
[_d
WdZ[h[h
F[diY^
][m[i[d
msh[(
Oed
ZW^[h
iY^[_dj
c_h
Z[h
[_dp_][
P[]&
Z_[
P_[Z[ha[^h
pk
X[[_d\bkii[d&
Z[h&
i[_d[
>ii[dp
pk
sdZ[hd(z P_[Z[hkc&
i[^h
dujpb_Y^(
:X[h
m_[
[hh[_Y^[d
L_[
ZWi9 yPuhZ[
Z_[
>h_dd[hkd]
Wd
[_d[
leh^[h][]Wd][d[
P_[Z[h' a[^h
[i
ct]b_Y^
cWY^[d&
i[_d[
AWdZbkd][d
pk
sdZ[hd9z =Wi
m[_ii
_Y^
d_Y^j(
=Wi
m[hZ[d
L_[
i[^[d&
m[dd
L_[
i_[
^WX[d( y>_d[
P_[Z[ha[^h
_ij
d_Y^j
][dWkie
m_[
ZWi
E[X[d
ZWleh&
d_Y^j
mW^h9z =[h
:d\Wd]
_ij
_cc[h
Z[hi[bX[( y;[^Wbj[d
m_h
X[_
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
led
[_d[c
E[X[d
pkc
WdZ[h[d
Z_[
i[bX[
L[_di[X[d[
X[_9z %*

=WhuX[h
]_Xj
[i
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
M^[eh_[d(
>_d[
M^[eh_[
X[iW]j&
ZWii
mWi
cWd
_d
[_d[c
E[X[d
[hmehX[d
^Wj&
i_Y^[h
mWY^i[d
m_hZ(
:X[h
[i
]_Xj
l_[b[
WdZ[h[
M^[eh_[d( y@[^thj
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
pkh
>ii[dp9z >i
_ij
X[ii[h
pk
iW][d&
ZWii
[i
c_j
yBY^iz
l[haduf\j
_ij&
Z_[
_d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
b_[][d(
>i
]_Xj
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
:hj[d
led
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d4
][mt^db_Y^[i
@[ZsY^jd_i&
>h_dd[hkd]
Z[ii[d&
mWi
m_h
^th[d&
>h_dd[hkd]
Z_[i[i
Loij[ci&
>h_dd[hkd]
Wd
@[hkY^&
>h_dd[hkd]
Wd
LjhWii[d(
:X[h
m_h
ifh[Y^[d
led
Z[c
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d&
ZWi
m_h
a[dd[d(
=_[i[i
>h_dd[hkd]il[h' ct][d
aWdd
i[^h
b[_Y^j
l[hZehX[d
m[hZ[d( y>i
]_Xj
E[kj[
c_j
f^eje]hWf^_iY^[c
@[ZsY^jd_i
L_dZ
i_[
X[mkiij[h9z >i
]_Xj
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
:hj[d
led
@[ZsY^jd_i(
L_[
^WX[d
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:hj
led
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d(
>_d
WdZ[h[h
^Wj
[_d[
WdZ[h[
:hj(
:X[h
L_[
atdd[d
B^h[
[_][d[
:hj
Z[i
>h_dd[' hkd]il[hct][di
X[ii[h
eZ[h
iY^b[Y^j[h
dkjp[d&
_dZ[c
L_[
X[' mkiij[h
eZ[h
m[d_][h
X[mkiij
i_dZ(
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
]_Xj
[i
_d
Wbb[d
S[djh[d(
>i
cW]
_d
[_d_][d
S[djh[d
[_d
X_iiY^[d
X[ii[h
i[_d
Wbi
_d
WdZ[h[d&
WX[h
[i
]_Xj
dkh
[_d[
F[j^eZ[&
kc
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
pk
ijsha[d
'
_dZ[c
cWd
X[mkiij[h
m_hZ(
G_Y^j
dkh
^Wj
`[Z[i
S[djhkc
i[_d
[_][d[i
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d&
iedZ[hd
[i
][^th[d
[_d_][
:hj[d
led
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
pkh
>ii[dp
kdZ
[_d_][
pkh
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j( yBij
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
[_d[
?kdaj_ed
Z[i
Dthf[hi9
DWdd
[i
c_j
Z[h
;[m[]kd]
l[h]b_Y^[d
m[hZ[d9z L_[
atdd[d
[i
[_d[
Dthf[h\kdaj_ed
d[dd[d&
m[dd
L_[
mebb[d(
:X[h
mepk
[i
c_j
Z[h
;[m[]kd]
l[h]b[_Y^[d9
>_di
_ij
d_Y^j
m_[
ZWi
WdZ[h[(
=Wi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
_ij
[jmWi
_d
kdi&
l_[bb[_Y^j
_d
Z[h
>ii[dp&
l_[bb[_Y^j
_d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j(
P_h
[h_dd[hd
kdi
_d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
WX[h
Z_[
>h_dd[hkd]
Wd
@[iY^cWYa
eZ[h
@[hkY^
b_[]j
_d
Z[h
>ii[dp(
:X[h
cWd
[h_dd[hj
i_Y^
_d
P_hab_Y^' a[_j
_d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j( yPWi
cuii[d
m_h
jkd
kc
pk
l[hc[_Z[d&
ZWii
kdi[h
>h_dd[' hkd]il[hct][d
l[hZehX[d
m_hZ9z :hX[_j[d
L_[
pk[hij
Wd
Z[h
>_dX_bZkd]5
ZWdd
Wc
Eu][d(
=_[i[ &!

pm[_
=_d][
p[hijth[d
kdi[h
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d(
:bi
m_h
pk' [hij
lec
Eu][d
ifhWY^[d&
\WdZ[d
[i
Z_[
E[kj[
iedZ[hXWh5
i_[
[haWddj[d
d_Y^j&
ZWii
cWd
i[_d
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
lebbijsd' Z_]
p[hijth[d
aWdd(
Dscf\[d
L_[
WkY^
c_j
Z[h
>_dX_bZkd]&
d_Y^j
dkh
Wbi
Lfehj
eZ[h
rXkd]( yPWi
aWdd
kdi
ZWX[_
^[b\[d&
Eu][d
_d
kdi
i[bXij
mW^hpk' d[^c[d9z =W
]_Xj
[i
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
=_d][5
Wbi
[hij[i
:dWboi[
led
?Waj[d&
Pehj[d
kdZ
M^[eh_[d(
>i
^_b\j
i[^h&
pk
[ha[dd[d&
m_[
WdZ[h[
E[kj[
bu][d&
kdZ
ZWdd&
[_d[i
iY^td[d
Feh][di&
aWdd
cWd
X[_
i_Y^
i[bXij
X[]_dd[d( yS[hijthj
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[h' ct][d9z CW&
cWd
aWdd
iW][d&
ZWii
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
ZWi
>h_dd[' hkd]il[hct][d
[djm[Z[h
p[hijthj
eZ[h
[djij[bbj( yBij
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
[_d[
?ehc
Z[h
Eu][9z EWii[d
L_[
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j(
L_[
_ij
a[_d[
?ehc
Z[h
Eu][&
i_[
_ij
[_d[
:Xm[^h(
BdZ[c
cWd
c_jj[bi
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
kdWd][d[^c[
?eb][d
l[hc[_Z[j&
aWdd
cWd
i_Y^
i[bXij
Wk\
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:hj
\u^b[d( yK[ikbj_[hj
Z_[i[i
O[hZ[hX[d
Z[i
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][di
_d
[_d[h
f^oi_ebe]_iY^[d
qdZ[hkd]9z H^&
`W
>i
aWdd
jejWb[d
PW^di_dd
^[hX[_\u^h[d(
=_[
Wbj[d
IioY^ebe][d
mkiij[d
Z_[i(
L_[
ifhWY^[d
led
Aoij[h_a[hd
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
:X[h
i_[
[haWddj[d
d_Y^j&
ZWii
m_h
][hWZ[
ZkhY^
kdi[h
uXb_Y^[i
fioY^ebe]_iY^[i
Lf_[b
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
l[hZ[h' X[d
atdd[d(
BZ[[d
[hbu][d&
uX[h
BZ[[d
f^WdjWi_[h[d
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h( yP[bY^[
P_hakd]
^sjj[
^Whj[
:hX[_j
Wc
@[ZWda[d'Ljeff[d
Wk\
Z_[
P_[Z[ha[^h9z HX
h_Y^j_]
eZ[h
\WbiY^&
[i
Xb[_Xj
l_[bl[hifh[Y^[dZ( yP_[
aWdd
cWd
ZW^_d
][bWd][d&
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
_d
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
pk
[djm_Ya[bd9z =Wi
_ij
i[^h
_dj[h[iiWdj
kdZ
i[^h
m_Y^j_](
>i
_ij
dejm[dZ_]&
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
pk
[djm_Ya[bd&
m_[
[i
WkY^
ct]b_Y^
_ij&
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
pk
p[hijth[d(
@[csii
Z[h
M^[eh_[
Z[h &"

P_[Z[ha[^h
_ij
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
Z[h
[_dp_][
P[]&
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]i' l[hct][d
pk
[djm_Ya[bd(
P[dd
cWd
i_Y^
i[_d[h
i[bXij
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d
[h_dd[hj&
m_hZ
cWd
i_Y^
WkY^
ZWi
dsY^ij[
FWb
[h_dd[hd( yBij
[i
ct]b_Y^&
X[_
Z[h
BZ[[
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
[cej_edWb
pk
\u^b[d9z CW&
[i
_ij
ct]b_Y^&
X[iedZ[hi&
m[dd
cWd
WkY^
dkh
[_d[
ab[_d[
>h_dd[hkd]
^Wj(
BY^
c[_d[
d_Y^j
Wbb[i&
WX[h
ie]Wh
[_d[
iY^mWY^[
>h_dd[hkd]
aWdd
_dj[h[iiWdj[i
[cej_edWb[i
O[hij[^[d
[h][X[d( yP[dd
cWd
ZWi
ijWha[
@[\u^b
^Wj&
ZWii
[_d
>h[_]d_i
X[h[_ji
pkleh
ijWjj\WdZ&
aWdd
cWd
[i
ZWdd
X[dkjp[d&
kc
ZWi
>h_dd[' hkd]il[hct][d
pk
[djm_Ya[bd9z H^&
[i
aWdd
Wk\
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
:hj[d
][iY^[^[d5
dkh
dWY^
i[^h
bWd][c
kdZ
i[^h
[hdij^W\j[c
GWY^\ehiY^[d
aWdd
cWd
pk
Z[c
LY^bkii
aecc[d&
ZWii
[i
i_Y^
ZWX[_
ct]b_Y^[hm[_i[
kc
MWjiWY^[d
^WdZ[bj( yBY^
cWY^j[
c_h
@[ZWda[d
ZWhuX[h&
eX
[i
kdi[h[h
dsY^ij[d
P_[Z[ha[^h
d_Y^j
pkjhs]b_Y^
msh[&
m[dd
m_h
c_j
Z_[i[h
:hX[_j
[jmWi
Wd\Wd][d
atddj[d&
X[leh
m_h
ij[hX[d(z CW&
mWi
pkleh
][iY^_[^j&
aWdd
X[ij_cc[d&
mWi
dWY^^[h
Wk\
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
:hj[d
][iY^_[^j(
=Wi
_ij
d_Y^j
P_[Z[ha[^h( =_[
?hW][
_ij&
m_[
cWd
i_Y^
Wk\
Z_[
P_[Z[ha[^h
lehX[h[_j[d
aWdd(
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
L_[
mebbj[d
_d
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
E[X[d
[jmWi
jkd&
kdZ
L_[
c[ha[d&
ZWii
L_[
[i
d_Y^j
jkd
atdd[d(
=Wi
[h\ehZ[hj
A_b\[(
P[dd
L_[
Z_[i[
A_b\[
d_Y^j
f^oi_iY^
[h^Wbj[d
atdd[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
ZWhuX[h
dWY^Z[da[d
kdZ
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
Wk\
Z_[i[
A_b\[
ms^h[dZ
Z[i
leh^[h][]Wd][d[d
E[X[di
lehX[h[_j[d
cuii[d(
=_[i[i
E[X[d
_ij
pk
ifsj5
ZWi
dsY^ij[
E[X[d
_ij
pk
ifsj5
ZWi
leh^[h][^[dZ[
E[X[d
_ij
Z_[
[_dp_][
m_][
P_[Z[ha[^h
bsiij
i_Y^
d_Y^j
c_j
kdi[h[c
][][dmshj_][d
S[_ji_dd
l[h[_dXWh[d(
=Wh_d
b_[]j
Z_[
]Wdp[
LW' Y^[&
Z[i^WbX
ckii
cWd
Z[d
S[_ji_dd
beim[hZ[d(
P_[Z[ha[^h
X[p_[^j
i_Y^
Wk\
>m_]a[_j&
d_Y^j
Wk\
S[_j( yDtdd[d
m_h
ZWi
Fkij[h
ZWled
WX^Wbj[d&
i_Y^
pk
m_[Z[h' ^eb[d9z P[dd
L_[
[_d
]kj[i
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
^WX[d&
atdd[d
L_[
[i( y;[^Wkfj[d
L_[&
ZWii
[i
m_hab_Y^
[jmWi
WkicWY^[d
muhZ[&
m[dd
cWd
Z_[
M^[eh_[
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
Wap[fj_[hj9z P[dd
cWd
b[hdj&
m[dd
cWd
WhX[_j[j&
]_Xj
[i
FWj[h_Wb
pkc &$

O[hij[^[d(
P_h
l[hm[dZ[d
O[hij[^[d
kdZ
FWd][b
Wd
O[hij[' ^[d(
P[dd
m_h
][dk]
Z[da[d&
ct][d
m_h
[jmWi
l[hij[^[d&
kdZ
m_h
atdd[d
Z_[
P_[Z[ha[^h
jWjisY^b_Y^
sdZ[hd( yPsh[
[i
h_Y^j_]
pk
iW][d&
Z[h
[_dp_][
;[m[_i
\uh
Z_[
P_[' Z[ha[^h
b_[][
ZWh_d&
ZWii
i_Y^
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d
[_d_][
E[kj[
[h_dd[hd&
pkleh
][b[Xj
pk
^WX[d9z G[_d&
ZWi
_ij
i[^h
iY^mWY^(
L[^h
m[d_]
E[kj[
[h_dd[hd
i_Y^&
kdZ
L_[
atdd[d
_cc[h
iW][d&
ZWii
i_[
bu][d( yPuhZ[
Z[h
@bWkX[
Wd
Z_[
P_[Z[ha[^h
d_Y^j
_d
[_d[c
ijWh' a[d
=hWd]&
:dijh[d]kd][d
pk
kdj[hd[^c[d&
h[ikbj_[h[d9z @bWkX[
m_hZ
d_Y^j
^[b\[d5
@bWkX[
ijkcf\j
WX5
[h
^Wj
d_Y^j
][dk]
DhW\j(
:X[h
X[_
Z[h
b[X[dZ_][d
:diY^Wkkd]
atddj[
Z_[i
Z[h
?Wbb
i[_d( P_h
atdd[d
[_d_][
=_d][
ZkhY^
=[da[d
l[hij[^[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
Z_[
?hW][&
eX
Wbb[
F[diY^[d
_d
]b[_Y^[h
P[_i[
led
Z[h
P_[Z[ha[^h
X[hu^hj
m[hZ[d(
>i
_ij
kdct]b_Y^&
[_d\WY^
`W
eZ[h
d[_d
pk
iW][d&
m[_b
ZWi&
mWi
Wk\
[_d[d
F[diY^[d
Wd][m[dZ[j
m[hZ[d
aWdd&
i_Y^
d_Y^j
Wk\
[_d[d
WdZ[h[d
Wdm[dZ[d
bsiij(
?uh
[_d[d
F[diY^[d
m[hZ[d
[i
Z_[i[bX[
LjhWii[&
ZWii[bX[
AWki&
Z_[i[bX[d
DWjp[d
i[_d(
:X[h
\uh
WdZ[h[
F[diY^[d
aWdd
[i
WdZ[hi
i[_d(
@heii[
=_Y^j[h&
]heii[
LY^h_\jij[bb[h
cuii[d
l_[b' b[_Y^j
d_Y^j
Z_[i[bX[d
LjhWii[d
][^[d(
L_[
atdd[d
WdZ[h[
LjhWi' i[d
][^[d
kdZ
ZeY^
Z_[i[bX[d
=_d][
jkd(
=_[i[c
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
XhWkY^[d
a[_d[
:dijh[d]kd][d
pk]hkdZ[
pk
b_[][d&
iedZ[hd
?s^_]a[_j[d&
E[_ijkd]
kdZ
[_d
m[_j[h
Aeh_pedj
Z[i
=[da[di
kdZ
?u^b[di(
>_d
]heii[h
=_Y^j[h
XhWkY^j
l_[bb[_Y^j
Z_[i[bX[d
O[hi[
d_Y^j
deY^
[_dcWb
pk
iY^h[_X[d(
O_[bb[_Y^j
pe]
[h
d_Y^j
Wbb[i&
WX[h
][dk]&
Wki
i[_d[h
Nc][Xkd]&
ie
ZWii
[h
[jmWi
Wd' Z[h[i
fheX_[h[d
aWdd&
ZWi
[h
ZWi
b[jpj[
FWb
d_Y^j
l[hikY^j[( yGWY^
Z[d
Oehb[ikd][d
\hW][d
Z_[
E[kj[
_cc[h&
eX
]heii[
=_Y^j[h
ZWi
L[_d
led
F[diY^
b&
,
kdZ
-
^WX[d(
Gkd
iW][d
L_[&
ZWii
[_d
=_Y^j[h
Z_[i[bX[
LWY^[
d_Y^j
deY^
[_dcWb
cWY^[d
ckii(z G[_d(
>h
cW]
[_d
]heii[h
=_Y^j[h
i[_d
kdZ
Z[ddeY^
pkh
eX`[aj_l[d
Dkdij
][^th[d(
:dZ[h[&
m[d_][h
]heii[
=_Y^j[h
ct][d
eX`[aj_l[
Dkdij
^[hlehXh_d][d( &%

=[da[d
L_[
uX[h
[_d_][
Z_[i[h
BZ[[d
dWY^&
WX[h
]bWkX[d
L_[
d_Y^j&
ZWii
L_[
m_ii[d(
>i
]_Xj
l_[b[
OWh_Wj_ed[d&
l_[b[
Ft]' b_Y^a[_j[d(
=[da[d
L_[&
Z[dd
[i
]_Xj
d_Y^ji
P_Y^j_][h[i
\uh
L_[(

&&

%(,)-02)3490/-(,.)-5

,GLC
9QRBGC
\@CO
BCL
GK?EGLZOCL
4CLPAFCL

&(

&138135

=[h
M[nj
Z_[i[i
DWf_j[bi
_ij
[_d[
K[aedijhkaj_ed
led
:dc[h' akd][d&
Z_[
I(
=(
Hkif[diao
Wdbsiib_Y^
led
Mh[\\[d
skii[hj[&
Z_[
pm_iY^[d
+3-*
kdZ
+3..
][^Wbj[d
mkhZ[d(
>_d_][
O[hsdZ[hkd][d
_c
PehjbWkj
mWh[d
kdl[hc[_Zb_Y^
X[_c
O[hikY^&
:djmehj[d
Wk\
?hW][d
_d
kdj[hiY^_[Zb_Y^[d
Dedj[nj[d
pkiWcc[dpkij[bb[d
kdZ
i_[
_d
[_d[
K[_^[d\eb][
pk
Xh_d][d5
WX[h
[i
mkhZ[
ieh]\sbj_]
ZWhWk\
][WY^j[j&
Z_[
:di_Y^j[d
Z[i
:kjehi
d_Y^j
pk
l[hsdZ[hd
eZ[h
_^d[d
[jmWi
^_dpkpk\u][d(
?hW][d&
Z_[
F_j]b_[Z[h
led
Hkif[diaoi
@hkff[d
ij[bbj[d&
i_dZ
_d
:d\u^hkd]iijh_Y^[
][i[jpj&
kc
i_[
led
Hkif[diaoi
Pehj[d
pk
kdj[hiY^[_Z[d&
Z_[
d_Y^j
_d
:d\u^hkd]iijh_Y^[d
ij[^[d( Bd
Z_[i[c
;kY^
\_dZ[d
i_Y^
Pehj[
kdZ
:kiZhuYa[&
Z_[
if[p_[b' b[
;[Z[kjkd][d
_d
SkiWcc[d^Wd]
c_j
[_d[c
Loij[c
Z[i
O_[h' j[d
P[]i
^WX[d&
m[bY^[i
Hkif[diao
b[^hj[(
=Wi
;kY^
aWdd
led
a[_d[c
l[hijWdZ[d
m[hZ[d&
Z[h
Z_[i[
;[Z[kjkd][d
d_Y^j
a[ddj(
>i
m_hZ
^_[h
a[_d[
>hbskj[hkd]
l[hikY^j&
[hij[di
m[_b
Z_[i
;kY^
\uh
E[kj[
X[ij_ccj
_ij&
Z_[
Z_[
LfhWY^[
X[h[_ji
a[dd[d&
kdZ
pm[_j[di
m[_b
Z_[
>hbskj[hkd]
Z[h
X[iedZ[h[d
;[]h_\\[
_d
Hki'
f[diaoi
l[ht\\[djb_Y^j[d
P[ha[d
pk
\_dZ[d
_ij&
X[iedZ[hi
_d
GCJ
BGCPCP
9VPQCKP
"
7RDDCO
CGL
/GLBCOLGP
D\O
BGC
,LQTGAIJRLE
BCP
.CTGPPCLP
"
5MQTCLBGEICGQ
KMO?JGPAFCL
,KNDGL" BCLP
"
7RDDCO
RLB
.CTGPPCL
"
)CBCRQRLE
SML
^9CCJC_
GL
BGCPCK
9VPQCK
"
9CCJC
D\QQCOQ
BCL
4MLB
"
4MLB
GL
PGAF
COPAF?DDCL
"
h_dd[hd
kdZ
ZkhY^
L_Y^'
d_Y^j'_Z[dj_\_p_[h[d
p[hijthj
m[hZ[d( =_[
BZ[[
Z[i
@[m_ii[di
kdZ
Z_[
BZ[[
Z[h
Ik\\[h
X[Zuh\[d
bWd][d
LjkZ_kci&
WX[h
m[dd
m_h
led
Z[h
cehWb_iY^[d
L[_j[
Z_[i[i
Loij[ci
ifh[Y^[d&
ie
iebbj[
led
:d\Wd]
Wd
l[hijWdZ[d
m[hZ[d&
ZWii
[_d
F[diY^
[_d[d
L_dd
\uh
]kj
kdZ
iY^b[Y^j
^WX[d
ckii(
P[dd
[h
Z[d
d_Y^j
^Wj&
aWdd
d_Y^ji
\uh
_^d
][jWd
m[hZ[d(
>h
ckii
c_j
[_d[c
][m_ii[d
cehWb_iY^[d
L_dd
X[]_dd[d&
[_d[c
L_dd
\uh
h_Y^j_]
eZ[h
\WbiY^&
kc
c[^h
pk
X[aecc[d(
>h
ckii
pk[hij
Z_[
K[bWj_l_jsj
Z[h
][mt^db_Y^[d
FehWb
l[hij[^[d&
kdZ
pm[_j[di
ckii
[h
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
Z[i
eX`[aj_l[d
K_Y^j_]
eZ[h
?WbiY^
[ha[dd[d(
>hij
m[dd
[h
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
led
[_d[c
eX`[aj_l[d '"

kdZ
f[hcWd[dj[d
K_Y^j_]
kdZ
?WbiY^
[_di_[^j&
m_hZ
[h
Z_[
=_d][
lec
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Z_[i[i
Loij[ci
Wki
X[jhWY^j[d( @[m_ii[d
_ij
_d
Z[h
>ii[dp&
d_Y^j
_d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
ms^' h[dZ
ZWi
FW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
_d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
_ij&
d_Y^j
_d
Z[h
>ii[dp(
=Wi
FW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
m_hZ
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d
[hmehX[d(
>i
_ij
_c
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[d
M[_b
Z[i
[cej_edWb[d
S[d' jhkci&
eX]b[_Y^
l_[bb[_Y^j
WkY^
_c
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[d
M[_b
Z[i
_dj[b' b[ajk[bb[d
S[djhkci&
kdZ
^Wj
;'>_d\buii[
pkh
@hkdZbW][( yFkii
cWd
Ik\\[h
d_Y^j
[dj\[hd[d&
kc
ZWi
@[m_ii[d
pk
[hm[Ya[d9z
\hW]j[
`[cWdZ( P[dd
Ik\\[h
dkh
iY^ed
[hiY^ujj[hj
m[hZ[d&
[hmWY^j
ZWi
@[' m_ii[d( yP_[
aWdd
cWd
[djZ[Ya[d&
m[bY^[i
Z_[
[_][d[d
Ik\\[h
i_dZ9z
\hW]j[
[_d
WdZ[h[h( FWdY^cWb
][^j
[i(
P[dd
cWd
Z_[
h_Y^j_][
Oehij[bbkd]
led
Ik\\[hd
^Wj&
aWdd
cWd
i[_d[
[_][d[d
\_dZ[d( >i
]_Xj
[_d[d
]heii[d
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
pm_iY^[d
>djiY^kbZ_]kd][d
kdZ
Ik\\[hd(
>djiY^kbZ_]kd][d
atdd[d
`[Z[i
FWb
l[hiY^_[Z[d
i[_d&
m[dd
WX[h
Z_[
>djiY^kbZ_]kd]
`[Z[i
FWb
Z_[i[bX[
_ij&
m_hZ
i_[
pkc
Ik\\[h( Ik\\[h
ij[^[d
c_j
@[m_ii[d
_d
O[hX_dZkd](
@[m_ii[d
_ij
[_d
Pehj&
ZWi
m_h
][mt^db_Y^
_d
[_d[c
aedl[dj_ed[bb[d
L_dd
l[h' m[dZ[d&
kc
[_d[
:hj
Wd[hpe][d[h
[cej_edWb[h
@[me^d^[_j
pk
X[p[_Y^d[d(
Bd
PW^h^[_j
_ij
@[m_ii[d
[_d[
X[iedZ[h[
?s^_]a[_j&
Z_[
`[Z[h
X[i_jpj&
WX[h
Z_[
d_[cWdZ
_c
LY^bW\pkijWdZ
][XhWkY^[d
aWdd(
L[bXij
m[dd
m_h
ZWi
@[m_ii[d
\uh
[_d[d
:k][dXb_Ya
pk\sb' b_]
\u^b[d&
m_hZ
[i
[_d[
i[^h
iY^c[hp^W\j[
>h\W^hkd]
i[_d&
ie
iY^c[hp^W\j&
ZWii
m_h
[i
ie]b[_Y^
beim[hZ[d
mebb[d(
E[kj[&
_d
Z[d[d
][b[][djb_Y^
ZWi
@[m_ii[d
\buY^j_]
Wk\jWkY^j&
[h\_dZ[d
Wbb[
:hj[d
led
F[j^eZ[d&
kc
Z_[i
@[\u^b
bei
pk
m[hZ[d(
>i
_ij
Z_[
?s^_]a[_j&
Wbb
ZWi
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
pk
\u^b[d&
mWi
m_h
][mt^db_Y^
K
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
S[_j[d
\u^b[d(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
pk
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
Wbb
kdi[h[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
yBY^zi
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
@[\u^b[
^WX[d(
>_d
yBY^z
\u^bj&
ZWii
[i
[jmWi
cW]&
ms^h[dZ
[_d
WdZ[h[i
[i
^Wiij&
kdZ
[_d[c
Zh_jj[d
yBY^z
_ij
[i
]b[_Y^(
:X[h
m_h
\u^b[d
Z_[i[
=_d][
d_[
pkh
]b[_Y^[d
S[_j&
m[_b
Ik\\[h
pm_iY^[d
_^d[d
b_[][d( '#

P[][d
Z_[i[h
Ik\\[h
atdd[d
m_h
ZWi
@[m_ii[d
d_Y^j
X[dkjp[d&
atdd[d
m_h
d_Y^j
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
pm[_
m_Z[hifhuY^b_Y^[
=_d][
\u^' b[d&
Z_[
m_h
pk
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
S[_j[d
\u^b[d(
P[dd
[_d
F[diY^
i_[
pk\sbb_]
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
\u^bj&
b[_Z[j
[h(
=W^[h
i_dZ
_d
kdi[h[c
][][dmshj_][d
SkijWdZ
Ik\\[h
dejm[dZ_][
=_d][&
e^d[
Z_[
[_d
F[diY^
l[hhuYaj
muhZ[(
:X[h
m[dd
[h
i_[
l[hij[^j
kdZ
i_Y^
lehX[h[_j[j&
ZWdd
aWdd
[h
dWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
Wd\Wd][d&
Z_[
P_Z[h' ifhuY^[
pk
p[hijth[d
kdZ
Z_[
Ik\\[h
pk
X[i[_j_][d( =Wi
;h[Y^[d
[_d[h
c[Y^Wd_iY^[d
@[me^d^[_j&
eX
]kj
eZ[h
iY^b[Y^j&
cW]
kdX[gk[c
i[_d&
Z[dd
m_h
^WX[d
c[Y^Wd_iY^[
@[' me^d^[_j[d
m_[
O[h^Wbj[dih[][bd
kdZ
cehWb_iY^[
K[][bd&
Z_[
m_h
_d
kdi[h[h
>hp_[^kd]
[h^Wbj[d(
Bd
Z[d
c[_ij[d
?sbb[d
[h\W^h[d
m_h
ZW^[h
ZWi
@[m_ii[d
d_Y^j5
m_h
^WX[d
pk
l_[b[
Ik\\[h(
P_[
_Y^
iW]j[&
]_Xj
[i
Mh[ddmsdZ[
pm_iY^[d
kdi[h[d
[cej_edWb[d
AWbjkd][d&
kdZ
ZWi
@[m_ii[d
pk
[h\W^h[d
X[Z[kj[j&
^kdZ[hj
=_d][
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
pk
i[^[d(
P[dd
Mh[ddmsdZ[
l[hiY^m_dZ[d&
m[hZ[d
Wbb[
_dd[h[d
P_Z[hifhuY^[
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
][i[^[d(
=Wi
_ij
i[^h
kdWd][d[^c&
kdZ
ZW
[i
kdi[h
][me^dj[i
E[X[difh_dp_f
_ij&
kdWd][d[^c[
>cf\_d' Zkd][d
kdZ
PW^hd[^ckd][d
pk
l[hc[_Z[d&
bWk\[d
m_h
leh
_^h[c
:dXb_Ya
ZWled(
:k\
Z_[i[
:hj
iY^W\\[d
m_h
_dd[h[
Ik\\[h(
P_Z[h' ifhuY^[&
Z_[
[_d[h
dWY^
Z[c
WdZ[h[d
Wk\jWkY^[d&
iY^[_d[d
d_Y^j
m_Z[hifhuY^b_Y^5
i_[
cuii[d
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
][i[^[d
m[hZ[d( P_h
i_dZ
FWiY^_d[d
kdZ
cuii[d
i[^[d&
me
m_h
[jmWi
sdZ[hd
atdd[d&
Z[dd
_d
`[Z[h
FWiY^_d[
]_Xj
[i
_cc[h
[_d[d
Ikdaj&
Wd
Z[c
[i
ct]b_Y^
_ij
Wdpk\Wd][d( FWdY^cWb
\hW][d
E[kj[&
eX
[i
_h][dZ[jmWi
;[ijsdZ_][i
_d
kdi
]_Xj(
Sm[_
=_d][
]_Xj
[i&
Ik\\[h
kdZ
LY^msY^[d(
=_[
LY^msY^[d
m[hZ[d
cWdY^cWb
F[hacWb[
][dWddj&
WX[h
i_[
i_dZ
m_hab_Y^
dkh
LY^msY^[d(
C[Z[h
^Wj
[_d[&
pm[_
eZ[h
Zh[_
X[iedZ[h[
LY^msY^[d&
kdZ
`[Z[h
^Wj
X[ij_ccj[
Ik\\[h&
Z_[
pk
_^c
][^th[d(
>h
X[ij[^j
Wki
Ik\\[hd&
WX[h
[_d_][
i_dZ
X[iedZ[hi
m_Y^j_]&
m[_b
i_[
Wbb[
i[_d[
>djiY^[_Zkd][d
kdZ
i[_d
][iWcj[i
O[hij[^[d
X[[_d\bkii[d(
=_[i[
F[hacWb[
kdZ
Ik\\[h
i_dZ
Wbb[i&
mWi
_d
kdi
X[ijsdZ_]
][dWddj
m[hZ[d
aWdd&
kdZ
[i
_ij
kdi[h
@buYa&
ZWii
[i
d_Y^ji
I[hcWd[dj[h[i
_d
kdi
]_Xj&
Z[dd
Z_[i[
=_d][
I[LLCL
][sdZ[hj
m[hZ[d( Ik\\[h
i_dZ
audijb_Y^5
i_[
i_dZ
d_Y^j
eh]Wd_iY^5
i_[
m[hZ[d '$

^WkfjisY^b_Y^
ZkhY^
GWY^W^ckd]
[hmehX[d(
D_dZ[h
X[]_dd[d&
[hmWY^i[d[
E[kj[
dWY^pkW^c[d
kdZ
[hp[k][d
ie
[_d_][
_^h[h
Ik\\[h(
:dZ[h[
m[hZ[d
kdm_ii[djb_Y^
led
Z[h
>hp_[^kd]
[hiY^W\' \[d(
P[dd
[i
ct]b_Y^
msh[&
[_d
D_dZ
kdj[h
E[kj[
pk
][X[d&
Z_[
[hmWY^j
i_dZ&
muhZ[
[i
d_Y^j
[_diY^bW\[d&
WX[h
'
kdj[h
Z[d
;[Z_d]kd][d&
_d
Z[d[d
m_h
b[X[d
'
jh_jj
Z_[
_cW]_dsh[
I[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
eZ[h
ZWi
_cW]_dsh[
yBY^z
_d
[_d[c
D_dZ
_d
[_d[c
:bj[h
led
i_[X[d
eZ[h
WY^j
CW^h[d
Wk\(
FWdY^cWb
\hW][d
E[kj[&
eX
m_h
Ik\\[h
_d
kdi[h[c
][][dmshj_][d
;[mkiiji[_dipkijWdZ
i[^[d
atdd[d(
P_h
atdd[d
i_[
_d
WdZ[h[d
E[kj[d
i[^[d&
WX[h
d_Y^j
_d
kdi
i[bXij(

=[h
F[diY^
m_hZ
_d
l_[h
M[_b[
Wk\][j[_bj4
Dthf[h&
L[[b[&
>ii[dp
kdZ
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j( I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
kdZ
>ii[dp
iY^[_d[d
d_Y^j
][jh[ddj
pk
i[_d&
WX[h
m_h
atdd[d
ijkZ_[h[d&
mWi
pkh
>ii[dp
][^thj
kdZ
mWi
pkh
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
][^thj(
=_[
Oehij[bbkd]
led
Z[h
L[[b[
Wbi
[_d[c
i[fWhWj[d
Hh]Wd_icki&
Z[h
Z[d
f^oi_iY^[d
Dthf[h
X[^[hhiY^j&
aWdd
d_Y^j
Wbi
X[]hudZ[j
Wd][i[^[d
m[hZ[d(
=_[
dsY^ij[
:dds' ^[hkd]
Wd
Z_[
Oehij[bbkd]
led
Z[h
L[[b[&
m_[
i_[
X_i
pkc
i_[X' p[^dj[d
CW^h^kdZ[hj
l[hijWdZ[d
mkhZ[&
_ij
ZWi&
mWi
>ii[dp
][dWddj
m_hZ(
=[h
;[]h_\\
L[[b[
m_hZ
_d
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
l[h' mWdZj&
WX[h
dkh
_c
L_dd[
led
E[X[difh_dp_f(
>ii[dp&
I[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
kdZ
L[[b[
[djifh[Y^[d
pkiWcc[d][decc[d
Z[c&
mWi
][mt^db_Y^
L[[b[
][dWddj
mkhZ[(
:X[h
[i
mkhZ[
Wd][decc[d&
ZWii
Z_[
L[[b[
[_d[
lec
Dthf[h
i[fWhWj[
>n_ij[dp
^WX[&
ms^h[dZ
m_h
_d
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
d_Y^j
Wdd[^c[d&
ZWii
>ii[dp&
I[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
kdZ
L[[b[
[_d[
lec
Dthf[h
][jh[ddj[
>n_ij[dp
^WX[d( >i
m_hZ
kdi
][iW]j&
ZWii
m[dd
[_d
F[diY^
ij_hXj
eZ[h
m[dd
_h][dZ[jmWi
ij_hXj
"F[diY^
eZ[h
DuY^[diY^WX[&
[i
_ij
][dWk
ZWi
]b[_Y^[#
i[_d[
L[[b[
"Z(^(
i[_d
E[X[difh_dp_f#
pkc
FedZ
][^j(
=_[
L[[b[
_ij
Lje\\5
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
F[d][
\[_d[d
Lje\\[i&
>d[h' ]_[&
m[dd
L_[
ct][d&
Z_[
Z[d
Dthf[h
X[_c
MeZ
l[hbsiij(
Bd '%

[_d[c
dehcWb[d
F[diY^[d
^Wj
Z_[
L[[b[
a[_d
;[mkiiji[_d&
i_[
_ij
h[_d
c[Y^Wd_iY^&
ie
ZWii
i_[
d_Y^j
b[_Z[j(
:X[h
Z[h
F[diY^
aWdd
[_d[
:hj
led
AWbX';[mkiiji[_d
[hp[k][d&
ZWi
_d
Z_[
L[[b[
uX[h' ][^[d
aWdd&
kdZ
ZWdd
cW]
Z_[
L[[b[&
Z_[
pkc
FedZ
][^j&
Z[ii[d
][mW^h
i[_d&
mWi
c_j
_^h
][iY^_[^j(
=_[i
][iY^_[^j
dkh
_d
i[^h
i[bj[d[d
?sbb[d
kdZ
dkh&
m[dd
Z_[
>ii[dp
ms^h[dZ
Z[i
E[X[di
][ijehX[d
_ij(
=Wdd
aWdd
Z_[
L[[b[
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
[_d_][i
FWj[h_Wb
led
Z[h
>ii[dp
X[aecc[d(
Bd
Z[h
MWj
]_Xj
[i
l_[b[
WdZ[h[
E[kj[&
Z_[
Z_[
>ii[dp
jtj[d
kdZ
_c
E[X[d
m_hab_Y^
jej
i_dZ&
WX[h
ZWi
X[jh_\\j
kdi
`[jpj
d_Y^j(
EWii[d
L_[
kdi
Wbie
ZWhuX[h
ifh[Y^[d&
mWi
[i
X[Z[kj[d
muhZ[&
Z[d
FedZ
_d
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
[hp[k][d( Sk[hij&
mWi
_ij
Z[h
FedZ9
PWi
_ij
Z_[
?kdaj_ed
Z[i
FedZ[i
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Z[d
F[diY^[d&
Wk\
Z[d
_dZ_l_Zk[bb[d
F[diY^[d9
PWi
muhZ[
][iY^[^[d&
m[dd
Z_[i[
?kdaj_ed
Z[i
FedZ[i
l[hiY^m_d' Z[d
iebbj[5
msh[
[i
lehj[_b^W\j
eZ[h
ZWi
@[][dj[_b9
P_h
m_ii[d
pkc
;[_if_[b&
ZWii
Z[h
FedZ
Wbb[
kdi[h[
;[m[]kd][d
X[^[hhiY^j&
ie
ZWii
m_h
d_Y^j
\s^_]
msh[d&
_h][dZ[_d[
;[m[]kd]
pk
cWY^[d&
\Wbbi
Z[h
FedZ
l[hiY^m_dZ[d
iebbj[5
m_h
muhZ[d
pkiWcc[dXh[Y^[d
m_[
FWh_ed[jj[d&
Z[h[d
?sZ[d
ZkhY^][iY^d_jj[d
mkhZ[d( P_h
cuii[d
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
Wbb
Z_[i
i_Y^
Wk\
ZWi
L[_d
X[p_[^j(
PWi
i_dZ
Z_[
F[hacWb[
kdi[h[i
L[_di9
=Wi
AWkfjc[hacWb
kdi[h[i
L[_di
_ij&
ZWii
m_h
l_[b[
i_dZ&
d_Y^j
[_d[h(
P[dd
m_h
Wd
kdi[h[c
L[_d
WhX[_j[d
mebb[d&
ZWc_j
[i
kdi[h[c
S_[b
X[ii[h
[djifh_Y^j&
cuii[d
m_h
l[hikY^[d&
[_di
pk
m[hZ[d(
:X[h
ZWi
_ij
[_d
i[^h
\[hd[i
S_[b(
PWi
X[Z[kj[j
[i&
[_di
pk
m[hZ[d9
=[h
[hij[
LY^h_jj&
Z[h
deY^
i[^h
m[_j
[dj\[hdj
_ij&
X[ij[^j
ZWh_d&
[_d
f[hcW' d[dj[i
@hWl_jWj_edip[djhkc
pk
iY^W\\[d(
=_[i
_ij
c_j
6Z[d
FedZ
_d
kdi
i[bXij
[hp[k][d9
][c[_dj(
=[h
FedZ
_ij
[_d
f[hcWd[dj[i
@hWl_jWj_edip[djhkc
_d
kdi[h[c
f^oi_iY^[d
E[X[d(
P[dd
m_h
[_d
@hWl_jWj_edip[djhkc
_d
kdi
i[bXij
iY^W\\[d&
XhWkY^[d
m_h
Z[d
FedZ
d_Y^j( :X[h
[hij
cuii[d
m_h
X[ij_cc[d&
mWi
Z_[
:Xm[i[d^[_j
Z[i
f[hcWd[dj[d
yBY^z
X[Z[kj[j(
P_h
\_dZ[d
Wd
i[_d[h
Lj[bb[
l_[b[
Z[h
F[hacWb[
eZ[h
LY^msY^[d&
Z_[
m[_j[h
eX[d
[hms^dj
mkh' Z[d&
WX[h
Z_[i[
cuii[d
[_dZ[kj_]
X[m_[i[d
i[_d&
ZkhY^
kdi
i[bXij&
ZkhY^
;[eXWY^jkd](
=Wdd
cuii[d
m_h
[_d[d
DWcf\
][' '&

][d
Z_[i[
F[hacWb[&
Z_[
kdi
ZWhWd
^_dZ[hd&
[_di
pk
m[hZ[d&
X[]_dd[d(
P_h
cuii[d
c_j
>_dX_bZkd]&
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
kdZ
>_][dm_bb[d
ascf\[d(
>^[
Z_[i[h
DWcf\
[h\eb]h[_Y^
i[_d
aWdd&
cuii[d
m_h
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
Z_[
iY^b_ccij
ct]b_Y^[
:hj
led
>_dX_bZkd]
lec
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Z[i
>hm[hXi
[_d[i
@hWl_jWj_edi' p[djhkci
Wki
Z[h
@bWkX[
_ij&
_h][dZ[jmWi
Wki
i_Y^
i[bXij
QRL
pk
atdd[d(
A_[hdWY^
cuii[d
m_h
c_j
Z[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
ascf\[d&
Z_[
kdi
ZWhWd
^_dZ[hd&
ZWi
pk
jkd&
mWi
kdi
_d
O[hX_d' Zkd]
c_j
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
][iW]j
mkhZ[(
=[dd
cWd
ckii
[ha[d' d[d&
ZWii
>_][dm_bb[
dkh
ZWZkhY^
][XheY^[d
m[hZ[d
aWdd&
ZWii
cWd
jkj&
mWi
[_d[c
][iW]j
mkhZ[(
>h
aWdd
d_Y^j
ZWZkhY^
][Xhe' Y^[d
m[hZ[d&
ZWii
cWd
jkj&
mWi
cWd
i[bXij
[djiY^_[Z[d
^Wj&
Z[dd
ZWi
m_hZ
m[_j[h^_d
>_][dm_bb[
i[_d(
>_][dm_bb[
_ij
_cc[h
DWcf\
][][d
Z[d
P_bb[d
[_d[i
WdZ[h[d(
>_][dm_bb[
aWdd
i_Y^
d_Y^j
cWd_\[ij_[h[d&
e^d[
i_Y^
][][d
Z[d
P_bb[d
[_d[i
WdZ[h[d
pk
ij[bb[d( >i
cW]
B^d[d
^[b\[d&
m[dd
L_[
[_d
;bWjj
IWf_[h
d[^c[d
kdZ
ZWhWk\
Wk\iY^h[_X[d&
mWi
B^h
L[_d
WkicWY^j(
=Wdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
i[^[d&
ZWii
ZWi
L[_d
d_Y^j
Wki
i_Y^
i[bXij
mWY^i[d
aWdd(
Skc
;[_if_[b
_ij
[_d
F[hacWb
kdi[h[i
L[_di&
ZWii
m_h
FWiY^_d[d
i_dZ5
[_d
WdZ[h[i&
ZWii
m_h
dkh
_d
[_d[c
ab[_d[d
M[_b
kdi[h[h
FWiY^_d[
b[X[d5
[_d
Zh_jj[i&
kdi[h[
O_[bpW^b
Wd
yBY^iz(
P_h
iW][d
yBY^z&
WX[h
Z_[i[i
yBY^z
_ij
`[Z[d
:k][dXb_Ya
WdZ[hi(
Bd
[_d[c
:k][d' Xb_Ya
iW][
_Y^
yBY^z&
kdZ
[i
_ij
[_d
yBY^z5
\ud\
F_dkj[d
ifsj[h
iW][
_Y^
yBY^z&
kdZ
[i
_ij
[_d
WdZ[h[i
yBY^z(
Le
^WX[d
m_h
l_[b[
yBY^iz&
Z_[
i_Y^
Wbb[
Wk\
Z[hi[bX[d
>X[d[
X[\_dZ[d&
kdZ
[i
]_Xj
a[_d
p[djhWb[i&
Zec_dWdj[i
yBY^z(
=_[i
_ij
kdi[h
L[_dipkijWdZ5
m_h
i_dZ
d_[cWbi
[_d[h
kdZ
m_h
i_dZ
d_[cWbi
Z[hi[bX[(
P[dd
L_[
Wbb
Z_[i[
F[hacWb[
d_[Z[hiY^h[_X[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
i[^[d&
mWi
[_d[
qdZ[hkd]
Z[i
L[_di
X[Z_d][d
muhZ[
kdZ
mWi
][sdZ[hj
m[hZ[d
aWdd(
Bd
`[Z[c
X[iedZ[h[d
F[hacWb
]_Xj
[i
[jmWi&
ZWi
i_Y^
sdZ[hd
aWdd&
kdZ
[_d[
ab[_d[
qdZ[hkd]
_d
[_d[c
F[hacWb
X[Z[kj[j
WkY^
[_d[
qdZ[hkd]
_d
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d( >_d[h
Z[h
[hij[d
kdZ
m_Y^j_]ij[d
?Wajeh[d
X[_c
O[hikY^&
i_Y^
pk
sdZ[hd&
_ij
Z_[
M[_bkd]
i[_d[h
i[bXij(
=_[
h_Y^j_][
M[_bkd]
_ij
pm_iY^[d
Z[c&
mWi
m_hab_Y^
yBY^z
_ij&
kdZ
Z[c
][iWcj[d
K[ij& ''

Z[d
m_h
yHkif[diaoz
d[dd[d
atdd[d&
eZ[h
m_[
WkY^
_cc[h
B^h
GWc[
i[_d
cW](
P[dd
Z_[i[
M[_bkd]
d_Y^j
][cWY^j
m_hZ&
m[dd
cWd
i_[
l[h]_iij
kdZ
m[_j[h^_d
Wk\
Z_[
uXb_Y^[
P[_i[
uX[h
i_Y^
i[bXij
Z[daj&
eZ[h
m[dd
cWd
\ehj][i[jpj
yBY^z
kdZ
Hkif[diao
X[dkjpj&
WX[h
Wk\
Z_[
\WbiY^[
:hj&
ZWdd
^thj
Z_[
:hX[_j
Wk\(
=_[
[hij[
E_d_[
Z[h
:hX[_j
aWdd
dkh
Wk\
Z[h
@hkdZbW][
Z_[i[h
M[_bkd]
\ehjiY^h[_j[d(
D[_d[
WdZ[h[d
E_d_[d
i_dZ
e\\[d&
m[dd
Z_[i[
M[_' bkd]
l[h][ii[d
m_hZ&
WX[h
[i
ckii
Z_[
h_Y^j_][
M[_bkd]
i[_d(
>i
][iY^_[^j
e\j&
ZWii
E[kj[
[_d[
\WbiY^[
M[_bkd]
cWY^[d(
PWi
i_[
Wd
i_Y^
i[bXij
ct][d&
d[dd[d
i_[
yBY^z&
kdZ
mWi
i_[
d_Y^j
ct][d&
eZ[h
mWi
iY^mWY^
eZ[h
kdm_Y^j_]
_ij&
ZWi
d[dd[d
i_[
yHkif[d'
iaoz&
yI[jhe\\z&
yBlWde\\z
eZ[h
mWi
_cc[h
_^h
GWc[
][hWZ[
_ij(
P[dd
L_[
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
j[_b[d&
_ij
[i
ltbb_]
\WbiY^(
>i
_ij
d_Y^j
][dk]&
ZWii
L_[
^[kj[
[_d[
h_Y^j_][
>djiY^[_Zkd]
jh[\\[d
kdZ
i_[
ceh][d
l[h][ii[d(
L_[
cuii[d
[_d[
h_Y^j_][
>djiY^[_Zkd]
jh[\\[d
kdZ
i_[
_d
B^h[c
@[ZsY^jd_i
X[^Wbj[d( ">i
mkhZ[
[_d
jWjisY^b_Y^[i
;[_if_[b
[_d[h
\WbiY^[d
M[_bkd]
][][X[d(
>_d
FWdd
dWc[di
I[jhe\\&
Z[h
pk
[_d[h
led
Hkif[d'
iaoi
@hkff[d
][^thj
^Wjj[&
kdj[hj[_bj[
i_Y^
_d
pm[_
M[_b[(
>_d[d
led
_^d[d
X[iY^h_[X
[h
Wbi
y[h
[h^sbj
c_Y^
Wc
E[X[dz
kdZ
dWddj[
_^d
yBY^z5
Z[d
K[ij
dWddj[
[h
I[jhe\\(# =_[i[
\WbiY^[
M[_bkd]
_ij
[_d\WY^
Eu][d&
i_Y^
i[bXij
;[bu][d&
mWi
iY^b_cc[h
_ij
Wbi
Wbb[i
WdZ[h[&
Z[dd
_d
Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya&
_d
Z[c
cWd
Z[h
ab[_dij[d
LY^m_[h_]a[_j
X[][]d[j&
m_hZ
i_Y^
Z_[i
ZkhY^
_dd[h[i
:h]kc[dj_[h[d
kdZ
\WbiY^[i
O[hijsdZd_i
p[_][d( yPeh_d
b_[]j
Z_[
NhiWY^[
Z_[i[h
LY^m_[h_]a[_j&
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
j[_b[d9z
\hW]j[
Fhi(Q( y=[h
Nhifhkd]
i_dZ
L_[
kdZ
Fhi(
Q(
Fhi(
Q(
]bWkXj&
i_[
m_ii[
X[ii[h
Wbi
L_[(
L_[
]bWkXj
m_Y^j_][h
pk
i[_d
kdZ
ctY^j[&
ZWii
L_[
jkd&
m_[
i_[
m_bb( y>_d[
Z[h
LY^m_[h_]a[_j[dz&
iW]j[
Fh(
R(&
y_ij&
ZWii
R(
_d
X[ij_ccj[d
L_jkWj_ed[d
X[ii[h
m[_ii
Wbi
6BY^8(z R(
m[_ii
d_Y^ji( y:X[h
[h
]bWkXj
[iz&
iW]j[
Fh(
R( Fuii[d
L_[
][^ehY^[d9
P[dd
L_[
]bWkX[d&
[h
m_ii[
Wc
X[' ij[d&
ZWdd
X[eXWY^j[d
L_[
_^d
[_d\WY^&
kdZ
ZWi
m_hZ
L_[
pkc '(

h_Y^j_][d
O[hij[^[d
\u^h[d(
=_[
[hij[
;[Z_d]kd]
_ij&
ZWv
L_[
d_Y^ji
]bWkX[d
Zuh\[d(
PWi
dujpj
[i&
m[dd
L_[
l[hikY^[d&
[_d
f[hcWd[dj[i
yBY^z
pk
[hp[k][d&
ms^h[dZ
L_[
m[_j[h^_d
Wd
Fh(
R(
]bWkX[d9
=Wi
m_hab_Y^[
yBY^z
m_hZ
ZkhY^
ZWi
O[hbWd][d
WR
PCGL
kdZ
WR
TGPPCL
][iY^W\\[d
kdZ
Wbb[i
WdZ[h[
]_Xj
[i
d_Y^j(
:bie
]_Xj
[i
[_][djb_Y^
d_Y^ji
pk
j[_b[d(
P_h
Zuh\[d
d_Y^ji
]bWkX[d
eZ[h
m_h
m[hZ[d
d_h][dZme^_d
][bWd][d( Bd
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
aWdd
led
Z[c
Pehj
yBY^z
Wk\
\ud\
:hj[d
Wk\
\ud\
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
>X[d[d
][ifheY^[d
m[hZ[d(
=[h
F[diY^
_d
i[_d[c
][mt^db_Y^[d
SkijWdZ
X[ij[^j
Wki
[_d[h
O_[bpW^b
led
yBY^iz5
Z_[i
_ij
Z_[
[hij[
;[Z[kjkd](
Bc
=_W]hWcc
m_hZ
i_[
ZkhY^
ZWi
JkWZhWj
led
yBY^iz
Wd][Z[kj[j(
P[dd
[_d
F[diY^
i_Y^
[djiY^b_[iij
pk
WhX[_j[d&
[hiY^[_dj
[_d
X[eXWY^j[dZ[i
yBY^z
"Wk\
Z[c
=_W]hWcc
_d
iY^mWhp
][p[_]j#5
ZWi
_ij
Z_[
pm[_j[
;[Z[k' jkd](
=_[
Zh_jj[
;[Z[kjkd]&
ZkhY^
Z[d
ab[_dij[d
Dh[_i
X[p[_Y^' d[j&
_ij&
me
Z[h
Lj[bbl[hjh[j[dZ[
AWki^sbj[h
[hiY^[_dj(
>h
X[' ^[hhiY^j
[_d[
:dpW^b
yBY^iz(
=_[
l_[hj[
;[Z[kjkd]&
ZkhY^
Z[d
c_jjb[h[d
Dh[_i
Wd][p[_]j&
_ij&
me
Z[h
AWki^sbj[h
[hiY^[_dj(
>h
X[^[hhiY^j
Wbb[
yBY^iz(
=_[
\ud\j[
;[Z[kjkd]
_ij
Z_[
Z[i
A[hhd(
>h
_ij
Wbi
]hev[h
skv[h[h
Dh[_i
][p[_Y^d[j&
ZW
[h
[_d[d
S[_j' athf[h
^Wj(
>h
a[ddj
Z_[
O[h]Wd][d^[_j
kdZ
WkY^
Z_[
Skakd\j&
eXme^b
[i
^_[hled
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
@hWZ[
][X[d
ckii(

P_[
[habshj
mkhZ[&
kdj[hj[_b[d
m_h
_d
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
_d
yBY^z
kdZ
yCed[iz&
yBY^z
kdZ
yLc_j^z
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h&
m_[
WkY^
_cc[h
kdi[h[
GWc[d
][hWZ[
bWkj[d(
PWi
dkd
l[hijWdZ[d
m[hZ[d
ckii&
_ij&
ZWii
Ced[i&
Lc_j^&
BlWde\\&
I[jhe\\
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h
Z_[
9AFCGL" NCOP[LJGAFICGQ
i_dZ&
Z_[
`[Z[h
led
kdi
^Wj&
WX[h
Z_[i[
M[_bkd]
ZWh\
d_Y^j
c_j
Z[h
M[_bkd]
pm_iY^[d
>ii[dp
kdZ
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
l[h' m[Y^i[bj
m[hZ[d( >ii[dp
_ij&
mec_j
m_h
][Xeh[d
m[hZ[d&
kdi[h[
?s^_]a[_j[d
kdZ
Nd\s^_]a[_j[d(
L_[
ij[^j
c_j
Z[c
yMofz
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
m_[
WkY^
c_j
Z[c
f^oi_iY^[d
Dthf[h(
P_h
atdd[d
Wd
_^h
d_Y^j
Z_h[aj ')

WhX[_j[d(
Oec
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wd
kdi
i[bXij
Wki
X[' jhWY^j[j&
_ij
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
^WX[d(
P[dd
[_d
F[diY^
pk
WhX[_j[d
X[]_ddj&
hk\j
ZWi
FW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
ZWi
X[eXWY^j[dZ[
yBY^z
_di
E[X[d(
=_[i
yBY^z
_ij
WkY^
[_d[
I[hitd' b_Y^a[_j&
Z_[
Z[d
K[ij
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
kdZ
>ii[dp
[hp_[^[d
ckii( yBij
[i
h_Y^j_]
Wdpkd[^c[d&
ZWii
[_d[
I[hied
c_j
[_d[h
^eY^
[djm_Ya[bj[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
iY^m_[h_][h
\_dZ[d
muhZ[9z CW
kdZ
d[_d(
>i
^sd]j
d_Y^j
ie
l_[b
lec
@[m_Y^j
Z[h
I[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
WX
Wbi
led
_^h[c
SkijWdZ&
eX
i_[
[hpe][d
_ij&
iY^b[Y^j
[hpe][d
eZ[h
kd[hpe][d(
L_[
aWdd
_d
Z[h
@[mWbj
Z[i
_cW]_dsh[d
yBY^z
i[_d&
kdZ
ZWdd
_ij
i_[
\WbiY^( =Wi
L[_d
m_hZ
led
Z[h
M[_bkd]
_d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
kdZ
>ii[dp
d_Y^j
X[jhe\\[d(
P_ii[d
kdZ
L[_d
i_dZ
pm[_
L[_j[d
Z[ii[d&
led
Z[c
m_h
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
c[diY^b_Y^[h
>djm_Yabkd]
ifh[Y^[d(
L_[
X_bZ[d
[_d
][][disjpb_Y^[i
IWWh(
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
kdZ

'*

>ii[dp
X_bZ[d
[_d
m[_j[h[i
@[][diWjpfWWh
Wk\
[_d[h
WdZ[h[d
LaWbW( I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
_ij
[hmehX[d5
>ii[dp
][^thj
kdi&
[i
_ij
ZWi&
mec_j
m_h
][Xeh[d
mkhZ[d&
ZWi&
mWi
d_Y^j
led
kdi
WX][jh[ddj
m[hZ[d
aWdd(
L_[
i_dZ
l[hc_iY^j&
kdZ
m_h
atdd[d
][][dmshj_]
Z_[
[_d[
d_Y^j
led
Z[h
WdZ[h[d
kdj[hiY^[_Z[d&
WX[h
[i
_ij
dujpb_Y^&
i_Y^
Z_[i[h
M[_bkd]
Wbi
[_d[h
j^[eh[j_iY^[d
MWjiWY^[
pk
[h_dd[hd( =_[
>ii[dp&
eZ[h
Z[h
F[diY^[djof&
_ij
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
fbWd[jWh_' iY^[h
>_d\buii[(
IbWd[jWh_iY^[
>_d\buii[
X[ij_cc[d
l_[b[
]heii[
>h[_]d_ii[
_c
E[X[d
Z[h
F[diY^^[_j&
m_[
Dh_[][
kdZ
K[lebkj_e' d[d(
Ndi[h[
@[\u^b[
ijWcc[d
khifhud]b_Y^
led
Z[d
IbWd[j[d&
kdZ
kdj[hiY^_[Zb_Y^[
DecX_dWj_ed[d
fbWd[jWh_iY^[h
>_d\buii[
[hp[k][d
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
>ii[dp[d(
C[
dWY^
kdi[h[c
Mof
^WdZ[bd
m_h
_d
X[ij_ccj[d
NcijsdZ[d
Wk\
Z_[
[_d[
eZ[h
WdZ[h[
P[_i[(
FWd
iW]j&
ZWii
[i
pmtb\
eZ[h
WY^jp[^d
AWkfjjof[d
kdZ
ZWdd
DecX_dWj_ed[d
led
Z_[i[d
]_Xj(
>i
_ij
i[^h
i[bj[d&
ZWii
L_[
[_d[c
h[_d[d
Mof
X[][]d[d&
WX[h
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
F[hacWb[
if_[b[d
[_d[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
Kebb[
_d
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
Mof[d&
eXme^b
`[Z[h
Mof
Wbb[i
^Wj( yP[dd
L_[
Wbi
[_d
X[ij_ccj[h
Mof
][Xeh[d
i_dZ&
atdd[d
L_[
_^d
`[cWbi
sdZ[hd9z
\hW]j[
`[cWdZ( P[dd
[i
[_d
i[^h
iY^b[Y^j[h
Mof
_ij
kdZ
L_[
i[^h
^Whj
WhX[_j[d&
atdd[d
L_[
_^d
sdZ[hd(
Sk[hij
cuii[d
L_[
Z[d
Mof
a[dd[d
'
ZWi
^[_iij
Z_[
>ii[dp
a[dd[d(
P[dd
L_[
_d
Z[h
>ii[dp
[jmWi
\_dZ[d&
ZWi
c_j
Z[c
S_[b
kdl[h[_dXWh
_ij&
ZWdd
atdd[d
L_[
[i
l_[bb[_Y^j
sdZ[hd&
m[dd
L_[
i[^h
^Whj
WhX[_j[d(
>ii[dp
_ij
_d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
l[hXeh][d5
Z_[
LjhW^b[d
fbWd[jWh_iY^[h
>_d\buii[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
^_dZkhY^Zh_d][d&
m[_b
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
pk\sbb_]
_ij(
=_[
E[kj[
m[hZ[d
ZkhY^
fbWd[jWh_iY^[
>_d\buii[
dkh
_d
X[ij_ccj[d
M[_b[d
_^h[h
i[bXij
X[hu^hj&
M[_b[d&
Z_[
_cc[h
ZW
i_dZ&
ie
ZWii
Z_[i[
>_d\buii[
[_d[
P_hakd]
Wk\
F[diY^[d
_d
Z[h
FWii[
^WX[d&
WX[h
_d
dehcWb[d
?sbb[d
dkh
i[bj[d
BdZ_l_Zk[d
X[hu^h[d( yBd
m[bY^[c
:kicWiiz&
\hW]j[
`[cWdZ&
yaeccj
[_d
F[diY^&
Z[h
kdj[h
Z[c
@[i[jp
Z[i
Sk\Wbbi
ij[^j&
WX][i[^[d
led
i[_d[h
@[Xkhj
kdZ
i[_d[c
MeZ&
kdj[h
ZWi
@[i[jp
Z[i
LY^_YaiWbi9z =Wi
^sd]j
led
Z[c
O[h^sbjd_i
pm_iY^[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
kdZ (!

>ii[dp
WX(
P[dd
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
ijWha
_ij&
X_bZ[j
i_[
[_d[
LY^Wb[
kc
Z_[
>ii[dp&
ZWdd
]_Xj
[i
i[^h
m[d_]
LY^_YaiWb(
=_[
fbWd[jWh_iY^[d
>_d\buii[&
Z_[
LY^_YaiWb&
Mof&
>ii[dp
X[^[hh' iY^[d&
[hh[_Y^[d
kdi
d_Y^j&
m[dd
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
i[^h
ijWha
_ij(
:X[h
[i
]_Xj
[_d_][
E[kj[&
Z_[&
]sdpb_Y^
e^d[
Z[d
>_d\bkii
led
yLY^kb[dz&
c[^h
_d
Z[h
>ii[dp
b[X[d(
Bd
_^d[d
_ij
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
i[^h
iY^mWY^&
kdZ
i_[
ij[^[d
c[^h
kdj[h
Z[c
@[i[jp
Z[i
LY^_YaiWbi
Wbi
WdZ[h[
E[kj[(
L_[
i_dZ
led
][m_ii[d
>_d\buii[d
WX^sd]_][h
Wbi
WdZ[h[
E[kj[5
_Y^
m[hZ[
d_Y^j
iW][d&
mWi
Z_[i[
>_d\buii[
i_dZ&
Z[dd
ZWi
\u^hj
dkh
pk
>_dX_bZkd][d(
L_[
cuii[d
Z_[i
i[bXij
^[hWki\_dZ[d(
Bc
E[X[d
][mt^db_Y^[h
F[diY^[d
\_d' Z[j
i_Y^
d_Y^ji
led
LY^_YaiWb&
@[Xkhj
kdZ
MeZ
Wki][decc[d(
P_[
_Y^
][iW]j
^WX[&
kdj[hb_[]j
Z[h
_dZ_l_Zk[bb[
F[diY^
Z[d
fbWd[jWh_iY^[d
>_d\buii[d
dkh
_d
][h_d][c
FWii[&
m[_b
i[_d[
>ii[dp
kd[djm_Ya[bj
kdZ
i[^h
ab[_d
_ij
eZ[h
iedijm_[
pk
ijWha
c_j
i[_d[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
l[hc_iY^j
_ij(
=W
Z_[i[
>_d\buii[
Z_[
I[h' itdb_Y^a[_j
d_Y^j
ZkhY^Zh_d][d
atdd[d&
kdj[hij[^[d
iebY^[
F[d' iY^[d
Z[c
@[i[jp
Z[i
Sk\Wbbi(
PuhZ[
Z[h
F[diY^
_d
i[_d[h
>ii[dp
b[X[d&
b[Xj[
[h
kdj[h
fbWd[jWh_iY^[d
>_d\buii[d
eZ[h&
c_j
WdZ[h[d
Pehj[d&
kdj[h
Z[c
@[i[jp
Z[i
LY^_YaiWbi(
HX
Z_[i
pk
i[_d[c
Oehj[_b
msh[
eZ[h
d_Y^j&
_ij
[_d[
WdZ[h[
?hW][(
>i
cW]
_d
[_d[c
?Wbb
X[ii[h
i[_d
kdZ
_d
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
iY^b[Y^j[h(
Bc
Wbb][c[_d[d
X[ii[h(
:X[h
fbWd[jWh_iY^[
LjhW^b[d
atdd[d
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
d_Y^j
ZkhY^Zh_d][d5
i_[
m[hZ[d
led
_^h
h[\b[aj_[hj( ":bi
:djmehj
Wk\
[_d[
?hW][
uX[h
fbWd[jWh_iY^[
>_d\buii[
kdZ
:ijhebe]_[
iW]j[
Hkif[diao4# DecX_dWj_ed[d
led
>_d\buii[d
fheZkp_[h[d
DecX_dWj_ed[d
led
Mof[d(
P_h
m_ii[d
d_Y^j&
mWi
i_[
i_dZ
kdZ
atdd[d
[i
d_Y^j
^[hWki\_dZ[d&
_dZ[c
m_h
[_d
Aeheiaef
cWY^[d(
=Wi
msh[
ie
[jmWi
m_[
c_jj[bWbj[hb_Y^[
IioY^eWdWboi[( y:X[h
Z_[
DecX_dWj_ed[d
ijWcc[d
led
IbWd[j[d&
d_Y^j
mW^h9z CW&
khifhud]b_Y^(
:bb[
kdi[h[
@[\u^b[
kdZ
Wbb
kdi[h[
Oehij[b' bkd][d
aWc[d
khifhud]b_Y^
led
Z[d
IbWd[j[d&
i_[
mkhZ[d
d_Y^j
^_[h
][Xeh[d( yLebbj[
cWd
l[hikY^[d&
_d
>_dabWd]
c_j
i[_d[d
>cej_ed[d
pk ("

b[X[d&
eZ[h
iebbj[
cWd
ij[ji
l[hikY^[d&
[_d[d
]kj[d
@hkdZ
\uh
i[_d
Mkd
pk
\_dZ[d9z =Wi
_ij
iY^m[h
pk
iW][d(
@[\u^b[
atdd[d
l[hiY^_[Z[d
i[_d&
kdZ
Z_[
?s^_]a[_j&
i[_d
E[X[d
pk
X[^[hhiY^[d&
aWdd
l[hiY^_[Z[d
i[_d(
L[^h
e\j
_ij
[i
>_dX_bZkd](
L[^h
e\j
i_dZ
Wbb[
?hW][d
m_[
yLebbj[
_Y^
Z_[i
jkd9z
eZ[h
yLebbj[
_Y^
`[d[i
jkd9z
ltbb_]
audij' b_Y^&
Z[dd
cWd
aWdd
dkh
Wk\
[_d[
:hj
QRL#
L[^h
e\j
]bWkXj
cWd&
[jmWi
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
eZ[h
`[d[
:hj
jkd
pk
atdd[d&
WX[h
_d
PW^h^[_j
aWdd
cWd
[i
dkh
Wk\
[_d[
:hj
jkd(
FWd
^Wj
a[_d[
Dedjhebb[(
:X[h&
kc
pk
Z[h
?hW][
i[bXij
pk
aecc[d&
c[_d[
_Y^&
ZWii
[i
dujpb_Y^
_ij&
led
Z_[i[c
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Wkipk][^[d4
Sk
i[^[d&
m[bY^[
:hj
led
@[\u^b[
L_[
c[_d[d&
eX
[i
@[\u^b[
i_dZ&
Z_[
pkh
>ii[dp
][^th[d&
eZ[h
@[\u^b[&
Z_[
pkh
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
][^th[d(
NdZ
i[^h
e\j
'
d_Y^j
_cc[h&
WX[h
i[^h
e\j
'
atdd[d
L_[
Z[d
@[\u^b[d
l[hjhWk[d&
Z_[
pkh
>ii[dp
][^th[d
kdZ
Z[d
@[\u^' b[d
c_iijhWk[d&
Z_[
pkh
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
][^th[d(
:X[h
Z_[i
_ij
a[_d[
Wbb][c[_d[
K[][b5
i_[
p[_]j
dkh
K_Y^jb_d_[d
Z[i
LjkZ_kci
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
B^h[h
?hW][(
=_[
?hW][
i[bXij
p[_]j&
_d
m[bY^[
K_Y^jkd]
B^h
=[da[d
][^[d
ckii(
L_[
cuii[d
uX[h
>ii[dp
kdZ
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
dWY^Z[da[d(
L_[
cuii[d
uX[h
=_d][
dWY^Z[da[d&
Z_[
L_[
_d
i_Y^
i[bXij
aedjhebb_[h[d
atdd[d
kdZ
=_d][&
Z_[
L_[
d_Y^j
aedjhebb_[h[d
atdd[d(
>i
_ij
a[_d[
pk
X[Wdjmehj[dZ[&
iedZ[hd
[_d[
pk
kdj[hikY^[dZ[
?hW][( yBij
Z_[
>ii[dp
_cc[h
]kj9z G[_d&
a[_d[im[]i( =_[
>ii[dp
_ij
c[Y^Wd_iY^&
i_[
b[Xj
d_Y^j
Wki
i_Y^
i[bXij&
i_[
^Wj
a[_d[d
if[p_[bb[d
=[daWffWhWj5
i_[
ckv
ZkhY^
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
Z[da[d( >ii[dp&
Mof
kdZ
LY^_YaiWb
i_dZ
fhWaj_iY^
ZWii[bX[&
WX[h
MWj' iWY^[d
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
Z[c
LY^_YaiWb
i_dZ
i[^h
iY^m[h
pk
\_dZ[d&
c_j
:kidW^c[
led
X[_dW^[
f^oi_iY^[d
MWjiWY^[d
m_[
Z_[
:hj
Z[h
@[ikdZ^[_j&
?s^_]a[_j[d
eZ[h
s^db_Y^[i(
>i
]_Xj
l_[b[
WdZ[h[
=_d][&
WX[h
i_[
i_dZ
iY^m[h
pk
[ha[dd[d&
Z[dd
_d
kdi[' h[c
SkijWdZ
WhX[_j[j
Z_[
>ii[dp
i[bj[d
led
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
][jh[ddj(
O_[b[
=_d][&
Z_[
m_h
][d[_]j
i_dZ&
Z[c
LY^_YaiWb
pkpk' iY^h[_X[d&
][^th[d
_d
PW^h^[_j
pkh
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j(
=W^[h
_ij
[i (#

][\s^hb_Y^&
LY^buii[
pk
p_[^[d(
:X[h
[_d_][i
atdd[d
m_h
[ha[d' d[d&
pkc
;[_if_[b&
ZWii
X[ij_ccj[
Mof[d
led
E[kj[d
X[ij_ccj[
Mof[d
led
E[kj[d
Wdp_[^[d(
L_[
^WX[d
Z_[i[bX[
:hj
?h[kdZ[&
Z_[i[bX[
:hj
Leh][d&
Z_[i[bX[
:hj
LY^m_[h_]a[_j[d&
WX[h
dWjuh' b_Y^
d_[cWbi&
e^d[
ZWii
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
[_d[d
M[_b
[_dds^c[(
:bie
atdd[d
L_[
[i
d_Y^j
h[_d[i
LY^_YaiWb
d[dd[d5
[i
l[h^sbj
i_Y^
c[^h
m_[
NhiWY^[
kdZ
P_hakd]( yFkii
cWd
^shj[h
WhX[_j[d&
kc
i[_d[d
Mof
pk
sdZ[hd&
Wbi
kc
i[_d[
[hmehX[d[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
pk
sdZ[hd9z ?Wbbi
[i
dejm[dZ_]
_ij&
WX[h
l_[bb[_Y^j
_ij
Z[h
Mof
ltbb_]
_d
HhZ' dkd](
Bd
Z[d
c[_ij[d
?sbb[d
ckii
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
][sdZ[hj
m[h' Z[d5
kdaedjhebb_[hj[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
aWdd
d_Y^j
_d
HhZdkd]
i[_d( Gkh
i[^h
m[d_][
E[kj[
atdd[d
Wd
Z[h
>ii[dp
WhX[_j[d(
:kY^
_ij
[i
d_Y^j
][hWZ[
[_d
Oehj[_b
\uh
Z_[
E[kj[&
Z_[
[i
atdd[d&
m[_b
[i
i[^h
iY^m[h
\uh
i_[
_ij(
Bc
Wbb][c[_d[d
WhX[_j[d
m_h
Wd
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
kdZ
Z_[i
_ij
Z_[
[_dp_][
:hX[_j&
Z_[
m_h
jkd
atdd[d&
kdZ
m[dd
m_h
WhX[_j[d&
m_hZ
[i
kdi
_h][dZme^_d
\u^h[d( yP[dd
m_h
kdi[h
P[i[d
pk
sdZ[hd
l[hikY^[d&
_ij
ZWdd
Z_[
>ii[dp
][dWkie
X[jhe\\[d
m_[
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j9z P_h
cuii[d
Wd
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
WhX[_j[d&
WX[h
Z_[
>ii[dp
m_hZ
ZWled
X[jhe\\[d&
m[dd
m_h
m_hab_Y^
[jmWi
sdZ[hd( yLW]j[d
L_[&
ZWii
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
dkh
Wki
Eu][d
X[ij[^j9z G[_d&
_Y^
iW]j[&
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
i[_
\Wij
ltbb_]
audijb_Y^&
][hWZ[
ie&
m_[
Z_[
>ii[dp
\Wij
ltbb_]
m_hab_Y^
_ij( yL_dZ
kdi[h[
6BY^i8
M[_b
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
eZ[h
Z[h
>ii[dp9z ;[_Z[i(
>i
]_Xj
yBY^iz&
Z_[
pkh
>ii[dp
][^th[d&
kdZ
yBY^iz&
Z_[
pkh
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
][^th[d( yLj[^[d
i_[
c_j
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
S[djh[d
_d
O[hX_dZkd]9z
\k^h
Z[h
i[bX[
?hW][ij[bb[h
\ehj( @[m_ii&
[i
]_Xj
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[
yBY^iz&
;[m[]kd]i'yBY^iz
kdZ
_dij_daj_l[
yBY^iz( >_d
yBY^z
_ij
dkh
CGL
O[hbWd][d&
CGL
PkdiY^(
C[ZeY^
Z_[dj
Z_[i[
Ndj[hiY^[_Zkd]
b[Z_]b_Y^
Z[h
;[gk[cb_Y^a[_j(
L_[
atdd[d
i_[
l[h][ii[d&
m[dd
L_[
mebb[d&
eXme^b
i_[
ij_ccj(
;[^Wbj[d
L_[
[_d\WY^&
ZWii
yBY^iz
ab[_d
i_dZ
kdZ
Z_[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
iY^ed
aecfb_p_[hj[h[
PudiY^[
kc\Wiij( ($

yLj[^j
ZWi
_dij_daj_l[
S[djhkc
_d
[d][h
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
Z[h
>ii[dp9z CW&
[i
X[^[hhiY^j
Z_[
;[Zuh\d_ii[
Z[h
>ii[dp( yBij
Bdj[bb_][dp
M[_b
Z[h
>ii[dp9z :bb][c[_d
][iW]j&
`W(
:X[h
_Y^
muhZ[
][hd[
m_ii[d&
mWi
L_[
kdj[h
Bdj[bb_][dp
l[hij[^[d(
P[dd
_Y^
y`Wz
iW][&
atdd[d
L_[
[i
d_Y^j
Wdm[dZ[d5
[i
m_hZ
jej[i
DWf_jWb
Xb[_X[d( yDWdd
Z_[
Bdj[bb_][dp
ZkhY^
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
;[^WdZbkd]
mWY^i[d
eZ[h
pkd[^c[d9z
[hakdZ_]j[
i_Y^
Z[h
i[bX[
?hW][' ij[bb[h( @[dWk
ZWi
iW]j[
_Y^(
P[dd
m_h
uX[h
kdi
i[bXij
ifh[Y^[d&
m[hZ[d
m_h
i[^[d&
ZWii
Bdj[bb_][dp
Wk\
[_d[
i[^h
l[hc_iY^j[
:hj
pk
>ii[dp
kdZ
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
][^thj5
eXme^b&
Wk\
[_d[
aeic_iY^[
:hj&
`[Z[h
>ii[dp
[_d
X[ij_ccj[h
;[jhW]
Wd
Bdj[bb_][dp
c_j][][' X[d
_ij(

=[h
F[diY^
kdj[hij[^j
[_d[h
]heii[d
O_[bpW^b
led
@[i[jp[d
'
f^oi_iY^[&
f^oi_ebe]_iY^[&
X_ebe]_iY^[&
@[i[jp[&
Z_[
Z[h
F[diY^
i[bXij
[hp[k]j[
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h&
X_i
m_h
pk
Z[d
@[i[jp[d
Z[i
f[hitdb_Y^[d
E[X[di
kdZ
iY^b_[iib_Y^
pkc
_cW]_dsh[d
yBY^z
][' bWd][d(
=_[i
_ij
ZWi
m_Y^j_]ij[
@[i[jp&
ZWi
kdi[h
E[X[d
b[daj
kdZ
kdi
ZWpk
\u^hj&
_d
Z[h
d_Y^j
[n_ij[dj[d
i_[Xj[d
=_c[di_ed
pk
b[X[d(
>_d[
]heii[
F[d][
Wd
Dhs\j[d
eZ[h
>_d\buii[d
m_haj
pk
`[Z[c
][][X[d[d
:k][dXb_Ya
Wk\
Z[d
F[diY^[d&
eXme^b
Z_[
E[kj[
^WkfjisY^b_Y^
led
>_dX_bZkd]
X[^[hhiY^j
m[hZ[d(
P_h
X_bZ[d
kdi
[_d&
WdZ[hi
pk
i[_d&
Wbi
m_h
i_dZ&
kdZ
ZWi
[hp[k]j
Bbbki_ed[d(
:X[h
[i
]_Xj
dejm[dZ_][
@[i[jp[(
P_h
i_dZ
[_d][' iY^hsdaj
ZkhY^
X[ij_ccj[
GW^hkd]
kdZ
X[ij_ccj[
Ek\j&
ZkhY^
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
M[cf[hWjkh
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
P_h
i_dZ
ie
aedZ_j_e' d_[hj
ZkhY^
>_d\buii[&
ZWii
m_h
i[^h
m[d_][
?h[_^[_jict]b_Y^a[_' j[d
^WX[d(
P_h
cuii[d
kdi[h[
_dd[h[
AWbjkd]
sdZ[hd(( E[kj[&
Z_[
WkiiY^b_[iib_Y^
kdj[h
:'>_d\buii[d
b[X[d
kdZ
Z_[
;'>_d\buii[&
m[dd
i_[
_^d[d
X[][]d[d&
Wk\
Z[hi[bX[d
Ljk\[
m_[
:'>_d\buii[
[cf\Wd][d&
ij[hX[d
][mt^db_Y^
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d( (%

L_[
atdd[d
athf[hb_Y^
Wc
E[X[d
i[_d&
WX[h
ZWi
^[_iij
d_Y^j&
ZWii
_^h[
>ii[dp
i_Y^
[djm_Ya[bd
aWdd( yL[^[d
jej[
E[kj[
Wki
m_[
Wbb[
WdZ[h[d9
E[X[d
i_[&
m_[
m_h b[X[d9z L_Y^[hb_Y^(
P[_b
i_[
[_d[
L[[b[
X[i_jp[d
kdZ
Z_[
rX[hXb[_Xi[b
Z[h
>ii[dp(
L_[
atdd[d
i_Y^
i[bXij
WXi_Y^[hd yL_[
ifhWY^[d
leh^[h
ZWhuX[h&
[_d
f[hcWd[dj[i
yBY^z
pk
[hp[k][d(
PWi
c[_d[d
L_[
ZWc_j9z BY^
c[_d[
ZWc_j&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^[h
i[_d
atdd[d&
ZWii
[i
`[Z[i
FWb
ZWii[bX[
yBY^z
_ij&
m[dd
L_[
yBY^z
iW][d(
Gkd
iW][d
L_[&
yBY^
m_bb
Z_[iz&
kdZ
[_d[
^WbX[
LjkdZ[
ifsj[h
iW][d
L_[&
yBY^
m_bb
ZWiz(
=Wi
yBY^z
_ij
ltbb_]
l[hiY^_[Z[d(
>i
]_Xj
>_d[i
'
9GC
"
kdZ
[i
]_Xj
l_[b[
_cW]_dsh[
yBY^iz(
^9GC_
_ij
ZWi&
mWi
m_hab_Y^
_ij&
kdZ
L_[
cuii[d
b[hd[d&
[i
pk
kdj[hiY^[_Z[d(
>i
aWdd
i[^h
ab[_d&
i[^h
[b[c[djWh
i[_d&
WX[h
L_[
atdd[d
[jmWi
>_dZ[kj_][i
kdZ
I[hcW' d[dj[i
kdZ
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
Leb_Z[i
_d
i_Y^
\_dZ[d( P[dd
L_[
Wd
Wbb[i
ZsY^j[d&
mWi
][iW]j
mkhZ[&
muhZ[d
L_[
i_Y^
dWY^
:XbWk\
led
p[^d
PeY^[d
B^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd(
G[^c[d
L_[
pkc
;[_if_[b
ZWi
LjkZ_kc
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j(
=Wi
_ij
[_d[
Z[h
iY^d[bbij[d
F[j^eZ[d(
C[
c[^h
L_[
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
l[hij[^[d&
Z[ije
c[^h
m[hZ[d
L_[
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd(
PWi
ZWi
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
l[h^_dZ[hj&
_ij
leh
Wbb[c
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j(
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
aWdd
kdZ
mudiY^j
i_Y^
_^h[h
i[bXij
d_Y^j
pk
[h_dd[hd&
kdZ
i_[
mudiY^j&
ZWv
i_Y^
a[_d[
WdZ[h[
I[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
_^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hj(
L_[
l[hikY^j
][hWZ[&
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
pk
ijeff[d5
d_ccj
_h][dZ[_d[
?ehc
led
LY^bW\
kdZ
d[ddj
ZWi
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd(
=Wdd
_ij
i_[
lebbWk\
]buYab_Y^( LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
_ij
[jmWi
;[iedZ[h[i5
9GC
i_dZ
_^h
[dj][' ][d][i[jpj(
FWd
ckii
ZW\uh
ieh][d&
ZWii
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
l[hiY^m_dZ[j&
eZ[h
Wk\
`[Z[d
?Wbb
ZWh\
i_[
d_Y^j
_d
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
[_d][^[d(
=_[i
]_bj
\uh
`[Z[d&
kdZ
`[Z[h
ckii
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
X[]_dd[d(
Sk
Wbb[h[hij
cuii[d
L_[
B^h[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
a[dd[d&
kdZ
L_[
Zuh\[d
_^h
Wk\
a[_d[
P[_i[
l[hjhWk[d
'
_^h[d
@[ZWda[d&
_^h[d
Pehj[d&
_^h[d
AWdZbkd][d(
L_[
atdd[d
i_[
d_Y^j
p[hijth[d&
WX[h
L_[
atdd[d
i_[
\uh
[_d[
P[_b[
fWii_l
cW' Y^[d&
kdZ
ZWdd
atdd[d
L_[
i_[
dWY^
kdZ
dWY^
iY^msY^[d( (&

=_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
[n_ij_[hj
d_Y^j
m_hab_Y^&
WX[h
m_h
X_bZ[d
kdi
[_d&
i_[
[n_ij_[h[(
L_[
[n_ij_[hj
ZkhY^
_^h[
>hiY^[_' dkd]i\ehc[d&
WX[h
d_Y^j
Wbi
[_d
M[_b
led
kdi(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
d_Y^j&
i_[
pk
Z[\_d_[h[d&
iedij
m[hZ[d
L_[
i_Y^
_d
Pehj[d
l[hb_[' h[d&
[i
][^j
`[ZeY^
ZWhkc&
i_Y^
c_j
MWjiWY^[d
Wki[_dWdZ[hpki[j' p[d(
>i
]_Xj
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[&
WX[h
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
]_Xj
[i
i_[
d_Y^j5
[i
]_Xj
a[_d
m_hab_Y^[i
S[djhkc
\uh
i_[(
=_[i
_ij
[_d[i
Z[h
F_ii][iY^_Ya[
kdi[h[i
SkijWdZi(
=GO
PGLB
SMJJCO
LGAFQ
CUGPQGCOCL" BCO
+GLEC# "C[cWdZ
iW]j[&
[h
X[pm[_\b[
cWdY^cWb
Z_[
>Y^j^[_j
i[_d[i
Bdj[h[ii[i
Wd
Z[h
:hX[_j(
>h
atdd[
i_Y^
i[bXij
X[bu][d(
Hkif[d'
iao
Wdjmehj[j[4# Gkh
L_[
atdd[d
ZWi
X[Wdjmehj[d&
kdZ
dkh&
\Wbbi
L_[
d_Y^j
Z_[
]hkdZb[][dZ[d
Ih_dp_f_[d
l[h][ii[d&
_dZ[c
L_[
yBY^z
pk
[jmWi
iW][d&
ZWi
dkh
[_d
yBY^z
_ij(
L_[
cuii[d
WdZ[h[
yBY^iz
a[dd[db[h' d[d
kdZ
i_Y^
_^h[h
[h_dd[hd(
P[dd
L_[
ZWi
l[h][ii[d&
l[h][ii[d
L_[
Wbb[i(
Le
bWd][&
m_[
L_[
i_Y^
ZWhWd
[h_dd[hd&
atdd[d
L_[
i_Y^
Wd
Wbb[i
[h_dd[hd(
=_[i
pk
l[h][ii[d&
_ij
Z_[
]heii[
@[\W^h&
kdZ
[_d
b[_Y^j[h
PWdZ[b
_d
[_d[h
Db[_d_]a[_j
h[_Y^j
Wki&
kc
Wbb[i
pk
l[h\sbiY^[d( >_d_][
@hkff[d
led
yBY^iz
i_dZ
dujpb_Y^&
[_d_][
i_dZ
audijb_Y^
kdZ
[_d_][
i_dZ
fWj^ebe]_iY^(
:bb[
E[kj[
if_[b[d
Kebb[d5
`[Z[
I[hied
^Wj
kd][\s^h
\ud\
eZ[h
i[Y^i
Kebb[d&
Z_[
i_[
_d
_^h[c
E[X[d
if_[bj(
L_[
if_[bj
i_[
kdX[mkiij&
eZ[h
m[dd
i_[
i_[
X[mkiij
pk
if_[b[d
l[hikY^j&
_Z[dj_\_p_[hj
i_[
i_Y^
i[^h
iY^d[bb
c_j
_^d[d
kdZ
if_[bj
i_[
m[_j[h^_d
kdX[mkiij(
=_[i[
Kebb[d
pkiWcc[d
X_bZ[d
ZWi
_cW]_dsh[
yBY^z( LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
_ij
ZWi
_cW]_dsh[
yBY^z( "C[cWdZ
\hW]j[&
eX
^t^[h[
;[mkiiji[_dipkijsdZ[
]hkdZb[' ][dZ
iY^b[Y^j[h[
eZ[h
]b[_Y^[hcWii[d
]hkdZb[][dZ
X[ii[h[
F[d' iY^[d
^[hlehXhsY^j[d(
Hkif[diao
Wdjmehj[j[4# G[_d&
ZWi
_ij
\WbiY^(
LY^b[Y^j[
E[kj[
atdd[d
dkh
ZkhY^
Lj[_' ][hd
Z[h
F[Y^Wd_i_[hj^[_j
^[hleh][XhWY^j
m[hZ[d(
L[bXij'>h_d'
d[hd
aWdd
a[_d[
\WbiY^[d
K[ikbjWj[
[hp[k][d&
lehWki][i[jpj&
Z_[
O[hX_dZkd]
pk
WdZ[h[d
BZ[[d
Z[i
Loij[ci
m_hZ
Wk\h[Y^j[h^Wb' j[d&
WX[h
m[dd
cWd
[_d[
LWY^[
Wk\]_Xj
kdZ
[jmWi
WdZ[h[i
Wki ('

Z[c
Loij[c
d_ccj
'
m[dd
cWd
pkc
;[_if_[b
[hdij^W\j
Wc
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
WhX[_j[j&
e^d[
Z_[
BZ[[
Z[h
M[_bkd]
Z[h
yBY^iz
pk
a[dd[d&
ie
ZWv
cWd
i_Y^
led
:d\Wd]
Wd
Wbi
>_d[d
d_ccj
"Wbi
[_d[
>_d^[_j#
'
ZWdd
m_hZ
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
pk
\WbiY^[d
K[ikbjWj[d
hu^h[d
kdZ
aWdd
ie]Wh
[_d[
\[^b[h^W\j[
Dh_ijWbb_iWj_ed
X[m_ha[d
kdZ
[_d[
>djm_Yabkd]
kdct]b_Y^
cWY^[d(
>i
]_Xj
pkc
;[_if_[b
LY^kb[d
eZ[h
Loij[c[&
Z_[&
eXme^b
i_[
[i
d_Y^j
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
WkiZhuYa[d&
_d
Z[h
MWj
Wk\
\WbiY^[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
X[hk^[d
kdZ
Wk\
Z[c
DWcf\
ECECL
@[m_ii[d(
LebY^[
:hX[_j
m_hZ
X[ij_ccj
\WbiY^[
>h][Xd_ii[
^[hlehXh_d][d(
Sk[hij
m_hZ
i_[
[_d[
:hj
Ljsh' a[
^[hlehXh_d][d&
WX[h
i_[
m_hZ
Z_[
>djm_Yabkd]
^t^[h[d
;[' mkiiji[_di
pkh
Ndct]b_Y^a[_j
cWY^[d(
>djm[Z[h
p[hijthj
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
ZWi
>h_dd[hkd]il[hct][d
eZ[h
[i
[djij[bbj
[i( L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
_ij
[jmWi&
ZWi
Wk\
h_Y^j_][h
?kdaj_ed
X[hk^[d
ckii(
@b[_Y^p[_j_]
cuii[d
L_[
Wd
Z[h
LY^msY^kd]
Z[h
LY^[_df[h' itdb_Y^a[_j
WhX[_j[d(
O[hiY^_[Z[d[
E_d_[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
m[hZ[d
led
:d\Wd]
Wd
dW^[][b[]j
kdZ
[hbskj[hj
kdZ
Wbb[
cuii[d
pkiWc' c[dif_[b[d(
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
Xbeii
[_d[
LWY^[
jkd
kdZ
[_d[
WdZ[h[
d_Y^j(
:bb[
i_dZ
dejm[dZ_]&
kc
Z_[i[
h_Y^j_][
DecX_dW' j_ed
pk
[hp[k][d&
WX[h
pk[hij
ckii
ZWi
O[hij[^[d
Z[h
LY^[_df[h' itdb_Y^a[_j
kdZ
Z[h
DWcf\
c_j
_^h
aecc[d(
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
cWd
l[hikY^j[&
i_Y^
i[_d[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd
kdZ
mebbj[
a[_d[
:dijh[d]kd][d
][][d
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
kdj[hd[^c[d&
ZWdd
muhZ[d
Wbb
_^h[
F[hacWb[
^[hlehjh[j[d&
i_[
muhZ[d
iW][d&
^0AF
cW]
Z_[i[
E[kj[
d_Y^j5
GAF
ctY^j[
Z_[i
d_Y^j&
GAF
ctY^j[
ZWi
d_Y^jz
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
=Wdd
m_hZ
[i
d_Y^j
:hX[_j
i[_d&
iedZ[hd
][dWk
ZWi
@[][dj[_b(
P[dd
cWd
Wk\
Z_[i[
\WbiY^[
:hj
pk
WhX[_' j[d
l[hikY^j&
aWdd
i_[
[_d[d
ijsha[h
cWY^[d&
Wbi
cWd
pkleh
mWh&
WX[h
`[
ijsha[h
cWd
_d
Z_[i[c
?Wbb
m_hZ&
Z[ije
][h_d][h
_ij
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
Z[h
>djm_Yabkd](
Oeh
Z[h
>djm_Yabkd]
\_n_[h[d{
ZWi
_ij
Z_[
@[\W^h( yBij
[_d
][bWd]m[_bj[h
F[diY^
\h[_
led
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed9z EWd][m[_b[
_ij
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
c_j
i_Y^
i[bXij&
c_j
Z[h
\WbiY^[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
c_j
[jmWi
_d
[_d[c
i[bXij(
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
_ij
[_d
X[_dW^[
f[hcWd[dj[h
SkijWdZ
\uh
kdi(
L_[
_ij
Z_[
AWkfjcWd_\[' ((

ijWj_ed
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
kdZ
Z[im[][d
atdd[d
m_h
Z[h
\WbiY^[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
d_Y^j
[djaecc[d(
L_[
cuii[d
\s^_]
i[_d&
Z_[i[d
SkijWdZ
][jh[ddj
led
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
i[^[d&
][iedZ[hj
led
i_Y^
i[bXij&
kdZ
Z_[i
atdd[d
L_[
dkh&
m[dd
L_[
l[hikY^[d&
X[mkiij[h
pk
m[hZ[d&
l[hikY^[d&
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd&
l[hikY^[d(
B^h[h
i[bXij
][mW^h
pk
i[_d(
Gkh
m[dd
L_[
B^h[h
i[bXij
c[^h
][mW^h
m[hZ[d&
i_dZ
L_[
_d
Z[h
EW][&
c_j
>hiY^[_dkd]i\eh' c[d
m_[
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
kdZ
Eu][d
pk
ascf\[d
kdZ
c_j
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
i[bXij(
:bb[
:hX[_j
ckii
Wd
Z[h
LY^[_df[h' itdb_Y^a[_j
i[_d(
P[dd
L_[
_h][dZ[_d[
WdZ[h[
:hX[_j
jkd
kdZ
Z_[i[
WkibWii[d&
_ij
[i
dkjpbei[
:hX[_j&
kdZ
L_[
m[hZ[d
i[^h
iY^d[bb
l[hiW][d(
P_[
X[_
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d&
Eu][d
kdZ
Wbb[d
>_dX_bZkd][d&
aWdd
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
d_Y^j
e^d[
BZ[dj_\_' aWj_ed
[n_ij_[h[d(
L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
[_d[
DecX_dWj_ed
Wbb[h
Eu][d&
F[hacWb[
kdZ
yBY^iz
_ij&
Z_[
d_[cWbi
_d
_h][dZ[_d[c
L_dd
eZ[h
Wk\
_h][dZ[_d[
:hj
dujpb_Y^
i[_d
atdd[d&
m[Z[h
_c
E[X[d
deY^
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
'
m_[
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[( y;[hk^j
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
lebbijsdZ_]
Wk\
d[]Wj_l[d
@[' \u^b[d9z Bd
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
]_Xj
[i
l_[b[
=_d][
d[Xij
d[]Wj_' l[d
@[\u^b[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
]_Xj
[i
_d
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
_cc[h
iY^b[Y^j[
][_ij_][
@[me^d^[_j[d
'
\WbiY^[i
=[da[d(
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
eZ[h
M[_b[
Z[h
\WbiY^[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
X[hk^[d
_cc[h
Wk\
\WbiY^[c
=[da[d(
@b[_Y^p[_j_]
muhZ[
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
pkiWcc[dXh[Y^[d&
m[dd
L_[
_^h
Z_[
d[]Wj_' l[d
@[\u^b[
m[]ds^c[d5
i_[
atddj[
d_Y^j
e^d[
i_[
[n_ij_[h[d( y:bie
[djifh_d][d
Wbb[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitd' b_Y^a[_j9z
\hW]j[
`[cWdZ
WdZ[h[i( CW&
][m_ii(
P_[
atddj[
[i
WdZ[hi
i[_d9
=_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
_ij
iepkiW][d
[_d
X[iedZ[h[i
Hh]Wd
\uh
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[&
\uh
Z_[
>dj\Wbjkd]
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[&
\uh
ZWi
@[c[ii[d
d[]Wj_' l[h
@[\u^b[&
\uh
ZWi
A[hlehXh_d][d
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[(
L_[
[h_d' d[hd
i_Y^&
ZWii
_Y^
iW]j[&
[i
]sX[
a[_d
m_hab_Y^[i
S[djhkc
\uh
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[(
=_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
m_haj
Wbi
S[djhkc
\uh
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[( ()

yP_[
aWdd
cWd
c_j
Z[h
>_j[ba[_j
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
kc][^[d9z L_[
cuii[d
[hij
Wbb[
_^h[
F[hacWb[
a[dd[d
kdZ
ZWdd
cuii[d
L_[
h_Y^j_]
Z[da[d(
P[dd
L_[
h_Y^j_]
Z[da[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
P[][
\_dZ[d&
kc
c_j
_^h
kcpk][^[d(
L_[
Zuh\[d
i_[
d_Y^j
h[Y^j\[hj_][d5
i_[
b[Xj
led
Z[h
K[Y^j\[hj_]kd]&
]Wh
Z[h
O[h^[hhb_Y^kd]
Wbb[h
_^h[h
F[hacWb[(
Bd
X[_dW^[
`[Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya
kdi[h[i
E[X[di&
ie]Wh
_d
hk^_][d
Fec[dj[d&
h[Y^j\[hj_][d
m_h
i_[
_cc[h&
X[' jhWY^j[d
i_[
Wbi
b[]_j_c
kdZ
\_dZ[d
Wbb[
ct]b_Y^[d
>djiY^kbZ_]kd' ][d
\uh
i_[(
=_[i
_ij
c_j
\WbiY^[c
=[da[d
][c[_dj(
:bie
cuii[d
L_[
Wbi
[hij[i
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
a[dd[d&
kdZ
ZWdd
cuii[d
L_[
h_Y^j_]
ZWhuX[h
Z[da[d(
L_[
cuii[d
m_ii[d&
mWi
i_[
_ij
'
i_[
iepkiW][d
fbWp_[h[d
'
ZWi
_ij
Z[h
[hij[
LY^h_jj(
NdZ&
m_[
_Y^
iW]j[&
cuii[d
L_[
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
?JJC
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed&
?JJCP
:Xms' ][d&
?JJCP
Eu][d&
?JJCP
i_Y^
i[bXij
;[bu][d&
?JJC
LY^msY^[d&
?JJC
P_Z[hifhuY^[&
e\\[d
kdZ
l[hij[Yaj&
ZWii
PGC
?JJC
\WbiY^[
I[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
i_dZ(
P[_j[h^_d
][^th[d
Wbb[
?ehc[d
led
>_][dm_bb[d
pkh
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
Wbie
cuii[d
L_[
i_[
\hu^[h
eZ[h
ifsj[h
ef\[hd( yLW]j[d
L_[&
?JJ
kdi[h[
Oehb_[X[d
kdZ
:Xd[_]kd][d
i[_[d
_d
Z[h
\WbiY^[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j9z =_[
c[_ij[d
led
_^d[d(
NdZ
ie]Wh
Z_[&
Z_[
khifhud]b_Y^
d_Y^j
pk
_^h
][^thj[d&
Z_[
m_hab_Y^[
Pkhp[bd
^WX[d&
Wbb[
][^[d
ZkhY^
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j( "C[cWdZ
\hW]j[&
eX
cWd
Z_[
][iWcj[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
a[dd[d
cuii[&
kc
][][d
i_[
pk
ascf\[d&
m[_b
[i
_^c
iY^_[d&
Wbi
atdd[
cWd
dkh
ab[_d[
LjuYa[
led
_^h
a[dd[d(
Hkif[diao
Wdj' mehj[j[4# FWd
ckii
i_[
a[dd[d(
L_[
_ij
m_[
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
AkdZ[hWii[(
P[dd
L_[
i_[
d_Y^j
a[dd[d&
atdd[d
L_[
d_Y^j
uX[h
i_[
h[Z[d(
P[dd
L_[
i_[
][i[^[d
^WX[d&
atdd[d
L_[
uX[h
i_[
ifh[Y^[d(
Gkh
LjuYa[
pk
i[^[d&
m_[
L_[
iW]j[d&
_ij
lebbWk\
][dk](
C[Z[h
ab[_d[
M[_b
led
_^h
^Wj
Z_[i[bX[
?WhX[(
P[dd
L_[
Z_[i[d
AkdZ
[_dcWb
i[^[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
_^d
_cc[h
a[dd[d(
>h
X[bbj
Wk\
[_d[
X[iedZ[' h[
:hj5
[h
bsk\j
Wk\
[_d[
X[iedZ[h[
:hj( "C[cWdZ
\hW]j[&
eX
Z[h
yAWkfjpk]z
"Z(
^(
ZWi
AWkfjc[hacWb (*

Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j#
GW^hkd]
\uh
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
msh[(
Hkif[diao
iW]j[4# =[h
AWkfjpk]
_ij
a[_d[
GW^hkd](
=[h
AWkfjpk]
GPQ
LY^[_d' f[hitdb_Y^a[_j(
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
X[hk^j
_d
Z[d
c[_ij[d
?sb' b[d
Wk\
[_d[c
F[hacWb&
ZWi
Wd
Wbb[c
j[_b^Wj(
>_d[i
MW][i
m[hZ[d
m_h
[_d_][
;[_if_[b[
led
AWkfjpu][d
d[^c[d
kdZ
L_[
m[hZ[d
i[^[d&
m_[
[i
_d
Z[h
MWj
ZWi
_ij&
mWi
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
WkicWY^j( yPWi
_ij
Z_[
X[ij[
:hj&
dWY^
i[_d[c
AWkfjpk]
pk
ikY^[d9z \hW]j[
`[cWdZ( L[^[d
L_[
[_d\WY^
i[bXij(
BY^
m[_ii
d_Y^j&
m_[
_Y^
[i
X[ii[h
[habsh[d
iebb(
>i
_ij
ct]b_Y^&
ZWii
cWd
[jmWi
\_dZ[j
'
Z[d
AWkfjpk]
Z[i
:k][dXb_Yai(
>h
_ij
[_d][X_bZ[j[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j5
ZWi
_ij
Z[h
AWkfjpk]
\uh
`[Z[d( yDWdd
cWd
i[_d[d
AWkfjpk]
sdZ[hd9z
\hW]j[
`[cWdZ
WdZ[h[i( Sk[hij
ckii
cWd
_^d
a[dd[d(
P[dd
L_[
_^d
a[dd[d&
m_hZ
l_[b
led
Z[h
JkWb_jsj
B^h[i
P_ii[di
WX^sd][d(
P[dd
L_[
_^d
]kj
a[dd[d&
ZWdd
_ij
[i
ct]b_Y^&
_^d
pk
sdZ[hd( yP[dd
[_d[
AWbjkd]
^_dj[h
[_d[c
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b
i[^h
Wbj
kdZ
[_d][\b[_iY^j
_ij&
ct]b_Y^[hm[_i[
[_d
F[hacWb&
m_[
aWdd
_Y^
[i
Wd]h[_\[d9z ;[]_dd[d
L_[
c_j
Z[c
F[hacWb(
?_dZ[d
L_[
ZWi
F[hacWb&
ifh[Y^[d
L_[
ZWhuX[h
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h( >i
_ij
dejm[dZ_]&
uX[h
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
L?AFWRBCL" ICL!
kdZ
_d
cWdY^[d
?sbb[d
atdd[d
L_[
[djiY^_[Z[d
[_d[
:hj
led
AWkfjpk]
i[^[d&
Z[h
_d
Wbb[i
[_d][^j&
m_[
Z_[
:Y^i[&
kc
Z_[
i_Y^
Wbb[i
Zh[^j(
FWd
aWdd
_^d
p[_][d&
WX[h
Z_[
X[jh[\\[dZ[
I[hied
m_hZ
iW][d&
y:XikhZ&
Wbb[i&
WX[h
d_Y^j
ZWiz
HZ[h
cWdY^cWb
_ij
[i
ie
e\\[di_Y^jb_Y^&
ZWii
[h
d_Y^j
l[hb[k]d[j
m[hZ[d
aWdd&
WX[h
c_j
Z[h
A_b\[
led
Ik\\[hd
aWdd
cWd
_^d
m_[Z[h
l[h][ii[d(
BY^
^WX[
E[kj[
][aWddj&
Z_[
_^h[c
AWkfjpk]
c[^hcWbi
[_d[d
GW' c[d
]WX[d
kdZ
_^d
[_d[
S[_j
bWd]
_c
@[ZsY^jd_i
X[^_[bj[d(
=Wdd
jhW\
_Y^
i_[
m_[Z[h
kdZ
i_[
^Wjj[d
l[h][ii[d&
eZ[h
m[dd
i_[
i_Y^
[h_dd[hj[d&
^Wjj[d
i_[
[_d
@[i_Y^j&
kdZ
m[dd
i_[
l[h][ii[d
^Wjj[d&
^Wjj[d
i_[
[_d
WdZ[h[i
@[i_Y^j
kdZ
X[]Wdd[d
pk
h[Z[d&
Wbi
^sjj[d
i_[
d_[
ZWhuX[h
][ifheY^[d(
L_[
cuii[d
i[bXij
ds^[h )!

ZWhWd
aecc[d(
P[dd
L_[
_^d
i[bXij
\u^b[d&
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
m_ii[d5
m[dd
cWd
[i
B^d[d
b[Z_]b_Y^
iW]j&
atdd[d
L_[
_cc[h
l[h][ii[d( yDWdd
_Y^
[_d[d
:d^Wbjifkdaj
\uh
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
X[aecc[d&
m[dd
_Y^
Wd
>h[_]d_ii[
Z[h
O[h]Wd][d^[_j
Z[da[9z FWdY^cWb
atdd[d
L_[
ZWi(
>djm[Z[h
_d
Z[h
O[h]Wd][d^[_j
eZ[h
_d
B^h[d
?h[kdZ[d(
:X[h
L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
L_[
[X[d\Wbbi
[_d[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
^WX[d&
d_Y^j
dkh
B^h[
?h[kdZ[ yDtdd[d
m_h
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
e^d[
A_b\[
i[^[d9z M^[eh[j_iY^
ifh_Y^j
d_Y^ji
ZW][][d&
dkh
iW^
_Y^
deY^
d_[
ie
[_d[d
?Wbb
kdZ
a[_d
WdZ[h[h&
Z[d
_Y^
a[dd[&
iW^
ie
[_d[d
?Wbb(
Le]Wh
m[dd
cWd
_^d[d
^_b\j&
i_dZ
Z_[
E[kj[
][mt^db_Y^
d_Y^j
ZWhWk\
lehX[h[_j[j&
i_[
pk
i[^[d(
>i
_ij&
Wbi
iebbj[d
L_[
[_d[c
F[diY^[d
i[_d
:XX_bZ
_d
[_d[c
m_hab_Y^[d&
jWjisY^b_Y^[d
Lf_[][b
p[_][d&
kdZ
[h
muhZ[
iW][d&
y=Wi
X_d
d_Y^j
_Y^(
=Wi
_ij
[_d
audijb_Y^[h
Lf_[][b&
a[_d
m_hab_Y^[h
Lf_[][b(
=Wi
_ij
a[_d
Lf_[][b' X_bZ
led
c_h(z
:X[h
m[dd
[_d
F[diY^
lehX[h[_j[j
_ij&
_ij
[i
cWdY^cWb
ct]b_Y^&
[_d
F[hacWb
eZ[h
[_d[
LY^msY^[
_d
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
[ha[dd[d(
P[dd
[_d
F[diY^
Z_[i
F[hacWb
a[ddj&
m[dd
[h
X[]_ddj&
[i
_c
@[ZsY^jd_i
pk
X[^Wbj[d
kdZ
ZWhWd
pk
Z[da[d&
ZWdd
cW]
[_d
X[ij_ccj[h
:k][dXb_Ya
aecc[d&
_d
Z[c
[h
led
Z_[i[c
F[hacWb
\h[_
_ij&
_d
Z[c
i[_d
AWdZ[bd
d_Y^j
ZkhY^
i[_d[
LY^msY^[
X[ij_ccj
_ij( FWdY^cWb
d[^c[d
kdi[h[
F[hacWb[
eZ[h
LY^msY^[d
[_d\W' Y^[
?ehc[d
m_[
?Wkb^[_j
Wd&
WX[h
_d
WdZ[h[d
?sbb[d
i_dZ
_^h[
?ehc[d
ie
]kj
l[hab[_Z[j&
ZWii
[i
a[_d[
][mt^db_Y^[d
Pehj[
]_Xj&
kc
i_[
pk
X[iY^h[_X[d&
kdZ
i_[
atdd[d
dkh
ZkhY^
[_d[
:hj
=_W]hWcc
eZ[h
S[_Y^dkd]
X[iY^h_[X[d
m[hZ[d( ?uh
cWdY^[
E[kj[
X[ij[^[d
Zh[_
O_[hj[b
_^h[i
E[X[di
eZ[h
c[^h
Wki
?Wkb^[_j(
FWdY^cWb
_ij
?Wkb^[_j
i[^h
m_Y^j_]&
cWdY^' cWb
_ij
i_[
Z[h
AWkfjpk]
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j(
L[^h
e\j
_ij
i_[
Z[h
AWkfjpk]&
kdZ
Z[h
]Wdp[
K[ij
^sd]j
led
Z[h
?Wkb^[_j
WX
kdZ
Z_[dj
Z[h
?Wkb^[_j(
:X[h
Z[da[d
L_[
ZWhWd&
ZWii
[i
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
:hj[d
led
?Wkb^[_j
]_Xj(
FWd
ckii
i_[
ZkhY^
L[bXijX[eXWY^jkd]
kdZ
ZkhY^
;[eXWY^j[d
WdZ[h[h
E[kj[
^[hWki\_dZ[d(
Skc
;[_' )"

if_[b
]_Xj
[i
i[^h
][iY^s\j_][
E[kj[&
Z_[
_cc[h
[jmWi
jkd
kdZ
Z[ddeY^
aWdd
_^h
.CGPQ
\Wkb
i[_d(
=Wi
][iY^_[^j
^sk\_][h
Wbi
Wbb[i
WdZ[h[(
?Wkb^[_j
_ij
d_Y^j
dkh
Z[h
PkdiY^&
pk
i_jp[d
kdZ
d_Y^ji
pk
jkd( ";[_
[_d[c
i[_d[h
Mh[\\[d
\hW]j[
`[cWdZ
Hkif[diao&
eX
cWd
_h][dZ[jmWi
Wbb[_d[
jkd
atdd[&
eZ[h
eX
[i
c_j
A_b\[
WdZ[h[h
][iY^[^[d
cuii[(
Hkif[diao
iW]j[&
ZWii
E[kj[
ie\ehj
pk
Wh]k' c[dj_[h[d
X[]sdd[d&
m[dd
[h
_^d[d
iW][&
mWi
pk
jkd
i[_&
kdZ
d_Y^j
dkh
pk
Wh]kc[dj_[h[d&
iedZ[hd
i_[
muhZ[d
d[]Wj_l(
>h
iW]j[&
ZWi
i[_
_d
PW^h^[_j
Z[h
@hkdZ&
mWhkc
d_Y^j
][^eb\[d
m[hZ[d
atdd[&
kdZ
mWhkc
[i
dejm[dZ_]
i[_&
K[][bd
kdZ
][dWk[
:d\ehZ[hkd][d
pk
[hij[bb[d(
P[dd
[i
b[Z_]b_Y^
dejm[dZ_]
msh[&
E[kj[d
dkh
pk
p[_][d&
mWi
pk
jkd
_ij&
ZWdd
msh[
ZWi
[_d\WY^&
WX[h
[i
i[_
d_Y^j
_cc[h
[_d\WY^&
Z[d
AWkfjpk]
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
pk
[habsh[d#(
FWdY^cWb
_ij
[h
Z[kjb_Y^
i_Y^jXWh&
ZWdd
m_[Z[h
_ij
[h
l[hXeh][d[h
kdZ
iY^m_[h_][h
pk
i[^[d&
kdZ
pk
m_[Z[h
WdZ[h[d
S[_j[d
_ij
[i
dkh
ct]b_Y^
_d
[_d[h
Wbb][c[_d[d
:hj
uX[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
dWY^pkZ[da[d(
:X[h
[i
]WX
d_Y^j
[_d[d
[_dp_][d
?Wbb&
_d
Z[c
Z_[
E[kj[
d_Y^j
^[\j_]
pk
Wh]kc[dj_[h[d
X[]Wdd[d&
m[dd
_Y^
Z[d
AWkfjpk]
p[_]j[( ";[_
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
Mh[\\[d
iW]j[
`[cWdZ&
ZWii
[i
_^c
][b[' ][djb_Y^
][b_d][&
i_Y^
X[_c
:aj
Z[i
:Xms][di
eZ[h
i_Y^
BZ[dj_\_'
p_[h[di
pk
X[eXWY^j[d(
>h
\hW]j[&
eX
[h
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
i[_d[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
a[dd[db[hd[d
kdZ
i_[
ZkhY^
;[eXWY^j[d
iY^msY^[d
atdd[(
Hkif[diao
Wdjmehj[j[&
Z_[i
i[_
Z[h
[_dp_][
P[]
kdZ
i[^h
]kj&
iebWd][
cWd
[i
pk
l[hikY^[d
d_Y^j
cuZ[
muhZ[#(
Sk
;[]_dd
\Wd][d
l_[b[
E[kj[
i[^h
[_\h_]
Wd&
m[hZ[d
WX[h
iY^d[bb
cuZ[
kdZ
X[]_dd[d
ZWi
Pehj
yBY^z
kdj[hiY^_[Zibei
pk
l[hm[dZ[d&
e^d[
i_Y^
pk
\hW][d&
m[bY^[i
yBY^z&
m[bY^[h
M[_b
led
yBY^z(
Ndi[h
AWkfj\[_dZ
_ij
ZWi
Pehj
yBY^z&
m[_b
m_h
a[_d
K[Y^j
^WX[d&
[i
jWjisY^b_Y^
_d
][mt^db_Y^[d
L_jkWj_ed[d
pk
][XhWkY^[d(
O_[b
ifsj[h&
dWY^
bWd][h
:hX[_j&
atdd[d
m_h
Wd
[_d[
Z[h
@hkff[d
led
yBY^iz
pk
Z[da[d
X[]_dd[d
"m_[
`[d[&
Z_[
m_h
Lj[bbl[hjh[j[dZ[h
AWki^sbj[h
][dWddj
^WX[d#&
Z_[
i_Y^
Wki
Z[c
FW]d[j_iY^[d
S[djhkc
Wbi
yBY^z
[djm_Ya[bd(
:X[h
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^ )#

kdj[h
][mt^db_Y^[d
;[Z_d]kd][d
^0AF
cW]
d_Y^jz
iW][d
^th[d&
ZWdd
cuii[d
L_[
i_Y^
\hW][d&
m[bY^[i
B^h[h
yBY^iz
d_Y^j
cW](
:k\
Z_[i[
:hj
m[hZ[d
L_[
i_Y^
Wd
Z_[
O_[b^[_j
[h_dd[hd&
Z_[
_d
kdi
Wbb[d
_ij(
P[dd
L_[
[i
[_dcWb
l[h][ii[d&
m_hZ
[i
b[_Y^j[h
i[_d&
[i
WkY^
ZWi
dsY^ij[
FWb
pk
l[h][ii[d(
>i
]_Xj
l_[b[
]kj[
:d\sd][
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j&
kdZ
ZWdd
m_hZ
Z_[i
l[h][ii[d&
kdZ
Z_[
E[kj[
X[]_d' d[d
WXpk]b[_j[d&
kdZ
Wbb[i&
mWi
Wc
>dZ[
[_djh_jj&
_ij&
ZWii
i_[
c[Y^Wd_iY^[h
Wbi
pkleh
m[hZ[d( yDtdd[d
m_h
kdi[h[
F[hacWb[
d_Y^j
ZkhY^
;[eXWY^j[d
[dj' Z[Ya[d9z >i
_ij
i[^h
kdmW^hiY^[_db_Y^(
P_h
i_dZ
pk
ijWha
_d
_^d[d5
m_h
^WX[d
d_Y^j
][dk]
I[hif[aj_l[&
ie
ZWii
m_hab_Y^[
:hX[_j&
[hdij' ^W\j[
:hX[_j
dkh
lec
F[hacWb
Wki][^[d
aWdd(
BY^
c[_d[
d_Y^j&
ZWii
ZWi
\uh
`[Z[i
BdZ_l_Zkkc
WXiebkj
dejm[dZ_]
_ij&
Z[dd
[i
]_Xj
?sbb[&
_d
Z[d[d
Z_[
F[hacWb[
d_Y^j
X[ij_ccj
m[hZ[d
atdd[d(
=_[
;[ij_cckd]
cuiij[
ie
aecfb_p_[hj
i[_d&
ZWii
i_[
a[_d[d
fhWaj_iY^[d
P[hj
^sjj[(
Bd
ie
[_d[c
?Wbb
h[_Y^j
[i
Wki&
Z_[
Wbb][c[_d[
M[_bkd]
_d
yBY^z
kdZ
zHkif[diaoz
pk
d[^c[d(
Gkh
_ij
[i
dejm[dZ_]&
pk
[_d[c
OGAFQGECL
O[hijsdZd_i
Z[ii[d
pk
][bWd][d&
mWi
yBY^z
_ij
kdZ
mWi
yHkif[diaoz
_ij&
ZWi
^[_iij&
mWi
L_[
i_dZ
kdZ
mWi
Eu][
_ij(
>i
h[_Y^j
pkc
;[_if_[b
d_Y^j&
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
Z_[i[h
M[_bkd]
[_dpkhskc[d
kdZ
ZWdd
pk
iW][d&
ZWi&
mWi
L_[
ct][d&
i[_
yBY^z
kdZ
mWi
L_[
WXb[^d[d&
i[_
d_Y^j
yBY^z(
>i
_ij
bWd][
:hX[_j&
kdZ
Z_[
h_Y^j_][
M[_bkd]
aWdd
d_Y^j
ie\ehj
][\kdZ[d
m[hZ[d&
WX[h
[i
ckii
[_d_][
A_dm[_i[
][X[d&
Z_[
L_[
\uh
Z[d
;[]_dd
Z[i
P[][i
\_dZ[d
atdd[d(
G[^c[d
L_[
pkc
;[_if_[b
Wd&
L_[
\ehckb_[h[d
B^h
S_[b
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
Z_[i[h
:hX[_j&
_dZ[c
L_[
iW][d&
yBY^
ctY^j[
\h[_
i[_dz(
=Wi
_ij
[_d[
i[^h
]kj[
;[ij_cckd]&
WX[h
mWi
aeccj
ZWdWY^9
Sk[hij
cuii[d
L_[
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
L_[
d_Y^j
\h[_
i_dZ(
P[dd
L_[
l[hij[^[d&
_d
m[bY^[c
:kicWii
L_[
d_Y^j
\h[_
i_dZ&
kdZ
m[dd
L_[
B^h
O[hbWd][d&
\h[_
pk
i[_d&
\ehckb_[h[d&
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
_d
i_Y^
i[bXij
i[^[d&
m[bY^[h
M[_b
led
B^d[d
\h[_
i[_d
ctY^j[
kdZ
m[bY^[h
M[_b
d_Y^j( "C[cWdZ
\hW]j[&
eX
Z_[
MWjiWY^[&
[_d
F[hacWb
pk
i[^[d&
_d
i_Y^
i[bXij
Wkih[_Y^[&
kc
[i
pk
l[hc_dZ[hd&
kdZ
WkY^&
mWi
cWd
Wd
i[_d[
Lj[bb[
i[jp[d
atdd[(
Hkif[diao
iW]j[&
L[^[d
muhZ[
[i )$

d_Y^j
l[hc_dZ[hd&
[i
i[_
dejm[dZ_]&
ZW][][d
Wdpkascf\[d(
>h
\k^h
\ehj4#
>hij
iebbj[
cWd
l[hikY^[d&
[i
ZkhY^
Z_h[aj[d
DWcf\
pk
fhu\[d(
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
cWd
c[haj&
ZWii
cWd
pk
l_[b
Wh]k' c[dj_[hj&
ZWdd
ZWh\
cWd
d_Y^j
Wh]kc[dj_[h[d&
ZWi
_ij
Wbb[i(
PWhkc
[jmWi
Wd
i[_d[
Lj[bb[
i[jp[d9
>i
_ij
d_Y^j
dejm[dZ_]&
_h][dZ[jmWi
Wd
i[_d[
Lj[bb[
pk
i[jp[d
Wkii[h
LY^m[_][d( "C[cWdZ
ifhWY^
uX[h
[_d[
dkjpbei[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j&
Z_[
i_[
][deii&
eXme^b
i_[
mkiij[&
ZWii
i_[
dkjpbei
mWh(
Hkif[diao
iW]j[4#
Bd
iebY^
[_d[c
?Wbb
atdd[d
L_[
c_j
Z_[i[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
ascf\[d&
_dZ[c
L_[
WdZ[h[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j[d
ijsha[d&
Z_[
_^h
[dj][][dij[^[d(
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
L_[
^WX[d
[_d
X[ij_ccj[i
[dZ' ]ubj_][i
F[hacWb&
c_j
Z[c
L_[
ascf\[d
ctY^j[d&
kdZ
L_[
l[hikY^[d
[_d
WdZ[h[i&
c_j
_^c
kdl[h[_dXWh[i
F[hacWb
pk
\_d' Z[d&
ZWi
dujpb_Y^
i[_d
atddj[(
P[dd
L_[
_d
B^h[c
][][dmshj_][d
;[ijWdZ
d_Y^ji
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
LjWha[i
\_dZ[d&
Z[c
L_[
[i
[dj][][d' ij[bb[d
atdd[d&
ie
iY^Wk[d
L_[
_d
B^h
@[ZsY^jd_i(
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
L_[
\_dZ[d
[_d
F[hacWb&
ZWi
kdl[h[_dXWh
_ij
c_j
Z[c&
ZWi
L_[
beim[hZ[d
mebb[d
kdZ
ZWi
dujpb_Y^
i[_d
aWdd&
ZWdd
[hi[jp[d
L_[
[_d\WY^
ZWi
[_d[
ZkhY^
ZWi
WdZ[h[(
:X[h
[i
cW]
lehaecc[d&
ZWii
i_[
ie]Wh
ZWdd
X[_Z[
]buYab_Y^
pkiWcc[d
b[X[d(
=Wi
[_d[
cW]
Wc
:X[dZ
Wdm[i[dZ
i[_d&
ZWi
WdZ[h[
Wc
Feh][d&
kdZ
i_[
X[][]d[d
i_Y^
l_[bb[_Y^j
d_[( >i
]_Xj
dkh
[_d[
m_hab_Y^[
@[\W^h(
P[dd
cWd
\uh
[_d[
bWd][
S[_j
e^d[
Wkih[_Y^[dZ[
:dijh[d]kd][d
m[_j[hcWY^j
eZ[h
e^d[
[jmWi
[hdij^W\j
pk
jkd&
ZWdd
j[_bj
cWd
i_Y^&
WdijWjj
[_di
pk
m[hZ[d&
_d
pm[_&
ie
ZWii
Wbb[
F[hacWb[
kdZ
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j[d
_d
pm[_
@hkff[d
][j[_bj
m[hZ[d
'
led
Z[d[d
[_d
M[_b
Z[h
:hX[_j
dujpj&
Z_[
f[hitdb_Y^[
:hX[_j
\thZ[hj
iem_[
[_d[d
WdZ[h[d
[djm[' Z[h
]b[_Y^]ubj_][d
eZ[h
ie]Wh
\[_dZb_Y^[d
M[_b(
=Wi
_ij
[_d[
m_hab_Y^[
@[\W^h&
Z[dd
m[dd
pm[_
M[_b[
X[]_dd[d&
i_Y^
Z[hWhj
pk
X_bZ[d&
l[hZ_hXj
Z_[
@b[_Y^]ubj_]a[_j
Z[i
[_d[d
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
Z[h
:hX[_j
Z[i
WdZ[h[d(
=[cdWY^
ckii
cWd
i[^h
iY^d[bb
kdZ
i[^h
ijWha
ZW][][d
Wdascf\[d&
iedij
aWdd
[i
pk
Zeff[bj[h
Dh_ijWbb_iW' j_ed
aecc[d( yPWi
l[hij[^[d
L_[
kdj[h
Dh_ijWbb_i_[h[d9z P_h
X[dkjp[d
ZWi
Pehj
_d
[_d[c
X[iedZ[h[d
L_dd(
C[Z[i )%

F[hacWb
aWdd
ah_ijWbb_i_[hj
m[hZ[d&
][dWk
ie
m_[
Ik\\[h
ah_ijWbb_' i_[h[d(
=_[i[h
;[]h_\\
aWc
Wki
Z[h
j^[eief^_iY^[d
M[hc_debe' ]_[5
[h
_ij
cWdY^cWb
dujpb_Y^(
BY^
Z[da[&
`[Z[h
^_[h
^Wj
led
^t^[h[d
Dthf[hd
][^thj&
Z[c
WijhWb[d&
c[djWb[d
kdZ
aWkiWb[d(
=_[
BZ[[
_ij&
ZWii
Z[h
F[diY^
dkh
CGLCL
NFVPGPAFCL
Dthf[h
^Wj
kdZ
Z_[
>djm_Yabkd]
_d
Z[h
>djm_Yabkd]
F[FCOCO
Dthf[h
X[ij[^j(
Le
[djifh_Y^j
F[diY^
Gh(
/
Z[h
Dh_ijWbb_iWj_ed
Z[i
WijhWb[d
Dth' f[hi&
F[diY^
Gh(
0
Z[h
Dh_ijWbb_iWj_ed
Z[i
c[djWb[d
Dthf[hi
kdZ
F[diY^
Gh(
1
Z[h
Dh_ijWbb_iWj_ed
Z[i
aWkiWb[d
Dthf[hi( :X[h&
ZW
m_h
led
Z[h
Dh_ijWbb_iWj_ed
led
F[hacWb[d
ifh[Y^[d&
[_d[
I[hied
aWdd
i[^h
]kj[
kdZ
i[^h
iY^td[
F[hacWb[
^WX[d
kdZ
ZeY^
^_dj[h
Z_[i[d
[_d
ab[_d[i
F[hacWb
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
Wk\m[_i[d&
ZWi
Z_[
:hX[_j
\uh
i_[
i[^h
[hiY^m[hj&
l_[b' b[_Y^j
c[^h
[hiY^m[hj
Wbi
\uh
`[cWdZ
WdZ[h[d&
Z[h
iebY^
Xh_bb_Wdj[
F[hacWb[
d_Y^j
Wk\m[_ij( LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
aWdd
leh][X[d&
Wd
Z[h
:hX[_j
_dj[h[i' i_[hj
pk
i[_d&
aWdd
=_d][
\uh
i_Y^
X[WdifhkY^[d
kdZ
d[]Wj_l[i
kdZ
c[Y^Wd_iY^[i
:]_[h[d
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
eZ[h
[jmWi
q^d' b_Y^[i
d[dd[d(
:X[h
i_[
aWdd
a[_d[
dujpb_Y^[
:hX[_j
jkd5
i_[
aWdd
b[Z_]b_Y^
Z_[
;[cu^kd][d
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j[d
l[hZ[hX[d&
Z_[
:hX[_j
b[_ij[d
kdZ
>h][Xd_ii[
[hp_[b[d
atdd[d( Bc
E_Y^j
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
_ij
Z_[i
Loij[c
[_d
ltbb_]
WdZ[h[i5
[i
m_hZ
pk
[jmWi&
ZWi
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
ijshaj
kdZ
ZWi
mW^h[
Loij[c
\uh
L_[
iY^msY^j(
Bd
Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya&
_d
Z[c
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
ZWi
Loij[c
\uh
i_Y^
uX[hd_ccj&
\u]j
i_[
[_d
Pehj
^_[h
kdZ
Zehj
[_d
WdZ[h[i
Pehj
^_dpk(
L_[
atdd[d
i_Y^
d_Y^j
lehij[bb[d&
m_[
i[bjiWc
[_d_][
Z_[i[h
BZ[[d
ab_d][d&
m[dd
i_[
c_h
m_[Z[h
leh][jhW][d
m[hZ[d(
>_d
Wki
[_d[h
?ehckb_[hkd]
m[]][bWii[d[i
Pehj
[h]_Xj
[_d[d
ltbb_]
WdZ[h[d
@[ZWda[d5
kdZ
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
_ij
lebbWk\
[djiY^kbZ_]j
kdZ
aWdd
jkd&
mWi
i_[
mudiY^j
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h( yPsY^ij
kdi[h[
?s^_]a[_j
pkh
:hX[_j
][dWk
_d
Z[c
FWii&
m_[
m_h
_d
Z[h
EW][
i_dZ&
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
pk
iY^msY^[d9z :bb[i&
mWi
cWd
[hh[_Y^[d
aWdd&
aWdd
cWd
dkh
Wk\
Deij[d
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
[hbWd][d(
Lfsj[h&
m[dd
i_[
d_Y^j
][][dmsh' j_]
_ij&
aWdd
cWd
l_[b[i
Wk\
Deij[d
WdZ[h[h
=_d][
[hm[hX[d&
WX[h )&

\uh
[_d[
bWd][
S[_j
ckii
cWd
iepkiW][d
led
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitd'
b_Y^a[_j
b[X[d( yBij
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
Z_[
]heii[
LY^hWda[&
Z_[
kdi
lec
;[mkiiji[_d
jh[ddj9z
& Sk
Wbb[h[hij&
`W(
:X[h
ZWd[X[d
l_[b[
c[Y^Wd_iY^[
@[me^d^[_' j[d(
FWdY^cWb
ie]Wh
c[Y^Wd_iY^[
@[me^d^[_j[d
_d
WdZ[h[d
S[djh[d( yP[dd
cWd
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
X[i[_j_][d
atddj[
(((z
X[]Wdd
`[cWdZ( L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^ji
[dj\[hd[d5
[i
_ij
][dWk
ie&
Wbi
l[hikY^j[d
L_[&
i_Y^
B^h[d
Def\
WXpkiY^d[_Z[d(
:X[h
L_[
atdd[d
Z_[
LY^[_d' f[hitdb_Y^a[_j
m[d_][h
dWY^ZhuYab_Y^
kdZ
X[ijsdZ_]
cWY^[d(
P[dd
L_[
_d
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
:k][dXb_Ya
Z_[
@[\W^h
Z[h
FWd_\[ijWj_ed
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
\u^b[d
kdZ
L_[
[_d[d
P[]
\_dZ[d
atdd[d&
kc
i_[
pk
ijeff[d
'
^_[hc_j
cuii[d
L_[
X[]_dd[d(
=_[
?hW][
Z[i
;[i[_j_][di
jWkY^j
^_[h
uX[h^Wkfj
d_Y^j
Wk\5
i_[
ij[^j
c_j
ltbb_]
WdZ[h[d
=_d][d
_d
SkiWcc[d^Wd](
L_[
cuii[d
b[hd[d&
Z_[
>hiY^[_dkd]i\ehc[d
pk
X[^[hhiY^[d(
:X[h
m[dd
cWd
BCLIQ!
cWd
atdd[
[jmWi
jkd&
kdZ
i_Y^
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
m[_][hj&
Wc
>hm[hX
Z_[i[h
Dedjhebb[
pk
?O@CGQCL!
ZWdd
[djm_a'
a[bd
i_Y^
Z_[
=_d][
iY^b[Y^j(
FWd
aWdd
lebb[h
>dj^ki_Wicki
ZWhuX[h
i[_d&
mWi
cWd
jkd
iebb&
X_i
cWd
m[_ii&
mWi
cWd
pk
jkd
^Wj(
P[dd
cWd
[i
m[_ii&
m_hZ
cWd
i[^h
d[]Wj_l
kdZ
l[hikY^j&
[i
pk
l[hc[_Z[d
eZ[h
Wk\
[_d[
WdZ[h[
:hj
pk
[habsh[d(
=Wi
cuii[d
L_[
l[hij[^[d
'
ZWii
Z_[
9AFCGLNCOP[LJGAFICGQ
PGAF
PCJ@PQ
SCOQCG" BGEQ#
L_[
cuii[d
WkY^
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
L_[&
m_[
L_[
i_dZ&
Wk\
B^h[h
][][dmshj_][d
Ljk\[
d_Y^j
[_dcWb
Wd\Wd][d
atdd[d
pk
WhX[_j[d(
Sk[hij
cuii[d
L_[
ZWi
[_d[
eZ[h
WdZ[h[
sdZ[hd(
:X[h
L_[
atdd[d
dkh
Wk\]hkdZ
B^h[h
[_][d[d
;[eXWY^jkd][d
^[hWki\_d' Z[d&
mWi
L_[
pk
sdZ[hd
^WX[d&
kdZ
Z_[i
_ij
\uh
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
E[kj[
l[hiY^_[Z[d( @[b[][djb_Y^
m_hZ
[i
h[Y^j
abWh&
mWi
][sdZ[hj
m[hZ[d
ckii&
kdZ
ZWdd
X[]_ddj
Z[h
DWcf\&
m[_b
Z_[
9AFCGLNCOP[LJGAFICGQ
PGAF
WRO
=CFO
PCQWQ#
Mkd
L_[
_cc[h
[jmWi&
ZWi
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
d_Y^j
cW]&
kc
c_j
_^h
pk
ascf\[d&
kdZ
L_[
m[hZ[d
i[^h
XWbZ
^[hWki\_dZ[d&
mWi
i_[
d_Y^j
cW](
P[dd
L_[
\ehj\W^h[d&
m_hZ
i_[ )'

sh][hb_Y^[h
kdZ
sh][hb_Y^[h
m[hZ[d
kdZ
i_Y^
Z[kjb_Y^[h
kdZ
Z[kj' b_Y^[h
p[_][d&
ie
ZWii
i_[
XWbZ
Wkii[h
?hW][
ij[^[d
m_hZ(
:X[h
m[dd
L_[
d_Y^ji
jkd&
kc
Z[h
\WbiY^[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
>_d^Wbj
pk
][X_[j[d&
msY^ij
i_[(
L_[
aWdd
d_Y^j
led
i[bXij
WXd[^c[d(
Oeh' b_[X[d
atdd[d
i_Y^
sdZ[hd
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h&
WX[h
i_[
msY^ij(
Gkh
Z_[i[
>djm_Yabkd]
\_dZ[j
_c
c[Y^Wd_iY^[d
E[X[d
ijWjj
'
iedij
a[_d[(

EWii[d
L_[
kdi
uX[h
Z_[
;[p_[^kd]
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
pk
WdZ[h[d
M[_b[d
Z[i
F[diY^[d
ifh[Y^[d(
Bd
`[Z[c
F[diY^[d
iY^h[_j[j
Z_[
>djm_Yabkd]
_d
`[Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya
][csii
Z[ii[d
\ehj&
mWi
cWd
[_d[
ijWj_iY^[
Mh_WZ[
d[dd[d
atddj[(
=_[i[
Mh_WZ[
m_hZ
[_d[
ijWj_iY^[
Mh_WZ[
][dWddj&
m[_b
Dthf[h&
L[[b[
kdZ
>ii[dp
_cc[h
Wd
Z[hi[bX[d
Lj[bb[
Xb[_X[d
kdZ
Wbi
Z_[
d[kjhWb_i_[' h[dZ[
DhW\j
m_ha[d&
ms^h[dZ
Z_[
WdZ[h[d
Dhs\j[
i_Y^
dkh
i[^h
bWd]iWc
sdZ[hd(
=_[
][iWcj[
Mh_WZ[
Xb[_Xj
Z_[
]Wdp[
S[_j
uX[h
c[^h
eZ[h
m[d_][h
Wc
i[bX[d
IbWjp( =Wi
[hij[
=h[_[Ya
p[_]j
Z[d
SkijWdZ
Z[i
F[diY^[d
_c
][' mt^db_Y^[d
E[X[d5
ZWi
pm[_j[
p[_]j
i[_d[d
SkijWdZ&
m[dd
[h
i_Y^
pk
[djm_Ya[bd
X[]_ddj(
Sm_iY^[d
Z[c
SkijWdZ
Z[i
[hij[d
kdZ
Z[c
SkijWdZ
Z[i
pm[_j[d
=h[_[Yai
b_[][d
bWd][
S[_jhskc[&
kdZ
deY^
bsd][h[
pm_iY^[d
_^d[d
kdZ
Z[c
Zh_jj[d
=h[_[Ya(
MWjisY^' b_Y^
]_Xj
[i
l_[b[
Sm_iY^[dijWZ_[d&
WX[h
Z_[i[
Zh[_
h[_Y^[d
Wki&
kc
Z[d
P[]
Z[h
>djm_Yabkd]
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
pk
p[_][d( FWd
ckii
X[Z[da[d&
ZWii
a[_d[h
Z_[i[h
SkijsdZ[
f[hcWd[dj
_ij(
C[Z[h
SkijWdZ
cW]
kd][\s^h
[_d[
^WbX[
LjkdZ[
ZWk[hd&
kdZ
ZWdd
cW]
[_d
WdZ[h[h
SkijWdZ
aecc[d&
ZWdd
m_[Z[h
[_d
WdZ[' h[h
SkijWdZ(
=Wi
=_W]hWcc
p[_]j
b[Z_]b_Y^&
TGC
Z_[
>djm_Yabkd]
l[hbsk\j(
>i
msh[
ct]b_Y^&
ZWi
=_W]hWcc
uX[h
ZWi
f[hcWd[dj[
yBY^z
^_dWkipk\u^h[d&
m[_b
ZWi
f[hcWd[dj[
yBY^z
l_[b[
?ehc[d
^Wj( =_[
Mh_WZ[
m_hZ
ZkhY^
Z[d
Dthf[h&
Z_[
L[[b[
kdZ
Z_[
>ii[dp )(

Wc
:f[n
][X_bZ[j(
:c
pm[_j[d
Ikdaj
b_[]j
yBY^z5
ZWi
^[_iij&
Z_[
l_[b[d
yBY^iz&
Z_[
Z_[
I[hied
WkicWY^[d&
ZWi
X[Z[kj[j&
Wbb[
@[\u^b[
kdZ
>cf\_dZkd][d&
Z_[
d_Y^j
M[_b
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
i_dZ( =[h
Zh_jj[
Ikdaj
Z[i
=h[_[Yai
m_hZ
led
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
[_d][decc[d
"ZWi
^[_iij&
ZWi
[_d][X_bZ[j[
;_bZ
i[_d[h
i[bXij#( Bc
][mt^db_Y^[d
F[diY^[d
d[ddj
i_Y^
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
yBY^z&
WX[h
dWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
X[]_ddj
_d
[_d[c
F[diY^[d&
\Wbbi
[h
pkh
>djm_Yabkd]
\s^_]
_ij&
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
pk
mWY^i[d(
>h
cW]
[i
Wbi
yX[iedZ[h[
Bdj[h[ii[dz&
yBZ[Wb[z&
yBZ[' [dz
eZ[h
[jmWi
s^db_Y^[i
X[p[_Y^d[d(
:X[h
m[dd
[h
Z_[i
cW]d[' j_iY^[
S[djhkc
_d
i_Y^
pk
\u^b[d
X[]_ddj&
[djZ[Yaj
[h
[_d[d
][iedZ[hj[d
M[_b
_d
i_Y^&
kdZ
led
Z_[i[c
M[_b
][^j
i[_d
PWY^i[d
Wki(
=_[i[i
PWY^i[d
aWdd
dkh
Wk\
Deij[d
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
ijWjj\_dZ[d&
Z[dd
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
aWdd
d_Y^j
pkh
i[bX[d
S[_j
Wk\jh[j[d
m_[
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc( Dthf[h&
L[[b[&
>ii[dp

l_[b[
yBY^iz

LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j

Dthf[h&
L[[b[&
>ii[dp

cW]d[j_iY^[i
S[djhkc
Dthf[h&
L[[b[&
>ii[dp

LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j

f[hcWd[dj[i
yBY^z

l_[b[
yBY^iz

)*

P[dd
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
_d
[_d[c
F[diY^[d
][X_bZ[j
_ij&
aWdd
[h
[_d[h
LY^kb[
X[][]d[d&
kdZ
m[dd
[h
pk
WhX[_j[d
X[]_ddj&
ckii
[h
][][d
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
WhX[_j[d(
=Wi
^[_iij
d_Y^j&
ZWii
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
l[hiY^m_dZ[j5
[i
X[' Z[kj[j
b[Z_]b_Y^&
ZWii
i_[
d_Y^j
_cc[h
Wdm[i[dZ
_ij(
Sk
:d\Wd]
_ij
i_[
\Wij
_cc[h
Wdm[i[dZ&
WX[h
m[dd
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[d' jhkc
pk
mWY^i[d
X[]_ddj&
l[hiY^m_dZ[j
i_[&
cWdY^cWb
\uh
[_d[
^WbX[
LjkdZ[&
cWdY^cWb
ie]Wh
\uh
[_d[d
MW](
=Wdd
aeccj
i_[
pkhuYa
kdZ
Xb[_Xj
[_d[
PeY^[
bWd]
=W^[h
ckii
Wbb
kdi[h[
:hX[_j
][][d
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
][h_Y^j[j
i[_d( P[dd
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
\uh
[_d[
akhp[
S[_j
l[hiY^m_d' Z[j&
m_hZ
yBY^z
ijsha[h&
dkh
_ij
[i
d_Y^j
m_hab_Y^
yBY^z&
[i
kc\Wiij
l_[b[
yBY^iz(
C[
bsd][h
Z_[
S[_jhskc[
ZWk[hd&
_d
Z[d[d
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
l[hiY^m_dZ[j&
Z[ije
ijsha[h
m_hZ
ZWi
Wki
l_[b[d
yBY^iz
pkiWcc[d][i[jpj[
yBY^z(
=Wi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[d' jhkc
aWdd
_d
Z[d
Lj[bbl[hjh[j[dZ[d
AWki^sbj[h
kc][mWdZ[bj
m[hZ[d&
kdZ
m[dd
Z[h
Lj[bbl[hjh[j[dZ[
AWki^sbj[h
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
[hbWd]j&
ZWdd
Xh_d]j
[h
m_hab_Y^
Wbb[
kddtj_][d
=_d][
Wk\
Z_[
L[_j[
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
^_duX[h&
kdZ
dkh
Z_[
dujpb_Y^[d
=_d][
Xb[_X[d
Wk\
Z[h
L[_j[
Z[i
yBY^z(
Bd
[_d[c
deY^
ifsj[h[d
SkijWdZ
cW]
[i
ZWdd
i[_d&
ZWii
ZWi
f[hcWd[dj[
yBY^z
c_j
Wbb[c&
mWi
ZWpk
][^thj&
Wk\
Z_[
L[_j[
Z[i
yBY^z
jh_jj(
=Wdd
m[hZ[d
l_[b[
yBY^iz
Wk\
Z[h
L[_j[
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
i[_d&
WX[h
m_h
atdd[d
`[jpj
deY^
d_Y^j
l_[b
ZWhuX[h
iW][d(
>i
m_hZ
ZWi
f[hcWd[dj[
yBY^z
][X[d&
c_j
Wbb[c&
mWi
ZWpk
][^thj&
WX[h
m_h
m_ii[d
d_Y^j&
mWi
ZWpk
][^thj(
=Wi
f[hcWd[dj[
yBY^z
^Wj
ltbb_]
WdZ[h[
?kdaj_ed[d&
[_d
]Wdp
WdZ[' h[h
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Wbi
Wbb[i&
mWi
m_h
][me^dj
i_dZ( =_[
ijWj_iY^[
Mh_WZ[
p[_]j&
ZWii
[djm[Z[h
f[hitdb_Y^[
:hX[_j
eZ[h
=[][d[hWj_ed
_d
;[p_[^kd]
Wk\
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
FWd_\[ijWj_e' d[d
Z[h
\WbiY^[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
leh
i_Y^
][^j&
WX[h
ZWii
Dthf[h&
L[[b[
kdZ
>ii[dp
Z_[
]Wdp[
S[_j
]b[_Y^
Xb[_X[d(
GWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
m[hZ[d
WkY^
i_[
X[hu^hj&
WX[h
i_[
][^[d
d_Y^j
_d
Z_[
:d\Wd]ipk' ijsdZ[
[_d(
=[h
Dthf[h
m_hZ
Z[hi[bX[
Dthf[h
Xb[_X[d&
Z_[
>ii[dp
m_hZ
i_Y^
ifsj[h
mWdZ[bd&
WX[h
i_[
][^j
d_Y^j
_d
Z[d
;[]_dd
Z[h
:hX[_j
[_d(
@[csii
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
jh_jj
Z_[
>ii[dp
dkh
_diem[_j *!

_d
>hiY^[_dkd]&
Wbi
i_[
c_j
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
l[hc_iY^j
_ij(
P_h
X[^WdZ[bd
i_[
d_Y^j
][jh[ddj&
m[_b
m_h&
m_[
X[h[_ji
[hbskj[hj&
a[_d[
F_jj[b
^WX[d&
kc
][jh[ddj
led
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
Wd
Z[h
>ii[dp
pk
WhX[_j[d( yPWi
X[m_hajz&
\hW]j[
`[cWdZ&
yZWii
ZWi
mW^h[
6BY^8
i_Y^
pk
[djm_Ya[bd
kdZ
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
pk
iY^m_dZ[d
X[]_ddj9z >hij
[_dcWb
_ij
[i
[_d[
?hW][
Z[h
S[_j(
LW][d
m_h&
Z_[
LY^[_d' f[hitdb_Y^a[_j
_ij
_c
][mt^db_Y^[d
E[X[d
ms^h[dZ
Zh[_kdZpmWd' p_]
led
`[m[_bi
l_[hkdZpmWdp_]
LjkdZ[d
ZW&
ie
m_hZ
i_[
dkh
deY^
pm[_kdZpmWdp_]
LjkdZ[d
ZW
i[_d&
m[dd
Z_[
:hX[_j
X[]_ddj&
kdZ
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
m_hZ
[_d[
LjkdZ[
bsd][h
Wbi
uXb_Y^
Wdm[i[dZ
i[_d(
F_j
Z[h
S[_j
m_hZ
ZWdd
Z_[
][iWcj[
LY^[_df[h' itdb_Y^a[_j
WXd[^c[d
kdZ
m[d_][h
m_Y^j_]
m[hZ[d(
"=_[i
_ij
_c
pm[_j[d
SkijWdZ
Z[i
=_W]hWcci
][p[_]j&
_d
Z[c
Z_[
LY^[_df[h' itdb_Y^a[_j
fWii_l
kdZ
Z_[
l_[b[d
yBY^iz
kc
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
^[hkc
Waj_l
][mehZ[d
i_dZ(#
L_[
atdd[d
Z_[
LY^[_df[h' itdb_Y^a[_j
d_Y^j
_c
L_dd[
led
@heii[&
me^b
WX[h
_c
L_dd[
led
S[_j
l[hh_d][hd( C[cWdZ
WdZ[h[i
iW]j[&
yBY^
^Wjj[
X_i
`[jpj
Z[d
>_dZhkYa&
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
i[_
Z_[
:diWccbkd]
Wbb
Z[h
l_[b[d
6BY^i8(
=_[i[i
=_W]hWcc
^Wj
c_h
Z_[
=_d][
[_d
m[d_]
kdl[hijsdZb_Y^
][cWY^j(z Ndj[h
Z_[i[d
l_[b[d
yBY^iz
]_Xj
[i
l_[b[
fWii_l[
yBY^iz&
Z_[
Z[h
:d\Wd]
[_d[h
WdZ[h[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
i[_d
atdd[d(
=_[
LY^[_d' f[hitdb_Y^a[_j
aWdd
i_Y^
d_Y^j
[djm_Ya[bd5
i_[
_ij
ltbb_]
\WbiY^(
=[im[][d
iW]j[
_Y^&
ZWii
Wbb[
:hX[_j
][][d
Z_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
][h_Y^j[j
i[_d
ckii(
P[dd
cWd
a[_d[d
>h\eb]
^Wj&
b_[]j
ZWi
ZWhWd&
ZWii
cWd
Z[h
\WbiY^[d
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
d_Y^j
][dk]
:k\c[haiWca[_j
][iY^[daj
^Wj&
i_[
d_Y^j
ijkZ_[hj&
d_Y^j
][][d
i_[
][WhX[_j[j
^Wj(
=_[
\WbiY^[
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j
X[ij[^j
Wki
l_[b[d
yBY^iz&
kdZ
i_[
i_dZ
Wbb[
_cW]_dsh( yBY^
l[hij[^[
d_Y^j&
mWi
L_[
c_j
fWii_l[d
6BY^i8
c[_d[d(z yBY^iz&
Z_[
led
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d&
Waj_l[d
yBY^z
X[^[hhiY^j
m[hZ[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
m[hZ[d
]kj[
Oehisjp[
led
Z[h
?Wkb^[_j
X[^[hhiY^j(
?Wkb^[_j
_ij
Waj_l&
]kj[
Oehisjp[
i_dZ
fWii_l(
=Wi
yBY^z
eZ[h
Z_[
^[hhiY^[dZ[
O[hX_dZkd]
led
yBY^iz
_ij
Waj_l(
=_[ *"

yBY^iz&
Z_[
X[^[hhiY^j
eZ[h
][\u^hj
m[hZ[d&
i_dZ
fWii_l(
O[hij[' ^[d
L_[
[i
]Wdp
i_cf[b( =_[i[i
=_W]hWcc
ij[bbj
[_d[d
SkijWdZ
ZWh&
ZWdd
[_d[d
b[_Y^j
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
SkijWdZ
kdZ
deY^
[_d[d
WdZ[h[d
SkijWdZ(
F_j
A_b\[
Z_[i[i
=_W]hWcci
atdd[d
L_[
Zh[_
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
SkijsdZ[
Z[i
F[diY^[d
i[^[d&
Wd][\Wd][d
c_j
Z[c
[b[c[djWhij[d(
Bc
[b[c[djWhij[d
SkijWdZ
_ij
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
Waj_l&
kdZ
yBY^z
_ij
fWii_l(
Dthf[h&
L[[b[
kdZ
>ii[dp
Xb[_X[d
_cc[h
d[kjhW' b_i_[h[dZ(
P[dd
dWY^
l_[b[d
SkijsdZ[d
ZWi
f[hcWd[dj[
yBY^z
aeccj&
ZWdd
m_hZ
yBY^z
Waj_l&
l_[b[
yBY^iz
m[hZ[d
fWii_l&
kdZ
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
l[hiY^m_dZ[j(
O_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
=_W' ]hWcc[
atdd[d
pm_iY^[d
Z_[i[d
X[_Z[d
>njh[c[d
][p[_Y^d[j
m[hZ[d&
kdZ
deY^
ZWhuX[h
^_dWki
]_Xj
[i
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
Ft]b_Y^' a[_j[d( "Hkif[diao
mkhZ[
][\hW]j&
eX
[i
[_d[d
Hhj
_d
Z[h
ijWj_iY^[d
Mh_WZ[
]sX[&
Wd
Z[c
[_d[
@hkff[
led
c_j
Z[c
cW]d[j_iY^[d
S[djhkc
d_Y^j
l[hXkdZ[d[d
yBY^iz
Waj_l
kdZ
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
fWii_l
i[_(
>h
Wdjmehj[j[&
ZWii
[h&
Wbi
[h
iW]j[&
][m_ii[
@hkff[d
led
yBY^iz
eZ[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j[d
muhZ[d
Waj_l&
`[d[
c[_dj[&
Z_[
kc
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
p[djh_[hj
i_dZ(#
Sk[hij
ij[^[d
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
kdZ
ZWdd
`[d[
yBY^iz&
Z_[
i_Y^
kc
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
]hkff_[h[d&
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j
[dj][][d(
Bd
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
:k][dXb_Ya
m_hZ
ZWdd
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
Waj_l
kdZ
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
fWii_l(
=Wi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
_ij
[_d[
O[hX_dZkd]
led
][m_ii[d
@hkff[d
led
Bdj[h[ii[d(
=Wi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
\u^hj
L_[
d_Y^j&
Z[dd
?u^h[d
muhZ[
?ehjiY^h[_j[d
X[Z[kj[d&
kdZ
L_[
Xb[_' X[d
Wc
i[bX[d
Hhj(
:X[h
m[dd
Z_[
=_d][
[_djh[j[d&
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
c_j
A_b\[
Z[i
cW]d[j_iY^[d
S[djhkci
\s^_]
i[_d&
pk
i[^[d&
mWi
mWi
_ij&
eZ[h
eX
L_[
Wd
[_d[h
LWY^[
_dj[h[ii_[hj
i_dZ
eZ[h
d_Y^j(
L_[
atdd[d
[_d[
PW^b
jh[\\[d(
;[leh
cWd
pkh
:hX[_j
aeccj&
^Wj
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
[_d[d
X[ij_ccj[d
Ikdaj
[hh[_Y^j&
Z[h
[i
_d
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
@hkff[
led
Bdj[h[ii[d
l[h' mWdZ[bj(
P[dd
cWd
pkh
:hX[_j
aeccj&
\_dZ[j
[i
Bdj[h[ii[
Wd
Z[h
LY^kbWhX[_j
kdZ
l[hiY^m_dZ[j
ZWdd
Wbi
cW]d[j_iY^[i
S[djhkc&
Z[dd
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc
_ij
[_d[
iY^mWY^[
:d][b[][d^[_j( *#

=_[i[i
=_W]hWcc
iebb
ZWpk
Z_[d[d&
Z_[
:d\Wd]iijWZ_[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
pk
X[iY^h[_X[d&
kdZ
ZW^[h
^WX[
_Y^
i[^h
m[d_][
Z[h
O[hX_dZkd][d
^_d[_d][b[]j&
Z_[
][p[_]j
m[hZ[d
atddj[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
^WX[d
m_h
_c
[hij[d
=h[_[Ya
[_d[
Mh_WZ[&
Z_[
Wki
Dthf[h&
L[[b[
kdZ
>ii[dp
"7#&
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
"%#
kdZ
yBY^iz
"'#
pkiWcc[d][i[jpj
_ij(
P[dd
cWd
dkd
Wdd_ccj&
ZWii
Z_[i[
yBY^iz
X[h[_ji
_d
X[ij_ccj[
@hkff[d
kdj[hj[_bj
i_dZ&
ZWdd
_ij
[_d[
Z_[i[h
@hkff[d
ZWi
cW]d[j_iY^[
S[djhkc(
=Wdd
]_Xj
[i
WdZ[h[
@hkff[d&
Z[c
cW]d[j_iY^[d
S[djhkc
l_[bb[_Y^j
d_Y^j
Wd][iY^beii[d&
WX[h
_^c
Z[ddeY^
d_Y^j
\[_dZb_Y^&
Z_[
[n_ij_[h[d
kdZ
i_Y^
c_j
Z[h
S[_j
pk
[jmWi
;[ii[h[c
[djm_Ya[bd
atdd[d(
=_[
@hkff[d
led
yBY^iz&
Z_[
_cc[h
\[_dZb_Y^
kdZ
_cc[h
iY^sZb_Y^
i_dZ&
i_dZ
Z_[
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^a[_j
i[bXij( "C[cWdZ
\hW]j[&
eX
Z[h
PWdZ[b
led
[_d[h
?ehc
Z[h
Mh_WZ[
pk
[_d[h
WdZ[h[d
led
[_d[h
P[i[disdZ[hkd]
WX^sd][(# CW&
`[Z[
ab[_d[
qdZ[hkd]
_ij
[_d[
P[i[disdZ[hkd]&
eXiY^ed
Z_[i[h
:kiZhkYa
_c
Wbb][c[_d[d
Wk\
]htii[h[&
[hdij[h[
qdZ[hkd' ][d
Wd][mWdZj
m_hZ(
P[dd
m_h
led
P[i[disdZ[hkd]
h[Z[d&
ifh[Y^[d
m_h
pkc
;[_if_[b
lec
PWdZ[b
Z[h
F[diY^[d
Gh(
b&
,
kdZ
-
pk
F[diY^
Gh(
.(
=_[i
_ij
P[i[disdZ[hkd]&
WX[h
dWjuhb_Y^
X[ij[^j
Z_[i[h
]heii[
Lfhkd]
Wki
l_[b[d
ab[_d[d
Lfhud][d(
=_[
ijWj_iY^[
Mh_WZ[
ij[bbj
L_[
ZWh(
L_[
p[_]j
Z[d
>RPQ?LB
B^h[i
P[i[di&
mWi
L_[
_d
[_d[c
][][X[d[d
:k][dXb_Ya
i_dZ(
>_d[h
Z_[i[h
Ikdaj[&
Dthf[h
kdZ
>ii[dp&
Xb[_Xj
_cc[h
Z[hi[bX[&
WX[h
Z_[
;[p_[^kd]
Z[h
WdZ[h[d
pm[_
Ikdaj[
sdZ[hj
i_Y^(
P[dd
Dthf[h
kdZ
>ii[dp
dehcWb
i_dZ&
i_dZ
i_[
kdfWhj[__iY^
kdZ
[h]h[_' \[d
d_Y^j
Z_[
[_d[
eZ[h
Z_[
WdZ[h[
IWhj[_&
WX[h
m[dd
[jmWi
c_j
_^d[d
d_Y^j
ij_ccj&
ij[^[d
i_[
Wk\
Z[h
L[_j[
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitdb_Y^' a[_j(

P[dd
L_[
_d
[_d[c
SkijWdZ
Z[i
Sm[_\[bi
i_dZ&
Z[da[d
L_[
ZWhWd&
[i
pk
l[hikY^[d&
kdZ
Xh_d][d
L_[
WdZ[h[
yBY^iz
Wk\&
Z_[
[_d[
][m_ii[
P[hjiY^sjpkd]
^WX[d(
=_[i
_ij
Z_[
[_dp_][
:hj&
Sm[_\[b *$

pk
X[pm_d][d(
Nc
i_Y^
pk
[djm_Ya[bd&
cuii[d
L_[
[_d[
X[ij_cc' j[
?s^_]a[_j
pkh
P[hjiY^sjpkd]
^WX[d(
=[h
[_dp_]
fhWaj_iY^[
Sk]Wd]
X[ij[^j
ZWh_d&
Wd
B^h[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
L[_j[d
pk
Z[da[d
kdZ
ZWX[_
Z_[
L[_j[d&
Z_[
WhX[_j[d
atdd[d&
kdZ
`[d[&
Z_[
ZWi
d_Y^j
atdd[d&
pk
[djZ[Ya[d(
>_d_][
E[kj[
^WX[d
m_hab_Y^[
P[h' j[&
[_d_][
^WX[d
\WbiY^[
P[hj[&
kdZ
[_d_][
^WX[d
uX[h^Wkfj
a[_d[
P[hj[(
F_j
Z[d
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
yBY^iz
_ij
[i
ZWii[bX[5
[_d_][
iY^sjp[d
mW^h[
=_d][&
WdZ[h[
?WbiY^[i&
kdZ
WdZ[h[
iY^sjp[d
d_Y^ji( FWd
aWdd
i[_d
E[X[d
ZWc_j
l[hXh_d][d&
Loij[c[
kdZ
Loij[c' X[]h_\\[
pk
ijkZ_[h[d
kdZ
d_[cWbi
pk
mW^h[d
=_d][d
pk
][bWd][d(
=h[_l_[hj[b
eZ[h
G[kdp[^dj[b
kdi[h[i
][mt^db_Y^[d
P_ii[di
[n_ij_[hj
d_Y^j
m_hab_Y^5
[i
X[ij[^j
dkh
_d
Z[h
>_dX_bZkd]( >ha[dd[d
Z[i
LY^bW\i
_ij
ZWi
[_dp_]
PW^h[(
FWd
ckii
P[][
[djZ[Ya[d&
m_[
cWd
[hmWY^[d
aWdd&
WX[h
pkleh
ckii
cWd
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
cWd
iY^bs\j(
O[h]b[_Y^[d
L_[
LY^bW\
kdZ
PWY^[d(
:bb[
BZ[[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
X[]_dd[d
c_j
Z[h
BZ[[
Z[i
LY^bW\i
kdZ
Z[h
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
Z[i
>hmWY^[di(
:bb[
WdZ[h[d
BZ[[d
'
BZ[[d
Wki
Z[c
E[X[d
'
ct][d
][_ijh[_Y^
eZ[h
ZkhY^ZWY^j
i[_d&
WX[h
i_[
Wbb[
i_dZ
BZ[[d
led
iY^bW\[dZ[d
F[diY^[d&
^[hleh][XhWY^j
\uh
WdZ[h[
iY^bW\[dZ[
F[diY^[d(
LY^bW\
_ij
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
l_[b[h
=_d' ][4
M[_bkd]
Z[h
I[hitdb_Y^a[_j[d&
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
yBY^iz&
P_Z[h' ifhuY^[
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
:X[h
ZWi
[hij[
kdZ
m_Y^j_]ij[
led
Wbb[c&
]Wdp
h[_d
e^d[
_h][dZm[bY^[
M^[eh_[&
_ij
ZWi
,OICLLCL
BCP
9AFJ?DP#

*%

/ECAIPEGGA

,GLC
>RP?KKCLPQCJJRLE
SML
XRPPCORLECL
6RPNCLPIVP!
F?RNQPZAFJGAF
\@CO
BGC
5MQTCLBGEICGQ
CGLCO
;LQCOTCODRLE
BCP
,GECLTGJJCLP
?JP
i
mkhZ[
[X[d\Wbbi
ZWhWk\
][WY^j[j&
Z_[
:Xi_Y^j
Z[h
:djmehj[d
d_Y^j
ZkhY^
uX[hjh_[X[d[i
Duhp[d
Z[i
Dedj[nji&
Z[c
i_[
[djdecc[d
i_dZ&
pk
X[[_djhsY^j_][d(
:ki
Z_[i[c
@hkdZ
m[hZ[d
[_d_][
Z[h
AWkfj][ZWda[d
uX[h
Z[d
DWcf\
c_j
Z[c
>_][dm_bb[d
_c
M[nj
c[^hcWbi
c_j
X[_dW^[
Z[di[bX[d
Pehj[d
m_[Z[h^ebj( ,GECLTGJJC
_ij
\uh
F[diY^[d
X[ij_ccj&
Z_[
c_j
Z[c
Loij[c&
ZWi
Hkif[diao
b[^hj[&
kdZ
i[_d[h
X[iedZ[h[d
M[hc_debe]_[
l[h' jhWkj
i_dZ(
Loij[c
kdZ
LfhWY^[
X[iY^h[_Xj
I(
=(
Hkif[diao
_d i
aWdd
dkh
[jmWi
[hh[_Y^j
m[hZ[d&
m[dd
cWd
[_d[
f[h\[aj[h[
F[j^eZ[
Wdm[dZ[j(
=_[
[hij[
;[Z_d]kd]
_ij
O[hij[' ^[d(
=[h
][iWcj[
K[ij
[djifh_Y^j
Z[c
O[hij[^[d(
>i
ckii
WkY^
:dijh[d]kd][d
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
@[\u^b[d
kdZ
P_bb[d
][X[d(
FWd
ckii
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
][][d
i_Y^
Wdpk][^[d&
kc
i[_d[d
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[d( Sk[hij
cuii[d
L_[
i_Y^
\hW][d4
PWi
_ij
P_bb[9
P_h
^WX[d
a[_d[d
P_bb[d&
m_[
iebb[d
m_h
Wbie
Wk\][X[d&
mWi
m_h
d_Y^j
^WX[d9
=_[i
X[Z[kj[j&
ZWii
L_[
d_[
pkij_cc[d&
a[_d[d
P_bb[d
pk
^WX[d5
L_[
ij_cc[d
dkh
_d
Pehj[d
pk(
Sm[_j[di
^WX[d
m_h
d_Y^j
_cc[h
P_bb[d&
iedZ[hd
dkh
p[_jm[_i[(
P_bb[
X[Z[kj[j
[_d
ijWha[i
O[hbWd][d(
H^d[
[_d
ijWha[i
O[hbWd][d
]_Xj
[i
d_Y^ji
Wk\pk][' X[d5
[i
]_Xj
a[_d[d
P_bb[d(
Bd
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
:k][dXb_Ya
^WX[d
m_h
[_d
ijWha[i
O[hbWd][d&
ZWi
][][d
Z_[
:hX[_j
][h_Y^j[j
_ij&
kdZ
m[dd
m_h
[i
ijeff[d&
^[_iij
ZWi&
ZWii
m_h
P_bb[d
Wk\][X[d(
P_h
atdd[d
P_bb[d
d_Y^j
_d
`[Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya
Wk\][X[d
iedZ[hd
dkh
_d
X[iedZ[h[d
Fec[dj[d(
NdZ
mWi
^[_iij
y][][d
Z_[
:hX[_j
][h_Y^j[jz9
>i
^[_iij&
][][d
K[][bd
kdZ
Ih_dp_f_[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
][h_Y^j[j
i[_d
eZ[h
][][d
[jmWi&
ZWi
cWd
L_[
f[hitdb_Y^
pk
jkd
eZ[h
d_Y^j
pk
jkd
Wk\][\ehZ[hj
^Wj(
>i
]_Xj
X[ij_ccj[
][d[h[bb[
K[][bd
kdZ
Ih_dp_f_[d&
kdZ
[i
aWdd
f[hitdb_Y^[
;[Z_d]kd][d
\uh
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
E[kj[
][X[d( -O?EC#
Lebbj[
cWd
kc
m[_j[h[
f[hitdb_Y^[
:dm[_ikd][d
\hW][d9 6RPNCLPIV#
CW&
WX[h
m[dd
cWd
\hW]j&
ckii
cWd
][^ehY^[d(
FWd
_ij
d_Y^j
l[hf\b_Y^j[j&
_h][dZ[jmWi
pk
jkd&
m[dd
cWd
d_Y^j
\hW]j&
Wbie
ckii
cWd
[i
i_Y^
pm[_cWb
uX[hb[][d&
X[leh
cWd
\hW]j( -O?EC#
P[dd
cWd
X[h[_j
_ij
pk
][^ehY^[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
:dm[_' ikd][d
][X[d9 6RPNCLPIV#
P[dd
i_Y^
Z_[
@[b[][d^[_j
X_[j[j(
>i
ckii
_d
[_d[c
:k][dXb_Ya
][iY^[^[d&
m[dd
L_[
P_bb[d
^WX[d(
>i
ckii
[_d
[djiY^_[Z[d[i
O[hbWd][d
ZW
i[_d&
[jmWi
pk
jkd&
ZWi
Z_[
:hX[_j
eZ[h
WdZ[h[
E[kj[
X[hu^hj(
@[mt^db_Y^
^WX[d
m_h
iY^b[Y^j[d
P_bb[d(
P_h
^WX[d
i[^h
i[bj[d
]kj[d
P_bb[d(
P[dd
L_[ **

]kj[d
P_bb[d
^WX[d&
ifh[Y^[
_Y^
d_Y^j
ZWhuX[h5
_Y^
iW][
[_d\WY^&
cWY^[d
L_[
m[_j[h&
\W^h[d
L_[
\ehj&
b[hd[d
L_[( A_[h
i_dZ
l_[b[
=_d][
c_j[_dWdZ[h
l[hc_iY^j(
L_[
m_ii[d
d_Y^j&
m_[
L_[
uX[h
P_bb[d
Z[da[d
iebb[d(
F_j
[_d[h
B^h[h
L[_j[d
[ha[d' d[d
L_[&
ZWii
L_[
FWiY^_d[d
i_dZ&
WX[h
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
mebb[d
L_[
][csii
B^h[h
[_][d[d
F[_dkd]
^WdZ[bd(
Bd
Z_[i[c
:k][dXb_Ya
cuii[d
L_[
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
pk
ijeff[d5
d_Y^j
pk
jkd&
mWi
L_[
mebb[d(
=_[i
]_bj
d_Y^j
\uh
:k][dXb_Ya[&
_d
Z[d[d
L_[
d_Y^j
X[WXi_Y^j_][d&
_h][dZ[jmWi
pk
jkd&
WX[h
L_[
cuii[d
\s^_]
i[_d
pk
ijeff[d&
m[dd
B^h
PkdiY^
][][d
K[][bd
eZ[h
Ih_dp_f_[d
][^j&
eZ[h
][][d
ZWi&
mWi
B^d[d
][iW]j
mkhZ[( >i
_ij
m_Y^j_]&
pm[_[hb[_
pk
[ha[dd[d4
=Wii
m_h
d_Y^j
6jkd8
atdd[d
kdZ
ZWii
m_h
kdj[h
Z[c
@[i[jp
Z[i
Sk\Wbbi
b[X[d(
Bd
Z[d
c[_ij[d
?sbb[d
Z[da[d
Z_[
E[kj[&
jkd
pk
atdd[d&
ZWii
i_[
X[' aecc[d
atdd[d&
mWi
i_[
mebb[d&
kdZ
ZWii
[i
dkh
pk\sbb_]
d_Y^j
][b_d]j(
=_[
E[kj[
]bWkX[d&
ZWii
Sk\Wbb
i[^h
i[bj[d
kdZ
ZWi
c[_ij[
Wk\
NhiWY^[
kdZ
P_hakd]
pkhuYapk\u^h[d
_ij(
=Wi
_ij
ltbb_]
\WbiY^(
>i
_ij
dejm[dZ_]&
Wk\
Z_[
h_Y^j_][
:hj
Z[da[d
pk
b[hd[d&
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
m_h
i[^[d&
ZWii
Wbb[i
ECPAFGCFQ!
kdZ
ZWii
m_h
kdj[h
Z[c
@[i[jp
Z[i
Sk\Wbbi
b[X[d( Bd
X[pk]
Wk\
6Mkd8
_ij
[i
\uh
kdi
iY^m[h
pk
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
[i
pkc
;[_if_[b
d_Y^j
jkd
_ij&
m[dd
E[kj[
[_d[
;huYa[
XWk[d5
[i
_ij
dkh
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
Wbb[h
leh^[h][]Wd][d[d
:dijh[d]kd][d(
>i
_ij
pk\sbb_](
Nc
Z_[i
pk
l[hij[^[d&
cuii[d
L_[
Wd
Z_[
[hij[
;huYa[
Z[da[d&
Z_[
:ZWc
XWkj[&
kdZ
Wd
Z_[
][iWcj[
>lebkj_ed
Z[h
;huYa[d(
Sk[hij
_ij
[i
pk\sbb_]
'
[_d
;Wkc
\sbbj
gk[h
uX[h
[_d[d
?bkii&
ZWdd
XWkj
Z[h
F[diY^
[jmWi
s^db_Y^[i
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
=_[ E[kj[
6jkd8
d_Y^j5
[_d[i
\eb]j
Wki
Z[c
WdZ[h[d( P[dd
L_[
i_Y^
[h_dd[hd&
ZWii
L_[
LGAFQP
QRL
atdd[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
i_Y^
l_[b[h
WdZ[h[h
=_d][
[h_dd[hd(
@[mt^db_Y^
]_Xj
[i
Zh[_
eZ[h
l_[h
AWkfjijebf[hij[_d[&
kdZ
m[dd
L_[
d_Y^j
uX[h
Z[d
[_d[d
\Wbb[d&
\Wbb[d
L_[
uX[h
Z[d
WdZ[h[d(
Sk
6jkd8
_ij
[_d[h
led
_^d[d(
Bd
O[hX_dZkd]
^_[hc_j
]_Xj
[i
[_d_][
]hkdZb[][dZ[
Ih_dp_f_[d&
Z_[
L_[
d_[cWbi
l[h][ii[d
Zuh\[d(
=Wii
L_[
pkc
;[_if_[b
Wk\
i_Y^
i[bXij
iY^Wk[d
cuii[d
kdZ
d_Y^j
Wk\
WdZ[h[
E[kj[5
ZWii
E[kj[
d_Y^ji
Wki
i_Y^
i[bXij
jkd
atdd[d&
iedZ[hd
ZWii
'
m[dd
[i "!!

ct]b_Y^
_ij&
i_Y^
pk
sdZ[hd
'
[i
dkh
c_j
Z[h
A_b\[
Z[i
Loij[ci&
Z[h
Hh]Wd_iWj_ed&
f[hitdb_Y^[h
:hX[_j
kdZ
[_d[i
LjkZ_kci
Z[i
Loij[ci
ct]b_Y^
_ij(
L_[
cuii[d
Z[hWhj_][
=_d][
[djZ[Ya[d
kdZ
i_Y^
_^h[h
[h_dd[hd( -O?EC#
P_[
aWdd
cWd
i_Y^[h
i[_d&
ZWii
cWd
i_Y^
_^h[h
[h_d' d[hj9 6RPNCLPIV#
Lj[bb[d
L_[
i_Y^
leh&
m_[
L_[
c_j
Z[h
:Xi_Y^j
[jmWi
pk
jkd&
pk
fbWd[d
X[]_dd[d(
Gkh
m[dd
L_[
[jmWi
Wk\
[_d[
?LBCOC
:hj&
Wbi
[i
][mt^db_Y^
ECPAFGCFQ!
m_hab_Y^
pk
jkd
l[hikY^[d&
[ha[dd[d
L_[&
ZWii
[i
?@PMJRQ
RLK[EJGAF
GPQ!
?LBCOP
WR
F?LBCJL#
=_[
Asb\j[
Z[h
][ij[bbj[d
?hW][d
X[p_[^j
i_Y^
Wk\
6jkd8
'
m_[
cWd
Z_[i
sdZ[hd&
ZWi
p[hijth[d&
`[d[i
l[hc[_Z[d
aWdd
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
:X[h
[i
X[ZWh\
[_d[h
][mWbj_][d
:dijh[d]kd]&
kc
WkY^
dkh
[_d[
Db[_d_]a[_j
pk
sdZ[hd(
;[leh
L_[
[i
d_Y^j
l[hikY^[d&
atdd[d
L_[
[i
uX[h^Wkfj
d_Y^j
[ha[dd[d(
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^ji
sdZ[hd&
Wkii[h
ZkhY^
ZWi
Loij[c(
=Wi
m_hZ
][mt^db_Y^
l[h][ii[d( :bb[i
][iY^_[^j(
FWd
aWdd
d_Y^ji
jkd(
Oec
:k][dXb_Ya
kdi[' h[h
@[Xkhj
X_i
pkh
S[_j&
ZW
m_h
ij[hX[d&
][iY^[^[d
=_d][&
][iY^[^[d&
][iY^[^[d&
kdZ
m_h
]bWkX[d
pk
6jkd8(
=_[i
_ij
kdi[h
][mt^db_Y^[h&
dehcWb[h
SkijWdZ
_c
E[X[d&
kdZ
WkY^
dkh
Z_[
ab[_dij[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j&
[jmWi
pk
6jkd8&
aeccj
Wbb[_d
ZkhY^
Z_[
:hX[_j
kdZ
pk[hij
dkh
_d
kdi
i[bXij&
d_Y^j
skii[hb_Y^(
Le]Wh
_d
kdi
i[bXij
X[]_ddj
6jkd8
i[^h
e\j
c_j
LGAFQ
jkd(
;[leh
L_[
[jmWi
jkd
atdd[d&
ZWi
L_[
d_Y^j
jkd
aeddj[d&
cuii[d
L_[
l_[b[
=_d][
LGAFQ
QRL!
Z_[
L_[
pkleh
jWj[d( -O?EC#
AWj
cWd
cWdY^cWb
[_d[
PW^b
pm_iY^[d
pm[_
ct]b_' Y^[d
>h[_]d_ii[d9 6RPNCLPIV#
Gkh
_d
i[^h
ab[_d[d
=_d][d&
kdZ
ie]Wh
ZWdd&
m[dd
L_[
c[ha[d&
ZWii
Z_[
=_d][
Wk\
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:hj
bWk\[d
kdZ
i_Y^
[djiY^b_[ii[d&
i_[
pk
sdZ[hd&
m[hZ[d
L_[
[djZ[Ya[d&
m_[
iY^h[Yab_Y^
kdX[gk[c
[i
_ij&
=_d][
pk
sdZ[hd(
Le
a[^h[d
L_[
pk
Z[di[bX[d
=_d][d
pkhuYa( -O?EC#
P[dd
cWd
m_hab_Y^
pk
l[hij[^[d
X[]_ddj&
ZWii
cWd
d_Y^j
6jkd8
aWdd&
m_hZ
cWd
[_d[
]heii[
F[d][
Fkj
X[dtj_][d(
P_hZ
[h
ZWhWki
[djij[^[d&
ZWii
cWd
i_Y^
led
Z[h
LY^[_df[hitd' b_Y^a[_j
X[\h[_j9 "!"

6RPNCLPIV#
Sk
Z_[i[c
O[hij[^[d
][bWd]j
cWd
d_Y^j
ie
[_d' \WY^(
>i
aeccj
dWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wd
i_Y^
i[bXij&
ie
ZWii
cWd&
m[dd
cWd
pk
Z_[i[h
>ha[ddjd_i
][bWd]j&
Wkii[hZ[c
l_[b[
WdZ[h[
>ha[ddjd_ii[
^Wj5
_d
Z[h
AWkfjiWY^[&
ZWii
[i
P[][
]_Xj&
i_Y^
pk
sdZ[hd&
m[dd
cWd
ZWi
h_Y^j_][
Bdijhkc[dj
Wc
h_Y^j_][d
Hhj
kdZ
pkh
h_Y^j_][d
S[_j
Wdm[dZ[j(
FWd
ckii
Z_[i[
Bdijhkc[dj[
^WX[d&
kdZ
i_[
m[hZ[d
m_[Z[hkc
dkh
ZkhY^
Z_[
:hX[_j
][][X[d(
>i
_ij
PCFO
m_Y^j_]&
pk
Z_[i[h
>ha[ddjd_i
pk
][bWd][d(
H^d[
i_[
m_hZ
cWd
d_Y^j
Z_[
h_Y^j_][d
=_d][
jkd5
cWd
m_hZ
i_Y^
i[bXij
[djiY^kbZ_][d( -O?EC#
BY^
l[hij[^[
d_Y^j&
mWhkc
cWd
i_Y^
[djiY^kbZ_][d
iebbj[( 6RPNCLPIV#
FWd
ctY^j[
Z_[
Oehij[bbkd]
d_Y^j
Wk\][X[d&
6jkd8
pk
atdd[d&
ie
ZWii
cWd&
ie]Wh
m[dd
cWd
[ha[ddj&
ZWii
Z_[
=_d][
[_d\WY^
][iY^[^[d&
>djiY^kbZ_]kd][d
\_dZ[j&
m_[&
y=Wi
_ij
([_d
Sk\Wbb&
WX[h
ceh][d
m_hZ
[i
WdZ[hi
i[_dz(
=[i^WbX
atdd[d
m_h
Z_[i[
BZ[[
d_Y^j
kci[jp[d(
Ndi[h
]Wdp[i
E[X[d
i[^[d
m_h&
m_[
=_d][
][iY^[^[d&
WX[h
m_h
[habsh[d
i_[
m[_j[h^_d
Wbi
Sk\sbb[&
Wbi
:kidW^c[d
Z[h
K[][b&
ZWii
m_h
6jkd8
atdd[d(
>djm[Z[h
l[h][ii[d
m_h
[i
eZ[h
i[^[d
[i
d_Y^j
eZ[h
i_dZ
d_Y^j
Wk\c[haiWc
][dk](
P_h
]bWkX[d
_cc[h&
ZWii
m_h
`[Z[d
:k][dXb_Ya
pk
6jkd8
X[]_dd[d
atdd[d(
Le
Z[da[d
m_h
][mt^db_Y^
ZWhuX[h(
P[dd
L_[
_d
B^h[c
E[X[d
[_d[
S[_j
mW^hd[^c[d&
_d
Z[h
L_[
[jmWi
pk
jkd
l[hikY^j[d
kdZ
[i
c_iibWd]&
ie
m_hZ
ZWi
[_d
;[_if_[b
i[_d&
Z[dd
L_[
m[hZ[d
[djZ[Ya[d&
ZWii
L_[
B^h[d
?[^biY^bW]
Wbi
[_d[d
Sk\Wbb&
[_d[
:kidW^c[
[habsh[d(
P[dd
=_d][
i_Y^
m_[Z[h^eb[d&
Z[da[d
L_[
m_[Z[h&
L_[
m[hZ[d
pk
6jkd8
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
kdZ
m[dd
L_[
Z_[i
m_[Z[h
i[^[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
B^h[d
?[^biY^bW]
m_[Z[hkc
Wbi
dkh
pk\sbb_]
[habsh[d(
>i
_ij
i[^h
dujpb_Y^&
B^h
E[X[d
kdj[h
Z_[i[c
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
ZkhY^pk][^[d(
L_[
X[WXi_Y^j_][d
[_d[
LWY^[&
kdZ
[jmWi
WdZ[h[i
][iY^W^(
P[dd
L_[
m_hab_Y^
[hdij^W\j
i_dZ&
m[hZ[d
L_[
i[^[d5
m[dd
Z[c
d_Y^j
ie
_ij&
m[hZ[d
L_[
i_Y^
i[bXij
uX[hh[' Z[d&
ZWii
ZWi&
mWi
][iY^W^&
][dWk
ZWi
mWh&
mWi
L_[
mebbj[d 6RPNCLPIV#
L_[
cuii[d
c_j
[_d[h
aedah[j[d
BZ[[
X[]_dd[d(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
^[hWkipk\_dZ[d&
mWi
L_[
m_hab_Y^
ZWled
WX^sbj&
_d "!#

Z[h
:hX[_j
Waj_l
pk
i[_d(
>i
_ij
dejm[dZ_]&
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
Waj_l
pk
i[_d5
cWd
aWdd
d_Y^ji
[hh[_Y^[d&
m[dd
cWd
fWii_l
_ij( =Wdd
l[h][ii[d
m_h
Z[d
:d\Wd]&
me
kdZ
mWhkc
m_h
X[]Wdd[d&
kdZ
Z_[
c[_ij[
S[_j
Z[da[d
m_h
d_Y^j
[_dcWb
Wd
ZWi
>GCJ!
iedZ[hd
dkh
Wd
ab[_d[
>_dp[b^[_j[d(
D[_d[
>_dp[b^[_j[d
i_dZ
e^d[
ZWi
S_[b
led
_h][dZm[bY^[c
Gkjp[d(
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
_ij
dkjpbei
e^d[
>h_dd[hd
Z[h
S_[b[
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
kdZ
Z[i
khifhud]b_Y^[d&
]hkdZb[' ][dZ[d
S_[bi(
P[dd
Z_[i[
S_[b[
d_Y^j
[cej_edWb
[h_dd[hj
m[hZ[d&
atdd[d
CW^h[
l[h][^[d&
kdZ
cWd
m_hZ
_c
i[bX[d
SkijWdZ
Xb[_X[d(
>i
h[_Y^j
d_Y^j
Wki&
Z[d
O[hijWdZ
pk
[hp_[^[d5
[i
_ij
dejm[dZ_]&
Z[d
P_bb[d
pk
[hp_[^[d(
L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
mWi
kdi[h
P_bb[
_ij(
Oed
S[_j
pk
S[_j
^WX[d
m_h
P_bb[d(
P_bb[
_ij
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
led
O[hbWd][d(
Bd
Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya&
_d
Z[c
m_h
[_d
ijWha[i
O[hbWd][d
^WX[d&
]_Xj
[i
P_bb[d(
Bd
Z_[i[c
:k][dXb_Ya
cuii[d
m_h
kdi[h[d
P_bb[d
ijkZ_[h[d
kdZ
i[^[d&
mWi
][jWd
m[hZ[d
aWdd(
P_h
^WX[d
a[_d[d
P_bb[d&
iedZ[hd
>_][dm_bb[d
kdZ
>_][di_dd(
P[dd
cWd
ZWi
l[hij[^j&
ckii
cWd
ckj_]
][dk]
i[_d&
i[_d[d
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][' X[d&
Wk\
ZWi
pk
WY^j[d&
mWi
][iW]j
mkhZ[(
L_[
cuii[d
dWY^
Z_[i[d
:k][dXb_Ya[d
:kiiY^Wk
^Wbj[d
kdZ
Zuh\[d
i_[
d_Y^j
l[hiskc[d(
BY^
c[_d[
d_Y^j&
i_[
audijb_Y^
pk
[hp[k][d&
eXme^b
_d
[_d[c
AWki
"ZWi
][csii
:hX[_jifh_dp_f_[d
eh]Wd_i_[hj
_ij#
X[ij_ccj[
Ft]b_Y^' a[_j[d
][][X[d
i_dZ&
kc
i[_d[d
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[d&
ie
ZWii
L_[&
m[dd
L_[
B^h[d
P_bb[d
Wk\][X[d&
ifsj[h
B^h[d
[_][d[d
P_bb[d
^WX[d
atdd[d(
:X[h
ie]Wh
E[kj[&
Z_[
d_Y^j
_d
Z[c
AWki
i_dZ&
atdd[d
i_Y^&
m[dd
i_[
i_Y^
X[eXWY^j[d
kdZ
ieh]\sbj_]
i_dZ&
_d
iebY^[d
:k][dXb_Ya[d
uX[hhWiY^[d
kdZ
i_Y^
\hW][d&
mWi
i_[
jkd
iebb[d(
C[Z[h
ckii
^[hWki\_dZ[d&
m_[
i[_d[
[_][d[
L_jkWj_ed
X[iY^W\\[d
_ij( -O?EC#
P_[
iebbj[d
m_h
uX[h
kdi[h[
Nd\s^_]a[_j
pk
6jkd8
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
O[hWdjmehjb_Y^a[_j
Z[da[d9 6RPNCLPIV#
>i
m[hZ[d
_^d[d
X[ij_ccj[&
][dWk
kch_ii[d[
:k\]WX[d
][][X[d&
=_d][&
Z_[
pk
jkd
i_dZ(
P[dd
L_[
b[hd[d&
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd&
ie]Wh
dkh
[_d
m[d_]&
m[hZ[d
L_[
[djZ[a'
a[d&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Wbb[i
WdZ[h[
_d
[_d[h
X[ii[h[d
:ki]Wd]ibW][
X[\_dZ[d( -O?EC#
Lj[bbj
ZWi
Loij[c
deY^
_h][dZ[_d[
WdZ[h[
M^[i[
uX[h "!$

Z_[
P_bb[diahW\j
Wk\
Wkii[h
Z[h&
ZWii
i_[
ZkhY^
:dm[dZ[d
msY^ij
kdZ
ZkhY^
G_Y^j][XhWkY^
ZW^_diY^m_dZ[j9 6RPNCLPIV#
=Wi
Loij[c
[habshj&
ZWii
L_[
l_[b[
yBY^iz
^WX[d
kdZ
ZWii
`[Z[i
i[_d[d
[_][d[d
P_bb[d
^Wj(
P[dd
L_[&
WdijWjj
l_[b[
pk
i[_d&
[_di
m[hZ[d&
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
CGLCL
P_bb[d
^WX[d(
P_bb[
_d
Z[d
][mt^db_Y^[d
F[diY^[d
Gh(
b&
,
kdZ
-
_ij
dkh
ZWi
>h][X' d_i
led
PudiY^[d(
@[m_ii[
m_Z[hijh[_j[dZ[
PudiY^[&
eZ[h
O[h' aduf\kd][d
led
PudiY^[d
bWii[d
L_[
Wk\
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:hj
W]_[h[d(
=Wi
_ij
Wbb[i( -O?EC#
Bij
ZWi
X[eXWY^j[dZ[
yBY^z
Z[h
D[_c
Z[i
I[hcWd[dj[d
yBY^z9 6RPNCLPIV#
=Wi
X[eXWY^j[dZ[
yBY^z
_ij
Z[h
D[_c
Z[i
I[hcWd[dj[d
yBY^z&
WX[h
[i
^Wj
a[_d[d
m_hab_Y^[d
P_bb[d(
L[_d
P_bb[
_ij
Z[c
>_][dm_bb[d
d_Y^j
[dj][][d][i[jpj(
PWi
aWdd
Z[c
>_][dm_bb[d
[dj][][dij[^[d9
>i
]_Xj
dkh
pm[_
[dj][][d][i[jpj[
=_d][4
:hX[_j
kdZ
>_][dm_bb[(
>_][dm_bb[
mudiY^j
pkc
;[_if_[b
pk
iY^mWjp[d&
kdZ
[i
]_Xj
[_d[
K[][b
][][d
@[iY^msjp(
=WhWki
\eb]j
[_d
DWcf\&
kdZ
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
^sd]j
ZWled
WX&
m[h
led
X[_Z[d
][m_ddj( -O?EC#
:dijh[d]kd][d
pk
cWY^[d
_ij&
mWi
L_[
DWcf\
d[dd[d&
WX[h
d[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
cWd
_ij
i_Y^
a[_d[i
DWcf\[i
X[mkiij9 6RPNCLPIV#
=Wi
X[Z[kj[j&
ZWii
[h
][iY^W^(
=_d][
atdd[d
kdi
Wk\
l_[h
:hj[d
][iY^[^[d
'
ZkhY^
Sk\Wbb&
ZkhY^
NhiWY^[
kdZ
P_hakd]&
ZkhY^
LY^_YaiWb
kdZ
ZkhY^
P_bb[d(
DWcf\
ckii
m_b' b[djb_Y^&
WXi_Y^jb_Y^
ijWjj\_dZ[d(
NdZ
L_[
cuii[d
i_Y^
B^h[h
:X' i_Y^j
][mW^h
i[_d(
L_[
atdd[d
a[_d[
:dijh[d]kd]
cWY^[d
kdZ
Z[ii[d
d_Y^j
][mW^h
i[_d(
P_bb[
msh[&
m[dd
L_[
[jmWi
mebbj[d
kdZ
i_Y^
[djiY^btii[d
kdZ
^WdZ[bj[d
kdZ
[hh[_Y^j[d&
mWi
L_[
mudiY^j[d(
@[dWk
ZWi
_ij
m_Y^j_]( -O?EC#
BY^
]bWkX[&
_Y^
^thj[
iW][d&
ZWii
[_d
F[diY^
l[hij[^[d
m_hZ&
m_[
@hkff[d
led
yBY^iz
[_dWdZ[h
^[b\[d&
m[dd
[h
@hkf' f[d
led
yBY^iz
ijkZ_[hj( 6RPNCLPIV#
PWi
_d
Z_[i[c
?Wbb
m_Y^j_]
_ij&
_ij
m_bb[djb_Y^[i
AWdZ[bd(
Sk
;[]_dd
mkhZ[d
kdi
dkh
Zh[_
=_d][
][dWddj
'
P_bb[&
LY^_YaiWb
kdZ
Sk\Wbb(
=Wdd
aWc[d
m_h
pk
Z[c
LY^bkii&
ZWii
[i
[_d[
l_[hj[
DWj[]eh_[
][X[d
ckii&
Z_[
Z[c
DWhcW "!%

[djifh_Y^j(
:X[h
ZW
Z_[i[i
Pehj
l_[b[
\WbiY^[
:iiep_Wj_ed[d
Wki
Z[h
M^[eief^_[
[hmehX[d
^Wj&
l[hmWdZj[d
m_h
Z_[
;[]h_\\[
NhiW' Y^[
kdZ
P_hakd]
kdZ
c[_dj[d
ZWc_j
[jmWi&
ZWi
_d
Z_[i[c
E[X[d ][iY^_[^j
kdZ
i_Y^
dkh
Wk\
[_d[d
i[bXij
X[p_[^j&
Z[dd
led
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Wki
X[hk^j
Z_[
]Wdp[
P[bj
Wk\
NhiWY^[
kdZ
P_hakd]( -O?EC#
Bd
Z_[i[d
l_[h
DWj[]eh_[d
m_hZ
P_bb[
d_Y^j
e\j
l[h' mWdZj&
d_Y^j
mW^h9 6RPNCLPIV#
P_bb[
ckii
Wd][mWdZj
m[hZ[d(
P_h
i_dZ
d_[cWbi pkh
:hX[_j
X[h[_j&
WX[h
m_h
cuii[d
jhejpZ[c
WhX[_j[d(
P[dd
m_h
X[h[_j
i_dZ&
ZWdd
m_hZ
kdi
WdZ[h[
:hX[_j
][][X[d&
\uh
Z_[
m_h
d_Y^j
X[h[_j
i_dZ( -O?EC#
P[dd
cWd
i[_d
LY^_YaiWb
a[ddj&
m_[
aWdd
cWd
[_d[
E_d_[
[_d^Wbj[d&
kc
Sk\sbb[
pk
l[hc[_Z[d9 6RPNCLPIV#
BY^
m[_ii
d_Y^j&
mWi
L_[
c_j
6ZWi
LY^_YaiWb
a[dd[d8
c[_d[d(
>i
^Wj
d_Y^ji
c_j
Sk\sbb[
l[hc[_Z[d
pk
jkd(
FWd
l[h' c[_Z[j
Sk\sbb[
"_d
kdi[h[c
X[iedZ[h[d
L_dd#&
_dZ[c
cWd
NhiW' Y^[d
[hp[k]j
kdZ
P_hakd][d
l[hc[^hj(
=Wi
_ij
:dds^[hkd]
Wd
Z[d
P_bb[d(
>i
_ij
d_Y^j
P_bb[&
WX[h
:dds^[hkd]
ZWhWd(
Gkh
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:dpW^b
led
=_d][d
aWdd
_d
[_d[h
LjkdZ[
eZ[h
Wd
[_d[c
MW]
][iY^[^[d5
m[dd
cWd
ZW^[h
c[^h
NhiWY^[d
[hp[k]j&
Xb[_Xj
m[d_][h
KWkc
\uh
Sk\sbb[( P_h
atdd[d
LY^_YaiWb
dkh
_d
X[pk]
Wk\kdi[h[d
athf[hb_Y^[d
Sk' ijWdZ&
kdi[h[
@[ikdZ^[_j
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h
d[^c[d(
LY^_YaiWb
^Wj
d_Y^ji
c_j
>hhkd][diY^W\j[d
pk
jkd(
NhiWY^[
kdZ
P_hakd]
i[jp[d
Z[d
:d\Wd](
:X[h
NhiWY^[
kdZ
P_hakd]
_ij&
m[dd
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
Wk\
kdi[h[c
[_][d[d
AWdZ[bd
X[hk^j&
WX[h
d_Y^j
Wk\
lehX[ZWY^j[c
AWdZ[bd(
Bd
Z[h
:hX[_j
cuii[d
m_h
l[hikY^[d&
P_bb[d
Wdpkm[dZ[d
'
ie
l_[b&
m_[
m_h
^WX[d(
P[dd
cWd
[_d[d
Sebb
P_bb[d
^Wj
kdZ
_^d
][XhWkY^j&
ZWdd
m_hZ
cWd
pm[_
Sebb
^WX[d&
ZWdd
Zh[_
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h( -O?EC#
P_[
aWdd
_Y^
b[hd[d&
_c
E[X[d
WdZ[hi
pk
^WdZ[bd&
kc
Z_[i[bX[d
X[]h[dpj[d
kdZ
i_Y^
m_[Z[h^eb[dZ[d
@[\u^b[
pk
l[h' c[_Z[d&
Z_[
_Y^
dkd
\u^b[9 6RPNCLPIV#
=Wi
_ij
kdi[h
S_[b5
ZWi
_ij
ZWi
S_[b
Z[h
]Wdp[d
:hX[_j(
=Wi
_ij
Z[h
@hkdZ&
mWhkc
Z_[
:hX[_j
eh]Wd_i_[hj
mkhZ[&
mWhkc
m_h
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
M^[eh_[d
ijkZ_[h[d&
kdi
l[hiY^_[Z[d[h "!&

K[][bd
[h_dd[hd
cuii[d
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
L_[
ifh[Y^[d
led
[_d[c
m[_j
[dj\[hdj[d
S_[b(
Sk[hij
cuii[d
m_h
_c
Loij[c
WhX[_j[d(
BdZ[c
m_h
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
Z[c
Loij[c
kdZ
Z[h
Hh]Wd_iWj_ed
^WdZ[bd
b[hd[d&
b[hd[d
m_h
_c
E[X[d
^WdZ[bd5
WX[h
m_h
atdd[d
d_Y^j
b[hd[d&
_c
E[X[d
pk
^WdZ[bd&
e^d[
pk[hij
ZkhY^
ZWi
Loij[c
pk
][^[d( -O?EC#
P[dd
m_h
]Wdp
LY^msY^[
kdZ
e^d[
Ljsha[
i_dZ&
Wki
m[bY^[h
Jk[bb[
p_[^[d
m_h
ZWdd
[_d[
Z[hWhj_][
DhW\j&
m_[
m_h
i_[
Wbb[_d
iY^ed
^WX[d
cuii[d&
kc
Z_[
:hX[_j
Wd
kdi
pk
X[]_dd[d9 6RPNCLPIV#
P_h
cuii[d
[_d[
][m_ii[
Ljsha[
^WX[d(
P[dd
m_h
dkh
iY^mWY^
i_dZ&
atdd[d
m_h
d_Y^ji
jkd(
:X[hm[dd
m_h
uX[h^Wkfj
a[_d[
DhW\j
^sjj[d&
muhZ[d
m_h
kdi
d_Y^j
\uh
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
_dj[h[ii_[' h[d(
P[dd
m_h
kdi[h[
L_jkWj_ed
[ha[dd[d&
^WX[d
m_h
X[h[_ji
[_d[
][m_ii[
Ljsha[&
kdZ
d[k[i
P_ii[d
l[hc[^hj
Z_[i[
Ljsha[(
:bie
^WX[d
m_h
\uh
Z[d
:d\Wd]
ltbb_]
Wkih[_Y^[dZ[
DhW\j(
Lfsj[h
aeccj
c[^h
DhW\j
Wki
d[k[c
P_ii[d
kdZ
d[k[d
:dijh[d]kd][d
^_dpk( 6RPNCLPIV#
Le\[hd
E[kj[
d_Y^j
led
:d\Wd]
Wd
Wkih[_Y^[dZ[
:dijh[d]kd][d
cWY^[d&
m_hZ
ZWi
Loij[c
\uh
i_[
dkjpbei
i[_d(
:dijh[d]kd][d
cuii[d
eh]Wd_i_[hj
i[_d(
PWi
^[_iij
ZWi9
P[dd
L_[
kdi[h[
:hX[_j
d_Y^j
l[hij[^[d&
m[hZ[d
m_h
d_Y^j
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
B^d[d
pk
^[b\[d(
P_h
atdd[d
B^d[d
dkh
^[b\[d&
m[dd
L_[
kdi[h[h
:hX[_j
X[_jh[j[d(
L_[
cuii[d
Wd
Zh[_
@[X_[j[d
WhX[_j[d(
;[leh
cWd
l[hij[^[d
aWdd&
mWi
Z_[i
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Z_[
(O@CGQ
X[Z[kj[j&
ckii
cWd
Zh[_
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
:hX[_ji][X_[j[
_d
PGAF
PCJ@PQ
l[hij[^[d4
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[
:hX[_j
">hm[hX
led
P_ii[d#&
[cej_edWb[
:hX[_j
":hX[_j
Wd
@[\u^b[d#
kdZ
:hX[_j
Wc
P_bb[d
":hX[_j
Wd
kdi[h[c
AWdZ[bd#(
FWd
^Wj
a[_d[d
ie
]heii[d
P_bb[d
m_[
F[diY^
Gh(
1&
WX[h
cWd
^Wj
_d
X[ij_ccj[d
:k][dXb_Ya[d
P_bb[d(
P_bb[
_ij
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
led
PudiY^[d(
P_bb[
aWdd
_d
:k][dXb_Ya[d
][i[^[d
m[hZ[d&
ZW
[_d
ijWha[h
PkdiY^&
[jmWi
pk
jkd
eZ[h
d_Y^j
pk
jkd&
ZW
_ij(
Gkh
Z_[i[
:k][dXb_Ya[
i_dZ
m_Y^j_](
=Wi
Loij[c
aWdd
dkh
Z[d[d
^[b\[d&
Z_[
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
i_[
_^h[d
P_bb[d
d_Y^j
X[^[hhiY^[d
atdd[d(
=Wdd
m_hZ
_^d[d
ZWi
Loij[c
[djm[Z[h
^[b\[d&
_^h[d
P_bb[d
pk
X[^[hhiY^[d&
eZ[h
i_[
cuii[d
jkd&
m_[
_^d[d
][iW]j
mkhZ[( -O?EC#
@_Xj
[i
d_Y^j
ie
[jmWi
m_[
ZWi
>hpm_d][d
[_d[h
L_jkW' j_ed9 "!'

6RPNCLPIV#
>i
cW]
ie
Wkii[^[d&
WX[h
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
][iY^W^
[i(
P[dd
[i
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
d_Y^j
][iY^[^[d
aeddj[&
ZWdd
aeddj[
[i
d_Y^j
][iY^[^[d(
P[dd
=_d][
Wk\
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:hj
fWii_[' h[d&
m[hZ[d
m_h
lec
Ljhec
][jhW][d&
m_h
WX[h
]bWkX[d&
Z[d
Ljhec
pk
X[^[hhiY^[d( -O?EC#
P[dd
cWd
[_d[d
:k][dXb_Ya
bWd]
\u^bj&
ZWii
cWd
_d
Z[h
EW][
_ij&
pk
6jkd8&
iW][d
m_h&
[_d[
X[iedZ[h[
;[iY^s\j_]kd]
_dd[h^WbX
Z[h
][mt^db_Y^[d
:hX[_j
ZkhY^pk\u^h[d&
m_[
bWkj[j
^_[hpk
Z_[
>habshkd]9 6RPNCLPIV#
P[dd
cWd
Wki][X_bZ[j
m_hZ&
[jmWi
pk
jkd&
b[hdj
cWd&
[_d[h
X[ij_ccj[d
:hj
led
@[iY^[^d_ii[d
pk
\eb][d&
eZ[h
m[dd
L_[
mebb[d&
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:hj
led
@[iY^[^d_ii[d
_d
@Wd]
pk
i[jp[d&
kdZ
ZWdd
[djm_Ya[bd
i_Y^
Z_[i[
kdZ
cWd
h[ddj
^_dj[h' ^[h&
eXme^b
cWd
i_Y^
[_dX_bZ[j&
i_[
pk
\u^h[d( -O?EC#
P[dd
cWd
Z_[
h_Y^j_][
AWbjkd]
^Wj
((( 6RPNCLPIV#
G[_d&
AWbjkd]
^Wj
ZWc_j
d_Y^ji
pk
jkd(
=_[
AWb' jkd]
cW]
h_Y^j_]
i[_d
kdZ
ZWi
O[hij[^[d
cW]
h_Y^j_]
i[_d&
WX[h
L_[
c[ha[d
m[_j[h^_d&
ZWii
Z_[
=_d][
Wk\
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:hj
][iY^[^[d(
C[]b_Y^[
][mt^db_Y^[
LWY^[(
>i
_ij
i[^h
dujpb_Y^&
m[dd
cWd
i_Y^
Z[h
?sbb[
pk
[h_dd[hd
l[hikY^j&
_d
Z[d[d
cWd
l[hikY^j
^Wj&
[jmWi
WdZ[hi
pk
jkd&
kc
ZWdd
pk
i[^[d&
m_[
cWd
ij[ji
pkh
i[bX[d
LWY^[
pkhuYaaeccj&
ie]Wh
ZWdd&
m[dd
[_d[
b[_Y^j[
:Xm[_Y^kd]
][bWd]&
jh[_X[d
kdi
][mWbj_][
Dhs\j[
_d
Z_[
Wbj[d
@[b[_i[
pkhuYa( -O?EC#
:bi
L_[
iW]j[d&
m_h
atddj[d
d_Y^ji
ZWhWd
sdZ[hd&
ZWii
Z_[i[bX[d
=_d][
][iY^[^[d&
c[_dj[d
L_[&
X_i
kdi[h
L[_d
][mWd' Z[bj
_ij9 6RPNCLPIV#
BY^
ifhWY^
d_Y^j
led
:hX[_j(
BY^
iW]j[&
[i
i[_
dejm[dZ_]
pk
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
m_h
?RP
RLP
PCJ@PQ
d_Y^j
6jkd8
atdd[d(
P[dd
L_[
ZWi
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
l[hijWdZ[d
^WX[d&
atdd[d
L_[
ZWhuX[h
dWY^Z[da[d&
mWi
pk
jkd
ct]b_Y^
_ij4
m[bY^[
;[Z_d' ]kd][d&
m[bY^[i
P_ii[d
kdZ
m[bY^[
A_b\[
X[dtj_]j
m[hZ[d(
:X[h
pk[hij
_ij
[i
dejm[dZ_]
pk
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
L_[&
m[dd
L_[
_c
][mt^db_Y^[d
E[X[d
[jmWi
WdZ[hi
pk
cWY^[d
l[hikY^[d&
c[h' a[d&
ZWii
L_[
[i
d_Y^j
atdd[d(
>hij
m[dd
Z_[i
][\u^bicsii_]
l[hijWdZ[d
_ij&
m_hZ
[i
ct]b_Y^&
m[_j[h
pk
][^[d( "!(

-O?EC#
P[dd
m_h
FWiY^_d[d
i_dZ&
m_[
atdd[d
m_h
kdi[h
P[i[d
sdZ[hd9 6RPNCLPIV#
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
mWhj[d&
X_i
L_[
i_Y^
sdZ[hd(
>i
]_Xj
[_d
i[^h
m_Y^j_][i
Ih_dp_f
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
'
L_[
iebbj[d
d_[
B^h[d
Dhs\j[d
[djifh[Y^[dZ
WhX[_j[d&
iedZ[hd
_cc[h
uX[h
B^h[
Dhs\j[
^_dWki(
=Wi
_ij
[_d
f[hcWd[dj[i
Ih_dp_f(
Bd
Z[h
:hX[_j
cuii[d
L_[
_cc[h
c[^h
jkd&
Wbi
L_[
atdd[d(
Gkh
ZWdd
atdd[d
L_[
i_Y^
sdZ[hd(
P[dd
L_[
dkh
ZWi
jkd&
mWi
ct]b_Y^
_ij&
m[hZ[d
L_[
Xb[_X[d&
me
L_[
i_dZ(
FWd
ckii
ZWi
Ndct]b_Y^[
jkd(
L_[
Zuh\[d
ZWi
Pehj
6kdct]b_Y^8
d_Y^j
pk
^eY^
[_diY^sjp[d&
WkY^
[_d
X_iiY^[d
X[Z[kj[j
l_[b(
L_[
cuii[d
c[^h
jkd&
Wbi
L_[
atdd[d&
eZ[h
L_[
m[hZ[d
i_Y^
d_[cWbi
sdZ[hd(
A_[h
kdj[hiY^[_Z[j
[i
i_Y^
lec
E[X[d
'
_c
E[X[d
jkd
L_[
dkh&
mWi
ct]b_Y^
_ij( -O?EC#
BY^
ctY^j[
[_d[d
P[]
\_dZ[d&
kc
[_d[d
>djiY^bkii
pk
:hX[_j[d
pk
jh[\\[d&
led
Z[c
_Y^
d_Y^j
WXjh[j[d
aWdd( 6RPNCLPIV#
=Wi
_ij
[_d[
kdi[h[h
]htiij[d
Bbbki_ed[d&
ZWii
m_h
>djiY^buii[
\Wii[d
atdd[d(
Nc
>djiY^buii[
pk
\Wii[d&
_ij
[i
dejm[dZ_]
pk
PCGL!
Z[dd
ie&
m_[
m_h
i_dZ&
jh_\\j
[_d
ab[_d[i
yBY^z
>djiY^[_Zkd][d
kdZ
led
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
yBY^z&
ZWi
d_Y^ji
ZWled
m[_ii&
m_hZ
[hmWhj[j&
ZWii
[i
i_[
ZWdd
Wki\u^hj(
=_[i
_ij
[_d[h
Z[h
[hij[d
Ikdaj[&
Z_[
m_h
[ha[dd[d
cuii[d&
ZWii
m_h&
ie
m_[
m_h
i_dZ&
d_Y^j
[_dcWb
_d
Db[_d_]a[_j[d
>djiY^[_Zkd][d
jh[\\[d
atd' d[d
'
Z_[
=_d][
][iY^[^[d
[_d\WY^(
:X[h
m[dd
L_[
Z_[i
h_Y^j_]
l[hij[^[d&
m[dd
L_[
dWY^
Z[d
NhiWY^[d
WkipkiY^Wk[d
X[]_dd[d
kdZ
m[dd
L_[
Z_[i[
NhiWY^[d
\_dZ[d&
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
\s^_]
i[_d
pk
WhX[_j[d&
kdZ
l_[bb[_Y^j
m[hZ[d
L_[
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
>dj' iY^buii[
pk
\Wii[d&
WX[h
\uh
[_d[
bWd][
S[_j
dkh
_d
X[pk]
pkh
:hX[_j&
pk
d_Y^ji
WdZ[h[c( =Wi
[hij[&
mepk
L_[
i_Y^
[djiY^b_[ii[d
cuii[d&
_ij&
B^h[
[_][d[
:hX[_j
pk
jkd
kdZ
pmWh
h[][bcsii_]&
i_Y^
Wd
i_[
pk
[h_dd[hd&
i_[
d_Y^j
[djiY^buf\[d
pk
bWii[d(
P_h
l[h][ii[d
pk
b[_Y^j(
P_h
[dj' iY^b_[ii[d
kdi
pk
:dijh[d]kd][d
'
X[ij_ccj[
:hj[d
led
:d' ijh[d]kd][d
kdZ
X[ij_ccj[
:hj[d
led
;[eXWY^jkd][d
'&
kdZ
ZWdd
kdj[hXh[Y^[d
]Wdp
][mt^db_Y^[
=_d][&
][mt^db_Y^[
HajW' l[d
Wbb[i&
kdZ
m_h
l[h][ii[d
[i
]Wdp(
P_[Z[h
[h_dd[hd
m_h
kdi
kdZ
m_[Z[hkc
l[h][ii[d
m_h
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
P_h
cuii[d
m[d_][h "!)

l[h][ii[d
kdZ
c[^h
[h_dd[hd(
>i
_ij
dejm[dZ_]&
X[ij_ccj[
>h' a[ddjd_ii[&
X[ij_ccj[
=_d][&
Z_[
L_[
X[h[_ji
[haWddj
kdZ
l[h' ijWdZ[d
^WX[d&
_cc[h
][][dmshj_]
pk
^WX[d(
L_[
cuii[d
l[hik' Y^[d&
i_[
d_Y^j
pk
l[h][ii[d( =_[
AWkfjiY^m_[h_]a[_j
b_[]j
ZWh_d&
T?P
cWd
jkd
iebb
kdZ
TGC
cWd
i_Y^
ZWpk
Xh_d]j&
[i
pk
jkd(
Sk
h[][bcsii_][c
=[da[d
pk
][bWd][d&
pk
h[][bcsii_][h
:hX[_j
'
ZWhWk\
aeccj
[i
Wd(
Gkh
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
i[^[d
X[]_dd[d&
ZWi
^[_iij
i[^[d&
mWi
m_Y^j_][h
kdZ
mWi
m[d_][h
m_Y^j_]
_ij&
mehWk\
pk
WY^j[d
_ij
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
PWi
][iY^_[^j
iedij9
L_[
[djiY^b_[ii[d
i_Y^
pk
WhX[_j[d&
[jmWi
pk
jkd&
[jmWi
pk
sdZ[hd
'
kdZ
ZWdd
Xb[_X[d
L_[
[_d\WY^&
me
L_[
mWh[d(
O[hikY^[d
L_[&
uX[h
B^h[
:hX[_j
dWY^pk' Z[da[d&
mWi
L_[
pk
jkd
l[hikY^[d&
mWhkc
L_[
[i
pk
jkd
l[hik' Y^[d&
mWi
B^d[d
ZWX[_
^_b\j
kdZ
mWi
L_[
X[^_dZ[hj&
ieme^b
led
_dd[d
Wbi
led
Wkii[d(
>i
aWdd
[X[d\Wbbi
dujpb_Y^
i[_d&
uX[h
skii[h[
>h[_]d_ii[
dWY^pkZ[da[d&
Z[dd
i_[
p[_][d
B^d[d&
m_[
l_[b
Wk\
Z[h
MWjiWY^[
X[hk^j&
ZWii
Z_[
E[kj[
iY^bW\[d&
ZWii
i_[
kd\s^_]
i_dZ&
h_Y^j_]
pk
Z[da[d&
kd\s^_]
pk
l[hij[^[d(
P[dd
L_[
Z_[i
Wkii[h^WbX
][i[^[d
^WX[d&
atdd[d
L_[
[i
Wk\
i_Y^
i[bXij
Wdm[dZ[d(
L_[
m[hZ[d
Z_[i[bX[
O[hm_hhkd]
uX[h
Wbb[hb[_
:hj[d
led
M^[c[d
_d
i_Y^
i[bXij
i[^[d(
>i
_ij
iY^m[h
pk
Z[da[d&
iY^m[h
pk
i[^[d&
me
cWd
pk
Z[da[d
Wd\Wd][d
iebbj[4
P[dd
L_[
Z_[i
[_dcWb
l[hij[^[d&
X[]_dd[d
L_[&
Wk\
Z_[
h_Y^j_][
:hj
pk
Z[da[d(
P[dd
L_[
B^h[
:hj
^[hWki\_dZ[d&
m_[
uX[h
[_d[d
@[][dijWdZ
h_Y^j_]
pk
Z[da[d
_ij&
m_hZ
B^d[d
ZWi
kdc_jj[bXWh
^[b\[d&
uX[h
WdZ[h[
=_d][
h_Y^j_]
pk
Z[da[d(
=_[
LY^m_[h_]a[_j
b_[]j
ZWh_d&
ZWii
Z_[
E[kj[
uX[h
]Wh
d_Y^ji
h_Y^j_]
dWY^Z[da[d( 6RPNCLPIV#
PWi
^[_iij
[i&
fhWaj_iY^
pk
WhX[_j[d9
>i
X[Z[kj[j&
d_Y^j
dkh
Wc
Bdj[bb[aj
pk
WhX[_j[d&
iedZ[hd
WkY^
Wd
Z[d
@[\u^' b[d
kdZ
Wc
P_bb[d(
:hX[_j
Wc
Bdj[bb[aj
X[Z[kj[j&
Wk\
[_d[
d[k[
:hj
pk
Z[da[d&
d[k[
@[i_Y^jifkdaj[
pk
[hiY^W\\[d&
Bbbki_ed[d
pk
p[hijth[d(
:hX[_j
Wd
Z[d
@[\u^b[d
X[Z[kj[j&
a[_d[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
WkipkZhuYa[d&
i_Y^
d_Y^j
pk
_Z[dj_\_p_[h[d&
d_Y^j
_dd[h' b_Y^
pk
[hms][d
kdZ
ifsj[h&
WkY^
Wd
Z[d
@[\u^b[d
i[bXij
pk
WhX[_j[d(
:hX[_j
Wc
P_bb[d4
PWi
X[Z[kj[j
ZWi9
PWi
_ij
P_bb[
_d "!*

F[diY^
Gh(
b&
,
kdZ
-9
>h
_ij
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
led
PudiY^[d(
P_bb[
_ij
Z[h
?WZ[d
c_j[_dWdZ[h
l[hXkdZ[d[h
PudiY^[&
kdZ
ZW
i_Y^
kdi[h[
PudiY^[
ZWk[hdZ
sdZ[hd&
^WX[d
m_h
a[_d[d
f[hcWd[d' j[d
?WZ[d(
Le
^sd]j
Z[h
][mt^db_Y^[
P_bb[
led
PudiY^[d
WX&
kdZ
PudiY^[
atdd[d
i[^h
l[hiY^_[Z[d
i[_d5
Z[h
PkdiY^&
[jmWi
pk
jkd
kdZ
Z[h
PkdiY^&
[jmWi
d_Y^j
pk
jkd(
=[h
F[diY^
^Wj
a[_d[d
P_bb[d&
iedZ[hd
dkh
>_][dm_bb[d
kdZ
>_][di_dd( P_h
cuii[d
kdi
\hW][d&
mehWk\
Z[h
P_bb[
led
F[diY^
Gh(
1
X[hk^[d
atddj[(
>h
ckii
Wk\
lebb[c
;[mkiiji[_d
X[hk^[d&
kdZ
Z_[i
X[Z[kj[j
P_ii[d
kdZ
O[hij[^[d
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
eX`[aj_' l[c
;[mkiiji[_d
kdZ
I[hcWd[dj[c
yBY^z(
Gkh
Z_[`[d_][d&
Z_[
Z_[i[
Zh[_
=_d][
^WX[d&
atdd[d
m_hab_Y^[d
P_bb[d
^WX[d5
ZWi
^[_iij&
[_d
P_bb[&
Z[h
led
Wbb[c
WdZ[h[d
kdWX^sd]_]
_ij
kdZ
dkh
Wk\
;[mkiiji[_d&
P_ii[d
kdZ
I[hcWd[dj[c
yBY^z
X[hk^j( ?hW][d
L_[
i_Y^
dkd&
mehWk\
>_][dm_bb[
kdZ
>_][di_dd
X[hk' ^[d(
L_[
X[hk^[d
_cc[h
Wk\
P_Z[hifhkY^(
>_][dm_bb[
^[_iij&
m[dd
pkc
;[_if_[b
`[cWdZ
i_[^j&
ZWii
[_d
WdZ[h[h
d_Y^j
m[_ii&
m_[
[jmWi
pk
jkd
_ij
kdZ
iW]j&
[h
mebb[
[i
[habsh[d&
kdZ
Z[h
WdZ[h[
iW]j&
yG[_d&
_Y^
m_bb
[i
Wbb[_d[
jkdz(
=[h
>_][dm_bb[
[djifh_d]j
Z[c
P_Z[hifhkY^(
>_][di_dd
_ij
ZWi
]b[_Y^[&
dkh
Wbb][c[_d[h(
>_][di_dd
aWdd
[_d[
:hj
@[me^d^[_j
i[_d( Nc
pk
ijkZ_[h[d&
m_[
c_j
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wc
P_bb[d
X[]edd[d
m[hZ[d
iebb&
m_[
cWd
_^d
jhWdi\ehc_[hj&
ckii
cWd
i[_d[d
P_bb[d
Wk\][X[d(
=_[i
_ij
[_d[
i[^h
][\s^hb_Y^[
;[iY^h[_Xkd]&
m[dd
i_[
c_iil[hijWdZ[d
m_hZ(
>i
_ij
m_Y^j_]&
h_Y^j_]
pk
l[hij[^[d&
mWi
yi[_d[d
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[dz
X[Z[kj[j(
>i
\hW]j
i_Y^&
m_[
cWd
ZWi
jkd
iebb(
>hij[di
ckii
cWd
l[hikY^[d&
@[ZWda[d&
Pehj[
kdZ
AWdZbkd][d
c_j
BZ[[d&
>h\ehZ[hd_ii[d
kdZ
Bdj[h[ii[d
Z[i
Lo' ij[ci
pk
l[hX_dZ[d
kdZ
pk
aeehZ_d_[h[d(
P_h
^WX[d
pk
l_[b[
pk\sbb_][
@[ZWda[d&
Z_[
Z_[
]Wdp[
:d][b[][d^[_j
l[hsdZ[hd(
P[dd
m_h
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
i[_d
mebb[d&
cuii[d
m_h
Wbb
kdi[h[
@[ZWda[d&
Pehj[
kdZ
AWdZbkd][d
lec
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Z[h
:h' X[_j
Wki
uX[hfhu\[d(
>_d_][
led
_^d[d
atdd[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
iY^W' Z[d(
P[dd
L_[
Wbie
WhX[_j[d
mebb[d&
i_dZ
L_[
d_Y^j
bsd][h
\h[_5
L_[
cuii[d
Z_[
0JJRPGML
Z[h
?h[_^[_j
l[hb_[h[d(
=_[
?hW][
_ij4
AWX[d
m_h
?h[_^[_j9
AWX[d
m_h
[jmWi
pk
l[hb_[h[d9
=_[
[_dp_][
?h[_^[_j& ""!

Z_[
m_h
^WX[d&
_ij&
Z[h
:hX[_j
kdZ
Z[d
E[kj[d
pk
iY^WZ[d(
BdZ[c
m_h
b[hd[d&
Z[h
:hX[_j
d_Y^j
pk
iY^WZ[d&
b[hd[d
m_h&
kdi
i[bXij
d_Y^j
pk
iY^WZ[d5
a[_d[
kdl[hWdjmehjb_Y^[d&
kdpkiWcc[d^sd' ][dZ[d
MWj[d
pk
lebb\u^h[d(
=W^[h
][X[d
m_h
d_Y^ji
P_hab_Y^[i
Wk\( 6RPNCLPIV#
=_[
?[ijb[]kd]
kdZ
=[\_d_j_ed
Z[i
S_[bi
_ij
[_d
i[^h
m_Y^j_][h
:k][dXb_Ya
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j(
@[mt^db_Y^
][iY^_[^j
[i&
ZWii
cWd
i[_d
S_[b
ltbb_]
h_Y^j_]&
_d
Z[h
ZkhY^Wki
h_Y^j_][d
K_Y^jkd]
Z[\_d_[hj&
dkh
d_ccj
cWd
[_d
S_[b&
ZWi
i[^h
m[_j
[dj\[hdj
b_[]j(
F_j
Z_[i[c
S_[b
leh
:k][d
X[]_ddj
cWd
ZWdd
pk
b[hd[d
kdZ
FWj[h_Wb
Wdpk^sk\[d(
P[dd
cWd
ZWi
dsY^ij[
FWb
l[hikY^j&
i[_d
S_[b
pk
Z[\_d_[h[d&
Z[\_d_[hj
cWd
[i
[_d
X_iiY^[d
WdZ[hi
kdZ
\_dZ[j
[_d
S_[b&
ZWi
[_d
m[d_]
ds^[h
b_[]j(
=Wi
dsY^ij[
FWb
m_[Z[h
[_d
X_iiY^[d
ds^[h
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h&
X_i
cWd
[_d
S_[b
\_dZ[j&
ZWi
]Wdp
dW^[
b_[]j
'
ceh][d
eZ[h
uX[hceh][d(
=Wi
_ij
_d
Z[h
MWj
Z[h
h_Y^j_][
P[]
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
S_[b[&
m[dd
m_h
led
_^d[d
e^d[
X[ij_ccj[
Pehj[
ifh[Y^[d(
C[ZeY^
atdd[d
m_h
d[Xij
Z_[' i[d
l_[b[
\_dZ[d&
Z_[
[_dZ[kj_]
[hms^dj
mehZ[d
i_dZ(
y>_di
pk
i[_d(z
Otbb_]
h_Y^j_]5
i[^h
]kj[i
S_[b(
y?h[_
pk
i[_dz(
P_[9
Gkh&
m[dd
cWd
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
Z_[
FWiY^_d[
[hbWd]j(
C[cWdZ
aWdd
iW][d4
yBY^
ctY^j[
P_bb[d
^WX[dz(
L[^h
]kj(
yBY^
m_bb
mWY^
i[_d(z
:kY^
i[^h
]kj(
:bb
Z_[i[
S_[b[
b_[][d
Wk\
Z[hi[bX[d
E_d_[&
b[Z_]b_Y^
_d
kdj[hiY^_[Zb_Y^[d
:XijsdZ[d( -O?EC#
BY^
X_d
pk
Z[c
LY^bkii
][aecc[d&
ZWii
Z_[
c[_ij[d
c[_d[h
S_[b[
pk
[dj\[hdj
b_[][d
kdZ
_Y^
ctY^j[
c[^h
Wd
Z[h
fhWaj_iY^[d
L[_j[
WhX[_j[d( 6RPNCLPIV#
CW&
Z[dd
X[leh
L_[
[dj\[hdj[
S_[b[
[hh[_Y^[d
atdd[d&
]_Xj
[i
l_[b[i&
ZWi
L_[
A_[h
kdZ
C[jpj
pk
jkd
^WX[d&
kdZ
^_[h_d
kdj[hiY^[_Z[j
i_Y^
Z_[i
Loij[c
led
\Wij
Wbb[d
WdZ[h[d
Loij[c[d(
;[_dW^[
Wbb[
WdZ[h[d
Loij[c[
X[]_dd[d
c_dZ[ij[di
p[^djWki[dZ
F[_b[d
m[_j[h
lehd[
kdZ
^WX[d
a[_d[
fhWaj_iY^[
;[Z[kjkd]5
WX[h
Z_[i[i
Loij[c
X[]_ddj
_d
Z_[i[c
S_cc[h(
=Wi
_ij
Z[h
Ndj[hiY^_[Z&
kdZ
ZWi
ckii
Wbi
Wbb[h[hij[i
l[hijWdZ[d
m[hZ[d( P_[Z[h
kdZ
m_[Z[h
cuii[d
m_h
pk
Z_[i[h
?hW][
pkhuYaa[^h[d& """

mWi
m_h
led
Z[h
:hX[_j
mebb[d(
;[dkjp[d
L_[
d_Y^j
Z_[
M[hc_de' be]_[
Z[i
Loij[ci&
iedZ[hd
\_dZ[d
L_[
^[hWki&
mWi
L_[
i[bXij
mebb[d(
P[dd
L_[
iW][d&
L_[
mebb[d
X[mkiij
i[_d&
ie
_ij
ZWi
Wbb[i
i[^h
]kj(
:X[h
mWhkc9
PWi
mebb[d
L_[
ZWZkhY^
[hh[_Y^[d&
ZWii
L_[
X[mkiij
m[hZ[d9
L_[
Zuh\[d
d_Y^j
Z[da[d&
ZWii
L_[
Z_[i[
?hW][
ie\ehj
X[Wdjmehj[d
atdd[d(
L_[
_ij
i[^h
iY^m[h(
:X[h
L_[
Zuh\[d
d_Y^j
Wk\^th[d&
Wk\
i_[
pkhuYapkaecc[d(
NdZ
L_[
cui' i[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii&
X[leh
Z_[
S[_j
aeccj&
ZW
L_[
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d
m[hZ[d
pk
[h^Wbj[d&
mWi
L_[
mebb[d&
L_[
m_ii[d
cuii[d&
mWi
[i
_ij(
=Wi
_ij
[_d[
i[^h
[dZ]ubj_][
;[Z_d]kd](
L_[
atdd[d
d_[cWbi
[jmWi
[h^Wbj[d&
X[leh
L_[
[i
d_Y^j
a[dd[d
kdZ
iW][d
atdd[d
yBY^
m_bb
Z_[iz(
=Wdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
[i
l_[bb[_Y^j
X[aecc[d
eZ[h
l_[bb[_Y^j
WkY^
d_Y^j5
WX[h
L_[
atdd[d
[i
d_[cWbi
X[aec' c[d&
X_i
L_[
d_Y^j
m_ii[d&
mWi
[i
_ij(
>X[d\Wbbi
cuii[d
L_[
Z_[
=_d][
_d
Z[h
h_Y^j_][d
HhZdkd]
mebb[d( -O?EC#
PWi
X[Z[kj[j
ZWi9 6RPNCLPIV#
FWd
ckii
Z_[
h_Y^j_][
HhZdkd]
Z[h
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
ijkZ_[h[d
kdZ
l[hij[^[d(
=Wi
_ij
[_d[
i[^h
_dj[h[iiWdj[
:d][b[' ][d^[_j( -O?EC#
F[_d[d
L_[
_c
Loij[c9 6RPNCLPIV#
F_j
A_b\[
Z[i
Loij[ci(
:X[h
L_[
atdd[d
[i
Wk\
B^h[
[_][d[
:hj
\ehckb_[h[d(
L_[
cuii[d
Wk\h_Y^j_]
c_j
i_Y^
i[bXij
i[_d(
L_[
cuii[d
][dWk
m_ii[d&
mWi
L_[
mebb[d&
kdZ
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
L_[
i_Y^
\hW][d4
yP_hZ
ZWi
Loij[c
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
c_h
ZWX[_
pk
^[b\[d&
[i
pk
[hbWd][d9z
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
:X[h
L_[
cuii[d
m_ii[d&
mWi
L_[
mebb[d( P_h
i_dZ
d_[
pm[_
MW][
^_dj[h[_dWdZ[h
Z_[i[bX[d(
:d
[_d_][d
MW][d
m[hZ[d
m_h
[h\eb]h[_Y^[h
i[_d&
Wd
WdZ[h[d
m[d_][h(
:bb[i&
mWi
m_h
jkd
atdd[d&
_ij&
ie
l_[b
m_[
ct]b_Y^
pk
uX[hXb_Ya[d(
P_h
atdd[d
d_[cWbi
iY^m_[h_][h[
=_d][
X[^[hhiY^[d&
m[dd
m_h
Z_[
b[_Y^j[d
d_Y^j
X[^[hhiY^[d(
C[Z[d
MW]
kdZ
`[Z[
LjkdZ[
]_Xj
[i
=_d][&
Z_[
m_h
X[^[hhiY^[d
atddj[d
kdZ
d_Y^j
jkd5
ie
atdd[d
m_h
d_Y^ji
G[k[i
pkc
;[^[hhiY^[d
^WX[d(
P_h
i_dZ
kc][X[d
led
l[hdWY^bsii_]j[d
=_d][d(
@htiij[dj[_bi
X[^[hhiY^[d
m_h
kdi[h
=[da[d
d_Y^j(
P_h
Z[da[d
Wk\
[_d[
lW][
:hj
Wd
ZWi&
mWi
m_h
mebb[d&
WX[h
m[dd
m_h
d_Y^j
\ehckb_[h[d&
mWi
m_h
mebb[d&
m_hZ ""#

d_Y^ji
][iY^[^[d(
=_[i
_ij
Z_[
[hij[
;[Z_d]kd]&
WX[h
[i
]_Xj
l_[b[
A_dZ[hd_ii[( BY^
^WX[
uX[h
Z_[i[
?hW][
Z[i
S_[bi
][ifheY^[d&
m[_b
_Y^
B^d[d
hWj[&
ZWhuX[h
dWY^pkZ[da[d&
pk
uX[hfhu\[d&
mWi
L_[
X[' h[_ji
uX[h
S_[b[
][ZWY^j
^WX[d
kdZ
ZWhuX[h
dWY^pkZ[da[d&
m_[
L_[
B^h
S_[b
dWY^
[_d[c
LjkZ_kc
Z_[i[h
BZ[[d
dkd
Z[\_d_[h[d
muhZ[d(
>i
_ij
pm[Yabei&
[_d
S_[b
pk
Z[\_d_[h[d&
ZWi
d_Y^j
[hh[_Y^j
m[hZ[d
aWdd(
P[dd
L_[
`[ZeY^
[_d
S_[b
Z[\_d_[h[d&
ZWi
L_[
pk
[hh[_Y^[d
^e\\[d
atdd[d&
ZWdd
m_hZ
B^h[
:hX[_j
X[mkiij&
[hdij'
^W\j
i[_d( P[dd
_Y^
ZWdWY^
][\hW]j
muhZ[&
msh[
c[_d[
:djmehj&
ZWii
ZWi&
mWi
[_d
F[diY^
X[aecc[d
aWdd&
mWi
_^c
kdj[h
Z[h
;[Z_d' ]kd]&
ZWii
[h
WhX[_j[j&
l[hifheY^[d
m[hZ[d
aWdd&
ZWh_d
X[ij[^j&
ZWii
[h
i_Y^
dWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
Z[h
:hX[_j
i[bXij
i[^[d
m_hZ(
>h

cW]
WdZ[h[
=_d][
[hh[_Y^[d&
m_[
;[mkiiji[_d&
>_d^[_j&
O[hX_d' Zkd]
c_j
^t^[h[d
S[djh[d&
Wbb[
\eb][d
dWY^
'
kdZ
m_h
m_ii[d
d_Y^j&
_d
m[bY^[h
K[_^[d\eb][
i_[
_d
>hiY^[_dkd]
jh[j[d(
:X[h
m_h
cuii[d
Wd
[_d[i
Z[da[d5
X_i
m_h
Z_[i
[hbWd][d
'
X_i
m_h
kdi
i[bXij
i[^[d
'
atdd[d
m_h
d_Y^ji
WdZ[h[i
[hh[_Y^[d(
;_i
m_h
c_j
Z_[i[c
S_[b
leh
:k][d
pk
WhX[_j[d
X[]_dd[d&
atdd[d
m_h
d_Y^j
iW][d&
ZWii
m_h
pk
WhX[_j[d
X[]edd[d
^WX[d(
=[cdWY^
cuii[d
m_h
dWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
kdi[h
kdc_jj[bXWh[i
S_[b
Wbi
kdi
i[bXij
pk
i[^[d
\ehckb_[h[d
atdd[d(
G_Y^j
[_dcWb
kdi
i[bXij
pk
ICLLCL
"ZWi
aeccj
ifsj[h#&
iedZ[hd
kdi
i[bXij
pk
PCFCL# 6RPNCLPIV#
Le]Wh
P_ii[d
kdZ
O[hij[^[d
atdd[d
d_Y^j
^[b\[d&
m[dd
cWd
d_Y^j
Wc
L[_d
WhX[_j[j(
P[dd
Z[h
P_bb[
d_Y^j
]b[_Y^' p[_j_]
msY^ij&
aWdd
cWd
l[hij[^[d
kdZ
Z[ddeY^
d_Y^j
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
[jmWi
pk
jkd( -O?EC#
L_[
iW][d&
[i
i[_
ct]b_Y^
pk
l[hij[^[d
kdZ
Z[ddeY^
d_Y^ji
ZWc_j
Wd\Wd][d
pk
atdd[d9 6RPNCLPIV#
CW&
m[dd
cWd
d_Y^j
led
:d\Wd]
Wd
[hdij^W\j[
:dijh[d]kd][d
kdj[hdecc[d
^Wj&
P_bb[d
pk
[djm_Ya[bd(
P[dd
Z[h
P_bb[
kd[djm_Ya[bj
Xb[_Xj&
ZWdd
aWdd
Z_[
>djm_Yabkd]
Z[i
O[hij[^[di
d_Y^j
l_[b
^[b\[d(
FWd
aWdd
i[^h
l_[b
l[hij[^[d&
WX[h
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
d_Y^j
\s^_]
i[_d&
_h][dZ[jmWi
ZWc_j
Wdpk\Wd][d( ""$

-O?EC#
Bij
Z[h
P_bb[
M[_b
Z[i
L[_di9 6RPNCLPIV#
CW&
][dWkie
m_[
;[mkiiji[_d
eZ[h
O[hijsdZd_i(
Gkh&
m[dd
L_[
pk
l_[b
Wc
O[hijsdZd_i
WhX[_j[d
kdZ
Z[d
P_bb[d
Wkii[h
WY^j
bWii[d&
ZWdd
m_hZ
B^h
P_bb[&
WdijWjj
ijsha[h
iY^msY^[h
m[hZ[d
eZ[h
][dWk
ie
Xb[_X[d&
m_[
[h
mWh(
F_j
kdi[h[c
P_bb[d
'
Z[c
P_bb[d
led
F[diY^
b&
,
kdZ
-
'
atdd[d
m_h
dkh
CGL
S[djhkc
X[^[hhiY^[d&
m[dd
m_h
Z_[
][iWcj[
kdi
ct]b_Y^[
Dedp[djhWj_ed
[_di[jp[d(
P_h
atdd[d
d_[cWbi
pm[_
eZ[h
Zh[_
S[djh[d
X[^[hh' iY^[d&
kdZ
Wkii[hZ[c
^sd][d
Z_[
S[djh[d
led[_dWdZ[h
WX(
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
m_h
[djiY^btii[d
kdi&
[_d
S[djhkc
pk
X[^[hh' iY^[d
kdZ
ms^h[dZZ[ii[d
\kdaj_ed_[hj[d
WdZ[h[
S[djh[d
Wbb[_d[
m[_j[h&
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
i_[
ie\ehj
ZWi
S[djhkc
Wdij[Ya[d&
ZWi
m_h
X[^[hhiY^[d
mebb[d
kdZ
[i
m_[Z[h
pk
c[Y^Wd_iY^[c
K[W]_[h[d
Xh_d][d( -O?EC#
P_[
aWdd
cWd
Z_[i[
:hj
P_bb[d
[hbWd][d9 6RPNCLPIV#
=Wi
mkhZ[
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Z_[
yLjefz'rXkd]$
[h' abshj(
=_[`[d_][d&
Z_[
Z[d
OehjhW]
uX[h
Z_[
yLjefz'rXkd]
^th' j[d&
ct][d
i_Y^
[h_dd[hd(
F[^h
Wbi
[_d
S[djhkc
pk
X[^[hhiY^[d&
_ij
Z_[
@hkdZbW][
Z[h
yLjefz'rXkd](
L_[
aWdd
dkh
Wki][\u^hj
m[hZ[d&
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^
kdj[h
[_d[d
WdZ[h[d
P_bb[d
ij[bb[d&
Z[dd
B^h
[_][d[h
P_bb[
h[_Y^j
d_Y^j
Wki(
FWdY^cWb
aWdd
[i
dejm[dZ_]
i[_d&
l_[h
S[djh[d
pk
X[^[hhiY^[d&
kdZ
ZWi
FWn_ckc
B^h[h
P_bb[di[d[h]_[
aWdd
dkh
[_d
S[djhkc
X[^[hhiY^[d(
=W^[h
_ij
[_d
WdZ[h[h
P_bb[
dejm[dZ_](
:ki
Z_[i[c
@hkdZ
i_dZ
LY^kbZ_ip_fb_d
kdZ
LY^kbuXkd][d
dejm[dZ_]( -O?EC#
P_[
atdd[d
m_h
][][d
Z[d
>_][dm_bb[d
Wd][^[d9
Bij
[i
kdi&
ie
m_[
m_h
i_dZ&
ct]b_Y^&
Z_[
:k][dXb_Ya[
pk
[ha[dd[d&
_d
Z[d[d
m_h
m_hab_Y^[d
P_bb[d
^WX[d9 6RPNCLPIV#
G_Y^j
m_hab_Y^[d
P_bb[d5
Z[d
atdd[d
m_h
d_Y^j
^WX[d(
:bb[i&
mWi
m_h
^WX[d&
i_dZ
>_][dm_bb[
kdZ
>_][di_dd
eZ[h
ab[_d[
LjuYa[
led
P_bb[d&
Z_[
i_Y^
Z_[
]Wdp[
S[_j
sdZ[hd(
P_hab_' Y^[h
P_bb[
_ij
deY^
i[^h
m[_j
m[]5
[h
X[hk^j
Wk\
I[hcWd[dj[c
yBY^z&
;[mkiiji[_d
kdZ
BdZ_l_ZkWb_jsj(
P_h
^WX[d
_^d
d_Y^j( PWi
Z_[
?hW][&
m_[
m_h
][][d
>_][dm_bb[d
WhX[_j[d
atdd[d& $
Skh
;[iY^h[_Xkd]
Z[h
yLjefz'rXkd]
i_[^[
I(=(
Hkif[diao4
(RD
BCO
9RAFC
L?AF
BCK
=RLBCO@?OCL!
;[hd&
FudY^[d&
P_[d
+300&
L(
/+1',-#

""%

WdX[bWd]j4
L_[
atdd[d
ZWi
Loij[c
ijkZ_[h[d(
>i
]_Xj
X[ij_ccj[
:d\ehZ[hkd][d
_c
Loij[c5
=_d][&
Z_[
L_[
jkd
eZ[h
kdj[hbWii[d
iebb[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
iebb[d
L_[
d_Y^j
h[Z[d&
Z[dd
m[dd
L_[
[i
jkd&
m[hZ[d
L_[
dkh
Eu][d
[hps^b[d(
L_[
atdd[d
[hij
uX[h
ZWi
Loij[c
ifh[Y^[d&
m[dd
L_[
[i
a[dd[d
kdZ
l[hij[^[d(
:k\
Z_[i[
:hj
X[][]d[d
L_[
led
:d\Wd]
Wd
:hX[_ji_Z[[d&
Z_[
Z[c
>_][d' m_bb[d
[dj][][dbWk\[d(
P[dd
L_[
Z_[
:hX[_j
l[h][ii[d&
WhX[_j[d
L_[
d_Y^j
][][d
>_][dm_bb[d(
=_[
[_dp_][
:hj&
][][d
>_][dm_bb[d
Wdpkascf\[d&
_ij&
i_Y^
Z[h
:hX[_j
pk
[h_dd[hd(
>i
aWdd
][iY^[' ^[d&
ZWii
Z_[
:hX[_j
_d
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
:k][dXb_Ya
uX[h^Wkfj
a[_d[
Kebb[
if_[bj&
WX[h
_d
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
:k][dXb_Ya
_ij
i_[
X[j[_b_]j&
kdZ
_d
Z_[i[c
Fec[dj
atdd[d
L_[
l[hij[^[d&
mWi
Z[d
>_][dm_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[d
X[Z[kj[j(
?hW][d
L_[
i_Y^
i[bXij4
Bij
[i
lec
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wki
h_Y^j_]
eZ[h
d_Y^j9
=Wi
_ij
DWcf\
][][d
>_][dm_bb[d( Sk[hij
ckii
cWd
l[hij[^[d&
mWi
P_bb[
_ij(
P_h
^WX[d
a[_d[d
P_bb[d5
m_h
^WX[d
dkh
>_][dm_bb[d
kdZ
>_][di_dd(
>_][dm_bb[
_ij
L[bXijX[ijsj_]kd](
>_][di_dd
^[_iij
][][d
[jmWi
Wd][^[d&
][][d
K[][bd
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
;[_Z[
X[_d^Wbj[d
[_d[
:hj
Hffei_j_ed
][][d
[jmWi&
kdZ
_d
Z_[i[h
?ehc
]_Xj
[i
i_[(
=[h
F[diY^
^Wj
a[_d[d
khifhud]b_Y^[d
P_bb[d&
Z[h
e^d[
P_Z[hijWdZ
[n_ij_[h[d
aWdd
kdZ
Z[h
X[ijsdZ_]
_ij(
:ki
Z_[i[c
@hkdZ
ckii
[h
kdj[hmeh' \[d
m[hZ[d(
=_[i[
Ndj[hm[h\kd]
iY^kbj
_^d&
ie
ZWii
[h
^_dj[h^[h
[_d[h
X[ij_ccj[d
E_d_[
\eb][d
aWdd(
P[dd
[h
ijWha
][dk]
m_hZ&
XhWkY^j
cWd
_^d
d_Y^j
bsd][h
pk
X[]h[dp[d(
=[cdWY^
aWdd
Z[dd
Z[h
P_bb[
d_Y^j
][bWii[d
m[hZ[d&
m_[
[h
_ij(
C[jpj
bsk\j
[h
_d
Wbb[
K_Y^jkd][d(
>h
ckii
][iY^kbj
m[hZ[d&
kdZ
kc
_^d
pk
iY^kb[d&
ckii
cWd
l_[b[
kdWd][d[^c[
=_d][
jkd( Bc
][mt^db_Y^[d
F[diY^[d
\eb]j
Z[h
P_bb[
[_d[h
S_YapWYa' b_d_[
eZ[h
Zh[^j
i_Y^
_c
Dh[_i(
P_bb[
p[_]j
Z_[
K_Y^jkd]
Z[h
:dijh[d]kd][d(
:dijh[d]kd]
_ij
kdi[h
@[bZ(
P_h
cuii[d
c_j
:dijh[d]kd][d
X[pW^b[d(
>djifh[Y^[dZ
Z[h
Ljsha[
Z[h
:dijh[d' ]kd][d
kdZ
Z[c
S[_jfkdaj
Z[h
:dijh[d]kd][d
'
_d
Z[c
L_dd&
eX
[i
Z_[
h_Y^j_][
S[_j
\uh
Z_[
:dijh[d]kd]
_ij
eZ[h
d_Y^j
'
[hp_[b[d
m_h
>h][Xd_ii[(
:dijh[d]kd]
[h\ehZ[hj
P_ii[d&
D[ddj' d_i
Z[h
:k][dXb_Ya[&
_d
Z[d[d
:dijh[d]kd]
dujpb_Y^
_ij(
=_[ ""&

:dijh[d]kd][d&
Z_[
m_h
cWY^[d
atdd[d&
i_dZ
iebY^[
Z[h
L[bXij' X[eXWY^jkd]
kdZ
Z[i
L[bXij'
>h_dd[hdi(
P[dd
E[kj[
led
:d' ijh[d]kd]
^th[d&
Z[da[d
i_[
Wd
[_d[
:dijh[d]kd]
Z[i
yMkdiz(
=Wi
msh[
l[hbeh[d[
:dijh[d]kd]
eZ[h
\WbiY^[
:dijh[d]kd]&
WX[h
:dijh[d]kd]
Z[h
L[bXijX[eXWY^jkd]
eZ[h
Z[i
L[bXij'>h_d'
d[hdi
_ij
h_Y^j_]&
m[_b
[i
h_Y^j_][
>h][Xd_ii[
Xh_d][d
aWdd( -O?EC#
PWhkc
iW]j[d
L_[&
m_h
cuiij[d
kdi
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd
l[hikY^[d&
m[dd
[i
Wc
iY^m_[h_]ij[d
_ij9 6RPNCLPIV#
L_[
m_ii[d&
ZWii
L_[
[jmWi
d_Y^j
jkd
iebb[d(
>_d
M[_b
led
B^d[d
m_bb
[i
jkd(
=Wdd
[h_dd[hd
L_[
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
kdZ
ijeff[d
L_[
_^d(
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
^Wj
[_d
>b[c[dj
led
P_bb[d
_d
i_Y^(
P[dd
[i
dkh
jhskc[d
^_[ii[
yBY^
X_d&
_Y^
X_d&
_Y^
X_dz&
msh[
[i
d_Y^ji(
L_[
cuii[d
[_d\WY^
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
S[_j
ZWhWk\
l[hm[dZ[d
ZWhuX[h
dWY^pkZ[da[d&
mWi
>h_dd[hd
X[Z[kj[j
kdZ
mWi
>h_dd[hd
d_Y^j
X[Z[kj[j&
kdZ
mWi
\uh
[_d[
P_hakd]
>h_dd[' hkd][d
^WX[d(
=Wdd
atdd[d
L_[
l_[b[hb[_
P[][
[h\_dZ[d&
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd(
C[ZeY^
_ij
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
_d
Z[h
MWj
a[_d[
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[
eZ[h
WXijhWaj[
:d][b[][d^[_j5
[i
X[Z[kj[j
:k][dXb_Ya[
led
P_bb[d(
>i
_ij
d_Y^j
=[da[d5
[i
_ij
AWdZ[bd(
>i
X[Z[kj[j&
l[hc[^hj[
Dedjhebb[
pk
^WX[d5
led
m[bY^[c
Gkjp[d
msh[
[i
iedij9
L_[
atdd[d
i_Y^
dkh
_d
:k][dXb_Ya[d
Z[i
L[bXij'
>h_dd[hdi
aedjhebb_[h[d(
=_[
c[Y^Wd_iY^[
Dedjhebb[&
Z_[
ZkhY^
LY^kbkd]
kdZ
>hp_[^kd]
[hmehX[d
m_hZ
'm[dd
kdi
][b[^hj
m_hZ&
m_[
m_h
kdi
_d
X[ij_ccj[d
L_jkWj_ed[d
l[h^Wbj[d
iebb[d
'
_ij
a[_d[
m_hab_Y^[
Dedjhebb[( -O?EC#
Lebb[d
m_h
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
@[mW^hi[_d
X[Z[kj[j9 6RPNCLPIV#
G_Y^j
dkh
@[mW^hi[_d(
>i
X[Z[kj[j
WkY^
[_d[
][m_ii[
?s^_]a[_j&
Wk\
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:hj
pk
^WdZ[bd&
pk
jkd&
mWi
L_[
mebb[d(
L[^[d
L_[&
_d
kdi[h[h
be]_iY^[d
=[dam[_i[&
][csii
be]_iY^[c
P_ii[d&
jh[dd[d
m_h
;[mkiiji[_d
lec
P_bb[d(
:X[h
;[mkiiji[_d
@CBCRQCQ
P_bb[(
Bd
Z[h
hkii_iY^[d
LfhWY^[
pkc
;[_if_[b
_ij
yP_bb[z
ZWii[bX[
Pehj
m_[
y?h[_^[_jz(
=Wi
Pehj
y;[mkiiji[_dz
c[_dj
[_d[
O[hX_dZkd]
Wbb[d
P_ii[di5
Wbi
^sjj[d
L_[
B^h
][iWcj[i
P_ii[d
pkh
i[bX[d
S[_j
leh
i_Y^(
:X[h
;[mkiij' i[_d
X[Z[kj[j
WkY^
P_bb[&
kdZ
P_bb[
X[Z[kj[j
?h[_^[_j( ""'

-O?EC#
PWi
^[_iij
[i&
Z[d
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[d9 6RPNCLPIV#
:k\][X[d
led
D_dZ_iY^i[_d&
Ndm_haiWca[_j
kdZ
Eu][d( -O?EC#
;[_d^Wbj[j
Z_[
:k\]WX[
Z[i
>_][dm_bb[di
[X[d\Wbbi
Z_[
:k\]WX[
Z[i
[_][d[d
Nhj[_bi9 6RPNCLPIV#
>i
aeccj
ZWhWk\
Wd&
meh_d(
PWi
X[Z[kj[j
:k\]W' X[
Z[i
P_bb[di9
P_[
aWdd
[i
[hh[_Y^j
m[hZ[d9
L_[
^WX[d
\WbiY^[
Oehij[bbkd][d
^_[huX[h(
>hij[di
ij[bb[d
L_[
[i
i_Y^
Wbi
[_d[
[dZ]ub' j_][
AWdZbkd]
leh4
ZWii
L_[
P_bb[d
Wk\][X[d
kdZ
a[_d[d
m[_j[h[d
P_bb[d
c[^h
^WX[d(
=Wi
_ij
[_d[
Bbbki_ed&
Z[dd
m_h
^WX[d
a[_d[d
Z[hWhj_][d
P_bb[d&
Z[d
m_h
Wk\][X[d
atddj[d(
Ndi[h[
P_bb[di' ahW\j
h[_Y^j
\uh
hkdZ
Zh[_
F_dkj[d(
P_bb[
m_hZ
p[_jb_Y^
][c[ii[d(
P[dd
m_h
[_dcWb
Zh[_
F_dkj[d
P_bb[d
Wk\][X[d&
m[hZ[d
ceh][d
m[_j[h[
Zh[_
F_dkj[d
P_bb[d
mWY^i[d(
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[d
_ij
[_d
aedj_dk_[hb_Y^[h
Ihep[ii&
d_Y^j
CGLC
AWdZbkd](
>_d[
[_dp_][
AWdZbkd]
X[Z[kj[j
d_Y^ji(
>_d
pm[_j[h
?[^b[h
_ij&
i_Y^
d_Y^j
X[ij_ccj[h
Ih_dp_f_[d
pk
[h_dd[hd&
Z[d[d
][][duX[h
L_[
P_bb[d
Wk\][X[d&
m_[
pkc
;[_if_[b
K[][bd(
>i
]_Xj
X[_if_[bim[_i[
[_d[
K[][b&
ZWii
L_[
d_Y^j
uX[h
Z_[i[i
Loij[c
ifh[Y^[d
iebbj[d(
=[h
dWjuhb_Y^[
PkdiY^
_ij
pk
h[Z[d&
WX[h
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^
pkhuYa^Wbj[d&
^[_iij
ZWi&
ZWii
L_[
B^h[d
P_bb[d
Wk\][X[d5
ZWii
L_[
Z_[i[h
K[][b
][^ehY^[d(
>i
]_Xj
l_[b[
m[_j[h[
Ih_dp_f_[d&
Z[d[d
][][duX[h
L_[
B^h[d
P_bb[d
Wk\][X[d
cuii[d&
kc
_^d[d
pk
\eb][d( -O?EC#
;[Z[kj[j&
i[_d[d
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[d&
d_Y^j
e^d[
O[h' ij[^[d
pk
^WdZ[bd9 6RPNCLPIV#
L[^[d
L_[&
ZWi
_ij
[_d
m[_j[h[h
B^h[h
?[^b[h(
L_[
Z[da[d&
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[d
X[Z[kj[&
[jmWi
pk
QRL#
=Wi
][iY^_[^j
i[^h
i[bj[d(
Bd
Z[d
c[_ij[d
?sbb[d
m_hZ
B^d[d
][iW]j&
[jmWi
LGAFQ
pk
jkd(
A_[h_d
b_[]j
[_d
]heii[h
Ndj[hiY^_[Z(
Skc
;[_if_[b
mebb[d
L_[
`[cWdZ[c
[habsh[d&
mWi
L_[
led
_^c
^Wbj[d&
kdZ
L_[
Zuh\[d
[i
d_Y^j
jkd(
>i
_ij
[_d[
?hW][
Z[h
rXkd](
P_bb[
aWdd
[djm_Ya[bj
m[hZ[d&
m[dd
[_d
F[diY^
Wd
i_Y^
WhX[_j[j
kdZ
i[_d[d
P_bb[d
pm_d]j&
Z[d
:hX[_jifh_dp_f_[d
pk
][^ehY^[d(
=_d][&
Z_[
Z_[
:hX[_j
d_Y^j
X[jh[\\[d&
atdd[d
d_Y^j
ZWc_j
l[hXkdZ[d
m[hZ[d&
WX[h
`[
c[^h
L_[
i_Y^
c_j
Z[h
:hX[_j
X[\Wii[d&
Z[ije
c[^h
=_d][
X[]_dd[d
Z_[
:hX[_j
pk
X[hu^h[d(
:X[h
ZWi
[h\ehZ[hj
S[_j( ""(

P[dd
_^h[
_][dm_bb[d( Sk
Z_[i[h
Oehij[bbkd]&
i[_d[d
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[d4
>i
ckii
m_[Z[h^ebj
m[hZ[d&
ZWii
F[diY^
Gh(
b&
,
kdZ
-
a[_d[d
P_bb[d
^WX[d&
iedZ[hd
dkh
>_][dm_bb[d
kdZ
>_][di_dd(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
pk
l[hij[^[d&
mWi
ZWi
X[Z[kj[j(
>_][di_dd_]
i[_d
^[_iij&
ZWii
cWd
[jmWi
O[hXej[d[i
pk
jkd
mudiY^j
eZ[h
jWjisY^b_Y^
jkj&
dkh
m[_b
[i
l[hXej[d
_ij(
NdZ
[i
_ij
[_d
?Wbb
led
>_][dm_bb[d&
m[dd
`[cWdZ
i_[^j&
ZWii
L_[
[jmWi
pk
jkd
l[hikY^[d&
ZWi
L_[
d_Y^j
pk
jkd
l[hij[^[d&
kdZ
ctY^j[
B^d[d
^[b\[d&
WX[h
L_[
iW][d&
yG[_d&
_Y^
m_bb
[i
i[bXij
jkdz(
=_[i
i_dZ
Z_[
pm[_
Mof[d
led
P_bb[d&
Z_[
m_h
^WX[d(
L_[
X[hk^[d
Wk\
Hffei_j_ed(
PW^h[h
P_bb[
ckii
Wk\
;[mkiiji[_d&
P_ii[d
kdZ
I[hcWd[dj[c
yBY^z
X[hk^[d(
Le
m_[
m_h
i_dZ&
^WX[d
m_h
a[_d[d(
:bb[i&
mWi
m_h
^WX[d&
i_dZ
>_][dm_bb[
kdZ
>_][di_dd(
Ndi[h
P_bb[
_ij
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
led
PudiY^[d(
PudiY^[
atdd[d
i[^h
]kj
l[hXeh][d
i[_d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
cW]
[_d
F[diY^
`[cWdZ[d
ah_j_i_[h[d
mebb[d&
kdZ
[h
d[ddj
[i
:k\h_Y^j_]' a[_j(
:X[h
Z[h
PkdiY^
pk
ah_j_i_[h[d
cW]
ie
ijWha
i[_d&
ZWii
[h
[_d[
m_hab_Y^
]heii[
:dijh[d]kd]
kdj[hd[^c[d
cuiij[&
kc
_^d
pk
ijeff[d&
kdZ
[_d
F[diY^
aWdd
a[_d[
m_hab_Y^[d
:dijh[d]kd' ][d
Wki
i_Y^
i[bXij
cWY^[d( Nc
P_bb[d
pk
[hp[k][d&
ckii
[_d
F[diY^
l[hikY^[d&
`[Z[
[_dp[bd[
i[_d[h
AWdZbkd][d
c_j
Z[d
BZ[[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
pk
aeehZ_' d_[h[d5
[h
ckii
i_Y^
X[_
`[Z[h
AWdZbkd]
\hW][d4
P_[
m_hZ
[i
lec
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Z[h
:hX[_j
^[h
Wkii[^[d9
Bij
[i
dujpb_Y^
eZ[h
iY^sZb_Y^
\uh
c_Y^
eZ[h
\uh
Z_[
:hX[_j9
P[dd
[h
[i
d_Y^j
m[_ii&
aWdd
[h
\hW][d(
P[dd
[_d
F[diY^
bWd][
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
][m[i[d
_ij&
]_Xj
[i
fhWaj_iY^
a[_d[
[_dp_][
AWdZbkd]&
Z_[
d_Y^j
Z_[
:hX[_j
X[hu^hj[5
[i
]_Xj
a[_d[
kdWX^sd]_][d
AWdZbkd][d(
Bd
Z_[i[h
A_di_Y^j
_ij
cWd
d_Y^j
\h[_&
_d
Z[c
L_dd[&
ZWii
cWd
d_Y^j
jth_Y^j
kdZ
mW^bbei
^WdZ[bd
aWdd(
FWd
KRPP
Z[da[d&
X[leh
cWd
^Wd' "")

Z[bj(
P[dd
cWd
d_Y^j
i_Y^[h
_ij&
aWdd
cWd
\hW][d(
=_[i
_ij
Z_[
CGLWGEC
F[j^eZ[&
c_j
Z[h
P_bb[
[hp[k]j
m[hZ[d
aWdd&
kdZ
\uh
Z_[i[
F[j^eZ[
_ij
LY^kb'Hh]Wd_iWj_ed
dejm[dZ_](
H^d[
LY^kb[
aWdd
cWd
d_Y^ji
jkd( -O?EC#
:bi
L_[
uX[h
P_bb[d
ifhWY^[d&
iW]j[d
L_[&
ZWii
[i
pk[hij
Z[h
P_bb[
WdZ[h[h
E[kj[
kdZ
ifsj[h
kdi[h
[_][d[h
P_bb[
i[_(
P_[
m[hZ[d
m_h
kdj[h
Z[d
P_bb[d
WdZ[h[h
E[kj[
][bWd][d9 6RPNCLPIV#
P[dd
L_[
c_j
Z[h
pm[_j[d
kdZ
Zh_jj[d
E_d_[
ledV
:hX[_j
_d
;[hu^hkd]
aecc[d&
aecc[d
L_[
dejm[dZ_][hm[_i[
c_j
Z[c
P_bb[d
WdZ[h[h
_d
;[hu^hkd]( -O?EC#
;[Z[kj[j
ZWi
Ljeff[d
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[
kdZ
Z[h[d
qkii[hkd]
d_Y^j
c[^h
eZ[h
m[d_][h
ZWii[bX[
m_[
ZWi
:k\][X[d
Z[i
>_][di_ddi9 6RPNCLPIV#
PWhkc
mebb[d
L_[
[_d[d
LWY^l[h^Wbj
_d
[_d[d
Wdh
Z[h[d
uX[hi[jp[d9
>_][dm_bb[
aWdd
WkY^
e^d[
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
O[hX_dZkd]
pk
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
l_[b[
?ehc[d
^WX[d( -O?EC#
>i
iY^[_dj
c_h&
ZWii
cWd
X[aeccj&
mWi
cWd
ctY^j[&
m[dd
cWd
Z[d
>_][dm_bb[d
Wk\]_Xj5
ZWii
cWd
ZWi
][mudiY^j[
>h][Xd_i
[hp_[bj&
_dZ[c
cWd
Z[d
PkdiY^
Wk\]_Xj( 6RPNCLPIV#
=Wi
_ij
d_Y^j
>_][dm_bb[(
>_][dm_bb[
kc\Wiij
d_Y^j
Wbb[i&
mWi
L_[
ctY^j[d(
P[dd
L_[
^kd]h_]
i_dZ
kdZ
[ii[d
mebb[d&
ZWdd
_ij
ZWi
a[_d
>_][dm_bb[(
>_][dm_bb[
^[_iij
lehpkp_[^[d&
dWY^
[_][d[c
@kjZuda[d
pk
^WdZ[bd
kdZ
_d
kdi[h[c
?Wbb&
d_Y^j
Z_[
:hX[_j
kdZ
Z_[
Ih_dp_f_[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
_d
;[jhWY^j
pk
p_[^[d(
P_h
ifh[Y^[d
led
Ih_dp_f_[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
kdZ
>_][dm_bb[d(
P_h
atd' d[d
=_d][
Wk\
kdi[h[
[_][d[
:hj
jkd
eZ[h
d_Y^j(
P[dd
c[_d
>_][dm_bb[
pkc
;[_if_[b
ZW^_d
][^j
pk
\bkY^[d&
kdZ
_Y^
][X[
[i
Wk\&
m[_b
[i
][][d
Z_[
:hX[_jifh_dp_f_[d
l[hijtiij&
me
i_dZ
ZW
Z_[
[hmudiY^j[d
>h][Xd_ii[&
led
Z[d[d
L_[
ifh[Y^[d9 P_[
_Y^
pkleh
iW]j[&
_ij
>_][dm_bb[
_cc[h
c_j
[_][d[d
:di_Y^' j[d
l[haduf\j&
[_d
F[diY^
]bWkXj
_cc[h&
[h
m_ii[
[jmWi(
=Wdd
aeccj
[h
pkh
LY^kb[
kdZ
[ha[ddj&
ZWii
[h
d_Y^ji
m[_ii(
:ki
Z_[i[c
@hkdZ
_ij
OehX[h[_jkd]
dtj_]
\uh
Z_[
LY^kb[(
FWd
ij[Yaj
][mt^db_Y^
lebb[h
[_][d[h
F[_dkd][d
kdZ
>_][dm_bb[d(
>_][d' m_bb[
_ij
m_[
[_d
D_dZ&
ZWi
iW]j&
yBY^
m[_ii
[i
i[bXij5
_Y^
m_bb
[i
i[bXij
cWY^[dz(
>_][dm_bb[
^Wj
l_[b[
F[hacWb[(
>i
m_hZ
][iW]j& ""*

cWd
iebb[
[jmWi
d_Y^j
jkd&
kdZ
ie\ehj
m_bb
cWd
[i
jkd5
[i
m_hZ
][iW]j&
[jmWi
i[_
\WbiY^&
kdZ
ie\ehj
iW]j
cWd&
yG[_d&
_Y^
m[_ii
[i
X[ii[hz(
>_d
F[diY^&
Z[h
pk
[_d[h
LY^kb[
aeccj&
ckii
X[h[_j
i[_d&
Z_[
E[^h[d
kdZ
Z_[
=_ip_fb_d
Z[h
LY^kb[
pk
Wap[fj_[h[d5
[h
ckii
\h[_
i[_d&
i_[
pk
Wap[fj_[h[d&
WdZ[hd\Wbbi
m_hZ
[h
d_Y^ji
X[aecc[d(
>h
aWdd
a[_d[d
P_bb[d
[hm[hX[d&
m[dd
[h
d_Y^j
Z[d
>_][dm_bb[d
Wk\]_Xj5
][dWkie&
m_[
[h
a[_d
P_ii[d
[hm[hX[d
aWdd&
m[dd
[h
d_Y^j
i[_d[
[_][d[d
:di_Y^j[d
Wk\]_Xj( -O?EC#
FNLL
cWd
Z[d
>_][dm_bb[d
i[bXij
Xh[Y^[d
eZ[h
_^d
Xh[Y^[d
bWii[d9 6RPNCLPIV#
FWd
ckii
[i
i[bXij
jkd&
kdZ
cWd
ckii
_^d
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
][XheY^[d
^WX[d&
kc
_d
[_d[h
LY^kb[
pk
i[_d(
FWd
ckii
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
\h[_
ZWled
i[_d&
kc
=_d][
e^d[
[_d[d
DWcf\
Wap[fj_[h[d
pk
atdd[d(
FWd
aWdd
d_Y^j
Wbb[
Wbj[d
:di_Y^j[d
kdZ
F[_dkd][d
X[^Wbj[d
kdZ
d[k[
[hm[hX[d(
FWd
ckii
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
e\\[d
i[_d&
kc
Z_[
Wbj[d
Wk\pk][X[d&
pkc_dZ[ij
[_d[
S[_j
bWd](
FWd
ckii
\s^_]
i[_d&
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
led
=_ip_fb_d
[_dpki[' ^[d(
P_bb[
aWdd
d_Y^j
[hp[k]j
m[hZ[d&
m[dd
cWd
d_Y^j
[_d[
][m_ii[
=_ip_fb_d
Wap[fj_[hj( 6RPNCLPIV#
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
[_d
F[diY^
muhZ[
ZkhY^
`[cWdZ
WdZ[h[d
X[mkiij
][cWY^j5
[h
m_hZ
pk
[_d[c
Bdijhkc[dj
_d
Z[d
AsdZ[d
WdZ[h[h(
=_[
[_][d[d
:dijh[d]kd][d
i_dZ
dejm[dZ_]&
Z[dd
iedij
m_hZ
[_d
F[diY^&
WkY^
m[dd
[h
X[mkiij
][cWY^j
mkhZ[&
d_Y^j
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
i[_d
;[mkiiji[_d
Wdpkm[dZ[d(
>i
b_[]j
_d
Z[h
GWjkh
Z[h
LWY^[&
ZWii
;[mkiiji[_d
kdZ
P_bb[
d_Y^j
][iY^[daj
m[hZ[d
atdd[d(
FWd
ckii
Wbb[i
[haWk\[d5
d_Y^ji
m_hZ
kciedij
][][X[d(
=Wi
iY^m_[h_]ij[
_ij
pk
b[hd[d&
m_[
cWd
X[pW^' b[d
aWdd(
FWd
X[aeccj
][dWk
ie
l_[b&
m_[
cWd
X[pW^bj&
WX[h
m[dd
Z_[i
_d
m[d_][d
Pehj[d
[habshj
m[hZ[d
atddj[&
XhWkY^j[
cWd
d_Y^j
pkh
LY^kb[
pk
][^[d( P[dd
L_[
l[hij[^[d&
mWi
>djm_Yabkd]
X[Z[kj[j&
m[hZ[d
L_[
i[^[d&
ZWii
Z[h
F[diY^
i_Y^
dkh
ZkhY^
i[_d[
[_][d[d
:dijh[d' ]kd][d
[djm_Ya[bd
aWdd(
=[h
P_bb[
aWdd
i_Y^
d_Y^j
c[Y^Wd_iY^
[djm_Ya[bd5
;[mkiiji[_d
aWdd
i_Y^
d_Y^j
kdX[mkiij
[djm_Ya[bd&
[i
aWdd
d_Y^j
Wki
d_Y^ji
^[hWki
mWY^i[d5
cWd
ckii
\uh
Wbb[i "#!

X[pW^b[d(
=Wi
\u^hj
kdi
m_[Z[h
pk
LY^kb[d
kdZ
Z[h
?hW][&
mWhkc
cWd
\uh
[_d[
LY^kb[
X[h[_j
i[_d
ckii(
FWd
ckii
i[_d[
L_jkWj_ed
[ha[dd[d
kdZ
X[h[_j
i[_d
pk
X[pW^b[d(
C[
c[^h
cWd
X[h[_j
_ij
pk
X[pW^b[d&
Z[ije
c[^h
[hm_hXj
cWd(
G_Y^ji
aWdd
][iY^[daj
m[h' Z[d(
=Wii[bX[
]_bj
\uh
F_jb[_Z(
P[dd
cWd
[jmWi
X[i_jpj
kdZ
[i
iY^[da[d
ctY^j[&
ie
aWdd
cWd
ZWi
d_Y^j(
=_[
GWjkh
Z[h
LWY^[&
Z_[
cWd
][X[d
ctY^j[&
_ij
ie
X[iY^W\\[d&
ZWii
Z_[
E[kj[
ZW\uh
X[pW^b[d
K\PPCL#
FWd
aWdd
i_[
d_Y^j
ZWpk
l[hWdbWii[d&
i_[
Wdpkd[^c[d5
i_[
cuii[d
i_[
i[^h
ijWha
mebb[d
kdZ
X[h[_j
i[_d&
ZW\uh
pk
X[pW^b[d(
>i
]_Xj
a[_d[d
WdZ[h[d
P[](
Gkh
ZWdd
aWdd
i_[
_^h
>_][djkc
m[hZ[d5
WdZ[h[d\Wbbi
_ij
i_[
l[hbeh[d( ;[pW^b[d
_ij
[jmWi
ltbb_]
WdZ[h[i
Wbi
@[bZ
][X[d
eZ[h
[jmWi
s^db_Y^[i(
;[pW^b[d
_ij
[_d
Ih_dp_f(
@[bZ
kdZ
=_[dij[
pk
][X[d
_ij
[_d[
?hW][
Z[h
Ft]b_Y^a[_j(
Nd]buYab_Y^[hm[_i[
]_Xj
[i
dkh
ZWi
[_d[
Pehj
y;[pW^b[dz&
ie
ZWii
[i
_d
kdj[hiY^_[Zb_Y^[c
L_dd
l[hmWdZj
m[hZ[d
ckii(
;[pW^b[d
c_j
@[bZ
^sd]j
^WkfjisY^b_Y^
lec
O[hijsdZd_i
WX&
j[_bm[_i[
led
Z[h
Ft]b_Y^a[_j(
=_[
WdZ[h[
;[pW^bkd]
_ij
m_Y^j_][h&
kdZ
cWd
ckii
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
i_[
kdX[' Z_d]j
dejm[dZ_]
_ij( -O?EC#
BY^
c[ha[&
ZWii
_Y^
\uh
kdc_jj[bXWh[
>h][Xd_ii[
WhX[_' j[&
d_Y^j
ZW\uh&
Wk\pkmWY^[d(
Bij
ZWi
[_d
\WbiY^[i
S_[b9 6RPNCLPIV#
>i
_ij
^_[h
a[_d[
?hW][
led
h_Y^j_]
kdZ
\WbiY^5
[i
][^j
b[Z_]b_Y^
ZWhkc&
B^h
S_[b
pk
a[dd[d(
=Wi
S_[b
ckii
_cc[h
_d
Z[h
@[][dmWhj
b_[][d
kdZ
i_Y^
Wk\
Z_[
Skakd\j
X[p_[^[d( -O?EC#
=[h
O[hikY^&
c[_d
S_[b
pk
Z[\_d_[h[d&
^Wj
c_h
][p[_]j&
ZWii
_Y^
d_Y^j
m[_ii&
mWi
[i
_ij
kdZ
ZWii
_Y^
[i
^[hWki\_dZ[d
ckii&
X[leh
_Y^
m[_j[haecc[d
aWdd( 6RPNCLPIV#
BY^
\uhY^j[&
L_[
Z[da[d
dkh
Wk\
[_d[
WXijhWaj[
:hj
ZWhuX[h
dWY^(
Lj[bb[d
i_[
i_Y^
[_d\WY^
leh&
L_[
]_d][d
_d
[_d
]heii[i
@[iY^s\j
c_j
l_[b[d
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
:Xj[_bkd][d(
L_[
cui' i[d
m_ii[d&
mWi
L_[
aWk\[d
mebb[d(
P_[
atdd[d
L_[
[jmWi
X[' aecc[d&
m[dd
L_[
d_Y^j
m_ii[d&
mWi
L_[
mebb[d9
:k\
Z_[i[
:hj
cuii[d
m_h
ZWi
IheXb[c
Wd][^[d(
=_[
[hij[
?hW][
_ij4
=?P
mebb[d
L_[9
P[dd
L_[
Z_[i
[_dcWb
m_ii[d&
m_hZ
Z_[
dsY^ij[
?hW][
bWkj[d4
Ee^dj
[i
i_Y^&
ZW\uh
pk
X[pW^b[d
kdZ
^WX[d
L_[
][dk]
@[bZ9
:X[h
Z_[
[hij[
?hW][
_ij4
yPWi9z "#"

;[pW^bkd]
_ij
[_d
i[^h
m_Y^j_][i
Ih_dp_f
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
kdZ
[i
ckii
l[hijWdZ[d
m[hZ[d&
ZWii
i_[
WXiebkj
dejm[dZ_]
_ij(
H^d[
;[pW^bkd]
atdd[d
L_[
d_Y^ji
X[aecc[d5
kdZ
L_[
atdd[d
dkh
ie
l_[b
X[aecc[d&
m_[
L_[
X[pW^b[d
'
d_Y^j
c[^h( Bd
I[j[hiXkh]
mkhZ[
Z_[
?hW][
][ij[bbj4
yP[dd
cWd
c[^h
kdZ
c[^h
kdZ
c[^h
X[pW^bj&
iekdZie
l_[b&
aWdd
cWd
[jmWi
X[aec' c[d9z
=Wi
X[Z[kj[j
Hf\[h(
:X[h
[i
ZWh\
d_Y^j
pk
l_[b
>_][dm_bb[
ZW
i[_d&
d_Y^j
[_dcWb
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Hf\[h( -O?EC#
Dtdd[d
m_h
_d
kdi[h[c
][][dmshj_][d
SkijWdZ
X[kh' j[_b[d&
mWi
[_d[
cehWb_iY^[
AWdZbkd]
_ij9 6RPNCLPIV#
>i
_ij
i[^h
b[_Y^j&
?[^b[h
pk
cWY^[d&
WX[h
]b[_Y^' p[_j_]
atdd[d
m_h
Z_[i
X[khj[_b[d(
P_h
X[]_dd[d
[hij(
C[
]htii[h
kdi[h[
Dedjhebb[&
Z[ije
]htii[h
kdi[h
;[mkiiji[_d4
kdZ
;[mkiij' i[_d
_d
Z_[i[c
L_dd[
kc\Wiij
P_bb[d(
Bd
kdi[h[c
][mt^db_Y^[d
SkijWdZ&
e^d[
Dedjhebb[&
atdd[d
m_h
dkh
uX[h
^[hatccb_Y^[
FehWb
ifh[Y^[d&
WX[h
m[dd
m_h
[_d_][
Dedjhebb[
^WX[d&
m[hZ[d
m_h
l[hWdjmehjb_Y^[h(
C[
kdX[mkiij[h
m_h
i_dZ&
Z[ije
c[^h
ct' ][d
kdi[h[
AWdZbkd][d
_c
P_Z[hifhkY^
pkh
FehWb
ij[^[d(
:k\
`[Z[d
?Wbb
_ij
Z_[
[hij[
;[Z_d]kd]
\uh
cehWb_iY^[i
AWdZ[bd&
ZWii
[i
X[mkiij
i[_d
ckii(

"##

$)+'5-7)
#)*:,/)

#37/
)>7;2/:/
/3731/9
./9
(/./7
GCJ
RLB
=COQPAFZQWRLE
"
9CJ@PQ",OGLLCOL
?JP
4GQQCJ!
RK
KGQ
LCE?QGSCL
.CD\FJCL
WR
IZKNDCL
"
(JJC
LCE?QGSCL
.CD\FJC
PGLB
PAFJCAFQ
RLB
CGL
>CGAFCL
SML
9AFTZAFC
"
5CE?QGSC
.CD\FJC
I[LLCL
WRK
Zb[i&
d_Y^ji
LY^td[i
eZ[h
LjWha[i
[dj^Wbj[d(
Bd
PW^h^[_j
X[_d^Wbj[d
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
d_Y^ji
Wbi
LY^msY^[
kdZ
i[^h
e\j
Z[d
;[]_dd
led
Aoij[' h_[&
DhWda^[_j
eZ[h
O[hXh[Y^[d(
=Wi
[_dp_]
@kj[
Wd
_^d[d
_ij&
ZWii
i_[
e^d[
O[hbkij
p[hijthj
m[hZ[d
atdd[d&
ZW
i_[
ltbb_]
dkjpbei
kdZ
audijb_Y^
Wki
>_dX_bZkd]
kdZ
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
][iY^W\' \[d
i_dZ
'
kdZ
Z_[i
_ij
Z_[
[_dp_][
djiY^kbZ_]kd][d
\uh
i_[
kdZ
iY^m_cc[d
_d
[_d[c
F[[h
led
L[bXijc_jb[_Z
eZ[h
L[bXij' ikY^j&
m_[
[i
][hWZ[
i[_d
cW]&
kdZ
[djZ[Ya[d
?[^b[h
Wd
Wbb[c
Wkii[h
Wd
kdi
i[bXij(

$yBZ[dj_\_p_[h[dz
eZ[h
yBZ[dj_\_aWj_edz
_ij
[_d
c[hamuhZ_][h
SkijWdZ&
_d
Z[c
Z[h
F[diY^
kd][\s^h
Z_[
Asb\j[
i[_d[i
E[X[di
l[hXh_d]j&
ms^h[dZ
Z_[
WdZ[h[
Asb\j[
_d
lebbijsdZ_][c
LY^bW\
pk][XhWY^j
m_hZ(
>h
_Z[dj_\_p_[hj
i_Y^
c_j
Wbb[c4
c_j
Z[c&
mWi
[h
iW]j&
mWi
[h
\u^bj&
mWi
[h
]bWkXj&
mWi
[h
d_Y^j
]bWkXj&
mWi
[h
mudiY^j&
mWi
[h
d_Y^j
mudiY^j&
mWi
_^d
Wdp_[^j&
mWi
_^d
WXijtiij(
:bb[i
m_hZ
CO!
eZ[h
X[ii[h&
CO
m_hZ
CP#
>h
m_hZ
pk
Wbb[c&
mWi
[h
cW]&
kdZ
mWi
[h
WXb[^dj(
=Wi
X[Z[kj[j&
ZWii
Z[h
F[diY^
_c
SkijWdZ
Z[h
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
kd\s^_]
_ij&
i_Y^
][iedZ[hj
lec
HX`[aj
i[_d[h
BZ[dj_\_' aWj_ed
pk
i[^[d(
>i
msh[
iY^m[h&
WkY^
dkh
ZWi
Db[_dij[
pk
\_dZ[d&
c_j
Z[c
Z[h
F[diY^
i_Y^
d_Y^j
_Z[dj_\_p_[h[d
atddj[(
@b[_Y^p[_j_]
^Wj
Z[h
F[diY^
_d
[_d[c
SkijWdZ
Z[h
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
ie]Wh
deY^
m[d_][h
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
i[_d[
c[Y^Wd_iY^[d
K[Waj_ed[d
Wbi
pk
`[Z[h
WdZ[h[d
S[_j(
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed&
_^h[
;[Z[kjkd]&
NhiWY^[d
kdZ
P_hakd][d&
m_hZ
skii[hij
]kj
_d
=OGQGLEP
DOMK
QFC
7FGJMI?JG?
led
>(
DWZbekXeliao
kdZ
@(
>(
IWbc[h&
EedZed
+3/+&
L(
--2&
IWh(
-.
'
0&
X[iY^h_[X[d(

"#)

# ;[leh
m[_j[h[i
uX[h
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
][iW]j
m[hZ[d
aWdd&
iebbj[d
m_h
]Wdp
akhp
Z_[
]hkdZb[][dZ[
Oehij[bbkd]
h[aWf_jkb_[' h[d&
Wk\
Z[h
kdi[h
LjkZ_kc
Z[i
F[diY^[d
]hudZ[j(
=[h
F[diY^&
m_[
m_h
_^d
a[dd[d&
_ij
a[_d
lebbijsdZ_][i
P[i[d5
Z_[
GWjkh
[djm_Ya[bj
_^d
X_i
pk
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
Ikdaj
kdZ
uX[hbsiij
[i
ZWdd
_^c&
i_Y^
[djm[Z[h
Wki
i[_d[d
[_][d[d
:dijh[d]kd][d
kdZ
F_jj[bd
m[_j[h
pk
[djm_Ya[bd
eZ[h
ie
pk
b[X[d
kdZ
pk
ij[hX[d&
m_[
[h
][Xeh[d
mehZ[d
_ij(
=[h
F[diY^
iY^h[_Xj
i_Y^
l_[b[
Dhs\j[&
?s^_]a[_j[d
kdZ
>_][diY^W\j[d
pk&
Z_[
_^c
d_Y^j
][^t' h[d&
kdZ
Z_[
_^c
d_[cWbi
][^th[d
m[hZ[d&
[^[
[h
i_Y^
d_Y^j
pk
[_d[c
\[hj_][d
P[i[d
[djm_Ya[bj
^Wj(
=[h
F[diY^
[ha[ddj
d_Y^j&
ZWii
[h
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
[_d[
FWiY^_d[
_ij&
e^d[
kdWX^sd]_][
;[m[]kd][d&
Z_[
ZkhY^
skii[h[
>_d\buii[
_d
@Wd]
][i[jpj
m_hZ(
=_[
m_Y^j_]ij[
Z[h
JkWb_jsj[d&
Z_[
Z[h
F[diY^
i_Y^
pkiY^h[_Xj&
WX[h
d_Y^j
X[i_jpj&
_ij
;[mkiiji[_d(
F_j
;[mkiiji[_d
c[_d[d
m_h
[_d[
X[iedZ[h[
:hj
led
@[mW^hi[_d
_c
F[diY^[d&
@[mW^hi[_d
i[_d[h
i[bXij&
@[mW^hi[_d
Z[ii[d&
mWi
[h
_ij&
mWi
[h
\u^bj
eZ[h
Z[daj
eZ[h
mWi
[h
_c
:k][dXb_Ya
_ij(
L_[
cuii[d
ZWhWd
Z[da[d&
ZWii
Z[h
F[diY^
d_Y^j
Z_[
]Wdp[
S[_j
uX[h
]b[_Y^csii_]
X[mkiij
_ij&
kdZ
ZWii
m_h&
[djifh[Y^[dZ
Z[h
:hj&
Wk\
Z_[
m_h
Z[d
F[d' iY^[d
ijkZ_[h[d&
X[huYai_Y^j_][d&
ZWii
[h
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
pk
l_[h
;[mkiiji[_dipkijsdZ[d
^Wj(
=_[i[
i_dZ4
9AFJ?D!
=?AFWRPQ?LB
MBCO
OCJ?QGSCP
)CTRPPQPCGL!
BCO
BOGQQC
)CTRPPQPCGLPWRPQ?LB
MBCO
9CJ@PQ@CTRPPQPCGL
kdZ
BCO
SGCOQC
)CTRPPQPCGLPWRPQ?LB
MBCO
M@HCI" QGSCP
)CTRPPQPCGL!
WX[h
_c
][mt^db_Y^[d
E[X[d
m[_ii
Z[h
F[diY^
d_Y^ji
lec
eX`[aj_l[d
;[mkiiji[_d&
kdZ
a[_d[
>nf[h_c[dj[
_d
Z_[i[h
K_Y^jkd]
i_dZ
ct]b_Y^(
MWjisY^b_Y^
b[Xj
Z[h
F[diY^
dkh
_d
pm[_
SkijsdZ[d4
>_d[d
M[_b
i[_d[i
E[X[di
l[hXh_d]j
[h
_c
LY^bW\
kdZ
Z[d
WdZ[h[d
_d
Z[c&
Z[h
PWY^pkijWdZ
][dWddj
m_hZ&
eX' me^b
[h
i_Y^
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
dkh
i[^h
m[d_]
lec
LY^bW\
kdj[h' iY^[_Z[j(
P[dd
m_h
led
;[mkiiji[_d
ifh[Y^[d&
X[p_[^[d
m_h
kdi
ZW^[h
Wk\
[_d[d
SkijWdZ
]htii[h[d
;[mkiiji[_di
Wbi
kdi[h[d
][mt^db_Y^[d
PWY^pkijWdZ(
P_h
^WX[d
a[_d[
A[hhiY^W\j
uX[h
Z_[i[d
SkijWdZ&
WX[h
m_h
^WX[d
[_d[
][m_ii[
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
Z_[ "#*

:hj&
m_[
m_h
ZWhuX[h
Z[da[d&
kdZ
m_h
atdd[d
kdi[h
=[da[d
Z[h][ijWbj
Wk\XWk[d&
ZWii
[i
;[mkiiji[_d
Xh_d]j(
BdZ[c
m_h
kdi[h[d
@[ZWda[d
[_d[
K_Y^jkd]
][X[d&
Z_[
i_[
_d
[_d[c
:k][d' Xb_Ya
Z[i
;[mkiiji[_di
^sjj[d&
atdd[d
m_h
;[mkiiji[_d
^[hlehhk' \[d(
=_[i[
IhWaj_a
d[dd[d
m_h
9CJ@PQ",OGLLCOL# P[_j[h^_d
ifhWY^[d
m_h
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
kdi[h
LjkZ_kc
Z[i
F[d' iY^[d
led
Z[h
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j&
Z_[
l_[h
AWkfj\kdaj_ed[d
Z[h
c[diY^b_Y^[d
FWiY^_d[
pk
l[hij[^[d
'
=[da[d&
?u^b[d&
;[m[' ]kd]&
Bdij_daj
'
kdZ
pk
l[hikY^[d&
Z_[
JkWb_jsjikdj[hiY^_[Z[
_^h[h
FWd_\[ijWj_ed
_d
`[Z[c
Z[h
Zh[_
;[mkiiji[_dipkijsdZ[
pk
X[eXWY^j[d(
:bb[
l_[h
?kdaj_ed[d
atdd[d
i_Y^
_c
LY^bW\
cWd_\[' ij_[h[d&
WX[h
_^h[
FWd_\[ijWj_ed[d
i_dZ
\buY^j_]
kdZ
kdpkl[hbsi' i_]5
i_[
atdd[d
_d
a[_d[h
P[_i[
X[dkjpj
m[hZ[d&
i_[
bWk\[d
led
Wbb[_d[
WX(
Bc
SkijWdZ
Z[i
h[bWj_l[d
;[mkiiji[_di
eZ[h
PWY^pk' ijWdZi
atdd[d
i_[
_d
[_d[c
][m_ii[d
:kicWii
kdi[h[h
Hh_[dj_[' hkd]
Z_[d[d(
B^h[
>h][Xd_ii[
atdd[d
l[h]b_Y^[d&
uX[hfhu\j&
_d
h_Y^j_][
HhZdkd]
][XhWY^j
m[hZ[d&
kdZ
eXme^b
i_[
l_[b[
Bbbki_e' d[d
[hp[k][d
atdd[d&
^WX[d
m_h
_d
kdi[h[c
][][dmshj_][d
SkijWdZ
d_Y^ji
WdZ[h[i
kdZ
cuii[d
ZWi
;[ij[
Wki
_^d[d
cWY^[d(
P[dd
m_h
Z_[
F[d][
\WbiY^[h
;[eXWY^jkd][d&
\WbiY^[h
M^[e' h_[d&
\WbiY^[h
LY^buii[
kdZ
:Xb[_jkd][d
a[dd[d
muhZ[d&
Z_[
_d
Z_[i[c
SkijWdZ
][cWY^j
m[hZ[d&
muhZ[d
m_h
]Wdp
kdZ
]Wh
Wkb^th[d&
kdi
pk
]bWkX[d(
:X[h
Z_[
F[diY^[d
[ha[dd[d
d_Y^j&
m_[
jhu][h_iY^
_^h[
;[eXWY^jkd][d
kdZ
_^h[
M^[eh_[d
i[_d
atd' d[d&
kdZ
i_[
]bWkX[d
m[_j[h^_d
Wd
i_[(
@[hWZ[
Z_[i
^sbj
Z[d
F[diY^[d
ZWled
WX&
Z_[
i[bj[d[d
:k][dXb_Ya[
pk
X[eXWY^j[d&
m[dd
_^h[
?kdaj_ed[d
i_Y^
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
LY^_cc[hd
Z[i
Zh_jj[d
;[mkiiji[_dipkijWdZ[i
eZ[h
L[bXijX[mkiiji[_di
cWd_\[' ij_[h[d( ?kdaj_ed[d
pk
X[eXWY^j[d&
_ij
[_d[
bWd][
:hX[_j(
FWd
ckii
\uh
`[Z[
pW^bh[_Y^[
;[_if_[b[
\_dZ[d(
;[_c
LjkZ_kc
X[]_dd[d
m_h
pk
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
m_h
d_Y^j
Wbb[i
Wk\
Z[hi[bX[d
>X[d[
ijkZ_[h[d
atdd[d&
ZWii
m_h
kdi
d_Y^j
i[bXij
kdX[\Wd][d
X[eXWY^j[d
atd' d[d(
P_h
i[^[d
kdm[_][hb_Y^&
ZWii
[_d_][
?kdaj_ed[d
lec
@[' $
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
m_hZ
_d
(RD
BCO
9RAFC
L?AF
BCK
=RLBCO@?OCL
led
I(=(Hkif[d'
iao&
;[hd&
FudY^[d&
P_[d
+300&
L(
+02
\\(
X[iY^h_[X[d(

"$!

i_Y^jifkdaj
kdi[h[i
S_[bi
Wki
h_Y^j_]
kdZ
WdZ[h[
kd[hmudiY^j
i_dZ(
NdZ
m_h
cuii[d
[_d
S_[b
^WX[d&
iedij
aWdd
a[_d
LjkZ_kc
_h][dZm[bY^[
>h][Xd_ii[
Xh_d][d(
P[dd
m_h
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
m_h
iY^bW\[d&
_ij
ZWi
S_[b
Wk\pkmWY^[d5
m[dd
m_h
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
m_h
FWiY^_d[d
i_dZ&
_ij
ZWi
S_[b&
Wk\pk^th[d
FWiY^_d[d
pk
i[_d(
P[dd
m_h
X[mkiij[h
i[_d
mebb[d&
cuii[d
m_h
ZWhuX[h
dWY^Z[d' a[d&
mWi
kdi
ZWled
WX^sbj&
kdi
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd(
:bie
cuii[d
m_h
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
P[hjkd]
Z[h
?kdaj_ed[d
led
Z[c
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Wki
[_d\u^h[d&
eX
i_[
\uh
ZWi
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
dujpb_Y^
eZ[h
iY^sZb_Y^
i_dZ( P[dd
L_[
[_d[
[hdij^W\j[
:dijh[d]kd]
kdj[hd[^c[d&
?kda' j_ed[d
kc
_^h[h
i[bXij
m_bb[d
pk
X[eXWY^j[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
>_d[i
[ha[dd[d(
L_[
m[hZ[d
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
\uh
][mt^db_Y^
X[_
Wbb[c&
mWi
L_[
jkd&
X[_
Wbb[c&
mWi
L_[
Z[da[d&
X[_
Wbb[c&
mWi
L_[
\u^b[d&
d_Y^j
B^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd(
@b[_Y^p[_j_]
m[hZ[d
L_[
c[h' a[d&
ZWii
L_[&
m[dd
L_[
\uh
[_d[
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
bWd][
S[_j
][du][d' Z[
:dijh[d]kd][d
kdj[hd[^c[d&
B^h[
?s^_]a[_j
pkc
L[bXij' >h_dd[hd
ij[_][hd
atdd[d(
L_[
m[hZ[d
X[]_dd[d&
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
^sk\_][h
kdZ
j_[\[h
pk
[h_dd[hd5
L_[
m[hZ[d
X[]_dd[d&
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
c[^h
BZ[[d
pk
[h_dd[hd&
m_[
Z[h
BZ[[
Z[i
;[mkiiji[_di&
Z[h
BZ[[
Z[h
:hX[_j
kdZ
Z[h
BZ[[
Z[i
L[bXij' ijkZ_kci( =_[
?hW][
_ij4
P_[
iebb[d
m_h
kdi
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd&
m_[
iebb[d
m_h
kdi
kdi[h[h
i[bXij
][mW^h[h
m[hZ[d9 P[dd
L_[
[hdij^W\j
uX[h
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
dWY^Z[da[d&
m[h' Z[d
L_[
c[ha[d&
ZWii
i_[
Z_[
AWkfj\Wajeh[d
i_dZ&
Z_[
kdi
Wc
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
^_dZ[hd(
:bie
aWdd
ZWi
>_d[
d_Y^j
e^d[
ZWi
:dZ[h[
][^[d(
L_[
atdd[d
a[_d[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
X[ascf\[d&
e^d[
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
c[^h
pk
[h_dd[hd&
kdZ
L_[
atdd[d
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
d_Y^j
c[^h
[h_dd[hd&
e^d[
c_j
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
pk
ascf\[d(

"$"

Nc
Z[d
DWcf\
c_j
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
Wk\pkd[^c[d&
ckii
cWd
pkWbb[h[hij
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
[i
a[_d
[_dp_][i
dujpb_Y^[i
d[]Wj_l[i
@[\u^b
]_Xj(
G[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
i_dZ
Wbb[
]b[_Y^
uX[b
kdZ
[_d
S[_Y^[d
led
LY^msY^[(
:bi
dsY^ij[i
cuii[d
m_h
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
m_h
c_j
_^d[d
ascf\[d
I[LLCL!
ZWii
i_[
X[i_[]j
kdZ
p[hijthj
m[hZ[d
atdd[d&
m[_b
[i
a[_d
m_hab_Y^[i
S[djhkc
\uh
i_[
]_Xj(
P[dd
[i
[_d
m_hab_Y^[i
S[djhkc
\uh
i_[
]sX[&
^sjj[d
m_h
a[_d[
ce' j_ed[d
ltbb_]
kddujp
i_dZ&
ZWii
i_[
a[_d[
XhWkY^XWh[
?kdaj_ed
_d
kdi[h[c
E[X[d
^WX[d
kdZ
ZWii
ZeY^
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
ZWi
]Wdp[
E[X[d
Wk\
_^d[d
X[hk^j(
@[dWk
Z_[i
[ha[ddj
d_[cWdZ( >_d[
Z[h
ijshaij[d
Bbbki_ed[d
_ij
Z[h
@bWkX[&
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
muhZ[d
led
skii[h[d
NcijsdZ[d
X[m_haj&
kdZ
m_h
ifh[Y^[d
ZWled&
yWki
[_d[c
ltbb_]
][h[Y^j[d
@hkdZz
sh][hb_Y^
pk
i[_d&
WX[h
Wbb[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
i_dZ
_d
kdi&
GL
RLPCOCK
0LLCOCL#
;[leh
m_h
c_j
_^d[d
pk
ascf\[d
X[]_dd[d
atdd[d&
cuii[d
m_h
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
[i
a[_d[
X[h[Y^j_]j[d
@hudZ[
]_Xj&
sh][hb_Y^
pk
i[_d(
P_h
]bWkX[d
'
kdZ
m_h
]bWkX[d
[i
][hd[
'
ZWii
kdi[h[
d[]Wj_l[d
>cej_ed[d
[djm[Z[h
ZkhY^
Z[d
?[^b[h
WdZ[h[h
E[kj[
eZ[h
ZkhY^
Z[d
?[^b[h
Z[h
NcijsdZ[
X[m_haj
m[hZ[d(
=Wi
_ij
[_d[
Bbbki_ed(
F[_d
qh][h
b_[]j
d_Y^j
_c
:dbWii&
iedZ[hd
_d
c_h(
B^h
qh][h
b_[]j
d_Y^j
_c
:dbWii&
[h
_ij
_d
B^d[d(
=_[
@hudZ[
\uh
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
b_[][d
d_Y^j
_d
skii[h[d
:dbsii[d&
i_[
b_[][d
_d
kdi
i[bXij(
>i
]_Xj
WXiebkj
a[_d[d
[_dp_][d
kdl[hc[_ZXWh[d
@hkdZ&
mWhkc
Z_[
AWdZbkd]
[_d[i
WdZ[h[d
eZ[h
][m_ii[
Nc' "$#

ijsdZ[
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
_d
c_h
fheZkp_[h[d
iebbj[d(
>i
_ij
Wbb[_d
c[_d[
LY^msY^[( P[dd
L_[
i_Y^
i[bXij
X[eXWY^j[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
i[^[d&
ZWii
Z_[
skii[h[d
@hudZ[&
eXme^b
i_[
Z_[i[bX[d
Xb[_X[d&
cWdY^cWb
d[]W' j_l[
@[\u^b[
_d
B^d[d
X[m_ha[d
kdZ
cWdY^cWb
d_Y^j(
=[h
@hkdZ
^_[h\uh
_ij&
ZWii
Z[h
mW^h[
:dbWii
\uh
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
_d
B^d[d
b_[]j
kdZ
ZWi
skii[h[
>h[_]d_i
dkh
Z[h
iY^[_dXWh[
@hkdZ
_ij(
P[dd
L_[
_d
[_d[c
]kj[d
SkijWdZ
i_dZ&
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
[h_dd[hd&
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^
d_Y^j
_Z[dj_\_p_[h[d&
ZWdd
'
h[bWj_l
][' ifheY^[d
kdZ
DWjWijhef^[d
Wki][decc[d
'
aWdd
d_Y^ji&
ZWi
ZhWkii[d
][iY^_[^j&
[_d
d[]Wj_l[i
@[\u^b
_d
B^d[d
X[m_ha[d(
P[dd
L_[
_d
[_d[c
iY^b[Y^j[d
SkijWdZ
i_dZ&
_Z[dj_\_p_[hj&
_d
[_d[h
>_dX_bZkd]
l[hikda[d
eZ[h
[jmWi
q^db_Y^[i&
ZWdd
m_hZ
Wbb[i&
mWi
dkh
[_d
m[d_]
kdWd][d[^c
_ij&
[_d
^[\j_][i
@[\u^b
_d
B^d[d
^[hlehhk\[d( Bd
[_d[c
O[hikY^
pk
p[_][d&
ZWii
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
ZkhY^
skii[h[
:dbsii[
^[hleh][hk\[d
m[hZ[d&
m[hZ[d
cWdY^cWb
?hW' ][d
uX[h
=_d][
m_[
MhWk[h
X[_c
MeZ
[_d[i
?h[kdZ[i
kdZ
WdZ[h[
:hj[d
led
E[_Z[d
][ij[bbj(
E[_Z[d
_ij
Wd
i_Y^
a[_d
d[]Wj_l[i
@[\u^b(
>i
aWdd
dkh
ZWdd
[_d
d[]Wj_l[i
@[\u^b
X[m_ha[d&
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^
ZWc_j
_Z[dj_\_p_[h[d(
E[_Z[d
aWdd
m_hab_Y^
i[_d5
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
i_dZ
d_Y^j
m_hab_Y^(
LY^b_[iib_Y^
d_ccj
E[_Z
[_d[d
i[^h
ab[_d[d
M[_b
Z[i
E[X[di
[_d&
WX[h
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
d[^c[d
[_d[d
]heii[d
M[_b
[_d
'
i_[
[h\ubb[d
ZWi
][iWcj[
E[X[d(
NdZ
mWhkc9
P[_b
m_h
i_[
h[Y^j\[hj_][d(
P_h
]bWkX[d&
i_[
muhZ[d
ZkhY^
[_d[d
skii[h[d
@hkdZ
X[m_haj(
@[m_ii
i_dZ
E[kj[&
Z_[
lebb[h
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[
kdZ
G[]Wj_l_jsj
ij[Ya[d&
][[_]d[j&
s^d' b_Y^[
K[Waj_ed[d
_d
WdZ[h[d
E[kj[d
^[hlehpkhk\[d&
WX[h
cWd
ckii
b[hd[d&
i_Y^
_d
iebY^[d
?sbb[d
ZkhY^
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
kdZ
G_Y^j'BZ[dj_\_p_[h[d
WXpkiedZ[hd
kdZ
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
pk
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
:XiedZ[hkd]
d_Y^j
@b[_Y^]ubj_]a[_j
X[Z[kj[j(
P[dd
m_h
m_ii[d&
ZWii
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
d_Y^j
led
skii[h[d
:dbsii[d
X[' m_haj
m[hZ[d
atdd[d&
l[hiY^m_dZ[d
Z_[
c[_ij[d
led
_^d[d(
:X[h
Z_[
[hij[
;[Z_d]kd]
_ij&
ZWii
m_h
lebb
[ha[dd[d
cuii[d&
ZWii
i_[
LGAFQ
ZkhY^
skii[h[
NhiWY^[d
X[m_haj
m[hZ[d
I[LLCL!
m[dd
m_h
i_[
d_Y^j
pk
^WX[d
mudiY^[d(
>i
]_Xj
i_[
\uh
][mt^d' "$$

b_[^&
m[_b
m_h
i_[
pkbWii[d&
_^h[
@[][dmWhj
Wbi
Z_[
LY^kbZ
led
skii[h[d
:dbsii[d
[habsh[d&
ie
ZWii
m_h
d_Y^j
c_j
_^d[d
ascf' \[d(
G[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
e^d[
>_dX_bZkd]
[n_ij_[h[d(
>_d\WY^
LY^c[hp[d
pk
[hb[_Z[d&
_ij
a[_d[
d[]Wj_l[
>cej_ed&
WX[h
m[dd
>_dX_bZkd]
kdZ
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
^_dpk
aecc[d&
m[hZ[d
i_[
pk
[_d[c
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b(
>cej_edWb[h
LY^c[hp&
m_[
athf[hb_' Y^[h
LY^c[hp&
_ij
Wd
i_Y^
a[_d
d[]Wj_l[i
@[\u^b&
WX[h
m[dd
m_h
X[]_dd[d&
_^d
Wk\
Wbb[hb[_
:hj
WkipkiY^cuYa[d&
m_hZ
[h
[i(

Lfsj[h
m[hZ[d
m_h
pk
F[j^eZ[d
aecc[d&
kc
c_j
@[\u^b[d
i[bXij
pk
ascf\[d&
Z[dd
[i
]_Xj
l_[b[
kdZ
X[ij_ccj[
F[j^eZ[d&
Z_[
\uh
kdj[hiY^_[Zb_Y^[
@[\u^b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d
i_dZ&
WX[h
pk[hij
cuii[d
m_h
c_j
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
kdZ
>_dX_bZkd]
ascf\[d(
=_[
E[kj[
iY^h[_X[d
Z[c
Pehj
>_dX_bZkd]
[_d[
ltbb_]
audijb_Y^[
kdZ
]Wdp
kdl[hZ_[dj[
;[Z[kjkd]
pk&
_c
L_dd[
[_d[h
ah[Wj_l[d
eZ[h
i[b[aj_l[d
?s^_]a[_j(
>_dX_bZkd]
_ij
[_d[
p[hijth[h_iY^[
?s^_]' a[_j&
Z_[
d_Y^j
X[^[hhiY^j
m[hZ[d
aWdd(
P_h
X[]_dd[d&
kdi
[jmWi
[_dpkX_bZ[d&
kc
kdi
i[bXij
pk
][\Wbb[d&
kdZ
i[^h
e\j
\Wd][d
m_h
Wd&
[i
pk
]bWkX[d&
eZ[h
pkc_dZ[ij
[_d[d
M[_b
ZWled(
>_dX_bZkd]
X[ij[^j
_c
Wbb][c[_d[d
ZWh_d&
i_Y^
_h][dZ[_d
P_ii[d&
[_d[
DhW\j&
[_d[
JkWb_jsj
pkpkiY^h[_X[d&
Z_[
cWd
d_Y^j
X[i_jpj(
=_[i
_ij
[_d[
][\s^hb_Y^[
>_dX_bZkd]&
ms^h[dZ
[i
^Whcbei
kdZ
ie]Wh
Wd][' d[^c
i[_d
aWdd&
i_Y^
=_d][
[_d\WY^
_d
Z[d
L_dd
aecc[d
pk
bWii[d
eZ[h
i_Y^
MW]jhskc[d
^_dpk][X[d&
iebWd][
Z_[i
\h[_
led
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
][iY^_[^j(
=_[i[h
DWcf\
c_j
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
kdZ
>_dX_bZkd]
h[_Y^j
Wki&
l_[b[
Z[h
uXb_Y^[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
pk
p[hijth[d
'
Wk\
`[Z[d
?Wbb&
i_[
l_[b
b[_Y^j[h
pk
cWY^[d(
L_[
cuii[d
^_[hc_j
Wd\Wd][d&
Z[dd
L_[
atdd[d
dkh
ZWdd
c_j
Z[c
>_diWjp
ijsha[h[h
F[j^eZ[d
][][d
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
Wd][^[d&
m[dd
L_[
pk
[_d[c
][m_ii[d
:kicWii
c_j
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
ascf\[d
atdd[d&
kdZ
m[dd
L_[
d[]Wj_l[
>_dX_bZkd]
X[h[_ji
][ijeffj
^WX[d(
=Wc_j
ckii
lebbijsdZ_]
Wk\][^thj
m[hZ[d(
>i
_ij
pm[Ya' bei&
m[_j[h[
F[j^eZ[d
pk
b[hd[d&
X[leh
Z_[i
][jWd
_ij(
P[dd
L_[ "

%$ l[hikY^[d&
>_dX_bZkd]
pk
X[i[_j_][d&
X[ij[^j
a[_d[
@[\W^h&
m_ha' b_Y^[i
?u^b[d
WkipkiY^b_[ii[d5
m[dd
[i
[Y^j
_ij&
aWdd
[i
d_Y^j
X[i[_j_]j
m[hZ[d(
G[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
I[LLCL
L_[
ijeff[d&
kdZ
Wbb[_d[
ZWi
LjkZ_kc
Z[h
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
m_hZ
i_[
X[h[_ji
l[hc_d' Z[hd&
WX[h
Z[h
m_hab_Y^[
DWcf\
c_j
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
i[bXij
X[]_ddj
ifsj[h(
>h
X[hk^j
pk
Wbb[h[hij
Wk\
h_Y^j_][c
O[hij[^[d&
m_[
i_[
[hp[k]j
m[hZ[d&
mWi
^_dj[h
_^d[d
ij[^j&
m_[
dkjpbei
i_[
i_dZ&
kdZ
m_[l_[b
L_[
l[hb_[h[d&
m[_b
L_[
i_Y^
ZWi
O[h]du][d
[hbWkX[d&
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
pk
^WX[d(
P[dd
L_[
[ha[dd[d&
m_[' l_[b
L_[
l[hb_[h[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
l_[bb[_Y^j
][dk]
>d[h]_[
^WX[d&
[jmWi
ZW][][d
pk
kdj[hd[^c[d(

L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
ZWi
Ljeff[d
Z[i
(RPBORAIP
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[
kdZ
Z[h
DWcf\
c_j
Z[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
i[bXij
pm[_
ltbb_]
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
Ndj[h\Wd][d
i_dZ(
Sk[hij
aeccj
Z[h
O[h' ikY^&
Z[d
:kiZhkYa
pk
ijeff[d(
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^ji
Wd
Z[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
i[bXij
sdZ[hd&
X_i
L_[
][b[hdj
^WX[d&
Z[h[d
:kiZhkYa
pk
ijeff[d(
P[dd
L_[
[_d[
][m_ii[
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
Z[d
:kiZhkYa
d[]Wj_l[h
>cej_ed[d
[hbWd]j
^WX[d&
atdd[d
L_[
X[' ]_dd[d&
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
i[bXij
pk
ijkZ_[h[d(
L_[
atdd[d
l[hik' Y^[d&
B^h[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
pk
abWii_\_p_[h[d(
L_[
atdd[d
^[h' Wki\_dZ[d&
m[bY^[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
L_[
^WkfjisY^b_Y^
^WX[d5
mWhkc
i_[
aecc[d&
mWi
i_[
^[hX[_\u^hj
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
B^h[
[_dp_][
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
ZkhY^
B^h[d
O[hijWdZ
][^j&
WX[h
Z_[
Dedjhebb[
jh_jj
d_Y^j
kdc_jj[bXWh
Wk\(
P[dd
L_[
i[Y^i
FedWj[
bWd]
h_Y^j_]
Z[da[d&
m[hZ[d
Z_[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
Wd][]h_\\[d
i[_d&
Z[dd
i_[
X[hk^[d
Wk\
\WbiY^[c
=[da[d(
P[dd
L_[
^[kj[
h_Y^j_]
pk
Z[da[d
X[]_d' d[d&
m[hZ[d
i_Y^
Z_[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
d_Y^j
ceh][d
][sdZ[hj
^WX[d5
WX[h
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
atdd[d
i_Y^
_dd[hj
i[Y^i
FedWj[d
][sdZ[hj
^WX[d&
m[dd
L_[
`[jpj
Wd\Wd][d&
h_Y^j_]
pk
Z[da[d(
=Wi
@[bsdZ[
ckii
[hij
lehX[h[_j[j
m[hZ[d(
P[dd
L_[
b[hd[d
atdd[d&
[_d[
h_Y^j_][
>_dij[bbkd]
B^h[h
K[_pXWha[_j
][][duX[h
pk
[hp[k' "$&

][d&
B^h[h
iY^b[Y^j[d
EWkd[&
B^h[c
F_iijhWk[d
eZ[h
m[bY^
kdWd' ][d[^c[i
@[\u^b
WkY^
_cc[h
L_[
Wc
^sk\_]ij[d
[hb[X[d
'
ZWdd
m_hZ
B^d[d
Z_[i[
>_dij[bbkd]&
dWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
^[b\[d&
ZWi
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b
_c
D[_c
pk
[hij_Ya[d(
GWY^Z[c
[i
[_dcWb
[_d[d
:d\Wd]
d[^c[d
Zkh\j[&
atdd[d
L_[
[i
d_Y^j
c[^h
ijeff[d(
P[dd
L_[
ZWii[bX[
[_dcWb
WkipkZhuYa[d
X[]_dd[d&
i_dZ
L_[
_d
i[_d[h
@[mWbj(
=[h
DWcf\
ckii
_d
B^h[c
O[hijWdZ
X[]_dd[d&
kdZ
L_[
cuii[d
B^h[d
P[]
\_dZ[d&
uX[h
[_d[d
X[ij_ccj[d
@[][dijWdZ
dWY^pkZ[da[d(
L_[
atdd[d
B^h[
EWkd[
d_Y^j
aedjhebb_[h[d&
m[dd
i_[
X[h[_ji
pkc
OehiY^[_d
aeccj(
>i
_ij
iY^ed
pk
ifsj5
i_[
_ij
X[h[_ji
^[hWki][ifhkd][d(
L_[
atdd[d
ie
[jmWi
m_[
@[\u^biWki' XhuY^[
pkc
;[_if_[b
dkh
Wk\
[_d[
:hj
X[^[hhiY^[d(
G[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
L_[
iebb[d
[_d[d
X[ij_ccj[d
F[diY^[d
jh[\\[d&
kdZ
d[^c[d
L_[
Wd&
[h
h[_pj
L_[(
PWdd
_cc[h
L_[
_^c
X[][]d[d&
d[_]j
B^h
M[cf[hWc[dj
ZWpk&
i_Y^
pk
p[_][d(
L_[
ct][d
[i
d_Y^j&
WX[h
m_[
atdd[d
L_[
[i
ijeff[d9
L_[
cuii[d
X[_
Z[h
:dWboi[
B^h[i
=[d' a[di
Wd\Wd][d(
PWi
BCLICL
L_[
uX[h
Z_[i[d
F[diY^[d
'
d_Y^j&
mWi
9GC
D\FJCL!
m[dd
L_[
][h[_pj
i_dZ&
iedZ[hd
mWi
Z[da[d
L_[
_d
hk^_][d
:k][dXb_Ya[d
uX[h
_^d9
L_[
ct][d
^[hWki\_dZ[d&
ZWii
L_[
_dd[hb_Y^
c_j
_^c
Wh]kc[dj_[h[d5
L_[
X[m[_i[d
_^c&
ZWii
[h
kdh[Y^j
^Wj5
L_[
iW][d
_^c
Wbb
i[_d[
?[^b[h5
L_[
\_dZ[d
Wbb][c[_d&
ZWii
[h
i_Y^
B^d[d
][][duX[h
\WbiY^
X[jhs]j(
>X[d
^_[h_d
^WX[d
L_[
kdh[Y^j(
L_[
cuii[d
b[hd[d&
h_Y^j_]
pk
Z[da[d5
L_[
cuii[d
Z[d
P[]
\_dZ[d&
h_Y^j_]
pk
Z[da[d(
P[dd
B^d[d
ZWi
][b_d]j&
m_hZ
\eb][dZ[i
][iY^[^[d4
HXme^b
ZWi
@[\u^b
l_[b
iY^d[bb[h
Wbi
Z[h
@[ZWda[
_ij&
_ij
ZWi
@[\u^b
[jmWi
OehuX[h][^[dZ[i&
aWdd
Z[h
@[ZWda[
X[ijsdZ_]
][cWY^j
m[hZ[d5
`[Z[icWb&
m[dd
ZWi
@[\u^b
^[hWkiifh_d]j&
jh_\\j
[i
Wk\
Z_[i[d
X[ijsdZ_][d
@[ZWda[d
kdZ
aWdd
i_Y^
d_Y^j
m[_j[h
cWd_\[ij_[h[d(
=W^[h
atdd[d
L_[
c_j
Z[c
:kiZhkYa
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[&
m_[
_d
Z_[i[c
;[_if_[b&
dkh
ascf' \[d&
m[dd
L_[
X[ijsdZ_][i&
h_Y^j_][i
=[da[d
iY^W\\[d(
P_h
m[h' Z[d
`[jpj
pk
Z[h
?hW][
pkhuYaa[^h[d&
mWi
c_j
h_Y^j_][c
=[da[d
kdZ
h_Y^j_][h
>_dij[bbkd]
Wbi
PW\\[d
][][d
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
][c[_dj
_ij(

"$'

' EWii[d
L_[
c_Y^
m_[Z[h^eb[d&
ZWii
L_[
Wbi
Wbb[h[hij[i
l[hij[^[d
K\PPCL!
m_[
\WbiY^
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
i_dZ&
m_[
kddujp
i_[
i_dZ&
kdZ
ZWdd
cuii[d
L_[
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
i_[
d_Y^j
e^d[
BZ[dj_\_aW' j_ed
X[ij[^[d
atdd[d(
L_[
m[hZ[d
bWd][
XhWkY^[d&
kc
Z_[i
pk
[ha[dd[d&
WX[h
m[dd
L_[
ie
m[_j
i_dZ&
cuii[d
L_[
l[hikY^[d&
B^h[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
_d
Zh[_
DWj[]eh_[d
[_dpkj[_b[d(
>hij[di&
Z_[
c[^h
eZ[h
m[d_][h
][mt^db_Y^[d&
Wbbjs]b_Y^[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[&
Z_[
i[^h
e\j
lehaecc[d
kdZ
_cc[h
c_j
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
l[hXkdZ[d
i_dZ(
@[m_ii
cuii[d
L_[
i_[
X[eXWY^j[d&
kdZ
L_[
cuii[d
X[h[_ji
[_d
][m_ii[
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
_^h[d
:kiZhkYa
^W' X[d(
=Wdd
cuii[d
L_[
Wd\Wd][d&
i_Y^
c_j
_^d[d
pk
X[\Wii[d&
_dZ[c
L_[
l[hikY^[d&
i_Y^
d_Y^j
pk
_Z[dj_\_p_[h[d&
_dZ[c
L_[
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
ie
m[_j
m_[
ct]b_Y^
l[hc[_Z[d&
d_Y^j
dkh
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Z_[i[
@[\u^b[&
iedZ[hd
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
Wbb[i(
P[dd
L_[
_d
i_Y^
Z_[
?s^_]a[_j
[hiY^W\\[d&
i_Y^
d_Y^j
pk
_Z[dj_\_p_[h[d&
ie
m_hZ
ZWi
Z_[i[
@[\u^b[
Wd]h[_\[d
kdZ
L_[
m[hZ[d
c[ha[d&
ZWii
i_[
Wd\Wd' ][d
pk
l[hiY^m_dZ[d( =_[
pm[_j[
DWj[]eh_[
jWkY^j
d_Y^j
js]b_Y^
Wk\(
L_[
i_dZ
Z_[
iY^m_[h_][h[d&
aecfb_p_[hj[h[d
@[\u^b[
kdZ
X[hk^[d
Wk\
_h][dZ' m[bY^[d
c[djWb[d
Oeh]sd][d
'
F_iijhWk[d&
l[hb[jpj[
@[\u^b[
kdZ
l_[b[i
q^db_Y^[(
L_[
i_dZ
iY^m_[h_][h
pk
X[msbj_][d(
L_[
atdd[d
c_j
_^d[d
kc][^[d&
_dZ[c
L_[
c_jj[bi
=[da[d
[_d[
h_Y^j_][
][_ij_][
>_dij[bbkd]
^[hlehXh_d][d
'
d_Y^j
ZWdd&
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^
_d
[_d[c
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b
][\Wd][d
\_dZ[d&
iedZ[hd
_d
Z[h
Sm_iY^[dp[_j&
m[dd
L_[
hk^_]
i_dZ(
O[hikY^[d
L_[&
Z_[
h_Y^j_' ][
>_dij[bbkd]&
Z[d
h_Y^j_][d
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
pk
\_dZ[d
kdZ
_^d
X[ijsdZ_]
pk
cWY^[d(
P[dd
L_[
h_Y^j_][i
=[da[d
iY^W\\[d&
m_hZ
ZWi
Wbb[
DhW\j
led
Z_[i[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
d[^c[d( =Wdd
]_Xj
[i
[_d[
Zh_jj[
DWj[]eh_[&
l_[b
^[\j_][h&
l_[b
iY^m_[h_' ][h
kdZ
i[^h
i[bj[d(
@[][d
i_[
atdd[d
L_[
d_Y^ji
jkd(
=_[i[
pm[_
F[j^eZ[d
'
DWcf\
c_j
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
kdZ
>hp[k][d
h_Y^j_][h
>_dij[bbkd][d
'
^[b\[d
d_Y^j(
P[dd
iebY^[
@[\u^b[
aecc[d&
atdd[d
L_[
dkh
[_d[i
jkd4
L_[
cuii[d
l[hikY^[d&
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd5
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
c_j
A_b\[
Z[i
@[\u^bi
pk
[h_dd[hd( "$(

=Wi
m_hZ
i_[
dWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
sdZ[hd(
:X[h
^_[h\uh
cuii[d
L_[
lehX[h[_j[j
i[_d5
[i
_ij
[jmWi
]Wdp
;[iedZ[h[i(

! P_h
kdj[hikY^[d
kdi
d_Y^j
led
Z[c
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Wki&
mWi
m_h
i_dZ&
iedZ[hd
mWi
m_h
m[hZ[d
atdd[d&
ie
ZWii
m_h
iec_j&
m[dd
m_h
X[ij_ccj[
=_d][
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
ijkZ_[hj
^WX[d&
ZWhWd
WhX[_' j[d&
i_[
pk
sdZ[hd(
:kih[_Y^[dZ
[hdij^W\j[i
LjkZ_kc
X[m_haj
_d
i_Y^
i[bXij
[_d[
qdZ[hkd]&
WX[h
Wbb[
>h][Xd_ii[
Z_[i[i
PWdZ[bi
atdd[d
ZkhY^
X[ij_ccj[
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
l[hZehX[d
m[hZ[d5
P[dd
L_[
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
Z[h
L[bXij'qdZ[hkd]
X[]_dd[d&
e^d[
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
pk
X[msbj_][d&
m_hZ
[_d[
B^h[h
L[_j[d
WhX[_j[d
kdZ
[_d[
WdZ[h[
L[_j[
m_hZ
B^h[
:hX[_j
l[hZ[hX[d&
ie
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
dWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
_d
[_d[c
iY^b_cc[h[d
SkijWdZ
Wbi
pkleh
X[\_dZ[d
atdd[d(
>i
_ij
X[h[_ji
c[^hcWbi
E[kj[d&
Z_[
_^h[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
pk
X[^Wbj[d
mudiY^j[d&
][iY^[^[d&
ZWii
_^' d[d
Z_[
?ehj\u^hkd]
Z_[i[h
:hX[_j
kdct]b_Y^
mkhZ[(
>i
]WX
:k][dXb_Ya[&
ZW
i_[
Z_[
@[\s^hb_Y^a[_j
_^h[h
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
[haWddj[d&
WX[h
i_[
l[hiskcj[d&
ms^h[dZ
Z_[i[h
Fec[dj[
Wki' h[_Y^[dZ[
:dijh[d]kd][d
pk
kdj[hd[^c[d&
kdZ
Z_[
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
mkhZ[d
ijsha[h(
>i
mkhZ[
X[h[_ji
[habshj&
ZWii
[_d[
h_Y^j_][
>_dij[bbkd]
Z[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
][][duX[h
Z_[
c[_' ij[d
led
_^d[d
p[hijthj(
P[dd
m_h
Z_[
O[hd_Y^jkd]
Z[h
>h][X' d_ii[
kdi[h[h
:hX[_j
l[hc[_Z[d
cuii[d&
_ij
[i
m_Y^j_]&
ZWii
m_h
Z_[i[
>_dij[bbkd]
led
:d\Wd]
Wd
pk
akbj_l_[h[d
b[hd[d( >_d[
h_Y^j_][
>_dij[bbkd]
[_d[c
@[][dijWdZ
][][duX[h
_ij
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
h_Y^j_][d
=[da[di
uX[h
Z[d
X[ij_ccj[d
@[][dijWdZ(
O_[b[
F[diY^[d
b[X[d
X[_if_[bim[_i[
led
>_dmsdZ[d5
i_[
^Wbj[d
i_Y^
dkh
ZWdd
\uh
abk]&
m[dd
i_[
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
[jmWi
[_d[d
>_dmWdZ
\_dZ[d(
P[dd
i_[
a[_d[d
>_dmWdZ
\_dZ[d&
ZWdd
^WX[d
i_[
d_Y^j
ZWi
@[\u^b&
pk
WhX[_j[d&
pk
Z[da[d
eZ[h
iedij
[jmWi
pk
jkd(
GeY^
[_dcWb4
;[_dW^[
Wbb[
kdi[h[
f[hitdb_Y^[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
X[hk^[d
Wk\
Oehmuh\[d
kdZ
Z[h
:ddW^c[&
ZWii
`[cWdZ
WdZ[h[h
iY^kbZ
_ij(
P[dd
m_h
ZkhY^
X[^Whhb_Y^[i
=[da[d
[ha[d' "$)

d[d&
ZWii
d_[cWdZ
WdZ[h[h
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
kdi
iY^kbZ_]
i[_d
aWdd
kdZ
m_h
Z[h
@hkdZ
\uh
Wbb[i
i_dZ&
mWi
kdi
][iY^_[^j&
m_hZ
i_Y^
kdi[h[
>_dij[bbkd]
`[d[d
@[\u^b[d
Z[h
:dabW][
][][duX[h
l[h' sdZ[hd(
LY^b_[iib_Y^
aWdd
Z_[i
h_Y^j_][
=[da[d&
Z_[i
A[hlehXh_d' ][d
[_d[h
h_Y^j_][d
>_dij[bbkd]
eZ[h
[_d[i
h_Y^j_][d
@[i_Y^ji' fkdaji
[_d
f[hcWd[dj[h
Ihep[ii
m[hZ[d&
kdZ
ZWdd
m[hZ[d
d[]W' j_l[
@[\u^b[
dkh
deY^
][b[][djb_Y^
Wk\jWkY^[d(
@[dWk
ZWZkhY^&
ZWii
Z_[i[h
Ihep[ii
h_Y^j_][d
=[da[di
X[ijsdZ_]
m_hZ&
^Wj
[h
FWY^j
uX[h
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[5
[h
pu][bj
i_[
]b[_Y^
pk
;[]_dd( P_h
atdd[d
b[hd[d&
[_d_][
@[i_Y^jifkdaj[
pkhuYapkm[_i[d
kdZ
WdZ[h[
pk
Wap[fj_[h[d(
Oed
[_d[c
LjWdZfkdaj
Wki
i_dZ
m_h
ie
c[Y^Wd_iY^
kdZ
atdd[d
d_Y^ji
jkd&
ms^h[dZ
[i
led
[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
Wki
_d
kdi
'
l_[bb[_Y^j
d_Y^j
l_[b[
WX[h
c[^h[h[
'
=_d][
]_Xj&
Z_[
m_h
pk
jkd
X[]_dd[d
atdd[d(
P_h
^WX[d
X[ij_ccj[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j[d
_d
kdi&
Z_[
m_h
d_Y^j
dkjp[d(
>i
_ij
mW^h&
ZWii
L_[
d_Y^ji
QRL
atdd[d
_d
Z[c
L_dd[&
ZWii
L_[
d_Y^j
sdZ[hd
atdd[d&
mWi
L_[
_d
[_d[c
][][X[d[d
:k][dXb_Ya
D\FJCL!
WX[h
L_[
atdd[d
i_Y^
i[bXij
l[hWdbWii[d&
_d
[_d[c
][][X[d[d
Fec[dj
uX[h
[_d[d
X[ij_ccj[d
@[][dijWdZ
L?AFWRBCLICL#
=Wi
_ij
Z[h
:d\Wd](
L_[
cuii[d
m_ii[d&
mWi
ct]b_Y^
_ij
kdZ
led
ZW
Wki
X[]_dd[d&
Z[dd
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j&
[jmWi
pk
jkd
WdijWjj
[jmWi
][iY^[^[d
pk
bWii[d&
m_hZ
iY^d[bb
pkd[^c[d(
L_[
atdd[d
i_Y^
l[hWdbWii[d&
uX[h
[_d[d
X[ij_ccj[d
@[][dijWdZ
Wk\
[_d[
X[' ij_ccj[
:hj
dWY^pkZ[da[d&
kdZ
L_[
atdd[d
i_Y^
'
m[dd
[i
dtj_]
_ij
'&
ZWpk
l[hWdbWii[d&
d_Y^j
pk
Z[da[d( L_[
[ha[dd[d
d_Y^j&
mWi
\uh
[_d[
][mWbj_][
FWY^j
_c
=[da[d
b_[]j(
=Wi
_ij
d_Y^j
Wbi
f^_beief^_iY^[
>hthj[hkd]
Z[h
FWY^j
][c[_dj(
=_[
FWY^j
b_[]j
_d
Z[h
MWjiWY^[&
ZWii
L_[&
m[dd
L_[
uX[h
X[ij_ccj[
=_d][
_cc[h
h_Y^j_]
Z[da[d&
Z_[i[d
@[ZWda[d
f[hcWd[dj
cWY^[d
atdd[d&
kdZ
[h
i_Y^
pk
[_d[h
f[hcWd[dj[d
>_dij[bbkd]
[djm_Ya[bd
m_hZ(
P[dd
L_[
_d
i_Y^
Z_[
G[_]kd]
pkh
\WbiY^[d
[cej_edWb[d
FWd_\[ijWj_ed
_h][dZ[_d[h
:hj
[djZ[Ya[d&
ZWdd
atdd[d
L_[
][dWk
_d
Z_[i[c
:k][dXb_Ya
d_Y^ji
ZWhWd
sdZ[hd&
Z[dd
L_[
^WX[d
_d
i_Y^
ZkhY^
\WbiY^[i
=[da[d
Z_[
?s^_]a[_j
pk
Z_[i[h
:hj
Z[h
K[Waj_ed
^[hWd][X_bZ[j5
WX[h
dWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
h_Y^j_][d
=[da[di
atdd[d
L_[
_d
i_Y^
Z_[
?s^_]a[_j "$*

pk
[_d[h
WdZ[h[d
K[Waj_ed
^[hWdX_bZ[d(
Gkh
KRPP
Z_[i[
F[j^e' Z[
h_Y^j_]
SCOPQ?LBCL
TCOBCL!
kdZ
Z_[i
O[hij[^[d
KRPP
E?LW
QGCD
ECFCL#
L_[
atdd[d
Z_[i[
F[j^eZ[
Wk\
l_[b[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
=_d][
Wdm[dZ[d(
=Wi
_ij
_d
Z[h
MWj
ZWi
[_dp_][&
mWi
L_[
jkd
atdd[d(
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^ji
WdZ[h[i
jkd(
>i
]_Xj
a[_d[d
Z_h[aj[d
P[]&
c_j
d[]Wj_l[d
FWd_\[ijWj_ed[d
pk
ascf\[d&
m[_b
cWd
i_[
d_Y^j
[_d' \Wd][d
aWdd5
kdZ
[i
]_Xj
a[_d[
:hj&
i_[
pk
l[h^_dZ[hd&
Wkii[h
cWd
_ij
Wk\
i_[
lehX[h[_j[j(
>_d[
lehuX[h][^[dZ[
>ha[ddjd_i&
ZWii
i_[
\WbiY^
i_dZ&
m_hZ
d_Y^j
^[b\[d5
i_[
ckii
i[^h
j_[\
i[_d&
iedij
m[hZ[d
L_[
m_[Z[h
[_d[d
]b[_Y^
iY^m[h[d
Ihep[ii
pk
ZkhY^' bWk\[d
^WX[d&
kc
Z[d
;eZ[d
\uh
[_d[
WdZ[h[
FWd_\[ijWj_ed
lehpkX[h[_j[d(
L_[
cuii[d
[ha[dd[d&
m_[l_[b
i_[
ZkhY^
Z_[i[
ifedjWd[d
:kiZhkYai\ehc[d
d[]Wj_l[d
_dij[bbkd]
pk
^WX[d&
cuii[d
m_h
b[hd[d&
WdZ[hi
pk
Z[da[d
kdZ
JZLECOC
.CB?LICL
pk
^WX[d(
C[Z[h
kdi[h[h
@[ZWda[d
_ij
pk
akhp(
>hij
m[dd
L_[
Wki
[_][d[h
;[eXWY^jkd]
Z[d
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
pm_iY^[d
bWd][d
kdZ
akh' p[d
@[ZWda[d
[hb[Xj
^WX[d&
m_hZ
B^d[d
Z_[i[
BZ[[
[jmWi
X[' Z[kj[d( LebWd][
m_h
kdi[h[c
=[da[d
][ijWjj[d&
lebbijsdZ_]
Wk\
][' me^dj[h
:iiep_Wj_ed
pk
X[hk^[d&
m_hZ
[i
i_Y^
d_Y^j
l[hlebbaecc' d[d5
WX[h
ZkhY^
>_d\u^h[d
d[k[h
@[i_Y^jifkdaj[
atdd[d
m_h
d[k[
:iiep_Wj_ed[d
^[hlehXh_d][d(
P_h
i_dZ
[i
X[_if_[bim[_i[
][me^dj&
_d
WXiebkj[d
;[]h_\\[d
pk
Z[da[d
'
Wbb[i
eZ[h
d_Y^ji
'
WX[h
[i
_ij
dejm[dZ_]
pk
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
Wbb[i
G[k[
pk[hij
Xb_jp' Whj_]
Wk\jh_jj(
>i
aeccj&
ZWdd
l[hiY^m_dZ[j
[i
m_[Z[h(
>hij
dWY^
[_d[h
][m_ii[d
S[_j
m_hZ
Z_[i[i
:k\Xb_jp[d
bsd][h
kdZ
ZWdd
deY^
bsd][h&
ie
ZWii
L_[
[i
i[^[d
kdZ
mW^hd[^c[d
atdd[d(
G_Y^ji
aeccj
ie\ehj
_d
lebbijsdZ_][h
?ehc(
:bb[i&
mWi
[hmehX[d
m[h' Z[d
aWdd&
aeccj&
l[hiY^m_dZ[j&
aeccj
m_[Z[h&
l[hiY^m_dZ[j "%!

[hd[kj(
GWY^
[_d[h
bWd][d
S[_j
aeccj
kdZ
Xb[_Xj
[i
[_d
X_iiY^[d&
ie
ZWii
L_[
_d
Z[h
EW][
i_dZ&
[i
pk
X[d[dd[d&
[i
pk
X[c[ha[d(
BY^
m_bb
a[_d
;[_if_[b
][X[d&
Z[dd
[i
muhZ[
pk
>_dX_bZkd]
\u^h[d(
:bb[i&
mWi
_Y^
iW][d
m_bb&
_ij&
ZWii
cWd
X[_if_[bim[_i[
ZkhY^
X[ij_ccj[
:dijh[d]kd][d
Z[i
L[bXij'>h_dd[hdi
=_d][
i[^[d
atddj[&
Z_[
cWd
`[jpj
d_Y^j
i[^[d
aWdd(
Ndi[h[d
:k][d
i_dZ
d_Y^j
ie
i[^h
LY^hWda[d
][i[jpj&
m_[
m_h
Z[da[d(
>i
]_Xj
l_[b[i&
ZWi
i_[
i[^[d
atdd[d&
WX[h
d_Y^j
X[c[ha[d(
P_h
atdd[d
d_Y^j
WdZ[hi
mW^hd[^c[d&
X[leh
m_h
d_Y^j
WdZ[hi
Z[da[d(
P_h
^WX[d
dkh
uX[h
kdi[h[
@[ZWda[d
Dedjhebb[5
m_h
^WX[d
a[_d[
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
Z_[
PW^hd[^ckd](
PW^hd[^ckd]
^sd]j
d_Y^j
led
Pud' iY^[d
eZ[h
>djiY^buii[d
WX&
i_[
_ij
^WkfjisY^b_Y^
ZkhY^
kdi[h[d
;[mkiiji[_dipkijWdZ
X[Z_d]j&
ZkhY^
kdi[h
PWY^[hi[_d(
P[dd
cWd
\uh
[_d[
][du][dZ
bWd][
S[_j
[hmWY^j&
iW][d
m_h
\uh
[_d[
LjkdZ[&
aWdd
cWd
l_[b[
=_d][
i[^[d&
Z_[
cWd
`[jpj
d_Y^j
mW^h' d_ccj(

" =_[
?hW][
Z[i
@[XhWkY^i
[_d[h
h_Y^j_][d
>_dij[bbkd]
Wbi
PW\\[
][][d
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
[h\ehZ[hj
O[hij[^[d5
i_[
X[p_[^j
i_Y^
Wk\
kdi[h[
>_dij[bbkd]
Z[d
@[\u^b[d
i[bXij
][][duX[h&
Z[dd
m_h
atdd[d
[_d[
h_Y^j_][
eZ[h
\WbiY^[
>_dij[bbkd]
kdi[h[h
G[]Wj_l_jsj
][][duX[h
^WX[d(
L_[
kdj[hiY^[_Z[j
i_Y^
_d
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
?sbb[d
kdZ
bsiij
i_Y^
d_Y^j
l[hWbb][c[_d[hd(
Gkd
cuii[d
m_h
Z_[
>_dij[b' bkd][d
Wd
i_Y^
X[jhWY^j[d
kdZ
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
[_d[
fei_j_l[
>_dij[bbkd]
_d
[_d_][d
?sbb[d
h_Y^j_]
kdZ
[_d[
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[b' bkd]
_d
WdZ[h[d
?sbb[d
h_Y^j_]
_ij(
>_d[
fei_j_l[
>_dij[bbkd]
][^thj
pk
Z[c
M[_b
kdi[h[i
Bdj[bb[aji&
Z[h
yCWz
iW]j
kdZ
[_d[
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[bbkd]
pk
Z[c
M[_b&
Z[h
yG[_dz
iW]j(
>i
aWdd
WkY^
WdZ[h[
>_dij[bbkd][d
][X[d&
WX[h
Z_[i[
X[_Z[d
i_dZ
Z_[
m_Y^j_]' ij[d(
FWd][bdZ[i
O[hij[^[d
][][duX[h
[_d[c
@[][dijWdZ
eZ[h
[_d[c
IheXb[c
aWdd
[_d\WY^
ZWZkhY^
^[hleh][hk\[d
i[_d&
ZWii
cWd
_^d[d
][][duX[h
[_d[
\WbiY^[
>_dij[bbkd]
^Wj(
>i
]_Xj
E[kj[&
Z_[
Wbb[c
kdZ
`[Z[c
][][duX[h
[_d[
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[bbkd]
^WX[d& "%"

kdZ
[i
]_Xj
WdZ[h[&
Z_[
[_d[
fei_j_l[
>_dij[bbkd]
Z[d
=_d][d
][][duX[h
pk
akbj_l_[h[d
l[hikY^[d&
Z[d[d
][][duX[h
i_[
[_d[
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[bbkd]
^WX[d
iebbj[d(
P[dd
m_h
Z_[
Pthj[h
yfei_' j_lz
kdZ
yd[]Wj_lz
_c
uXb_Y^[d
L_dd
led
Skij_cckd]
eZ[h
:Xb[^dkd]
l[hm[dZ[d&
atdd[d
m_h
iW][d&
ZWii
m_h&
kc
X[' ij_ccj[
=_d][
l[hij[^[d
pk
atdd[d&
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[bbkd][d
^WX[d
cuii[d&
ms^h[dZ
WdZ[h[i
fei_j_l
l[hijWdZ[d
m[hZ[d
aWdd(
Sk
l_[b
led
[_d[h
mW^bbei
fei_j_l[d
>_dij[bbkd]
aWdd
=_d][
][dWk
ie
l[hZ[hX[d&
m_[
[_d[
^WhjdsYa_]
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[b' bkd]
=_d][
l[hZ[hX[d
aWdd&
WX[h
cWdY^cWb
_ij
[_d[
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[bbkd]
dujpb_Y^&
m[_b
[i
l_[b[i
_c
E[X[d
]_Xj&
ZWi
dkh
ZkhY^
[_d[
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
]kj[
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[bbkd]
l[hijWdZ[d
m[hZ[d
aWdd(
@[m_ii
muhZ[
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
c_j
[_d[h
d[]Wj_l[d
>_dij[b' bkd]
[_d
d[]Wj_l[i
@[\u^b
l[hkhiWY^[d&
WX[h
ZWi
aWdd
l[hc_[Z[d
m[hZ[d&
kdZ
i[^h
e\j
_ij
BZ[dj_\_p_[h[d
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
[_d[h
\Wb' iY^[d
>_dij[bbkd](
Le
fWhWZen
[i
iY^[_d[d
cW]&
l_[b[
d[]Wj_l[
@[\u^b[
^WX[d
m_h&
m[_b
m_h
a[_d[
Wkih[_Y^[dZ
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[b' bkd]
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
][][duX[h
^WX[d(
:dZ[h[hi[_ji
m[hZ[d
L_[
_d
Z[c
:k][dXb_Ya&
ZW
L_[
[_d[
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[bbkd]
][][d' uX[h
[_d[c
Z[h
=_d][
^WX[d&
Z_[
c_j
Z_[i[h
>djm_Yabkd]iWhX[_j
l[hXkdZ[d
i_dZ&
Wk\^th[d&
i_[
pk
l[hij[^[d( P_h
cuii[d
X[]h[_\[d&
ZWii
m_h
a[_d[
Dedjhebb[
^WX[d&
ZWii
m_h
FWiY^_d[d
i_dZ&
ZWii
kdi
Wbb[i
ypkijtiijz(
>i
][du]j
d_Y^j&
uX[h
Z_[i[
MWjiWY^[d
pk
ifh[Y^[d&
kc
i_[
pk
sdZ[hd(
Nc
Wk\pk' ^th[d&
c[Y^Wd_iY^
pk
i[_d&
XhWkY^j
[i
[jmWi
WdZ[h[i(
>_d[
qdZ[hkd]
Z[h
>_dij[bbkd]
_ij
dtj_](
>_dij[bbkd][d
atdd[d
led
@[\u^b[d
kdWX^sd]_]
i[_d&
kdZ
_d
[_d[c
][m_ii[d
:kicWii
atdd[d
i_[
kdi[h[h
Dedjhebb[
kdj[hb_[][d(
P_h
^WX[d
pkc
;[_' if_[b
[_d_][
Dedjhebb[
uX[h
kdi[h[
>_dij[bbkd][d
][][duX[h
P_i' i[d&
][][duX[h
?h[kdZ[d&
][][duX[h
Z_[i[h
:hX[_j
kdZ
][][d' uX[h
Z[c
L[bXij'LjkZ_kc(
>_d[
>_dij[bbkd]
_ij
jWjisY^b_Y^
[_d
@[i_Y^jifkdaj&
kdZ
m[dd
Z_[i[h
h_Y^j_]
_ij&
]_Xj
[i
[_d[
P_hakd]5
m[dd
Z[h
@[i_Y^jifkdaj
\WbiY^
_ij&
[_d[
WdZ[h[(
P_h
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
m_h
d_Y^ji
jkd
atdd[d&
WX[h
m_h
atdd[d
kdi[h[
>_dij[bbkd][d
sdZ[hd( >_d[
h_Y^j_][
>_dij[bbkd]
aWdd
iY^h_jjm[_i[
ZkhY^
ZWi
LjkZ_kc "%#

i[_d[h
i[bXij
kdZ
ZWi
LjkZ_kc
Z[i
E[X[di
[djm_Ya[bj
m[hZ[d&
][csii
Z[h
X[iedZ[h[d
:hj&
_d
Z[h
m_h
i_[
ijkZ_[h[d(
=_[i[i
LjkZ_kc
X[hk^j
d_Y^j
dkh
Wk\
P_ii[d&
iedZ[hd
Wk\
[_d[h
WdZ[h[d
=[daWhj(
:dZ[h[i
=[da[d
aWdd
dkh
Wki
WdZ[h[d
>_dij[bbkd][d
aecc[d
kdZ
Wki
[_d[c
O[hij[^[d
Z[i
h[bWj_l[d
P[hji
Z[h
=_d][(
PWdZ[b
Z[h
>_dij[bbkd][d
Xh_d]j
d_Y^j
led
Wbb[_d[
[_d[
qdZ[hkd]
Z[i
c[diY^b_Y^[d
P[i[di
c_j
i_Y^(
>i
][^thj
P[hjkd]
ZWpk(

"%$

Bemerkungen zur Arbeit

145

Bd^Wbj

)CKCOIRLECL
WRK
(O@CGQPCLQPAFJRPP
)CKCOIRLECL
WRO
(O@CGQ
?L
PGAF
PCJ@PQ
=?P
GPQ
BGC
9AFRJC'

"%(

-AHAKFNICAI
QNH
,K>AEMLAIML?DGNLL =[da[d
L_[
i[^h
[hdij^W\j
ZWhuX[h
dWY^&
[^[
L_[
i_Y^
ZW\uh
[djiY^[_Z[d&
c_j
Z[h
Oehij[bbkd]
i_Y^
pk
sdZ[hd&
Wd
i_Y^
pk
WhX[_j[d&
ZWi
^[_iij&
c_j
Z[c
[djiY^_[Z[d[d
S_[b
pk
WhX[_j[d&
X[mkiij
pk
m[hZ[d&
kdZ
Z_[
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
Z[d
^t^[h[d
S[dj' h[d
pk
[djm_Ya[bd(
=_[i[
:hX[_j
bsiij
a[_d[d
Decfhec_ii
pk
kdZ
[h\ehZ[hj
[_d[
]heii[
F[d][
L[bXijZ_ip_fb_d
kdZ
;[h[_jiY^W\j&
Wbb[d
K[][bd
kdZ
X[iedZ[hi
Z_h[aj[d
:dm[_ikd][d
pk
][^eh' Y^[d( rX[hb[][d
L_[
i_Y^
i[^h
[hdijb_Y^4
L_dZ
L_[
m_hab_Y^
X[h[_j
kdZ
m_bb[di
pk
][^ehY^[d&
kdZ
l[hij[^[d
L_[
lebbWk\
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]' a[_j
^_[hpk9
>i
]_Xj
a[_d
SkhuYa(
P[dd
L_[
pkij_cc[d
kdZ
ZWdd
pkhuYajh[j[d&
m[hZ[d
L_[
Wbb[i
l[hb_[h[d&
ZWi
L_[
X_i
pk
Z_[i[h
S[_j
[hmehX[d
^WX[d&
kdZ
L_[
m[hZ[d
jWjisY^b_Y^
c[^h
l[hb_[h[d&
Z[dd
Wbb[i&
mWi
L_[
[hh[_Y^j
^WX[d&
m_hZ
i_Y^
_d
B^d[d
_d
[jmWi
?WbiY^[i
l[hmWdZ[bd(
=W][][d
]_Xj
[i
a[_d
A[_bc_jj[b( =Wi
O[hij[^[d
Z[h
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j&
K[][bd
kdZ
Z_h[aj[d
:d' m[_ikd][d
pk
][^ehY^[d&
ckii
Wk\
Z[h
>ha[ddjd_i
B^h[h
F[Y^W'
d_i_[hj^[_j
kdZ
B^h[h
A_b\bei_]a[_j
]hudZ[d(
P[dd
Z_[i[
>ha[ddj' d_i
d_Y^j
ijWha
][dk]
_ij&
iebbj[d
L_[
X[ii[h
mWhj[d
kdZ
i_Y^
c_j
][mt^db_Y^[h
:hX[_j
X[iY^s\j_][d5
LjkZ_kc
Z[i
Loij[ci&
:hX[_j
_d
@hkff[d
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
P[dd
L_[
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
[hdij^W\j
jkd
kdZ
Wd
Wbb[
K[][bd
Z[da[d&
m_hZ
L_[
ZWi
pkh
>ha[ddjd_i
B^h[i
SkijWdZi
kdZ
B^h[h
;[Zuh\d_ii[
\u^h[d(
:X[h
L_[
Zuh\[d
d_Y^j
pk
bWd][
pWkZ[hd(
P[dd
L_[
pkh
m_hab_Y^[d
:hX[_j
aecc[d
mebb[d&
cuii[d
L_[
i_Y^
X[[_b[d(
L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^' a[_j&
Z_[
^[kj[
[n_ij_[hj(
B^d[d
d_Y^j
deY^cWbi
X[][]d[d
ckii(
=khY^
St][hd
kdZ
pk
bWd][i
PWhj[d
atdd[d
L_[
Wbb
B^h[
_d
O[hikY^&
Z_[
=_d][
ZkhY^pkifh[Y^[d&
[_d[
_hed_iY^[&
c_iijhWk_iY^[
eZ[h
d[]Wj_l[
>_dij[bbkd]&
?khY^j
eZ[h
FWd][b
Wd
O[hjhWk[d
m[hZ[d
Z_[
:k\]WX[
ie\ehj
kdct]b_Y^
cWY^[d(
P[dd
L_[
[_d
@[\u^b
Z[i
St][hdi
Wd
Z[h
:k\]WX[&
Z_[
B^d[d
Wd][Xej[d
mkhZ[&
mW^hd[^c[d&
Z[da[d
L_[
Wd
B^h[
F[Y^Wd_i_[hj^[_j&
Z[d' a[d
L_[
Wd
B^h[
G[]Wj_l_jsj&
Wd
B^h[d
>_][dm_bb[d
'
WX[h
Z[da[d
L_[
iY^d[bb(
L_[
atdd[d
Wbb[_d[
d_Y^ji
][][d
B^h[
iY^mWY^[d
L[_j[d
Wkih_Y^j[d(
=_[
:k\]WX[d&
Z_[
B^d[d
Wd][Xej[d
m[hZ[d&
^WX[d
pkc
S_[b&
B^d[d
pk
^[b\[d(
P[dd
L_[
pt][hd
eZ[h
i_[
pkhuYam[_i[d&
m[_i[d
L_[
A_b\[
pkhuYa(
=Wi
ckii
B^d[d
_d
B^h[c
O[hijWdZ
ltbb_]
abWh
i[_d( =_[
>ha[ddjd_i
B^h[h
A_b\bei_]a[_j
kdZ
B^h[i
j_[\[d
LY^bW\i
ckii
f[hcWd[dj
_d
B^d[d
][][dmshj_]
i[_d(
L_[
atdd[d
i_[
ZWZkhY^
ijsha[d&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
ZWk[hdZ
Wd
B^h[
G_Y^j_]a[_j&
B^h[
LY^b[Y^j_]a[_j&
B^h[
LY^msY^[d
Wbb[h
ct]b_Y^[d
:hj
[h_dd[hd(
L_[
^WX[d
WXiebkj
d_Y^ji&
mehWk\
L_[
ijebp
i[_d
atdd[d(
L_[
^WX[d
d_Y^ji&
mehWk\
L_[
B^h
Nhj[_b
]hudZ[d
atdd[d(
P[dd
L_[
Wk\h_Y^' j_]
c_j
i_Y^
i_dZ&
atdd[d
L_[
Wbb
Z_[
F_ii]h_\\[
kdZ
Wbb
Z_[
?[^b[h
i[^[d&
Z_[
L_[
cWY^j[d&
m[dd
L_[
Wk\
[_][d[
?Wkij
pk
^WdZ[bd
l[hikY^j[d(
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
h_Y^j_]
Z[da[d(
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
h_Y^j_]
\u^b[d(
L_[
X[dtj_][d
ZWk[hdZ[
A_b\[&
kdZ
L_[
atdd[d
i_[
X[aecc[d(
:X[h
L_[
cuii[d
ZW\uh
X[pW^b[d
'
pkc_dZ[ij
ZWc_j&
ZWii
L_[
d_Y^j
Wh]kc[dj_[h[d( L_[
cuii[d
[_d[
]_]Wdj_iY^[
:hX[_j
b[_ij[d&
m[dd
L_[
WdZ[hi
m[hZ[d
mebb[d(
P_[
atdd[d
L_[
`[cWbi
^e\\[d&
_h][dZ[jmWi
pk
[hh[_Y^[d&
m[dd
L_[
X[_
Z[d
[hij[d
LY^h_jj[d
pt][hd
kdZ
Wh]k' c[dj_[h[d
eZ[h
deY^
d_Y^j
[_dcWb
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
Z[h
A_b\[
[ha[dd[d
eZ[h
c_iijhWk_iY^
kdZ
d[]Wj_l
m[hZ[d9 P[dd
L_[
[hdij^W\j
WhX[_j[d
mebb[d&
cuii[d
L_[
l_[b[
=_d][
_d
i_Y^
X[msbj_][d(
L_[
atdd[d
B^h[
Oehkhj[_b[&
B^h[
ijWhh[d
rX[h' p[k]kd][d&
B^h[
f[hitdb_Y^[d
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed[d
eZ[h
:d_cei_js' j[d
d_Y^j
c_j
i_Y^
iY^b[ff[d( :X[h
l[hikY^[d
L_[
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
pk
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
f[hitdb_Y^
d_Y^j
_cc[h
\WbiY^
X[Z[kj[j(
I[hitdb_Y^
i[_d&
aWdd
B^d[d
X[_
Z[h "&!

:hX[_j
^[b\[d&
WX[h
WkY^
i[^h
][\s^hb_Y^
i[_d&
m[dd
[i
d_Y^j
ZkhY^
Z[d
DWcf\
c_j
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
kdZ
Z_[
>ha[ddjd_i
B^h[h
F[Y^Wd_i_[hj^[_j
kdZ
B^h[h
LY^msY^[
][bskj[hj
_ij(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
lehisjpb_Y^[d
E[_Z[di
kdZ
X[mkiij[h
:d' ijh[d]kd]
pk
l[hij[^[d(
>i
i_dZ
Z_[i
Z_[
X[_Z[d
[_dp_][d
=_d][&
Z_[
L_[
sdZ[hd
kdZ
B^h[c
S_[b
ds^[h
Xh_d][d
atdd[d( Oehisjpb_Y^[i
E[_Z[d
^[_iij
d_Y^j
dejm[dZ_][i
E[_Z[d&
ZWi
L_[
i_Y^
i[bXij
Wk\[hb[]j
^WX[d(
>i
X[Z[kj[j
[_d[
>_dij[bbkd]
Z[c
E[_Z[d
][][duX[h(
E[_Z[d
aWdd
Wbi
K[ikbjWj
B^h[h
@[\u^b[&
@[ZWda[d
kdZ
AWdZbkd][d
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
B^h[h
:k\]WX[
Wk\jh[j[d5
[i
aWdd
led
Wbb[_d[
Wbi
>h][Xd_i
B^h[h
[_][d[d
?[^b[h
eZ[h
Wbi
>h][Xd_i
Z[h
AWdZbkd][d&
>_dij[bbkd][d
eZ[h
@[\u^b[
WdZ[h[h
E[kj[
aecc[d(
:X[h
m_Y^j_]
_ij
B^h[
>_dij[bbkd]
Z[c
E[_Z[d
][][duX[h(
>i
m_hZ
lehisjpb_Y^&
m[dd
L_[
d_Y^j
ZW][][d
h[X[bb_[h[d&
m[dd
L_[
[i
d_Y^j
pk
l[hc[_Z[d
l[hikY^[d&
m[dd
L_[
d_Y^j
`[cWdZ[d
ZW\uh
WdabW][d&
m[dd
L_[
[i
Wbi
[_d[d
cec[djWd
dejm[dZ_][d
M[_b
B^h[h
:hX[_j
Wap[fj_[h[d
kdZ
Wbi
[_d
F_jj[b&
B^h
S_[b
pk
[hh[_Y^[d( ;[mkiij[
:dijh[d]kd]
_ij
Z_[
:dijh[d]kd]&
Z_[
Wk\
O[hij[^[d
X[hk^j5
pkWbb[h[hij
O[hij[^[d
_^h[h
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
kdZ
O[hij[' ^[d
Z[h
@hudZ[&
Z_[
i_[
dejm[dZ_]
cWY^[d(
=[h
AWkfj]hkdZ
\uh
Z_[
X[mkiij[
:dijh[d]kd]
_ij
B^h
;[Zuh\d_i&
Z_[
Psbb[
Z[h
F['
Y^Wd_i_[hj^[_j
pk
ZkhY^Xh[Y^[d&
Z[i
>_][dm_bb[di
kdZ
Z[i
FWd' ][bi
Wd
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd&
Z_[
][][dmshj_]
B^h
L[_d
WkicWY^[d( =Wc_j
L_[
X[ii[h
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
l[hij[^[d&
:k\]WX[d&
Z_[
B^d[d
][][X[d
m[hZ[d&
e^d[
St][hd
pk
Wap[fj_[h[d&
Z_[
Gej' m[dZ_]a[_j
_dj[dj_edWb[d
E[_Z[di
kdZ
X[mkiij[h
:dijh[d]kd]&
Z[da[d
L_[
uX[h
Z_[
Oehij[bbkd][d
dWY^&
Z_[
L_[
pkh
:hX[_j
hu^hj[d&
Z[da[d
L_[
Wd
ZWi
[hij[
>ha[dd[d
B^h[h
F[Y^Wd_i_[hj'
^[_j
kdZ
Wd
ZWi
[hij[
>ha[dd[d&
ZWii
L_[
d_Y^ji
m_ii[d(
Sk
;[]_dd
[haWddj[d
L_[
ZWi
kdZ
ikY^j[d
A_b\[&
WX[h
dkd
X[pm[_' \[bd
L_[&
eX
L_[
m_hab_Y^
ZWi
jkd
cuii[d&
mWi
B^d[d
][iW]j
m_hZ(
NdZ
L_[
l[hikY^[d&
P[][
pk
\_dZ[d&
kc
[i
pk
l[hc[_Z[d&
kc
Wk\
B^h[c
[_][d[d
Nhj[_b
kdZ
B^h[c
[_][d[d
O[hij[^[d
pk
X[^Whh[d(
L_[
l[hijWdZ[d
[_dcWb
abWh&
ZWii
B^h
Nhj[_b
kdZ
B^h
O[hij[^[d
\WbiY^
kdZ
iY^mWY^
i_dZ&
WX[h
dkd
l[hikY^[d
L_[&
led
d[k[c "&"

ZWhWd
\[ijpk^Wbj[d(
L_[
mebb[d
i_[
d_Y^j
Wk\][X[d(
Gkd&
L_[
atdd[d
i_[
X[mW^h[d&
WX[h
L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
L_[
c_j
_^d[d
Wbb[i
X[^Wbj[d
m[hZ[d&
mWi
\WbiY^
kdZ
iY^mWY^
_d
B^d[d
_ij(
>i
]_Xj
a[_d[
AWbX^[_j[d(
L_[
cuii[d
i_Y^
[djiY^[_Z[d(
Pebb[d
L_[
WhX[_j[d
eZ[h
d_Y^j9

-AHAKFNICAI
QNK
,K>AEM
=I
LE?D
LAG>LM O[hikY^[d
L_[
i_Y^
pk
[h_dd[hd
kdZ
kdWk\^thb_Y^
Wbb
Z_[
E_d_[d
_d
B^h[c
@[ZsY^jd_i
pk
X[^Wbj[d&
Wd
Z[d[d
L_[
WhX[_j[d
cuii[d(
L_[
cuii[d
Wc
O[hijWdZ&
Wc
;[mkiiji[_d&
Wd
Z[d
>cej_ed[d
kdZ
Wc
P_bb[d
WhX[_j[d(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
pk
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
`[Z[
E_d_[
Z[h
:hX[_j
X[iedZ[h[
:k\c[haiWca[_j
[h\ehZ[hj&
X[iedZ[h[
F[j^e' Z[d
kdZ
X[iedZ[h[i
O[hij[^[d(
GWY^
[_d_][h
S[_j
m[hZ[d
Wbb[
l_[h
[_dWdZ[h
pk
^[b\[d
X[]_dd[d&
kdZ
ifsj[h
m[hZ[d
i_[
_d
[_di
l[h' iY^c[bp[d&
WX[h
pk
;[]_dd
cuii[d
Z_[
l_[h
E_d_[d
][jh[ddj
bWk\[d( O[hikY^[d
L_[
Z_[
:hX[_j
Wd
B^h[c
iej[h_a&
LY^kb[d
kdZ
:hX[_jic[j^eZ[d
X[pk]d[^c[d(
;[^Wb' j[d
L_[
Z_[i[
Oehij[bbkd][d
_d
B^h[c
@[ZsY^jd_i&
eZ[h
aecc[d
L_[
pkc_dZ[ij
ie
e\j
m_[
ct]b_Y^
Wk\
i_[
pkhuYa(
B^h
@[_ij
ZWh\
d_[cWbi
kdjsj_]
i[_d(
Bd
`[Z[c
ct]b_Y^[d
:k][dXb_Ya
cuii[d
L_[
uX[h
Z_[
[_d[
eZ[h
Z_[
WdZ[h[
BZ[[
dWY^Z[da[d&
uX[h
Z[d
[_d[d
eZ[h
Z[d
WdZ[h[d
:if[aj
Z[i
Loij[ci
kdZ
Z[h
F[j^eZ[d( O[hikY^[d
L_[
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
pk
l[hij[^[d&
Z_[
F[j^eZ[d
kdZ
Ih_dp_f_[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
_d
0FO
NCOP[LJGAFCP
3C@CL
[_dpk\u^h[d
kdZ
leh
Wbb[c
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
h_Y^j_][d
=[da[di
uX[h
Wbb[
f[hitdb_Y^[d
?hW][d
kdZ
_^h[d
ct]b_Y^[d
;[pk]
Wk\
B^h[
:hX[_j(
H^d[
Z_[i
m[hZ[d
L_[
d_[cWbi
>_d^[_j
[hh[_Y^[d(
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
[_d[c
M[_b
_d
i_Y^
!][ijWjj[d&
\WbiY^
pk
Z[da[d
kdZ
^e\\[d&
ZWii
[_d
WdZ[h[h
M[_b
_d
B^d[d
h_Y^j_]
Z[da[d
m_hZ( "&#

=Wi
O[hij[^[d
led
Ih_dp_f_[d&
K[][bd
kdZ
F[j^eZ[d
Z[h
9AFRJ?O@CGQ
_ij
[_d[h
Z[h
m_Y^j_]ij[d
M[_b[
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wc
O[h' ijWdZ(
=[h
O[hijWdZ
ckii
ZWh_d
][uXj
m[hZ[d&
_d
i[_d[h
PW^b
pm_iY^[d
h_Y^j_]
kdZ
\WbiY^
d_Y^j
pk
pt][hd&
[h
ckii
lebbaecc[d
h_Y^j_]
Z_[
;[p_[^kd][d
pk
c_h&
pk
WdZ[h[d
E[kj[d
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
kdZ
pk
E[kj[d
Wkii[h^WbX
l[hij[^[d( =[h
O[hijWdZ
ckii
X[]h[_\[d&
ZWii
cWd
]b[_Y^
pk
;[]_dd
[hdij^W\j[h
:hX[_j
Wd
i_Y^
i[bXij
i[_d[
?h[_^[_j
Wk\]_Xj(
Sm[_\[b' bei
_ij
[i
[_d[
_bbkieh_iY^[
?h[_^[_j&
WX[h
m[dd
cWd
i_Y^
Z[d
@[i[jp[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
kdj[hij[bbj&
ij[^j
cWd
dWjuhb_Y^
kdj[h
c[^h
@[i[jp[d
Wbi
`[cWdZ
Wkii[h^WbX
Z[h
:hX[_j( O[hikY^[d
L_[
Z_[
;[Z[kjkd]
Z[i
9AFTCGECLP
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
pk
l[hij[^[d&
Z_[
;[Z[kjkd]
Z[h
(RDOGAFQGEICGQ
kdZ
Z_[
;[Z[kjkd]
Z[h
=?FOFCGQ# FWd
aWdd
d_[cWbi
[hmWhj[d&
_h][dZ
[jmWi
Wki
Z[h
:hX[_j
pk
X[aecc[d&
m[dd
cWd
d_Y^j
iY^m[_][d
aWdd&
me
[i
\uh
ZWi
Pe^b
Z[h
:hX[_j
d_Y^j
dejm[dZ_]
_ij
pk
ifh[Y^[d(
=_[
E[kj[
h[Z[d
Wbb][c[_d
pk
l_[b&
h[Z[d
pk
_^h[h
[_][d[d
;[\h_[Z_]kd]&
Wki
Ljebp
uX[h
i_Y^&
Wki
>_j[ba[_j&
Wki
Z[c
O[hbWd][d&
Wd][d[^c[
eZ[h
iY^c[hp^W\j[
>h\W^hkd][d
deY^
[_dcWb
pk
ZkhY^b[X[d5
i_[
ifh[' Y^[d&
m[_b
i_[
Z[h
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
c_j
Z[c
K[Z[d
d_Y^j
m_Z[hij[' ^[d
atdd[d&
eZ[h
m[_b
i_[
d_Y^j
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
i_[
d_Y^j
Wk\
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:hj
eZ[h
uX[h
[_d[d
X[iedZ[h[d
@[][dijWdZ
ifh[' Y^[d
iebbj[d(
L[^h
e\j
b_[]j
Z_[
X[iedZ[h[
:dp_[^kd]iahW\j
Z[i
K[Z[di
_d
Z[h
MWjiWY^[&
ZWii
i_[
m_ii[d&
ZWii
i_[
d_Y^j
h[Z[d
iebbj[d( BY^
c[_d[&
ZWii
cWd
d_Y^j
[_dcWb
c_j
E[kj[d
Wkii[h^WbX
Z[h
:hX[_j
ifh[Y^[d
iebb(
=Wc_j
ckii
kc][]Wd][d
mehZ[d
i[_d&
bWd][
X[leh
[_d[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
pk
[hdij^W\j[h
:hX[_j
_d
kdi
[dj' ij[^j( PWi
_Y^
c[_d[
_ij&
ZWii
cWd
i[^h
Wk\
Z[h
Akj
i[_d
ckii&
ie]Wh
c_j
i[_d[d
?h[kdZ[d
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
pk
ifh[Y^[d&
X_i
cWd
led
c_h
Wk\][\ehZ[hj
m_hZ&
pk
h[Z[d( >X[d\Wbbi
aWdd
cWd
d_Y^ji
[hmWhj[d&
m[dd
cWd
d_Y^j
c_j
i_Y^
i[bXij
kdZ
c_j
c_h
Wk\h_Y^j_]
i[_d
aWdd(
F_j
WdZ[h[d
E[kj[d
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
aWdd
cWd
[_d[
][][di[_j_][
O[h[_dXWhkd]
_c
A_d' "&$

Xb_Ya
Wk\
H\\[d^[_j
uX[h
Wbb[i
eZ[h
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
X[ij_ccj[
=_d][
^WX[d&
WX[h
Z_[i[
aWdd
dkh
c_j
c[_d[h
Skij_cckd]
kdZ
c[_d[h
lebbijsdZ_][d
D[ddjd_i
Z[i
@[iW]j[d
][jhe\\[d
m[hZ[d( P[_j[h^_d
aWdd
cWd
d_Y^j
[hmWhj[d&
_h][dZ[jmWi
_d
Z[h
:h' X[_j
pk
[hh[_Y^[d&
m[dd
cWd
i_Y^
\uhY^j[j
eZ[h
i_Y^
m[_][hj&
c_h&
WkY^
e^d[
WkiZhuYab_Y^[
:k\\ehZ[hkd]&
Z_[
PW^h^[_j
pk
iW][d( L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
d_[cWdZ&
Z[h
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
Xb[_X[d
ctY^j[&
`[cWdZ
WdZ[h[d
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
X_jj[d
aWdd&
[jmWi
leh
c_h
][^[_c
pk
^Wbj[d&
kdZ
d_[cWdZ
aWdd
ZWi
O[hifh[Y^[d
][X[d&
_h][dZ[jmWi
][^[_c
pk
^Wbj[d(
=_[i
_ij
[_d
i[^h
m_Y^j_][h
Ikdaj( FWd
ckii
_cc[h
X[h[_j
i[_d&
c_h
Wbb[i
uX[h
i_Y^
i[bXij
kdZ
Wbb[i&
mWi
cWd
uX[h
[_d[
WdZ[h[
I[hied
[h\s^hj&
pk
[hps^b[d(
NdZ
cWd
ckii
[i
led
i_Y^
Wki
jkd&
e^d[
ZWhWd
[h_dd[hj
pk
m[hZ[d&
kdZ
pmWh
c_j
lebb[c
;[]h[_\[d&
ZWii
Z_[i
[_d
m[i[dj' b_Y^[h
Ikdaj
Z[h
:hX[_j
_ij( L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
L_[
d_Y^j
[_d[d
M[_b
Z[h
K[][bd
Wdd[^c[d
kdZ
[_d[d
WdZ[h[d
M[_b
pkhuYam[_i[d
eZ[h
l[h][ii[d
atdd[d(
L_[
cuii[d
Z_[
;[Z[kjkd]
Z[h
=_ip_fb_d
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
X[]h[_\[d( L_[
cuii[d
Z_[
;[Z[kjkd]
Z[h
Pehj[
yHf\[hd
L_[
B^h
E[_Z[dz
l[hij[^[d&
[X[die
Z_[
h_Y^j_][d
:k][dXb_Ya[&
Z_[
h_Y^j_][d
F[' j^eZ[d
iem_[
S_[b
kdZ
ct]b_Y^[
>h][Xd_ii[
iebY^[d
Hf\[hi( L_[
cuii[d
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
l[hij[^[d&
ieh]\sbj_]
pk
i[_d&
m[dd
L_[
yBY^z
iW][d(
P[dd
L_[
uX[h
i_Y^
ifh[Y^[d&
atdd[d
L_[
dkh
yBY^z
iW][d&
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^[h
i_dZ&
ZWii
L_[
uX[h
Z_[
:hX[_j
eZ[h
BZ[[d
eZ[h
K[][bd
eZ[h
Ih_dp_f_[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
ifh[Y^[d
eZ[h
_d
rX[h[_dij_cckd]
c_j
Wbb[d
K[][bd
kdZ
Ih_dp_f_[d(
Bd
Wbb[d
WdZ[h[d
?sbb[d
cuii[d
L_[
pk
l[hij[^[d
l[hikY^[d&
m[bY^[h
M[_b
_d
B^d[d
][hWZ[
ifh_Y^j
eZ[h
Z[daj
kdZ
_^d
[djifh[Y^[dZ
X[d[dd[d(
=_[i[
Oehij[bbkd]
ZWh\
d_Y^j
uX[hjh_[X[d
m[hZ[d(
L_[
atdd[d
e^d[
LY^WZ[d
iW][d4
BY^
m[hZ[
]b[_Y^
S_]Wh[jj[d
aWk' \[d(
:X[h
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
iW][d4
BY^
cW]
Z_[i[d
F[diY^[d
d_Y^j(
L_[
cuii[d
^[hWki\_dZ[d&
m[bY^[h
M[_b
_d
B^d[d
_^d
WX' b[^dj
kdZ
mWhkc
kdZ
Zuh\[d
i_Y^
Z_[i[
:Xd[_]kd]
d_Y^j
Wbi
@[iWcj^[_j
pkiY^h[_X[d( "&%

L_[
cuii[d
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
Z[h
L[bXijX[eXWY^jkd]
\uh
ZWi
L[bXij'LjkZ_kc
Z[kjb_Y^
l[hij[^[d(
L_[
cuii[d
Z[d
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
pm_iY^[d
?kdaj_ed[d
kdZ
;[mkiiji[_d
X[]h[_\[d(
P[dd
L_[
Wd
?kdaj_ed[d
Z[da[d&
cuii[d
L_[
_cc[h
_d
Z[h
EW][
i[_d&
Z_[
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[d&
[cej_edWb[d&
;[m[]kd]i'
kdZ
_dij_daj_l[d
?kdaj_ed[d
pk
kdj[hiY^[_Z[d5
fei_j_l[
kdZ
d[]Wj_l[
M[_b[
Z[h
S[djh[d
_c
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[d
kdZ
_dij_daj_l[d
S[djhkc5
;[m['
]kd]i'&
[cej_edWb[
kdZ
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[
M[_b[
_d
Wbb[d
S[djh[d(
L_[
cuii[d
Z_[
:k\c[haiWca[_j
ijkZ_[h[d
kdZ
l[hij[^[d&
m_[
L_[
ZkhY^
ZWi
LjkZ_kc
Z[h
:k\c[haiWca[_j
M[_b[
led
S[djh[d
kd' j[hiY^[_Z[d
atdd[d( Bd
X[pk]
Wk\
ZWi
LjkZ_kc
Z[i
)CTRPPQPCGLP
cuii[d
L_[
i_Y^
Z[ii[d
[h_dd[hd&
mWi
L_[
uX[h
LY^bW\
kdZ
PWY^'SkijWdZ
m_ii[d&
Z_[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
>X[d[d
Z[i
PWY^'SkijWdZi
kdZ
Z_[
O[hX_d' Zkd]
^t^[h[h
S[djh[d
c_j
^t^[h[d
;[mkiiji[_dipkijsdZ[d(
L_[
cuii[d
ZWhWd
Z[da[d&
ZWii
B^h
S_[b
_ij&
_d
B^d[d
^t^[h[
;[' mkiiji[_dipkijsdZ[
^[hlehpkhk\[d
kdZ
[_d[
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
^t' ^[h[d
S[djh[d
^[hpkij[bb[d(
L_[
cuii[d
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
^t^[h[
S[djh[d
l_[b[
kdX[aWddj[
?kdaj_ed[d
^WX[d&
Z_[
_d
Z[h
][mt^d' b_Y^[d
LfhWY^[
d_Y^j
X[iY^h_[X[d
m[hZ[d
atdd[d(
L_[
^WX[d
l_[b
c[^h
FWY^j
kdZ
Zh_d][d
j_[\[h
_d
Z_[
GWjkh][i[jp[
[_d(
L_[
cuii[d
ZWhWd
Z[da[d&
ZWii
l_[b[&
\uh
kdi[h[d
][mt^db_Y^[d
O[hijWdZ
kdbtiXWh[&
IheXb[c[
\uh
^t^[h[
S[djh[d
[habshXWh
m[hZ[d
atdd[d(
NdZ
L_[
cuii[d
_cc[h
pkh
BZ[[
Z[i
I[hcWd[d' j[d
yBY^z
pkhuYaa[^h[d
kdZ
[ha[dd[d&
m_[
m[_j
L_[
ZWled
[dj' \[hdj
kdZ
m_[l_[b[
:dijh[d]kd][d
kdZ
Hf\[h
dtj_]
i_dZ&
kc
[i
pk
[hbWd][d( ;[_
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wc
)CTRPPQPCGL
cuii[d
L_[
Wbi
Wbb[h[hij[i
X[]h[_\[d&
ZWii
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
ZkhY^Wki
fhWaj_iY^
_ij(
M^[eh[j_' iY^[i
LjkZ_kc
m_hZ
d_Y^j
^[b\[d(
Sm[_j[di
cuii[d
L_[
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
Z_[
:hX[_j
Wc
;[mkiiji[_d
dkh
>h][Xd_ii[
Xh_d][d
aWdd&
m[dd
i_[
X[ijsdZ_]
_ij&
eZ[h
Z_[i
ie
m[_j
m_[
ct]b_Y^
m_hZ(
Lfhkd]^W\j[&
pk\sbb_][&
kdj[hXheY^[d[
:hX[_j
aWdd
a[_d[
K[ikb' jWj[
p[_j_][d(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
Wbie
^[hWkipk\_dZ[d&
m_[
L_[
i_Y^
pk
aedj_dk_[hb_Y^[h
:hX[_j
Wc
;[mkiiji[_d
Xh_d][d
atdd[d(
Sk
;[]_dd
ckii
L_[
B^h
O[hijWdZ
hu^h[d(
L_[
ZWk[hdZ
Wd
Z_[
Gej' "&&

m[dZ_]a[_j&
i_Y^
B^h[h
i[bXij
pk
[h_dd[hd
cW^d[d
kdZ
B^d[d
^[b\[d&
Z_[
:k][dXb_Ya[
Z[i
G_Y^j'>h_dd[hdi
pk
[h\Wii[d( :X[h
[ha[dd[d
L_[&
ZWii
Z[h
O[hijWdZ
L_[
dkh
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hX[_j
SMO@COCGQCL
kdZ
L_[
b[Z_]b_Y^
[_d[
][m_ii[
Ljh[Ya[
m[_j
hu^h[d
aWdd(
Bd
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wc
;[mkiiji[_d
atdd[d
L_[
dkh
c_j
A_b\[
Z[i
P_bb[di
kdZ
Z[h
@[\u^b[
\ehjiY^h[_j[d( =[da[d
L_[
WkY^
ZWhWd&
ZWii
;[mkiiji[_d
Wd
Z[h
Esd][
Z[h
Fec[dj[
led
;[mkiiji[_d
kdZ
Wd
Z[h
Ask\_]a[_j
Z[i
:k\jh[j[di
Z_[i[h
Fec[dj[
][c[ii[d
m[hZ[d
aWdd( :dijh[d]kd][d&
;[mkiiji[_d
_d
i_Y^
pk
[hp[k][d&
Xh_d][d
pk
:d\Wd]
\Wij
[_d
@[\u^b
Z[h
Ae\\dkd]ibei_]a[_j
c_j
i_Y^(
:X[h
i[^h
XWbZ
m[hZ[d
i_[
K[ikbjWj[
pk
p[_j_][d
X[]_dd[d(
L_[
m[hZ[d
Z_[i[
>h][Xd_ii[
ZWZkhY^
X[c[ha[d&
ZWii
L_[
:k][dXb_Ya[
led
;[mkiiji[_d
X[eXWY^j[d&
Z_[
led
i[bXij
e^d[
_h][dZ[_d[
:d' ijh[d]kd]
B^h[hi[_ji
Wk\jh[j[d(
Bd
PW^h^[_j
i_dZ
i_[
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
lehWd][]Wd][d[h
:dijh[d]kd][d( =_[
rXkd]&
@[ZWda[d
pk
ijeff[d&
^_b\j
Z[c
L[bXij'>h_dd[hd
i[^h
ijWha(
DWcf\
c_j
>_dX_bZkd]
kdZ
c[Y^Wd_iY^[c
K[Z[d
c_j
i_Y^
i[bXij
kdZ
WdZ[h[d
_ij
led
:d\Wd]
Wd
dejm[dZ_](
:X[h
cWd
m_hZ
deY^
ijsha[h[
A_b\[
ZWhWki
[hbWd][d&
ZWii
cWd
i[_d
E[_Z[d
ef\[hj(
:bb[_d
Z_[i
aWdd
Z_[
:hX[_j
Wc
;[mkiiji[_d
h[Wb
kdZ
[hdij^W\j
cWY^[d(
Oeh^[h
_ij
Wbb[i
dkh
OehX[h[_jkd]
ZW\uh( =_[
:hX[_j
Wd
Z[d
.CD\FJCL
m_[
Z_[
:hX[_j
Wc
;[mkiiji[_d
cuii[d
led
:d\Wd]
Wd
fhWaj_iY^
i[_d(
L_[
X[]_ddj
c_j
Z[c
DWcf\
][][d
ZWi
:kiZhuYa[d
d[]Wj_l[h
@[\u^b[(
P[dd
[_d[
][m_ii[
Dedjhebb[
[hmehX[d
_ij&
kdZ
m[dd
L_[
lebbWk\
Wbb[
iY^b[Y^j[d
L[_j[d
Z[h
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[
_d
B^h[c
[_][d[d
E[X[d
kdZ
Z[c
E[X[d
_c
Wbb][c[_d[d
l[hij[^[d&
cuii[d
L_[
[_d[d
IbWd
\uh
B^h[
f[hitdb_Y^[
:hX[_j
Wd
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed&
>_dX_bZkd]
kdZ
Eu][d
\uh
Z_[
X[iedZ[h[d
?ehc[d&
Z_[
i_[
_d
B^d[d
Wdd[^' c[d&
Wk\ij[bb[d( Bd
Z_[i[h
:hX[_j
Zuh\[d
L_[
a[_d[
:d]ij
^WX[d&
i_Y^
m[^
pk
jkd(
O[hij[^[d
L_[&
ZWii
L_[
dkh
ZWZkhY^&
ZWii
L_[
i_Y^
i[bXij
m[^
jkd&
[h^Wbj[d
atdd[d&
mWi
L_[
mudiY^[d(
L_[
atdd[d
ZWi
jkd&
_dZ[c
L_[
K[][bd
X[WY^j[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b&
_dZ[c
L_[
[jmWi
uX[h
i_Y^
i[bXij
eZ[h
WdZ[h[
skii[hd&
ZWi
L_[
d_Y^j
iW][d
mebb[d& "&'

iedZ[hd
ZWi
B^d[d
X[\e^b[d
mkhZ[(
L_[
atdd[d
WkY^
[_d[d
i[^h
[cej_edWb[d
SkijWdZ
_d
i_Y^
X[m_ha[d&
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^
ZWhWk\
lehX[h[_j[d&
Wk\
Z_[i[
:hj
pk
ifh[Y^[d&
ZWi
^[_iij&
i_Y^
lehij[b' b[d&
[i
muhZ[
B^d[d
X[\e^b[d&
Z_[
PW^h^[_j
uX[h
Z_[
iY^m_[h_]' ij[d
kdZ
_dj_cij[d
=_d][
pk
iW][d&
led
Z[d[d
L_[
]bWkX[d&
ZWii
i_[
ltbb_]
l[hij[Yaj
eZ[h
l[h^ubbj
i_dZ( >ha[dd[d
L_[
WkY^&
ZWii
[i
l_[b[
WdZ[h[
:hj[d
led
E[_Z[d
]_Xj&
Z_[
L_[
ZkhY^bWk\[d
m[hZ[d&
X[leh
L_[
B^h
S_[b
[hh[_Y^[d(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
pk
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
E[_Z[d
ZWi
CGLWGEC
?IQGSC
7OGLWGN
GL
RLP
_ij&
ZWi
_d
^t^[h[i
?u^b[d
l[hmWdZ[bj
m[hZ[d
aWdd
'
mWi
WkY^
^t^[h[i
=[da[d
kdZ
^t^[h[i
O[hij[^[d
_ij( AWX[d
L_[
a[_d[
:d]ij&
Wd
B^h[
@[\u^b[
pk
Z[da[d
kdZ
P_Z[hifhuY^[
_d
_^d[d
pk
[djZ[Ya[d&
WkY^
m[dd
[i
B^d[d
m[^
jkj(
Gkh
m[dd
L_[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[
@[\u^b[&
Z_[
i_Y^
Wk\
Z[di[bX[d
@[][dijWdZ
X[p_[^[d&
l[h]b[_Y^[d&
atdd[d
L_[
Ik\\[h
_d
i_Y^
[djZ[Ya[d
kdZ
l_[bb[_Y^j
p[hijth[d&
m[dd
L_[
^Whj
WhX[_j[d
kdZ
a[_d[
:d]ij
^WX[d&
i_Y^
i[bXij
m[^
pk
jkd( >h_dd[hd
L_[
i_Y^&
ZWii
Z_[i
L_[
pkc
>hmWY^[d
Z[i
@[m_ii[di
\u^h[d
m_hZ&
mWi
ZWi
]b[_Y^p[_j_][
?u^b[d
Wbb[h
m_Z[hifhuY^b_Y^[d
@[\u^b[
_ij5
kdZ
[h_dd[hd
L_[
i_Y^&
ZWii
ZWi
>hmWY^[d
Z[i
@[m_ii[di
[_d
dejm[dZ_][h
LY^h_jj
_ij&
kc
Wk\
Z[d
^t^[h[d
;[mkiiji[_dipkijWdZ
^_duX[hpkm[Y^i[bd( rX[d
L_[
i_Y^
ZWh_d&
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
kdZ
>_dX_bZkd]
led
Z[d
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
WXpkp_[^[d&
e^d[
i_[
pk
p[hijth[d(
L_[
atd' d[d
ltbb_]
kd[hmWhj[j[
kdZ
i[^h
_dj[h[iiWdj[
K[ikbjWj[
[h^Wbj[d( E[hd[d
L_[&
@[\u^b[
_d
][_ij_][
>_dij[bbkd][d
pk
l[hmWdZ[bd
kdZ
i_[
_d
Z[d
O[hijWdZ
pk
uX[h\u^h[d(
O_[b[
@[\u^b[&
Z_[
_c
[cej_edWb[d
S[djhkc
ltbb_]
dkjpbei
kdZ
ie]Wh
iY^sZb_Y^
i_dZ&
m[_b
i_[
Zehj
d_Y^j
e^d[
BZ[dj_\_aWj_ed
kdZ
>_dX_bZkd]
[n_ij_[h[d
atdd[d&
m[hZ[d
Wbi
][_ij_][
>_dij[bbkd][d
]Wdp
dujpb_Y^
kdZ
^[b\[d
Z[h
L[bXijX[eXWY^jkd]&
Z[h
;[eXWY^jkd]
WdZ[h[h
E[kj[
kdZ
Z[c
Wbb][c[_d[d
O[hij[^[d( O[hikY^[d
L_[&
Wbb
B^h[
@[\u^b[
ms^h[dZ
Z[h
]Wdp[d
S[_j&
_d
Z[h
L_[
c_j
Z_[i[c
Loij[c
l[hXkdZ[d
i_dZ&
ZkhY^pk][^[d&
@[' \u^b[&
Z_[
i_Y^
Wk\
ZWi
Loij[c
i[bXij
X[p_[^[d&
Wk\
c_Y^&
Wk\
L_[
i[bXij
kdZ
Wk\
WdZ[h[
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j( "&(

O[hikY^[d
L_[&
i_Y^
i[bXij
][][duX[h
Wk\h_Y^j_]
pk
i[_d(
>h' a[dd[d
L_[&
m_[
L_[
_cc[h
l[hikY^j
^WX[d&
Wki
B^h[h
M[_bdW^c[
Wd
Z[h
:hX[_j
Oehj[_b[
pk
p_[^[d5
pkc
;[_if_[b
ZWZkhY^&
ZWii
L_[
Z_[
X[iedZ[h[
Bdj_c_jsj&
Z_[
kdj[h
E[kj[d
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
[djij[^j
_d\eb][
][c[_diWc[d
fioY^ebe]_iY^[d
LjkZ_kci
kdZ
Z[i
O[h' iY^m_dZ[di
l_[b[h
Ik\\[h&
X[dkjpj[d&
kc
?h[kdZiY^W\j[d
Wk\
Z_[
][mt^db_Y^[
c[Y^Wd_iY^[
kdZ
i[dj_c[djWb[
:hj
pk
iY^b_[ii[d&
E_[X[iX[p_[^kd][d
[_dpk][^[d
kdZ
ie
m[_j[h(
L[^[d
L_[&
m[b' Y^[d
Gkjp[d
L_[
Wki
B^h[h
O[hX_dZkd]
c_j
Z[h
:hX[_j
][pe][d
^WX[d(
>ha[dd[d
L_[&
m_[
e\j
L_[
i[bXijiuY^j_]
kdZ
X[h[Y^d[dZ
mWh[d&
m_[
m[d_]
L_[
Z[h
:hX[_j
]WX[d
kdZ
m_[l_[b
L_[
Wki
_^h
dW^c[d(
L[^[d
L_[&
m_[l_[b
:Xms][d
_d
B^h[d
>_dij[bbkd][d
mWh&
m_[
l_[b[
?ehZ[hkd][d
kdZ
m_[l_[b
:Xb[^dkd]&
X[iedZ[hi
m[dd
E[kj[
B^d[d
pk
^[b\[d
l[hikY^j[d(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
pk
i[^[d&
m_[
Whci[b_]
B^h[
P[hjiY^sjpkd]
Z[h
:hX[_j
mWh&
kdZ
m_[l_[b
L_[
ZWZkhY^
l[hiskcj[d(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
pk
i[^[d&
m_[
jth_Y^j
L_[
mWh[d&
Z[d
d[]Wj_l[d
:di_Y^j[d
led
E[kj[d
:kiZhkYa
pk
][X[d&
Z_[
B^d[d
^sjj[d
^[b\[d
atdd[d&
kdZ
led
Z[d[d
l_[b[
X[h[_ji
l[hiY^mkdZ[d
i_dZ(
O[hikY^[d
L_[
i_Y^
pk
i[^[d&
m_[
L_[
m_ha' b_Y^
i_dZ(
Kk^[d
L_[
i_Y^
d_Y^j
Wki&
X[hk^_][d
L_[
i_Y^
d_Y^j
c_j
\WbiY^[d
Ae\\dkd][d
kdZ
>hmWhjkd][d
led
PkdZ[c
eZ[h
c_j
>djiY^buii[d&
ceh][d
WdZ[hi
pk
^WdZ[bd( =[da[d
L_[
uX[h
ZWi
E[X[d
_c
Wbb][c[_d[d
dWY^&
Z[da[d
L_[
uX[h
Z_[
FWii[d
Xb_dZ[h
kdZ
iY^bW\[dZ[h
E[kj[
dWY^&
Z_[
a[_d[
djiY^[_Zkd]
jh[\\[d&
Z_[
B^h
E[X[d
X[hu^h[d
aWdd&
e^d[
pk[hij
kc
c[_d[
F[_dkd]
pk
X_jj[d(
B^h[
[_][d[d
>djiY^[_Zkd][d
_d
[hdij[d
:d][b[][d^[_j[d
X[hk^[d
pmWd]ibsk\_]
Wk\
>_][dm_bb[d( :X[h
L_[
atdd[d
d_Y^j
kc
c[_d[
F[_dkd]
eZ[h
c[_d[
>dj' iY^[_Zkd]
X_jj[d&
m[dd
B^h
>djiY^bkii
X[h[_ji
][\sbbj
_ij&
kdZ
L_[
X[h[_ji
Wk\
Z_[i[h
;Wi_i
pk
^WdZ[bd
X[]edd[d
^WX[d&
Z[dd
ZWi
X[Z[kj[j
>_][dm_bb[
_d
:aj_ed&
kdZ
_d
iebY^
[_d[c
?Wbb
_ij
[i
pk
ifsj&
c_Y^
pk
\hW][d(
LY^[_dXWh[
?hW][d
dWY^
c[_d[h
F[_dkd]
kdZ
c[_d[h
>djiY^[_Zkd]&
m[dd
B^h
>djiY^bkii
X[h[_ji
][jhe\\[d
_ij&
i_dZ
jWjisY^b_Y^
FWd_\[ijWj_ed[d
Z[h
NdWk\h_Y^j_]a[_j
c_j
B^d[d
i[bXij
kdZ
O[hikY^[&
c_Y^
ZkhY^
Oehif_[][bkd]
\WbiY^[h
MWjiWY^[d
pk
jskiY^[d( O[hikY^[d
L_[
pk
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
c[Y^Wd_iY^[
AWdZbkd][d
kdZ
c[Y^Wd_iY^[
>djiY^[_Zkd][d
_cc[h
Wk\
>hms]kd][d
Wki' i[h^WbX
Z[h
:hX[_j
X[hk^[d
"WkY^
m[dd
L_[
i_Y^
ZWled
uX[hp[k' ][d&
ZWii
ZWi
>h][Xd_i
\uh
B^h[
:hX[_j
dujpb_Y^
i[_d
m_hZ#&
>hms]kd][d
Z[i
O[h]du][di&
Z[h
;[gk[cb_Y^a[_j
eZ[h
;[^W]' b_Y^a[_j5
eZ[h
i_[
h[ikbj_[h[d
Wki
d[]Wj_l[d
@[\u^b[d
eZ[h
Wki
>_dX_bZkd]( O[hikY^[d
L_[
pk
l[hij[^[d&
ZWii
Z_[
c[Y^Wd_iY^ij[
FWd_\[' ijWj_ed&
m[dd
L_[
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
i_dZ
kdZ
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
pk
i[_d
mudiY^[d&
_ij&
c_Y^
Wdpkbu][d
eZ[h
Z_[
PW^h^[_j
leh
c_h
pk
kdj[hZhuYa[d( =_[
?ehZ[hkd]
dWY^
ltbb_][h
>^hb_Y^a[_j
X[p_[^j
i_Y^
d_Y^j
Wk\
E[kj[&
Z_[
][hWZ[
c_j
c_h
pk
WhX[_j[d
X[]_dd[d(
L_[
cuii[d
bWd][
OehWhX[_j
Wd
O[hijWdZ
kdZ
;[mkiiji[_d
b[_ij[d&
X[leh
lebbijsdZ_][
>^hb_Y^a[_j
dejm[dZ_]
kdZ
eXb_]Wjeh_iY^
m_hZ(
:X[h
m[dd
i_[
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
f[hitdb_Y^[h
A_b\[
[ha[dd[d
kdZ
m[dd
_Y^
\_dZ[&
ZWii
i_[
X[h[_j
i_dZ
kdZ
_Y^
_^d[d
^[b\[d
aWdd&
m_hZ
ZWi
Ih_dp_f
lebbijsdZ_][h
>^hb_Y^a[_j
eXb_]Wjeh_iY^(
NdZ
[i "'!

_ij
pm[_\[bbei
\uh
Wbb[
E[kj[
eXb_]Wjeh_iY^&
Z_[
i[_j
\ud\
CW^h[d
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
i_dZ
kdZ
WkY^
\uh
[_d_][&
Z_[
m[_j
auhp[h
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
i_dZ&
WX[h
X[h[_ji
_^h
S_[b
\ehckb_[hj
^WX[d( =[da[d
L_[
ZWhWd&
ZWii
kdi[h[
AWkfjWhX[_j
Z[c
>_][dm_bb[d
][bj[d
ckii(
FWd
X[]_ddj
i[_d[d
P_bb[d
Wk\pk][X[d&
_dZ[c
cWd
K[][bd
Wap[fj_[hj&
WX[h
cWd
ckii
Wk\h_Y^j_]
ZWc_j
i[_d(
Lfsj[h
ckii
cWd
i[_d[d
>_][dm_bb[d
_d
Wbb[d
[hdij^W\j[d
:d][b[][d^[_' j[d
Wk\][X[d
kdZ
Z[d
P_bb[d
[_d[h
WdZ[h[d
I[hied
Wap[fj_[h[d&
_d
Z_[i[c
?Wbb
Z[d
c[_d_][d(
Gkh
m[dd
cWd
ie
^WdZ[bj
kdZ
[i
c_j
lebb[c
O[hij[^[d
Z[h
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
^_[hpk
jkj&
m_hZ
cWd
X[]_dd[d&
bWd]iWc
i[_d[d
[_][d[d
P_bb[d
pk
[hm[hX[d(
MWjisY^' b_Y^
_ij
Z_[
[hij[
AWdZbkd]
Z[i
:k\][X[di
led
>_][dm_bb[d
Z[h
[hij[
:aj
kdZ
Z_[
[hij[
FWd_\[ijWj_ed
m_hab_Y^[d
P_bb[di( =_[
l_[h
E_d_[d
Z[h
:hX[_j
Wd
i_Y^
i[bXij
atdd[d
X[p[_Y^d[j
m[hZ[d4
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[
:hX[_j
'
GCJ&
:hX[_j
Wd
Z[d
@[\u^b[d
'
4GQQCJ!
,LCOEGC&
:hX[_j
Wc
P_bb[d
'
2MLQOMJJC
kdZ
[X[d\Wbbi
,LCOEGC#

;=L
ELM
@EA
7?DNGA+ -O?EC%
PWi
_ij
Z_[
LY^kb[9 6RPNCLPIV%
=_[
LY^kb[
_ij
[_d[
Hh]Wd_iWj_ed
pkh
rX[hjhW]kd]
led
P_ii[d&
ZWi
led
[_d[c
^t^[h[d
@[_ij
"F_dZ#
ijWccj&
Wk\
[_d[
X[ij_ccj[
:dpW^b
lehX[h[_j[j[h
E[kj[( =Wi
P[i[djb_Y^ij[
_d
Z[h
LY^kb[
_ij
ZWi
P_ii[d&
ZWi
Wki
[_d[c
^t^[h[d
@[_ij
aeccj(
=Wi
X[Z[kj[j&
ZWii
LY^kb[d
d_Y^j
m_bbauh' b_Y^
e^d[
;[j[_b_]kd]
led
E[kj[d
][X_bZ[j
m[hZ[d
atdd[d&
Z_[
P_ii[d
_d
LY^kb[d
[cf\Wd][d
^WX[d(
>_d
WdZ[h[h
i[^h
m_Y^j_][h
?Wajeh
_ij
Z_[
led
LY^kb[d
X[m_haj[
:kimW^b&
ZWi
^[_iij
Z_[
:kimW^b
Z[h
LY^ub[h(
Gkh
E[kj[
c_j
[_d[h
X[ij_ccj[d
OehX[h[_' jkd]
kdZ
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
G_l[Wk
Z[i
O[hij[^[di
m[hZ[d
pk][bWii[d(
>_d[
LY^kb[
aWdd
d_Y^j
Wbb[d
e\\[dij[^[d&
i_[
aWdd
d_Y^j
[_dcWb
\uh
l_[b[
pk]sd]b_Y^
i[_d(
>_d[
LY^kb[
_ij
_cc[h
[_d
][iY^beii[d[h
Dh[_i
c_j
Z[c
E[^h[h
_d
Z[h
F_jj[( LY^kb[d
atdd[d
led
i[^h
l[hiY^_[Z[d[c
?ehcWj
i[_d&
ZWi
led "'"

Z[h
OehX[h[_jkd]
kdZ
Z[h
L[_di[X[d[
Z[i
LY^ub[hi
WX^sd]j(
C[
^t^[h
ZWi
G_l[Wk
Z[h
LY^kb[&
Z[ije
]htii[h
Z_[
:d\ehZ[hkd][d&
Z_[
Wd
Z_[
LY^ub[h
][ij[bbj
m[hZ[d( -O?EC%
PWhkc
i_dZ
LY^kb[d
dejm[dZ_]9 6RPNCLPIV%
;[leh
cWd
ZWled
ifh[Y^[d
aWdd&
T?ORK
LY^kb[d
dejm[dZ_]
i_dZ&
ckii
cWd
[ha[dd[d&
D\O
TCL
LY^kb[d
dejm[dZ_]
i_dZ&
Z[dd
LY^kb[d
i_dZ
\uh
Z_[
]heii[
FWii[
Z[h
E[kj[
uX[h' ^Wkfj
d_Y^j
dejm[dZ_](
LY^kb[d
i_dZ
\uh
iebY^[
E[kj[
dejm[dZ_]&
Z_[
X[h[_ji
Z_[
Ndpkbsd]b_Y^a[_j
Z[i
P_ii[di&
ZWi
Z[h
][mt^db_' Y^[
O[hijWdZ
iWcc[bj&
[ha[dd[d
kdZ
Z_[
\u^b[d&
ZWii
i_[
Wbb[_d[&
Wki
_^h[h
[_][d[d
DhW\j
m[Z[h
Z_[
i_[
kc][X[dZ[d
IheXb[c[
bti[d
deY^
Z[d
h_Y^j_][d
P[]
\_dZ[d
atdd[d(
Gkh
iebY^[
E[kj[
i_dZ
\s^_]&
Z_[
LY^m_[h_]a[_j[d
pk
uX[hm_dZ[d&
Z_[
c_j
Z[h
LY^kbWhX[_j
l[hXkdZ[d
i_dZ&
kdZ
dkh
\uh
i_[
i_dZ
LY^kb[d
dtj_]( Nc
pk
l[hij[^[d&
T?ORK
LY^kb[d
dejm[dZ_]
i_dZ&
ckii
cWd
[ha[dd[d&
ZWii
ZWi
P_ii[d&
ZWi
led
F[diY^[d
^t^[h[d
@[_ij[i
"F_dZ#
aeccj&
dkh
[_d[h
i[^h
X[]h[dpj[d
:dpW^b
led
E[kj[d
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
uX[hjhW][d
m[hZ[d
aWdd5
Z_[i
ckii
kdj[h
dejm[dZ_' ][h
;[eXWY^jkd]
[_d[h
]Wdp[
K[_^[
Z[\_d_j_l[h
;[Z_d]kd][d&
Z_[
Z[c
E[^h[h
Z[h
LY^kb[
]kj
X[aWddj
i[_d
cuii[d&
][iY^[^[d&
e^d[
Z_[
ZWi
P_ii[d
d_Y^j
ECL?R
uX[hc_jj[bj
m[hZ[d
aWdd( =_[
>n_ij[dp
Z_[i[h
;[Z_d]kd][d
kdZ
Z_[
Ndct]b_Y^a[_j&
e^d[
i_[
Wkipkaecc[d&
[habsh[d
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
[_d[h
Hh]W' d_iWj_ed(
=_[
rX[hc_jjbkd]
led
P_ii[d
[h\ehZ[hj
:dijh[d]kd][d
ieme^b
led
L[_j[d
Z[ii[d&
Z[h
[i
[cf\sd]j
Wbi
WkY^
led
Z[c&
Z[h
[i
]_Xj(
=_[
Hh]Wd_iWj_ed
[hb[_Y^j[hj
Z_[i[
:dijh[d]kd][d
eZ[h
[hct]b_Y^j
i_[(
=_[i[
;[Z_d]kd][d
atdd[d
d_Y^j
led
Wbb[_d[
Wk\jh[j[d(
>_d[
LY^kb[
aWdd
dkh
][csii
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d&
][dWk
\[ij][b[]j[d
IbWd
eh]Wd_i_[hj
m[hZ[d&
Z[h
leh
bWd][h
S[_j
Wki][WhX[_j[j
mkhZ[
kdZ
X[aWddj
mWh(
Bd
[_d[h
LY^kb[
aWdd
[i
d_Y^ji
P_bbauhb_Y^[i
eZ[h
Bcfhel_i_[hj[i
][X[d(
:X[h
LY^kb[d
atdd[d
led
l[hiY^_[Z[d[c
Mof
i[_d&
[djifh[Y^[dZ
Z[d
l[hiY^_[' Z[d[d
P[][d(
rX[h
Z_[
l[hiY^_[Z[d[d
P[][
m_hZ
ifsj[h
][ifhe' Y^[d
m[hZ[d( -O?EC%
DWdd
[habshj
m[hZ[d&
meh_d
Z_[i[
;[Z_d]kd][d
X[' ij[^[d9 "'#

6RPNCLPIV%
=_[i[
;[Z_d]kd][d
i_dZ
c_j
[_d[h
X[ij_ccj[d
>_][diY^W\j
Z[h
c[diY^b_Y^[d
GWjkh
l[haduf\j&
dscb_Y^
`[d[h&
ZWii
[i
pm[_
L[_j[d
Z[i
F[diY^[d
]_Xj&
Z_[
i_Y^&
_d
Z[h
Wbb][c[_' d[d
>djm_Yabkd]
Z[i
F[diY^[d&
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
kdZ
fWhWbb[b
[dj\Wb' j[d
iebbj[d4
=GPPCL
kdZ
9CGL#
=_[
E[kj[
m_ii[d&
eZ[h
]bWkX[d
pk
m_ii[d&
mWi
P_ii[d
_ij&
kdZ
_d
[_d[c
X[ij_ccj[d
:kicWii
X[]h[_\[d
i_[
Z_[
K[bWj_l_jsj
led
P_ii[d(
:X[h
i_[
i_dZ
i_Y^
d_Y^j
X[mkiij&
mWi
L[_d
_ij&
kdZ
i_[
l[hij[^[d
d_Y^j
Z_[
K[bWj_l_jsj
Z[i
L[_di
kdZ
Z_[
MWjiWY^[&
ZWii
P_ii[d
lec
L[_d
WX^sd]j(
Bdpm_' iY^[d
p[_j_]j
Z_[
>djm_Yabkd]
Z[i
P_ii[di
e^d[
[djifh[Y^[dZ[
>djm_Yabkd]
Z[i
L[_di
eZ[h
[_d[
>djm_Yabkd]
Z[i
L[_di
e^d[
[djifh[Y^[dZ[
>djm_Yabkd]
Z[i
P_ii[di
\WbiY^[
K[ikbjWj[(
LY^k' b[d
i_dZ
dejm[dZ_]&
kc
iebY^
[_d[
[_di[_j_][
>djm_Yabkd]
kdZ
Z_[
ZWc_j
l[hXkdZ[d[d&
kd[hmudiY^j[d
>h][Xd_ii[
pk
l[hc[_Z[d(
=_[
;[Z_d]kd][d
Z[i
E[^h[di
_d
Z[h
LY^kb[
i_dZ
ie&
ZWii
Z_[
:hX[_j
led
Z[d
Wbb[h[hij[d
LY^h_jj[d
Wd
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
[djbWd]
pm[_' [h
E_d_[d
\ehjiY^h[_j[j&
Z[h
E_d_[
Z[i
P_ii[di
kdZ
Z[h
E_d_[
Z[i
L[_di(
Oed
Z[d
[hij[d
MW][d
_d
Z[h
LY^kb[
Wd&
X[]_ddj
[_d
F[diY^&
Z_[
F[Y^Wd_i_[hj^[_j
pk
ijkZ_[h[d
kdZ
][][d
F[Y^Wd_'
i_[hj^[_j
_d
i_Y^
i[bXij
pk
ascf\[d&
][][d
kdm_bbauhb_Y^[
AWdZ' bkd][d&
][][d
kddtj_][i
K[Z[d&
][][d
>_dX_bZkd]&
][][d
MW]' jhskc[d
kdZ
][][d
LY^bW\(
>i
m_hZ
_^c
[habshj&
ZWii
i[_d
P_ii[d
led
i[_d[c
L[_d
WX^sd]j(
P[dd
[_d
F[diY^
[_d[d
LY^h_jj
[dj' bWd]
Z[c
I\WZ
Z[i
P_ii[di
kdj[hd_ccj&
ckii
[h
[_d[d
LY^h_jj
[djbWd]
Z[c
I\WZ
Z[i
L[_di
jkd(
=_[
Ih_dp_f_[d
Z[h
LY^kbWhX[_j&
Wbb[
Wd
_^d
][ij[bbj[d
?ehZ[hkd][d&
Z_[
K[][bd&
Z_[
[h
[h_dd[hd
ckii&
Wbb[i
^_b\j
_^c&
i[_d
P[i[d
pk
ijkZ_[h[d
kdZ
ZWhWd
pk
WhX[_j[d&
[i
pk
sdZ[hd( -O?EC%
PWhkc
_ij
P_ii[d
dejm[dZ_]9 6RPNCLPIV%
=Wi
S_[b
[_d[i
F[diY^[d&
Z[h
i[_d[d
SkijWdZ
kdZ
i[_d[
EW][
[ha[ddj&
m_hZ
pkh
P[i[dimWdZbkd](
=_[i[
qdZ[hkd]
_ij
ie
iY^m[h&
ZWii
i_[
_d
Z[h
MWj
kdct]b_Y^
msh[&
m[dd
[i
ZWi
P_ii[d
d_Y^j
]sX[&
kc
_^c
pk
^[b\[d( -O?EC%
DWdd
[_d[
P[i[disdZ[hkd]&
ZWi
^[_iij&
ZWi
>hh[_Y^[d
[_d[h
X[ij_ccj[d
L[_di[X[d[&
P_ii[d
Xh_d][d9 6RPNCLPIV%
G[_d&
ZWi
aWdd
[i
d_Y^j(
P_ii[d
kdZ
L[_d
ZhuYa[d "'$

pm[_
L[_j[d
Z[h
c[diY^b_Y^[d
GWjkh
Wki&
Z_[
i_Y^
[djm_Ya[bd
kdZ
mWY^i[d
atdd[d&
WX[h
_^h[
>dj\Wbjkd]
[h\ehZ[hj
kdj[hiY^_[Zb_Y^[
:dijh[d]kd][d( -O?EC%
Peled
^sd]j
O[hij[^[d
WX&
lec
P_ii[d
eZ[h
lec
L[_d9 6RPNCLPIV%
P[Z[h
P_ii[d
deY^
L[_d
atdd[d
][jh[ddj
h_Y^j_' ][i
O[hij[^[d
[h][X[d(
=[h
@hkdZ
^_[h\uh
_ij&
ZWii
O[hij[^[d
ZWi
K[ikbjWj
Wki
P_ii[d
kdZ
L[_d
_ij(
>_d
PWY^i[d
Z[i
O[hij[' ^[di
_ij
dkh
c_j
]b[_Y^p[_j_][c
PWY^i[d
led
P_ii[d
kdZ
L[_d
ct]b_Y^(
P[dd
[_d[i
l_[b
iY^d[bb[h
Wbi
ZWi
WdZ[h[
msY^ij&
aWdd
i_Y^
ZWi
O[hij[^[d
d_Y^j
_d
Z[h
h_Y^j_][d
K_Y^jkd]
[djm_Ya[bd( -O?EC&
PWi
_ij
c_j
PWY^i[d
Z[i
P_ii[di
kdZ
PWY^i[d
Z[i
L[_di
][c[_dj9 6RPNCLPIV%
=Wi
PWY^i[d
Z[i
P_ii[di
X[Z[kj[j
[_d[d
rX[h' ]Wd]
lec
;[iedZ[h[d
pkc
:bb][c[_d[d&
led
>_dp[b^[_j[d
pkc
@Wdp[d&
lec
Bbbki_edsh[d
pkc
K[Wb[d(
@[mt^db_Y^[i
P_ii[d&
eZ[h
mWi
P_ii[d
][dWddj
m_hZ&
_ij
_cc[h
[_d
P_ii[d
led
>_dp[b' ^[_j[d
e^d[
D[ddjd_i
Z[i
@Wdp[d&
[_d
P_ii[d
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
;bsjj[h&
eZ[h
Wk\
Z_[
:Z[hd
eZ[h
:kipWYakd][d
Wd
;bsjj[hd
e^d[
D[ddjd_i
Z[i
;Wkci(
PW^h[i
P_ii[d
p[_]j
d_Y^j
dkh
[_d[
][][X[d[
>_dp[b^[_j&
iedZ[hd
WkY^
Z[d
IbWjp&
Z_[
?kdaj_ed
kdZ
Z_[
;[Z[kjkd]
Z[h
>_dp[b^[_j
_c
@Wdp[d(
Bd
kdi[h[c
][mt^db_' Y^[d
P_ii[d
]_Xj
[i
S[_j[d&
Z_[
kdi
dW^[
Wd
mW^h[i
P_ii[d
^[hWd\u^h[d(
Skc
;[_if_[b
Z[\_d_[hj
_c
][mt^db_Y^[d
;[p[_Y^' dkd]iioij[c
d_Y^j
dkh
`[Z[
SW^b
Z_[
Iej[dp&
iedZ[hd
p[_]j
Z[d
LjWdZehj
Z_[i[h
DhW\j
_d
Z[h
K[_^[
Z[h
Iej[dp[d
led
Gkbb
pkh
Nd[dZb_Y^a[_j(
:bb[i
mW^h[
P_ii[d
_ij
led
Z_[i[h
:hj( PW^h[i
P_ii[d
aeccj
lec
^t^[h[d
@[_ij
"F_dZ#&
ZWi
^[_iij
lec
@[_ij
Z[h
F[diY^[d&
m[bY^[
Z_[
^tY^ij[
>djm_Yabkd]
[h' h[_Y^j
^WX[d&
Z_[
Z[c
F[diY^[d
ct]b_Y^
_ij(
>i
m_hZ
M@HCIQGSCP
=GPPCL
][dWddj&
_c
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
pkc
P_ii[d
][mt^db_Y^[h
F[d' iY^[d&
ZWi
ikX`[aj_l[i
P_ii[d
^[_iij(
HX`[aj_l[i
P_ii[d
_ij
_cc[h
9AFRJTGPPCL!
ZWi
^[_iij
_d
[_d[h
LY^kb[
[hmehX[d[i
P_ii[d(
>_d
F[diY^
aWdd
[i
d_Y^j
c_j
i[_d[c
[_][d[d
@[_ij
[hh[_Y^[d
eZ[h
Wki
;uY^[hd
X[p_[^[d( >_d[h
Z[h
@hkdZ][ZWda[d
eX`[aj_l[d
P_ii[di
_ij&
ZWii
P_ii[d "'%

Z[h
m_hab_Y^[d
P[bj
ct]b_Y^
_ij&
WX[h
dkh
kdj[h
Z[h
;[Z_d]kd]&
ZWii
cWd
[i
l[hij[^j&
Z_[
Ih_dp_f_[d
led
8CJ?QGSGQZQ
kdZ
4?PP
Wdpkm[dZ[d
kdZ
\[hd[h
Z_[
]hkdZb[][dZ[d
@[i[jp[
Z[i
Nd_l[h' ikci&
ZWi
.CPCQW
BCO
+OCG
kdZ
ZWi
.CPCQW
BCO
9GC@CL
a[ddj(
=[h
Sk]Wd]
pkc
LjkZ_kc
eX`[aj_l[d
P_ii[di
X[]_ddj
c_j
Z[c
Ljk' Z_kc
[_d[h
eX`[aj_l[d
LfhWY^[(
=[h
dsY^ij[
LY^h_jj
_ij
ZWi
LjkZ_kc
i[_d[h
i[bXij&
ZWi
c_j
Z[c
O[hij[^[d
Z[i
IbWjp[i
Z[i
F[diY^[d
_c
Nd_l[hikc
kdZ
Z[c
LjkZ_kc
Z[h
c[diY^b_Y^[d
FWiY^_d[
Wd\sd]j(
=_[
D[ddjd_i
i[_d[h
i[bXij
_ij
ieme^b
S_[b
Wbi
WkY^
F_jj[b( >_d
F[diY^&
Z[h
a[_d[
LY^kbb[^h[d
[h\s^hj&
ZWi
^[_iij&
[_d
F[diY^
led
][mt^db_Y^[h
=[dam[_i[&
b[Xj
led
Bbbki_ed[d
kc][' X[d&
Z_[
i_Y^
^WkfjisY^b_Y^
Wk\
_^d
i[bXij
X[p_[^[d(
>h
]bWkXj&
P_bb[d
pk
^WX[d
kdZ
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
Z[h
PW^b
_d
`[Z[c
:k][d' Xb_Ya
i[_d[i
E[X[di5
[h
]bWkXj&
QRL
pk
atdd[d5
[h
]bWkXj&
BdZ_l_' ZkWb_jsj
pk
^WX[d&
ZWi
^[_iij&
[jmWi
I[hcWd[dj[i
kdZ
Ndl[hsdZ[h' b_Y^[i5
[h
]bWkXj&
[_d
]b[_Y^[hcWii[d
f[hcWd[dj[i
kdZ
kdl[hsd' Z[hb_Y^[i
yBY^z
eZ[h
>]e
pk
X[i_jp[d5
[h
X[jhWY^j[j
i_Y^
Wbi
@CTRPP" QCP
=CPCL
kdZ
d_ccj
Wd&
ZWi
E[X[d
Wk\
Z[h
>hZ[
ZWZkhY^
WhhWd' ]_[h[d
pk
atdd[d&
ZWii
[h
Z[d
A_dm[_i[d
led
O[hdkd\j
kdZ
Ee]_a
\eb]j5
[h
X[p[_Y^d[j
i[_d[d
][mt^db_Y^[d
;[mkiiji[_dipkijWdZ&
_dZ[c
[h
b[Xj
kdZ
^WdZ[bj&
Wbi
IJ?OCP
)CTRPPQPCGL!
ms^h[dZ
[h
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
iY^bs\j(
Bd
Z_[i[c
LY^bW\
b[Xj
[h&
iY^h[_Xj
[h
;uY^[h&
[h\_dZ[j
[h
M^[eh_[d&
\u^hj
[h
Dh_[][&
jtj[j
[h
WdZ[h[
iY^bW\[dZ[
E[kj[
kdZ
ij_hXj
[h
i[bXij&
e^d[
WkY^
dkh
[_d[d
:k][dXb_Ya
\uh
mW^hiY^[_db_Y^
pk
^Wbj[d&
ZWii
[h
Wk\mWY^[d
atddj[( >h
[ha[ddj
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
pkh
>djm_Yabkd]
eZ[h
pkc
PWY^i' jkc
d_Y^j(
>h
iY^h[_Xj
i_Y^
pk&
mWi
[h
d_Y^j
X[i_jpj(
:X[h
[h
m[_ii
d_Y^j&
m_[l_[b
[h
[hbWd][d
atddj[( P[dd
[h
[_d
F[diY^
m_ii[diY^W\jb_Y^[h
:di_Y^j[d
_ij&
hskcj
[h
Z[h
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
[_d[h
_dZ_l_Zk[bb[d
>lebkj_ed
Z[i
F[diY^[d
uX[h
Z_[
@h[dp[d
uXb_Y^[h
_dj[bb[ajk[bb[h
>djm_Yabkd]
ms^h[dZ
[_d[i
E[X[di
^_dWki
a[_d[d
IbWjp
[_d(
LjWjjZ[ii[d
[ha[ddj
[h
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
Z[h
>lebkj_ed
Z[i
F[diY^[d
?JP
9NCWGCP
Wd
kdZ
[h
X[jhWY^j[j
[_d[
iebY^[
>djm_Yabkd]
Wbi
ltbb_]
c[Y^Wd_iY^&
ZWi
^[_iij&
d_Y^j
led
_h][dZ
`[cWdZ[i
P_bb[d
WX^sd]_]( "'&

P[dd
[h
[_d
h[b_]_ti[h
F[diY^
_ij&
]bWkXj
[h
Wd
[_d
pkaud\j_][i
E[X[d
kdZ
ZWii
[h
WR
PCGLCK
CGECLCL
.RQCL
led
^t^[h[d
Dhs\j[d
][b[_j[j
m_hZ&
c_j
Z[d[d
[h
c_jj[bi
@[X[j[d
_d
O[hX_dZkd]
jh[j[d
aWdd( P[dd
[h
c_j
Z[h
M^[eief^_[
l[hjhWkj
_ij&
]bWkXj
[h
Wd
ZWi
@[i[jp
led
DWhcW
kdZ
K[_daWhdWj_ed5
[h
_ij
Z[h
F[_dkd]&
[_d[d
:ijhWbathf[h&
[_d[d
F[djWbathf[h
kdZ
[_d[d
DWkiWbathf[h
pk
X[i_jp[d
kdZ
ZWii
[h
ZkhY^
[_d[
kdl[hc[_Zb_Y^[
>djm_Yabkd]
Z_[
Wbb[h^tY^ij[d
Ljk\[d
[hh[_Y^[d
m_hZ&
m[dd
d_Y^j
Wk\
>hZ[d&
ZWdd
Wk\
_h][dZ[_d[c
WdZ[h[d
IbWd[j[d( P[dd
[h
X[h[_ji
Z_[
Ndpkbsd]b_Y^a[_j
kdZ
_bbkieh_iY^[
GWjkh
m_ii[diY^W\jb_Y^[h&
h[b_]_ti[h
kdZ
j^[eief^_iY^[h
BZ[[d
X[]h_\\[d
^Wj
kdZ
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
_dd[h[d
PWdZ[bi
_c
F[diY^[d
[h' a[ddj&
i_[^j
[h
d_Y^j
Z[ii[d
LY^m_[h_]a[_j
[_d&
[ha[ddj
[h
d_Y^j
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j
bWd]m_[h_][h
kdZ
ioij[cWj_iY^[h
:dijh[d]kd' ][d&
Z_[
e^d[
D[ddjd_i
Z[h
F[j^eZ[d&
e^d[
[nWaj[
kdZ
Z[jW_b' b_[hj[
D[ddjd_i
Z[h
c[diY^b_Y^[d
FWiY^_d[
kdct]b_Y^
i_dZ(
B^c
iY^[_dj&
ZWii&
mWi
aecc[d
I?LL!
WkY^
aecc[d
KRPP# :X[h
_d
P_hab_Y^a[_j
aeccj
d_Y^ji
led
Wbb[_d[(
FWd
ckii
i_Y^
[hij
led
Bbbki_ed[d
X[\h[_[d
kdZ
ZWdd
WhX[_j[d&
kc
[_d
WdZ[h[i
L[_d
pk
[hbWd][d(
=_[i[
:hX[_j
[h\ehZ[hj
bWd][
kdZ
ioij[cWj_iY^[
:dijh[d]kd][d
iem_[
P_ii[d( -O?EC%
PWi
_ij
Z[h
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
pm_iY^[d
Z[h
LY^kb[&
led
Z[h
L_[
ifh[Y^[d
kdZ
Z[h
y[iej[h_iY^[d
LY^kb[z
_d
Z[h
M^[eief^_'
iY^[d
@[i[bbiY^W\j9
>i
iY^[_dj
c_h&
ZWii
Z[h
@[ZWda[&
Z[h
X[_Z[d
pk]hkdZ[
b_[]j&
_Z[dj_iY^
_ij( 6RPNCLPIV%
=[h
AWkfjkdj[hiY^_[Z
pm_iY^[d
Z[h
LY^kb[&
led
Z[h
_Y^
ifh[Y^[&
kdZ
Z[h
y[iej[h_iY^[d
LY^kb[z
b_[]j
_d
Z[h
MWjiWY^[&
ZWii
Z_[
y[iej[h_iY^[
LY^kb[z
iepkiW][d
Z[h
rX[hXWk
eZ[h
ZWi
eX[h[
LjeYam[ha
Z[h
][iWcj[d
M^[eief^_[
_ij(
Nc
pkh
y[iej[h_iY^[d
LY^kb[z
pk
aecc[d&
ckii
cWd
Z[d
]Wdp[d
K[ij
Wap[fj_[h[d(
NdZ
_c
j^[eief^_iY^[d
Loij[c
]_Xj
[i
i[^h
l_[b&
mWi
dW_l&
kdbe]_iY^&
m_Z[hifhuY^b_Y^
kdZ
kdct]b_Y^
_ij( -O?EC%
PWi
_ij
Z[h
Ndj[hiY^_[Z
pm_iY^[d
Z[d
yF[_ij[hdz
kdZ
Z[d
P[i[d
^t^[h[d
@[_ij[i9 6RPNCLPIV%
yF[_ij[hz
_d
Z[h
M^[eief^_[
ij[^[d
c_j
[_d[h
abWh "''

kch_ii[d[d
3CECLBC
_d
O[hX_dZkd]&
Z_[
c_j
;bWlWjiao
X[]_ddj(
Nc
yF[_ij[hz
pk
Wap[fj_[h[d&
cuii[d
L_[
Z_[
][iWcj[
E[][dZ[
Wdd[^c[d(
Bdpm_iY^[d
]_Xj
[i
i[^h
l_[b&
ZWi
_d
Z_[i[h
E[][dZ[
kdWdd[^cXWh
kdZ
kdct]b_Y^
_ij(
3CRQC
F[FCOCL
.CGPQCP
ij[^[d
c_j
a[_d[h
:hj
led
E[][dZ[
_d
O[hX_dZkd](
=[h
F[diY^&
m_[
m_h
_^d
a[dd[d&
m_hZ
d_Y^j
Wbi
Z[h
^tY^ij
ct]b_Y^[
:kiZhkYa
i[_d[h
:hj
kdZ
d_Y^j
Wbi
[_d
lebbijsdZ_][i
P[i[d
X[jhWY^j[j&
iedZ[hd
Wbi
[_d
P[i[d
_d
[_d[h
X[ij_ccj[d
I^Wi[
i[_d[h
ct]b_Y^[d
:O?LPDMO" K?QGML#
=_[i[
MhWdi\ehcWj_ed
m_hZ
Wbi
_d
[_d[h
E[X[diifWdd[
ct]b_Y^
Wd][i[^[d&
ZWi
^[_iij&
[i
m_hZ
Wd][decc[d&
ZWii
[_d
F[diY^&
Z[h
_d
[_d[h
X[ij_ccj[d
I^Wi[
][Xeh[d
_ij&
ms^h[dZ
[_d[h
E[X[diifWdd[
_d
[_d[
WdZ[h[
uX[h][^[d
aWdd(
P[dd
m_h
ZWi
;[_if_[b
[_d[h
LY^c[jj[hb_d]i
d[^c[d&
ZWdd
_ij
Z[h
F[diY^
Wdds^[hdZ
[_d[
KWkf[(
NdZ
Z_[
]heii[
F[^h^[_j
Z[h
F[diY^[d
ij_hXj
Wbi
yKWkf[dz(
:X[h
Wki
Z[h
FWii[
led
KWkf[d
][^j
WdZWk[hdZ
[_d
ab[_d[h
:dj[_b
i_Y^
jhWdi\ehc_[h[dZ[h
P[i[d
^[h' leh(
=_[i[
i_Y^
[djm_Ya[bdZ[d
P[i[d
i_dZ&
\uh
kdi&
3CRQC
F[FC" OCL
.CGPQCP
"F_dZ#(
P_h
m_ii[d
led
_^h[h
>n_ij[dp
Wki
Lfkh[d
_^h[h
:aj_l_jsj
_d
Z[h
@[iY^_Y^j[&
^WkfjisY^b_Y^
_d
Dkdij
kdZ
K[b_]_ed(
=W
i_[
[_d[d
f[h\[aj[h[d
@[_ij
Wbi
][mt^db_Y^[
F[d' iY^[d
X[i_jp[d&
l[h\u][d
i_[
uX[h
]htii[h[i
P_ii[d(
=_[
LY^kb[d&
led
Z[d[d
_Y^
ifh[Y^[&
^WX[d
pkc
S_[b&
][mt^db_Y^[
E[kj[&
Z_[
Z_[
Gejm[dZ_]a[_j&
Wki
_^h[c
][][dmshj_][d
SkijWdZ
WkipkXh[' Y^[d&
][\u^bj
eZ[h
[haWddj
^WX[d&
Z[d
BZ[[d
dW^[
pk
Xh_d][d&
Z_[
led
F[diY^[d
^t^[h[d
@[_ij[i
"F_dZ#
aecc[d&
Z[dd
Wbb[_d
Z_[i[
BZ[[d
atdd[d
_^h[
MhWdi\ehcWj_ed
kdj[hijujp[d&
ZWi
^[_iij&
_^h[d
rX[h]Wd]
Wk\
[_d[
d[k[
L[_diijk\[
][ms^hb[_ij[d( -O?EC%
@bWkX[d
L_[&
ZWii
P[i[d
m_[
;kZZ^W
eZ[h
i
_ij
i[^h
iY^m[h&
[_d[d
[nWaj[d
FWvijWX
Wdpk][X[d&
kc
[_d[
Ndj[hiY^[_Zkd]
X[_
Z[h
[hij[d
;[][]dkd]
c_j
[_d[h
LY^kb[
pk
jh[\\[d&
m[_b
iebY^
[_d
Dh_j[h_kc
led
Z[h
M_[\[
kdZ
JkWb_jsj
Z[h
OehX[h[_jkd]
WX^sd]j(
?uh
c_Y^
f[hitdb_Y^
mWh
Z[h
[hij[
;[m[_i&
ZWii
BGCPC
LY^kb[
h_Y^j_]
_ij&
[_d
kdpm[_\[b^W\j[i
kdZ
][dWk[i
fioY^ebe]_iY^[i
P_ii[d&
ZWi
Wbb[i
uX[hjhW\&
mWi
_Y^
`[cWbi
pkleh
_h][dZme
][^thj
^Wjj[
kdZ
Z_[
IioY^ebe]_[
pk
[_d[h
[nWaj[d
kdZ
fhWaj_iY^[d
P_ii[diY^W\j
cWY^' j[(
=Wi
mWh
[_d[
MWjiWY^[&
\uh
c_Y^
kdkcijtiib_Y^&
kdZ
_Y^
^Wjj[
[_d[
X[iedZ[h[
OehX[h[_jkd]&
kc
Z_[i[
MWjiWY^[
pk
X[khj[_b[d( "')

7?DNGAI
FRIIAI
OJI
NIMAKL?DEA@GE?DAH
4EOA=N
LAEI +
OehX[h[_j[dZ[
LY^kb[d
Z[i
O_[hj[d
P[][i
atdd[d
_d
pm[_
DWj[]eh_[d
[_d][j[_bj
m[hZ[d(
Skh
[hij[d
DWj[]eh_[
][^th[d
LY^kb[d&
Z[h[d
E[^h[h
Z_[
Y@COJCECLFCGQ
PCGLCP
CGECLCL
=CPCLP
\@CO
B?P
=CPCL
BCO
9AF\JCO
X[ijsj_]j
kdZ
^_[hZkhY^
Z[c
LjkZ[d' j[d
A_b\[
l[hifh_Y^j&
Z_[
Wk\
Z[h
:dm[dZkd]
led
Dhs\j[d
X[hk^j&
Z_[
Z_[
?s^_]a[_j[d
[_d[i
][mt^db_Y^[d
F[diY^[d
uX[hij[_][d(
NdZ
pkh
pm[_j[d
DWj[]eh_[
][^th[d
LY^kb[d&
Z[h[d
E[^h[h
dkh
Z_[
rX[hb[][d^[_j
PCGLCP
=GPPCLP
X[ijsj_]j( ,
LY^kb[d
Z[h
[hij[d
DWj[]eh_[&
ZWi
^[_iij
LY^kb[d&
Z[h[d
E[^h[h
Z_[
rX[hb[][d^[_j
i[_d[i
L[_di
kdZ
i[_d[i
;[i_jp[i
led
Dhs\j[d&
uX[h
Z_[
Z[h
][mt^db_Y^[
F[diY^
d_Y^j
l[h\u]j&
X[ijs' j_]j&
i_dZ
kdl[h]b[_Y^b_Y^
iY^m_[h_][h&
kdZ
[i
_ij
dkh
ct]b_Y^&
_d
_^d[d
pk
i[_d&
_dZ[c
cWd
i_Y^
?LB?RCOLB
Z[h
:hX[_jifh_dp_f_[d
[h_dd[hj&
_dZ[c
cWd
i_Y^
Z[c
E[^h[h
SMJJPQZLBGE
kdj[hm_h\j
kdZ
Z_[
K[][bd
PQOGIQ
[_d^sbj(
=_[
b[_Y^j[ij[
:Xm[_Y^kd]
ZWled&
i_Y^
Z[h
Ih_dp_f_[d
pk
[h_dd[hd&
i_Y^
Z[c
E[^h[h
pk
kdj[hm[h\[d
kdZ
K[][bd
[_dpk^Wbj[d&
cWY^j
Z_[
?ehji[jpkd]
Z[i
LjkZ_kci
_d
[_d[h
iebY^[d
LY^kb[
kdct]b_Y^( -
Bd
LY^kb[d
Z[h
pm[_j[d
DWj[]eh_[
aWdd
Z[h
E[^h[h
l_[b[
Fsd][b
_dZ_l_Zk[bb[h
LjkZ[dj[d
[djiY^kbZ_][d&
eXme^b
[i
_^h[
:hX[_j
l[hpt][hj&
ie
bWd][&
m_[
[i
Z[h
Wbb][c[_d[d
:hX[_j
Z[h
LY^kb[
d_Y^j
iY^WZ[j( .
=_[
:hX[_jiX[Z_d]kd][d
pk
[hb[_Y^j[d&
Z_[
:d\ehZ[hkd][d
pk
h[Zkp_[h[d
eZ[h
led
L[_j[d
Z[i
E[^h[hi
Dedp[ii_ed[d
pk
cWY^[d&
_ij
d_[cWbi
[_d
Ih_l_b[]
eZ[h
[_d
Oehh[Y^j
\uh
Z_[
LY^u' b[h&
_c
@[][dj[_b
m[_ij
ZWi
_cc[h
Wk\
?[^b[h
_^h[h
:hX[_j
kdZ
_^h[d
O[hbkij
Z[i
IbWjp[i
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
^_d( /
Gkh
ZWi
:d^[X[d
eZ[h
Lj[_][hd
Z[h
:d\ehZ[hkd][d
_ij
[_d
Ih_l_b[]( "'*

0
=[h
IbWjp
_d
Z[h
:hX[_j
m_hZ
ZkhY^
OehX[h[_jkd]&
bsd][h[
Sk][^th_]a[_j&
:dijh[d]kd][d&
?s^_]a[_j[d&
O[hjhWk[d
_d
Z[d
E[^h[h
kdZ
O[hij[^[d
Z[h
:hX[_jip_[b[
X[ij_ccj( 1
>_d
LY^ub[h
aWdd
X[]_dd[d&
e^d[
Z_[
;[Z[kjkd]
Z[h
BZ[[d&
Z_[
led
^t^[h[c
@[_ij
aecc[d&
kdZ
Z_[
S_[b[
Z[h
LY^kb':hX[_j
lebb
pk
l[hij[^[d(
:X[h
dWY^
[_d[h
][m_ii[d
S[_j
m[hZ[d
OGAFQGEC
,GLPAFZQWRLE
kdZ
O[hij[^[d
led
_^c
l[hbWd]j&
kdZ
e^d[
Z_[i[
>_diY^sjpkd]
kdZ
Z_[i[i
O[hij[^[d
aWdd
[h
d_Y^j
\ehj\W^h[d( 2
=Wi
:k\jWkY^[d
led
F_iijhWk[d
][][duX[h
Z[c
E[^h[h
kdZ
X[iedZ[hi
Z[h
:kiZhkYa
iebY^[d
F_iijhWk[di
][][duX[h
Z[c
P_ii[d&
Z[d
F[j^eZ[d
eZ[h
f[hitdb_Y^[d
:di_Y^j[d
Z[i
E[^h[hi
cWY^j
Z_[
?ehji[jpkd]
Z[h
:hX[_j
_d
Z[h
LY^kb[
kdct]b_Y^( 3
=[h
LY^ub[h
ckii
ZWhWd
Z[da[d&
ZWii
f[hitdb_Y^[
:di_Y^j[d
Z[i
E[^h[hi&
Z_[
i[_d[d
[_][d[d
f[hitdb_Y^[d
F[_dkd][d
m_Z[h' ifh[Y^[d&
Wk\
X[ii[h[d
;[khj[_bkd]i'
kdZ
;[eXWY^jkd]ic[j^e' Z[d
X[hk^[d
Wbi
Z_[&
Z_[
_^c
pkh
O[h\u]kd]
ij[^[d
atdd[d(
L_[
iebbj[d
ZW^[h
\uh
_^d
[_d
@[][dijWdZ
Z[i
LjkZ_kci&
d_Y^j
[_d
@[][dijWdZ
Z[i
Ljh[_ji
eZ[h
Z[i
Ihej[ij[i
i[_d( +*
>h
ckii
i_Y^
[h_dd[hd&
ZWii
[_d[i
Z[h
S_[b[
i[_d[h
:hX[_j
[_d
PWdZ[b
_d
i[_d[d
@[i_Y^jifkdaj[d
_ij&
Z[dd
i[_d[
Wbj[d
@[i_Y^ji' fkdaj[
'
Z_[
Z_[
@[i_Y^jifkdaj[
[_d[i
iY^bW\[dZ[d
F[diY^[d
i_dZ
'
atdd[d
d_Y^j
h_Y^j_]
i[_d(
=_[
:k\]WX[
Z[i
E[^h[hi
_ij
[i&
_^c
Z_[
Ft]b_Y^a[_j
led
@[i_Y^jifkdaj[d
pk
p[_][d&
Z_[
fWii[d
kdZ
]b[_Y^p[_j_]
pk
i[_d[c
>hmWY^[d
X[_jhW][d
m[hZ[d( ++
=[h
LY^ub[h
ckii
ZWhWd
Z[da[d&
ZWii
[h
][aecc[d
_ij&
kc
pk
b[hd[d
kdZ
d_Y^j&
kc
pk
b[^h[d
eZ[h
i[_d[d
:di_Y^j[d
:ki' ZhkYa
pk
l[hb[_^[d( +,
F[_dkd]il[hiY^_[Z[d^[_j[d
c_j
Z[c
E[^h[h
atdd[d
[_d
A_dm[_i
ZWhWk\
i[_d&
ZWii
Z[h
LY^ub[h
X[h[_ji
Wbb[i
led
_^c
[h^Wbj[d
^Wj&
mWi
[h
X[aecc[d
aWdd&
kdZ
ZWii
[h
Z_[
LY^kb[ "(!

l[hbWii[d
kdZ
kdWX^sd]_]
WhX[_j[d
iebbj[(
@b[_Y^p[_j_]
aWdd
[_d[
F[_dkd]il[hiY^_[Z[d^[_j
[_d\WY^
p[_][d&
ZWii
Z[h
LY^ub[h
[_d_][
Z[h
]hkdZb[][dZ[d
:hX[_jifh_dp_f_[d
l[h][ii[d
eZ[h&
mWi
deY^
iY^b_cc[h
_ij&
[_d_][
i[_d[h
[_][d[d
^_dpk][\u]j
^Wj&
[jmWi&
ZWi
[h
d_Y^j
lec
E[^h[h
^thj[(
=Wi
cWY^j
Wbb[
m[_j[h[
:hX[_j
pm[Yabei( +-
L[bXijsdZ_][
:hX[_j
Wkii[h^WbX
Z[h
LY^kb[
_ij
_d
DedjWaj
c_j
Z[c
E[^h[h
eZ[h
e^d[
Z[di[bX[d
ct]b_Y^( +.
=[h
DedjWaj
_ij
lec
LY^ub[h
kdZ
d_Y^j
lec
E[^h[h
WX^sd' ]_]&
kdZ
[h
[djij[^j&
m[dd
Z[h
LY^ub[h
i_Y^
Wd
Wbb[i
[h_dd[hj&
mWi
[h
`[cWbi
lec
E[^h[h
][^thj
^Wj
kdZ
Z[c
e^d[
_h][dZm[bY^[
:Xm[_Y^kd][d
\eb]j&
kdZ
leh
Wbb[c&
e^d[
[jmWi
>_][d[i
^_dpk' pk\u][d( +/
=[h
E[^h[h
jhs]j
Z_[
O[hWdjmehjkd]
\uh
Z_[
:hX[_j
Z[h
LY^ub[h
kdZ
aWdd
_^d[d
X[_
_^h[d
LY^m_[h_]a[_j[d
dkh
ZWdd
^[b\[d&
m[dd
i_[
_d
X[pk]
Wk\
_^d
Z[d
Ih_dp_f_[d
Z[h
LY^kb[d
[hij[h
DWj[]eh_[
\eb][d
kdZ
i_Y^
Z[d
K[][bd
Z[h
LY^kb[d
[hij[h
DWj[]eh_[
kdj[hm[h\[d5
ZWi
^[_iij&
m[dd
i_[
d_[
l[h][ii[d&
mWi
_^d[d
[_dcWb
][iW]j
mkhZ[
kdZ
m[dd
i_[
c_j
Z[c
E[^h[h
d_Y^j
Wh]kc[dj_[h[d( +0
=Wi
m_hZ
cWdY^cWb
9AFRJ?O@CGQ
GKGQGCOCL
][dWddj( +1
Bd
[_d
kdZ
Z[hi[bX[d
LY^kb[
aWdd
[i
kdj[hiY^_[Zb_Y^[
LY^u' b[h
][X[d&
ZWi
^[_iij
LY^ub[h
led
LY^kb[d
Z[h
[hij[d
DWj[]eh_[
kdZ
LY^ub[h
led
LY^kb[d
Z[h
pm[_j[d
DWj[]eh_[(
=_[i[h
Ndj[h' iY^_[Z
pm_iY^[d
Z[d
LY^ub[hd
m_hZ
Wbb[_d
ZkhY^
_^h[
>_dij[bbkd]
Z[c
E[^h[h
][][duX[h
X[ij_ccj(

"("

«Das Ziel eines Menschen, der seinen Zustand und seine Lage erkennt, wird zur Wesens­ wandlung. Diese Änderung ist so schwer, dass sie in der Tat unmöglich wäre, wenn es das Wissen nicht gäbe, um ihm zu helfen.» Ouspensky war ein Meister sowohl des gespro­ chenen als auch des geschriebenen Wortes. Er war in erster Linie ein Lehrer, und die fünf Kapitel in vorliegendem Buch sind nicht das Produkt eines Mannes, der zurückgezogen ei­ ne Studie verfasst, sondern das eines Lehrers, der ein System von Gedanken erläutert, die nur mittels besonnener Fragen seitens seiner Zuhörer und ihres aufrichtigen Wunsches zu lernen allmählich gewürdigt und richtig ver­ standen werden konnten.