384 27 70MB
English Pages 823 [827] Year 1876
IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3)
1.0
l.i
1.25
1^
CIHM/ICMH
CIHM/ICMH
Microfiche
Collection de microfiches.
Series.
Canadian
Institute for Historical Microreproductions
Institut
1980 it
Canadian de microreproductions historiques
Technical Notes / Notes techniques
The
Institute
has attempted to obtain the best
copy available for filming. Physical features of this copy which may alter any of the images in the /eproduction are checked below. original
T P o
L'Institut a
microfilm^
le meilleur exemplaire possible de se procurer. Certains d^fauts susceptibles de nuire d la quality de la reproduction sont notds ci-dessous.
fi
qu'il lui a 6t6
T Ci
D
Coloured covers/ Couvertures de couleur
D
Coloured maps/ Cartes gdographiques en couleur
Pages disv^oloured, stained or foxed/ Pages ddcolordes, tachetdes ou piquies
D D
Coloured plates/ Planches en couleur
D
Show through/ Transparence
Coloured pages/ Pages de couleur
o ai
Tl fi
in
IV
in
Tight binding (may cause shadows or distortion along interior margin)/ Reliure serrd (peut causer de I'ombre ou de la distorti.m le long de la marge int^rieure)
D
Additional
U|
D
Pages damaged/ Pages endommagdes
^
comments/
Commentaires suppl6mentaires
Bibliographic Notes / Notes bibliographiques
/
D D n
D
Only edition available/ Seule Edition disponible
D
Pagination incorrect/ Erreurs de pagination
Bound with other material/ documents
D
Pages missing/ Des pages manquent
Cover
D
Des cartes gdographiques manquent
Relid avec d'autres
Le
title
titre
missing/
de couverture manque
Plates miissing/
Des planchsii manquent
Additional
comments/
Commentaires suppl6mentaires
Maps missing/
b
rks the niaehine, or with
of theoretical
arms has largely absorbed that indus-
the life-blood of a civilized state, and the individ
uality of the citizen
one
While
and were utterly foreign to a sound education of the young
instruction, the physical drill in
!/i(rj'
defeat.
the Iolmc of war has been as listlessly and coolly
precepts imposed
its
In Continental Iiuroi)e, however, with a
trial
assured
possible, or
physiology are deemed indispensable to every sound
physics and
hand, that when a
in
is
feather-light in
Great Britain, the assumption
crisis shall
demand
is
ever
the soldier, there will be
found the hero and the victory.
This possible
is
trifling
matter
in
with grave issues.
modern
It
is
a verv rare,
times, for a great
if
not an im-
war to ensue witliout
antecedent deliberation on the part of one or both o{ the parties in
interest.
related
The mighty aggregate
to intense brain-work,
of European armies
is
closely
and no advocate more exhaustively
anticipates the contingencies of evidence
and the
sco[)e of past ad-
6
4 *, :
f'
THE KEY TO MILITARY HISTORY.
MI1.ITAKY SCIENCK
1
do
judications, than
and
tlie
adepts
in
[i775
military sc-ii-ncc rovit;\v their maps,
sprciilatc ujxin tlvj very riTcsscs, as wi-ll as the VL'sourccs of tlie
coiintr\" llu\- |>iirpiisr to attack.
tlurcforc, possible
It is,
ree neoiile
t(j
with
ai id
hecomiiiLj, for the educ.ited
th.it familiarity,
science into evi'ry housi-hold.
which has
Tlu'
the
a IK 1 this,
fruit
the
rii^htly fits
of
iiul ei)endenc'.'
demand
IVat
unacknowled;j;ed sentiment, that the
tle,
be smoothl)' and
will
from the
dcvelopeil
laws are
of farm-
1
invention
there
sub-
with
all this,
civil
functions of the state
performed by those
fairly
fact that
am
fresh
and personal action,
thoiii^ht
ol
of the times.
the
due
in
those of n.itura!
carrii-d
heads of mechanics
have ached from the e'laboralion of some
sons,
ers'
masses of
principles wliuli hich under
ot if tl the
These principles have not been unfolded
ational lU-fense.
proportion
and
Uearn sonietluni:j •th
in force,
assured of wise and conipetent s.uiction.
is
,i
This
in chari;e.
llere bej^ins for military
.And yet, before
science,
its startiiii^^
tluie
to be I'-^tablishetl cert.iin s^round-woik, necessarily i^^nored
is
point,
while
strictly military writers,
purpose
its L^enesis.
adapt, ition of
and
crisis,
and fund.urientid
its iliscussion,
by
to the ;j;eneral
view.
in
Milit.iry law, while that
u]ion the
intej^r.il
is
and that those laws arc
uuthods of
its
The wi-dom
all
f
of force,
ai)])lic,ition
tin st.itesman
the householder, aiul
both
is
;is
is v virtue
of
Tlic niciital pro-
various shaftings.
dilferciii a/^/^/ieatioits, but the
prime
activities are the same.
The domain of natural It
ti.d
so witli
is
physics.
force, the milit.ir)- art,
atory to
all
f.iils
its
demand.
as offenses
so shall
of e.xperts
all
in its
This
sciiuice h.is its
departments and sections. of
.\nd yet, to the ijreat eni;4ma all
science's exttiid
behalf.
rests
upon
All a
their
dynamic
No
aitl.
force
l)a\-s
simple necessity.
esseii-
labor-
tribute
In.ismuch
against society and law, require the sanction of force, a|)pliances of
.art
and science contribute
their
full
measur
b.itu lit
nerve and commensurate in
possible
all
possible
all
and
'fiieiilla
vin-
enip/ojin^^ force to
h.is
il
captains, i)eloro
and
not
and since
unseldom
its
pe'riod, filled
th.it
h.ive
\.o
Frederic .md Jomiiii asserts nothing
its
e.\i)res>ion,
The philosojjhy
masterly ap[)lication.
the
be}()iul
of
wisdom
,ind
skill
therein illustr.ited. It
is
.issuined that
all
truth which be.irs direct rel.ition to a better
undeisl.indiiij^ of those battles,
imis t be placed side by th.it histors' t
iry science
sitle.
bear
tavil
must
fill
is
of value to the student,
m
tlieir ii.irt
its pi, ice.
the elucid.ilioii. .ind mil-
or the jud;j;ment will
of the future.
tl le
cussion of military scii-nce, the purpose lund.iment.il laws
and
rel.itions
which
wil
to
is
to reach
fiil
conclusion- wliieli convi.'rl the anleceuent experience ot i^uides lor the resolution
llistor)'
with the })hilosophy which interprets
men
propcjsed brief dis
set
forth
the re.ider
.lid
lh>.
into sate ife
onl\-
m
h is
those
UKdu-
Jl
inent o( the ficts, ins[)ire fresh respect for that talent which sustains
the
commonwealth
in ,in
hour of
sense of responsibility for a Ljcncies
fit
(.l.in;_;er,
which can come to the body
In the
discussion of battles
topogr.iphical
have been
illustr.ition,
summoiud
and
pre[).ir.ition
i)ossibly ti
)
induce
meet
a 11
I'
.i
le
hii^her
contin-
politic.
.md
battle-direction,
including
the
the standard authorities of both countries
;o the witness-staiul,
.md
are duly accredited.
!'
h
!
CHAPTER 1()K
ai'()L(k;v
u-.r (if
in
the
and
niatcd, ar
their application in the
(.IcnnMUs that shape or ap[)iy to force,
of estaljlishiii;^ or
ilircctioii
militarv art.
riiK
niilitai)' .irt, havin;.^
iionii.il
fiiiw.-, all
a])propriale place
so
the
iJiiiiciplcs (if
Till'"-
IV.
the stale, have their
protectin;,^'
Those principles,
relation-,.
much matters
uihdoin to
of discovery as the tlirect
rii^ht
thal
struf''.
tf
do
to war, are
'o
.111(1
must
proL;ress of invention
inti nsily
inli-
human
application of
All priniitiw; ([uestions of ethics or morals,
The
already
reco;_;iiized e.\ii;encies.
to the abstract
table
,is
not of nece^.sity and exclusively professional, nor are tliey
•
physical
force
essential principles
merged
and
m
all
discussion as
the-
actual, inevi-
(jccur.
indeed developed machinery to
lias
and multiply
its
forms of action
;
hut the
have not been created; tluy are only UKjre
lully
I
Ml
detectetl, unl
The I
ill
.;d
and ut nizerl
successful man, of whatever calling,
through intimacy with the
by use of such
skill in
sprin;.;s
the adju-itmei
must achieve that success
and modes of human t
.iction, a.nd
of plans as to meet or anticipate
such action.
Mental philos(jphy demaiuls as much credit IS for an\'
for military success,
other success.
ie(JL;raphical (iisco\ery, so
hypotl lesis
oi
the proper
c,
died. has al\va\s
harmony
had some antecedimt
and lias thus So with physics,
of the physical wor'
been impelled to push the conviction to assurance.
whether of ice i
M
and
all
e.irlli
or heaven.
Even
the diversities of the earth's sur-
avenues of inter communication have proved as
military as to commercial or political
common
relations.
1
with other science, applies sound reasoning to
contingencies that can
come
within
its
vital to
he arrt of war,
sphere of duty.
all
in
possible
APOLOGY FOR TIIK MII.ITARV AK
17751
shares
It
with sonic
wherever
tlic"
limitations of
niilit;
fmilc knowlcdLjc, and
all
any
rv buiiaii, n(jr stored in
and
obst;rv'ation, iiuickness,
sa_L;acit>',
harmony .md material. Types of mind of e(iual
«9 is
not closeted inheres
arsenal.
It
[)recisi(jn,
have their
best
with
slren;^th in all those
circumst.inces of birth,
tile
cleinents
— will
education
or
various
objectives and exhiljit tlissimilar manifestations, so that society, its
civil
adiustments and
;^ro\vth,
which couM'rvc the riidiU of the
The
\>()V\i.
m.ixinis of
rel.itions,
civil
or)-, indicatiuL^'
the
l'',n;_;lish
common
which
l.iw
honor, when
its
a correspundiny;
physical sup-
.iffecl civil life,
and
are but accumulated ex[)erience, beycjiid date or mein-
how
society
many
of the
ri;^dits
and
in all
the same faculties
emjjloys
and vindicate
state,
of sanction
the aid
peril invoke-^
onl)'
drift
v/ill
seek
may
so happily
and securely
subsi-^t, that
be but the ai^grej^ate of individual
shall
ri;^hts.
These flow from the the centuries: but
past, i^ainiiiL;
thiJse
are
volume and illumination with
not older nor
more
with
consistent
iiuman reason than are the ijeneral maxims which inspire a wise
They
defense, and the conse(iuent, national defense.
one and indivisible. war, that
{(>
is
it
It is
llow
self
toi^ether,
as great an ern-r to predicite of the art of
abnormal and beyoml the
field of
the schokir, as to
tre.it
the whole system of state and nmnicipal politics as of
terial
concern to the individual ulizen,
in
his
imma-
comparatively passive
sphere of trust and de])endence. In proportion
takes part
as the citizen
in their
his privilege
freely exercises
and duty to understand,
respond to their hearty supi)ort
if
7i'/iy,
assailed.
idea that these are
cal
in
are
agents
(jf
is
and mora! sujjport is
i.o
rights, it
lioxv,
and
become he
shall
delegation of certain
predicated upon the
the people, duly responsible
their charge; but the obligation to render
their trust,
civil
when, and
The
trusts to the cabinet, the bench, or the bailiff,
trusts
his
establishment ;uul perpetuation, so does
all
for
the
needed physi-
the faithful discharge of the functions of
im[)erative in every well ordered state.
These functions
performed almost automatically during peace, with but incidental
friction,
and under
light burdens.
But the contingencies of lawlessness and violence and a consequent appeal to force are not to be ignoretl, because in abeyance, or out of sight. In the state, as in the houseiiold, during
wholesome peace, the
supremacy of law seems to be most positive when the external display
20
FOR THE MILITARY ART.
AI'OI.OGV
['775
::!
•I
nf sanction
There
prominent.
least
is
no exception
is
there every outlook
77ic visih/c ivldp stands for its
comprehends
a possible strut^;^le,
precludes the idea of substantial peace. tncajis
•
\
rest
from
ready
the case of states haviiiij large armies
in
There
is
no
;
use.
for
which of
itself
and
/'cace
rrst,
with a corresponding devotion of personal
coiijlkt,
,• 1
and national resources to permanent
i^ood.
While therefore, that sanction which
is
the reser\e force to
com-
•'
(
sii!
paraded
pel order, nia\' not be
must be pervasive
the sight of
in
men,
all
and the capacity to defend or
;
its
existence
assert rights
depends alone upon outside forbearance,
wise, ever\- franchise
most
accepted, that
of
fickk'
elements, falsely
all
policy.
have a deej) concern
tliat all citizens
lies in
stx-led
other nations.
man
iile tlie
i
l'
'
1
itii
its
its
crowning
those deeds of self-sacrifice and
ot
penalty acts as a preventive
its
assault, so
off
history of
;1»
I!
um e
oif
crmie, auui
does true valor
most brutal aspects, and assimilate the guardian
all
legitimate warfare
and
justice.
instinct with the exhibition
is
of noble attributes and profound wisdom.
h
possibilities, its
indeed the sphere
advent.
vindicate rights wards
rescue war from
The
compared with that of
glories, be
of public peace to the administrator of law
i
every [primary truth
compensations and
of values in its
assurance
thee cai)acity to
1
that
can alone secure renewal of primeval perfection, there
large wealth
heroism which hasten
W
w
If peace,
sweet domesticities and mu-.t be
(jr
therefore
is
the direction of national defense, or guides their judgment
to a right estimate of the national history, as
wherein
in
It
must
Other-
be coextensive with the ultimate value of the rights enjoyed.
If the object
of this vol-
were but the simple compilation of battle-narrative, there would
be no
pi, ice for
the present discussion
battles in the scales,
and
but the desire
;
test their merits
is,
to place the
by the experience of other
nations and other great captains, in order that
all
non-military schol-
'.
I
ars
who have
set
uj) false
standards of judgment, or have presumed
upon the ignorance gnorance of ot past generations, as to
;
direction
of the
will
deny
and ambition nr
denounce
There tion of
who
wi 11
rej
to the soldier a
for place it
will
;iy
determine
for
themselves
and
battle-
American Revolution.
Th ere are those
Some
m
ption advanced in behalf of the battles
the issu
ect
the
term, " science
of war.
higher purpose than self-support,
and power, and decry the profession as
servile,
as despotic.
not be wanting those
Germany and
who
will treat
the general educa-
the elastic resources of France, as at variance
APOLOGY FOR THE MILITARV ART.
1775]
with the assumption, that nations
dition of society
is
peace
;
and
suffers,
and
true
is
it
to
tl;at
the teeth are
the normal con-
proportion as the resources of the
in
state are diverted to \varlike uses, exccj)t
pensable preparation
armed
liabittially
Nevertheless,
sloioly bleediii!^ to dee.th.
2\
///
extremis, or in the indis-
impeiulin;^ or continj^ent dant^er, society
for
suffers just in proportion as the oblit^ations of
are impcnitivo.
and
God's law
depends upon adherence to those
vital prosperity
oblii^ations.
All similar and related questions of every kind are swallowed
up
in the fact, that as society suffers from internal violence, so nations as
True wisdom
such, are put in peril.
discharije of every tluty that as an outrage,
Should
homage
which humanity
at large
any maintain that
to military attainment,
the it
such a just and honorable
lies in
war without
just cause,
is
only possible,
would condemn and resent.
time has
must be
passed
made
first
for rendering
to appear that
all
nations are prompt to rentier justice, and to accept and practice the cardinal principles which Montestjuieu declares to be the spirit of laws,
that the higher refinement of duty which attaches to the precepts
or,
of the Saviour himself, has already blossomed fact
that true
is,
life
is
made up
resolution as against oppression,
of for
inner
all
When
life.
holy ends,
.it
ami ambition
these partake of
the risk of
life,
into fruit.
iMnulation
struggle.
of
for
is
great
in
labor,
preferment are parts
.self-sacrifice
the subject
The
lifted
and ex[)osure
above the
pl.uie
monumental worth and bright example. Where these elements work evil, and assail the rights of man. the
of mere living, to that of
issue
must be squarely met
by every agent
avail.ible
for
the
r
suppression.
No
nation rises by easy spring
Injustice f.ir
to well balanced independence.
and wrong assert their claims, and unless a people
indicate
under any possible phase of the future, there to their experience the
bitter lessons
will
be brought
which have involved so
so
duty
home many
corrupted, and conceited nations in remediless ruin.
listless,
If a nation, like
the m.in, be tloubly armed,
conscious dignity that cause,
will
their self-respect as willingly to understand their
is
in
a just c.iuse, so tne
ability to maintain that
strong assurance of independence, and a stern warning to
aggressors.
No
student of history
of arms has ever been
The
follows an assured
will fail to see that
the profession
esteemed honorable.
sacred record which
lies
at
the foundation of society
and thus becomes the vitalizing and essential element of
all
itself,
true pro-
f
AI'Ol.OCY FOR
22
I1775
honorable testimony to the prowess of those
gress, bears
liljH
MII.irAKY ART.
I'lIK
The
arms against unrigliteous violence.
who
the necessity for those
bear the shield
records and honors their triumphs.
the front of battle, both
in
Where,
classic epic, will
in
found more jubilant refrains over victories won, than
Deborah
\er\- l.iws
Moses
be
the song of
and what can surpass the majesty and all-embracing
!
ness of the chorus of Miriam and
The
who bore
Bible, therefore, recognizing
full-
!
and usages of chivalry were predicated upon the
idea that the true soldier represented the best type of ri'tlnement and
honor.
I'iety itself,
now
once but a synonym its
manifestations of
the hero of Virgil.
so exalted, self-denying, and precious, was
generous courage and true manhood.
for
In
combined with brave deeds, was fouml There have indeed been periods of history, when love,
filial
the soklier knight was almost exclusively the scholar, and the cloister alone furnished those who, besides himself, could transcribe thought
upon parchment or paper.
Bunyan and Milton assume the metaphors and terms
of military
while they delineate their highest characters, and expend the
life,
best efforts of their genius
forms which borrow strength and
in
cance from the military profession.
combine
to
honor him who honors himself
fight " has not
been fought
glories of millennial peace
crowned
for other merit
out. ;
signifi-
Both sacred and profane history
This
is
arms.
in
not the day
for
The
"
good
the gracious
neither should the military profession be
than that which attaches to
its fa'ithfulness
to
duty, as the conservator of just and sacred rights. T/u' ever iiiereasing responsibilities t/uil
•a the
zi'or.'d's
vivilizcd
population,
and
and barbarous
t/ie
attend
people into intimacy
and
rapid increase of which brings half-
tlic
eotnniereial enterprise
interfusion with less
populous, but better educated nations, are pregnant with issues ivhich
M
provoke luDiian passion and huvuiii
conflict.
Tidal waves of armed
ignorance, superstition, and brutalism are not impossible because a select minority of the earth's inhabitants
are enlightened and
civil-
[
ized.
h
History has recorded such events under circumstances no more I
f
difficult
than the future
may
evolve.
So
also, the irresponsibility of
despotic power, and the fiery scourge of religious fanaticism, are not )arrcd
ou t bee ause just now
There
is
restrain ed.
already a relaxation of fealty to authority, an indepen-
dence of individual obligation to the rights of the many, a jealousy of superiority, whether of mental or industrial attainment, which
APOLOGY FOR THE MILITARY ART.
'775.J
tend to anarchy arrogant
spirit
inquiringly
;
and these work
in
23
the same direction with the
of centralization and oppression, which gradually and
lifts its
arm
of a
as in the middle ages.
must be resolved, either by
The common moral final issue
obligation,
and respect
the conflicts of physical force will go
intelligent recognition
for the rights of all
beyond
their true mission
;
or
and
introduce unparalleled conflict. Tlicre
not
is
no aspect
commend
itself to
in
which the knowledge of military science does
the favor of the present generation.
The
les-
sons to be derived from history were never so pre-eminently useful
and they will hereafter hold a more solemn place in the mind of the thoughtful scholar. In introducing those principles
as now,
which place military attainment stating the laws tion,
it
by which
in fellowship
with true science, thereby
to test the deeds of the
American Revolu-
can not be entirely foreign or discursive thus to blend their
statement with honorable mention of
its
history.
'i
'i.'.
1'
r
ii
ji"
-III
I
fii
ii
}
'(
,
'
WARS BKTWKEV
1775-
NATIONis.
35
makes the distinction between those solemnly undertaken by the state, and those non-so/oiiii, that ^low out of the acts of subordinate authority, not r.itified by the head of the state. IV/icaion asserts that, if war be declared in form by one state, it Grotiiis
entitles both bellii;erent parties to all the rights of
whether the war be
other,
I
Ilallcck notices the
distinction
one case,
wars, when, in
all
tln'ngs, as illustrated in
is
in
179S.
and defensive have
offensive
more applicable
tinguish wars, although
also
been applied to
Even
in
dis-
to military opcratioiiSy since
every war o" considerable magnitude or duration, has of attack and defense.
in
a limitation ol persons, places,
the character of hostilities authorized by
the United States against France
The terms
between perfect and imperfect
the citizens of two states are placed
anta^Ljonism, aiul in the other, there
and
war against each
just or not.
its
alternations
the shaping of cabinet policy, these
terms are rather those of action than of type of contest, the verbal or diplomatic initiative b ing so aggressive as to
compel protest and
armed resentment.
An
equivalent principle obtains at
acts," so called,
may
common
warrant physical redress.
carry this discussion into the
It
law, is
where
" verbal
not proposed to
domain of international law, which is and energizing
largely that of ethics, but to recognize the distinctions
principles of battle-issues.
Writers have needlessly enlarged upon the classification of wars,
and only a wnich has itjcd
brief allusion real
While wars vary cess involves
is
deemed necessary
to cover
all
the ground
value to the citizen or student.
the
the manifestation and use of force, their suc-
in
same
principles of the military art.
The elements
that inspire hostility, and tender the battle-issue, largely determine his
the character of the war, and decide whether a whole nation
the
put
e
is
be
its
resources and existence at
force for
risk,
is
to
or only to display a partial
some temporary advantage to itself, or in behalf of another But when two nations, as two pugilists, em-
nation seeking its support.
iCise
ploy their resources exhaustively against each other, the term national
:tive
Tfrtrhas proper application.
IS
in
Such wars are peculiarly
free
from those
heathenish exhibitions which attach to internecine types of conflict.
The
national honor, sensitive and forced to the issue, aims to pay
respect to international law,
and thereby to challenge the moral recog-
nition of civilized neutrals. It
is
not an error,
in
a qualified sense, to treat as national wars,
WAKs
26 the
striigf;lcs
of
The
cicnce.
supprcssrcl riiitidiiality
althoui^h lacking piibhc
rc;^ain
I'okiiul
their iiulcpcii-
])atiiotic
its
loni^iii^^s,
Hungary
.iiul
by the force of
hut assertion of national
union whicli
Such cases
contiuest.
tended re-assertion of
for
example,
i/i/i'/y,
differ,
n.itional character in
kept
in
subjection
however, from a pre-
attempted disruption of a
the consent of both parties, and where the merger
h.ul
Thus Scotland became an by common consent. Turkey has
of individuality has oeen voluntary and complete.
became an
intej^ral
of (ireat Ihitain, ami Te.xas
irt
i
integral part of the United States
repeatedly
made war
Russia to ward off the accumulating force
witii
which threatened her iniiependeiice, her national
The General
life.
of the Netherlands against Spain, of the Spa!iish
stiu_ij;;^Ie
peninsula against France, of France against the
Halleck
wars
as
allies,
and
indepentlence,
for
are treated
)'et
fi'
of
i.Sij,
as a
between
war
for
(ireat IJritain
independence.
and the United
It
.States,
by
those were
national wars, to perfect and vindicate national existence. II
aiul
the struLj^le par-
re>unie their place anion^ nations, so that revolt was not
to
.nerel)' insurrection,
i
h.is
[1775
rccoijiiitioii until successful,
takes of a national character. tried
)ns.
vanquished pt-nplc to
oncL-
;i
nati
ri:t\vf;i:n
The war
has been treated
was, however, largely the culmination
of misunderstandings, put at issue indeed by the dawning develop-
ment of those
rights of citizenship which in later years have gained
general acceptance.
The
of independence from
a claim for independence
The former was
claim of America was no ni'^re an assertion
l^ritish in
control, than
was that of Great
l^ritain
the control of her home-born subjects.
the outgrowth of questions unsettled by the Ameri-
can Revolution, and the latter but the instinctive adherence to long
The former guaranteed
existing prerogative.
the
full
measure of national protection
petual allegiance of
all
once
;
to the adopted citizen
the latter claimed the per-
and the right to reclaim their
citizens,
persons even on the high seas, whenever found.
was
truly a national war.
mission.
It is
A
war
for
The
war, howeve-,
independence suggests
its
own
the struggle of a colony, a dependent section of the
state or of a distinct race, to obtain as a distinct nation.
It
finds
its
and maintain public recognition
key
the
in
first
grade of Revolution
hereafter considered. liaron Jouiini
declares that. " the
spontaneous uprising of an
united nation, must not be confounded with a national defense, in
accordance with the institutions of the state and
ernment."
His statement originates
in
ilirected
by the gov-
the idea, that the govern-
[1775
WARS
I77S]
ment
nirrwKKN' nations.
m.iy'act indopendeiUly of
He would
or wishes.
people, .ind foreign to their interests
tiie
thus limit
37
iiiitional w.irs to popiil.ir
outbursts
in
search of iiuiepcndcnce, or such as are necessary to save the national life
which has been put
whose government
of the people,
will
The statement
in peril.
is rep,
cscntativc,
"The term
adds:
lie
ignores those states
and therefore the e.^ecutive of the national,
can
only be
applied to such wars as are waged against an united people, or a
majority of them,
filled
entire
ition
1.
may be precipitated upon an by blunders of administration, misconception of con-
flicting issues, or
which
with a noble ardor, and determined to sustain
Wars, however,
their inilependence."
want of that
will ^'eierally
command
and generous negotiation
catholicity [)eace
when
nations really desire peace.
There may be re.di/.ed in such cases only a lukewarm support of the government by the people but the nation is responsible for the war, ;
and is
government
its
responsible to the people.
is
begun which dishonors national character and
of other nations, without
wars
conquest are of this type, and so are
the propagandism of ideas, whether political or religious.
for
Upon
any reasonable equivalent to the party tak-
Wars for
ing the aggressive.
the assumption, not to be thoughtlessly discredited, that every
nati(Jii,
as an abstract matter, has a rightful
independence
pursuits of peace, but no right to enforce Lsscrtion Britiiin
uhjects.
Anicri-
equally independent nations,
pcr-
|hc
their
iii
tnvevc", [its
own
of the
tvhich, as
between nations,
which governs citizens
The Crusades and
of an
lie
gov-
tovern-
legitimate
upm
forms of propagandism by force of
the
is
but the application of the wise restraint
Moslem wars were
shows in
itself.
To
fruit,
and
of the character adverted
defiance of all social and mere conquest have rarely perpetuated the state which committed the robbery. The compensations of time under Providence brand conquest. The mark of Cain national rights.
in
Fortunately, wars for
rob a nation of
life, is
not to be a glorious mission
the future.
Wars of
Intervention, once so
common
in
behalf of a so-called
balance of pozvcr, are almost invariably of doubtful expediency,
can only be justified
|nse, in
in
domestic policy
the exercise of individual personal rights.
in
of evil passions and evil
to, full
ignition lolution
all
its
arms are destructive of society, and violate that international comity
to long citizen
Sometimes a war strikes at the rights
when
and
there has been that willful violation of the
law of nations, which calls upon the strong to protect or vindicate the
weak from an attempt are
at conquest, or the destruction of rights
fundamental and essential to national
The
true balance
uf poiver,
is
which
life.
that of moral and industrial excel
»'•:
WARS BETWEEN NATIONS,
28
All else savors of the dark ages, and
lence.
is
[i77S.
as absurd
irl
essence,
as the impossible equality of individuals in wealth or accomplishments.
Hit
Equality to-day, will end to-morrow, just
in
proportion as the deserving
improve their acquisitions and the unthrifty and
When will
the French
prompt
army
selfish
shall equal the German,, the
waste them.
German -impulse
a fresh expenditure to retain ascendency in the material
of war, at the expense of domestic rest.
Such
are the considerations
which, as a general rule, are to determine the character of national
wars and indicate their
A nation
limit.
has in fact no right to go to war unless
entire national resources to the hazard.
to go to war
if
As
pose to destroy or absorb it
will
its
its
a general rule, one nation has no pur-
opponent, but only to wear
be too tired to keep up controversy.
general rule, nations are in
can pledge
there be any attainable settlement of controversy upon
a just basis without war.
so that
it
Neither has a nation the right
left after
it
out a
As an
little,
equally
war pretty much where they started
respect of the issue made, but fearfully poor in the elements of a
truly national
life
it!
1
13
"
4
1
[i77S.
CHAPTER CIVIL
WAR, DISTINCTION BETWEEN
Vr. INSURRECTIO'-I, REBELLION,
AND REVOLUTION.
CIVIL war
is
a war of one's
own household,
intestine,
and
full
of
bitter issues.
conserves the rights of
In proportion as a state
its
citizens
and
dispenses even justice, a civil struggle has the same merit which the
claim of any bodily
member might
assert against the
supremacy of the
Just as the mangled limb or deranged function
head or the heart.
imperils the whole system,
wholesoine acceptance of
and can only revive
its
its
normal use by
dependence, and such treatment as sub-
serves the welfare of the uninjured parts, so do civil feuds and strifes
endanger the state at the expense of the disaffected members, crowning the struggle with the ruin of
war proper,
Civil
is
all alike.
a war of factions, not necessaiily aiming at the
integrity of the state, but involving separate
control of the state, or at least
aspirations to obtain
supremacy over the
rival faction.
The
South American States and Mexico furnish impressive examples of civil
war.
The
English "
War
of the Roses," that of the
League
in
France, and of the Guelphs and Ghibellines in Italy, arc suggestive of the mischief to the
body
push personal or party
strifes to the
Success
itself
times
an
effort to
in
defiance of others' rights.
Such wars were
rife in
for national offense or defense,
by the
of rival aspirants for local power or influence at court.
Civil war,
however, has a general sweep which includes other and
related classes similar
attftnd
usurpation of national authority.
and more than once the powers of Burgundy and
;
France were well-nigh paralyzed selfish strife
which must
has no sound basis of perpetuity, because essentially
maintained only feudal
politic
;
these having subjective relations while
elements,
viz.,
INSURRECTION,
Rebellion,
full
of dis-
Revolution
!
»
It
^
•;:
ir
CIVIL WAR.
30
Each
alike, belong; to
bcloni; to tlic state
IxsURRKC'l'IDN
{
•Molllisr
lllr
uvnw
1)1
I
,11111)',
c
sill. nils, li.illril tllr
l.ll;'/1))'
I.k
tutiily
(iiini.il
tin- h.iin
i)iiii)rlliil
I
37
•.
;i|;.iiii
issue
iilTnisivr
with
,illil
1.1
I
r.iviiii,
.rviiit)' piil Mil, ill
ill-
t
prrsMirr
Ni.Miii .iml (iliivi-r (l(-scit(-r
III
ufii-
lluiisi-
ISiiliili
rilil.li|il|)lli
h.iil
iilH
(
,
ill;;,
111-
I
llli-
Ik iIh-
triiii|ts ,iiiil
llMlll
I{iii;;iiyiii-
r'-trr,ll
luildU
liMiii
iiiliiiiin
mils
IK A
!s
1,1.1
Ainniciii
ill'
I
iiiiusii.il
iiMi\v,il
i-ii
llii'
III
111
tiiniril llltn
.iiiil
i)iiliisi:il
,11
Wliitf
II
llllril
>i',
II
iiltiiii,i!n
i
1I||)
(
laiiil,
,md limi
I"!!-;
(I
I
llli-
.
.iivilli',
llii'
l)\-
tllc (MllllfrV,
I.S^i;,
S'')!
1
l')ll
Im milmiil Imili
ll'
1)1
,
jr
iiinhi
'
si-cdiiiI
.\i-'.\
Im-
li-
t
niDVciiiriil
N (-W
1)1
ii'.ii
a
.ivi-
ir.si
\aliu.'
mi
.1
Ii'iiii
Na
111-
t
rmi t|-.)l
In-
t
that
1)11
(iirccl Iv
VHW
li.
Imii.-
1)1
DplT.ll
111
I
war
ii .III
I
U'l'll
Id
t
.mil
Li.iii->vill''
VIC
ll
U'llll
CDiiliiliiMli-
)\\(st I
llVi-
of
c's
l''l
'
/"III' •l'^
tlir ITSdlllH
ill
I'
All)'
iic
llllillli'-
till-
IllililllA' ll.lM-,
rmas-
l)\ l)\'
1
.lllf
lilCFlNKI).
KINCII'I.I.S
1
"775. J
loj-
.a
l'LnL;lanil
army
of
tiiird line of
Iroin
oper.uimis,
lliri.iliiiiii;^'
the otln:r tol oiin-s
Washington, which
reiii.iiiie-d
but
llii;
on
tlie
i
u?
rUINl-Il'I.MS DKKINKI).
52 '.
•
alert, u'itliin wliicii
w
IS
strikiiv^
to strike
distance of
toga.
Wliile a base restini^ on the sea
as was
New
'S'
i
'II
t^
f-
(1
!
fi'ii
York,
still
paralyzed the arm
must be adecjnately supplied,
York, throus^h superior maritime resources,
was that of Cornwallis, '^
New
with Hur^^oyiie, and his operations closed at Sara-
true that an .irniy forced back
I
11775-
(
is lust.
n/>ofi
it
.is
equally
the sea by a competent force, as
CHAPTER STRATEC.Y
TIIR prime objective of
X.
WAR CON IINUKO.
IN
the war of 1775 -17S1, w.is
of the colonial armies and enforcement of
The occupation of territory or
cr(3\vn.
while the opposinLj armies ke[)t
tlie
tiie
tlie
rcduclioii
authority ot the
by an ina(le(|iiate force, was therefore of tran>iei\t
cities
fieM,
benefit.
made
Philadelphia was
the objective of the British
the campaii^n of 1777, mainly because
Congress removed to Wilmington,
Gcrmantown,
close to the city,
A
conchision.
sinj^Ie
reniaik
it
was the
— Washington
and the
issue
army
ca[)ital of
struck a blow at
was as
f.ir
as ever from
therefore i)ro])er as to the
is
diirin;,^
the enemy.
v.
due
ot
a
national ca])ital as a chief military objective. Colcjnel llamley,
excellent .states
(
British Staff College, in
is
not
field.
It
is
final,
" The mere possessicin enemy can still make head
when the
ascendency over it,
so long as the
th.it
the;
his
of War," (edition of 1S75)
the proposition very precisely.
capital
retake
commandant of the " The )per,itions
volume u[)on
seizure of the capital
is
cou[)led
of the in
the
with such
defensive armies that they can ne\er hope to
further resistance
to national extinction, and that
is
felt
to
be hopeless, as lead \nn to an issue
front.
Ironl
its
adwuilaj^e, so that the
wu It
artificial
has l)eeu called the stratiy;ic front.
deni.inil
itod
however, an
indication of the tract wi thin w nic h
n
matter of
.1
is,
nn passable stream,
decisive
strategic iVoiit
As
itselt".
an
,rm\- be oi'lniK ri lis
This
inarch.
(l,l\'S
dependiMU upon the nature of the country.
tance, wlioll)-
N;ipo-
[
hrKAlKClV
tVb
artificial
obstacles should be iiKule
army wiien driven
Riv ers often form lines of defense, as
to the stationary dein
repeated instance:
STRATEGY IN WAR CON'ITXUED.
5f>
during the campaign of 1781 quarters of the American
The winter
the Soutliern States.
in
army
[»775.
at Valley I"\)rge. 1777-S,
were a
line
of defense no less than a peculiarly well selected strategic position.
A
back country was accessible
large
impoverished by the waste of war,
army
at Philadelphi.i fulfilled all
for supplies,
]5ritish
the conditions which were necessary
reasonable safety, keep the troops on the
to secure
although greatly
the distance from the
anil
both opportunity and intlucement
alert,
and afford
observation and operations to
for
the front.
A
line of
defense should be as compact as possible, with a strategic
front so limited as to give promi^t concentration of the
One
critical points.
student
who would
army
assured of
is
equal, that to
considenition
rightly estimate the merits of an issue,
means of defense.
artificial
army which holds
the advantage
If
a firm position, h.i^
of that position,
while
the
strength equal to the estimated loss involved
issue, the
elements which
No |i
i^a
£
line of
/>/iis
strength equal has iiiinus
;issailant
forcing that position.
in
force of discipline
command
and both the moral and physical
success are
left
to their free exercise.
detensc should he passively occupied.
Fayette to Barren
and Washington's attack
Hill,
The at
atlvance of
Germantown,
were expressions of torce which gave value to the position Forge, exalted itself
its
defensive
tioo
properties,
The
upon a quasi-dcfcnsivc.
campaign, had
when one
forces be otherwise
where successful movements and hard fighting make
In an ojien field
up the
army upon
uorthy of suggestion to the
is
latter
and
at
Valley
put the British army
army during the New Jersey
ultimate lines of defense.
cordon of posts extending to
The banks of the Dela-
New
Brunswick and Perth
ware, with
X\\c
Amboy,
nied one, and the river Raritan on the right, was auxiliary
foi
to the former, so long as the fleet controlled the waters about Staten Istand. I
The
latter
was
l!-!l
working southward from the
movements
middle :.i
tiiii
V,
New
practically an
New
advanced base
for operations
York, with a strategic front looking to
of Washington's
army which occupied the heights
of
Jersey.
Zones of opodtion are belts of territory controlled by m )ving columns, or those within which columns can act in real concert. Several lines of operation
may
fall
within one zone.
During the war of 1775-178 1,
New
Jersey and Pentisylvania were
within the cetitre zone, while (ieorgia and the Carolinas belonged to
the
left.
During
the American
war of 1861-1865, the
trans-Mississippi
:^
[1775.
SrUATEGY
i:75.J
states filled the right zone
IN
;
WAR
CONTINUi:i).
57
the country eastward to Virginia, indi-
cated the centre; while the Atlantic belt, with operations on Rich-
mond, determined the zone of the
left.
with the motlern telegraph and railroad system,
It is possible,
for
a competent commander to ordain a general policy, by which operations in different zones may determine together toward the general Thus General Grant on the left, and General Sherman in the result. centre, acted in full concert during the spring and summer of 1864,
so to
occupy the Confederate forces as to neutralize the benefit which
otherwise enured to the latter by virtue of a series of interior railroad lines,
which enabled their armies to operate alternateiy against the
Federal armies of either zone, by a shorter route than was available for
the latter troops.
ity,
Dining July, lS62,the author was instructed by competent authorto meet Generals Halleck and Pope on their arrival at Wash-
ington, t)
which pkice they had been called by telegram,
inform them that an immediate interview was desired by dent, then at the Soldiers'
Home,
antl
to
tiie Presi-
The
a short distance from the city.
whole object of the proposed interview was, that the Presitlent might determine souri,
own mind whether the
in his
judgment, or merely accidental. eral
different operations in Mis-
Kentuck}', and Tennessee, were the result of one forecast, or
Halleck was placed
of staff to the President,
in
general
As the result of their arrival, command, under the st\'le of
who thereby
asserted his constitutional pre-
General
rogative as commander-in-chief, ufion the assumption that
Halleck had
(ien-
chief
mental scope and executive ability to handle
the
all
General Pope was also
the armies over the entire theatre of w.ir.
assigned to a highly responsible sphere of duty. rile details ot
separate zones are necessarily distinct, as are
many
same
zone.
oper.itions of single arinies
moving on separate
General Sherma:i\ march to the sea operations, because he kept entire
command,
that
it
was
w.is
lines in the
practically but
one
line of
up such constant communication with at all times in
the efficient accom[)lishment of his plans.
hand If
for concentration, it
his
and
be regarded as the
equivalent of two lines of operations acting together within one zone, it
had the perfect accord of purpose and action, which under
hands, makes every key in music to vibrate
in
harmony
skillful
together.
grand divisio f his army moved as a unit, on their mission. During the war of 1775-178 1, the operations of General Clinton were marked by great wisdom, and a fi.xed purpose to secure a suf1
lie
srUAII-CV IN
S8
concentration of force to realize success on
ficiont
proposed oper.ition. 1
WAR COXriNUFD.
hulson river and
'riie
tiiree
tlie
zones of
bounded on the left by tiie was favored by Lord Geort;e (jerniaine,
riL;ht
delenses,
its
but at the sacrifice
[177:
zone,
results elsewhere, aiul without an appreci.ition
ot
of the resistance with which he had to cope, and the character of the
country
in
which the war was
c.irricd on.
^Althou;4h Massachusetts was after 1
!'
t> posscsscil
till'
li
^lnwlv, ihr
traiiiiiiL^, iri)iit
vi|4i>r iif W'.i-^liiiv^tdi),
soldiLis
l.\rlU>
ai)ove-
all
others.
'
'J!
'!
"'iji'
The ^reat represented
German
-I
m.ii(ru\ri' which ciiaracteri/.eil I*'rederic
skill in
Clinton,
l)y
troops came' promptly
methods of severe
IVrcy .md
Kn_\'piiau-en,
duty
to
u|)
Tarjeton,
was
well
and the
accordance with the
in
which they had been trained.
schooliiiL^ to
'
t
Lee,
\\'ashin;.;ton, (ireene,
i
,,.1'JI
however t)f
com-
otlu-r coni])etent
who took
toreii;n,
armv
the .\merican
ham!, wt-re compelled to enter the contest before their soldiers,
in
I
and
.Ma.xwell,
American and
maViders, both
i
well-drilled, indi\idually, could possibly accjuiie that
action which
This affords in
the
field.
makes
An
many
clew to
tiie
army
of ,m educated
illustration oi
concert
a perfect machine.
disasters which attended oper.itions
recent d.ite will del'iue the point in
\iew.
rcijimeiUs
single
m
instructed
commanders
been
h.ul
arm\'
I'"edera!
These movements were
ilrill.
e.xact.
llriijatle
from the colonels
ibk
o lar f. a-
assitjnec
divisions,
had been commeiicetl ami well .ulvaiiced
ever, the
re-'iiiieiit
their ori;.inic i
divisions, ri le
captain
I
si )kiR r,
wiiich
svstem, even ,is
opportunit)' i.in lu^^dstic-.
art.
and
within a period so short
dc'ci-^ive',
and ada[)tation of
])reparation
of
hy had
the (aiuiean war
diu-in'.;
aili'.'s
movement
tin;
proni-ited
on^icU.-raljly
u.is
I'rn^-^ia,
modern
oi
have cvinceil a niuic
limes,
tiioron;_di
meet the demands
m.iterials to
in
the Franco
of
hattIe-i.-..-.ues.
Tin:
Coast of (juinea campai;.nis of Great
Ahys-inia and
were marked hy C(;mmenTurate connn.ind he
\
(hff'iciiit
its neccTsitii.;
sewrel)' ta-.ke'd exactin;,^^
:S
lo;_;i^iic^
whether of service or
i,
nl
h\"
SOi -1865.
1
modern war the
is
siir^le
I'i'UT-iian
not
the i)recision the
\',ist
direction of transportation i-;
is
found
u|) on
necessary to
i
Ijelon;.;
s
I'aris invi.)lved
(juinii)re-sent
oifensive
,ind
\'et
recpjirt.'S
move six
armies.
hundi'eil
ioilin;4'
hrid'^e
re(iuisitif)n,
with
all
th.in;_;s
inspection
liie
thousand
department of
control, that accidents
work.
the control
head of railroad cor-
and such was were
and
r,u-e.
essential
t(j
of troops and
its
ol
to tais dej),irtmcnt.
not referahle to had
lo_L,dslics.
in
the
To
means
of equippin;^ an
OvercroAded transports
shipn\ent of sui)piii;s, the confusion of
arms of the
SL-rvice,
table, unles.s
the m'tli-
or
m
and exact s>'slem
tr.iins,
that
the
in
the
indiscrimin.Ue
iteri.d helon;^in:4 to dilfcrent
and the misdirection of these '.
army
;4:\e el'lect to this resjjonsihh: trust,
there must he thorou:^h coacert of i)ur[)osc
execution.
re-S'Mii'Ce-.,
the adjustments of
ICveuy
untailin;^!)- sup[)lied
The; a; can he no deficiency is
liian
was called into
en;_;ineerin;.;
ami
at the
mo\'ed more
rail'.v.i\'s
army was
Comfort and supplies
which enteied into
made the ,-esiilt pos-^ihle. 'idle sjjhere hound up in merely mechanical w(irk. In
(ireat tale'Ut
The advance
and
would
several staff department>> were
TIk.:
stock and material to dilfereut roads. huiliiin;,;"
tin;
(>\
It
fully met.
porations: and similar capacity
troops.
Jiritain
outfit
of lahor aloni;
however,
of a m, titer mind,
'I'he
the
clim.ite.
the e-normou-. drain up-ui their
demand was
'i'lie 'livi->ii)ii
of
adjustin'4
in
to estimate the expenditure of material
the .\mc:rican w.u"
the
skill
sup[jlies are inevi-
be Ldd down clearly, and competent
officers
T
LOGISTICS.
I77;-
1775
Battle iiistory
instructions.
to "-rcat captains, to
wlio taiK'd
when
is
full
71
of disasters which attach thscredit
responsibiht}- properly belonj^ed to tiiosc
tlie
to execute, tlie will of the
api)reciate, or accurately
comm.uuler. It is
authoritatively stated, that on the evenin;^ of July 4th, 1809,
before the battle of Wayrani, the nii;ht bein;^ dark, and in
ini;
tlie rain
f.ill-
torrents, when one hundred and fifty thousand men were across the arm of the Danube, there one huiulred and fifty
puslied
yards wide,
1)_\-
brid;4es, that
three
who
assigned to Davoust,
w.is
it
commanded tlie r!;^ht win;.;, to cross the centre bricf-je, and to Oudinot, who commanded the cmitre, to cross the bridLje to the rigiit. These commamlers obe)-ed the orilers as received, and such was the marvellous discipHne of the triio[)s tliat the armies jj.issed each oilier with-
out disorder, and the
movement was accomplished without knowledge
While the
of the enemy.
error
dictatin;4 the onler, Berthier
take, since he
is
attributed to Najioleon's haste
criticised
is
in
observini^ the mis-
for not
was called u[)on to make ten copies of the
cM'der
for
information of the army. asserts, that " Na])oleon
Jomini broadly
contiui^ciicy of retreat,
be done, but
was
It
in
loliat
army was
in
the
o!tl
confol of experienced The
livetl,
loL^istics
the siege of Boston, devolved vast mili-
inexperienced citizen
into the
soon
.IS
Nliort
enlistment involved a
new
Those consider.itions
tory ot successive campaigns, eltect of b